POLISCOPE

The public record

OAKLEY (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Sep 10, 2019 - 06:30 PM

Tuesday, September 10, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Sep 10, 2019 - 06:30 PM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

Commissioner Councilmember Romick

1 statement

  1. Statement

    Commented on the map, the north (right side of map) top 1/4 would be.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 91,754 stored characters

>> OR FIREMAN DURING COAL'S FREE TIME HE LIKES TO DRAW AND PLAY WITH HIS FRIENDS HE'S PART OF THE S TAS SWIM CLUB AND EXCITED TO START BASKETBALL THIS SEASON. HE GOES CAMPING NEAR THE BOARD WALK EVERY YEAR WITH HIS FAMILY. >> 1.3 IS ITEM 1.3 PROCLAMATION RECOGNIZING SEPTEMBER AS NATIONAL SUICIDE PREVENTION + ACTION MONTH I WILL READ THE PROCLAMATION. [READING]: WHEREAS; SEPTEMBER IS KNOWN APPROPRIATE SUPPORT SERVICES; AND [READING]WHEREAS; SUICIDAL THOUGHTS CAN AFFECT ANYONE REGARDLESS OF AGE, GENDER, RACE, ORIENTATION, INCOME LEVEL, RELIGION, OR BACKGROUND; AND [READING]WHEREAS; ACCORDING TO THE AMERICAN FOUNDATION FOR SUICIDE PREVENTION (AFSP), MORE THAN 40,000 PEOPLE DIE BY SUICIDE EACH YEAR; AND [READING]WHEARAS; SUICIDE IS THE 10TH LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH AMONG ADULTS IN THE US, AND NEARLY 20% OF ALL SUICIDES WERE COMPLETED BY PEOPLE AGES 45-54; AND [READING] WHEREAS; OAKLEY, CALIFORNIA IS NO AND [READING]WHEREAS; LOCAL TALK ABOUT; AND [READING]WHEREAS, EVERY MEMBER OF OUR COMMUNITY SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT THROUGHOUT LIFE'S STRUGGLES WE ALL NEED THE OCCASIONAL REMINDER THAT WE ARE ALL FIGHTING OUR OWN BATTLES; AND [READING]WHEREAS, I ENCOURAGE ALL REALIZE THAT SUICIDE IS NOT THE ANSWER. [READING]NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT OF OAKLEY, CALIFORNIA [READING] WE WILL NOW MOVE ONTO PUBLIC COMMENT I HAVE QUITE A FEW CARDS BEFORE WE BEGIN, I WILL EXPLAIN THAT AS YOU COME UP, EACH SPEAKER WILL HAVE ABOUT THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK. THIS LITTLE LIGHT DEVICE WILL GIVE YOU A GREEN LIGHT IN THE BEGINNING THEN TO YELLOW THEN TO RED AT WHICH TIME YOU NEED TO END YOUR COMMENTS THESE PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA IF YOU ARE WISHING TO SPEAK ON ITEMS ON THE CURRENT AGENDA I WILL CALL YOUR NAME LATER WHEN THAT ITEM COMES UP. THE FIRST SPEAKER REQUEST IS FROM DAN MENDOZA AND MR. MENDOZA HANDED THIS INFORMATION TO US PRIOR TO THE MEETING IF YOU WANTED TO TAKE A LOOK AT IT. THANK YOU. >> PI NAME IS DAN MENDOZA A 58 RESIDENT OF OAKLEY I HANDED YOU TWO PACKETS FIRST IS OAKLEY CODE ENFORCEMENT AND GUARD WOOD MAP. GUARD WOOD IS A BIKE PATH OF [INAUDIBLE] OF PUBLIC SCHOOL. KIDS WALK TO SCHOOL AND BUCK AND NOR CROSS THROUGH THE SYSTEM. THE COUNTY TOOK CARE OF GUARD WOOD LANE THERE WAS ONE GARBAGE CAN THERE. ONCE A WEEK AND MAINTAIN GUARD WOOD LANE. WHEN WE TURN THE CITY OF OAKLEY, THE CITY MAINTAINED GUARD WOOD MAIN AFTER A FEW YEARS DIDN'T WANT TO MAINTAIN IT. HAVE THE PROPERTY OWNERS MAINTAIN IT. YOU TALK OAKLEY GUARD WOOD WAS ESTABLISHED 1925 I WAS TOLD THERE IS NO MONEY TO MAINTAIN IT. WHERE IS MY TAXES GOING TO TIRED OF SEEING CONTRACT WORKERS IN CITY MAINTENANCE WORKERS CITY MAINTAIN REDO GUARD WOOD LANE FOR THE KIDS AND FAMILY THAT USES IT TO WALK BACK AND FORTH FROM SCHOOL. I ALSO CITY MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR A FEW YEARS BACK FOR THE SAFEY OF THE KIDS HE TOLD ME NOT TO GO THERE. SECOND PICTURES I GAVE YOU FOUR PICTURES NOW WE HAVE A CODE A DOG PARK POUR PICTURES, THAT SHOWS GARBAGE CANS EACH PARK GOT 15 POUNDS AND GOT TWO GARBAGE CANS, AND MAINTAINED BY CONTRACTORS WHAT IS MORE IMPORTANT DOGS OR KIDS? I'M ALSO HERE TO SUPPORT THE SCHOOLS CLOSING OF THE PARKS. SO, I JUST LIKE TO SEE WHAT THE BOARD COULD DO FOR US WE CAN WALK DOWN THERE IT'S RIGHT DOWN STREET FROM THE SCHOOL. WE CLEANED IT UP, NOW ONE PICTURE SHOWS GOT DETAGGED OR BEING DEBRIS CLEANED IT UP, NOW WE WANT THE CITY TO MAINTAIN IT. KEEP IT UP AND MAYBE DO THAT SO IT'S A NICE AREA PEOPLE ENJOY WALKING THROUGH IT INSTEAD OF THROWING TRASH THIS IT. >> THANK YOU. I DO HAVE A QUESTION IS GARWOOD LANE A PRIVATE ROAD? >> IT'S A PUBLIC ALLEY THERE'S A ONE SIDEWALK IN FRONT OF OUR HOMES IF WE HAVE DEBRIS IN THAT SIDEWALK OR A TREE OVER HANGING THAT SIDEWALK IT'S US AS A PROPERTY OWNER TO REMOVE THE DEBRIS FROM THE SIDEWALK AND REMOVE THE TREE IMPEDING THE CORRECTION OF NOTICE BY MR. MENDOZA IS TO CLEAR THE STREETS IN FRONT OF HIS PROPERTY BUT IT'S A PUBLIC ALLEY. >> THIS IS GARWOOD LANE. THEY WOULD COME ONCE A WEEK TO MAINTAIN IT. IT'S A DIRT ROAD WITH A POST CARS CAN'T GO THROUGH I WAS TOLD I A KID GOT HIT BY A CAR BEFORE. I WAS TOLD IT CONDITION BE REMOVED CAN'T BE GRAVEL I WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO MAINTAIN IT AND MAKE NICE PARKS HERE IT HAS BEEN HERE SINCE 1925 WOE SHOULD BE ABLE TO DO SOMETHING AS A CITY. THE COUNTY HAS DONE A NICE JOB. >> WERE YOU ABLE TO GET IN CONTACT WITH THE PUBLIC WORKS. >> I LEFT MESSAGES. >> DO YOU KNOW WHO. >> WE WERE PLAYING TAG. >> GARWOOD LANE PEOPLE DON'T KNOW THE NAME OF IT. I GAVE YOU GUYS MAPS I OUTLINED O'HERA MAN DIS AND GARWOOD IN THE MIDDLE. ALWAYS MAINTAINED BY THE COUNTY. [INAUDIBLE] I SHOULDN'T HAVE TO DO THAT FOR THE KIDS. >> I WOULD BE HAPPY TO MEET WITH HER MEN DO SA AGAIN I LEFT MESSAGES AFTER THE LAST MEETING I DIDN'T RECEIVE A RETURNED PHONE CALL IN FRONT OF YOUR PROPERTY YOU NEED TO MAINTAIN. >> TO GO BACK AND FORTH TO THE SCHOOL TO GO TO THE CITY TO PARK IN FRONT OF THE SCHOOL THERE IS MORE TRAFFIC THAN ANYTHING IT'S NOT A REGULAR NEIGHBORHOOD WALKING. >> THANK YOU MR. MEN DO SA YOU CAN CONTINUE THAT CONVERSATION. >> I WOULD LIKE TO SEE WHAT THE BOARD THINKS ABOUT IT. >> ITEMS IN PUBLIC COMMEND AND THEY ARE NOT GENERALIZED COMMENT. >> HOW DO I MAKE IT AGENDA. >> WOULD HAVE APPEAR ON THE AGENDA YOU HAVE ADDRESS STAFF. >> AFTER THIS MEETING I SHOULD SHOW YOU WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE IT'S CLEAN JUST MAINTAIN IT. IT SHOULDN'T BE MY RESPONSIBILITY. >> I UNDERSTAND. >> WAR GARBAGE CANS DOG PARKS. >> YOU GONE WELL OVER THE THREE MINUTES, WE HAVE TO MOVE ON. THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER IS MARK SMITH. >> HI GOOD AFTERNOON. I'M HERE IN REGARDS TO REPRESENTING MY GRANDPARENTS BARBARA AND ADRIAN CHAVEZ WHO LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY THEY HAVE BEEN EXPERIENCING SOME HEAVY RENT INCREASES THEY LIVE IN A 55 PLUS SENIOR CITIZENS NEIGHBORHOOD. AND IT SEEMS THAT ALTHOUGH EXTENSIONS TO THEIR LEASE WERE PRESENTED. THE TERMINOLOGY THERE IT'S NOT REALLY STRAIGHTFORWARD IN TERMS AN CONDITIONS OF THE LEASE AGREEMENT REMAIN UNCHANGED THE NET TENT CONTRIBUTION IN EFFECT OF THE NEXT YEAR OR ADDENDUM UNTIL THE LEASE IS EXECUTED X AMOUNT FOR THE RENTS. THIS IS A LEASE ADDENDUM THAT EXTENDS THEIR RESIDENCY FOR ONE YEAR HOWEVER ALTHOUGH THEY ARE LOCKED IN FOR ONE YEAR, EVERY THREE MONTHS A 5% INCREASE IS MADE TOWARDS THE RENT 53 MONTHS FOR ONE YEAR EQUATES TO 20.37% INCREASE INCREASE TOWARD THEIR RENT MY GRANDPARENTS AND MULTIPLE FINE CITIZENS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD ARE ON FIXED INCOME YOU HAVE $800 RENT FOR A REASON THERE. THAT'S WHAT THE INCOME ALLOWS, WE HAVE A RESIDENT THAT ALLOWS AN INCOME OF $1,120 FROM RAISING THE RENT FROM 870 TO $1,000 THIS PERSON IS LEFT WITH $120 TO--THIS PERSON ALSO HAS A $35 FOR THEIR MEDICAL SO IT LEAVES THEM WITH $95 FOR THE MONTH BASED OFF THEIR FIXED INCOME. THESE RAISES ARE BASICALLY MUSCLING OUT ELDERLY PEOPLE A LOT OF THEM AREN'T LUCKY ENOUGH TO HAVE FAMILY AREN'T TO LET THEM KNOW WHAT THEIR RIGHTS ARE. WHERE THEY CAN GO. WE HAVE ELDERLY COMMUNITIES HAVING RENTS LIKE UP ON THEM AT RIDICULOUS RATES THAT ARE IN NEED OF HELP AND THEY DON'T KNOW WHERE TO TURN THAT'S WHY I'M HERE IN FRONT OF THE CITY OF OAKLEY TO SEE IF WE CAN FIND GUIDANCE AND HAVE CONVERSATION TO EXPLORE THIS ISSUE THAT'S HAPPENING BEFORE ENTIRE GROUP OF ELDERLY ARE MUSCLED OUT OF THEIR HOMES. >> THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] [MULTIPLE SPEAKERS]. >> IS THAT SUMMER CREEK? >> SUMMER CREEK. WE HAVE A NUMBER OF SPEAKERS THAT WILL TELL US THE SAME PROBLEM, WE HAD THIS PROBLEM IN THE PAST. MR. MONTGOMERY COULD HELP EXPLAIN? >> SURE. >> POSSIBLY EXPLAIN WHERE THEY CAN GO TO, WE ARE NOT THE BOARD THAT CAN HELP YOU THERE IS NOTHING WE CAN DO AS CITY COUNCIL TO EFFECT THE RANGES CHARGE IT'S A FEDERAL GOVERNMENT THAT MANAGES YOUR RENT. EXCUSE ME, WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK RIGHT NOW IT IS MY OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK AND MR. MONTGOMERY AND STAFF WILL EXPLAIN WHO YOU NEED TO REACH OUT TO. THE CITY CANNOT--WE CAN SEND LETTERS OF SUPPORT FOR YOU, BUT WE CANNOT EFFECT THE RATE CHANGES AT ALL. NO EXCUSE ME ONE MORE TIME. I AM SPEAKING YOU WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY WHEN YOUR NAME IS SPOKEN. DO NOT INTERRUPT ME THANK YOU. IF WE CAN HAVE STAFF FRAPP TELL YOU WHO TO REACH OUT TO. I UNDERSTAND WE HAVE GONE THROUGH THIS NOT ONLY THIS DEVELOPMENT BUT A NUMBER OF OTHER PROPERTIES IN OAKLEY THAT ARE SUFFERING THE SAME PROBLEMS AND THE SAME ISSUES THAT WE DON'T HAVE ANY CONTROL OVER. SO, MR. MONTGOMERY STAFF COULD YOU MAYBE EXPLAIN WHO TO REACH OUT AND HOW WE CAN HELP YOU REACH OUT TO THOSE PEOPLE? >> YES AS THE COUNCILMEMBER AS INDICATED, THERE SAY LOT OF EMPATHY RESIDENTS SUCH AS YOUR GRANDPARENTS HAVE COME BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL IS POWERLESS TO EFFECT THE RENTS THAT ARE GOVERNED BY BOTH GOVERNMENT AND FEDERAL STATE LAW. THERE IS NOTHING FOR FEDERAL JURISDICTION TO DO ANYTHING THAT WRITE A LETTER OF SUPPORT, WE HAVE A FLYER THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPERS PRESENTED OUT THOSE FLYERS IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHO TO CALL. SAY LISTEN MY RENT IS GOING UP X AMOUNT WHY IS THAT FAIR ARE THEY FOLLOWING THE RULES? THEY IS GOVERNED BY THE FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS AND CONTACT THOSE INDIVIDUALS AND HOPEFULLY GET AN ANSWER. THERE ISN'T ONE THING THEY CAN DO TO HELP. WE WILL PROVIDE FLYERS FOR ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE A COPY CALL THOSE NUMBERS LET US KNOW IF THERE IS ANYTHING WE CAN DO BY LETTER OR PHONE CALLS THE RATES ARE NOT SET BY THE CITY NOR ARE THE INCREASES. >> I DO UNDERSTAND THE TERMS YOU SPEAK OF OUR HANDS ARE TIED, WE SPEAK BECAUSE THIS IS THE FIRST STEP WE CAN TAKE AND WE APPRECIATE [MULTIPLE SPEAKERS]. >> NO PROBLEM. WE APPRECIATE ALL OF YOUR INPUT AND EFFORTS AND WE HOPE TO COUNT ON THE CITY COUNCIL OF OAKLEY AND YOUR SUPPORT IF WE NEED TO TAKE THIS TO THE NEXT STEP THEN WE WILL TAKE IT TO THE NEXT STEP, WE HOPE WE CAN COUNT YOU TO BE A RINGLEADER AND HAVE OUR BACK THOUGHT THE SITUATION THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER IS [APPLAUSE] ADRIANA SMITH. IS ADRIANA SMITH AVAILABLE? HELLO. >> GOOD EVENING HERE WE ARE AGAIN IN REGARD TO THE GOOD FOLKS ON EMPIRE WHO ARE REALLY STRUGGLING SEVERAL PEOPLE SINCE WE LAST MET HAVE MOVED ARE R IN REALLY BAD PLACES SEVERAL HAD TO FIND OTHER PLACES TO LIVE IN DIFFERENT STATES SOME HAVE BEEN AT THE MERCY OF THEIR FAMILIES, SINCE I HAVE TO SAY IT'S DISHEARTENING THOSE ARE YOUR CONSTITUENTS ALSO. THEY'RE A GREAT GROUP OF PEOPLE. THIS IS LOW INCOME HOUSING THE AGREED OF THE CORPORATE FROM NEW YORK THOSE REALITIES THEY ARE PUSHING OUT SO VICIOUSLY EVERY MONTH. $150 $50 HERE. ANOTHER $78 THERE. I LISTENED TO SO MANY I HAVE TALKED TO SO MANY RESIDENTS THEY BARELY HAVE ENOUGH MONEY FOR FOOD AFTER THEY GET THEIR SOCIAL SECURITY CHECK THEY BARELY HAVE 28 BUCKS TO THEIR NAME. WE SPEND MORE ON THAT ON STARBUCKS DON'T WE? I KNOW I HAVE $30 RIGHT NOW ON MY STARBUCKS ACCOUNT I'M HAPPY TO SPEND EXTRA TO HAVE MY PARENTS THERE. SPEND TIME WITH THAT COMMUNITY. THEY HAVE SUCH A WONDERFUL COMMUNITY THERE. THEY TAKE CARE OF EACH OTHER. THE POLICE COME IMMEDIATELY OAKLEY POLICE IS AWESOME. THE PARAMETRICS THEY COME IMMEDIATELY THEY ARE AWESOME. AND THEY ARE RELYING ON YOU AS THEIR LEADERS TO HELP THEM. CHAMPION FOR THEM. I'M JUST A DAUGHTER I DON'T LIVE THERE. THEY DON'T HAVE TO LIVE THERE THEY ARE LOW INCOME AND THEY ARE LUCKY ENOUGH TO LIVE THERE. THEY ARE VERY PROUD TO LIVE THERE. THE COMMUNITY THOSE LADIES THE GENTLEMEN THAT LIVE THERE, WOW WHAT A GREAT GROUP OF PEOPLE I KNOW I FEEL SO SAFE KNOWING MY PARENTS LIVE THERE AND I CAN VISIT THEM IT'S RIGHT BY THE STORE IT'S IDEAL WHEN YOU WALK AROUND OTHER PLACES AND DIFFERENT CITIES THEY DON'T HAVE WHAT OAKLEY HAS A SMALL COMMUNITY REALLY A VERY GOOD PLACE TO LIVE. THE DELTA FREEZE IS WONDERFUL I A A QUICK WALK TO THE GROCERY STORE TO GET YOUR PRESCRIPTIONS TO WALK OUTSIDE AND TALK WITH YOUR NEIGHBOR WITHOUT ANY HARASSMENTS JUST A GREAT PLACE TO LIVE BUT IT'S ALL GOING AWAY FROM CORPORATE AGREED. SEVERAL. VERY FAST THEY'RE DYING BECAUSE THEY'RE PUSHED OUT TO PITTSBURGH OR BAY BUOYANT. FAMILY MEMBERS THEY DON'T KNOW OR CARE TO BE THIS. THAT'S WHY THEY'RE OUT HERE. MAYBE CITIES TO LIVE CHEAPER NOT IN CONTRA COSTA. NOT IN CALIFORNIA COME ONMENT HOW MANY OF YOU HAVE YOUR KIDS STILL LIVING WITH YOU THAT ARE 20 YEARS OLD IT IS A FACT. PLEASE HELP OUR PARENTS PLEASE. >> THANK YOU. PATRICIA SOLARI? >> I TOO AM ONE OF THE DAUGHTERS OF ONE OF THE RESIDENTS SHE'S 95 YEARS OLD AND SO FEARFUL OF LIVING THERE I WON'T HAVE THAT SPEECH PLANNED YOU ALREADY PUT US DOWN SO I WON'T BOTHER. I WANDER IF YOU CAN'T DISABLED PEOPLE. A LOT OF THEM ARE IN WHEELCHAIRS CAN'T WALK, CAN'T COME OUT, WE HAVE 80 RESIDENTS HALF OF THEM HAVE TO STAY INSIDE AND CAN'T MOVE BUT IT SEEMS TO ME THE COUNTY WOULD WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IS NOT HAPPENING IN OAKLEY IS NOT HAPPENING IN THEIR COMMUNITY THEY'RE GOING TO BE HOMELESS A LOT HAVE NO OTHER FAMILY BUT THIS PLACE. IF THEY'RE HOMELESS IT'S GOING TO COST THIS COUNTY A WHOLE LOT MORE MONEY TO CARE OF THEM LIVING UNDER THE BRIDGE THAN TO HELP US AT LEAST STOP THESE PEOPLE AND WHAT THEY WANT TO DO. I UNDERSTAND THEY WANT TO RAISE IT TO $1,395 IN THE NEXT SIX MONTHS MY MOTHER IS IN A DEFICIT OF $500 A MONTH LIVING THERE I'M SUBSIDIZING $500 A MONTH OR SHE WOULD BE OUT IN THE STREET RIGHT NOW. SOMEWHERE ALONG THE LINE, WE CAN'T IGNORE THESE HANDICAPPED NEEDY PEOPLE THAT HAVE NOTHING BUT THIS PLACE. I MOVED HER THERE FIVE YEARS AGO IT WAS BEAUTIFUL UP UNTIL A YEAR AGO THAT'S WHEN THEY STARTED INCREASING THE RENT CONTINUOUSLY TO A LARGE AMOUNT. I WOULD HOPE THAT SOME SORT OF COMMUNITY YOU CAN'T GO ANY WHERE IN THIS AREA WITHOUT 2, 3, 4-YEAR WAITING LIST. I CAN'T HAVE HER THAT FAR AWAY I CARE FOR HER I LIVE IN BRENTWOOD. TO ME I GOT TO MAKE SURE SHE'S CLOSE SHE'S 95 MY GOD WHAT ELSE CAN WE DO FOR THEM. WE THROW OUT OUR OLD PEOPLE IN THE STREET AND WALK AWAY IT DOESN'T SEEM RIGHT. THANK YOU. >> MAYOR IN FATTING. [APPLAUSE] BACK ON THE BACK TABLE THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTORS PUT THOSE FORMS THERE. WHAT WE HAVE RESEARCHED IN THE PAST DEPENDING ON THE HOUSING COMPLEX THE FEDERAL LAW ALLOWS FOR A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF RATE INCREASES IF IT DOESN'T OCCUR ONE YEAR THEY CAN CATCH UP. WE DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS THOSE AREN'T OUR REGULATIONS THE PHONE NUMBER IS ON THE SHEET ON THE BACK AS MANY TIMES AS YOU CAN TO GET ANSWERS THE UNFORTUNATE ANSWER THEY PROVIDE THEY'RE ALLOWED TO DO WHAT THEY'RE DOING. I DON'T KNOW THAT. >> THEY HAVE ALL OF THE RESIDENTS FORCED TO SIGN A SHEET SAYING THEY WERE MAKING $62,000 A YEAR OR LESS. >> THAT IS INFORMATION IF YOU CAN PROVIDE THAT TO THE FEDERAL AGENCIES, THAT SEEMS SUSPICIOUS TO ME. >> MY MOTHER MAKES $14,000 A YEAR. >> UNDERSTOOD. THE FLY YES, SIR IN THE BACK WILL PROVIDE THOSE NUMBERS AND ENCOURAGE YOU CALL AND LET US KNOW HOW TO HELP FROM THAT POINT. THE CITY COUNCIL DOESN'T. >> THEY WERE GOING TO TRY AND PUT IN CONTRA COSTA NOT RENT CONTROL BUT FREEZE. >> WE UNDERSTAND THE STATE LEGISLATURE IS TAKING ACTION ON THAT. MAY BE A TOPIC FOR ANOTHER MEETING THESE ARE FEDERAL REGULATIONS. ANY CITY OR EVEN STATE. >> LOW INCOME IS WHAT THEY ADVERTISED. [INAUDIBLE] [SPEAKING OFF THE MIC] HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS. >> MY MOTHER IS 87 EMPATHETIC WE ARE TALKING TO THE WRONG PEOPLE. >> THANK YOU. >> ONCE AGAIN TO COMMENT ON THIS STUFF. WE EMPHASIZE WE UNDERSTAND WHAT IS GOING ON. WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH HERE. I LIVE ACROSS THE STREET FROM SUMMER CREEK I WAS THERE WHEN THEY BUILT SUMMER CREEK I MOVED WITH THE PEOPLE ON SUMMER CREEK I HAVE BEEN THERE A NUMBER OF OCCASIONS WORKING THERE THIS SINCE IT WAS BUILT EVERY 4 OR 5 YEARS THE ISSUE RISES TO THE TOP YOU GET NEW OWNER UP OR MANAGEMENT THEY LOOK AT THE RENT AS MR. MONTGOMERY SAID, WE HAVEN'T RAISED RENT FOR FOUR YEARS, WE HAVE THE ABILITY TO CATCH UP. THOSE PEOPLE WHO MOVE IN WERE TOLD THEY WERE PAYING A CERTAIN AMOUNT THEY GET STUCK TRYING TO CATCH UP. SO, INSTEAD OF RATING IT EVERY YEAR LIKE THEY SHOULD THEY HOLD IT OFF 4 OR 5 YEARS RAISES THE RATE TO WHAT THEY SHOULD BE PAYING UNFORTUNATELY AS A CITY, AS A COUNCIL AS A GOVERNMENT WE HAVE NO POWER TO GO TO THE STATE OR THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND TELL THEM THEY CANNOT DO THAT. THEY CANNOT DO THAT. WE HAVE NO CONTROL OVER ANYTHING THAT GOES ON OUT THERE. SO, WE EMPATHIZE IF THERE IS ANYTHING WE CAN DO TO SUPPORT, WE HAVE IN THE PAST. WE WILL RALLY LETTERS WE WILL CALL FOR YOU. ONCE AGAIN WE'RE DEPENDENT ON THE STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS FOR THE CHANGES TO HAPPEN THERE AB1472 OR 82 PASSED TODAY IN THE STATE. CAPPED RENTS AT 5% ACROSS HAS TO GO TO THE ASSEMBLY AND GOVERNOR'S DESK I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT EFFECTS THIS TYPE OF HOUSING WHO CONTROLS THE HOUSING I DON'T KNOW IF THAT 5% RENT INCREASE, LIKE I SAY, APPLIES TO THE HOUSING THAT IS FUNDED THROUGH THIS PROGRAM. AND ONCE AGAIN, LIKE I SAY, WE EMPATHIZE, WE ALL HAVE PARENTS. SUE HAS TO GO BACK TO IOWA TO VISIT HER MOTHER MY MOTHER IS 89 YEARS OLD LIVES IN HAYWARD. DOUG'S HAS PASSED, WE UNDERSTAND, WE ARE IN TOUCH WITH WHAT IS GOING ON. THERE'S A NUMBER OF US THAT HAVE REACHED THAT SENIOR STATUS SITTING ON THIS BOARD TONIGHT. WE EMPATHIZE AND UNDERSTAND IF THERE IS ANYTHING WE CAN DO TO EFFECT CHANGES, WE WOULD DO IT. >> WE WERE TOLD THE COUNTY WAS GOING TO MAKE THE MOVE TO DO IT. >> WE'RE NOT THE COUNTY EITHER. CONTRA COSTA NEED TO GO TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. ONCE AGAIN WE'RE NOT THE COUNTY WE DON'T CONTROL THAT. >> FOR TEN YEARS I OWNED A BUSINESS I HAVE RENTED PROPERTY OUT AND I WAS NOT ALLOWED TO INCREASE IT MORE THAN 5% PER YEAR IT WAS IN BUTTE COUNTY. I WAS NOT ALLOWED. THAT WAS THE RULE NOT MORE THAN 5% I UNDERSTAND IF IT CHANGED OWNERSHIP, WE WERE SURE IT DID NOT CHANGE OWNERSHIP. >> YOU PROBABLY GOT NEW MANAGEMENT [INAUDIBLE] OWNERSHIP PROBABLY WENT TO MANAGEMENT AND SAID YOU HAVEN'T RAISED RENTS IN FOUR YEARS. CATCH UP. >> THEY ARE CLAIMING NOW THEY WORK WITH HUD AND HUD DOESN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THEM. >> WE WILL SUPPORT YOU, WE WILL GRAB THE SAME FLYER AND REACH OUT TO THE SAME ORGANIZATION YOU REACH OUT THERE AND TELL THEM. THIS ISN'T FAIR THIS ISN'T RIGHT, WE NEED TO CHANGE IT. WE CAN'T EFFECT THAT CHANGE EITHER UNLESS SOMEONE AT THE FEDERAL AT THE STATE LEVEL MAKES CHANGES AT THAT END. >> WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ONTO THE NEXT SPEAKER FOR A SAKE OF TIME TO SPEAK AT THE PODIUM. DIANE SPURIR. DIANE? >> I'M ALSO A RESIDENT OF SUMMER CREEK PLACE WHICH IS I BELIEVE THEY ARE ON A PROGRAM CALLED THE SECTION 42 PROGRAM UNDER THE GOVERNMENT AND THAT IS ALSO KNOWN AS LOW INCOME HOUSING PROPERTY AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING. WHAT'S GOING ON WITH THAT. I BELIEVE IT'S ELDER ABUSE. THESE SENIORS ARE SUFFERING ELDER ABUSE THEY ARE IN WHEELCHAIRS THEY ARE WALKERS HALF OF THEM ARE LIMITED TO THEIR HOMES ELDER ABUSE IS HAPPENING RIGHT NOW THEY ARE DRIVING THEM INTO THE STREETS PROPERTY MANAGEMENT IS AWARE OF THE FACT THE MAJORITY OF THE SENIORS ARE ON FIXED INCOMES AND FORCED ONTO THE STREET THE ABUSE IS PSYCHOLOGICAL AND EMOTIONAL, WE NEED OR ELECTED OFFICIALS TO STAND BEHIND US AND DO SOMETHING FOR US WE ARE REQUESTING YOUR HELP NOW WHETHER IT BE YOU WRITING LETTERS AS WELL AS US WRITING LETTERS, WE NEED YOU TO HELP US WRITE LETTERS. WE NEED TO GET SOMEBODY'S ATTENTION AND THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT WHATEVER LEVEL GOVERNMENT THIS IS YOU ARE ALSO IN A LEVEL OF GOVERNMENT YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO BE RUNNING YOU ARE THE PEOPLE OF OAKLEY. SENIOR CITIZENS ARE THE PEOPLE OF OAKLEY AS WELL AT SUMMER CREEK PLACE I THINK IT'S A CRIME WHAT IS GOING ON. I'M GOING TO CALL THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE ABOUT ELDER ABUSE THAT'S HAPPENING THERE. THE FACT WE CAN'T GET REPRESENTATIVES BEHIND US TO HELP US DO THESE THINGS BECAUSE YOU ARE ELECTED OFFICIALS AND THAT IS YOUR JOB. THAT'S ALL. THANK YOU. >> VICKY MORGAN. >> HI COUNCIL. MY MOTHER AND LIEUTENANT LIVE IN SUMMER CREEK AS WELL. I WILL NOT GO INTO THAT. I HEARD WHAT YOU SAID I UNDERSTAND YOUR POSITION BUT THERE ARE A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS I WANT TO BRING TO YOUR ATTENTION, WE ARE GOING TO START A BUNCH OF CONSTRUCTION ON EMPIRE AND LAUREL AND PUTTING THE LIGHT IN ON GATEWAY AND EMPIRE WHEN WE BUILT THE 711 AT LAUREL AND EMPIRE THAT WAS A TRAFFIC NIGHTMARE I CALLED THE GENTLEMEN IN CHARGE OF, THAT HE BASICALLY TOLD ME TOO BAD THIS IS THE WAY IT'S GOING TO BE AND THAT WAS THE END OF THE CONVERSATION. SO, I WANT TO BRING IT TO YOU THIS TIME AND HOPE THAT THEY CAN START WORK AFTER SCHOOL TRAFFIC. THEY CAN WAIT TO PUT THE CONES OUT TO MINIMIZE THE LANES AFTER TRAFFIC TIME IN THE MORNING WHEN THEY DIG HOLES IN THE STREET, THEY CAN BURY THE PLATES WHEN WE DRIVE OVER THEM, OR CARS AREN'T RUINED FOR MONTHS ON END IT WAS A YEAR WE DROVE OVER HUGE PLATES ON EMPIRE NUMEROUS TIMES A DAY. THE RIMS OF MY CAR GOT DENTED DRIVING OVER THAT. THERE WERE NO SIGNS THEN WHEN THEY FORTHE CONCRETE OR ASPHALT TO FILL IN THE LITTLE AND THE TIRED DIV OTHER THAT IS WEAR AND WEAR ON US THAT IS NOT FAIR THEY SHOULD HAVE TO DO IT RIGHT SO THE OTHER THING I WANTED TO ASK YOU ABOUT NOW THAT LAUREL AND EMPIRE ARE THE THROUGH FARES WHO IS IN CHARGE OF PICKING UP THE TRASH THE DISCARDED FOOD FROM 711 THAT MY DOGS EAT EVERY DAY COVERED IN ANTS ON THE STREET WHO IS IN CHARGE OF PICKING UP THE CAR PARTS THE DEAD ANIMALS GETTING HIT. WHO IS IN CHARGE OF THAT? IS ANYBODY GOING TO TAKE CARE OF THAT? DO I HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF THAT? LET'S SEE. I THINK THAT IS IT. THOSE ARE THE THREE THINGS I WANTED TO BRING TO YOUR ATTENTION THAT DIDN'T GET HANDLE PROPERLY LAST TIME I APPRECIATE YOU GUYS VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. IN REGARDS TO THE TRASH, DEPENDING ON THE AREA DIRECTLY AROUND 711 I BELIEVE THAT IS 711'S OBLIGATION TO CLEAN UP AND AROUND THAT AREA IF YOU DO SEE DEAD ANIMALS THOSE ARE TO BE REPORTED TO ANIMAL CONTROL THEY PICK UP ANIMALS TRASH AND DEBRIS ALONG THE STREET THAT IS THE CITY'S RESPONSIBILITY. WE DO I DON'T KNOW HOW OFTEN STREET SWEEPER THAT COME BY IF THERE ARE BIGGER PARTS AND HAZARDS IN THE ROAD WAY LET THEM KNOW HERE SO THEY CAN SEND SOMEONE OUT TO CLEAN THOSE UP RIGHT AWAY. >> CAN I TELL YOU ONE THING? THE TRASH IS NOT AT 711 IT'S UP AND DOWN THE STREET ON EMPIRE THE DEAD ANIMALS GET KNOCKED ON THE SIDEWALKS BY THE CLEANERS. >> THOSE NEED TO BE REPORTED TO ANIMAL CONTROL. >> THEY DON'T PICK IT UP. SO, THEN WHAT? >> THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION. >> THOSE ARE MY QUESTIONS. >> THANK YOU. WE WILL GO TO MARGARET BERRY. >> YES MY NAME IS MARGARET BERRY I LIVE AT SUMMER CREEK PLACE ONE OF THE TENANTS. THIS IS CRIMINAL WHAT THEY'RE DOING IT'S INJUSTICE I'M A REALTOR I KNOW. THEY FORCE YOU TO SIGN THINGS THEY WON'T GIVE YOU A COPY OF IT. THEY RECENTLY MADE A SIGN THAT SAID WE WERE ALL MAKING A LITTLE BIT UNDER 62,000. I ASKED MARIA WHAT IN THE HECK IS THIS FOR? SHE WOULD NOT GIVE ME ANY INFORMATION I KNOW EXACTLY WHAT SHE DID TO IT. SHE TOOK IT TO THE TAX CREDIT BOARD AND TOLD EVERYBODY WE'RE MAKING A LOT MORE MONEY THAN WE'RE MAKING THAT'S WHAT SHE DID. THEY USE STRONG ARM TACTICS IF THEY DON'T LIKE WHAT YOU ARE DOING THEY GIVE YOU THREE-DAY NOTICE TO MOVE OUT. YOU GOT TO CLEAN YOUR CARPETS WHEN THEY SAY YOU GOT TO CLEAN YOUR CARPETS IF THEY DON'T LIKE YOU FEEDING THE BIRDS THEY GIVE YOU A THREE DAYS NOTICE THEY USE STRONG ARM TACTICS THEY ARE IN AND OUT OF OUR APARTMENTS THEY HAVE HAD AT LEAST TEN INSPECTIONS FOR ONE REASON OR ANOTHER. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY'RE FOR AND THEY JUST COME IN AND NITPICK WHAT YOUR APARTMENT SHOULD LOOK LIKE THEY DON'T LIKE IT THEY GIVE YOU A THREE-DAY NOTICE TO FIX IT OR YOU ARE OUT OF THERE. I HAVE RENTED I'M A REALTOR I USED TO OWN UNITS I NEVER DID ANY OF THIS STUFF. IF I GAVE THEM A RENT INCREASE IT WAS ONCE A YEAR IT'S ABNORMAL WHAT THEY'RE DOING THEY ARE OUT OF STATE OWNERS THAT LIVE IN IDAHO AND USING THE TAX BASIS FOR TAX CREDIT PROGRAM THERE IS SOME INJUSTICE HERETORY INSTITUTION SAID WE HAVE THE RIGHT FOR PEACEFUL AND SECURE SAFE ENVIRONMENT WE ARE NOT LIVING IN THAT. WE ARE NOT LIVING UNDER DURESS AND ALSO GUISTOPPO WITH MARIA DICTATOR TELLING US WHAT WE CAN AND CAN'T DO WHEN WE CAN AND WHEN WE CAN'T DO IT. WE ARE TIRED OF TIE RANY THIS IS AMERICA NOT MEXICO WHERE SHE'S FROM. WE HAVE CIVIL LIBERTIES THEY ARE CROSSING OVER OUR CIVIL LIBERTIES, WE NEED THEM STOPPED. A CITY WHERE TYRANNY IS GOING OWN IS INVOLVED UNTIL YOU CAN INVESTIGATES WHAT'S GOING ON THERE. IT'S NOT RIGHT. I HAVE BEEN A REALTOR SINCE 1979 OKAY? AND I HAVE HAD MY UNITS TAKEN AWAY FROM ME IN EAST PALO ALTO BY THE TENANTS AND HERE WE HAVE NO RIGHTS. IT'S CRIMINAL WE DON'T HAVE ANY RIGHTS ESPECIALLY THESE PEOPLE. I'M 75 YEARS OLD AND I'M STILL KICKING AND I'M ANGRY AND THESE PEOPLE REPRESENTING ALL THEIR PARENTS THEY CAN'T COME BECAUSE THEY'RE IN BED THEY'RE SICK IN WHEELCHAIRS THEY'RE HELPLESS THEY'RE OUT IN THE STREET IF THIS IS HAPPENING IN AMERICA I DON'T HAVE MUCH HOPE FOR YOU ALL. >> IF IT'S CRIMINAL YOU MIGHT TRY CONTACTING DISTRICT ATTORNEY THAT'S WHAT I DO IF SOMETHING IS DOING SOMETHING ILLEGAL ABOUT ME. >> [SPEAKING OFF THE MIC] [INAUDIBLE]. >> YOU GOT PLENTY OF PEOPLE TO CONTACT LOCALLY I WOULD TRY THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY THEY GOT THE POWER. >> MICHAEL DUPREE? HI AYE MIKE DUPREE I LIVE IN OAKLEY I'M REALLY PROUD OF THOSE SENIORS YEAH. THERE'S A REAL ISSUE A REAL PROBLEM. WHAT I'M SEEING HERE IS CALL THESE OTHER FOLKS DO THIS, DO THAT HAVE YOU ALL ACTUALLY GONE OVER AND PARTICIPATED IN THEIR MEETING TOSS TRY TO ACTIVELY PROACTIVELY SOLVE THE PROBLEM THIS YEAR, WE HAVE TWO ANATOMY 8% COLA FOR SOCIAL SECURITY. MOST ALL OF THAT WAS EATEN UP BY MEDICARE PREMIUM INCREASES THERE IS NOT GOING TO BE ANOTHER COLA NEXT YEAR BUT THE CPI INFLATION RATE WILL GO UP 2% MAYBE MORE THAT EXACERBATES THE INCREASES IN RENTS. AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS SUPPOSED TO BE 1/3 OF YOUR INCOME RIGHT NOW FOR TEACHERS IT'S 50% FOR STUDENTS IT'S MORE FOR SCENE YEARS IT'S INCREDIBLE. YOU GUYS REALLY NEED TO BE PROACTIVE I UNDERSTAND YOUR HANDS MAY BE TIED MAYBE WE SHOULD INVESTIGATE THE HAND BEESING UNTIED AND GOING AFTER IT. I'M FOR GOING AFTER IT DOING WHATEVER I CAN DO. THERE ARE THINGS THAT CAN BE DONE. I'M SURE THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ISN'T THE END ALL DO ALL. I UNDERSTAND I WORKED WITH THEM A LONG TIME. THERE IS WAYS TO GET AROUND IT I'M SURE THERE IS A WORK AROUND WE WILL FIND IT ONE WAY OR THE OTHER, I SUGGEST YOU AT LEAST GO TO THEIR MEETINGS GET IN THERE AND BE PROACTIVE INSTEAD OF TELLING THEM GO MAKE THE PHONE CALL I CAN'T SAY ENOUGH. WE MOVED SOME PEOPLE ALREADY. THE VETERANS THE ROTARY CLUB AND THE SENIORS IT'S GOING TO GET WORSE YOU ALL KNOW YOUR NEPHEW GOT RAKED OVER THE COALS THE HOMELESS ISSUES IT COSTS 300,000 TO TAKE CARE OF THE HOMELESS FOLKS AND 50,000 TO GET THEM OFF THE STREET. WE NEED TO KEEP THIS FROM HAPPENING WE ARE NOT PROTECTING YOUR NEIGHBORS AND RESIDENTS AND FRIENDS I'M SORRY YOU GOT TO GET UP AND DO SOMETHING. >> MARK FOLI? >> MAYOR ALAURA MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL GOOD EVENING I OWE YOU AN APOLOGY IT'S BEEN NINE YEARS SINCE I COME HERE FOR CONFESSION OR PUBLIC COMMENT BACK THEN I WAS CELEBRATE ONE OF MY SOFTBALL PLAYERS MAKING IT TO THE REGIONAL PITCHING AND RUN COMPETITION YOU HAVE PROCLAMATION IN HER HONOR. HERE WE ARE FAST FORWARDED NINE YEARS LATER I STAND BEFORE YOU AS THE NEWEST DISTRICTER OF BART FOR DISTRICT TWO. I SIMPLY WANTED TO WELCOME MYSELF TO YOUR CITY SO SAY I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE CITY OF OAKLEY IN FINDING WAYS BART AND OAKLEY CAN ADDRESS EXPANSION TO ADDRESS GETTING FOLKS OUT OF THEIR CARS AND INTO TRANSIT. AND JUST SIMPLY WAYS, WE CAN WORK TOGETHER TO MAKE THIS REGION MOVE BETTER. SO, I LOOK FORWARD TO THE FUTURE TOGETHER AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT WE WILL HAVE A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE SOME POSITIVE CHANGE SO THANK YOU. >> WELCOME MARK. >> THANK YOU MARK. WE CAN SET UP BY ANNUAL REPORT OUT. >> I WOULD LOVE TO DO THAT. >> THAT ISN'T PART OF THE PUBLIC COMMENTS YOU CAN GO MORE THAN THREE MINUTES AND TALK ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON WITH BART. YOU WORK WITH STAFF WE CAN GET YOU ON A SCHEDULE. GET YOU REGULARLY SCHEDULED IN HERE OF. >> I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR THAT. >> SOUNDS LIKE A WONDERFUL I APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU. >> I DO HAVE A HANDFUL OF CARDS THAT ARE ALSO ABOUT THE RENT CONTROL ISSUE AT SUMMER CREEK I HAVE READ THROUGH THEM. I WILL ALLOW MY COLLEAGUES TO READ THROUGH THEM. AND ENTER THEM IN THE PUBLIC RECORD THESE ARE THOSE WHO WISHED TO SPEAK FOR PUBLIC COMMENT. THE NEXT PUBLIC COMMENT IS VER VA MARTINEZ AND DAVE WALL WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK TOGETHER. >> HONOR MAYOR VICE MAYOR MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL MY NAME IS DAVE WALL HONORED TO BE SPEAKING THIS EVENING ON BEHALF OF THE ROTARY CLUB OF OAKLEY AS THE CHARTER PRESIDENT RESPECTING TWO-DOZEN ROTARYIANS SOME IN THE AUDIENCE THIS EVENING JOINED THE 1.2 MILLION ROTARYIANS AND CLUBS AROUND THE WORLD, WE CHARTER ROTARY NATIONAL MAY 29TH. AVENUE SEVEN WEEKS OF PUBLIC INFORMATION SESSIONS AND MEETINGS AND OUT REACH, WE HAVE ASSEMBLED NEIGHBORS AND LEADERS AND FRIENDS AND PROBLEM SOLVEER WHO VIEW THE WORLD AS A MACE TO UNIQUE TO TAKE ACTION TO MAKE POSITIVE CHANGE AROUND THE GLOBAL AND COMMUNITY IN OUR LIVES SERVICE COMMUNITIES GLOBAL ACTIONS COMMUNITY PROVIDE DISEASE PROVIDE CLEAN WATER SERVE MOTHERS AND CHILDREN SUPPORT EDUCATION AND GROW LOCAL ECONOMIES SO FAR WE HAVE ENJOYED SUPPORTING ARRAY OF AGENCIES THE FREEDOM HIGH BOOSTERS BARBECUEING OF HOT DOGS BACK TO SCHOOL NIGHT AND THE BOOTH AT THE OAKLEY CITY HOOD CELEBRATION, WE WILL CONTINUE BY BARBECUEING TRY TIPS AT THE BELL GAME AND HOMECOMING AND OF COURSE, STAFFING A BOOTH FOR THE UPCOMING HEART OF OAKLEY CELEBRATION. BIG BREAK REGIONAL STORE LINE PARK THIS = DOING DUNE RESTORATION DELIVERING 6050 DICTIONARIES THIRD GRADERS TO THE OAKLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS, WE HOPE YOU WILL THINK OF US WITH OPPORTUNITIES SERVICE RELATED PROJECTS AND PROBLEMS TO SOLVE WE WANT TO BE AT YOUR SERVICE AND BE ACTIVE ASSET IN OUR COMMUNITY WE MEET EVERY THURSDAY MORNING AT BLACK BEAR DINER 7:30 A.M. WOULD LOVE FOR YOU TO JOIN US AND FINITE OUT WHAT ROTARY IS ACT. I WOULD LIKE INTRODUCE OUR PRESIDENT ELECT. VERA ELECT. >> THANK YOU MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS I'M HERE TO TELL YOU ABOUT AN EVENT WE DO HAVE COMING UP TO CELEBRATE THE CHARTER OF OUR ROTARY CLUB OF OAKLEY. THAT IS ON SEPTEMBER 28TH. IT'S GOING TO BE AT THE OAKLEY RECK CENTER IT'S GOING TO BE A SPECIAL DINNER AND COMEDY SHOW. WE HOPE NOT ONLY OUR FELLOW ROTARYIANS BUT ALSO THE COMMUNITY WILL HELP US CELEBRATE IT'S ONLY $50 PER PERSON. YOU GET DINNER AND YOU GET THE COMEDY SHOW FEATURING MICHAEL MANCINI THE WORLD'S FUNNIEST COP. I'M LOOKING FORWARD TIT. I'M HOPING WE WILL SEE LOTS OF OUR COMMUNITY THERE AS WELL. IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN GETTING TICKETS FOR OUR EVENTS YOU CAN CONTACT ME DIRECTLY OR PRESIDENT DAVE WALL OR YOU CAN GO ONLINE TO ROTARY OAKLEY rotary.com OR YOU CAN LIKE US ON FACEBOOK. THAT WILL HAVE INFORMATION ABOUT OUR EVENT AS WELL IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANYTHING YOU MIGHT HAVE. >> THANK YOU FOR THE INVITATION FOR THE PUBLIC AND WHAT YOU GUYS DO FOR THE COMMUNITY. >> ABSOLUTELY. THANK YOU. >> THAT IS THE END OF PUBLIC COMMENT I WILL MOVE TO THE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> MOTION. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR, PLEASE SAY, "AYE." >> (MULTIPLE VOICES): AYE. >> THAT PASSES. NOW, MOVING ONTO 4.14190 BROWN ROAD MINOR . >> THANENING YOU GOOD EVENING MAYOR MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. THIS IS TENTATIVE MAP EXTENSION REQUIRED TO COME BACK TO THE CITY COUNCIL FOR APPROVAL. AS THE ORIGINAL PUBLIC HEARING COMMITTEE FOR THE MAP. THIS IS FOR MINOR SUBDIVISION THAT IS LESS THAN FIVE LOTS LOCATED ON THE NORTH END OF BROWN ROAD SOUTH OF THE CANAL AND THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED. ADDITIONAL THREE-YEAR EXTENSION TO THE EXPIRATION WOULD HAVE EXPIRED BUT THEY APPLIED FOR THIS EXTENSION PRIOR TO THAT EXPIRATION THAT AUTOMATICALLY EXTENDS IT TO THE HEARING DATE IF THE COUNCIL DOESN'T APPROVE THIS EXTENSION WOULD MOVE IT OUT TO 2022. THERE IS ALREADY A THREE-YEAR EXTENSION I THIS WOULD USE ALL SIX YEARS OF DISCRETIONARY EXTENSION PERIOD. IF 2022. ROLLS AROUND THE MAP WOULD EXPIRE. THEY NEED TO FILE A NEW APPLICATION BARRING AUTOMATIC LEGISLATIVE EXTENSIONS OR THE CODE ALLOWING DISCRETIONARY EXTENSIONS STAFF RECOMMENDS APPROVAL OF THIS. THAT CONCLUDES MY REPORT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? COMMENTS? >> MOVE APPROVAL. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR. >> AYE. >> IT PASSES. WE'VE HAD A REQUEST TO SWITCH AROUND 4.3 BEFORE 4.24.3 SUBDIVISION 9015. 4.3 SUBDIVISION PLANNER) [READING] I WILL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING AND STAFF REPORT. >> YES. THANK YOU AGAIN. I WANT TO BRING UP IS THERE A MAP. I WAS GOING TO BRING UP A MAP OF THE SUBDIVISION THIS IS REQUEST FOR EXTENSION THIS IS ALSO FOR THREE YEARS THIS WOULD ALSO RESULT IN THE FINAL DISCRETIONARY EXTENSION AVAILABILITY FOR THIS MAP. THIS IS FOR WHAT IS KNOWN AS CASSETTEY INCREASE SUBDIVISION COMMONLY REFERRED TO MACHADO LANE SUBDIVISION ON SOUTH SIDE OF CYPRESS ROAD. A LITTLE BIT FURTHER EAST OF THE EXISTING STORAGE FACILITY BEING CONSTRUCTED AND SOUTH OF EMERSON AND CYPRESS ROAD. THERE IS TWO PRIVATE OWNERS AT THIS TIME. THEY ARE REQUESTING THIS EXTENSION TO HAVE MORE TIME TO MEET WITH DEVELOPERS OF THIS PROPERTY AND WORK OUT ANY SORT OF PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT THAT CONCLUDES MY REPORT, WE DO RECOMMEND EXTENSION OF THIS PROJECT THIS WOULD BE IMPORTANT PROJECT FOR THE CYPRESS COOCCUR, WE HAVE APPROVALS IN PLACE AND TRAINAGE AVAILABILITY TO THE NORTH AND ALL OF THOSE UTILITYINGS. >> IS THE THIS THE FIRST EXTENSION THEY HAVE REQUESTED. >> THIS ONE ALSO HAD A PREVIOUS EXTENSION JUST LIKE THE LAST 13 YEARS AGO, THEY DID ONE. >> THANK YOU. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? I DON'T HAVE ANY PUBLIC TESTIMONY OR HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION? >> MOVE APPROVAL. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR, PLEASE SAY, "AYE." >> AYE. >> IT PASSES NOW WE MOVE TO 4.24.3 PLANNER). [READING] I WILL OPEN THE PUCK HEARING AND RECEIVE THE STAFF REPORT >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MADAME MAYOR THIS IS FOR SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HOMES DETACHED UNITS FOUR REQUESTS FOR PLANNING ENTITLEMENTS THE FIRST IS THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT THIS WOULD BE TO REDESIGNATION A 2.80. FROM SINGLE FAMILY TO MULTIFAMILY LOW DENSITY. THE DESIGNATION OF THE LAND USE DESIGNATION DOES NOT DICTATE THE TYPE OF PRODUCT TO BE BUILD N THIS CASE THE MULTIFALLLY LOW WOULD INCREASE THE DENSITY 2.2, 5.5 TO MAXIMUM OF 9.6 DWELLING PER ACRE THE REZONE FROM THE R6TH DISTRICT WHICH IS MINIMUM [INAUDIBLE] TO A PLANNED DIRECT CALLED P1 ON OUR ZONING MAP. THESE TYPES OF DISTRICTS P1'S TYPICALLY GO WITH THE PROJECT BEING PRONO EASYED. SO, THE PLAN COMMITTED WOULD D DICTATE THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN THEY SHOW THE LOT SIZES AND SET FORTH DEVELOPMENT FOR THAT PROJECT. THE TWO APPLICATIONS ARE FOR THE VESTED TENTATIVE MAP. THIS WOULD SPLIT THE LOT SITE. TO 63 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LOTS A FORM TAT WATER TREATMENT AREA ALONG OAKLEY ROAD. FRONTAGE DEDICATION TO THE CITY AND DEVELOPMENT. IMPROVEMENTS ALONG THE ROAD INCREASE GUTTER AND SIDEWALK AND LANDSCAPING THE DESIGN REVIEW IS FOR THE DESIGN OF THE PROJECT. IT IS FOR NOT ONLY THE SITE DEVELOPMENT AND LANDSCAPING BUT ALSO FOR THE HOME DESIGNS THE ARCHITECTURE OF THE HOME. THIS IS THE SIGH PROJECT LOCATION ON THE RIGHT-HAND SIDE. [INAUDIBLE] NORTH BY OAKLEY ROAD THE ROAD TO THE LEFT OF THE RECTANGLE RUNNING UP AND DOWN NORTH AND SOUTH IS LIVE OAK AVENUE NORTH YOU SEE A VACANT SITE NORTH OF THAT IS THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL ON LIVE OAK. SOUTH OF THE PROJECT IS HOLLY CREEK PARK. THESE ARE THE SURROUNDING USES TO THE NORTH THERE ARE LEGAL NON-CONFORMING RESIDENTIAL USE LOCATED IN A LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ZONE THERE IS ADDITIONAL TO THE NORTH EAST OF THE PROJECT SITE. WHICH IS THE RESIDENTIAL P1 SUGGESTING, WE DO HAVE A GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT APPLICATION FOR THE VACANT SITE TO THE NORTH JUST TO THE NORTH OF THIS SITE. YOU SEE A RECTANGULAR VACANT SITE THE COUNCIL DID A WORKSESSION ON THAT ONE THAT WOULD BE FOR SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT TO THE EAST IS ADDITIONAL SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT IS ZONED R6 DESIGNATED SINGLE FAMILY HIGH DENSITY IN THE GENERAL PLAN TO THE WEST WE HAVE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT. SIX SEWNS THAT IS DESIGNATED HIGH DENSITY THOSE ARE LARGER LOTS OVER THERE SOME OF THEM RETAIN AGRICULTURE LIMITED DURING THE REZONING SEVERAL YEARS BACK AND SO THE SOUTH IS ZONED P1 SIMILAR TO WHAT THIS PROJECT IS REQUESTED AND DESIGNATED SINGLE FAMILY HIGH DENSITY AS WELL AS HOLLY CREEK PARK. ON THE RECAP ON THE GENERAL WORK PLAN LAST SEPTEMBER THIS PROJECT WHEN IT CAME TO THE COUNCIL THAT DAY HAD 62 UNITS 20 SPACE PUBLIC PARKING LOT AND THOMAS DRIVE WAS ALLOWED TO HAVE THROUGH TRAFFIC WOULD HAVE GONE POTENTIALLY FROM OAKLEY ROAD TO THOMAS DRIVE BACK AND FORTH THERE ARE SEVERAL CONCERNS BY THE CITY COUNCIL THE MINUTES OF THAT ARE ATTACHED TO THE STAFF REPORT SOME OF THOSE WERE AMENDING TO MULTIFAMILY LOW DENSITY OPENING TO A LOW DEVELOPMENT BUILT SOME DAY INCLUDING POSSIBLY APARTMENTS SOME NOT ALL COUNCILMEMBERS SPOKE OF THE PROJECT THE COPY OF THE MINUTES IS ATTACHED. OTHER CONCERNS INCLUDE JUST INCLUDED OVERALL THE INCREASE IN DENSITY FROM WHAT THEY'RE PROPOSING WHICH WOULD HAVE ALLOWED AT THAT TIME EIGHT ADDICTIONAL STUDENTS FROM WHAT THE SINGLE FAMILY HIGH DENSITY WOULD ALLOW THE CUT TO THOMAS DRIVE THE LOSS OF THE VINES THE SITE IS CURRENTLY A VINEYARD AND MISUSE OF THE PUBLIC PARKING LOT BY MAYBE RESIDENTS THAT BACKED UP THEIR GARAGES AND DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH SPACES BECAUSE YOU CAN'T PARK ON THE STREET ON THIS DEVELOPMENT. SO, POTENTIAL FOR THEM TO USE THAT PARKING LOT IS PERSONAL PARKING THERE IS TALK ABOUT A NEED FOR RESTROOM. IN HOLLY CREEK PARK. THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT. TO GO OVER THAT IN DETAIL THE PROPERTY IS DESIGNATED FOR SINGLE FAMILY HIGH DENSITY DEVELOPER CAN PROPOSE UP TO 64 SINGLE FAMILY HOMES PER ACRE THAT WOULD COMPLY WITH THE GENERAL PLAN IN THE ZONINGING ON THE PROPERTY. INCREASE OF NINE OVER WHAT THE CURRENT GENERAL PLAN WOULD ALLOW IN DOING THAT THEY ARE REQUIRED TO DOE HIGHER DENSITY AFTER THE GENERAL PLAN WORKSESSION AND HEARING THE CONCERNS OF THE COUNCIL STAFF MET WITH THE APPLICANT WE CAME ONE THE IDEA RATHER THAN AMEND THE ENTIRE SITE TO ML WHY NOT AMEND A PORTION OF IT. WHEN YOU COMBINE THE DENSITIES IT WOULD GIVE THEM A MAXIMUM WHAT THEY'RE PROPOSING 63 UNITS THAT'S WHAT THE APPLICATION BEFORE YOU HAS THAT'S WHY IT HAS A PORTION TO ML NOT THE ENTIRE SITE. THIS IS KIND OF A SUMMARY OF EVERYTHING SO THE ROW UP TOP HAS A DIFFERENT SCENARIO SO THE FIRST ONE WOULD BE THE EXISTING PERMITTED FAMILY THAT IS 5.5-GROSS ACCESSOR ASSOCIATE WEDNESDAY THE SITE PRIOR TO SUBDIVISION. AND A MAXIMUM UNITS WOULD BE 54. THE ORIGINAL REQUEST WHEN THEY CAME TO THE WORKSESSION AND JUST WANT TODAY SAY LET'S AMEND IT TO ML THAT WOULD BE AT 9.87 ALSO DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE I BELIEVE THAT'S 9.6 IT WOULD RESULT IN 95 POTENTIALLY 95 UNITS THOSE COULD BE SINGLE FAMILY OR MULTIFAMILY PROJECT SO WHAT WE HAVE INSTEAD IS THE PROPOSED MIX GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT WHICH WOULD CAP THE NUMBER OF UNITS IF APPROVED AT 63 NOT 64 NOT 95 BUT 63. AGAIN THE REZONE THIS WOULD ALLOW FOR THE DEVELOPMENT UNDER THE P1ST DISTRICT ANY PROPOSED PLANS THAT CAME IN WOULD HAVE TO PRETTY MUCH MATCH WHAT IS PROPOSED ON THE PLANS IF APPROVED ON THE PLANS THEN WHEN WE DO THE REZONING ORDINANCES STAFF IS CAREFUL TO DEVELOP THOSE REGULATIONS AND MAKE THEM CONSISTENT WITH WHAT IS SHOWN ON THE PLANS. SO, SET BACK MINIMUM LOT SIZE ALL THOSE ARE INCLUDED REFERENCED BACK TO THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN THAT LOCKS IN PROPOSED PROJECT WITH THAT P1ST DISTRICT THAT'S ADOPTED. WITH THAT SPECIFIC ORDINANCE. THIS IS TWO MAPS. THIS ISN'T ONE PROJECT MAP. THIS IS A PROPOSED VESTING TENTATIVE MAP ON THE LEFT AND ALTERNATE ON THE RIGHT. THE MAIN DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THESE TWO MAPS THERE IS SOME TALK ABOUT POSSIBLY GATEING THE PROJECT PUTTING A VEHICLE GATE ON OAKLEY ROAD AND THE OPTION ON THE RIGHT PROVIDES ENOUGH CUEING SPACE FROM OAKLEY ROAD AND WIDTH TO DO A GATE THE MAIN DIFFERENCE IS THE LOT WAY OUT ALONG OAKLEY ROAD THERE ARE SLIGHT SHIFTS IN THE LOTS IN THE LAYOUT MAINLY OPEN ROAD THE PROPOSED LOT WOULD BE ONE LOT ALONG THE TOP THERE. THE ALTERNATIVE MAP WITH THE GATE WOULD REQUIRE THE ENTRANCE TO BE SHIFTED TO THE SOUTH AND THERE TO BE A SIDE LOADED STREET ON TO THE ENTRANCE ROAD SO THERE WOULD BE ROOM FOR THE GATE TO OPEN THAT RESULTS IN TWO HOUSES BACKING UP TO OAKLEY THREE LOTS REALLY. PROBABLY ONE HOUSE AT A DIAGONAL ANGLE FOR THE DESIGN REVIEW AGAIN THIS LOOKS AT EVERYTHING P1 FILED. PLAN THE FLOOR PLANS THE LANDSCAPING FENCING WALLS AND THE COLORS AND MATERIALS THIS IS THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN. AGAIN THIS SHOWS THE TWO DIFFERENT PROPOSED MAP ON THE TOP AND THE ALTERNATIVE MAP ON THE BOTTOM THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A P1 IS PROPOSED THEY SHOW THE LOT LAYOUTS WHICH HOWS ARE PROPOSED TO GO ON WHICH LOTS ETC. A COUPLE THINGS BROUGHT UP IN THE WORKSESSION IS THE COUNCIL WANT TODAY SEE POTENTIAL FOR RV PARKING EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE SMALLER LOTS THEY ARE MINIMUM 4,000 SQUARE FEET THEY AVERAGE 46 TO 4,800 THESE LOTS HAVE POTENTIAL MORE RV AND BOAT PARKING ON THE SIDE, WE HAVE 12 TO 14 FEET GARAGE DRIVEWAY THERE IS 80 OAK TREES PROPOSED TO BE PLANTED THOSE WOULD BE SIGNIFICANTLY LARGE 40-INCH BOX TREES FOR MORE IMMEDIATE IMPACT AND SOME OF THE EXISTING VINES WOULD BE RELOCATED TO THE PROJECT FRONTAGE BETWEEN THE BAY SIN AND THE SIDEWALK THIS IS A PICTURE OF A CONCEPTUAL LANDSCAPE PLAN. MOST OF THE TREES THERE ARE DIFFERENT. THERE ARE THREE SPECIES OF OAK TREES YOU WILL NOTICE THE THOMAS DRIVE ON THE LEFT. THAT IS NO LONGER PROPOSED TO BE A THROUGH TRAFFIC. THIS WOULD BE HOA MAINTAINED PRIVATE STREET DEVELOPMENT WHETHER GATEED OR NOT, THERE WOULD BE NO STREET PARKING ALLOWED AND NO THROUGH TRAFFIC TO THOMAS DRIVE SHOULD BE NO ADDITIONAL IMPACT ON THE RESIDENT INS THAT AREA NEXT TO THE PARK NEXT TO HOLLY CREEK PARK. THESE ARE JUST SOME OF THE FENCES THAT ARE BEING PROPOSED, THERE SAY COUPLE DIFFERENT TYPES, THERE SAY VIEW FENCE ON THE BOTTOM RIGHT. THAT IS PROPOSED ON THE PROPERTIES ADJACENT TO THE PARK. THE PARKING VEHICLE ACCESS ON THOMAS DRIVE AT THE VEHICLE ENSEMBLES ENTRY. I DIDN'T PUT ALL THE PLANS IN HERE THIS. SAY LONGER POWERPOINT THEY ARE IN YOUR PACKET THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF THE THREE DIFFERENT HOME PLANS THERE'S A SINGLE ONE STORY PLAN AND 22 STORY PLAN WITH THIS DEVELOPMENT. THERE ARE THREE ARCHITECTURAL STYLE AND EACH ONE OF THOSE HAS THREE DIFFERENT COLOR SCHEMES INITIATED STUDY DECORATED MITIGATION DULY POSTED AND FILES WITH THE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY CLERK AND OFFICE OF [INAUDIBLE] RESEARCH STATE CLEARINGHOUSE AND THE ADOPTION OF THE MITIGATED NEGDEC IF THIS PROJECT APPROVED IS INCLUDED IN WITH THE PROJECT RED ALEUTIAN THERE IS NO NEED TO MAKE ADDITIONAL ACTS ON THAT ALSO THE MITIGATION MEASURES AND THE DOCUMENT ARE REFERENCED IN THE REZONING ORDINANCE AND TENTATIVE MAP AND DESIGN REVIEW RESOLUTION CITY DID RECEIVE FOUR COMMENTS ON THE INITIAL STUDY AND THE CONSULTANT THAT CONDUCTED INITIAL STUDY DID RESPOND TO THOSE LETTERS IN RESPONSE TO COMMENTS WHICH ARE PART OF THE INITIAL STUDY IN THE MITIGATED NEGDEC AND DID NOT RESULT ANY IN ADDITIONAL CHANGES TO THE PROJECT. WENT THROUGH THIS ALREADY. I WON'T GO OVER IT AGAIN 2.2 ACRES OR THE LIMITED 2.2-ACRE GENERAL PLAN ANALYSIS WOULD LOCK IN THE PROJECT NO MORE THAN 63 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL FAMILY UNITS THESE ARE NOT APARTMENTS OR DUPLEX ATTACHED UNITS A HIGHER COMBINE MAXIMUM 64 DWELLING STUDENTINGS PER ACRE RATHER THAN THE CURRENT DENSITY OF 5.5 UNITS PER ACRE THE REZONE WOULD ALLOW FOR THIS PROJECT WOULD ALLOW FOR DETAILED RESIDENTIAL PRODUCT THE HIGHER DENSITY THE SINGLE FAMILY PRODUCT WOULD RESULT IN THE LOT SIZE THAN THE CONVENTIONAL R6 THEY WOULD BE 12 TO 1,400 SQUARE FEET SMALLER ON AVERAGE. WE WENT THROUGH THIS ALREADY. 63 UNITS PRIVATE ROAD. HOA NO THROUGH TRAFFIC EVA AT THOMAS. THERE IS TWO OPTIONS NON-GATEED ONE LOT VERSUS GATEED WITH THREE LOTS BACKING UP TO =LY ROAD. STAFF REQUEST IF THE COUNCIL DOES MOVE TOWARDS APPROVING THIS PROJECT ONE OF THOSE OPTIONS IS CHOSEN AS THE AAPPROVED MAP. THIS IS ANNOYANCES TO THE DESIGN REVIEW THERE IS ADDITIONAL ANALYSIS THE FINDINGS ARE IN THE TENTATIVE MAP AND DOE SIGN REVIEW RESOLUTION THERE ARE A COUPLE OF THINGS WE WANTED TO POINT OUT ONE IS A 20% SINGLE STORY GUIDE LINE WHEN WE HAVE P1 DISTRICTS WITH SMALL LOTS THAT IS DIFFICULT FOR SOME DEVELOPERS TO REACH THAT 20% THIS PROJECT HAS DONE 30% SINGLE STORY ALSO WE ASK FOR 50% OF CORNER LOTS, TO BE SINGLE STORY THIS HAS 82% OF THE CORNER LOTS OF SINGLE STORY THERE IS CONDITION OF APPROVAL. GARAGE SET BACKS UP TO FIVE FEET WHERE FEASIBLE. THE CONDITION SAYS 2-AND-A-HALF TO FIVE FEET DEPENDING ON THE AVAILABILITY OF THE LOT SIZE WE DON'T WANT TO CRAM THE REAR SET BACKS TOO MUCH, THERE SAY STORM DRAIN LINE THAT RUNS ALONG THE EASTERN PROJECT BOUNDARY KEEP IN MIND THE EASTERN BOUNDARY IS LONG THE BOTTOM OF THE SITE PLAN I'M SHOWING ON THE PLAN IT SHOWS RELOCATED ALONG THE EASTERN STREET THAT RUNS THROUGH THE PROBABILITY THAT STORM DRAIN LINE FROM PUBLIC WORKS ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT TO REMAIN IN PLACE. THIS RESULTS IN DECEMBER DISRUPTION. THAT LINE NEEDS MAINTENANCE AND STREET AND SIDEWALK LANDSCAPING AND A LOT OF HOMES WOULD BE EFFECTED IN THE NEW SUBDIVISION IF THAT WERE THE CASE. THIS WOULD LEAVE A 15 FEET WIDE EASEMENTS BETWEEN EXISTING FLAG LOTS ON EXISTING BUILDINGS TO THE EAST AND THE PROPERTIES THAT BORDER THE EASTERN SIDE OF THIS PROJECT THAT WOULD BE PROHIBITED BUILDING PERMIT STRUCTURES GAZEBOS AN AESTHETIC OVER 120 SQUARE FEET WOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO BE IN THAT 15-FOOT WIDE EASEMENT. THIS IS ANOTHER SLIGHT CHANGE SO WHAT IS PROPOSED IN THE CEQA THE ENVIRONMENTAL STUDY REQUESTED THE APPLICANT PAY FAIR SHARE FOR TRAFFIC SIGNAL AT LEAVE OAK AND OAKLEY ROAD. THIS INTERSECTION CAN BACK UP QUITE A BIT. STAFF HAS REQUESTED 6789 THE APPLICANT GO ABOVE AND BEYOND THAT AND INSTALL THE TRAFFIC LIGHT PRIOR TO THE PROJECT BEING BUILT. ANY ADDITIONAL FEES OVER THEIR FAIR SHARE WOULD BE REIMBURSED TO THEM FOR THE TRAFFIC FEE AND THE TRAFFIC IMPACT FEES ARE 30 TO 40% HIGHER THAN TOTAL THAN THE SIGNAL, WE STILL COLLECT SOME FEES SOME REIMBURSED IF THIS WAS APPROVED THAT IS IN CONDITION OF APPROVAL NUMBER 60 PART C2 THE COMMUNITY BENEFIT PROGRAM WHICH WAS ADOPTED IN 2015 BY THE COUNCIL IS AT 100% VOLUNTARY PROGRAM DEVELOPERS MAY PARTICIPATE IN WITH THE CITY. THE DEVELOPER HEARD THE DISCUSSION OF THE RESTROOM AND THEY REQUESTED A MAXIMUM CONTRIBUTION $150,000 TOWARDS THE INSTALLATION OF A PUBLIC RESTROOM AND HOLLY CREEK PARK. THE RESTROOM WOULD PROBABLY BE LOCATED SOUTH OF THE BELL DON LANE TERMINIS ABOVE THE PROGRAM. [INAUDIBLE] STAFF'S RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PROJECT APPROVAL OR DENIAL. THESE ARE STAFF'S RECOMMENDATIONS THANK YOU FOR STICKING WITH ME DURING THIS DETERMINATION TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE FOLLOWING DEVELOPMENT PLAN ARE APPROVED AND IF SO TO ADOPT THE MET GATEED DECLARATION THAT IS PART OF THE GENERAL PLAN RESOLUTION THE THREE ACTIONS WOULD BE ADAPT A RESOLUTION [INAUDIBLE] WAVE THE READING AND INTRODUCE THE REZONING ORDINANCE AND ADOPT THE TENTATIVE MAP EXTENSION I KNOW THE APPLICANT IS HERE WOULD LIKE TO GIVE A SHORT PRESENTATION ON THE PROJECTS. >> THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE INITIAL QUESTIONS FOR STAFF? YES? KEVIN. >> JUST TO CLARIFY AND RESTATE IF THE MAP IS APPROVED TONIGHT EVEN THOUGH WE'RE REZONING 2 PLUS ACRE AS MULTIFAMILY THERE IS NO WAY ANY TIME THIS MAP IS ACTIVE OR ANY TIME IN THE FUTURE THE APARTMENT BUILDINGS WILL BE BUILT ON THIS PROPERTY? >> [SPEAKING OFF THE MIC] THAT IS CORRECT. THE 2.2 ACRES WOULD BE AT OAKLEY ROAD AND P1 ALLOWS COMBINE DENSITY THIS IS SINGLE FAMILY PRODUCT. >> CAN YOU GO BACK TO THE MAP AND SHOW US WHICH PART OF THE PLOT IS THE TWO REQUESTED, TO BE REZONED THE TWO ACRES OR SO? >> I DON'T HAVE THAT ON HERE. IT IS IN YOUR PACKETS IF YOU WHAT WANT TO LOOK AT THE GENERAL PLAN ORDINANCE RESOLUTION IT'S IN ORDINANCE TO THAT. IT'S THE NORTHERN 5TH. >> THE NORTHERN PART OF THE LOT. >> YES. >> GO AHEAD AND BRING ONE OF THE MAPS BACK UP. THAT ONE WILL WORK. THAT WILL WORK. >> OKAY. >> SO NORTH ON THIS MAP IS A RIGHT SIDE. SO, WE'RE FACING NORTH. >> OAKLEY. >> ON THE RIGHT SIDE. TO THE NORTH IS OAKLEY ROAD. SO, ENVISION THE TOP QUARTER OF IT BEING TWO ACRES YOU ARE THINKING OF. >> OKAY. >> THAT IS THE PART ZONED AS MULTIFAMILY. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR STAFF? I DO HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT THEN YES. >> I DO HAVE ONE QUESTION REAL QUICK WHY THE LATTICE ON TOP OF THE FENCE? >> ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THE ONE THAT IS COMPLETELY. >> THE TWO FOOTER. THE ONE FOOT LATTICE. >> YOU KNOW, THAT COMES FROM A HIGHER DESIGN QUALITY OF FENCING I GUESS THERE IS DIFFERENT TYPES OF LATTICE THE OPEN LATTICE OR OVERLAP IT TO HAVE TEXTURE MORE ATTRACTIVE FENCE THAT IS WHERE THAT'S FROM. THERE ARE SOME ITEMS IN OUR DESIGN GUIDELINES THAT'S A FENCES EITHER THE FENCE GO BETWEEN A SIDE PROPERTY LINE OR HOUSE OR CORNER LOTS SHOULD HAVE A DECORATIVE TOP ONE FOOT OF LATTICE. THAT IS THE ORIGIN OF THAT. >> I DID THAT ON MY FENCE TO CUT DOWN ON THE WIND. >> OPEN? YEAH. >> ONE MORE QUESTION ON THE FENCING DO YOU HAVE TO HAVE THAT OPEN VIEW TO THE PARK FENCING? >> THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE RECOMMENDING THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE PROPOSING I'M SURE IF A BUYER DIDN'T WANT THAT THEY COULD OPPOSITE FOR SOMETHING DIFFERENT THE APPLICANT MAY BE ABLE TO ADDRESS THAT. >> ON THAT MAP YOU WERE SHOWING THREE HOMES THAT WOULD ABUT OAKLEY ROAD WHAT'S ACROSS THE STREET FROM THAT. IS THAT UP AGAINST SOMEBODY'S HOME THE ALTERNATIVE MAP ON THE RIGHT. ADDING THAT IS THAT THE EMPTY FIELD SITE. >> YEAH. TO THE NORTH YOU SEE THE EXISTING HOME ON THE PARCEL ALL THE WAY UP TO THE NORTH. >> YES. >> THAT IS ABOUT THE ENTRANCE WITH THE GATEED ENTRANCE THE HOMES WOULD BE SLIGHTLY FURTHER TO THE RIGHT ON THAT. IT WOULD BE THE OTHER PROJECT PROPOSING SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL IT WOULD BE ENTRY ROAD ON THAT LOCATION AND ELEVATION ONE OTHER SIDE ELEVATION. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. >> ANY QUESTIONS? WE WILL HEAR FROM THE APPLICANT FIRST MR. KEVIN FIRE. >> HI GOOD EVENING. MADAME MAYOR COUNCILMEMBER S FROM MLC HOLDINGS LANE COMPANY. EXCITED TO BE HERE TONIGHT. KEN AND STAFF THANK YOU FOR YOUR HELP ALONG THE WAY IT'S BEEN ALMOST A YEAR NOW SINCE THE STUDY SESSION, WE HAVE WORK WEDNESDAY STAFF TO ADDRESS SEVERAL ISSUES RAISED THAT NIGHT MORE SPECIFICALLY YOU TOUCHED ON A LITTLE BIT. A CREATIVE WAY TO MAKE SURE WE'RE CAPPED AT THE 63-UNIT PLAN WE'RE PROPOSING THIS EVENING IT'S A LITTLE BIT OF A FUNKY UNIQUE WAY TO GET THERE AND CAUSE CONFUSION WITH THE MULTIFAMILY WORDING THE GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION ON A PORTION OF THE SITE AND REZONING TO PD IS A CREATIVE AND EFFECTIVE WAY TO ENSURE YOU ARE GETTING WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING TONIGHT AND THIS DIFFERENT, AN ATTEMPT TO GET APPROVALED TO GET SOMETHING ELSE CONSTRUCTED. THAT IS NOT THE INTENTION AT ALL. IT IS A CREATIVE AND EFFECTIVE WAY TO DO THAT. WE WORKED TO ADDRESS SOME OF THE ISSUES TRAFFIC IS CONCERNED, WE HAVE ALTERNATIVE PLAN IN PART BECAUSE THE IDEA OF GATING THE COMMUNITY IS A CONVERSATION WE HAD WITH STAFF AND LOOKED AT IT FROM A PRACTICAL PERSPECTIVE AND AESTHETIC HOW WE FEEL ABOUT A GATEED AND NON-GATED COMMUNITY WITH THOMAS DRIVE BEING A THROUGH STREET, WE WITH WERE CONCERNED WITH CUT THROUGH TRAFFIC AND TRYING TO DISCOURAGE THAT. BY TAKING THOMAS DRIVE TO EVA, EMERGENCY VEHICLE ACCESS AND BIKE AND PEDESTRIAN PUTTING BALL LARDS IN THE STREET TO MAKE SURE THERE IS NO VEHICULAR ACCESS THE GATING BECAME NECESSARY FOR CUT THROUGH TRAFFIC A NON-GATED OPPORTUNITY AS YOU SEE HERE ALLOWED US TO LOCATE THE ENTRIES A LITTLE BIT TO CREATE A BUFFER ALONG EQUALLY ROAD THE GREEN AREA YOU SEE JUST BELOW OUR ENTRANCE IS BIO TREATMENT AREA RELOCATING THE EXISTENCE OF VINES IN THAT AREA. SO, YOU DON'T HAVE A WHOLE LOT OF HOUSING RIGHT UP ON THE STREET YOU JUST HAVE LOT 18 HOUSED CITED ONTO OAKLEY PROXIMATE TO IT. THAT IS THE NON-GATED OPTION. THE GATEED OPTION AS KEN MENTIONED THE DRIVE GETS WIDER AND LONGER TO ALLOW CUEING FOR THE GATE ACCESS AS WELL THAT SHRUNK DOWN OUR LOTS THAT REDUCED THE NUMBER OF RV LOTS WITH ADDITIONAL WIDTH. FROM 14 IN THIS PLAN DOWN TO 8TH. IN THE GATEED PLAN, WE RELOCATE ENTRANCE POINT SWUNG AROUND THREE OF THE HOMES THAT BACKED ONTO OAKLEY ROAD. WE FELT THIS IS MORE AESTHETICALLY PLEASING FROM OAKLEY AND PROVIDED THE OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL RV LOTS THIS IS THE PLAN WE PRESENTED AS PREFERRED PLAN OPEN TO DISCUSSION QUESTIONS COMMENTS ON THAT. WE WANTED TO PROVIDE AS AN ALTERNATIVE AS OPPOSED TO NOT ADDRESSING IT AT ALL. I KNOW THE IDEA OF GATING. THE DISCUSSION OF GATING WAS KIND OF AN IMPORTANT ONE WE WANT TODAY PROVIDE THAT OPPORTUNITY THE SINGLE STORY HOMES IS A BIG FEATURE A BIG FOCUS FOR US WITH STAFF AS WELL. WE SPENT QUITE A BIT OF TIME ON ARCTURE. THE COMMUNITY BENEFIT PROGRAM TO TRY TO ADDRESS THE NEED WITHIN HOLLYWOOD CREEK PARK. THE INMUM LOT SIZE 4,000 SQUARE FEET IS MENTIONED A FEW TIMES KEN IS RIGHT OVER 4,800 SQUARE FEET CONSISTENT WITH THE LOTS IN THE HOLLY CREEK PARK AREA. LAST THING I WANTED TO MENTION I SPENT TIME HERE RECENTLY TO ADDRESS THE FEEDBACK WE SAW. AND WE HAVE GOTTEN ABOUT OUR EDGE CONDITIONS AND TRYING TO BE A GOOD NEIGHBOR TO THE FOLKS THAT SURROUND THIS PROPERTY. IT'S A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE FROM LONG STANDING VINEYARD IT'S RESIDENTIAL DESIGNATED SITE FOR I THINK CLOSE TO 20 YEARS OBVIOUSLY, IT'S NOT RESIDENTIAL [INAUDIBLE] BEEN TRYING TO WORK WITH ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF THE NEIGHBORS I HAVE MET AND WANT TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT TO LOOK FOR WAYS TO LIMIT THE VISUAL IMPACTS OF THIS PROJECT ON THOSE NEIGHBORS THEY HAVE BEEN HERE FOR SOME TIME IN MANY INSTANCES, WE DON'T WANT TO BE INSENSITIVE TO THE FACT THIS CHANGE CAN BE IMPACTFUL HAPPY TO CONTINUE THAT PROCESS AND WORK WITH STAFF AND THE NEIGHBORS TO ENSURING WE ARE AS GOOD OF NEIGHBORS AS WE CAN BE. IT WON'T BE WELCOME WITH OPEN ARMS WHEN CHANGE IS COMING WE WANT TO BE LIKE I SAID EFFORTOUS IN THAT PAIN. EXCITED TO BE HERE AND OPEN FOR QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE THANK YOU. >> ONE THING I NOTICE WITH ALL OF THE HOMES AND THE GARAGES THERE IS NO ACCESS TO THE OUTSIDE FROM THE GARAGE. YOU HAD A SINGLE DOOR THAT WENT INTO THE HOUSE. BUT THERE WERE NO DOORS TO THE OUTSIDE. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THOSE DOORS ON ALL THE HOUSES. >> WE ARE TRYING TO CREATE 400 SEAR ROOMS I MENTIONED IT TO THE ARCHITECT THIS EVENING TO MY GUYS IT WAS AN OVERSIGHT. YES THOSE SHOULD BE INCLUDED MAKES ALL THE SENSE IN THE WORLD THANK YOU FOR POINTING THAT OUT. >> PSEUDOYOU WANT TO ASK THAT QUESTION. >> IF WE HAVE NO GATE WOULD WE STILL HAVE AN HOA. >> YES. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. >> IT'S A PRIVATE STREET. KEN MENTIONED IN CASE THERE IS ANY CONCERN WE ARE PROPOSING GUEST PARKING ON ONE SIDE OF THAT INTERNAL LOOP STREET MAY HAVE ACCIDENTALLY SAID THERE IS NO PARKING IN THERE. THERE IS GUEST PARKING ON ONE SIDE THERE IS AVAILABLE GUESS PARKING AS WELL AS FULL DRIVEWAYS ON ALL THE HOMES THERE. BUT PRIVATELY MAINTAINED H OA MAINTAINED STREET THERE. I THINK OUR INTENTION IS FOR YARDS TO BE HOA AS WELL. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> I DO HAVE TWO MR. SPEAKERS KEITH HERNEY. >> FAMILIAR FACES UP THERE. EVEN THOUGH I HAVEN'T BEEN TO MANY OF THESE. WE HAVE SEVERAL CONCERNS WITH THIS STARTING WITH TRAFFIC IS MAIN CONCERN AS YOU ALL KNOW WITH THE SCHOOL TRAFFIC THERE IT'S PRETTY MUCH GRIDLOCK COMMENTS WERE GIVEN TO US THEY ARE GOING TO PUT A TRAFFIC LIGHT AND POSSIBLY EMINENT DOMAIN AND TRY TO DO TURN LANE. THAT'S WHAT WE RECEIVED. TRAFFIC LIGHT IS NOT GOING TO DO ANYTHING FOR THAT GRIDLOCK. IT'S PARENTS WAITING TO PICK UP THEIR KIDS. YOU CAN PUT A LIGHT THERE YOU ARE GOING TO SIT THERE AND STAIR AT A GREEN LIGHT NOBODY IS GOING TO MOVE THE WHOLE AREA TRAFFIC IS PRETTY BAD DURING THOSE TIMES. UM...THEY'RE RURAL ROADS IT'S MADE FOR A RURAL COMMUNITY WHICH IS WHY WE WENT THERE BEING ALONG THE VINEYARD WE HAD THE LATTICE FENCES BECAUSE WE HAVE A BEAUTIFUL VIEW OF THE VINEYARD. BUT YEAH. PUTTING 63 HOMES IN THAT SMALL OF AN AREA IS GOING TO NOT BE CONDUCIVE FOR THE TRAFFIC GOING TO MAKE IT WORSE MORE STUDENTS AT THE SCHOOL MORE PARENTS WAITING IT'S EFFECTING WE SENT OUT TO 300 FEET I THINK OF THE EXISTING PROJECT THE EFFECT IS WAY MORE THAN THE SMALL AMOUNT OF HOMES IN THAT 300 FEET BUT THERE ARE STATES AND EVERYBODY USING THOSE AREAS AS WELL. SO, I ASKED TO MOVE AND SEE IF WE CAN EXPAND GET MORE COMMENT FROM OTHER PEOPLE AS WELL. PROPERTY VALUES. I OWN TWO PROPERTIES THAT BORDER THAT I'M KIND OF CONCERNED LOWERING MY PROPERTY VALUES I'M GOING TO HAVE A WALL OF HOUSES YOU KNOW WORDERING THAT PROPERTY NOW SO WE MOVE THERE BECAUSE OF THE RURAL SETTING AND THIS ISN'T CONDUCIVE WITH THAT. SO, YEAH. BORDERING MY TWO PROPERTIES I'M LOOKING AT YOU KNOW SEVEN PROPERTIES THAT WILL BE TOUCHING MY PROPERTIES. LET'S SEE. I WROTE NOTES I JUST STARTED TALKING SO YEAH. WE'RE NOT AGAINST BUILDING BUT IT NEEDS TO.--THE ROAD THE INFRASTRUCTURE DOESN'T MEET THE DEMAND OR THESE HOUSES WE WOULD LIKE IT TO EXISTING HOUSES IN THE AREA. 63 HOMES COMPARED TO I THINK 15 HOMES ON THE SAME AREA. ON OUR NEIGHBORHOOD. THE SAME AREA OF TEN ACRES ON THE OTHER SIDE HAS SIX HOMES SO WE'RE TRYING TO CRAM A LOT IN THERE AND THEN WE HAD BEEN WORKING WITH KEVIN. MY WIFE HAS TALKED TO HIM A COUPLE OF TIMES I GUESS NOW THEY'RE GETTING HIM LOOKING AT IT. THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE TO RAISE THE PROPERTY AND DO A RETAINING WALL FENCE ON TOP LOOKS LIKE IT'S GOING TO BE MORE IMPOSING ON MY PROPERTY AS WELL SO THAT'S IT. THANK YOU. >> SCOTT HOPS? >> THANK YOU SCOTT HOBB'S MY PROPERTY IS UP THE ENTRANCE IS ON OAKLEY ROAD. I HAVE TALKED WITH KEVIN ON MULTIPLE TIMES AND I GOT YOU BEAT I GOT 90 PROPERTIES BUTTING UP AGAINST MINE. I GOT ALMOST HALF OF THE WEST SIDE IS MY LOT. I WILL SAY OF COURSE, I'M NOT EXCITED ABOUT DEVELOPMENT THE VINEYARD HAS BEEN A WONDERFUL VIEW FOR 25 YEARS NOW FOR MY FAMILY. BUT PROGRESS. I WILL SAY THAT THE DEVELOPER HAS TALKED TO ME ON MULTIPLE OCCASIONS THEY HAVE AGREED. I SAW IN THE PLANS THEY'RE PUTTING IN THE CONCRETE WALL RATHER THAN WOOD FENCE BECAUSE THAT WAS GOING TO BE A MAINTENANCE NIGHTMARE FOR ME. MY BACKYARD IS FAIRLY LARGE AND THEY DID AGREE. THEIR MAP SHOWS THEY PUT SINGLE FAMILY HOMES. THAT BUTT UP TO MY BACKYARD SO THEY HAVE BEEN VERY ACCOMMODATING TO OUR CONCERNS. IF I HAD MY CHOICE, OF COURSE, THE VINEYARD WOULD STAY FOREVER HOWEVER THE OTHER PLAN WORKS BETTER FOR ME FROM A FRONT YARD VIEW THE TWO CORNER HOMES WILL TURN AND FACE MORE TOWARDS OAKLEY. I DON'T HAVE A TWO STORY HOME AS SOON AS I WALK OUT MY FRONT DOOR BUT THAT'S A VISUAL THING THE HOA WAS APPEALING MY WIFE AND I CONSIDERED DOWNSIZING AND MOVING INTO ONE OF THOSE SINGLE STORY HOMES, WE WILL SEE. ANY WAY THE OTHER CONCERN WAS THE TRAFFIC. I DON'T KNOW IF A LIGHT WE WILL FIX THAT OR NOT. I DID HEAR MENTION OF A TURN LANE OF SOME SORT. I DON'T KNOW WHERE THAT WOULD BE PLACED GIVEN MY PROPERTY IS RIGHT THERE: I DON'T KNOW IF THAT WOULD EFFECT ME IF I LOSE FRONTAGE OR NOT. I HAVE A BIGGER CONCERN WITH THE PROPOSED PROPERTY ACROSS THE STREET FROM ME EVEN MORE HOUSES AND EVEN MORE TRAFFIC IMPACTING THE NEIGHBORHOOD I'M OUT OF THERE BY 630, 7 O'CLOCK THE SCHOOL DOESN'T EFFECT ME. I CAN'T ADDRESS THAT. ANY WAY IT HAS BEEN A PLEASURE DEALING WITH THE DEVELOPER AND I HAD A LONG RELATIONSHIP WITH THE VINEYARD OWNER SO I DO APPRECIATE THEIR EFFORTS TO ACCOMMODATE US THE BEST THEY CAN. >> SCOTT I WANTED TO ASK, WERE YOU TELLING US YOU LIKE THE ONE WITH THE GATE OR WITHOUT THE GATE. >> I DON'T KNOW IT WAS THE GATE THE OTHER PLAN SHOWS THAT THE ENTRANCE MOVES DOWN THE ROAD A LITTLE WAYS. WITH THE GATE THOSE TWO CORNERS 17 AND 18 WOULD KIND OF TURN MORE OF A CIRCULAR CORNER BUT THAT'S JUST ME. >> THANK YOU. THERE ARE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE TURNING LATE AND HOW THAT SIGNAL WOULD WORK DO WE HAVE VISUALS HOW THAT WOULD WORK. >> THAT WOULD BE LIVE OAK THE SIGNALS INSTALLED THERE AND WIDTH PROVIDED IT WOULDN'T BE A TURN LANE PER SE RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE PROJECT THIS GENTLEMEN'S PROPERTY PROBABLY WOULDN'T BE EFFECTED EITHER UNLESS THE WHOLE ROAD WAY NEEDS TO BE WIDENED AT THAT LOCATION THE TRAFFIC SIGNAL HAS NOT BEEN DESIGNED YET. WHEN IT IS, WE HOPE TURN LANE TO KEEP TRAFFIC FLOWING THROUGH THERE. SCHOOL TIME IS PROBABLY NOT. >> IF THIS IS PART OF THE REQUEST OR THE DESIRE OF THE APPLICANT TO INSTALL THAT. SHOULDN'T THE DESIGN REVIEW BE PART OF THAT AS WELL. >> IT'S A TECHNICAL DESIGN RATHER THAN A PLANNING APPROVAL YOU SHOULDN'T TYPICALLY SEE THE CONSTRUCTION PLAN FOR APPROVAL BY COUNCIL WE CAN SHOW YOU WHAT'S BEEN SKETCHED. >> THEY DO GO HAND IN HAND AND IT WOULD HELP WITH THE DESIGN REVIEW PORTION TO KNOW EXACTLY HOW THAT WOULD EFFECT THE REST OF THE OUTLINING AREA ON THAT NOTE WHAT IS OAKLEY ROAD GOING TO BUILD TO? IS IT GOING TO BE ONE LANE WITH A CENTER TURN LANE IS IT TWO LANES EACH DIRECTION? W

Minutes of Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Meeting held September 10, 2019 1) OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Mayor Claire Alaura called the meeting to order at 6:31 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California. In addition to Mayor Alaura, Vice Mayor Doug Hardcastle and Councilmembers Sue Higgins, Randy Pope and Kevin Romick were present. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Cole Sicheneder, 3rd Grade Student at Laurel Elementary School) 3rd Grade Laurel Elementary School Student Cole Sicheneder led the Pledge of Allegiance. The City Council thanked him. 1.3 Proclamation Recognizing September as National Suicide Prevention + Action Month Mayor Alaura read the proclamation. 2) PUBLIC COMMENTS Dan Mendoza commented on Garwood Lane between Norcross Lane and Landis Avenue. He submitted a correction notice, map and photos which were made part of the meeting record. He explained children use the dirt path on Garwood Lane to travel to and from school, the County maintained the path until the City incorporated, then property owners adjacent to Garwood Lane were told by the City that they are responsible for maintaining it. He commented that there are garbage cans maintained by contractors at Koda Dog Park and inquired what is more important, dogs or kids. He requested the City maintain Garwood Lane. He also commented that he supports the schools of closing of the parks. Mayor Alaura inquired if Garwood Lane is a private road. City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded it is a public alley, but if debris or landscape encroach onto it, the property owners are responsible to maintain it and this is why Mr. Mendoza received a correction notice. Mr. Mendoza commented he wants to see it maintained by the City. Mayor Alaura inquired if Mr. Mendoza has connected with City staff to discuss the matter.

Mr. Mendoza commented he and City staff have been leaving messages for one another; however, the property was always maintained by the County. Mr. Montgomery mentioned he has left messages for Mr. Mendoza as Mr. Mendoza indicated and he is happy to meet with him to discuss the matter further. Mr. Mendoza commented he wants to discuss the matter with the City Council. Mayor Alaura explained the item is not on agenda; therefore, the City Council cannot have a discussion on the matter, but he is welcome to work with staff, then it can be considered as an agenda item. Marc Smith commented he is representing his grandparents in regard to rent increases in their neighborhood. He explained lease amendments have been presented to tenants to extend residency for 1 year; however every 3 months a 5% increase will be imposed. He further explained tenants receive fixed income, the average rent is currently $800 per month and the stated increase will leave tenants very little money for food and other expenditures. He shared many are not fortunate to have family around to assist, they are in need of help and not certain where to turn; therefore, they are looking for guidance and where to explore resolution. Councilmember Pope inquired which development is being discussed. Councilmember Romick responded it is the housing behind Lucky's called Summer Creek. He mentioned a number of speakers may have the same problem and explained the City Council does not regulate rent. He mentioned the City Council can provide a letter of support and this is not an issue unique to this development; other developments are going through similar issues. City Manager Bryan Montgomery expressed empathy. He explained the City has no jurisdiction and is powerless to regulate rent because State and Federal law regulates rent. He shared that the City can provide information regarding which agencies tenants can contact and invited tenants to let the City know if it can provide letters of support or make calls, but the City does not regulate rent. Mr. Smith thanked the City Council and commented he hopes to have the City's support moving forward. Adriana Smith commented that because of the rent increase, some tenants have moved to other affordable housing, relocated to other states, or they are at the mercy of their families for support. She shared it is disheartening to see low-income housing in the hands of corporate greed that has increased rent to a point in which residents have little money for food; most people spend more at Starbucks than the amount of money tenants have left after paying rent. She shared Summer Creek is a wonderful community, police and fire are responsive, her parents are proud to live there, she feels safe knowing her parents live there, it is ideal since it is close to stores, and it is a good place to live, but it is all going away because of corporate greed; tenants are being pushed out. She commented tenants are relying on the City Council as its elected leaders to champion for them. She asked the City Council to please help her parents. Patricia Solari commented she is the daughter of a tenant at Summer Creek who is 95 years old and she won’t go through her speech because the City Council has already put them down. She inquired what can be done to help tenants. She explained many are disabled and many will be homeless in result of the rent increase which will cost the County more. She further explained

rent is expected to be raised to $1,395 in the next 5 months and she is already subsidizing $500 per month to her mom for her to live there. She shared it was good up until a year ago when rent increases were announced. She mentioned there is an average 2-4 year waiting list for other places in the area and she has to be close to her mom to take care of her. Mr. Montgomery mentioned forms with contact information for agencies the tenants can contact are now available on the back table. He encouraged residents to call and let the City know how it can help. He mentioned it may be that the corporation is allowed under Federal law to charge the increases in rent. He added that the State legislature is working on something, but the City does not regulate rent. Councilmember Romick commented he lives near Summer Creek and remembers when it was built. He shared that the new management or ownership may have the ability under Federal law to catch up with rent increases; rather than raising rent each year, they raise it at once to catch up. He expressed empathy and support, but explained the City does not regulate rent; State and Federal laws regulate rent. He mentioned AB 1482 was just approved in the State legislature to address rent control. Ms. Solari commented she is here because she was told the County was going to pass rent control. Councilmember Romick commented the County Board of Supervisors is the appropriate body to speak with regarding County matters. He mentioned the City will support and can call the organizations, but cannot regulate State and Federal law. Diane Spurrier commented she is a resident of the Section 42 program also known as low- income housing and affordable housing and believes the rent increase and the way tenants are being treated is emotional and psychological elder abuse. She explained some tenants are limited to their homes due to their health and the property management is aware residents are on fixed income. She requested the City Council stand behind the tenants, help write letters, and represent the people of Oakley. She mentioned she will be contacting the Attorney General’s Office because they can’t get representatives behind them to do something. Vicki Morgan commented her mother and aunt live in Summer Creek and she understands the City Council’s position. She mentioned the construction at Laurel and Empire is a traffic nightmare and she hopes crews can start work after school traffic in the mornings, bury plates in the streets so cars are not damaged, and pour concrete correctly. She explained her car rims were dented because of the many times she has had to drive over construction plates and her tires have divots from the concrete; she believes the workers should have to do it right. She inquired who is responsible for trash, car parts and animals on the major arterial roads. Mayor Alaura responded that the responsibility depends on the area where the trash is located; if it is around 7-Eleven, she believes it is the store’s responsibility. She added that animal control handles dead animals and street trash is handled by the City’s contractor for street sweeping. Ms. Morgan commented animal control does not pick up the dead animals. Margaret Berry commented she is a Summer Creek resident and the rent increase is criminal and unjust. She explained tenants are forced to sign an income statement that they make less than $62k per year and are provided no copy of what they have signed. She spoke of someone

named Maria who took information to the tax credit board and has used strong arm tactics at Summer Creek. She explained tenants have had at least 10 inspections and are uncertain what they are for; in result, tenants are being given only 3 days’ notice to correct issues or they have to get out. She commented it is abnormal treatment and the owners are out of state and using the tax basis/credit for its own means. She expressed she is tired of living under duress and under tyranny. She stated this is America, not Mexico where Maria is from. She explained she has been realtor since 1979 and she knows what they are doing is not right. She shared she is 75 years old, angry, and moving people is wrong. Vice Mayor Hardcastle suggested if she believes criminal activity is involved and wants to speak with someone more local, she might try contacting the District Attorney’s Office. Mike Dupray commented he is proud of the seniors. He recommended the City Council participate in their meetings to try and proactively address the rent increases rather than just telling tenants to make calls. He explained there is no COLA next year but the CPI is going up and housing is generally recommended to be 1/3 of a household income, but in this situation, it far exceeds that recommendation. He expressed he understands hands may be tied, but it is worth going after as the federal government is not the end all, they just need to find a work- around. He mentioned the homeless issue is going to get worse by this situation; it costs about $300k to leave people homeless, but it costs only $50k to get them off the streets. Mark Foley introduced himself as the newest director of BART. He commented he is looking forward to working with the City to jointly address transportation matters to make the region move better. Councilmember Romick requested Mr. Foley work with staff to set up a report to the Council twice a year which Mr. Foley was agreeable to do. Mayor Alaura announced the City Council received a handful of comments from people regarding rent increases at Summer Creek who do not want to speak, but would like their comments submitted for the meeting record and they will be entered into the meeting record (infra). Sandra Johnson submitted comments that rent increases began at Summer Creek in 2018 and since January 2019, increases have been imposed at $50 every 3 months; rent will be $1,045 in October and then increased to $1,095. She added the owners have made inspections 4 times per year and take pictures of the inside. Margaret Flaugher submitted comments that she is confused because Summer Creek is not a HUD facility, yet the owners use Cal State Tax/HUD laws to increase rent ($50 every 3 months=35% in one year) yet don’t apply the same laws to fixed incomes of tenants; in many cases, rent is exceeding income. Pauline “PJ” Jimenez submitted comments that the owners accept tenants at Summer Creek because of age and low-income, but then raise the rent exceeding income which can create homelessness. Barbara LaSpada submitted comments that she has lived at Summer Creek for 10 years in which the rent this past year has totaled a $305 increase beginning July 2018 through October 2019, with continued increases every 3 months.

Margaret Garcia submitted comments that she does not understand how their rent at Summer Creek can continue to go up $50 every other month (by February 2020, it will go up to $1,003) when they know most tenants only get $980 per month, some up to $1,100 per month with social security. Ann Peters submitted comments with concern regarding the high cost of rent and continual increases of rent at Summer Creek. Hester Frazier submitted comments requesting help due to the ongoing rent increases at Summer Creek. Mary Francisco submitted comments requesting help to stop the continuing rent increases at Summer Creek as many tenants will end up homeless unless the City intervenes and helps. Mary Jo McCullough submitted comments that she is present because of the high rent at Summer Creek. Juanita Perez submitted comments that she is present because of the high rent at Summer Creek. Dave Wahl, President of the Oakley Rotary Club, announced the Oakley chapter of the Rotary was chartered May 29 and they have assembled a group to unite and take action for positive change in the community. He shared local community service events Oakley Rotary has been involved in as well as upcoming events. He invited the community to join and participate in Oakley Rotary meetings held at Black Bear Diner in Oakley, Thursdays at 7 a.m. Vera Martinez, also with the Oakley Rotary Club, announced an event Oakley Rotary is hosting September 28 at the Oakley Recreation Center which will include dinner and a comedy show featuring Michael Mancini, world’s funniest cop. She mentioned tickets are $50 per person and can be purchased by contacting her or Dave Wahl, or online at www.oakleyrotary.com, or through liking Oakley Rotary on Facebook. Mayor Alaura thanked them for their work and community support. 3) CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve Minutes from Regular Joint City Council/City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held August 13, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Award of Construction Contract to Cowboy Concrete Pumping for the FY 2019/20 Curb, Gutter, & Sidewalk Repair & Replacement Project – CIP 233 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.3 City of Oakley 4th Quarter Investment Report (Tim Przybyla, Finance Director) 3.4 Successor Agency 4th Quarter Investment Report (Tim Przybyla, Finance Director) 3.5 Heart of Oakley Road Closure (Eric Christensen, Chief of Police)

3.6 Adopt a Resolution Updating Job Classifications and Related Disclosure Categories as set forth in Section 2.9.008(a) of the Oakley Municipal Code Regarding the Conflict of Interest Code (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.7 Consideration of a Resolution Repealing Resolution No. 118-05 and Designating a Board Member and an Alternate Board Member to the Municipal Pooling Authority of Northern California (MPA) (Tim Przybyla, Finance Director) It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) 4) PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 4190 Brown Road Minor Subdivision Tentative Map Extension (TME 01 19) – Request for a three (3) year extension to the expiration of the Tentative Parcel Map MS 08-978, located at 4190 Brown Road. (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Mayor Alaura opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Ken Strelo presented the staff report. There were no questions from the City Council, no comments from the applicant and no public comment. Mayor Alaura closed the public hearing. There was no deliberation. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to adopt the resolution. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) Mayor Alaura announced item 4.3 will be heard before item 4.2. 4.2 The Vines at Oakley Subdivision 9507 (GPA 05-18, RZ 09-18, TM 06-18, DR 13-18) – Request for approval of a General Plan Amendment, Rezone, Tentative Map, and Design Review to construct a new residential subdivision with 63 single-family residential lots located at 2371 Oakley Road.(Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Mayor Alaura opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Ken Strelo presented the staff report. Councilmember Romick clarified and restated that if the map is approved tonight, there is no way, at any time, that apartments will be built on this property. Mr. Strelo confirmed apartments will not be built on this property. Mayor Alaura inquired which part of the property is being requested for rezone.

Mr. Strelo responded that it is not shown on the slides, but the information is in the staff report packet; it is a portion of the northern section of the lot. Councilmember Romick commented on the map, the north (right side of map) top 1/4 would be rezoned as multi-family residential, low-density. Vice Mayor Hardcastle inquired why lattice is shown on top of the fence in the renderings. Mr. Strelo explained lattice is a higher design quality fencing and the design guidelines would require it for side or corner lots. Councilmember Higgins inquired if homes would have to have open-view fencing facing the park. Mr. Strelo responded that the applicant may wish to address whether or not it would be required. Councilmember Higgins mentioned 3 proposed homes abut Oakley Road. She inquired what is across the street from the proposed homes. Mr. Strelo responded it is an empty field for now. Applicant Comments MLC Holdings, LLC, a Meritage Land Company, representative Kevin Fryer thanked staff and the City Council for working together with him. He mentioned his team took comments and concerns from the previous work session and worked to address those issues creatively and effectively. He mentioned there was a through traffic concern and now a bollard and bike/pedestrian-only access on Thomas Drive will resolves cut-through traffic access or a gated community provides another option; however, because the drive is wider, the gated option shrinks lots that would have had additional RV access, the entrance point would relocate and 3 of the homes would rotate to face Oakley Road. He mentioned he is open to discussion on options. He shared that previous feedback indicated single-story homes are a big feature, a community benefit program is desired to address restrooms at Holly Creek Park, and that the Council desires his team to be good neighbor to adjacent residents. He mentioned his team has looked for ways to try and limit visual impact of the project as they are sensitive that change can be impactful to residents; he knows it may not be welcome with open arms, but he is willing to discuss. Councilmember Romick commented he noticed there is no access door from garages to the outside and it is an addition he would like to see. Mr. Fryer responded he believes it was an oversight and has asked his architects to include it. Councilmember Higgins inquired if there would still be a home owners association (HOA) if there is no gate. Mr. Fryer responded that there would still be an HOA that would likely maintain the street and front yards. He mentioned guest parking will be available on one side of the neighborhood and in full driveways for each home.

Public Comments Monica Hurney submitted a letter to the City Council and staff which was made part of the meeting record. Keith Hurney commented he has concerns about school traffic which grid locks and will happen even with the proposed traffic light, which may require eminent domain for a turn lane. He explained the traffic light won’t do anything with parents stopping to pick up their kids. He mentioned these are rural roads made for a rural community and they will be losing the view of the vineyards. He indicated that 63 homes in that small of an area will make traffic worse. He mentioned he understands notice of the project was provided to homeowners/landowners within 300 feet of the existing project, but he believes more homes than in that 300 foot radius will be impacted and noticing should be expanded so that more people are informed. He shared that he owns 2 properties bordering this property and he is concerned about the impact on the value of his properties since 7 properties in this project will touch his 2 properties. He commented he is not against building, but the infrastructure doesn’t support the homes and he would like the homes to match existing homes in the area, meaning less density. He added that he has already spoken with Mr. Fryer regarding a retaining wall. Scott Hobbs commented that his property is on the entrance to Oakley Road and he has spoken with Mr. Fryer on multiple occasions. He shared that 9 of the proposed properties will abut his property, he is not excited about the development and the vineyard has been a wonderful view-if it were his choice, the vineyard would stay forever. He mentioned Mr. Fryer has been accommodating to their concerns and if he has a choice of plans, the first plan is better for him. He mentioned he and his wife have considered downsizing and maybe they would move into one of the proposed homes. He also mentioned he is not sure that the traffic light would resolve traffic matters and the turn lane may require losing some property frontage. He added a bigger concern may be regarding the housing across from him which will be more impacted by traffic. He expressed it has been a pleasure to deal with the developer. Councilmember Higgins asked Mr. Hobbs if he likes the plan with the gate or without the gate. Mr. Hobbs responded he likes the plan with the gate where the entrance moves down. Mayor Alaura inquired if any visual renderings are available for the traffic signal. City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded that renderings are not available because the traffic signal has not been designed yet; however, it would be located at Live Oak Avenue and the property may not be affected. Mayor Alaura inquired if the traffic light should be included as it is part of the project. Mr. Montgomery responded staff can bring it back for Council review. Mayor Alaura commented she believes they go hand-in-hand to decide on this item. Councilmember Pope inquired what the build-out will look like on Oakley Road.

Mr. Montgomery responded the City doesn’t have the right-of-way so some land may have to be obtained. He mentioned the site plan and rezone wouldn’t relate to this, but staff can bring it back. Vice Mayor Hardcastle inquired if the traffic study considers what is going on across the street or just the property to be developed. Mr. Strelo responded that it is in the General Plan designation that they must look at all surrounding lots in the traffic study. Mayor Alaura requested staff address the traffic study. Associate Civil Engineer Billilee Saengchalern explained that the General Plan provides that Oakley Road will have 4 lanes east, 2 lanes west, and Live Oak Avenue will have 4 lanes north, 2 lanes south to meet ultimate needs, but staff will design for the interim condition to accommodate current needs. Councilmember Romick explained that Oakley has a lot of country roads and future development will help build out the roads. Mayor Alaura closed the public hearing. Mayor Alaura asked Mr. Strelo to return to the items on his slide presentation that the Council needs to address. Councilmember Pope commented that he appreciates that the applicant has been good to work with the residents and staff toward creative solutions. He mentioned the property is near the edge of the City and it has been zoned residential as long as the City has been incorporated; however, he is sensitive to residents’ concerns and encourages the applicant to continue to be a good neighbor. He expressed preference for the plan with the gate. He mentioned he is glad there will be a HOA, no through traffic, and that the traffic signal will happen sooner than later to address school traffic. He also mentioned that widening the road will provide sidewalks for kids to walk. He shared he is sympathetic to the residents who abut the property and encouraged the applicant to do anything it can to lessen the impact of the development. He encourage staff to help facilitate supporting that. He mentioned there are more houses than originally zoned, but some buyers may be looking for a smaller place with less maintenance. Councilmember Romick commented that he dittos a lot of Councilmember Pope’s comments and appreciates the compromises made to provide a loop rather than through traffic on Thomas Drive and a bathroom at Holly Creek Park. He shared that he lives in Holly Creek and can empathize with the loss of the vineyard; the vineyard behind his house may also be gone in the future. He mentioned school traffic anywhere in the City is heavy. He expressed preference for the non-gated plan because it provides more street scape, a softer entrance to the development, and it is aesthetically pleasing. Vice Mayor Hardcastle expressed preference for the gated plan. He mentioned people living there might appreciate it so the street is not used for a drag strip. He also mentioned he likes that traffic cannot drive through Thomas Drive and all looks good. Monica Hurney inquired about swapping lots.

Mr. Fryer responded that they can make adjustment to the lots for the Hurney’s. Ms. Hurney commented lots 55-59 abut their property. Mr. Fryer commented that they would like to put on the meeting record that if the gated plan is approved, lots 54 and 55 flip and if the non-gated plan is approved, lots 55 and 57 flip. Councilmember Higgins thanked everyone for working together. She expressed preference for the gated plan because of safety and no through traffic. She commented school traffic is heavy everywhere. Mayor Alaura agreed with the comments shared. She mentioned she appreciates the applicant working well with the residents and also appreciates the comments staff took from the meeting held one year ago and for providing creative solutions to address resident concerns. She expressed preference for the gated plan. Councilmember Pope inquired what the street frontage will look like from Oakley Road with the gated option. Mr. Strelo explained there is no conceptual plan, but staff can bring back a conceptual plan by memo on the Consent Calendar or staff can approve a conceptual plan in accordance with the City Council’s direction. Councilmember Pope commented he appreciates the landscape on the non-gated plan, to save and relocate vines to maintain the rural character of the area. City Manager Bryan Montgomery suggested it could be a condition of approval which would give staff and the applicant direction to comply. Councilmember Romick commented he is fine with the option Mr. Montgomery has stated; however, he is not fond of the gated option, but majority wins. City Attorney Derek Cole advised the Council can make a motion for the recommendations provided by staff. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Pope to approve the recommendations provided by staff with the exception that the gated plan landscaping mimic the non-gated plan landscaping as closely as possible and lots 54 and 55 shall be flipped. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) Mayor Alaura thanked everyone for working together. 4.3 Subdivision 9015 Tentative Map Extension (TME 02-19) – Request for a three (3) year extension to the expiration of Tentative Map 9015 (known as “Cosetti and Creson Subdivision”) located at 4219 Machado Lane (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Mayor Alaura opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Ken Strelo presented the staff report.

Mayor Alaura inquired if the applicant received a previous extension. Mr. Strelo responded that the applicant received an extension three years ago. There were no comments from the applicant and no public comment. Mayor Alaura closed the public hearing. There was no deliberation. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to adopt the resolution. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) 5) REGULAR CALENDAR 6) REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager City Manager Bryan Montgomery reported that the Recreation Division has relocated its offices to the new Oakley Recreation Center and in-person registration for classes is now available there (1250 O’Hara Avenue) or online. He also reported the Farmers Market is open Sundays, 9am-1pm, at Civic Center Plaza. He announced the City will host a Movie in the Plaza, Saturday September 14, and the Heart of Oakley Festival Saturday, September 21, both at Civic Center Plaza. He shared the last Friday Night Bites and concert was excellent and the next food and concert event will be held October 4 at Civic Center Plaza. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Announcement of appointments to a School Parks Ad hoc Subcommittee Mayor Alaura announced the City Council appoints Councilmembers Sue Higgins and Randy Pope to the School Parks Ad hoc Subcommittee and she believes the school district has also selected its appointees. (b) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Romick reported he attended the Grand Opening of the new fitness court (located between the Oakley Recreation Center and multi-purpose field at 1250 O’Hara Avenue) and Mayor Alaura was the first mayor to use the equipment. He commented that he hopes it becomes more visible and since it is adjacent to the trail, he hopes a staircase may be installed from the trail to the fitness court. He encourage everyone to visit the fitness court and download the associated electronic application which allows individuals to track workouts. Mayor Alaura mentioned there are different workouts available on the electronic application.

Councilmember Romick also reported the Contra Costa Transportation Authority put together its 2020 Transportation Expenditure Plan which will be presented at the October 8 Oakley City Council meeting. He explained the half-cent sales tax measure will provide a $3.6 billion of revenue with 55% of it going toward transit and alternative modes and nearly 30% invested in East County. He explained the funds will improve and provide congestion relief on State Route 242, Highway 4 and through the eBART corridor. He added that future business at the former DuPont property and developing the Byron airport will provide more local jobs. He expressed that he hopes to support it moving forward. Councilmember Higgins welcomed the Oakley Rotary Club and mentioned there is a place for them to put their sign up. She reported she attended the 20th Anniversary Committee meeting and announced author Carol Jensen who wrote a historical book on Oakley (Oakley Through Time) will be at the Heart of Oakley Festival. Mayor Alaura announced the 20th Anniversary Committee will sell bricks to be placed at Koda Dog Park and purchasers will receive a scarf for their dog when ordering. She reported she attended the Mayors’ Conference where the Contra Costa Transportation Authority presented its expenditure plan. She mentioned she also learned that the 10th Annual Mayors’ Healthy Cook-Off will occur September 26 (at Todos Santos Plaza in Concord, 4pm-7pm) and announced Stephane, owner of the Oakley Bistro, will join her to participate. She shared it is open to public and if they win, they bring back a trophy for a year. She also reported she attended a district safety committee meeting at the schools where Oakley Police Chief Christensen provided an update regarding safety drills that Police, Fire and the schools are participating in. She announced the Nixle program is available to residents; it provides emergency updates directly from Police and anyone can sign up at www.nixle.com. (c) Requests for Future Agendas None. 7) WORK SESSIONS 7.1 Oakley General Plan Update Work Session – Update on public input and next steps (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Community Development Director Joshua McMurray presented the staff report. He mentioned in regard to public outreach, 2 community meetings were held in June but not well-attended; however, over 100 responses were received with the online public survey, and consultants at Denova created a white paper. Beth Thompson, Principal, and Elise Carroll, Senior Planner, both with De Novo Planning Group, provided a presentation and explained the purpose of the General Plan, opportunities with the update, elements required by state law and optional topics, the process of the update, visioning, top values and priorities (including community character, mobility, economy/local jobs, shopping/services and family oriented recreation venues), and the update schedule. Councilmember Higgins shared that she attended one of workshops and it was very helpful to see the layout on the map and where people would plot things.

Ms. Thompson commented the map was made available on the online survey in their effort to try and reproduce the in-person workshop experience online. She shared they received precise, informative responses with constructive suggestions. Mayor Alaura thanked them. She mentioned it takes a lot of work to host sessions combined with the data received online. Councilmember Pope commented he is disheartened about the lack of attendance of in-person meetings. He mentioned he understands the City did a lot of outreach and inquired if there was anything the City could have done differently. Mr. McMurray responded that they held evening meetings so people commuting would have a better opportunity to attend and staff noticed the public workshops; however, this is not an anomaly; it happens often and this is why they chose an online tool to provide people an opportunity to respond. Councilmember Pope commented that online participation may be a shift of what to expect in future. Mayor Alaura thanked them for their presentation and work. She mentioned she looks forward to the next step. 8) CLOSED SESSION 9) ADJOURN There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:45 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk

Sep 10, 2019 - 06:30 PM — Agenda

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Sep 10, 2019 - 06:30 PM — Minutes
  • Sep 10, 2019 - 06:30 PM

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e31214ba0ad5c1b1a53aa6811bdd3cd9. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record