POLISCOPE

The public record

DUVAL COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Land Use & Zoning Committee

Tuesday, November 4, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Land Use & Zoning Committee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 85,821 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Good evening, everybody. It is NOVEMBER 4th at 5 o'clock. Want to welcome you to land use and zoning committee. We're going get started here with introductions to the left. >> For the first time first, hey, Hey, Rock Johnson District. 14 resident afternoon. Julia de straight. Good evening, Rory Diamond District. 13, the beaches, Joe Carlucci District 5. Good evening row areas. District 11 Brandon White District. Well. Terrence Harvey Office of General Counsel. Suzann Kelly Planning Department. >> on the planning department, Casey Cox planning department. >> All right. And >> committee members, we're going to welcome, MR. Harvey, for his first meeting up here with us. >> On the front row. That's right. That's right. So >> he's got an easy one tonight. So we'll take it easy on. And now we also want to welcome >> Jackson Mincer come on and stand up. This is our page tonight. Sophomore at a Quarry Creek and Good cross country runner from what I've heard had he woke up at this morning. To go to meet out in Lake City years. Yeah, that's that's early morning. Thank you for being here and helping us out tonight. All right. With Kuzma Johnson. Yes, You're recognized. >> Thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, quickly as we begin to start, congratulations to our page. So glad that he's here. And I want to see if MR. Harvey could give us his idea on the Salem Amendment. Looking at here as one. If you have anything you want to add 4. Thank you. And MR. We'd love to hear from you on that. >> Look, I've watched enough of I think in exist. >> don't worry. We had to. >> Welcome to the fund committee. It's fun when we can have fun. >> Item number one. 25 1.72 Is deferred. I don't. Number 2, 25, 1, 7, 3, is deferred item number 3. 25 47 suffered. >> Item number 4.20, by 4.88 Is deferred 5. 25 5.92, counselors. Police declare any ex parte communication this time. And this is actually the first one we have they all the other 5, 9, to 5 men for. >> Ms Miller. So let's do this. We go the clear ex parte. >> That Author, know, we're just on 5.90, for right now. But so what we're going to on this one just for the audience, we received a request for a deferral, but it came in a little bit late. And I know COUNCILMAN Gaffney had a meeting previously with the applicant, had another one before this meeting. So we just want to get a feel like what's what's going on with We'll hear from you this Miller and then kind of share what the options are. But first, let's go and get the ex parte. If anyone has it and then we'll go to the staff report and public hearings. So COUNCILMAN Gaffney, ex Parte. You're recognized. Thank you to the chair. >> Around for the class. I just Ian and approximately, I think at 3.30, with Randy, the 4 former COUNCILWOMAN Rented before south, who you'll be here from a few minutes ago. Also met with misses and a couple of neighbors last week. Who is the opposition City Council meeting with opposition to this bill. So everything file its latest services. All right. Councilor why you're recognized. >> Yes, they're all the clear export. Receive 6 or 8 e mails and over half of them was in support several was in opposition and all has been involved with legislative services. >> Thank you, council members with that. We'll go ahead and get a staff report. >> Thank you, MR. Chair. This is the convention. Rezoning ordinance 2025 0, 5, 9, 2, for a property located at 71. 26 Garden Street. This application is seeking to rezone approximately one acre from commercial residential office to Rld 60 in order to allow for the keeping of horses on the property. There are 2 companion applications. That one is for a zoning exception to allow for the use of the horses on the property and then also in administrative deviation for reduction in the required lot size, all 3 applications would be needed in order to allow for the horses on the property subject. Property is located on the south side of Garden Street where the surrounding areas predominantly real character and a low density in nature where the predominant use is single-family dwellings situated larger. Lots. The property owner intends to only have 3 horses and those horses are required to be kept a fenced-in in a fenced-in enclosure. Staff has reviewed the request and finds that the proposed rezoning is consistent with the comp plan with the existing land use category of rpi. Where are all the 60 as a secondary zoning district within that land use category. We find it furthers the goals and objectives of the comp plan by maintaining adequate land designated for residential uses, which can accommodate the project in population. This rezoning would be considered a down-zoning removing some commercial and multifamily residential uses development options, which would be consistent with the established pattern of development along Garden Street where again, the primary use is single-family residential. So because of these reasons and those in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval for the rezoning request and then the zoning exception. Lot area production will be reviewed in the following bills. The application was heard by Planning Commission on SEPTEMBER 4th, and there were 2 neighbor, neighbors, property owners for 7100 Garden Street who spoke in opposition to the requests. The department did received letters of support from the other surrounding property owners. And you have a copy of those letters in front of you. The concerns from the neighboring property owners centered on the adequacy of the property size for keeping of the horses and the potential for odors associated with the use and the close proximity to their residents. The commission expressed concerns regarding the reduction lot for the ad and the number of the proposed horses on the property and the commission ultimately voted unanimously to deny the application. Thank you so much. >> With that before we go to the applicant get, did you want to speak in here? So thought, okay, Thank you to chair. I want file additional as party. Also received a call from former COUNCILWOMAN Brenda Priestly Jackson as well. Yesterday and also visit the property. I think like a month ago. I mean, should we get those states nominees? Everything if legislative services. So thank you for that. And times. It is definitely in favor of the rezoning. Do have some concerns we're still in the public so so this is what I want to do just to kind of feel out the whole situation because we've got. >> The 3 options here tonight and this Mueller, if you want to go ahead and come you'll 3 minutes to here. So so just just for the We did, we did up in a public hearing. So Ms Miller, basically where we're at right now is there's a request to defer. There's a. >> You know, because we get the kind of said in the agenda meeting previously, he didn't think that was necessary. He had another meeting with you after that. So there's 3 options you can convince us to different week you can withdraw or we can vote on it. >> Those are 3 options and we just want to kind of do what fits best for all parties involved. So just keep that in mind. And if you want to speak to any of those. Yeah, I would love to name a name and address and things start to my name is Mary Agnes Van Cleave Miller Isis. >> My address is 71. 25 Martin Street and to answer your question, I would in trying to differ because COUNCILMAN Gaffney asking for more information. I have that information but I need to get it all together and get it to you. So I really need to differ. Understood. Thank you. And I'm so sorry I've been talking, you got a grant you have a card man. I do. Okay. Well, I'm trying to help her cause. She just was talking to man. She's I know she's very nervous and she's not getting the words out. Okay. So want to you come up and speak with your name and address and you can go and have to absolutely. This is Amy grand. So and my address is one 89 at rules way South Ponte Vedra Beach so I've been speaking with cis over the last couple weeks. The sub civically a lot last night and then also right after. You know. Conversation with MR. Gaffney and so based on that conversation, my understanding speaking with her is that. She has realized that she really does need counsel in this matter. And so I'm sorry, no, no, it's fine. You can keep going. We will hear from we'll hear from the committee second. Okay. And so when we were speaking right outside of of this meeting room, that's what she had expressed. And she had expressed that she did not raise this particular issue with MISTER Gaffney or you, Mr, Coach. And in terms of her request for a deferral and so and so I told her to that was my recommendations for her to say that first. So that would be clear as to why she's asking for a deferment is based on the fact that she does need counsel at this point based on the conversation with MR. Gaffney that happened this afternoon. Thank you so much. COUNCILMAN Gaffney Junior do want to speak at this point. Are want to get to car? So this is well, Matt, thank >> And fairness that we've been going to decide it. I think a lot laughter, informants. I think this was file back all this AUGUST. The 12th MAY. Right now we is NOVEMBER 4th. So it's going on 3 months mammoths us. We have probably spoke maybe a 5 10 times. We have information from us and we haven't received it. We just recently had a conversation and we still don't have the information. I'm very concerned about this project. My biggest concern is that we defer it is will be going into the new year. Talking about this project. Like I say, it's already been AUGUST. I really just want to deal with it. Like I say, as you probably get a lawyer, they will have to have another community and then they say no, we'll be going through 4 different millions. And I'm not sure what I have gay for fair enough time to provide the information. I just want to continue to track this along. That's my biggest thing. You know, she stated clearly that you don't have all the information needed meet a vote. Tonight. We go in that because it's a major concerns that could cause some environment issues. So. Right now, I just want to go ahead and vote way to get out the way. Like I said, we differ when it will be here next year and at this thing, you know, I have gay for adequate enough time to get information to deal with it. Big town. >> No Quinn, d I you've already spoke in your Time's Up. If we have questions, we can call you back up for questions about to more cards. So I'll speak them. >> Okay. >> Kuzma diamonds. You want to speak at this point? No. Okay. We're gonna go through the rest. The public hearing cards and then we will close public hearing will bring back the committee to kind of get a sense of we're going to go on this. So next up, we have then son Scott. After event and Scott, we have Rhonda Scott and then we have Billy Williams. Anyone I'm sorry. Been since got here here. But doesn't want speak. Do you wish to speak? No, yeah. Sure. She can speak for Sky. Name and address. Please. Okay. Rhonda. Sky Interest, 7, 1, 0, 0, Garden Street Jacksonville. >> Opposing 0, 5, 9, 2, there is existing illegal use and proper possible PRESIDENT While allowing additional not comply. The subject properties already being used illegally. All right. To the approval of any special use. Our Tony really. Granting this bill would effectively reward a code violation, creating a dangerous PRESIDENT. Property owners MAY disregard zoning laws established prohibit uses and later think to legalize them. Although misspoke home giving permission by the planning Department. Thanks. Action undermines the credibility of the cities downing enforcement process and compromises public confidence in the Fairness Co compliance. The intensity. Of the propose use is incompatible with surrounding thank a family resident. And approval represent and over to suffocation abuse, inconsistent with the city's comprehensive plan. The applicant. Maintains another parcel across street, which is already zoned appropriately. The existence. Turn to demonstrates that the current request is unnecessary. Enjoy reasonable use of the property. Approval of this request and invite similar petitions. Other smile, a lot property owners. Thank you to introduce agricultural uses into residential areas. This is inconsistent with the city stated goal, preserving community health, safety and welfare. >> All right. Thank you, ma'am. And next we have the instant Scott come on down. >> I mean, it's been since cat. I love the 71. 26 Garden Street. The house right next to it to him. This property. 7100 excuse me. And been able to horses now we have on this land with 22 years. And I think the applicant just bought it. The property 2 or 3 years And now all of a sudden she already owns 5 acres. The horses across the street. So she's just about this. She wants to bring her lessons across the street on the residential side. Across the street. Already is own rule. I don't think unfair. On this side street residential always been. Residents been there for the last 22 years. And just because you want I just bought them. I just bought the property 3 years ago, but I want to bring them over because I want to cut you. Might there be homeless and got so many people to come in to support yeah, she's good. He can do that. He's a good horse. You know. Traina a good keeper, but it's not fair to us. I don't want my property to decrease. The city's. It's a city a statute which is 6.56 >> Well, for one 6 states that horses and ponies like him. Well, private Riley use only and the minimum la area. Shelby not listed one and a half acre. The Jacksonville statue. She has 3 horses a half acre because law does one acre that half of the lead is a house. You're talking my one horse for. One and a half picking. You got want and it's right next to by half. I think with other people think because there not been active with horses are if that's where my house passes in the Bay. And I think it's unfair. And heat coming here and we file a petition. In MAY of this year. The city inspector who told us the facts. And then we come and then we go into all of this and then they don't have enough room for And we've got so many people come in and we we can fight all the friends. Who do you live around there about right and let I'm not going about it, right? No, that is because someone from the horses today at because they're ready for so I wish you all deny this I wish we get Can I have about 20 hours trying to get the >> All right. Thank you, Nice. We had Billy Williams. >> Good evening, Billy Williams. 71 11 Garden Street. I have owned by 3 acre lot at 71 11 Garden Street since 1982. Almost 45 years. I also own my residence immediately north of 71 11 Garden Street in the water, Brook Falls Subdivision, a 260 home development that opened 20 years ago. I am PRESIDENT Of the board of directors, the Water Brook Falls, Homeowners Association and have been since 2012. The applicant Ms Van Cleave Miller Sixt rezone her one acre property at 71. 26 Garden Street from to will be 60. Her plan for 71. 26 Garden Street is both consistent and compatible with the character of the area. A balance mixture of old line rule downs, more and modern single-family subdivision hopes besides 260 homes Water, Brooke Fall Subdivision includes around 50 acres of land under conservation, easement. I believe that this rezoning from which could lead to possible adverse uses 2 rld 60 is in the best interest of my properties. The owners and water Brook falls and the general community, our sensitivity to adverse issues or uses of non residential zoning has been heightened by the controversy surrounding the Belvedere Fuel terminal last year. We appreciate the work of this council and this committee in arranging a solution that will benefit both the project developer and the residents of water. It falls another area subdivisions. Please consider approving 2025, 0, 5, 9, 2, I will speak to the horses swim at the proper time. Thank you. Ok? Thank you, sir. Next we have Maguire. >> My name is Tom Maguire. My address is 4, 7, 1, 1, herder road Jacksonville, Florida, 3, 2, to one hero. It's good to be here tonight this is something I take very seriously what? They're asking for tonight is just for you to approve the status quo. The horses have been there for some time. The horses as it was just admitted or across the street. So there's really this smallest of differences between forces across the street and forces. On the other side of the street. The applicant is already spoken with the state about She's been found complying with state standards Council members have been admitted they've gone out there and check the property and found. Only small problems at best. So. Like I say, just approved the status quo. The horses are there. They've been there for a while. Let's just let them stay. Nice. We have. >> Karen? Her and thank you. 7 are after the h I think you know that. Yeah, I have an address. >> Okay. My name is Karen. Her attic. 80 to 56 Wallingford Hills Lane in Jacksonville. Let's say where I am. Oh, my gosh. Include Miller has devoted her career to helping children with special needs through therapeutic horseback. Riding at the North Florida School of Special Education. 2 cares for her animals responsibly and follows the state good practices for small farms. The property is world has safety. Has safely House horses before and she has been quick to respond to any neighbor concerns. This is a modest responsible requests that supports a lifelong community contributor I maintain is the current character of the area. Please vote yes. And I also want to mention that we were taught they were talking about the property value going down. Will her property is is a commercial property. So if they were to put a business on that property that's going to change the dynamics of the residential property to begin with. So we're says on that property would be a lot nicer than having maybe a 7.11, or something. There. Just saying and I also have a letter from a friend of I allowed to read that as well. A letter that came to us from a woman named Laura Watts. >> Stand by. Hold on one second. Pause a timer. No MR. Know, okay. Sorry. You cannot. Thank you for hearing me. All right. Thank you, ma'am. Next we have Kathryn Baumann. >> Bowman Mountain. >> Cap'n, are you here? >> Right. And does not wish to speak is in support. That's why not okay. Robert Cleave supporters does not wish to speak. So with that yeah, we're going close. The public hearing will bring it back to committee. Kind of get a sense of where we want to land this plane tonight. Committee members, if you're in the green room, would love to love to get you back up here so we can have a full course. Good cause. We're getting talk to us. Thank you to the chair. Support the rezoning rezoning to change Rld safety I do have a few concerns about the additional bills. So our support the rezoning, which now I just have some concerns about the additional legislation that's coming up. Now to issue is. That we could potentially rewind this bill if we I mean, I don't know. You know, we support this. But we don't support the bills. I love. So that's not that's my issue. But I do support. The rezoning. So rezoning to the 50 right now. The neighborhood is pretty much are the 50. Got it okay. All right. That's good information >> and >> if there's any other committee members in the queue, all just go to one quick thing, MR. Harvey, how would it work if just kind of 3 of these traveling together so to speak, but they're not really companions necessarily. There is Sony Knicks. There's a rezoning in the U.S. Straight into those any exception. They're going to administer deviations. So. What happens if we approve one and not the other and then or approve this one of the next one up the last one like it seems like its all for the end product or product of the horses being allowed to be there. So talk to us about that. And then we'll see if there's any other questions on this. Sure. So if you were to approve the rezoning, she would be down zone to an rld 60. >> And then if you went ahead and voted on the other 2 matters and they were both tonight, it would be if it would be that, though there will be a denial of an administrative, the deviation, Amazon Inc exception and she would be stuck in that down-zoning. Now, if there was conversation to be had for to allow her to withdraw. So that way she wouldn't be forced to down zone in. That would be something that you guys would have to discuss prior to voting on the. We to the rezoning of the First Amendment. I mean, that skews me first Bill, which is 5, 9, 2, So if you were to make a taking action to approve that when she would be stuck at the 60. >> Okay. And understood. Understood. So with that, we'll go kind of the rest. The number will we have one member of the ku areas and then we will. Does that make sense? Because we got okay. No, you can't We can ask you a question and perhaps someone will. But for now, we're gonna go to the queue has areas you're recognized. Thank you, MISTER Chair. I do have a question for Ogc right now. Is Carney looking at potentially all the 60 if it? Passes to all the 60, what's going to happen to the national properties that are attorneys on this either going to be out of compliance or I mean, now Do the chair to councilmember area snow. They would it would be consistent. And I believe. >> Staff can speak on the surrounding areas regarding that particular property being downed zone from to our the 60 here in the compatibility chair of your mind. >> Through the chair to come to an area. So, yeah, I mean, this is rezoned the 60 it wouldn't affect any of the other surrounding properties, they would still keep their entitlement right for doing commercial uses this this property. So 71, 26 within just lose those commercial potential uses and only be allowed to do the uses under our od 60, which is primarily single-family dwellings. Perfect. All right. >> I I you know, one of the things that I was Rhode Island the expertise knowledge of the District Council member. >> And in this case, MISTER Gaffney, as you stated, you know, I want individuals to enough is enough. You've had going on 3 months now of these conversations. I don't see what the difference of one more conversation of the be. I would be in support of supporting primary because you are you councilmember, you know, better than this. Then all of us. And also, you know, U.S. Has been 3 months. It was just a one-time there for the first time. I will open to that, but it's it's been moved county couple tied the county couple times. But I would support the 60 Down-zoning. That's the case. However. I don't think that's what they're going to want. It doesn't go through all the all the way to the end. All I'll see how the conversations go here with the body. Thank you. >> Alright, Councilmember White. You're recognized. Owns more of a legal question of. Leo. Using since move I've ever seen one like business. Number one really affects what, 2, 3, I don't know if you can take him out of water calls. If the zoning what passed on the horses and I don't put MISTER Gaffney also admits there is a is she might want to keep it. See but commercial on it which people would like either. I think it's unfair to her to be caught in this trap. Is there any way we can look at the other 2 0st? Or I'll call appear must be written or mine on as that question. But I think you just answered it. That was my first question. If the other 2 fails. Yes, sir. >> If you wanted to if you were to vote on this first one and it went through and then the other 2 were to fail. You would be able to do a motion for reconsideration on on this issue. If you wanted to provide her and opportunity not to lose the down-zoning but to provide a and for the other 2 bills, if you were to take them out of order, you wouldn't be able to granting them the ministry, the deviation on exception that you had his own and are ready. >> came out and going visit a question or request. If that happens that way and understand I would put the reconsider and I hope that would get support. >> Yeah, I mean, that's >> that we did have one of those like either last year, the year before where it similar to where the land use will pass within the zoning doesn't pass for whatever reason. We have to go back and we have to unwind the land. You color up an extra question course. >> Yes, Do you kind of follow where we're headed? >> a guess. My question is like some some things were said that aren't. >> Well, can I use it to your question to the It looks like MR. Deathly want him boat on one. And if it. >> I thought you just asked if we could vote on that one last. >> No, Things that come out of water. We have to vote on this one. But if the other 2 it and I don't know what will happen on them, but they failed. One of us up here would ask for reconsideration on the first one. And you we can drill that back in and you could probably keep your zone. And as it stands, just want to make sure you understood that. >> Yeah, I definitely want to keep my zoning was thank you. That's all. I'm a man. Okay. All right. Thank you. Council recognized. >> Thank you, MR. Chair. I'm exactly where COUNCILMAN, why was I just didn't want the applicant to lose the zoning that she has now. So all support a reconsideration down the road. That's where we need to go Canada just to show my cards like I grew up in the ranch country like 3 horses. Don't give me any Harper in the slightest. >> But it doesn't look like there's a lot of interest in that appear. So I suspect we'll just, you know, do the revisit. >> All right. We have no other speakers in the queue. >> And I believe the bill and having moved the bill. I think we a motion in second on the i was a motion a second on the bill. No further discussion open about records of >> 40 yeas, one nay. All right. Direction. You have approved. 25 5.92 And next we will go to item number for 6, which is the zoning exception. Just to me okay. 2025 5.93 Council is pleased to clear any ex parte communication you've had at this time. Gaffney recognized thank chair. After the Clarence it would be Mueller and landed before in my office at 3.30, today. >> Also received a call from Brenda Priestly yesterday, asking them to support. Also visit the neighbor's property. I don't have a date only but a Michigan 5 legislative services. Thank you. Councilmember White. You're recognized. >> It's same x part. A is a previous bill and all of them will be filed with legislative services. >> All right. With that, we will go ahead and open the public hearing to staff report. >> Thank you. This is the companion zoning exception ordinance 2025 Dash 0, 5, 9, 3, which is seeking to allow for animals other than household pets. Specifically 3 horses within the rld 60 zoning district. The subject property get is located along Garden Street, which is primarily developed with single-family dwellings, where the immediate surrounding lot are larger in size. Approximately one acre or larger staff has reviewed their request and finds that the propose use is consistent with the comp plan to allow for the keeping up horses with rpi land use category, which is allowed as a secondary use. We find the used to be compatible with the existing contiguous lot has similar equestrian uses are present on neighboring parse properties which are zoned r Acre and do allow for horses by right, which further demonstrate the compatibility allowing the property owner to keep the horses on the property will not create environmental impacts inconsistent with the health safety and welfare of the community that currently exist, which does have a more world feel with larger. Lots and existing equestrian uses. So because of these reasons and those in the staff report, we forward a recommendation of approval. Again, application was heard by Planning Commission on SEPTEMBER 4th. Were there too property owners adjacent 7100 garden trees spoke in opposition. Again. The concern for the lot sizes in the orders from the horses commission had the same concerns and they voted unanimously to deny the zoning exception application. >> Thank you so much with that. We will go to our speaker cards first, we'll go to the applicant. Ms Miller. And again, for all the speakers out there, just keep your comments directed to the zoning exception and that's that's pretty much it. That's what we're having right now. So goodness, Miller, and are you ready? >> name is Mary Agnes been Cliff Miller. Isis. Thank you for letting me address my 3 requests. I work at the door for school. Special education, teach their peak or spec riding there. The challenge, children. My husband was diagnosed with aggressive form of cancer. We bought the property at 71. 26 Garden Street higher there with 3 of my older retirement. Their peak or says. A previous owner had 3 horses living on this land. And according to her with that was without an issue. I put a carport up for shelter for the worse is and one of my neighbors complained to the city. I asked Mr, Scott, where he would like the shelter to go and he told me out in the middle, my pastor. So I paid to have somebody calm and I promptly moved that to be a good neighbor. I'm now seeking to change my property from commercial to residential allowing up to 3 horses. This is Scott mentioned that I was doing this illegal. Know I got the citation. I have been in constant contact with Officer Collins updating her on what's been happening. I'm not doing anything illegal I am honest in person and I'm a rule follower. So I just needed to clear that up. So in the wild, so addressing horses on this property. In the wild horses need at acre and a half to live on the land. I am feeding them twice a day so they do not need that amount of land. So it's not something that they're lacking there. Happy and healthy. MR. Gaffney talk to me to today. He mentioned that I had able time I have not had ample time to address that. I have had the city out and I have had the state out when the city came Stephen came out, he said it was workable, but he wanted the state's opinion on it. I am now a member of the small farms, best practices program. And I talked to Kelly Johnson from there and also I have forwarded that information since we met this afternoon I got with the men have for that. Both to COUNCILMAN Carlucci and to you so you do have all the information and I was told that that is legally binding and that all they would should need to do. Just to give you that information. And I have my member number, which is on that information that was sent to you before this meeting. Start. So once again, a few which is twice a day, they do not need an acre to have to be on the horse. Experts have come out and approve that they've addressed that. There is not a water shed area. And she pointed out that I'm not even near the Saint Johns River and the only water that on my properties from a spring and natural spring that runs through the 2 properties next to me, my property. And it used to run through MR. Scott's property. Okay. Thank you so much nights. We have. >> Aimee Grand Xao. >> This is Amy Grant. I belief that the committee members have already received by support letter. My daughter is actually one of the students who's been receiving therapeutic horse riding lessons from cis for the last 4 years. She is a wonderful teacher. She teaches. Disabled children and very challenge special needs children like my daughter. And I've seen her with her horses. I know nothing about horses, except I'm wearing some cowboy boots tonight. And that's all I know about horses. But I do know that she deeply cares for these therapeutic horses. They are all retired horses. They're not. Running around. I mean, they're, you know, walking slow and they're very gentle. There. Very nice sources that deserve a place to retire. And I know SIs we'll be providing them a fantastic place and she takes very good of the quick care of the horses. I'm city girl. I don't like to smell horses and I've never had an issue going Wesson class. Where says he's there. There's never been an issue of. Horse manure and all that kind of stuff that I would possibly find offensive, end. So if this were my neighbor and I live in a very nice neighborhood Ponte Vedra Beach, I would not have an issue because I know the horses would be very well kept. They would be very clean and I would not smell anything. And I I'm a sensitive, no smaller things. You know, my child is very, very lucky. Winning score to be receiving classes from says. And I think she's a well deserved. You know, 2 men in this community. And I understand that some of the neighbors MAY not be very happy with the horses, but it's very strange that if they lift with horses next story for over 6 years, my understanding is that why is it now that they're having issue and also in concert, you know, considering that the horses are no longer desirable, that seems to be very strange to me that they've never complained during that entire time where those previous sources where the were there, that seems very strange to me. And so and it seems like they've been neighbors and insistent says has been in the neighborhood for what, like 36 years. So these people obviously know each other very well. So I I find it very strange that they win. No, that's s. Having many horses on her property. I think it's what 6 or so on our current property. What want to keep some? Forces. You know, after she bought this piece of property. That's all I can share. Thank you very much. And I still I still what I want I spoke with says last night, just I didn't recommend to her that she should good counsel. I don't understand why MR. Gaffney didn't, you know, suggested. I think that would be the reasonable thing to do given that she's got 3 different items. She doesn't have any background in doing this sort of thing. That was the first thing out with that was pay. Was your counsel? That's why time. Thank you. Thank you so Next, we MR. Vincent Scott. >> 2, MISS. Got to go first. Not this time. All right. Come Name and address. Of course, I disagree with that. Change in and Florida allowed the horses. And have this in everyone. I'm the one who lives next to the horses. Want to talk about how good they're up. His and I'm going take your with us. And the hosts might need that. Misty, we have 5 acres across the street and I don't need that much eat by not leaving across the street when they were. I'm the one that lives next door. I feel like my property that is going to be decrease. Understanding your friends. Look for I mean, I would think I look for my friends are right. Some nice about me to also. But if to my understanding the place that you they have the vision to help horses. So I mean, you you can leave us a little bit where you work. You have to bring home especially across the street next to me. The statement that I'm the one that total for the put Which I think again, the COUNCILMAN, copy of the conversation in email she kept actually we want to put it that the city told him to move it. I don't contact the city, no, but will you want to put? I want to please, you? No, you just want to see something and then say MR. Scott, to me to do it. And that's exactly what happened. And I gave COUNCILMAN Gaffney copy of the email so you can see it. No, I don't think is fair. I don't think that you should be able buy a piece of property and just change zoning, whether residents there like it or not. Yeah, I'm with it to the crease in the prep today. Yes, you could make app to anything you want to that it might. Yeah, it's good for the community. It's good. It's it's healthy for the neighborhood. We have a residential community. Nobody has a 1500 pounds a and the House. And what a great fall. And in the neighborhood around there that this is we're trying to improve the neighborhood. We're not trying to go back to 1960, this spending bill and have the everyday. I mean, so you don't have to have your horses there at that. Just does that. I did have been in that therapy. Horses. You got places for that. This is something that you won't change the law to be various. Give me a deviation. Donate to be can I wanted to be a half a year. Well, this is room in fetal twice a day. Anybody can do that. Just what I want get my friends to come up put me whether I'm right or wrong. Forget with the need stay. They were there for us. I don't care. I want my whole there. And that's with scenes. And it's not fair. Thank you, sir. Next we have Rhonda Scott. >> Rhonda everyone, 0, 0 Garden Street. What the previous people have already Some of that is incorrect. When we first moved that property. 22 years ago we bought the property and then they're 18. There were not any forces there with the previous neighbor. There's been great previous residence there. One resident did have horses, however, we were unaware of any zoning violation if they have any needs on violations that we were aware of, someone had told about it. We would have reported them and I want to get that straight. We do not want horses on this property. As of MAY. Their horses on their property. 2 to 3 horses, the its own. So they should not be new horses only in the first place until this has been resolved. Also, the property has a natural creek that runs Weston, 8th. My house sits on the east side of the property. Sometimes if it rains, the overflowed. So some of the what it gets in our yard. However, there is concern. There will be a concern and has been a concern to any runoff that contains animal waste. Your rent or chemical residues would enter this creek. And what I feel like that this runoff will a risk of bacterial contamination equal lie. Increased nutrient loading but isn't nitrogen phosphorus and the downstream ecosystem. Given that the property also includes an 1100 square foot residence rain and other structures. The horses reside on the back side of the property, which is directly by my garage. Unfortunately, with this, there's only 50 or 60, 50 to 40% of that. What none not acreage and which the 3 forces are on. So right when I walked out my side or garage, I see this table with the horses, which is completely unacceptable. This is a residential area and we should have to be. Oppose that to happen. You subject to that. Also, there is an older they can attract course by stable flies and mosquitoes. There's ongoing health and sanitation concerned. And these notices will directly affect us. Not anybody else here, but only me and my husband. It would affect us. And we have experienced express fear deteriorate. Outdoor air quality. And while so peaceful enjoyment of our own property. Additionally, any noise and visual blight from animal pens and waste. Will reduce the neighborhood character in property values, the neighborhood character, not horses. You're no other horses in this neighborhood. This lady is the only one horses and she should keep them across the street where they belong. >> Thank you, ma'am. In think a recognized account been Freeman for joining us. Thank you for joining us. Right on time for that. The 3 bills traveling together. So with that will go to Tom Maguire. If you wish to speak. After that, we have Amy Tomko. >> And then Karen, Aaron Carroll, thank you. >> Good evening. Maguire for 7, 1, 1, heard a road, Jacksonville, Florida, 3, 2, 2, 1, 0, and let me be clear on this. I think the greatest, the greatest purpose that y'all. But Phil, as members of the City council is to bring about utility Kerry and his son. That is the greatest good for the greatest number. These horses are community benefit that needs to be considered as you move forward we've also already covered the on this property are consistent and compatible with city and state standards and the city described the property as workable for state has no objections. So I don't see why you all should have any objections either. As for some of the things brought up biting insects. Well, if there were dogs on the property, those would also draw biting insects. Water I understand The the creek has been somewhat obstructed anyway. So that's impacting water runoff. So we're already dealing with that so again, I ask you to consider what is the greatest good for the greatest number. These horses benefit people. We already people talking about the benefits their their family is receiving from these sources. So I urge you to do the right thing here. Help the people out. Thank you. >> All right. Next we have Amy Tomko. And the thing. My name is Amy Tomko, 3, 7, 7, 5, Oaks drive east. I'm here to show my support ordinance. 2025. '05, 9, 2, 9, 3, 9, 4, These horses are well cared for. I volunteer and work at the school and work with the children with writing program for the disabled children and Sis always has the best interest of animals and the people in mind because they're well cared for. She feeds twice a day, as we said, and the matter guards, too. Smells mining in sacks. The horse flies are in wooded areas. They don't come just because there is forces around and for that matter odor, they school of special education is in the middle of a neighborhood area. You do not notice any odor whenever any of the children are coming for their classes, our into the barn, even. And then for that matter, if we're saying that it's ok for says staff a horse across the street, then the biting and Saks, so-called flies and mosquitoes. And older not know a property line. So if they would should already be experiencing that problem, which they do not. So I just please ask for you to vote in support. >> All right. Thank you. Next we have Hering Co. So at the last letter there's on is here. Okay. Alright, in support does not wish to speak. >> Billy Williams. One down. >> Philly up, William, 71 11 Garden Street. My experience has fears of loud noises odors and other nuisances being created by. Keeping courses are often unfounded, are exaggerated. I have resided at 71 11 Garden Street. And later in my adjacent home in the water, also division since 1982. In addition to 71 26 Garden Street. The applicant also owns rural residential properties at 71 17 and 71. 25 Garden Street these border, both my rural residential acreage in my subdivision, residents lot in water, Brook falls. There have been horses house lawfully at 71 17 71. 25 Garden Street for many years under various owners. My residences within within 100 feet of the horses. And there have been 0 problems of any type over the years. Property values have been rising rapidly and water, Brooke Fall subdivision and the surrounding area up around 40% since 2020. I see no possibility of declining values caused by the presence of horses on Akers size. Lots. Van Cleave Miller is a very conscientious horse owner or animals appear will fared and cared for. She donates her time in animals to helping those less fortunate. Among us, she has a proven track record and housing horses with no negative effects to those living nearby. In summary, my properties completely border her acreage on the east and north several homes in the Water. Root Ball subdivision border. Her acreage on the West during my 14 years as PRESIDENT Of the water Falls Homeowners Association board of directors and chair sharing many meetings during those years. I have heard no complaints about odors noise or other problems originating from her property. I recommend approval of 2025, 0, 5, 9, 3. Thank you. Thank you, sir. >> All right. Next we have Kathryn Bauman does not wish to speak is in support. And Robert Van Cleave does not wish to speak is and support. With that will close public bring back to committee. All right. We have a motion to second on the bill committee. Members now would be the time to kind of. Ask your route. Your thoughts. This is the exception for the Rld, 60 zoning that we just approves. i've got a few. Comments for myself, but, you know, definitely want to hear from his many committee members as MR. Gaffney will good start with you. You're recognized. Thank you to the chair. So let me say I love horses. I'm pretty sure we all do. I do want to make this about horses that we did not as Bill. It's about this is not about. >> Or is this is about the zoning exception. My biggest concern about this legislation it's a creek is floor from the applicant er to the neighbor's yard, which means horse with the use the restroom whatever reason, some buy products that a horse, it flows into the neighbor yard. That was one of the reasons why planning Commission the knot this piece legislation. That's one of my biggest issue that brought that before as Marilyn attention, I would go and shimmy list. They wanted to Mueller than about that. If you define that, we just took a team. The draft is on for weeks. It's been issue for like the last full weeks. This whole create this lawn. And I the only issue when it's raining because, you know, that's when it flows when it's raining some type of a breeze and stuff like that. But besides for a couple of the neighbors, they point out as Miller also own property across the street when she have 5 to 6 horses. This current on the property. My whole thing is. Or are we take a horses from across the street, rezone another property and bring horses over here? You know, if you have one the council is trying keep the horses over there. I mean, that's not try to resolve is not compatible and it doesn't lead to cat at a neighborhood that's on the other side of the street. Like I said, an issue that that that that's a major concern. And and I like I This administrative, the mediation, this deception haven't been a section on this side. The last 5 to 10 years is very inconsistent. And what is neighborhood is going on this side of the street is inconsistent and what is areas going at? So as you can see pd are the 60's around? It is no administration ba sons in the last to 10 years on the side. So think about questions. >> Councilmember you're recognized. Thank you, MISTER Chair. I'm conflicted. I was also my colleagues in the District Council the same time. Some retired therapy horses coin therapy does so much for people. Do what you do with tire decline therapy horses after the fact they're like the most awful chill. Course you're going to find these are not wild that job or says they're just going to hang out and do nothing. Allison, everybody else. But this is this isn't giving me a lot of heartburn to say yes, but, you know, you know, the neighborhood and the neighbors that you. Alright, COUNCILMAN Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you, chair. I had a >> question maybe don't even know whether we can can because this MAY be planning. But this is more about. I heard someone say one of the gentleman that spoke, who's the next door neighbor about property value isn't it? The place is right across the street and kind of looked at it on the map. Avenues have not been there, but wouldn't the property value be the same? Because you are like literally yards away from where it is now. Can someone speak to that or could there be a possible decrease in value based on? Putting this next to the House. Is that something that is substantive? Anybody? Whoever I mean, >> it would be a speculative answer. I think so. It's anybody who understands what was taken. Give me anything. I just want to for make a decision. All right. The other thing is, as the COUNCILMAN Said earlier about was there, any attempt to mitigate? >> The runoff. As the councilmen that canceled after was talking about the runoff in creek to go next door. Was there any kind of attempt to make it to one up? If I chair, if I could give me what that mitigation attempt was. >> Name and address, ma'am. And you can enter the COUNCILMAN's include Miller. 71. 26 Garden Street when we got deny, deny, deny. They said talk to this person. We've spoken to him. Talked see what the so the city came out, Stephen, with the city came out and said it was doable. But that did not. Was not a water issue was not a runoff issue, but he don't know in courses so well deferred. I will do whatever the states. And so then the state came out. Kelly Johnson from the state of Florida Water Management came out, saw the property gave a couple suggestions. I did them all. She wanted to have it. It's actually not a creek at This is spring. There's a spring in effects. My 2 neighbors, myself and the neighborhood Block this spring that used to flow through. It's not right. But anyway, so it's not flowing anymore the way it used to. So what Kelly from the state of Florida came out and said 2 line, the whole property. So it is all been lime. So even if there were any small at all, it's not anymore. There's lawn. And also we planted a whole nother section of grass. So there, you know, everything has been done to make this property perfect for these horses and some mitigation. Just so I understand because I want get to the crux of it. >> The mitigation was the line and the side correct? Yes. We also cut there are some vegetation around where the spring water went. So I cut that out, too. Do Thank you for that is an event and I did send all the information and I'm now a member of the best practices. Counsel and deputy, when you say you're concerned about that, that the state of Florida has looks at random. Got to stay on the looked at specifically right, understand it because I don't have a limited time. Sure. Thank you. Through the Is anybody from planning? Does that sound like the line and the site? Is that something that we know? I mean, obviously that's not your bailiwick. So to speak. >> But is that something that usually is mitigation? >> Proper for. >> Having those kind of to the chair to account when Johnson just limited research, I have heard of that before. And so, but I would refer to the experts from the state what mitigation would be needed. And I listen to my colleagues, thank you. And for the feedback. >> Councilor areas you are recognized. Thank you, MR. Chair. I am like my colleague, MISTER Dimon. I feel the same sentiment regarding, you know, it's across the street. And what difference does it make in the grand scheme of things? But when it comes to council murdered Johnson's question regarding party value. Obviously we can answer that. However, I will tell you this. It will directly affect the neighbors that reminding started this property in Maine have not affected before because cross the street. But right now it will be right next to them. And if I was sitting in their shoes, our feel same way it could potentially affect my property. It is somebody MAY not want to buy a house. My house I want to sell because there's a horse now, right next to me were before was across the street effect. The next door neighbor. So not not regard. I do feel for them. The second part is the way I see it is while they've been good neighbors and they are still good neighbors. They've been there I don't know, decades across street and now to have them come across the street to this new part it just doesn't work that way. My world and any world, any scenario because at the end what's been grandfathered in before. Doesn't mean that should be grandfathered in automatic. Moines across your where the cases, that's reason why there's the term grandfathered in now they're doing is literally changing that. I guarantee you if they had tried to do this, you know, in Mike in 10 years from now. And they want to put horses there. They probably won't even get approved to put horses there because that whole area is starting to be developed by hoping residential property. So I the way I see it as they're grandfathered in, they're already there and that sweet spot where they're at it. I would. I would support having them stay there because of the neighbors. Are they going to be directly affecting and once again there to grandfathered in. So that's my logic behind all this. But once again, all that the body continue to speak, but I will be once again siding with district councilmember because this is his district that he knows better. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Before I could count in Gaffney for the second just ask a few questions for myself. >> To MISS Abney, I think I heard you and you can looking much green. Is there a limit to the number of horses like let's say, we approve. >> The zoning exception and the administrative eviation. I don't like either one. I guess the ad is kind of removes the acreage thing. But is there a limit on the number of course, is that? Could be on this property if all 3 of these were approved. >> To the chair. So the zoning code does not set a limit on the number of courses that you can have. Our only criteria is that you have a minimum of 1.5 acres that it's fun, stand-in for private use. But we don't limit the number of horses you can, though, through the zoning exception, set a limitation on the number, course, is that would be allowed on this parcel and that would run with the with the land. >> Understood. There's not a limit, so to speak in the zoning code. There. Kylie's meeting just my overarching comments which are, you know, Sister Ms Miller, obviously you have. Amazing reviews. Like I think you're doing amazing service with your program horse therapy. I've got another friend who does it at their ranch. And it's it's a real thing. And it really does help a lot of people and you take care of your horses. That's been clear. That's been clearly stated. The the tough part is. No, we're not really voting for you. Might your background and your expertise. We're just voting on 71. 26 Garden Street because a year from now. You could not be there. I'm sure you will be. But that property then is stuck with. >> a whole slew of. >> Rezonings and someone could come in with 50 horses. And then, you know, then in a really not Really. The neighbors are really that spot. So that's just kind of looking down the road and understanding, you know. As much as you sound like an amazing person that has a really big heart and that does a lot of good service. That doesn't necessarily. Kerry, all the weight needed just for the property itself because that we're strictly looking at 71. 26 Garden Street. So just to remind my colleagues up here, that's that's kind of. You know, my my thoughts and comments right now. So Kuzma Gaffney, you are recognized and you're the last one in the queue. If anyone else has any comments. Yeah, we'll wait to hear a good cause. We Chad, appreciate you staying there. >> And I did this to be brief as If you come up, please. This nasa. Question. The night, the day I came things less. It's a 7 o'clock. When I came out, was it water flowing from your home, pinning this on the ball? >> No, there's not water flowing because they have blocked the water. This and the horses are on the water either is okay just under 5. Okay. Once again, move to not is because like I said, we have about the ministration deviation on assignment last 5 to 10 years. >> Decides pretty much residential are at the 50 are at the safe in the Knesset direction is going to. It's no horses on this side of land. Misys. You have 4 acres land costs the street. She have 5, 6, houses to add on it. She doesn't even stay at property. A purchase and property inches of rezoning it. So she could this bit horses on the property. I know her attentions is eventually to move. I'm it's a move at his property. But right now she doesn't even stay at his property. So for the reason that I mentioned blessed, I feel like it disrupts the quality make a motion to move, to deny. I'm looking for a second. >> Okay. We do have a motion and second on the motion 2, I >> is that the proper procedure, MR. Be okay. >> And >> I as Miller is. It now is kind of the critical time, right? If we and MR. Harvey, maybe you can just explain this to us, right? Like what happens if we move to deny and we vote this down versus a withdrawal like what it what are the implications? And I don't know. That's what you want to do or not. I'm just I want to educate everybody and what that what that looks like just for options. >> Sure. So the body decides to vote this down. She will be precluded from bringing this similar application before you guys for one year. If she withdraws there's a motion to withdraw from the body. She'll have the opportunity to come back in a later for him but would be restricted to that one year period. Ap vote down this ad. Her excuse me to zoning exception. You've already voted up the the rezoning. So if they were still appetite for that guy's with Dan have to go back and do that motion for reconsideration. Other I should be stuck with down. To the 60 along No, don't exception or administrative deviation if it's go down as Totally understand. So final question, I guess to MISS Miller is. >> You know. If you rather this be withdrawn, speak now or forever hold your peace kind of. This thing. Could Miller? >> 21 country. Do you understand the procedure you either have to if you ever did want to bring it back, as I know, you're thinking moving everything. >> If we deny deny. >> Can't >> come back with any applications for any of this for 12 months, if for some reason you are able to work something. Now, if we withdraw then you can come back in a month or 2 months or 3 months or whatever. I'm just giving you a soft landing spot versus a 12 months. We can't hear anything from you. >> I heard and before the me starting, we're trying to toughen tied about deferring or not. You said that if there is new information or something that we could look at it in different then they're that information has been sent about from the state of Florida. And it. >> We're not there right now. Ms Miller, where we're that option is not on the table. The so there's no motion on the motion defer. No, the motion on the tables to deny. I'm giving you the olive branch of a withdrawal. Okay. And so doesn't withdraw mean that. >> I can. It still gets basically it means that just lose $5,000. Because that's what it took me to apply. Or is it? Yes. That's the that's the cost. It just doesn't seem fair to me to not differ when there's more information and okay, it it said that earlier we could. >> Council Johnson, thank you. Thank you for that guy. Kuzma Johnson the weather. The question about property value property. No, No, ma'am. No, ma'am. Sorry. You can't do that. >> COUNCILMAN, MR. CHAIRMAN, is it possible? And I don't know whether this and it is to to d c obviously that money is paid for the application to the city. If she withdraws, could she then still? Be able use those fees for that future? Applications. And she does want to the properties that possible. If you got through the chair to council member Johnson, if you you guys were to go to withdraw the application the bill. >> You could return that these would be the option that she would have or you guys would. Not those are got it. >> All right. So basically where we're at is Miller, we could we could vote to return the fees to you. And I think there's an app that I think there's a consensus. Here to do that. So basically the Boston right now we need the we need to have the motion to deny withdrawn, make another motion to withdraw. Correct. We have a motion to second on table right now which is to did not deny, correct. We need that removed. Make a motion to withdraw your motion ok and return fees. Okay. Motion a second on the motion to withdraw with the return of fees. Correct? All right. All in favor of the withdrawal. With the fees return is that now the? All right on about? And it was quick down there 7 yeas, 0 nays. >> Okay. So by our action we have withdrawn. 25 5.93 with the return of fees. So with that now, counselors, we need to go back to item. All right. We have a motion

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Land Use & Zoning Committee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: eb0ac4d4ce05a301187d95e1aec0007f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record