POLISCOPE

The public record

PASADENA (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Meeting: March 21, 2022

Monday, March 21, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Meeting: March 21, 2022

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 136,205 stored characters

good evening everyone. Welcome to the MARCH 21st 2022 meeting of the past and the city council. I apologize on behalf of the council we're late getting into public session. We had a heavy closed session agenda which we were not able to complete and so the council will at the end of the public meeting return to close session in order to complete its closing agenda. Let's start with the roll call council member hampton blessed to be here caspari kennedy here customer madison just informed me he's on his way trying to log in but is not here yet. COUNCILMAN Asuda here customer service here, COUNCILMAN Williams here, vice well wilson is absent. Mayor gordo here. There's a quorum of the council present. Ok, MR. Williams, if you'll lead us in the pledge of allegiance again thank you. Uh, the united states of america and the republic for which it stands one nation under GOD liberty justice for all. We do have one ceremonial matter at the request of MR. Madison but we'll allow MR. Madison to join the meeting or handle next week. With that we have public comments for matters not on the agenda. I would like to point out that we have a few public hearings and so we'll try and give everyone an opportunity that we can within the first twenty minutes otherwise will your card will be called at the end of me and with that we will call CHAIRMAN Jane ward by michael williams file by jasmyn richards abduallah and it's a minute and a half for speaking . I will ring a bell to let the speakers know when they have thirty seconds. MISS Ward, go ahead first. Thank you for taking a break from your special meeting strategy to suppress public comment. My name is jane and I'm one of the lead organizers for the altadena pasadena chapter of showing up for racial justice or third word chapter of third national which has over a hundred other chapters and affiliates across forty seven states in the us. What does surge do we educate and mobilize white people in our community to enter their support for racism and police violence and this includes ending support for local politicians like the ones on pasadena city council who care more about police departments and police associations than their own constituents demands for police accountability surge members from around the country are working to help move resources away from racist policing and into the communities that need them. We've helped to secure victories in louisville, atlanta, cleveland, buffalo, los angeles and dozens of other cities. If you are listening and are a resident or a city staff person, a journalist or anyone else who'd like to be part of this growing movement to end the racist corruption in the city of pasadena and to demand justice for anthony mclean, we would love to have you you can find us by locating our chapter on the search website search dot org. So thank you to the city for this platform which allows us to share information with the community while council members stare vacantly instant in their racist dupas seat at the next meeting michael williams followed by richard jasmyn richards abdullah MR. Williams women thirty seconds go ahead. This thursday will be the 10th anniversary for the murder of kendrick mcdade. Some of you were not on the council when kendrick was killed. Some of you were. But in the ten years there hasn't been any significant changes to the pasadena police policy and procedures to prevent something like kendrick meek from happening. And sure enough, eight years into after his death we had another shooting of a man running in the police in the back same way kendrick was killed. It should be a monumental failure for you all. You guys should feel embarrassed that this is what you have let your city come to that you sat here and promise community members, his mother and others that you would do things to make sure that these things did not happen here in pasadena and yet they continue to happen even though it's been ten years, his family still feels the pain hasn't gone away and it hasn't gotten any easier for them and that's why we call in every week demanding justice for not only him but anthony mcclain and others because we're going to bring the pain that these families feel to you every single week until you do something until you finally do something that is going to make sure that this did not happen again. Michael, you're going to be sick. MR. Williams, your time has expired and having the same conversations with the same basis fire the jasmine richards abduallah followed by adriana batista followed by brittany pawlak. You jasmine you just muted there you go. One minute. Thirty seconds please. Go ahead. I'm actually calling I'm calling to demand that I actually open up three hall chambers. I'm the city has done it. We will I know why we haven't because it's easier for you guys not to pay attention and also take mcdade's. My dad was killed by officer matthew byrd and jeffrey newlon ,two officers who are still on duty still patrol the same area. I actually ran into both of them together but they were burstow and I see that to see a PRESIDENT Don't care about me they in the office of independent review report hinge that was done. It's murder. There's 56 recommendations that henry djanogly had experts recommended to pasadena police department they put in nine ok, they they changed no policy of these officers were found out of policy. So I don't know why they're not fired and I don't know why they haven't been prosecuted. So I just want to say a and yeah I'm really just sick and tired of this period because we're going through the circle of police oversight commission that can't do anything you guys are you keep having this circle of life going on but in a minute we're going to target with MISS Abduallah your time has expired to do something about this man to continue right now. Well, we're asking you guys of adriana batista followed by britney followed by looks like carolyn maloney but maybe not checked into the meeting yet. MISS Battista women thirty seconds please. Matthew griffin and jeffrey nolan are not only on the police force but they still get scheduled to work on duty together and they still get invited to retirement parties. For example, lieutenant burgess's retirement party at el cerrito in pasadena this weekend, they were both invited and nobody in has an issue with it. So pbt is full of bad cop and bad representatives that none of you are willing to make sure they get disciplined or fired. This is madness and sickening. Kendrick mcdade was killed ten years ago to this thursday and on thursday you're you're having a meeting about the city manager. Well, we need a city manager who's actually going to hold murderous city employees accountable and kendrick mcdade had just transferred the pcc as a student also the oira report the independent auditor on the case. Their report on our website remain still redacted to this day. His mother and jasmine richard adua fought hard to demand that the report be completely unredacted and completely transparent. But to say your time is expired the report remains the redacted justice for kendrick mcdade. Thank you brittany for by carolyn maloney followed by julie martinez. Neither one has checked in so we could go to cab a night in the any MISS Pollack, go ahead. Yes we can one minute thirty seconds. Go ahead. I'm calling in the names of kendrick meek, david and anthony mcclain to demand justice and accountability for their brutal killings by the pasadena police department. As speakers have already mentioned, kendrick was murdered when he was 19 years old almost ten years ago. That's a teenager. he was a kid ten years later, community still demanding that y'all do something about these murders and ppd and still you sit there most of you with your cameras off literally almost all of you doing GOD knows what at home but doing absolutely nothing to hold the police accountable. Why are you all still meeting virtually where are you turning your cameras on this is your job literally. Where are you? This is public comment. Mass mandates are being lifted in schools and public places. Y'all are cowards. Shame on you show up to the community maybe if this council would have taken the death of a black community member seriously ten years to go and fought for accountability for kendrick we could have saved anthony mclean from his murders in AUGUST of twenty twenty. You not doing anything continues to push this to the side and actually is going to get people killed. Police in this country kill on average three people every single day. This is back in twenty twenty one police murdered a thousand fifty five people and that number is absolutely undercounted. Pasadena pd is a part of this and you all decided to give them eighty six dollars million of the budget last year. Hilarious. But thirty million dollars less than the fire department gets. How can you justify this the total budget for pasadena is MISS Pollack, your time has expired that you made your choice always a choice and you gave that money to murderers over carolyn galani. No, not carolyn sixty. No. Ok, julie martinez no. All right. Cabaye nyoni followed by cryonic covais you have one minute and thirty seconds. Go ahead. Got it. I'm calling to start with I just I think it's about time to open the doors. It's about time that you guys need to confront the public who has been waiting to see you guys and ask you guys to do your job if adaiah, your old man go to work every morning to clean up our street. You guys we don't give a if madison doesn't feel safe to come to the public if everyone go to work, come to work. We were looking forward to meet you ten years ago kenneth mcveigh diked jeffrey miller, jeffrey miller and matthew griffin. These killer cops cops who killed innocent 19 year old walking around this street in the same place that they cause all these traumas and you clowns you sit down and allow someone like steve marmol not to do his job for 17 months after a killing of anthony mclain you that was your job. You selected you elected steve merrymount. It was your job to put him on the it was your job to do your job. It was your job to fire him and not letting him to get more money if know you didn't you didn't. And steve and anthony mclain's name it will be you all be remembered as part of that. It's time to bring justice to pasadena. Either you bring it or we will bring it. We go every single few guys we know our right this is a threat considers a threat to all of your careers. We will you're not going to get elected. You're not going to get our money our tax money to go against the community and we're policeman nyoni all of your time has expired k followed by heavenly hues. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. One minute thirty seconds. Go ahead. Thank you. My name corrine on been resident and a member of black lives matter los angeles and I'm echoing all the other calls who have called in about your ridiculousness having a community wait for an hour to open up this public meeting not being held accountable to the public who you are supposed to serve kendrick meek dade was murdered ten years ago this week, ten years ago this week and your pasadena police department is no less white supremacists, no less rabid, no less racist and you will have taken part in that your city attorney's office you the results all of you elected officials play a part in the systemic and institutionalized racism and white supremacy and violence that happens in the city of pasadena. kendrick mcdade was murdered and you have allowed another police murder to happen in anthony mclean and that is on you will and you are set up I've said it before you're set up to have another death over and over and over again and there'll be a lack of accountability. We need the officers who killed anthony mcclain fired ok? We need edwyn do mclinden fired ronald's right. Not like those other officers that are still on the force that murdered kendrick fire. That is accountability. What you all are doing here is not accountability and it's for sure not public service bigger your lives out black lives matter. You should be ashamed of yourself. Ten years now and over two years and you still haven't disciplined those officers who murdered anthony mclean cleans up your public safety, not municipal. I say the same stuff y'all are the crime. You're only the screen. Your time is expired blood and we'll call heavenly hues by alan shay mitsuse hello. Can you hear me? We can one minute thirty seconds go ahead. Say his name anthony mcclain say his name anthony mcclain. We've been saying his name for over a year and still to this day we do not see any accountability by the officers who murdered anthony mcclain. Cynthia kurtz, this message is for you. We've in talking to the city council and they do nothing nothing has happened. I am asking you, cynthia herb and cheryl moody, if you can hear me, please review the case reopen and review the case of anthony mcwane. You have the power the community also gives you the power and says this is what we want. We want the murderers of anthony mcclain fired my name is have me killed. I am the co-founder of my prize my five rights focus on police accountability. We're asking those that are in the community here in our voices if you are concerned about the police violence, please contact you can contact my side bryza or or sign up for racial justice. We need the city council to know that over 50 percent of the community is higher up there now. No accountability within passing the police department within the city council and also cynthia, acourt, we're looking for you as the city manager to also please do your job. Thank you. Allen shay allen. One minute. Thirty seconds. Go ahead. Thank you. Good afternoon, honorable MR. Gordon. City council members, I'm calling to just remind you that the ninth circuit court has indicated that a city manager has the power to fire the officers and allow them to exercise their due process rights through the legal system . The city manager has the authority the community has spoken the the video is clear. It's very clear anthony mcclain had no gun shot in the back twice a gun brought into the crime scene by pasadena police and pasadena police have manipulated and created a narrative that you the city is standing by which makes no sense. You have the ninth circuit court on your side. You have the community voice indicating what needs to take place. Please do not continue to send our city through this madness and fire those officers. And cynthia kurtz, please show leadership in your role as city manager. Thank you. That completes the public comments speakers that have submitted cards for matters not on the agenda. Thank you, MR. Clark. MR. Madison, you made a request to adjourn tonight's meeting in memory of russell collier. Did you want to introduce that matter as mayor? Thank you very much. The request and I'll be brief was to honor and remember two prominent members of our community, russ collee and dorothy jolli verner. I think most of us knew russ and julie. They were both involved in a whole panoply of issues in pasadena from all saints church and the search for new rector when rodriguez retired to pasadena community foundation, jolli earner was known well for her if I recall correctly thirty year tenure as the head of the lower school polytechnic school and very, very prominent in pasadena and she passed away within the last month or six weeks after a very, very long and well lived lives. So I would ask my colleagues to honor them and remember them this evening. Thank you. I think your request for dorothy jolli turner to adjourn in memory of dorothy jollier and russell huli are very well taken and the council will adjourn in memory of both at the end of this meeting. Thank you mayor. So the next is items not on the I'm sorry consent calendar and there has been a request to pull on the part of MR. Kennedy item three that item. Yes. And so that matter will be consistent with our new practice will be heard at the end of the council meeting with a brief presentation. Is there a motion on well or we need to have people coming? We do have public common speakers on items four and 10. So let's take a public comment. Ok, sarah brewer boehland followed by michael williams, followed by britney pollet and in are speaking on consent calendar items and you'll have a minute and a half for the calendar comments spolar MISS Bohlen can you hear me? Yes we can go ahead one minute 30 seconds. go ahead. The community is not asking for increased police surveillance if you would listen the community is asking for justice for anthony mcclaine and kendrick mcdade it's eighty six million dollars last year out of the two hundred fifty four million dollar budget isn't enough. Why would we want more money to go to police surveillance? We do not. Thank you. That was for item four. I believe britney holga speaking on item four in 10 followed by camille lewis who seems to not be checked in followed by krynica. Hello. Can you hear me? Yes. So you're calling to speak items for inten go ahead. Thank you. I just want to know how on earth again you all can justify giving more money and support to surveillance and things that police are community members out of the city budget. This is almost half a million dollars that you want to spend controlling the community. Four hundred and seventy three thousand that would be going to use development programs, jobs programs, food assistance, rent assistance. I mean I could go on and on and on and on and on. Budgets are a choice and this is an absolutely terrible choice. This is a terrible decision. Again, I got cut off last time. You all decide to give 80 six million dollars over that almost eighty seven dollars million of the city's two hundred and fifty four dollars billion budget. That means over one dollar out of every three dollars that the city spends public money. This is the citizen's money. People should be one out of every three dollars you give to the police. How can you justify that this is your job and you give over thirty four percent of the city's money to the police departments? How do you do that? How do you justify that and this community police oversight commission what what was it invented to do hold police accountable? What is it even doing? What is the purpose of it if you can't simply fire the officers who have murdered people, you have literally murderers who are being paid by the public purse the public MISS Paula calumnies expired and you can't even fire them. You're under move on to michael wilayat and then camille lewis is not checked in. So then we'll go to krynica michael no michael williams. We can go to carina carina go ahead. You have women. Thirty seconds. Go ahead. You're speaking on items four in ten. Go ahead. I would have preferred to have a minute and thirty seconds for each item on the agenda but that's ok. My name kreenholm of pasadena, resident member of black lives matter los angeles regarding item number four, why are you putting over 400000 dollars worth of security cameras in areas that are predominantly black and brown and poor? Why are you doing that so that you can send the pasadena police department over to black and brown and poor people and continue to criminalize them to kill them? Why are you doing that? Why aren't you stirring up that number of security cameras in other neighborhoods? Obviously if you do that in those neighborhoods like you're doing is shotspotter, that's where you're going to find, you know, behavior that you deem is criminal sleeping for example being unhealth for example, you're full of. You shouldn't be doing that regarding item number ten in the wake of the towards floyd protests, the pasadena community demanded the building oversight and all of you lawyers appear in city council to explicitly created the civilian oversight commission to have no power whatsoever. It's a book club. Ok, we demanded oversight of the pasadena police department. There's an officer who was just pulled over by the california highway patrol drunk with a gun fled the scene of the observer of the accident and is a police officer. These are the people that you're protecting. What are you doing? We need absolute pasadena police. we need actual civilian oversight and yelling at it not intentionally made the creation of the civilian oversight commission to have no power whatsoever. So shame on you yet again. We need those officers who killed anthony mclean fired korina. Your time has expired for him and black lives matter. Thank michael williams apologies for skipping out. And then camille lewis followed by nicole king followed by alan shay michael williams, michael ,go ahead. You have one minute and 30 seconds. You're speaking on items four in 10. Go ahead. Recently there was a video released about an officer that was pulled over and drunk with a gun in his car with a minor present. That officer ran from chp and chp did not shoot him in the back. Surprise, surprise. It seems like there is some restraint. It seems like it's possible to apprehend people without shooting them in the back even though they have a gun whether or not they have a gun. MR. Williams, both four and ten. Thank you. The under arching and overarching is that in the ten years that casual day has been gone you all have prioritized and reinforcing your police department and building up your police department and no time has been spent on actually creating things that are going to keep these incidents from happening. There should be an investigation on these officers . There should be investigation. MR. Williams, if you'll stick to MS. Florentin I am on foreign tangent, sir. If you would listen and don't cut me off before I'm finished. What I'm saying there needs to be an investigation by both parties by intruding on john perez. Chief john perez, I need a big investigation on how these were handled and that should go that should be a power as the the commission in the oversight body should have stopped putting money into security cameras, stop putting money into blatantly publicity stunt. MR. Williams, your time has expired. Please. I would like my time because MR. Gordon interrupted me unnecessarily. I like 20 seconds. Ok, go ahead. Go ahead and finish ten seconds . There needs to be more done to make sure that these incidents don't happen. Stop putting money and energy and time into stuff that are just pr stunt and do real stuff to do real things that will keep people safe from your the police departments. The thing that you control you don't control anyone else in this street. You control the police departments. so do something about that. Thank you. Your time has expired. Camille lewis no. Ok, nicole king followed by ellen shafe by heavenly hues. MISS King star six ten mute. You're calling to speak on item ten. Go ahead. Yes calling in again as a family member assignee maclane we just can't believe the city brings up the police oversight commission and won't reopen a second investigation of anthony's case. It really baffles me that the city manager will not fire the police officers if it's for the people. This is just another slap in our family's face and we need to get some justice for anthony . Thank you. Alan schaefer by heavenly hughes followed by oldham denham no longer she is no longer in the meeting will go to heavenly hues mitsuse hello. Yes sir can you hear me? We can item ten go ahead. So my understanding is that the pasadena city council is the actual oversight of the police department. Fifty occurred. You are the actual oversight of the police department since your post. Did you know that a pasadena police officer had a traffic stop was pulled over? He was drunk with a weapon and he ran from the chp officers and again it shows how the city of pasadena does not hold police officers accountable. he is still he is still working the streets of pasadena when he committed a felony. Serle moody said that when you run from the cop that's a felony simply occurs when you murder a civilian. That's a felony. How is it that you are comfortable to allow felon to allow felons to allow felons to oversee and and govern the streets of pasadena? You have given them the power to execute human being black human beings in the street felons. You've allowed felons to do that. So again, cheryl moody said at the previous oas meeting that when you run from a police officer with a pasadena police officer your time has expired. It's still in me. It's that old and denham no that completes all the public comments speakers have submitted cards and are in the meeting. Ok, I mayor yes. MR. Ham. I'll be very brief. I will before I leave. I'd like to move as we as we move forward together we we are with the exception of a number three with the exception of number three that's been pulled and will be heard at the end of the meeting at the request of MR. Kennedy is so is that a motion to move the balance of the consent? Yes. And then I would like to make a comment is there a second second ok move the seconded MR. Hampton I'm sure we will go first or big pharma before before if you're going to make a comment on ok, that's fine. All right. I'm too I am I just want to mention to one of our staff and to the occasional it's it's a great opportunity for our employees to receive some better treatment released to the locker room experience etc. And creating a better workspace to thank you. And as for item number four with installation cameras going up in part that is parks those are things that the community members that live around the parks also patronize parks have been asking for and so grateful for those folks going in. I do just want to mention that, you know, I've been listening to all the public comments as it relates to our police department things that they would like to see. I'm city manager be involved in and accountability et cetera. I do want to encourage all of the public commenters to go to the intake meeting for what we should be looking at for our next city manager. I think their opinions will be well served with participating in the survey in that survey is not up mayor. Maybe on every agenda item on the at the top of every agenda, MR. Clarke, that we could put a place where somebody could put an eye or see the link where they could do this survey and also on top of our home page of the city the city U.S. News website will then as relates to, you know, kindersley data, I just want to say to the family days my prayers are still with you and your family and we do as a as a city council and as a city have to do better when it comes to our policies for the family members of anthony mcclain, there's no words I could say to explain my dismay with the lack of management of our as well facility management for our police officers accountability is key if our officers can't say that we're waiting for the va and I've already said this and I know that this to council and you guys decided to make a decision on us but at the end of the day without accountability we're going to continue to get this done and it's going to look very one sided now for the officer who was involved in dui that ran from the police. I am you know, just saying that I'm gratified that he's still alive and he wasn't shot in the back by captain claymores. I'd also like to say that accountability is key so we have officers that are involved in things that MR. Hampton we do a lot. We're straying pretty far from the agenda here and I'll just know no, we're really not we're really not we are not far from the agenda once again, accountability is key there and if there is something into that with the video that I just recently watch, I'm not sure yet on don't know exactly who the individuals are just happened to watch the video that was posted online. I would like to understand to the extent that I can understand because you know, we're always talking about how we you talk about personnel matters how or what happened in this case is this police officer still a police officer, et cetera? You know, accountability see, our officers our management needs to do the job that we hired them to do and that is to manage our employees. We are an employee that was a traffic job or any other department with a dui that ran from the police. They'd be fired. Thank you. I have to say thank MR. And because it's been raised either MAY I suggest that I might or I asked that I might make a comment on the last item you brought up about council member hampton the incident that's being spoken about that the videos are now available for occurred in 2020. The department was aware of it at the time it was reviewed by the leadership in the department and probably the city at the time and there were actions taken but that is a personnel item. I can't speak to what those actions were the case was closed. It is impossible on a personnel item to go back and open it up and decide that you can take a different action once that's decided by the leadership and implemented that resolves that and the personnel file is closed. So that's the most I can offer. But it is several years old and yes, people were aware of it and actions were taken but one of the no. One of the that I'm still on board although as myshkin i need the city attorney let the council know if there are new facts that the executive leadership or those making decisions related to personnel matter did not have at the time the decision was made if in fact they can review this drug watch what let's just let let's let's have the city attorney provide in her weekly letter what the process is. But again, this matter is not on the agenda and we're straying pretty far from I didn't bring it up. I understand. Bring it up. I understand the manager brought up the issue and said that it was final and could not be considered. My question as one council member is a very fine night question. If there are new facts that are presented in a matter, do they provide the decision makers meaning the staff of the right to reopen or reconsider a matter that's not for me to opine on? That's for the city attorney to opine on based upon the comments that have been provided by the city manager I did not bring up this. I understood that the city attorney will provide a brief response to the council in her weekly letter. Ok, so there's did we have a motion on that in the second on the consent calendar? Mischievous. I'm you broke up and I wasn't even before that was by the council member. Kennedy mentioned that they want to respond to our city manager moving forward. Our next city manager. Right. I mean it sounds like the city manager's office doesn't really get apprized any of this information. Would that be a fair assumption to make? I mean why don't I offer some of what happened to the city attorney and she can provide what's appropriate to the council in her letter why don't we do that? Ok, just moving forward something like this happens again. I hope that the city manager's office is involved in the decision because it's always there's always some sort of point back to my well our MR. Ham our management team of the police department as far as I'm concerned, it's not our police officers. It's our management and we need a reason to do a better job of managing not just in this case but in every sense of it when it comes to employee matters, we need to do a better job. MR. Hampton mayor is making a point of order. I'm completely confused about what's the case or what decision we're talking about right now, what legenda doing on this? It's not on the agenda. Let's let's look let's move on. I think MR. Hampton's made his point. Mirrorless, just really briefly since it was brought up as a city attorney would brief us provide some sort of letter if that letter could address whether any criminal charges are brought or dropped in this situation we're discussing I understand that would be a matter of public record be helpful to me. Ok, well will the city attorney will explain the process. Ok, next there's a motion and a second on the consent calendar except for item three I do want to mention related to item nine and this is the result of our virtual meetings or combination of zoom and in person as part of a trial we are going to move starting on APRIL 4th. Twenty twenty two we are going to move public comment for matters not on the agenda to the end of the meeting in order to allow the council to complete its business in a timely manner and in order to allow the public to contribute to agenda to matters that have been agenda and noticed as being heard. And so that will practice consistent with the ad hoc committee's recommendation council ad hoc committee's recommendation will start on APRIL four of twenty twenty two and a clarification. Yes, a clarification. Mm hmm. Are you saying that how we normally conduct our meeting mayor where the public is allowed to speak for a limited period of twenty minutes at the beginning of the meeting will no longer take place. They will speak at the end of the meeting in order to allow the yes in order to allow the council and to have with that is that many of the speakers MAY be parents MAY be taking care of young children and oftentimes what occurs is that someone who puts their name in at the beginning of the meeting and is not called will not wait to the end of the meeting particularly when our meetings go past ten o'clock. And so I don't see how that is good government and that's my comment on that issue. I was not apprized of what is taking place at the moment and I appreciate the fact that you let me from the point of clarification I think I think the same can be said about people who want to contribute for matters on the agenda. MR. Kennedy. And that's the point is people are being denied the opportunity to because our meetings have run so late to participate on matters that are listed on the agenda and properly noticed there are parents and there are people with kids and there are people who work on tuesday who see our agenda take the time to read the reports and are denied an opportunity to participate on matters that we are taking action on and I think that's unfair. I've heard from members of the public and so often council elections are taken without the public having had an opportunity to weigh in and that's that that weighs heavily on me as it did on the ad hoc committee who's making this recommendation and we're going to try it on a pilot basis and see how it works out with regard to also item nine virtual meetings. I also wanted to mention that we're going to show the public understand where we're rehabbing for thirty days and on APRIL 11th we will have another discussion and continue to monitor the situation. But it is our intent to return to public meetings and that determination will be made in within the next 30 days and we will notify the person leading mare I'm sorry although we are currently using in person I'm sorry I apologize in person meetings. Thank you. In person meetings start no they will not start APRIL 11th but we will monitor and hopefully have another discussion. Ok with that roll call and the consent calendar for all items except for item number three council member hampton yes. Councilor kennedy yes. Councilor madsen customer madisen yes. Councilor massouda customer massouda yes. Customer service yes. Councilor williams yes. Vice mayor wilson is absent mayor gordo yes. Moshe's approved without opposition. Ok, that brings us to the public hearing public hearing and this is item twelve and I'll ask the clerk to open the whole hearing. Thank you, mayor. This is the time and place for the public hearing on landmark designation for the property located at aido one south san rafael avenue, the city clerk's office. Actually a public hearing notice was mailed and posted on FEBRUARY 28th. twenty twenty two the city clerk's office received nineteen letters in support of the city designating the property at eight one s san rafael as a landmark and providing comments related to john van de camp's life and legacy and five letters expressing concerns with the staff recommendation or in opposition to the staff designating the property as a landmark and expressing concerns with passing heritage quote weaponized and quote historic preservation. Those letters were posted online made part of the public record and made available to the city council as well. Ok, why don't we turn it over to mr rees and his staff to go to mayor just very quickly, mayor and city council some opening remarks we feel very strongly no. One that mr van camp was an important person in the city of pasadena in the state of california and that he lived in this house when he was doing some of his productive work. I think there are some issues that are brought up this evening that are new for staff new for the city council and I think first and foremost is the fact that this is being nominated over the council excuse me over the property owners wishes. Our code does not require that the property owner approve a landmark designation and so staff's recommendation is mr johnson will share is because we believe it meets the requirements for landmark designation the city of pasadena that that the city council would landmark this this property at ada one s san rafael. Mr johnson johnson, welcome. Good evening. Mayor and council members as david indicated this is an application to designate the property theta one s san central avenue as a landmark move to the next slide please excuse me. This application was submitted by pasadena heritage and the property owners as david indicated, do object to the potential designation of their property the historic preservation commission reviewed the nomination at their hearing on OCTOBER 19th twenty twenty one and denied the application and the applicant appealed on OCTOBER twenty eight twenty twenty one by the city council also considered calling the historic preservation commission decision for review on NOVEMBER 1st of twenty twenty one and the motion to call the decision for review failed at that time . Here we see a map showing the location of the property on the southwest side of san rafael avenue between san rafael terrace and hillside terrace. It is a single family residence that was constructed in nineteen forty seven. There was no architect of record on the original permit but the original owner and builder was holmes p. Tuttle. It is in the monterey colonial revival style and here are images of the property from twenty eleven and twenty twenty two showing the property before it was rehabilitated and the current state of the property rehabilitation with most of its important features remaining intact on the facade pasadena heritage has requested to designates the property under criterion b which is for association with the life of a person who is significant in the history of the city. Some of the considerations that must be made according to our code for for those types of designations is that the person in question must be significant within a historic context such as a professional field or a specific historical period. They must then they must be demonstrated to have gained importance within their field and they're not eligible if no scholarly judgment can be made because insufficient research has occurred or insufficient passage time. A property does also have to retain integrity of its historical characteristics based on the criterion that is being that is being nominated under a again this nomination sorry this legacy and the nomination is for significance of john van de kamp who was born in nineteen thirty six and passed away in nineteen twenty seventeen who lived in the house from nineteen eighty seven until his passing in twenty seventeen john van de kamp was the thirty seventh district attorney for the county of los angeles and the twenty eighth attorney general for california. As I mentioned he moved into the house in nineteen eighty seven and then ran for democratic nominee for governor but lost to dianne feinstein and then retired from politics in nineteen ninety one and became more active in his law practice until from 1991 until his passing of the applicant in their presentation will provide some of the information that they provided to staff of vanderkam significant achievements while residing at the property and will demonstrate that this was the period when he achieved significance in in JUNE of twenty seventeen the city council renamed the la loma bridge to the john van de kamp bridge to commemorate his significant achievements. Some other considerations related to the property is that the property must be associated with the person's productive life reflecting the time period when they achieved significance and as I mentioned the applicants will go over that in their presentation to provide the additional detail that was included that resulted in staff's determination that it qualifies for designation that the property also must be compared to other related properties associated with that person. And our records indicate that van de kamp also lived at four eighty nine prospect terrace prior to nineteen eighty seven . However that property has been altered and is not related to the time period when van de kamp achieved significance. In addition, generally the property is only considered for eligibility if it is achieved significance a minimum of fifty fifty years ago unless it is of exceptional importance and the applicant again has provided information demonstrates the exceptional significance of van de kamp to the city's history. A substantial recommendation is that although the owner objects to the designation of the property as a landmark, their consent is not required for local landmark designation and that the council affirmatively make the findings of the staff report and staff recommends the council approve the designation of the structure as a loan that concludes that presentation. Be happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Next we'll turn to council members for question. Any member of the council will have questions. MISS Williams, I have two questions. Thank you for the present station. Could you clarify the the fifty year thing? I'm trying to understand what apc's decision was with the five years and the is that a requirement that it has to be more than five years the person has been deceased or I'm just trying to understand why they made that determination and there is the city's code doesn't have any definitive requirement for a fifty year rule or any specific amount of time that needs to have passed . There is guidance from the national park service that we are required to consider and that's where that fifty year socotra comes into play. So I think the hpc and their determination they felt that because there hasn't been sufficient amount of time since then they can't passed away that there wasn't sufficient evidence to determine that he had that exceptional significance for less than fifty years. That's part of that national park guidance. So it's not a structure that has to have significance for fifty years. It's the individual that it's being correct because in this case it's significant for its relationship to the the significant person who lived in the house from nineteen eighty seven to twenty seven as opposed to an event. Correct and not not related to the year the house was built. And then the second question is can you clarify who the owners of the property and maybe we'll be hearing from them later. But my understanding is there was one owner when this initially came up and there's a difference now. So I just want to clarify the ownership and I the the property owners representative ,MR. Mcdonald will be able to speak to the current ownership is we did a little bit of deep dove and you're correct the ownership has changed. It is currently under an llc and there are new tenants that are either living or proposed to live there besides the original folks MR. MRS. Deborah and rodney deborah rocklin ross and rodney ross and I think that mr mcdonald will to clarify further who his clients are. That's it. Thank you. Questions MR. MR. Thank you mayor and david, last time that this was at the council I really gave a lot of weight because in the end and this concern that the owners of the property was against the landmark designation. So here's my question now there has been a change you said in ownership or the designation of the ownership. What are the negative reasons a landmark designation does for an owner that doesn't want it to think that we wouldn't categorize them as negative? There are additional restrictions that are placed on properties that are landmark that are designate those landmarks that require review for alterations that have been done. And you're correct and you might recall that this this property was before the city council in regards to an ftp hillside development permit request. The property in the last two years has undergone extensive renovations in the interior major structural upgrades as well as the construction of an aidoo in the backyard and some other renovations to the front facade. So further requests by the current property owner or future property owners. If the council were to landmark it would require a certificate of appropriateness if it was a major project just to ensure that the alterations were done consistent with the secretary of the interior standards that would really be the effect in addition, this property owner could apply for a mills' act tax relief from their property taxes if the property is landmarked. Thank you very much david. Thank you. I just want to clear I just want to make sure I'm understanding the facts correctly. So when this issue surface there was a different owner and so the current owner would have been under difficulty. Yeah. So is it correct to state that when this matter initially surfaced there was a different owner so the current owner had noticed that they were buying a property that could potentially be landmarked by the city? Is that correct? That's our understanding of the timeline, mayor. Ok, that's certainly an important point to to raise and for us to consider any other questions or comments before we move on to the appellants argument I would just have one question I think about are there any binding or any additional information that you're providing tonight MR. A's to support staff decision that is different from the last time this came to council? Yes, this is the first time the issue of landmark designation has been in front of city council council member kennedy the first time we were here and again you might recall the city council ultimately denied the request of the property owner for the fdp that that was not an issue of historic designation. So this is in fact the first time this item is before you. And so all the information is new of this is it would be considered a totally different action for consideration by the council. Is that what you're explaining to me? Yes. Council member in the staff presentation I think it will possibly be salome and or andrew probably be easier for me. He had mentioned that staff looked at property were john van de kamp was a resident on prospect terrace. Did I did I hear that correctly? MR. Kevin johnson is the principal planner for design historic preservation. Andrew selimi works for pasadena heritage. But you are absolutely correct you're absolutely correct that MR. Johnson identified a different residence where MR. Van de camp resided at 487 prospect ok, did staff also look at the significance of six nine one la loma road in its consideration? No council member that is not part of the analysis in terms of the presentation that was made that reference the council action of naming the la loma bridge, the john van de kamp bridge what was the basis for naming that bridge to john van de kamp bridge? to our understanding that was a memorial designation that was granted by the city council. The city council decided to do that. There were no specific findings or standards or or any other analysis that was done. It was really just to recognize the individual and to to memorialize the bridge in his name as he grew up in that area . I think that that's one take on it. But if that were accurate we could also have named the colorado bridge the john van de kamp bridge. The reality is that we named the la loma bridge I think unanimous lee of the john van de kamp bridge because john van de kamp grew up in part in terms of the younger years at six nine one la loma and that gave the focus for that particular bridge is renaming so it puts me as one councilor in a quandary at least a little bit looking at that historic nature of the house at six nine one la loma and then looking at the house at eight one s san rafael given the fact that preservation historic commission for historic preservation commission unanimously agreed that it was not of we did not fit within the parameters of naming such as historic. So at least for one council member this is somewhat problematic and is it unusual that staff would basically contravene a unanimous decision or recommended nation as it relates to designation by the historical preservation commission? I would if I could just like to add on to my previous statement that we didn't study 691 and I think it's really important that this be in the record. It is clarified I believe in the staff report the the criteria for designation has to do with obviously where somebody lived but also when they achieve their significance and growing up in a house that is not when MR. Van de kamp achieved significant so it was identified we understood that that address but it wasn't something that was analyzed because that's not where he achieved significance. We don't find ourselves in this position very often if ever where we are completely at odds with historic preservation commission, we certainly are at odds in terms of ordinances and certain elements of ordinances with respect to a designation council member, I do not know if we've been in a position where they have voted unanimously one way and staff is recommending another. Our recommendation is really based on the facts that are really relevant to this case and not opcs a decision? Well it's p c thing to have felt extremely strongly about their view about this particular property. I have serious reservations that it meets the qualification for the contemplated designation. I'd say that as one who championed john van de kamp legacy was very instrumental in his campaign, gave major fundraising for him when he ran for governor. I believe that he and andrea are friends and particularly john was a big supporter of mine as I was a kid but I'm not sure john van de camp would be as a lawyer in agreement with the staff's recommendation in this instance and I want to applaud my colleagues for their previous actions by naming the la loma bridge after an extraordinary california in pasadena munmorah named john van de kamp. Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you. Any other questions from the council before we turn to the appellant's applicants sometime ? Ok, let's turn to the applicant so we're going to turn on the cameras for sue mossman and andrew selimi and the applicant propellent in this case will be given seven to ten minutes to make a presentation. They have a powerpoint and then the city council will have an opportunity after their presentation to ask any questions and then we will turn to the homeowner after that. Mark, you're coming in and out. Oh, sorry. I should I repeat that the applicant pellant will have a seven or ten minute presentation followed by counsel questions and then we'll turn to the homeowners. We will bring up the powerpoint for I believe andrew will be making the presentation unless suhas wants to start. I would like to start please go ahead and mossman I'll start the clock. Go ahead, mayor and city council members and in response to council member kennedy's question, it is pasadena heritage that brought this nomination forward to you understand it clearly and disagree sadly but significantly with the decision of the death recommendation to the hpc the same as its recommendation to you that this property and the residence of john decamp for thirty years during the most productive time of his life and career as a public figure is the place that we suggest should be marked as a landmark in the city of pasadena have because of john's prominence his many accomplishments and his extraordinary career. He was also a champion of pasadena and after his time as attorney general he went on to do so many more things while living and up and working here at this residence. So I just want to suggest that heritage bringing this nomination forward to new because we believe under criterions be the this house is the place of significance in john's career. We're asking you tonight to support landmarking up this property we're sorry that the ether current or previous owner now a bit confused did not support the nomination. But we bring it forward to you to mark this place as a significant part of pasadena history because of john's extraordinary life and career. I would like to call on my colleague andrew sullivan who prepared the nomination to just walk you through some of john's many accomplishments while living at of one. So let me hand off andrew to walk us through the presentation and andrew mark andrew as we yeah. As we bring it up, I just want to let you know when you want to advance the slide just say next slide you have four minutes. Forty five seconds left with another three minutes additional for this time period. So the seven to ten minutes so go ahead. Ok, next slide please. So the basic needs of this nomination criterion be we believe that john van de kamp is a truly extraordinary person and andrew van de kamp also achieved remarkable thing the house of the nineteen forty seven months colonial built by home he taught all but the importance of this nomination is not with the architecture itself. It's what john accomplished while living in this house and beloveds basic set of his contributions to society that will try to cover in this presentation next slide. So the vanderkam family actually comes from a food empire his uncle started a potato chip company originally in downtown L.A. They branched into center and which is turning 100 this year. The van de kamp bakery building louris the prime rib and this was something that john really grounded john early on. He worked his first job as a host and flower flower the prime rib in beverly hills and until twenty seventeen he served as the restaurant's CHAIRMAN And board of directors. So just keep in mind he comes from a middle class family, kind of hit it big and really did find success through this food empire. Next slide, he was born in altadena and actually is his uncle had started the restaurant but eventually his dad did invest and they found some success and he moved to pasadena from altadena. He graduated from your high school. But when he was here as a child he purchased it in what was called the trail find a school for boys in altadena. He traveled all over the country visiting national parks and he really learned his love for the outdoors living in pasadena and altadena and as many of you who know him, he was passionate about this the arroyo, the mountains until his passing in nineteen fifty two he was accepted into dartmouth college, 16 years old. Fifty nine in nineteen fifty nine he received his jd from stanford only twenty three years old and then briefly went into the national for six months. Next slide from there he had a long list of accomplishments where he just every few years moved up. He was assistant U.S. Attorney followed by the U.S. Attorney and while there he was the director of executive office for U.S. Attorneys in nineteen sixty nine for those early years he was based in dc but in 1969 he returned to pasadena to run for congress but was defeated. He was a staff director for jesse monroe's gubernatorial campaign who was defeated by ronald reagan. And this is a theme you'll see quite often it was a much more republican time in california and it's kind of unimaginable now. But he had some really tough campaigns from 1971 to 1975. This has been a very important role. He was the first federal public defender of L.A. He was appointed by the ninth circuit court of appeals to represent defendants who could not afford the legal fees and many of you know if you are low income or working class a lot of times you're buried by the law and you can't afford legal representation. It was john van de kamp who represented working people for the first time as first federal public defender from 75 to 81. He was thirty seven boss angeles county district attorney. He focused on gang sexual assault, domestic violence, child abuse, career criminals, an officer involved shooting and he also established people to help establish programs to help victims and witnesses of crime. He was very focused on the people who have the least resources and fighting for working class and an underrepresented angelina's sex life. Andrew, I'm just glad you know you have three minutes and one second left of the ten minutes that you were allotted. So you'll have to complete this in the next three minutes just wanted you to know I'm moving on. Go on. As a state attorney general, this is when he coincided coincidentally lived in the house. He moved into the house in 1987 and the peak of his career and some of the contributions during this time included sponsoring the trial court salary reduction act. He sponsored the california aids drug testing program. He opposed supermarket and utility mergers and he sued L.A. And orange county companies for violating 65. So he was very focused on consumer protection, environmental rights and also criminal justice. And then in nineteen eighty nine which was probably the one of the highest points of his career and is mentioned in every single article at the time of his death was the nineteen eighty nine cleveland elementary school shooting in stockton created what is reverdy ruths assault weapons control act of nineteen eighty nine which was california's first assault weapons ban and it's still being litigated to this day don vanderkam worked as the attorney general and went to the state capital with an ak 47 to show what was allowed at the time he made front page of the new york times and it's just a testament of his legacy. Next slide. one thing I want to talk about because I'm running low on time is we talk to andrea vanderkam. There's been some confusion of whether he lived in washington, D.C. Or whether he lived in sacramento. But as he chose an office in downtown L.A. And he also had an office within eight on snl. So he was here, you know, most days of the week when he had to go to sacramento. He went on on weekends a couple of weeks a year when he was here during his attorney generalship. Next slide and then continuing after after he left the attorney general he served in private practice of dewey dewey in the book and mayor brown he was the PRESIDENT Of the state bar bar association from 2004 to 2005. He found a role as an independent trustworthy figure so from 2005 and 2006 he was the independent monitor for the j. Paul getty trust really turn them around from 2011 to 2016 he was an independent reform monitor for the city of vernon and really oversaw good governance. And then in 2015 fifteen two years before his death he was advocating for civil rights probe of orange county against the district attorney's office and the sheriff's department. And next slide I don't have much more time but MR. Salemi in your time actually has expired just now. Ok, ok. Thank you. T

Untitled 1

http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readstep2.html

THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING FOR MARCH 21, 2022 AT 4:30 P.M. WILL TAKE PLACE SOLELY BY VIDEOCONFERENCE/TELECONFERENCE.

City Council Meeting Policy:

www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/wp-content/uploads/sites/21/City-Council-Meeting-Policy.pdf

In order to facilitate public participation at meetings held solely by electronic means, the City will accept public comment in the following manner:

1. During the meeting, members of the public may provide live public comment by submitting a speaker card prior to the start of public comment on that item, at the following webpage:

www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/public-comment

If a public comment speaker wishes to speak on more than one agenda item, please indicate so on the online form (multiple item speakers will be handled according to the process posted on the agenda and as specified in the City Council meeting policy). Public comments are limited to 3 minutes each, and the Mayor and City Council may limit this time if reasonable under the circumstances.

2. Speaker Card Help Line : If a public comment speaker needs assistance in completing a speaker card, please call the City Clerk’s Office at: (626) 744-4124. Help line will open 30 minutes prior to the posted start time of the meeting.

After submitting a public speaker card, join the virtual meeting after the published start time with a computer, other electronic device, or by telephone. The same name or telephone number on the Speaker Card should be used for the virtual meeting in order to locate and unmute the speaker. Your phone call to the City Council meeting will be recorded as part of the City Council meeting. By staying on the line and making public comment during the City Council meeting, you are agreeing to have your phone call recorded.

Computer or electronic devices, join the meeting at:

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/161482446

Telephone only dial-in: 1-669-900-6833, Meeting ID: 161 482 446

3. Members of the public may submit correspondence of any length prior to the start of the meeting, at the following email address:

correspondence@cityofpasadena.net

Correspondence will be forwarded to the City Council prior to the start of the meeting, posted online, and made part of the legislative record for the item.

LIVESTREAM WITH CAPTIONING IS AVAILABLE AT

WWW.PASADENAMEDIA.ORG ,

AND ALSO AT

WWW.CITYOFPASADENA.NET/COMMISSIONS/AGENDAS ,

TO HEAR A LIVE SPANISH TRANSLATION OF THE MEETING (LISTEN ONLY), PLEASE DIAL-IN 10 MINUTES PRIOR TO THE MEETING (4:20 P.M.):

TOLL-FREE DIAL-IN: (888) 585-9008

PARTICIPANT PASSCODE: 739-142-091, THEN #

IF YOU NEED A REASONABLE MODIFICATION OR ACCOMMODATION PURSUANT TO THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT

BECAUSE YOU ARE UNABLE TO PARTICIPATE ELECTRONICALLY AS SET FORTH ABOVE, CONTACT THE CITY CLERK’S OFFICE

AS SOON AS POSSIBLE AT (626) 744-4124 OR

CITYCLERK@CITYOFPASADENA.NET .

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

LA REUNIÓN DEL CONSEJO MUNICIPAL DEL 21 DE MARZO DE 2022 A LAS

4:30 P.M. TENDRÁ LUGAR ÚNICAMENTE POR VIDEOCONFERENCIA/TELECONFERENCIA.

City Council Meeting Policy:

www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/wp-content/uploads/sites/21/City-Council-Meeting-Policy.pdf

Para facilitar la participación del público en reuniones realizadas únicamente por medios electrónicos, la Ciudad aceptará comentarios del público de la siguiente manera:

1. Durante la reunión, los miembros del público pueden hacer comentarios públicos en vivo presentando una tarjeta de oratoria antes del inicio del comentario sobre el artículo que se está tratando

en el siguiente sitio web:

www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/public-comment

Si un orador de comentario público desea hablar sobre más de un artículo del orden del día, le solicitamos que lo indique en el formulario en línea (los oradores sobre artículos múltiples se manejarán según

el proceso publicado en la agenda y lo especificado en la política sobre las reuniones el Consejo Municipal). Los comentarios públicos se limitan a 3 minutos cada uno y el Alcalde y el Consejo Municipal

pueden limitar este tiempo si lo consideran razonable para las circunstancias.

Showing the first 24,000 of 136,205 characters. The full document is at the source.

good evening everyone. Welcome to the MARCH 21st 2022 meeting of the past and the city council. I apologize on behalf of the council we're late getting into public session. We had a heavy closed session agenda which we were not able to complete and so the council will at the end of the public meeting return to close session in order to complete its closing agenda. Let's start with the roll call council member hampton blessed to be here caspari kennedy here customer madison just informed me he's on his way trying to log in but is not here yet. COUNCILMAN Asuda here customer service here, COUNCILMAN Williams here, vice well wilson is absent. Mayor gordo here. There's a quorum of the council present. Ok, MR. Williams, if you'll lead us in the pledge of allegiance again thank you. Uh, the united states of america and the republic for which it stands one nation under GOD liberty justice for all. We do have one ceremonial matter at the request of MR. Madison but we'll allow MR. Madison to join the meeting or handle next week. With that we have public comments for matters not on the agenda. I would like to point out that we have a few public hearings and so we'll try and give everyone an opportunity that we can within the first twenty minutes otherwise will your card will be called at the end of me and with that we will call CHAIRMAN Jane ward by michael williams file by jasmyn richards abduallah and it's a minute and a half for speaking . I will ring a bell to let the speakers know when they have thirty seconds. MISS Ward, go ahead first. Thank you for taking a break from your special meeting strategy to suppress public comment. My name is jane and I'm one of the lead organizers for the altadena pasadena chapter of showing up for racial justice or third word chapter of third national which has over a hundred other chapters and affiliates across forty seven states in the us. What does surge do we educate and mobilize white people in our community to enter their support for racism and police violence and this includes ending support for local politicians like the ones on pasadena city council who care more about police departments and police associations than their own constituents demands for police accountability surge members from around the country are working to help move resources away from racist policing and into the communities that need them. We've helped to secure victories in louisville, atlanta, cleveland, buffalo, los angeles and dozens of other cities. If you are listening and are a resident or a city staff person, a journalist or anyone else who'd like to be part of this growing movement to end the racist corruption in the city of pasadena and to demand justice for anthony mclean, we would love to have you you can find us by locating our chapter on the search website search dot org. So thank you to the city for this platform which allows us to share information with the community while council members stare vacantly instant in their racist dupas seat at the next meeting michael williams followed by richard jasmyn richards abdullah MR. Williams women thirty seconds go ahead. This thursday will be the 10th anniversary for the murder of kendrick mcdade. Some of you were not on the council when kendrick was killed. Some of you were. But in the ten years there hasn't been any significant changes to the pasadena police policy and procedures to prevent something like kendrick meek from happening. And sure enough, eight years into after his death we had another shooting of a man running in the police in the back same way kendrick was killed. It should be a monumental failure for you all. You guys should feel embarrassed that this is what you have let your city come to that you sat here and promise community members, his mother and others that you would do things to make sure that these things did not happen here in pasadena and yet they continue to happen even though it's been ten years, his family still feels the pain hasn't gone away and it hasn't gotten any easier for them and that's why we call in every week demanding justice for not only him but anthony mcclain and others because we're going to bring the pain that these families feel to you every single week until you do something until you finally do something that is going to make sure that this did not happen again. Michael, you're going to be sick. MR. Williams, your time has expired and having the same conversations with the same basis fire the jasmine richards abduallah followed by adriana batista followed by brittany pawlak. You jasmine you just muted there you go. One minute. Thirty seconds please. Go ahead. I'm actually calling I'm calling to demand that I actually open up three hall chambers. I'm the city has done it. We will I know why we haven't because it's easier for you guys not to pay attention and also take mcdade's. My dad was killed by officer matthew byrd and jeffrey newlon ,two officers who are still on duty still patrol the same area. I actually ran into both of them together but they were burstow and I see that to see a PRESIDENT Don't care about me they in the office of independent review report hinge that was done. It's murder. There's 56 recommendations that henry djanogly had experts recommended to pasadena police department they put in nine ok, they they changed no policy of these officers were found out of policy. So I don't know why they're not fired and I don't know why they haven't been prosecuted. So I just want to say a and yeah I'm really just sick and tired of this period because we're going through the circle of police oversight commission that can't do anything you guys are you keep having this circle of life going on but in a minute we're going to target with MISS Abduallah your time has expired to do something about this man to continue right now. Well, we're asking you guys of adriana batista followed by britney followed by looks like carolyn maloney but maybe not checked into the meeting yet. MISS Battista women thirty seconds please. Matthew griffin and jeffrey nolan are not only on the police force but they still get scheduled to work on duty together and they still get invited to retirement parties. For example, lieutenant burgess's retirement party at el cerrito in pasadena this weekend, they were both invited and nobody in has an issue with it. So pbt is full of bad cop and bad representatives that none of you are willing to make sure they get disciplined or fired. This is madness and sickening. Kendrick mcdade was killed ten years ago to this thursday and on thursday you're you're having a meeting about the city manager. Well, we need a city manager who's actually going to hold murderous city employees accountable and kendrick mcdade had just transferred the pcc as a student also the oira report the independent auditor on the case. Their report on our website remain still redacted to this day. His mother and jasmine richard adua fought hard to demand that the report be completely unredacted and completely transparent. But to say your time is expired the report remains the redacted justice for kendrick mcdade. Thank you brittany for by carolyn maloney followed by julie martinez. Neither one has checked in so we could go to cab a night in the any MISS Pollack, go ahead. Yes we can one minute thirty seconds. Go ahead. I'm calling in the names of kendrick meek, david and anthony mcclain to demand justice and accountability for their brutal killings by the pasadena police department. As speakers have already mentioned, kendrick was murdered when he was 19 years old almost ten years ago. That's a teenager. he was a kid ten years later, community still demanding that y'all do something about these murders and ppd and still you sit there most of you with your cameras off literally almost all of you doing GOD knows what at home but doing absolutely nothing to hold the police accountable. Why are you all still meeting virtually where are you turning your cameras on this is your job literally. Where are you? This is public comment. Mass mandates are being lifted in schools and public places. Y'all are cowards. Shame on you show up to the community maybe if this council would have taken the death of a black community member seriously ten years to go and fought for accountability for kendrick we could have saved anthony mclean from his murders in AUGUST of twenty twenty. You not doing anything continues to push this to the side and actually is going to get people killed. Police in this country kill on average three people every single day. This is back in twenty twenty one police murdered a thousand fifty five people and that number is absolutely undercounted. Pasadena pd is a part of this and you all decided to give them eighty six dollars million of the budget last year. Hilarious. But thirty million dollars less than the fire department gets. How can you justify this the total budget for pasadena is MISS Pollack, your time has expired that you made your choice always a choice and you gave that money to murderers over carolyn galani. No, not carolyn sixty. No. Ok, julie martinez no. All right. Cabaye nyoni followed by cryonic covais you have one minute and thirty seconds. Go ahead. Got it. I'm calling to start with I just I think it's about time to open the doors. It's about time that you guys need to confront the public who has been waiting to see you guys and ask you guys to do your job if adaiah, your old man go to work every morning to clean up our street. You guys we don't give a if madison doesn't feel safe to come to the public if everyone go to work, come to work. We were looking forward to meet you ten years ago kenneth mcveigh diked jeffrey miller, jeffrey miller and matthew griffin. These killer cops cops who killed innocent 19 year old walking around this street in the same place that they cause all these traumas and you clowns you sit down and allow someone like steve marmol not to do his job for 17 months after a killing of anthony mclain you that was your job. You selected you elected steve merrymount. It was your job to put him on the it was your job to do your job. It was your job to fire him and not letting him to get more money if know you didn't you didn't. And steve and anthony mclain's name it will be you all be remembered as part of that. It's time to bring justice to pasadena. Either you bring it or we will bring it. We go every single few guys we know our right this is a threat considers a threat to all of your careers. We will you're not going to get elected. You're not going to get our money our tax money to go against the community and we're policeman nyoni all of your time has expired k followed by heavenly hues. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. One minute thirty seconds. Go ahead. Thank you. My name corrine on been resident and a member of black lives matter los angeles and I'm echoing all the other calls who have called in about your ridiculousness having a community wait for an hour to open up this public meeting not being held accountable to the public who you are supposed to serve kendrick meek dade was murdered ten years ago this week, ten years ago this week and your pasadena police department is no less white supremacists, no less rabid, no less racist and you will have taken part in that your city attorney's office you the results all of you elected officials play a part in the systemic and institutionalized racism and white supremacy and violence that happens in the city of pasadena. kendrick mcdade was murdered and you have allowed another police murder to happen in anthony mclean and that is on you will and you are set up I've said it before you're set up to have another death over and over and over again and there'll be a lack of accountability. We need the officers who killed anthony mcclain fired ok? We need edwyn do mclinden fired ronald's right. Not like those other officers that are still on the force that murdered kendrick fire. That is accountability. What you all are doing here is not accountability and it's for sure not public service bigger your lives out black lives matter. You should be ashamed of yourself. Ten years now and over two years and you still haven't disciplined those officers who murdered anthony mclean cleans up your public safety, not municipal. I say the same stuff y'all are the crime. You're only the screen. Your time is expired blood and we'll call heavenly hues by alan shay mitsuse hello. Can you hear me? We can one minute thirty seconds go ahead. Say his name anthony mcclain say his name anthony mcclain. We've been saying his name for over a year and still to this day we do not see any accountability by the officers who murdered anthony mcclain. Cynthia kurtz, this message is for you. We've in talking to the city council and they do nothing nothing has happened. I am asking you, cynthia herb and cheryl moody, if you can hear me, please review the case reopen and review the case of anthony mcwane. You have the power the community also gives you the power and says this is what we want. We want the murderers of anthony mcclain fired my name is have me killed. I am the co-founder of my prize my five rights focus on police accountability. We're asking those that are in the community here in our voices if you are concerned about the police violence, please contact you can contact my side bryza or or sign up for racial justice. We need the city council to know that over 50 percent of the community is higher up there now. No accountability within passing the police department within the city council and also cynthia, acourt, we're looking for you as the city manager to also please do your job. Thank you. Allen shay allen. One minute. Thirty seconds. Go ahead. Thank you. Good afternoon, honorable MR. Gordon. City council members, I'm calling to just remind you that the ninth circuit court has indicated that a city manager has the power to fire the officers and allow them to exercise their due process rights through the legal system . The city manager has the authority the community has spoken the the video is clear. It's very clear anthony mcclain had no gun shot in the back twice a gun brought into the crime scene by pasadena police and pasadena police have manipulated and created a narrative that you the city is standing by which makes no sense. You have the ninth circuit court on your side. You have the community voice indicating what needs to take place. Please do not continue to send our city through this madness and fire those officers. And cynthia kurtz, please show leadership in your role as city manager. Thank you. That completes the public comments speakers that have submitted cards for matters not on the agenda. Thank you, MR. Clark. MR. Madison, you made a request to adjourn tonight's meeting in memory of russell collier. Did you want to introduce that matter as mayor? Thank you very much. The request and I'll be brief was to honor and remember two prominent members of our community, russ collee and dorothy jolli verner. I think most of us knew russ and julie. They were both involved in a whole panoply of issues in pasadena from all saints church and the search for new rector when rodriguez retired to pasadena community foundation, jolli earner was known well for her if I recall correctly thirty year tenure as the head of the lower school polytechnic school and very, very prominent in pasadena and she passed away within the last month or six weeks after a very, very long and well lived lives. So I would ask my colleagues to honor them and remember them this evening. Thank you. I think your request for dorothy jolli turner to adjourn in memory of dorothy jollier and russell huli are very well taken and the council will adjourn in memory of both at the end of this meeting. Thank you mayor. So the next is items not on the I'm sorry consent calendar and there has been a request to pull on the part of MR. Kennedy item three that item. Yes. And so that matter will be consistent with our new practice will be heard at the end of the council meeting with a brief presentation. Is there a motion on well or we need to have people coming? We do have public common speakers on items four and 10. So let's take a public comment. Ok, sarah brewer boehland followed by michael williams, followed by britney pollet and in are speaking on consent calendar items and you'll have a minute and a half for the calendar comments spolar MISS Bohlen can you hear me? Yes we can go ahead one minute 30 seconds. go ahead. The community is not asking for increased police surveillance if you would listen the community is asking for justice for anthony mcclaine and kendrick mcdade it's eighty six million dollars last year out of the two hundred fifty four million dollar budget isn't enough. Why would we want more money to go to police surveillance? We do not. Thank you. That was for item four. I believe britney holga speaking on item four in 10 followed by camille lewis who seems to not be checked in followed by krynica. Hello. Can you hear me? Yes. So you're calling to speak items for inten go ahead. Thank you. I just want to know how on earth again you all can justify giving more money and support to surveillance and things that police are community members out of the city budget. This is almost half a million dollars that you want to spend controlling the community. Four hundred and seventy three thousand that would be going to use development programs, jobs programs, food assistance, rent assistance. I mean I could go on and on and on and on and on. Budgets are a choice and this is an absolutely terrible choice. This is a terrible decision. Again, I got cut off last time. You all decide to give 80 six million dollars over that almost eighty seven dollars million of the city's two hundred and fifty four dollars billion budget. That means over one dollar out of every three dollars that the city spends public money. This is the citizen's money. People should be one out of every three dollars you give to the police. How can you justify that this is your job and you give over thirty four percent of the city's money to the police departments? How do you do that? How do you justify that and this community police oversight commission what what was it invented to do hold police accountable? What is it even doing? What is the purpose of it if you can't simply fire the officers who have murdered people, you have literally murderers who are being paid by the public purse the public MISS Paula calumnies expired and you can't even fire them. You're under move on to michael wilayat and then camille lewis is not checked in. So then we'll go to krynica michael no michael williams. We can go to carina carina go ahead. You have women. Thirty seconds. Go ahead. You're speaking on items four in ten. Go ahead. I would have preferred to have a minute and thirty seconds for each item on the agenda but that's ok. My name kreenholm of pasadena, resident member of black lives matter los angeles regarding item number four, why are you putting over 400000 dollars worth of security cameras in areas that are predominantly black and brown and poor? Why are you doing that so that you can send the pasadena police department over to black and brown and poor people and continue to criminalize them to kill them? Why are you doing that? Why aren't you stirring up that number of security cameras in other neighborhoods? Obviously if you do that in those neighborhoods like you're doing is shotspotter, that's where you're going to find, you know, behavior that you deem is criminal sleeping for example being unhealth for example, you're full of. You shouldn't be doing that regarding item number ten in the wake of the towards floyd protests, the pasadena community demanded the building oversight and all of you lawyers appear in city council to explicitly created the civilian oversight commission to have no power whatsoever. It's a book club. Ok, we demanded oversight of the pasadena police department. There's an officer who was just pulled over by the california highway patrol drunk with a gun fled the scene of the observer of the accident and is a police officer. These are the people that you're protecting. What are you doing? We need absolute pasadena police. we need actual civilian oversight and yelling at it not intentionally made the creation of the civilian oversight commission to have no power whatsoever. So shame on you yet again. We need those officers who killed anthony mclean fired korina. Your time has expired for him and black lives matter. Thank michael williams apologies for skipping out. And then camille lewis followed by nicole king followed by alan shay michael williams, michael ,go ahead. You have one minute and 30 seconds. You're speaking on items four in 10. Go ahead. Recently there was a video released about an officer that was pulled over and drunk with a gun in his car with a minor present. That officer ran from chp and chp did not shoot him in the back. Surprise, surprise. It seems like there is some restraint. It seems like it's possible to apprehend people without shooting them in the back even though they have a gun whether or not they have a gun. MR. Williams, both four and ten. Thank you. The under arching and overarching is that in the ten years that casual day has been gone you all have prioritized and reinforcing your police department and building up your police department and no time has been spent on actually creating things that are going to keep these incidents from happening. There should be an investigation on these officers . There should be investigation. MR. Williams, if you'll stick to MS. Florentin I am on foreign tangent, sir. If you would listen and don't cut me off before I'm finished. What I'm saying there needs to be an investigation by both parties by intruding on john perez. Chief john perez, I need a big investigation on how these were handled and that should go that should be a power as the the commission in the oversight body should have stopped putting money into security cameras, stop putting money into blatantly publicity stunt. MR. Williams, your time has expired. Please. I would like my time because MR. Gordon interrupted me unnecessarily. I like 20 seconds. Ok, go ahead. Go ahead and finish ten seconds . There needs to be more done to make sure that these incidents don't happen. Stop putting money and energy and time into stuff that are just pr stunt and do real stuff to do real things that will keep people safe from your the police departments. The thing that you control you don't control anyone else in this street. You control the police departments. so do something about that. Thank you. Your time has expired. Camille lewis no. Ok, nicole king followed by ellen shafe by heavenly hues. MISS King star six ten mute. You're calling to speak on item ten. Go ahead. Yes calling in again as a family member assignee maclane we just can't believe the city brings up the police oversight commission and won't reopen a second investigation of anthony's case. It really baffles me that the city manager will not fire the police officers if it's for the people. This is just another slap in our family's face and we need to get some justice for anthony . Thank you. Alan schaefer by heavenly hughes followed by oldham denham no longer she is no longer in the meeting will go to heavenly hues mitsuse hello. Yes sir can you hear me? We can item ten go ahead. So my understanding is that the pasadena city council is the actual oversight of the police department. Fifty occurred. You are the actual oversight of the police department since your post. Did you know that a pasadena police officer had a traffic stop was pulled over? He was drunk with a weapon and he ran from the chp officers and again it shows how the city of pasadena does not hold police officers accountable. he is still he is still working the streets

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Meeting: March 21, 2022
  • City Council Meeting: March 21, 2022 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: e0a5274c4d0000d1a155bec472003fda. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record