POLISCOPE

The public record

ENCINITAS (SAN DIEGO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Urban Forest Advisory Committee

Thursday, September 24, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

If needed, Oral Communication items will be referred to city staff either for resolution by administrative action or placement on a futu

Why it matters

This item is supported by a public source record.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Captured actions

5

Recorded outcomes

0

Source artifacts

3

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

AGENDA

Regular Meeting of the Urban Forest Advsisory Committee

Thursday, September 24, 2026 5:30 p.m.

Council Chambers

505 South Vulcan Avenue

Encinitas, California 92024

A copy of the Committee meeting packet may be viewed by the public in the City Hall lobby and on the City's webpage at www.encinitasca.gov .

Members of the Urban Forest Advisory Committee

Tony Gurnoe, Chair

Laura Lisauskas, Committee Member

Steven Houbeck, Committee Member

Matthew D Altman, Committee Member

Caitlin Kreutz, Committee Member

Brad Lefkowits, Committee Member

Mark Jenne, Committee Member

The Encinitas Urban Forest Advisory Committee welcomes you and encourages your continued interest and involvement in the City's decision-making process.

KNOW YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE OPEN GOVERNMENT LAWS: Government's duty is to serve the public, reaching its decisions in full view of the public. Commissions, boards, councils and other agencies of the City exist to conduct the people's business. For more information on your rights under the Brown Act and other State laws, visit the city's webpage at www.encinitasca.gov under the heading Resources.

Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Committee regarding any item on this agenda received after the posting of the agenda and prior to the meeting will be made available for public inspection in the City Hall lobby during normal business hours.

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act/Section 504 Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and Title VI, this agency is an equal opportunity public entity and does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, ethnic origin, national origin, sex, religion, veteran status or physical or mental disability in employment or the provision of service. If you require special assistance to participate in this meeting, please contact the UFAC Secretary at 760-633-2841 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting.

HOW TO WATCH:

Channel 19 on Cox Communications, Channel 24 on Spectrum Cable and Channel 99 on AT&T U-Verse (Program Name: “City of Encinitas Broadcasts”). The Committee meetings are also broadcasted live and archived for viewing via the City’s website at https://encinitasca.gov/Government/Agendas-Webcasts.

VISUAL MATERIALS FOR COMMITTEE MEETINGS

All digital presentation materials must be emailed to ufac@encinitasca.gov at least 2 hours before the meeting. Accepted formats include digital photos, Microsoft Office files, and PDFs. CDs, DVDs, and USB drives will not be accepted. All files must be in PC format and labeled with the corresponding agenda item number.

HOW TO PARTICIPATE

WRITTEN COMMENTS: •To submit written comments, e-mail ufac@encinitasca.gov and include the related agenda item in the subject line. Email comments will be provided to the Committee and included in the meeting record.

IN PERSON COMMENTS: • Speaker Requests will be accepted no earlier than 30 minutes before the start of the meeting. Please be aware that the chair has the authority to reduce equally each speaker’s time to accommodate a larger number of speakers. Speakers are allotted three (3) minutes to address the Committee on any one item. All requests to speak must be submitted before the Committee begins to discuss the item.

Audio of past Urban Forest Advisory Committee meetings is available on our website at www.encinitasca.gov .

1.

CALL TO ORDER

2.

ROLL CALL

3.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

4.

ORAL COMMUNICATIONS / POSSIBLE DIRECTION TO STAFF

(30 MINUTES)

Each speaker is allowed three (3) minutes to address the Committee. Time donations are not permitted during Oral Communications. Please submit a "WHITE" speaker slip to the Committee Clerk. If needed, Oral Communication items will be referred to city staff either for resolution by administrative action or placement on a future agenda.

Vacant Site Presentation Added 9-24-26 at 2:50PM

5.

CHANGES TO THE AGENDA

Showing the first 24,000 of 87,037 characters. The full document is at the source.

time and being here at all. We re gonna call this meeting to order. And I ll pass it over to. Roll call. Tony Gerno Here Laura Lisa Uscas. Here. Stephen Hobeck. Matthew Altman. Caitlin Kreutz here. Brad Lefkowitz Mark Mark Jenny, let the record show those are present. Great. And next item on the agenda is for those of you who can join us in pledging allegiance to the flag. Thank you and it looks as though we re in for some oral communications tonight, is that correct? Yes sir, can we have Ellen Byrne, please. Can we get her mic on, please? Are you there? Ok. Um um. I, I did not know whether or not we still had a. A full time. Urban forester yet or not. I came to the last meeting hoping to meet that person I told been told there was one, and then I left, um, and the main reason I came was the main reason I m here tonight is I know that there s overlap of responsibilities for trees, but I m gonna pass it off to you to get to the right person there is a Torry Pine that fell about a month ago in Glen Park. It was probably the biggest. I don t, maybe not the tallest, probably the oldest I heard people s counting and saying, well, it s 147 rings and somebody else said it s 169 rings, so there s a portion of the stump still left partially raised out of the ground. I would like Dudek to do a postmortem on why that tree fell. Uh We don t have that many of them left. It s really strange because the Torrey pines that are along Arinda and I guess in the right of way maybe look are perfectly pruned looks like they were pruned like they were ficus, only they re not FICAs, they re Tory Bins. We don t have that many left. There s 2 other Torrey Pines there that are probably gonna go, uh, but there s one still left in the middle of the park or not the middle close. To where the other one fell, that probably needs some attention, uh, but I really don t understand why that big one was not pruned. And it was really in need of pruning when all the others were. Um Oh, in case you haven t heard, last night as part of our emergency response, the city manager has said that somebody will be out looking at all the trees that might be at risk in the city for. Falling or damage due to wind, rain, flooding, what night. But not so, it sounds like a heavy lift for anybody. Um, but please, I would appreciate somebody passing this on and then maybe getting back to me about why that tree fell. Thank you. Thank you Alan. Um, Hansen, I m gonna trust that you know what the right conduit is for the moment and We don t have Rob here tonight, but, um, yeah, it s noted. I ll, I ll take a look at that and, um, respond accordingly. Next up, Mark Wisniewski. Hansen, can you pull up the presentation, please? Thank you. Good evening, CHAIRMAN Gurno, members of the ufac committee. I ve heard a couple of things in the last couple of years regarding uh vacant tree sites and at the last meeting it was noted that it s hard finding suitable viable spots for planting. And That kind of surprised me because I ve been tracking vacant tree sites in the town for decades and we ve always and and we ve always had and a and surplus of them. So I asked my friend Tim Clancy, associate of mine, to put together this, uh, this PowerPoint. And This is called a species diversity diversity summary. It includes the top 10 species as of AUGUST 2026. From the latest inventory that the city uh has provided us dated AUGUST 11th. So number one rank is vacant site. 4,452 and it s 20% of all sites. 2 queen palm 1886.8%. Number 3, Mexican fan palm, which is also on our invasive species list 1,124, 5%. Number 4, king palm 797.4%. Number 5, pygmy date palm 8 to 10 ft tall at maturity, 733.3%. 1st 4 trees all palms. Did you know that? Are you surprised to see that? Number 6, African fern pine 6243% number 7 stumps 614 if you remove the stumps, you therefore have more vacant sites. 3%. Number 8. Brisbane Bucks 584 3% 9 California pepper tree also on on the invasive species list for 772% number 10, back to the poems of Kentia 395. The color coding. For the green is trees with functional canopy have living foliage and crown structure that can actively deliver biological and public benefits such as photosynthesis, shade cooling, interception. Habitat screening and particulate capture. The yellow, which is the majority of the top 10. A functional vacancy. It s a tree site that is nominally occupied by a plant but functionally vacant because the occupant cannot reasonably develop or deliver the canopy, longevity or services expected to the site. So, uh, Tim and I have decided what you need to start with probably is a priority ranking of these 4000 sites to develop a strategic plan. Tim and I are willing to do that at your next meeting. We have developed a comprehensive methodology to plant all the vacant tree sites. I could have about 2 more sentences. Thank you, Mark. Go ahead. And so suggests that strategy. To plant all 4000 sites in 5 years if you want to hear about this, put us on the agenda. We ve already developed it. Um, what I would like to do as a light request towards our kind of nebulous staff. And consultant positions is. Maybe I don t wanna um assume what you re to do list looks like, but this notion of Ground truth and vacant sites might be a good field notes thing. Perhaps just an idea. Thank you, Mark. Uh It s Why not? Yeah. Uh, well, he s doing that. Just crunched in the machine. Oh, nice. Ok, this is a 2017 Save Our Shade Award. And we re, we re trying to be on the same team here, Mark. This was a statewide award. Anthony is one that if I find the article in the paper. I would appreciate that. Ok, well, just so that it s a little bit on the mic, that was a statewide award and perhaps there s gonna be some more information to follow. Uh, with the chair s permission, one quick question for MR. Wisniewski, uh, These functionally vacant, the Queen Palm Mexican fam pm. There s a tree there, but you re calling it functionally vacant. Is that part of this 4000 or is that in addition to the 4000 that you ve identified? No, the, the vacant site is functionally vacant because there s no tree there. The trees in yellow and other ones. Many more that are not trees that are in the tree inventory are functionally vacant as well. They don t provide the services of shade cooling water interception, another and you re referring to the palms because they re not technically trees, and they don t, uh. Produce a big robust canopy. That s correct. Hanson, this could be something I think we re gonna do the first kind of report in OCTOBER that we had talked about kind of an annual. Uh, planting. Loss report this time permitting that, you know, vacancy assessment could maybe be part of that. Uh, yeah, I mean, there s a lot to say about that. Um, there s a lot to unpack, and I think, you know, working with Mark and hearing what he had to say and maybe providing some clarity for the reason why a lot of those are vacant is always valuable. Conversation that we love to have. Um, I will not be sitting in the seat in OCTOBER, so I will pass that on to the new urban forester. He can take on those field notes and all those different aspects, um, But yeah, I ll, I ll note it and pass it on, and I think it s a, you know, It s always been something that I ve wanted to tackle, but, um, just have not had the time. So, uh, it s a valid thing we need to do and I ll, I ll pass that to the new urban forester for some. A quick comment, could this tie into the um tree map somehow. This data could be tied into the tree map saying there was a tree, but it was removed, but it s like a dot that s showing there s a potential site. That s kind of where this comes from. So this is part of the data set that is what the city s inventory overall, you know, this is an excerpt from that, essentially. All right, who s up next? Ok, next is Russell Levo Levon. Mm. Shows me 4 pages and I ll just. Show up there Ready? Sure. Good afternoon, uh, Russell Levan, I wanted to do a little follow up on the Orpheus trees, um. I went out there, uh, 3 hours ago and recounted, uh, what s going on. And basically, since last month, um, But first of all, there s 97 trees planted as far as I can tell, unless I miscounted, but I ve counted like 40 times, um, cause I kept coming up with one different number. Anyway, um, What I found interesting was that, uh, in the last month, they removed 16 of the trees. And there are still 4 of them that are. You know. Dead yet, but they re pretty much dead. Um, so basically there were 20. Trees in essence that died out of 97, they were planted at like the hottest time of the entire year, and I m not sure exactly why we. Chose to plant them at that time. They weren t tree vacancy sites, by the way. And so my questions are, one, is there flexibility in planting time when That probably wasn t the best. Time to go out and do this when it was. Literally one of the hottest days of the year, and for the, for the next two weeks. Um um, I m stoked they planted them. I m, I mean, I think it s desperately needed along the freeway right of way. That s just like the best place to plant a whole bunch of trees, um, And uh. So those are a couple of my questions. Is this normal to have a 20.6% failure rate. Um, and I did go through and I had a beautiful, it s on my computer, it looks much better. Um, so I, in the pink are the ones that were removed, the yellow are the ones that are dead, and there s 4 pages of this, so it doesn t look so great. But, um, and it will show each of the types of trees. So if we want, I can send this in later and you can actually see which trees fared the best, um. Based on my observations. So you can just kind of flip through those, um. It was the uh. Cointella, I think it is those were definitely. Super hard hit, um, they They didn t do well. 3rd page. So, and I was going from the, I numbered these from the north to the south, and so when you got to the south part of Orpheus. We had like 8 trees in a row that were removed that that that died, and, but I found it interesting, the spacing cause there s a few today of 19 seconds that were in great shape. Right next to a tree that was had been removed, so. I m not sure exactly how that worked. Last question is, when you replant the ones that you removed, the dead ones. Do those count yet again for another tree planted in the city or is it only counted once? I think that s important to know. Thank you. Do you have anything to say on that last note, otherwise, I think that This is too big of a subject for us to try to wrestle with in this context, but it would be nice for us to review this as part of that annual kind of, you know, Forest profit and loss statement report almost for lack of a better way to put it. Answer to the last question is they will not be counted twice. Any tree that gets removed, essentially, it s like any code of a tree removal that happens. You know, is a negative in every single tree that s, uh, that gets planted as a positive, so it won t be, it ll negate essentially. Um, yeah, there s a lot to say about Orpheus. I ve said a ton about it already. Uh, maybe not in this specific setting, um, but there s There s, yeah, there s a lot to say about it, um, I can give a specific. Um, return to the council if you guys want or the committee. About this thing, um, about this planting specifically and what the plan is. If that s something that you guys desire. What I would like to see, given that part of what we re trying to assess in this annualized report is what is causing the losses that we re suffering in our, in our urban forest, I think that the notion of Failure and success of planting would be a nice kind of breakout element in that. I know that I m providing you a suggestion to pass along at this point, but I, it seems to me that that might be a good way for this to be incorporated into our existing schedule of agenda items. Sure, noted. Is that it for tonight? Ok. Do we have any changes to the agenda tonight? No changes. Ok, that brings us to the minutes from the last month s meeting, and I want to proactively acknowledge something that Mark Wisniewski sent in a public comment about, which is that in the minutes as they re written, it s still calls the tree that we voted to recommend as a heritage tree last month. Eucalyptus facifolia, and it supposed to be at least ultimately needs to be on the um website and plaque fic. Sofiafolia means as leaves like a ficus, and I ll spare you all the reasoning behind eucalyptus versus Carribia unless you really wanna know. But having said that, does anybody else have changes? Does it only appear in the minutes at one time, or is there multiple? i saw it at least once. I think it s only under um. Agenda item number 7 from last month. Yeah, so 7 a. I see one. So if we could just correct that to switch that a to an I, I think we re good. So if the if the heritage tree application is also wrong, we probably want to correct that as well. Yeah, it s noted it, it ll be as it moves on to planning, we ll, we ll get that correct. Um, I would make a motion to Approved the minutes with that one change? I ll second that. Thank you all that passes is unanimously and it brings us to item number 7, 7a, and I ll pass it over to Hanson. We have received Beetle, so it s a beetle that primarily affects eucalyptus. This the It Is your mic on there, Hansen? Uh, yeah, sorry, am I not talking into it, um. So it was first detected in California in 2022 in la, um, it s established kind of in the southern part of the state. It attacks 20 plus eucalyptus and Cribia species. Um, The key impacts of it are severe foliage loss and branch defoliation, and they tend to Produce a lot, um, and they re kind of always present seemingly. There s 2 generations per year, and, um, they accelerate, an accelerated spread, the repeated infestation can also lead to tree mortality, which is kind of that the key issue here is that They ve been a nuisance for sure. Um, a lot of complaints about the, the droplets and just the Beatles in general going on other people s plants, but it s really the defoliation that can be more of an impact. And, and that is really the repeated defoliation. So we haven t seen any trees. Die from this yet, um, but we could eventually, you know, as this defoliation continues year over year, but it hasn t, at this point has been more of a nuisance than a, a real problem. Um, So the management of this is to maintain the tree health and irrigation if supplied prune-infested branches and remove debris. Um, professional insecticide treatment when warranted, so that would kind of be the final stage. Um, the identification, the beetle looks like this guy. It s quite a little bit larger than a, um, ladybug. It s 3/8 inches long, yellow, orange with black spots. The larva has yellow, um, and is yellow with like a little black head and they tend to cluster kind of on the leaf and, and move and defoliate it. Um, so the takeaway is early detection in greater pest management are critical to protecting the eucalyptus canopy. It has been a tough pest to deal with because there isn t much besides an insecticide that really has been effective. Um, So this is an adult beetle feeding on the eucalyptus, and this is, um, the larvae right here. So this is kind of what you ll tend to see. Uh, we re not actively currently managing this pest, as I stated before, it s kind of a nuisance, but this could be something that would change in the past if we did see a decrease in health of a lot of our eucalyptus, um, eucalyptus, just for those who don t know, is on a species list that get pruned every single year. Um, so we do try to manage it in that way, which isn necessarily the appropriate way. Um, and since this is a relatively new past. Uh, they re, you know, maybe some fluctuation or something that we end up trying to help. Mitigate this, but options are a little limited at the moment. Can I ask you a question? Sure, um, so we ve got this beetle now, and we ve had the Lp psyllid for a long time. Are the cycles of defoliation the same, or do they alternate each other. And do you guys think that over time we re going to lose more eucalyptus because of this. Yeah, um, I don t know about the cycles particularly. I noticed that this is kind of, uh, kind of a constant. There seems to be two little bumps, but they re Seemingly always present at this moment, um, And I do think that, you know, obviously, if we have the Lurb psyllid as a, you know, it, um, a problem for the tree, and then this is just another problem. So any additional pest is always going to be a concern with tree health. So it ll have to be something that we monitor. We do have a lot of use in the city, and they re all kind of in a state of Maturity or senescence, you know, there s not a lot of new ukes out there except for volunteers. So we ll have to be. If we can be proactive about this pest, if possible, um, so welcome any good ideas and You know, we can try to tackle this together. I have 2 questions for you. Um, You, uh, mentioned at the outset that people are complaining about affecting other plants? Are you seeing, is it just that they re around and present on other planets, or are you seeing actual damage to other plants that aren yukes. I haven t personally seen actual damage every time that I ve reached out to a resident, you know, it doesn t quite get that far. Um, I ve, you know, had these all over my house and different plants and property that I have, but, um, I haven t seen them. They just seem to be present at the moment and not necessarily, you know, maybe if a little bit of defoliation on some trees before they decide that that s not really what they re looking for. So I haven t had any specific examples of Anything been completely defoliated from this beetle outside of eucalyptus, um, if anyone else has, you know, that would be great information to kind of,, I think I had a similar experience. My neighbor has a couple of uks and they were. A lot of them in my yard at a point in time in the year, but I didn t see them actually doing any damage to any of my plants. Yeah, so, and I think that ll be one of those things that since it is a new pest, if we do see it jump to a different species, you know, that could be a concern as well. So we ll have to keep our eye on it and kinda. Like I said, um, try to be creative and be as proactive as we can with this as it. Kind of continues to grow as a problem within the city. My other question was, uh, do you have a sense of other regions in California or areas like are we kind of the front line here? Is this more further down the road somewhere else, or do you have any information on other places this is happening? Yeah, it s kind of happening all over Southern California. I know we tend to be the start of many problem pests, um, so I, I don t think there s a lot of other options and a lot, a lot of other stuff that I ve run into. I ran this by our pca and got a similar Kind of, um, instruction. So I think it s just gonna be one of those things that moves south or moves north and, um, we re just gonna have to see what creative solutions come out of it. I have seen them because they produce like a honeydew, so sometimes if they re very close to a plant that they ll get honeydew on, then this black moldy mildew grows on the leaves, and it can kind of the, you know, uh, photosynthesis of the plant. Um, and sometimes things will get like small bedding plants will get buried in the leaf litter, but. That s about it, so that s good. A quick question about if we start tackling this pest on eucalyptus and maybe eucalyptus is already old and sort of invasive species even though they ve been here for 100 years, but the, you know, provide less value than other trees, for, for instance, would that investment be worth it, or maybe slight, like gradual removal of older trees that are invested invested and replacing them. With something else. I know the site of eucalyptus is a little bit tough to immediately plan something. Yeah, and I think that s always the consideration with any like. Application that we would do in the city, you know, it gets evaluated if it s. Fiscally responsible, kind of like the Palm Weevil did, came in, we decided it wasn t physically responsible for the city to maintain that and we didn t do it. So any application that was broad or like a species-specific would have to go through the proper channels to make sure that it was, you know, it s not gonna be an overnight decision. So it would be. You know, especially if it is an invasive species or something that we re not intentionally needing to keep, you know, although. Eucalyptus tend to be some of the biggest trees in our area, and they re not Typically being replanted with trees of the same canopy size, you know, a lot of the trees that have been planted, eucalyptus specifically are not in. Infrastructure, conflict zones that we would plant another large califer tree, so it, you know, We have to be hesitant about how we remove our large canopy trees because it is a lot harder to get the canopies that we re we re losing again and maybe critical canopies could be, uh, strategically saved, those trees could be treated, you know, and then something else that is just a. Funding, you know, and, and money required to, there s a little bit more to it than that, and just for context because I ve been involved with this stuff for a long time with the city, and um, Hanson specifically mentions integrated pest management in this and part of that is because we actually have an integrated pest management policy in the city and so. Any of the treatments that would be effective on this would be systemic neonicotinoid treatments, which actually require a specific exemption which involves engaging a. Pest control advisor and then I ll just kind of like um Remind everybody about the last thing that was something new like this. Was a little bit similar and a little bit different, which is the Canary Island date palms in the South American palm weevils and that whole procedure did end up in a, a pretty big report, which I helped to contribute to and ultimately the urban forest advisory Committee had a lot of involvement with the evaluating like which of the trees within this subset are special, kind of like you re referring to, and it s tricky, and there s a lot of public concern about broad use of chemicals. And so, um, we re not gonna resolve it tonight, but this is an interesting kind of like next iteration of that process of analysis because there wasn t that much love lost for those big Canary Island date palms, but they don t produce the kind of canopy and carbon sequestration and things that we re seeing in eucalyptus of this age, so maybe it ll be a slightly different conversation, but we ll have to get to it. I think that that s the chemical specifically will bring up a lot of concerns with pollinators, right, because bees love eucalyptus kind of on that note, one of the issues with the Canary Island Palm was 3 or $400.30 dollars or $400 per quarter in perpetuity and so once we started doing the math on that, that was crazy for the treatment of this, is it like a once a year thing or do you have a sense of how often it would be necessary. I d have to check with the pca application and like Tony said, it s quite a process to go through to get any of this approved. Um, so, Yeah, it d just be part of the general conversation. Um, we don t have as many, well, we do have a lot of ekes, but so it can add up really fast. And I think what we would end up doing. If we really had to make these tough decisions, which at least with this past, it s, at this point, it s just defoliation and not something that s, you know, as big of a deal as the palm Weevil. Um, so, but there are gradients of, you know, like, there s some really nice ekes in specific parks that we might treat a little differently, or, you know, there

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

5 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 5 of 5

Browse by category5 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Urban Forest Advisory Committee
  • Urban Forest Advisory Committee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.
  • Low-grade, ungraded, procedural, or superseded items remain in the complete agenda inventory rather than the meeting digest.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e695ffa576254e54c6b0bbea014f6654. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record