POLISCOPE

The public record

RIOVISTA (SOLANO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Measure K Oversight Committee - Apr 28, 2025 (Agenda)

Tuesday, April 29, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Measure K Oversight Committee - Apr 28, 2025 (Agenda)

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 241,329 characters. The full document is at the source.

Measure K Oversight Committee – April 28, 2025 Regular Meeting Agenda Page 1 of 2 MEASURE K OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA MONDAY, APRIL 28, 2025 6:00 P.M. – REGULAR MEETING CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1 MAIN STREET RIO VISTA, CALIFORNIA 94571 ZOOM* MEETING ID (CLICK TO JOIN): 844 8492 8847 1. CALL TO ORDER, ROLL CALL 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. ESTABLISHING MEASURE K OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE 3.1 Committee Members’ Oath Of Allegiance 3.2 Selection Of Chair 3.3 Selection of Vice Chair 3. PUBLIC COMMENT (Time Limit – 5 minutes per speaker) Members of the audience may comment on any item of interest to the public within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Committee and any item that is not on the agenda. Each person will be allowed five minutes, or less, if a large number of requests are received on a particular subject, all subject to the Chair’s direction. With certain exceptions, the Committee may not discuss or take action on items that are not on the agenda. If you wish to offer public comment or speak on any item on the agenda, please complete a speaker form (voluntary) and deliver it to the City Clerk prior to the discussion of the item or otherwise indicate your desire to speak to an item. When your name is called or you are recognized by theChair, please stand, make your way to the podium, and present your comments 4. DISCLOSURE OF EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS Committee Members should disclose any communications they have had onapplicable agenda items at this time. 5. ACTION ITEM(S) 5.1 Committee to receive and consider Measure K expenditure proposals, and provide recommendation to City Council 6. ADJOURNMENT The next regularly scheduled Measure K Oversight Committee meeting is Monday, July 28, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. COMMITTEE MEMBERS Jennifer Brizel Danny Lindstrom Richard Loomis Daniel Schindler Ann Sumner City Council Liaison: Walt Stanish

Measure K Oversight Committee – April 28, 2025 Regular Meeting Agenda Page 2 of 2 *The public may participate and provide public comments in person or via Zoom Meeting. Please be advised that when all Committee Members are attending the meeting in person, the Zoom option is provided as a courtesy to the public. If, for any reason, there are technical difficulties, theCommittee meeting will continue in person, provided there is quorum at the meeting. Written comments that are received by 5:00 p.m. on the Monday before the City Council meeting will be disseminated to the City Council and made available to the public for review on the City’s website. Comments sent via email must be sent to ccpubliccomments@ci.rio-vista.ca.us; please provide the agenda item number in the subject line of your email. If you do not have access to a computer, please contact Jen Schultz at 707-374-6451 to make alternative arrangements to submit public comment. Written public comments will not be read into the record. Disclosable public records related to an open session item on a meeting agenda distributed by the City of Rio Vista to the Measure K Oversight Committee are available on the City’s website & at City Hall for public review at least 72 hours prior to a regular meeting and 24 hours prior to a special meeting or, in the event information is delivered to the Committee less than 72 or 24 hours prior to an open meeting, as soon as it is so delivered. To arrange for alternative agenda document format or to arrange aid or services to modify or accommodate persons with a disability to participate in a public meeting contact the City Clerk’s Office 48 hours in advance of the meeting date by calling 707- 374-6451. Pursuant to applicable laws and regulations, including without limitation, California Government Code Section 65009 and or California Public Resources Code Section 21177, if you wish to challenge in court any of the above decisions (including any action regarding planning, zoning and/or environmental decisions), you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing(s) described in this notice/agenda, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. CERTIFICATION OF POSTING – I, Jen Schultz, City Clerk for the City of Rio Vista, declare that the foregoing agenda was posted and available for review on April 24, 2025 on the City’s website and at City Hall, 1 Main Street, Rio Vista, California, in accordance with Government Code §54954.2(a). /s/Jennifer Schultz Jennifer Schultz, City Clerk

SUBJECT: REVIEW MEASURE K FUNDING PROPOSALS AND PROVIDE A RECOMMENDATION TO THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: April 28, 2025 RECOMMENDATION Staff recommend the Measure K Oversight Committee review the Measure K funding proposals and provide a recommendation to the City Council. BACKGROUND The City provided numerous community presentations to inform the public about Measure K prior to the November General Election. As part of the presentation ( Attachment 1) City staff provided some ideas as to how Measure K revenues could be spent. First and foremost, the funds were proposed to maintain existing Police, Fire/Paramedic and General City services. The remaining funding was proposed to be used for any of the following purposes: 1. Improve Roads and Sidewalks 2. Replace Police Station 3. 2 nd Fire Station to improve response times 4. Improve Parks and Recreation Services and Facilities 5. Increase Activities and Services for Seniors 6. Economic Development It was communicated to the public thatthe City would not be able to fund all of these proposed projects. In fiscal year 2025/2026, the City anticipates receiving approximately $1,729,000 of Measure K revenue. Approximately $1,029,000 is needed to maintain the current City police, fire, and general City services, leaving about $700,000 for special projects. It is recommended these funds be used for projects whose costs do not extend beyond the five-year term of funding, even though there are staffing needs within the City. Committee Agenda ReportAgenda Item #5.1April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 1 of 182

DISCUSSION Proposed Projects Include (not in any particular order): • Airport Road Tree Planting Project: 200 trees for Airport Rd streetscape project - $125,000 Justification: There is an existing Class I multi-use path on Airport Road from Church Rd. to Liberty Island Rd. However, the path is rarely used due to a lack of shade. The Rio Vista Active Transportation Plan (ATP) identified the Class I multi - use path to be extended from Church Road to Norman Richardson Drive creating greater connectivity to all parts of Rio Vista. Completing tree planting in this area is the first step in implementing the ATP. • Public Works Corp Yard Modular Building - $275,000 Justification: The City currently leases a modular building at the Corp Yard for $2,148.57 per month. The City could purchase a replacement modular building with a lifespan of 20-30 years, saving the City $240,000 to $450,000 over the life of the building. • Street Repairs - $2,500,000 Justification: While providing presentations regarding the proposed Measure K sales tax measure, many requests for improving road conditions were received. The City Council at their April 15, 2025,meeting approved the Pavement Management System update (Pavement Report)(Attachment 2). The City’s current weighted network average Pavement Condition Index (PCI) is 59, as of January 2025. PCI of 50-70 is in the good category but at the lower end. If we remain at status quo of a $50,000 budget over the next five years, the PCI will drop eight points to 51. Additionally, the maintenance backlog will increase from $6.03 M to $7.22 M by fiscal year 2029/2030. The Pavement Report lists five budget scenarios listing options to improve our PCI. Each scenario reviews how much the City would need to expend each year for the next five (5) years, what our PCI would be at the end of the five years, and what the backlog is estimated to increase to at the end of the five years depending on the strategy applied. To maintain the current average network PCI of 59, the City will need to allocate a total budget of $2.27M, equating to an average annual budget of $455K, for the next five years. Additionally, to increase the average network PCI to 61, the City will need to allocate a total of $2.9M, equating to an average annual budget of $579K, for the next five years. To further increase the average network PCI to 64 at the end of FY 29-30, the City will need to allocate a total of $3.66M, equating to an average annual budget of $732K, for the next five years. The following table summarizes this information: PCI level Total Budget Needs over 5 Year Period Average Annual Budget Need PCI to remain at 59 $2,270,000 $455,000 Increase PCI to 61 $2,900,000 $579,000 Increase PCI to 64 $3,660,000 $732,000April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 2 of 182

To maximize the benefit and provide an immediate impact, the Measure K Oversight Committee could recommend the City Council provide an interfund loan from the Municipal Improvement Fund to allow a larger project in the amount of $2,500,000 be completed in Year 1. Significant cost savings wouldbe experienced by bidding one larger project versus five smaller projects. Doing such would also materially increase the PCI. Measure K revenues received over the next five years would then be used to pay back the interfund loan. • Pilot Sidewalk Repair Grant - $50,000 Justification: In Rio Vista most sidewalks are the responsibility of the adjacent property owner to maintain. Many property owners fail to maintain their sidewalks. $50,000 could be allocated towards a sidewalk matching grant program, whereby the City matches the property owner 50/50. This could help the City become a more walkable community, which is a goal identified within the Economic Development Strategic Plan. • Small Multi-Function Mini Pumper - $450,000 Justification: A mini-pumper can do about 90% of the worka fire engine can do, yet they are smaller, more maneuverable, require less maintenance and are safer to operate. The mini-pumper would also reduce the use of Engine 56 (E56). This would potentially extend its service life and reduce maintenance costs. This does not remove the need for the purchase or refurbishment of E56 and the Ladder Truck (T55). When a second station is built, it will be a first-out unit for the area north of Church Rd. A mini-pumper is a good unit for the gated communities and future wildland interface in the Brann Ranch development. • Shade Structures at City Parks - $340,000 Justification: Based on results of a parks needs survey, the Park and Recreation Commission discussed needs within City Parks at their April 14, 2025, special meeting. 142 responses to the survey were received from residents. Notably, when asked whether additional shade structures would encourage more park visits, 82.98% of respondents answered affirmatively. Among the types of shade preferred, natural tree shading and shade sails emerged as the most popular options. The Park and Recreation Commission recommends the following be funded with Measure K revenues: • Drouin Park: cost $60,000 - Two shade sails are proposed; one shade sail over each bench. • Liberty Park: Cost $190,000 - One shade structure and two shade sails at the dog area are proposed. • Val de Flores Park: $90,000 - Three shade sails are proposed. • Tennis and Pickleball Court with fencing $200,000 Justification: Based on results ofthe park needs survey, the Park and Recreation Commission discussed needs within City Parks at their April 14, 2025 special meeting. A notable number of respondents specifically mentioned the absence of tennis and pickleball courts in theCity's parks, which they felt were essential to supporting an active and engaged community. The Sports & Fitness Industry Association(SFIA) reports that pickleball participation has grown by over 50% between 2022 and 2023, with every age group showing increased participation.The Association of Pickleball Professionals (APP) estimates that nearly 9 million players were attracted to the sport in 2023April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 3 of 182

alone, reports Pickle for Pay. Pickleball is reportedly the fastest growing sport in the United States and can be played by all age groups. Staffing Needs Identified within the City The following positions have been identified as a need within the City to provide better or enhanced services(in no particular order). While these positions are needed, it is recommended that Measure K revenues be used to fund projects rather than staffing positions. • Full-time Code Enforcement Officer - total cost salary and benefits $103,000 Justification: This position is needed to ensure compliance with the Rio Vista Municipal Code. The current Code Enforcement Officer works two days (or less) per week, limiting the number of code enforcement violations that can be addressed to major violators on a complaint basis. One full -time code enforcement officer would be consistent with staffing at similar sized cities and allow the City to more effectively manage code enforcement violations. • Part-Time Administrative Assistant - total cost salary and benefits $27,000 Justification: The City Manager does not have an administrative assistant to assist with day-to-day administrative tasks such as filing, scheduling appointments, responding to inquiries, public records requests, etc. An administrative assistant is needed to allow the City Manager to focus on leadership,visioning, strategic planning, policy implementation, staff management, and improving efficiencies and effectiveness within the City. • 2nd Battalion Chief - total cost salary and benefits $192,000, however, 40% may be funded by other sources Justification: This position would allow the department to maintain 24/7 command coverage. The Battalion Chief positions will cover second or third back-to-back calls, fill in for the Fire Chief when unavailable, improve our participation in County Fire matters at the operations and training level, and retrieve members from hospitals and shuttle equipment. Most importantly, this position would allow the captains and crew to focus on incident stabilization and life safety during emergencies while command, resource management, and incident stabilization are covered by the Battalion Chief. Infrastructure Needs within the City Replacement Police Station and 2nd Fire Station Since Measure K funding is certain for only five years, we could not obtain a loan to fund a second fire station or police station without securing the loan with the General Fund. The Finance Director, however, has other ideas as to how this infrastructure could be funded utilizing the Municipal Improvement Funds and other financing mechanisms, such as USDA Community Facilities Direct Loans. The Municipal Improvement Fund currently has an available fund balance of $7.76M.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 4 of 182

SUBMITTED BY Kristina Miller, City Manager ATTACHMENT 1. Measure K Staff Presentation 2. City of Rio Vista Pavement Management System Update dated March 31, 2025 3. Photos of Shade Structure and Shade Sail locationsApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 5 of 182

Sales Tax Measure • Also known as Measure K • Proposed 1% tax equates to a one cent per dollar tax on taxable goods (not groceries)Attachment 1April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 6 of 182

Fiscal Year 2024/2025 General Fund Budget • The City experienced a deficit of $935, 606 in FY 2024/2025 prior to budget cuts • Does not include any cost-of-living adjustments for employees • City Council directed staff to propose budget cuts to reduce the deficit as part of the FY 2024/2025 budget process.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 7 of 182

Fiscal Year 2024/2025 General Fund Budget • Final Approved Budget Cuts resulted in not funding the following positions: • Fire Battalion Chief • Recreation Supervisor • Public Works Administrative Asst. PT • Human Resources Analyst/Deputy City Clerk PT Along with other Operations and Maintenance cuts within the Fire Department • Still resulted in a deficit ($496,866) • Does not include any cost-of-living adjustments for employeesApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 8 of 182

Why do we need a Sales Tax Measure? • Since 2021 General Fund revenue has only increased 3.4%, while inflation has increased 12.80%* • Cannabis Revenue is declining *Based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index for the Urban West Series Id: CUURS49BSA0April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 9 of 182

8,778,104 9,256,932 9,053,713 9,078,818 61.40% 60.63% 66.58% 69.72% 50.00% 55.00% 60.00% 65.00% 70.00% 75.00% 5,000,000 5,500,000 6,000,000 6,500,000 7,000,000 7,500,000 8,000,000 8,500,000 9,000,000 9,500,000 FYE 2021 FYE 2022 FYE 2023 FYE 2024 The Cost of Salaries (%) is Outpacing General Fund Revenue TOTAL GENERAL FUND REVENUE - GF & MEASURE O General Fund Salaries & Benefits and Shared of County Sheriff Personnel as a % of GF RevenueApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 10 of 182

Staffing and Salaries • From a staffing standpoint operations are very slim. • Volunteer staff operate the front desk of the Fire and Police Departments • Assistant City Manager is also responsible for IT, the only Human Resources employee, and is also the Deputy City Clerk • Public Works Director also oversees Community Development • Finance Department Reorganization in 2023 reduced staffing • Rio Vista ranks close to the bottom (6 out of 7) in terms of employee compensation when compared to other Solano County cities resulting in recruitment and retention problems. • City recently lost 3 employees in the Fire Department due to not providing a competitive salary. • Three rounds of recruitment to fill a vacant Community Service Officer positionApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 11 of 182

Why do we need a Sales Tax Measure? 2024 Median Home Price Sales Jurisdiction Year Median Home Price 1% Assessed Value Rank Benicia 2024 $ 764,000 $ 7,640.00 1 Fairfield 2024 $ 629,314 $ 6,293.14 2 Dixon 2024 $ 612,000 $ 6,120.00 3 Vacaville 2024 $ 609,371 $ 6,093.71 4 Suisun 2024 $ 545,000 $ 5,450.00 5 Vallejo 2024 $ 525,000 $ 5,250.00 6 Rio Vista 2024 $ 461,900 $ 4,619.00 7April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 12 of 182

Where does your money go?April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 13 of 182

Why do we need a Sales Tax Measure? FY 2022-2023 Per Capita Sales Tax Revenue Distribution to Solano County Cities Fiscal Year From Fiscal Year To Jurisdiction Revenue Distributed¹ Population² Per Capita Revenue Generation Rank 2022 2023 Dixon $ 12,562,407 19,143 $ 656.24 1 2022 2023 Vacaville $ 28,905,142 101,918 $ 283.61 2 2022 2023 Benicia $ 6,950,393 26,567 $ 261.62 3 2022 2023 Fairfield $ 30,876,424 119,338 $ 258.73 4 2022 2023 Vallejo $ 18,671,616 123,564 $ 151.11 5 2022 2023 Rio Vista $ 1,349,504 10,375 $ 130.07 6 2022 2023 Suisun $ 2,586,062 28,949 $ 89.33 7 ¹California Department of Tax and Fee Administration ²2022 Census, United States Census BureauApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 14 of 182

Sales Tax Rate Comparison Regional City Sales Tax Rates Antioch 9.750% Benicia +0.5% (Proposed) 9.625% Vallejo 9.250% Benicia Current 9.125% Suisun City +0.75% (Proposed) 9.125% Rio Vista + 1.0% (Proposed) 9.125% Brentwood 8.750% Fairfield 8.375% Suisun City 8.375% Dixon +1.0% (Proposed) 8.375% Lodi 8.250% Vacaville 8.125% Rio Vista Current 8.125% Dixon 7.375%April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 15 of 182

Sales Tax Generation • We need Economic Development! • Average Restaurant $8,000-$20,000 • Average Gas Station $50,000-$75,000 • In order to make-up deficit, we would need 10 gas stations (@ $60,000 each) and 34 new restaurants (@ $10,000 each). • This does not occur overnight.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 16 of 182

• 0.5% would not generate enough revenue to maintain services let alone increase services Why did the City Council elect to move forward with placing a 1% sales tax measure on the November General Election? Estimate of Additional Revenue Percent Increase from 8.125% FY 24-25 FY 25-26 FY 26-27 FY 27-28 FY 28-29 FY 29-30 0.5% 865,000 889,000 914,000 937,000 959,000 980,000 1% 1,729,000 1,779,000 1,828,000 1,873,000 1,917,000 1,960,000April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 17 of 182

Why a Sales Tax Measure? • Sales taxes are paid not only by our residents, but also commuters and visitors that buy gas, visit our restaurants, or shop here • We get to keep 100% of the revenue generated; none of it goes to the State or CountyApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 18 of 182

Details of Sales Tax Measure • Five-Year Sunset Clause • Oversight Committee will review proposed expenditures and revenues then make public recommendations to the City CouncilApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 19 of 182

What Could the Sales Tax Measure fund? Options to include: Maintain Existing Police, Fire/Paramedic and General City Services Improve Roads and Sidewalks Replace Police Station 2nd Fire Station to improve response times Improve Parks and Recreation Services and Facilities Increase Activities and Services for Seniors Economic DevelopmentApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 20 of 182

What if the Sales Tax Measure Does Not Pass • Citywide service reduction to Fire, Police, and other General City Services • It’s dire • Police staffing • Fire/Paramedic Services reduced • Parks and City facilities left unmaintainedApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 21 of 182

What if the Sales Tax Measure Does Not Pass • Public Works • Park and Recreation Services not funded, including overtime for community eventsApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 22 of 182

What if Sales Tax Measure Passes • Dedicate Significant Funding to Improve Roads and SidewalksApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 23 of 182

Road Improvements Improve Pavement Condition Index by 5 points Average funding of $589,753 (based on 2022-2023 figures) is needed per year for maintenance and rehabilitation. The City needs additional revenue to improve the conditions of our roads.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 24 of 182

What if the Sales Tax Measure Does Not Pass • Police Department • School Resource Officer • Code Enforcement • Reduce Sworn Law Enforcement School Resource Officer Code EnforcementTraffic Officer (Currently IOD)April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 25 of 182

What if the Sales Tax Measure Does Not Pass • Fire Department • Reduce Second Engine StaffingApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 26 of 182

Thank you! Any questions? Kristina Miller, City Manager kmiller@ci.rio-vista.ca.us 707.374.6451 ext. 1101April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 27 of 182

P-TAP Round 25 Pavement Management System Update Budget Option Report (Final Project Report) March 31, 2025 Submit to: Metropolitan Transportation Commission & City of Rio Vista Public Works Department Adhara Systems, Inc. 675 N. First St. Suite 725 San Jose, CA 95112 (408) 441-0340 Attachment 2April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 28 of 182

Table of Contents 1.Abstract ..................................................................................................................................... 1 2.Purpose ...................................................................................................................................... 2 3.Definitions and Assumptions....................................................................................................... 4 4.Network Description ................................................................................................................... 5 5.Current Condition ....................................................................................................................... 6 6.Budget .......................................................................................................................................8 7.Budget Needs ............................................................................................................................. 8 8.Budget Scenario ....................................................................................................................... 10 8.1 Scenario 1: Budget Plan - $50K / $5.2K PM 11 8.2 Scenario 2: Maintaining PCI 59 12 8.3 Scenario 3: Increasing PCI to 61 14 8.4 Scenario 4: Increasing PCI to 64 15 8.5 Scenario 5: Zero Funding 17 9.Budget Analysis Comparison ..................................................................................................... 18 10.Comments and Recommendation............................................................................................ 21April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 29 of 182

Appendices APPENDIX A Network Summary APPENDIX B Budget Needs Analysis APPENDIX C Budget Scenario Analysis Reports C-1 Budget Plan - $50K / $5.2K PM C-2 Maintaining PCI 59 Analysis C-3 Increasing PCI to 61 Analysis C-4 Increasing PCI to 64 Analysis C-5 Zero Funding Analysis APPENDIX D Sections Selected for Treatment D-1 Budget Needs D-2 Budget Plan - $50K / $5.2K PM D-3 Maintaining PCI 59 Analysis D-4 Increasing PCI to 61 Analysis D-5 Increasing PCI to 64 Analysis APPENDIX E Decision Tree APPENDIX F GIS Report APPENDIX G StreetSaver Budgeting Overview APPENDIX H Survey & Quality Management ReportApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 30 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 1 Budget Options Report 1. Abstract Metropolitan Transportation Commission (“MTC”) has contracted with Adhara Systems, Inc. (“ADHARA”) for its Pavement Management Technical Assistance Program (“P-TAP”) and assigned ADHARA to the City of Rio Vista, California (“CITY”) for its P-TAP Round 25 Pavement Management System (“PMS”) Update Project (“PROJECT”). The Project includes updating the CITY’s PMS database in accordance with the MTC StreetSaver Online Pavement Management Program. CITY manages 170 sections, 27.31 centerline miles (55.01 lane miles, 4.62 million ft2) of road network. CITY also has 1 unmanaged section, 0.03 centerline miles (0.06 lane miles, 3.2 thousand ft2) of road network. Through the PROJECT, a total of 31.74 lane miles (12.5 feet wide) were evaluated for 27.31 centerline miles of CITY’s managed network between November 2024 and December 2024. Total sampled and evaluated area was 2.09 million ft2 out of the total inventory area of 4.62 million ft2 (45.2%). Sections without M&R uploaded to the final inspection units file. The CITY’s current weighted network average Pavement Condition Index (“PCI”) is 59 as of January 12, 2025. This PCI rating places the CITY’s street network condition in “the GOOD” (50<=PCI<70) category. This report analyzes the CITY’s Budget Needs along with additional budget scenarios that CITY may want to apply to the future M&R plans. CITY reviewed treatment types and costs in the Decision Tree (see Appendix E). CITY selected 3% inflation and 3% interest rates to calculate the CITY’s Budget Needs. CITY’s Network Replacement Cost is $22.18M. The Budget Needs analysis determined that CITY needs $8.49M to eliminate all deferred M&R over the next five years. This analysis indicates that CITY’s network PCI will be 83 at the end of FY 29-30 with unlimited and flexible funds. If the CITY follows the budget plan established during the last P-TAP project, allocating an annual budget of $50K, including $5.2K for allocated for Preventive Maintenance (PM) over the next five years, the average network PCI will drop to 51 by the end of this period. Additionally, the maintenance backlog will increase from $6.03M at the end of FY 25-26 to $7.22M by the end of FY 29-30.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 31 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 2 Budget Options Report To maintain the current average network PCI of 59, CITY will need to allocate a total budget of $2.27M, equating to an average annual budget of $455K, for the next five years. Additionally, to increase the average network PCI to 61 at the end of FY 29-30, CITY will need to allocate a total of $2.9M, average annual budget of $579K, for the next five years. To further increase the average network PCI to 64 at the end of FY 29-30, CITY will need to allocate a total of $3.66M, average annual budget of $732K, for the next five years. If $0 is allocated for maintenance and rehabilitation for the next five years, the average network PCI will fall to 49 and maintenance backlog will grow to $6.72M at the end of FY 29-30. All the calculations for the required budgets and average network PCI values are performed by the StreetSaver Target Driven Budget Scenario module. 2. Purpose The purpose of this report is to assist CITY in utilizing the results of the field survey data and budget options analyzed in the PMS. This report assesses the adequacy of the budget and identifies a practical budget scenario that meets the M&R needs recommended by the PMS program and that will improve the CITY’s M&R strategies over the next five years and compares this cost to the CITY’s the budget. The following criteria were used in identifying a practical scenario:  PCI value: Improve or maintain average network PCI.  Cost-effectiveness: Allocate more funds to arterial/collector roads than residential roads with appropriate PM ratio  Affordability: Provide a realistic expenditure plan that can stabilize Deferred Maintenance or minimize increase. The process of generating the budget option reports is designed to provide a robust pavement maintenance program for the CITY, guided by StreetSaver, the framework provided by the MTC. The overall process unfolds in the following stages:April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 32 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 3 Budget Options Report 1) Framework Establishment: MTC provides a structured approach for CITY to formulate their pavement maintenance programs, ensuring consistency and efficiency in maintaining road quality. 2) Maintenance Needs Assessment: Initially, the CITY’s complete maintenance requirements are assessed, assuming there are no financial constraints. This theoretical exercise helps in understanding the full extent of maintenance work needed to keep the CITY’s pavements in optimal condition. 3) Budget Scenario Analysis: Subsequently, various budget scenarios are examined. Each scenario is presented with its projected performance outcomes. This analysis is useful for understanding the impact of different funding levels on pavement conditions. 4) Strategic Budgeting: The insights gained from the scenario analysis are provided. This can be utilized as a foundation for future planning, allowing the CITY to optimize its budget while remaining aligned with financial resources and pavement system objectives, ensuring that the most effective and efficient use of funds is achieved. This structured process enables the CITY to make informed decisions, prioritize spending, and ultimately achieve a sustainable pavement maintenance program that meets the community’s needs and expectations. Appendix G provides more information on how the StreetSaver program’s budgeting module works.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 33 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 4 Budget Options Report 3. Definitions and Assumptions Deferred Maintenance: Maintenance backlog. The dollar amount of maintenance and rehabilitation work that should have been treated, but funding was not allocated. Inflation Rate: 3% Interest Rate: 3% PCI Treated: Future PCI value with budget allocation. It shows PCI trends with limited or unlimited budget. PCI Untreated: Future PCI value without budget. It shows PCI trends “what if there is no fund for certain period of time”. Preventive Maintenance (“PM”): Any treatment that extends pavement life more than five years and is applied to road sections with a PCI of Condition Category I. Common examples of PM include slurry seal, Microsurfacing, chip seal, cape seal, etc. PM %: Preventive and Maintenance amount vs. total budget. In order to have a balanced budget in budget scenarios, PM % might be varied. Treatment scenario also influences the PM ratio. Excess Rehab Funds: Unused amount of budget that is allocated to Rehabilitation. It is set to be used for PM. Stop Gap: Dollar amount of temporary repairs applied to maintain the pavement in a usable condition (e.g., pothole repair). These repairs are temporary and do not extend the pavement life. Allocated PM funds will be used. Stop Gap Interval: Number of years between applications of Stop Gap treatments that are applied to Deferred Maintenance sections. Set to five years in this report. Surplus PM: Total amount of budget that is not used after Preventive Maintenance funding is allocated.April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 34 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 5 Budget Options Report 4. Network Description CITY’s managed network consists of 27.31 centerline miles, 55.01 lane miles, 4.62 million ft2 of street, or 170 pavement sections. Table 1 and Figure 1 summarize the network inventory by functional classes. The network breakdown is as follows: Functional class No. of Sections Centerline Miles Lane Miles Area (1,000,000 ft²) Area (1,000 yd²) % of area (Weighted) Arterial 7 1.16 2.33 263.29 29.3 5.7% Collector 30 9.71 19.42 1,581.24 175.7 34.2% Residential 133 16.43 33.26 2,776.12 308.5 60.1% TOTAL 170 27.31 55.01 4,620.65 513.4 100.0% Table 1. Summary of the CITY's Network Figure 1. Inventory Information 7 1.16 263.3 29.3 5.7% 30 9.71 1,581.2 175.7 34.2% 133 16.43 2,776.1 308.5 60.1% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% No. of Sections Centerline Miles Area (1,000 ft²) Area (1,000 yd²) % of Area (Weighted) Residential Collector ArterialApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 35 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 6 Budget Options Report 5. Current Condition The current weighted average PCI of the CITY’s network is 59 as of January 12, 2025, placing the CITY’s network condition in the “GOOD” (50<=PCI<70) condition category. The following table and figure show the CITY’s network statistics in terms of the PCI rating categories. The PCI rating categories are from StreetSaver Online. PCI Ratings No. of Sections Centerline Miles Area (1,000 ft²) Area (1,000 yd²) % (Area) Very Good (70<=PCI) 67 11.1 1,879.31 208.8 40.7% Good (50<=PCI<70) 37 7.2 1,326.67 147.4 28.7% Poor (25<=PCI<50) 27 3.1 550.68 61.2 11.9% Very Poor (PCI<25) 39 6.0 864.0 96.0 18.7% Total 170 27.3 4,620.65 513.4 100.0% Table 2. PCI Rating Category for the Entire Network As the illustration shows, the conditions of 67 out of 170 sections, 40.7% in area, are categorized as “VERY GOOD” (70<=PCI) and 39 sections, 18.7% in area, are in “VERY POOR” (PCI<25) condition. Figure 2. PCI Rating Categories for the Entire Network 67 11.1 208.8 37 7.2 147.4 27 3.1 61.2 39 6.0 96.0 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% No. of sections Centerline miles Area (1,000 yd²) Very Poor Poor Good Very GoodApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 36 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 7 Budget Options Report The following illustrates the weighted average PCI of the CITY’s network by functional class. Functional Class No. of Sections Weighted Average PCI Centerline Miles Area (1,000 ft²) Area (1,000 yd²) % of Area (Weighted) Arterial 7 60 1.16 263.3 29.3 5.7% Collector 30 63 9.71 1,581.2 175.7 34.2% Residential 133 57 16.43 2,776.1 308.5 60.1% Total/Average 170 59 27.31 4,620.7 513.4 100.0% Table 3. Weighted PCI Average by Functional Class Figure 3. Weighted PCI Average by Functional Class 60 63 57 59 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 Arterial Collector Residential Total/AverageApril 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 37 of 182

City of Rio Vista, P-TAP 25 Pavement Management System Update March 2025 8 Budget Options Report 6. Budget CITY has a previously established budget plan with an annual budget of $50K including $5.2K allocated for preventive maintenance (PM). If this plan is implemented, the proposed funding for the next five years is detailed in Table 4. Funding FY 25-26 FY 26-27 FY 27-28 FY 28-29 FY 29-30 TOTAL Total M&R ($ thousand) $50 $50 $50 $50 $50 $250 PM Only ($ thousand) $5.2 $5.2 $5.2 $5.2 $5.2 $26 Table 4. Budget Plan of $50K with $5.2K PM 7. Budget Needs Based on the principle that it costs less to maintain roads in good condition than bad, the MTC PMP strives to develop a maintenance strategy that will first improve the overall condition of the network, and then sustain it at that level. The first step to calculate the Budget Needs is to develop a cost-effective M&R strategy by determining, assuming unlimited resources, the maintenance “needs” of the CITY’s road network. Using the Budget Needs module, maintenance needs over the next five years were estimated at $8.49M. If the CITY follows the strategy recommended by the program, the average network PCI will increase to 83 at the end of FY 29-30. Selected sections to eliminate maintenance backlog are listed in Appendix D: Sections Selected for Treatment – Budget Needs. If, however, no maintenance is applied over the next five years, roads already distressed will continue to deteriorate and the average network PCI will decrease to 49. The results of the Budget Needs analysis are summarized in the table and figure below. Appendix B presents the Budget Needs Analysis report in detail. FY 25-26 FY 26-27 FY 27-28 FY 28-29 FY 29-30 Total Rehab $5,672.1 $524.1 $370.7 $822.0 $597.1 $7,986.0 Preventive Maintenance $414.5 $23.6 $8.4 $50.9 $6.2 $503.6 Budget Needs $6,086.5 $547.7 $379.2 $872.9 $603.3 $8,489.6 Deferred Maintenance $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 Treated PCI 84 82 82 83 83 Untreated PCI 59 56 54 51 49 Table 5. Summary of results from Needs Analysis ($ in thousand)April 28, 2025, Measure K Oversight Committee meeting - Item 5.1 - Page 38 of 182

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Measure K Oversight Committee - Apr 28, 2025 (Agenda)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e5ea87e63938efd9ff19a646f847929b. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record