The 30-second read
Recorded outcomeCHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY
Why it matters
This item is supported by a public source record.
What happens next
No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.
The public record
Wednesday, October 8, 2025 · Government meeting record
The 30-second read
Recorded outcomeWhy it matters
This item is supported by a public source record.
What happens next
No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.
This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.
to the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America likely for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> we'll do a roll call. Mister Le Mans Mister Clermont here. Mister Christie. President Mister Salem. And Mister DiLeo is not president. And are there any requests for changes to the word of the day? >> Have any myself not know. Thank you, Steph. Okay. serve the pleasure of conduct. >> We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues will not engage in personal attacks. All right. And then suggested time limits for each position. So today we have 2 quasi judicial Is that typically 15 minutes for staff and applicants in 5 minutes for members of the public. >> Actually, the default would be 10 minutes for applicant and 10 minutes for city. 5 of his profession, persons 3 minutes for general public. We have with that. That work, everybody applicant is don't rubber shull. So we might one. I believe the applicants are okay with And everyone coming to the oath. >> one that will testifying speaking before the board today. Please rise. And raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony evidence or factual representations you're about to get to the plane board during this hearing held this 8th day of October 2025. Are truthful. >> All right. And explanation for a quasi judicial process. Please. Both the today are quasi judicial hearings as you hearing >> is a slightly more former formal hearing that a legislative public hearing there are parties to because I just hearing the parties include the applicant, the city and anyone who has applied for and obtained affect a person's status under the city zoning code. The parties may proffer evidence, testimony, expert testimony and documentary evidence parties have the opportunity to cross examine opposing parties into presented closing rebuttal argument. The decision of the planning board in a quasi judicial hearing must be based on the confidence, substantial evidence in the record and at the beginning of the public hearing board members will indicate if it had any ex parte communication on any of the matters that is contact with any parties outside of the hearing today. So I ask the board members if any of them had ex parte communications. None for me. None for me. Also there are known so we'll move on >> and at this will be reviewing requests from affected persons. If there are any. I do not believe there are any. Okay so we're going to move on to open the public hearing for item number one. And we'll have the applicant come down. And that is. So right there with me. 24 S P 0, 9 Central Gardens. ? And if you could just please introduce yourselves. Joe Freeman, Freeman Consulting. I have been sworn. William Russell see a surge that housing authority. Excellent. Thank you all for having us today. And today I'm here Sarasota Housing Authority and the Sarasota Housing Funding Corporation. >> To discuss a site that were cut. We Central Gardens. We get my act together here. If I could have the overhead, please. You can see this property. They're outlined in red. It's on the Southside of 22nd Street east of Central Avenue. It within the sheriff's own housing authority overlay and it is zoned rmf too. back in. 2023, Boy, Time 5, you may recall that that parcel of one of the parcels was added into the housing authority overlaid by the city Commission designated high-density residential. And so that gives us the ability on that site to go 15 per acre, which is why we're doing the 32 0.9, I think units per acre on this site. Let me show you the site plan. 22nd Street is their central concedes a single building it contains 39 units in a 4 story building. The staff report summarizes the tree removal and presentation a tree and statistics. A lot of trees are being removed. However, no grand trees are being removed. The trees that are being removed are very high quality trees and were mitigating everything on site. So that's a really good thing that we're able to actually replant the trees on site. The unit mix for the 39 units still be 15 one-bedroom units. And 24 2 bedroom units. The project complies with all of the housing Authority overlay district regulations. Traffic generation was deemed him in a mess. I was going to ask the William platt soak last. He had trouble getting here. So let me just quickly up my architect and on could be trouble. you can see the building. It's very straightforward for stories it's not straight that it's got some indications. It's it's a nicely scaled building. You can see how the front of it, you know, and late a little bit. The narrow. So it's very limited on where we could put the building because there's maximum setbacks and the overlay district. So that's why the building is where it is. I mean, it just made Lauch. That's the only place it could be put because there's a maximum 20 foot set back from the it is where it is. I'm going to quickly go through the review criteria for site plans. The first criteria is does the development comply with the various developing regulations? Yes, it does. We obviously wouldn't be here if we didn't regulations. The second criteria can. The design is to design compatible with plan? Well, by meeting other regulations that basically says we're complying with the city plan. I mentioned about the location of the building is pretty well set. Has the information being that can create be enough for review and it does again, we wouldn't be here if we weren't complete and fully reviewed. Can it be changed to mitigate any Again, the building is where it is. We located the building closest to the intersection again because of code This really doesn't create any off-site impacts. The parking lot will be buffer done there in on the South side very well on the east side as well. Can the designed each of them 7 and number number 5 and number both complete deal with parking and loading. We're providing more parking than required by code and loading zone. We comply with clothes so we're we're in good shape in that one. And number 7 relates to compliance with the tree ordinance. And as I said, yes, there are a lot of trees being removed. They are not quality trees, in my opinion, no grand trees are being removed are impacted. So that's a good thing. So again, shorten Pretty straightforward. This is important for the housing authority would think you want to say project >> we've just we've been working on this. >> For a while >> one of the sites was donated to U.S. years and years And then we were finally able to acquire the land to the west of that down the Central Avenue. Now. To accumulate enough to, you know, put some multifamily housing on it. And it's also. Yeah, my board wanted to have. Also have control of the land as well. Just as kind of the southern gateway, if you will, to the existing Jamie's gardens community. So this is going to be right across the street and kind of facing Jamie's garden. So and we also believe that. The amenities of James Gardens will also be available too. Our Central families as well. So there's a clubhouse ERs, a computer allow. There's a There's now a school that's operating of the face or clubhouse. yeah, thank you all. Be nice to incorporate. The central gardens residents and community as well. >> And this is a plan only. So you are making the final recommendation on this one. So hopefully you can support the project and move us that his move forward. questions. Mister Self. No question. Mister Christie. what consideration was given to additional units given the over use of parking in the under use of the zoning. It wouldn't fit. I mean, what what? Well, I mean, it is not a designer. So yeah, out what? Why can't we lose some of that parking on the eastern and and still get another stack of units there without restricting the flow or even the parking on the eastern end of property. All right. With that looked at, yes, it We we need open space. Okay. But this is this is sort of off the main here, this side of the main areas. So we thought it was good to have a little extra parking on this one. >> Because you've got twice as much as needed. And it's not little bit well. understand why so much of the code requires right? Read. it just seems too so that we wouldn't be impacting the neighborhood to the south. But we did look at this and it just didn't work out. units financing Now, also tried to acquire the lot. Are these okay? And that's been a whole nother. Yeah. That was another experience. And I JK want to do yourself. Yeah. Sorry, played a Jags. I don't know what Smith and NZ affordable group. >> But I think the only thing that I would add is one thing is called and another is that the housing authority and it all and I sent and then we all these buildings long term as we collect a lot of feedback from residents and management and a lot of times we try to get, you know, somewhat closer to one to one parking. And so I think between the playground that on there in gress just that's that's what I didn't seem to make You know, ice is a good question. >> Just sit since you touched on. It is or to access points required there with their but another kind of traffic flow configuration that again made of. Maximize some additional space on edge or the other from a mission from trash pickup point the loading. A got fire departments happier with to access. Isn't all that you have is that actually require now? Fire department probably could have gotten away with, but the trash collection just would have been impossible. >> Okay, because we've had to create a huge cul de sac, you know, turnaround for the trash truck, OK? You have no other questions. Thank you. Mister Clement. No questions. All right. I don't have other any questions. I ? >> Afternoon Rebecca certified Planner Development Services. I have been sworn. So this is a safe plan. 24 S P o 9 being proposed for an approximately 1.1 8 acre property located at 14. 42 14. 56 22nd Street. The subject property is currently zoned residential, multiple family to arm of 2 and as a future land use classification of multiple family. High density, the subject property is currently owned by the Sarasota Housing Authority and Sarasota Housing Funding Corporation and is located within the housing Authority over Lee District. The property is located south of the Chinese garden development within the Central Coconut neighborhood. The Jamie's Garden development is currently zoned residential, multiple family. 5 a 5 and has a future land use classification of multiple family, medium density. They're single family home south of the subjects site within the central coconut neighborhood that are zoned rmf too. And future land use classification of single-family. Low density single-family homes that are west of the site are currently zoned residential, single family. 3 are RSF 3 and in the future. Clint Land use classification of single-family, low density, the parcels abutting the subject site to the east are currently vacant and have an existing zone district of of 2 and a future land use and multiple family, medium density the subject property is currently vacant and the applicant is requesting site plan approval for the development of a 4 story. 39 unit, multifamily development. All units proposed are are proposed to be affordable housing units managed by the Sarasota Housing Authority. The proposed development is compliant with all development standards of the zoning code for the IMF to zone district in the housing authority over Lee District. There are a total of 40 trees on site at the time of the tree survey and 39 trees are proposed to be removed from the site. This includes a number of invasive tree species, including for invasive Cuban laurels one invasive queen palm when invasive your tree. 17 Cabbage Palms for Live oaks for strangler. Figs 3 P countries to put a car pastries when Casey a witch has been determined to be invasive. Buyer city arborist when sugar Berry and one Magnolia. The applicant is exceeding the tree mitigation requirements per code. And there are no grand trees located on the subject site. An initial transportation concurrency analysis was completed and determine the produce. A proposed site plan to be de minimis and did not require a full traffic study. The application received development Review committee signed off on September 5th 2025. Steph is found the proposed site plan. 24 S P 0, 9, to comply with all required standards for a view of site plan. Petitions and recommends approval with the conditions as outlined in the staff report. I'm happy to answer any questions. Just >> I just question is regards to the buffer in the back. When this came before us My issue was just the parking lot being at rear of the residential houses better to the south of the property. And what's that? What's besides the trees? What's going to prevent the automobile noise from traveling. Basically at the the bedroom of these individual houses that are to the South. And headlights and all those things. >> Well, I believe that parking spaces are mainly on the northern part of the parking lot. But aside from the trees, that is the buffer and they are meeting the buffer requirements per code. >> So so there's nothing. There's nothing in the code as far as a light. It's just because the trees won't be mature when they the foliage the trees. While. >> For automobile lights. >> There's nothing in the code for that. >> There's not anything in the code for headlights, but there are lighting requirements as far as like the parking lot line on cell phone. And I'm speaking like someone hoops whose parking their car. 2 o'clock in the morning or whatever. And lights are shining into the back of the homes. You know, there's nothing in the code about the headlights. >> does appear to be 6 foot high fence. But I guess the applicant can speak to Yeah, that what type of fences board on board. I don't that's existing or proposed. It seems like the proposed. It's and I think some people, some of the properties that are there of what I saw had they have their own to have their own rent. They have some And I saw I think one. There's a couple different wooden fence and whatnot. But what are what is this project proposing? >> A 6 foot high fence. What type? I'm not sure the for the >> that's my only question wasn't a proponent of putting parking lot of people's backyard, but I think the parking is oriented away from the from you're think the best they look, looks like they're pointed toward the start the new structure. that's that's assuming people Park forward. And it's Boise when the backup human. And I always like the back and because I'm not the best person backing out. This classic. Sarah no backing in rules that. >> There is a fence, though, correct? Six-foot high board onboard fence. >> On South property line. ? And that should block. I have no other questions. Kind of kind of the same corollary from the city side when an applicant comes in with this kind of project. Is there any undertaking by city staff to facilitate or discuss maximizing the? >> Capacity of the site for especially for a tenable for the housing. I know. I mean, as I read. And knowing it's a city goal. And as I read the code, I mean, that would be a benefit to the community and something that. I would hope is discussed or considered. Is that a normal part of the intake process on a site plan for a project of this sort are not, if not, why not? >> It can be part of the consideration, but we're looking at whether the proposal meets technical review per code. Okay. So it's not maximizing something. There's no undertaking by city staff to try to coax a >> additional development capacity on a site like this. Now. Okay. All right. That's it. Thank you. No questions. I do not have any questions. All right. That brings us to citizens since there are no affected persons often up to citizens. We don't have any of those either. Okay. So that will be rebuttal for city staff. Correct for applicant. So I just want to clarify on that southern boundary. We do have a brand new. >> board on board fence. So I'd like to go through it. And even if there's an existing fence on the we're going to be put in our offense with landscaping along that side, that. The trees will be growing. >> And to mister sounds the question. I did speak to hear the neighbors to our South. And one of the concerns headlight lights coming into properties. And that was part of the reason wanted to put a fence up as well. So because technically that would not be required right? Any further discussion. It will close the hearing. I any discussion on that. >> reluctantly moved to. A proven not let the perfect be the enemy of the good hold on a second. still feel that if you modify it. Based on the evidence in the record put the stands review, I'm going to adopt a move that we adopt a motion to find site plan. 24 dash SP does 0, 9, consistent with the. >> True protection ordinance be difficult criteria of 4, Dash 506, of the zoning code and approved petitions subject to the for rated. A recommended conditions in our materials. >> All right, Mister yes. Mister Christie. Yes, unfortunately. Mister Clermont us, Mister. Many yes, motion passes 4 to 0. It's going to the public hearing, which Mireles phase for site plan. 25 dash SP Dash 11. I think the 30 day today. Again, Joe Friedman, Freeman, the talk consulting have been sworn. Chris Gallagher Hood, our tax. Jake, Jake Smith the Affordable Group. Russell serves on housing. Cameras, park face for. >> This will be the final phase here today. representing. Just the housing authority there. The owners of the property. show this map on the other one. This is the overlay district and you can see where this is located within the overlay. That was the property before. But anyway. Get an aerial out here. I can see it. Here's the property outlined in red. I will point out that this little dog leg or whatever you want to call it here has been now. Can taken out of the site and put toward the built Boys and Girls Club? That is leasing these properties here. You'll be seeing that in the future. By the way, they're going to be doing a brand new facility. So it's very exciting about that. So we're here to talk about a site plan in the G's owning district. So you'll be making a recommendation to the city Commission. As I said, this is a 2.0, 1, 4, 5, acre site that's in the overlay zone. G. zoning map is pretty straightforward order to go. It said you can see it's right in the center of that G zoning area right here. Around it by Amaryllis Park. Housing Authority overlay district allows up to 25 units an acre in this case. So this phase is going to include 61 units into buildings. We show you the site plan here. You can see ghosted out is phase 3 down here and then across to some drivers space, too. Here's phase one that's constructed. Phase 3 is under construction right now. Phase 2 is one is actually off the paper there. Oh, that's right. I'm sorry. Phase one is here. This is off a 3. Thank you, Chris. originally was part of phase 3 but was moved into this final phase for a variety of reasons. Gives more units to be developed during this phase funding, etcetera, etcetera. Jake can in William can answer any of that. But it works out really well. And you can see these are the actual grand trees on the site. They were able to work around. So that was really fortunate how that all worked out. These are 3 story buildings, as I mentioned. 61 units into buildings. There are there were 32 single storey buildings on the site before this. So we're going from technically from 31. 32 61. Staff report does summarize the tree numbers say he said. So in this. The unit makes a little 36 one-bedroom units, 13, 2 bedroom and 12, 3 bedroom units. The project complies with all the housing authority overlay district regulations. Someone asked, Chris, if you I know to go into the New Mexican. 36 one-bedroom, 13 to bend and 12, 3. Yeah, I don't have much to Jones said this is the 4th phase that started several years ago with a camera was park place which is faces out an Orange Ave. >> This is original 1940's development here. So it's a he's a well do for renovation. walk like the face to face before regional in Rose Park Place was fussy news. These and more for a family. So these are all walk-ups this completes that there is also when we did phase 2, put in a community amenity center in there as well. So all of these all of these buildings, we use that same community center, the access for these buildings is. A very much already in Greg Street to the West and then the access going out on 21st Street in the north as those already in place to put in place turning. So Greg Court Greg Street was there all along. But phase 2 completed the access and North. these look very much phase 2, again and simple. 3 story buildings again, split evenly to from buildings. One with 25 units, one with 31 units. 36 units. 25 36. So quickly going through the review criteria. Again, the first one do we need to develop and regulations? We do. >> Is a compatible with the city planned. This is obviously part of the housing authority overlay. We're meeting the regulations. So that's consistent with the city plan. All the information has been provided that's necessary for the review. I'm pretty much as far as could this be changed to mitigate any impacts? This all along was really contemplated when the master plan and the whole idea for the redevelopment of Amaryllis Park was going about. >> Pretty much maximizing the number of units being allowed on the site. Basically we're having to have joint use agreement because each little parcel may not comply like this is a little bit more dense. So there's extra density that was here. So we moved it over here. So again, this is all pretty pretty well maxed out. next one is 5, 6, as far as parking. Now in this case, we are not meeting one to one is Jake's as they try to do that. But we do comply with the overall parking requirement, as you can see from the plan. There's quite a bit of parking in the in the whole plan. Effective the overlay again. Thank you. So again, we think we're providing enough parking for the project. And number 7 compliance with the Tree Protection ordinance. And again, this worked out very well where we can work around the 2 grand trees that are there all other trees to be mitigated and again, very exciting to finally see this thing. It started many years ago I can remember the year phase one started. You're just a young child and opened the Emerald Park place up and up. And 22 22 opened So that after construction. So. We're very excited about this. I think I mentioned phase 3 is under construction now. So things are happening out there. He questions. question, but it's not really germane to the site plan, but I'm just curious. >> Mister Russell, who's going to be doing the management of these is that going to be the investor or with the housing Authority be doing management and maintenance Solis. Initially it's going to be in DC as a private management Brinton and they're currently managing emeralds Park Place and Cypress Square right now. >> OK, that's not the investor, but it's it's a management company that. Are co developer. Has hired. >> And how long? How long is that in place for him before the Housing Authority assumes responsibility? >> That's a complicated question. But I mean, technically. Technically we could step in and manage it after stabilization. So for the first 2 or 3 years. But then they would have to accept it. The partnership. Which can get a little if still have developer fees that are owed to them, we'd have to pay them out. And we and then we have to put a operating guarantees to the investor sense, not. It's not a simple thing, but its spot as a So >> from the from the lessons learned from the development Central with Gardens did you all? Any language into the agreement that gives you the ability. 2. Spruce up the place so that it doesn't become dilapidated. So as when the investor is out of the projects, you're not just handed a dilapidated building, sort of kind of like what you can begin with James guarding. >> so one of things. That we changed, you know, Michael's was our first development partner and they own their own management company. And so we kind of learn from that and decided we're not going to. Partner with a developer that on their own management company because if they're not performing, they're not going to the line of fire themselves. But in this case, there's no identity Ventura. So if you know, if NDC is not performing, if they're not maintain the property. We can either step in and take over. We can cause them to be replaced by another manager in Asia. So >> and that can be done without you. paid, correct? Okay. >> All right. Sounds good. But we intentionally did that because. They're not. They don't have any. Financial relationship for ownership. Interest and the current manager, an agent. And so if they need to be changed, they need to be changed. I agree. Okay. Thank you for asking that question. No other questions. Mister Christie. Same issue again, I can tell our materials what our actual capacity would have been at the site, given the acreage. And I realize it's unusual kind of lay out. But you. >> believe testimony, Joel, is that it? You think you've already maximized? But just for the sake of curiosity, what is actual capacity on that site with the existing? Say areas, 14 acres? >> I got to use a magnifying glass. Don't you love I'm sorry. Hold on. You are. if you know the answer, so that could have been 350. Approximately units. I don't know what the total we've got so far. And we're on this site itself where 28 units per acre. So we're over. So right, borrowing right from the other. >> are you know that this was a 2 acre site if you're too 30. >> It's it's a Okay. Says the entire site. science I get that. And then. Again, just a representation is you think you maximize the capacity for this? Yeah, we're actually a little over on this one. because we over sharing density from some of the other. >> And then I didn't see it referenced in or materials except for recommended the joint use agreement essentially. We'll be in place to facilitate shared use of. Dumpster common amenities outside of this actual face for property that are joining entire shared storm water. Get parking a car Okay. didn't understand that you actually exists already started. And how because of the first 3 phases got do. I think that's it. That's all ahead. Think actually had one more question for Are you officially part of a push to make are now? Okay? Just want return. One of the material said you are what you make it was that just has a lot For now. This is dated. February of this year in state. Okay. All right. Just curious. Thank you. Wasn't really relevant. But it had asked Mister Clement. Yes, Reza maintenance goes maintenance right now. Looks really good. How you took the time to drive through there. >> It's a nice sight. It's it's a nice project. It looks more upscale than you might expect. It's good relief to the building. It's colorful as well maintained. I even looked at how it was trimmed, you know, along the building and all that. And it's a place I think that most people would be happy to live. you know, hopefully that continues. So basically that's I don't question just a comment that, you know, for continuing that pattern. I'm all for it looks really nice since the great add to the city. I questions myself. Thanks, guys. All right. Stuff. Good Times cursed survive planner with RBI planning and landscape architecture representing development services. >> I have been sworn. The FDA did a really good summary of But the application is for 25 SP 11 for the Emerald Park Place. Phase 4 located at 21. 0, 1, North Orange Avenue and they're requesting develop to develop 61 multifamily units into 3 story buildings. The site is the portion of the the fate. This phase of the site is 21 or I'm sorry, 2.1, 5 acres and is located in the government G Zone with the future land use designation of multiple family, medium density and with it being located in the genes, I just what we do have a correction for recommended motion. A procession for 501 G. This does go to commission to see you guys be recommending rather than making the the final decision on this. The jeizon typically requires compliance with the most restrictive abutting zone district which in this case would be RSF 4. However, this property is also in the housing Authority overlay district, which has its own development regulations with Shaw. Their proposed site plan. Is it hearing too? The site is owned a main developer, the Surfside Housing Authority Authority is Affordable Housing Project. feet phases. One through 3 have already been Noted in your staff report. We do mention that there was an amendment, which is a 0, 8, which was to shift a building from a previously approved face-to-face for which staff review that had no issue with. And that was approved. The transportation Concurrency analysis determined the site to de minimis in nature. There are no grand trees being removed. Their 13 trees. >> 13 trees are proposed to remove none of which are grand trees will be mitigated with 21 trees which exceeds mitigation requirements. That's the project received ERC approval on September 4th of 2025 and with that staff does recommend emotion recommending approval of 25 SP 11 subject to the conditions outlined in the staff report. And I'm happy to answer any questions you may have. >> Any questions. I just got question in regards this thing about history of that particular property. >> So I do realize they're all the units. There have been elevated. They've bought in significant amount of feel. That area with heavy downpours prior to the development always retained a lot of water. >> So >> now that it's been redevelop, an elevated. It's going to shed all that water into the retention. Why wasn't it draining properly prior to the development? >> I'm not engineer. So I I can't answer that. I'd defer to the applicant's engineer on that. >> Because I'm just curious as to where that water is going to go because with it with state and local building code the slight I got I got yeah. we'll have to be investigated and approved at building permit level. But for further information regarding their storm, water management plan. I would defer to the applicant on I guess, OK? So we're basically where I'm going with this that area. Was known for flooding. Just that particular area right there. So there was it drains at a at a certain point drains and it all goes away. So my question is now that it is elevated. The tributaries that takes it to the bay. Going to be more inundated. Now because before it was training very slowly. So I was just curious as to how they were going to deal with that. Downstream. And just missed curious about it. I do doing that. We know it's going to be inundated more. I mean, is it possible that there's like less impervious? Coverage on the site. Now with my understanding would have to drain at the same level that it did previously. So I would assume and not leave this to the afternoon, but that the water we held managed on site during released of the same rate. >> But again, I would I would defer to their engineers to give further details on that. >> They are showing the storm water sheet C 3. The civil plan. If I can get the overhead. ? The hatched areas. ? It's just showing where it on the state. Yeah. >> That's better for way. >> There's a lot going on, but no, I I would defer to applicant endure for a little more explanation. But no, my understanding would be that it would have to maintain. Current levels and rates that the site seas with the phasing of this city. Obviously, some of this has already started to occur. And so we kind of and there has >> The first I'm really is the. This is the senior building. They have had flooding issues with that one. And I'm assuming it might have been addressed. But the building when it rain, water would come up in the building and they floor drains. And that building. Just just curious, are. Another question. It's worth. trying to hold serve or does come. Mister Christie. That's okay. I guess just a technical. >> Comment or question if there's an existing J J for the site were really wanting to amend the existing one, right? Not a whole new one I believe socially. Read the. This phase. We just have to be included within and amend the city seeing that. Obviously the city gets that as it would be required prior to building permit a in the city is a party to the agreement, OK? just think we might want to tweak or proposed motion to. Make that nuanced point. All right. And the thing for me, thank you. Thank you. All right. brings us to affected persons, They're not about General citizens. So go back to the applicant for rebuttal. >> Did you fill out a speaker card? I. If you fill out a speaker card, you can come down and speak. Mister Limmer. This one goes to the city commission for approval right? Yeah, we're recommending approval. You come up or we'll just we're not recommending approval crop the Holden. The morning. We have to see. have you been sworn in? No. Morning. Raise your hand. >> Do you swear or affirm that the testimony evidence or factual representations you're about to give the plane word this 8th day of October 2025. Are truthful. Yes. And then you speaking with Mike and introduce yourself. >> Yes, I have 3 minutes make an attorney. I have a and goes back to what Mister Salem was saying. Also have a property behind. >> Where they're put in new units and so thank you. At the time. With the ones that's over there since the new units. >> Is there a used to be a ditch ran in front of. The new units. If you go back and look, that did was built in, they stopped maybe about 40 years ago. So when now it rains the from 21st to 23rd Street. And it rains. I call the county the county staff to call the city the city. And got in touch with the budget city. But using send someone out to clean that age. But since the new units has been there. It rains. I mean, any type rain. It comes up. So if they could put pipes in and fan is close in those ditch. I'd be happy. But something needs to be done. That's very >> The storm, what is controlled by? Yeah. you just get you to run around >> Well, that's what they tell a soul. They told me I have to get a city at to get the Because it is in. But we my property and someone else property. But they see it close. The read before where it sinks down on 21st Street. If anybody knows Sarasota, it always was a Dick's there in Iran all the way out to the Bay down open and go around. So this the right road tracks. But anyways, this city did that years ago. 40 years ago. >> So rebuttal from the applicant. Dunn. >> I think us the city has something to say about the citizens it. ? >> So with me here is Mark viewer with. He turned green, but I says he turned green, you know. And the ISS and I haven't worn. Great questions regarding the drainage. The phase 3 and phase 4 was reviewed by the Water Management district as well as the city as well as a whole and actually has received its stormwater permitting, but not only is and we could pull that site. Cleanup. He says. one that was fine. So not only are there new ponds for food come phase 3 and phase 4 were >> permitted for the storm are component together. Not only are their ponds provided at the back. The wrap around here, they're open ponds, but they're also subsurface chamber systems on under about 2 thirds of the parking area as well. That is also added all of that storm. Water infrastructure did not exist. And in the 40's venue. In addition to that during the pro meeting with the water Management district we there because there is some previous floodplain area on there that had to be mitigated independently. So not only do you have the new stormwater management system that has shared by the city does have to be throttled back. So it's discharging get no greater than the pre development rate. So there is no ability to inundate downstream greater than it did in the pre development. But we also have separate facilities mitigating that floodplain compensation area. So it's got both independent functions suits, but it's designed to you address them. Both of those issues as well as in general having less impervious footprint in the post development conditions. And can translate that. Does that mean this is better now than it was before? It should be much they can make again was 0 storm water management or stood We It's not worse than the inundation before, but here. >> It was even also better. And it was even expanded further through the water management district permitting. Thank U.S.. Any other questions. Just to clarify, the the density went up almost 2 acts, but the impervious coverage is less than it was before as a player. >> It is because it was heavily open parking and there were a lot of streets through here that are minimized by. >> Limited drive aisles and that type of thing. >> You've got it. Okay. Thank you. Are a lot more buildings. multi-story and now there's also question about phase one about water backing up and that was corrected shortly after the building is finished to that store on the problem. >> Mister Gallegos, what was your interpretation of shortly? >> Well, let's put it with several years out from their Doesn't know who's in that first year. I want a took a lie. >> The people kept calling me I had some power to make a I got I can't do anything about that. Yeah, I just know that it it lasted. We should stop handing out your cell phone number handed out where I can make thank you. Thank And with that close the public hearing. not up for discussion. There's any know. Okay. Motion. Doctor motion. Find that so plan. 25 just just 11 is consistent with the Tree Protection Ordinance and meets the applicable criteria of Section 4. >> Dash 5, 6, of the zoning code and to approve of the site plan subject to the following conditions, one through 3 on Page 6 of our packet. >> We do need to alter that slightly to recommend approval instead of approved because this will have to go to the city Commission. So we we word that round apologize that should say recommend approval. All right. I was enjoying a little power trip. Sorry about that. The zoning. Yes, So recommended reread. You don't. I don't need to. Really woman did. Yeah. That's got change second it as long as we're also a little clear about that. First. And you made a point with the existing joint use agreement versus a new one which is little ambiguous, distracted from my perspective. >> We will amend the existing Thank you. They are second. Yes, that's my second. And friendly amendment. Mister. Soon. Yes, Mister Christie, yes, Mister Clermont. Yes, Mister. My yes. Motion passes 4 to 0. >> Clarify for the woman that spoke that that is a county issue. The ditch. >> Yes, so some ongoing discussions happening with the city in the county on the whole storm water issue overall, the whole city. So but yes, as of right now, the county is responsible for storm water in the city limits. So work done in the city still require city permits. But they maintain a correct? Yeah. Yeah. So the money is responsible for stormwater management and maintenance of the storm. management system in the city. I can give you my contact to ration and we can talk. >> Thank Think you're awesome. All Okay. So general citizens input. Nobody left seeing none >> and get a consensus on the members of the planning board to approve or modify the meeting minutes from prior meeting. And it looks fine to me can go presentation topics by city staff. >> I have none. >> I thought we were revisiting the CTA sings. So fun. >> We >> restart a couple people I wanted it. Well, I can make presentation about 20 I did reach out to a couple people in putting together like a but I think maybe can I kick this down to the next meeting may sure. And I can do not with Madonna from your aunt, but >> I'm not too much. I mean, we did talk about it on myself in the city attorney and I'm holding a workshop is not in the duties of the board so you wouldn't be able to really hold a workshop yourselves as the planning board. But you can make recommendations to the city commission. So just need to be worth it that way. >> To the city commission, I here. Forthcoming. Okay. That's it. >> had my weird one about e-mails. If we can get some direction on there e-mails, especially the ones that are Brando email or you just asking if you can delete them. Yes, yes, you can delete email us. Thank you. >> But permission to do the >> I just want to make sure I could do it. You can nothing to do with the planning board topic. I don't know anybody else got it. But even planning word related e-mails. You can delete them because they're still all like understood. There's never delete anything. Yeah. Haha. I just want to be able like safely ignored and safely delete it. And not only did OK, thank you. It's it's somewhere in the city. The 3rd just one double check. And that's basically where they want that on your personal enters. Yeah. Yeah. That that e-mail know was yeah. If you got in, get that e-mail. Your tip fortunate if you're not checking your email here, you also better for it. I was a for the record. only went to me. I could buddy else. But I kind of assumed that guy was me out, send it to you then you can believe it. And but cool.
| CITY OF SARASOTA Development Review Division Development Services Department MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE PLANNING BOARD/LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY OCTOBER 8,2025 at 1:30 p.m. in the Sarasota City Commission Chambers | | | --- | --- | | Planning Board Members Present: | Vice Chair Shane LaMay,PB Member Dan Clermont,PB Member Terrill Salem,PB Member Douglas Christy | | Planning Board Members Absent: | Chair Dan Deleo(recused from both items on the agenda) | | Staff Members Present: | John Shamsey,Deputy City Attorney Alison Christie,AICP,General Manager,Development Services Rebecca Webster,AICP,Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services Tom Sacharski,AICP,Planner,Development Services Miles Larsen,Manager,Public Broadcasting John Nopper,Coordinator,Public Broadcasting Amanda Cisneros,Development Review Coordinator,Development Services |
## I. CALL MEETING TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
1:30 p.m.
Acting Chair Shane LaMay called the meeting to order. Alison Christie (acting as the Planning Board's Secretary) called the roll.
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
## III. CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY
No changes to the order of the day.
## IV. LAND USE ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC HEARINGS
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak at the following public hearings will be required to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the Planning Board.)
Deputy City Attorney Shamsey announced time limits, gave the Oath and explained Quasi- Judicial hearings. The PB Members disclosed ex-parte communications.
A. Reading of the Pledge of Conduct
Ms. Christie read the Pledge of Conduct.
B. Quasi-Judicial
---
1. Central Gardens (1442 & 1456 22nd Street): Site Plan Application No. 24-SP-09 request for Site Plan approval to construct a 39-unit, multi-family development on an approximately 1.18-acre site with street addresses of 1442 and 1456 22nd street. The subject property is located within the Residential Multiple Family 2 (RMF-2) Zone District as well as the Housing Authority Overlay District, and has a Future Land Use Classification of Multiple Family (High Density). Vehicular access is proposed via Central Avenue and 22nd Street. All units are proposed as attainable.
(Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services)
## Applicant Presentation:
Joel Freedman and William Russell presented, and Mr. Freedman provided a brief description of the proposed request. Mr. Freedman discussed the location, zoning, the Site Plan, and Standards for Review. Mr. Russell briefly discussed the history of the site.
PB Member Christy posed a question regarding additional units. Mr. Freedman spoke to the question. Jake Zunamon noted that comments from residents were taken into consideration regarding parking, ingress/egress, and amenities.
## Staff Presentation
Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner presented. Ms. Webster discussed the location, zoning, allowable number of units, surrounding parcels and discussed the proposed request. Ms. Webster provided the number of trees to be removed and noted that the proposed request meets all Standards for Review.
PB Member Salem posed a question regarding buffers. Ms. Webster spoke to the question. Ms. Christie clarified the buffer requirements.
PB Member Christy posed a question regarding the number of additional units. Ms. Webster spoke to the question.
## Affected Persons:
No affected persons.
## Citizen Input:
No Citizen input.
## Applicant Rebuttal:
Joel Freedman provided clarification for buffering.
## Staff Rebuttal:
---
No rebuttal.
PB Member Christy made a motion to approve the proposed request. PB Member Clermont seconded the motion. Motion passed 4-0.
2. Amaryllis Park Place Phase IV (0 21st Street): Site Plan Application No. 25-SP-11 request for Site Plan approval to redevelop the approximately 2.55-acre. Phase IV of the Amaryllis Park Place development project will include the demolition of thirty-two existing residential units and the construction of a three-story, 36-unit residential building and a three-story, 25-unit residential building with amenities. All residential units are proposed as attainable. Vehicular access will remain via 21st Street. The site is currently zoned Governmental (G) Zone District and is located within the Housing Authority Overlay District with a Future Land Use designation of Multiple Family (Medium Density).
(Tom Sacharski, AICP, Development Review Planner, Development Services)
## Applicant Presentation:
Joel Freedman, Chris Gallagher, Jake Zunamon, and William Russell presented. Mr. Freedman provided a brief description of the proposed request and discussed the location, zoning, and number of units in each building. Mr. Gallagher discussed the amenities, access, and design. Mr. Freedman discussed the Standards for Review.
PB Member Salem posed a question regarding management. Mr. Russell spoke to the question.
PB Member Christy posed questions regarding maximum capacity on site and sharing of amenities. Mr. Freedman spoke to the questions.
PB Member Clermont spoke to the proposed project.
Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting
Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting
AGENDA
October 8, 2025 - 01:30 P.M. City Hall Commission Chambers
Notice of Meeting Click Here to View Notice of Meeting
I.
CALL MEETING TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
II.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
III.
CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY
IV.
LAND USE ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC HEARINGS NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak at the following public hearings will be required to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the Planning Board.)
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak at the following public hearings will be required to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the Planning Board.)
A.
Quasi-Judicial Public Hearing
1.
Central Gardens (1442 & 1456 22nd Street): Site Plan Application No. 24-SP-09 request for Site Plan approval to construct a 39-unit, multi-family development on an approximately 1.18-acre site with street addresses of 1442 and 1456 22nd street. The subject property is located within the Residential Multiple Family 2 (RMF-2) Zone District as well as the Housing Authority Overlay District, and has a Future Land Use Classification of Multiple Family (High Density). Vehicular access is proposed via Central Avenue and 22nd Street. All units are proposed as attainable. (Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services)
Click Here to View Staff Report
Click Here to View Site Plan
2.
Amaryllis Park Place Phase IV (0 21st Street): Site Plan Application No. 25-SP-11 request for Site Plan approval to redevelop the approximately 2.55-acre. Phase IV of the Amaryllis Park Place development project will include the demolition of thirty-two existing residential units and the construction of a three-story, 36-unit residential building and a three-story, 25-unit residential building with amenities. All residential units are proposed as attainable. Vehicular access will remain via 21st Street. The site is currently zoned Governmental (G) Zone District and is located within the Housing Authority Overlay District with a Future Land Use designation of Multiple Family (Medium Density). (Tom Sacharski, AICP, Development Review Planner, Development Services)
Click Here to View Staff Report
Click Here to View Site Plan
V.
Citizen s Input NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time Citizens may address the Planning Board on topics of concern. Items which have been previously discussed at Public Hearings may not be addressed at this time. (A maximum 5-minute time limit.)
VI.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1.
September 10, 2025
Click Here to View Draft Minutes
VII.
PRESENTATION OF TOPICS BY STAFF Items presented are informational only (no action taken). Any issue presented that may require future action will be placed on the next available agenda for discussion.
VIII.
PRESENTATION OF TOPICS BY PLANNING BOARD Items presented are informational only (no action taken). Any issue presented that may require future action will be placed on the next available agenda for discussion.
IX.
ADJOURNMENT Note: The City s Website address is sarasotafl.gov. Select the meeting under Meetings/Agendas/Video from the Main Web Page to view agendas, videos of meetings, and minutes.
Notice to Public Click Here to View Notice to Public
Showing the first 24,000 of 41,793 characters. The full document is at the source.
to the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America likely for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> we'll do a roll call. Mister Le Mans Mister Clermont here. Mister Christie. President Mister Salem. And Mister DiLeo is not president. And are there any requests for changes to the word of the day? >> Have any myself not know. Thank you, Steph. Okay. serve the pleasure of conduct. >> We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues will not engage in personal attacks. All right. And then suggested time limits for each position. So today we have 2 quasi judicial Is that typically 15 minutes for staff and applicants in 5 minutes for members of the public. >> Actually, the default would be 10 minutes for applicant and 10 minutes for city. 5 of his profession, persons 3 minutes for general public. We have with that. That work, everybody applicant is don't rubber shull. So we might one. I believe the applicants are okay with And everyone coming to the oath. >> one that will testifying speaking before the board today. Please rise. And raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony evidence or factual representations you're about to get to the plane board during this hearing held this 8th day of October 2025. Are truthful. >> All right. And explanation for a quasi judicial process. Please. Both the today are quasi judicial hearings as you hearing >> is a slightly more former formal hearing that a legislative public hearing there are parties to because I just hearing the parties include the applicant, the city and anyone who has applied for and obtained affect a person's status under the city zoning code. The parties may proffer evidence, testimony, expert testimony and documentary evidence parties have the opportunity to cross examine opposing parties into presented closing rebuttal argument. The decision of the planning board in a quasi judicial hearing must be based on the confidence, substantial evidence in the record and at the beginning of the public hearing board members will indicate if it had any ex parte communication on any of the matters that is contact with any parties outside of the hearing today. So I ask the board members if any of them had ex parte communications. None for me. None for me. Also there are known so we'll move on >> and at this will be reviewing requests from affected persons. If there are any. I do not believe there are any. Okay so we're going to move on to open the public hearing for item number one. And we'll have the applicant come down. And that is. So right there with me. 24 S P 0, 9 Central Gardens. ? And if you could just please introduce yourselves. Joe Freeman, Freeman Consulting. I have been sworn. William Russell see a surge that housing authority. Excellent. Thank you all for having us today. And today I'm here Sarasota Housing Authority and the Sarasota Housing Funding Corporation. >> To discuss a site that were cut. We Central Gardens. We get my act together here. If I could have the overhead, please. You can see this property. They're outlined in red. It's on the Southside of 22nd Street east of Central Avenue. It within the sheriff's own housing authority overlay and it is zoned rmf too. back in. 2023, Boy, Time 5, you may recall that that parcel of one of the parcels was added into the housing authority overlaid by the city Commission designated high-density residential. And so that gives us the ability on that site to go 15 per acre, which is why we're doing the 32 0.9, I think units per acre on this site. Let me show you the site plan. 22nd Street is their central concedes a single building it contains 39 units in a 4 story building. The staff report summarizes the tree removal and presentation a tree and statistics. A lot of trees are being removed. However, no grand trees are being removed. The trees that are being removed are very high quality trees and were mitigating everything on site. So that's a really good thing that we're able to actually replant the trees on site. The unit mix for the 39 units still be 15 one-bedroom units. And 24 2 bedroom units. The project complies with all of the housing Authority overlay district regulations. Traffic generation was deemed him in a mess. I was going to ask the William platt soak last. He had trouble getting here. So let me just quickly up my architect and on could be trouble. you can see the building. It's very straightforward for stories it's not straight that it's got some indications. It's it's a nicely scaled building. You can see how the front of it, you know, and late a little bit. The narrow. So it's very limited on where we could put the building because there's maximum setbacks and the overlay district. So that's why the building is where it is. I mean, it just made Lauch. That's the only place it could be put because there's a maximum 20 foot set back from the it is where it is. I'm going to quickly go through the review criteria for site plans. The first criteria is does the development comply with the various developing regulations? Yes, it does. We obviously wouldn't be here if we didn't regulations. The second criteria can. The design is to design compatible with plan? Well, by meeting other regulations that basically says we're complying with the city plan. I mentioned about the location of the building is pretty well set. Has the information being that can create be enough for review and it does again, we wouldn't be here if we weren't complete and fully reviewed. Can it be changed to mitigate any Again, the building is where it is. We located the building closest to the intersection again because of code This really doesn't create any off-site impacts. The parking lot will be buffer done there in on the South side very well on the east side as well. Can the designed each of them 7 and number number 5 and number both complete deal with parking and loading. We're providing more parking than required by code and loading zone. We comply with clothes so we're we're in good shape in that one. And number 7 relates to compliance with the tree ordinance. And as I said, yes, there are a lot of trees being removed. They are not quality trees, in my opinion, no grand trees are being removed are impacted. So that's a good thing. So again, shorten Pretty straightforward. This is important for the housing authority would think you want to say project >> we've just we've been working on this. >> For a while >> one of the sites was donated to U.S. years and years And then we were finally able to acquire the land to the west of that down the Central Avenue. Now. To accumulate enough to, you know, put some multifamily housing on it. And it's also. Yeah, my board wanted to have. Also have control of the land as well. Just as kind of the southern gateway, if you will, to the existing Jamie's gardens community. So this is going to be right across the street and kind of facing Jamie's garden. So and we also believe that. The amenities of James Gardens will also be available too. Our Central families as well. So there's a clubhouse ERs, a computer allow. There's a There's now a school that's operating of the face or clubhouse. yeah, thank you all. Be nice to incorporate. The central gardens residents and community as well. >> And this is a plan only. So you are making the final recommendation on this one. So hopefully you can support the project and move us that his move forward. questions. Mister Self. No question. Mister Christie. what consideration was given to additional units given the over use of parking in the under use of the zoning. It wouldn't fit. I mean, what what? Well, I mean, it is not a designer. So yeah, out what? Why can't we lose some of that parking on the eastern and and still get another stack of units there without restricting the flow or even the parking on the eastern end of property. All right. With that looked at, yes, it We we need open space. Okay. But this is this is sort of off the main here, this side of the main areas. So we thought it was good to have a little extra parking on this one. >> Because you've got twice as much as needed. And it's not little bit well. understand why so much of the code requires right? Read. it just seems too so that we wouldn't be impacting the neighborhood to the south. But we did look at this and it just didn't work out. units financing Now, also tried to acquire the lot. Are these okay? And that's been a whole nother. Yeah. That was another experience. And I JK want to do yourself. Yeah. Sorry, played a Jags. I don't know what Smith and NZ affordable group. >> But I think the only thing that I would add is one thing is called and another is that the housing authority and it all and I sent and then we all these buildings long term as we collect a lot of feedback from residents and management and a lot of times we try to get, you know, somewhat closer to one to one parking. And so I think between the playground that on there in gress just that's that's what I didn't seem to make You know, ice is a good question. >> Just sit since you touched on. It is or to access points required there with their but another kind of traffic flow configuration that again made of. Maximize some additional space on edge or the other from a mission from trash pickup point the loading. A got fire departments happier with to access. Isn't all that you have is that actually require now? Fire department probably could have gotten away with, but the trash collection just would have been impossible. >> Okay, because we've had to create a huge cul de sac, you know, turnaround for the trash truck, OK? You have no other questions. Thank you. Mister Clement. No questions. All right. I don't have other any questions. I ? >> Afternoon Rebecca certified Planner Development Services. I have been sworn. So this is a safe plan. 24 S P o 9 being proposed for an approximately 1.1 8 acre property located at 14. 42 14. 56 22nd Street. The subject property is currently zoned residential, multiple family to arm of 2 and as a future land use classification of multiple family. High density, the subject property is currently owned by the Sarasota Housing Authority and Sarasota Housing Funding Corporation and is located within the housing Authority over Lee District. The property is located south of the Chinese garden development within the Central Coconut neighborhood. The Jamie's Garden development is currently zoned residential, multiple family. 5 a 5 and has a future land use classification of multiple family, medium density. They're single family home south of the subjects site within the central coconut neighborhood that are zoned rmf too. And future land use classification of single-family. Low density single-family homes that are west of the site are currently zoned residential, single family. 3 are RSF 3 and in the future. Clint Land use classification of single-family, low density, the parcels abutting the subject site to the east are currently vacant and have an existing zone district of of 2 and a future land use and multiple family, medium density the subject property is currently vacant and the applicant is requesting site plan approval for the development of a 4 story. 39 unit, multifamily development. All units proposed are are proposed to be affordable housing units managed by the Sarasota Housing Authority. The proposed development is compliant with all development standards of the zoning code for the IMF to zone district in the housing authority over Lee District. There are a total of 40 trees on site at the time of the tree survey and 39 trees are proposed to be removed from the site. This includes a number of invasive tree species, including for invasive Cuban laurels one invasive queen palm when invasive your tree. 17 Cabbage Palms for Live oaks for strangler. Figs 3 P countries to put a car pastries when Casey a witch has been determined to be invasive. Buyer city arborist when sugar Berry and one Magnolia. The applicant is exceeding the tree mitigation requirements per code. And there are no grand trees located on the subject site. An initial transportation concurrency analysis was completed and determine the produce. A proposed site plan to be de minimis and did not require a full traffic study. The application received development Review committee signed off on September 5th 2025. Steph is found the proposed site plan. 24 S P 0, 9, to comply with all required standards for a view of site plan. Petitions and recommends approval with the conditions as outlined in the staff report. I'm happy to answer any questions. Just >> I just question is regards to the buffer in the back. When this came before us My issue was just the parking lot being at rear of the residential houses better to the south of the property. And what's that? What's besides the trees? What's going to prevent the automobile noise from traveling. Basically at the the bedroom of these individual houses that are to the South. And headlights and all those things. >> Well, I believe that parking spaces are mainly on the northern part of the parking lot. But aside from the trees, that is the buffer and they are meeting the buffer requirements per code. >> So so there's nothing. There's nothing in the code as far as a light. It's just because the trees won't be mature when they the foliage the trees. While. >> For automobile lights. >> There's nothing in the code for that. >> There's not anything in the code for headlights, but there are lighting requirements as far as like the parking lot line on cell phone. And I'm speaking like someone hoops whose parking their car. 2 o'clock in the morning or whatever. And lights are shining into the back of the homes. You know, there's nothing in the code about the headlights. >> does appear to be 6 foot high fence. But I guess the applicant can speak to Yeah, that what type of fences board on board. I don't that's existing or proposed. It seems like the proposed. It's and I think some people, some of the properties that are there of what I saw had they have their own to have their own rent. They have some And I saw I think one. There's a couple different wooden fence and whatnot. But what are what is this project proposing? >> A 6 foot high fence. What type? I'm not sure the for the >> that's my only question wasn't a proponent of putting parking lot of people's backyard, but I think the parking is oriented away from the from you're think the best they look, looks like they're pointed toward the start the new structure. that's that's assuming people Park forward. And it's Boise when the backup human. And I always like the back and because I'm not the best person backing out. This classic. Sarah no backing in rules that. >> There is a fence, though, correct? Six-foot high board onboard fence. >> On South property line. ? And that should block. I have no other questions. Kind of kind of the same corollary from the city side when an applicant comes in with this kind of project. Is there any undertaking by city staff to facilitate or discuss maximizing the? >> Capacity of the site for especially for a tenable for the housing. I know. I mean, as I read. And knowing it's a city goal. And as I read the code, I mean, that would be a benefit to the community and something that. I would hope is discussed or considered. Is that a normal part of the intake process on a site plan for a project of this sort are not, if not, why not? >> It can be part of the consideration, but we're looking at whether the proposal meets technical review per code. Okay. So it's not maximizing something. There's no undertaking by city staff to try to coax a >> additional development capacity on a site like this. Now. Okay. All right. That's it. Thank you. No questions. I do not have any questions. All right. That brings us to citizens since there are no affected persons often up to citizens. We don't have any of those either. Okay. So that will be rebuttal for city staff. Correct for applicant. So I just want to clarify on that southern boundary. We do have a brand new. >> board on board fence. So I'd like to go through it. And even if there's an existing fence on the we're going to be put in our offense with landscaping along that side, that. The trees will be growing. >> And to mister sounds the question. I did speak to hear the neighbors to our South. And one of the concerns headlight lights coming into properties. And that was part of the reason wanted to put a fence up as well. So because technically that would not be required right? Any further discussion. It will close the hearing. I any discussion on that. >> reluctantly moved to. A proven not let the perfect be the enemy of the good hold on a second. still feel that if you modify it. Based on the evidence in the record put the stands review, I'm going to adopt a move that we adopt a motion to find site plan. 24 dash SP does 0, 9, consistent with the. >> True protection ordinance be difficult criteria of 4, Dash 506, of the zoning code and approved petitions subject to the for rated. A recommended conditions in our materials. >> All right, Mister yes. Mister Christie. Yes, unfortunately. Mister Clermont us, Mister. Many yes, motion passes 4 to 0. It's going to the public hearing, which Mireles phase for site plan. 25 dash SP Dash 11. I think the 30 day today. Again, Joe Friedman, Freeman, the talk consulting have been sworn. Chris Gallagher Hood, our tax. Jake, Jake Smith the Affordable Group. Russell serves on housing. Cameras, park face for. >> This will be the final phase here today. representing. Just the housing authority there. The owners of the property. show this map on the other one. This is the overlay district and you can see where this is located within the overlay. That was the property before. But anyway. Get an aerial out here. I can see it. Here's the property outlined in red. I will point out that this little dog leg or whatever you want to call it here has been now. Can taken out of the site and put toward the built Boys and Girls Club? That is leasing these properties here. You'll be seeing that in the future. By the way, they're going to be doing a brand new facility. So it's very exciting about that. So we're here to talk about a site plan in the G's owning district. So you'll be making a recommendation to the city Commission. As I said, this is a 2.0, 1, 4, 5, acre site that's in the overlay zone. G. zoning map is pretty straightforward order to go. It said you can see it's right in the center of that G zoning area right here. Around it by Amaryllis Park. Housing Authority overlay district allows up to 25 units an acre in this case. So this phase is going to include 61 units into buildings. We show you the site plan here. You can see ghosted out is phase 3 down here and then across to some drivers space, too. Here's phase one that's constructed. Phase 3 is under construction right now. Phase 2 is one is actually off the paper there. Oh, that's right. I'm sorry. Phase one is here. This is off a 3. Thank you, Chris. originally was part of phase 3 but was moved into this final phase for a variety of reasons. Gives more units to be developed during this phase funding, etcetera, etcetera. Jake can in William can answer any of that. But it works out really well. And you can see these are the actual grand trees on the site. They were able to work around. So that was really fortunate how that all worked out. These are 3 story buildings, as I mentioned. 61 units into buildings. There are there were 32 single storey buildings on the site before this. So we're going from technically from 31. 32 61. Staff report does summarize the tree numbers say he said. So in this. The unit makes a little 36 one-bedroom units, 13, 2 bedroom and 12, 3 bedroom units. The project complies with all the housing authority overlay district regulations. Someone asked, Chris, if you I know to go into the New Mexican. 36 one-bedroom, 13 to bend and 12, 3. Yeah, I don't have much to Jones said this is the 4th phase that started several years ago with a camera was park place which is faces out an Orange Ave. >> This is original 1940's development here. So it's a he's a well do for renovation. walk like the face to face before regional in Rose Park Place was fussy news. These and more for a family. So these are all walk-ups this completes that there is also when we did phase 2, put in a community amenity center in there as well. So all of these all of these buildings, we use that same community center, the access for these buildings is. A very much already in Greg Street to the West and then the access going out on 21st Street in the north as those already in place to put in place turning. So Greg Court Greg Street was there all along. But phase 2 completed the access and North. these look very much phase 2, again and simple. 3 story buildings again, split evenly to from buildings. One with 25 units, one with 31 units. 36 units. 25 36. So quickly going through the review criteria. Again, the first one do we need to develop and regulations? We do. >> Is a compatible with the city planned. This is obviously part of the housing authority overlay. We're meeting the regulations. So that's consistent with the city plan. All the information has been provided that's necessary for the review. I'm pretty much as far as could this be changed to mitigate any impacts? This all along was really contemplated when the master plan and the whole idea for the redevelopment of Amaryllis Park was going about. >> Pretty much maximizing the number of units being allowed on the site. Basically we're having to have joint use agreement because each little parcel may not comply like this is a little bit more dense. So there's extra density that was here. So we moved it over here. So again, this is all pretty pretty well maxed out. next one is 5, 6, as far as parking. Now in this case, we are not meeting one to one is Jake's as they try to do that. But we do comply with the overall parking requirement, as you can see from the plan. There's quite a bit of parking in the in the whole plan. Effective the overlay again. Thank you. So again, we think we're providing enough parking for the project. And number 7 compliance with the Tree Protection ordinance. And again, this worked out very well where we can work around the 2 grand trees that are there all other trees to be mitigated and again, very exciting to finally see this thing. It started many years ago I can remember the year phase one started. You're just a young child and opened the Emerald Park place up and up. And 22 22 opened So that after construction. So. We're very excited about this. I think I mentioned phase 3 is under construction now. So things are happening out there. He questions. question, but it's not really germane to the site plan, but I'm just curious. >> Mister Russell, who's going to be doing the management of these is that going to be the investor or with the housing Authority be doing management and maintenance Solis. Initially it's going to be in DC as a private management Brinton and they're currently managing emeralds Park Place and Cypress Square right now. >> OK, that's not the investor, but it's it's a management company that. Are co developer. Has hired. >> And how long? How long is that in place for him before the Housing Authority assumes responsibility? >> That's a complicated question. But I mean, technically. Technically we could step in and manage it after stabilization. So for the first 2 or 3 years. But then they would have to accept it. The partnership. Which can get a little if still have developer fees that are owed to them, we'd have to pay them out. And we and then we have to put a operating guarantees to the investor sense, not. It's not a simple thing, but its spot as a So >> from the f
5 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.
Showing 5 of 5
CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY
Department: CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY · Topics: land use
ning Board.)
Department: CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY · Topics: roads, housing, land use
V. ces)
Click Here to View Staff Report
Department: CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY · Topics: roads, housing, land use, local-government
.
Department: APPROVAL OF MINUTES
resented that may require future action will be placed on the next available agenda for discussion.
Department: APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Recording and media
Official pages
Records considered
Not claimed by this page
No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.
Canonical record: e619392e7f52949438f23f7ea40716e1. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.
Publisher tools