POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Governmental Oversight and Accountability · Closed Captions

Wednesday, February 11, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Governmental Oversight and Accountability — Closed Captions

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 110,013 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Members, we're going to call the Government Oversight and Accountability to order and Tamra, please call the roll. >> Chair Mayfield? >> Here. >> Vice Chair DiCeglie? >> Here. >> Senator Arrington? >> Here. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Here. >> Senator Brodeur? Senator Grall? >> Here. >> Senator McCain? >> Here. >> Senator Polsky? >> Here. >> Senator Rodriguez? >> Here. >> The quorum is present. >> Great. Thank you. Please silent all electronic devices. Anyone wishing to speak before the committee please complete an appearance form legibly, please, so we can read your name and hand it to the sergeant office. Should you select to waive your speaking time, your position will be included in the committee meeting records. And if you will please stand for the pledge allegiance, that is going to be led by Senator Grall. Members, we are going to start with Senator Bradley under Tab 1 is a committee substitute for Senate Bill 332 on public meetings and private property rights, and you're recognized to explain your bill. But I see you have a delete all. So we are going to take up delete all Amendment 328364. >> Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you for hearing this bill. Senators, under current law, local governments are required to deliberate litigation strategies in public during the 90 day pre-suit period in a Bert Harris claim. This requirement for public deliberation during the pre-suit period discourages early resolution through settlement and requires open discussion of litigation strategy, both driving up litigation costs for both parties and delaying resolution. This bill provides a narrow and temporary public exemption for communications related to legal strategy and negotiation posture during the pre-suit Bert Harris period. The bill does not eliminate transparency or hide settlements which will become public. Instead, it provides transparency and outcomes while maintaining confidentiality in strategy. The strike all amendment clarifies that the meeting exemption is applicable to an agency as defined in 119.001, creates a public records exemption for transcript recordings, minutes, and records generated during the closed portion of the pre-suit settlement meeting. It also aligns this bill with the House. And that is the bi. >> Great. Thank you. Any questions, members on the delete all? Seeing no questions, no appearance form, any debate? Seeing no debate. Senator Bradley, you're recognized to close on your delete all amendment? >> Waive close. >> Waive close. All in favor of the amendment, say yea. >> Yea. >> All opposed, say nay. The amendment is adopted. Now we're back on the bill as amended. Any questions on the bill as amended? We do have. Matthew Singer is waving in support of the bill. Matthew, thank you for being here. And Jeffrey Scala, with the Florida Associations of County is waving in support. Thank you for being here. Members, now, is there any debate on the bill as amended? Seeing none, Senator Bradley, you recognized to close? >> I'll waive Close, ma'am. >> Waive close. Tamra, please call the roll on committee substitute for committee sustitute for Senate Bill 332. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall? >> Yes. >> Senator McCain? >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky? >> Yes. >> Senator Rodriguez? >> Yes. >> Senator DiCeglie? >> Yeah. >> Chair Mayfield? >> Yes. And by your vote committee substitute for committee substitute for Senate Bill 332 is reported favorable. >> Thank you, Chair. >> Members, we're going to go to Tab 2 and take up Senate Bill 464 on observation of Veterans Day by K-12 schools and by Senator Avila. You're recognized, Senator Avila. Explain your bill. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And Senators, Florida law designates Veterans Day November 11th as one of numerous legal holidays to be observed in the state and provides that if a legal holiday falls on a Sunday, that following Monday will be considered. This bill ensures that all Florida school districts formally observe Veterans Day as a school holiday, honoring the men and women who have served in the United States Armed Forces, including the nearly 1.4 million veterans that call Florida home. It reinforces the importance of civic education, patriotism, and community recognition of our Veterans' sacrifices. This bill ensures statewide consistency, so every student, teacher, and family has the opportunity to honor veterans on that day. That is the bill, Madam Chair. >> Great. Thank you. Any questions on the bill, members? Seeing no questions, no appearance forms, any debate? Well, I'd like to thank you for bringing this forward. Senator Avila, it is something that I think our school children should be honoring on that day, and I think that we don't do enough for our veterans on what they've done for us in this country. So thank you for doing that, and thank you for your service as well. Senator Avila's recognized to close. >> Thank you, Madam Chair, for those comments, and certainly appreciate this committee and appreciate you for bringing this bill. I do want to say Florida prides itself on being one of the most, if not the most veteran friendly states in the union, and this is a testament of that. With that, I ask for your favorable support. Thank you, Madam Chair. >> Great. Thank you. Tamra, please call the roll on Senate Bill 464. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall? >> Yes. >> Senator McCain? >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky? >> Yes. >> Senator Rodriguez? >> Yes. >> Senator DiCeglie? >> Yes. >> Chair Mayfield? >> Yes. And by your vote, Senate Bill 464 will be reported favorably. Members, while we're waiting for other members to come, we are going to go ahead and take up Tab 6, which is Senate Bill 984 by Senator DiCeglie and it is the firefighters cancer benefit and prevention. And, Senator DiCeglie you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Senate Bill 984 clarifies firefighter families have access to the death benefit for one year after terminating employment, allowing firefighters with terminal cancer to spend their final days at home when they are not physically able to stay on the job. It uncouples a requirement for retired firefighters to remain on their employer sponsored health insurance, to receive the one time payment when diagnosed with occupational cancer. This will help transition firefighters to less expensive health plans and gives employers financial and administrative benefits. It removes redundant best practices language that is already in the fire fighter OSHA statute. Madam Chair, that is the bill. >> Great. Thank you. And I see you do have one late filed amendment. Would you like to explain that late there any objections of taking up the late file amendment first? Seeing no objections, we're going to take up Amendment bar code 493180 by Senator DiCeglie. You're recognized. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. This amendment provides a statement of important state interest. This is being put on out of a bunch of abundance of caution because of potential indeterminate costs. It is important to note the bill also includes provisions that should result in health insurance cost savings to employers. Madam Chair, that is the amendment. >> Great. Questions on the amendment? Seeing no questions? No appearance forms. Any debate? Seeing no debate. Senator DiCeglie you're recognized to close on the amendment. >> I waive close. >> Waive close. All in favor of the amendment, say yea. >> Yea. >> All opposed say nay. The amendment is adopted. Now we're back on the bill as amended. Any questions on the bill as amended? >> A question. >> Senator Rodriguez. >> Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Senator DiCeglie. From my understanding of cancer, everything I read is that it's measured in five year increments, survivability, statistics, I see refer to the five year periods, and the remission isn't usually achieved until five years later. Would you be willing to make any changes to reflect that in your bill? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. Yeah, I'm always open to suggestions to make the bill better, and happy to discuss with you further. >> Follow up. You good? Any other questions? Seeing none. We have a couple of appearance forms. We have Chief Miller with the Florida Fire Chiefs' Association waiving in support. And we have Bernie Bernoska with the Florida Professional Firefighters, and he would like to speak. >> Chair, members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to be here today. On behalf of the more than 31,000 firefighters I represent, I'd like to first thank Senator DiCeglie for this good bill and ask for your support. You passed the firefighter cancer law in 2019, and since then, we've worked with local employers and firefighters to help make sure it was implemented consistently across the state and in the manner you intended. When small clarifications or tweaks were needed, you made them happen. We have a few more small tweaks to make. This bill does not expand eligibility for any benefit. Eligibility remains limited to firefighters with occupational cancer, and it's crafted in a way that benefits firefighters and employers and provides clarity for everyone. Thank you, Chair, for putting this bill up today, and again, thank you, members, for your support of Florida's Professional Firefighters. >> Thank you, Bernie. Also, we have Mr. Perez is speaking for. [BACKGROUND] Come on up. >> Good afternoon, Chairman and senators. My name is Dr. Elio Perez, lieutenant with Metro Dade Fire Rescue. I am speaking in support of this bill, and I appreciate the work that has gone into bringing it forward. However, I have a concern with one tiny little detail in this bill and its enormous impact. Specifically, I am referring to line 65 through 71, which covers the death benefits for firefighters. I spent more than 20 years in the fire service, and I seen what this job does to my fellow brothers and sisters, physically and psychologically, after a terminal cancer diagnosis. And in that time that follows when firefighters receive a terminal cancer diagnosis, policies like this can create pressure to keep working sometimes until they are physically cannot because stepping away too soon may mean losing the financial protection that their family depends on. And that leads to a difficult reality. A firefighter who knows his time is limited should be spending those final months with his spouse, his children, and with his family, not worrying about whether the people he leaves behind will be taken care of. Cancer caused by firefighting does not follow a one year timeline. Allow me to give you two examples. In 2022, Brett Miller retired to cancer and died 251 days later. In 2023, Jimmy Green also retired due to cancer and died 414 days later, just over a year. Under a strict one year limit, a firefighter like Jimmy Green falls outside the line, not because the cancer was different, not because the exposure was different, but simply because the calendar turned. The cause was the job. No one has given decades of service protecting. The public should have to make that choice. A one year cutoff doesn't change the science. It doesn't change the exposure. It doesn't change the outcome. It only changes who carries the burden, and too often, the burden falls with the surviving family. Firefighters are not asking for special treatment. We are asking for policy that reflects medical reality and honors the service that created the illness in the first place. Cancer doesn't end at retirement. Thank you for your time. >> Thank you for your testimony. And we also have Diane North, who is waiving in support of the bill. Members, we are now in debate. Debate on the bill. Seeing no debate, Senator DiCeglie you're recognized to close on your bill as amended. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And I want to somewhat address that. I think that anything that we do here in the legislature is about striking that balance. Obviously the $75,000 payout after death it's available for one year after the employment. So I think that's something that we can have a conversation, but just keep in mind that we go out to five years, that shifts some of the balance here, and we just want to make sure that we have a product that the stakeholders are comfortable with, and certainly looking forward to have that conversation moving forward, but I just wanted to lay out that balance is key here and with that, senators, I ask for your favorable support today. >> Great. Thank you. Tamra, please call the roll on committee sustitute for Senate Bill 984. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall? >> Yes. >> Senator McCain? >> Yeah. >> Senator Polsky? >> Yeah. >> Senator Rodriguez? >> Yes. >> Senator DiCeglie? >> Yeah. >> Chair Mayfield? >> Yes, and by your vote, committee substitute for Senate Bill 984 is reported favorably. Members, we're going to go back to Cap 3, and we're going to take up Senator Harrell's bill. And it is Senate Bill 576 on local government cybersecurity. And I see you have a delete all amendment, so we're going to go ahead and recognize and take that delete all, which is 104076. >> Thank you, Madam Chairman. And thank you for hearing this very important bill. As you know, cybersecurity is a major issue in the state of Florida, especially in our cities and counties as they address the issue of what is going on, whether it is their lack of expertise in the area or lack of equipment and ability to handle it. We had a major cyber attack in Stuart in Martin County just a year and a half ago, and it created a major problem in our tax collectors office, and they have all our driver's licenses, which, of course, get uploaded to the state system. Major problem. So what this bill does, the amendment clarifies that the local government cybersecurity protection program will be administered under the Florida Digital Service. And really, it's geared to helping local governments develop and strengthen that cybersecurity risk management and also have the equipment and the ability to counter them. Central component of the program under this bill is that the cities and counties can leverage the state's buying ability and buying power by having the state coordinate and organizing the purchase of various equipment, as well as programming in order to allow them to address the cybersecurity risks. You can turn $30 million of local funds into $300 million by really through this grant program and the ability of the state to purchase and leverage with big companies to buy the necessary equipment and programming they need. Also, under the Florida Digital Service is authorized to contract for health information commodities and cybersecurity services and then have the local governments use them with this bill. The amendment also strengthens the statewide cybersecurity defense system by requiring data sharing agreements from participating local governments and the Florida Digital Service. Again, that interoperability and coordination between the state and local governments is essential. This coordinated approach improves the state's ability to detect, prevent, and respond to cybersecurity attacks. Also the bill expands and sustains the program. >> It codifies the program that had been put in place and was funded with non-recurring dollars. So it puts this in place and codifies it and authorizes the state to go for federal grants, and then the local governments would have access to those. So it's a partnership with the state through Florida Digital Service. And if we wind up making some other changes later on in another bill, it will transition to that entity. And importantly, it's going to make a big difference for our local governments to have access to the programming, the commodities, the services that they need to protect their local information. And that is the amendment. >> Great. Thank you. Members, any questions on the Delete All Amendment? Seeing no questions, we have no appearance forms. Any debate? Seeing no debate, Senator Hill, you're recognized to close on your amendment? >> We close. >> We Close. All in favor of the Delete All Amendment say yay. All opposed, say nay. The amendment is adopted. We're back on the bill as amended. Any questions on the bill as amended? Seeing no questions, we have Zach Herbert with the FLGISA is waving in support, and Sam Wagner with the Florida League of Cities, is waving in support. We're back on the bill as amended. Is there any debate on the bill? Seeing no debate, Senator Hill, you're recognized to close on your bill. >> I think this will make a big difference for our local communities to address the major threat that they are facing. And with that, I would ask for your favorable support. >> Great. Thank you. Tameron, please call the roll on committee substitute, Senate Bill 576. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis. >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur. >> Yes. >> Senator Grall. >> Yes. >> Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky, Senator Rodriguez, Senator DiCeglie, Chair Mayfield. >> Yes, and by your vote, committee substitute for Senate Bill 576 is reported favorably. >> Thank you. >> And you have a special guest. Would you like [OVERLAPPING] >> Yes. And if you don't mind, a moment of personal privilege, I'd like to introduce my wonderful daughter, Stephanie Harold, who is visiting from San Francisco. And also members, we're hosting that reception to meet her husband, [inaudible] surprise winning author, and I would love to have you at 5:30. >> Great. Thank you, and welcome, Stephanie, to the Capitol and to the Florida Senate. Members, we are going to go to Senator Wright, which is Tab 5. How did I skip Tab 5? Here we go. Tab 5 is Senate Bill 964 on financial disclosures. And Senator Wright, you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Members, Senate Bill 964 revises requirements for reporting of certain gifts and honorarium. The bill implements the commission on ethics recommended by clearly mandating that reporting individual paper file Form 10 with a commission on ethics rather than electronically file their form with one or six, Form 1 and Form 6. This is accomplished by deleting the current statutory language that requires that Form 10 be filed with individual's financial disclosures. And simply that is the bill, Madam Chair. >> Great. Thank you. Members, are there any questions on the bill? Seeing no questions, no appearance forms. We do have an appearance form. We have Kerrie Stillman, Executive Director of the Florida Commission on Ethics, and she is speaking for the bill. Welcome, Kerrie. >> Thank you, Chair. Is that on? Quickly, the bill does not change any particular substance of the filing requirement. It will allow us to change the rule to reflect that the form gets filed with the commission and not electronically because the Form 10 is a paper form. So we thank you for your consideration. >> Great. Thank you for being here. Members, are there any debate? Seeing no debate. Senator Wright, you're recognized to close on the bill. >> Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Our good friend Linda Stewart has asked that this bill be presented, and so I'm here to support her, and appreciate your favorable support. >> Thank you. Tameron, please call the roll on Senate Bill 964. >> Senator Arrington. Senator Bracy Davis. >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur. >> Yes. >> Senator Grall. >> Yes. >> Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky, Senator Rodriguez, Senator DiCeglie. Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, Senate Bill 964 is reported favorably. Members, we are now going to go to Tab 10, which is, hold on one second, is Senator DiCeglie and it's going to be Senate Bill 1612 on electronic payments to local governments. You have a delete all as well. >> I do. >> You do have a delete all amendment, and it is your Delete All Amendment 948168? >> Yes. >> You're recognized to explain your delete all amendment. >> Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. The amendment matches the bill to the house's language and adds a finding of important state interest to meet constitutional requirements. The bill clarifies that local governments must accept electronic payments in all instances, not just online, provides an exemption where another law requires local governments to accept another form of payment, pushes back the effective date of the bill to January 1, 2027. This will give local governments time to make any technological updates needed to comply with the bill. That is the amendment. >> Great. Questions on the delete all amendment, members? Seeing no questions. We have no appearance forms. Senator DiCeglie, you're recognized to close when you delete all amendment. >> We have close. >> All in favor of the amendment say yay. Yay. All opposed say nay. The amendment is adopted. Now we're back on the bill as amended. Questions on the bill as amended? Seeing no questions, no appearance form, any debate? Seeing no debate. Senator DiCeglie, you're recognized to close on your bill as amended. >> We've close. >> We've close. Tameron, please call the roll on Committee Substitute for Senate Bill 1612. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis. >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur. >> Yes. >> Senator Grall. >> Yes. >> Senator McClain? >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky, Senator Rodriguez, Senator DiCeglie. Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, Committee Substitute for Senate Bill 1612 is reported favorably. Members, we are going to take up our appointee since we're waiting on members to get through the committee. Members, we have 20 appointees to be considered for confirmation. These appointees were not required to be here today. Unless a senator requests a separate vote on an individual appointees, we will take one vote for all appointees. Now, Senator Polsky has requested a separate vote to be taken on Tab 31, which is Jeffrey Aaron, and we are going to take up a separate vote on that. And is there any appearance forms on those? No appearance forms. There any discussion? Senator Polsky? >> I thought it was on the separate vote. > You wanted a separate vote on Jeffrey Aaron. >> So now is the time. >> So we have Jeffrey Aaron now. >> Got you. Sorry. Forgive me. Yes, [OVERLAPPING] It's a little confusing. I wanted to separate this vote so we could make it clear as compared to the other folks that we are voting on, that this is a very problematic appointment, in my opinion. The Public Employees Relations Commission, PERC, is a small, independent quasi-judicial agency with a primary mission of adjudicating and facilitating mediation of public sector labor and employment disputes. PERC also performs other essential non-adjudicatory functions such as registering labor organizations, unions, and conducting secret ballot elections throughout Florida for state and local government employees voting for or against establishing and maintaining union representation, to be continued later today. When asked to come and testify about the concerns related to the $10 million Medicaid donation to the Hope Florida Foundation, Jeff Aaron did not attend, despite him being kept on a $5,000 a month flat retainer for Hope Florida, to provide general legal advice. Additionally, he serves as the Friends of James Uthmeier Political Committee Chair. He also has a history representing Governor DeSantis in legal disputes and public sector employers, while simultaneously weighing in on cases of alleged violations of labor law committed by public employers as a public official. Aaron was appointed PERC commissioner by DeSantis in 2021 for a term that was set to end January 1, 2025. His ongoing political connections and lack of professional transparency does not lead me to have confidence in his appointment to the PERC, and I therefore will be voting no to advance him for confirmation. Thank you. >> Thank you, Senator Polsky. Is there any other discussions on the appointee? Seeing none, is there a motion to recommend confirmation to Jeffrey Aaron? So moved by Senator Brodeur, move to recommend confirmation of Jeffrey Aaron to the Public Employees Relations Commission. Tameron, please call the roll. >> Senator Arrington? >> No. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> No. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall, Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky? Senator Rodriguez? >> Senator DiCeglie? Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, the confirmation of Jeffrey Aaron is recommended favorably. Members, now we are going to take up Tab 12-30 regarding the remaining appointees noticed on the committee agenda. Are there any appearance forms on them? No. Is there any discussion on the balance? No. Is there a motion to recommend confirmation for these appointees? Well, Senator Brodeur moves to recommend confirmation. >> No, no. >> I'm sorry. Senator Rodriguez moves to recommend confirmation of the appointees Tab 12-30. Tameron, please call the roll. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall. Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky, Senator Rodriguez, Senator DiCeglie. Chair Mayfield. >> Yes, and by your vote, confirmation of the appointees on Tab 12-30 is recommended favorably. Is Senator Leek here? There he is. Senator Leek is here, and we're going to go to Tab 4, which is Senate Bill 830, and you are recognized to explain public records, county administrators. And you're recognized to explain the bill. >> Thank you. Senate Bill 830 creates a public records exemption for the home addresses, telephone numbers and dates of birth for county administrators, deputy county administrators, assistant county administrators, city managers, deputy city managers, assistant city managers, as well as the names and telephone numbers and place of employment of their spouses and the names and addresses of the school and daycare attended by their children. The November 2021 report by the National League of Cities found that out of 112 local public official surveys, 81% of city managers had reported increased threats and acts of violence during their time in office. Last session, this legislature passed Senate Bill 268, which exempts the same personal identifying information from public record for state and local elected officials. This would extend that same protection to the people who are running those local governments. That is the bill. >> Great. Thank you. Questions on the bill, members? Seeing no questions, we do have one appearance form from Jeff Scali with the Florida Association of County is waving in support. Any debate on the bill? Senator Arrington. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And Senator Leek, I just want to thank you for this good bill. I ran it last year. You obviously did a better job getting Chair McClain to put it up in a committee than I did. But you said it perfectly. These folks are the ones on the front lines that are dealing with the issues, and I've heard many stories of folks with threats, and we want to keep these people working for us in the public sector. So thank you for running this, and I appreciate you. >> Just for the record, Senator Arrington, I was not the chairman last year. [LAUGHTER] Senator Leek, you are recognized to close on the bill. >> Let me start by apologizing for Senator McClain. [LAUGHTER] Listen, we did it for ourselves and the locals. It's only fair that we do it for the others, too. So with that, I ask for your support. >> Great. Thank you. Tameron, please call the roll on Senate Bill 830. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis? >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur? >> Yes. >> Senator Grall? Senator McClain? >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky? >> Yes. >> Senator Rodriguez? Senator DiCeglie? >> Yes. >> Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, Senate Bill 830 is reported favorably. Thank you, Senator. Thank you. We have Senator Burgess is here, and we're going to go to Tab 27 and take up the Senate Bill 1096 on remedies for violations of the Florida Civil Rights Act, and you are recognized to explain your bill. >> Thank you very much, Madam Chair. This bill simply clarifies the statute of limitations timeframe for the amount of time that a person has to file an employment discrimination complaint with the EEOC or the FHRC, and if they have an alleged discrimination, they can go one path or the other, and this bill seeks to clarify that statutory time frame because there's some confusion between the appellate districts. >> Great. Thank you. Members, any questions? Seeing none, we have one appearance form from Carolyn Johnson. She is speaking four with the Florida Chamber. Carolyn's going to wave in support. Members, we're on debate. Any debate? Seeing no debate, Senator Burgess, you're recognized to close on the bills. >> We've close. >> We've close. Tameron, please call the roll on Senate Bill 1096. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis. >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur. >> Yes. >> Senator Grall. >> Yes. >> Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky? Senator Rodriguez. Senator DiCeglie. >> Yes. >> Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, Senate Bill 1096 is reported favorably. Senator Burgess, you have one other bill, which is Tab 11, and that is Senate Bill 1656 on designation of the official state flagship. And you're recognized to explain your bill. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. This is a really exciting bill. This bill designates the SS American Victory, a World War II merchant vessel as Florida's flagship. The SS American Victory is one of only four operational World War II merchant vessels that are left. America. The SS American Victory was built in 1945, saw service in World War II in the Pacific Theater, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War. While serving in Korea, the SS American Victory repatriated 260 casualties, including three fallen Floridians, Army Private P.C. White, Marine Second Lieutenant, Robert C. Craig, and Marine Private First Class Joseph T. Jacobs. For the past 25 years, the SS American Victory has been an important part of the Tampa waterfront, and now it's a museum which hosts about 30,000 visitors a year. Since 2002, it has been recognized on the list of national historic places, and the ship is also a first responder training site and a tribute to those who served in the Merchant Marines. And I actually have the honor of having General [inaudible] and General Dave Scott, who are both with the American Victory Ship Foundation sitting right over here. Wave gentlemen. Thank you for your service, and thank you for being here to hear this bill be presented today. >> Great. Thank you. And members, there was no questions, no appearance forms, no debate, and you close. >> That's the bill. >> And now we're ready to vote. Tameron, please call the roll on 1656. >> Anchors away. >> Senator Arrington? >> Yes. >> Senator Bracy Davis. >> Yes. >> Senator Brodeur. >> Yes. >> Senator Grall, Senator McClain. >> Yes. >> Senator Polsky. >> Here. Senator Rodriguez, Senator DiCeglie. Chair Mayfield. >> Yes. And by your vote, Senate Bill 1656 is reported favorably. We're going to take informal recess and waiting for our next Senator to come from his other committee hearing. >> Members, we will call our Government Oversight Committee back to order, and we are going to take up tab 8, Senate Bill 1296 on Public Employee Relations Commission by Senator Martin, and you are recognized to explain the bill. >> Good afternoon, Chair, Committee. >> Good afternoon. >> This bill strengthens protections for members of public employees organizations while carrying the obligations of those unions, while clarifying the obligations of those unions. The bill modernizes operations of the Public Employee Relations Commission, including updated registration and renewal processes for employee organizations. It requires certification of a union by majority vote of all eligible bargaining unit members, closing loopholes that previously allowed certification with extremely minimal participation in some cases. This bill establishes an expedited mediation timeline when salary negotiations reach impasse, helping to ensure legislatively appropriated raises reach public employees in a timely manner. This enhances transparency by requiring clear reporting to members on how union dues are spent, including expenditures involving parent organizations. It increases maximum fine limits for violations committed by public employee organizations. It clarifies how public employers manage leave time for employees engaged in union related activities, including political advocacy and membership solicitation. It makes technical and conforming statutory changes to improve clarity around certification, recertification, and decertification procedures. This bill promotes accountability, transparency, and fair representation for public sector employees. That is the bill. >> Great. Thank you, members. Are there any questions? Senator Arrington. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, Senator Martin. Have you read the bill analysis and the constitutional issues that were brought up by staff? >> You're recognized. >> Yes, I read both bill analysis. >> And then, thank you, Madam Chair, if I can continue. The title of your bill references the Public Employees Relations Commission, yet the analysis says it's unclear whether the current state of the bill violates the single subject rule. Do you have any concerns regarding that or want to address it? >> You know what? We're going to get back in the right order, my fault. So we do have a proposed committee bill. So there is a proposed committee bill substitute for this bill by the Government Oversight and Accountability Committee. Is there a motion to take up the proposed committee substitute? Senator DiCeglie moves the committee takeup proposed committee substitute, Bill, bar code 655050. Without objection, show that motion adopted. Now, Senator Martin, you're recognized to explain the proposed committee substitute. Now we're to explain that one first. Then for some of your questions. >> Thank you. I'm looking for the talking points in the PCS. [inaudible] the talking points? The PCS, what this does, it updates the Public Employee Relations Commission registration, certification, and recertification processes for employee organizations. It requires a showing of interest form signed by a bargaining unit employee within the last 12 months to be submitted with an application for certification or recertification. It clarifies the bargaining unit process which allows determination of the unit after a change in case or statutory law. It institutes a two tier voting threshold for the certification, recertification, and decertification of an employee organization where public safety employee organizations may be certified or recertified by a majority of employees who vote in the election, and nonpublic safety employees organizations may be certified or recertified by a majority vote of the employees in the bargaining unit. It narrows the paid union leave for nonpublic safety union members to only those situations where the union fully reimburses the public employer for the employee's time performing duties that are directly related to the union, such as engaging in collective bargaining, participating in grievances, or representing other employees in disciplinary proceedings. This does not apply to unions for public safety field workers whose members may still engage in paid union leave for these activities without the union having to fully reimburse the public employer. Few more points, it requires a public employer to allow equal access to any employee organization or not for profit organization to access its communal spaces or communication systems that it allows other employees organizations or its affiliates to use, and institutes a fast track impasse process for local government salary increases as specifically approved by the legislature. That is the PCS. >> Great. Thank you, Senator Martin. Now, Senator Arrington, you have questions. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, Senator Martin. Let's take 2. My last question that I had said and just to follow up on that one then is on the bill analysis, it says it's unclear whether the current state of the bill violates the single subject rule. Do you have any concerns regarding that, as well? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you, Chair. Obviously, we don't want any of our bills to be unconstitutional, but I think that there's a pretty clear distinction between public safety unions and the unions that we're talking about in this bill. And I think that's a clear distinction that would allow any court to see that especially after the debate today, they could just watch this debate. They can read the Senate analysis. There's a compelling government interest in making sure that our public sector unions are different than our public safety unions. Public safety being the first and foremost responsibility of the state. And we want to make sure that those public safety unions are represented in a manner that meets the demands and the unique nature of their job, the stresses of their job, the amount of lawsuits that they have to face for interacting with the public in a very fluid situation. So we want to make sure that those protections remain while moving forward as the state of Florida has introduced tremendous amount of competition into the classroom, parents, and students can now have an immense amount of choices. The unions especially with the educators, I think there's a compelling reason that we need to get involved in making sure that those who choose to be in the unions or those who are in the unions actually chose to be in the unions and somebody else isn't just forcing them to join. >> Follow up? Yes, ma'am. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. So let's talk a little bit about the penalties if they violate the no strike requirement. Why are we increasing that fee or you are increasing that fee from 20,000-$40,000? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you to discourage strikes. >> Follow up. >> Thank you. >> Let's keep the comments to yourselves. We're going to keep a decorum in this room because it's a very personal and I understand that. It's a very personal issue to everybody sitting in this room. So let's just please make sure that we keep our decorum. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And Senator Martin, I have a couple of questions on regards to the financial urgency, which I believe starts on lines 15, 18. And what I'm reading is that any bargaining unit that receives funds from the state for salaries, they would be required to be at the bargaining table no later than 15 days after the effective date of the bill, and then complete their bargaining no later than 30 days after the effective date of the bill or declare an impasse. But the state budget has a July 1st implementation date. Meaning that by July 15th, unions would have to be at the table and then they have to complete their bargaining by July 30th. Is that correct? Is that how you're reading that? >> That is correct. >> Is that correct? >> It is. >> Yes. >> That is correct. >> Yes. >> That is correct. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And then a follow up on that because I have some concerns on that timeline. Are you aware that school districts are closing out their school year and preparing for the new school year during the month of July? So most school districts do not begin their bargaining until they know their student enrollment numbers, which is usually mid to late August. >> Yes. >> You're recognized. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. And then, are you also aware that the TRIM, the Truth in Millage notices, they're prepared and mailed to property owners by August 24, so school districts must advertise their tentative budget and hold their budget millage hearings in August and September. So how do you propose school districts negotiate salaries by July 30th without knowing the status of the rest of their operating budget? My senator. >> Thank you. That they negotiate based on the information they have and the projections they have, and then if changes have to be made, then they can move into that. If there's an emergency, there's a mechanism for that that they can move into. >> Last one, madam Chair. So if we're really saying that this is financial urgency, then why don't we have this deadline also apply to unions that represent our police, firefighter, paramedics, and EMTs and correctional officers? They don't have that same timeline that you're requiring for our teachers. >> You're recognized. >> Thank you. Our first responders have around the year schedule. They don't have a summer break, a winter break where the types of work they're doing, whether it's winding down a school year, preparing for a new school year are affecting their ability and the law enforcement agencies ability, the first responders agency's ability to recruit and train. There's constant movement in and out throughout the calendar year in many first responder agencies. And the contracts for educators are based on a timeline that I think that reflects the unique nature of the school year. >> Follow up. Senator Polsky. >> Thank you, Madam Chair. In 2023, we had SB 256, which made radical changes to the way these unions had to operate. What more needs to be done from that bill? Why was that bill not sufficient in trying to get at whatever problem it is you're trying to fix? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. That's a good question. I have some numbers from elections for various unions and the recertification process, it just shows there's very little interest, if any, expressed in membership of these unions. And I think it's something that we need to take a look at. If I think we're all elected officials that are making these decisions here in this room. If we're sitting at home on election night and watching the results come in, and we saw that 2% of the people voted in that election or less, I think we'd have really big concerns, and we would look at that and say, "What are we doing? Why does nobody care?" And I think it's unfortunate that the teachers unions haven't realize that this is happening with them and taking a look like I know you would look at if there was massive amounts of constituents just sitting home and not caring, nothing's changed. There's very few teachers actually are voting to be members of the teachers unions. And I think we need to take a hard look at that. And if it takes a bill like this to get filed so we can have these discussions, I want good quality teachers in our classrooms. I want because ultimately, that reflects on the quality of the students who are going to be graduating. And if the teachers don't think that this is important for them to do their job, then let's get rid of this hurdle. Let's get rid of the politics involved with it, and let's just focus on the kids and the product that we all can agree that we want good citizens to graduate from our schools, and we should get rid of all the things that get in the way of that. >> Follow up, Senator Polsky. >> Thank you. So if teachers are so disinterested in the union, is there any reason why they can't leave the union, especially if they're paying to be in it? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you. Well, when the union is speaking on behalf of all the teachers in that entire class, and they basically have a door into whether it's the superintendent's office and they're negotiating for things that so few people are actually concerned about based on their lack of involvement and even voting, I think it binds the hands of the other individuals who don't want to be have clearly made a statement by not voting, and they don't want to be a part of those discussions. >> Follow up? Yes. >> Thank you. If so many people didn't vote, how is it that the union was certified? >> You're recognized Senator Martin. >> Thank you. The certification for the union to be certified doesn't require a majority vote of all the members in that class. >> Follow up, yes. >> Is it possible that as Senator Arrington pointed out, that some of these elections are taking place in the summer when folks might be working a different job in a different state because they need to make more money. They work at camps and different things and they're just not physically able to vote over the summer, when school is not in session? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you. I don't know why individuals who claim to represent an entire class of teachers would make it so difficult for the bulk of the teachers to vote. If they're doing that, it makes me wonder one of two things, again, are they paying attention to what's actually happening? Have they done any self reflection, like, again, anybody in here would do if nobody was turning up to vote. And three, I know where the teachers are during the school year. They're in the schools. So if they want more turnout, why would they do the election in the summertime? >> Follow up. >> Unless, of course, the people in charge of the unions don't want the input and they want to keep their friends in power, and they want to keep pushing their agenda while they pretend to speak for the majority of schoolteachers. >> Follow up. >> It's pretty clear you have a bias against the union leadership, which I don't appreciate. So let's just get to the facts. Who sets the dates for these elections? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you. I don't know who sets the date for the election. But the school teachers have the ability to have much more input if they want to have the input. And unfortunately, we're seeing a very low involvement from the school teachers who the unions claim to represent. >> Follow up. >> Thank you. If 60% of teachers are paying their dues, isn't that good evidence that they want to be in the union and they want the union to represent them? >> You're recognized, Senator Martin. >> Thank you. If 60% are paying their dues and we know that the dues are coming from them and not from anybody else. And we're talking about all the teachers across the entire state, or we're talking about each individual district? >> Senator Polsky. >> I got information from statewide union people that 60% are paying their dues. And remember, we made it very much harder for them to pay their dues. It wasn't automatically deducted from their paycheck, and they had to affirmatively pay their dues, whether they do it by Venmo or check or some other way, I don't know. But 60% are paying their dues. So doesn't that say that they are happy with their union representation? >> You're recognized. >> Thank you. I know in Pinellas County of 2,320 eligible voters, only 212 actually voted. I know that in Flagler County, there were 922 eligible voters and only 236 actually voted. If you want to talk about just the dues, I don't know all the benefits that come with those dues because sometimes by joining a union, you can get a discount. You can buy in bulk. I don't know what those discounts are, so I don't know all the incentives that somebody would have to pay a due, but it doesn't necessarily mean that they agree with the leadership, and it doesn't mean that they actually want to be a member. They might just like a discount. >> Senator Polsky. >> Aren't these adults that if they are unhappy, will withdraw from the union? Why are we speaking for and I guess we're just picking on teachers, though there are other unions that are involved here. But aren't they capable of pulling out of the union if they so choose? >> Senator Martin. >> To the same respect that they could vote to stay in the union? >> Senator Polsky. >> The bill we passed in 2023 said that 60% have to pay dues or the union is decertified. So isn't that very telling that the unions are staying put since we tried to put them out of business a few years ago? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. The two your previous question, it makes me wonder why magically 60% of the members are paying their dues or 60% of the class is paying their dues. It sounds like they're doing just the bare minimum just to pay the dues. And again, I don't know who's paying the dues for them. I filed a bill. I haven't had anybody provide me that information, so I haven't had the opportunity to ask them those questions. >> Senator Polsky. >> Do you have any evidence that anyone is paying anyone else's dues besides the union member? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. I'm hearing about this for the first time from you as opposed to the union. I would have loved to ask them those questions. I assume you would have asked them those questions as well. Especially since it's extremely coincidental that they had to have 60% of their membership pay their dues, and then exactly 60% are actually paying dues. They just, hey, we got all dues money, let's send the rest of the money back or it just seems really coincidental. So I'm sure there was a follow up. I'd like to know what they said when you followed it up. >> Senator Polsky. >> Do you know what percentage of the electorate voted for you in the last election? Not percentage that you won by. Percentage of the people who are registered to vote actually vote. >> You don't have to answer that question. That didn't have anything to do with the bill at all. >> Let me rephrase. None of us were elected were required to have over 50% of the people who are registered to vote in order to win. We could win with 100 people voting. So why is it different for union members than those of us in the legislature? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. That's a good question, and I think that's something I expected to be discussed. In the United States, you have every right to not vote. In some parts of the world, you get fined if you don't vote. I think when you move into unions, when you move into those other clubs, those other organizations, if I want to be a member of an organization in college, if I want to be a member of a fraternity, if I wanted to join an organization down the road, I spend time joining that organization, whether it's contributing to it, whether it's reading their materials, if you're not voting, generally, I don't know why you want to be a member of that organization because usually that organization is something that you join in order to have your voice heard or to meet a certain need. So I'd have to ask, well, why are these individuals who are members of the Teachers Union not voting? And again, it goes back to some of the questions. I'd love to have these conversations with the members of the teachers unions about why are people not voting? Why do they feel like they don't need to vote. And I think you can't compare the system of government we have here in the United States because you can't elect to to live here or not live here, and you can't be agnostic about it. You're either here or you're not here. So you're going to be subject to the rules of whatever government entity is in power in somebody else's boat. If you're a teacher, it's entirely possible that you want to be a teacher but not have the union speak for you. And I think that what's getting lost in this message. There's a lot of individuals who don't want the union to speak for them or don't feel the union speaks for them. They're not voting for or against it because they just want to be left alone, but they want to teach. And they shouldn't be forced to leave their profession in order to not be a part of the union or to not have the union speak for them in negotiations. >> Thank you. What do you mean by a teacher having to leave if they don't want to be part of the union? >> And I understand your question because I misspoke on that. Not the teacher has to leave the profession, but when they're a teacher in a school, whether they're a member of the union or not, the union is speaking for all the teachers. They may not believe that the union is speaking for them, but they're stuck with whatever the union is negotiating for them. And that's what I meant. >> So we're talking a lot about teachers, but what other types of unions are covered under this bill? >> Thank you. Now there's a list. I'm trying to get you that list, but it's non first responders. Public Service. >> While you're looking for that, can I ask another question? >> I'm sorry. >> Well, he's looking for the list, but can I ask another question, Ma'am? >> Yeah. >> Thank you. Because it relates to that. So who would create the contract with the employer if there is no union? For example, like bus drivers are part of this public sector unions. So how would that work in a school district or nurses in a hospital? How would it work if there was no union, as far as hiring and salary and benefits? >> Thank you. I've never been a member of a union and I've never had to fill out a contract in order to get a job and collect a paycheck. >> So I'm just going to go back and forth. So we're all pretty familiar with unions representing teachers negotiating with school districts. So if under these rules, a teachers' union is decertified, what would it look like as far as setting the salaries and the benefits for the teachers if there was no union? >> Senator Martin. >> There wouldn't be a union to get in the way. An individual could either take an offer if there's not enough individuals that are willing to work for that offer, then what every other business tends to do that doesn't deal with unions, they just either figure out how to work without those employees or they raise the benefits, and then they attract workers. And there's ways to do that without just talking about money. There's work-life balance, there's fringe benefits. There's career building and other opportunities, but what's unique about that system is you don't have to have a one size fits all for thousands of employees or tens of thousands of employees in a school district or in a certain class. And the employer to attract talent is forced to meet the needs of those who want to come work or those who want to come work, if there's a shortage of workers can demand more than what might be a one size fits all. >> Senator Polsky. >> Thank you. Are you aware of any public school district who has hired teachers, set salaries, etc, without a union? >> Senator Martin. >> I know my school district, Lee County School District, has had to bypass some of these negotiations and some of these contracts in order to attract teachers to some of the failing schools. In order to attract good teachers. You can't have a one size fits all contract that the teachers who are already part of A plus schools already teaching there, entrenched there, they're not going to want to leave that school unless you offer them something else. And so they've actually had to go to the courts and fight the teachers union who was refusing to allow individuals who are going to those failing schools, which again, aren't in the nice neighborhoods. They're in the poorest neighborhoods. They're in the roughest neighborhoods where single parent homes put stress on the kids. When our school district tried to incentivize teachers to go into those schools, guess who sued them, the teachers Union. The teachers union that was run by a bunch of teachers who were already in a great little spot in A plus neighborhoods, lived in a great part of town and had kids that came from two parent households. That's really what we're dealing with, is the unions got in the way of helping the underprivileged, got in the way of helping those who were looking for that one opportunity to live the American dream, and they sued our school district. So that's the legacy of the unions in my county. >> Senator Polsky. >> Thank you. You said in response to one of Senator Arrington's questions that public safety employees, their unions should have protections, and you use the word protections, meaning that their unions do things to protect their employees that seemed important and that that should remain. But teachers unions and you said teachers specifically, they shouldn't be forced to join. Did you know that public sector nurses are also part of these unions that could be affected? So why aren't they protected the same way? Let me rephrase. If you believe that there are good protections that unions provide to public safety officers, why is it that they wouldn't provide it to public hospital nurses or school bus drivers or custodians? >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. That's a policy discussion that I'm happy to have where we landed on this bill was the first responders. And there's a distinction in my mind, and I know if I can put it into words for you, I'm not sure if that would be helpful or not, but we give first responders lights and sirens on their vehicles because their job is very, very different. Nurses have incredibly important jobs, and for whatever reason, we haven't given them lights and sirens because we've made a distinction between nurses and first responders. It doesn't mean that they're less important. It just means that the demands of their job is different. It doesn't mean it's not demanding. It just means it's demanding in a different way. But demanding in a different way than first responders is also demanding in a different way than teachers. So I think we created a bright line between those two classes. And I think any court that's trying to determine the constitutionality of it will probably be reminded as they're driving to work that day and they see a ambulance, a fire truck, a police officer with lights and sirens, but these other public service unions and classes are entirely different. Not that their jobs are less important, but that the way the jobs are done every single day is different, which means the scrutiny is different. The split second decisions in an unfamiliar environment without a patient on a table, like a nurse might have versus somebody who's running from law enforcement, who's putting a neighborhood in risk. Just different types of decisions are being made. So the decisions that are being made, I think, lead to different types of scrutiny after the fact, and that's why I think it's important that there is a distinction between the two types of unions. >> Senator Polsky. >> Thank you. I don't understand what the difference in the job is. >> Obviously, a lot of people have different jobs, the sanitation workers are covered, teachers, nurses, custodians, bus drivers. What's the difference in what they do and the danger of their job with respect to how a union represents them? Can you explain that? Because that is the constitutional challenge that the staff analysis brought up. >> Senator Martin. >> Thank you. Just from some of the issues I've dealt with this year as Chair of Criminal Justice, dealing with law enforcement unions and dealing with individuals who road officers, accusations might be made. It's very important in those situations when we want to make sure that our law enforcement officers are able to protect us that they're not crossing a line and violating our constitutional rights, that we investigate accusations that are made. We want to make sure that that is not weaponized to the point that we don't have any law enforcement officers on the road and everyone working behind a desk because bad guys can come in and just make accusations. So we have to have protections to make sure that those workers who put themselves in a very different position are still able to do their job, and the unions do a good job in many of those cases of making sure that their legal fees are paid, and then also contributing to the safety of our communities by making sure that those law enforcement officers are able to get back on the road as soon as possible. >> Senator Polsky. >> Thank you. We haven't talked about paid release time. Can you explain why prohibiting paid release

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Governmental Oversight and Accountability — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: ec24fcd624a1b12fe77958728b775760. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record