POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Tuesday, March 19, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 213,548 stored characters

>> test miami-dade . >> it's the first day of spring, man. Trying to keep up with you, my man. We got a lot of very honorable women here for women's month so guys, please keep it down. We are in women's month so we're going to have a beautiful and respective presentation with chief edwards. Commissioner hardemon has some presentations today so without further ado mission or. >>commissioner hardemon: wall that beautiful bing footage. . >> MS. Carter served over 13 years in the brownsville area. After graduating from nursery school in north carolina she joined other black nurses a houston hospital, the first black hospital in miami. When the hospital relocated to the brownsville community in 1939 she was able to walk to work. She then became one of the lead nurses of miami's first black pediatrician , doctor simpson whose officers are located in liberty city. She cared for children for 30 years. Among her duties MS. Callier was a long-standing member of the brownsville neighborhood association. More alice is the marketing manager at the center. Through her career she spent engaged in work collecting residents of the community to healthcare services as well as members of the migrant community. She is a proud member of the women's community of the chamber of commerce and is a member of the roberto clemente park. Catherine mizell along with her husband dan is the founder of the fountain blue residency which offers artists a place to live and work in miami. Their passion for art has led them to support over 300 artists fom around the world. Mizell has been featured on hgtv, miami magazine and the miami herald and currently has one of florida's most important contemporary art collections. Esther lubin was born in haiti and came to the united states in the late 1970s. As a renowned haitian-american figure business leader a wife and mother, she has successfully managed and operated lubin's discounts apply and together with her husband esther has elevated and provided services to the little haiti community for over four decades. When you say community health care , and he served as PRESIDENT And ceo of the jesse trice community health center for over 19 years. She was deputy secretary of health and chief public health nurse of the florida department of health. Serving as executive administrator of miami-dade health department she is a decorated healthcare professional and loyal civic leader with four decades of experience. Ladies and gentlemen, put your hands together and please welcome this year's women's history month recipients. [Music] >>commissioner hardemon: we obviously owe them a huge congratulations for all the accomplishments they've made so far. But I'd also like to give a huge shout out to my staff for creating that wonderful video. And you give them a round of applause? They really stepped it up. [Applause] And what I'd like to do is I thought I was going to give each one of them out but it's okay. So what I'd like to do instead is offer them a few words if they'd like to say something to the crowd and the honor they've been able to accomplish so I'll start. >> it's such an honor and pleasure to be here and to see you speak as I had the pleasure of seeing you speak about the arts and how you speak about your family and the importance of your role in leading this community it moved me to my core so thank you, it's an honor to be here with you and I want people to be inspired by the arts. I want you to see the power of art to change our lives, to change how we view one another and move through this world and I do that by bringing artists in from around the world and open up the studios to artists throughout miami-dade county so hopefully you will come and take advantage of all the free events we have delta arts. >> thank you so much for having me here. We appreciate your support of the center and we remember you from being there with us and I'm grateful to be here and thank you. . [Applause] Good morning you all. Thank you commissioner, to the CHAIRMAN Of the commission, this is such an honor to be honored doing women's history month. But it also is such an honor because this ends my 19 years at the jesse trice community health system. We are here to keep you healthy . And I am most proud to tell you I am being seceded by ryan hawkins is born and raised miami and will keep the legacy of jesse trice community health system and this community in keeping you healthy. Because prevention and primary care is what it is. If you don't have your health you don't have anything. Thank you and GOD bless all of you. [Applause] >> MS. Callier couldn't be here today but on behalf of the brownsville civic association we accept this award on her behalf . Thank you guys. >> thank you commissioner. Thank you to your staff. Esther lubin and michelle lubin and their five children , we have 13 grown kids at the sight of my husband we were working for many years. We accomplished a lot of things. I'm sorry if I talk like that. I wasn't going to talk. As I say we accomplished a lot of stuff. We do everything many people who were supposed to do but we do it alone for many years. And two of them are there. They're so proud of us. Thank you very much. [Applause] >> let me say thank you, your thanking us but we thank you because the tapestry of our greatness is actually woven by each of you and your stories and efforts and work , your love for people, this is who we are. Women's history month is a time we take to acknowledge it but we should acknowledge it every day and you all please event a round of applause. >> a picture. >> let's go with the cell phones first. >> let's go with the cameras please. Middle. >> were going to rearrange. >> while they're doing that I want to say to the ladies on behalf of mme. Mayor who was unable to be here this morning , she asked me as chief edwards to sep in and say congratulations and thank you for your service so I want to make sure her voice is heard. >>... >> your new shoes are very nice . >> I have this new bopper I shine with. >> good morning again everyone. Good morning again everyone. Again I'm oliver gilbert, chair of the board of county commissioners, this is the presentation portion and our next presentation on what to recognize commissioner cabrera asked to go forth and it is the vilomah awards. This is to recognize someone who's lost a child but through that tragedy they create extraordinary things. Commissioner cabrera you are recognized. >> I'd like to call up andres and melissa fernandez. They turn that grief into something better for our community and they unfortunately lost their daughter in 2022 in a tragic boating accident at the age of 13. Lucy fernandez as you all might have heard. And they turn integrating the lucy fernandez foundation. And what did they do? Not only do they provide learning opportunities for children all over our county will provide building awareness to make sure that no other parents has to deal with the same tragedy. And in making sure wherever they MAY be that they know all the different precautions you should be taking to make sure that you're safe and that you're doing these things in a safe manner that no one has to go through this and I do want to turn I over to them. >> thank you commissioner. [Applause] CHAIRMAN, vice CHAIRMAN And the rest of the commissioners, we are honored and we are honestly humbled by this recognition . You know, losing our daughter lucy shook this family but it also impacted this community. And we thought of no better way of honoring her legacy which was really unfinished and by forming the lucy fernandez foundation. And while the foundation has several initiatives one of our main initiatives is motor watercraft safety. Lucy love the water. It was her absolute favorite place . We are a family of boaters area we've been boating for decades but when I learned how to vote was different times. The books now are a lot bigger, they're a lot faster. And it really has become a dangerous environment. So our goal through the foundation and our initiatives is to make sure that next generation of boaters are prepared, certified and trained . And through the foundation we are going to move that needle so thank you for this recognition . [Applause] >> I look out into the ground and I see so many beautiful people, mothers, fathers , grandmothers, grandfathers. Losing a child is really the most unimaginable loss that a parents and a family can go through. The fact that we get to say her name every day, talk about her every day , bring her story forward and hope that we can prevent another family from going through this, there's nothing more precious in our lives than our children and the futures that they dreamed and the hopes that they had. And the fact that the commissioners and the cities and all of you honor something as hard as this, grief is just so lonely and so difficult but in being able to find purpose and meaning and through the foundation through our initiatives, through all the awareness and the fights that we have ahead, it gives us a sense of healing and we're very grateful to our community. We are grateful to all of you for today , to all of you commissioners. Thank you so very much. And I hope that you look up the foundation, lucy fernandez foundation.Org and join our movement. Whether you're a boater, a passenger, you're the main operator , it affects everyone and we need to protect our children and keep this city safe. And it starts by education and awareness. But as a parent are grateful , we thank you and we're very honored for this opportunity. >> thank you for the strength I know it takes to come here and really is the story and for the great work you do in our community. >>chair: thank you for the work you're doing. As a county we understand we can never truly grasp your pain but what's come from that, educating, making sure no one else goes through what you have is important so please give another round of applause. Let's gather for a photo. Chief, would you like to have a word? >>mayor: the only word I can think of is joy comes in the morning. She would have a hard so I will transfer a hug from mayor eileen cava to you through me but I do know joy does come in the morning. >>chair: thank you. Before we start the next vilomah award I'm going to ask for the chambers to be qiet. If you have to talk, over to my left if you will have to speak please go outside of the chambers. Please go outside of the chambers, if you have to have a conversation right now have a conversation outside. In FEBRUARY 2016 a young boy who was just being a young boy , I can't emphasize that enough. He was just being a young boy. He was killed by a stray bullet. His name was jane carter. But every account he was the most beautiful kid. Energetic, loving, everyone who met him just adored him. through that tragedy which I truly can't imagine being a father, his parents monica and sonja carter actually created a program that helps educate and train kids in the fashion industry. They do after school, they do summer. They do toy giveaways. Because it was their mission to make sure this wonderful young boy who never got the chance to feel the magnificence that is life, that his legacy would be something greater. They do that and today is my pleasure to present the vilomah awards to them so please come off. [Applause] >> how's everybody doing? It's overwhelming and so difficult burying a child especially at the ripe age of six years old. FEBRUARY 2016 I can recall like yesterday he was making a shirt for a client in my living room and my son asked me for a dollar, I gave him three dollars and he walked outside the door owing to the candy lady , a funeral down from where we stayed and I heard like nine shots and I ran outside and found my son in a pool of blood with the three dollars I gave him with his eyes wide open. But that FEBRUARY 25, a funeral down from where we stayed and I heard like nine shots and I ran outside and found my son in a pool of blood with the three dollars I gave him with his eyes wide open. But that FEBRUARY 25, 2015 my son was able to go get toys out with us a couple months before god called him home we had our finished toy drive and he understood that importance of giving, embracing people who don't have it from our community. We been doing our efforts and the tragedy with king in our lives was highlighted and more people scoped in on us but I think all the commissions were honoring us and thinking about giving us such a prestigious award and assisting us in any way they can do. We get up every night and visit the children's hospitals, ymca, boys and girls club, youth detention centers. We visit private schools, everywhere like we're just putting in our work making sure our son out of which came came and if you showed king the way to be raised you know how to kick take care of a queen and show a queen how to go in a righteous way. [Applause] >> good morning, my nme is monica carter and I want to tell everybody thank you for looking out for us. We were in the same room getting our name and nobody didn't say no and the first thing when it happened you were there. You've always been there for us, never turn your back on us and you've always helped us from day one so I appreciate you and I appreciate everyone of you looking out for us because it's hard. It's very hard to get up and know that your child is not there. Every time somebody says his name I break down crying because I wasn't there. I was at work. And so from then on when they told me be strong, I stand up crying. It doesn't matter , if a kid reaches out to me I look out for them. We tried the kids I saw there were 1617 years old they were lost so they gravitate to the age of those kids so they will be lost. The love is lost in their home so we needed that. Thank you. >> one more thing. [Applause] For those kids who was in the act that caused my son to die the shooter wanted to talk to me and I wanted to talk to the shooter, he was lost. I want to go sit with him and me touching his kee close as you can be to have a heartfelt conversation with this kid because he still a young kid. When they were incarcerated, with me and my wife and my program when he told you with the fashion you've taken on everything for fashion to what we're looking at to what we hear so in our program we engage in helping them create new fashion , audio recording, visual recording, just bringing out a safe haven so they can bring out their niche in them so thank you so much. >> chief, would you like to say something? >> for this family your story touches my heart. I lost my brother to violence at a young age and had to watch my parents bury their son and it is not kind and it's difficult but what you are doing is what god intended for you to do which is to reflect a beacon of hope, to show resilience , grace and love and everyone in this chamber is grateful for you fulfilling your purpose and your child's purpose so on behalf of mme. Mayor I will also transfer the hug from her through me to you. When the commissioner that started this award in 2018 did this I can't even imagine he thought we would even have the opportunity to honor people. My hope is that one day we won't. But in the meanwhile please do everything you can to protect our community and continue to show love. >> can we take one step back please? >> let's go cameras. Camera. >>... On three, one, two, three. . >>chair: county commission meeting will begin in two. >>chair: the people in the red shirts, there is no public hearing for this on the agri-tourism. >> good morning, commissioner bastien. Commissioner bermudez. [Roll call] 10 members present, you have a quorum . >>chair: sergeants, secure the chambers. Please rise for invocation and pledge of allegiance. And GOD today on this day we've never seen before and will never see again we ask for your grace, guidance, your love are these your people. Keep us in your willingham , make us so we are good stewards and pool resources we are preparing to our community and make it so that we are good leaders of this community, a man. >> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under GOD indivisible with liberty and justice for all. . [Inaudible] >> good morning martin attorney . >> good morning . >> I think it's probably an appropriate time for us to move to the reasonable opportunity to be heard. >> okay. So reasonable opportunity to be heard is not available, if you would like to be heard, hopefully you've signed up at this point. Come to the podium, give us your name, your address and you will have two mnutes. Just a couple of ground rules for the audience. There's some things that we don't do, we don't actually laugh out loud in the audience, if you disagree with something you frown and you smile. If you, we tried to get the people at the podium speaking respect so and will make sure they give you when you stand up . We do not do outbursts of any type in the chambers so I appreciate your compliance with these guidelines. I'm going to call names, please sign up behind the podiums and you will have two minutes. >> even messiah, anthony l castro. Daniel rodriguez. [Reading names] >> good morning everyone, my name is anthony alec castro, 5150 >> good morning everyone, my name is anthony alec castro, 5150 collins avenue in miami beach. And I wanted to have the opportunity to address the commission. I asked the commission to reject the resolution of 11 to 8, that is the termination of the atm contract and ask you to reject it and reject the termination for straightforward reasons. The first reason is that the vendor in this case unix traffic which I am a proud employee is fulfilling the terms of its contract area and that is not an alternative of the three alternatives that are being presented to the commission this morning. Secondly, after three years of performance of the contract I see it as a citizen over in miami-dade as a tremendous waste of money of the taxpayer money to try to change something that is in effect working. And of course as a person who drives around the county a termination of the contract and trying to rstart it after three years is going to lead to tremendous delay so both from a funding perspective and delay I urge you to not vote for this. Finally I'd like to make a point this is a complex project and I want t make sure the commission has an opportunity to review and an objective fashion all the materials. I think there's only one side of the story being told at this point which is the county's view which we respect but I think it's important there are fresh and independent eyes that look at this matter. So I thank you for your consideration and ask that you either reject the proposal out right or take time to seriously get into the matter and hear all sides of the contract. Thank you vry much. >> I am a resident of 129 southwest 79 miami-dade florida here to stay to reject the termination of the itm contract . As I truly believe that's going to be a huge loss to taxpayers. The prediction about the hundred $50 million that's been a huge loss. Especially right now, the project is moving very fast as much as possible. As you know every week there are 50, 60 assets testing , sign and seal . In fact just last month 200 assets are installed. From the time last SEPTEMBER cei starts to provide 40 assets and average weekly, unix tracker traffic are able to migrate over 80 assets. The assets are already migrated. And out of 1400 out of 1800 assets already requesting ci. It means we have a clear path that these 1400 assets will be released for construction in a matter of a few weeks. So if there is not any issues like cabinet issues , it's out of the contractor's hands. I really believe these assets can be installed in a few weks and thank you fr considering my objection and I really would like to object for termination of the contract. >>chair: thank you. Morning commissioners, I'm here to put a face to the engineering aspect of this contract and local business aspect. >> give me your name and address first. >> my address is 8135 nw. 35th ln. Doral florida. I'm here to put a name and a face to the impact this contract has overall on miami-dade county. I want to talk to you about the success for local business and for us as an engineering firm area hundred 23 patents signed and sealed in four months. Migration over 176 migrations completed, 367 testing done. In four months. What that means is you are translating this contract into success for people living in miami-dade county. The other aspect is also give us the benefit of the doubt. This contract is employing full-time overton engineers in miami-dade county and those engineers, those jobs are high-paying jobs that could possibly be lost with this change. Hbc is a small business. We successfully working on this contract ask that you please allow us to complete this project and to get it done on time and on schedule and I believe we are trying to do so. Change and migrating now would be a loss of time and possibly the loss of essential jobs in miami-dade county and I implore you to please reject this ordinance and give us an opportunity to finish what we started. >> thank you. >> my name is danny rodriguez and my address is 8935 nw. 35th ln. My name is danny rodriguez and my address is 8935 nw. 35th ln. One of the reasons why I'm in this meeting today is to reject the cancellation of the rfp for the 80 ms project and from hbc engineering company. One of the things I wanted to say is we are all local firm. I'm a venezuelan native, been in the united states for 13 years, seven in florida and I got my education from fiu so I've received all the training and am also a florida registered professional engineer. One of the things that's important with these technology projects is the learning curve. It's a very complex technology project and we forgot it very successfully as I mentioned for the past four months, we've made a lot of progress. >>chair: hold on a second, pause the time. Silence your phones first and there's a lot surrounding noise going on. I know it feels like you're whispering to your neighbor but everybody whispering their neighbors creates a loudness will go ahead, continue. >> so just like the county has the goal of improving safety we follow the same goal, have the same goal and we promise we're going to be able to live to deliver this project on time with the quality you are requesting and with that I'd like to thank you for the opportunity to let me speak and give my opinion. >> my name is claudia bustamante, my address is 8935 nw. 35th ln. Doral 33172. I'm glad to be here to have this opportunity to tell my story. I'm also a engineer for other civil engineers talking about the technical part. What impact wll this cancellation have on cool business. From our side I want to tell you we are very happy to be working in this contract. We have put a lot of effort , we've been working very hard. We hired new people, job engineers that are supporting this work day and night because we have to collect information, analyze it and we think we've done a very good job. We have been working in a very good pace and we are continuing to have this same spirit with the same ever that we will do if you give us an opportunity to finish the contract. From our sde, when I tell you we are a firm that we didn't matter to hire new employees, train them and everything to have a good job from our side and have safer traffic lights out there for the county. Maybe from the point for the people , they have to think it's that we are providing a service that will impact and have opportunity for all the traffic lights that we are improving so thank you very much for this opportunity. Thank you. >> thank you. >> marion brown 1022 northwest avenue to everyone in their respectful place I think we have a lot of resolutions on the board today. But the main resolution is that in the area I grow up that it seemed like they're turning that into a parking lot. Everywhere you look and everywhere you see there's a new building coming up.There is no development, no jobs being created, the only jobs being created and once the construction starts jobs are created and once it stops jobs and. This is becoming a big problem in the community. The community is not going forward, it's going backwards. Down the corridor seven avenue their developing and put in new buildings, structured buildings where they can bring in jobs for the community, things that are not supplying, things they're not doing. And also just being a native of this community and when I was there at MARCH in selma alabama where my great aunt was pushed off the bridge and she couldn't swim at the time and she died even speaking on at that point it seems like for years and decades, that you sit here and you see that things are not going forward. Seems like we've still been stuck in the past from what my eyes can see and I'm pretty sure a lot of people can see the resolutions and everything that's getting put forward pertaining to that community and pertaining to the areas tied to the community for us it's the causeway and bridges and all that and the beaches. Everything is being taken away , or it's getting displaced or misplaced by something else. If you go through the area you don't see nothing or anything where a person can atually work or survive or thrive for a decent job, all you do is buildings and new development area thank you. >> thank you. >> I live at 14115 southwest 1/64 miami, fl 33196 . I live in district 11 next to the farm was to the urban development boundary and I'm here to speak about the agricultural study that will be discussed today. First our agricultural sector is a boon to our economy in west bay. Farmers and farmland are critical to the university of florida study determined by 2030 the agricultural sector that employees will thousand workers will need a minimum of 64,800 acres to remain viable so we should keep our agricultural sector viable passing any legislation that is not fully support agri-tourism should be opposed area we should not reduce the acres needed to keep our agricultural sector sustainable second commercial activities on top of farmland will lead to overdevelopment it will worsen traffic. I drove all the way from kendall and as a kendall resident I can tell you with confidence traffic is worse than it's ever been. The worst it's ever been and I know that a majority... >> you signed up for three a1 which is not the item you're speaking on the reason why that's important is because we are obligated to get everyone the same opportunities. So you're going to either speak on three a1 or you're going to take a seat. >> sorry, I thought it was about the agricultural center. >> andreas bauer. >> good morning everyone. My name is andrea's bauer, northwest springs and I as a systems engineer working for miami d county a dns project for pretty much since the beginning. So when I wanted to say is I strongly oppose the decision to terminate the project. And the reason why is there are severe delays in this project especially wth the deployment of t hns software and one of the severe causes for this delay is there are inefficiencies, there are like free sources and there's like collaboration on the miami dade county itd side, the it department so that is one of the pain points we are experiencing and we went through that and we built our relationship, we started incorporating ad if you're you terminate the contracts and someone else comes in they're going to have to go through the same struggle. So I'm opposing strongly the decision because I think it's not going to do any good area for this city area thank you. >> thank you. Names listed, public hearing is now closed. Man attorney. >> good morning MR. Chair. There are a few preliminary matters. Item 2b6 next two b6 , commissioner higgins adds this item to the poll list. And item 78 the prime sponsors have requested withdrawal of this item so with the setting of the agenda the item will be withdrawn, that item 78. Hp one and its supplement, senator garcia, commissioner colin higgins and commissioner Mcgee are adding their names to the poll list. And on 11 a1 commissioner mcghee adds this item to be pull list. 11 82, commissioner cohen higgins at this item to the pull list. I have additional requests for cosponsorship, 11 a3 senator garcia cosponsor and item 1185, vice CHAIRMAN Rodriguez, commissioner gonzales and senator garcia wish to be listed as cosponsors. Items to be considered at today's meeting will be those listed in the final printed agenda with additions to scrivener's errors noted in the CHAIRMAN's memorandum. The commission will approve all these items by a single vote setting the agenda except we had one remaining raisins presentation, item 2b7 which is the appointment of the interim director of the solid waste department. Ordinances for first reading, public hearings, ordinances set for second reading, item 3b to a commercial services character or contract must be voted on separately and is not in your pull list and the following items. >> MR. Chair. >>. >>chair: I like to be listed as a co-crime on a five. Like to be a cosponsor at least on 11 a5 being involved in these things longer than anybody else . >> anybody else that would be listed as a co-crime I am happy to accept. >> jerry, co-crime. >> mcghee, co-crime. >>chair: trenton bastien, gonzales, cohen higgins co-crime. Regalado co-prime. >> I don't say this much can I be listed as a sponsor for 8 p1 . >> sponsorship of 8 p1. >> that item was a sponsor I believe. Cosponsor, yes. >> MR. Chair, so we have also on 11 eight 2 commissioner cohen higgins is releasing that I am, I think we have still one polling commissioner on 1180 2. The commission will approve all these items with a single vote except the remaining citizens presentation 2b7 which is the appointment of the interim director southwest management district. Ordinances set for second reading, item 3 b2 and the following pull list items, to be six, eight p1, 11 a1, 11 82, 11 a3, 14 a1 which is first reading though I will do that with your first reading items, 1483, 14 b1, 14 b2 and 15 d3. Motion to set the agenda is in order. >>chair: so moved. >> just on the readiness as relates to 11 a1 I want to release the hold but I want to put the reason why we're releasing the whole. >> 11 a1 I'm releasing the whole but I just want to put on the record we have the mayor from homestead al garcia, the association PRESIDENT Matt goodman, treasurer stephen address and hardwick are here and I'm asking that te members of the rodeo meet with the racetrack and the city of homestead to have dialogue as relates to this item and I believe that's something district 8 and I are both in agreement with. >> through the chair thank you so much commissioner, that was my concern and I appreciate your amendment. >> thank you. It's been moved and seconded. >> on 2 b6 I am the only polling commissioner, there was a report on accessible housing and we read our own item and it asked for reports so were getting the data but we didn't get any forward-looking recommendations to the director I would appreciate if you want your team did a little thinking about that and if you don't mind in a month or so get together with me to see if there are recommendations around things you need to do. If possible. After that I moved the item. >> okay. >> really quickly on that and thank you for that commissioner. The only thing I would add is maybe something specific about neuro-diversity because we've had issues with sf media and there is a hard rule we're trying to change that I think we need to also include that if that would be fine. >>. >>chair: okay, bermudez I am still on the agenda . >>commissioner regalado: I want to point out today is a special occasion and it holds significant value not just in our community but around the world and today MARCH 18 is transit driver appreciation day so I hope that we have approximately 2100 bus and train operators and they play a role every day in something that's important to us. All of us. And which is making sure we have seamless transportation for our residents select as a body extend our heartfelt gratitude gratitude to the boss and training oerators today here in our community because they are the ones that make this one. I know it's near and dear to your heart and also commissioner higgins who couldn't get here without their help so let's thank them and keep them in mind today. >>. >>chair: I have a motion and a second on the agenda, all those in favor signify by saying aye . The agenda passed . >> you have item 3 b2 which we need a separate motion approved on. >> it's been moved by commissioner higgins, seconded by commissioner regalado, all those in favor say aye. >> there are some 14 items that have not been pulled, would you like to take those now? >> let's take the 14 items, we have the mayor's report. >> we have the interim appointment, 2b7 which is up to you if you wish to discuss. >> we don't need to discuss it, we just need to accept it. >> so 2b7 is done and the 1482, 1483, and 14 b2. >> happy to move those MR. Chair. commissioner. . >>chair: >>commissioner cabrera: most of these went through committee so that's why I think it's okay to move forward . >>chair: they've been moved, seconded by the vice chair and all those in favor signify by saying aye. Show them past. >> you have a citizens presentation, 1a 1 . Would you like to do that now? >>chair: sure, please. Where doing the citizens presentation on 1 p1. I think that the commission auditor is coming down to us, right? >> let's move on I guess. >> I'm the sponsor of the item and that's because every year this is an annual report and this is the citizens presentation by doctor maria , assistant director of planning and operations for florida's national university regarding the commission auditor status in miami-dade county. Okay. Yes, five minutes. It's really less what commission auditor you are recognized. >> good morning, we once again present the 2023 report. As you know this is an report produced in collaboration with fiu. We did identify some key indicators that we believe will be important to share with the board and as you are aware of the commission for women also had its programs through this report so I'll pass on to the chair to give you a quick briefing and if you have any questions we would be happy to answer them. >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN for bringing this item for and cmmissioners for continuing to support. Women and our thriving community by putting agenda on policies and raising awareness on some of the issues and barriers that still impede the progress of women. As your auditor said this is the seventh annual report that was that started back in 2016 after the ordinance that authorized this annual analysis of data on the status of women in miami-dade county and as you see on the next line the board focuses on four main areas. Economic development or economic opportunity, education health and safety. In addition as I'll present in one of the slides we also reviewed data from some of your county departments that speaks about the representation of women and the equity within the county. So let's start first with some basics. And I'm pointing out because you heard discussion about declining birth rates and that's affecting how are communities growing and the extent to which our economy can continue to grow based on the workforce challenges that MAY be posed as a result of the birth rates or the number of children in our community and the shrinking working population. We call this demographic constrictive population impairment because of its shape and you see it in the bottom portion there are a very small percentage of children and that our incoming talents, that's our workforce area we've seen over in 2022 a slight uptick in birth rates actually when you look at the trends over the last two decades there is still a downward trend so birth rates are declining and certainly you can see it from the school board data there has been a decline in all age children. On the next slide we show you some of the educational attainment data and I want to know first preface it by saying the same percentages of women and men in our community have bachelors degree or higher. However you see double-digit gaps in earnings based on each educational attainment category. And part of it is explained by the types of degrees women hold there are more women in education than men and there certainly are more women in the last category, arts humanities area we see generational shifts certainly with more younger women going into science, engineering and stem fields of study and certainly careers but some of the gaps MAY partially be explained by the differences in types of degrees they have and in the jobs women and men hold. We did the review back in our economic opportunity section and I will show you another slide in which you will see the gaps by occupations first the headliner is that the gap expanded in 2022 . If you'll recall in our previous report we recorded a gap of 13% for a median earnings of full-time workers and we know more women work part-time than men, that's why we look at only full-time workers and women's labor force participation rate is still behind men's. On the next slide as I mentioned are some of the very large gaps for certain occupations and these gaps are persistently high. Again we observed many of those in the previous report for most of these occupations the gaps have expanded or stayed the same so we're not making progress and that's reflected in the expanding medium earnings gap. In terms of health we have a high percentage of women with injuries but there are certain conditions that affect women more. We see a rise in stds among women and also significant disparities, I'm sure you're well attuned to that. Based on race and ethnicity in maternal and infant health both related to mortality and morbidity. For black women is significantly higher, both morbidity and mortality and infant mortality rates. In terms of safety highlights are we see a rise in both domestic violence and forcible sex offense cases if I MAY have a minute to finish with the final slide which is actually about county data and it shows that women's gaps in earnings in the county have stayed consistent over the last year, eight years in which we've reviewed the data about 16.7% so the overall 16.7% and there is a slight presentation of women among county workers. I always like to note on a positive note that the gap that we see for county employees are much smaller than the overall gap in the public administration factor where the gap is almost 29% of the county is doing something right in making sure women in terms of pay are faring better than public administrators overall in the county. Thank you MR. Chair . >> thank you CHAIRMAN And as doctor maria ilcheva just to close out we've noted improvements and we've also noted improvements in the county gap but we still want to raise our highlight on the areas of crime when it comes to women that we've seen an increase both in sexual offenses. Those are the two primary key areas would like to highlight for the board and if there would be any questions we would be available again. >> mdm. Attorney is there any action we need to take as a board? Colleagues? Any comments on the report, see commissioner from the second district, you are recognized. >> through the chair tank you for a very detailed report. I read it with a lot of attention but there are three things that really made me think and told me as policymakers things that we need to look at in order to create parity and inclusion for all residents of miami-dade county. The first one being that poverty. It's stated here that among black women poverty african-american women the poverty increased by 17% in 2021 and 20% in 2022. This is a grave concern and something we definitely need to look at. The second pertains to maternity health. A disparity among white hispanic and black women. There seems to be a big gap in maternity health. This is something we as policymakers probably need to consider. And the last ting is multi-mortality rate for comparable diagnosis, black women tend to die even though they are number maybe less but they mortality rate is higher than white and hispanic women so these are the two things that in violence of course and I must attract your attention to the fact that there is a relationship between the poverty rate and health and violence so it's important to make this relationship so that when in our efforts for inclusion and parity we understand why violence continues to increase among young women and I'm really concerned about that especially when we look at throughout our system we see a lot of big states to increase among young women. We used to think about young man, being involved in the juvenile justice system but more and more we are seeing young women and their getting younger and younger and there's a relationship within poverty and health and violence. Thank you again for a very detailed report. Appreciate it. commissioner from the 13th district you are recognized. >> that you MR. CHAIRMAN and thank you for the great report you put together. You're absolutely right when we look at health health outcomes it's important to look at you mention the increased number of std rates amongst women and we see what's happening in our community right now. We still lead the country in broward south florida because the changes between data and broward county in new infections and we keep on talking about that because the ones that are now being infected the most are african-american women and hispanic women so I appreciate you highlighting that and I look to this administration to work together with department of health and come up with a solution because the only way we're going to turn the corner is to educate is through education and prevention and while we've done some efforts in the past we don't see what innovative educational programs are out there now and going into our communities to ensure women are educated to best take care of themselves. While the disease has changed where it was to where it is today we know we are taking medication you can live a long life without passing the disease but it's a shame our minority women are the ones affected. But it's a shame our mothers and women in this community are the ones most impacted s it's incumbent upon us in this county commission and our mayor to come up with a plan to ensure we address that thank you for allowing me to be on this soapbox but it's important for me to get that out there with a room full of individuals so I can understand what is happening in our community thank you for that detailed report, GOD bless you. >>chair: commissioner cohen higgins you are recognized . >>commissioner cohen higgins: thank you for putting together such a detailed report and I'm always interested in this report. So a quick question and I think I alluded to this last year on this report, there is an 18% earnings gap articulated in the report and I think you mentioned briefly there's statements that the wage gap is attributed to women choosing different career paths. Is that accurate, it's not the key that men and women are entering the same job at the same time in miami-dade county and getting paid 18% less, is that the accurate ? >> I said partially attributed because that's not a full explanation. There are certain jobs in which women are fewer than men. That is the reality. These are construction jobs. These are still the computer and science engineering jobs in which men are about three quarters of workers so that obviously affects the gap , and engineer earns less than a teacher as I explained in terms of representation but there are other issues affecting earnings gap. It MAY be the jobs that women are choosing our there choosing them because of certain conditions. Women take care of the family, they need more flexibility, they need types of jobs do their other job as mothers or as caregivers older family members. So it's a complex issue about what's causing it. Without specific analysis within companies and within certain occupations, will never know what is the combination of factors that leads to that gap . >> thank you, I just wanted to mention barbie has released a campaign recently and it's a compelling advertisement, very young little girls between the ages of five and seven and the young girls are articulating these statistics that boys are more likely to get tested for gifted than girls and that boys are more likely to receive toys related to math and science than girls and the couch the campaign as close the dream gap in that we as mothers and fathers are raising our daughters to be redirected towards certain careers as opposed to maybe careers earning more money like you articulated on the microphone so if you haven't checked it out I think it's something to check out and they phrase it as the dream gap and I think it's something we should be cognizant of and I thank you for these statistics and all your hard work on this report. . >> commissioner, you are recognized . >>commissioner regalado: good morning MR. Chair. Thank you for your report. I think the clarifications you made are very important. As a school board member as commissioner bastien mentioned one of the biggest issues is you know, the mommy track and women choosing by mommy track and I think in certain professions physically in the legal profession there's been changes to maternity leave which now consider ramp up and wrapped down. That didn't exist when I had my children 20 years ago so I think that there are areas where women are now in a majority there at the policymaking piece of it and they're making changes for these things. But I think there needs to be a broader conversation about child care because whenever you drill down on the pay gap you find yourself having a conversation about access to childcare, proximity of childcare. This generation des not have access to parents that are staying home to take care of children that no longer exists. So as the sandwich generation which is raising children and taking her of elderly parents , rumor's are not staying home to take care of children similar to what their parents did for them. So I think that the main thing is childcare. I think if we took on the childcare issue and obviously date learns has done, there is a movement towards that. The programming that we now offer for four-year-olds has been transformative. If we offered the same for three-year-olds it would take a chunk out of this but the reality is I don't think we have enough childcare for children three months to two years which is a lot of the gaps that women have if they don't have a safety net. And then finally regarding what girls are exposed to , the school board has done a lot of work on this. When I was there we did cotela, which exposed girls to math and the age is important. You have to expose them to engineering and math and coding before they are 10 because nothing happens around nine or 10 that women decide math is not for me or science is not for me so if were talking about access and intervention I want everyone to understand it has to happen at a young age. When this work is done later we find it's not as impactful. So different programs like cotela and others that target young girls are where we see a shift and they have the data to prove it so thank you, I think it's important data and I think it will be useful to us and our partners. >> thank you, you all can come . >> you guys say through the chair and be recognized. Bfore we go to the chief on this let me say I appreciate the information. Just remember when we're tying to address these deficits we don't do it, we don't necessarily do it with big things, we do it with little things in face these decisions every day area like childcare when we're contracting with people, who they pay, how they pay, how they hired it's the little decisions that make a big difference and I encourage us to remember that at budget time and I think the mayor should and the administration come up with a program that addresses the spread of stds among minority women but let's remember we have a budget that is a legislative priority. We have to budget those things all those things don't just go away because we want them to go away, they go away because we do something that impacts decisions and impacts opportunities for young girls. We actually have to do something to impact and make a difference. >> thank you CHAIRMAN And very well said and I appreciate that. Mme. Mayor when she was put as part of this commission that commissioned this report I think she intended for us to have a body that could then opine on the actions that could be taken to address the gap whether it's in health or in violence, immortality as well as disease and violence. I wanted to thank the chair as well as the commission for engaging in listening to this report ad entertain any suggestions or recommendations the aministration could explore to try to close that gap. So I just wanted to thank you on behalf of of mayor. [Inaudible] Cava. >>. >>chair: thank you, mdm. Attorney . >> would you like to go into first readings? >>chair: sure. >> 4 a comment section b 133 of the code requirements the portion of sw. 2nd st. For 585 feet west of the right-of-way line of southwest 1 37th avenue providing separability inclusion in the date code an effective date, or be a doctor or ratifies the school year 2023 supplemental adjustments and amendments for various counties amending ordinance numbers 22 b 112, 22 b 114 and 22 b 1/17 to make budget adjustments ratifying orders and other board actions with set fees for fiscal year 20 2223 operating grant donation and contribution funds for fiscal year 2223 in accordance with section 2 b 1996 approved certain budgetary reallocations waving section 2 b 790 7g with respect to transferring carryover , to public housing and community development partner department providing separability and an effective date. 4c is a ordinance related to service concurrency management program; amending section 33g-5 of the code of miami-dade county, florida; delegating authority to the county mayor or county mayorc/b?B=s designee to enter into proportionate share mitigation agreements for roadway concurrency; providing severability, inclusion in the code, and an effective date. 4d is a ordinance relating to the rules of procedure of the board of county commissioners; amending section 2-1 of the code of miami-dade county, florida; exempting from committee review certain property or right-of-way conveyance items; making technical and conforming changes; providing severability, inclusion in the code, and an effective da. 4e is a ordinance relating to operation of micromobility devices, electric bicycles, and motorized scooters in the incorporated and unincorporated areas of miami-dade county; creating section 2-98.3 of the code of miami-dade county, florida; providing regulations for operation of micromobility devices, electric bicycles, and motorized scooters on rights-of-way; providing for legislative intent, applicability, and definitions; providing mechanism for municipal enforcement of regulations; providing for enforcement by civil penalty; providing severability, inclusion in the code, and an effective date. Those are your first reading items. >>chair: any member wishing to bifurcate these items, moved by regalado second by commissioner cohen higgins, call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously. >>chair: commissioner regalado recognized for emotion. >>commissioner regalado: if I could have the attorneys read the motion. 's. >> commissioner regalado moves to suspend the rules of procedure and both the municipal notice requirement as to 4e, 20429 moves to suspend the rules of procedure and both the municipal notice requirement as to 4e, 204292 amend item 15 be one to set the public hearing on item 480 at the APRIL 28 meeting of the CHAIRMAN's policy council and public affairs community, three, direct the clerk to publish all necessary notices and direct the agenda coordinator to send appropriate municipal notices. You. >>chair: moved by regalado. Motion on 14 a1. >>chair: moved by regalado, seconded by the vice chair, all those in favor signify by saying aye. You are recognized . >>commissioner higgins: if attorneys could read the motion on 14 a1. >> commissioner higgins moves to waive the four-week municipal notice requirement on item 14a1, registrar number 24602482 amend 15 be one to set a hearing at the APRIL 10, 2024 transportation mobility and planning committee, direct the agenda coordinator to send appropriate notice and and direct all notices to this board. >> so moved. >>chair: moved by commissioner higgins, seconded by the chair, all those in favor signify by saying aye. >>. >>vice chair: question, when we waved this way is there an extra step a commission or clerk goes through to make sure the commissioners have various municipalities notified besides the normal notification? >>chair: I think we send it to them . >>vice chair: but the reason those rules are in place is to give them adequate time to prepare. Those sort of things so I was just wondering is there anything additional that it does? This is sent with great importance sort of notice. Is it a notice that we waved the four-week notification period so people can have better attention to it? I want to find a way to say this is a high priority this is not for today but tomorrow. Any other ways we can notify the municipalities we are doing this that we're doing this by waving a notice period so maybe pay attention to this. Future but we can direct these items, just direct staff to make sure to send this directly to the mayor and city commissions of each city has affected so we can do that for these items and you can carry an item that requires I guess special attention. >>commissioner hardemon: MAY be that for this and someone from the county attorney's office to help me with a piece of legislation to help codify that . >> let's make sure we get this sent over so we know those things have been waived. I'm certain there watching the meeting. All right. First readings are done, what's next mme. Attorney . >> your public hearings. >> we can do all the public hearings at once. >> five a is a resolution code designating the portion of 56 32 nw. 20th avenue as trudy knowledge street and its supplement 5b is a resolution renaming a portion of county owned and operated beach known as the beach pathways against cancer beach and its supplement, 5c substitute rates and establishes a special taxing district within the boundaries of the city of homestead generally bounded on the north by one ovary right-of-way and on the east by 162 avenue ne. 18th avenue and on the south by southeast by one ovary right-of-way and on the east by 162 avenue ne. 18th avenue and on the south by se. 20th st. And on the west by canal see one ovary right-of-way known and described as part of points division special district and the services to be provided authorizing cost to be operated areas for improvement and providing exclusion for the code an effective date and its corresponding resolution relating to the multipurpose special taxing district located within the boundaries of the city of homestead, transferring the special taxing district to the city and waving election pursuant to two thirds vote area 5d is a ordinance creating and establishing a special taxing district in miami-dade county, florida, generally bounded on the nrth by nw 6 street, on the east by nw 122 avenue, on the south by theoretical nw 2 terrace, and on the west by nw 123 avenue, known and described as G.M. Academy street lighting special taxing district; identifying services to be provided; authorizing and directing the county mayor or county mayor designee to provide for the installation of streetlights; approving a street lighting agreement with florida power and light and authorizing the county mayor or county mayor designee to execute the agreement; waiving provisions of resolution no. R-130-06; and providing exclusion from the code and an effective date and five d1 is a corresponding resolution confirming a preliminary assessment rule of the district. 5e is a ordinance creating and establishing a special taxing district in miami-dade county, florida, generally bounded on the north by sw 344 street (West palm drive), on the east by sw 196 avenue, on the south by sw 348 street, and on the west by sw 199 avenue, known and described as legacy villas at palm drive multipurpose maintenance special taxing district; identifying services to be provided; authorizing and directing the county mayor or county mayorc/b?B=s designee to cause to be maintained and operated various public improvements; and providing for exclusion from the code and an effective date. 5f is a ordinance creating and establishing a special taxing district in miami-dade county, florida, generally bounded on the north by sw 228 street, on the east by sw 133 avenue, on the south by sw 230 street, and on the west by sw 133 court, known and described as jimenez subdivision street lighting special taxing district; identifying services to be provided; authorizing and directing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to provide for the installation of streetlights; approving a street lighting agreement with florida power and light and authorizing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to execute the agreement; waiving provisions of resolution no. R-130-06; and providing for exclusion from the code and an effective date. And 5f1 is a corresponding resolution approving a rule for the district. 5g is a ordinance creating and establishing a special taxing district in miami-dade county, florida, generally bounded on the north by theoretical sw 260 lane, on the east by sw 138 court, on the south by sw 262 street, and on the west by sw 139 avenue, known and described as moderna multipurpose maintenance and street lighting special taxing district; identifying services to be provided; authorizing and directing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to cause to be maintained and operated various public improvements and to provide for the installation of streetlights; approving a street lighting agreement with florida power and light and authorizing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to execute the agreement; waiving provisions of resolution no. R-130-06; and providing for exclusion from the code and an effective date. 5g one is a corresponding resolution confirming a preliminary assessment rule for the district. 5h is a ordinance creating and establishing a special taxing district in miami-dade county, florida, generally bounded on the north by theoretical nw 120 lane, on the east by nw 27 avenue, on the south by nw 120 street, and on the west by nw 27 place, known and described as safeguard subdivision street lighting special taxing district; identifying services to be provided; authorizing and directing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to provide for the installation of streetlights; approving a street lighting agreement with florida power and light and authorizing the county mayor or county mayor's designee to execute the agreement; waiving provisions of resolution no. R-130-06; and providing for exclusion from the code and an effective date. And 581 is a corresponding resolution confirming the assessment rule for the district. 5I is a resolution approving the plat of mitch subdivision filed by pinn

Miami-Dade Commission Agenda

--->

Legislative Survey ---> ADA Notice

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners Agenda

OFFICIAL

Version

Tuesday, March 19, 2024

9:30:00 AM

Commission Chambers

Disclaimer

Agenda Definitions

Printable PDF Format

County Commission Rules - Rule 6.05 DECORUM

"Any person making impertinent or slanderous remarks or who becomes boisterous while addressing the commission, shall be barred from further audience before the commission by the presiding officer, unless permission to continue or again address the commission be granted by the majority vote of the commission members present. No clapping, applauding, heckling or verbal outbursts in support or opposition to a speaker or his or her remarks shall be permitted. No signs or placards shall be allowed in the commission chambers. Persons exiting the commission chamber shall do so quietly.

The use of cell phones in the commission chambers is not permitted. Ringers must be set to silent mode to avoid disruption of proceedings. Individuals, including those on the dais, must exit the chambers to answer incoming cell phone calls. County employees may not use cell phone cameras or take digital pictures from their positions on the dais.

Miami-Dade County provides equal access and equal opportunity and does not discriminate on the basis of disability in its programs or services. If you need a sign language interpreter or materials in accessible format for this event, please contact the Miami-Dade County Agenda Coordinator�s Office at 305-375-2035 or [email protected] at least five days in advance.

When a resolution or ordinance is placed on the agenda at the request of a commissioner, the commissioner who requested the preparation of the item shall be designated as the prime sponsor. Any other commissioner who wishes to sponsor the resolution or ordinance shall be designated as a co-sponsor.

Pursuant to Rule 5.06(h), where a commissioner is listed as a sponsor, the first named commissioner is the prime sponsor and all other named commissioners are co-sponsors."

1A

INVOCATION AS PROVIDED IN RULE 5.05(H)

1B

ROLL CALL

1C

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

1D

SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS (SCHEDULED TO BEGIN AT 8:30 AM)

1D1

240405

Special Presentation

Oliver G. Gilbert, III, Prime Sponsor

SPECIAL PRESENTATION OF THE VILOMAH AWARDS:

1. SANTONIO AND MONICA CARTER NOMINATED BY CHAIRMAN GILBERT, III

2. ANDRES AND MELISSA FERNANDEZ NOMINATED BY COMMISSIONER CABRERA

3/19/2024

Presented

1D2

240458

Special Presentation

Keon Hardemon, Prime Sponsor

SPECIAL PRESENTATION HONORING WOMEN�S HISTORY MONTH

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e39a2d3587cc372c7a65a57c582542ad. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record