POLISCOPE

The public record

DAVIS (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Special Meeting

Tuesday, April 28, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Special Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 194,287 stored characters

community members to exercise their free speech, right? For we continue to do so this evening. And this local government strives to treat people equitably without discrimination, in all the services, we provide discussions surrounding the map are report have been painful for many yet. They have also created an opportunity for community members from multiple perspectives, to share their concerns, their angers their fears and lived experiences in a public platform. It is clear to staff that the anger and fear on the many sides of this issue are real. Deep rooted. And are not fully resolvable by city staff or the or the davis city council. The city strives to provide an atmosphere where all community members feel safe to practice their religions, honor their heritages and speak their beliefs within legal boundaries. And while respecting constitutionally protected individual freedoms, this is our role. With that, in mind, staff's recommendations reinforce and reiterate to primary points. That the city is committed to free speech. And that the city stands against discrimination, we will continue to provide local services for which we are responsible and run this city organization with these 2 foundational standards. We recommend deferring to other jurisdictions to determine their own governance approaches. In conclusion. Staff recommendations are as follows. As per the city's policy and process. We recommend that the city council receive as informational the human relations commission recommendations. We recommend that you acknowledge that discrimination of all forms exists in davis and a friend. The city's commitment to ongoing education and action to prevent discrimination. We recommend that we continue to provide awareness and education about the right to freedom of speech. Emphasizing political expression is constitutionally protected, regardless of viewpoint. The supplies to all members of our community. And finally, we recommend that we asked the hate free together initiative to partner with the city to develop and share broad-based cross-cultural antibiotics information resources or training that would be made available to the community. With that, I'll conclude my colleague to my left, carrie, dyer. And I as well as the city attorney in the city manager are all available to answer questions as needed. Great, thank you so much city manager, dunstan, and assistant city manager, stackowitz to my colleagues. Have any clarifying questions for staff at this point? Not seeing any very good. So, what I'm going to do is we're going to move now to public comment, but I have some comments to make and I'm looking for uh fire marshal who I believe is still outside, we're good. We're so at this point we're still good on capacity, but we do want people to line up outside. We do not, they can line up in chambers because people are not outside in line, okay? So let me make some comments before everyone cues up and very good. So, as I mentioned earlier, each person will have 2 minutes to offer public comment and you MAY address this once on this item, I am going to be strictly enforcing the 2-minute time limit, and I'll just apologize in advance. Because I know that some of you have very, very heartfelt testimony. But I do need to be fair to everyone. So I will stop you at the 2-minute mark. You'll hear a beep go off and then you can kind of wrap your sentence up and please finish. Um, you always have the prerogative as you come up to offer, public comment of simply saying that you agree or disagree with the speakers before you. You do not necessarily have to use your 2 minutes. That's always your prerogative. Um, I mentioned earlier and I know some of you to have just walked in, but to the members of the audience, please refrain from expressions of approval or disapproval, while others are offering their testimony. The clap being hissing, booing other expressions of approval or disapproval. Please refrain from those s that everyone feels safe expressing their point of view. I also mentioned earlier that it is absolutely permitted by law to video record, but you must do. So in a way, that doesn't interfere with anyone else's ability to participate in the meeting or block their their visibility. I noticed everyone is being really great with their signs and not holding them up in a way that blocks people and thank you for that. I'm appreciative of that. I need to address 1, more issue because it has come up repeatedly here in chambers. I need to talk to a moment about the issue of hate speech. I want everyone who's here this evening or who MAY be watching that all of us sitting up here at the des condemn hate speech in all of its forms, whether that hate speech is based on race, ethnicity sexual orientation, gender, religion, disability, or national origin. We're all committed to making this essay city, a safe welcoming place for everyone. That said hate speech is constitutionally protected, under both state and federal law. This means that we as city council members, can't suppress or limit that speech, even when it MAY be hateful doing so, would potentially violate the first amendment rights of the speaker as my constitutional law professor would say in a city council meeting raised this speech islamophobic speech, transphobic speech anti-semitic speech are all constitutionally protected ed or as he would say, in my living room, I get to kick you out, but this is alimited public forum. Free speech is at play and you MAY hear things that seem hateful but I want to be sure that you all know that even though we need to, we can't suppress that speech that we absolutely do not condone it in any way shape or form. After we hear from our the public comment this evening, my colleagues and I MAY have some responsive comments to, um, offer to what we hear this evening. So with that said, I am going to ask folks to start to line up for public comments. I'm not sure if you were the first but I'm not going to. I'm not going to leg, legislate that 1 and and you don't all have to line up at once, at and I do ask people to please be careful about blocking the doors. And so with that said, okay, we are opening public comment. Please go ahead. Good evening. I I have no doubt that there is a lot of hate uh towards all sorts of groups. Remember when the the kid put the bacon on the mosque, maybe some of you young people don't remember that 1, you know. And uh, so it's true. And, I just have to say, I repudiate hate against any group. And my group, w have experienced a lot of hate. I got flipped off the other day, I was sitting in the tent, in the park on saturday. Somebody walked by, I guess, it was a saturday before that somebody wlked by and they just, you know, gave me the finger you know, so I would like to thank the city manager for his leadership. That was I so well spoken, thank you so much. Um, and but what I worry about is that there are people that have an agenda and they would like to get influence for their personal political agenda into efforts in this community to uh, limit or get rid of hates. Hate and hate speech. And so you have to be very careful. Um you you all know you've all heard it from everyone. Um, it's been a rough couple of years. I mean there's a war going on and it's been rough, man. People on all sides are feeling a lot of pain. That's right. Thank you kelly for saying that. And so, we need to as a community say. That we need to stop hate and if you want to do trainings, outreach, whatever. Bt for everybody all groups don't single out any particular group because everybody's getting it from everybody and it's got to stop please, and MAY all the killing stop. Hi. My name is dora jensen. Uh, first off, I wanted to say something. I really appreciated. I appreciated the comments by the mayor. Uh, who said that um uh so-called hate speech, who knows what that is? Um, people & have different definitions of hateful things or comments, but anyway, uh, it is constitutionally protect protected and so I appreciate that. She mentioned that. Um, and as for her saying that the everybody on the on the day is there condemns hate speech. Well, I don't know, you can say what you want, too. We all get to see what we want. I'm not particularly bound by your feelings or opinions, but fine, you condemn hate speech, however you define it. Um 1 thing, I don't appreciate 2 different things. Um hi, my name is dora jensen. Uh, first off, I wanted to say something. I really appreciated. I appreciated the comments by the mayor, uh, who said that? Um, uh, so-called hate speech, who knows what & uh, be in charge of giving, um, resources or training about what they're doing. That seems very problematic, especially since they're still a draft report on how well they're doing or whether they should even continue that name. So I don't know why you want them to be working on your, uh, way forward. And secondly, um, the worst thing is when the um, human resources council voted to, uh, to forward the recommendations to the city council. It was 6 to 1 the person, um, who voted no wanted to include his recommendations as a & minority opinion, that wasn't allowed. And I turns out it was um published today and davis site.Com. So I don't see why that wasn't allowed. We're supposed to have diversity of opinions, and that was excluded from the report that seems, uh, very unfortunate regarding the human resources co committee. That's my message. Thank you so much. Thank you. Hi, my name is beth born. Um, I have 2 kids, I raised, um, through the davis schools, um, my daughter came out as transgender about 6 years ago and I was lucky, I was able to protect her body. Um, she grew up to be a healthy whole woman, um, but I do know of 6 girls at davis high school. At least who've had their breasts amputated. So for mayor neville to say, it's transphobic to even question this unfolding social medical scandal. I think that is hate speech. What you are saying to me as a woman who wants to protect my daughter and all the other vulnerable kids in davis? All these autistic, quirky kids who don't fit in and you call me transphobic for that. Um, I just want to remind you where the hate is coming from and davis. You will remember that at a turning point usa event. I had a sign that saying why are there so many mastectomies in davis? Um, women don't have penises. Um, you can see that there's a man here, who attacked me I was at court last week because he's a felony charges, right? A man pretending to be a woman attacked me in the back of the head. Um it's not hateful to say that women should have our own rights. It's not hateful to ask. Why are so many girls having double mastectomies? Um, you know, if I had this sign in my front yard, that just said right here. Trump vance 2024 make women sports female again. Um, I would risk and I have right. My car tires have been slashed twice. Now I get regular death threats daily. Um, I have uh people um following me around town. Um I get I think the hate is coming from uh, this chair. Um, this commission, these city bodies hate for you to gather. What does that mean? Oh, hate anybody who trump vance 2024 make women sports female again. Um, I would risk and I have right. My car tires have been slashed twice. Now I get regular death threats daily. Um, I have uh people um following me around town. Um back on. Sorry. Hi. My name is nick buckton. I'm here to urge you to support the mapper report recommendations. I think we all know. That if this report was to survey of any other marginalized community uh group in our community, it's recommendations would have been approved with the consent calendar after all, who can be opposed to recommendations which acknowledged discrimination izzard asked constitutional in our town who afraid to speak out to say, what they feel, who feels silent censored and erased and sadly, some of the response we've seen to this really reasonable recommendations is another attempt to silence and erase certain communities, but if we are to be a community, that's that aspires to be what I think. Davis. A consistently says, it wants to be a community that is inclusive and respectful of all there. Can't be exceptions to every to anyone. We can't be davis, except for is a for everyone, except palestinians or davis is for everyone, except arabs or accept muslims, I realized for the city councilors. Uh, the answer might be to sidestep these issues or to follow the city staff recommendations of saying that all lives matter. But that would not be a solution because that would be another act of eras. When asian-americans came to this community, uh, in in during co and said, we're expressing discrimination, the city acknowledge that discrimination and specifically named asian-americans. When we had anti-semitic incidents in 2024, the city's specifically named anti-semitism and so we stand alongside you I don't think there can be an exception in this case, so I asked you to be brave and say mappa communities matter because we all matter. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Um, before the next speaker approaches, I just need to confirm. Are we at capacity or not? Doing. We need t have people going 1 in 1 work still good. Okay. Thank you, please. Come ahead, sir. Mayor council members. My name is jj serach, I'm a retired lawyer and I have lived in davis for 6 years now. I served years ago as a legal officer with the international committee of the red cross, the organization that created the geneva conventions. Anti-muslim bigotry is real and it deserves a attention. No question about that. But the map I report is not the way to go about it. It is, in fact, political advocacy masquerading as a human relations inquiry. 3 facts, really struck me first the APRIL 24th hrc meeting timestamp. 3 facts, really struck me first. The APRIL 24th hrc meeting timestamp. 228555 chair. Cavin baker, said o his own report, quote. It was an important for me to investigate the truth or accuracy of any event they experienced. That was stunning to me. How can you adopt recommendations from a commission that called the truth of its own findings irrelevant? Second. The report claims hundreds of conversations when in fact, there were only 43 respondents anonymous and unverified and only 12 identified as muslim arab or palestinian third, the commission silence, its own descent a sitting commissioner sought to file a minority rear view the commission voted to forbid. It imagine a supreme court ruling barring, dissenting justices from publishing, their opinions unthinkable, right? And yet, that's what the hrc did. Finally gaza is not this council's business. Neither are sudan, yemen, ukraine or iran. Either the hrc takes up every human right crisis in the world or it tends exclusively to davis issues. Thank you very much. Thank you. What has happened? To our city of davis. I can hardly recognize the place I've called home for the past 40 years. The rampant anti-zionism and anti-semitism on uc davis campus. And the maury port stigmatizing, my people. Is designed specifically to diligent about and marginalized jews and a single us out as fair game as part of an organized. Global anti-israel effort against jews and zionists. To paraphrase a friend of mine rather than serving as a constructive call for inclusion and healing. The mopar report ad its recommendations are political documents designed to divide. Our davis community with further prejudice and hatred, it erases, legitimate, jewish concerns and demands acceptance repeating, false accusations and propaganda. When we defend ourselves, we are called racist. The mopa report weaponizes. Islamophobia. Thank you. Good evening. My name is mabel mini and I'm here to to read um, a letter. The subcommittee's response to staff recommendations. Dear mayor and council members rewrite as co-authors of the muslim arab, palestinian and ally recommendations as a member of the community, that has waited more than a year for you to address this matter. We must express our absolute dismay at the staff recommendations to you on how to proceed with the recommendations. After extensive volunteer labor community, outreach testimony and repeated engagement with city processes. It is deeply disappointing to see the relations commission's, carefully considered recommendations reduced to vague generic statements that fail to meaningfully address, the very harms that prompted this process. At its core, the hrc's work documented, the lived experiences of muslims arabs palestinians and their allies in davis and found clear themes, fear retaliation silencing erasure intimidation and disregard the purpose of the recommendations is to respond to those specific harms with specific actions. Instead, the staff proposal replaces specific responsive actions with the generic all lives matter. Um framework that avoids. Naming the harm and erases the community that came forward in its first place in the first place. This is particularly egregious, given that there was a clear assessment that a razor was 1 of the key harms identified in our assessment. Responding to a razor with further. Erasure is something. We believe will be a lasting stain on this. His city's history, should you choose this approach? When a community says, we are experiencing harm, they answer cannot be to reduce that harm to generic language. So no 1 feels discomfort while deepening the hurt of those who had the courage to come forward. Imagine if, when asian-americans spoke out about being targeted on at the onset of the code, pandemic institutions, responded by not naming that harm. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, I'm going to continue reading this subcommittees prepared, remarks. Um, most people would immediately recognize that response is missing the moment and the need entirely and as instant insulting attempt to decide step, the real issue, the staff's recommendations, also in this case came across as an exception given that the city has not in the past shied away from naming the harm inflicted on specific groups as it has done to address anti-semitism and anti-asian racism to name a few examples. We are specially troubled by the recommendation to strip out, explicit language, affirming the protected right to speech advocating for justice for palestine, and the palestinian people replacing it, with broad statements about political speech. Generally, their original recommendation was intentional. It responds to a real climate in which speech supporting palestinian justice has been uniquely. Stigmatized, child, and mischaracterized to remove that specificity including and very importantly, the word justice is to ignore the problem. The recommendation was designed to solve, likewise the response to recommendation for mischaracterized. What is actually being requested. We are not asking the city to create a separate or exclusive training program. Nor did we ignore the fact that the city already conducts atibiotics and anti-discrimination training? W specifically asked that the existing training include content addressing anti-palestinian racism and anti-muslim bias. We meant for this to also include anti-air racism as well. This is a common and reasonable approach in equity work. If a community says, please ensure anti-lgbtq plus bigotry is explicitly covered in your anti-base training. It would not be a meaningful response to simply say we already have training that avoids, the substance of the request. Our recommendation is about inclusion, relevance and ensuring that reported forms of bias. No matter the method of reporting or actually named and addressed refusing to incorporate specificity does not create neutrality. It leaves known harms on addressed which on its own is the opposite of neutrality is a repeat of the harms that this group has already endured. We are also disappointed by the recommendation that the city should take no meaningful steps. Regarding uc davis or djusd because they are separate jurisdictions. Thank you. Thank you. I will be. I will be continuing to read the report. Um, leadership often means convening urging collaborating and using moral authority. I recommendations ak simply for requests partnership and engagement, not control. W urge you not to accept a watered down substitute that transforms concrete recommendations into symbolic and vague gestures that do nothing to address this specific harms. We hope for you to address. We asked the council instead adopt the original human relations commission, recommendations I substance including explicit acknowledgment of anti-miscegenation and direction to engage djusd and uc davis. On this matter. This vote will will communicate far more than policy language. It will show whether communities, who come forward in pain are met with courage and care or with dilution and deflection, please choose courage. Um, sincerely deema tamimi, uh the commissioner, ellie, kaplan, another commissioner, and kevin baker, uh, commission co-chair. Thank you. hello. My name is rachel darling, and I'm the executive director of halal at davis in sacramento. Hello is a jewish student centered organization grounded in values of respect pluralism and dialogue. We actively support interfaith engagement, and serve on both the interfaith campus council and the university, religious council creating space for open and respectful conversation across the differences. Across differences is central to our mission. We were deeply concerned by the inclusion of helal in the mata report in connection with serious allegations of surveillance harassment and doxxing. In response, we promptly reached out to the hrc and the city council to request an opportunity to discuss these these allegations. Aside from mayor donald neville, we received no response. This lack of engagement from the hrc remains deeply concerning particularly given the seriousness of the allegations in hrc's stated purpose to promote mutual respect, understanding justice and human rights for all. The hrc fell short of its purpose by producing a flawed report that has exacerbated divisions in our community rather than bringing us together. And should not be adopted by city council. We remain. Ready and willing to engage in respectful, dialogue with muslim arab and palestinian students. And community members. We believe in building relationships, listening to 1, another and engaging across differences in meaningful and constructive ways. We are here and we are ready to engage. Thank you. Good evening, davis city council. My name is emily, and I am a student at uc davis representing aggies for israel, aggies, for israel. Is a uc davis student club. Dedicated to advocating for israel, and its right to exist. As a club, we support a 2-state solution and the rights of both israeli and palestinian civilians. As a club, we stand for peace, inclusion, and respect for all communities, regardless of their identity or background. We are disheartened by the students and community member statements of feeling unsafe or discriminated against we do not associate ourselves with this behavior nor supported by any means as a uc davis student. I too often feel, unsafe, both on campus, and in this community and I don't wish that feeling on anyone. As we work to move forward together afi is committed to upholding respectful, balanced dialogues ad strongly standing against any form of aggression or discrimination towards any members of our community. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, city council. My name is toby and I am a jewish student attending uc davis. I'm active in halal and aggies for israel. As a jewish student, I felt I have also felt unsafe on campus and within davis as a broader community, it is disappointing. And upsetting to know that & this is a shared experience regardless of your position. Afi does not in any way invalidate, the experiences of our fellow students and of davis residents aggies for israel is a student club active on campus and we stand to uphold a shared responsibility of coexistence. It is an incredible privilege for us to exist, within a campus and community where multiple viewpoints should be heard and respected. We want to work together to find means of coexistence afi is dedicated to continuing to advocate and work together to make davis safer and more inclusive through open dialogues and discussions. Aggies for israel will continue to be active and open in these conversations and efforts both on campus. And in the broader community. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Hi, I am in davis resident, and also affiliated with the university. I highly recommend the council commit to the survey recommendations and much more. The survey is about the real, uh and uh documented harassment and dscrimination against palestinians and arabs in their allies. This would be a very basic form of acknowledgement for us and the past few years alone, as an arab woman, I have been called a terrorist repeatedly. I have been harassed repeatedly and followed on campus by self-proclaimed zionists from davis after palestine related events, while my experience a series, I personally know, several people who have been the target of much more serious tactics to the level of physical assault, and intimidation by zionists in this city, these stories are documented in and beyond the survey and yet still so much goes unreported due to real fear. The victim should be allowed to name an advocate against their own depression, the perpetrators feelings and identity, whether they are zionist, jewish, or otherwise & doesn't actually matter where real safety is a concern. Given the breadth and depth of anti-palestinian and anti-arab violence and discrimination in the city of davis. It is a grave error in a major safety concern to erase and suppress the survey recommendations. Accepting these recommendations doesn't even meet the bare minimum. For our safety and well-being. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening members of the davis city council. I urge you to vote in favor of the recommendations put forward by the hrc subcommittee that conducted the bapa survey as palestinians and our allies continue to face many forms of harassment. The steps outlined in the recommendations are basic starting points. And the council has the discretion not to accept recommendations that disregard muslims arabs palestinians and our safety. The findings, explicitly, identify razer, and disregard by local institutions as common experiences failing to stand up for us, perpetuates. That very erasure and disregard attempts at a razor. And silencing are not new to me as a palestinian and I would be deeply disappointed if my own city could not agree on simple acknowledgements and affirm that my rights and the rights of my community. A matter as much as anyone else is asking to be included and considered should not be controversial. We continue to show up and engage in good faith in service of the affirmation of justice and hman rights and our time, and our work is to be taken seriously and respected for being palestinian. And speaking about palestine, in my time in davis, I have been shouted at and followed. I've been told, I don't know my own history and that I support terrorism sometimes on my own campus and buy my own faculty. And it's assumed, I will set aside my grief during the ongoing genocide as if I do not need to live somewhere that recognizes my humanity, the status quo continues to harm us and you must not ignore the map of recommendations in favor of maintaining it. Thank you. Thank you. Hello. Um, I'm here to recommend that the city council adopts, the mappa specific recommendations. I grew up in davis and now I teach kids at the local, mosque kids, who are also growing up in davis who have islamophobic anti-arab. And anti-palestinian stories that are on a much bigger scale than mine, they describe bullying, and microaggressions, and negative inaccurate. Representations of their religion and cultural heritage, not only by students, but by teachers as well. Acknowledging, the struggle of these kids, just like anyone going through any struggle would make a world of a difference if you've been through any hard situation on a personal basis, someone just listening and acknowledging you specifically makes you feel seen and takes half the load off your chest. The map of recommendations do exactly that they recognize our community and our struggle and are a step twards making progress. The map a specific recommendations open up conversations and trainings that are vital to changing to challenging the system that has for decades oppressed the map of community. We as 7 year old palestinian kids who are just entering the silencing school system. 30 year, old muslim adults who are just building up the courage to speak up and as 70 year old arab seniors who have been dealing with racism for decades. Ask you to see us hear us and use your voice and power that we don't have to support our community by adopting. These map of specific recommendations. Thank you. Thank you. My name is molly boyle. I'm a jewish student attending uc davis since my arrival. In davis in 2023, I have been repeatedly harassed or have felt unsafe in ways that are firmly intertwined with my jewish identity in my stance as an anti-zionist. 1 instance of this was at a protest that took place last year in which myself and a group of students were participating in a peaceful protest for palestine on campus. On this particular day, there was also a group of zionist counterparts. The pro palestine organizers that I was with made & it explicitly clear, that we were not to engage with or antagonize the counter protesters. So we didn't we initiated zero interaction with them. The the group of zionist counter protesters on the other hand seemed to be there for the sole purpose of instigation and harassment. Many of them were getting up in our faces inches away, from our faces yelling at us, insulting us calling us terrorists and anti-semitic filming us and waving israeli flags in our faces. Not only did this make me feel unsafe because they were verbally harassing us and hurling insults at us, but more specifically the repeated use of the word anti-semitic. Growing up my synagogue taught me to stand up for those whose voices aren't being listened to, and in doing so, and embodying, this jewish value, I have been labeled an, I have been labeled as an enemy to my own people. The constant insistence to intertwine anti-zionism with anti-semitism the idea that all jews and entire group of people must stand by the same exact ideas and values is in itself. Anti-semitic. The idea that judaism is nothing more than zionism is anti-semitic. I as a jewish individual, have my own thoughts and beliefs unique to my own life and experiences. Now, the idea that if I express my auntie zionist values, it strips me of my jewishness a fundamental part of my identity is anti-semitic discriminatory and dehumanizing. They're at the harassment that I have faq as a jwish ally to the palestinian people is only a small fraction of the harassment and discrimination that the map of community continues to face in davis. This is why it is so important to accept the map o recommendations. The proposed recommendations will serve to protect the safety of the map of community including jewish allies like myself as well as the muslim arab and palestinian members of our community. Thank you, thank you. My name is sadie. I am a jewish. 30. Are you today of a student? I am an anti-zionist jewish ally to muslim, arab and palestinian community members here in davis. I'm in full support of the map report and its findings, according to the map report people feel threatened are harassed. And generally feel unsafe in this community due to their beliefs and appearances. I believe it is extremely important for the committee of davis to acknowledge the discrimination. The mapper report, the map reports because all members of the community deserve to have their voices heard, and it is important to give everyone safe a safe space to voice their opinions and experiences zionist groups, such as aggies for israel silence and harass muslim arab, palestinian and ally community members. When peacefully, protest, protesting, and voicing their opinions. This harassment I partially fueled by the false belief that being anti-zionist is anti-semitic. If the davis committee were to perpetuate this silencing and if the davis committee were to perpetuate this silencing and raiser through not acknowledging the discrimination of map of people, it could cause harm to muslim arab and palestinian committee members in the community at large, it is in the community's best interests to acknowledge the experiences of those who have been discriminated against because silencing voices and oppressing discourse such as this leads to harmful cycles of a rager that puts the whole community at risk for the future of and free speech for everyone, I urge you to vote. Yes, on the maple recommendations. Thank you. Thank you. And thank you. So then just before you approach, I'm trying to make sure we can quiet the atrium a little. Um it sounds like they're already working to address that. Uh, so I'm benton, um I'm here in full support of the mappa, hrc recommendations. Um I think this is really important when we need to stand with people who are every municipality across the united states between to stand with um people who are currently, um, being discriminated against, um, and I hope the all vote. Yes on it in action is not a zero sum game and we have to, you know send together with them. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, my name is catalina hera and I'm with the davis college democrats. I want to strongly urge you all to vote and pay for the recommendations made by the mappa report. Um, in fact, the recommendations you see in front of you today are actually incredibly watered down and do a great disservice to the muslims hello, my name is catalina hera, and I'm with the davis college democrats. I want to strongly urge you all to vote and pay for the recommendations made by the mappa report. Um, in fact, the recommendations you se assault are actually sitting in front of you today. Um, and so I'm here to say that is unfair um, for my friends. And I to be neglected for the the discrimination and the assault, we faced, um, and supporting these recommendations does not take away, the deeply felt impact of anti-semitism in our community, but not supporting these recommendations will take away the deeply felt impact of zionism and hatred towards muslims arabs, palestinians and allies. Thank you. I yield my time thank you. Hi, good evening. My name is benjamin. She I am a resident of davis at uc davis student and a member of the davis college democrats. I urge city council to accept all of the hrc recommendations in the map of report staff recommendations rely too much on existing structures and policies. That as the details are very clearly failing mapa communities, uh at the very least, I urge council and staff to explore and implement more concrete, and proactive policies to mitigate hate towards mapa communities and davis. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, I am a jew in davis and I am adamantly in favor of the recommendations in the map report. My father is a thanks. I am in favor of the recommendations. M father is a sn of holocaust survivors. He said it's succinctly. Anti-semitism is a pearl problem, but it's no worse than anti-muslim hate in my jewish community. In davis. We are not interested in making others. Feel unsafe, silencing them or pretending their problems. Don't exist. We embrace human experience, taking responsibility and mutual support. Only my uderstanding of basic psychology. Helps me understand how the descendants of oppressed people can support the oppression of others, and turn their eyes away from starvation murder torture and devastation regardless of who the aggressors are where would be be as a jewish people if not for the brave acts of others who stood up and fought for us in almost 17 years. In davis? I have never once been personally subjected to anti-semitism or fearful because of my identity, that is until a few very vocal scared, and blindly loyal jews. In my opinion, in town started harassing, my pro palestinian jewish peers and mappa members of our community in the last 2 years. I have been insulted by other jews and only ever treated with warmth and inclusion by muslims in palestinians. In davis. In sacramento, I did start to fear becoming the target of hate because of my association with people who were openly supporting war crimes and apartheid, I have removed myself and my family from the local congregation and for the first time in my life and reconsidering my association with judaism as I do, not trust, it can be fully, separated from zionism and israeli act acts of violence. Thank you. Thank you. Hello. Um, this report notes that anti-semitism is constantly weaponized against davis's mapa community as a jewish ally of the community, I'm in a privileged privileged position to speak out wthout immediately being written off as anti-semitic despite the threat of my zionist, jewish cousins doxxing me are accusing me of being self-hating people, ask how I can be anti-zionist when violence against jews predominantly happens to those of us in the diaspora, but violent violence against diasporic jews. Only strengthens my convictions. That jews should be safe wherever we are and I'm not so arrogant. As to believe that. I am more deserving of safety than my palestinian nighbors zionists. MAY assert that, I am simply simp simply ignorant of how far anti-semitism goes in the diaspora. But I learned hebrew in a classroom with windows boarded up after being shattered, by bullets in this room, iwas taught that we are all made bets, alum, me, and the image of GOD, judaism rests, on a fundamental belief and equity and justice for all. I was taught to kuno, lamb repairing, the world without safety for all their safety for none, and davis as much as pallet as in palestine, to conflate anti-zionism with anti-semitism am israel with medi. Not is israel, is to misappropriate. A sever, several thousand-year-old faith to justify an 80 year. Old settler colonialist project. Thank you. Thank you. Um, I'm dafna romeo. A davis resident while I deeply appreciate what our city manager said. And I wholeheartedly agree with it. And while the staff recommendations themselves are not anything, I would argue against this is bigger than that, there would be no recommendations without the up a report. So though the recommendations MAY be benign, the staff report says that the mappa report provided the information basis for them and it is still on the city website and it has not been condemned. It has not been rejected but at most must be both condemned and rejected and then hate can be dealt with in good faith. We've spoken to you extensively in person. We've written many emails. There are documents circulating that with um, the circulating that detail the fatal flaws of the report and expose the dangerous hate and lies that it contains. I will not get into we've spoken to you extensively in person, we've written many emails. There are documents circulating that with um, the circulating that detail the fatal flaws of the report and expose the dangerous hate and lies ` let yourself cow in the face of those who label, anyone who questions their narrative or behavior, as racist, fascist islamophobic, who seek to scapegoat an entire community, you can uphold your responsibilities and reverse course or you can abdicate cave to the bullying and try to put us all o this mopa train, but be warned the jews in davis, california in 2026 are not going to get on that train, like sheep, reject, and condemn. This monstrosity in its entirety and get it off the public website. Take the target off of our backs and return to city business that helps everyone hello, my name is brett coder. A board member of the jewish community relations council of sacramento region. A psychotherapist and a parent of a child attending a davis school. I want to thank the city manager and staff for their remarks and putting forth a uh, viewpoint neutral set of recommendations that protect equal, rights combat, all hate, stay within the purview of the city and do not entertain recommendations that would unnecessarily divide the community and break neutrality. However, this map of report should not have should have been rejected from the outset continuing to platform the report, even if only, if it's only considering the recommendations is tacit endorsement to hate spewed within it. I urge the council to denounce it or move it from the website and do not entertain such flaws reports in the future. Flaws of this reporter numerous as I have been documented, anecdotal unverified and inflammatory complaints from a highly unrepresentative sample of muslims arabs and palestinians. Misrepresented methodology in a tiny sample size with sweeping broad, conclusions drawn from it. Libels, denigrating comments and the use of zionists as a slur and other dog, whistle language attempting the jewish community. These have no place and polite society. If we are serious about stamping out hate, we cannot platform it. I'm particularly concerned that the commission, denied, the opportunity for a minority opinion to be entered in the commission's record that makes it quite clear that this isn't actually about hearing minority views. It's about silencing some to advance others. Attempts to address hate should be viewpoint neutral and factual. The city cannot offer special treatment to 1 viewpoint that would platform hate instead of countering it. Let's get back t actual city business and end these efforts to hijack the council and its commissions. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Uh city manager, MADAME Mayor and council people. I wanted to say. I appreciate the city manager's comments about neutrality, and I'd like to thank the committee for their recommendations. My name is lori nolan. I am a board member at congregation beth sholom in an active member of the jewish federation countering anti-semitism committee. I'm also speaking on behalf on behalf of clary schuman, who's been involved as vice chair of the jewish community relations council and local holocaust remembrance initiatives who could be couldn't be here today due to illness and I'm asking the council to please, um, reject the mappa report. The mappa report is a poorly researched misleading and deeply flawed document. It should have never have been treated as credible basis for public decision-making. It also misrepresents the majority of the jewish community and attempts to frame zionism as racism. And that is not new uh that reflects a decades old anti-jewish propaganda now, repackaged in the language of social justice. Since OCTOBER 7th davis has experienced, excuse me, a documented rise in anti-semitism. This includes visible displays of logos associated with terrorists organizations, the report did not grapple with this reality. Instead it frames the documentation of these incidents as aggression and persecution. When documenting anti-semitism and extremism is treated as the problem, rather than the anti-semitism not analysis. Its deflection. And I want to make a clear that I do not doubt that the arab and muslim communities faced, prejudice and discrimination, these issues deserve serious credible attention. But mappa is not recognized or established body. Thank you very much. Hello. Thank you all for being here. My name is nina livni. I'm a davis resident and currently a student at davis. Senior high school. Every citizen in davis deserves to have their voices heard. I hope everybody here can agree on that. What the mapper report does is represents a certain group and allows them to share their feelings. Some of these feelings and thoughts, clearly make other people hear uncomfortable. I personally can confirm confirm a lot of the feelings that were shared in the map report. For those curious about credibility and it is disappointing that there are people here, who do not take these opinions seriously and who wish to dismiss them just because you do not appreciate or even agree with somebody's feelings. Does not justify taking away, a group's right to express themselves. I find it shocking and extremely concerning as a young person in davis that there are people that there are people who do not believe a group should be allowed to express their lived experiences and are therefore creating fear and hatred rather than a space to share and maturely understand. I find it even more disturbing that the city council would side with 1 volkl, pushing an agenda of fear to dictate whether or not a group is allowed. To share their personal feelings and requests for city support, which is something every person is deserving of in the city. I hope. Sorry, it is the duty of our city council and the goal, I hope of our city of davis to make every group feel welcome. Even if it makes you uncomfortable, I urge you to consider this in your decision and support the recommendations as they are written. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, my name is thomas. I'm a student at uc davis and I strongly urge the approval of the hrc's recommendations and to continue actions in support of the map of community the protection of the dignity, dignity and rights of all people in the community will always, always has been and will continue to be city business. Thank you. Hi. My name is betsy elsaan and I have lived in davis for over 30 years ad I have spent all that time. It's an active member of congregation beth haven and also for context, my brother has lived in israel for longer than I've lived in davis and has a family there and my brother has lived in israel for longer than I've lived in davis and has a family there and I worried for their safety, all the time. That being said, the and I the other thing i'll say is that the mappa report as people have said, I know there are issues with it and some of my concerns related to it is its inability to protect the anonymity of some of the people in, in the report. However, I think it's message is clear and even if it was 5, people I think it's message is clear, and even if it was 5 people who had had those experiences, they're unacceptable in a city like davis. And I feel that, as a family who are survivors of the holocaust, we cannot allow this to happen to other groups and just and and I believe that this is a group that has been subject to bigotry and harassment and as a family who are survivors of the holocaust, we cannot allow this to happen to other groups and just and and I believe that this is a group that has been subject to bigotry and harassment and I reall and and minority groups in davis. And I just think it's good to acknowledge this. And something that we read at our yom kipur services of a form of this um, that I think it's important. From pastor martin. Nemer. first, they came for the socialists and I did not speak out because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade units uionists, and I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist, then they came for the jews and I did not speak out because was not a jew and then they came for me. And there was no 1 left to speak for me. Thank you. Those aren't mine. Hello, I am reading this on behalf of professor, seth sanders. I'm writing to you as a professor of religious studies and jewish studies emeritus at uc davis to urge you to act on the muslim arab, palestinian and allies recommendations, which seemed in my professional opinion, to be fair balanced. And indeed the least that a place that cares about equality could do. The math, the map of subcommittees assessment which is well documented, is that alongside other issues of discrimination? There's also a history in davis of public intimidation and harassment against arabs and muslims including the ones that I have witnessed and that have been copiously documented by uc davis students and professors a significant part of this discrimination has come from the old expected. Directions of what supremacists and christian nationalists. Who feel that? Nobody except white christians belong in america. But import, but an important and different type of discrimination, against arabs and muslims. I have witnessed in davis, comes from a political position, namely the ethnic nationalist version of zionism. This version of zionism discriminates not only against arabs and muslims but also against jews, in fact, the only cases o anti-semitism I experienced in davis were from such zionists who attacked me for supporting palestinian rights. It was quite something to be singled out as an observant jew out of out at the farmers market with my family, wearing a cuba and screamed at by a non-religious, community member with no interest in jewish observance. Similarly, while celebrating hanukkah with my family publicly in davis. I was socked to have our prayers interrupted by secular nationalists screaming the israeli national anthem. Obviously, if the nationalist zionists in this community were willing to be aggressive towards jews in public. The level of abuse directed at palestinians as well as muslims and other arab community members has been even more intense instances I have witnessed include a prominent zionist community member screaming at palestinian students and their supporters early in the middle of the night. Quote, wake up terrorists during the period of the harassment became so intense that my own department chair took to staying out. Thank you. Sorry. I was just gonna finish that. Sincerely said zionists in this community were willing to be aggressive towards jews in public. The level of abuse directed at palestinians as well as muslims. And other arab community members has been even more n urge the city council to adopt the report as written by the subcommittee, um, for the specific reasons that the the version, uh, offered by the staff is a sanitized version. That is practically nearly meaningless because it strips any specificity from the language. The only criticism that I have of the, um, of the subcommittee is just that there was a a parallel subcommittee on anti-semitism that. Didn't, that did disband without giving a report, and we can all agree that anti-semitism is a real problem, but anti-semitism is not just a problem for jewish people. But also for palestinians who are also submitted people. So this is a problem of people. Being displaced by a settler colonialism and these struggles are intertwined together. The the ultimate enemy of both of these things is white nationalism and settler colonialism. Um, as far as uh rejecting uh, recommendations 35 and 6 because they are uh, the city council can't dictate what other bodies do. That is not what the recommendations, uh, called for, they collaboration. So, that's in my opinion, a willful mystery reading of that, finally, uh, reaffirming free speech is not something you need to do, it's in the us constitution, we all know that. Um, the uh finally the the staff rejecting need for training on anti-palestinian anti-muslim hate is absolutely necessary because the conflation of anti-zionism and and uh, anti-semitism or being pro- palestinian and anti-semitism is a false conflation and using that and designating it as hate speech and then policing that speech. It totally goes against the whole uh, ethos of trying to be create a fair and open society. If you are, uh, policing palestinians speech as hates protesting against hate speech, that is, um, not right. Thank you. Good evening, city council. I'm victoria. And I want to tlk about the urgency of this moment today. We live in a world where the city and PRESIDENT Of the united states can call for destruction of an entire country in the middle east and a moment such as this, the need for local government to protect us, is crucial now more than ever before by adhering to maple recommendations. We foster our community that will step in to protect the oppressed when the moment calls for it. Thank you very much. Thank you. My name is alan brownstein, I've lived in davis for 45 years. I urge this council not to endorse adopt or implement the recommendations of the map report in any way. You can't implement the recommendations of reporting claim, not to be endorsing. The content of the report on which the recommendations are based. And the map report should not be endorsed by this council. For example, it repeatedly demonizes, zionist jews as racist islamophobic, fascists supremacists, exercising manipulative, control over, local gvernment and threatening the rest of the community. And not only ignores the serious problem of prejudice and bigotry against jews and davis, it dismisses, those concerns a the weaponization of anti-semitism with a hard question, the council has to confront is, what do you do now? You have this report and its recommendations in front of you, if you repudiate it, you will alienate the map of constituencies who will feel that their concerns are not being recognized by the council. If you adopt the recommendations, you will be slapping. The jewish community of davis to significant extent right in the face and telling us our concerns are entirely irrelevant to the city council. So what do you do? Well, I'm not sure I know te answer to that question, but I suggest that you put the map report and the human relations commission, aside, and you try to develop an alternative approach. That tries to identify ways that muslims and jews and palestinians and israelis can live together in dvis, if not on the basis of mutual respect, which would be ideal that at least on the basis of mutual toleration, and for that to happen, the council has to accept 1 a binding, principal do no harm and the mapper report harms the jewish community. Thank you. Good evening. Um, I'm here to strongly recommend that this council um, adopt the recommendations from the mappa report. I am a davis site. I am an armenian american and I am an american citizen because my grandparents escaped programs and a genocide. And a genocide that was only recognized by the united states nearly a hundred years after it had passed, my grandmother lived to a hundred and she never got to see the us. Acknowledge the genocide that she fled that brought her to this country. Um, it is really difficult when you have 2 marginalized communities, that end up being pitted against each other. The um, whether or not you adopt the recommendations in the report, it doesn't change the reality of what exists in the report which you have heard so much of this evening. You can't, the question is, whether you are going to acknowledge that reality and face it or not, which is going to reflect on you and not what's happening in davis. Um, just & because a group is a small group within a community that doesn't mean that their experiences don't matter. In fact, in most cases you have a majority that is makes it difficult to hear that the voices of the minority and that is what we are seeing happen right now. Um, I have 4 dearest friends in the world out of those. 3 of them ae jewish and the fourth, 1 is married to a jewish man. I am deeply concerned about anti-semitism and by far the anti-semitism the rising anti-semitism. We are seeing in the western world is from christian white nationalists and not from muslims. Thank you. Thank you. Hello council members, my name is ava martin and I have lived in davis since 2017 I want to issue my full support for the report produced by the city of davis. Human relations commission. Subcommittee on muslim arabs, palestinian and their allies, and I urge you to vote, yes, to adopt the mappa recommendations, the recommendations are a starting point. Davis is for everyone, it is for a muslim brothers and sisters, palestinian brothers, and sisters, jewish brothers, and sisters, asian, brothers, and sisters, black brothers, and sisters, latino brothers, and sisters lgbtqia, plus, brothers, and sisters, everyone. We are all important. Everyone has a right to live free and without harassment. There should be zero tolerance for this hate vote. Yes, to the map of recommendations. Thank you. Good evening, everyone. I frequent chabad, I frequent halal. I'm a board member of aggies for israel and above all of that. I'm a proud jew. Last year, I was a senator for the uc davis student & government there. I dealt with hate and discrimination, not because of anything I had said or done. But because people assumed the type of person I was based on the group's identify with people refused to work with me or even speak to me. I was doxed online and called names in person and humiliated publicly and privately. When deciding how to proceed, I had a choice. I could back down and hide, I could fight back. Or I could be and give love to myself as well as everyone around me. As I mentioned earlier, last year, I faced this extreme discrimination but there was 1. Other senator that would work with me and she is palestinian. We work together on a project for the coffee house, something completely unrelated to the middle east. And together we made a positive change. In our free time, I told her about my family in israel and she taught me about the details on a kafia. Although, we didn't agree on mostly anything political our project was was a success and I came out on the other end with a better understanding of muslim, arab, and palestinian communities. I urge our city leaders, as well as everyone in this room, to focus on the little things, like the story. I just mentioned. We've dealt with pain anger and hate from both sides from far too long. And obviously, something needs to change. We can address the problem systematically. But w can also start on our own. Please be kind because I can tell you from personal experience. It goes a really long way. Thank you. Good evening. Honorable mayor MADAME Deputy mayor city council members and city administrators. I'm a student here at davis and tonight, I stand before you to voice my concerns for the city staff version of the map report. I see the staff's attempt to make a universally welcome message. However, when people say stop asian hate, do you respond with stop? Oh, hate in hopes to appeal and protect. Everybody know your any neutral language is silence. Complicity neutrality in the face of an ongoing genocide is the antithesis of davis is for everybody. This recommendation is but a first step, bt what does his history think? When this city can't even adopt adopt a recommendations without watering it down and taking the out, the muslim arabs and palestinians and their allies out the frame. The sope of the human relations committee was to not put a target on any community at all, but to center te fears, the stories, the struggles that the map of community has endured we're here tonight, still but henry jab would is no longer we can speak about the fears of our communities are living under but are not al sharif. No longer can we're here tonight, still, but henry jab would is no longer. We can speak about the fears of our communities are living under but are not al sharif. No longer can. Well, we hesitate to even adopt a thank you council. I'm a jewish student at uc davis and the recommendations of the hrc. Undeniably affect me. I was wearing this same bandana a while biking through campus alone when I was approached by a fellow jewish student. I had never met this person and his first words to me were, are you a terrorist? He followed me for more than a block on his bike screaming in my face that I'm a self-hating jew and support the more, the murder of civilians, the framing of palestinian culture as inherently anti-semitic, cannot be per

CITY OF DAVIS CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA COMMUNITY CHAMBERS, 23 RUSSELL BOULEVARD, DAVIS, CA 95616 TUESDAY, APRIL 28, 2026 5:30 P.M. Members of the City Council: Donna Neville, Mayor Gloria Partida, Vice Mayor Josh Chapman Linda Deos Daryel Dunston, City Manager Bapu Vaitla Inder Khalsa, City Attorney 1. Roll Call & Approval of Agenda 2. Follow Up from Human Relations Commission Recommendations from Mus- lim/Arab/Palestinian/Allies (MAPA) Subcommittee Report (City Manager Daryel Dun- ston/Assistant City Manager Kelly Stachowicz/Community Relations Program Man- ager Carrie Dyer) Recommendation: 1. Receive as informational the recommendations made by the Human Relations Commission in response to the Muslim, Arab, Palestinian, and Allies (MAPA) re- port, which was prepared by a subcommittee of the commission. 2. Acknowledge that discrimination of all forms exists in Davis and affirm the City’s commitment to ongoing education and action to prevent discrimination. 3. Continue to provide awareness and education about the right to freedom of speech, emphasizing that political expression is constitutionally protected, re- gardless of view point. This applies to all members of our community. 4. Ask the Hate-Free Together to partner with the City to develop/share broad- based, cross-cultural, anti-bias information, resources or training that would be made available to the community. Public Comments Any member of the public may address the City Council on the matter listed on this agenda. IN PERSON PUBLIC COMMENTS: The Mayor will invite public comment at the appropriate time following staff presentation. Speakers will be asked to line up at the podium and state their name for the record. Comments are limited to no more than 2 minutes per speaker. Up to 5 minutes may be granted if an individual is speaking on behalf of 5 or more people present together at the podium, a recog- nized organization, or a jurisdictional partner. Please note that time allowance may be reduced by the Mayor if warranted by the volume of speakers present. WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS: Submit written public comments to CityCoun- cilMembers@cityofdavis.org. Emails are distributed to City Council and staff. To04-28-26 City Council Special MeetingAgenda - 1

Davis City Council Special Meeting Agenda April 28, 2026 Page 2 of 2 ensure the City Council has the opportunity to review information prior to the meet- ing, please send emails by 3:00 p.m. on the meeting date. 3. Adjournment The April 28, 2026 special meeting agenda of the Davis City Council was delivered to each Councilmember and posted on the outside public bulletin board at City Hall, 23 Rus- sell Boulevard on April 24, 2026 and made available to the public during normal business hours. Meetings may be viewed online. They are live streamed at http://cityofdavis.org/city- hall/city-council/city-council-meetings/meeting-videos. Meetings are also televised live on City of Davis Government Channel 21 (available to those who subscribe to cable television). Closed captions are available - to view, activate captions on your viewing device. General Notes: • By request, alternative agenda document formats are available to persons with disa- bilities. To arrange an alternative agenda document format or to arrange aid or ser- vices to modify or accommodate persons with a disability to participate in a public meeting, contact the City Clerk by calling 530-757-5648 (voice) or Clerk- web@cityofdavis.org. • Staff recommendations are guidelines to the City Council. On any item, the Council may take action which varies from that recommended by staff. • The City does not transcribe its proceedings. Anyone who desires a verbatim record of this meeting should arrange for a court reporter or for other acceptable means of recordation. Such arrangements will be at the sole expense of the individual request- ing the recordation. • For questions about this agenda, call the City Clerk’s Office 530-757-5648 or email Clerkweb@cityofdavis.org.04-28-26 City Council Special MeetingAgenda - 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 194,287 characters. The full document is at the source.

community members to exercise their free speech, right? For we continue to do so this evening. And this local government strives to treat people equitably without discrimination, in all the services, we provide discussions surrounding the map are report have been painful for many yet. They have also created an opportunity for community members from multiple perspectives, to share their concerns, their angers their fears and lived experiences in a public platform. It is clear to staff that the anger and fear on the many sides of this issue are real. Deep rooted. And are not fully resolvable by city staff or the or the davis city council. The city strives to provide an atmosphere where all community members feel safe to practice their religions, honor their heritages and speak their beliefs within legal boundaries. And while respecting constitutionally protected individual freedoms, this is our role. With that, in mind, staff's recommendations reinforce and reiterate to primary points. That the city is committed to free speech. And that the city stands against discrimination, we will continue to provide local services for which we are responsible and run this city organization with these 2 foundational standards. We recommend deferring to other jurisdictions to determine their own governance approaches. In conclusion. Staff recommendations are as follows. As per the city's policy and process. We recommend that the city council receive as informational the human relations commission recommendations. We recommend that you acknowledge that discrimination of all forms exists in davis and a friend. The city's commitment to ongoing education and action to prevent discrimination. We recommend that we continue to provide awareness and education about the right to freedom of speech. Emphasizing political expression is constitutionally protected, regardless of viewpoint. The supplies to all members of our community. And finally, we recommend that we asked the hate free together initiative to partner with the city to develop and share broad-based cross-cultural antibiotics information resources or training that would be made available to the community. With that, I'll conclude my colleague to my left, carrie, dyer. And I as well as the city attorney in the city manager are all available to answer questions as needed. Great, thank you so much city manager, dunstan, and assistant city manager, stackowitz to my colleagues. Have any clarifying questions for staff at this point? Not seeing any very good. So, what I'm going to do is we're going to move now to public comment, but I have some comments to make and I'm looking for uh fire marshal who I believe is still outside, we're good. We're so at this point we're still good on capacity, but we do want people to line up outside. We do not, they can line up in chambers because people are not outside in line, okay? So let me make some comments before everyone cues up and very good. So, as I mentioned earlier, each person will have 2 minutes to offer public comment and you MAY address this once on this item, I am going to be strictly enforcing the 2-minute time limit, and I'll just apologize in advance. Because I know that some of you have very, very heartfelt testimony. But I do need to be fair to everyone. So I will stop you at the 2-minute mark. You'll hear a beep go off and then you can kind of wrap your sentence up and please finish. Um, you always have the prerogative as you come up to offer, public comment of simply saying that you agree or disagree with the speakers before you. You do not necessarily have to use your 2 minutes. That's always your prerogative. Um, I mentioned earlier and I know some of you to have just walked in, but to the members of the audience, please refrain from expressions of approval or disapproval, while others are offering their testimony. The clap being hissing, booing other expressions of approval or disapproval. Please refrain from those s that everyone feels safe expressing their point of view. I also mentioned earlier that it is absolutely permitted by law to video record, but you must do. So in a way, that doesn't interfere with anyone else's ability to participate in the meeting or block their their visibility. I noticed everyone is being really great with their signs and not holding them up in a way that blocks people and thank you for that. I'm appreciative of that. I need to address 1, more issue because it has come up repeatedly here in chambers. I need to talk to a moment about the issue of hate speech. I want everyone who's here this evening or who MAY be watching that all of us sitting up here at the des condemn hate speech in all of its forms, whether that hate speech is based on race, ethnicity sexual orientation, gender, religion, disability, or national origin. We're all committed to making this essay city, a safe welcoming place for everyone. That said hate speech is constitutionally protected, under both state and federal law. This means that we as city council members, can't suppress or limit that speech, even when it MAY be hateful doing so, would potentially violate the first amendment rights of the speaker as my constitutional law professor would say in a city council meeting raised this speech islamophobic speech, transphobic speech anti-semitic speech are all constitutionally protected ed or as he would say, in my living room, I get to kick you out, but this is alimited public forum. Free speech is at play and you MAY hear things that seem hateful but I want to be sure that you all know that even though we need to, we can't suppress that speech that we absolutely do not condone it in any way shape or form. After we hear from our the public comment this evening, my colleagues and I MAY have some responsive comments to, um, offer to what we hear this evening. So with that said, I am going to ask folks to start to line up for public comments. I'm not sure if you were the first but I'm not going to. I'm not going to leg, legislate that 1 and and you don't all have to line up at once, at and I do ask people to please be careful about blocking the doors. And so with that said, okay, we are opening public comment. Please go ahead. Good evening. I I have no doubt that there is a lot of hate uh towards all sorts of groups. Remember when the the kid put the bacon on the mosque, maybe some of you young people don't remember that 1, you know. And uh, so it's true. And, I just have to say, I repudiate hate against any group. And my group, w have experienced a lot of hate. I got flipped off the other day, I was sitting in the tent, in the park on saturday. Somebody walked by, I guess, it was a saturday before that somebody wlked by and they just, you know, gave me the finger you know, so I would like to thank the city manager for his leadership. That was I so well spoken, thank you so much. Um, and but what I worry about is that there are people that have an agenda and they would like to get influence for their personal political agenda into efforts in this community to uh, limit or get rid of hates. Hate and hate speech. And so you have to be very careful. Um you you all know you've all heard it from everyone. Um, it's been a rough couple of years. I mean there's a war going on and it's been rough, man. People on all sides are feeling a lot of pain. That's right. Thank you kelly for saying that. And so, we need to as a community say. That we need to stop hate and if you want to do trainings, outreach, whatever. Bt for everybody all groups don't single out any particular group because everybody's getting it from everybody and it's got to stop please, and MAY all the killing stop. Hi. My name is dora jensen. Uh, first off, I wanted to say something. I really appreciated. I appreciated the comments by the mayor. Uh, who said that um uh so-called hate speech, who knows what that is? Um, people & have different definitions of hateful things or comments, but anyway, uh, it is constitutionally protect protected and so I appreciate that. She mentioned that. Um, and as for her saying that the everybody on the on the day is there condemns hate speech. Well, I don't know, you can say what you want, too. We all get to see what we want. I'm not particularly bound by your feelings or opinions, but fine, you condemn hate speech, however you define it. Um 1 thing, I don't appreciate 2 different things. Um hi, my name is dora jensen. Uh, first off, I wanted to say something. I really appreciated. I appreciated the comments by the mayor, uh, who said that? Um, uh, so-called hate speech, who knows what & uh, be in charge of giving, um, resources or training about what they're doing. That seems very problematic, especially since they're still a draft report on how well they're doing or whether they should even continue that name. So I don't know why you want them to be working on your, uh, way forward. And secondly, um, the worst thing is when the um, human resources council voted to, uh, to forward the recommendations to the city council. It was 6 to 1 the person, um, who voted no wanted to include his recommendations as a & minority opinion, that wasn't allowed. And I turns out it was um published today and davis site.Com. So I don't see why that wasn't allowed. We're supposed to have diversity of opinions, and that was excluded from the report that seems, uh, very unfortunate regarding the human resources co committee. That's my message. Thank you so much. Thank you. Hi, my name is beth born. Um, I have 2 kids, I raised, um, through the davis schools, um, my daughter came out as transgender about 6 years ago and I was lucky, I was able to protect her body. Um, she grew up to be a healthy whole woman, um, but I do know of 6 girls at davis high school. At least who've had their breasts amputated. So for mayor neville to say, it's transphobic to even question this unfolding social medical scandal. I think that is hate speech. What you are saying to me as a woman who wants to protect my daughter and all the other vulnerable kids in davis? All these autistic, quirky kids who don't fit in and you call me transphobic for that. Um, I just want to remind you where the hate is coming from and davis. You will remember that at a turning point usa event. I had a sign that saying why are there so many mastectomies in davis? Um, women don't have penises. Um, you can see that there's a man here, who attacked me I was at court last week because he's a felony charges, right? A man pretending to be a woman attacked me in the back of the head. Um it's not hateful to say that women should have our own rights. It's not hateful to ask. Why are so many girls having double mastectomies? Um, you know, if I had this sign in my front yard, that just said right here. Trump vance 2024 make women sports female again. Um, I would risk and I have right. My car tires have been slashed twice. Now I get regular death threats daily. Um, I have uh people um following me around town. Um I get I think the hate is coming from uh, this chair. Um, this commission, these city bodies hate for you to gather. What does that mean? Oh, hate anybody who trump vance 2024 make women sports female again. Um, I would risk and I have right. My car tires have been slashed twice. Now I get regular death threats daily. Um, I have uh people um following me around town. Um back on. Sorry. Hi. My name is nick buckton. I'm here to urge you to support the mapper report recommendations. I think we all know. That if this report was to survey of any other marginalized community uh group in our community, it's recommendations would have been approved with the consent calendar after all, who can be opposed to recommendations which acknowledged discrimination izzard asked constitutional in our town who afraid to speak out to say, what they feel, who feels silent censored and erased and sadly, some of the response we've seen to this really reasonable recommendations is another attempt to silence and erase certain communities, but if we are to be a community, that's that aspires to be what I think. Davis. A consistently says, it wants to be a community that is inclusive and respectful of all there. Can't be exceptions to every to anyone. We can't be davis, except for is a for everyone, except palestinians or davis is for everyone, except arabs or accept muslims, I realized for the city councilors. Uh, the answer might be to sidestep these issues or to follow the city staff recommendations of saying that all lives matter. But that would not be a solution because that would be another act of eras. When asian-americans came to this community, uh, in in during co and said, we're expressing discrimination, the city acknowledge that discrimination and specifically named asian-americans. When we had anti-semitic incidents in 2024, the city's specifically named anti-semitism and so we stand alongside you I don't think there can be an exception in this case, so I asked you to be brave and say mappa communities matter because we all matter. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Um, before the next speaker approaches, I just need to confirm. Are we at capacity or not? Doing. We need t have people going 1 in 1 work still good. Okay. Thank you, please. Come ahead, sir. Mayor council members. My name is jj serach, I'm a retired lawyer and I have lived in davis for 6 years now. I served years ago as a legal officer with the international committee of the red cross, the organization that created the geneva conventions. Anti-muslim bigotry is real and it deserves a attention. No question about that. But the map I report is not the way to go about it. It is, in fact, political advocacy masquerading as a human relations inquiry. 3 facts, really struck me first the APRIL 24th hrc meeting timestamp. 3 facts, really struck me first. The APRIL 24th hrc meeting timestamp. 228555 chair. Cavin baker, said o his own report, quote. It was an important for me to investigate the truth or accuracy of any event they experienced. That was stunning to me. How can you adopt recommendations from a commission that called the truth of its own findings irrelevant? Second. The report claims hundreds of conversations when in fact, there were only 43 respondents anonymous and unverified and only 12 identified as muslim arab or palestinian third, the commission silence, its own descent a sitting commissioner sought to file a minority rear view the commission voted to forbid. It imagine a supreme court ruling barring, dissenting justices from publishing, their opinions unthinkable, right? And yet, that's what the hrc did. Finally gaza is not this council's business. Neither are sudan, yemen, ukraine or iran. Either the hrc takes up every human right crisis in the world or it tends exclusively to davis issues. Thank you very much. Thank you. What has happened? To our city of davis. I can hardly recognize the place I've called home for the past 40 years. The rampant anti-zionism and anti-semitism on uc davis campus. And the maury port stigmatizing, my people. Is designed specifically to diligent about and marginalized jews and a single us out as fair game as part of an organized. Global anti-israel effort against jews and zionists. To paraphrase a friend of mine rather than serving as a constructive call for inclusion and healing. The mopar report ad its recommendations are political documents designed to divide. Our davis community with further prejudice and hatred, it erases, legitimate, jewish concerns and demands acceptance repeating, false accusations and propaganda. When we defend ourselves, we are called racist. The mopa report weaponizes. Islamophobia. Thank you. Good evening. My name is mabel mini and I'm here to to read um, a letter. The subcommittee's response to staff recommendations. Dear mayor and council members rewrite as co-authors of the muslim arab, palestinian and ally recommendations as a member of the community, that has waited more than a year for you to address this matter. We must express our absolute dismay at the staff recommendations to you on how to proceed with the recommendations. After extensive volunteer labor community, outreach testimony and repeated engagement with city processes. It is deeply disappointing to see the relations commission's, carefully considered recommendations reduced to vague generic statements that fail to meaningfully address, the very harms that prompted this process. At its core, the hrc's work documented, the lived experiences of muslims arabs palestinians and their allies in davis and found clear themes, fear retaliation silencing erasure intimidation and disregard the purpose of the recommendations is to respond to those specific harms with specific actions. Instead, the staff proposal replaces specific responsive actions with the generic all lives matter. Um framework that avoids. Naming the harm and erases the community that came forward in its first place in the first place. This is particularly egregious, given that there was a clear assessment that a razor was 1 of the key harms identified in our assessment. Responding to a razor with further. Erasure is something. We believe will be a lasting stain on this. His city's history, should you choose this approach? When a community says, we are experiencing harm, they answer cannot be to reduce that harm to generic language. So no 1 feels discomfort while deepening the hurt of those who had the courage to come forward. Imagine if, when asian-americans spoke out about being targeted on at the onset of the code, pandemic institutions, responded by not naming that harm. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, I'm going to continue reading this subcommittees prepared, remarks. Um, most people would immediately recognize that response is missing the moment and the need entirely and as instant insulting attempt to decide step, the real issue, the staff's recommendations, also in this case came across as an exception given that the city has not in the past shied away from naming the harm inflicted on specific groups as it has done to address anti-semitism and anti-asian racism to name a few examples. We are specially troubled by the recommendation to strip out, explicit language, affirming the protected right to speech advocating for justice for palestine, and the palestinian people replacing it, with broad statements about political speech. Generally, their original recommendation was intentional. It responds to a real climate in which speech supporting palestinian justice has been uniquely. Stigmatized, child, and mischaracterized to remove that specificity including and very importantly, the word justice is to ignore the problem. The recommendation was designed to solve, likewise the response to recommendation for mischaracterized. What is actually being requested. We are not asking the city to create a separate or exclusive training program. Nor did we ignore the fact that the city already conducts atibiotics and anti-discrimination training? W specifically asked that the existing training include content addressing anti-palestinian racism and anti-muslim bias. We meant for this to also include anti-air racism as well. This is a common and reasonable approach in equity work. If a community says, please ensure anti-lgbtq plus bigotry is explicitly covered in your anti-base training. It would not be a meaningful response to simply say we already have training that avoids, the substance of the request. Our recommendation is about inclusion, relevance and ensuring that reported forms of bias. No matter the method of reporting or actually named and addressed refusing to incorporate specificity does not create neutrality. It leaves known harms on addressed which on its own is the opposite of neutrality is a repeat of the harms that this group has already endured. We are also disappointed by the recommendation that the city should take no meaningful steps. Regarding uc davis or djusd because they are separate jurisdictions. Thank you. Thank you. I will be. I will be continuing to read the report. Um, leadership often means convening urging collaborating and using moral authority. I recommendations ak simply for requests partnership and engagement, not control. W urge you not to accept a watered down substitute that transforms concrete recommendations into symbolic and vague gestures that do nothing to address this specific harms. We hope for you to address. We asked the council instead adopt the original human relations commission, recommendations I substance including explicit acknowledgment of anti-miscegenation and direction to engage djusd and uc davis. On this matter. This vote will will communicate far more than policy language. It will show whether communities, who come forward in pain are met with courage and care or with dilution and deflection, please choose courage. Um, sincerely deema tamimi, uh the commissioner, ellie, kaplan, another commissioner, and kevin baker, uh, commission co-chair. Thank you. hello. My name is rachel darling, and I'm the executive director of halal at davis in sacramento. Hello is a jewish student centered organization grounded in values of respect pluralism and dialogue. We actively support interfaith engagement, and serve on both the interfaith campus council and the university, religious council creating space for open and respectful conversation across the differences. Across differences is central to our mission. We were deeply concerned by the inclusion of helal in the mata report in connection with serious allegations of surveillance harassment and doxxing. In response, we promptly reached out to the hrc and the city council to request an opportunity to discuss these these allegations. Aside from mayor donald neville, we received no response. This lack of engagement from the hrc remains deeply concerning particularly given the seriousness of the allegations in hrc's stated purpose to promote mutual respect, understanding justice and human rights for all. The hrc fell short of its purpose by producing a flawed report that has exacerbated divisions in our community rather than bringing us together. And should not be adopted by city council. We remain. Ready and willing to engage in respectful, dialogue with muslim arab and palestinian students. And community members. We believe in building relationships, listening to 1, another and engaging across differences in meaningful and constructive ways. We are here and we are ready to engage. Thank you. Good evening, davis city council. My name is emily, and I am a student at uc davis representing aggies for israel, aggies, for israel. Is a uc davis student club. Dedicated to advocating for israel, and its right to exist. As a club, we support a 2-state solution and the rights of both israeli and palestinian civilians. As a club, we stand for peace, inclusion, and respect for all communities, regardless of their identity or background. We are disheartened by the students and community member statements of feeling unsafe or discriminated against we do not associate ourselves with this behavior nor supported by any means as a uc davis student. I too often feel, unsafe, both on campus, and in this community and I don't wish that feeling on anyone. As we work to move forward together afi is committed to upholding respectful, balanced dialogues ad strongly standing against any form of aggression or discrimination towards any members of our community. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, city council. My name is toby and I am a jewish student attending uc davis. I'm active in halal and aggies for israel. As a jewish student, I felt I have also felt unsafe on campus and within davis as a broader community, it is disappointing. And upsetting to know that & this is a shared experience regardless of your position. Afi does not in any way invalidate, the experiences of our fellow students and of davis residents aggies for israel is a

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Special Meeting
  • City Council Special Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: deec745b8bc9f7d26f496ee03852ace1. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record