POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Convocation of Governments - Audio only

Friday, January 17, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Convocation of Governments - Audio only

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

Commissioner Sarasota County Commission Chair Joe Neunder

1 statement

  1. Statement

    Commented on the Venice football championship.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 67,870 stored characters

>> But good morning, everybody. Today's Fri. JANUARY 19,025. My name is Robert sachem the magistrate that will be hearing today's docket I'll ask those of you in the audience it will be providing testimony this morning to please rise and allow the court to swear u n. >> In testimony, you are about >> Calling case number e n f to she o d dash 2, 4, dash 0, 1, 0 one to Sarasota County vs Peter duisburg. >> When he was captain Sir city Kathryn joosten for Sarasota County code enforcement officer and I have been sworn. For mayor investigated code enforcement case anf cod 24 0, 1, 0, 1, 2, subject properties located at 6.60 olive Street. And what Florida property Eddie's 0, 4, 9, 6, 0, 5, 0, 0, 4, 7, On JUNE 30,024 hours the side a complaint. From the Sarasota County. Sheriff's Office for debris accumulation on this property. To an inspection with the sso officer was conducted when I also met. MISTER Dole duisburg at his residence at 6.10 Marson Avenue. I expected the parcel at 6.60 all of with MISTER Duisburg to explain the property was owned by his deceased father and finds it extremely difficult to remove the debris due to extenuating health conditions based on the accumulation of the proper outdoor storage when the parcel and there's a violation was submitted for violating Sarasota County khou section 54 for 73. I like to submit composite photographs exhibit one as the initial inspection dated 6 2824 exhibit who was are inspections photos dated Aug. 27 24. 1/7/2025. And the latest one from yesterday of Jan. 16th, 2025. These composite photos were accurately depicted for the violation of the time they were taking. >> government 1, 2, 3, are admitted. >> I've had several conversations with them MISTER Duisburg and he has experience multiple setbacks including reports of burglary of the structure a 6.60. All of street and the recent multiple tropical storms and hurricane. I've had several conversations with MISTER Duisburg with the suggestion of seeking assistance through social services for other financial assistance, impossible volunteer assistance to alleviate the violation of improper outdoor storage of this parcel. This morning I spoke to MISTER Ghost Bergen he'd. Definitely want to come to this a hearing. He called and he said he had a attempted break in early this morning. And he's in the process of making a report and having. That is when the front door exchanged at this point though that if the special magistrate finds a violation existed on this parcel of the county recommends. They suggested extension of 45 days is a property owner MAY have this property poured into compliance with some assistance. >> ok so that would take him to Mar. 3rd. Correct yes, he feels in terms of your discussions with him, he feels that's adequate time to get things cleaned oath. >> If possible because we have to coordinate with other with if this could be a status hearing at that time ok it MAY be more recruitment. >> Okay that be Mar. 21th so that gives them some additional time firing. We can see worries ahead at that point. Ok case number eon effort to stop dash 2, 4, to 0, 1, 0, 1, to Sarasota County versus Peter Doocy for this involves a property located at 6, 6, 0, olive Avenue Englewood Florida p I d 0, 4, 9, 6, 0, 5, 0, 0, 4, 7, The evidence today shows that the respondent has allowed an overgrowth the grass and weeds and accumulation of improper outdoor storage. Remaining on this parcel, this is a violation of Sarasota County code, some an order that the respondent remove the improper outdoor storage or started to completely enclose buildings acute pain. The grass and weeds must be mode to a length the less than 12 inches and be maintained in that manner at all times. All this must be accomplished within 45 days which is 3/3/2025. I'm going to schedule a hearing on 3/21/2024, I've that 2014 as it says here. To determine whether or this order has been complied with. Thank you. Thank you. Calling case number tnf dash cod dash 2, 4, dash 0, 2, 4, 4, 8, Sarasota County versus Alexis properties llc. The state your name for the record set on. >> Dan Bailey, a council Alexis properties and all good morning. >> Go ahead MISTER Well your honor I'm Scott Foster psychiatry for Sarasota We have with me at that table here MISTER Kevin Mitchell who's the best team officer coming up Donna Thompson is an administration whose here as well. MR. Mitchell go through The evidence is photographs and such are the evidence as you call it. MISS Thompson will discuss some of the zoning issues that are involved in this property. There's also a 3rd My list MISTER West who is neighboring property on it who is a such a representative of of the folks who live near the property to kind of speak to the impacts that current violations had on surrounding he MAY or MAY not be called after these 2. But I'll leave the floor to MISTER Mitchell this title case. Thank you. Good morning. My name is Kevin Mitchell code enforcement officer with Sarasota County and I have to swarm. >> I am familiar with and then this chemistry case number enough the s e l d s to 4 tests 0, 2, 4, 4, 8, The subject property is located at 4, 9, to Riverview drive South and the coolness the p id number is 0, 4, 0, 5, The 0, 6, 0, 0, 4, 4, The subject properties in Sarasota County Florida. On 10/16/2024 Sarasota County received multiple complaints that the business known as all scrapped, is polling scrap metal and stocked pond on this partial. Further on 10/16/2024. I conduct uh-1 speck shun observed a significant accumulation of scrap metal being piled on this partial additionally customers were off looms scrap millet is partial causing heavy traffic flow in the neighboring streets. I would like to submit composite photographs as government exhibit number one day that dated 10/16/2024. Your honor and tops of those are in the book that has had a number one. Any objection, a motion MISTER Bailey them. A government one is admitted that. I inspected the property on 10/31/2024 and observed the continued accumulation of scrap metal on the partial false crack. In addition to customers often scrap metal. I would like to submit for the graphic evidence as government exhibit number 2 dated 10/31/2024. Again MISTER Bailey any the actions of these photos being entered into evidence. Thank you government to submit it based on these observations and amended a notice of violation was served on Nov. 12th of 2024 to the respondent alleging violations of Sarasota County code unified development code article 6 section 1, 2, 4, dash 7, 6, d 2 d I'll Wu says a lot by special exception and Sarasota County cold unified development code article 8 section one 24 dash one 43. All scrap was directed to cease and desist all operations as of NOVEMBER, 14,024 per the amended a notice of violation. A re inspections of the property. On NOVEMBER, 15,024 and thereafter from the property with the continued violation. Weekly inspections were conducted throughout the the inspection very when you say continuing is is that of the cease and desist order the activities that are activities in a cease and desist order but thank you. I would like to submit re inspection for the graphic evidence as government saying that exhibit number 3 dated 11/21/2024. Government exhibit number 4 dated 12/18/2024. And government exhibit number 5 dated Jan. 15th of 2025. Any objection MISTER Bit the government's 3, 4, 5, are admitted. Thank you. I will I would also like to submit exhibit number 6 shown aerial views of the partial dating back 4 years. An exhibit number 7 so on the website of all scrap advertise in the business as a recycling facility and its locations. And MISTER Bailey any objection judge Kaye thank government 6, 7, are made of. >> That all the evidence that you have for us was to us it was it. That money. This really have any What to them back to the property more recently. >> Uh yes, my last exhibit was Jan. 16th. Okay. Well that is that one in here. Which was sent to be number 5. And did you put genna a 15th, I'm sorry was my last exhibit. Exhibit number 5 to turn away 15th of 2025 did you. Did you notice a substantial dam edition. In the corner to give a material on the side comparing that they'd with the dates back and yes, I did that because of the stench extension cleanup since then. Yes. Thank GOD, I'm not when asked uh MISS Thompson. For the record Thompson's an administrator and I have been sworn. >> I became aware of this property in FEBRUARY when they submitted a request for an interpretation that the property could be used for outdoor storage they are and I'll so Dean district which does allow for outdoor storage an unlimited quantities. What was described in their letter that they provided him photographs of their operation that appeared to have met the conditions for the outdoor storage. So I let it was granted stating that they could use the property for outdoor Stuart. Then in OCTOBER after the 2 Hurricanes came through we begin the it cost that an undue amount of scrap had been delivered to the site and it was continue and it had increased to a very large stockpile of scrap metal. We were sympathetic that they were trying to assist with debris removal have are under the dc that is considered a waste transfer. Service which is out I'll double you unless you have 10 acres and a special exception approval by County Commission. So at that point in will hear these the lessons I could do. >> I'd say we were advised that they operating as a waste transfer facility at that point in time without this cat coming in. There's only an out and I'll that the district with the special exception and 10 acres which they don't have the 10 acres to meet that condition. At that point in time the notice was granted and they have been asked to come back into compliance of outdoor storage and demonstrate that they're meeting the conditions of outdoor storage is defined in the utc. >> What was there in light of the storms and hurricanes was or any County exception. 2 accumulating scrap metal are getting debris off the that that might implicate zoning requirements. >> No there was no, I mean and other properties have had similar issues that resulted in and could violations because there was such a a you overabundance of debris after the storm and obviously cleanup is a priority. But. You know nothing came from the board organization to the site every parcel in the concrete some sort or require a irrespective of right what the debris piles look like or anything for that matter. >> And anything the Austin and it stops him if if I MAY I'm. True to taps liberate know what they're telling her as a documents. Look at what is on what's have 8. >> Tab a is the request for scram as keen to have outdoor storage is a permitted use and I'll w joining the stricken could they operate as outdoor storage. >> And did you indicate a You base your response on the mission of 5 in that letter. The exclusively and did you learn information. Afterwards that would have changed your. Response at all. >> Not until the calls came in about the exorbitant amount of scam that has been brought in from the hurricane debris. Nigel storm coming and then tap 9 and you must have known. Yes 10 night is the letter that was written by myself that stated that they could operate outdoor storage at the facility and that's a zone in interpretation that's done under the utc process correct. We've asked for aid exhibit 8, 9 to be entered into the record a much action this year the The exhibit 8, 9, are admitted a question I just want to make sure I have the timeline right to your. >> Zoning interpretation letters dated FEBRUARY 30,024. Correct cut substantively it it does allow for the type of outdoor storage that these respondents engage in is that correct. >> It allows for what they've provided in the letter of request that they were storm facilities it has a nice clean impaired sight. There is no indication of any scrap clean around there contain shipping container say, yes. >> Has it on the on the medals were contained in shipping containers from the photos that I was provided meant it appeared so it was a nice clean site that had no indication that it operating as a place to be answered. >> And so these photographs that the company their request are or what you based your interpret an interpretive letter and it said Kerr accurate. Yes, the voters attachment. They request. >> Is there any in his own in code for this particular product or so. >> Is there any a. Limitation a him. I'm the amount of scrap that can be stored there and is it required to have it in containers. >> Outdoor storage and I'll that the district would have to be screened from public view neighboring properties in public right away. So it. It would at least be limited either the height of the building which could go to 65 feet or offense which typically is a fee with screening so there are limitations that it needs to be screened says not visible from neighboring property in a see those are laid out in your in your letter correct okay that's a post Harvey of any more questions so I I guess just to make sure everyone's on the same page on Donna. What would be the necessary steps for the responded to take to bring the property plans at this point. >> They are going to demonstrate that they're going to need to demonstrate that they're operating as outdoor storage is defined in the d c. >> ok, what would that look like. Stack of papers here. I'm trying to get we do have some microphone is today Bergin some background noise. So we had the same problem on Tue. When I was down here. >> So outdoor storage is defined as the outdoor storage of products whether for sale or as material for processes occurring on the site generally for more than 24 hours a day. This definition express they includes products on pallets and shipping containers are in crates. >> So the accumulation of debris outside of those parameters is prohibited correct. MR. Bo start any more questions not like to come. MISTER Daley give any questions of this with us the first clear indication. That you're the it was the the map for a couple things the mass of material. >> The home side that could be viewed from the street above the fence that was part of the problem. The problem has been corrected. Since then has it not. >> The mass pictures said. What's provided for code enforcement division. Still shows some scrap metal that. >> Doesn't appear to be in any kind of containers or anything yet. That pile has been taken down. >> That definition. That has to be containerized what they what they've done. They do say is they've they've compacted the metal. And the bails. Essentially or containers. And then placed on trucks and then tracked down to Fort Myers. Do you agree that the pales constitute. Containers. >> I'm not so sure I would agree that a bail as a container but. Containers like a boxer something that you put something into it. >> Which says this definition, especially in clues. Any products and pallets and shouldn't containers or in crates that doesn't can find and that does not say that there has to be in the container doesn't. >> Not specifically. It can be in. Under the definition of does not have to be. Ok and that your views because there was there is a requirement a as I understand it. That not be visible from the street. And it was understandably but if it's not just go from Street. There's that transformer back in the door storage. How's become compliant with outdoor storage. Us in terms of not being visible from the street. Down where you couldn't see it from the street transform it in your view. Recycling facility back to becoming an outdoor storage facility. >> But would have to meet the requirements that are set forth in the letter that they were provided in FEBRUARY. This is no outdoor storage should be allowed in the street yards or other as Florida the front building 9. Outdoor storage MAY be located to the side of the building and provided in his outside of the required side yard area meaning the set back area for the aisle done. And they could use any rear yard for outdoor storage purposes. Outdoor shabby scream from the view from the public right away public parking areas are adjacent residential development by an opaque take wall or a fence a minimum of 8 feet in height. And a chain link fence would be consider is on offense were inserted into the chain link fence. >> That would you agree that the. The extent to which is not compliant with the standards for outdoor storage. That would still be asked or store she just would be not in compliance with our standards and we have been put into compliance. Right they don't change then change its nature and make it a recycling facility really because it doesn't comply with the standards. Outdoor storage. >> But it's up to them to demonstrate that they don't meet the definition of waste services asa to what they're doing is not waist chains for okay. >> We are prepared to call a witness to address that issue of the time. Any for anything further. I'm not for this witness, your honor. I was going out com MISTER West. He's a a neighboring property owner who and prepare a statement to kind of speak to the affected the neighboring property owners as this is going on obviously credit to the responder for having significant reduce the amount of material there but this kind to give a flavor of what's going on in the interim terms of the perspective of someone who's got a live there could not could you give me a little sort of map as to what had a is this a homeowners are during just one neighborhood to neighborhood. Jason neighborhood. Yeah and is it. I mean did what give me a little geography so MISTER Wess if you go down Riverview drive South. The entrance of false craft is on Riverview drive k. MR. S property is the first property Street. So if you go out the entrance you'll see House waycross another lot that his house ice yet so he's. >> What's so. There's a street right after the break when you passed the entrance of Oscar at there's a street you make a right and his house is the first House on Fri. And are there other houses. Yes, yes are also communicates a subdivision basically yes, okay. And I'll ask him to come for now, thank you believe he's been smart. I'm not even my chair. I have reviewed the statement ahead of time so should I take a few. You like to use this Mike this good morning Sir could you state your name for the records but as the West and charitable. Thank you and could use a state your address for the record. >> Seven-thirty Mount Street ok I lives. So that you might recall nearly 3 years now. I'm humbled to have the option to just big day on behalf of my neighbors, families and friends. All of you know community this illegal scrap yard that had a profound impact on neighborhoods. I didn't buy that is disrupt the lives. They just safety at averting a quality of life. When you put just a home we understood the Jason lamb was owned for industry like was it. We researched what this entailed who 7 not call the windows down we more of that noise levels on activity. We feel confident enough cision to make becomes a home and raise a family. However of the hurricane note and a community faced unprecedented challenges not from storm damage from the illegal operation of a lot of skills industrial struck out. Cleanup efforts off the hurricane were struck by scrapbooking roads speeding for residential streets and using private in ways that the driveways to right this jet does it say to our children and delay to central services like mental every. During the storm's aftermath. We often have to drive hundreds of yards on the wrong side of the road else like wolves to get around the procession of waiting scrap was just to reach jobs. This hurricane season, we're directly affected by 3 hurricanes in a very short period of time. It's a legal scrapyard open a 3rd. We then have 2 or 3 more Hurricanes threats, but luckily didn't last had one of the affected is for you to break the storm with high winds the dangerously high matchup scrap would decimate the homes and properties as well as like the trial. Increasing damage raising insurance premiums. This cause significantly heightened stress and concern during these polls storms a hurricane to vote in our area on not. Except anymore their routine. The part of a life and the law should be seen as a special substance. Since crept up again over actions, we've enjoyed relentless noise. 6 days a week from sunrise to sunset the constant battering. Crunching dragging and dropping uncharted made it impossible to join Isis bases really when does a during the cooler months. Somebody was from home these dust or losses from what one calls the most focusing much of its treaty difficult when having times of move the vibrations also strongly road loss where my captains my name is most now one of my neighbors must now travel to his office in Sarasota take important corporate schools, Jude law knows destruction. He's bears. Sunday's of the day we fight rest by from the noise and even then exciting for the next weak link is the struggles of ration having to do significant health and environmental risks, the racy kinds of orange dust blowing off the pile from a insulation as it is and clean medal. A cover of properties have post be releasing has been tariffs and yet the industrial Greg Craig unload trail start 3 high River refrigerators and toss them into exile, potentially releasing Freon gas. It's the environment. These actions leamy fearful of the cost just by finding MAY be breathing from being in such close proximity. Pulling their describe polls, drug nails and screws all roads leading to numerous lot to us. Safety has vehicles and pedestrians. We lost count of how many last my neighborhood has experienced just because of this multiple times per family. Well Kim in many circumstances. The script has turned a quiet neighborhood into a dangerous and chaotic environment. Scrap is ready go streets and driveways forcing residents to take long go to the rigs overtaxed a flat eyes. Children over for the feel safe play outside. We got a Lima children the school Anymore so they don't have to will the scrubland payments opposed to gays awaiting scraps a neighborhood kids still must will the goal that why stay. With a serious cause for concern of for the children's safety. They sufficiently size love with it because the way safely away for is that there is no have such an issue. One neighbor had spent hours directing traffic to keep very successful. And others had of ripples of a truck crossing from scrap was going on to storm damage from pc they can to both grab all of it. What are neighbor's car co far his driveway. 2 fire trucks, one ambulance and for sheriff's suvs but thankfully able to act quickly respond because it was the often the script. It was closed. Such access would know to be likely all mere possible jury script, you know as you look in that congestion danger he lives of the community. The script has diminished a company's value. Pro Cuba is affecting plummeted making homes and sent to the head sellable because no one wants to live next we feel will now track it, I'm being held hostage by this company. Residents being judged for a living next to a junkyard and friends are reluctant to visit you look at dishes, the roads and the number of flat tires they heard by the neighborhood experiencing. Longtime residents, including a 35 year neighbor. He's recovering from multiple strokes and other medical missions report emotional agitation and the inability to enjoy the peace of their lives. This is not a storage facility. This is a collection facility. The destruction caused by this illegal scrap yard of the danger it poses to our community and the school's what such operation should not be permitted on him and one 0.3 4 make a lot. A neighbor is that your neighbors. Well we recognize the need for scapegoats in the county this location ordering homes businesses and public recreation for the facilities is wholly inappropriate. This company's intent has been clear long before her guns, the heavy industrial equipment was also before Milton was even on the radar, this is the same set of the use of their of locations. They are not here to help the head to help themselves make money and that unity is that paying the price. We citizens full account you'll need to play by the rules. Meanwhile, the scrap yard has flirted legal degrees ignored environmental concerns and showed no regard for being a good neighbor, enough is enough. I hope today we can take decisive action to restore community safety peace and things. MR. Bailey do you have any questions of its way too. The ocean. >> a reduction in that area was in the number of the noise that's really the 6 days a week not all I thought those of the a few weeks ago my mother and even though the most awful is working because the side of thunder is exactly what we're hearing. Every few minutes just call to relent back back back back back. >> All that 6 days. It's 6 stress levels a craze but now I'm looking in through the front gate because I have the the displeasure of having a direct love you for the whole lot through the 6 foot fence which is screened by the jury which is no idle story today. A first but such a thing his nose up to the company owes it to show they were said jailing with greetings last Snow summit. They have is acceptable. A lesson voters residential property in which case at a foot. So the event is required which is not actually included everything. But get the materials and I just don't know the dust recruitment of the the is operating right next to the line I believe this ordinance of I hired close they by a recent it was closing below lives that that very month that the law was only a 124 feet across a police dog piling a fire by recycling centers. Pasta company would 75 the of the line to there's no doubt that the equipment the recycling could look industrial record. He's been 200 feet of a lot with 124 while all that snow around that site. So they have a low this equipment is cool to go and even the the probate how it was that the news of Bhutto's they pick up the containers and then they are pushing that sta but stop close-cropped correct which is a huge source of noise. It's relentless I cannot get that across most how much of a pain. It has been living next to this for months on end. Those are questions. >> Serve as the it but since you became a resident there how long ago was that. >> It was just for you and the business existed at that time that I know this is business opened a really goes the the Mon. Off to the 40 pulled over Mon. After the hard to know that. I was being a and possible innocence but safe when we moved in we did our due diligence on my next a veteran of the Afghanistan and a very detail oriented very black and white and unlike great. So what we we do what you do is pretty hot. We both the highs we came in and we came in several times a day we saw that we were no Windows die, and we just listened to his haul when as I know we see on that list we want to know what we are moving in next door and let the family use of the neighborhood and the us stopped I but what I just told a full that with the parasite had a great role as I was shocked to homes like a we go to a time we didn't call and complain because that's what we need is best for the company moving in need to do to do business with the stand the set up, but then when they actually got up and running it was relentless continued disruption. Come to think that enough is being helped living next door to that and knowing that doing all illegally invite business but it and trying to portray themselves as our top stories when it is a collection facility for 5 years. It is recycling themselves are some things there for themselves or cycling center. Everyone up offers a cartoon because they don't want to abide by the Goldmans. Any additional questions from anybody enough. Thanks thank you, thanks very much. >> Any additional witnesses MR. Bo snow that note this is a test might this time I think I think in terms of recommendation and maybe the offer some simplicity and that's. They some MISS Thompson c'est money. We think compliance would be for the responded to bring the property into a condition, consistent with more. Precise a consistent with MISS Thompson's letter exhibit 9. And I know the suggestion from staff was to do this within 14 days. We'll hear from the respondent on that and then we'll have a discussion of that the close of that, but that's it is that essentially to the station cease and desist order still in effect. It would be cease desist until that conditions are still reached it's still out there still out there but obviously we understand that they've made a tremendous amount of progress in getting that the material down to a closer to acceptable level. They just need to finish the job and in a way that's consistent with that showed it handles outdoor storage ok, so ok so if I understand your position again the so long this facility and responded meets the conditions. >> Of outdoor storage as set forth in zoning interpretation letter the county satisfied that the businesses operating appropriately and consistent with all County codes. >> Yes in terms of this question I know there's an issue with his use permit that that is has not yet been obtained, but but I >> think that's this is kind of step one. And the price the property gets into this condition. It will then be the county more amenable to a business permit to be issued which MAY or MAY not have conditions on it but that's for that process to go through but this is step one. Step one is get the property to a condition where the activity is going to be normalized to something that has been authorized by the administration k and. >> We heard the concerns of the neighboring community compliance with the zoning interpretation letter in those conditions. It sounds like the noise hand, the traffic in the debris that's a. Put on the streets as a result of the traffic. With with that go away. Entirely condition. I don't know that I really go away but I think what that does is puts the respond in a position where. >> They can then apply for that is used for Matt and then like I said sometimes conditions are put on that it might be. Have a machine might be limited by times and I'm just thinking out loud I'm not saying these are ideas but these are just. Now they MAY have a limitation would have a machine or maybe use that MAY have a limitation on. You know hours of of business in terms of traffic. Yeah store traffic coming in and out. Limitations on what type of. You know issue needs to be within a structure or not things like that there's there's any number of things that they could examine. Once we get this situation under control that we can move to the next step of of putting them in addition where they can perform their business functions in a way that is more compatible with the surrounding neighborhoods that we don't have this this come up again. Later on. Ok MISTER Bailey do you have any witnesses. I have no objection of some of the steps in our evidence packages well it's ok thank So exhibit a of the respondent is admitted. That exhibit. >> Of number 2 pages in the lower right hand corner we know so I'm thinking maybe for those just want to give you kind of overview before we. Our position is and how call to support some of >> Well MISTER Bailey it to begin could could you give me a little overview of the business and and how long this business is yes of fact and what they do actually. Yes, Sir, thanks for. This all scram and that's a sister company to the owner, a Lexus. A secondhand dealer and secondary metal recycling facility. They shun Fort Myers. The shuttle operation in Naples and it had one in Venice. Until this one was a bit. By the way the one in Venice, this sense of precisely the same zoning. Precisely the same operations on a smaller arsenal. And they close to it when open this one. They acquired this one because this was a large parcel. The one advantage. Conducting operations in the public right of way. The outdoor storage was the classification there was no contention that time. Worst George is not permitted. And I'll bet you outdoor storage. Involved in operations precisely what there's occurring on this site. There's a citation. The pace 26. See that was issued to the same company, but it. Again a fires a different location. 1, 8, 1, James Street, Venice. And the only of a ledge violation. We're not there was the contention that it was a that was George only that it was allowing its activities spill over on the street. And then that was socially correct it and of course as I was subsequently closed. The company does not process materials simply by them. Collect them by commodity because the compound of commodities. And then they host sell them to of buyers and users. They do not change the elemental composition of the material which it would be if it were actually recycle activity. So in FEBRUARY that last year. Who shared a cfa. Wrote the letter which Scott has done a fact. I think the coffee I have his day in Feb. 15 say mornings, they shouldn't 8 the striving the operations that you've seen. They do help him understand what you could do that confirmed that operation will be permitted on this side based upon that business plan that he is going to hear about. And then so she issued a zoning confirmation letter. It was just all She she indicated that she researches the county staff, this is a collaborative. Qualified as outdoor storage. Just as it probably did the events. So then the client went ahead and went under contract by the party. Subsequently bought the property. They are safe or 1.3. They in plus. So they could begin operation. They After the closure that began get the property ready for operations with building repairs. Paying attention repaving your cleanup. The removal of jobs in the previous hour. Sure the site and what you see today. Versus I'm sure that they had purchased before. They spent approximately $275,000 to get the problem and working order for their operations and they plan to open in late OCTOBER. Sept. 26. Hurricane Lane game. And brought with it the high winds and storm surge and we know about that result in significant damage to our community as well as tremendous amount the breed. All of them in the Rose. And if that weren't enough Oct. 9. There was a long hurricane Lane. Even worse the conditions. So on Oct. 18 days later 5 days later, they the an operations on this week on the side. You had to prescribe are all over the county. It had gotten off the roads, so you could safely travel. This became a the shorts that it could be brought to. You MAY recall seeing. The summer site albeit much larger stickney 0.41. That the property about that That was a mountain of debris that was I don't know whether it was fame over the county. Doing it. But uh I question whether it had a special exception for that and I the question of the day and are still a our debris on the middle of it. So this is this is emergency circumstances and we're having to deal with. That was fortuitous that the site opened up. Fortuitous for the region they had a place that was could be brought and then dispatched to another location to be sold. In a moment I will call MISTER Trump has she talk about the distinctions between. The outdoor storage and waste related service. One of the things. This technically some of these materials 10 years but are not waste. Laist it's something you get rid of and you pay somebody to take. These people do is they received the materials and paid the donor the person is given the tone. It's not it's not waste. It's actually has value. So much storm debris in palu all over the region. In fact you still see around and a but consequently over 3 million pounds of metal materials were delivered to all scraps location. The big compacted and moved to their signing former arms the blinds were greater than anticipated and that precluded normal operations and thank normal operations and not begun until like this week. They've got that got it down to a a volume that they can actually turn around in 2 days. Something this delivered to them. Today could be the compacted put on truck and it's gone today, the 2 nations now. And had his materials not been delivered all scrap that still be littering the streets and highways are region protection blocking traffic and sugar. The unfairness Donna. The materials the photos that at first her love for every 20. Showed a much smaller volume then we know occurred after the hurricane. It was just it was just a tsunami materials that came in. But that's all changed. But anyway, Kevin Mitchell had issued notice of violation for not having a business permit. Not client felt that the business permit it. The thought that he was incorrect in this assumption, the business permit yet and initially it was that the trash for this location that we now know that requires a new. This is huge permit. The same day Oct. 21 issued 2 more. Notices of violation which in combination allege that all scrap was operating a recycling facility. And I'll w district without require special exception. And Don of all that up with an email confirming it that she felt like it was a we recycle scrap mile no signs to start of the We apply for special exception the problem with the special exception is. Recycling equipment camp. Has to be a can be located within 200 feet of the person boundary the partial zone heard 35 feet across. Joe will not qualify for special exception to that degree. The procession would have to take place inside a building which there's not one. There was an error when we got that John confirmation or I thought I heard you say earlier that. >> There's no >> recycling at occurs right right right. Will have jumped come talk about why what recycling is k then the context there which talks about waste. We we contend the daughters the termination back in FEBRUARY which and the correct. And we also have to acknowledge that we are there certain standards with which we must comply. And it it's visible from the road. And it's not supposed to be and that has to be wrecked it. The other standard they were not watch with this one where that was part of the problem that regardless that does not transform it into a recycling facility. It just means noncompliant that was short of the show. Now 7 weeks will push back at the moment. We had a The virtual meeting with Scott and Donna an early DECEMBER. And they expressed a concern about the volume property and the commitment was made at that time that we were going where frantically to get a car down. And all scrapped, good work. Long hours over the Christmas holidays. They get it down the point where we said. I wish we hope this substantially in compliance and we we feel it is in terms of this time, but again volume is not what determines with activity Constitution. A shortage because as we know that's to give the standards say this is you can have unlimited storage. That this point I'm going to ask MISTER Has to come up here and uh address this issue of outdoor storage and waste related service. State your name for the Charles has said about Chuck and what is your title and chief financial officer, the owner of this respondent yes okay you've been sworn, yes I am okay. Thank you. Background his terms and that was in the street. i've been a resident of Southwest Florida since my birth in Tampa 1979. >> I've been involved in several industries in southwest Florida ranging from Tampa all the way a further South as Naples heavy equipment industries, education management control. Logistics. A manufacturing facilities, a whole house here in Florida. I was a the cfo and Seo for a a major landscape company that dealt with hurricanes. Obviously and most recently my career has brought me to where I am now as the chief financial officer, one of the executive members. The team for the Johnsons for all 3 of locations as well as the real estate and the Lexus properties. I have a major in biology and a minor in chemistry. And I've learned business through alternate programs throughout my career dating back to when I was 23 years old. >> the liturgy for every 20. Activities that actually were taking place. >> At the facility have containers that material is sorted. And places like commodities has been described and the collection process. And we also have bays that are buildup to separate certain materials that are put and therefore then shipping or for containment. And the process are not are the transport of it and to the compact or to the bales to the trucks. So wasn't this shirt. It reduces the volume by 5 times. Of any of the 3 to 4 different commodities that we transport in that manner. So virtually if you took. For example. Post-hurricane all of them. The vast majority of the material, there's aluminum and there are different grades and their Variety's of of aluminum. So when we separate those that put him in and to containers there've been removed taken toward Fort Myers facility where there weather but in larger quantities and then shipped out. Those Metairie on materials are are highly volumes a alumnus actually so what that entails and constitutes is that you have. A tractor-trailer. If you do not contact the material you might be able to get 7500 pounds of material into that trailer and one left by contacting it compressing it into the bails and then putting those veils and the trailers you can get 40 to 45,000 pounds they have quicker and use it which obviously expedites the process of what we would call dropping the pile from that was a direct result of of Elaine and that which are abnormal circumstances totally not our day to day operation business. That's not what we But in efforts to help the community get the stuff off the streets. That's what we did to give you an idea taking 3.2 million pounds of that type of material trying to get that out at 7500 pounds a pop. You would have to run 25 trucks a day 24 hours a day for. I don't know 6 or 7 months. We diverted all our transportation and logistics utilizing the compact or which is portable. It's back where can be seen. We got out using our our our logistics our own trucks are on trailers we divert everything from our other 2 operations at our own expense meaning that the other 2 operations. We're not able to conduct their normal business. In efforts to drop out for the community and the come comply with the with the outdoor storage cut. We diligently at this we work within the parameters of the normal 8 to 5 day. And then half a day on Sat. Which we do it all or other facilities. It was watched over. I know Kevin's been there from day one taking pictures watching that the progress. I don't think that he can say anything other than that we've been bused are about to there uh it's it's been on our on our plates and this is all com the cost to expense of the ownership group. As was mentioned before a large distinction between waste. Way says refuse that is not usable. People pay those services whether it's out of their pocket for through taxes. They haven't removed like your normal trash collection. We buy. Useful materials. Which is step one of the entire recycling process. We're strictly of metals buyer we buy the metal like commodities organized transport. We sell those medals that is one aspect of what that license constitutes further down the line you get into processing the materials which changes the elemental calm down the composition of the 2 from one raw material to an end use product we do not do that that would be resigning, that's that's the actual recycling process of the entire recycling market. The license that we have the licensure constitutes all of that. If we wanted to do those things and that was part of our business model and we were had the properly in the problem, whatever the coach will be we would be able to do that that's not our business model. We don't we don't do that any of our facilities even are 5 acre facility in Fort Myers. The same as the comas it's the same as our Ben its location was it's the same has hour neighbors location, it's just on a much larger scale. That's I think the conceptual content and context and semantics of the waste versus recycling in the recycling you can't lump everything into one term because there are multiple stages and processes to it just as there are ways from that. Having you know said that the outdoor storage model back to the question of if of containment under normal business circumstances which we have a cheat as of late Fri. Midday Mon.. The materials coming in containerized it's going out with 24 to 48 hour period. If you close the doors. The front and you're standing there. It's my understanding from our our general manager there's my counterpart in the enterprise that you cannot see any material sticking up anywhere or anything like that due to the traffic patterns and the way that we have people come into the yard. And the way the material under the material it paid for the material and leave. All of that material is at the back. Any material that's there for the brief amount of time that it exist before we remove it from the property to our larger facility in Fort Myers. Is at the rear part of the problem. Closed the gates, the defense says the hunt is it has the mash across it as and I and I asked I even pastor in the construction like during our. Unification of the property. What we need to do defensively needed a permit you know I have all the documentation say no this type of things we needed. We can also that if need be, but you know if you're looking at it from a stop violent situation which has been thrown around mention we're not doing that under normal business operations which we're very very fortunate, glad that we're back to because at the end of the day. All of this has been astronomical cash flow financial. Burden on our companies to the ownership of self funded all this operation and pay people time in half over time and reconstructed our business model and logistics to to accomplish this feat that getting this material you know the piles dropped and getting it out that doesn't do us any good to have a material that let me ask you to focus on the definition was related services. >> Indicate why that this is >> Artie and said it but ways related services are refuse not are usable. Waste their specific definitions that you're talking about normal garbage things like that that are going to landfills so forth and so on. We buy materials that every usable and recyclable as part of the recycling process. We pay for that material. We then sell it to other people who sell to pay us for the material and then whether they're the end user or or they are. You know another step in the chain the 2 more larger Boeing roads that go. You know wherever they MAY give. This is not something that you're throwing out that being stuck in the land. It is a environmental um. Blocking landfills and we all know or are leaning over film they're also using materials again another chain and another life span and the recycling process. And the major thing that differentiates from waste this is not a waste. They are materials that can be used again in another life and put it in and built into other products that's the in cycle of the oversight process that's not what occurs went with waste whether liquid or solid. And there's a specific definitions that we have that that describes. We simply in its simplest fashion inform regardless of volume where we're doing it. We purchase material from commercial entities and public entities. People up the street whether you want to bring your appliances and there are strict codes that we have to follow there are certain materials that we cannot buy better better either whether they be hazardous or things like catalytic converters the country. It contains We're not allowed to buy those that's only go back to us we don't. We report all of our purchases for every single person that comes through with pictures from friends and after report that daily to the local County sheriff. Everything that we do is to help the community, recycled products that are out there for the vast amount of construction and building that we all know what's going on Southwest, Florida. And that you use the term cycle. >> And in the materials. Yes Scott provided the region because we are the harsh light. We are part of the metal recycling process, we're step one where in the collection. The sorting of the commodities then we sell that's one step of a multi-step process which is collection. Like commodities. Transport to herself to another user that user can then take them and put them in a when you transform the elemental composition of the material. You're going to melt it. Russian. Changing the actual composition to then be put into a mold or whatever you want the 4 medals. All those things require specific specialized industry of women that's way out of the round of anything that only has to give that you're talking about the 3rd and 4th and 5th. Items or our process is in a circular chain of of what the recycling model actually consist of. So we're just we're just the guys are getting off the streets and get it to the next person so it can be. But into usable form again, but back in 2 and to the building site. So it's not least stop waste and you're not the recycler your first step Brett the blast is to the side or act. There's a misconception the way that the licenses written because it uses the term or cycling, but it does that because it's an all encompassing license for anybody who wants to have involvement for business doing any of those steps. To give you an example. We collect with the steel. It is a sorted and the number one and number 2 pairs steel. We put that in large containers, driving to new or the company that and frost room floor. They take that materials and you're talking all all kinds of different steals they take that material. They put it into a Ford that's nothing and turn it into remark which is there and using product that is process. They are resigned. They are the recycling process center. That's why they have that the same license we do because they're purchasing the material from us then they're going to the next step then they're going to the next step they do the whole bit. When asked about the all sides and backs you heard the testimony as it. Amid all that does is it as you mentioned, since OCTOBER. We got hit with a cat 4. I've been to everyone directed since Charley in 2004. I just happen to move to the race cities in the right time and I've been to all. I'm no stranger to with hurricane cleanup is like I've been involved with that through all of my the experience and the community. At multiple levels. I've been the landfills and waste transfer stations have seen the equipment I help sell the equipment. I tell them build the equipment as far as the industries that I've been in. The particular storm. And the amount of debris that was brought in and there's a trade publication. It was actually 10 times what was brought a when you look at your arms. The fact that we had 2 storms within less than a 14 day period. Intensified that effect. We started off overwhelmed. Like anybody with that situation. However. We started Oct. 14th. We did not work on Sundays. We didn't ship typically on Sat. Scores that are half day. When you break it down into business states. I think up until last week there were 65.5 actual business days from a divide that we are moving material out of that facility at no less than 46,000 pounds a day Yes, I would say. I don't know anywhere else in the Southwest area that it wasn't and I've got family from from Tampa from Orlando all the way down to the names, family and friends. All affected by the storms. Dealing with the same thing I've been through it time and time again as a resident of the area. Our response. And the willingness of our ownership group. To finance the capital expenditure. It took to remove that material as fast as we did should be applied. And that drastic change and the traffic flow which yes, it took us a few days. A lot of the description that was given in earlier testimony was a short sample size of the first 2 weeks after the storm. Traffic people come in people come out, they're not lining in the road. That's that's been long gone. And that was also there in the state of emergency that was issued by governor desantis which is still in which is still in effect as a matter of fact and I'm not positive on this I believe we're still in a state of emergency. For me, The fact that we get we get them out of time that we it accomplished that I worked in a lot of industries Tyler work for $7 billion companies down to cell phone companies like this. I've never seen a reaction and a response. The way that we executed. And that was with what we went through in 2 years ago. That was our first really major one that I was involved with here. And we've improved our processes and procedures that as well and again the Johnsons funded that all personally to to ensure that we could you know help the community. That as far as noise. Traffic that was a direct. To a natural disaster. That's not our normal business. And our normal business has resumed. And we feel as though based on the code is owning the letters that we are compliant. There are other things that we need to do to make sure that we time now but we're more than willing. That's a further questions all and as we know MISTER Voser you have any questions just with just a couple things Sir. Thank thank you for coming in this morning. It. >> I'm looking at the section one 2524. An outdoor surge which is I think it's page 11. Send in your packet them. And that bottom half of the page there on on c outdoor storage. This want to go through the subset some of the subsections here. Number 2. I'm just confirmed with me that. Do you have any outdoor stores located. 50 feet from a lot of pressure right away. About the legacy true, that's a problem. I think technically it is but. >> Even though it's still all. It's away from that there was there. >> We'll have to look at what look at that more depth but we need to look at that. Is there any. How to search occurred and street yards or otherwise for the front building. Do you have a surgeon, the side of the building outside reports art. The area. Our building sits on the side of him, ok very. Quite sure how much of the Senate and yet this incident this at the site. So you talked, we don't have anything on that so that's why there's no room defense current. And then on us up for screening. Understand you have fencing and what's the height of that fencing it's a 6 foot fence. Ok you understand that the the substation across the 8 foot. Is that something will be able to do. Yes, okay. We're going to do it and we're going to but our wire on which with which is it even extends to them and then when we expedite are moving to the property in doing that here. All right and then the last subject I understand you get that experience in this in this field. Know you guys employed pollution prevention. Bnp these. Using a 3rd party. Are in a geological consultant. The gentleman named on me. Actually we I mean the Johnsons prior to being in that hired him. A problem that you wear it on 21. Purchase of the Fort Myers location because we. Let's just say the previous ownership they're operating Levy. So we wanted to make sure everything was come Senate under comes out like that so since then we have continue to keep them on as a consultant to do all our sampling and testing for all locations. >> So we do it through a 3rd party because and pieces the fda c s is all that stuff because stopping us doing things like that he survived, and does all those things so is it safe to presume that if we assume that your business will operate as this Thompson's letter direct in terms of that to search that will be easier to do. And it your intent to continue operating that they're going forward. Yes and are under normal business. So if I understand that the essence of your testimony. The various exhibits that were introduced to by the county. Demonstrating the amount of debris like the remember 21 pictures the Dec. 18 picture years. That was in response to the hurricane and the debris from the hurricane is that correct yes that's that that would not be expected to be normal in your business is that correct that is absolutely. And the one 1525 pictures. Our they more the call maybe not completely but more accurately reflect your current business practice and and the the amount of storage that would remain on this parcel. From one 15 which was. Yes it that reduces that was Wed.. Okay, the yesterday into I believe 35,000 so that we do so that this would be but I would consider. He you've heard what the county is recommended Sort of a multi step process and resolving some of the issues here and the first is the requirements that were set forth in the zoning interpretation letter and you just went through some of those conditions and it sounds like most of them are met other than the 8 foot fence requirement would you grab that the circles that the testimony is you know its pensions. Well clarify that going forward. But that's my understanding and you don't have your company doesn't have any objection to meeting those requirements absolutely. Let's talk about the neighborhood a little bit. Let's talk about the neighborhood a little bit we heard some up. Some I want want maybe dramatic isn't the right word for it, but some very very concerning testimony from the neighborhood regarding traffic regarding noise. Regarding hours of operation regarding debris on the street. And things like that and what I'm concerned about is that in this matter is and I want to balance your business practices in years ability to conduct your business which. This sounds like you've done a service for the community in a implementing that business. But also I want to take into account the concerns of the neighborhood it sounds to me that if you comply with the zoning ladder then the strict requirements thereof that can be the end of that as far as you're concerned. And because you've met those requirements. But then you have the neighbors that have delays have concerns about the toxicity that MAY be in the in the air. The debris on the streets with all the flat tires all of that. I'm assuming you meet all they are all of the requirements in the zoning letter and hand if we go to another step and was your intent to address some of the neighborhood issues and step 2. Not necessarily specifically when perhaps in the disease process and that process is and for another time because that might be like I said some there might be some conditions that might allay those issues in that process. >> This process takes really just to get them. There does operate in the way that it's supposed got pretty per the letter that was issued. >> But what assurance can you give the your neighbors. That he'll work with them. Or do things that will immediately or 8. Some of their concerns. >> His question though is a desert. Some better communications between neighbors. >> Well it's beyond compliance. I got to get it, you know like I said you can say oh well we we comply with we comply with all the requirements of the zoning in the storage and all that stuff but still we have nails in the street, we got a lot of noise and people can open their windows and stuff. That's what kind of commitments can you can you make to the neighbors and working with them in the House. We actually operating less tha

Convocation of Governments - Audio only

January 17, 2025

09:00 a.m.

MINUTES

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS

SUNCOAST TECHNICAL COLLEGE

4748 BENEVA ROAD

CONFERENCE CENTER

SARASOTA, FLORIDA

CONVOCATION OF GOVERNMENTS

SARASOTA COUNTY: Chair Joe Neunder, Vice Chair Ron Cutsinger, and Commissioners Teresa Mast, Mark Smith, and Tom Knight; County Administrator Jonathan Lewis; and Deputy Clerk Charlie Maloney

SARASOTA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD: Chair Tim Enos, and Board Members Liz Barker, Thomas Edwards, and Bridget Ziegler; Superintendent Terry Connor, and Administrative Assistant Kathy Tomkins

CITY OF NORTH PORT: Mayor Phil Stokes, and Commissioners David Duval, Barbara Langdon, and Demetrius Petrow; and City Manager Jerome Fletcher

CITY OF SARASOTA: Vice Mayor Debbie Trice, and Commissioners Jen Ahearn-Koch and Kathy Kelly Ohlrich; Interim City Manager Douglas Jeffcoat; and Commission Reporter Jamese Johnson

CITY OF VENICE: Mayor Nick Pachota and City Manager Ed Lavallee

TOWN OF LONGBOAT KEY: Mayor Ken Schneier, Commissioner Sarah Karon, Town Manager Howard Tipton, and Administrative Assistant/Records Management Specialist Stephanie Garcia

(09:00 a.m.)

1.

WELCOME/PLEDGE/INTRODUCTIONS

Sarasota County School Board Chair Tim Enos welcomed the County, City, Town Commissioners, Council Members, School Board Members, and Representatives present.

(09:02 a.m.)

2.

CONVOCATION GOALS AND AGENDA

The Board/Commissioners/Council/School Board Members reviewed the Convocation goals and agenda.

Public Presenters: Sarasota County School Board Chair Tim Enos and Sarasota County Schools Superintendent Terry Connor

(09:04 a.m.)

3.

OPEN TO THE PUBLIC - Opened and closed without comment.

(09:04 a.m.)

4.

SARASOTA COUNTY SCHOOLS

A. Interlocal Agreement

B. New School Construction Updates

C. Planning for Future Growth and Capacity

D. Impact of HB 1473 - School Safety/Security and Access

Publc Presenters: Sarasota County School Board Chair Tim Enos, Sarasota County Schools Chief Operations Officer Dr. Michael Kemp, Sarasota County Schools Executive Director of Facilities Services Jody Dumas, Sarasota County Schools Director of Long Range Planning Diane Cominotti, Sarasota County Schools Director of Construction Services Jane Dreger, Sarasota County Schools Planning Analyst Amy Anderson, Town of Longboat Key Mayor Ken Schneier, City of Sarasota Vice Mayor Debbie Trice, Sarasota County Schools Superintendent Terry Connor, Sarasota County School Board Member Tom Edwards, City of North Port City Commissioner Barbara Langdon, City of Sarasota Commissioner Jen Ahearn-Koch, and City of Sarasota Commissioner Kathy Kelly Ohlrich

Item submitted: A copy of a PowerPoint presentation

(10:28 a.m.)

5.

CITY OF NORTH PORT

Showing the first 24,000 of 67,870 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> But good morning, everybody. Today's Fri. JANUARY 19,025. My name is Robert sachem the magistrate that will be hearing today's docket I'll ask those of you in the audience it will be providing testimony this morning to please rise and allow the court to swear u n. >> In testimony, you are about >> Calling case number e n f to she o d dash 2, 4, dash 0, 1, 0 one to Sarasota County vs Peter duisburg. >> When he was captain Sir city Kathryn joosten for Sarasota County code enforcement officer and I have been sworn. For mayor investigated code enforcement case anf cod 24 0, 1, 0, 1, 2, subject properties located at 6.60 olive Street. And what Florida property Eddie's 0, 4, 9, 6, 0, 5, 0, 0, 4, 7, On JUNE 30,024 hours the side a complaint. From the Sarasota County. Sheriff's Office for debris accumulation on this property. To an inspection with the sso officer was conducted when I also met. MISTER Dole duisburg at his residence at 6.10 Marson Avenue. I expected the parcel at 6.60 all of with MISTER Duisburg to explain the property was owned by his deceased father and finds it extremely difficult to remove the debris due to extenuating health conditions based on the accumulation of the proper outdoor storage when the parcel and there's a violation was submitted for violating Sarasota County khou section 54 for 73. I like to submit composite photographs exhibit one as the initial inspection dated 6 2824 exhibit who was are inspections photos dated Aug. 27 24. 1/7/2025. And the latest one from yesterday of Jan. 16th, 2025. These composite photos were accurately depicted for the violation of the time they were taking. >> government 1, 2, 3, are admitted. >> I've had several conversations with them MISTER Duisburg and he has experience multiple setbacks including reports of burglary of the structure a 6.60. All of street and the recent multiple tropical storms and hurricane. I've had several conversations with MISTER Duisburg with the suggestion of seeking assistance through social services for other financial assistance, impossible volunteer assistance to alleviate the violation of improper outdoor storage of this parcel. This morning I spoke to MISTER Ghost Bergen he'd. Definitely want to come to this a hearing. He called and he said he had a attempted break in early this morning. And he's in the process of making a report and having. That is when the front door exchanged at this point though that if the special magistrate finds a violation existed on this parcel of the county recommends. They suggested extension of 45 days is a property owner MAY have this property poured into compliance with some assistance. >> ok so that would take him to Mar. 3rd. Correct yes, he feels in terms of your discussions with him, he feels that's adequate time to get things cleaned oath. >> If possible because we have to coordinate with other with if this could be a status hearing at that time ok it MAY be more recruitment. >> Okay that be Mar. 21th so that gives them some additional time firing. We can see worries ahead at that point. Ok case number eon effort to stop dash 2, 4, to 0, 1, 0, 1, to Sarasota County versus Peter Doocy for this involves a property located at 6, 6, 0, olive Avenue Englewood Florida p I d 0, 4, 9, 6, 0, 5, 0, 0, 4, 7, The evidence today shows that the respondent has allowed an overgrowth the grass and weeds and accumulation of improper outdoor storage. Remaining on this parcel, this is a violation of Sarasota County code, some an order that the respondent remove the improper outdoor storage or started to completely enclose buildings acute pain. The grass and weeds must be mode to a length the less than 12 inches and be maintained in that manner at all times. All this must be accomplished within 45 days which is 3/3/2025. I'm going to schedule a hearing on 3/21/2024, I've that 2014 as it says here. To determine whether or this order has been complied with. Thank you. Thank you. Calling case number tnf dash cod dash 2, 4, dash 0, 2, 4, 4, 8, Sarasota County versus Alexis properties llc. The state your name for the record set on. >> Dan Bailey, a council Alexis properties and all good morning. >> Go ahead MISTER Well your honor I'm Scott Foster psychiatry for Sarasota We have with me at that table here MISTER Kevin Mitchell who's the best team officer coming up Donna Thompson is an administration whose here as well. MR. Mitchell go through The evidence is photographs and such are the evidence as you call it. MISS Thompson will discuss some of the zoning issues that are involved in this property. There's also a 3rd My list MISTER West who is neighboring property on it who is a such a representative of of the folks who live near the property to kind of speak to the impacts that current violations had on surrounding he MAY or MAY not be called after these 2. But I'll leave the floor to MISTER Mitchell this title case. Thank you. Good morning. My name is Kevin Mitchell code enforcement officer with Sarasota County and I have to swarm. >> I am familiar with and then this chemistry case number enough the s e l d s to 4 tests 0, 2, 4, 4, 8, The subject property is located at 4, 9, to Riverview drive South and the coolness the p id number is 0, 4, 0, 5, The 0, 6, 0, 0, 4, 4, The subject properties in Sarasota County Florida. On 10/16/2024 Sarasota County received multiple complaints that the business known as all scrapped, is polling scrap metal and stocked pond on this partial. Further on 10/16/2024. I conduct uh-1 speck shun observed a significant accumulation of scrap metal being piled on this partial additionally customers were off looms scrap millet is partial causing heavy traffic flow in the neighboring streets. I would like to submit composite photographs as government exhibit number one day that dated 10/16/2024. Your honor and tops of those are in the book that has had a number one. Any objection, a motion MISTER Bailey them. A government one is admitted that. I inspected the property on 10/31/2024 and observed the continued accumulation of scrap metal on the partial false crack. In addition to customers often scrap metal. I would like to submit for the graphic evidence as government exhibit number 2 dated 10/31/2024. Again MISTER Bailey any the actions of these photos being entered into evidence. Thank you government to submit it based on these observations and amended a notice of violation was served on Nov. 12th of 2024 to the respondent alleging violations of Sarasota County code unified development code article 6 section 1, 2, 4, dash 7, 6, d 2 d I'll Wu says a lot by special exception and Sarasota County cold unified development code article 8 section one 24 dash one 43. All scrap was directed to cease and desist all operations as of NOVEMBER, 14,024 per the amended a notice of violation. A re inspections of the property. On NOVEMBER, 15,024 and thereafter from the property with the continued violation. Weekly inspections were conducted throughout the the inspection very when you say continuing is is that of the cease and desist order the activities that are activities in a cease and desist order but thank you. I would like to submit re inspection for the graphic evidence as government saying that exhibit number 3 dated 11/21/2024. Government exhibit number 4 dated 12/18/2024. And government exhibit number 5 dated Jan. 15th of 2025. Any objection MISTER Bit the government's 3, 4, 5, are admitted. Thank you. I will I would also like to submit exhibit number 6 shown aerial views of the partial dating back 4 years. An exhibit number 7 so on the website of all scrap advertise in the business as a recycling facility and its locations. And MISTER Bailey any objection judge Kaye thank government 6, 7, are made of. >> That all the evidence that you have for us was to us it was it. That money. This really have any What to them back to the property more recently. >> Uh yes, my last exhibit was Jan. 16th. Okay. Well that is that one in here. Which was sent to be number 5. And did you put genna a 15th, I'm sorry was my last exhibit. Exhibit number 5 to turn away 15th of 2025 did you. Did you notice a substantial dam edition. In the corner to give a material on the side comparing that they'd with the dates back and yes, I did that because of the stench extension cleanup since then. Yes. Thank GOD, I'm not when asked uh MISS Thompson. For the record Thompson's an administrator and I have been sworn. >> I became aware of this property in FEBRUARY when they submitted a request for an interpretation that the property could be used for outdoor storage they are and I'll so Dean district which does allow for outdoor storage an unlimited quantities. What was described in their letter that they provided him photographs of their operation that appeared to have met the conditions for the outdoor storage. So I let it was granted stating that they could use the property for outdoor Stuart. Then in OCTOBER after the 2 Hurricanes came through we begin the it cost that an undue amount of scrap had been delivered to the site and it was continue and it had increased to a very large stockpile of scrap metal. We were sympathetic that they were trying to assist with debris removal have are under the dc that is considered a waste transfer. Service which is out I'll double you unless you have 10 acres and a special exception approval by County Commission. So at that point in will hear these the lessons I could do. >> I'd say we were advised that they operating as a waste transfer facility at that point in time without this cat coming in. There's only an out and I'll that the district with the special exception and 10 acres which they don't have the 10 acres to meet that condition. At that point in time the notice was granted and they have been asked to come back into compliance of outdoor storage and demonstrate that they're meeting the conditions of outdoor storage is defined in the utc. >> What was there in light of the storms and hurricanes was or any County exception. 2 accumulating scrap metal are getting debris off the that that might implicate zoning requirements. >> No there was no, I mean and other properties have had similar issues that resulted in and could violations because there was such a a you overabundance of debris after the storm and obviously cleanup is a priority. But. You know nothing came from the board organization to the site every parcel in the concrete some sort or require a irrespective of right what the debris piles look like or anything for that matter. >> And anything the Austin and it stops him if if I MAY I'm. True to taps liberate know what they're telling her as a documents. Look at what is on what's have 8. >> Tab a is the request for scram as keen to have outdoor storage is a permitted use and I'll w joining the stricken could they operate as outdoor storage. >> And did you indicate a You base your response on the mission of 5 in that letter. The exclusively and did you learn information. Afterwards that would have changed your. Response at all. >> Not until the calls came in about the exorbitant amount of scam that has been brought in from the hurricane debris. Nigel storm coming and then tap 9 and you must have known. Yes 10 night is the letter that was written by myself that stated that they could operate outdoor storage at the facility and that's a zone in interpretation that's done under the utc process correct. We've asked for aid exhibit 8, 9 to be entered into the record a much action this year the The exhibit 8, 9, are admitted a question I just want to make sure I have the timeline right to your. >> Zoning interpretation letters dated FEBRUARY 30,024. Correct cut substantively it it does allow for the type of outdoor storage that these respondents engage in is that correct. >> It allows for what they've provided in the letter of request that they were storm facilities it has a nice clean impaired sight. There is no indication of any scrap clean around there contain shipping container say, yes. >> Has it on the on the medals were contained in shipping containers from the photos that I was provided meant it appeared so it was a nice clean site that had no indication that it operating as a place to be answered. >> And so these photographs that the company their request are or what you based your interpret an interpretive letter and it said Kerr accurate. Yes, the voters attachment. They request. >> Is there any in his own in code for this particular product or so. >> Is there any a. Limitation a him. I'm the amount of scrap that can be stored there and is it required to have it in containers. >> Outdoor storage and I'll that the district would have to be screened from public view neighboring properties in public right away. So it. It would at least be limited either the height of the building which could go to 65 feet or offense which typically is a fee with screening so there are limitations that it needs to be screened says not visible from neighboring property in a see those are laid out in your in your letter correct okay that's a post Harvey of any more questions so I I guess just to make sure everyone's on the same page on Donna. What would be the necessary steps for the responded to take to bring the property plans at this point. >> They are going to demonstrate that they're going to need to demonstrate that they're operating as outdoor storage is defined in the d c. >> ok, what would that look like. Stack of papers here. I'm trying to get we do have some microphone is today Bergin some background noise. So we had the same problem on Tue. When I was down here. >> So outdoor storage is defined as the outdoor storage of products whether for sale or as material for processes occurring on the site generally for more than 24 hours a day. This definition express they includes products on pallets and shipping containers are in crates. >> So the accumulation of debris outside of those parameters is prohibited correct. MR. Bo start any more questions not like to come. MISTER Daley give any questions of this with us the first clear indication. That you're the it was the the map for a couple things the mass of material. >> The home side that could be viewed from the street above the fence that was part of the problem. The problem has been corrected. Since then has it not. >> The mass pictures said. What's provided for code enforcement division. Still shows some scrap metal that. >> Doesn't appear to be in any kind of containers or anything yet. That pile has been taken down. >> That definition. That has to be containerized what they what they've done. They do say is they've they've compacted the metal. And the bails. Essentially or containers. And then placed on trucks and then tracked down to Fort Myers. Do you agree that the pales constitute. Containers. >> I'm not so sure I would agree that a bail as a container but. Containers like a boxer something that you put something into it. >> Which says this definition, especially in clues. Any products and pallets and shouldn't containers or in crates that doesn't can find and that does not say that there has to be in the container doesn't. >> Not specifically. It can be in. Under the definition of does not have to be. Ok and that your views because there was there is a requirement a as I understand it. That not be visible from the street. And it was understandably but if it's not just go from Street. There's that transformer back in the door storage. How's become compliant with outdoor storage. Us in terms of not being visible from the street. Down where you couldn't see it from the street transform it in your view. Recycling facility back to becoming an outdoor storage facility. >> But would have to meet the requirements that are set forth in the letter that they were provided in FEBRUARY. This is no outdoor storage should be allowed in the street yards or other as Florida the front building 9. Outdoor storage MAY be located to the side of the building and provided in his outside of the required side yard area meaning the set back area for the aisle done. And they could use any rear yard for outdoor storage purposes. Outdoor shabby scream from the view from the public right away public parking areas are adjacent residential development by an opaque take wall or a fence a minimum of 8 feet in height. And a chain link fence would be consider is on offense were inserted into the chain link fence. >> That would you agree that the. The extent to which is not compliant with the standards for outdoor storage. That would still be asked or store she just would be not in compliance with our standards and we have been put into compliance. Right they don't change then change its nature and make it a recycling facility really because it doesn't comply with the standards. Outdoor storage. >> But it's up to them to demonstrate that they don't meet the definition of waste services asa to what they're doing is not waist chains for okay. >> We are prepared to call a witness to address that issue of the time. Any for anything further. I'm not for this witness, your honor. I was going out com MISTER West. He's a a neighboring property owner who and prepare a statement to kind of speak to the affected the neighboring property owners as this is going on obviously credit to the responder for having significant reduce the amount of material there but this kind to give a flavor of what's going on in the interim terms of the perspective of someone who's got a live there could not could you give me a little sort of map as to what had a is this a homeowners are during just one neighborhood to neighborhood. Jason neighborhood. Yeah and is it. I mean did what give me a little geography so MISTER Wess if you go down Riverview drive South. The entrance of false craft is on Riverview drive k. MR. S property is the first property Street. So if you go out the entrance you'll see House waycross another lot that his house ice yet so he's. >> What's so. There's a street right after the break when you passed the entrance of Oscar at there's a street you make a right and his house is the first House on Fri. And are there other houses. Yes, yes are also communicates a subdivision basically yes, okay. And I'll ask him to come for now, thank you believe he's been smart. I'm not even my chair. I have reviewed the statement ahead of time so should I take a few. You like to use this Mike this good morning Sir could you state your name for the records but as the West and charitable. Thank you and could use a state your address for the record. >> Seven-thirty Mount Street ok I lives. So that you might recall nearly 3 years now. I'm humbled to have the option to just big day on behalf of my neighbors, families and friends. All of you know community this illegal scrap yard that had a profound impact on neighborhoods. I didn't buy that is disrupt the lives. They just safety at averting a quality of life. When you put just a home we understood the Jason lamb was owned for industry like was it. We researched what this entailed who 7 not call the windows down we more of that noise levels on activity. We feel confident enough cision to make becomes a home and raise a family. However of the hurricane note and a community faced unprecedented challenges not from storm damage from the illegal operation of a lot of skills industrial struck out. Cleanup efforts off the hurricane were struck by scrapbooking roads speeding for residential streets and using private in ways that the driveways to right this jet does it say to our children and delay to central services like mental every. During the storm's aftermath. We often have to drive hundreds of yards on the wrong side of the road else like wolves to get around the procession of waiting scrap was just to reach jobs. This hurricane season, we're directly affected by 3 hurricanes in a very short period of time. It's a legal scrapyard open a 3rd. We then have 2 or 3 more Hurricanes threats, but luckily didn't last had one of the affected is for you to break the storm with high winds the dangerously high matchup scrap would decimate the homes and properties as well as like the trial. Increasing damage raising insurance premiums. This cause significantly heightened stress and concern during these polls storms a hurricane to vote in our area on not. Except anymore their routine. The part of a life and the law should be seen as a special substance. Since crept up again over actions, we've enjoyed relentless noise. 6 days a week from sunrise to sunset the constant battering. Crunching dragging and dropping uncharted made it impossible to join Isis bases really when does a during the cooler months. Somebody was from home these dust or losses from what one calls the most focusing much of its treaty difficult when having times of move the vibrations also strongly road loss where my captains my name is most now one of my neighbors must now travel to his office in Sarasota take important corporate schools, Jude law knows destruction. He's bears. Sunday's of the day we fight rest by from the noise and even then exciting for the next weak link is the struggles of ration having to do significant health and environmental risks, the racy kinds of orange dust blowing off the pile from a insulation as it is and clean medal. A cover of properties have post be releasing has been tariffs and yet the industrial Greg Craig unload trail start 3 high River refrigerators and toss them into exile, potentially releasing Freon gas. It's the environment. These actions leamy fearful of the cost just by finding MAY be breathing from being in such close proximity. Pulling their describe polls, drug nails and screws all roads leading to numerous lot to us. Safety has vehicles and pedestrians. We lost count of how many last my neighborhood has experienced just because of this multiple times per family. Well Kim in many circumstances. The script has turned a quiet neighborhood into a dangerous and chaotic environment. Scrap is ready go streets and driveways forcing residents to take long go to the rigs overtaxed a flat eyes. Children over for the feel safe play outside. We got a Lima children the school Anymore so they don't have to will the scrubland payments opposed to gays awaiting scraps a neighborhood kids still must will the goal that why stay. With a serious cause for concern of for the children's safety. They sufficiently size love with it because the way safely away for is that there is no have such an issue. One neighbor had spent hours directing traffic to keep very successful. And others had of ripples of a truck crossing from scrap was going on to storm damage from pc they can to both grab all of it. What are neighbor's car co far his driveway. 2 fire trucks, one ambulance and for sheriff's suvs but thankfully able to act quickly respond because it was the often the script. It was closed. Such access would know to be likely all mere possible jury script, you know as you look in that congestion danger he lives of the community. The script has diminished a company's value. Pro Cuba is affecting plummeted making homes and sent to the head sellable because no one wants to live next we feel will now track it, I'm being held hostage by this company. Residents being judged for a living next to a junkyard and friends are reluctant to visit you look at dishes, the roads and the number of flat tires they heard by the neighborhood experiencing. Longtime residents, including a 35 year neighbor. He's recovering from multiple strokes and other medical missions report emotional agitation and the inability to enjoy the peace of their lives. This is not a storage facility. This is a collection facility. The destruction caused by this illegal scrap yard of the danger it poses to our community and the school's what such operation should not be permitted on him and one 0.3 4 make a lot. A neighbor is that your neighbors. Well we

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Convocation of Governments - Audio only — Minutes
  • Convocation of Governments - Audio only — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e849576a92099278c8a63375458f3a34. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record