POLISCOPE

The public record

VEROBEACH (INDIAN RIVER COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)

Monday, August 23, 2021 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Vero Beach Charter Review Committee met to discuss potential updates to the city charter, focusing on the protection of city parks and the management of city-owned property. The committee debated whether to recommend adding specific park properties to the charter for protection and discussed the financial impact of city land being removed from the tax rolls.

Why it matters

The committee is evaluating which city-owned properties should be protected under the city charter, a decision that influences future land use, potential tax revenue, and the city's ability to sell or lease property.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE MINUTES MONDAY, AUGUST 23, 2021 9:30 A.M. CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, VERO BEACH, FLORIDA PRESENT: Nancy Cook, Chairman; Ken Daige, Vice Chairman; Members: Linda Hillman, Jeff Stassi and Peter Benedict Also Present: John Turner, City Attorney and Tammy Bursick, City Clerk Excused Absence: Mr. Mark Mucher, Alternate Member 1. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Cook called the meeting to order at 9:30 a.m. and today’s meeting resumed. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chairman Cook led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES A) August 12, 2021 Mr. Daige made a motion to adopt the August 12, 2021 minutes. Mrs. Hillman seconded the motion and it passed unanimously. 4. PUBLIC COMMENT 5. NEW BUSINESS Mr. Daige reported that he met with the City Manager and the Public Work’s Director at Edgewood Addition regarding the Park property that he would like to have put in the Charter under protected properties. He said that while they were meeting they spoke to the neighbor adjacent to this piece of property and there was some concerns about having a Park that close to their property. The neighbors will be meeting to discuss the possibility of putting this piece of property into the Charter and he will report back to the Committee. Chairman Cook commented that the Charter Review Committee’s purview is only to make recommendations. The Committee needs to decide if they want to put this piece of property into the Charter. She said whoever maintains this piece of property is not part of their purview. Mr. Daige requested holding off until their next meeting to decide on this because it will give the neighbors time to meet and he will report back at that meeting. Chairman Cook asked the Committee if this is something as a group that they want to do (put it in the Charter) or do they want to pass on it. Mrs. Hillman suggested deciding if they want to recommend it to City Council and then move forward. 6. OLD BUSINESS Page 1 CRC 8/23/2021

A) Finalize Charter Review Commission Recommendations being sent to the City Council Chairman Cook requested that the Committee go back and review all the recommendations that they have made since their review of the Charter first started and then add anything that they would like to see in the Charter. Mrs. Hillman mentioned that she wrote down at their last meeting that they were going to ask the City surveyor how much green space is left in the City. Chairman Cook reported that the City has 27 Parks located within the City limits and 44% of those Parks have been taken off of the tax rolls for one (1) reason or another. She wondered how much percentage of property is allowed to be taken off the tax rolls. Mr. Stassi commented that they have discussed a lot of the different properties and there are some small slivers here and there that could be put up for sale. He said maybe the neighbors would purchase them and it would bring in some additional revenue for the City. Chairman Cook looked at the list of surplus property that they were provided with by the City surveyor and said that most of it looks like abandoned easements. Mr. Stassi commented that if the City is mowing and maintaining these pieces of properties it would be worth it for them to look at selling them. He said that the maintenance of these properties is costing the City $2 million a year. Mr. Daige explained the $2 million is for the entire maintenance package and the on-going costs to maintain bathrooms at their Parks, roofs, Leisure Square, etc. He said they can go through and pick what they want to sell off. He said if they think some of the protected Parks are too big and they want to get rid of some of the land associated with the Parks they could look at doing that also. Mrs. Hillman brought up the 1.2 acres given to Florida Power and Light (FPL) to build their substation. She asked if there was some additional land remaining at this postal annex property that could be sold. Mr. John Turner, City Attorney, explained that this property was going to be declared surplus and sold. The City will first obtain an appraisal and then go out for proposals. Chairman Cook asked if they should be suggesting to Council what pieces of surplus properties should be sold. Mr. Turner said no. He said that they just needed to stick to reviewing the Charter. Chairman Cook asked what about the pieces of property that are listed in the Charter and have been declared surplus property. Mr. Daige explained that the Parks that are in the Charter are protected pieces of property and have not been declared surplus. Mr. Turner said there is no surplus property that he is aware of other than the two (2) pieces of property located on the Three Corners site. Page 2 CRC 8/23/2021

Mr. Stassi commented that because the Charter is only reviewed every 10 years this would be the time to put everything on the table that they would either like added to the Charter or removed from the Charter. Mr. Turner explained the purpose of having a Charter Review Committee is for them to review the Charter in the context of updating the Charter. He said that is what the City Council has instructed them to do. He said as far as surplus property that is handled by Ordinance. Mrs. Hillman said since they are supposed to be discussing the Charter that they start from the beginning and go through it and comment on everything that they have previously discussed so that the Council can see it as part of the record. Chairman Cook did not feel that they needed to go through the whole Charter again. She said lets discuss the things that they have previously voted on. Mr. Daige agreed with going over the highlights that they have discussed and if there is something on the list that they need to talk about again that they could do that. Chairman Cook agreed to going through their recommendations one (1) at a time. She said the big change for the City is that now they don’t have the electric utility to rely on for revenue anymore. She said they may want to recommend additional items to the Charter with regards to tax free property in the City because that is their income source. Mr. Daige suggested looking at the properties in the Charter that are protected and see if there are any properties that they would like to take out of the Charter. Chairman Cook said that generally speaking there is a large amount of property that has been taken off the tax rolls already. Mr. Daige added that there are a few nonprofit organizations using City Parks that are on protected property so there is no revenue coming in for those properties. Chairman Cook suggested looking at more properties to take off the tax rolls and limiting the amount of property that the City allows to be taken off the tax rolls. Mr. Stassi felt that was up to the City Manager to review those on a regular basis and determine what is surplus and can get it back on the tax roll. Mr. Daige recalled if they go back in history they had some Councils’ concerned about the budget and they did look at surplus property and there wasn’t much that made a difference as to whether they kept it or sold it. He said they may want to have a discussion going forward on whether or not the City should lease out property to nonprofit organizations. Mr. Stassi said that would be up to staff. He said if it was up to him he would have a rate for nonprofits and a rate for profits, but not lease property for a dollar a year. Chairman Cook reiterated that 44% of properties inside the City limits are off the tax rolls. Page 3 CRC 8/23/2021

Mr. Daige said they could do a breakout of that 44% and see what they are. He said that some of this 44% is submerged lands, schools, churches, etc. He said there is not really that much to sell off. He agreed that there are budget restraints and they are trying to generate more revenue for the City, but that is not up to this Committee. It would be up to the sitting City Council on how to bring in more revenue. At this time, the Committee went through the items outlined on the July 14, 2021, memorandum that they previously voted on. 1. Issue to be addressed pursuant to Council directive: Compensation for City Councilmembers. A motion was made that the Mayor’s salary be increased to $1,300 a month and that the City Councilmember’s salary be increased to $1,075 a month. That they should get the CPI index increase for the last year or what the employees received last year, which was 3%. Then whatever is given to the City employees going forward should also be given to the City Council. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Stassi commented that if they don’t make a change now to the City Councilmember’s salaries then it could be another 20 years before they are given an increase. He said that they have looked at what other cities are paying their Councils and they are not out of line with this recommendation. The Council needs to have a salary that would entice a younger person to run for City Council or someone that doesn’t make a lot of money where they work and needs the additional income to participate as a Councilmember. He said the National League of Cities (NLOC) states that the average City Councilmember in a city of their size works about 20 hours a week and makes up to $20,000 a year. He reiterated that nothing that they have recommended is out of line. Mrs. Hillman commented that at the present time they may have some members serving on Council that don’t have to depend on this income. But, as a whole everyone in the City has urged young people to get involved and younger people have to depend on their income and they should have some incentives to run for City Council. She agrees with moving forward and recommending this raise. This gives people a chance to run for City Council and have some money to depend on when they give up their income to attend City meetings. Mr. Benedict commented that they needed to make sure that this amendment would not be a “budget buster.” He would support the motion as it is. Mr. Daige agreed that what they came up with is very modest and it is up to the City Council if they want to approve it or not. Chairman Cook also agreed that it is very modest and helps cover the extra cost for someone thinking about being on the Council and not having them to essentially pay to be on the Council. Mr. Turner reminded the Committee that the Council was looking for the pros and cons for each of their recommendations. He said that the pros would be that this is a modest increase and is reasonable based upon the amount of time that Council spent preparing for agenda items. It shows respect for people who volunteer to take the position of City Councilmember because it makes it more attractive. One (1) of the cons could be that it would have an impact on the budget. Mr. Daige commented that if City Council allows this item to go on the ballot and when the voter looks at it and considers it they will not think that it is a huge increase and will vote for it. He said it is not something that will shock the voter. Page 4 CRC 8/23/2021

Mr. Benedict wanted to make it clear that they were approving this recommendation, but this would not be the language that appears on the ballot. Mr. Daige said that was correct. The language is up to the City Attorney. 2. Issue to be addressed pursuant to Council directive: Process of selecting the Mayor The motion made was that the Mayor will be an elected separate office for four (4) years. The motion passed 3-2 with Mr. Mucher voting yes, Mr. Daige no, Mr. Stassi yes, Mrs. Hillman yes, and Chairman Cook no. Chairman Cook stated that she still stands by the way she voted before and that is no. She said they have a strong City Manager run government, which works out very well for this City and having the electors choose the Mayor would not be in the best interest of the City Council. Mr. Benedict wanted to hear the pros and cons. Mr. Stassi commented that ICMA shows that 50% of Mayors are elected for a four (4) year term and these cities have a City Manager form of government. He said having longer terms for Mayor allows the Mayor and the City Council to see some projects through completion. He felt that it was better to have longer terms for the Mayor. He said by not allowing the Mayor to be selected by the voters they could be infringing on people’s democratic process. The Mayor would be more responsive to the people that elected him rather than the City Council. Mr. Benedict wanted to make it clear that through the election process someone would run specifically for Mayor. He was not in support of having the Mayor elected because they could have qualified candidates who might have run for City Council, but chose to run for Mayor because the seat was open. He said that this seems like it would work better for a bigger City. Mr. Daige liked the way that the City handles this now and that is the City Council nominates the Mayor. He said that the Mayor sets the tone of the meeting. If during the term of office there is a need for a different Mayor then the Council is able to do that. Mrs. Hillman looked at the wall in the back of the Council Chambers and counted how many Mayors that were in office while they were trying to sell the Power Plant. She said that there were seven (7) Mayors. If the Mayor was elected for a four (4) year term the sale probably would have occurred earlier because they wouldn’t have had to start over every time a new Mayor came into office. She feels the people should have the opportunity to select the Mayor and is in favor of having an elected Mayor for four (4) years. Mr. Stassi expressed that the Mayor is one (1) voting member of the Council. He or she has no authority over day to day operations of the City. Selecting a Mayor for four (4) years is better than two (2) years because that is just not enough time. He said that it takes four (4) years to get something done. Mrs. Hillman added that every single year the Mayor is selected by the Council and it usually takes the Mayor at least a year to learn his or her duties for the City. She doesn’t believe that is enough time for him or her to learn all the responsibilities of being Mayor. Page 5 CRC 8/23/2021

Mr. Stassi reiterated that the selection of the Mayor by the voters is a fair democratic process. Mrs. Hillman made a motion that the citizens elect a separate Mayor for a four (4) year term. Mr. Stassi seconded the motion and it failed 3-2 with Mr. Benedict voting no, Mr. Stassi yes, Mrs. Hillman yes, Mr. Daige no, and Mrs. Cook no. 3. Issue to be addressed pursuant to Council directive: Terms of office. The motion was to change the term of Councilmembers from two (2) years to four (4) year terms. The motion passed 4-1 with Mr. Mucher voting yes, Mr. Daige no, Mr. Stassi yes, Mrs. Hillman yes, and Chairman Cook yes. Everyone on the Committee was in support of increasing the term of office to four (4) years except for Mr. Daige. The Committee went over the pros and cons. Mr. Benedict said that one (1) of the pros would be for the Councilmember to have the ability to have more time to get up to speed. Mr. Daige commented that he has seen many times in the past that a Councilmember would come in with an idea that is not good for the City and the City suffers. This would be a con. If the voters want to put the person back into office after a two (2) year term then they could. He was not changing his vote. Mr. Benedict asked if this passed how they would work out the terms. He was told that they would need to be staggered over a couple of years. Mr. Daige mentioned that this matter has been put on the ballot a couple of times and each time it did not pass. Mr. Stassi said one (1) of the pros is that the cost of the Election would be cheaper. Mr. Benedict added that another pro would be that the candidate would be able to be more productive without having to campaign every two (2) years. Mr. Daige commented that the City Council wants to hear the pros and the cons, which is good for them to hear. He said that the word needs to get out for both sides. 4. Issue to be addressed pursuant to Council directive Charter Review The motion passed unanimously that the Charter of the City of Vero Beach should be reviewed every five (5) years. The Committee all agreed that this recommendation needs to go forward to Council. Mr. Turner mentioned that it does not necessarily have to be done every five (5) years. He suggested that it be reviewed every eight (8) to 10 years. He said it does take time to form a Charter Review Committee and have the review done. He said if something comes up in the meantime, Council can always send a Charter change to the voters. Page 6 CRC 8/23/2021

Mr. Stassi agreed that the normal time to wait to have a Charter review is 10 years, but he thinks that is too long to wait to review making changes in the Charter for the City government. Mr. Benedict wondered if they could use like five (5) to eight (8) years and have some flexibility in the language that goes on the ballot. Mr. Turner would not recommend that. Chairman Cook felt that this Committee had to meet a lot longer than they should have because the Charter in this case had not been reviewed for such a long time. Mr. Daige recalled that the Committee had a lot of discussion in making the decision to review the Charter every five (5) years. He said that he was fine with leaving it at five (5) years. The City Council might change that time period, but the Committee’s message is that it be reviewed sooner than every 10 to 15 years. Mr. Stassi recalled that when they were all being interviewed to be on this Committee what he heard from most of the Councilmembers is that they believed 10 years was a long time to wait to review the Charter. 5. Issue to be addressed pursuant to Council directive: Canvassing Board The Charter Committee unanimously agreed to housekeeping measures for Section 4.06 of the Charter to now read: The City Canvassing Board shall be composed of the City Clerk, City Manager, and the City Attorney. An alternate member, if needed for any reason, shall be chosen by the Canvassing Board. The City Attorney shall act as Chairman. The responsibilities of the Canvassing Board shall be to cooperate with the Supervisor of Elections in canvassing the returns of the Election, general supervision of the Election procedures, and any other procedural responsibilities related to the Election appropriate under applicable law. The Canvassing Board shall meet after the Election at the Supervisor of Election’s office at a specified time and date and shall proceed to canvass the returns of the Election and shall deliver to City Council at its Organizational meeting a certificate provided by the Supervisor of Elections containing the total number of votes cast for each candidate. The certificate shall be placed on file with the City Clerk. Mr. Turner stated that it was time to clean up this language that was in the Charter and make it relevant to their situation now. Chairman Cook noted that this was just a housekeeping measure for the Election process and she does not see any cons to making this change to the Charter. Chairman Cook went back to the piece of property in the Edgewood Addition and asked the Committee if they wanted to put it in the Charter to be protected. Mr. Daige requested to wait until they hear back if the neighbors are in agreement to do this. He would prefer that the neighbors decide. He knows that he was the one that was pushing to have this in the Charter, but once everyone met on the property some concerns came up from the neighbors. Chairman Cook did not see any reason for the Committee to meet again. The Committee agreed with including this piece of property in the Charter. Page 7 CRC 8/23/2021

Mrs. Hillman made a motion to add the piece of Park property located in Edgewood Addition to the Charter under protected properties and that the legal description be included. Mr. Daige seconded the motion and it passed unanimously. Mrs. Hillman thanked staff for all of their help in getting through this process. Chairman Cook will present these recommendations to the City Council at their September 21st City Council meeting. Chairman Cook thanked the Committee for all of their input and said that this has been a very positive experience. 6. ADJOURNMENT Today’s meeting adjourned at 10:34 a.m. /tb Page 8 CRC 8/23/2021

CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY, AUGUST 23, 2021 9:30 A.M. CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, VERO BEACH, FLORIDA A G E N D A 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES A) August 12, 2021 4. PUBLIC COMMENT 5. NEW BUSINESS 6. OLD BUSINESS A) Finalize Charter Review Commission Recommendations being sent to the City Council 7. ADJOURNMENT This is a Public Meeting. Should any interested party seek to appeal any decision made by the Commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of the proceedings and that, for such purpose he may need to ensure that a record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the City’s Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Coordinator at 978-4920 at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.

CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE MINUTES THURSDAY, AUGUST 12, 2021 9:30 A.M. CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMERS, VERO BEACH, FLORIDA PRESENT: Nancy Cook, Chairman; Ken Daige, Vice Chairman; Members: Linda Hillman, Jeff Stassi, Peter Benedict and Alternate Member, Mark Mucher Also Present: John Turner, City Attorney and Tammy Bursick, City Clerk 1. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Cook called the meeting to order at 9:30 a.m. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chairman Cook led the Committee in the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag. APPROVAL OF MINUTES A) July 12, 2021 Mr. Daige made a motion to approve the minutes. Mrs. Hillman seconded the motion and it passed unanimously. 3. PUBLIC COMMENT Mrs. Tammy Bursick, City Clerk, read into the record a letter from Mrs. Rosemary White (attached to the original minutes). In the letter, Mrs. White mentioned the Park in the Edgewood neighborhood and that it should be placed in the Charter for protection. Mr. Mucher wanted to know what the future plans for the Park are. Mr. Daige mentioned that recently the City received $35,000 from a piece of surplus property that was sold. He thought that maybe that money could be used towards cleaning up the Park at Edgewood. He is going to meet with the City Manager and the Public Work’s director on site to discuss the Park and the cleanup work that needs to be done. He will report back at their next meeting. Mr. Mucher asked what plans the neighbors are making for that Park. Mr. Daige said that they are waiting to see what the City is going to do. He said it needs to be cleaned up because it is overgrown. He will report back at their next meeting. Chairman Cook did not think that it was a part of the Charter Review Committee’s responsibility on who is going to take care of this property. Mr. Mucher said that it might not be their purview, but he is interested to see if someone is going to accept the responsibility. Page 1 CRC 08/12/2021

Mr. Stassi mentioned that the City of Vero Beach spends over $2 million on their Parks and it is getting very expensive. He doesn’t know how much the City can continue to take on and do they want to. They need to get input from City staff before they add something to the Charter. Mr. Daige commented that there really is not that much green space. He said that a good portion of the $2 million is being spent on the Island. What they are discussing here is a very small piece of grass area with a lot of over growth. They will have a cost going forward on what it will cost to maintain it. He said that it has taken over six (6) years to upgrade a neighborhood that was declined and neglected. The maintenance of this Park should be very minimal. Mr. Mucher wondered if the intent at this time was to keep the Park as greenspace. He saw how this worked for the Dodgertown Golf Course and at the Marina. He recalled that a former Mayor got in trouble for saying that the City had too many Parks. Chairman Cook commented that they could find out if the City is willing to maintain this property. The question for this Committee is do they want to make it protected and add it to the Charter. The other concern in Mrs. White’s letter was allowing nonprofits to use their Parks. Mr. Benedict asked if this was a topic for the Charter Review Committee to be discussing. Chairman Cook commented that they are looking at the long term and she thinks that is a big issue. She said people need to recognize how much Park land is being turned over and how much Park land is available and being taken off the tax rolls. Mr. Benedict mentioned that there are probably close to three (3) nonprofit organizations interested in being a part of the Three Corners project. Mr. Mucher brought up the baseball fields and that they have been relinquished to nonprofit organizations, but there has not been a change of use done. Mr. John Turner, City Attorney, was not sure that the wording of allowing or not allowing nonprofits to use Parks should be a part of the Charter. Council needs to be able to addresses these on a case by case basis. He said that this Committee needs to focus on the language that is now in the Charter and how to improve it. He said that is the advice that Council is asking them for. Mr. Daige went back to the Charter protected properties. He said right now the way the Charter is written is that nonprofits come in and make their case and leases can be done. He said that people are concerned with property being tied up with nonprofit organizations. He said that sometimes nonprofit organizations have fees to support their missions. If they can come up with some type of language where these nonprofits come in and the voters have a say that they can lease property out to the nonprofits then that would be okay. He said right now there is no revenue coming into the City’s General Fund from these nonprofit organizations. Mr. Stassi felt that it should be up to the City Manager to negotiate with these nonprofit organizations. 4. NEW BUSINESS A) Chair to report on the July 20, 2021 City Council meeting – (minutes attached) Page 2 CRC 08/12/2021

Chairman Cook reported that the Council has given them an extension to meet until September 30, 2021. She said that they would like to see the pros and cons of each recommendation that they make to them. The minutes from the July 20, 2021, City Council meeting when this item was discussed were given to the Committee members. B) Setting Meeting Dates This item was discussed at the end of the meeting. 5. OLD BUSINESS A) Continuing to review the Charter The Committee moved on to discuss Section 5.05 – Limitation on alienation of city-owned real property. Mr. Mucher mentioned that there are City owned properties that are not in the Charter and probably are not in there because they do not need to be protected. He said unless they feel that there are some properties that should be in the Charter then this is out of their purview. Mr. Stassi did not understand why the City was holding on to surplus property and not getting it out there to be sold. Mr. Daige explained that there are little pieces of property scattered throughout the City. However, they could look at the larger pieces pf property. It never seems to work out too well when the City sells property. They can cherry pick what they would like to recommend to Council to be sold. He was curious on how much surplus property that they have remaining. He said that this City likes their green space and that is who they are. He talked about different pieces of property that have been purchased by the City over the years like Dodger Pines and the Marina property. Mr. Benedict suggested that they go through the list and decide on what pieces of properties need to remain in the Charter and what pieces of property that they feel should be put in the Charter. Mr. Turner said what they could do is look at what they want to add to the Charter if anything. Mr. Daige acknowledged that Council gave the Committee permission to go back and review the decisions that they have already made. Today he will give the City Manager a call and ask for an appointment to meet him and the Public Work’s director at Edgewood concerning the Park there and will report back to the Committee. He said that this piece of property is well under a quarter of an acre. There is no discussion of any type of playground equipment or rest rooms going on this piece of property. It is a Pocket Park and not designed to have parking. It is for people in the neighborhood to come and use, however it is open to everyone and it is important to keep it mowed. Mr. Stassi said that they would need to consider how much additional work would be added to what staff is already doing. He said there is only so much you can do without having to add more employees and purchase more equipment. Mr. Daige agreed. He said that this is only one (1) piece of property that he asking be put in the Charter and it is because he has been working on this area for the last six (6) years to fix it up. Page 3 CRC 08/12/2021

Chairman Cook commented that the issue they are really talking about is limited funds and how much revenue is the City bringing in. The land that is not on the tax rolls is not bringing any revenue into the City. They don’t want to compound the problem of being able to pay for this City and having it here for the future. She asked if there was anyone who has any objections to the Parks that are already in the Charter and only adding one (1) Park to the Charter and that would be the Park located in the Edgewood subdivision. Mr. Mucher brought up the Old City Nursery. He said it looks like there is still a lot of land at the Cemetery to meet their needs for a long time. Mr. Daige brought up the negotiations that the City is having with the County regarding the towers. He said that the public hearing would be held on August 17th and this item may be on this year’s ballot. Mr. Mucher mentioned that City limits get changed, but they are never voted on. Mr. Turner explained that City limits are set by State law and have to be in the City Charter. They are voted on by City Council if there is a need to expand services or annex properties into the City. Mr. Benedict mentioned that two (2) of the three (3) properties for the Three Corners piece of property are in the Charter. He asked has there been any discussion about the Committee removing those items from the Charter and would there be any advantages to doing that. Mr. Turner was not aware of any discussions with removing these two (2) properties from the Charter. Mr. Benedict asked would they be in a better position if these items were not in the Charter. Mr. Mucher answered yes. His personal opinion was that he would like to see the old Power Plant moved off of that land. If it stays there a variance will have to be granted for the height issue because it will not be zoned industrial any more. Mr. Stassi wondered if the items were removed from the Charter first would it be a benefit to give the City Council and City Manager more latitude in developing that piece of property. Mr. Benedict did not want to get down to details on what happens on this site. This is a real opportunity for this community and he would like to see it developed for the community. He was just wondering if having these properties in the Charter is hamstringing it from moving forward. He just wondered if they would be helping the City by removing these items from the Charter so that they could move forward on this project. Mr. Mucher said that they would have a better chance of getting this through for sure, but this is probably something that the voters would want to vote on. Mr. Daige recalled that back when the people voted on those pieces of properties to be put in the Charter they knew individually that those industrial uses would go away. Once the building is gone there would be blank pieces of property and people want to have the green space. At the end of the day if they select a plan for that property then that is what the public wants. He said an investor would say that the best thing to do with the Power Plant property is to put condos there with a Marina out front with big docks. However, there are other things that the community wants to see, but there are not much investments tied with them. Page 4 CRC 08/12/2021

Chairman Cook commented that this is one (1) of the most valuable pieces of property in the City and they need to get the highest and best use to fund that Park. They can’t have it be all green space in order to fund it. Mr. Daige was looking at some community plans on what is going to happen on the property. He said that there could be some long term leases and the property could still be protected. Mr. Turner expressed that the Steering Committee came up with a plan to make the property a balanced development and to bring in some revenue. The City’s stance is not to sell the property, but lease it. He said of course that would be the Council’s final decision. Council would need to consider if it would be in the best interest of the City to take these properties out of the Charter to give them a little more latitude. Mr. Benedict did not want to change course of what already has been decided on. He agrees that the Steering Committee has come up with a great plan. He is just bringing up the approach to pulling this off and would it help them to not have these properties in the Charter. Mr. Daige commented that the City must figure out a way to generate revenue. He said right now it is through taxes. If anyone attended the recent budget hearings they would know that there were some things that could not be funded because the revenue to pay for them is not there. He saw no reason why they could not do the Three Corners plan in phases. Mrs. Hillman commented that the planning for the Three Corners project has already been going on for two (2) years and soon it will be three (3) years. She wondered how much longer it would go on before people will be able to vote on it. Mr. Daige felt that where there was an overall plan that the community is in favor of it then the other details can be worked out. Mr. Turner added that the concept plan is what the Steering Committee has recommended to the City Council and the City will be going out to review proposals. It is not going to be a general plan, but what the City feels is the best way to proceed in a general way. Developers have not yet had the opportunity to give their opinions on what is best for the City. In moving forward there will be a Comprehensive Plan review in changing the zoning on this property. He felt that the Committee was getting into the area of what the Steering Committee has been working on. He said if they want to submit this as a question to the City Council that these items be removed from the Charter then they need to make a list of why they want it removed giving the pros and cons. Mr. Mucher felt that if it was taken out of the Charter he could see developers going on the property and building as many condos as they can fit on the property. Mr. Daige reiterated that the market today would call for condos on the riverfront with private boat docks there. Mr. Benedict made it clear that was not why he brought this up. He said that the community has created a vision of what they would like to see on the property and he was seeing if the Committee could help in getting that accomplished. Mr. Mucher said if they take it out of the Charter then people would not have the opportunity to vote. Page 5 CRC 08/12/2021

Mr. Stassi who is also a member of the Steering Committee mentioned that some of the development that was discussed by the Steering Committee was having residential be on top of a commercial dwelling. He said that the developer will know what he is going to develop and have businesses that are going to buy into it. He said when a developer is spending millions of dollars they have plans on what is going to be developed on the property. Mr. Benedict asked about the wording in the referendum. Mr. Turner said that it will say something like “shall the City develop the following….” - Approve or Disapprove. He said there has to be a summary of what they are proposing that cannot be longer than 75 words. Chairman Cook wondered if they should get a response from the Steering Committee on whether or not they want the properties left in the Charter. Mr. Turner explained that would need to go to the City Council to address and the Committee would need to have a list of the pros and cons on why these properties should be taken out of the Charter. He said that they could put it on their final list for Council to consider. Chairman Cook felt that it should be considered. Mr. Daige commented that in this City the community is very attuned to their green space and are watching this meeting. He has heard that the community does not want to see the properties out of the Charter. They remember voting to protect the properties. Chairman Cook brought up the need for revenue in the City. Mr. Stassi addressed green space. He said at one (1) of the Steering Committee meetings the Planning and Development Director gave a presentation on the amount of Park space that the City has and there is more than the industry standards call for. He said that the City more than meets the requirements. The City has enough green space and parks. They need to look at opportunities for new revenue sources without taxing people to death. Mr. Daige wanted to ask the City surveyor how much usable space is still available. He remembers the presentation given by Mr. Jeffries and that a Board member was curious about mitigation space, which is green space, but cannot be used by the people. He was curious about the usable space. Mr. Mucher watched all the Steering Committee meetings and said that it wasn’t so much green space that they were after as it was fun space. They wanted the plan to be revenue neutral and bring in some money. Mr. Daige agreed that there needs to be a balance on what types of businesses are there. That is what the community wants to see, but there needs to be some revenue coming in. He brought up that the City doesn’t benefit from all of the tourist tax that they bring in. They are trying to get more money from the County from the tourist tax dollars and the County will probably say no. Mrs. Hillman felt that they needed to decide whether or not they wanted to take this to City Council and then move on. They have spent all morning discussing it and have not gotten anywhere. She asked do they want the properties to remain in the Charter or have them taken out of the Charter. Page 6 CRC 08/12/2021

Mrs. Hillman made a motion to present to City Council whether they wish to remove these properties or keep them in the Charter, then give them pros and cons to decide this. Mr. Stassi seconded the motion. Mr. Mucher asked don’t they want to consider yes or no. Mrs. Hillman answered no. She said that they would provide the pros and cons to the City Council and then let them decide. Mr. Turner asked if this was for both properties. Mrs. Hillman answered yes. Mr. Turner said then listing the pros and cons would be the next step. Mr. Daige stated that he was not in favor of sending this to the City Council and having them remove it from the Charter. He said that he would be against the motion. Mr. Mucher said that he is an alternate member and would not be able to vote today. However, if he was allowed to vote he would not want to take this out of the public’s opportunity to vote on it. Mr. Benedict commented that he raised the question this morning and has heard compelling reasons for leaving it in the Charter. At this point he would be in favor of leaving it in the Charter. Mr. Daige thanked Mr. Benedict for bringing it up and getting it on the table for discussion. Mrs. Hillman suggested holding off on the motion until their next meeting and having further discussion on the matter and let the public weigh in on it. Mr. Mucher mentioned that the Mayor was not able to announce their meeting on the radio because the station got hit by lighting. However, hopefully he will bring it up at Coffee with the Mayor, which will be held tomorrow and maybe they will have some people from the public attend their meeting. Mrs. Hillman was sure that there will be some public comment and withdrew her motion and the second withdrew his second on the motion. Mr. Mucher recalled when they hired the consultant for the Three Corners project he did not want the postal annex to be a part of the project, however he wanted the Power Plant to remain and said that it was the most beautiful piece of art that he has ever seen. He knew that this didn’t have anything thing to do with the Charter Review Committee, but said as far as he knows there are no uses for the postal annex property. Mr. Benedict asked if the Steering Committee included the postal annex property in their plan. Mr. Stassi answered no and agreed to leave it out of the Charter. He said that the plan does include a lot of parking. Section 5.06 – Zoning limitations The Committee agreed that they don’t want to change the height limitations. The Charter has served them well and it has protected them. They (Committee) were not in favor of changing anything in Section 5.06. Article VI. Transition Schedule Page 7 CRC 08/12/2021

Mr. Turner mentioned that in Section 6.05. – Effective date it currently reads This Charter shall become effective on May 1, 1982 except that section 6.03(b) shall become effective immediately on becoming law.” He does not see a section 6.03(b) in the Charter. The Committee agreed that this needed to be cleaned up in the Charter. The paragraph will now read This Charter shall become effective on May 1, 1982. This will need to go to referendum and they will inform the Council of the reasons for the change. In Appendix A. – Description of Corporate Boundary. The boundaries are updated when needed. The last change made was on October 13, 2020. Chairman Cook stated that at their next meeting they will review their motions and work on the pros and cons for each motion and conclude with what their recommendations to Council will be. The Committee will resume discussion at their next meeting to be held on August 23, 2021, at 9:30 a.m. 7) ADJOURNMENT Today’s meeting adjourned at 11:16 a.m. /tb Page 8 CRC 08/12/2021

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF) — Minutes
  • Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: ea702176bcb4785c695b1853729fad94. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record