POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners

Wednesday, February 18, 2026 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 249,757 stored characters

>> test. >>. >>chair: quiet in chambers we can start our meeting on clerk please goal. >>commissioner bastien: here. >>commissioner bermudez: >>commissioner cohen higgins: present. >>senator garcia: >>commissioner gilbert: >>commissioner gonzalez: >>commissioner lopez: erman rodriguez, we have 12 members present, we have a quorum. >>chair: everyone please stand. Good morning everybody. We are honored to be in this chamber in this room together and I want to honor commissioner gnzalez with the opportunity and lead us in prayer, I wanted to declare this first as we prayed which is micah chapter 6 verse eight, it says people the lord has told you to do what is good to require you to do justice what is right to love mercy and walk humbly with GOD. That's will what we are believing for so if you bow your heads with me we give thanks to jesus for this day you've given us, a new day to put our hands on the plow and that that what you've called us to and I thank you for every commissioner, every city official lord the opportunity to serve and I thank you for the districts we represent, the counties we represent GOD would you grant favor this morning over that project, over all the things we are leading the initiatives, that we are your steward and thank you for every family representative for the city of miami we break it looks like heaven so father would you lead us, rental strategy and supernatural favor to do everything you've called us to do, MAY we walk humbly before you in the name of jesus, we pray amen. Class I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under GOD indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >>chair: you MAY be seated. We understand. It's the intent. All right. >>commissioner gilbert: MR. CHAIRMAN, MAY I give a point of information. >>chair: it's the first day of lent, go ahead. >>commissioner gilbert: is the first day of lent and GOD doesn't want me to be lukewarm so I want to be consistent, I make a motion to amend the prayer to have all of miami county look like heaven and not just the city of miami. GOD bless the city of miami and no place else exactly. >>chair: we understand what the pastor meant, thank you. Thank you for your prayer. Commissioner colin higgins, which like to be recognized for a moment of silence. Commissioner. At this time or a later time. >>commissioner cohen higgins: I appreciate you recognizing me to gve a moment of silence for a community leader we lost very recently in MISS Thelma gibson. Many of us knew her and knew her very well. She did incredible things for our community for many years so I wanted to honor her and recognized her service to our community if you will all please join me in a moment of silence in honor of our late thelma gibson. >>chair: colleagues please join commissioner cohen higgins in a moment of silence in recognition. >>commissioner cohen higgins: thank you MR. Chair. >>chair: commissioner regalado you are recognized for another moment of silence. >>commissioner regalado: just to say something, obviously we can talk about thelma but thelma was the city of miami commissioner appointed during the vacancy, the first woman to serve on the city of miami commission so GOD bless the city of miami and thelma gibson. >>commissioner gilbert: MR. CHAIRMAN. >>chair: commissioner bastien. >>commissioner bastien: thank you MR. Chair, first I'd like to thank every commissioner colleen who called me while I was under the weather, thank you and I also would like to say a few words about thelma gibson, this is someone who I've had long years, mny years of collaboration when I worked at jackson 18 years when I was a board member. Ova health foundation of south florida. She represents power and MR. Chair I like to have a point of privilege to welcome city COUNCILWOMAN Ervin who is visiting us today, stand up and be recognized. >> vice CHAIRMAN You are recognized for a moment of silence. >> we also lost another great national leader in jesse jackson who passed away at this moment we would like to take a moment of silence to recognize him for all the work you've done. >>chair: stand again and join our vice CHAIRMAN In a moment of silence for jesse jackson. All right. Commissioner steinberg and then commissioner gilbert, you are recognized. >> wanted to make a quick announcement this morning downstairs are miami-dade fire rescue is down there for an awareness and wellness check for the month of FEBRUARY. We really want to make sure people are paying attention to heart health. They're going to be performing oxygen pulse checks, blood pressure, glucose checks. Any sort of mitigation medication mitigation, general wellness referral services and health information booth downstairs. I know we have a full house today so take advantage. >>chair: commissioner gilbert you are recognized. >>commissioner gilbert: I would like to offer just a few words about both jesse jackson and thelma gibson because in so many ways we lost people for giants. Jesse jackson of course nationally and locally always offering the work that would actually bring us together and not break us apart and thelma gibson one of the true pioneers of leadership in south florida. I have the opportunity to spend a lot of time with MS. Gibson and I went to law school with her grandson. I know commissioner cohen higgins was honored at the thelma gibson awards this past year but that honor came in the reason why the award is named after her is because of the extraordinary kindness was, the vision she had, the strength that she showed, who she was as a person speaks about the greatness of who we are as miami-dade county. So a lot of folks won't necessarily know, but I believe she's in the women's hall o fame here. She's in the woman's hall of fame and you wouldn't necessarily know her name but when you think about people who read the bedrock, the foundation of what miami-dade county could end would become she's definitely one of them and her family is definitely in my prayers. >> with that MADAM Attorney can we go straight into item 281. >> the mayor's veto and the veto message and that's before the board. Impacts us if I MAY have been present time. >>. >>chair: I'm happy to recognize you first, the layer and I requested to speak on it and I'm happy to grant that. I'll go ahead and recognize MADAM Mayor, you are recognized for a brief comment. >>mayor cava: thank you chair and to the commissioners, today we are deciding not just on one application, we are deciding on something much bigger, we are talking about the future of our county and long-standing policies we have developed here that protect our water, neighborhoods and our future and that is why I called upon you to sustain my veto and stand by the community in protecting miami-dade. The urban development boundary exists for a reason and it has served us very well. We have the most coverage economy, we've been aggressively addressing our housing needs, we have been concerned about following the guidance from the community development master plan and urban development boundary line to not unfairly burden our taxpayers with infrastructure for building outside of the protected area and sensitive areas, of course it protects us from sprawl and it supports smarter more resilient development, it doesn't stop development, it just provides guidance on what sort of development is necessary and important for our county. It protects our agricultural account economy, still number two and it protects the wetlands. It safeguards our drinking water because our water flows directly from the aquifer exactly in these areas and it also reduces fooding in our community so right now we are under a water shortage warning. I hope you know and that alone should give us pause. The disdain aquifer is the source of our drinking water and the wetlands are not obstacles to development, they are infrastructure and natural infrastructure protects us, they filter our water, recharge the aquifer and they protect us during heavy rains and storms. So this veto was not issued lightly. You know I've provided very few vetoes during my term as mayor and I understand the importance of economic growth and we have been growing successfully with our economy. We are in fact the place everybody wants to be for their companies and to live so I understand the need for housing and jobs and we have been responsible in dealing with those issues and have been very successful growth must be responsible. It cannot be unbridled so over the past two weeks we've seen a clear growing momentum for sustaining this veto across the county, three cities already passed formal resolution supporting the veto two more have resolutions tonight. Several editorials have urged sustaining the veto and the number of respected environmental organizations including several with us today have joined us along with business leaders so I'm asking you to listen to the people you represent. Read the editorials, consider the resolutions passed by cities that are being considered, take note of the voices across the business community. Are filled they are gone. This is an opportunity to further protect our environment, safeguard taxpayer dollars and plan responsibly for the future. We have a udp for a reason. I remain ready to work with this board and our community to ensure we can continue to grow responsibly. Thank you MR. Cair. >>chair: with that as I stated I will recognize commissioner bermudez. >>commissioner bermudez: I promise to behave because it's lent and I go to mass at five. I made that commitment to my staff because they want me to give up certain things but I do have a motion the motion. >> you're not giving up on the motion. Amendments 26 for kelly tractor application JANUARY 22 2026. I make this motion because applicant wants to comply with the points the mayor brought up on her message which she reiterated. The applicant will be proffering additional on-site wetlands preservation as well as additional preservation on the north trail basin that can only be done at the meeting with the cmp application will be heard again hopefully then come before us. So I think there's some people from the kelly tractor team. Don't know if you want to hear from them but I think that's a solution that allows applicant and you see the number of people employed by kelly tractor and the many more and I think this is a solid solution to allow the staff and administration in particular staff to deal with the isues that some of my colleagues brought up so eloquently including commissioner regalado about the wetlands mitigation. So that's my motion and I know that they're here if you want to ask questions of them. And if not ask questions of me. >> we have a motion, a second by the vice chair. Any discussion on the, and just I'm sure you want to discuss but I was wondering who all the people work, mostly in the blue shirts but by raise of hand who is here deciding on kelly tractor I suppose. Got it, I was unsure what it was. I saw you guys walking through. I was like what is going on. But thank you for joining us today and with that you are recognized. >>commissioner gilbert: thank you MR. CHAIRMAN and commissioner, I'll second the motion. Although what you want to do I'll support it. I do have hesitancy and let me preface this by saying I understand it's ash wednesday, you should understand I'm not catholic. I didn't give up anything. So I gave up nothing today. I need everybody to be clear about that. >>chair: sounds like he's choosing violence. >>commissioner gilbert: I wasn't going to but sometimes things are better left unsaid because I didn't plan on speaking on this item I just need to say that. The reason why is because this is the same administration that proposed a waste to energy facility outside the udp. They proposed it when I asked based on the principle they could do it because it was a government facility. And I can appreciate that, that's what the law allows. It also allows a text amendment but if your concern is the actual environment, the fact that you can do something is not matter whether you should do something. So this is the administration that recommended we build a waste-to-energy facility. Outside the udp and I didn't get any emails from environmental groups saying it's bad for the environment. Because the government was doing it. So now somebody's talking about putting something less intrusive and less burdensome on the environment outside the udp now there's this consternation. Think that we owe it to people to be consistent. So actually measure the effect, see if we been mitigated and move past it solely to the extent this motion be considered allows us to mitigate any harm to the environment I'm supportive of it but I would have been supportive of that done that in the zoning item anyway when it had to come back before us. I would have done that then. So I think that we have this way sometimes of when people are really watching and there's a big issue that we get real convenience. Like, this is real convenient and I appreciate we are the most recovered economy since mcghee, broward and palm beach show, cool but it wasn't put in place to protect the environment, it was put in place to be a confinement because we didn't have the ability to stretch our resources and infrastructure out that far. We've made it something it isn't and I can be comfortable without also but I need us to be more consistent. If we are going to say this is the rule that we are not going to allow things like text amendments, because this text amendment would allow us to function and expand without actually having a fight. Then I think the administration should bind themselves by that same principle and not recommend things outside the udp. Just because they can. Because just because they could kelly tractor could. And we had the capacity to think about overwriting vetoes, the fundamental question I asked myself is was the information I am being presented that I did not have prior to my vote. So there are folks who didn't support this application and I respect that, they didn't support the application based on the information that they had, based on information I had previously. When this has been before us a bunch of times before we sent it to tallahassee I didn't hear any of these concerns from the administration. The first time this has been before us. So because now the cameras are rolling and that harold is writing and you can get people to comment on social media posts and send emails, now it's supposed to change fundamentally how I deliver it. and I'm okay if it's a body or even as administration sometimes we do things consistent, I can't be inconsistent in that way. I have a deliberative process and I'm not hearing anything, I yield. >> I feel far be it from me of the guy who says with things and I agree there have been other applications near this property that were text amendments and nothing popped up. I've already said my say on this application and I'm supportive of it. I respect the mayor's position but I would vote like you would vote on the situation. We have all sorts of facilities outside the udp. Which from cemeteries to jails etc. So that's a debate for another day. There is no udp at broward or palm beach. A lot of the people that spoke on this item last time don't even live in miami-dade county much less district 12 however and I understand commissioner gilbert's point of view and share a lot of his opinions. Despite the fact that we have different religions but having said that, the important thing is this gives an opportunity for the applicant kelly tractor to work with staff to correct some of the concerns our colleagues at that's the only reason why I'm doing it. But I share your opinion. You know, it's okay, nobody probably has spoken as clearly on some of these things as I have but I think and I do think our economy is better for many different reasons, certainly not be urban development boundary that has nothing to do with improving our economy rehab so while I am about protecting the environment I'm also about jobs. So I shared your sentiments on that also. This motion is being done to give the applicant and staff an opportunity to take care of some of our colleagues concerns. That's the only reason I'm doing this and it's important and kelly tractor is here in case you want to ask them any questions MR. Chair but it's as simple as that and some of you know I will point out colleagues MAY have concerns and I want to make sure they are at least looked into. >>chair: commissioner gilbert I wanted to state I don't think you can yield to another commissioner. >>commissioner gilbert: he started talking. >>chair: I am okay with it, just wanted to make it clear that you don't yield to other commissioners. >>commissioner gilbert: it's ash wednesday, cut me a break. >>chair: I did not interrupt. Now you're catholic. >>commissioner gilbert: yesterday was fat tuesday so you all ate and drank a lot? I will end with this, where going to reconsider this, the motion is successful we will reconsider it and they will work with staff you are not like nostradamus but I have a prediction. They're going to work with staff and they're going to capitulate and concede to a bunch of points, all the remediation stuff and we will be back here because staff is not going to support this item one of the issues I often have is when we negotiate with folks whether it's each other or the administration, if we negotiate something that means we are negotiating for us to come into court. Going to be an accord. So we will be back on the stove in a month. I don't think substantively the administration's position will change because if they're saying it's otside of the udp as the primary reason is not going to be inside the udp in a month. It's not going to be inside the udp in a month. Going to concede some stuff, they're going to say it's better. But then they're going to say it's still outside the udp. And we're going to take this vote, thank you MR. CHAIRMAN. >> commissioner lopez yu are recognized. >>. >>commissioner lopez: as I read the vtol letter there are two issues I see that are of consequence to the veto, one of course is that mitigation of the wetlands and honestly that could probably be resolved. What I'm trying to understand is the issue with text amended versus a udp application. So maybe if I MAY I'd like to CHAIRMAN To explain because when we say we reconsider that leads me to believe the mayor could reconsider the text amendment and the wetlands mitigation and I want to be clear about what the issue was with the text amendment versus the udp. >> you are recognized for her response. >>mayor cava: thank you for the chair and commissioner lopez, exactly. Wetlands obviously there were concessions made. This board did not at the last hearing more concessions could be made that would be preferable. At the end of the day and to commissioner gilbert's point, to commissioner gilbert's point it isn't only this is outside the udp, obviously there are other things that get developed outside the udp, defendant didn't follow the proper process to allow us to do the full valuation because of the text amendment. And text amendments have historically been brought forward to refine our policies. When you have a full application or have a joint zoning application you say exactly what's ging to happen and then you can discuss those exact impacts. You also established need which there wasn't a cost to establish, this is a great company. Nothing that I have said or whatever say is against the company itself which is doing well. That's good for all of us. It's a great company but they have not because they used the text amendment process they've not been able to establish why it was necessary for them to go outside the udp to build this riff that is really the problem of the process and I know it would be better and I hope this commission will look to further refine what is appropriate through a text amendment. But I can assure you that it was never intended to facilitate site-specific urban development outside the udp. So we are not able to evaluate fully that proposal in its current form. >> so MADAME Mayor I guess lynn trying to get at is given that, I'm trying to figure out why and maybe there's confusion as to how you can use the text amended. It sounds like it's clear that you use the udp application process when it's site-specific but when you're trying to generally speaking I want to understand what you're saying, when you're speaking about refining the cmp process or what we have in code, that's when you use a text amendment so is that correct? >> through the chair of the way it has been used but it isn't clearly defined. So it's, I want to say it opens the door pandora's box because basically it allows other proposals to come through that are not properly vetted by using this text amendment process. That is why it was not recommended, will we consider what might be offered, of course we will consider, is not dead on arival I do want to say that but it does raise grave concerns to approach a project of this magnitude to a text amendment rather than a full udp application. >>commissioner gilbert: I want to point out you said consider what's coming and just as a function of grammar that invalidates everything in the preceding clause. It's a subtle thing that happens in language but it works most times. I need to know is there an actual world this comes via a text amendment. That the administration would support it as a text amendment because if it's not then let's let them start the process all over and let's kill it today. Kill it today, if it's not but time has value also. Time has value so if this administration is not going to support these types of applications being text amendments, till the board now. Tell them now so that we can all vote our conscience and our intellect now. And one way just move forward but I don't want in a month for us to come back and say yes, they did a lot of good stuff. But it's still a text amendment and I don't want to set the precedent because what I'm hearing you say is it's a valid point. Point. Maybe we should change the process. Change the process that. But your point fundamentally is that you don't want the functional expansion of a udp based on very specific parcels by other text amendment process. That is the basic point. That point cannot be remedied in their negotiations. >>mayor cava: I appreciate additional concessions are being offered. I have not presented with those, nobody has approached me to say this is what we are offering in separation of the points you raised. I just like you need to consider what is being proffered. We're talking a month. This is the project that would be over a decade. This is not a short-term project. Appropriate and valid to allow me ad the community and concerned citizens and businesspeople and everybody to have a chance to see what is being proffered. That being said text amendment isn't the proper vehicle, does that mean I would never support it? It doesn't necessarily mean that as long as we understand we do need to move with this process. >>commissioner gilbert: I would stand by the mayor is taking a principled stance, I don't disagree necessarily but I don't think this is going to remedy it. MISS Regalado has ideas but none of those translate to a udp application. So I tink we will be back here. We don't need to spend a lot of time, do whatever you want, let's just do it quickly. >>chair: commissioner regalado you are recognized. >>commissioner regalado: I think there's a series of complexities. I agree regarding the text amendment, it is a new vehicle, we've only used the txt amendment once in the last few years and we do need to consider what are the limitations of the text amendment so that is something we need to grapple with separate and apart from this application. That being said as I pointed out when this application came before us one of the issues is the wetlands being impacted in this text amendment were part of a covenant of a prior udp application so they were wetlands proffered, mitigated, restored and protected from another application. That is different than other things that have come before us. There will be a wetland mitigation because of what is being poposed. That is a separate conversation so there's two different things happening and I think there is confusion as to that. And there is a prioritization based on the quality and placement of those wetlands which is what I tried to convey when this was before us. I think staff, I disagree with commissioner gilbert, staff was making reasonable requests regarding the prior mitigation their request was simple. Covenant was made and because that covenant can be broken, just because you can do something doesn't mean you should. Just because that covenant can be broken doesn't mean we should break that covenant especially since those wetlands have been restored and protected. all that being said I will say I don't think a month is enough time. If that's the will of the board then staff will work with that but I don't think that gives us enough time to consider some of the factors. To the mayor's point there is a series of steps that were not done because this was a text amendment and not a full application. I think the board would feel more comfortable with plans that were more like the udb application then a text amendment and that is possible. Again we have not really defined what a text amendment is, we just use it for parking in this particular area and it's for us to determine what that process is for the text amendment so we could input these things into the text amendment process. I don't think you necessarily throw everything out. But I don't think a month will be enough time for staff to be able to analyze all the issues that have been brought up specifically regarding the wetlands and poviding solutions for the current wetlands that are protected and then the potential litigation. >>chair: on that comment and I'll recognized commissioner bermudez in a second. I don't need specifics that I want to make sure I have never lied to and I don't think I am but based on something you said I understand the reason this applicant brought this application in this fashion was because they were told to add the direction of the administration. And I'm seeing the nodding of lawyers, the applicants and chris kelly himself. It is wild to me that this is what they heard from the administration, I don't need to go into the specifics. Can't imagine they are all nodding their heads and just lying in a public setting. I can't imagine that's the case so I don't disagree with what you're saying, I don't think they disagree but they were guided and spent countless dollars on proffering it in this fashion per the direction they received speaking with the admin's ration. So but again, if we are considering this they can correct it and come back and hopefully approve, it's just overall a little bit of a waste of our time but it's in the spirit of doing the right thing. And bettering it, I understand. Commissioner brmudez. >>commissioner bermudez: you brought up a very important point. You are correct, this was transmitted to the state, nobody said anything about it at that time. I guess if we were going to talk about text amendments etc. The time we should have been talking about it back then so all I'm trying to do is give and the administration an opportunity and I don't think it should be more than a month because everybody knows what I think about the urban development boundary and now I'm going to double down because it's ued by, it's used whenever it is, I won't even say appropriate. I agree, it's used loosely which is why we've got to revisit it and I've said over and over to the administration, I've said it to the environmentalists that are here by the way get paid to do this and I said it to developers. Everybody should sit in the room and it's why we have moved this line in 50 years because when it was created people, some that were sitting here a lot down with us, now we're not going to touch something that should be revisited that when it was created it was created to be revisited and it's never going to do it application by application so that's my two cents there three of but the reason why this motion for reconsideration is proffered is because I believe there might be an opportunity for the ministration to work with this applicant and you are honey on the applicant is fine with it. You are 100% correct, 100% correct. This was sent to tallahassee, money was spent, came back to us to the state and by the way I'm not going to talk about it because I said my say and miccosukee support, that's not even the issue. Because if we want to have that fight I'll amend my motion and change it to something else but at this point I am cognizant commissioner gilbert has touched on a lot of points but one month to give the administration an opportunity to sit down and the applicant and see if some of these concerns can be resolved, i don't want it to be deferred forever so we can talk about wetlands and nausea. We're talking about this particular veto and this application. So you know, my motion is to comments one to be back in front of us probably at that point we will have to make a decision and you know, it MAY or MAY take the same position and if the mayor does take the same position I think we all know we have to do at least I know what I'm going to do. I think I know what I have to do today and what I would do a month from now. And that would trigger for me. That would trigger something I've been asking for for a very long time which is let's look at things we should have looked at that prior commissions should have looked at the past 50 years because it was never meant to be permanent. It never ever. That's why paul leach doesn't have one so I will still, there was a second, I'm going to stick to my motion as it exists. But obviously I'd like to hear from my colleagues. >>chair: I will recognize you for a second and they will have questions so that way you address this but to the attorneys quickly as one of my colleagues says, on with commissioner bermudez bringing this back sooner rather than later but what are our time frames, I understand there's timelines we have to adhere to or else what happens with the application? What happens, how much time friend do we have. >> our recommendation would be perhaps there are some extensions that would need to be agreed two for purposes of state statute but if this item is ultimately reconsidered, it would have to be re-noticed and readvertised in the media at least 10 days notice so we need christian for purposes of advertisement but 10 days is the requisite notice. This back here in a month? >> if that's the board's desire, your next cdmp meeting is MARCH 19. >>chair: commissioner bastien you are recognized. >>commissioner bastien: thank you MR. Chair. I've been listening to all of you and MADAME Mayor I did read your memo and I understand most of your concerns. My question to you is your position regarding the motion on the floor. Would that give you an opportunity to discuss and find ground for some of your concerns. >>chair: I know you were raising your hand. >>mayor cava: through the chair thank you commissioner bastien for your question first I want to be clear, it was not recommended that the applicant use a text amendment. I was laid out in the transmittal memo to tallahassee. In fact it was rcommended denial and that there was a problem telling as a text amendment so that was sealed to this board and to the state. We have sought to discover who might have possibly indicated that. We are not able to discover anyone who specifically recommended this process so I want to be clear. Our staff are very collaborative, I talked with applicants, they talk about possibilities, they talk about different approaches but as far as we can discover nobody recommended it and in fact officially in the record we opposed it as a text amendment. Secondly I want to say the urban development boundary is not forever. It's a line that can be moved, that's what we are going through right now. You're looking, we already have urban expansion areas identified and there's an administrative need for growth, not just conveniently but there has to be an established need for growth, that's why we have these designated areas fom the last cycle seven years ago, we are in a new cycle and all these issues are to be considered, housing needs, transportation needs and as commissioner gilbert said a big reason for the urban development boundary was to protect the taxpayers having to pay for infrastructure outside of the core urban area which has served us very well yet it only increases sprawl. As to the specifics of whether I would be supportive of the motion for reconsideration of course prefer you wuld sustain my veto, that is why I vetoed so that you could take into consideration all of these concerns and look at it not specific to one application of the overall precedent being set by the approach to wetlands, the approach to the use of the text amendment. It's necessary we be clear in the future about the appropriateness of the text amendment but as commissioner regalado said this is not the usual process, this is way outside the ordinary so please consider to sustain my veto. If instead the board chooses to go forward with reconsideration of course the staff will meet with the applicant, the applicant could not only bring forward additional mitigation of wetlands, the applicant could forward a site plan and the staff could look at it in terms of establishment of whether there is a need. There's a new cycle that comes along later for the application but nothing would preclude the applicant from bringing forward everything that would make this application worthy of approval by the administration. >>chair: I have commissioner lopez. Commissioner had a question. >>commissioner lopez: my question is as we talk about the udb application process we said it will take a long time. Is there any expedited review under a udb application given all we know about this project so in other words could get they go through eight udb process quickly that would allow the administration to do exactly what the veto letter asked, would have done which is the site plan and analysis, I don't know the answer that might be a county attorney's question. >>mayor cava: if I could answer through the chair. As I said nothing prevents this applicant from coming forward with much more information that would be inclusive of the udb application, how quickly they could do that I don't know. That would require real thought and study by our staff but I want to say this, I don't stand on the form. I am here for the good of our community. The udb is a protective vehicle but if we can resolve these issues we will resolve them. >>chair: I've got commissioner cohen higgins unspoken. >>commissioner cohen higgins: thank you MR. Chair. Thank you to everyone in the audience who drove or walked upstairs and made it here for this hearing. As I'm listening closely to the conversation something is standing out to me because what we can say because we are in chamber of those that are watching cannot see in the discussion with our CHAIRMAN Regarding whether or not the applicant was instructed to do this by a text amendment. The applicant's sitting in the audience made it rather clear to us as board members that is what they were told so MR. CHAIRMAN I'd like to hear from the applicant directly because that is instructive to me. Similar to when this application came before us I had concern regarding precedent because there was some distinction between whether you needed seven votes or whether you needed nine votes and that was important to me because I'm always concerned about the message we're sending to not only our business community but everybody coming before this board. There needs to be a level of predictability based on the decisions we make as a body to move forward. There are dollars attached to this, jobs attached to this, there are peoples ability to feed their families attached to this so for me it is extremely of great import for me to know from your perspective whether you were instructed to bring this application in the form it was brought. I.E. The text amendment. >>chair: you are recognized to respond and introduce yourself. >> alexandra with offices at 701 bickell avenue, yes we've been instructed since we file this application 2023 to proceed with a text amendment. At no point were we advised to change the application to a udb extension, we looked at it and it was never advised to proceed and thus we kept it as a text amendment. We work with staff in good faith, if the direction was to go with an extension we would have done so. >>commissioner cohen higgins: this is a huge disconnect because this was three years ago and I know how these applications work because I've sent almost 6 years and I know how these applications work and the attorney before us articulated how these applications come, they work with the ministration, there's feedback, lots of information shared back and forth they take that information and adjust accordingly so help me square what was articulated on the microphone with what was previously represented, I.E. W never instructed them to travel under this lane, I.E. Text amendment, how is the text amendment now a huge problem when they were instructed in 2023 to bring this by text amendment, I need to understand that in the most clear and concise terms. >> you are recognized for a response. >> commissioner, staff we are able to identify has never told anyone they should do this through a text amendment. I personally was at a meeting at kelly tractor a year ago reviewing this project and that discussion didn't happen, we never discussed whether it would be a text amendment or not. The first time the item was transmitted the late mayor's letter both addressed to this commission in the state that she did not recommend it's because of that. We recently heard what your hearing today that that is what staff said. I went on my own quest through department directors assistant directors, all the people that said did anyone say this and I'm unable to find a soul that says they said it. >> MR. Chair. I MAY have an answer for that. >>commissioner bermudez: with all due respect to MR. Coley the urban expansion area, this is within the area. We had another text amendment in that area. So I'm not saying he hasn't been able to find somebody. Not at all. It's possible he's right. Maybe the person is not there anymore, I don't know but the mayor mentioned we've been looking at the urban expansion areas, there was another application in this urban expansion area. It's in the urban expansion area and I'm going to add something else. At one point we were able to consider you building water and sewer. And water and sewer facility in this parcel. We were going to try to I don't want to use the eminent domain word but I just want to be, let's be intellectually honest. Nobody spends this much money unless somebody tells them somebody else did it, you're in the urban expansion area which the mayor admits already we are looking at moving the line in the urban expansion area. It's about time they do it because it appears any time there's an election or any time there's some noise or any time they get all these emails from people in broward and other places that don't have urban expansion everybody all of a sudden whips out the udb. This parcel is in the urban expansion area and the only reason I'm bringing that up is because I could be wrong, this is a supposition, if it's in the urban expansion area I could say it's staff says it's happened before. We will take a look, if not impossible so I don't know if the person is there, I'm not questioning MR. Coley. i believe he always says he tries to say the truth most of the time. And maybe he just didn't find the person and that's all that happened, maybe he looked and that person is no longer working at the department so I want to be clear, it is in the urban expansion area. I doubt the applicant would have brought this application. Double down and I know chief coley would be honest and truthful all the time to the best I know so thank you for that but perhaps there might even be somebody the mayor doesn't know or you didn't. >>commissioner bermudez: I mean honest on the football, commissioner gilbert you've been waiting. >>commissioner gilbert: I know chief coley to be honest, the fact that he's an alabama fan confuses me because he makes statements is the greatest coach everywhere which everyone knows he wasn't but it's fine. I think commissioner bermudez supposition is probably in line with what actually happened. And let me just suggest something, a application is broader than a text amendment. So if I were sitting in the administration's position and I did not want rampant development in the udb, I would say hey, this is in the urban expansion area and we've done a text amendment over here before. We think this is a good project. So we can't really tell you anything but maybe I text amendment is better. That's probably how the conversation went with the person they can't find. I think that's probably how the conversation went. A couple of things, I know referred from the administration that the udb is not forever. I didn't know that because I thought the mantra was we hold the line. Which doesn't seem to in fact be forever. So all I just need to know is there's going to be an honest deliberation because the mayor's asking us to sustain her veto. That's what she wants us to do. And I'm comfortable with reconsidering this. But if the mayor insists on a veto vote, I'm okay with giving her own veto vote but I will not vote to sustain the veto based on this logic. Because I think that again consistency matters. This is the same administration that was going to build a waste-to-energy campus outside the udb. That was their suggestion, not ours. We are the people who took it off the table so when you talk about folks who protected the udb, that would have been the largest expansion of the udb contemplated in a while. We took that up so I get everyone will say if the environments, no, that's not it at all but I think if there's a way we can protect the environment and create jobs and help our economy why wouldn't we do that? So I think that balance has to be made and I'm comfortable moving forward however you want to move forward but we need to be consistent and commissioner I think you are correct. Either someone is if they're not lying the chief offered a qualified statement and he said he couldn't find the person. That doesn't mean the person doesn't exist. That just means he couldn't find the person who said it. They could still be here not admitting to it because if I were someone working in a cubicle right now and I admitted I told them to do this text amendment, there's certainty, they would be like man, nobody's going to agree to this because they're talking about it at a county commission meeting, no one is going to admit to telling them a text amendment, how will you get them to admit to that? It's pretty clear though they didn't go down this road, I'm just going to spend these thousands of dollars just because. That didn't happen MR. CHAIRMAN. >>chair: I have a response from the mayor and commissioner you are recognized for a follow-up. >>mayor cava: I'm going to ask chief coley to read from you the transmission language concerns about the text amendment and it was transmitted with this concern to correct the record. >> what's important is it was originally transmitted without recommendation and might have been submitted it was transmitted denial, it was without recommendation but did identify the text amendment as a problem and the second time it came to you all we recommended denial based on it so you first had a no recommendation then a denial but both times it was identified in a text amendment. >>mayor cava: there is a difference between private enterprise and compelling public purpose. To the point that is being made about airport west which after all was an airport, it was not pristine wetlands, it was an airport and also would be subject to environmental review so all of any one is subject to environmental review. >> chief, do you want to read that into the record or no? >> you got paragraph.5 in your item if you want to see the entire context. If you don't want lay boreas reading. >>chair: read the relevant portion. >>chair: so I guess you're correcting the record from the prior statement saying it was submitted with denial to transmit it neutrally? >> originally it was transmitted without a recommendation. >>mayor cava: but with the language. >> that was not recommended, commissioner gilbert. >> with the language you passed to be read. >> it says proposed expansion must demonstrate a need exists for additional urban areas as with city policy proposed introduction urban land use and open category application denial without adherence to those policies. >>chair: okay, commissioner gilbert. >>commissioner gilbert: sometimes you let people speak long enough to prove your point. Respectfully when you said there's a difference between compelling governmental use and private industry, there is. Not to invasive species. Not to all issues you list as environmental concerns. The environment doesn't say it's kelly tractor or dade county poisoning the water if it's going to poison the water. But environment is not judging who's doing it, the environment is reacting to the fact it is being done. My point initially was for the purposes of consistency I find it problematic that as a county we would endorse building a waste-to-energy facility outside the udb but then say this was a problem. I understand fundamentally the difference between how we act, we ask for the betterment of the 3 million people who benefit, the argument you made was based on hurting the environment. So if you're hurting the environment whether it's us doing it or then doing it, it's still is being done. So when this comes back if it's going to come back to us if they can mitigate hurting the environment, it should be the issue, not who's actually doing it because I would say again the only reason we couldn't build a waste energy facility outside the udb is because we exempted ourselves. We exempted ourselves from the policy. So we know in fact it's not an environmental policy because we exempted ourselves. Really was environmental policy we couldn't have exempted ourselves. We exempted ourselves and then took advantage of an exemption and proposed a facility outside the boundary. Which I'm fine with, I just want us to be consistent. That's all. >>chair: commissioner regalado and I will go to you MADAM Mayor. >>commissioner regalado: we are missing a lot of things here and for the record I think it's important. Just because the administration recommended opa locka west I was against it, I was one of the first people that sid, we were the first to raise our hands and say were not building an incinerator in the everglades, that's a hard know for me. Have this conversation I understand where you're going but that doesn't resolve the issues that have been raised first. I don't think that as a board we should enter into a staff which, number one. I would like clarity from the attorneys and roy as to what exactly was said in those two documents because one thing is awesome and for those of us attorneys, one thing is us talking about who said what. He said she said and it's another thing what was in the documents provided to this board which were provided to the attorneys which were part of the record which were publicly noticed so can we go back to that and make this point? As to what exactly was said about the process because if we are going to focus on the process everyone understands in florida you have a duty to read. Whether it was red or not, it's in there. I just want more clarity as to, and I understand the first was without a recommendation and within denial, what is the language we are saying should have triggered them to know a text amendment, I understand what roy read which is a application as needed, obviously text amendment does not have the determination of need so that when we you to a udb application so if you could clarify that and what are the documents presented to this board said. >>chair: you are recognized. >> yes commissioner. In the application a demonstration of need is required. That has to be found as a need to go forward. The text amendment wasn't even considered, they weren't even required to demonstrate a need and that's what makes the text amendment so much easier. For the record this has been transmitted as a denial. It was recommend denial and only after that did someone start saying the county told them to do that. I don't know how we can be held to a standard of something they don't have an email, nobody has a record saying we said to do it but because somebody says we said it we are supposed to live by it, I don't know how to do that. If there's an email I'm happy to stand corrected, how do we get to this point, I can't that. >>commissioner regalado: roy and I see lourdes is they are, at what point in your your negotiations where is there a discussion about the use of the text amendment, did this come up, is that what they're alluding to? >> quite frankly when I have these discussions with MR. Kelly we were told what the administration said it didn't matter, they have the votes. >>commissioner regalado: lourdes. >> commissioner, I was not personally in the meeting and questioning when this issue came up. My understanding is applicants did have a discussion with staff as to the different approaches that could be taken as has been acknowledged the text amendment is not prohibited explicitly in our rules so I don't think any staff would have taken the tactic to tell someone you cannot do this certainly it was pointed out and the statement read by the chief from the original recommendation from the initial recommendation indicates that this is not the conventional way to communicate this type of use request. >>commissioner regalado: so lourdes, we use the text amendment for the truck parking that's in this area, one other time after we used this vehicle because part of the issue is with the use of this vehicle and I understand the novelty and geographic similarities, so let's say there's a gographic similarity but beyond that has been used before? Used for broader changes of policy support needs as for example the mayor mentioned we are going through the evaluation and appraisal process right now which is an intentional look by staff and the task force that's been put together an input from members of the public to make changes to the policy. So ultimately that effort will result in text amendments to the broader policies behind the comprehensive plan that MAY or MAY not suggest specific changes that will impact specific applications. >>commissioner regalado: I'm going to make it easier. When has a text amendment been used by a private party and not the county? This is a confusion. So I text amendment outside the udb by a private party, how many times has that happened? I think the answer is once and it would explain a lot of the confusion. >>commissioner bermudez: MAY I ask a point of order question piggybacking on her question? >>chair: lourdes you are recognized to respond. >>commissioner bermudez: commissioner regalado is pointing out it happened once, my question is who recommended it at the time, I believe it was staff. >> if the question is about the tara application, that one because of the nature of the request, they were specifically fulfilling the need for the long-haul trucking facility which was part of an analysis that has existed for many years from the state regarding truck needs in our community. We have the PRESIDENT Already of having established to truck parking areas through text amendments in open land number one and down south by the turnpike. In that case the text amendment vehicle to accommodate this truck facility type of utilization was recommended. And in fact we put as part of that analysis which was important in that decision to make that recommendation the land value that was associated with a full-blown industrial moved udb inside the udb comparison of that land value versus the land value in the truck parking, existing truck arcing locations and that was significant because what we've seen is that industrial land if it's zoned industrial which truck parking is allowed in any industrial parcel it tends to go to higher and best use, it doesn't stay as an industrial facility, it evolves into a logistics use so that was the rationale making recommendations on the tara truck parking, we wanted to say. >>chair: the answer is staff recommended the application. I love the diatribe. >> commissioner, yu can finish. You still have the floor, just give me asecond. My thing is to commissioner gilbert's point. Whether this county found the need for truck parking or not the time, our clean drinking water does not discriminate. It is the same across the board. We have to send the same message. You still have the floor and you're welcome to finish of course but we're going in circles. And at the end I think we need to deliver our conscience or what favors us politically on this board. But let's take a vote because we're just going in circles and not getting anywhere. >>commissioner regalado: respectfully MR. Chair certain accusations running and I'm trying to untangle that because what lourdes just mentioned is three truck parking situations. So lourdes, or the other to also text amendments? >> the designation of truck parking was done through a text amendment. >> was it a private party? >> actually the original one many years ago was a private application. Then the county ended up expanding the truck parking area to the totality of open lands of area one and designating. >>chair: if memory serves me were talking about but 10 years, the first one was 10 years ago. >> it was 2009 that violation occurred. >>commissioner regalado: a little bit less so from 2009 today we are talking about three text amendment changes, one was done by private party, one was expanded by the county and one was done by a private party so that's what we're saying and it was truck parking. >> garrett is remembering another one that was an industrial parcel that it was industrially zoned, split where text was initiated by a private applicant about 10 years ago. >>commissioner regalado: so my point in clarifying the history of it is is it is not a vehicle often used by this board. We've had many many applications. The utilization of this vehicle has been very particular to a particular need. So if to lourdes's point staff can't tell them not to use it but if you look at the history of how it has been ued you either decide it's similar to what you're doing or it's different from what you're doing and that seems like a judgment call. So I just think again we need to clarify the text amendment, that's something we need to take up but clearly how it has been used and the possibility of now it being used in lieu of a udb application is what is concerning and I don't think that is in conflict with our policy. So I appreciate the distinction and they told us to do xy and z but we get back to in this case this isn't truck parking. This isn't truck parking. There hasn't been establishment of a need and there was a prior udb application that has protected wetlands so this is a unique application that requires some thoughtfulness in trying to untangle what is the best path forward. >>chair: commissioner lopez and senator garcia maybe. >>commissioner lopez: I met with staff earlier before this all started about process and I want to put on the record there were many concerns when it came before us at the zoning and cdmp meeting staff presented us with a two-page list of all the concerns and all I want to say is those concerns should have been brought to this board in JULY when you first saw this application. I think it's a matter of process. Staff told me it's just the way things are done. You transmit, it comes back and then they tell you whether they approve or deny. I would just caution this for that moving forward when things of this magnitude have these types of concerns, this application should never have been transmitted with adoption because it sends a message. It sends the message if the state doesn't have a problem with it it's good to go but in fact it was never good to go. From the get-go. And as evidenced by the fact after I met with lourdes and cedric I learned there was a host of them they then handed out five minutes before we had to vote on this zoning application. Always about process. I would encourage us to insist we don't do it the way it's always been done. You willy-nilly transmit to the state because let me tell you something, there's a bill unfortunately mving through the process in tallahassee that says we will not be able to do anything that is more strict than what the state says. So in this case if that passes and in this case if the state had returned to that application with no comments, none of this would be relevant. And I think it's because we get ourselves into these fixes ourselves. You have to let this board know every single concern you have because at that time we could have said no, it shouldn't be a text amendment. It should be a udb application so from the perspective of process we have to get better at this because we are sending mixed messages. The state certainly is looking at us like I don't know how you have all these problems after you transmitted it to us without even a recommendation but you definitely knew from the beginning all of this was not done properly. I don't know about who told who and I agree he should she said, we're never going to get to that and no one's ever going to admit to it but it was a judgment call as commissioner regalado said, probably not a good one given the fact it had only been used once and we have to clarify that moving forward but I'm telling you from a process perspective we have to let the administration know no zoning application or know cdmp can come to us that isn't fully vetted. You don't fix it after you transmit estate, you set it before you bring it here and we can make a decision should we transmit an application so I wanted to put that on the record because on the process oriented person and I thought the process was completely flawed. >>chair: commissioner steinberg. >>commissioner steinberg: I hear what you're saying, I think we know in JULY because there were concerns I had I've been consistent on this and what I don't want to see us to is an exercise in futility. I don't want us to have this process go forward, they try to meet. The mayor has said it's requesting things only an application would require, they're hoping it's volunteered. So I just wanted to say that in this moment I think obviously I'm going to stay consistent but I do think this process brought up more questions than answers in a lot of ways and we do need to address them going forward. >>chair: senator garcia. >>senator garcia: I concur we do have to come up with a solution for the udb and what's the purpose and how we come up with a standardized measure but anyway that's a conversation for another day. I agree with commissioner bermudez. I did look at this and I did have conversations and we do have to be intelle

Showing the first 60,000 of 62,321 characters. The full document is at the source.

Miami-Dade Commission Agenda

--->

Legislative Survey ---> ADA Notice

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners Agenda

OFFICIAL

Version

Wednesday, February 18, 2026

9:30:00 AM

Commission Chambers

Disclaimer

Agenda Definitions

Printable PDF Format

County Commission Rules - Rule 6.05 DECORUM

"Any person making impertinent or slanderous remarks or who becomes boisterous while addressing the commission, shall be barred from further audience before the commission by the presiding officer, unless permission to continue or again address the commission be granted by the majority vote of the commission members present. No clapping, applauding, heckling or verbal outbursts in support or opposition to a speaker or his or her remarks shall be permitted. No signs or placards shall be allowed in the commission chambers. Persons exiting the commission chamber shall do so quietly.

The use of cell phones in the commission chambers is not permitted. Ringers must be set to silent mode to avoid disruption of proceedings. Individuals, including those on the dais, must exit the chambers to answer incoming cell phone calls. County employees may not use cell phone cameras or take digital pictures from their positions on the dais.

Miami-Dade County provides equal access and equal opportunity and does not discriminate on the basis of disability in its programs or services. If you need a sign language interpreter or materials in accessible format for this event, please contact the Miami-Dade County Agenda Coordinator�s Office at 305-375-2035 or [email protected] at least five days in advance.

When a resolution or ordinance is placed on the agenda at the request of a commissioner, the commissioner who requested the preparation of the item shall be designated as the prime sponsor. Any other commissioner who wishes to sponsor the resolution or ordinance shall be designated as a co-sponsor.

Pursuant to Rule 5.06(h), where a commissioner is listed as a sponsor, the first named commissioner is the prime sponsor and all other named commissioners are co-sponsors."

1A

INVOCATION AS PROVIDED IN RULE 5.05(H)

1B

ROLL CALL

1C

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

1D

SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS (SCHEDULED TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM)

1E

CITIZEN'S PRESENTATIONS (5 MINUTES MAXIMUM)

1F

REPORTS OF OFFICIAL BOARDS

1G

REASONABLE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PUBLIC TO BE HEARD AS PROVIDED IN RULE 6.06

1H

MOTION TO SET THE AGENDA AND "PULL LIST"

1I

OFFICE OF COMMISSION AUDITOR

1J

OFFICE OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

1K

OFFICE OF COMMUNITY ADVOCACY

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e7c59d92cafefb33bab0716a40365b03. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record