December 11, 2024 Historical Preservation Board Meeting (2024-12-11)

The (-in ol ilkntnl Doru Historic Presertution Bourcl met on ll'elnesdta. .lunwtn 29. 2025 in the ( it.r ('lumhcrs on th(.first loor of ('in Hull. krated ut 5l(l :\' Buker Streel. ltlount l)oru. Fkridu ht tterc.ite their po*ers L^ astublished in the Lurul Developmenl ('rtlc. L Call To Order Having been duly noticed as required by law. the January 29.2025 meeting ofthe Mount Dora Historic Preservation Board was ca.lled to order at 3:00 p.m. by renewed Chairman. Det Joks. lI. III. lv. Roll Call with DetermiDation of Quorum Presenl: Kathleen Benjamin. Lynn Tipton. Det Joks, Juan Diaz. Robert Gordon. and Patricia Huizing Absent: None; Ms. Huizing arrived to the meeting at 3:15 P.M. City Stalf: Adam Sumner, Deputy Planning Director: Catherine Hutcheson, Administrative Coordinator: Whitne;- Scott. Administrative Coordinator; aad Andreu' Hand, Esq., Cir.n- Attomey Approval of Meetitrg Minutes from December 11,2021 MOTION by Ms. Tipton, SECONDED by Mr. Gordon, to AMEND the minutes of the Historic Presen'ation Board Meeting to include a thank you to Don Marx. FOR: Kathleen Benjamin. L1'nn Tipton. Det Joks. Juan Diaz. Robert Gordon AGAINST None MOTION CARRIED: 5-0 Public participation/comment for non-agenda items No member olthe public rvished ro provide public comment. Certificate of Appropriateness a. {23 N. Tremain Str€et- Re-Roof i. Ex Pane ( ommunication ii. Swearing in of staff/Applicant iii. Staff presentation ir. Public input r. Discussion Page I of3 CITY OF MOUNT DORA H ISTORIC PRESE RVATION BOARI) JANLIARY 29, 2025 NTEETING MINTITES

CITY OF MOU:.r..1 DORA HISTORIC PRESERV,ATION BOARD JANUARY 29. ]01.I Mr. Hand srvore in the applicants and Mr. Sumner presented the application. Staff recommended approval ofthe application as presented. Applicant Hunter Borrell. rvith Eco Construction Group. gave a brief oven-ierv of the design oi the shingle material that the ouner has requested to be used. The shingle is ven'similar to *hat the home currently has and will not look much different. Propert_,- Ow-ner. Jennifer Banta. spoke to the board about her excitement about or.vning this home. She loves the new shingle choice and is looking tbr it to be a big investment into the home and feel that the ne*.shingle will male the home really standout in the neighborhood. Mr. Perez discussed what the current paneling on the home is and what the applicant is requesting. Ms. Banta is requesting the fulI six mullions. Mr. Joks discussed the question of whether or not a chimney is on the building and ilit will be affected. Ms. Banta stated she is just looking to paint it the same color as the roof. Further discussion on the chimney. Mr. Sumner stated that the 3:3 Mullins is historically accurate which is why staff originally recommended approval. Ms. Huizing arrived to the meeting at 3: 15 P.M. An electronic submittal from Ms. Banta to be added to t}e application showing the shingle designs and color options. Discussion over the shingle designs and color options. MOTION by Ms. Tipton, SECONDED by Mr. Perez, to ACCEPT staff s finding of fact and to APPROVE the application as presented with the caveat that the change in roofshingle has been accepted and the window design has been acknowledged, FOR: Kathleen Benjamin. Lynn Tipton, Det Joks. Juan Diaz. Robert Gordon. and Patricia Huizing AGAINST: None MOTION CARRIED: 6-0 VI. New Business l.) Election of Chair and Vice Chair Voting for the chair and vice chair was done before the COA application presentation. Ms. Huizing was not present lor the voting. MOTION by Ms. Benjamin, SECONDED by Mr. Gordon to accept the Historic Presenation Boards choice of Chair, Det Joks. FOR: Kathleen Benjamin. L1-nn Tipton. Juan Diaz. Robert Gordon. Det Joks AG{NST: None Page 2 of3

CITY OF MOL'NT DORA HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD JANUARY:9. ]O?4 MOTION CARRIED: 5{ MOTION bv Mr..loks, SECONI)EI) b.r- Ms. Benjamin to accept the Historic Presenation Boards choice of Vice Chair, Robert (Jordon. FOR: Kathleen Benjamin. Lynn Tipton, Det Joks, Juan Diaz. Robert Gordon A(iA|NST: None MOTION CARRIEI): 5-0 2.) Sunshine Training with Attorne!' Andrerv Hand Mr. Hand gave a presentation regarding the Florida State Sunshine Law to the board members. Discussion with board members regarding the law. lr'1r. Joks clarified the ditl'erence between the law and contlict of interest with N{r. t{and. Mr. Hand stating that it iscovered inChapter I l2 ofthe Florida Sunshine l.aw Further discussion onconllict of interest. Vl I. Other Business Historic Preservation Ordinance overview was rescheduled to next month's meeting on February 26,2025. Mr. Joks stated that Land Development Code (LDC) Section 3.6- l. will be discussed at the February meeting. Mr. Gordon asked why the board was not going over the ordinance today. Mr. Sumner stated he was not prepped {br that and did not want to cause confusion amongsl the board members. Mr. Gordon requested going over LDC Sections 3.6.1 and 3.6.2 at the nexl meeting. The board members agreed to this and requested it be added to the agenda. Vlll. Staff Update No staff updates at this time lX. Announcemenl ofnext scheduled meeling: Februan 26,2025 X. Ad.iournment MOTION b1- Ms. Tipton, SECONI)El) bt Ms. Huizing, to adjourn the meeting. The Board unanimouslr \ oted to adjourn the meeting al l:02 p.m Dek Joks, Chuirnta Colheline Hutcheson, A d nt i n isl ro tive C oo rd i n a t o r 4 Historic Preservolion Boortl Page 3 of3