POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Jan 16, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, January 16, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Jan 16, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 158,216 characters. The full document is at the source.

>>Good evening everybody. reporting back from closed session there's no reportable action. Now we'll begin our council meeting. So if anyone wishes to address the City Council on any item considered at this meeting before or during the council's consideration of that item, please fill out a blue speaker request form located in the light at alcoves in the back of the council chambers. And submitted up here to the city clerk the City Council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for each agenda item staff reports are available online at the city's website at City of reading.gov or in the public view binder located on the podium at the north side of the chambers if you could please silence your cell phones Thank you. New rolecall are now legible. Let's do the Pledge of Allegiance first. Do you have someone for the pledge? Are we just leading the okay. >>I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >>Our invocation is by Lynn Fritz from the Native American tradition as a correct tribal descendant Shasta County interfaith forum chair and Joey Carroll Native American flute. >>Yes, please stay standing. Together we take a long, slow, deep breath in a relaxing, exhale as we offer this prayer and blessing to Creator, the great spirit to grandfather sky, Grandmother Earth to all the two legged, four legged winged creatures, to the rocks and minerals to all the plant life and the life that fills our waterways and to the life giving energy of water itself. We offer this prayer, this blessing and the presence of our ancestors or teachers that we invite into the space of this gathering, honoring their leadership, their wisdom. Tonight, in this community, there's an environment of deep respect value for each one. open minds and open hearts so that each one feels a part of belonging to the city of Redding, to north state, to this community, for we are one people. We work for the betterment of all safety for our families, wellness and health to allow each one to thrive. I know that they'll dedication of our elected officials and staff have city of Redding. That is their mission, their goal to help Redding thrive. So we support that mission. We open to the discussions allowing for differences of perspectives and hearing each other with great respect. Even when we don't always agree. We give thanks. We give thanks for each one, even beyond this room. Join us through technology that join us in consciousness and we bless each one and all our relations. A whole Thank you You may be seated. >>[ ROLL CALL ] >>We will now have a presentation by emergent. >>Good evening, how are you all? Thank you for having me over here. Counselor, Audette counselors and staff appreciate you guys giving me some time. It was a couple of years ago that we came up here as emerged in 3d and presented this idea of concrete 3d printing homes. We had a slide presentation prepared but apparently we weren't able to get the technology working. So you all have hard copies, I believe and you can just flip through them as I'm talking but it was a couple of years ago we talked about this idea of concrete 3d printing of homes and and as a as a builder of you know, close to 40 years now I thought that that's looking like a good opportunity to perhaps save some costs and you know, regenerate an industry that's losing workers. For every five of me that's aging out of the industry, there's only one young person coming in. So the thought of automating was was attractive to me. So I brought it to, to our city into housing I approached Steve bade first and then we did a presentation that included Barry and some others and, and with the support of the city leadership, we actually brought the project to fruition, we submitted plans, we got them approved, I can proudly say that the city of Redding was the first jurisdiction in the state to approve a concrete 3d printed on side house and, and we were actually the first one in the state as well, that got one and completed and certificate of occupancy. So it's something that we can all be proud of as city and, and, and staff and for us as a company. And so what you got in your book there in your, in your pages are just some images of the finished home, we built a couple at the city parks that you know, we had a ribbon cutting there, several of you were there. And, and they came out, you know, pretty darn nice. And from what I understand there's people living in those as Park hosts at this time, which we've been hearing some great reports about. And then since then we started construction up at St. Mark's in partnership with access home, and they're going to house, some folks there. And we're about three quarters done with that project the printings all done. And really the beauty of that one is that we built the same house across the city six times. And so we were able to measure our improvement as we went. And for those of you that happen to come to the first one, I probably had 15 or so employees working out because I just didn't know what to expect. And you know, I'd rather have too many than not enough. By the second house, we had five employees by about the fourth or fifth house, we were down to four employees. So we were getting more efficient, the costs were starting to come down and, and our quality was going up on the first several homes, we, you know, while we were on our learning curve, we put skim coats over the finishes. And by the time we got done they access home is saying Oh, we love it, just how it is right out of the printhead. And again, it's all going speaking towards the quality and the efficiency and then ultimately, the cost savings. So it's been, you know, about a year or so that we've been under construction. As I said, we're still finishing up at up at St. Mark's with the four up there. And during this time, we've worked with the housing quite closely with the housing department here and with regular meetings with just ongoing conversation, and there has been some concerns along the way. And that's I you know, to be quite candid, there's there were concerns about the cost. I stood up here a couple years ago talking about, you know, potentially saving 20 to 30% by 3d printing these homes and, and I still stand by that we're just not there yet, we're getting better. As I said, we've reduced our, our labor by 20%, you know, going from five employees to four to do that type of project and getting more efficient with the other trades. There has been some concern about the print quality, again, making no excuses other than our learning curve. But as I said, it's they have gotten better. And then just this ongoing concern with our housing department of a lack of funding for doing more houses. And that's that will ultimately be the ask that we make of you tonight is to help us identify some some further sources of funding. So some of the exhibits that I have in that packet for you speak to those very items. The first one is in regards to the cost of construction to build those homes. And it might be a little hard to see again, I was hoping I could have had it on the screen. But there's a couple of spreadsheets there. The first one was the cost that we went in when we first started. And then by the time construction actually got going, the cost had gone up quite a bit. But as you'll see on the spreadsheet, there's some highlighted lines. And what you'll notice is the cost for 3d printing did not change from beginning to end. It was everything else it was the roofing and the electrical and the doors and the windows and every other line item. Because we were in a post COVID world still are and cost constructions quite high. And so we did all we could to keep that cost in check. In fact, I would I would take it down to the bottom of the page where, you know, part of our agreement early on with Steve and with housing was that we would do these projects at zero markup for profit and at a fixed cost on our just our overhead cost in exchange for the city helping provide some extra funding to cover the cost of this, you know, big equipment that we bought and so As you'll see that the overhead margin originally started out as a 10% item, but then when all those other costs went up, we kept that overhead cost, as a, as the previous static number, we didn't allow that to go up just because we had to pay more for, you know, roofing and electrical and things like that, that were out of our control. That that second image that you have there speaks to the quality and, and again, I, you know, Joe, commend to you, I think it's gonna come up and speak here in a bit as well. was really eager to do the ribbon cutting at the reg annato boat ramp, and I wasn't crazy about it to be honest, I, I thought we could have done better. And sure enough, we did later. But we did want to show the public what we did. And certainly if you were to go up to St. Mark's, you'd see a different, a different product. And I don't know if that image really does it well on what you have there. But the printed layers really came out beautiful and very consistent, very smooth and, and the less we have to touch it, and the less we have to skim coat and do other work, then not only does it look better, but it keeps the cost in check. The third, the third item that housing kept bringing up was this idea that we had an agreement together to do up to 24 homes and and that that's a little bit of a longer story. And I know I don't have that much time. But when when this whole conversation first started, I had I had talked to you know, Steve bade actually, Steve and I go quite bad if I could say he and I went to same church together for probably 10 or 12 years. And so we just knew each other personally. So I saw what Katie was out there doing. I said, Hey, Steve, can I buy a lunch? Just tell me how does this work? What can we do? And so we started dreaming a little bit like, what can we do, and we talked about, I told him about this technology and how I wanted to bring it here and train a new generation of workforce and, and he said, You know what we if we come up with a good project, we can find a way to help you buy that machine helped make that happen. I said, That'd be wonderful. If you help me do that, then, you know, I will do these at my cost, you know, with without the markup. And so that's what that was what we did. And ultimately, as contracts started getting drawn up, they were quite convoluted because it included the city of Redding access home, Donna Jamin, construction, emergent 3d. And some of the projects had 20 year covenants, and it just got very detailed, it didn't make sense to have us all in it. So ultimately, when contracts went, kept getting revised, Donna Jamin construction and emergent was no longer a party to the contract, it only ended up between the city of Redding and access home. What I was told later is that, because I'm not privy to it to the contract, what I was told later is that the wording even got changed to say up to 24 homes, but I can tell you my comment to, to housing and to Steve and all was that, based on the strength of a contract, I can go get a loan and buy that printer. And so certainly, that's what I did. And then I come to find out later it was up to so I'm hoping we find a way to do more, because I still have quite a loan to pay off on that on that printer, by the way. So anything you guys can do to help there. And then lastly, I would just ask, and I know, funds are tight everywhere. But we have a housing department and we need housing. And we need housing across the board, not just pallet shelters, and not just the you know, the bigger, nicer, you know, step up homes. We need housing across the board to just you know, loosen up the the housing market know and allow housing for people that need it. And so whatever can be done to help us and help our community, provide more housing and do it in this way while we're training up this new workforce. And while we're bringing this technology would be would be very much appreciated. I can tell you that. As a company and as a community. We're getting worldwide recognition what's being done right here and reading with this printer is making news. If you're following concrete 3d printing, which I'm certain none of you are, but it for those that do follow it are really amazed at what we're doing here. They want to know how did we get it approved through our building department. And they're looking at us as a model. There's a gentleman in the industry, one of the probably the key spokesman in the industry just recently provided a power ranking what he called the power ranking of the concrete 3d printing industry. And it included not only companies like ours that execute this type of work, but also the manufacturers As the material suppliers, and emergent 3d out of 500 companies, emergent 3d came in fifth, fifth in the world in this industry, and it started right here in Redding. So more than anything, I wanted to give you guys the update the good news, and to say thank you like this could not have been done without you guys, several of you counselors were part of that approval we got a couple years ago. So thank you for that. And, and I'm just going to say we still have more work to do. So anything you could do to help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you. Is there any questions before I step off? >>I'll just say done. I am one of your followers. And thank you for what you're doing. I am watching. And so I saw that that recent award come out. It's pretty exciting. Thank you for being brave and stepping into that space. >>Thank you. >>I was at the first one. And I was impressed. The question I have at the moment is what's the lead time for printing? And building versus stick belt? >>You mean, what's the overall schedule to get it done? >>Or can you can you build a 3d printed home quicker than you can build it? >>Yes,We could save on the time, we could save a month or even two. And part of that is because we've gotten better at the layer quality and at the job we do. When we extrude our material for our walls. If we did a good enough job, we don't have to come back and skim coat over it. So it doesn't require the added time and labor of stucco. And it doesn't add added time and labor of drywall on the inside. And that's where a lot of the savings is. I think that it's important that we consider that certainly, we know there's a shortage of housing and reading, right, we're trying to fill our business park, and anybody that comes here that wants to do a business wants to know where their employees are gonna live. And to make an affordable project like this become a reality that we got to be a part of, I think is exciting. And sure we got to do it, we can build more of them, please, you can do it quicker. And that's what we need. Thank you. >>Thank you. >>Thanks, Tom. >>All right.Thank you. All right. >>Joe, committee, would you like to? >>Thank you, I really appreciate what you guys do. And you know that I mean that from my heart, that I really appreciate what you do. So thank you for these few minutes. Thank you for having the courage to be first in in this type of technology. And I just want to emphasize how important it is the disaster resistance, the climate resilience, the energy efficiency, I mean, this is a whole new way to build and a whole new way to live. And I think it's such a really cool on point concept. And we're introducing a whole new generation to this type of construction. And as Don mentioned, there aren't a lot of young people coming into the trades. And that's something near and dear to my heart. Because as you know, prior to a previous job I had I ran the Builders Exchange, and the trade school. And I think it's so important to bring in that next generation of construction workers. And it was so much fun to watch these jobs. Because these these young people were running around, nobody had a tool belt, there was no powers, no power saw there was no cords, it was a whole different way to build. And ultimately, you could build three or four houses from one location with multiple computers on multiple screens. So this is really what we need to do to get this next generation excited about construction. Because we still want to live in homes, we're still going to need people to build them. And I think this is really exciting. And I can't emphasize enough how proud I am that that Redding, Shasta County was the place where this happened. And I tell that all the time, because we know there's a lot of things going on in Chester County, and I'm not going down that road at all. But this is such good news. And it's so uplifting for our community. And it speaks so loudly to this administration and this staff, they had the courage to do that. And it's also ties into the housing spectrum. I want to give a shout out. I think the Evaluation Center, the Resource Center, navigation center, whatever you want to call it. I think it's a brilliant idea. It's going to there's going to be trials and tribulations as you know, but I think it's absolutely the right thing to do. Pilot shelters. I think that's another brilliant thing to do. This type of technology allows you to build those types of units, and they'll last a lot longer. We designed a concept for the mayor of Denver, where we could print seven single units in one printer setup and the cost was phenomenal and the ability To clean these things, and to keep them durable and long lasting, so they don't become bladed, we can also lift them up and move them. So I think that's a piece where this technology works. And it also allows us to build a whole housing spectrum, because you get them in the evaluation center, you get them in Pallet shelters, you move into transitional housing, then we have to move him into permanent housing. And ultimately, we have to move them into a home they can afford. Because that's really where the real value in America comes from, that net worth that you can generate, because you now own a home. And this type of technology allows us to do that. So I really, I really think we need your support. And I know I know all of you, most all of you personally, I know your heads are out, I know your commitment to our community, I think this is such an important thing for us to do. And then also in my last minute editorial, we have a housing shortage. And the county is not focused on doing this. And I don't know if and when they'll be focused on doing this. So my ask to you is if I can ask you leaders to step up and say we'll do it, we'll make sure we have a relationship with the county, we'll make sure we have access to the funds that come into this community to make sure they stay in this community, and they build the houses that our community needs. So again, thank you very much. >>Councilmember? >>Joe, that's so fast you could get away. >>I have just one question for you Sir. >>Sure. >> How does the insurance play in because of our area being wildland fire? susceptible? How does the insurance play into this, >>We're working on that. We're working with an institute the the Insurance Institute for business and home safety, and they're actually a watchdog for the insurance companies. And they are funded by insurance companies to to find the technologies that will help reduce risks mitigate their risk, as we know, that's what insurance companies are all about. So we are in communication with them have been in communication with them, we will probably bring them to one of the St. Mark's house and have them get certified. It's a long arduous process, especially when you're dealing with insurance companies. But that's something we absolutely have to do, because it's very difficult for people who are rebuilding. And we saw this in paradise. And we've seen it up in Keswick. They can't get insurance if if in fact they can afford to build the home. They can't afford to insure it. And that is just wrong on so many levels. So this technology really plays to supporting that and making them more affordable and making them insurable. But that is a behemoth bureaucracy, as you all know, and it will take some time to do it. But we are focused on that. Certainly, I'm focused on >>Thank you. Thank you. >>Sure. >>And that one more question. For Travis, I see you out there in the audience. Can I ask you a question? You want to come up for a minute? Thank you, Joe. >>Sure. Thank you guys. >>So we're staffing these homes with Park host. How's that going? What do you hear? >>So we have the first park host. It's a set of two people, they are at the bottom of the boat ramp. And there are some kind of growing pains with that somewhat customization to the new housing and getting you know, they have roommates now, so that one is done and working. And the park staff gets along with them. Great. They have duties sort of in that area. And we've already seen a good change there. The Enterprise one, we're still working on that to be able to fill that. So you think we did the right thing? Yeah, I think so. I think having a presence on the at those sites is very, very helpful. Especially once we get into enterprise being in North Park host duties include reservations, things like that, helping out that and it's just nice to have a presence in those large sites. >>Thank you very much. Thank you, Mayor. >>Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Dan. Thanks, Joe. Okay, we are going to move to public comment. Pursuant to the Brown Act, city council cannot take action on public comment items. The city council will allocate up to a maximum of 30 minutes, three minutes per speaker for 30 minutes total. At the beginning of the meeting for public comment for non agenda as matters within the city's jurisdiction. The mayor will determine the order of speakers. If 30 minutes is not adequate to accommodate all the individuals who have submitted a speaker request form to the city clerk the council will trail this item to the end of the open session agenda. The remaining speakers will address the city council at that time. Okay. All right. So Dr. Rick Penner, Alex Galecki, Jerry Garci and Susan Weiss >>Thank you very much, members of the council and staff for giving me the opportunity to speak to you. I'm 76 years old, retired here in Redding about 13, 14 years ago, and have served all my life as a pastor and as denominational executive. And as a consultant. In the course of all those activities, I've had the opportunity to travel a fair bit overseas, as well as in North America. And one of my particular delights has been to travel many, many times to Israel. And I've taken several 100 people over the years to join me over there on tours, including probably about 150 from Redding in the last few years. I'm very proud to say that some of my close friends are Jewish. And I'm also proud to say that some of my good friends over there are Palestinian. One of the things that motivates me to be here tonight, is not only what I've just said, and my passion for Israel, and my great grief at the destruction and the loss of life that's happening on Gaza. Another motivation is that my own maternal grandfather was once a mayor, also, in a little village, in what is today Ukraine, you've probably heard of these places in recent months, Zopa, Rosa napro, that's where my roots are. And someone tipped my grandfather off one day and said, the Bolsheviks are coming for you. You're on their list, and you will be executed unless you flee immediately. And I guess I'm here because he was successful in leaving. So why do I share these things with you? As I've already suggested, I have a very strong concern for what's going on in the Middle East. And I'm here as just as a private citizen. And I want to suggest to the council, that you consider adopting a resolution, a resolution that speaks of Israel's right to defend itself, to protect its citizenry, a resolution that deplores the terrible loss of life on both the Gaza side, the Palestinian side and the Israeli side. And I have several samples of resolutions that one of them comes from the United States Senate, and another one comes from one of the states. And it's still another comes from one of the American cities. And I'll be happy to leave that with staff, if that's appropriate. And I would like to ask you to consider not for tonight, of course, but maybe in the next meeting, to approve a resolution that would state these kinds of expressions of support. The second thing I want to mention is that the Israeli consulate in San Francisco, has assured me that if the civic leaders and the law enforcement and educators at the city of Redding would have an interest, they can provide a 43 minute video that shows the atrocities of October 7. And what you need to do if you wish to proceed with this is to ask me, and I can make those arrangements. So thank you very much for hearing this opportunity. Would you like me to leave these resolution drafts? >>Oh, it'd be great. We would appreciate it. >>Thank you very much. >>Thank you. Alex, Bielecki, Jerry, Jerry Garcia, Susan Weiss. >>Good afternoon, evening, everybody. I normally go off topic, but things don't ever seem to get that way. It all touches us. What I'm here now for is to talk about food for the homeless. And then housing. Well, you guys already did your gig on housing and tell the truth. Putting yourself or putting in reading and putting a quote unquote project, kinda like Harlem. In Redding downtown reading is dangerous and does pose a threat to human life. Why? Crime? Why? Because they can lie because they're on drugs. Why are there food problems? Food shortages. You don't get the things you want to store. And sometimes you don't even get the right medicines. Everything has to do with our southern border. I know. But it's real simple. The homeless here in this county. This State should be fed first. They're not. It's gifted away. Seems like it happened because of politicians. And people just selling out. selling out sounds cool. I don't think so. But when you get your chance to vote, please vote. Okay. And don't let anybody tell you get in their face. Because that's a crime. It was at the beginning. And the Vice President was real simple. And to us crime to win a politician's election is more selection. Thank you. >>Thanks. Jerry Garci, Susan Weiss, and Carl. >>Thank you, council members for this time. I'm here to support Mrs. Catherine McDonald regarding challenging council members violating the Brown Act. I was hoping she was going to go first because I was to follow up. But since I'm not, I'm not going to address the Brown Act or her issue. But I'm here to address another issue, which was before the council members in March of last year, which I believe another code violation was denied a violation which denied my legal right. So Bethells amendment went before the council and ended in a tie vote. That means there was no decision. Therefore, it reverted back to the planning commission Planning Commission's approval. Because there was no decision by the council, I again filed an appeal against Bethells amendment under the reading Municipal Code 18 point 11.090. So the city denied my claim or my appeal claiming that the reading municipal code does not allow for another appeal. That was Mr. DeWalt. And I asked him to show me in the reading Municipal Code where it stays that stated that Mr. DeWalt said, well, it doesn't state that, but I believe he can't. So I replied and said he shouldn't be deciding issues that doesn't exist in the city council should consider the reading municipal code. And the Redding minute Municipal Code allows for me to file the appeal. So I'm asking the council to allow me to move forward, five might file my appeal, subject to and in compliance with the reading Municipal Code. Thank you. >>Thank you, Jerry, Susan Weiss, Carl, pipe >>Hi, I'm Susan. Winter. And I'm here to address the homeless issue. Once again, I've come to you several times about this issue. I've been working for well over a year, educating myself about all of the issues I've been in Continuum of Care for over a year and I've been faithfully attending their meetings. I feel like I'm a citizen. I'm fairly well informed about all the agencies what they do and what the council in the county has done. I'm very disappointed that the county gave up lead agency, very disappointed, but I think it's in better hands with the city. And I really appreciate the city taking on the lead agency for the continuum of care. And I know it's it's a heavy lift for you. But I do want to address the ability for you in this process to take in community genuine community input. We have a lot of people in this community with whom I work that are very concerned, very interested in helping you help the homeless when you adopted the at home plan, the plan was put out by California counties to put the ability to handle the homeless issues back into the county's laps which I think is a good idea. But on your sheet that I got the first meeting the at home plan meeting where you came and reported out to the public what you were doing, it said, the plan is designed to be a collaborative effort that recognize that local officials understand local challenges, and are best equipped to develop local solutions that work for their residents. The plan allows for the development of a collaborative local plan to address homelessness. I don't feel like the way it's gone so far is collaborative. I went to the first meeting that the at home Advisory Committee reported out to the public, there was no as far as I could see any advertising about it, it was very poorly attended by the public because nobody knew about it. I went to the meeting and heard what the report was, from the group from the ad home group from the city and from all the agencies in the county. Is that the three of hearts Oh, hurry, but then I heard there was a second meeting last week. And I had I didn't hear about it. And I talked to three other people in the continuum of care that didn't hear about the meeting, which I was disappointed about. And then I went in your website, it didn't have any minutes of the meeting. It didn't tell when the next meeting was it had the agenda. And all I'm saying to you is you have a very engaged public who wants to help and you need to to elicit their support and their ideas and make them feel more valuable. >>Thank you, Susan. I will I can provide you the dates for the next three meetings. Carl Peploe and Catherine McDonald. >>Good evening. I'm Carl people. I've spent 20 years in the military PCs on 60 ships. I've been to the Middle East twice. And not just on ships. I've read the Koran. I've read the Bible because I am a Christian who my Lord and God is the Lord Jesus Christ or in his native language, Yeshua HaMashiach. I've known many Jews, I've known many Arabs. I have Seen the barbaric atrocities that Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis. Finance right now, through Iran, even by our current sitting president are doing or have done. Have friends even now in the Middle East. And not all of them are even Jewish. I strongly would like for the council to look at those proposals for a resolution in support of Israel defending its nation against the Palestinian Authority. Who have you read their charter and Hamas and Hezbollah. They have in writing proclaimed, they want every single Jewish man, woman and child in the Middle East dead. That is their goal. Israel is a fight for us not only his life as a nation, but his very existence as a people. Why won't they let the people out of the Gaza Strip as Egypt? Look at its southern border. Israel is the only army in the world that fights a war telling the enemy ahead of time where they're going to bomb and when tells the enemy Well, we're not going to bomb here because we think there's civilians here. So where do you think the terrorists Where do you think those holding 136 prisoners kidnapped from Israel on October 7 are doing this war would be over today right now. If Hamas and Hezbollah and the rest of the terrorist organizations that want every Jewish person dead, what surrendered give back those 136 hostages and a couple of them are also American citizens. So I would like to plead with you to look at what's happening. And if they can't if the city council is interested, I have a list of truthful information sources for you to consider of what's going on. >>Thanks Carl. I appreciate it. I'm Katherine McDonald >>So, some of you may know that I submitted a brand Brown at complaint against Mara debt and vice mayor winters and Mayor Pro Tem Munns for the vote for Miss Audette and Ms. Weiner to serve as mayor and vice mayor mayor at the December 5 council meeting. The Brown Act prohibits majority of the council from making a decision on a matter that is to be decided in a public meeting before that meeting. My complaint cites two pieces of evidence. The first is that Mr. Munns stated before the vote for mayor and vice mayor, we're doing what we think is right. Meaning that he knew before the council meeting, how the vote would go. My second piece of evidence that the Brown Act was violated is that Miss zodat submitted a financial forum to the state in October, identifying herself as the mayor of revenue Redding. This was a full two months before she was selected as mayor. Because of these violations of the Brown Act. I request that the council avoid as expensive litigation and cost to the taxpayers by rescinding the December votes for Miss Audette as mayor and Ms. Winter as Vice Mayor and hold a new vote for mayor and vice mayor. I ask that the council follow the traditional practice and vote for the previous Vice Mayor Mark Manzano to become Redding's new mayor. On a more positive note, my niece is the Mendez CIP Mendocino County Sheriff's manager and she told me that our new city attorney is a big loss for Mendocino County in a big game for Redding >>Thank you, Catherine. We'll now move to the consent calendar. The consent calendar contains items considered routine and are which have been individually scrutinized by city council members and are anticipated to require no further deliberation. If a member of the public wishes to address an item on the consent calendar, please fill out a speaker request form and submit it to the city clerk before the consent calendar is considered. It shall be the prerogative of any council member before the consent calendar is acted upon to one comment on an item to respond to any public comment on an item three requests to record reflect and abstention or nay vote on an item or four remove an item and place it on the regular portion of the agenda for delivery of a staff report and or extended discussion or deliberation. Does anyone wish to remove something from the Vice Mayor winter? >>Thank you. Yes. Thank you, Mayor. I would like to remove 4.1 A about Bill, a bill that we're looking at Senate Bill 76 in depth so that would become 9.1. A Thank you. Otherwise, I'm happy to make a motion to approve. >>Councilmember Dacquisto? >>Want to state for the record? I'm voting no. And I don't 4.6 A that's further funds for South City Park and I've been opposed to spending the money on it. So to be consistent, I'm voting no one 4.6 A >>Anyone else? Okay, we'll remove 4.1. >>And I made a motion. >>Second. >>All in favor? >>Aye. >>Any opposed? Okay. We'll move to 5.1 which is the consider the reappointment to the city of Redding administrative hearing board. I read that or do you want to? Okay. Well, recommendation is to approve my recommendation to reappoint Kelly capital to the city's administrative hearing board to serve an additional four year term effective February 1 2024. And expiring January 31 2028. Is Kelly here. Okay, well, God bless you and thank you for agreeing to serve again. >>Yeah, I'm happy to make a motion to approve 5.11. >>AnyoneWant to second that? >>I'll Second. >>All in favor? >>Aye. >>Any opposed? That passes unanimously. We will move to 9 A which is the City Council liaison assignments for calendar year 2024. This is informational. And do you want to? >>Yeah, this is just information that happens every year and that is the council liaison assignments. So one of the duties of mayors is to assign the liaisons. And liaison assignments consists of council members who will meet on a more regular basis with certain departments, or it includes membership on certain boards or commissions that the council is required to sit upon. And so there's no vote necessary. This is just a political item for your sharing to the public. And with that, I would recommend that you just acknowledge and move on. >>So Acknowledged. All right. 9, do we do 9B right? Yes, nine be considered reports from independent auditors for the year ended? June 30 2023. Do we have a right? >>Ourfinance director Greg Robinette will present this and then also, Mayor, if it's okay, we'll bring 910 a forward. And he'll be able to present that at the same time and get both of them accomplished at this time. That sounds great. Great. Thank you. >>Good evening, Mayor, council citizens. I will be honest, I'm not used to having such full room when I present such revenue topics like our financial statements or budget updates. So I'm excited to have you all here. And I'm going to assume you're here for me tonight. So I'm going to start off saving the thank yous, but acknowledging how much hard work goes into this document and where we're at, as a city with our financial information. And I hope that the presentation, while it tries to boils our boil hours and hours of work into maybe 10 minutes and 15 to 20 slides, I will at the end express my gratitude to those that need that gratitude. And I don't think it will be enough. And I hope everybody realizes that. So I'm gonna do my best. And I this is also a lot of dense information to try to present in this type of setting. And I'm gonna do my best to hopefully unpack it in a way that makes sense for everybody. So with that I always like to start with where does this report stand in the broader context of the information that we present to council. So the three major topics our budget or biennial budget, council budget updates, and then this report, which is the annual comprehensive financial report. So the biennial budget is always forward looking. So we're projecting revenues and expenditure needs. we're allocating revenues to create the expenditure plan, and we only modify this through Council action. The council budget updates, these are one of the opportunities for council to potentially make Council action to modify the budget. It also gives us an opportunity to measure actual performance with revenues and expenses against our projections that we did during the biennial budget. And as stated there, we do quarterly and mid year updates for council. Then this document, arguably one of the most important documents, it's our year end financial statements follows certain accounting principles which are very different than the budget, the budget is pretty much a cash basis of budgeting. Whereas the annual comprehensive financial report actually uses multiple bases of accounting depending on the page you're on. And it's pretty complex, but it follows general accepted accounting principles, governmental accounting, Standard Board requirements, in order to be consistent with the way all governments present their financial information. So this provides accountability and reporting consistency. Think about bond agencies, they really liked this report because it lets them know our financial financial picture clearly and similarly to any other government they might be looking at. So how is the annual comprehensive financial report comprised? So I kind of break it into three major sections. There's the introductory section, this is not audited by our auditors. So in a couple slides, I'll get into the opinions that our auditors have of our financial statements, but this section is not audited by them. This includes the transmittal letter, the certificate of achievement and excellence in financial reporting. I'll get into that in just a minute, our org chart or directory of city officials and some informational information. The next section this is the meat and potatoes is going to fill you up with dinner and you'll spend a lot of time reading this has the independent auditors report. It has what we call MDNA or management discussion and analysis spoiler if you have not a lot of time to try to understand this document, read that section. That is not audited, but it provides a lot of good useful information and helps you break down what you're seeing in the financial report. Then you move into the government wide financial statements are fun financial statements, notes to the financial statements. There's some required supplementary information which is also unedited, and then supplementary information as well. Then there's this statistical section, I'd say if you want to learn a little bit about what's going on with our government and our city. Flip to this section of the book, you'll have financial trends revenue capacity, debt capacity, demographic and economic information as well some operating information from a major funds and departments. So overall, a quick summary of our audit and the results of the ACC first annual comprehensive financial report, we received an unmodified opinion from CLA Clifton Larson Allen. And this was our first year with them as our audit partners. There was no findings or concerns noted in the reports or communications from CLA and an update, we received on our last five fiscal year, that Certificate of Excellence in financial reporting from GFO A, which is the Government Finance Officers Association for the 39th straight year, I think this speaks to the culture we have in our finance department that goes back many, many years. I will age myself, that's longer than I've been alive, we have received that award. And so it's pretty impressive when you think about all the people that have come through our department in that time, and the commitment we've had for a long time as a city to make sure that our financial information is accurately reported. And I think it shows our commitment to transparency as well. Additional audit information, there's a UCC 260 letter, this is a letter to those charged with governance. And there were no material findings discovered no significant deficiencies or material weaknesses in internal controls, no accounting issues, accounting principles were consistently applied. No disagreements with management. And then the last item, there's this the single audit, which is basically our information about how we expended federal grant funds, and then our passenger facilities program, which is for our municipal airport. And then the independent auditors report also included no material findings or deficiencies. So this is all a lot of information to say our audit went great. And the auditors were happy with how everything came together, they did express as much to the audit committee, and we're very pleased with our financial reporting for this fiscal year. So one quick note, we implemented one new Gatsby this year. The acronym everybody likes to use, which is kind of funny sounding is a spitta. So it's a subscription based information technology arrangement. In 2023, this is almost everything we do. We are implementing a new system right now we went live on July 1, with our new oracle system. That's an example of a spitta. So almost everything we enter into nowadays seems to be a spitta. And I will say Tammy man, our finance officer, who bears a lot of weight for this entire document, bared a lot of weight implementing this new Gatsby standard. And we're pretty happy with getting that implemented and accurately in from London, and our auditors were happy. So now I get into the information that can be kind of challenging, and I'm going to go as quick as I possibly can. But there's a lot of information on these slides. I will note right at the beginning, there's no way you're gonna be able to read that in the back of the room. But all of these numbers are in millions. And so I tend to try to focus on high level topics. This first slide is government wide. So this this slide is in what we call accrual basis of accounting. It's fully accrual, which is different than other bases that I'll get into in a couple of slides as we get into the general fund, which is modified accrual. So on this slide that probably the area that I would point out and I'm I do have some more slides later on to talk about in more depth is increases to our pension liability. And the associated deferred inflows and deferred outflows are the biggest changes that you'll see on this chart. That's the kind of the second set of graphs you see that deferred outflows bar, jumping up almost double, that's mostly the result of the changes in that are associated to the net pension liability, which the third set of bars there is the net pension liability jumping up year over year. And I'll get into some of those details as to why in a couple of slides. And then deferred inflows dropping is also associated with that same issue. So this is a' statement of activities. Think about this as your revenues versus your expenses. As you can see, our revenues and expenses were up. Most of that is the result of kind of planned one time or grant type expenditures and revenues. I will also no a major item that happened in this fiscal year that we're presenting tonight was in the fall of 2022. We had a pretty major electrical issue I actually some areas of the state lost power, and there were some increased costs to providing power in that period. So we have some increased wholesale purchases costs and increased wholesale sale power sales costs, included in the numbers as well. And as you can see, our grants that we received, year over year went up almost $45 million year over year. So that explains why that kind of lighter blue second line went up and the expense graph went up, as well. So now, that probably the area and our government gets the most focus, and it's, I say it's largely because the revenue streams in here have a lot of demands. And a lot of important services that we provide is the general fund. So our general fund balance sheet, as you can see their assets went down year over year, that's mostly the result of cash going down that's associated with our ARPA, planned expenditures that went down year over year. I will also point out that this is a good time to point out the difference between modified accrual and full accrual. That second set of graphs there is the liabilities. And on the previous slide, I told I told everybody, Hey, our liabilities went up because a pension liability and then here it's going down. Well, that's because this is a modified accrual, meaning Gatsby, the requirements of Gatsby 68 are not applied on the general fund because it's a modified accrual. So this next graph can be kind of confusing. If you want the bottom line, it's all the set of graphs all the way over there on the right is kind of the bottom line. The first set of graphs is our revenues. Second is our expenditures. The third is our transfers, then you have proceeds from long term debt, you have some other items and the financing sources and uses. All at all our, our basically, our expenses were greater than all of our revenue sources by about $2 million. The bulk of that was due to our revenues went fell below projections in this fiscal year. And we've updated counsel on that multiple times. It was two and a half $3 million worth of revenues below our projections. And so we try, I mean, the goal with general fund is to manage it to effectively zero so that you know you're maximizing your planned expenditures with your planned revenues. That's not always the case, a lot of times you're using reserves in order to do one time capital expenses. That's part of what was driving this number. This year, we knew we were going to be spending out of some of our reserves to get some things done, but also our revenues came in below projections. So this graph, I personally find this graph to be some of the most interesting graph because it kind of tries to take what's happened over the past five years. And look at what's what what did we forecast and our biennial budget happened in the next two years. And so the graph on the left is our revenues. And I think the first thing that jumps out to me is sales. The first the line on the very top is sales tax. And you can see, sales tax dropped last year. And that was the biggest portion of the revenue decrease, as I mentioned on the previous slide, and then you can see our forecasts there. Looking into the future at that we expect it to kind of normalize back on to a two and a half percent per year increase. We have seen sales tax revenues below our projections year to date. We just got our property taxes, it is above projections, we're still trying to figure out exactly how much and what we're going to bring an update on all of this information, a budget year to date on February 20. To council that will include the mid year update any requests for budget modifications from the department, but more in depth analysis of kind of what's happened here today. It will come at that time. On the right side there. I think the probably the biggest question that stands out or stood out to me and I'll talk about real quick was the police bar. So police looks like well, we spent more money last year than we're planning on spending next year. And the major reason for that is grants. There's also some other one time things in there such as rolling stock, where we don't budget for that expenditure in the year, it's going to happen when it happens. And they we have a rolling stock fund where the money is stored and then moved out of as we plan to expend that money. So we had some rollingstock expenditures that year, or last year that we're not planning for necessarily in the in the next year. So that's why you kind of appears like we're going to be spending less not actually planning to spend less. And I think that was well outlined during our budget workshops with counsel in the spring. So getting into some key financial trends and indicators. First, general fund as unassigned fund balance, I first always like to point out this is not cash. It's similar, but it's not cash. It's fun balance. So it actually includes more than what our cash number, but it is a useful metric that's used by governments to try to assess kind of the health of their general fund. And so typically, they want you to have three months of expenditures. Well, the first thing I always like to point out is three months of expenditures, depending on the year that you're going to look at it could be very different. And so you know last year particularly that includes some ARPA money that was being expended out of there, so it makes it look like our ratios lower. And also our fund balance did decrease a little bit, as I mentioned a couple slides ago. I think it's useful to look at it over five years because it's it can show you useful trends or indicators. But at the end of the day, this conversation of where our fund balances are where in our case, we talked about it as cash balance during our budget development is occurs during all of our budget meetings, we update counsel on the cash balance. And at this time, we expect our cash balance to be right on target with what we projected during the biennial budget. net cost of services. Another useful indicator, if you could manage this perfectly, you would try to have it hit 100% Every year, I think it's useful to look at it for multiple years to see if it's bouncing around, or if there's a certain trend that's happening. In this case, you can see we've had some years up over 100%, we've had some years even lower than the current year. But the net cost of services takes into account you have some timing issues with grants when you expend them versus receive them. And then you also have some timing issues of when you're planning on doing a certain project. And that will factor into increasing or decreasing your net cost of services, and then potential and then you analyze it relative to your tax available tax revenues to determine that percentage. So now into the item that I kind of foreshadowed earlier talking about pension liabilities and o peb. As you can see here, the first graph is our CalPERS miscellaneous plan. The second graph is our CalPERS safety plan. The third is the pars plan. And the last one is our O peb, which is our Other Post Employment Benefits costs. So CalPERS probably about a year ago tonight, I was telling everybody when it drops so significantly that this is coming, we are going to go back up, because I knew at that time what was in the forecast. And so basically reason it went down so significantly was because of larger than expected gains on their assets, they made 21% In fiscal year 2021. And they made negative 6.8% In fiscal year 2122. So the large increases caused them to actually structurally lower the discount rate. It's a policy that PERS passed. So that's part also adding to the increase to the pension liability on the CalPERS side. I also want to point out, this can be kind of confusing because there's three dates mentioned throughout the document when you're talking about pension liabilities and o peb. Liabilities, you have your measurement date, your your valuation date, your measurement date, and your reporting date. So the reporting date is June 30 2023. The measurement date of all of each of four of these is June 30 2022. It's the valuation date that changes so for the CalPERS plans evaluation is six June 3021. They use standard roll forward procedures in order to measure the net pension liability as of Jun 3022. Pars had a valuation date of June 30 2022 has we're we got an updated valuation in coordination with our biennial budget. And the OPA valuation was from June 30 2021. And also use standard roll forward procedures. So this is the important part of this, in my opinion, for council as decision makers is how are we planning to make our pension liability payments. And this is something on the next slide, you're definitely not gonna be able to read this. But we talked about this thoroughly during our budget workshops. But this is our this is a snippet out of our 10 year plan that was adopted by council in June of 2023. And it shows the highlighted area is our pension liability payments plan for all 10 years of the financial plan. So while that number, it's big, and it's scary, and I don't want to pretend it's not. I just want to point out that we have a plan that balanced and accounts for all of the payments required to pay off that unfunded liability at the appropriate time, as required by CalPERS. And finally, this can even be a little scarier. The sensitivity analysis is a useful way to measure if there were changes in the discount rate, what would happen to the pension liability? So there's the current discount rate is in the middle that on the left is or the group of numbers indicating if they decreased the discount rate from 7% to 6%. And the numbers on the right where if they increased the discount rate from 7% to 8%. I don't think the numbers on the right are very likely. I think many people believe the numbers on the left are maybe more reflective of what could happen. But overall it would have an impact on our pension liability if they were to Deke decrease the discount rate. And with that, I will say my thank yous First of all, I want to thank the audit committee, we had a great conversation during our audit committee meeting, I thought you asked wonderful questions. And I thought it was very insightful. But I also want to thank the finance department, we have a lot of hard working people. And this year has been a true test with implementing a new financial system, navigating an audit and a budget. And you don't get this kind of work done without having a lot of really good people in our department. And Tammy is in the audience. And there's a bunch of them at home right now. And so I want to thank her because she's here. But I also want to thank the entire finance department, for their dedication to this city in this financial information every day, to produce a report that we expect to get the GFO a award for the 43 year. And with that, I'm available for any questions, >>Councilmember Maisano? >>Great report. I'm working my way through this book. Look, if I was an accountant, I would understand all of that. But I'm not. So let me ask you this question. Are we bringing in enough money to keep all the cops we've hired? >>Yeah, I mean, Barry's gonna jump on. I see him moving. So do you want me to try to answer the question? >>There's two parts. Okay. Let's not forget, I say cost because I was one. But the police that we've worked so hard to get without raising taxes, and that third firefighter on every truck. How are we doing Barry? >>Well, today, we're paying for it, you have a budget, you develop one year from now. And that's when you will make those determinations for the next two years. >>Thanks. >>Councilmember or Mayor Pro Temp Munns? >>Call me whatever you want. It you know, I have been in your office few times, and I enjoy your conversations. And every single time I go in there, there's nobody jaw jacking around those. Those ladies have their heads down. They're working hard. You can you have this man stand up so we can give her some recognition. >>She doesn't she's not going to want to. >>But I see how hard she worked whenever I go in there. The whole staff does a great job. And when she's here, it sure would be nice to just recognize her and all of your staff. And you as well, because I know you're a hard Worker. >>I can tell you. The finance department is full of people that don't want that recognition. And they come in and do their job. And they're happy to do it. And Tammy is an example that you basically had to force her to stand up. So, >>Vice Mayor Winter? >>The mayor and I were part of the audit committee. And I too want to commend you, Director, Robinette, as well as all of your staff for the hard work it was it's a incredibly complex document. And the staff put in a lot of work to that. I also would like to for those of you who obviously weren't able to attend, we have a new accounting firm that did actually audited us. And they they commented how impressed they were with the quality of data and reporting that the city provided them. So it was it's a beautiful to get a clean, clean opinion. So I want to thank you for that and also acknowledged your certificate, another year of Certificate of Excellence that's hard to get and the audit committee said they had never heard of another city that received that so many times. So in light that I do want to I do want to ask you a few questions that I had highlighted in in the book if that's the book, actually. So on page 17, there's discussion about this is in the management discussion analysis about the general fund. And you. You mentioned this briefly, but basically, we are our general fund balance decreased by 2.2 million during the year ending June 30 2023. And you had said that was primarily due to loss of revenue was that sort of, I guess it wouldn't have been expected. But did you see that happening throughout the year? >>We Yeah, I think Council definitely knows the knows that we were reporting every quarter to council last year. And you know, me having been given I've been given these presentations on a cou

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Jan 16, 2024 6:00 PM - Redding City Council - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: dea6a8eaba3967a1c90710e802c023f5. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record