POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Regular City Commission Meeting - via Zoom/Hybrid

Tuesday, January 16, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Regular City Commission Meeting - via Zoom/Hybrid

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

Watch the meeting The recording is not indexed to individual votes.

8 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (8)

passed

Approve Proposed Agenda Schedule

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Alpertyes
Ahearn-Kochyes
Arroyoyes
Battieyes
Triceyes
passed

Consent Agenda No. 1 (Item 2)

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Alpertyes
Ahearn-Kochyes
Arroyoyes
Battieyes
Triceyes
passed

Consent Agenda No. 1 (Items 1, 3, 4)

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Alpertyes
Ahearn-Kochyes
Arroyoyes
Battieyes
Triceyes
passed

Consent Agenda No. 2 (Budget Resolutions)

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Alpertyes
Ahearn-Kochyes
Arroyoyes
Battieyes
Triceyes
passed

Public Hearing: Ordinance 24-5508

Yes
5
No
0
How they voted (5)
Alpertyes
Ahearn-Kochyes
Arroyoyes
Battieyes
Triceyes
approved

Ringling Boulevard and Pine Place Roundabout Contract — 5-0

approved

Zoning Code Amendments for Restaurants and Bars — 3-2 and 4-1 votes

People and votes

Arroyo

5 recorded votes

  1. Recorded vote

    Approve Proposed Agenda Schedule - Voted yes on the motion “Approve the proposed Agenda Schedule”; the record reports passed.

  2. Recorded vote

    Consent Agenda No. 1 (Item 2) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve Item No. 2 (St. Vincent De Paul CARES)”; the record reports passed.

  3. Recorded vote

    Consent Agenda No. 1 (Items 1, 3, 4) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve Item Nos. 1, 3, and 4”; the record reports passed.

  4. Recorded vote

    Consent Agenda No. 2 (Budget Resolutions) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve Item Nos. 1 and 2 (Resolution Nos. 24R-3227 and 24R-3228)”; the record reports passed.

  5. Recorded vote

    Public Hearing: Ordinance 24-5508 - Voted yes on the motion “Pass proposed Ordinance No. 24-5508 on first reading”; the record reports passed.

See all 8 roll calls with named votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

MINUTES OF THE REGULAR SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF JANUARY 16, 2024 PRESENT: Mayor Liz Alpert, Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch, Commissioners Erik Arroyo, Kyle Scott Battie, and Debbie Trice, City Attorney Robert Fournier, City Manager Marlon Brown, and City Auditor and Clerk Shayla Griggs (via Zoom/Hybrid) ABSENT: None 9:02 :26A.M. Mayor Alpert called the meeting to order at 9:02 A.M. 9:02:42 A.M. INVOCATION: City Auditor and Clerk Griggs 9:03:02 A.M. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch 9:03:24 A.M. PLEDGE OF PUBLIC CONDUCT: City Auditor and Clerk Griggs 9:03:35 A.M. 1. CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY: A) Please add under New Business, Agenda Item No. XII., Item No. 1 ., Discussion Re: Comprehensive Review of the City of Sarasota Zoning Code, per the request of Commissioner Battie 8) Please add under New Business, Agenda Item No. XII., Item No. 2., Discussion Re: Civility, Respect and Rhetoric, per the request of Commissioner Battie 9:04:08A.M. Mayor Alpert noted Commission consensus to accept the Changes to the Order of the Day. 9:04:14 A.M. 2. REVISED CHANGE TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY: C) Please remove under New Business, Agenda Item No. XII., Item No. 2 ., Discussion Re: Civility, Respect and Rhetoric and add under Unfinished Business, Agenda Item No . IX, Item No. 1., per the request of Commissioner Battie 9:04: 51 A.M. Questions posed by Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch were addressed. 9:07:00 A.M. Mayor Alpert noted Commission consensus to accept the Revised Change to the Order of the Day. Book 68 Page 40432 01/16/24 9:00 A.M.

9:07:10 AM. APPROVE PROPOSED AGENDA SCHEDULE 9:07: 17 AM. Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40433 9:00AM. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch to approve the proposed Agenda Schedule, which carried by a 5-0 vote. 9:07:42 A.M. Mayor Alpert acknowledged former Mayor/Vice Mayor/Commissioner Shelli Freeland Eddie along with her students from New College of Florida seated in the audience. 9:08:25 A.M . 3. COMMISSION PRESENTATIONS: (AGENDA ITEM I) 1) PRESENTATION RE: EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH AND TEAM OF THE MONTH FOR JANUARY 2024 (AGENDA ITEM 1•1): Presented to: Employee of the Month Crew Leader II Willie Butler, Public Works Department, and Team of the Month Senior Records Specialist Liz Thomas, Office of the City Auditor and Clerk, and Coordinator Permitting Keishondra Wilkins accepted on behalf of Administrative Specialist Ill Debbie Nelson, Development Services 9:17:26 AM. 4. CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS (AGENDA ITEM Ill) 9:18:22 A.M. Citizens' Input received from individuals in the Chambers at City Hall. City Manager Brown left and returned to the Dais at 9:18 AM . 9:27:40 AM. Jose Fernandez, City resident, displayed on the Chambers monitors a copy of a news article published in the Sarasota Herald-Tribune dated January 06 , 2024, titled "Let's Give City Staff Members the Respect they Deserve" which he takes exception to most of the article but most of all to the premise that City Staff is exempt from scrutiny and critique. 9:30 :36AM . Citizens' Input received from an individual via Zoom . 9:32 : 18 AM. 5. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 1 (AGENDA ITEM VI) 9:32:28 A.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch requested to remove from Consent No. 1, Agenda Item VI, Item No. 2. 1) Approval Re: Proposed 2023-2024 Budget Calendar requiring City Commission involvement (Agenda Item Vl-1)

3) Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute the Agreement between the City of Sarasota and Ajax Paving Industries of Florida, LLC (BID #23-03BK) pertaining to the Roundabout located at Ringling Boulevard and Pine Place in the amount of $3,722,466.40 (Agenda Item Vl-3) 4) Approval Re: Acceptance of the Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA) FY 23 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program in the amount of $30,928.00 for purchase of portable PTZ (point, tilt, zoom) video cameras and automatic license plate reader (ALPR) cameras (Agenda Item Vl-4) 9:32:41 AM. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Commissioner Battie to approve Item Nos. 1, 3, and 4, which carried by a 5-0 vote. 9:33 :14 AM. 6. ITEM REMOVED FROM CONSENT AGENDA NO. 1 (AGENDA ITEM VI) 1) Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute the Second Amendment between the City of Sarasota and Society of St. Vincent De Paul South Pinellas, Inc., d/b/a St. Vincent De Paul CARES for Affordable Housing Initiative Rental Housing Project at 1529 and 1539 25th Street (Agenda Item Vl-2) 9:33:25AM. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch stated that the item was removed to seek clarity on the gap in funding since the understanding is the Affordable Housing Initiative Rental Housing Project at 1529 and 1539 25th Street which was going to be funded by the Gulf Coast Community Foundation and St. Vincent de Paul South Pinellas Inc., was addressed by Jon Thaxton, Senior Vice President, Gulf Coast Community Foundation, who came before the Commission, and General Manager Cynthia "Cindy" Emshoff, Office of Housing & Community Development (OHCD), Planning Department, who also came before the Commission further clarified that there is no Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) in this; that this is the Affordable Housing Initiative. 9:35:28AM A motion was made by Commissioner Trice, seconded by Commissioner Battie to approve Item No. 2, which carried by a 5-0 vote. 9:35:48 AM. 7. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 2 (AGENDA ITEM VII) 9:36:00 AM. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs read proposed Resolution Nos. 24R-3227 and 24R-3228 by titles only. 1) Adoption Re: Proposed Resolution No. 24R-3227, amending the budget for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2023 by providing for supplemental appropriations in the amounts identified in exhibit A; providing for severability if any of the parts hereof are declared invalid, etc. (Title Only) to establish a revenue and expenditure budget in the amount of $4,070,466 for funds for the Ringling Boulevard Pine Place Roundabout project to be reimbursed by FOOT (Agenda Item Vll-1) Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40434 9:00 AM.

Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40435 9:00 A.M . 2) Adoption Re: Proposed Resolution No. 24R-3228, amending the budget for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2023 by providing for supplemental appropriations in the amounts identified in exhibit A: providing for severability if any of the parts hereof are declared invalid, etc. (Title Only) to establish a revenue and expenditure budget in the amount of $30,928.00 for funds for the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant received by SPD (Agenda Item Vll-2) 9:36 :56 A.M. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Commissioner Battie to approve Item Nos. 1 and 2, which carried by a 5-0 vote. 9:37 : 24A.M . 8. UNFINISHED BUSINESS (AGENDA IX} 1) DISCUSSION RE: CIVILITY, RESPECT AND RHETORIC (AGENDA ITEM IX-1) 9:37:51 A.M. Commissioner Battie presented and left his seat to display a copy of a printed black/white crinkled photograph on the Chamber Monitors from Kelly Franklin's social media page who referred to him and another constituent as a primate, monkey, ape, and gorilla, and stated that the item was placed on the Agenda to receive discussion and input from fellow-Commissioners wh ich was received. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left her seat at 9:46 A.M . to distribute copies of the printed black/white crinkled photograph to the Commission and returned to her seat at 9:47 A.M . 9:49 :05 A.M. Commissioner Trice spoke to the topic and voiced concern. 9:49 :29 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo spoke to the topic and voiced concern . 9:50 :01 A.M . Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the topic and posed questions which were addressed by Commissioner Battie and Tanya Borysiewicz, Owner, Corona Cigar Co . El Septimo VIP Lounge, who came before the Commission and left the Dais. City Manager Brown left and returned to his seat at 9:58 A.M . 9:55:23 A.M. Mayor Alpert spoke to the topic and Commissioner Battie provided input. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 10 :00 A.M. No Action Taken .

F 10:08:24 A.M. 9. LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS {AGENDA ITEM X) 10 :08:40 A.M. Mayor Alpert opened the Public Hearing. 10:08:49 A.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs administered the oath to persons wishing to speak during the Public Hearings. 1) PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 24-5508 , AMENDING THE FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE NO. 22-5431 , AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE NO. 23-5482, CHAPTER 1, ADMINISTRATION , SECTION 102.3, BASIS FOR ESTABLISHING FLOOD HAZARD AREAS, AND SECTION 103.9 , FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT RECORDS , SO AS TO UPDATE THE DATE OF THE FLOOD INSURANCE STUDY FOR SARASOTA COUNTY AS WELL AS THE LOCATION OF THE STUDIES, MAPS AND OTHER RELEVANT RECORDS SO AS TO COMPLY WITH FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY REQUIREMENTS ; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY OF THE PARTS HEREOF IF DECLARED INVALID, ETC. (T ITLE ONLY) {AGENDA ITEM X-1 ) 10:09:36 A.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs read proposed Ordinance No. 24-5508 by title only. Commissioner Battie left the Chambers at 10:10 A.M . 10 :11 : 19 A.M. Emergency Manager Richard "Todd" Kerkering, Sarasota Police Department, and Floodplain Manager Cynthia Cahill , Development Services Department, came before the Commission . 10:11 :29 A.M. Ms. Cahill presented and referred from a letter displayed on the Chambers monitors received from the Federal Emergency ManagementAgency (FEMA) and stated that the Development Services Department was changed from Annex. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 10:11 A.M . Commissioner Battie returned to the Chambers at 10:12 A.M. 10:14:18 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor, and Commissioners Arroyo, Trice, and Battie were addressed by Ms. Cahill. 10:21 :27 A.M. No one signed up to speak and the Mayor closed the Public Hearing. Book 68 Page 40436 01/16/24 9:00 AM .

Book 68 Page 40437 01/16/24 9:00 A.M. 10:21 :33 A.M. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Commissioner Trice to pass proposed Ordinance No. 24-5508 on first reading, which carried by a 5-0 vote. 10:21 :42 A.M . Ms. Cahill and Mr. Kerkering left the Dais. The Commission recessed at 10 :22 A.M. and reconvened at 10:32 A.M . 10:32:53 A.M. 2) PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 23-5502, AMENDING THE ZONING CODE (2002 EDITION ), ARTICLE II , DEFINITIONS AND RULES OF CONSTRUCTION , DIVISION 2, DEFINITIONS, SECTION 11-201 , DEFINITIONS, TO ESTABLISH NEW DEFINITIONS FOR RESTAURANT, BAR , BAR OUTDOOR, BOTTLE CLUB , AND NIGHTCLUB. AND DIVISION 3 1 DESCRIPTION OF USE CATEGORIES , SECTION 11-305 , COMMERCIAL USE CATEGORIES, AND SECTION 11-307 , INSTITUTIONAL USE CATEGORIES TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; ARTICLE VI , ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 51 COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS, SECTION Vl-504, SPECIAL NT , CP AND CT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; AND ARTICLE VII, REGULATIONS OF GENERAL APPLICABILITY, DIVISION 14, MISCELLANEOUS STANDARDS, SECTION Vll-1404, REFUSE AND RECYCLING STORAGE AREAS , TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY OF THE PARTS HEREOF; (T ITLE ONLY) (APPLICATION NO. 23-ZTA-04, APPLICANT: CITY OF SARASOTA) (AGENDA ITEM X-2) AND 3) PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 23-5503, AMENDING THE ZONING CODE (2002 EDITION ), ARTICLE VI , ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 5, COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 6 1 PRODUCTION INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 7, SPECIAL PURPOSE ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 9, SPECIAL PUBLIC INTEREST OVERLAY DISTRICTS, AND DIVISION 10 , DOWNTOWN ZONE DISTRICTS, TO UPDATE THE PRIMARY USE TABLES THEREIN ; ARTICLE VII, REGULATIONS OF GENERAL APPLICABILITY. DIVISION 6 1 ADDITIONAL USE AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION Vll-602 1 SPECIFIC STANDARDS FOR CERTAIN USES, SUBSECTIONS (F) AND (R} TO MODIFY THE STANDARDS REGARDING OUTDOOR SEATING AREAS AND SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, AND DIVISION 9 1 ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES, SECTION Vll-904, NON-RESIDENTIAL ACCESSORY USES, BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES, TO AMEND THE APPROVAL PROCEDURES APPLICABLE TO ACCESSORY BARS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY OF THE PARTS HEREOF, ETC. (TITLE ONLY) (APPLICATION NO. 23-ZTA-04, APPLICANT: CITY OF SARASOTA) (AGENDA ITEM X-3) Director Steve Cover, General Manager Ryan Chapdelain, Chief Planner Briana Dobbs , Planner Rebecca Webster, Planning Department, and Director Lucia Panica, Development Services came before the Commission. 10:33:23 A.M . City Auditor and Clerk Griggs read proposed Ordinance No. 23-5502 by title only.

F r- =q ', 10:34:28 A.M. City Attorney Fournier stated that at the previous Public Hearing the Commission chose to consolidate and has the option if desired. 10:34 :44 A.M . Mayor Alpert noted Commission consensus to combine Public Hearings Re: Proposed Ordinance Nos . 23-5502 and 23-5503. 10:34:50 A.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs read proposed Ordinance No. 23-5503 by title only. 10:35:57 A.M. Mayor Alpert opened the Public Hearings. 10:36:11 A.M. Mr. Cover provided a brief overview and referred from a PowerPoint presentation displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled "Restaurants, Bars, & Nightclubs." 10:38:31 A.M. Ms. Dobbs presented and referred from various slides displayed on the Chambers monitors. 10:42:02 A.M. Ms. Panica, Ms. Dobbs, Ms . Webster, and Messrs. Cover and Chapdelain left the Dais. 10:43:44 A.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs readministered the oath . 10:44:13 A.M. Citizens' Input received from an individual in the Chambers at City Hall. 10:46:01 A.M. Ron Kashden, City resident, displayed a photograph of "Tamiami Tap" on the Chambers monitors, indicating prior to being a restaurant this was a shot bar which had a different relationship with the neighborhood. 10:48:27 A.M. Citizens' Input continued from an individual in the Chambers at City Hall. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 10:51 A.M. 10: 52 :44 A.M . Lance Disley, City resident, read a prepared statement and placed printed materials on the Chambers monitors, indicating to what degree have Zoning Text in these jurisdictions or any other Florida jurisdiction been researched, compared , and best practice determined, suspects zero. Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40438 9:00AM .

10:57:31 A.M. Book 68 01/16/24 Citizens' Input continued from individuals in the Chambers at City Hall. 11:10:17 A.M. Citizens' Input received from individuals via Zoom. 11 :19:25 A.M. Page 40439 9:00 A.M. Ms. Panica, Ms. Dobbs, Ms. Webster, and Messrs. Cover and Chapdelain returned to the Dais . 11 :19:28 A.M. Mr. Cover addressed comments received during Citizens' Input and referred from a slide displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled "Updates Made since December 5 th City Commission Workshop." 11 :22:13 A.M . Questions posed by Commissioner Arroyo were addressed by Commissioner Battie and the City Manager, and he spoke to the topic. 11 :27:40 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo continued to pose questions which were addressed by Messrs. Cover and Chapdelain, and Ms. Dobbs, and the City Manager provided input. 11 :38 :23 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Battie were addressed by Mr. Chapdelain, Ms. Dobbs, and Mr. Cover. City Manager Brown left and returned to the Dais at 11 :31 A.M . 11:45:47 A.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch thanked Staff, spoke to the topic, and posed questions which were addressed by Ms . Dobbs, Messrs. Chapdelain and Cover, and the City Manager and Commissioner Battie posed questions to the Vice Mayor which were addressed, and the Vice Mayor continued posing questions which were addressed by Staff. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left the Dais at 12:01 P.M. and returned at 12:02 P. M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs, the City Manager, and Mayor left the Dais at 12 :02 P.M . and returned at 12:04 P.M. 12:05:32 P.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Trice were addressed by Ms. Panica, Messrs. Chapdelain and Cover, and Ms . Dobbs, and the City Manager requested and Staff displayed the slide on the Chambers monitors entitled "Restaurant," questions continued which were addressed by Staff and the City Manager.

r 12 :25 :00 P.M. Ms. Dobbs, Ms. Webster, Ms. Panica, and Messrs. Cover and Chapdelain left the Dais. The Commission recessed at 12 :25 P.M. and reconvened at 1 :32 P.M. 10 . LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS CONT'D {AGENDA ITEM X) 1:33: 17 P.M. 2) PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 23-5502, AMENDING THE ZONING CODE (2002 EDITION ). ARTICLE II , DEFINITIONS AND RULES OF CONSTRUCTION , DIVISION 2, DEFINITIONS, SECTION 11-201 , DEFINITIONS, TO ESTABLISH NEW DEFINITIONS FOR RESTAURANT, BAR , BAR OUTDOOR, BOTTLE CLUB. AND NIGHTCLUB, AND DIVISION 3, DESCRIPTION OF USE CATEGORIES, SECTION 11-305 , COMMERCIAL USE CATEGORIES, AND SECTION 11-307 , INSTITUTIONAL USE CATEGORIES TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; ARTICLE VI, ZONE DISTRICTS, DIVISION 5, COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS, SECTION Vl-504, SPECIAL NT, CP AND CT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; AND ARTICLE VII , REGULATIONS OF GENERAL APPLICABILITY, DIVISION 14. MISCELLANEOUS STANDARDS, SECTION Vll-1404, REFUSE AND RECYCLING STORAGE AREAS , TO REFLECT THE CHANGE IN DEFINITIONS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY OF THE PARTS HEREOF; (T ITLE ONLY) (APPLICATION NO. 23-ZTA-04, APPLICANT: CITY OF SARASOTA) (AGENDA ITEM X-2) AND 3) PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 23-5503. AMENDING THE ZONING CODE (2002 EDITION ), ARTICLE VI , ZONE DISTRICTS , DIVISION 5 1 COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS , DIVISION 6 1 PRODUCTION INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL ZONE DISTRICTS , DIVISION 7 1 SPECIAL PURPOSE ZONE DISTRICTS. DIVISION 9, SPECIAL PUBLIC INTEREST OVERLAY DISTRICTS, AND DIVISION 10, DOWNTOWN ZONE DISTRICTS , TO UPDATE THE PRIMARY USE TABLES THEREIN ; ARTICLE VII , REGULATIONS OF GENERAL APPLICABILITY, DIVISION 6 1 ADDITIONAL USE AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION Vll-602 , SPECIFIC STANDARDS FOR CERTAIN USES, SUBSECTIONS (F) AND (R} TO MODIFY THE STANDARDS REGARDING OUTDOOR SEATING AREAS AND SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES , AND DIVISION 9, ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES, SECTION Vll-904, NON-RESIDENTIAL ACCESSORY USES, BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES, TO AMEND THE APPROVAL PROCEDURES APPLICABLE TO ACCESSORY BARS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY OF THE PARTS HEREOF, ETC. (TITLE ONLY) (APPLICATION NO. 23-ZTA-04 1 APPLICANT: CITY OF SARASOTA) (AGENDA ITEM X-3) Ms. Dobbs, Ms. Webster, Ms. Panica, and Messrs. Cover and Chapdelaih returned to the Dais . 1:34:04 P.M. The Commission continued to speak to the topic and pose questions which were addressed by Staff and the City Attorney. 2:21 :27 P.M. City Manager Brown requested Staff to speak about the proposed expansion area in the Rosemary District which was addressed by Mr. Chapdelain who referred from a slide displayed on the Book 68 Page 40440 01/16/24 9:00A.M.

Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40441 9:00 A.M . Chambers monitors entitled "Proposal Expansion of Existing Exemption Area Map ", and questions posed by the Commission were addressed . 2:32:06 P.M. The Mayor closed the Public Hearings. 2:32 : 10 P.M. Ms. Dobbs, Ms . Webster, Ms. Panica, and Messrs. Cover and Chapdelain left the Dais. 2:34:49 P.M. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, and seconded by Commissioner Battie to pass proposed Ordinance No. 23-5502 and Zoning Text Amendment Application No. 23-ZTA-04 on first reading with the inclusion to allow the preparation of off-site meals for restaurants, no outdoor nightclubs, and to not expand the exemption area . 2:35:51 P.M. Commissioner Arroyo spoke to the motion. 2:36 : 33 P.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the motion which is not favored. 2:37:50 P.M. Commissioner Trice spoke to the motion which is not favored. 2:38:46 P.M. Commissioner Battie spoke in support of the motion. 2:40:57 P.M. Mayor Alpert called for a vote on the motion to pass proposed Ordinance No. 23-5502 and Zoning Text Amendment Application No. 23-ZTA-04 on first reading with the inclusion to allow the preparation of off-site meals for restaurants, no outdoor nightclubs, and to not expand the exemption area , which carried by a 3-2 vote with Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch and Commissioner Trice voting no. 2:41 : 38 P.M. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Commissioner Battie to pass proposed Ordinance No. 23-5503 on first reading , with the exception of no expansion of the exemption area. 2:42:34 P.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the motion which is not supported and Commissioner Trice posed a question which was addressed .

2:44:00 P.M. Mayor Alpert called for a vote on the motion to pass proposed Ordinance No. 23-5503 on first reading , with the exception of no expansion of the exemption area, which carried by a 4-1 vote with Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch voting no. 2:44:33 P.M. 11. NEW BUSINESS (AGENDA ITEM XII) 1) DISCUSSION RE: COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF THE CITY OF SARASOTA ZONING CODE (AGENDA ITEM Xll-1) 2:44:45 P.M. Commissioner Battie presented . City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 2:45 P.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 2:46 P.M. 2:46:52 P.M. Commissioner Arroyo spoke to the topic. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 2:47 P.M . 2:48:13 P.M . Commissioner Trice spoke to the topic. City Manager Brown left and returned to his seat at 2:49 P.M. 2:50:46 P.M. Commissioner Battie requested input from the City Manager which was received. 2:54:12 P.M. Citizens' Input was received from an individual in the Chambers at City Hall and the Mayor gaveled the speaker and stated no personal attacks. 2:57:21 P.M. Commissioner Battie addressed comments received from Citizens' Input. 2:59:22 P.M. Mayor Alpert spoke to the topic. 3:00:51 P.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the topic and posed questions which were addressed by the City Manager who stated that information will be brought back before the Commission during fiscal year (FY) 2024-25 Budget process . Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40442 9:00AM .

3:12:30 P.M. Book 68 01/16/24 Page 40443 9:00 A.M. A motion was made by Commissioner Arroyo, seconded by Commissioner Battie to direct the City Manager to bring back to the Commission what will be required (resources , etc.) to do a comprehensive review and revision of the City of Sarasota Zoning Code . 3:13:01 P.M . Commissioner Arroyo spoke to the motion. 3:14 : 36 P.M. Commissioner Battie spoke to the motion. 3:16:18 P.M . Commissioner Trice spoke to the motion which is not favored . 3:17:10 P.M. Mayor Alpert addressed concerns voiced by Commissioner Trice, and Commissioner Arroyo provided input. 3:17 :50 P.M. Commissioner Trice offered a friendly amendment of a focused review of problem areas as opposed to a comprehensive review which was not accepted by Commissioner Arroyo, the maker of the motion. 3:18:10 P.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch spoke to the motion which is not favored . 3:19:14 P.M. Mayor Alpert spoke to the motion which is supported . 3:19 :46 P.M . Mayor Alpert called for a vote on the motion to direct the City Manager to bring back to the Commission what will be required (resources, etc.) to do a comprehensive review and revision of the City of Sarasota Zoning Code, which carried by a 3-2 vote with Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch and Commissioner Trice voting no. 3:20 :15 P.M . Mayor Alpert sought and noted Commission consensus to reopen Unfinished Business, Agenda Item IX, Item No. 1, Discussion Re: Civility, Respect and Rhetoric for the following two reasons : 1) Commission received additional information, and 2) Afford Ron Kashden, Ms . Franklin's husband to speak to the issue.

12. UNFINISHED BUSINESS CONT'D (AGENDA IX) 1) DISCUSSION RE: CIVILITY, RESPECT AND RHETORIC (AGENDA ITEM IX-1) 3:21 : 15 P.M. Mayor Alpert stated that the Commission has received emails from Ms. Kelly Franklin indicating this was a manipulated Facebook post and not a post she made; that this was a mashup between two different posts she did. 3:23 :09 P.M. Commissioner Battie stated that the hope is this is not true; that someone extremely engaged in the City's political process would not do such a thing and read into the record emails received from Kelly Franklin and Donna Moffit. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned her seat at 3:27 P.M . 3:29: 50 P.M. Citizens' Input received from an individual in the Chambers at City Hall. 3:32 : 58 P.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch called for a Point of Order which was received. 3:33:59 P.M. Ron Kashden, City resident/Kelly (Kelly) Franklin 's husband, displayed on the Chambers monitors the back of a Request to Speak card entitled "Pledge of Public Conduct - Adopted by the City Commission" and a photograph from his iPad of Kelly, indicating Kelly has been diagnosed with a very serious mantel cell lymphoma, during Coronavirus, also known as COVID-19, and Kelly took lots of photos during a once-in-a-lifetime trip to Rwanda to see the gorillas. 3:37 :02 P.M. Citizens' Input continued from individuals in the Chambers at City Hall. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 3:40 P.M. Commissioner Battie left and returned to the Dais at 3:46 P. M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left and returned to her seat at 3:47 P.M. 3:46:17 P.M. Mayor Alpert spoke to the topic and voiced concern . 3:47 : 57 P.M. Commissioner Trice spoke to the topic and voiced concern. 3:50:07 P.M. Commissioner Battie spoke to the topic and voiced concern. Book 68 Page 40444 01/16/24 9:00 A.M.

3:57:15 P.M . Commissioner Arroyo spoke to the topic and voiced concern . No Action Taken. 3:58:52 P.M . Book 68 01/16/24 13. CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS (AGENDA ITEM XIII ) 3:59:13 P.M. Citizens' Input received from an individual in the Chambers at City Hall. 4:01 :20 P.M. Page 40445 9:00 A.M. 14. REMARKS OF COMMISSIONERS , ANNOUNCEMENTS , AND ITEMS FOR NEXT AGENDA (AGENDA ITEM XIV) 4:02 : 33 P.M . COMMISSIONER TRICE: Asked if the City is doing anything with Derelict Boats and the status of U.S. Recycling Company as the result of comments received during Citizens' Input; that the desire to see something happen sooner as opposed to waiting for a new development to come along and is there anything the City can do to expedite solving the problem, was addressed by Deputy City Manager Patrick "Pat" Robinson, City Manager's Office, who came before the Commission City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left the Dais and Commissioner Battie left the Chambers at 4:04 P.M. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs returned to the Dais at 4:05 P.M . 4:05:25 P.M . VICE MAYOR AHEARN-KOCH: Remarks received and distributed to the Commission printed emails and stated that the neighborhood did put up several monitors to monitor the air quality for the U.S. Recycling Company and the numbers came back very, very high; however, she has not verified any of this and would like discussion to get the Sarasota County involved; that the desire was to follow up on Consent No. 1, Agenda Item VI, Item No. 1, Approval Re: Proposed 2024-2025 Budget Calendar requiring City Commission involvement, which the Commission had discussed potentially having a meeting where the public can give input was addressed by the City Manager. 4:11 :01 P.M . MAYOR ALPERT: Remarks received .

4:01 :20 P.M. 15. OTHER MATTERS/ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICERS (AGENDA ITEM XV) 4:01 :56 P.M. CITY ATTORNEY FOURNIER: Stated that the Commission is being informed that input is needed for the case regarding Joanne Soucy, as personal representative of the Estate of John Kaafi, deceased v. City of Sarasota. Florida; that he will try to schedule the Out-of-the Sunshine (Shade) Meeting, immediately following the February 05, 2024, Regular Sarasota City Commission Meeting. 16. ADJOURN (AGENDA ITEM XVI) The Commission adjourned at 4:11 P.M . LI ~ER. MAR Book 68 Page 40446 01/16/24 9: 00 A.M .

Liz Alpert Mayor Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch Commissioner Erik Arroyo Commissioner Kyle Battie Commissioner Debbie Trice REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF JANUARY 16, 2024 WELCOME to a Regular meeting of the City Commission. This Agenda includes all matters scheduled to come before the Commission at this meeting. It is prepared to help you follow the proceedings of the meeting. Your interest is appreciated, and we invite your comments. Input from citizens is important; we need and welcome it. If you wish to address the Commission, please fill out a "Request To Speak" Form located on the table at the back of the Commission Chambers. Fill out the form completely, indicating the Agenda Item to which you intend to speak, and place the form in the box on the table. If you intend to speak under Citizens’ Input Concerning City Topics, the subject should also be noted on the "Request To Speak" Form. Agenda Items for which citizens' comments are not permitted are noted. In general, these will be items on which a public hearing has previously been held. Listed below are the time limits established for speaking: Public Hearings - Quasi-judicial: A reasonable amount of time to be determined by the City Commission will be provided to Applicants and Affected Persons desiring to speak. Public Hearings - Legislative: Citizens desiring to speak are allowed five (5) minutes. Petitioners are allowed fifteen (15) minutes with a five (5) minute rebuttal at the close of the public hearing. We will ask you to take an oath that all evidence and testimony presented during the public hearing are truthful. Citizens’ Input Concerning City Topics - Citizens desiring to speak are allowed three (3) minutes. Remember, appearances before the Commission are not a substitute for attempting to resolve your issue(s) through the appropriate administrative channels. Citizens’ Input is to allow citizens the opportunity to present their view on matters concerning City topics but not on items scheduled elsewhere on the Agenda. Questions and answers shall not be permitted. Matters presented to the Commission may be referred by the Mayor, with consensus of the Commission, to the Administration for action and possible follow-up at a future Commission meeting. We expect that citizens have first attempted to speak directly with the City’s Administration. Other Agenda Items permitting citizens’ comment - Citizens desiring to speak are allowed three (3) minutes. Agenda items for which citizens’ comments are not permitted are noted in the left margin of the Agenda. The City Auditor and Clerk will forward all Request to Speak forms to the Mayor. When the Mayor calls your name, come to the Commission table, and restate your name for the record. We ask that your comments be limited to the subject of the Agenda Item. Remember, we are always happy to listen to your comments; however, this is not intended to be an extended question and answer session. Again, the City Commission thanks you for taking the time to participate in our meeting. LIZ ALPERT Mayor 1

REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING CITY HALL 1565 First Street Sarasota, Florida January 16, 2024 City Commission Chambers 9:00 AM I. COMMISSION PRESENTATIONS: I.1 Presentation Re: Employee of the Month and Team of the Month for January 2024 I.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf Employee and Team of the Month Agenda Backup - January 2024.pdf II. SCHEDULED PRESENTATIONS: Scheduled Presentations are limited to 7 minutes. No action may be taken by the Commission other than referral to the administration. Citizens comments are not permitted on Scheduled Presentations III. CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS: (Limited to 30 minutes) Note to the Public: At this time, citizens may address the Commission on topics concerning the City. (3 minutes per person time limit) Citizens’ Input is to allow citizens the opportunity to present their view on matters concerning City topics but not on items scheduled REVISED AGENDA ** PLEASE NOTE: THE COMMISSION WILL RECESS FOR LUNCH AT APPROX. 12:00P.M. ** CALL MEETING TO ORDER INVOCATION PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE PLEDGE OF PUBLIC CONDUCT APPROVE PROPOSED AGENDA SCHEDULE Citizens' comments are not permitted on Proposed Agenda Schedule 2

elsewhere on the Agenda or items that were the subject of a previously held public hearing which has been closed and Commission deliberations continued to a future date. Questions and answers shall not be permitted; however, matters presented to the Commission may be referred by the Mayor, with consensus of the Commission, to the Administration for action and possible follow-up at a future Commission meeting. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Citizens' comments are not permitted on Approval of the Minutes items. V. BOARD ACTIONS: VI. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 1: Note to the Public: All matters listed under Consent Agenda No. 1, are considered to be routine by the City Commission and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items. If discussion is desired, that item will be removed from the Consent Agenda and will be considered separately. VI.1 Approval Re: Proposed 2023-2024 Budget Calendar requiring City Commission involvement VI.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf Agenda Attachment Commission Dates 2025.pdf VI.2 Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute the Second Amendment between the City of Sarasota and Society of St. Vincent De Paul South Pinellas, Inc., d/b/a St. Vincent De Paul CARES for Affordable Housing Initiative Rental Housing Project at 1529 and 1539 25th Street VI.2 Agenda Request Form.pdf Affordable Hsg Initiative_SVdP Request for Additional Funding.pdf VI.3 Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute the Agreement between the City of Sarasota and Ajax Paving Industries of Florida, LLC (BID #23-03BK) pertaining to the Roundabout located at Ringling Boulevard and Pine Place in the amount of $3,722,466.40 VI.3 Agenda Request Form.pdf Ringling Blvd & Pine Pl Roundabout_Agenda Backup.pdf VI.4 Approval Re: Acceptance of the Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA) FY 23 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program in the amount of $30,928.00 for purchase of portable PTZ (point, tilt, zoom) video cameras and automatic license plate reader (ALPR) cameras VI.4 Agenda Request Form.pdf BACK UP MATERIALS INCLUDED WITH.pdf VII. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 2: Note to the Public: All matters listed under Consent Agenda No. 2, are considered to be routine by the City Commission and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items. If discussion is desired, that item will be removed from the Consent Agenda and will be considered separately. VII.1 Adoption Re: Proposed Resolution No. 24R-3227, amending the budget for the 3

fiscal year beginning October 1, 2023 by providing for supplemental appropriations in the amounts identified in exhibit A; providing for severability if any of the parts hereof are declared invalid, etc. (Title Only) to establish a revenue and expenditure budget in the amount of $4,070,466 for funds for the Ringling Boulevard Pine Place Roundabout project to be reimbursed by FDOT VII.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf Res_24R-3227_backup_01-16-23.pdf VII.2 Adoption Re: Proposed Resolution No. 24R-3228, amending the budget for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2023 by providing for supplemental appropriations in the amounts identified in exhibit A: providing for severability if any of the parts hereof are declared invalid, etc. (Title Only) to establish a revenue and expenditure budget in the amount of $30,928.00 for funds for the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant received by SPD VII.2 Agenda Request Form.pdf Res 24R-3228_backup_01-16-24.pdf VIII. BOARD APPOINTMENTS: IX. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: IX.1 Discussion Re: Civility, Respect and Rhetoric (THIS ITEM WAS ADDED UNDER CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY) (THIS ITEM WAS MOVED TO UNFINISHED BUSINESS BY THE COMMISSION AT THE TABLE UNDER CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY) XII.2 Agenda Request Form.pdf X. LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS: Note to the Public: At this time citizens will take an oath if they desire to speak at the following public hearings. X.1 Public Hearing Re: Proposed Ordinance No. 24-5508, amending the Floodplain Management Ordinance No. 22-5431, as amended by Ordinance No. 23-5482, Chapter 1, Administration, Section 102.3, Basis for Establishing Flood Hazard Areas, and Section 103.9, Floodplain Management Records, so as to update the date of the flood insurance study for Sarasota County as well as the location of the studies, maps and other relevant records so as to comply with Federal Emergency Management Agency requirements; providing for severability of the parts hereof if declared invalid, etc. (Title Only) X.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf agenga package 01162024 24-5508 - Floodplain amend.pdf X.2 Public Hearing Re: Proposed Ordinance No. 23-5502, amending the Zoning Code (2002 Edition), Article II, Definitions and Rules of Construction, Division 2, Definitions, Section II-201, Definitions, to establish new definitions for restaurant, bar, bar outdoor, bottle club, and nightclub, and Division 3, Description of Use Categories, Section II-305, Commercial Use Categories, and Section II-307, Institutional Use Categories to reflect the change in definitions; Article VI, Zone Districts, Division 5, Commercial Zone Districts, Section VI-504, Special NT, CP and CT Development Standards, to reflect the change in definitions; and Article 4

VII, Regulations of General Applicability, Division 14, Miscellaneous Standards, Section VII-1404, Refuse and Recycling Storage Areas, to reflect the change in definitions; providing for severability of the parts hereof; (Title Only) (Application No. 23-ZTA-04, Applicant: City of Sarasota) X.2 Agenda Request Form.pdf Backup Material Ord. No. 23-5502.pdf City Commission Public Hearing January 16 2024 Final FINAL (2).pdf X.3 Public Hearing Re: Proposed Ordinance No. 23-5503, amending the Zoning Code (2002 Edition), Article VI, Zone Districts, Division 5, Commercial Zone Districts, Division 6, Production Intensive Commercial Zone Districts, Division 7, Special Purpose Zone Districts, Division 9, Special Public Interest Overlay Districts, and Division 10, Downtown Zone Districts, to update the primary use tables therein; Article VII, Regulations of General Applicability, Division 6, Additional Use and Development Standards, Section VII-602, Specific Standards for Certain Uses, subsections (f) and (r) to modify the standards regarding outdoor seating areas and sale of alcoholic beverages, and Division 9, Accessory Uses and Structures, Section VII-904, Non-residential Accessory Uses, Buildings and Structures, to amend the approval procedures applicable to accessory bars; providing for severability of the parts hereof, etc. (Title Only) (Application No. 23- ZTA-04, Applicant: City of Sarasota) X.3 Agenda Request Form.pdf Backup Material Ord. No. 23-5503.pdf XI. QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS: Note to the Public: At this time citizens will take an oath if they desire to speak at the following public hearings. XII. NEW BUSINESS: XII.1 Discussion Re: Comprehensive Review of the City of Sarasota Zoning Code (THIS ITEM WAS ADDED UNDER CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY) XII.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf XIII. CITIZENS INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS: (Limited to 30 minutes) Note to the Public: At this time, citizens may address the Commission on topics concerning the City. (3 minutes per person time limit) Citizens’ Input is to allow citizens the opportunity to present their view on matters concerning City topics but not on items scheduled elsewhere on the Agenda or items that were the subject of a previously held public hearing which has been closed and Commission deliberations continued to a future date. Questions and answers shall not be permitted; however, matters presented to the Commission may be referred by the Mayor, with consensus of the Commission, to the Administration for action and possible follow-up at a future Commission meeting. XIV. REMARKS OF COMMISSIONERS, ANNOUNCEMENTS AND ITEMS FOR NEXT AGENDA: XV. OTHER MATTERS/ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICERS: XVI. ADJOURN 5

Meeting Notice 1-16-24 Change to the Order of the Day Notice.pdf 1-16-24 Regular Meeting Notice.pdf City Commission Rules of Procedure CC.RulesofProcedure.AdoptedSept20-2021.pdf E-Comments, Request to Speak Cards & Items Received at the Meeting January 16, 2024 Regular Mtg eComments.pdf January 16, 2024 Regular Mtg Items Received.pdf January 16, 2024 Regular Mtg Speaker Cards.pdf MEETING NOTICE CITY COMMISSION RULES OF PROCEDURE ECOMMENTS, REQUEST TO SPEAK CARDS & ITEMS RECEIVED 6

Shayla Griggs City Auditor and Clerk Notice to the Public The City of Sarasota is committed to providing qualified disabled individuals an opportunity to participate in meetings of the City Commission. The City of Sarasota prohibits discrimination in all services, programs, or activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, sex or gender, marital or familial status, religion, sexual orientation, veteran status, or genetic information. Persons with disabilities who require assistance or alternative means for communication of program information such as Braille, large print, audiotape, etc., should contact: The City of Sarasota ADA Coordinator, Jake Brown, at (941) 263-6299 or by email at adacoordinator@sarasotafl.gov. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in a meeting should contact the ADA Coordinator at (941) 263-6299 at least two business days prior to the date of the meeting as to the nature of the auxiliary aids and/or service necessary. Every effort will be made to provide such aid or service to the extent that they are reasonable, do not result in undue financial or administrative burden, and do not alter the fundamental nature of the meeting. Consideration will be given to the individual's preferred aid or service. However, alternatives may be provided if in the City's determination such alternatives provide an effective means of communication. For the benefit of individuals utilizing hearing aids with a T-coil, the City Commission Chambers and SRQ Media Studio are outfitted with a Hearing Induction Loop for enhanced hearing assistance. Proceedings will be electronically recorded. Should an individual feel that a verbatim transcription of the proceedings may later be needed, said individual has the burden and expense of arranging for same. Copies of the electronic recording may be purchased from the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk. 7

Showing the first 24,000 of 317,411 characters. The full document is at the source.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING TUESDAY, JANUARY 16, 2024, 9:00 A.M. DISCLAIMER: THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER. 09:02:25 [ SOUNDING GAVEL ] 09:02:26 >>Mayor Alpert: GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. 09:02:28 I WANT TO CALL THIS MONDAY -- OR TUESDAY, JANUARY 16, 09:02:32 REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING TO ORDER AND ASK THE CITY 09:02:37 AUDITOR AND CLERK FOR THE INVOCATION. 09:02:41 >>Shayla Griggs: PLEASE STAND. 09:02:42 HEAVENLY FATHER, WE AFFIRM OUR FAITH IN THEE. 09:02:51 WE SEEK YOUR DIVINE STRENGTH, WISDOM AND GUIDANCE IN 09:02:54 DELIBERATIONS THAT AFFECT THE LIVES OF EACH OF THE CITIZENS 09:02:56 OF OUR COMMUNITY. 09:02:57 IN THY NAME WE PRAY, AMEN. 09:02:59 >>Mayor Alpert: VICE MAYOR, WOULD YOU LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE? 09:03:01 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: ABSOLUTELY. 09:03:02 [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] 09:03:14 >>Mayor Alpert: OKAY. 09:03:15 IF THE CLERK WOULD READ THE PLEDGE OF PUBLIC CONDUCT, 09:03:22 PLEASE. 09:03:23 >>Shayla Griggs: YES, THANK YOU, MAYOR. 09:03:24 WE MAY DISAGREE, BUT WE WILL BE RESPECTFUL TO ONE ANOTHER. 09:03:28 WE WILL DIRECT ALL COMMENTS TO ISSUES. 09:03:30 WE WILL NOT ENGAGE IN PERSONAL ATTACKS. 09:03:34 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU SO MUCH. 09:03:35 ARE THERE ANY CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY? 09:03:39 >>Shayla Griggs: YES, MADAM MAYOR. 09:03:41 THERE ARE TWO CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY. 09:03:43 PLEASE ADD UNDER NEW BUSINESS AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 12.1, 09:03:49 DISCUSSION RE: COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF THE CITY OF SARASOTA 09:03:52 ZONING CODE PER THE REQUEST OF COMMISSIONER BATTIE. 09:03:55 THE SECOND ITEM, PLEASE ADD UNDER NEW BUSINESS AGENDA ITEM 09:03:59 NUMBER 12.2, DISCUSSION RE: CIVILITY, RESPECT AND RHETORIC 09:04:04 PER THE REQUEST OF COMMISSIONER BATTIE. 09:04:06 THAT IS ALL THE CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY. 09:04:08 >>Mayor Alpert: OKAY. 09:04:09 THANK YOU. 09:04:14 >>Kyle Battie: IF I CAN MAKE A CHANGE, IF I MAY. 09:04:17 I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE ITEM ON CIVILITY, WHAT NUMBER IS THAT? 09:04:26 >>Shayla Griggs: 12.2. 09:04:27 >>Kyle Battie: UNDER UNFINISHED BUSINESS AND MOVE IT UP. 09:04:31 >>Shayla Griggs: THAT WOULD BE UP TO THE COMMISSION TO 09:04:33 DECIDE IF YOU ALL ARE WILLING TO ACCEPT COMMISSIONER BATTIE 09:04:39 MOVING ITEM 12.2 UNDER UNFINISHED BUSINESS.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:04:43 CONSENSUS WOULD BE GREAT. 09:04:45 >>Mayor Alpert: I'M FINE WITH THAT. 09:04:47 >>Erik Arroyo: YEAH, FINE WITH THAT. 09:04:49 >>Shayla Griggs: EVERYBODY OKAY WITH THAT? 09:04:51 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: I'M JUST CURIOUS, WHY. 09:04:53 >>Kyle Battie: I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK TO THE COMMISSION 09:04:56 BEFOREHAND AND GET THIS OUT OF THE WAY. 09:05:03 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: IT'S THE SAME ORDER, RIGHT? 09:05:06 >>Marlon Brown: ITEM UNDER NEW BUSINESS. 09:05:09 DOESN'T LOOK LIKE CONSENSUS, SO YOU'LL HAVE TO TAKE A VOTE. 09:05:11 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: I'M SORRY. 09:05:13 I'M STILL NOT CLEAR ON WHY THE REQUEST IS THERE. 09:05:18 >>Kyle Battie: PRIMARILY I JUST WANTED TO MOVE THIS JUST TO 09:05:23 GET THE CIVILITY SITUATION IN PUBLIC CIVILITY AND DISCOURSE 09:05:29 OUT OF THE WAY BEFORE WE START, YOU KNOW, GET ON WITH THE 09:05:33 REST OF THE MEETING. 09:05:40 >>Shayla Griggs: LET'S TAKE A VOTE. 09:05:41 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: I'M JUST CONFUSED. 09:05:42 RIGHT NOW I SEE 10.3 AND THE NEXT ITEM WOULD BE THE NEW 09:05:47 BUSINESS ITEMS. 09:05:47 AND THEN THIS WOULD MOVE UP TO RIGHT AFTER 10.3 SO BASICALLY 09:05:51 THE SAME ORDER. 09:05:52 >>Marlon Brown: NO. 09:05:54 MOVING TO UNDER UNFINISHED BUSINESS. 09:05:56 >>Shayla Griggs: IT WOULD BE AN UNFINISHED BUSINESS ITEM 09:06:01 NOW. 09:06:01 IT WOULD GO BEFORE THE PUBLIC HEARINGS. 09:06:03 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: OH, I SEE. 09:06:04 I WAS LOOKING AT LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS. 09:06:05 I GET IT NOW. 09:06:06 OKAY. 09:06:09 >>Debbie Trice: I UNDERSTAND WHY HE WANTS TO MOVE IT. 09:06:11 I JUST DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS UNFINISHED BUSINESS. 09:06:15 DID THE DISCUSSION OF THIS START BEFORE I JOINED THE 09:06:18 COMMISSION? 09:06:20 >>Shayla Griggs: I GET WHAT YOU ARE SAYING. 09:06:22 IT IS ALWAYS UP TO THE COMMISSION HOW YOU WANT TO HAVE 09:06:25 AGENDA ITEMS. 09:06:26 IF THAT IS THE WILL OF THE COMMISSION, THAT'S WHAT WE'LL DO. 09:06:29 >>Marlon Brown: COMMISSIONERS, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT 09:06:31 COMMISSIONER BATTIE SHARED WITH ME, SINCE WE HAVE 09:06:34 LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS COMING UP AND OBVIOUSLY THERE 09:06:36 ARE ITEMS THAT ARE GOING TO, YOU KNOW, WHERE THERE WILL BE A 09:06:41 LOT OF DISCUSSION, HE WANTED TO HAVE THAT DISCUSSION AHEAD 09:06:43 TO HAVE THAT CIVILITY DISCUSSION AHEAD OF THE PUBLIC 09:06:46 HEARINGS. 09:06:46 AGAIN, IT'S UP TO THE COMMISSION. 09:06:48 YOU CAN EITHER VOTE ON IT OR DO IT BY CONSENSUS. 09:06:51 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: I'M OKAY WITH IT. 09:06:54 NOW I UNDERSTAND WHERE IT'S GOING ON THE AGENDA. 09:06:57 I WAS CONFUSED. 09:06:59 >>Shayla Griggs: SO WE'RE GOOD?

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:07:00 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU. 09:07:03 >>Kyle Battie: THANK YOU, COMMISSION. 09:07:10 >>Mayor Alpert: NEXT WE NEED TO APPROVE THE PROPOSED AGENDA 09:07:14 SCHEDULE. 09:07:17 >>Erik Arroyo: MOVE TO APPROVE THE PROPOSED AGENDA SCHEDULE. 09:07:20 >>Mayor Alpert: IS THERE A SECOND? 09:07:21 >>Vice-Mayor Ahearn-Koch: SECOND. 09:07:24 >>Mayor Alpert: PLEASE VOTE, COMMISSIONERS. 09:07:27 >>Shayla Griggs: I DON'T KNOW WHY IT IS NOT SHOWING. 09:07:29 COMMISSIONER BATTIE? 09:07:32 >>Kyle Battie: YES. 09:07:34 >>Shayla Griggs: I WILL SAY THAT IT IS 5-0. 09:07:36 SORRY ABOUT THAT. 09:07:38 I DON'T KNOW WHY IT IS NOT SHOWING UP. 09:07:39 >>Mayor Alpert: THE MOTION PASSED 5-0. 09:07:42 BEFORE WE MAKE THE PRESENTATION, I ALSO WANTED TO 09:07:47 ACKNOWLEDGE IN THE AUDIENCE FORMER COMMISSIONER AND FORMER 09:07:52 MAYOR SHELLI FREELAND-EDDIE. 09:07:59 I'M NOT SEEING THAT WELL RIGHT NOW. 09:08:01 NOW I SEE YOU. 09:08:03 OKAY. 09:08:04 THANK YOU. 09:08:05 AND SHE IS HERE WITH STUDENTS FROM NEW COLLEGE. 09:08:12 THANK YOU FOR BRINGING EVERYBODY IN. 09:08:16 THANK YOU. 09:08:19 SORRY ABOUT THAT. 09:08:20 I CAN HEAR IT. 09:08:23 OBVIOUSLY YOU CAN'T. 09:08:24 THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME KNOW. 09:08:25 NEXT IS OUR COMMISSION PRESENTATIONS. 09:08:37 >> PLEDGE OF PUBLIC CONDUCT. 09:08:39 >>Mayor Alpert: SHE DID THAT. 09:08:40 IF YOU WOULD JOIN ME UP FRONT. 09:08:45 GOOD MORNING. 09:09:19 WE'RE GOING TO HONOR TODAY THE EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH AND THE 09:09:23 TEAM OF THE MONTH. 09:09:24 WE'LL START WITH THE EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH. 09:09:28 WILLIE BUTLER, A CREW LEADER II. 09:09:33 IS HE HERE? 09:09:33 WELCOME. 09:09:34 IN THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT OF THE CITY OF SARASOTA HAS 09:09:37 BEEN RECOGNIZED AS THE EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH FOR JANUARY 09:09:41 2024. 09:09:42 WITH AN IMPRESSIVE 23 YEARS OF DEDICATED SERVICE, WILLIE HAS 09:09:47 DEMONSTRATED EXCEPTIONAL COMMITMENT, DILIGENCE, AND 09:09:51 LEADERSHIP. 09:09:52 COLLEAGUES COMMEND HIM FOR HIS PROMPT AND THOROUGH 09:09:56 INVOLVEMENT IN SETTING UP, TEARING DOWN, AND CLEANING UP 09:09:59 DURING SPECIAL EVENTS, ENSURING THE CLEANLINESS OF THE 09:10:02 STREETS. 09:10:03 I KNOW ALL OF OUR RESIDENTS APPRECIATE THAT, TOO, WILLIE.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:10:06 WILLIE'S EXEMPLARY SUPERVISION STYLE, ATTENTION TO DETAIL 09:10:10 AND COMMITMENT TO CITY CLEANLINESS SET A HIGH STANDARD FOR 09:10:13 HIS TEAM. 09:10:14 HIS POSITIVE IMPACT ON SPECIAL EVENTS AND THE OVERALL 09:10:19 CLEANLINESS OF THE CITY HAS EARNED HIM THIS RECOGNITION, 09:10:22 REFLECTING WELL ON THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT AND 09:10:25 RESONATING WITH THE COMMUNITY. 09:10:27 WILLIE BUTLER'S 23 YEARS OF SERVICE EMBODY THE VALUES OF 09:10:32 RESPECT, INTEGRITY, TEAMWORK, AND ACCOUNTABILITY, MAKING HIM 09:10:36 A SOURCE OF PRIDE FOR THE CITY OF SARASOTA. 09:10:41 I'M GOING TO READ THE COMMISSION RECOGNITION, AND IT SAYS, 09:10:47 COMMISSION RECOGNITION IS PRESENTED TO WILLIE BUTLER, PUBLIC 09:10:50 WORKS, IN APPRECIATION OF OUTSTANDING DEDICATION, EXEMPLARY 09:10:55 PERFORMANCE, AND UNWAVERING COMMITMENT TO EXCELLENCE, THE 09:10:59 CITY OF SARASOTA PROUDLY PRESENTS THIS EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH 09:11:02 AWARD TO WILLIE BUTLER, DILIGENCE, SELF-MOTIVATION AND 09:11:07 DEDICATION YOU DISPLAY BY CONSISTENTLY GOING THE EXTRA MILE 09:11:12 TO ACHIEVE OPTIMAL RESULTS ARE TRULY COMMENDABLE. 09:11:16 DID YOU WANT TO SAY ANYTHING? 09:11:34 >> I JUST WANT TO THANK ALL THE PUBLIC WORKS GUYS FOR 09:11:38 HELPING ME KEEP THE CITY CLEAN AND MAKING PUBLIC WORKS THE 09:11:44 BEST. 09:11:45 [ APPLAUSE ] 09:11:58 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU SO MUCH. 09:12:48 [ APPLAUSE ] 09:12:48 NEXT WE'RE GOING TO RECOGNIZE THE TEAM OF THE MONTH. 09:13:00 LIZ THOMAS -- I'M NOT SEEING WELL. 09:13:13 TRYING TO GET USED TO DIFFERENT GLASSES. 09:13:15 LIZ THOMAS, SENIOR RECORDS SPECIALIST IN THE CITY AUDITOR 09:13:18 AND CLERK'S OFFICE AND DEBBIE NELSON, ADMINISTRATIVE 09:13:21 SPECIALIST III IN DEVELOPMENT SERVICES, HAVE BEEN RECOGNIZED 09:13:25 AS THE CITY OF SARASOTA'S TEAM OF THE MONTH FOR JANUARY 09:13:29 2024. 09:13:30 BOTH EMPLOYEES HAVE SHOWN DEDICATION AND EXCELLENCE IN THEIR 09:13:34 ROLES WITH LIZ STARTING AS A RECORDS SPECIALIST II IN 2018 09:13:40 AND DEBBIE PROGRESSING FROM PART-TIME ADMINISTRATIVE 09:13:44 SPECIALIST IN 2014 TO FULL-TIME ADMINISTRATIVE SPECIALIST 09:13:50 III IN 2019. 09:13:53 OVER THE PAST YEAR, LIZ AND DEBBIE COLLABORATED WITH THEIR 09:13:55 MANAGERS TO EFFICIENTLY HANDLE AND DIGITIZE THOUSANDS OF 09:13:59 PERMITTING AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES RECORDS, RESOLVING A 09:14:03 BACKLOG ISSUE AND OPTIMIZING DEPARTMENTAL EFFICIENCY. 09:14:07 THE NOMINATION FOR THIS RECOGNITION HIGHLIGHTS THEIR 09:14:10 PROACTIVE APPROACH TO ADDRESS A BACKLOG OF 380 BOXES OF 09:14:17 PERMITTING RECORDS, WHICH POSED A FINANCIAL LIABILITY AND 09:14:21 RESOURCE DRAIN FOR THE CITY. 09:14:24 LIZ AND DEBBIE SUCCESSFULLY ORGANIZED, SCANNED, AND 09:14:30 DESTROYED THESE RECORDS, CONTRIBUTING TO THE EFFICIENCY OF 09:14:34 MULTIPLE DEPARTMENTS. 09:14:37 THEIR METICULOUS ATTENTION TO DETAIL, PERSEVERANCE, AND 09:14:41 EXCEPTIONAL WORK ETHIC IN COMPLETING THIS MONUMENTAL PROJECT 09:14:46 HAVE BEEN COMMENDED.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:14:48 LIZ THOMAS AND DEBBIE NELSON EMBODY THE CITY'S VALUES OF 09:14:51 TEAMWORK, ACCOUNTABILITY, INTEGRITY, AND RESPECT, SHOWCASING 09:14:56 THEIR COMMITMENT TO EXCELLENCE AND PRIDE IN THEIR ROLES. 09:14:59 ALL RIGHT. 09:15:02 AND OUR COMMISSION RECOGNITION IS PRESENTED TO LIZ THOMAS 09:15:06 AND DEBBIE NELSON FOR THE CITY AUDITOR AND CLERK'S OFFICE 09:15:13 DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT IN APPRECIATION OF 09:15:14 OUTSTANDING TEAMWORK, DEDICATION, AND EXCEPTIONAL 09:15:18 CONTRIBUTIONS, THE CITY OF SARASOTA PROUDLY RECOGNIZES THE 09:15:23 JANUARY 2024 TEAM OF THE MONTH, THE COLLECTIVE COMMITMENT TO 09:15:28 EXCELLENCE, INNOVATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING AND UNWAVERING WORK 09:15:32 ETHIC HAVE NOT ONLY MET BUT EXCEEDED THE STANDARDS SET BY 09:15:37 OUR ORGANIZATION. 09:15:38 WOULD YOU ALL LIKE TO SAY SOMETHING? 09:15:40 LOVE TO HAVE YOU AT HOME ORGANIZING MY STUFF. 09:15:45 [ LAUGHTER ] 09:15:46 >> YES. 09:15:47 HI, EVERYONE. 09:15:48 I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR THE NOMINATIONS AND THE 09:15:50 RECOGNITION TODAY. 09:15:51 I WOULD LIKE TO THANK NICK AS MY BOSS. 09:15:55 GREAT WORK. 09:15:56 AND THE CITY AUDITOR AND CLERK THAT I WORK FOR, SHAYLA, HI. 09:16:00 THANK YOU. 09:16:01 I'LL SAY THANK YOU FOR DEBBIE, TOO. 09:16:04 I KNOW SHE'S NOT HERE. 09:16:06 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU SO MUCH. 09:16:07 ANYBODY ELSE? 09:16:10 >> MY NAME IS KEI WILKINS, PERMIT COORDINATOR, AND I WORK 09:16:14 WITH DEBBIE. 09:16:15 I CAME TO ACCEPT THE AWARD ON HER BEHALF. 09:16:18 SHE IS AN AMAZING WORKER AND I LOVE WORKING WITH HER EVERY 09:16:20 DAY, SO I JUST WANTED TO SAY THOSE WORDS. 09:16:24 [ APPLAUSE ] 09:16:32 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU AND CONGRATULATIONS. 09:17:02 ALL RIGHT. 09:17:26 OUR NEXT ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING 09:17:32 CITY TOPICS. 09:17:35 AGAIN, I'LL ASK THE CITY AUDITOR AND CLERK TO READ THE 09:17:40 PLEDGE OF CONDUCT. 09:17:41 >>Shayla Griggs: WE MAY DISAGREE BUT WE WILL BE RESPECTFUL 09:17:45 TO ONE ANOTHER. 09:17:46 WE WILL DIRECT ALL COMMENTS TO ISSUES. 09:17:47 WE WILL NOT ENGAGE IN PERSONAL ATTACKS. 09:17:50 >>Mayor Alpert: OKAY. 09:17:50 WE HAVE FOUR PEOPLE SET TO SPEAK TODAY. 09:17:52 I'LL CALL YOU UP ALL AT ONCE. 09:17:54 ARTHUR LINDEMANIS. 09:18:00 THOMAS RODGERS, SENIOR. 09:18:01 SHERMAN BALDWIN AND JOSE FERNANDEZ. 09:18:07 >>Shayla Griggs: ALSO, MAYOR, ONCE THEY ARE DONE, WE DO HAVE 09:18:10 ONE ZOOM PARTICIPANT.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:18:11 >>Mayor Alpert: OKAY. 09:18:12 THANK YOU. 09:18:12 ALL RIGHT. 09:18:18 MR. LINDEMANIS. 09:18:20 STATE YOUR NAME AND IF YOU ARE A CITY RESIDENT. 09:18:22 >> ARTHUR LINDEMANIS. 09:18:25 I LIVE IN THE CITY. 09:18:27 I'VE WORKED WITH MOST OF THE COMMISSION. 09:18:30 I'M HERE TO DISCUSS THIS CURRENT SITUATION WITH U.S. 09:18:33 RECYCLING. 09:18:35 I WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS THE NEIGHBORHOOD'S APPRECIATION TO 09:18:39 THE COMMISSION. 09:18:41 SINCE THE PRESENTATION BY JEN AUGUST A YEAR AGO, THE SUPPORT 09:18:48 OF THE CITY HAS BEEN PHENOMENAL. 09:18:52 BETWEEN THE PERMITS, THE ROAD, AS YOU WELL KNOW, CURRENTLY 09:18:57 THEY ARE UNDER A SALES CONTRACT WITH THE IDEA OF PUTTING IN 09:19:01 MIXED USE OR PUTTING IN CONDOS. 09:19:04 SO THAT'S FAR BEYOND WHAT WE EXPECTED THREE YEARS AGO. 09:19:08 SO THANK YOU FOR THAT. 09:19:09 NOW, I SENT JEN AND SOME OTHER PEOPLE AN UPDATE. 09:19:19 THE OPERATION CONTINUES TO PUT OUT LIFE-THREATENING 09:19:27 POLLUTION, AND IF THE SALE GOES THROUGH, WE DON'T EXPECT 09:19:31 THEM TO BREAK GROUND FOR TWO TO THREE YEARS. 09:19:34 WE ARE CONCERNED THAT DURING THAT TIME THEY WILL BE EMITTING 09:19:40 TOXIC LEVELS OF .25 PARTICLES. 09:19:44 WE MEASURED LEVELS THAT ARE AS HIGH AS 180, 200, WHERE 09:19:52 ANYTHING OVER 100 IS TOXIC. 09:19:54 THE NORMAL LEVEL THAT'S SEMI ACCEPTABLE IS 10 TO 25. 09:20:01 NOW, THE ISSUE HERE IS THAT WE HAVE PUT UP AN ARRAY OF 09:20:10 SENSORS, WEATHER STATION, AND WE ALSO HAVE CAMERAS. 09:20:13 AND WE WILL HAVE EVIDENCE THAT THE ATTORNEY WANTS TO SEE OF 09:20:19 VIDEO EVIDENCE TOGETHER WITH MEASUREMENTS TO PROVE WHAT THEY 09:20:24 ARE DOING. 09:20:25 WE REALLY DO NEED TO LOOK AT THE PERMITTING AND SUCH. 09:20:30 I'M GETTING TOWARDS THE END OF IT. 09:20:32 BUT BEYOND THAT, WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS CHALLENGE THE 09:20:36 CITY TO START THINKING ABOUT WHAT THAT ENTIRE AREA COULD BE. 09:20:43 IT IS A HUGE DOWNTOWN SITE. 09:20:49 THOMAS ROGERS WHO HAS ONE OF THE BUSINESSES THERE, PAT BALL 09:20:54 THAT YOU'VE WORKED WITH IN THE PAST OWNS H 2 O MARINE ARE 09:21:00 ALL UNITED IN WANTING TO SEE A MAJOR UPSCALE DEVELOPMENT 09:21:05 THERE. 09:21:05 YOU'RE LOOKING AT OVER 8 ACRES THAT COULD BE OFF THE BAY, 09:21:08 NOT ON THE BAY, BUT OFF THE BAY, A CULTURE CENTER. 09:21:12 IT COULD BE PHENOMENAL, AND I WOULD REALLY LIKE TO SEE THAT 09:21:16 GOING, AND I'LL TALK TO MARK SMITH WHO IS AN ARCHITECT. 09:21:19 HE IS A COUNTY COMMISSIONER. 09:21:21 HE SUPPORTS THE IDEA. 09:21:23 AT THIS POINT, I WOULD LIKE TO TURN IT OVER TO ONE OF THE 09:21:25 BUSINESS INDIVIDUALS THAT'S INVOLVED. 09:21:28 >>Mayor Alpert: AND YOU ARE. 09:21:29 >> THOMAS ROGERS, ROBERTSON BILLIARDS AND SPAS ON THE CORNER

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:21:33 OF INDUSTRIAL COURT AND CENTRAL. 09:21:35 WE'RE FROM TAMPA. 09:21:37 WE DECIDED TO OPEN A STORE IN SARASOTA. 09:21:41 I'VE ALWAYS LOVED SARASOTA. 09:21:42 COME DOWN HERE FISHING AND ALL THAT. 09:21:44 WE HAVE A STORE IN CLEARWATER AND DOWNTOWN TAMPA. 09:21:49 QUICKLY AFTER PURCHASING THE PROPERTY AND NOT LOOKING AT THE 09:21:54 SURROUNDINGS, AS I SHOULD HAVE, I NOTICED THE CONCRETE 09:22:00 FACILITY. 09:22:00 AFTER RENOVATING THE STORE AND OPENING I WANTED TO HAVE AN 09:22:07 OUTDOOR SHOW ROOM WITH SPAS, PAVERS, AND NICE LANDSCAPING. 09:22:12 WE WERE EXCITED ABOUT THAT. 09:22:13 QUICKLY UPON GOING OUTSIDE I NOTICED ALL THE TRUCKS AND THE 09:22:19 DUST AND IT WAS COVERED OUT THERE. 09:22:23 COULD NOT PUT SPAS AND THINGS OUTSIDE. 09:22:26 SO WE CAULKED ALL THE WINDOWS, SHUTTERED EVERYTHING, 09:22:31 PRESSURE WASHED THE BUILDING AND I BEGAN THIS JOURNEY THAT 09:22:33 WE'RE AT NOW AT TWO MINUTES AND TWO SECONDS. 09:22:36 I WANT TO THANK THE MEMBERS OF THE CITY COMMISSIONERS AND 09:22:41 THE MANAGERS AND THE AUDITORS FOR ANY INPUT YOU HAVE PUT 09:22:45 INTO THIS, BUT IT SEEMS LIKE AN IMPOSSIBLE BATTLE JUST TO 09:22:50 HAVE A CLEAN BACKYARD. 09:22:52 AND THAT'S ALL I EVER REALLY WANTED. 09:22:55 THE THINGS THAT ARTHUR IS TALKING ABOUT WILL TAKE A LOT OF 09:22:58 TIME, AND WE WON'T HAVE -- I'M 68. 09:23:02 I DON'T HAVE AN INCREDIBLE AMOUNT OF TIME TO FINISH WHAT I 09:23:08 SEE AS A DREAM STORE FOR OUR COMPANY. 09:23:10 I HAD MR. EIGLEHART WHO CLOSED THE BATTLE AT PINEY POINT 09:23:17 WITH THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION CAME 09:23:20 OVER AND VIEWED MY BUILDING EARLY ON IN THIS BATTLE TWO, 09:23:23 THREE YEARS AGO, AND HE LOOKED ME DEAD IN THE EYE AND SAID 09:23:26 NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO LIVE OR WORK UNDER THESE CONDITIONS. 09:23:30 I SAID, WELL, WHAT DO WE DO? 09:23:32 HE HAD SOME SUGGESTIONS. 09:23:35 HE QUICKLY TOLD ME HE HAD GIVEN THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE 09:23:37 ENVIRONMENT TO THE COUNTY UPON CALLING THE COUNTY, THE 09:23:41 COUNTY MANAGER, ROBERT STUART SAID TO ME, WHAT DUST ARE YOU 09:23:45 TALKING ABOUT? 09:23:45 I ALREADY KNEW PEOPLE HAD BEEN COMPLAINING ABOUT IT FOR 09:23:48 YEARS. 09:23:50 I'M DISCOURAGED, BUT THERE IS HOPE. 09:23:53 SADLY IT LIES IN MONEY INSTEAD OF RIGHTEOUSNESS. 09:24:00 I FEEL SORRY FOR THE PEOPLE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE STREET. 09:24:02 THERE ARE SIX OR SEVEN HOUSES IN THE IMMEDIATE SURROUNDING 09:24:05 AREA THAT ARE JUST LITERALLY COVERED IN DUST. 09:24:08 THEY DON'T PRESSURE WASH. 09:24:09 THEY DON'T BARBEQUE. 09:24:10 THEY DON'T GO OUTSIDE, AND THEY ARE ALL RELATIVELY POOR 09:24:13 PEOPLE. 09:24:16 ANYTHING THAT YOU GUYS DO IN GOVERNMENT THAT HELPS THE 09:24:20 LITTLE GUY, NOT ME, THE LITTLE GUY AND THE PEOPLE THAT LIVE 09:24:25 THERE, THE RESIDENTS, IS GREATLY APPRECIATED AND THAT IS THE

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:24:28 BATTLE THAT WE NEED TO FIGHT FOR THE LITTLE GUY. 09:24:32 THE BIG GUYS JUST DO WHAT THEY WANT. 09:24:35 I THANK YOU. 09:24:36 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 09:24:37 SHERMAN BALDWIN. 09:24:39 >> GOOD MORNING. 09:24:39 I'M SHERMAN BALDWIN. 09:24:41 MY FAMILY AND I HAVE BEEN RESIDENTS, PROPERTY OWNERS, AND 09:24:44 BUSINESS OWNERS IN THE CITY OF SARASOTA FOR ALMOST 40 YEARS. 09:24:48 I'M HERE TO TALK ABOUT THREE QUICK SUBJECTS. 09:24:51 NUMBER ONE, HART'S LANDING. 09:24:54 I AM THE CONCESSIONAIRE AT HART'S LANDING. 09:24:56 I'M HERE TO BEG, PLEAD, ASK, THAT WE DO SOMETHING ABOUT THE 09:24:59 DERELICT BOATS THAT SIT ANCHOR OFF OF HART'S LANDING. 09:25:04 JUST THIS MORNING A BOAT BROKE FREE. 09:25:06 AND THESE IRRESPONSIBLE, UNINSURED BOAT OWNERS ARE WREAKING 09:25:10 HAVOC ON OUR BUSINESS AS WELL AS POTENTIALLY DESTROYING 09:25:14 DOCKS OVER AT GOLDEN GATE AND WAIT TILL YOU HAVE A MILLION 09:25:19 DOLLAR CLAIM ON THAT WHEN IT WIPES OUT A HINCKLEY AND BOAT 09:25:23 DOCK, ANYTHING OF THAT NATURE. 09:25:25 ANY WINDS ABOVE 10 KNOTS WILL CREATE A PROBLEM THERE. 09:25:28 WE REALLY HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THAT. 09:25:30 I ASK THAT YOU EMPOWER THE SARASOTA MARINE POLICE TO ENFORCE 09:25:35 THINGS LIKE PUMP-OUT ABILITIES ON THESE BOATS, THAT DERELICT 09:25:40 BOAT OWNERS THAT AREN'T AT THEIR BOATS, JUST LEAVE THEM 09:25:43 FLOATING HAVE TO BE REMOVED BEFORE WHAT THEY DID IN 2020, 09:25:48 WIPE OUT OUR DOCK AND KEEP US OUT OF BUSINESS VIA WATER FOR 09:25:51 ALMOST FOUR MONTHS AT A GREAT COST TO THE CITY. 09:25:54 AND EVERY NIGHT THAT IT'S BLOWING OVER 10, I HAVE A 09:25:57 SLEEPLESS NIGHT, I REALLY DO. 09:25:59 I'M ASKING FOR THE BENEFIT OF MY BUSINESS AS WELL AS THE 09:26:02 RESIDENTS OF SARASOTA THAT WE DO SOMETHING TO ENFORCE THE 09:26:06 LAWS THAT ARE ALREADY ON THE BOOK AND MAYBE CONSIDER ANY 09:26:09 ORDINANCES TO PREVENT THESE DERELICT BOATS, THESE 09:26:12 IRRESPONSIBLE BOAT OWNERS FROM LEAVING THEIR BOATS THERE 09:26:15 WHERE THEY CAN BE POTENTIALLY HARMFUL. 09:26:18 NUMBER TWO, I AM VERY EXCITED TO ANNOUNCE THAT WE ARE ALSO 09:26:22 THE CONCESSIONAIRES AT THE PAYNE PARK TENNIS CENTER. 09:26:26 WE WERE JUST AWARDED THIS AND WE ARE BUILDING OUT THAT SPACE 09:26:28 RIGHT NOW. 09:26:29 WE HOPE THAT YOU WOULD ALL CHECK IT OUT. 09:26:31 IT'S GOING TO BE REALLY FUN AND INTERESTING WITH FOOD AND 09:26:34 BEVERAGES AND ALL OF THAT, SO WE REALLY HOPE THAT YOU COME 09:26:37 OUT FOR THAT. 09:26:38 AND THEN CIRCLING BACK TO HART'S LANDING, 2024 MARKS THE 09:26:42 90th YEAR THAT HART'S LANDING HAS BEEN PART OF THIS CITY. 09:26:47 AND WE LOVE THAT WE'VE TAKEN ON THIS LEGACY AND THIS 09:26:49 HISTORICAL PROPERTY AND WOULD LIKE TO LOOK TO THE COMMISSION 09:26:53 TO MAYBE HONORING 90 YEARS, STARTING WITH THE HART'S FAMILY, 09:26:56 THEN TO THE WALLACE FAMILY AND NOW WITH MY FAMILY, THE 09:26:59 BALDWIN FAMILY, THAT WE ARE VESTED INTO THIS AREA AND HART'S 09:27:03 LANDING IS SUCH AN AMAZING PLACE WITH FREE LIVE MUSIC SERIES

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-01-16-Commission.txt[1/17/2024 10:51:11 AM] 09:27:07 IN WELLEN PARK WHICH WE HOPE YOU ALL ATTEND. 09:27:11 LET'S HONOR THE INTEGRITY OF THIS HISTORICAL PLACE CALLED 09:27:16 HART'S LANDING. 09:27:17 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 09:27:24 >> MY DAUGHTER WENT TO HIGH SCHOOL WITH MR. BALDWIN'S SON. 09:27:28 >>Mayor Alpert: IT IS. 09:27:29 SARASOTA IS A SMALL CITY. 09:27:30 JOSE FERNANDEZ. 09:27:40 >> GOOD MORNING. 09:27:40 MY NAME IS JOSE FERNANDEZ. 09:27:42 I AM A RESIDENT OF SARASOTA. 09:27:43 AN ARTICLE BY MAYOR ALPERT WAS PUBLISHED IN THE JANUARY 09:27:51 6th HERALD TRIBUNE TITLED LET'S GIVE CITY STAFF MEMBERS 09:27:54 THE RESPECT THEY DESERVE. 09:27:55 I TAKE EXCEPTION TO MOST OF THE ARTICLE, BUT MOST OF ALL TO 09:27:58 THE PREMISE THAT THE CITY STAFF IS EXEMPT FROM SCRUTINY AND 09:28:01 CRITIQUE. 09:28:02 LET'S START WITH THE STATEMENT THAT STAFF ARE ACCOMPLISHED 09:28:05 PROFESSIONALS WITH MASTERS AND EVEN DOCTORATE DEGREES. 09:28:07 THIS IS AN ARGUMENT FROM AUTHORITY THAT IS AN OFTEN ABUSED 09:28:11 LOGICAL FALLACY. 09:28:12 THE MERE FACT THAT PEOPLE ARE EDUCATED DOES NOT MAKE THEM 09:28:16 INFALLIBLE NOR DOES IT MEAN THEIR DECISIONS CANNOT BE 09:28:19 CRITIQUED. 09:28:20 REMEMBER, THIS IS THE STAFF THAT WROTE A ZONING CODE THAT IS 09:28:22 BEING USED TO TRY TO BUILD AN 18-STORY BUILDING THAT WILL BE 09:28:25 ALMOST 350 FEET TALL. 09:28:27 THIS DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE BAD PEOPLE OR INCOMPETENT. 09:28:31 IT JUST SHOWS THAT THEY CAN BE WRONG. 09:28:33 THERE'S MORE. 09:28:34 CALLING COMPLAINTS AND CRITIQUES ABOUT CITY STAFF NOT SO 09:28:38 VEILED ATTACKS IS A MISCHARACTERIZATION OF WHAT'S BEEN SAID, 09:28:41 SOMETHING THAT ALL OF US WHO REGULARLY ADDRESS THIS BODY ARE 09:28:44 USED TO. 09:28:44 THE AUTHOR OF THESE COMPLAINTS HAS OFFERED CONCRETE 09:28:50 EVIDENCE, NOT OPINION, BACKING UP THEIR CLAIMS. 09:28:53 AN EMAIL FROM MR. FOURNIER TO MR. BROWN ON DECEMBER 8 09:28:53 REGARDING NOT COMMENTING TO THE PLANNING STAFF READ IN PART, 09:28:56 RATHER THAN OFFER SUBSTANTIVE COMMENTS THAT I KNEW FROM 09:29:01 EXPERIENCE COULD ENGENDER A STRONG NEGATIVE REACTION AND 09:29:03 MIGHT RESULT IN AN ARGUMENT I HAD NO INTEREST IN HAVING. 09:29:06 FOLLOWED ON THE 11th BY AN E-MAIL FROM MR. BROWN TO MR. 09:29:10 FOURNIER READ IN PART, WHAT YOU AND I DISCUSSED AT LUNCH WAS 09:29:15 STAFF BEING

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Commission Meeting - via Zoom/Hybrid — Minutes
  • Regular City Commission Meeting - via Zoom/Hybrid
  • Regular City Commission Meeting - via Zoom/Hybrid — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e90c6f778c6b5f7ebbc9576f75028cf1. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record