POLISCOPE

The public record

DUNNELLON (MARION COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Council

Wednesday, February 21, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Dunnellon City Council approved a new policy allowing part-time and reserve police officers to take home city vehicles. The Council also rejected a $9,000 contract for grant application assistance and postponed a decision on a USDA grant application for utility equipment.

Why it matters

The decision to allow police officers to take home city vehicles changes the operational policy for the Dunnellon Police Department, while the rejection of the grant consulting contract saves the city $9,000 in unbudgeted expenses.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

MASTER City of Dunnellon City Council Meeting Date: February 21, 2024 Time: 5: 30 p. m. Place: City Hall, 20750 River Dr., Dunnellon, FL34431 Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance: Mayor Green called the meeting to order at approximately 5: 41 p. m. and led the Council in the Pledge of Allegiance. Opening Prayer/ Moment of Silence Mayor Green invited any citizen wishing to volunteer to open with prayer. No one stepped forward and a moment of silence was observed. Roll Call Walter Green, Mayor, Seat 1 Tim Inskeep, Vice- Mayor, Seat 3 Chuck Dillon, Councilman, Seat 2 Rex Lehmann, Councilman, Seat 4 Valerie Hanchar, Councilwoman, Seat 5 Staff Present Mandy Odom, City Clerk Jan Smith, Finance Officer Chad Ward, Public Works Manager Chief Chris Scaglione, Police Department Captain Ron Bray, Police Department Julie Danowski, Records Clerk Legal Counsel Andrew Hand, Shepard, Smith, Kohlmyer& Hand, P. A. Proof of Publication The agenda was posted on the City' s website and City Hall bulletin board on Wednesday, February 14, 2024. Council Comments Regarding Agenda There were no Council comments. Public Comments— Non- Agenda Items Dave Porter, 11835 E. Blue Cove Dr., expressed his appreciation for the creation of the project check list and explained the benefits of the new process.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 2 of 9 Juliane Mendonca, 11894 E. Blue Cove Dr., thanked staff and Council for working to reinitiate the Special Magistrate hearings. She explained it is important to the taxpayers to hold people accountable. Joshua Hastings, 11885 Rainbow Garden Circle, stated there is a road behind Purple Sage and a retention pond in the same area which needs maintenance. He explained the negative impacts of not acting on these needs. Councilwoman Hanchar replied, Council would discuss it with Public Works. Mayor Green thanked Mr. Hastings for bringing this to their attention. Consent Agenda Meeting Minutes October 2, 2023 Workshop October 11, 2023 Meeting Authorize the Mayor to sign the Marion County School Board appreciation letter for closing during the January 9, 2024 storm. Reappoint Chair Scott Kiefer as a full member of the Historic Preservation Board for a three- year term, effective February 21, 2024 to February 21, 2027. Appoint Angie Rosier as the 1st Alternate on the Historic Preservation Board for a three- year term, effective February 21, 2024 to February 21, 2027. Authorize staff to proceed with determining the cost of the proposed Hale Street repaving project. Public Comment on Consent Agenda Sam Martian, 19293 St. Patrick Dr., stated San Angelo Parkway only has one house on it, but Bridges Road and St. Patrick Drive have quite a bit of traffic. He suggested asphalt or lime rock for these roads as well. Councilman Dillon replied, Bridges Road is not actually a road, it' s a path. He stated Council had discussed this in the past and there isn' t really anything the City can do to maintain it. Attorney Hand advised Bridges Road is entirely on State land, per the title search. Vice- Mayor Inskeep said the topic of grading Dunnellon Heights will come up later in today' s agenda. Councilwoman Hanchar moved the consent agenda be approved. Councilman Lehmann seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 5- 0. Regular Agenda 1) Agreements 1. a) Agreement# AGR2024- 06 Kimley- Horn IPO 107, Florida Boating Improvement Program ( FBIP) Grant Application Assistance Mayor Green called for public comment. Public Comment Juliane Mendonca, 11894 E. Blue Cove Dr., spoke in opposition of paying for grant application assistance at this time. She suggested budgeting funds in advance for grants and pointed out last year' s budget included obtaining quotes for Comprehensive Plan work which still needs to be

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 3 of 9 completed. She added staff is stretched thin and there is no one to manage this project. David Koger, 11983 Palmetto Way, stated he agrees with Mrs. Mendonca, and he said Kimley- Horn will be interested in taking our money for any reason. He asked to see the project checklist. Council Discussion Councilman Lehmann stated initially he was in favor of going forward with the grant assistance, but he has changed his mind based on Mrs. Mendonca' s comments. Councilman Dillon said responding to this grant opportunity in the time frame allowed makes no sense to him. He stated there are other things which need to be considered and he would rather use the money elsewhere. Vice- Mayor Inskeep stated this is not in the budget. He advised we need to do something with the boat ramp, but it needs to be planned. He suggested trying to come up with something ourselves. Mayor Green commented the best prepared grants have the most success and there is competition for grants. He said the conversation and public input is very convincing. Mrs. Smith stated this is a planning grant and not a construction grant. She said she recognizes the allotted time is short, but they will utilize data which has already been submitted saving preparation time. There was a brief discussion regarding Council' s desire to review the information and negotiate with Kimley- Horn. Vice- Mayor Inskeep moved to authorize the Mayor to sign Agreement # AGR2024- 06, Kimley Horn IPO No. 107 for FBIP grant application services in an amount not to exceed $ 9, 000. Councilman Lehmann seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion failed 0- 5, with everyone opposed. 2) Resolution 2. a) Resolution# RES2024- 07 Personnel Manual Amendment Mayor Green called for public comment. Public Comment Juliane Mendonca, 11894 E. Blue Cove Dr., asked for a brief summary of what this agenda item is about. Mrs. Odom replied, this Resolution would allow for part- time and reserve Police Officers to take home a police vehicle. Mrs. Odom stated she found several items which needed to be amended in this policy and she described the changes that were made.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 4 of 9 Vice- Mayor Inskeep suggested adding " with Council approval" at the end of paragraph two. He asked if there were enough vehicles to allow for this change. Chief Scaglione replied currently there are. Councilwoman Hanchar asked if we utilize a specific mechanic when there are vehicle problems. She suggested obtaining bids for the best price. Chief Scaglione replied they typically bring simple repairs to Gould' s and major repairs are taken to the dealership. Chief Scaglione stated he would like to contract with a tow service specific to the City of Dunnellon to tow either a City vehicle or a suspect vehicle. There was further discussion regarding warranty work, quality work, mechanical availability and setting up an approval process. Public Comment David Koger, 11983 Palmetto Way, stated he strongly suggests Council adopt this Resolution. Julianne Mendonca, 11894 E. Blue Cove Dr., stated she supports the vehicle take home policy and is pleased we have a responsible Chief of Police along with the proactiveness of the officers. Councilwoman Hanchar moved Resolution # RES2024- 07 be read by title only. Councilman Lehmann seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 5- 0. Mrs. Odom read the following into the record: RESOLUTION# RES2024- 07 A RESOLUTION BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUNNELLON ADOPTING PERSONNEL MANUAL AMENDMENTS AND CHANGES TO ARTICLE VIII, SECTION 1. 2 USE OF CITY VEHICLE AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE." Councilwoman Hanchar moved to approve Resolution # RES2024- 07 as amended. Councilman Dillon seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 5- 0. 3) Staff Agenda Items 3. a) USDA Rural Development Grant Application for the purchase of utility truck and equipment Mrs. Odom stated this item needs to be pulled from the agenda, because we need to readvertise. She said it will come back to Council in March. 3. b) South San Angelo Parkway quotes for survey Mr. Ward stated he received two quotes, one for $ 2, 525 and the other for $ 1, 800. He recommended going with the lower cost surveyor. Councilman Lehmann asked what the survey includes. Mr. Ward replied it shows everything which is owned by the City. Vice- Mayor Inskeep stated the survey will lead to improving the road. He asked Mrs. Odom to add paving all of Dunnellon Heights as a topic for discussion during the next workshop meeting.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 5 of 9 Mayor Green explained the survey is to help minimize the expense while providing access to a citizen' s property. Public Comment There were no public comments. Councilman Dillon moved to authorize staff to proceed with obtaining a survey of South San Angelo Parkway. Councilwoman Hanchar seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 5- 0. 3. c) FY2023- 2024 First Quarter General Fund Budget Update Mrs. Smith provided the first quarter budget update. She spoke about the year- to- date actuals and revenues which included items such as licenses and fees, grants, and charges for services. She said she is anticipating a surplus of$ 114, 000. Mrs. Smith stated there is about$ 685, 000 in expenses as of December 31, 2023 and she anticipates we will be slightly over budget. She shared details about departmental budgets including City Clerk, legal counsel, planning and development, building inspector, and more. Mrs. Smith explained the police trust expense and advised there are now funds available for police vehicle wraps. She advised overall she is anticipating a year end surplus of approximately 129, 000. She explained reserve funds are our City bank account and she shared how those funds are allocated. She also provided details regarding the City' s various equities. There were no Council questions. 04) Council Agenda Item 4. a) E. Pennsylvania Multi- Modal Project Councilman Dillon responded to a question from last week regarding the northern extension of the bike path. He provided a document which he said proves the extension is planned to continue to Tallahassee. He commented he can answer 95% of the objections brought forward. He displayed a diagram which indicated parking on the south side of East Pennsylvania but not on the north side. He explained the bicycles would be inside their own lane, which will include a curb similar to a sidewalk curb. He explained where the water meters and water line would be placed. He spoke about the designs for crosswalks and asserted someone is going to get killed on East Pennsylvania Avenue if these crosswalks are not installed. He added crosswalks will also slow down traffic. He shared there are no medians in this diagram, and he agrees with others the road is too narrow for them. He asserted there is a dangerous situation at the bridge with tubers crossing the street and it needs to be addressed. He commented his position is to listen, come up with answers for citizen concerns, and then vote accordingly. Councilwoman Hanchar shared an experience while driving along East Pennsylvania where a person was almost struck by a truck. She stated part of this project is to include safety measures

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 6 of 9 for our citizens and visitors. She spoke about the on- street parking and concurred with Councilman Dillon' s comments. Councilman Dillon asked who is going to pay Kimley- Horn for their engineering services. He stated no one is answering this question and he doesn' t understand why there can' t be a compromise. Councilman Lehmann stated he appreciated Councilman Dillon' s comments and the handout Nathan Whitt provided. He spoke about sections of the path which are incomplete, but he said restructuring East Pennsylvania will create positive benefits to the people. Vice- Mayor Inskeep stated FGUA is asking for a foot more than what Councilman Dillon described for their meters and water line. He advised they would like three feet to keep the workers safe from traffic. He commented the bridge plan is a poor one and he asserted we would be sending bicyclists right into the tube and kayak traffic trying to access the river. He said this trail does nothing for most of Dunnellon' s taxpayers while increasing the City' s maintenance burden on staff. He remarked losing any parking on East Pennsylvania makes no sense to him and this is not a business plan but rather a beautification project. He stated the County said if we go back and change the plan, we will incur the expense. He declared he would prefer to spend the money on something which would benefit the locals instead of the select few. Mayor Green stated this plan could be achieved by taking the parking area on the south side of East Pennsylvania and restripe it to preserve the sidewalk. He said no drainage would be changed and the size of the traffic lanes would not change. He commented we do need to do something about the safety of our pedestrians crossing the bridge. He advised we must plan for the future and concentrate on what 99% of what our citizens need, which is a traffic plan not a bicycle plan. He added he is in full support of installing a crosswalk. Public Comment David Koger, 11983 Palmetto Way, thanked Council for their work. He stated he looked at the pros and cons and he doesn' t see very many pros. He suggested detouring the bikers in such a way they are not in conflict with the tubers. Paula Koger, 11983 Palmetto Way, stated she only has one question; why? David Porter, 11835 E. Blue Cove Dr., commented a lot has changed since 2012. He said Dunnellon needs to have an integrated plan to bring bicyclists into Dunnellon. He stated this plan does significant damage to the residents. He asked Council to consider canceling this project because it was not well thought out. Chief Scaglione thanked Councilman Dillon for putting up the design diagram because it was something he hadn' t seen. He said he recommends stopping the program because the left hand doesn' t seem to know what the right hand is doing. He stated if you try to agree to a program right now, you will have no clue as to what is actually going to be built.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 7 of 9 Nathan Whitt, 12121 River View, stated he was told alternate D was the chosen design for the project and the State and County will not allow on street parking. He asserted all neighboring cities are moving forward with beautification projects and we also need to move forward, especially with this State and County approved project. He said Dunnellon plays a critical role in connecting the bike trail loop. He asked Mrs. Odom to display what he believes is the correct view of the bike path. He spoke about the benefits of the new design and attempted to address the problems which were raised. Julianne Mendonca, 11894 E. Blue Cove Dr., said the cities moving forward also have comprehensive plans and better roads and streets. She stated we don' t even know the plan we are voting on because we have seen several different versions tonight. Vice- Mayor Inskeep moved to cancel the East Pennsylvania Multi- Modal project. Councilman Lehmann seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 4- 1, with Councilman Dillon opposed. 05) Department Reports Mr. Ward stated he would like to move forward with installing an alarm system for Public Works from Johnson Controls. Mrs. Odom reminded Council they approved the installation of an alarm system from ADT back in August. She advised this system is under the $ 5, 000 threshold and is within Mr. Ward' s budget. Councilman Dillon commented Johnson Controls is a good company and commended Mr. Ward for his work on the project. Vice- Mayor Inskeep stated he reviewed both quotes and this one looks like the best option. Council agreed to allow Mr. Ward to move forward. Mr. Ward advised Council the Fire Department roof should be completed before the next Council meeting. He said the first Special Magistrate meeting was conducted, and it went very well. He added there is another meeting scheduled for March or April which will include 8 cases. He announced Public Works closed 110 work orders this month. Mr. Ward asserted he has been having difficulty convincing contractors to come out and provide quotes. He explained the reason is because they have repeatedly come out to quote in the past, but never receive any business. He suggested setting up a contract with Rock and Roll Pavers to ensure Dunnellon Heights is graded regularly and to resolve this quoting issue. Mayor Green stated this is a common problem for municipalities because we deal with taxpayer money, and it is difficult to compromise. Vice- Mayor Inskeep asked what prevents the City from going into a three to five- year contract with contractors. Mrs. Odom said as long as we follow our purchasing policy, she doesn' t see an issue. There was further discussion between Mrs. Odom and Attorney Hand regarding the purchasing policy and contracts. Vice- Mayor Inskeep suggested adding this topic to the March workshop.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 8 of 9 Councilman Dillon suggested allowing for material price fluctuations in the contract. There was further discussion regarding the benefit of this idea. Mrs. Smith spoke about cancelling the multi- modal path project. She advised the funding clause states the project could be cancelled if the benefit to the City has changed. She said, however, the State can ask us to repay the funds they approved. She offered to research further and find other possible ramifications. Mrs. Odom offered to compose the letter to the County announcing the Council' s desire to cancel the project. She said she will bring it to the March workshop for their review. Chief Scaglione stated last Friday there was an incident at Dunnellon Middle School. He advised Council they put the school on lock down and helped the kids to a shelter. He said the Sheriff' s Department came in to assist and everything went smoothly, including the reunification of the kids with their parents. He stated they learned a lot and have already identified the offender. Council commended Chief Scaglione and the entire Police Department for the way they handled the situation. Chief Scaglione announced they are working on cleaning up and beautifying the Police Department by painting the building and destroying old guns and evidence. He advised Council FDLE will arrive in July to audit the evidence room and they have begun to research other companies for their security system. He stated Brannen Bank is assisting them with alternatives and they will have a proposal from Johnson Controls soon. Chief Scaglione stated he is seeking Council' s direction for making an Ordinance change. He said he would like to change the fees for violations involving parking, the river, alcohol, and others. He asserted we need to be more specific with the fees and he said he would like to have those fees paid at the City rather than going through Marion County. He explained the positive financial impact of this change. Vice- Mayor Inskeep asked what the attorney fees would be to make the change in the Ordinance. Attorney Hand replied until he reviews what will be involved he cannot forecast the fees, but he doesn' t see this as being a high- cost Ordinance. He stated the Ordinance process is not the expensive part, but rather it is the approval process which drives the cost up. Council agreed they would like Chief Scaglione to proceed with this project. 06) Council Liaison Reports And Comments Councilman Lehmann stated he went to the Planning Commission meeting where they discussed Follow That Dream RV Park. He suggested Council find out if Marion County can put a traffic counter near the RV Park to measure the current traffic and again after the RV Park is complete to measure future traffic. He advised the RV Park owners have estimated six trips in and out per day, per RV slot. Attorney Hand informed Council this topic is coming before them as a quasi- judicial hearing. He urged Council not to discuss it and not to contact TPO about it. He stated traffic reports will come to them via evidence presented from staff.

City Council Meeting February 21, 2024 Page 9 of 9 Vice- Mayor Inskeep asked if he could find out from TPO what the steps are to putting a traffic counter out. Attorney Hand replied yes, as long as the question is not specific to the project. Vice- Mayor Inskeep provided an update on The Granda road project and stated it would be going out to bid within the next two weeks and construction is still on track for June. Mrs. Odom announced Andy Mathew and the Clerk' s staff have been working diligently with Granicus and because of this we have successfully live streamed tonight' s meeting. She explained the changes which have been made to resolve the previous issues. Mayor Green stated the Dunnellon Little League have begun this season' s practices. He offered his thanks to Council and staff for their concern while he was hospitalized. 07) City Attorney Report Attorney Hand stated he didn' t have anything new to report. Mrs. Odom suggested a special CRA meeting for March to finalize discussions about the grant policy. Councilman Dillon stated he is attempting to understand CRA better and he would like more time for discussion. Council agreed to discussion during the City Council Workshop on Monday and a special CRA Meeting prior to the City Council Meeting in March. 08) Adjourn At approximately 8: 30 p. m. Councilwoman Hanchar moved the City Council meeting be adjourned. Vice- Mayor Inskeep seconded the motion. A vote was taken, and the motion passed 5- 0. 16t e 4&n__ Penned signature of: Walter L. Green, Mayor Att Penned signature of: Amanda Odom, CMC, City Clerk

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e728151369fa489cf5c6391b8adc4cd5. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record