POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners

Tuesday, May 6, 2025 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 194,827 characters. The full document is at the source.

for those of you that don't know tese pipes don't take care of themselves and it's funny because I live in a district where a lot of people don't have acess to water, they have septic tanks and we got rid of some of the latest wells and everybody thinks this is a third world problem that these issues with water exist in other places, they exist here and we're doing our best to ensure everyone is connected but we also want to talk about water conservation and that's what today is about so I want to thank our educational partners, all the teachers and parents here that help us to share the message because every drop counts and with that I would like to introduce our personal water warrior, mayor daniela levine cava . >>mayor cava: commissioner regalado said why this is so important, I got turned into district water in district a and this is when I started calling myself a water warrior and since then it's been confirmed by outside sources so I can claim it but what I see is a whole raft of young water warriors and even one jack solomon put it in his poster not knowing that would be the theme of the day and we have statewide winners are part of the state there in the state calendar and I guess that's also by beach and plaxo thank you for your sponsorship. Look, nothing is more important. We say water is life . Do you all know that? We can serve it so that we take good care of our planet so mr. water guy. It's in the 70s . Okay, you guys okay with that? So a lot of what's happening right now is there's water and it's not sloshing around, it just makes up a good part of our bodies and we need water to survive. So what you do is incredibly important and we've been doing this at miami-dade county for 17 years sponsored by our water and sewer department which is impressive. So we just are thrilled you've learned about it, that you put creativity in it and apparently we are the best in the state. Thank you commissioner, let's say thank you. And to the teachers and the school administrators and to all the parents and family members we aren't know you are so proud as well that your young people are learning about something so critical because water is life. I was told I'm going to hand it off to the water guy but we've been joined by a couple of commissioners. Commissioner steinberg was first on the scene and she is another water champion . >> want to congratulate all the amazing students for all their hard work and you make us proud and we're excited to see all your posters. >> I want to congratulate everyone here, I got a chance to meet my district winner and their super creative by the way. much more creative I think that even we are up here with things like this which is amazing but yes, we live in a place where water is becoming across the world more important than many other things because our resources dwindle and we have overpopulation so I want to congratulate all of them and it's a great program. We at the forefront and mayor, thank you for being the water warrior leading us in the room this direction, commissioner regalado also the water nerd but you are nerdy in other things as well. It's cool, being a water nerd is cool but congratulations, it's great to honor these young men and women . >> I was the only one that got a message to wear a dress that looks like water so I don't know what went wrong with my colleagues. Anyway, I'm so proud of you. Every year I look at your posters and your designs and I learned something new about what I can do, I can't see all of you, every year I learn something new when I look at your posters and you are informing not just me but all the grown-ups around the county in ways we can make a difference to make sure we are conserving water, that we are valuing water, keeping water clean, keeping plastic and pollution out of the water so on behalf of every grown-ups that still has a lot to learn I want to say thank you all very much for participating in this contest and making beautiful art but that also teaches us how to be better people in the world, congratulations. [Applause] >>commissioner regalado: come on down . >> I'm roy coley, chief regulatory services officer and what I wanted to say to all you students is I'm so excited to learn how much you know about water conservation. Did you know the water conservation program that you're part of has been hugely successful in miami-dade county largely due to your work and the students before you. When we started the program we used 153 gallons of water per day per person. Today we use 131 gallons so that is real water savings for this county every single day and that's thanks to you, that's thanks to the leadership of our mayor and commissioners for allowing us to keep reinvesting in our utility system and replace all pipes, maintain the ones we have to soar for everybody please know our work will be on display downstairs so you will be able to see every single one of them can see the incredible talent our students have, I offer you my congratulations . >>. [Applause] >> I am a man a mechanic director of the water and sewer department and I'll be brief, I think that commissioners and mayor covered what we are here to support however I wanted to mention the board here, the mayor supports our infrastructure but what you're doing today is inspiring us. Inspiring us to conserve our water, inspiring us to vlue our water and we appreciate you . This program continues to grow. This year we had 4400 creative entries and that's 1000 more than last year so that's really incredible the participation that we've gained in the past 17 years. We have all the districts represented with 142 schools so again just a really amazing program, thank you for participating and thanks for your creativity and inspiration. [Applause] >> patrick martin, water efficiency use manager in miami-dade water and sewer, I'm the one that oversees the contest so I'm glad to welcome the 13 1st place winners of the contest and there is one for each county commission district but before I start calling them up I want to quickly recognize the sponsors of the contest on display on the screens above so thank their generosity and their support. I'd like to give thanks to publix for their catering of the luncheon we have after the contest and that's on the outside terrace right off the chambers. Now I'd like to, the moment we've been waiting for the call of each of the students, one from each district. So as CHAIRMAN Regalado had mentioned earlier parents and teachers we ask that you remain in your seats and following the ceremony we will have family and friends outside on the terrace after. If you could step forward for a picture with the district winner so students as I call your name please come to the front of the room to be presented with your water and remain for a final group photo so district one is amy campos martinez for a prep academy. >> the students will stay for the group photo, district 2 is gabrielle from st. James catholic school. Thank you, congratulations. District 3 is a leah barwick from it's a small world elementary school. Congratulations, district 4 is ekaterina krilova . >> look forward please, congratulations. District 5 is lily kepner from keypoint christian academy. Okay, district 6, dylan cirillo from miami springs elementary. Congratulations. District 7 and his jack along from william MAY elementary school. District 8, spencer santiago from the howard DR., elementary . District 8. District 9, writer lee from pine lake elementary school. District 10, ronald uh, bentley elementary school. District 11, isabel bacon , kendall square k-8 center. Congratulations, district 12 gabrielle gomez , ridge prep academy of doral . Congratulations, district 13 paolo garcia north hialeah elementary. Congratulations. Congratulations to all the winners, I'd like to thank all the students who participated. I have a big announcement to make, the florida water works association has announced two of the poster contest winners here at the county are also first place at the state level and the drop savers water conservation poster contest, I'd like to invite the fsa wsa state coordinator to join me to announce the wnners of the state competition. First one is aliyah from district 3. Congratulations. That's aliyah barwick from it's a small world elementary. And the other winner is from district 9, writer lee, pine lake elementary. Congratulations aliyah and writer and thank you for participating in these initiatives to promote water conservation in your daily routines and I'd like now to ask our winners, mme. Mayor, commissioners, chief coley, to come together for a group photo. So all the students, the students can come down for a group photo. >>... [Inaudible] >> one, two, three, water is life. Ready, one, two, three. Water is life. >> that includes our award ceremony, thank the students and families and we invite them upstairs for a luncheon. Thank you CHAIRMAN Regalado and board of county commissioners for hosting this special presentation. >>... >>chair: alright guys, we still have another special presentation. All right. We are going to get started. Those that are exiting the chamber, can we exit quietly? Those that are exiting the chamber. Sergeants, sergeants . I'm not going to speak all lot on this next presentation because I know those that are from columbus say the most but I will brag for a second because both of my boys are explorers I will brag and say my kids school is cooler than your kids school, I just want to say that. Guys, for consecutive years. 4 consecutive years state championships. Not only are my kids eplorers but columbus is in my district you guys representing our community, this county, we are so proud of what you've accomplished, your dedication, your commitment and obviously it starts with the leadership at columbus, we have our pres. With us, the coach, everybody else with us from columbus. I could be prouder to be part of the community representing you as your district commissioner and as your CHAIRMAN Of the board and of course to be part of that columbus family for several years now. I'm happy to have you here, glad to have you here, continue it, no pressure from next year but this has to go and if you could join me? Can the coaches, this has to go on some records, right? So it's back to back state championships. Guys, a round of applause for the columbus basketball team. Lebron wishes he would have gone to columbus. In all honesty it takes an army and you guys are dfinitely that army. The leadership is they are of course but without your dedication I know it takes a lot to be an athlete and it takes even more to be the best at it . So it's my honor to be here with you guys and present this proclamation to you. Anybody want to say anything? >> thank you to our CHAIRMAN For bringing this proclamation, congratulations to you young gentlemen. There are a lot of young people that look up to you, mine included, I have a 12-year-old boy who plays basketball and their entirely aspires to be in the seats you are sitting in right now so I know you are young men likely to go off to college but even at your young age know you are role models to much younger people and what their aspiring to each and every day including my little boy so congratulations on your back to back the chips and we look forward to you coming home another one next year, congratulations. >> first of all congratulations, not only back to back which is amazing, I want to congratulate the coaches. I don't represent your district, I represent that other school that won a championship a while back but I am the only guy up here to play for a number school before because I remember when brother felix was the coach and I would play jv so I'm the only guy that played high shool basketball, not to rub it in but people don't realize how difficult it is to win the state championships and I can tell you every young man, that's even harder, every young man and every young woman that placed the sport, my daughter did play, my middle daughter a state championship is one of the greatest honors you can get and you will never ever forget that. And I'm very happy my old school wanted which is important because that's where I spent half of my academic career and thank you for the hard work because even though you're being honored today and you will go on to much greater things and I promise I'm not going to do any illegal recruiting though I am a canes graduate, I want to remind everybody about that just in case, keep the canes in your mind but the most important thing is the lessons you've learned playing high school basketball will be lessons that will serve you the rest of your life. I learned to work with these younger wonderful people because I was on a basketball team that taught me wonderful lessons, how to lose, how to win, how to prepare. Those 6 am 7 am practices will come in handy one day and congratulations again to the columbus explorers. >>commissioner gilbert: I'm the county commission for district 1, I don't represent you all but I am a fan and a fan not just because of the football team but because of the institution and alumni. You all are student-athletes and I know when people look up to you they're not looking up because you can shoot the basketball, dunk the basketball, I understand the rigorous academic curriculum columbus put you through, they are preparing you not just to go to the nba but to be leaders in this world in the future so I appreciate that, I appreciate your commitment, appreciate your dedication because those traits when you apply them across a wide spectrum of other disciplines they will make you successful in life, congratulations and congratulations to columbus, you all do a great job. >>commissioner regalado: I am commissioner raquel regalado, my boy playing for southwest so I watched you guys bat him. But my nephews go to columbus so there's that and they're very happy there. Columbus is such a wonderful institution. You really are our future leaders. We don't get to talk a lot about faith up here but for those of us who believe, we are so excited to have leaders that share our principles and our values so thank you for that. As was mentioned your curriculum it is spectacular but also your dedication to our community and you have some alumni here which I have to give a shout out to, ralph is your biggest fan so our airport director proudly wears the sea every day. He reminds us every day he is a columbus graduate and there's other ones like carlos that every time you see that they feel the need, there you go. Another one. So you have an amazing alumni network and we couldn't be prouder of you, thank you for representing miami-dade county so well and congratulations for all your hard work and effort, as a mm who watched it I know there's days you don't want to go and to be there but it's all about showing up so thank yu for that, you are all really an inspiration. >>chair: guys, I'm so proud of you. I'm proud of what you've been able to accomplish to this point but I think oliver gilbert makes a great point and raquel makes a great point too. It's not only the accomplishments you have in sports although they are memorable and we are so proud of you, it's the way you carry ourselves as young men. We need more good young man and that comes with good mentor ship and although I am not an alumni and people like jb and the CHAIRMAN And ralph made me feel like alumni because folks at columbus they love hard but they work hard to. There's a saying in the latin, I don't know how to say it's because I don't speak latin but it goes a mdg and the premise of it is really everything that you do in life do it as if you're doing it for the glory of GOD, not for your glory, not for accolades but you're doing it for the glory of GOD and I know for a fact that columbus operates that way and I think your championships are a testament to that but your future and the leadership is a bigger testament to that will GOD bless you and carry on. >>chair: I'm going to have the mayor say a few words but can we quiet down in the chamber? Can we quiet down in the chamber? Sgt., if you see them speaking escort them, please. Follow rs, felony, I don't know. It is a joke. >>mayor cava: gentlemen, we are here with you because it matters what you've done on the court, what you've done at your school obviously has gained you tremendous respect and acclaim because of your expertise. We brought you to county hall because you are champions for all of us so the entire miami-dade county is standing with you cheering with you and if I have to declare another day off like I did a couple of years ago for another championship please MR., you just tell me because that happened. That is the truth. That is the truth. I did it. It was done because we all just want to revel in the incredible honor you've brought to all of us. That was different because I was on school premises. I know there have been rallies, I know they've been supported and we join you in that period to your coaches and your teachers and your leaders here in the school thank you for making it possible for this great team to achieve greater victories. Now national champions. >>chair: before we call you guys up and do the official proclamation if the coaches want to say a few words you are welcome to. >> mdm. Mayor, cmmissioners, thank you for this amazing honor. We are humbled and grateful you brought us together today but when you talk about our team and we have an extraordinary team, florida state championships, a national championship this yar what you'd be most proud of is they are amazing student-athletes and they represent our community so well. Every day when they're out there wearing their jerseys or when they're traveling or they're playing or going to indianapolis to win the national championship they represent our community so incredibly well. They do the work when nobody's working, do the hard work when nobody's looking at our community supports them like nothing I've ever seen so we are very grateful to be here today, thank you for this acknowledgment, thank you for this honor and we will promise to continue representing columbus like our boys have done this year we will do it into the future so let me turn it over to coach george. >> I want to start by thanking you guys for having us here, it's a huge honor. These guys, they really deserve it. They show up every day , they are relentless, there leaders in our community, they have unified our community. If you've been to any of our games , they have inspired the next generation so after games are over we have a bunch of little guys, a bunch of little ones just staying there, they're asking for pictures, asking for advice, they're asking to be around and it's special to bring the community together and those will be the next guys following in the path and they set a great example so some of the things we are proud of, these guys have the highest gpa out of all sports at columbus. That's just a testimony to how hard they work on the court, off the court, they are committed to each other and those are the skills that will transfer to real life, some of these guys will go to college, some of these guys will be amazing leaders in their community and that's something we are etremely proud of. I know we've won four in a row and we have a national championship but we have some guys graduating to go to the next level and we are excited but we have an amazing group coming back that we are extremely excited about and we're looking forward to get our fifth one and like you talk about our record has never been broken in the state of florida and we're going to get it. >>chair: all right, come on up. Coaches, come on up. Everybody take off your stickers. Take off your stickers. All right, and coach , be it resolved the mayor of the county danielle levine cava and the members of the board of county commissioners on behalf of the entire miami-dade county in this community hereby proclaim today tuesday, MAY 6 asked christopher columbus high school 2025 chipotle national champions day, congratulations. Guys, congratulations. Go explorers, get behind us because your tall and let's take a picture, get in the middle. PRESIDENT As well. Mayor, we should get in the middle with them. >>... No . >>chair: all right guys, let's quiet down in the chamber, take your seats. Take your seats, clerk please call the roll. >> good morning to all. >>commissioner bastien: >>commissioner bermudez: >>commissioner cohen higgins: >>senator garcia: >>commissioner gilbert: >>commissioner gonzalez: >>commissioner hardemon: >>commissioner higgins: >>commissioner regalado: >>commissioner steinberg: >>vice chair: >>chair: present. >> we have 10 members present, we have a quorum . >>chair: colleagues, ladies and gentlemen please stand for the invocation led by father josc sp joe at the invitation of commissioner regalado, thank you for being here with us today . >> as we begin I'd like to share with you a short reading from the book of numbers. And the lord said to moses together for me seven elders of israel and you will go to be the elders of the people and officers of them. Bring them to the meeting and let them take their stand there with you. And I will come down and talk with you there. And I will take some of the spirit which is upon you and put it upon them that they MAY share the burden of the people with you. That you MAY not bear it yourself alone. As we gather here today in service of the people of miami-dade county , a community rich in culture diversity , MAY we approach this meeting with humility, wisdom and a spirit of cooperation. That's why we pray for one another. As we say heavenly father, grant us the clarity to make decisions that reflect justice and equity. MAY our words be guided by respect and our actions by integrity. Lets us listen deeply to one another and to the voices of those we represent. Send your spirit upon us that in all that we do today we might be mindful of the trust placed in us. of your will for your people and the responsibility we share to protect the welfare and the future of our community. With your grace MAY this session be productive , guided by compassion and grounded in the common good. And we ask this through your son our lord, jesus christ, amen . >>chair: thank you father and of the vice chair will lead us in the pledge of allegiance. >> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under GOD with liberty and justice for all. >>chair: you MAY be seated. >> MR. Chair. Before the father leaves if he could tell us a little bit about lamieda, if he could tell us about lamieda for those that don't now about the national shrine in district 7. >>chair: please be brief but I would love to hear. >> lamieda which is a national shrine o our lady of charity is a place of worship and gathering right next to mercy house. It was founded actually in 67 by sydnor romano who was a leader in his community, spiritual and also very much a community leader and we just celebrated last year our 50th year of the inauguration of our sanctuary building and it's been a place of gathering for the people of miami , especially cubans but immigrants from every place come to thank GOD for being here in the united states and for their needs and prayers and there always welcome. They've always been invited to our celebrations and I hope to see you there and thank you commissioner regalado for the invitation to be here today, GOD bless you. >>chair: thank you father and thank you commissioner for inviting the father to come and give our invocation. We do have one more presentation this morning, I wanted us to take our seats so we could listen to it and be standing while it's given. So if the director could please come up to the podium. I understand we have results from the jd power north american airport satisfaction study. And we're going to have about five minutes for this presentation . >> I want to be brief, I'm going to introduce MR. Mike taylor and jd power as well as we know is a world-renowned organization that rates services for industries around the world. They will be presenting the latest update for mia and it's all good news, I will give you highlights in the last quarter from number 10 to number four of all the airports in the united states in customer satisfaction rating. The faa recently like they do every year we were found to be a well-managed safe airport and passed our annual operational audit with flying colors. We've received also rewards from global travel magazine is the best layer over airport in the country, MR. Taylor will be covering some of what leads to that ranking including the most improved airport in the united states this last quarter by 28 points and you'll also mention where bucking the trend, consider the modernization and construction, the fact that we are achieving those ratings is quite remarkable so with that I'll turn it over to MR. Taylor. >> through the chair, thank you, I want to say how proud I am of our mami-dade aviation department and our leader and our chief operating officer jimmy morales, you've concentrated and put so much effort into this and clearly we're seeing the results and obviously we will hear the specific ratings but now to note we are the fourth in north america among all airports which is a great line from where we were before and where we have challenges we are addressing them aggressively with your great support so I want to say thank you to all of you or the support that you've rendered and of course it's showing in the results from our passengers. >>chair: thank you director for your leadership as well. >> I have a lot of data slides but as ralph was saying these are the interim results. Not close enough, got it, sorry. These are the interim results so sort of the halftime of the 2025 study that releases in SEPTEMBER of this year and you can see miami is number four among the mega airports, the largest airports , there's about 18 or 19 and you see a lozenge or diamond next to the number which means it's significantly above the average and you can see there are some statistically below the average as well. Miami is the blue line and you can see the last five or 6/4 it's been a nice steady climb as ralph mentioned it's hard to do when you have a lot of things going on at the airport but there are two things that impact satisfaction, one is construction and one is passenger volume and you guys have got both in spades will you do an excellent job bucking the trend, we usually see a downward trend when we see higher passenger volumes and a lot of construction at the airport and some of the things shows you the rankings in each of the particular what we call dimensions which I won't spend any time on other than the level of trust which you are five out of 20 and a diamond means significantly above the average for people trusting miami airport. These are some of the individuals, I won't spend too much time. For completeness sake you can see some of these are trending up and down, terminal facilities is the only thing that rolling flat. It's hard when you got people going for the airport, that's more stress on the bathroom which is the most critical factor in people satisfaction. I know that all the improvement items the airport has going on that bathroom renovation is key among those. Questions anytime and I will take questions at the end. These are other things that don't don't go to the rankings themselves and I do want to point out one of the key factors that we see that makes a good airport into a great airport is having a sense of locality and it reflects the sense of the city and I know a lot of you have probably traveled for many decades as I have but 30, 40 years ago if you went to any airport . >>chair: can we quiet down in the back? Can we quiet down in the back? On our back here, thank you guys. >> if you went to an airport 30 or 40 years ago you saw the same things in every airport, you had Mcdonald's, MRS. Fields cookie and a tcby younger you could go anywhere in the world that's what you would find and we have found the last 20 years airports that highly perform in the satisfaction study are those that reflect a sense of community usually through food beverage and retail which miami does an excellent job at. One of the ky things holding miami back from that top spot is getting people to the airport on time. With a feeling of time so if you can improve access scores to your airport you can take advantage of the things miami does well which is its beverage and retail program and that moves the airport in rankings. So next slide. So on the right hand slide it's hard for me to read this this far up but you'll see we have some what we call image questions, these are on a seven point scale, not a 10 point scale but some I wanted to point out where that of all 20 airports in the mega category miami is ranked third in reliability as far as perception of reliability, all think they have a consistent experience, a good experience. There number two out of 20 in exciting so people think miami is an exciting airport and that's for those trends we've seen the last 20 years is it used to be when they ceated airports many years ago it was a place to get from one load of transportation to the other, now it's a destination and if it's got a vibrant excitement that really adds to satisfaction and non-aeronautical revenues and the last one I would mention is its reputation is also statistically above average and you can see it nds score which I won't go into and yes scores and I have 45 seconds left. The story here is through the halftime miami airport is improving on a consistent level of improvement from quarter to quarter and monitoring has a positive effect, people trust the airport as a great food beverage and retail five, it really reflects the sense that you're in the city of miami, some things you can improve on our access to the airport, you want to have so many people getting to your airport it's hard to get to but providing that sense of time is what helps with the swing factor hitting miami back to that spot and I have three seconds left. Any questions? All right, thank you. For coming down for the presentation. Mayor, thank you, commissioner hardemon. >>commissioner hardemon: I have a question, I'm glad the airport was here to make a presentation. It was our last meeting we had an airport item where we did extensions and stuff. At the most opportune time I want to discuss what we need to do because since that has happened it looks like as the ink is drying I'm not sure if there's some miscommunication or if we did eerything we thought we wanted to do or that things happened the way we intended so I want to get into the discussion about that. I'm not sure , I don't want to interrupt the flow of your meeting but I think it's an important thing to consider and to give you a quick example, we know there were a number of extensions where people had contracts and extended contracts but then the board added other people for us to consider. But even in some of what we were considering people already in the major contract that we were extending, they were part of that group competing for new spots. So it's just some things like that i want to talk through. >>chair: it's very opportune, there was an item submitted to my office for discussion. We have a packed agenda today but one of the prevailing cycles we can reconsider this item. I would like to add something on my end. >>chair: six I didn't want it to be reconsidered without discussion and the question would be for the county attorney's office do we need to reconsider before any other business is done or are we happy within the context of this meting at any time? >> if there was an appetite for reconsideration I would have to refer to today's meeting. >> any time in today's meeting . >> all right. Any other commissioner bastien you are recognized for a recognition. >>commissioner bastien: thank you MR. Chair. I wanted to give a privilege to wish everyone listening a happy asian heritage month. As you know the month of MAY is asian heritage month where throughout the nation and throughout the world that patient history is celebrated. From the time our ancestors led us excessive revolt which allowed our great nation to double in size, from the time our ancestors came to fight for the war of this great nation, from the times they founded the city of chicago, from the time pierre to st. Founded the city of new york and so many more, we celebrate the positive impact that haitians and haitian americans are making here in our county and around the world. We have a one month celebration for you to attend and we encourage you to do so and during that month we will be celebrating our history, our music, our traditions, our culture though I invite each and everyone to participate in these celebrations, they are all free of charge and before ending I'd like to thank each and every one for the celebration lunch, which was prepared for all of you, thank you for all of you who attended and had, we all had a great time and we brought you some gifts this morning we hope you will enjoy. Again, happy asian heritage month to all . >>chair: thank you for the lovely gifts, there's a lot of things in the basket. Commissioner gonzalez, you are recognized for a recognition . >>commissioner gonzalez: very important point of order, the best coffee in miami-dade county is here with the county commission today is dulce's birthday but friday was rosita's birthday and she also makes coffee, it's a tie up here I want to wish them a happy birthday. >>chair: thank you commissioner for that and I want t recognize with us today our supervisor of elections, thank you for being in the people's chamber today and just a quick announcement, unless you are the staff or an elected official you are not to be walking up to our clerk or where our clerk sits in the back or past that, on my right, your left. So back here is elected officials and staff only. The reason for this is there's been non-county staff approaching so with that, I am told our sheriff is in the chamber as well. Thank you for being with us as well. This MAY be because we have a midyear budget, is that why everybody's here today? Mme. Attorney can we move into the mayoral veto? >> yes you have to read something? We are on item 2a1. >>chair: you don't have to read it, fair enough and with that , yes, commissioner gonzalez is recognized. Let me say one little ting and I will recognize you commissioner because the item being vetoed is of course your item and I see the mayor wants to say some words as well and I suspect others MAY. I know this veto and the item this veto is vetoing, some of us are very passionate about and I don't like to use the word emotional but in some cases it has but let's try with all that's in us to stay within the realm of the discussion of the veto. That is what is before us today. Pros and cons of fluoridation, it is not those details, it is the veto so obviously that MAY extend a little bit but let's not go down a rabbit hole that we are presumably voting on today so with that commissioner gonzalez you are recognized . >>commissioner gonzalez: thank you MR. Chair and I'd like to make a motion to override the mayor's veto. >> second. >>commissioner gonzalez: I want to tll all my colleagues just like the CHAIRMAN Sid, this vote has nothing to do with fluoride. That ship has sailed . This commission has already made a decision as far as fluoride is concerned. What tis vote has to do with his leadership. It's miami dade county leading. This commission voted by a wide bipartisan margin to become the first major metropolitan area, the first major county in the united states of america to remove a neurotoxin from its water and guess what, the state took notice. So much so that the state followed and in so much conversations of being preemptive and making decisions because that's what this board is about, making decisions, not waiting but making decisions. This board led. Irrespective of what you think about fluoride. This board led. I take big issue when anybody says that the decision to impact and represent the people of miami-dade county and their health should not be made by this board. And should be left to the states or the national government. I take big issue with that because colleagues, I'm not going on a government rant here. But at the end of the day local government is the most important aspect of government connected to the people. The reason being is because we are the closest to the people. We the people every single day and every decision we make impacts the people very quickly. We learned that during covid, we learned that with masks, we learned that with forced vaccines. Folks, we made a decision for the people. And the people are sick and tired. The people are sick because their government has been poisoning them. Throw antiquated and distorted fda and cdc guidelines for years. >>chair: commissioner, as I said the rules apply to everybody. We're voting and we're speaking on a veto so by you leading the conversation granting that you are now opening up a full discussion that I am trying to keep this meeting in order so please stay on the veto . >>commissioner gnzalez: understood, MR. Chair. This vote does not have to do with what we feel about fluoride. It has to do with our connection to the people. And it has to do with this county commission leading. Stated before, we led. We made a decision. And at this point , I asked my colleagues to join me once more in a wide margin , bipartisan vote to override the mayor's veto so at this time I move resolution number 37025 be adopted and become effective notwithstanding the veto of the mayor. >>chair: we have emotion, we have a second by the vice chair . Commissioner from district 7, you are recognized. Is the commissioner from district 1 also going to be recognized? One second, naked as a custom I will go to you last. I see you down the line, I will grant you that for this one time but usually I go to the dais first . >>mayor cava: respectfully MR. Chair the action is my veto. >>chair: that's why I'm asking a question so hold that thought, I allowed him to speak first given he was the sponsor of the original item and as it is your veto you have before. >>mayor cava: like you MR. Chair. As you know last week the florida legislature did pass senate bill 700 and we expected it to be signed into law very shortly and among other measures it prohibits the addition of fluoride to public water systems statewide and i want to be very frank as we all are here, I am deeply disappointed by this decision. It disregards the overwhelming consensus of doctors dentists and organizations of medical experts. I do not substitute my judgment for theirs, I do not substitute my judgment for theirs. When this ws introduced by this board I took it upon myself to educate myself on this critical topic and listen closely to the community and to our most trusted medical experts. I met with dentists, doctors and parents to learn more and they told me fluoride is a proven safe and effective way to protect oral health or children and families and particularly for families committed to access to dental care. >>chair: mayor, you saw what I said to my colleagues on the board, I ask that you also remain as much as possible on the veto itself. Explain my veto, I will try to be brief. As to the medical I am not a physician but no studies have said laura nation at current levels are unsafe though that is on the record. So the doctors I've spoken with our. Clear it would have long-lasting health consequences especially for the most vulnerable cities and took out the fluoride had to add it back so many cities have agreed with me, I'm not done with my review of the medical data. Many cities have agreed, 15 local cities and other electives took action, passed resolutions or wrote letters to express their concern and I am additionally disappointed by the preemption. We don't like to be preempted and as commissioner gonzalez said this is a very important local decision taking care of the personal health and is taking it out of the hands of our local community so I believe our community trust us, that's what we've learned and I continue to believe that listening to the medical experts is the best way to protect our health so I know that despite these concerns and our opinions here we must comply with all state laws so I know this board must take a procedural step today. To be in compliance with state law but I will continue to navigate on behalf of our community for public health and I hope this commission will stand with me. >>chair: commissioner from district one you are followed by commissioner from district 7 and back to the commissioner from the 11th district. >>commissioner gilbert: thank you to the sponsor of the initial item commissioner gonzalez and thank you to our mayor. I've seen all of the press on this but I want to take a moment and make it smaller. Let's just make it smaller. We didn't do this in a bipartisan way because we are not bipartisan on this board, we are nonpartisan. We didn't do it because of the what people say in the audience, we did it because based on the evidence before us as a board. I appreciate the mayor's veto and I value her message and opinion and I believe it's part of our process, our process allows the mayor to speak at that time and if she disagrees to veto and for us to address that veto here on the board. So when the CHAIRMAN Says let's stick to the veto that's what we're saying. This is a healthy part of any government. Our ability to disagree without being disagreeable. We can have this conversation and it doesn't have to be hard. I cast a vote based on the evidence before me and I have seen nothing to change my mind since. And I appreciate , I've gotten the calls from the dentists including my dentist, thank you. I appreciate that and I appreciate that no one's trying to poison us, I appreciate that but I also appreciate the trust in contractors when they put asbestos in buildings. And we trusted plumbers when they gave us lead pipes. Sometimes when you know different you know better you do different. The evidence before us , if the evidence before us was that yes, we need this for good dental health I believe it is helpful fr good dental, I believe that. I also believe it could be harmful for people and it's our job to balance that and in balancing the equities of the most vulnerable. I believe that we should stand by our votes, thank you mr. chair . >>chair: commissioner from district 7 . >>commissioner regalado: thank you, I want to clarify some points. First of all we did not lead, we followed. This has been a priority of wilson simpson for over four years and I said that when we spoke on it . Part of the reason that this item was fast tracked is so we could get ahead of the state bill which had been filed, which had been vetted, which had gone to committee and which had had public hearing so let's not distort what this board decided to do. That being said, my issue remains one of process. It is not the role of this regional government to decide the chemical makeup of water. We do not have the expertise. We do not have the department for it. We follow federal guidelines and I said clearly when this item came up that the state was going to preempt us, that it has been in the works for some time and that is the our right to do so. This is a state decision or a federal recommendation. As we mentioned last time the federal government 10 years ago changed the amount of fluoride that it recommended for everyone to put in water. We followed that. My concern with this vote today is the slippery slope we are going down. As chair of infrastructure am I going to receive or worse yet not receive an item in two weeks asking us to change the amount of chlorine we use to clean our water? Where does it end ? We are not equipped to have these conversations. The this is not our wheelhouse. If you want to serve at the federal level served at the federal level, if you want to serve at the state level, served at the state level. These are not regulations we are tasked by our voters to determine. That being said as the mayor said we are here to follow state law not just as elected by myself as an attorney. Everyone here wants to do right by the state and by the federal government and if they made those changes, we have no other option but to abide by them. My question is procedurally what happens next? Because we know that the governor is going to sign this bill at 1:30 today but our rules state we must take up this veto before any substantive business. As far as I'm concerned tere's no need for this. I'm happy to support the mayor but because I've spoken for my residence, I can tell you what my residence and what I feel and I am deeply concerned at what was considered evidence and how it was presented to this board and I hope in the future if we make decisions of this caliber we do so hearing both sides at a minimum an opportunity for a comprehensive look at the issue and I say it as the only non-member of the committee that attended the presentation that only presented one side, I don't see say it as someone who didn't show up every time this item came up. So my question to the attorneys is what are our options in terms of the process? >> when a veto, when an item is vetoed the board has in essence three options pursuant to your rules, one is you can move to override the veto with a motion and a second to do that now. This particular item can be reconsidered before the motion to override is taken up. If we consider the veto as nullified at which point any option that would have been available that came to the board is available at that time and the third option is to do nothing. If no motion is made then the veto will be sustained . >>commissioner regalado: thank you jerry, I mentioned the reconsideration bcause there's several issues. The bill that preempts us at 1:30 today has an effective date of JULY 1. The item before us is different. The item before us did not consider the logistics of this change. And I know that everyone is interested in the instagram real but I'm interested in the day-to-day of water and sewer, of regulating this part of our water chemistry, I'm interested in the chemicals our department has purchased and how we are going to sell or get rid of those chemicals, I'm interested in the day-to-day and in the misrepresentations that have been made to the residents of miami aid county as to the water they have been receiving from us is not safe. I went before our municipalities and all the ones I went before asked us to keep fluoride and uphold the veto and those municipalities are the city of south miami, village of pinecrest, the village of key biscayne, village of palmetto bay and the city of homestead. So I didn't sit home and watch a real. I actually went to our partners and asked them what they thought and what their concerns were. Now the ship has sailed and this is a state issue but there are conflicts between what we passed which I voted against and what will happen at 1:30 JULY 1. The bill that was passed by the state does not have education , our bill does have education. Here are some things that are not the same and I think this board should reconsider this item. And do the right thing. I think we let the state do this. If you continue with this item you open yourself up to litigation . Let the state take the litigation. We have no reason to get involved in this fight. So I cannot move for reconsideration because I was not on the prevailing side, it has to be someone who was on the prevailing side. I believe from a procedural perspective the right thing to do is to reconsider the item and either defer it or amend it so that it complies with the law that was passed by the legislature. If not you remain with a conflict on the books and you remain with an issue that's difficult for us to effectuate. I hope that you do the right thing. >>chair: vice chair, your recognized. >>vice chair: my remarks are brief as relates to the veto. I have a letter from amb. Andrew young who had the opportunity to research this issue back in 2016 and I will be brief and read one line because consistent with what I was saying what I said previously as relates to this item we have a former congressman and ambassador to the united nations, key figure in the sclc and former mayor of atlanta, his exact words were the 2016 letter letter to the governor of georgia he said this is a civil rights issue and the people have a right to have the full story given to them. Those are my remarks. I borrow directly from our ambassador young as relates to why my position is what it is today so thank you . >>chair: we have a motion and we have a second. All in favor of the veto signify by saying aye. The veto override, sorry. Veto override. Sorry, words matter. Words matter. All in favor of the veto override which is the motion on the floor signify by saying aye, all opposed, nay. We need, the aye's have it, right? The aye's have it with jc. Show the veto overridden . >> point of order, how will we deal with the conflict? Water and sewer asked to effectuate this, how will we effectuate it? >> we would have to deal with the conflict later okay, we're not discussing that, I'm not answering, the administration is answering that question right now but not only whether it was or wasn't , that's not what we're here to discuss right now. We could bring an item, bring a discussion item or have a conversation with the administration but that's not where we're at right now. Attorney, should we move into reasonable opportunity at this time? >> now would be appropriate. >> reasonable opportunity for the public to be heard is open. When I call your name please state the item you're speaking on, name and address and you will have 2 minutes to speak. When I call your name lineup. Alexander margarita. [Reading names] None of these folks are in the audience? State your name and address, you have two minutes to speak. Names item which you are speaking on. >> I am speaking on 11a2, my name is alexander garc office is at 1101 paul ave., assistant city attorney for the city of hialeah and I'd like to thank senator garcia for sponsoring this item, this important and beneficial item and appreciate the time to speak, this is for the opportunity zones within the city of hialeah and is a very beneficial program that could come to the city. As many of you know the city is celebrating its centennial this year and throughout the 100 years of the city of hialeah programs like this have increased our ability to develop and have economic prosperity. So we are fully in support of this item and on behalf of mayor percy rojas in the entire city council we think the commission for taking this opportunity to vote on this item, thank you . >> my husband is scott and he is a magistrate and former judge so my home address is protected but my mailing address is 251 251 lancia avenue 251 lancia ave., coral gables, fl 251 lancia ave., coral gables, fl 33134. I am here on item 11a11 unsolicited to ask you to appoint natalie as district 6 commissioner. I was proud of the work of amb. Cabrera. I serve on neat streets for him and hope to continue to do so. M friend and fellow west miami resident natalie has changed the city of west miami for the better. As to MR. And vice mayor she has empowered the women of our city to network with each other. She has also started an autism decal program with the police and city. She also worked to resolve difficult issues regarding our schools and has been responsive to residents on both sides of the issue. She has and can do attitude and she will be an asset and will serve as commissioner with distinction. While I take my right to vote seriously I ask you to support the resolution and appoint the person my entire neighborhood and walk supports as next commissioner for district 6, natalie. >>chair: thank you, next. >> good morning german rodriguez, vice chair mcghee, mayor levine cava, commissioners and members of this committee, my name is tatiana silva and I want to express our sincere gratitude for your leadership and vision supporting coastal strategic development. I'm here today to express our support for item 3b3, project came in, I reside on harbor DR., key biscayne and we are here to express our support for project came in, a proposed $80 million investment in the construction of a new state of the art fish the production facility in south dade. This facility will create 50 new jobs at an average annual wage of $70,000. Significantly above the state average and the south dade's average. This initiative embodies our commitment to fostering inclusive economic route. While miami's kind of line continues to evolve with high-profile developments project came and brings transformative opportunities to communities beyond our traditional economic centers. This reflects the kind of balanced economic strategy we need. Investments that support local competitiveness across our entire county. the requested tgif and incentive of 1.5 million over 10 years is performance-based. Unless job creation and investment benchmarks are met each year over the course of a decade. The county stands to gain more than $1.2 million in net incremental general fund revenues with the net benefit ratio of 1.75 to 1. Thank you vice CHAIRMAN Mcghee, mayor levine cava and the office of economic development for your continued leadership and support ensuring miami-dade's economic future is both inclusive and robust. Thank you all for your support . >> good morning, scott polowitz, 21190 mainsail cir. 3180 aventura and I'm here to oppose item 4a which contains an extreme provision removing the public's ability to weigh in on permit applications. Under county code residents have the right to petition any short form permit application be heard before the county commission. This gives residence and our county commission a voice in this process on the public record and serves as a necessary check and balance to the executive power and administrative action. Removing this like proposed in section 2 of item 4a sponsored by commissioner higgins would allow developers to exploit loopholes in the permitting process and pushed through environmentally impactful developments without the opportunity from scrutiny or input from you. Removing this would be a step backwards for accountability and transparency which are two priorities for this board. I'm also with friends of biscayne bay a support organization for the aquatic preserves. We're concerned about the portion of this item allowing a seawall to stick out 2 and a half feet into the bay and how that MAY impact the shoreline. After all the bay is protected by state statute because it is an aquatic preserves and dredge and still are not allowed so we are curious how that would impact that. We would support 4a if these provisions were workshops and improved or removed. Perhaps limiting the scope of streamlining short form permit review to see wall construction and repair and making sure to exclude things like dredge and still and dark improvements to comply with state statute. Overall fixing and creating new seawall quickly without delay is important for resiliency and biscayne bay health but not at the cost of all public input into this process. Few times this provision has been used and it is currently not being abused in our view and is not the reason for the delays in this process, thank you . >> philip stoddard 64th court. I'm not going to repeat everything scott polowitz said because I pretty much agree with all of it. It is overall a good resolution. I appreciate what the commissioner is doing but I'm going to speak specifically to the loss of the public right to hearing. Staff tried something like this 20 years ago and it turned out to be a disaster because all the material in the application doesn't necessarily rflect all the contingencies on the ground. When I say it ended badly, it ended with the termination of the city manager and loss of the commission seats of all the people who supported it so south miami moved away from that pretty rapidly and we learned the hard way public voting is essential. >>chair: can we hve quiet in the chamber? >>chair: with that I conclude, appreciate you all . >>chair: is that everybody registered to speak on reasonable opportunity? All the names I called, MR. Young you're not on this list, you might be on another one but you are not in reasonable opportunity so I see you sir. Reasonable opportunity is now closed. We're going to take up a brief recess so I can verify something on the veto override vote. I need to get with the clerk so we're going to take it on a three mnute recess. Don't go anywhere. >>. [Recess] >>chair: we are resuming our meeting. We have to resume our meeting at this time. We have a long agenda. right, apparently we have a discrepancy on the veto override. So I'm going to have, I'm going to ask the clerk to do a roll call. So that we can have an exact roll call, we need a two thirds vote so that eight members from whose presence. >> if there is 12 here is a. Clerk, please call the roll on the veto override, we have to do this before we take action on any other item. . >>. >>commissioner gilbert: it must be said our co-code does not say that, our code says the clerk should place this item substantive item on the agenda, it does not say when we have to vote for it, that's something that an opinion given by the county attorney, it's not just on our code, it's based on their practices and I need us to understand that. >> it is my understanding from the attorneys this is the order we have to do it in, that's what the county attorney has stated. But either way it is my discretion to do it. We're going to just go ahead. >>vice chair: MR. CHAIRMAN. >>chair: commissioner hardemon . >>commissioner hardemon: I move we get a 15 minute recess. >>chair: you can get a second and do that, I'm not going to be okay with that. >>vice chair: thank you for your patience with this dais but I read the rules similar to commissioner gilbert and I read the rules with that understanding. The understanding is that yes, it has to be at the time but it doesn't say when we have to take the vote and because it's silent on when we have to take the vote I believe the tigers to this board. >>chair: mdm. Attorney I've asked this question several times, please respond because there is uneasiness on this. >> I can read from you what the rule says exactly and commissioner gilbert has read in essence told you what the rule says. The court shall place the veto items vetoed by the mayor together with the completed veto forms on the next regularly scheduled commission agenda as the first substantive items for commission consideration. He also said this has been the practice, this has been aboard customary practice for years and if the board wishes to change that customary practice you are free to do so but that has been a practice of this board for years, as far as I know . >>commissioner gilbert: I appreciate the role, I know what she said was accurate but I just want us to understand it's been discretion of this chair how and when we hear things that are on the agenda and I'm not going to usurp the authority of the chair. That rule certainly does not. >>chair: I am ready to take a vote, I've had is veto on my desk for days now, I've done my due diligence. If this board feels differently and there's a motion for a 15 minute recess and the second you guys

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e1797c0b0299c4204a6833885fdf3d01. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record