POLISCOPE

The public record

MANATEE COUNTY SCHOOLS · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

School Board Workshop

Tuesday, July 29, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

School Board Workshop

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

School district

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 224,193 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Good morning, everybody. Welcome to JULY. 29th School Board of Manatee County Workshop when officially call this workshop to order. Agenda amendments. We did have the chairs on cause to amend the agenda to include all items listed under the amended agenda, amendments on night tonight. 25 agenda updated 7/28/2025. Posted the district website. 2 schools that net things that were updated were just some of the slides and data information for couple of our topics that will speak on today. I do just want to the posted workshop showed the high school aaa update discussion. First and then board discussion with f s b a on the superintendent search rationing flip those so we can know get case out of here. Engine Ching, go home and not have to sit here all day. As we discussed high school options look at data. So I do want to open up with the with the fsb. A first superintendent search board. And with that, I'm going to kick it over to, but we're going take us tickets away and share. Just don't. Thank you. Appreciate it. >> Thank you very much. Today, as we discussed at our last meeting, we're here for the board to make selections of the semi finalist or finalists. And with me today is DR. Debra Pace with the Florida School Boards Association and just give a little background Dr Pace. She was a very successful teacher in Osceola County. Later, principal of a very challenging high school and she led. That's cool, too. And it says has sustained its high performance since then. She then became deputy superintendent and Osceola County was recruited by Brevard County and she became deputy superintendent in Brevard County for h r and then she was selected as superintendent in Osceola County in 2016 and lead Osceola County to the highest student performance they had ever had to that date since she's been retired. She works for the Florida School Boards Association, superintendent searches and she's been through a couple of searches already very successful searches. And also she has a connection Manatee County, which I wanted you to be aware of, because she works through the University of South Florida on a grant on project Management which connects with strategic planning Kevin and Omar and other staff people from Manatee County are involved in that partnership. You'll hear from Denver today, but you'll probably hearing more about Denver in that role because I know priority the board is to look at the new strategic plan. So a team like it connects very well. So that brief introduction, I'm gonna turn things over doctor Pace. >> Thank you so much. DR. Vogel and thank you. Members of the board CHAIRMAN Choate for welcoming us here today. We appreciate the participation of your community and the staff and certainly all of you in this important process. I'm here today on behalf of our team doctor. And remember, this is Andrea Messina, our ceo and Dr Demetrius Rice as well as my GOD row. They are joining us online. I want to 6 and a special thank you as well to the members of your districts, staff who have so helpful throughout this process. Superintendent Chapman Cox your it team and as well as your district Representative, Dr Vogel. It's it's really been a true team effort and we hope that will continue. We had 16 applicants initially applicant number 9 with 3, 1, Friday. I am happy to report that all of the applicants for superintendent meet the minimum requirements established by the board in the post qualifications, a master's degree in 10 or more years of leadership. Experience applicants represent 11 states including Nevada, Indiana, Georgia, New Jersey, Texas, North Carolina, Maryland, Wisconsin and Ohio as well as 3 from Florida, including one internal candidate. In addition, 6 of the applicants have some experience in Florida either in education leadership or as a classroom teacher. 8 are either current or former superintendents and 11 holds a doctorate degree. In addition, 2 of the 16 applicants have started served in our natures nation's military. One in the U.S. Army and one in the U.S. Navy. All of the applicants have held positions of leadership at this school in her district level. And all of them do have some classroom teaching experience. We do want to thank all of our applicants for their diligence in submitting their completed applications and answering our follow-up questions. We continue to be impressed by the professionalism and experience of our applicants. And we appreciate the time and energy. You all have school board members have committed to reviewing each candidate submission in order to prepare for today's meeting. In addition, your community has been very engaged and very appreciative of the search process and their opportunity for feedback. You had 251 community responses to our online survey, which you had an opportunity now to review since yesterday. Each of you has been provided to tally sheet for your use. In. Our identification process. I will be recording each of your responses to this question. Which applicants would you like to see move forward in the selection process? I will ask each of you one by one to identify your choices by number and name and repeat your response is to ensure that we're capturing that data accurately. The CHAIRMAN Has asked that we start with district one and right around the room, which thank you. That makes it easy for We will then start our discussion with those applicants with 5 board votes potentially for than 3. And then we will ask if there's anyone else that you all would like to advocate for being included in your semifinalists group. Once the board has reached consensus on a semifinalist pool. The official formal adoption of the pool will be done at tonight's board meeting and following that meeting, we will be following up as your fsb, 18 to notify candidates individually of your decisions and advise the semifinalists of the next step in the process. Couple of reminders for the community as much as as for the board, there is no magic number of semifinalists as your advisors in the process. We do encourage you to cast a wide net at the second stage of the selection process. But that is entirely up to the will of the board. If you wish to learn more about a particular candidate, we encourage you to submit his or her name for further discussion. Once the list of semifinalists is approved by the board at tonight's meeting, we will also follow up with additional vetting of the semi finalists, including complete background checks, reference checks and for the review of professional histories and any particular questions that board members MAY have. As a reminder that this be a is a member of the nationalist delineation of Superintendent searchers and Andrea and Demetrius have access to their counterparts counterparts from other state school boards associations across the country, in fact, was Demetrius and Andrea are attending conferences this week and we'll be able to reach out to those individuals about any semifinalist from out of state. I will also share with you that your hr team has done a great review of the initial information about these candidates through the Florida professional practice, a sport as well as fl dot certification database. We will be requesting that semifinalists submit their most recent evaluations for review and the community. We'll also have another opportunity to share feedback with the board. Once the superintendent semi finalists are selected, we will open up the survey again on Thursday and it will run through AUGUST 10th so that we will have opportunity to compile that information. Get it to the board for your review before you meet not AUGUST. The 12th to discuss the finalists. Are there any questions before we begin? Anything. >> Other than order of how we go. One through 5. >> I just want to. I point of privilege to go next to last. I don't want to go second. >> I mean, I just did it because this is what the she has for us to look at this. And the reason I went down 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, I don't particularly care. Does anyone have any issue? Don't want with vice chair going? I'm not going last right now. It's MR. Tatum, right spine. So you're asking for like chair and vice chair go last. Okay. I don't particularly care. Vice CHAIRMAN Inch 2 your first. Doesn't matter to you because your first de France. That's going tell is Katie mistreated bummed about the loss that he was. So when you're not going last for you're not I'm not matter of the last. At least it All right. Thank So Europe, film district? Well, I guess it will say let me let me just add something scientists that said you can go, then I jump in front. Let me ask you Facebook from us, especially. I mean, we've been through this before with those you when U.S. Election, but every Sunday I turned 40 last year, some old now. So I don't remember exactly how it went down. So so when we when we when we give, when ms Felton gives her. Selections. Yes. Are you wanting any discussion at that point? You want to discussion when we're all done is it up to the board member as we're giving us election to do any discussion on why they're pretty picking someone or what do you mean that that's kind of varies? Everything number, right person. >> Typically at this stage of the process, we simply asked. >> Board members to go through by name and number without ration out without discussion until the end when all 5 board members have submitted their recommendations then we'll come back. >> And allow time for that discussion again, unless you tell me otherwise. Start that. With 5 people who get 5 votes, you would assume would automatically be in the pool. But that's up again to the board then for than 3. And then we'll go as far or it as minimal as the board wants. Perfect. Thank you. You're welcome. Anything else now? That's it. Alright, mis-spelled. Think and you're not 50. >> Okay. So yeah. And and I'm not the oldest all Cam ready. So lets see candidate number for Doctor Laurie Breslin k candidate number 5, David Adams candidate number 8, DR. Thomas, a heart. Candidate. Number 10, Luis Solano and candidate number 12, DR. Andrea Roberts. And those women. >> So just to repeat, to make sure that captured these accurately you have submitted number for DR. Laurie Breslin, candidate number 5, David Adams. Candidate number 8, DR. Thomas, a heart candidate. Number 10, Luis Solano and candidate number 12, DR. Andrea Roberts. Correct? Yes, ma'am. Okay. Then I think that brings these 2 MR. Kennedy, thank you. >> Number 4, doctor Laurie PRESIDENT Number 5, David Adams, number 7, DR. Misty Mathis, and number 10, Louis Salon. >> Okay. Just to repeat again, MR. Kennedy is recommending number for DR. Laurie Breslin, number 5, David Adams, number 7, DR. Misty Mathis and number 10, Lewis, Alana, Correct. Thank you, Sir. Thank you. MR. Tatum. >> Just the 2. >> Number 4 and the obd arm out the Dr Brazil is number 4 and then number. So that are Mathis. >> Okay. For the record, MISTER Tatum has submitted DR. Laurie Blessed Rez Lynn and at number 4 and DR. Misty MAY not this number 7. That's Greg. Thank you, sir. District 2. >> I have a doctor, Breslin number for man. And number 16, Dr Mendis. So number 4, doctor, Breslin and number 16, DR. Mark merge us. Yes, thank you. And CHAIRMAN Show. I have 4. 5. >> time turn American on this new >> The CHAIRMAN Cho has recommended Dr Les PRESIDENT Number 4, David Adams, number 5 and Luis Solano number 10. That correct, sir? Yes, ma'am. Sorry. No, that's okay. Thank you very much. Just a priest. I'm looking at my list in the Sutherland now. I know sometimes it can be a little bit confusing. Good. Okay. As I'm looking at my my list, I see that DR. Lloyd Breslin has been recommended by all 5 board members. MAY we move forward and adding Dr Breslin to the semifinals pool? Yes, yes, yes. Okay. I don't see anyone else with 4 candidates. We have David Adams, candidate number 5 with 3 from this is Felton, MR. Kennedy and MR. Chote what's the pleasure of the board? Comes up for I have questions on that one. Numbers he number 5 number 5. >> On a handout that was given to us. With the Rq called Arc Up Kids. I scored every candidate. And number 5, Deborah. Required is a 1, 1, And preferred is a 2 too many. I didn't see where MR. Adams had 10 years of leadership and also on the hand out how that in with a question Mark. And then no on a doctorate as a preferred. >> When was counting his leadership, MR. Spray right use 3 years as a district title 5 years as a school leader and 2 years and his position as an academic data coach. As a teacher earlier. But again, that's up to the would you say that what we on that one incident and said no. >> 10 years. Leadership has a question are from the handout that we got? >> Oh, yea, I see Yeah, I did not. When I went through my assessment in reviewing qualifications, I didn't see 10 years. I didn't use that coaching part as a leadership and 2, there's no Florida experience to their. >> He's on my right experience guest, Austin or teacher in Lee County. Yeah, yeah, that's right. And again, it's you know a child 2 right? So to me that tenure was a problem. Pick him anyway. So don't let everyone else go on. >> mean, I'm a minute. Yes, I mean, there's 3. There's 3 summit. >> Moving forward and will ask for further verification of his. Yeah. I mean, I think there's 3 of us. I mean, I think that to. >> Enough to push him to the next level, MISTER, something like crazy from either one of you. The as not know why. The night that we don't know about are not thinking about. >> So the people that come as fun was then the trouble here. The right the point that we picked I was front of you. Yeah, as a semifinalist and point now. >> These these folks will move to get that background check. APRIL 12, we come back. Finalized yet again, depending on what information we get back from that background checked. And then those. On AUGUST 12th meeting, those will then move to the final U.S. Where we actually bring him an interview. It's not. >> So I believe we have a majority of the board who are comfortable moving this person forward to sharing my final us pool of All That brings us then to candidate number 10, Luis Solano has 3 members of the board who submitted his name. Also this felt and MISTER Kennedy and CHAIRMAN Shipped. >> County Lee and 2, 3, peace tip number 7. Several get to 7 like it too. You're on threes now. They've got 3 We go first. Yeah. I have 3. This felt me know the chair that you are known. I didn't know. I Ice Tatum. One of the Tatum Tatum, a 7, 0, that's going put 7 I'm sorry you in you and MR. Tatum or 7. Yes, MR. Kennedy and MISTER Tatum submitted Dr Mathis. >> Are we comfortable moving MR. With 3 votes move forward in the semifinalist MR. Something what I'm just going for event. I'd be interested hearing the reasons 3 board members chosen. Believe right? Would like to moving forward yet. I'll give you my real quick thing being in Florida as part of the school system or excuse looking at leadership, high school. He's almost been. Everywhere, except I guess he wasn't it. Elementary, but it's background, especially in Florida. Since into social superintendent. Of learning teaching and learning. In Florida. And then moving to online, moved to Detroit headed by jackets and all that kind of stuff to what, 8 years now. >> Being? >> Part of. And looks like to me what we would maybe consider cabinets. 54,000 school, 54,000 students. I would like to. To just see more from him. >> the board is interested, the superintendent in Detroit Dr Nikolaj the dea was the superintendent in Duval before going to Detroit. And so there was some connection there. Thank you. That record. I was actually just looking that up. If I should have done this before the meeting. But if Mr, Solano, went with DR. Beattie to treat it the same time. It doesn't look like it because Dr Beattie was. Looks like 2017. And I think person wanted resume for open. Don't know if you went with Dr of eating it whenever he's working. Collier attracted DR. Beattie prior to DR. Will superintendent in Duval. He did a lot of work in school improvement for the state. He was a deputy sport. So there's probably we don't know what I want to speculate, but potential connection. Yes, that's kind of a listen, Detroit talk to be because a number when he left, it's That prior to his role as superintendent, I guess search for the state and it was around the state visiting schools in need of improvement that >> from my reasoning, extensive classroom and school experience in Florida. So I really appreciate that he gets he gets what it is to be a teacher Principle here and then, you know, again, 8 years experience with really big district. So he understands more than some of our other candidates. What it is to have a lot of schools and a lot of kids. And there's lots of moving parts. And that really is important to me. Because we are such a large district that that they have. Experience with something this pick. >> Yeah, I finish off am. This eye feel and want to say this as a concrete statement. But from what I saw on the candidates. Have very few who met all of our preferred qualifications we as you said, all of them met. A sub-minimum preferences. I forget we what we term that. But our preferred qualities MR. So long it was one of the few Detroit public schools about our same size. And it's a county schools is a. Our students are concerned is majority minority school district. Just barely. But and Detroit public certainly that's that's who I think there's. Certain strengths that will come with a school leader whose operate in that environment and learned about environment working environment. So but yeah, he says as the chair mentioned, he's came up through Florida as an educator and now as executive experience. So i thought he was one of our stronger applicants. You he's not funny was one of our strongest. Applicants. >> And I know number 16 only got one vote. And according to the handout that we were giving Like I Rq required pq preferred You have said that. He did not have 20,000 students or more. That fire was prepared by your hr team. Ok, alright, prepares what I did. Summary did a very thorough review. This right here. >> Didn't see that one appeared by your hr team. Okay. He does have. If you look under his executive Director Administration of leadership in Cherokee County, 42,000 students, right. And that's what I was going to make a point that he did actually have. Because I did. My wrist actually has 6,000 employees. I don't know if that was bearing on anybody decision, but to me, saw that and I was like, well, how could they must stop? But if you look at the paperwork. Submitted by this applicant. I don't know where I saw that. At 42,000 students. A on the final applicants summary right down the a week ago. Right? But not with it on him and I When I look at the candidates resumes, I will also look at niche dot com rice student enrollment. That's what I'm saying. The candidate did not put it on his own paperwork. And I saw that route some of these most of them don't. That's why we do the additional research on their rent and last position. But when we posted it, it was number. Prefer to have at least 20,000 or more I'm just making a point. 2 people who apply. Look at your guidelines here because some of these applicants. Did not how near experience with. That, we prefer and this and that was a lot. And it was a lot to there. So. Just observation. My safe in assuming now that moving MR. Solano forward with 3 votes is appropriate into the pool. >> I think Okay. We've heard missus spray talk about DR. Mark Merge U.S. Candidate number 16. Are there any other board members who would want to see? Dr? Just move forward. >> great that you go over. Move a little bit of the bill. You like number please? >> he's like out one is just me. So I'm not gonna try to Convince board members, but during my research, this individual was up for superintendent. I really Georgia. That was a petition. That was signed by 1700 community individuals to pick doctor merges. I guess I'm saying that right? The board with the her son. That they absolutely did not want. So I watched the news clip. The be honest, it was a news clip about the whole incident and then when I does the searching on how many students and staff members was there? It was one of those. Okay. At least he is I would move forward. >> That was in Cherokee were used. Yeah. There was. That's why he left. And now is the principal. Yes, a chart. Exactly. That's why he left. So. >> Well, thank you for the hit. Some. Florida experience that might be more inclined to write. >> I get and I knew it a long shot. But I at least wanted point that out this is to anybody that's applying for this kind of up seat. You know, when put out qualifications and the preferred are required and preferred. I really. Because to apply. For a role that only a superintendent of 2 high schools. I don't know if that's factual or not, but and some of them, some of the cases in other states. And I know this for a fact. You can be a superintendent over a few schools township. Not entire district. Or a board member. At a school, but not and they district. So you kind of have to look at what the different states, how they run their districts. A lot of them are like I said. One of them. Has 9 board members. For very few schools. And I looked to see how many schools from a high schools from the elementary. I don't remember the one I was shocked. Why they would. I have gone through our and how they would have been sent to us, you know, with that kind altercation. >> On spray, you certainly are correct. And that many districts and other parts of the country are much smaller than Florida districts. You are also correct. And that board member sometimes can be over small township, right? That has 2 schools are even some districts are 1, 1, school, right? Not all board members are paid. Some of them. That's a volunteer But, you know, it's it's it's a unique situation across the country. And Florida somewhat unique in how we operate. >> And and that's what you have to look at for some of these applicants are ca. You can say they might have 10 years of leadership. But are they over 5 schools or 50. So you kind of really have to do your on. That's what I did. I do a lot of That's what I do. I don't like that. Urban. His transcripts along took karate and tennis. You so, but, you know, when you need one more credit, you take one of those courses to get through. So gun rambling, I currently my rationale of things. >> We currently have in semifinalists pool for your consideration. Dr Lee Brez David Adams and Luis Solano. Are there any other candidates that board members wish to advocate for being included in the semifinals pool. You have one other candidate number 7 with 2 votes. Number 8 has one number 12 has one. And the number 16 has won. >> To yeah, I I'm a little torn here because coming into this, I was kind of the. Thinking that if a candidate did not receive. 3 votes to advance, they should not advanced because there's not a board majority, but I do just want to take a second to talk about Dr Mathis from Nassau County. That's one county is a very high-quality school districts. Again, for I forget many times in a row. Smaller district. She does have a leadership experience. That we were looking for. She certainly has lots of Florida. Experience. And so that's why I included her she catch the eye of any other that's okay. And frankly, I'd. I still believe that. In this process, if you don't have 3. So it's the procedure should not proceed. >> But I did think that Dr Matthews was a really strong candidate here. But if weather permits them, you can feel the same. That's >> I picked her do. And remember looking at them that some kind of looked up again. And that's the kind of school district they have about 7 17,000 or students. You know, I think 4, maybe even 5 high schools in the district. Seems like a lot for that. Looking at that. Have a number of middle schools, a number of elementary schools. It's probably about half the size of our district. But low surprised at the number high schools and She's obviously done a good job of working within that district and moving it forward has very similar qualifications to doctor Roseland as a lot of. Experience and the Florida school system. So. I would think would be really a good idea take Hear from her. Let her. Talk us a little bit more because she's leading one of the best school. She's a senior leader and one of the best school districts in Florida. >> All 14 of the schools in Nassau County are this year for 325 and I believe it's their 5th year consecutive one district one. I had a chance to look that up. I was unable to verify yesterday the al the ese data that she reported, that that is something that should the board want to move forward with semi final selection. We can certainly do that, but I'm not advocating for against just trying to provide you with some additional data. Checking from thing. Thank Much of this >> And this is relevant to me, but really appreciate the document that we got yesterday with the community input because if this is not publicly available on our website yet, I think should be. Because it's really fascinating to read the comments that we've received in general question number one in general about the search and then question number 2, an opportunity leave feedback on specific candidates. This MAY mean something it MAY not, but DR. Mathis was the It's not Mathis received 30. Of DR. Vogel, help me out. How many comments weather you want. Okay. But for that question because it says that she received 30. Comments from the public, which is 20.4% Doctor Breslin Worsley the 101 community comments which is 68.7 and I read through this entire document yesterday. Every single word of this document, both questions and every single comment on Dr Mathis is positive. Every single comment about PRESIDENT, his positive in some cases, if you simply so positive. So I I thought that was just an indicator, though. I mean, I honestly. I identified with 4. Before it received this document. So when I received the public input document was like, okay, I'm I'm generally on the same page as the community. But that really that that really jumped out to me and hope the you know, for the sake of a well-rounded search, really think we should include Dr Mathis, but they're still only 2. Supporters for tonight. I want to be consistent. Some. >> I'm not opposed to adding her to the pool. My concerns or how small the district is. So that's that's really where my concern lied, lied. Because it is such a small district. I I appreciate her experience and how well her district is doing. And and all of that is fabulous. And so don't get me wrong. I'm not discounting that at all. But I just feel like with such a small dust it's not even 20,000. With such a district, I don't know. That. And she MAY I don't know, but I should be able to rise to the challenge. So that that was my concern. I mean, if the rest of the board would like to go ahead and move her forward, you know, just to add or and I'm okay with that. But but I feel like the other 3 are are more viable candidates stronger candidate. I'm at This felt if I make I walk with you, of to your 0, one of the things that want to give me pause, but one of one of things to consider is that Nassau County demographically is very different in Manatee County. So it's a smaller districts, much different for student body. >> So and that's that's it's a just want I think what you're saying is relevant. >> Yeah, that was also another one of the and I just actually pulled it up again because I wanted to to re fresh myself because I did look, I did look at the demographics of our applicants where they worked and because we do have a much more diverse population, a lot less affluent. And we all know that affluence also impacts school. Great. So if you have schools that are far more. Diverse in terms of affluence, you're. And it's not saying it's impossible. We have obvious proof of schools that are title one schools or low economic schools with huge numbers of kids who are free and reduced lunch. Have who've done it pulled up the grains and who are doing great but it is it. It's a different kettle of that expression for that great. >> So what you might believe that because these other candidates are from out of state and that. The fact that she has the schools in the demographics MAY be different. But the 2 somewhat of an expert. In the Florida school system. Maybe that counter balances a little bit. The fact that they're actually account and I think that is kind of 16 schools and the Nassau County District. I understand that working before just to do that But the fact that shes a district a school now the superintendent, the district, is in a school district and she has a lot of experience with the Florida system and kind of hesitant to bring people from. Out of state that. No one of the candidates was in statement went out of state. But that. Isn't plugged into kind of what's going on. The state of Florida unless they had some outstanding. Qualifications like, you know, Detroit public School system was the number one school system in the state of Michigan really counterbalance the fact that they've been out of the state and upload in what's going on. They don't have the relationships, but within the state are certainly within the community. I I would just encourage us at least Dr Map is because she has a going for her other than the you know, her district is about half the size of our district. With that. I think that. Positives, if you have to balance them out, outweigh the negatives that she's from a school district about half or size, which still requires. You know, schools the gap our size that we have a 1.6 billion dollar budget, but still 800 million dollars. It what's going on in that school district actually are part of school system. One 2. >> 3, the. >> 4 schools. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17. It looks like they're 70 schools Those are my thoughts that are positives outweigh her. The fact that she's from the school district for size. I would encourage us to put on the list. Very sharply. Thank you. Thing to say or >> I'm still unknown. Okay. Sorry. She was my next one up. I wanted. >> 3 I thought I think is our number. She was my. She was my next one up. For a lot of the region's. What what? MR. Tatum you just said the Florida experience, I think as big as teacher principal and then moving up in the in the district, I do have concerns and it just is what it about. The student population. It's a completely different dynamic you know, when you move to a district that we are, I think she would be a slam dunk. Semifinalist. Probably all 5 of us. She had couple years experience as a superintendent at even her side school, like even her size district. If she was actual superintendent, I think she probably be a slam dunk. I do think there's a lot of merit to being Florida being leadership here in Florida, teaching principle some willing to put her put her in the top 4 and move forward with or someone to say yes, she was my next one on the list. I think there's a lot of merits to what she brings the concern to why she was 4th and not moved up was was because of the size, right? Like, you know, when you're dealing with everyday issues. Even as it even has a. Assistant superintendent, even the Cabinet make it's different when you're dealing with 50,000 kids, then, you know, 15, 16, whatever the district is now in Nashville. Regardless, I think. Being in that cabinet at any district, especially in Florida. It's a difficult one. And so I'm absolutely Kate with with Putin, her putting her on our our finalist. >> And moving on with or chat for. >> Okay. So what I've heard from the majority of the board now is that we would have 4 semifinalists Dr Lloyd Breslin candidate for David Adams, candidate 5 DR. Misty Mathis, candidate 7 and Alyssa Milano candidate 10 and that will come back to the board this evening for formal adoption. Just as a reminder and perhaps to maybe put your mind at ease just a little bit again, there's no magic number here and the value of putting someone forward is that it just gives us a little bit of time to find some additional information. We will certainly take back the questions that you all have raised about each of these 4 terms of the vetting that we do, it's part of our process. And also I would mind you that there's no magic number of finalists, whether we have. We prefer not one, but that we've done them with one before to 3 or 4. It just it. The only factor that changes the variable is how much time you might spend with each individual candidate. We typically like to do 90 minute full board interviews. And just as a reminder to the public, those are open to the public or able to be viewed from home. In addition the following day, you have one hour typically individual interviews with each board member and that gives you the opportunity also and the candidate, the opportunity also to bring forward additional responses to the questions that you all have raised. The doubts that you MAY have at that stage of the ball game as well as than the meet and greet that evening for your community. And again, they will be qr code so that you'll get community survey now on your semifinalists pool starting on Thursday through AUGUST, the 10th. And then during the interview process over those 3 days. Missus, Messina is going to be following up with all of you to get started on your interview. Question bank both for the full board interview. And then if you want any. Suggestions, tips, sample questions for your individual word interviews, although that really can be a conversation between the board member and the candidate. We're going to continue to provide regular updates to Dr Vogel. And if you have any questions moving forward, please don't hesitate to contact Mussina or any member of the team. When we need on the 12th to select your finalists, it will near this evening's process. Again, no magic number. The only factor is how long you want to spend with each individual candidate. And just as a reminder, the full board interviews are scheduled for AUGUST. The 18th here at the District office followed by the community meet and greet that evening at Manatee Technical College and then individual board interviews which are not open to the public are scheduled for AUGUST. The 19th. And then you'll have an opportunity to get more community feedback prior to your selection meeting on AUGUST, the 26th. I did also want to say thank you to the Manatee Education Foundation. They've been working with Dr Vogel and the team graciously provided we'll be providing meals for the applicants and their families. During the interview period. And again, we appreciate your engagement in the process and our work with Dr Vogel, a new team as we prepare for the next round. Very much. Appreciate Thank you. Thank you. Shay. See you Yeah, we'll see. Jen, thank you very Drive safe thanks for making the trek. Over and have happy to do it. Great job. And thank you to the facilities team for allowing us to go first. Yeah, no the fight. Take care. All right. As we our transitions 105. >> We're going to move next topic, which is Ice-cool aaa update. We've got a plethora of people that are going Give us some thoughts. Says they make their way. >> you read, have you read this document? That's correct. The one I mean, it's great. Is great. The one yeah. Some guys 3 d. And I can't sue. Both. >> So board, I know During I-43 things and things like that. We've obviously discuss what nation to be about. The public that. You know, we've we've started with you know, within the last 5 years with triple a high school at one level. We've obviously pared and given our board's direction here so I know MISTER Rinaldi in in his his group is has done their due What what we had and size and scale and price and things like that. So I think today is really about us discussing a lot of the future of of what this potential school site looks. Life moving forward. Obviously bring a lot information on on data enrollment. Potential role how the market looks for build homes, etc. And so for us, I think it's and all that MR. Chapman, he comes back in get his ideas and thoughts to ultimately board. Thank you. My thought process you know, for us have a discussion online on this high school. Give some kind direction on on how this goes. I'm not saying we need to have a yes, let's do it tomorrow. No, let's not. You know, mean, we don't have a a full decision on anything. There's still some time to discuss this more. This is it for the rest of the day. I when we look at topics, I thought this is going to be something that could take a little bit to discuss option to go over and look at Yeah, so I'm excited to get into this discussion on what the future looks like here in Manatee County. Is he obviously a growth? You have a great area, great schools and and people want to move here. We want to live here so with that, MISTER CHAIRMAN, I'll give it to you just to give a stuff. Quick synopsis of what you think to this discussion can be about them will jump in. Yeah. Thank you, MR. Board, chair and and and. >> And board. This. This is one I'm excited about this workshop, right? This is this is good governance at its best, right? We've got to. >> panel of. Probably some of the best, if not the best experts in the to present that and get their perspective. >> We've got incredible wealth kinds of metrics. Like you said, MISTER Chair to spend. Most of the day here talking about how to. Responsibly use taxpayer dollars and the right way to to manage the growth in this county is. Exactly what we should be doing today. And it's it's exciting. This is this is a great example of of of of government in a government doing its job. And I'm just excited about it. So I know we've got a MR. Pendley here, MISTER And all Scarborough were also have a MR. Neale here to kind of resent what he's seeing in the market. So obviously it's up to MISTER Chair. But if we wanted to maybe have MISTER Neil present first here and we'll see where that goes. And then we can figure out the rest of the afternoon. >> Yeah, great. Was in the program mission do it. According the Yeah, that's not direction. >> I will say I will say we have I want to take launch. >> roughly Glen 45 11, 50 to run. The Cohen is as are speaking. So what I wanted to be able to take much, let's say 30 minutes to 35 minutes. So I don't know where you where you thought. MR. De would fit in to the process here or even doesn't even really matter what. At what point. He discusses is or is it ok just to go with about? >> I don't think it matters He's got I have seen this slides. We actually used to the same data metrics here. But other than that, he's his presentation completely independent. And we asked him be here today because obviously he's one of the largest homebuilders and and manatee also in Sarasota. So there's so much talk about slowdown in growth, young residential growth and things like that. That thought it would be a fresh perspective from you to hear directly from border. That is one of the largest areas. So you know, go now. I think you might want to stick around to see my >> We'll go ahead read MISTER Chair. I'm absolutely yes, sir. I might say very come from the budget by a board that you'd asked me to talk with the years. >> School board about the idea of a new high school. Remember, I'm a big believer in people who want to live moving prospered in Manatee County. So MISTER Chair, I'm kind of an advocate and I want to just say that schools are very important. Part of the home building business. Traditionally and typically up to the last few years, we sold the benefits of the Sarasota County schools and we still do. But Manatee County has made huge progress. Make a note of my my presentation and there's some advocacy here because I believe in schools as as a resource for the citizens of this community have a pass out. I could you handed have that? We gave them the graphics. So all you efforts, I'm going start on number 5 just because it's so personal to me Aaron, for legislature 51 years ago, they were 93,000. People in this town. I want to see Steve's dad, those that had been a state senator. And so could count on the people who ran Manatee County on a few hands. It was a small place. You knew everybody who lived here and it was like little bird. But its changed, MR. CHAIRMAN, there's according to the Census Estimate 240 58,000 people. Now as all say with greater detail after few years after 25 years will have 717,000 people in this crazy little county of ours. And the growth is not going to slow down. According to statistics I've seen it will actually increase not in rate, but in total numbers. Here's the very short version. No standing which read about the housing recession. The housing has grown quite so much, but we still are growing as a state 872 people per day for the last 10 years. Manatee County has been always among the top 6 3 years ago. It was the top one. Currently, it might be the top 3rd fastest growing county in our state. And I do have to say we'll continue to grow because the Gulf Coast really the remaining good area of the state where people can go. They don't go to the nature coast because there's no beaches. They don't go to the Gold Coast because it's full. They don't go to space coast because it's cold, know, go to the treasure coast because it's even colder in the beaches are some This is. I'm an advocate for Manatee County, MISTER But they're going to come to Manatee County, Florida. If you go to the slide that looks like this. The people we sell homes to are different. They're not the same people that we used to sell homes too. The baby boom, people my age getting your relevant. The folks who are moving here are pictures and that some of still have kids. If you look at stripes, the people who are moving to our town are people who are younger than the people who used to retirement age is lower country and people are coming to Manatee County who buy homes for me are younger than they were 10 years ago retirement builder. We used to sell 15 to 20% of our total homes, too. Those who were not empty nesters are active adults. Can't use the word retirement. MAY companies have forbidden word during campaign. MISTER, which means you have a job or you're active adult, which means you don't have jobs. That the baby boom is over and we sell about 31% of our jewel box homes to people who our Generation Xers. They have children. Of course, a Lakewood Ranch is the number. 2, master planned community in the United States. Only one that's bigger than that is the villages, which is actually been declining as proportion. The villages. 55 plus, which is less important for schools and what we're going to talk about today. Next slide Next. Slide is might be out of picture. Us ordinance turning out. Page are you that Mr? Well, I meant no page right now, ok, if Sunday's. The important thing I want to say is for the first time in history, Manatee County now sells builds and sells more homes in Hillsborough County. Think about yet. Not doesn't really come to mind that we nest build more homes in this town then are built in Hillsborough County. And it is I'm not going to stop. Against that. Chart 3 Sunday turn the page on chart 4. On the screen. This Ariel Lakewood Ranch. Hey, is this company from California to watch where all the residential people come in are? Community? Their presentation about 2 months ago. With Jorge Cruise present probably was for Jorge Cruise Emergent. What was to demonstrate that our growth would actually increase over the next few years rather decrease. That's an increase in numbers. Not necessarily an increase in rate that is the total numbers, which is what you have to for seats in schools will increase, even though as a proportion. It MAY not be quite as much as in the last 25 years. They'll be a lot more people coming here and over the next 5 years, they'll and increase in the growth about 44%. After that period of time, it slows down a little bit. We're going to chart 5, much more growth in the future. Mike is going to talk about this chart much more detail than I will and his will be right side You might wait till he talks about it. But the short version is that will grow by 250,000 people, 2, 2050, according to Ariel CEOs statistics and 210,000 in accordance with That's part planning organization. Neither case it's a lot of growth. 250,000 people or 210,000 people. Population. Today is 458,000. Curtis matter 2024, her testament for today is 467,004 67 250,000 people 25 years, 717,000 people. That would starting on this chart. Number 7. And says according to these lines, the continuation line would be the blue line, historically accurate. Why somewhere between the blue and the green line will be the growth rate and it. Starts off faster than previous growth and it continues and then slows down a little bit between 2035 2000. 2035 is only 10 years. Wayne, if you're building least based on my work in the legislature, you had to plan Warriors head. Make sure you have school for the kids be. According to the Mpo. If you add 44,000 homes in the Northeast 22,000 in the Southeast, that 64,000 dwelling units. If a Manatee County produce point, '06, 3, high school students for home. That's 4,032 additional high school students. So it seems clear to me that you'll need high schools, both in the North County. And in Lakewood Ranch. My case. I guess I'm building 930 homes across from the new high school. Plain sight for new high school. I plan to build roughly 3,600 additional homes to the east. On the other side of the Lake Manatee County Commission notwithstanding and planning to build about 1000 homes in South. Part of Lakewood Ranch. It Rex called the blob the land that they bought for me. Bern Newman Rosenthal estate. The state added to the ranch. And, you know, the ranch continues by new land adjacent to the property and they have other undisclosed land that they're still trying to acquire. Owners of Lakewood Ranch built the best master-planned community and state and region. And I think that area will grow. But in addition to that, there's currently 49,000. Well, units now approved in the North County. My son, John, has a 56. 5,600 on property called North River Ranch. That is very successful, MR. CHAIRMAN, because of the high school where we made a multi-million dollar contribution because of the new. All right. The elementary school. And now a new middle school that will open about 3 weeks. We we want to support your schools business way, but we also want you to continue to build beautiful new schools like you have. Building permits in the last 3 years in Manatee County, 4,702 1023, 5,312. And 24. In JUNE of 2025 the last. 9 months was 5,620. That's entries, not a decreased. There has been a decrease in sales with the building permits. Continue. I think as long as we have high interest rates, they'll be. Restraint on the number of new homes we sell, but we are selling them. Prices have declined. As you know, we'll build and sell no matter what. And so today if you buy on from Neil will buy down your mortgage interest rate and we'll give flex cash for buying a home art Everett concessions are about 12% right now, which is consistent with the marketplace. And I think will continue to meet the market? We have to meet the market to continue. I'm going to number 8, which is full of Sarasota County schools. Get this. MISTER CHAIRMAN, Sarasota County Schools. There's a county has been building schools, example, much older population than we do. They haven't built a high school since Booker. 31 years ago. But here's a new picture of their high school. Park 3 storeis school and building the road out in front of it. They're going to fill it up with kids. They also have a k 8 next to it and they have k 8 just our 3 Rivers Ranch project. So schools in Sarasota County are good, but what's exceptional about them is that they're there at all. This merely that have not had school population growth until the last few years. Closing them. I say do we need new schools in Manatee County? Answer heavens. I think it's clear. I'm not sure if people want it will be going to South East or Bayshore manatee in the same rates that they used to. My last big community. West Brayden was Perico Bay Club which are closed tonight close completed in 1992. We built some homes on the pa muscle peninsula. Since then that the growth in our community is primarily me. East Central, the Lakewood Ranch area and in the Northeast, which will continue to grow. With great speed. As I said, there's 4th at 49,000 home sites currently approved North East Manatee County. There's still 16,000 more dwelling units to be built in Lakewood Ranch, which is quite a few. And I said I'm planning to build. I share. I'm speaking to you as an advocate. I was appropriations CHAIRMAN, the state Senate, and I MAY say that I guess I have report you all. I was a Democrat and I MAY have supported all the taxes for schools. Certainly supported the local Millage for schools, which voters in Manatee County adopted. I worked very hard to pass that because I thought schools were important. Manatee County used to not vote for school bond issues in 1974, they turned down their school bond issue in. I guess it was JUNE when I work very hard to make sure that we had millage for schools. I also voted for the local option school attacks and the 2.12 50. The ceo and the s and p commenee that used to come from the state has declined. So you have to look at local sources that your committee has adopted more than 100 million dollars a year in local sources and its head, a pretty strong popular vote. The renewal of the local option sales tax was with 57%. Last time. It was only 50.7, 6 or 7. Time before that. I'm speaking to the net after You need this new high school. I'm sure you do because the people coming to Manatee County are different. And the folks who used to come in. As an expert in housing. And that's all. I have a question. Thanks for the chats. Might think. >> Thank you for coming. And we got a couple questions. I got a question for you, MISTER Neal, Page one. You said that 15% of the homes you are bill. Are people moving into your homes? Were? At the Masters, empty nesters or at adult on what used to be 15%. Now. >> Now Europe but 31 being okay. >> You have already board approved 49,000. Homes to be built. >> not me, but other be and other building. Un other builders. Okay come. >> Okay. All. >> I think I MAY have flipped the statistics. But effect is that there's more young people buying homes for me and person for me any way less than 59. >> So. >> When there since you talked politics. >> When there are political issues such The influx of people coming down. From stakes. During background. Just what I call covid Russian to Florida. Do you anticipate something like that? In the near future? Another Russian and people coming down. The governor has been talking about that. That's why I'm asking. >> and I call a Sunday, yes, of course. I'm investing zillions of dollars in land infrastructure and roads being built my expense also meant to expenses. Because I think that Manatee County, Florida is one of the most desirable places to be in the United States. Not only are we good, but the other places are bad New York City has new taxes to pass Chicago. Illinois hasn't police mayor now crime has gotten out of hand in parts of area surrounding inner city. So I think we will continue to be good in people continue to come to Florida because it's a desirable place to live and prosper and bring your family. >> Pierre and that I will say when. Lot of us that moved down here didn't ask permission to move here. We looked online to find a house, our job. And those opportunities became available. And we came here. We did not go to county or goes school board and say, can we your county? So because I know there's a lot of put develop that people. I'm more about smart growth like everybody else. And that's why we're talking about this. We're talking about what we need to do. In response to the growth that's already been approved with 49,000 new law coming. Well, they'll be sold. What's your projection? Who knows? We can't. We can't. Even think about that. But I have a good feeling that it's going to be a high percentage people that are going to be coming your state within the next I'm gonna say, 12 months. >> People vote with their dollars. Not necessarily with politics, right? Right. 4 times as many people. In this town in the 55 years I've been building and it's just going to continue. I would on a comparative basis, Florida even more desirable because the tax and jobs and management of our state compared to other states. And it was a I growth will as opposed to decrease. I'd current attitude in Manatee County is a bit transitory. I think I've got enough lots to build all I want to for many years. Things and being changed by the current. Ward >> well, appreciate the dark and I didn't just talk to So I'm really. Dive into it. I just want thank you for your expertise, your field. It something we all need to hear. Sometimes. >> Thank MISTER. Can you had a question? First, Matt, thanks for being here. It's been a long time since we've seen in this room. Well, it's good having. But, you know, I like to talk any time. No, this is really interesting. Factors to that we're discussing and generally speaking, I agree with your summation. The growth is coming at what rate becomes might be up for debate. But people are coming here. We know that. But I wonder if you could speak to in your Florida's a boom and bust 8 as we all know. At least it hasn't made boom and bust, but it's got its ups and downs. Obviously. What in your experience as as as a builder what are some of the circumstances we've seen in the past in Florida? That have are they all tied to national economic downturns? Because that's kind of what I think it is. But I have no expertise in the in the matter. Are what are potential trouble spots as far as growth? I think the trouble spots that we see. If you my average home price has declined, it's now about $659,000 to. >> For a family to buy a new home. >> They have to be able to afford it. And they have to that they have a safe, a path through employment and prosperity in the future. First, they have to ask for it. During the time that we had the 3, 4%, interest rates. A lot of Americans could afford a new home. Our average mortgage now is just a little bit lower than 7%. You can watch the ten-year tea at 250 basis points. You pretty much can see interest rates through the 10 year t bill and that risk premium over the U.S. Government securities that the mortgage Kerry's. But of course, the market tries to solve that. Charlie the way we do is we say if you want to buy home from Pat Neal today will pay the mortgage company, which which we also have a piece of to offer you a 5 and a quarter percent interest or Flynn are says 4.99 Next Tuesday we go to for 99. Also now that comes off value of the House. My perspective and our total concession or as I told you was 11 12 or 13% right now. So we're making it easy or for people to buy homes, but not that easy. I think we all believe than the next 2 or 3 or 4 years, interest rates will go down if the inflation pushed down. And that leads the second point they have to see if your prep laugh. They have to see a clear path for their employment and investment future. And stock market goes up 120 points down up and then down 400 and up and down. The volatility scares the retired people. I promise not to use that word, but I just it. But active adults. The back to the dots that active adults depend on their investments and their social. So the short version is they have to see a good future, too. Right now we've had a volatile year. I think that will settle down. And I think. I more prosperous future. And that means people will move and move with safety. 3rd problem is can they sell their home in Illinois or Ohio and got to be a problem for a lot of people. We don't take home contentions and sales anymore because many times they can't without taking a pretty big. Reduction in the price. Expect. Interest rates security toward the future and some of and why. So, really, it's kind of national factors cause effect say one thing. Of course, we now build Ardennes and bonus room is completely different. We build what I call. The Batista turned in and the sergeant Dan, the test turned in as a workplace at home. We sold a stockbroker in Erie, Pennsylvania, who caused about 3 weeks ago. He calls his secretary and asked what the weather is an airy so he can talk to his customers an area. But you don't have to be in Erie to be a stock broker, an rate and that's true. New Yorkers everybody else in this world as long as they have a good connection and we have all sorts of news. Connections that we can make to people to the outside world and they will continue. Come here because the office of the future is not an office at all. They can come here. 15% of purchasers have a consulting career are still career up north when they come here to work. Come here, working with was a number 15 protecting percent interest and Ardennes are way different than a study and the wiring is You're building a home office has basically intially. We're building home losses to be a real office as opposed to and office where you manage your investments. In a different place on home. And it's a quiet place. It's at the front of the house with the strong doors opposed to basket that's window because person an office close the door at their work time and they work all day. Different Of course, the market is designed to. Respond to that to those pressures. And we do. Because I have one more. As long as I have this opportunity Taiwan with consulting, Charlie, thank you. >> On topic but off, talk topic for the school district. In your opinion, being a former legislator. Big still connected to that world. When are we going to see property? Insurance? Really for reform? The million Dollar Florida >> Well, as your question by answering a different question, I think the governor is very committed to tax reform and his hopes form. And I think art broken revenue in our state is big enough that get his constitutional amendment on property tax reform. Full stop new topic. If you're a new home seller, we say the safest place for you to be if there's a storm in Florida is in a home built since 1986 and particularly built since 2012. >> I moved in the last year hurricane from wouldn't home in West Great. 71 year-old wooden home in West Bradenton who kneel custom home model in it was sound and strong and no, we have. We build what we call a lawyer Pu Foam. Charlie. That is everybody. Tessa Roof with fish scale spring to see it as 42 pounds of. Per square foot of uplift. We have a couple of continuity from the time being all the way down to the footing. We have a window that take a 2 by 450 miles an hour. A new home built by Neil has insurance from about $1300 to $2100 a year. A comparable pre 1986 home of the same values. About 5,500 or 6,000 year. It's not on the beach. So we say the solution, the insurance probably buy a new all the rest of It's Understood. It will be a problem solved we go into homes. Remember after Hurricane Andrew in particular, we started building. We caught up continuity the way to tie the footing of the house all the way. The roofs of nothing flies off. >> Thank you that. And thank you.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • School Board Workshop — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: deef459f36667074d390b6334e563bec. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record