POLISCOPE

The public record

GULFPORT (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Meeting

Tuesday, November 1, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Consent: 5.a. Consider approval of the Council Meeting minutes of October 4, 2022. EXHIBIT: Item 5.a - Minutes 10-04-2022.pdf

Why it matters

This item is supported by a public source record.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Captured actions

2

Recorded outcomes

0

Source artifacts

2

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 127,973 stored characters

>> Welcome to the November 1st City Council meeting for Gulfport, Florida. The invocation is given by April Thanos followed by the pledge of allegiance. so many years ago, I like to take my time and examine the two candidates. Seeing not only the candidates but the policies they will bring in, the people they will bring in, who might -- who they might appoint to the Supreme Court and look at the whole range of issues before making a decision. From Colin Powell. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Roll call please. Council member Thanos? >> Yes. >> Vice mayor brown? >> Yes. Mayor Henderson? >> Here. >> All right. First thing on the list tonight is our presentation for the Halloween decoration contest winner. Our commercial theme was won by Gulfport Beach Bazaar. As our general theme contest winner, is Dana here? All right. Congratulations. Thanks for the Halloween spirit. There you go. Thank you. Thanks for being a part of it. >> Good job. >> Thanks. All right. We'll start off with open public comment. This is for any item that's not otherwise on the agenda. You'll have three minutes. I'm going to go by a show of hands. Give your name and address if you're comfortable with it and we'll start off right now. Anything that is not otherwise on the agenda? Yes, sir. Come to the podium. You may have to adjust the mic to get yourself comfortable with it. How are you? >> My name is Jonathan Robert. I reside at 1012 Fremont Street. My wife and I purchased our home in June of 2021. We moved here from D.C. on the heels of the pandemic after both of our jobs went remote to be closer to family. Her dad retired in Pinellas County over five years ago to be near his sister, and her and her husband were both Pinellas County schoolteachers for 30 years. We purposely chose Gulfport because of the progressive, inclusive and welcoming nature that the city presents. Unfortunately, unbeknownst to us at the time, we closed on a house that was directly behind a man who lived behind hus he is a known quantity and widely regarded in the community as a menace. Everyone I've spoken to Mark at code enforcement rolled their eyes. We, my wife, and other neighbors reached out to councilman Ray about this because he's our ward councilman. He was helpful to set up a meeting between us and the chief of police and the City Manager. You know, unfortunately, in that time period, we've called the cops on him for his abusive and violent behavior on several occasions, and the Gulfport police department have been no help to us whatsoever in this. And after our meeting with the chief, I was told -- like, literally, I had a meeting where instead of being an advocate for these affected members of the community, I had to debate what a credible threat really was after I and my wife's life had been threatened by this gentleman. Today a Pinellas County judge found that our issues were credible. He issued an injunction against Mr. Donnellini. All four of the neighbors received this injunction. Now I only hope that when I call the police department, they will actually, effectively deal with this menace and deal with him appropriately. This pattern of appeasement seems like it has been going on for years. I know for a fact that the city used city resources and manpower to plant plans and landscaping in the easement in front of his house because it's that unsightly. I'm asking to be treated correctly under the law. I really want to know what the city will do about enforcing all the code violations over his property. He's got an RV sitting there for a year. It's rat-infested, it doesn't run, his fence is a mess, he has lights that shines directly into a neighbor's house that he uses for harassment and I don't have any progress with code enforcement. They've haven't done anything about these issues. >> All right. Thank you very much for your comments. Did you want to leave a copy of this document? >> I'll forward this all via email. It's at the point now that I feel like we've done everything we can as neighbors to protect ourselves. Now it's in the hands of bigger authorities than us, and I would hope they would take these issues seriously and respond in kind. I appreciate your time today. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Thank you very much. Ms. Levin. Karen Love, 23rd Avenue South. I wanted to say thank you. It took a long time, but you guys have started the ball rolling now to, in fact, hire another code enforcement officer. I know that based on the conversations that a big part of this job will be addressing the short-term rentals, but I think maybe you're starting to hear how many issues we have. I mean, what the gentleman just talked about, there's so many code enforcement issues here that are never enforced and it's very frustrating, and I don't know why we keep passing ordinances if we're not going to enforce them. Thank you very much for moving forward. I would like to ask publicly about the tennis courts. The last time I asked publicly, I was told they would be finished in March. That was in 2022. I know that they were started. And I know two days after Ian hit, they were working on them, which was quite impressive. But I was also told it would take a week, which I couldn't imagine. We've had no tennis courts now for five to six weeks. I don't think anything's been done in two weeks. So, I'm wondering if the contractor has been fired or if they, in fact, have quit to go on the bigger jobs. I'm hoping that could be publicly addressed so that we'd know what the story is on that. And then the third thing I wanted to address was some of the encampments that are popping up around town, and I've been to enough meetings to know that the city does not have a lot of rights which you can do with our >> As I've done in every election since I started voting homeless people, okay? I do feel like my life was threatened by the man who reside at pavilion number 3. I did talk about it when it happened. It -- it -- there was a little joke made, and I understood why, because, mayor, you had the same thing when you called the police and they wanted to know the address. He's there every day. He has a full encampment. He sleeps on the picnic bench, his chairs, food, furniture, his goods in the area. In addition to that, and I think this homeowner is gone and not aware there's been another house overtaken by a homeless person now on the corner of 26th And Beach. There's a house, and there's a gentleman that goes there every night, sets up his camp on their side porch/side yard, sleeps there all night. You can still see him because he sleeps until about 9:00 in the morning. Then he leaves all his stuff there all day and goes and does what he wants. He comes back. The hurricane shutters are on. Can the rest of us set up camp and rent out our yards? It's a serious question. >> Thank you. Who else for open public comment? Yes. How are you? >> Hi. Inagreed, 2701 56th Street South. I'm here on behalf of Gulfport Votes a nonpartisan group. November 8th, everybody will have voted, I hope. Just to give statistics, in 2020, Gulfport voted turnout was 88%. Woo! That's the number to beat this year, right? 88%. (Applause) I hope we can do better this. This is the midterms. People do not necessarily always turn out. After November 8th, we can put away our signs and roll up our sleeves to start working on continuing our lives here in Gulfport. For that, I wanted to make the invitation to the town hall that's sponsored by councilor Thanos and co-hosted by leaders, civic, business, community leaders, as well as a group of people, you'll see some with green shirts on here, and there are about 30 people helping produce this and co-host thisthis. So, I wanted to officially invite everybody, all the citizens. We need everybody at the table. We're hoping and planning on 80 people at the first one, which is not 17,000 residents, we know that, but we will be getting the word out. And we do invite people to come and participate, give their perspectives. I know people like to give their opinions. We're really asking for people to come in and give their perspectives. The purpose of the first one called "Finding Common Ground" is to really help people see where we are now. We are post-pandemic, post-elections, post-hurricane Ian and, yet, we know we're still in hurricane season. So, what are our current conditions now? What are some possibilities? We'll start talking about that. Everyone here is invited. Everyone that loves Gulfport that lives, works and plays in Gulfport. We're hoping to have students from Stetson, maybe from other colleges around to help out and participate in this, and we certainly want all the citizens to show up because their perspective is important. My ask of the council is that you bring people -- help people come to this. We really want this voice. This will be a facilitated process. We would love it if the invitation came from the council leaders to invite people to come. I'll be leaving information. You can give it out, and if we can work with the sunshine laws, we'd love to have you come, too. >> All right. Thank you very much. Anyone else for public comment? Yes. >> 59th Street. I have two quick questions. One, I know the utility rates changed recently, and I was wondering, I noticed that a number of people that have empty lots and are, quote, on standby only pay $16 or $17 a month while others play probably now $60 a month. I was wondering what that anomaly was that was built in there. Then the other question I have is, when the city is made aware of errors such as billing the wrong owner of a home, is there an attempt made to correct that? Thank you. >> All right. Thank you. Anyone else for open public comment tonight? Yes, in the back. Hi. >> Yes, um, Eileen in a -- Navarro. Have we installed Wi-Fi in the Hickman theater. I know it was in the budget. It was a grandiose plan to add Wi-Fi to a lot of the city fatalities. I asked you to put Wi-Fi in the Catherine Hickman theater as soon as possible. It's really, really needed. Thank you. >> Anyone else for public comment? Okay. Seeing no one, that brings us to the City Manager's report. If there's any of that you want to address now publicly, go for it. The rest we can follow up on post meeting. I can address a few of these. In regards to the Wi-Fi, we still have equipment on backorder that we're doing both the theater. He is working on it. As soon as we get everything delivered, we'll start the process for all the locations, including the theater. In regards to the tennis court and pickleball courts, it's an ongoing process. The contractor is still on the job. I'll check again with Tom tomorrow to get a better timeline. It usually takes longer than five to six weeks to be completed. Let me check on that. The other one that I do have an answer for is the house that was identified at 26th Avenue And Beach Boulevard, the police have investigated that situation, and that is a member of the -- I want to parse how I identify this individual. It's a family member of the property owner. And that's all I have. Oh, just a reminder. The Veterans Day parade will be Sunday at 11:00. >> All right. Fantastic. Thank you. City Attorney report? >> No report, mayor. Consider approval of council meeting minutes October 4th, 2022. Entertain a motion council. >> Motion on the consent agent. All in favor say aye. Passes unanimously. Ordinance number 2022-14. Providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between 44th street South and the north-south alley and legally described therein providing for severability in conflict here with. >> Mayor, this will be a three-part introductory. The board passed this on to you with a approval. Recommendation of -- it's only a recommendation of approval. Subsequently, they did add conditions to the project. It's within your memo outlining nondevelopment, nonuse of it for construction purposes and it will be included in the ordinance if you so choose. >> Do you mind giving background how this came about. >> Sure. We had an issue with -- and I understand we had an issue with accessibility to the area adjacent to the individual's property. This is a property located on what would be the north side of Clam Bayou where there was a question of accessibility. This turned into more than just an access distributive property. It became more of a neighbor dispute. The applicants do have the ability, through our city code, to make application for vacation. Hence, we're here. >> Okay. Mr. Taylor's here to give a brief, more detailed specifics. >> Okay. Fantastic. >> Mayor, we're going to cover each of the three. Now, you will have to address each separately. Mike's overview will be of all three properties. Right. >> The reason we do that because it's three separate plats. >> Yes, three separate actions. >> Okay. >> Good evening. >> Hey. How you doing, Mike? >> Pretty good. All three applications are for the vacation of a portion of Beach Drive. The access points at the south end of 44th Street, the alley that's in between 44th and Quincy, that's going to remain open. And, also, the southern point of Quincy Street, where it intersects with Beach Drive, that will remain open as well. Right-of-way vacation applications, they are granted by chapter 17 of the Code of Ordinances, specifically, it's section 17-7. It lays out to process of right-of-way vacation applications. And there's fourfour -- four parts to the application process. The first is the submittal of an application itself. The second is the site plan review committee review and recommendation or forwarding to the planning and zoning board. The planning and zoning board is the third portion of the application process. And then finally, City Council and the two readings of an ordinance. For the application submittal, there are actually four parts to it. The first part is the submittal of surveys. One would be the property survey of the applicant, and then surveys of the areas to be vacated. The second part of the right-of-way vacation application is to submit deeds of the property for each of the applicants. The third part are utility letters, and these utility letters come from Duke Energy, frontier communications, people's gas, the City of Gulfport, and that would be the public works department. The last item are letters of agreement from each property owner to vacate the right-of-way. So, the applications were -- were submitted. They were deemed to be sufficient. So, they were forwarded to the site plan review committee. The site plan review committee, they meet on August 5th. The only item that was identified was by public works, and they would like to have a 10 foot wide easement over the existing water and sewer line so they can maintain those. The site plan review committee went ahead, and they voted to recommend forwarding the applications to the planning and zoning board. The planning and zoning board met October 5th. They listened to the staff presentation, they listened to the applicants, they also listened to the general public who also made comments. The planning and zoning board went ahead and they voted to recommend approval to City Council. And that's why -- that's why y'all are here tonight, for those. The access at the three southern points, the opportunity for -- for access is there, whether or not it's truly there or not, that's -- that's -- there's a lot of mangroves down there and mangroves are regulated by the state. But the opportunity is there, and the applications don't take away from existing access points for water uses such as kayaks, paddleboards and what not. We have access points at Clam Bayou, at the marina and also the beach. I'm here to answer any questions that you might have on each of the three individual ones. The applicants are here, too. I'm sure they've got a presentation, and they can answer questions as well. >> Mike, can you list the conditions the planning and zoning board had set forth. >> Let's see. I probably have those. I got them right here if you want. >> Okay. >> I will pass you the pad. >> While you're looking for that, I'll present you with one of the questions that I think a lot of people have. Is number one, you know, why would we just vacate and give it to an individual property owner? I know we've done vacations in the past. We have alleys we no longer use that we vacated those in order to close that space. We vacated an area over by the high school where the old little league used to be and gifted is not the right word, but left that under the jurisdiction of Pinellas County school district. We're looking at waterfront property and a question people have, why would we give this? Shouldn't there be a monetary value attached it to in addition to those conditions? If you want to address any of those things in terms of what our abilities are, that might help people understand what is going on here. >> Go ahead, Mike. >> Okay. The -- the areas of -- of Beach Drive, if you looks at the property surveys in each of the applications, you can tell there's been a lot of erosion of the shoreline. >> Yeah. >> Um, it's -- its worth is probably diminished because of that erosion. Our public works department, they did state they don't really need that property itself in order to maintain the water and sewer lines as long as they have an easement. >> Okay. >> Mayor, I guess the best way to clarify this is our code provides for the applicants, not to sound redundant, to make application. What you are providing here is due process. >> Right. Why would we or not, that's a policy decision. We don't have a use for it determined by staff. But if council makes the determination -- >> Okay. I support that this be under the covenant it not be developed and not remove that native vegetation. If you are already having erosion with man groves, will be significantly more erosion without mangroves. >> You can't take them out. It's illegal. >> As long as we can put conditions on it. Clearly, it's never been Beach Drive. It's never been a roadway. >> And it's not in our transportation network either. >> We looked at that as potentially making a trail through there at some point. Likewise, it would require taking out native vegetation. >> If we do put the stipulates, which you'll read, can, at some later date, they get a variance to get around the stipulations? >> It would be recorded. The city would have to take action to unring that bell. But it would be recorded as part of their vacation agreement. >> But it could be changed? >> Well, anything can be changed. I mean, theoretically they could sue you to have it overturned by a judge or such or the attorney. But it will be recorded as part of their deeds. >> Is that recorded as part of the property deed itself forever? >> Right. You're granting with it that condition. Therefore, if you don't put the condition in, obviously, they could do whatever they wanted. If you're putting it as part of the condition, then that grans -- grants the vacation in the absence of these restrictions, you wouldn't have granted the vacation. So, it should revert back if they violate those restrictions. Meaning, it should go back to The City. >> While you're at it, City Attorney, do you mind expressing there's ownership on the south side of that right-of-way. We're talking about a strip that kind of bisects ownership of these properties? >> Yes. I'll give you time to find it. >> It was -- this ordinance is conditioned in two paragraphs. The first one being, this vacation ordinance shall be conditioned upon the city's reveet of a hold, harmless indemnity agreement on a form provided by the city and including without legitimacy, any environmental damage to the vacated property. The second paragraph condition is: This vacation ordinance shall be conditioned upon the city receipt of a 10-foot utility easement over the existing water lines and San -- sanitary sewer lines. >> What about keeping the -- the not being able to build on it? >> That's the next one. >> Oh, okay. I'm sorry. >> Basically, the shoreline shall remain a living shoreline and the uplands from that shoreline have a restricted covenant on them so makes it so they are prohibited from any development happening on those uplands. >> Thank you. >> All right. Any other questions for Mr. Taylor. In short, we're looking at all three of these sections with three different ordinances, with the exact same process, same information for both, other than the location. That's why we're doing it in three parts. We have to do each as an individual ordinance. >> Are you finished? >> Yes. >> You're first. You finished? >> Well, I guess one little question. I know there's a shed on one of these properties, and if we were to grant this, would you still have to take down that shed because it's not supposed to be there? >> If the ordinance was not granted -- or the vacation would not be granted, whatever was built within that Beach Drive right-of-way would have to be removed. >> If we granted it, wouldn't it still have to be removed because there's a stipulation for in development? >> Um, if it's an existing shed, it could remain. >> Even if it's not permitted? >> Um -- >> The question is if it was built illegally on property that didn't belong to the owner? >> We'd have to talk to the attorney. It may have to be removed because it was unpermitted work. That's a different issue, then. That's a code enforcement issue that they did sub-permit without work. What we're looking at is in the foreseeable there would be no development, no construction of the lean too to see if there's a permit for that. >> Can you talk to the mic so we could hear you? >> Sure. >> See down in the bottom right corner, that dotted line, and then it goes off the screen and comes back. Is that the real shoreline now? Do you see where I'm talking about? >> No. >> Probably not because this was a county map. >> Okay. >> The real shoreline is most likely represented in the property survey -- or the survey of Beach Drive that the applicants have submitted. >> And that stretch of land has never been a road? >> No, it hasn't. It's never been developed. >> Okay. Is this where I would ask the attorney a question? Can you -- can you speak to the word dedicated because there was a lot of people talking about that at the planning and zoning board, that this was dedicated. It was kind of sketchy what it really meant. >> Excuse me. A dedication is giving of a private land for public purpose. If somebody dedicates something for a public park, they're taking their private land and giving to it the municipal. The only thing is that the municipal has to accept it in order for it to be effective. We see that a lot of times. Then it's used for a public purpose. >> This was not dedicated for a purpose? >> This was not -- I don't believe we saw anything that found that the city had accepted any kind of dedication. >> Okay. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. One more thing. So, VR-22-01 has rapairian rights which means they have control of the bottom. So, 03 does not have repairian rights. That area is owned by the state of Florida. >> Mayor, I can bring up another issue? >> Please. As council knows, there's a lawsuit that the city is a party to that was brought by a homeowner regarding this issue. We have our insurance company that has provided counsel that is defending the city in this matter. There was a motion to dismiss that was heard last week. Two of the counts were allowed to move forward. One was for an injunction which would have stopped us from proceeding forward with this matter. That was not granted. I don't know if it was refiled or not. I believe the thought process is is that if you were to grant the variance, that they could move forward and come forward with an injunctive action because you've taken action, and you haven't taken any action yet. So the question whether or not the court would enjoin you from having this hearing, which they have not or subsequently do it before you pass an ordinance, assuming you were going to pass one. That still could happen. But that's up to the court to decide. We have no say on that. The reason you're moving forward with this is that there are due process rights of the applicants, and unless a court tells us not to proceed, we have to adhere to those rights, otherwise, we'd be looking at a lawsuit from them for violating their due process rights. The application has moved forward, as your ordinance provides. They made their determination and that's advisory to you. That's why the process is moving forward to you and why it hasn't been stopped. If a court makes a different ruling, then certainly we will bring that forward and we will alert you as to the process. >> So, what are the two parts of the lawsuit that are due process? >> They're declaratory actions to see whether or not the actual property was dedicated and used for public purpose. >> You said there were two things. >> That's two parts of the complaint. I'll let the -- the applicant move forward on it. I mean, I'm not defending the lawsuit. >> Understood. Councilman Ray. >> I'm a little confused on a couple of things. When there is no development, what does that mean? If they're allowed to put a dock on, but that dock would have to be in the water, but what about on the shore? >> It would be any normal transitory. You're allowed to have the transitory to the dock. But we're talking about construction -- as councilmember Thanos spoke of, there's a leantoo on the property. They would not be allowed to build a structure on the property. >> Can they put pavers? Or cement? >> It says they have to maintain the natural shore area. >> That would be part of my question. The lead up to the dock. >> Sure. You're allowed to have access to the dock. >> I mean, and I'm kind of curious. Does the property actually have invasions on to the right-of-way, the easement? >> There are currently things that are there, yeah, those would be handled through code enforcement. >> That's it for now. >> Okay. Councilmember Fridovich. >> I'm just listening. >> All right. I jumped in and asked my questions a little bit early. So, as far as I'm concerned, looking at this now, if that's just property that's already just got native vegetation on it, it's got the erosion control, the man groves that are there and the property owners will be stewards to it, there's no real value on the land on its own being sandwiched between private land lease. I'm okay vacating that under those conditions that not removing the native vegetation and there can't be development. I'm not casting a vote. I'm speaking. I'm telling you which way I'm leaning right now. I understand how it works. I've been here a while. >> Yeah, I know. >> Does the vacation transfer to another owner? >> Yes. >> And the conditions as well? >> Yes. They would be recorded as part of the area and the property. >> My only question following up to what councilmember Thanos and councilmember Ray were saying, they would be should to essentially blaze some sort of trail through that to access the dock, correct? >> Correct. >> In terms of building up something on land, like to put a cat caulk? >> No. >> If council wanted to move forward and they had particular restrictions, we would add that. Those would be part of the second reading. >> Okay. And last question is, what would we anticipate, just in the current climate, for example, ballpark, that's going to bring for revenue in terms of ad valorem property tax? >> There's so many different factors. I mean, your millage rate and also applied to other governing/taxing bodies. Your millage rate is 4.039. It's pretty minuscule. >> Okay. There's really no -- there's really no benefit to The City. This is pretty much a benefit to the property owners and, as it states in here, moving ahead with the land planning at the county level. >> Mayor, if I could respond to councilmember Thanos' specific question on the amended xrant. Count 1 is for declaration of public right of access, and count 2 is declaration of private right of access. Those are the two counts that, as far as I'm aware, remain. The third -- the follow-up one was temporary and permanent injunction to restore public access; that's my understanding. >> So, what is -- I get what the public access is. So, presumably they're wanting to be able to maintain the public access because that was public land. What is the private access mean? >> In my opinion, the private case is another way of doing the way of doing the public access. This particular person is trying to get use of -- almost to create a private easement to go over the property to use it. >> For just himself or for everybody? >> Well, the public one is for everybody. >> Our public accesses are 44th Street, the alley between Quincy and 44th and Quincy itself. Those are not currently set up as access right now. It's just where the road hits the water and that's that. Are all of our applicants for these three properties here tonight? Yeah, okay. Is that all three? >> Yes. Okay. All right. Well, if everyone's done with the initial questions, let's let the public speak on this. >> I'd like to hear what the public has to say. >> Mayor, the normal process in this situation would be to hear from the applicants first. >> Absolutely. We'll start with the one bordering 44th Street. I think we have the same speaker for all three. Are you speaking to all three? >> No, I'm only speaking on the first one. >> Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you very much for your time. Can you hear me? >> Yes. >> My name is Meredith delcamp. She's the owner of 2700 44th Street south, Gulfport. I want to thank our staff who has worked with us to try to get these petitions before you tonight. I don't want to rehash what has already been discussed, but I did want to go through a little bit of history. The dialogue was really helpful and I have more details on those questions. So, I have a couple of handouts here because I like papers. I just wanted to pass this out to you. This is the original plat of this area. What is being handed out to you is the original plat from 1913, and this history is important because we're dealing with Beach Drive, which was documented in a plat. And what the city can and can't do with Beach Drive will be governed by what is contained on this single piece of paper, this plat. As you can see in the plat, Beach Drive is this tiny little area way down in the corner that's really hard for everybody to see. But when you zoom in on it, it just has Beach Drive and it's a 50-foot right-of-way. All that's really dedicated in the plat, if you zoom in on this information down here, all that this plat actually as I said is it, says, all ra pairian rights are, as I said, to the subject to make such improvements by dredging or otherwise as they may deem necessary. So, really, all that's decide to the city in this plat are the repairian rights. Typically, in a plat you will see express language that says the roads or the parks or the whatever are dedicated. That's not what we have in this plat. Of course, we are here today asking the city to vacate Beach Drive, but my original point, it's not clear that Beach Drive was actually dedicated to the city. For purposes of today, to the extent the city does have a dedication for Beach Drive, we'd like to ask the city to vacate rights. I wanted to point that out because the repairian rights are part and parcel which any waterfront land. The rights go with that parcel out. You can sell them to different properties. That's what happened in this plat. The repairian rights were stripped from Beach Drive and dedicated to the public. But Beach Drive remains. But even assuming Beach Drive was dedicated to the city, what I also want to point out it's labeled as Beach Drive. It was labeled as a road. It's a 50-foot right-of-way and it's of consistent size and orientation as the other roads that were documented in this plat. It wasn't expressly called out as a park or a kayak launch or those other things. It was called Beach Drive for vehicular access. It provides vehicular access to only four lots in this plat, lots 172, 171, 56 and 55. So, it provides very limited vehicular access. Back in 1913, 109 years ago, it connected 44th Street South to Quincy Street South and dead ended at the bayou. It doesn't provide necessary access, what we call a right-of-way by necessity. All these lots have independent access without Beach Drive. It was really just additional access along the waterfront. At that time, apparently in 1913, the road was not submerged. Beach Drive appears in this plat to be all above water. And the submerged lands that are south of Beach Drive in this plat appear to be owned by the state. I mean, they're not specifically platted in this plat, but, at the time, it appears they would be owned by the state or potentially by the United States. So, what I want to show you next is how things change from 1913 to 1925. This is just 12 years from when the plat was originally recorded. The below map is the city map from 1925 in your packet. In just 12 years from the original plat, this subdivision was significantly modified over time. For example, lot 172 was never developed and lot 173 was greatly limited and Beach Drive was replaced with private homes on lots 16, 17 and 11, and that results in Beach Drive getting significantly smaller and providing even less access to adjacent lots. Most importantly, while we can see Beach Drive on this map, we know Beach Drive was never built. In fact, if you walk out there today, it just looks like abstention of everybody's backyards. So, the last thing I want to point out about this particular drawing, you can see by the time, 12 years later, by 1925, the lots south of beach drive, the submerged lots were subsequently platted and sold to the upland property owner. So, these property owners owned both the submerged land south of Beach Drive and the uplands north of Beach Drive and their properties bifurcated in half by Beach Drive. As we talk about the public's right of access to water and what they could do out there, keep in mind those submerged lands they're talking about are privately held lands by the upland owner. This history to me is important because it shows how the development was modified and changed over time. And it shows how the intention of the original developer changed. And that's important to me because at the planning and zoning hearing we talked a lot about the original intention of these developers that dedicated these property rights and whether we should honor their intentions so we could go with the intent of the plat. But when we think about that, I want to point out a few things. First, the developers that originally developed the subdivision, as I just showed you, developed the subdivision differently than originally platted in 1918. So, their intentions changed just over those 12 years. Some portions of Beach Drive were removed with houses put there. Developers have never built any portion of Beach Drive which reasonably leads us to understand that maybe their intentions changed. Third, importantly, when we look at the plat, again, this has to govern our decision what we can use this land for, the drafters of this plat noted it as Beach Drive, not a park, road only. We have to look at that when we consider their intentions. And then I want to real quickly go over the intentions of how these lot owners that lived adjacent to Beach Drive over a century and how they've used it. At the last hearing, we heard a lot of good testimony from prior owners of these parcels, folks that were raised on these properties and talked about how they never even heard of Beach Drive, never realized it was there. And that they always thought it was just a part of their backyard. In fact, my client, when she bought it five years ago, did not know Beach Drive was there. She thought it was a part of her backyard. Today, as we talked about, over half is submerged and it's continuing to submerge. In fact, what we heard at the hearing last month was without the hard work of the property owners that were taking care of this land for the last 100 years, really, all of Beach Drive would be submerged at that point and we wouldn't have anything to talk about today. They worked hard to replace the shoreline and replace vegetation to keep it from eroding. But for those efforts from those property owners treating it like their own, we wouldn't be here today. Of course, as it's submerged, you couldn't build a road in the current condition because it's half under water. The city acted as it had no intention to build Beach Drive and we heard they currently have no intention to build Beach Drive. That leads us to the understanding that Beach Drive was never intended to be built, and the original intentions did change. So, with that background, I just want to talk a little bit about the legal issues here. Our applications that are in your file identified several provisions of the zoning code and the comprehensive plan that I'm just going to incorporate by reference so we don't have to go through that tonight. Not vacating Beach Drive would violate the city's comprehensive plan. Incompatible lapped use is, for example, all those adjacent homes are zoned R1 for single-family residential uses. They're all owner occupied with families that live quiet lives. Beach Drive currently bifurcates their property. To build it as a road would be inconsistent with the uses, and it's really not necessary given that access is already available to everybody, and most of the land is submerged. And the one thing I thought we all agreed on at the last hearing is that nobody, not the public or city, have if I intent or want Beach Drive to be a road. There doesn't seem to be any good public use for that. There's no public benefit from creating that as a road. So, I think that's something we can all agree on. But most of the conversation at the last hearing was dominated by converting this road to another use. A lot of folks want to see it as a marina or a kayak launch or a walking trail. Based on the language that governs this in the plat, it's illegal for you to use it for anything other than a road. It was dedicated for that express purpose, and you can't convert it to any other public use without violating Florida law. I don't think water access is necessary. We heard staff talk about all the other water access points. There's a kayak launch immediately adjacent to the property. Again, because Beach Drive is submerged, having folks out there launching their kayaks or doing different things would be a safety hazard given the collapsing nature of the shoreline, and there's always wildlife and natural resources to consider if you open up that area to the public which I believe would be in violation of coastal management goals one and two. I don't think it's legally allowed to use this property for anything that's not consistent with the plat. Had Beach Drive been designated as a marina or a water park, or some other use, my clients would not have purchased that property. And the city is not at liberty to convert it to some other use. Having it as a park or some other use would be inconsistent with the adjacent land uses. My clients have developed an expectation of privacy in their backyard. We all have those. A couple of city's codes that support that are goal 1 of the city's comprehensive plan. You'll hear tonight, but a lot of the concerns of opening up this area to the public are the safety concerns. This area has been prone to crime and allowing this to be a public park and letting people come on it at any time of the night poses real safety concerns for my clients, and I believe that would be a violation of the housing goal one for this matter. It would also, I think, reduce my client's property values having a park in their backyard, essentially, which would be in conflict with the economic element objective 1.4. Two last issues before closing. One is the lawsuit. We did talk a lot about the lawsuit at the last hearing. I'm not involved in that lawsuit, so I'm not going to get into the substance of it but I want to clarify the timeline. There seemed to be a misconception that we filed these petitions in response to the lawsuit, and that wasn't the case. When my clients became aware of that somebody was trying to get access to what they thought was their private backyard, we met with the city to find out the options and vacating the right-of-way was an option presented. It took many, many, many months to get a surveyor out there to do the proper surveys to vacate right-of-way. By the time the applicants were finished, the lawsuit had been filed. I do think it's helpful to note that the lawsuit deals with getting access to public property, and from my perspective, and I would defer to your attorney, but from my perspective, if Beach Drive is vacated and no longer property, our intentions would make the lawsuit go away. I don't think it makes sense to wait on this matter to wait until the lawsuit to get resolved. We talked about those issues a couple of weeks ago. Finally, we've talked about property values and should there be compensation. From my clients' perspective, they thought they paid for waterfront property. They paid a premium for that property. From their perspective, they're not getting a windfall. They're preserving what they thought they already bought. I don't think that additional compensation would be justified in that because they have already paid that. They would be required to start paying taxes on Beach Drive, which would also -- lands converting them. I think the question is, is the city ever going to build Beach Drive for a road? If they're not, then I think vacating that road would be appropriate in this instance. What we're really asking you all to do tonight is formally acknowledge what has been the status quo in this area for the last 109 years. It has been used as private backyards and the city has never intended to build Beach Drive. We ask you to allow these folks to continue having privacy in their backyards. The conditions that we talked about from the planning and zoning board, my client is happy to agree to those. We can flesh those out as well. They're agreeable to preserving the easement and other conditions imposed by staff. I'd like to reserve any time for rebuttal, but I appreciate your time. >> Okay. Thank you. Any questions? >> I do. I understand your client has bought multiple properties in the past? >> Uh-huh. >> Did they not look at a survey of this property to know they didn't own that property? >> Well, I think beach -- Tanya can address this, if you'd like. I mean, you might want to answer what you thought. All these property owners, including my client, as well as the prior owners, were told prior to buying it that Beach Drive was never going to be built. I don't know that Tanya had that understanding, but that's what we heard at the last hearing. >> My question was similar. It sounds like a title company or a Realtor not doing their due diligence. >> Well certainly, it does show up on a survey. >> I understand they understood it wasn't going to be built as a road. Clearly, nobody was planning to do that. They should have known for sure that it didn't belong to them. >> Well, yes, the survey shows what it shows. Like I said, for the last hundred years -- >> I don't want that to cloud the argument. >> The folks out there were using it as their private backyards. >> All right. Thank you very much. >> You had stated that -- I had heard there was -- this was never dedicated as a road. It doesn't say that, no. I wanted to be clear that. It actually doesn't say that. You brought that up over and over again. It was never designated or dedicated to be a road. >> That means we could use it for other things. >> No, I don't think it was ever dedicated is my point. >> We don't show a dedication. >> I mean, I guess it's a little unclear. You're saying it was dedicated in this plat as a road and can't be used legally as anything else. I don't think that's right. >> I don't think it was ever dedicated to the city. Why are we here tonight? Well, the city has utilities in the area, and certainly these other roads, the city has been using. But from a legal perspective, unlike most plat I've seen, there's no express dedication of the roads to the city. It race the repairian rights along Beach Drive are dedicated to the public. That's all it actually says. >> Two of them have been sold since? Only two of the three have repairian rights? >> None of them have repairian rights. The repairian rights belong to the public. None of them have repairian rights. >> Two lots are submerged properties. >> That's the difference. Typically, you know, when you're selling waterfront land or dedicating waterfront land, you just dedicate the lot as a whole. You're not carving out repairian separately. You typically carve out repairian rights separately when you want to do something different with the land. They took the repairian rights, gave it to public and didn't say anything about who owns Beach Drive. >> So, how do we know we Own Beach drive? >> It's within the city jurisdiction. >> Sorry. >> What it is it's part of -- it's within your city jurisdiction. It is -- basically, all properties revert back to the city that don't have an identified owner. >> Even though you feel it was dedicated as a road, we could actually do whatever we want with it? >> We haven't -- we haven't -- >> We can't make a marina because we can't take out the mangroves arbeach, but we could have a path or nature trail. >> Honestly, that's an issue that may have to be determined by the court. In fact, we had originally suggested that we bring this matter -- we being the city -- bring this matter to the court and allow them to decide. We were discussing that at the time the lawsuit was filed against the city. >> So, the court would decide how that property could potentially be used? >> Well, the court would decide who actually has the right to use that property and for what use. >> I just want to be clear: I don't believe that this plat dedicates any part of Beach Drive to the city. But we're here today because to the extent the city claims they have a right to it, we would like that right vacated. >> Yeah, I understand that part. >> That's my first argument. My second point is, to the extent you believe this does create a right in the city for Beach Drive, it's labeled as Beach Drive. So, it only be used as Beach Drive. I did email these to the attorney a couple of weeks ago. This is a case. Florida Supreme Court. Recorded a plat showing this Oceanside area to be expressly made a park on the plat and the developers were bound to not use the land designated as a park for any other purpose. Another case is Wilson v. Dunlap, 101, southern second 801 Florida Supreme Court, 1958. The plat is complete in itself and will control the extrinsic evidence may not be received to vary its language. >> At this point, I'd like to -- unless there's something else you'd like to add, I'd like to open it up to the public. Welcome. Hi, I own and live at 2700 44th Street. And I have done so since 2016. Previous to that, I lived in Gulfport in another house for approximately 12 years, so I proudly consider myself a local now. Firstly, I just want to make it clear that myself, my neighbors that are all here and everyone else around 44th street and Clam Bayou have lived very peacefully and happily without a worry in the world until a certain neighbor moved in last year, okay. Yes, since Paul Herman moved in, um, he has disrupted our neighborhood. He has bullied and intimidated me and surrounding neighbors, and he is obsessed with me and my property, how I live and what I do. It's actually pretty frightening having this man live three doors down because it's just nonstop. Anyway, that aside, I just want to invite you all to this beach road. I'm sure Emily and Jimmy, I mean, you -- it's -- it's not even -- it's all submerged. It's -- >> Yeah, it's -- it's mangrove forests. >> Some of the mangroves are 20 foot high. >> It's a road on paper only. >> Exactly. It's a muddy bayou. That's what it is. You know, I can't even get to Emily's house because the mangroves divide us, even in the alleyway. I mean, there's no access. It's just man groves. I mean, there's a beautifully maintained Clam Bayou that has water access. I just want to say that the city have gone above and beyond. I'm just going to point out. They actually opened an old kayak ramp for Paul Herman to stop this nonsense. I'll actually show you where they opened it. They actually opened it -- I live -- this is my house here. They actually opened it here. He lives up there. They've given him this kayak ramp. That's not good enough. You know, I mean, what more does he want union you know? The last meeting, you know, me, the previous owner and, actually, the owner before that that lived there in the 1960s, the public never used it. I got photos down there that I took in 2012. The last homeowner that lived there in 1960, they spoke. In conclusion, I hope you will consider my safety and realize how ridiculous this whole situation is. I mean, he -- he just -- he just ruined my life. Unfortunately, he sucked Emily and Jimmy along because they live on Beach Drive as well. >> I was told they were not able to do a kayak ramp on the end of 44th because there's too many man groves. That's what public works told me. >> It was opened up. We launched the kayaks to test it. It's pretty good. >> Because they couldn't cut mangroves. >> Oh, they cut it. >> You can trim man groves, but I was told they couldn't trim enough to make it a kayak ramp. >> They trimmed enough for us all to get in. >> Okay. Is your property homeheaded? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Before we get down the road too much before we start having -- >> Sorry, does that matter if it's homesteaded? >> I'm curious. We're about to get into waters -- if neighbors are against neighbors already on this issue, that's not our issue. Our issue is figuring out whether this makes sense, whether it's the right thing to do, and to make sure that the lands that are current under the jurisdiction of city are going to have proper stewardship and be mandatory. I don't want to get disputes. I want to look at the facts of this, figure out what makes sense and go that way. If we came here to fight, we can fight all night. We've done it before, and it sucks. Let's try to not do that. Let's try to explore, you know, what makes sense in this case and go that way. I'd like to hear from some of the members of the public. >> And we have two more applicants. >> One at a time. >> This is only the first case. >> It's an unusual one we have tonight. I'm going to open this up to the public. If there's been some strong emotions with this in the past, I want us to try to keep it about the facts and about how we want to address this. >> Hello. I live at the end of Quincy Street. We bought the house under the assumption that nothing would ever change. I have to young daughters. I have two young daughters at home that I should be home feeding right now, but I'm here because of the some dispute in the neighborhood. You know, we bought the house to raise our girls at a dead-end street with privacy. And that's why I bought the house. I'm fourth generation Gulfport, my daughters are fifth. I want to be left alone. I don't need any of this -- you know. She's wanting to build a park down there, but she doesn't want anybody to build on that property, which we're fine with, we don't want to build on it. What will you do if you build a park or a trail? You're going to tear up the mangroves. It's useless land. You can do nothing with it. Who's going to swim in that water? It's a toxic dump from the city of St. Pete. Nobody is swimming in that water. Oysters don't even grow there any more. I'm from here. I know Clam Bayou. My dad grew up in Clam Bayou. He's not from here. So, the water quality is bad. I mean, what are you going to do down there? It's all mangroves. You can't see anything. So you're going to come down and look at my house? That's what you want to do? It makes no sense. You're going to go down there at high tide -- >> Just for the record, we haven't had a discussion about making a park. >> She keeps bringing it up. You know, you better bring your wading boots if you're going to come down there and hang out. I have to drive through saltwater to get through my driveway. The saltwater comes up over my driveway sometimes and we have to drive our vehicles through saltwater to get to our driveway. >> Only disagree on one thing. It does have a use. Those mangroves grow there. >> No, no, no. That's why I'm there. I want the mangroves. I want my girls to grow up on a preserve, you know what I mean? We're all bird-watchers, coyotes, the coolest mangrove salt marsh snake, bright orange. He lives there. We want it to stay that way. >> I appreciate that. In the back. Yes, sir. Welcome. >> Long time. >> Yep. Working nights, so I can't come. I live on 44th and 27th. We have lived there about 12, 13 years. When we first moved there, there was a kayak entrance at the end of 44. It was always kept neat and clean. And I went through once to put a kayak in. I sunk up almost to my knees in muck. And trying to lift my feet out, the mud would just suck my legs back in pint was hard to make any movement through it. And then all of a sudden someone quit taking care of that ramp. Now I just realized several years ago that all of a sudden someone started cutting the mangroves there. My wife says, it was city people that cut it down. So, I mean, it's useless land except for preserving the road. No one has ever driven on that road. I've never seen anyone walk on that so-called road since we've lived there. So, I mean, let them have the land. Let them have their peace. Let him raise his daughters where he feels safe. Because if you open up that road, what was it, about a month ago? Three kids stole a car in St. Pete. They went down the one road -- >> Quincy. >> -- Quincy. They had a helicopter looking for these three guys. They found two of them in the back of the Tanya's house hiding in her garden. The cops were leaving and she says, have you checked at my house. They said, no. She said, go check it. That's where they found the third guy. They have a gun, they still haven't found the gun. They shot at the other house next to Tonyas. They shot at the house. You have an access road in there. They're going to be able to run all over. When we first moved in there, it was a very high drug area. We kept calling The City and they told us to get license plates. We kept getting license plate numbers. We finally, after about three years, we finally stopped the drug situation down there. Because our corner was -- my wife said she seen a number of times cars drive by, hands out and they keep going in the direction they're going. >> It's not going to be a road. It is not going to be a road. >> Not a road. Anyone else for public comment on this specific item? >> Yeah. >> My name is Deb. I live at number 12 there. Okay. I totally support the city's decision to vacate the land. It is exactly what needs to be done. It actually should have been done 50 years ago. They're just a little slow. That's all. Do I appreciate the fact that the board -- what is it? The planning commission board did reach that decision, and they decided to keep it as a natural coastal. I didn't realize you guys had tried the oyster beds there, because that does clean up the dirty water. I would appreciate it maybe if you worked about wherever this Allie goes down to the water, if it's deep enough, to think about doing oyster beds there, too. That's what we need to look at. Not putting human beings in danger of walking -- seriously, he was not exaggerating. The mud comes up to there. They said, come on over and see if you want to put your kayak in. Great neighbors. Are you kidding? Why would I want to muck around in this mud when I can go two blocks down and use the kayak putin area that you guys have maintained through the years, and I appreciate that. So thank you for the good work. So, that's all I wanted to say. I totally support you guys making the decision to vacate this property. Thank you. >> Anyone else? Yes, ma'am. Well, go ahead. You're already up. Come on. How are ya? I'm fine. Thank you. My name is Paul Herman. I live on 44th Street. I wanted to dispel the idea that is something I brought up. I have a petition here just within the two blocks of 44th street. 25 people have opposed the vacation. I put an online petition and 67 signatures from the online suspicion -- petition. People look at me like I'm crazy. Because they don't believe the city would actually give away waterfront property. I have to show them documents. It takes some effort to explain it to people. I want to start -- unfortunately, with all respect to Ms. Delcamp, a lot of what she said is not entirely the case. She got 20 minutes, and I only have three minutes. I have to make this very brief. Um, those lands were dedicated to the public, not necessarily to the city of Gulfport. The repairian rights were dedicated to the people. The city was set up as a custody to protect those rights and to defend them. There is absolutely no requirement that that be a road. It doesn't have to be paved. As Ms. Thanos said, it can be anything. We can leave it be. What I suggest is this. There's a yes vote -- oh, by the way, this was considered in 1969 by The City and The City heard it and rejected it for all the same reasons. There's a sewer under there, the repairian rights, the rights of access are dedicated to the public. The people have a right to access it. It had fallen to the point where a lot of longtime users, some people on the petition had used it for a long time, some people didn't know about it. A yes vote or no vote. I'm sorry. I have to be very brief with this. The no vote, it seems to me says no. We go back to the way things have been 100 years, everybody gets to use the land privately and we canan removal this. We don't simply give away public property. More importantly -- equally as importantly, it violates the comprehensive plan. This is Thety City comprehensive plan. I wish I could impress upon you how important it is. It is enforceable under law. It was passed by this City Council and has the force of state law and city law. It says: Public access to the waterfront and shorelines by land and by water shall not be diminished, shall not be diminished. Mr. O'Reilly, a good and decent man, and an established professional in his field testified under oath, he was asked: Does Beach Drive provide public access to a shoreline? His response, yes. And, by the way, the same testimony given by senior members of staff. They testify it is public access to the shoreline. The comprehensive plan says there will be no diminishment of access to the shoreline. If we violate the comprehensive plan and the auditor general finds out about it, funding could be in jeopardy. It is a big deal. >> Thank you very much. Ma'am, yes. Hi. >> Hi. Nancy Robinson, 4422 27th Avenue South. So, the second house from the one end of this -- of the right-of-way in question. I've lived there for 31 years. It would be advantageous to my property to have invasive plants controlled so they won't spread and to have the coastline stabilized enough that erosion doesn't affect the adjacent public street. Because of the location of this right-of-way in the middle of private property, I deem it more practical

Gulfport City Council Agenda Template

City of Gulfport Florida

City Council Meeting Notice

Tuesday, November 01, 2022

Gulfport City Hall, 2401 53rd Street South Gulfport, FL

6:00 PM

AGENDA

Call to Order.

Invocation given by Councilmember April Thanos.

Pledge of Allegiance.

Roll Call.

Presentation: Halloween Decoration Contest Winners.

1.

Public Comment.

2.

City Manager Report.

3.

City Attorney Report.

4.

City Clerk Report.

5.

Consent:

5.a.

Consider approval of the Council Meeting minutes of October 4, 2022.

EXHIBIT: Item 5.a - Minutes 10-04-2022.pdf

6.

Ordinances:

6.a.

Ordinance No. 2022-13: First Reading: An ordinance of the City of Gulfport, Florida, providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between 44th Street South and the North-South Alley between 44th Street South and Quincy Street South and as legally described herein; Providing for severability; Providing for the repeal of ordinance, or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict; and Providing for an effective date.

EXHIBIT: Item 6.a - Memorandum.pdf

EXHIBIT: Item 6.a - Ordinance No. 2022-13.pdf

EXHIBIT: Item 6.a - Contact the Clerk's Office - Staff Report .pdf

6.b.

Ordinance No. 2022-14: First Reading: An Ordinance of the City of Gulfport, Florida, providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between Quincy Street South and the North-South Alley between 44th Street South and Quincy Street South and as legally described herein; Providing for severability; Providing for the repeal of ordinances, or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith to the extent of such conflict; and Providing for an effective date.

EXHIBIT: Item 6.b - Memorandum.pdf

EXHIBIT: Item 6.b - Ordinance No. 2022-14.pdf

EXHIBIT: Item 6.b - Contact the Clerk's Office - Staff Report .pdf

6.c.

Ordinance No. 2022-15: First Reading: An Ordinance of the City of Gulfport, Florida, providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between Quincy Street South and the east City of Gulfport boundary line and as legally described herein; Providing for severability; Providing for the repeal of ordinances, or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict and Providing for an effective date.

EXHIBIT: Item 6.c - Memorandum.pdf

Showing the first 24,000 of 127,973 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Welcome to the November 1st City Council meeting for Gulfport, Florida. The invocation is given by April Thanos followed by the pledge of allegiance. so many years ago, I like to take my time and examine the two candidates. Seeing not only the candidates but the policies they will bring in, the people they will bring in, who might -- who they might appoint to the Supreme Court and look at the whole range of issues before making a decision. From Colin Powell. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Roll call please. Council member Thanos? >> Yes. >> Vice mayor brown? >> Yes. Mayor Henderson? >> Here. >> All right. First thing on the list tonight is our presentation for the Halloween decoration contest winner. Our commercial theme was won by Gulfport Beach Bazaar. As our general theme contest winner, is Dana here? All right. Congratulations. Thanks for the Halloween spirit. There you go. Thank you. Thanks for being a part of it. >> Good job. >> Thanks. All right. We'll start off with open public comment. This is for any item that's not otherwise on the agenda. You'll have three minutes. I'm going to go by a show of hands. Give your name and address if you're comfortable with it and we'll start off right now. Anything that is not otherwise on the agenda? Yes, sir. Come to the podium. You may have to adjust the mic to get yourself comfortable with it. How are you? >> My name is Jonathan Robert. I reside at 1012 Fremont Street. My wife and I purchased our home in June of 2021. We moved here from D.C. on the heels of the pandemic after both of our jobs went remote to be closer to family. Her dad retired in Pinellas County over five years ago to be near his sister, and her and her husband were both Pinellas County schoolteachers for 30 years. We purposely chose Gulfport because of the progressive, inclusive and welcoming nature that the city presents. Unfortunately, unbeknownst to us at the time, we closed on a house that was directly behind a man who lived behind hus he is a known quantity and widely regarded in the community as a menace. Everyone I've spoken to Mark at code enforcement rolled their eyes. We, my wife, and other neighbors reached out to councilman Ray about this because he's our ward councilman. He was helpful to set up a meeting between us and the chief of police and the City Manager. You know, unfortunately, in that time period, we've called the cops on him for his abusive and violent behavior on several occasions, and the Gulfport police department have been no help to us whatsoever in this. And after our meeting with the chief, I was told -- like, literally, I had a meeting where instead of being an advocate for these affected members of the community, I had to debate what a credible threat really was after I and my wife's life had been threatened by this gentleman. Today a Pinellas County judge found that our issues were credible. He issued an injunction against Mr. Donnellini. All four of the neighbors received this injunction. Now I only hope that when I call the police department, they will actually, effectively deal with this menace and deal with him appropriately. This pattern of appeasement seems like it has been going on for years. I know for a fact that the city used city resources and manpower to plant plans and landscaping in the easement in front of his house because it's that unsightly. I'm asking to be treated correctly under the law. I really want to know what the city will do about enforcing all the code violations over his property. He's got an RV sitting there for a year. It's rat-infested, it doesn't run, his fence is a mess, he has lights that shines directly into a neighbor's house that he uses for harassment and I don't have any progress with code enforcement. They've haven't done anything about these issues. >> All right. Thank you very much for your comments. Did you want to leave a copy of this document? >> I'll forward this all via email. It's at the point now that I feel like we've done everything we can as neighbors to protect ourselves. Now it's in the hands of bigger authorities than us, and I would hope they would take these issues seriously and respond in kind. I appreciate your time today. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Thank you very much. Ms. Levin. Karen Love, 23rd Avenue South. I wanted to say thank you. It took a long time, but you guys have started the ball rolling now to, in fact, hire another code enforcement officer. I know that based on the conversations that a big part of this job will be addressing the short-term rentals, but I think maybe you're starting to hear how many issues we have. I mean, what the gentleman just talked about, there's so many code enforcement issues here that are never enforced and it's very frustrating, and I don't know why we keep passing ordinances if we're not going to enforce them. Thank you very much for moving forward. I would like to ask publicly about the tennis courts. The last time I asked publicly, I was told they would be finished in March. That was in 2022. I know that they were started. And I know two days after Ian hit, they were working on them, which was quite impressive. But I was also told it would take a week, which I couldn't imagine. We've had no tennis courts now for five to six weeks. I don't think anything's been done in two weeks. So, I'm wondering if the contractor has been fired or if they, in fact, have quit to go on the bigger jobs. I'm hoping that could be publicly addressed so that we'd know what the story is on that. And then the third thing I wanted to address was some of the encampments that are popping up around town, and I've been to enough meetings to know that the city does not have a lot of rights which you can do with our >> As I've done in every election since I started voting homeless people, okay? I do feel like my life was threatened by the man who reside at pavilion number 3. I did talk about it when it happened. It -- it -- there was a little joke made, and I understood why, because, mayor, you had the same thing when you called the police and they wanted to know the address. He's there every day. He has a full encampment. He sleeps on the picnic bench, his chairs, food, furniture, his goods in the area. In addition to that, and I think this homeowner is gone and not aware there's been another house overtaken by a homeless person now on the corner of 26th And Beach. There's a house, and there's a gentleman that goes there every night, sets up his camp on their side porch/side yard, sleeps there all night. You can still see him because he sleeps until about 9:00 in the morning. Then he leaves all his stuff there all day and goes and does what he wants. He comes back. The hurricane shutters are on. Can the rest of us set up camp and rent out our yards? It's a serious question. >> Thank you. Who else for open public comment? Yes. How are you? >> Hi. Inagreed, 2701 56th Street South. I'm here on behalf of Gulfport Votes a nonpartisan group. November 8th, everybody will have voted, I hope. Just to give statistics, in 2020, Gulfport voted turnout was 88%. Woo! That's the number to beat this year, right? 88%. (Applause) I hope we can do better this. This is the midterms. People do not necessarily always turn out. After November 8th, we can put away our signs and roll up our sleeves to start working on continuing our lives here in Gulfport. For that, I wanted to make the invitation to the town hall that's sponsored by councilor Thanos and co-hosted by leaders, civic, business, community leaders, as well as a group of people, you'll see some with green shirts on here, and there are about 30 people helping produce this and co-host thisthis. So, I wanted to officially invite everybody, all the citizens. We need everybody at the table. We're hoping and planning on 80 people at the first one, which is not 17,000 residents, we know that, but we will be getting the word out. And we do invite people to come and participate, give their perspectives. I know people like to give their opinions. We're really asking for people to come in and give their perspectives. The purpose of the first one called "Finding Common Ground" is to really help people see where we are now. We are post-pandemic, post-elections, post-hurricane Ian and, yet, we know we're still in hurricane season. So, what are our current conditions now? What are some possibilities? We'll start talking about that. Everyone here is invited. Everyone that loves Gulfport that lives, works and plays in Gulfport. We're hoping to have students from Stetson, maybe from other colleges around to help out and participate in this, and we certainly want all the citizens to show up because their perspective is important. My ask of the council is that you bring people -- help people come to this. We really want this voice. This will be a facilitated process. We would love it if the invitation came from the council leaders to invite people to come. I'll be leaving information. You can give it out, and if we can work with the sunshine laws, we'd love to have you come, too. >> All right. Thank you very much. Anyone else for public comment? Yes. >> 59th Street. I have two quick questions. One, I know the utility rates changed recently, and I was wondering, I noticed that a number of people that have empty lots and are, quote, on standby only pay $16 or $17 a month while others play probably now $60 a month. I was wondering what that anomaly was that was built in there. Then the other question I have is, when the city is made aware of errors such as billing the wrong owner of a home, is there an attempt made to correct that? Thank you. >> All right. Thank you. Anyone else for open public comment tonight? Yes, in the back. Hi. >> Yes, um, Eileen in a -- Navarro. Have we installed Wi-Fi in the Hickman theater. I know it was in the budget. It was a grandiose plan to add Wi-Fi to a lot of the city fatalities. I asked you to put Wi-Fi in the Catherine Hickman theater as soon as possible. It's really, really needed. Thank you. >> Anyone else for public comment? Okay. Seeing no one, that brings us to the City Manager's report. If there's any of that you want to address now publicly, go for it. The rest we can follow up on post meeting. I can address a few of these. In regards to the Wi-Fi, we still have equipment on backorder that we're doing both the theater. He is working on it. As soon as we get everything delivered, we'll start the process for all the locations, including the theater. In regards to the tennis court and pickleball courts, it's an ongoing process. The contractor is still on the job. I'll check again with Tom tomorrow to get a better timeline. It usually takes longer than five to six weeks to be completed. Let me check on that. The other one that I do have an answer for is the house that was identified at 26th Avenue And Beach Boulevard, the police have investigated that situation, and that is a member of the -- I want to parse how I identify this individual. It's a family member of the property owner. And that's all I have. Oh, just a reminder. The Veterans Day parade will be Sunday at 11:00. >> All right. Fantastic. Thank you. City Attorney report? >> No report, mayor. Consider approval of council meeting minutes October 4th, 2022. Entertain a motion council. >> Motion on the consent agent. All in favor say aye. Passes unanimously. Ordinance number 2022-14. Providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between 44th street South and the north-south alley and legally described therein providing for severability in conflict here with. >> Mayor, this will be a three-part introductory. The board passed this on to you with a approval. Recommendation of -- it's only a recommendation of approval. Subsequently, they did add conditions to the project. It's within your memo outlining nondevelopment, nonuse of it for construction purposes and it will be included in the ordinance if you so choose. >> Do you mind giving background how this came about. >> Sure. We had an issue with -- and I understand we had an issue with accessibility to the area adjacent to the individual's property. This is a property located on what would be the north side of Clam Bayou where there was a question of accessibility. This turned into more than just an access distributive property. It became more of a neighbor dispute. The applicants do have the ability, through our city code, to make application for vacation. Hence, we're here. >> Okay. Mr. Taylor's here to give a brief, more detailed specifics. >> Okay. Fantastic. >> Mayor, we're going to cover each of the three. Now, you will have to address each separately. Mike's overview will be of all three properties. Right. >> The reason we do that because it's three separate plats. >> Yes, three separate actions. >> Okay. >> Good evening. >> Hey. How you doing, Mike? >> Pretty good. All three applications are for the vacation of a portion of Beach Drive. The access points at the south end of 44th Street, the alley that's in between 44th and Quincy, that's going to remain open. And, also, the southern point of Quincy Street, where it intersects with Beach Drive, that will remain open as well. Right-of-way vacation applications, they are granted by chapter 17 of the Code of Ordinances, specifically, it's section 17-7. It lays out to process of right-of-way vacation applications. And there's fourfour -- four parts to the application process. The first is the submittal of an application itself. The second is the site plan review committee review and recommendation or forwarding to the planning and zoning board. The planning and zoning board is the third portion of the application process. And then finally, City Council and the two readings of an ordinance. For the application submittal, there are actually four parts to it. The first part is the submittal of surveys. One would be the property survey of the applicant, and then surveys of the areas to be vacated. The second part of the right-of-way vacation application is to submit deeds of the property for each of the applicants. The third part are utility letters, and these utility letters come from Duke Energy, frontier communications, people's gas, the City of Gulfport, and that would be the public works department. The last item are letters of agreement from each property owner to vacate the right-of-way. So, the applications were -- were submitted. They were deemed to be sufficient. So, they were forwarded to the site plan review committee. The site plan review committee, they meet on August 5th. The only item that was identified was by public works, and they would like to have a 10 foot wide easement over the existing water and sewer line so they can maintain those. The site plan review committee went ahead, and they voted to recommend forwarding the applications to the planning and zoning board. The planning and zoning board met October 5th. They listened to the staff presentation, they listened to the applicants, they also listened to the general public who also made comments. The planning and zoning board went ahead and they voted to recommend approval to City Council. And that's why -- that's why y'all are here tonight, for those. The access at the three southern points, the opportunity for -- for access is there, whether or not it's truly there or not, that's -- that's -- there's a lot of mangroves down there and mangroves are regulated by the state. But the opportunity is there, and the applications don't take away from existing access points for water uses such as kayaks, paddleboards and what not. We have access points at Clam Bayou, at the marina and also the beach. I'm here to answer any questions that you might have on each of the three individual ones. The applicants are here, too. I'm sure they've got a presentation, and they can answer questions as well. >> Mike, can you list the conditions the planning and zoning board had set forth. >> Let's see. I probably have those. I got them right here if you want. >> Okay. >> I will pass you the pad. >> While you're looking for that, I'll present you with one of the questions that I think a lot of people have. Is number one, you know, why would we just vacate and give it to an individual property owner? I know we've done vacations in the past. We have alleys we no longer use that we vacated those in order to close that space. We vacated an area over by the high school where the old little league used to be and gifted is not the right word, but left that under the jurisdiction of Pinellas County school district. We're looking at waterfront property and a question people have, why would we give this? Shouldn't there be a monetary value attached it to in addition to those conditions? If you want to address any of those things in terms of what our abilities are, that might help people understand what is going on here. >> Go ahead, Mike. >> Okay. The -- the areas of -- of Beach Drive, if you looks at the property surveys in each of the applications, you can tell there's been a lot of erosion of the shoreline. >> Yeah. >> Um, it's -- its worth is probably diminished because of that erosion. Our public works department, they did state they don't really need that property itself in order to maintain the water and sewer lines as long as they have an easement. >> Okay. >> Mayor, I guess the best way to clarify this is our code provides for the applicants, not to sound redundant, to make application. What you are providing here is due process. >> Right. Why would we or not, that's a policy decision. We don't have a use for it determined by staff. But if council makes the determination -- >> Okay. I support that this be under the covenant it not be developed and not remove that native vegetation. If you are already having erosion with man groves, will be significantly more erosion without mangroves. >> You can't take them out. It's illegal. >> As long as we can put conditions on it. Clearly, it's never been Beach Drive. It's never been a roadway. >> And it's not in our transportation network either. >> We looked at that as potentially making a trail through there at some point. Likewise, it would require taking out native vegetation. >> If we do put the stipulates, which you'll read, can, at some later date, they get a variance to get around the stipulations? >> It would be recorded. The city would have to take action to unring that bell. But it would be recorded as part of their vacation agreement. >> But it could be changed? >> Well, anything can be changed. I mean, theoretically they could sue you to have it overturned by a judge or such or the attorney. But it will be recorded as part of their deeds. >> Is that recorded as part of the property deed itself forever? >> Right. You're granting with it that condition. Therefore, if you don't put the condition in, obviously, they could do whatever they wanted. If you're putting it as part of the condition, then that grans -- grants the vacation in the absence of these restrictions, you wouldn't have granted the vacation. So, it should revert back if they violate those restrictions. Meaning, it should go back to The City. >> While you're at it, City Attorney, do you mind expressing there's ownership on the south side of that right-of-way. We're talking about a strip that kind of bisects ownership of these properties? >> Yes. I'll give you time to find it. >> It was -- this ordinance is conditioned in two paragraphs. The first one being, this vacation ordinance shall be conditioned upon the city's reveet of a hold, harmless indemnity agreement on a form provided by the city and including without legitimacy, any environmental damage to the vacated property. The second paragraph condition is: This vacation ordinance shall be conditioned upon the city receipt of a 10-foot utility easement over the existing water lines and San -- sanitary sewer lines. >> What about keeping the -- the not being able to build on it? >> That's the next one. >> Oh, okay. I'm sorry. >> Basically, the shoreline shall remain a living shoreline and the uplands from that shoreline have a restricted covenant on them so makes it so they are prohibited from any development happening on those uplands. >> Thank you. >> All right. Any other questions for Mr. Taylor. In short, we're looking at all three of these sections with three different ordinances, with the exact same process, same information for both, other than the location. That's why we're doing it in three parts. We have to do each as an individual ordinance. >> Are you finished? >> Yes. >> You're first. You finished? >> Well, I guess one little question. I know there's a shed on one of these properties, and if we were to grant this, would you still have to take down that shed because it's not supposed to be there? >> If the ordinance was not granted -- or the vacation would not be granted, whatever was built within that Beach Drive right-of-way would have to be removed. >> If we granted it, wouldn't it still have to be removed because there's a stipulation for in development? >> Um, if it's an existing shed, it could remain. >> Even if it's not permitted? >> Um -- >> The question is if it was built illegally on property that didn't belong to the owner? >> We'd have to talk to the attorney. It may have to be removed because it was unpermitted work. That's a different issue, then. That's a code enforcement issue that they did sub-permit without work. What we're looking at is in the foreseeable there would be no development, no construction of the lean too to see if there's a permit for that. >> Can you talk to the mic so we could hear you? >> Sure. >> See down in the bottom right corner, that dotted line, and then it goes off the screen and comes back. Is that the real shoreline now? Do you see where I'm talking about? >> No. >> Probably not because this was a county map. >> Okay. >> The real shoreline is most likely represented in the property survey -- or the survey of Beach Drive that the applicants have submitted. >> And that stretch of land has never been a road? >> No, it hasn't. It's never been developed. >> Okay. Is this where I would ask the attorney a question? Can you -- can you speak to the word dedicated because there was a lot of people talking about that at the planning and zoning board, that this was dedicated. It was kind of sketchy what it really meant. >> Excuse me. A dedication is giving of a private land for public purpose. If somebody dedicates something for a public park, they're taking their private land and giving to it the municipal. The only thing is that the municipal has to accept it in order for it to be effective. We see that a lot of times. Then it's used for a public purpose. >> This was not dedicated for a purpose? >> This was not -- I don't believe we saw anything that found that the city had accepted any kind of dedication. >> Okay. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. One more thing. So, VR-22-01 has rapairian rights which means they have control of the bottom. So, 03 does not have repairian rights. That area is owned by the state of Florida. >> Mayor, I can bring up another issue? >> Please. As council knows, there's a lawsuit that the city is a party to that was brought by a homeowner regarding this issue. We have our insurance company that has provided counsel that is defending the city in this matter. There was a motion to dismiss that was heard last week. Two of the counts were allowed to move forward. One was for an injunction which would have stopped us from proceeding forward with this matter. That was not granted. I don't know if it was refiled or not. I believe the thought process is is that if you were to grant the variance, that they could move forward and come forward with an injunctive action

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

2 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 2 of 2

Browse by category2 actions
  • Agenda item 5Discussion

    Consent: 5.a. Consider approval of the Council Meeting minutes of October 4, 2022. EXHIBIT: Item 5.a - Minutes 10-04-2022.pdf

    Department: Public Comment.

  • Agenda item 6Ordinances

    Ordinances: 6.a. Ordinance No. 2022-13: First Reading: An ordinance of the City of Gulfport, Florida, providing for the vacation of right-of-way known as Beach Drive located between 44th Street South and the North-South Alley between 44th Street South and Quincy Street South and as legally described herein; Providing for severability; Providing for the repeal of ordinance, or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith, to the extent of such conflict; and Providing for an effective date.

    Department: Public Comment. · Topics: procurement, transportation, public_hearing

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Meeting
  • City Council Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e2d893e0f28288826cc52c13490e1d14. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record