POLISCOPE

The public record

OAKLEY (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Oct 22, 2019 - 06:32 PM

Tuesday, October 22, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Oct 22, 2019 - 06:32 PM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 111,634 stored characters

[ROLL CALL] >> I LIKE TO CALL UP FERNANDO FLORES. FERNANDO IS A THIRD GRADER AND ENJOYS PLAYING FOOTBALL [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] HIS FAVORITE BOOKS ARE GOOSE BUMPS AND LOVES SCHOOL. HIS FAVORITE SUBJECT IN SCHOOL IS MATH AND JUST LEARNED FERNANDO IS CARRYING ON A TRADITION, HIS SISTER LED THE PLEDGE A COUPLE YEARS AGO, SO IT RUNS IN THE FAMILY. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION, UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. (APPLAUSE) >> WE HAVE A UPDATE TONIGHT BY CONTRA COSTA LIBRARY COMMISSIONER APPOINTEE YOLANDA PENA-MENDREK AND WILL DO THAT WITH OUR LIBRARY MANAGER, ANDREA FREYLER. >> GOOD EVENING MAYOR ALAURA AND CITY COUNCIL. WE ARE GOING TO GIVE YOU A SHORT PRESENTATION ABOUT WHAT THE LIBRARY HAS BEEN DOING FOR AT LEAST THE PAST 6 MONTHS WE THINK, AND WE HAVE VERY NICE SUMMER PROGRAM THAT TOOK PLACE THAT SERVED MANY STUDENTS, MANY PEOPLE. AND, YOU RECEIVED SEVERAL HANDOUTS. THEY SHOULD BE ON YOUR DESK, AND TO THAT EFFECT, I WILL ONLY REFER TO SOME OF IT INSTEAD OF READING THEM. SO, WE BELIEVE AND WE KNOW I THINK THAT THE LIBRARIES ARE THE PULSE OF THE COMMUNITY. THIS IS WHERE EVERYTHING TAKES PLACE NOW A DAYS, AND IT IS NOT ONLY FOR BRINGING THE PHYSICAL BOOKS, BUT ALSO HOW WE HAVE ACCESS TO ONLINE BOOKS CAN BE VERY FUN TO HAVE, ESPECIALLY IF YOU ARE ON BART, AMTRAK, YOU ARE FLYING FROM ONE PLACE TO THE OTHER, THE LIBRARY MAKES IT NICE AND AVAILABLE TO YOU AND IT IS VERY CONVENIENT. SO, IT IS NOT ONLY THE PULSE FOR THE COMMUNITY, BUT ALSO FOR THOSE TRAVELING ANYWHERE. THE MISSION ALSO STILL TO BRING PEOPLE TOGETHER, AND TO THAT EFFECT, THEY NEED TO HAVE BUILDINGS, SUCH AS THE NEW ONES THAT WERE BUILT AND WE ARE TALKING ABOUT BRENTWOOD AND THE EL CERRITO IN THE PROCESS BEING REMODELED AFTER HAVING A FIRE. WHEN WE SAY MAKE IT CONVENIENT TO HAVE BOOKS FOR EVERYONE TO READ, IT IS ALSO AN EXAMPLE THAT PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT ABLE YET TO READ WILL HAVE-WILL STRUGGLE THROUGHOUT THEIR LIVES SO ONE OF THE PROJECTS THE LIBRARY HAS HAD IN THE PAST AND THAT IS NOW BEING SUCCESSFUL IS THE PROJECT SECOND CHANCE, WHERE ADULTS ARE ABLE TO LEARN HOW TO READ, HOW TO WRITE, AND THEY CAN NOW SHARE BOOKS MAYBE WITH THEIR CHILDREN. THE PROJECT EQUITABLE ACCESS THAT WE HAD THE SPRING, IT IS BEING VERY SUCCESSFUL BECAUSE WE ARE RECEIVING BOOKS BACK FROM PATRONS TO HAVE THEM PUT AWAY AND THEY WERE AFRAID TO COME TO A LIBRARY BECAUSE THEY HAD TO PAY FOR THEM, AND SO THAT IS ANOTHER ONE OF THE THINGS THAT ARE HAPPENING. THE NEW LIBRARIES AND THEIR REMODELED LIBRARIES ARE ALSO BRINGING NEW PATRONS AND THEY ARE ATTENDING THE DIFFERENT ACTIVITIES BY THE LIBRARIES. ANDREA WILL TALK MORE ABOUT THAT DURING HER PRESENTATION. LIBRARIES ARE NOT ONLY WORK FOR THE POSITORY OF BOOKS BUT THE PLACES PEOPLE GET TOGETHER. THEY CREATE NEW FRIENDSHIPS AND BECAUSE OF THAT, WE NEED TO MAINTAIN, CONTINUE PROMOTING AND ALSO WORKING WITH THE LIBRARIANS AND THEIR STAFF SO THEY CAN MAKE THAT POSSIBLE FOR ALL THE PEOPLE ATTENDING. TALKING ABOUT THE LIBRARY AND PHYSICAL BOOKS AND ONLINE BOOKS, WE NOW FIND OURSELVES HAVING TO DEAL WITH THE PUBLISHERS WHO ARE PLAYING THEIR GAMES TO MAKE MORE MONEY OBVIOUSLY AND THEY ONLY GIVE A LIBRARY A SPECIFIC BOOK FOR SO MANY MONTHS SO IF YOU GO TO THE LIBRARY AND YOU WANT TO BORROW A BOOK AND YOU HAVE TO WAIT THREE MONTHS FOR IT, IT IS NOT BECAUSE THE LIBRARY DOESN'T WANT YOU TO HAVE THEM, IT IS BECAUSE THE PUBLISHER NOW SAYS WE'LL GIVE YOU THIS MANY BOOKS NORMALLY ONE, MAYBE TWO IF YOU ARE ARE A LARGE LIBRARY AND YOU HAVE TO WAIT FOR IT, THAT WAY THEY CAN MAKE MORE MONEY FOR THEIR COMPANY. THEY PLACED IT IS CALLED A EMBARGO, CORRECT? AN EMBARGO. WITH THAT, OUR LIBRARIAN IS WORKING WITH THE PUBLISHERS TO SEE HOW WE CAN MOVE THAT OBSTACLE SO PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO THE BOOKS. IF ANYONE CAN HAVE ACCESS TO A PLACE WHERE THEY FEEL SAFE AND COME TO INTERACT WITH COMMUNITY MEMBERS WE ARE VERY SUCCESSFUL IN THAT REGARDS BECAUSE THE LIBRARIES ARE OPENING THE DOOR TO JUST ABOUT ANYBODY TO COME AND BE PART OF THE COMMUNITY. AND THAT IS MY PIECE AND NOW LET ANDREA DO HER PART. SORRY, SORRY, SORRY, I LIE. I HAVE THE LAST LITTLE PIECE HERE. THE SUMMER READING. THEY HAD SUMMER READING AND LUNCH AT THE LIBRARIES. ONE OF THEM WAS 14.119 PEOPLE PLEDGED TO READ IN THE CONTRA COSTA LIBRARY. 7810 BABIES, KIDS, TEENS AND ADULTS FINISHED SUMMER READING. 10 PERCENT INCREASE FROM LAST YEAR. WE ARE TALKING SUMMER 2019. AND, 10 LIBRARIES HOSTED A SPECIAL EVENTS FEATURING A SPACE STATION AND GUESTED INCLUDING NASA AND SOME OTHER LOCAL PLACES, AND 5453 PEOPLE ATTENDED IN REACHING FUND PROGRAMS PLANNING THE SUMMER READING. THE LAST PIECE, 5973 MEALS WERE SERVED TO CHILDREN AGES 0-18 AS SOME OF OUR LOCAL CONTRA COSTA LIBRARIES. THANK YOU. >> HELLO MAYOR ALAURA AND COUNCIL. THANK YOU FOR THAT UPDATE ABOUT THE COUNTY ACTIVITIES. A DELVE MORE INTO OAKLEY AND TOUCH ON THE CONTE ONES. MY NAME IS ANDREA FREYLER. SO, THIS SUMMER YOLANDA TOUCHED ON THE OVERALL. IN OAKLEY SUMMER READING RUNS [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] OAKLEY WE HAVE 4 WEEKS SO OUR PROGRAM RUNS A LITTLE SHORTER. FREEDOM HIGH SCHOOL NEEDS TO USE THE LIBRARY FOR REGISTRATIONS, SO WE GET 4 WEEKS. IN THAT 4 WEEKS BECAUSE WE KNOW THAT WE HAVE THE OBSTACLES LIMITED IN THE PROGRAMMING YEAR ROUND, WE DO SOMETHING EVERY SINGLE DAY, SO ON THIS YEAR, ON TUESDAYS WE HAVE TUNE TUESDAYS AND MAKER WEDNESDAY. NEW THIS YEAR WE HAD THE ALL ABILITY STORY TIME. THIS STORY TIME WAS ESPECIALLY DESIGNED FOR A INCLUSIVE AUDIENCE. CHILDREN WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES AND SIBLINGS WERE ABLE TO JOIN STORY TIME AND SONGS AND PLAY AND FAMILIES WERE INVITED TO STAY AND PLAY AND CONNECT AFTER STORY TIME. THIS IS PROGRAMMING THAT WE KNOW NEEDS MORE SUPPORT IN OAKLEY. UNFORTUNATELY WE DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY SO GRATEFUL TO DO IT THIS SUMMER AND WILL DO IT AGAIN NEXT SUMMER. CARDBOARD CREATIONS WAS NEW THIS YEAR AND CAME OUT OF OUR STEAM BREAK. WE HAD CARDBOARD FOR KIDS AND DIDN'T REALIZE HOW MUCH THEY WOULD LIKE IT. CREATIVE LITERACY IS A REAL THING SO CARDBOARD CREATIONS FITS INTO THAT. IT IS IS THE ABILITY TO UNDERSTAND AND USE THE SKILLS THROUGH CREATIVE PROCESS, CONNECT, SOLVE PROBLEMS AND COMMUNICATE MEETING. THE SKILLS LIKE FOCUS, PERSEVERANCE, IN COLLABORATION NEEDED IN THE 21 CENTURY SO THAT IS WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO WITH THESE PROGRAMS. EXTENSION OF THAT IS LEGO SATURDAYS WE OFFER ALL YEAR. WE ADDED THE MINE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] COMPONENT. WE HAVE DONE MIND STORM ROBOTIC COMPONENT IN THE PAST, A CLASS, BUT WE JUST NOW HAVE IT OPEN AND THAT IS-I KNOW I TALKED ABOUT MIND STORMS. I DONT KNOW IF EVERYBODY KNOWS-I WANT TO SHOW, THEY ARE ROBOTS SO KIDS GET TO BUILD ROBOTS, WHICH I DON'T KNOW IF I KNOW HOW TO TURN THIS ON, BUT WE'LL SEE. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> RIGHT. THESE ARE SKILLS THEY WILL NEED. IF I CAN'T GET IT-OKAY. SO WE DID THAT. WE GAVE AWAY MORE THEN 500 PRIZES. IN THE PHOTOS ARE PEOPLE WINS A'S TICKETS ON BOTTOM, KID CARDBOARD, LEGO SATURDAY AND STORY TIME WHICH WE ALWAYS DO. TEEN TUESDAY WAS THE HARDEST WHEN IT ENDED BECAUSE THEY KNEW SUMMER WAS STILL GOING BUT WE HAD TO END BECAUSE WE HAD THE SPACE NO LONGER BUT THEY WERE CONFUSED BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT BACK IN SCHOOL. WE REALLY SAW-THIS YEAR WE HAD A SENSE BUT TEENS JUST NEED A SAFE PLACE TO HANG OUT AND RELAX AND WE REALLY HEARD THAT THAT WAS THE ONLY PLACE THEY GOT TO RELAX AND BE WITH THEIR FRIENDS IN THE SUMMER. THEY DIDN'T WANT IT DO THINGS. WE HAD GREAT PROJECTS PLANNED. THAT IS THE ONLY THING THEY DID BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO HANG OUT. THAT IS WOOD BLOCK PRINTING SO YOU CARVE WOOD BLOCKS AND MAKE STAMPS OUT OF IT. THAT IS THE ONLY ONE THEY DID. OTHERWISE THEY WANTED TO HANG OUT AND THAT IS WHAT THEY WANTED AND WE HAD THINGS AVAILABLE BUT SERVE THE COMMUNITY WITH WHAT THEY WANT. MAKER, THIS IS OUR 4TH SUMMER HOSTING A MAKER PROGRAM. IT IS ALWAYS MY FAVORITE. MY FAVORITE PROGRAM THIS SUMMER WAS RESCUE ROBOTS. IT WAS FIRST TIME WE GAVE KIDS POWER TOOLS, SO THEY GOT DRILLS AND HAMMERS. WE HAVE DONE HAMMERS BEFORE AND THEY JUST SCRAP WOOD AND PARTS AND STUFF THAT I HAD IN MY HOUSE AND MY GRANDFATHER HAD AND WE GOT THE STUFF AND GAVE POWER TOOLS AND NAILS AND THEY MADE ROBOTS, SOCK PUPPETS UP TOP. THAT IS IMPORTANT. AS MUCH AS TECHNOLOGY IS, JUST A NEEDLE AND THREAD AND HAD BOYS AND GIRL EVERYONE SEWING-HOPEFULLY I WON'T HAVE TO KNOW HOW IT WORK THIS BUT IN HIGH SCHOOL THE BEST CLASS MY HUSBAND TOOK WAS AUTO SHOP AND THE BEST I TOOK IS SEWING. THOSE ARE IMPORTANT LIFE SKILLS. WE HAD 4 WEEKS, 48 PROGRAMS, 739 PEOPLE AND I WILL SHOW YOU THE ROBOT. SHE IF SHE WILL GO AND IF NOT I'LL KEEP TALKING. WE'LL LEAVE HER THERE AND SHE'LL GO FOR A WHILE BUT I'LL KEEP TALKING. SO, EVEN THOUGH SUMMER IS OVER WE DO OUR BEST TO OFFER VIBRANT PROGRAMING TO THE COMMUNITY. WE HAD [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] SPACE AND SCIENCE CENTER OUT THERE PRESENTING HANDS ON DEMONSTRATION, LIVERMORE SHAKES IS OUT THERE. [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] SECOND GRADE CLASSROOMS IN THE OAKLEY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT AND DOES THE ONE IN OAKLEY, I DON'T KNOW THE NAME OF IT, BUT I SHOULD KNOW IT. YES, I SHOULD KNOW THAT. SORRY. THEN WE VISIT SCHOOLS SO THAT IS A PICTURE OF ME VISITING THE SCHOOLS IF SCHOOLS ASK. WE WANT TO TELL THEM WHAT WE DO. WE HAD OUR FIRST CAR CARE BASICS WITH FAST EDDIE SO THAT WAS A GREAT TIME AND PEOPLE GOT TO COME AND LEARN HOW TO CHANGE OIL AND THEY WERE TAKING NOTES AND THAT WAS SOMETHING-THAT IS COMMUNITY NEED. WE ARE LEARNING MORE AND MORE THE TACTILE THINGS, THE THINGS PEOPLE NEED THOSE SKILLS. WE ON SEPTEMBER 20 VISIT THE SENIOR CENTER SO EVERY OTHER FRIDAY WE VISIT THE SENIOR CENTER. ON THE FIRST WE ISSUED 20 CARDS. DOUG THOMAS WAS OUT THERE. WE HAVE SEEN 134 IN THE LIBRARY. WE KNEE TRANSPORTATION TO THE LIBRARY IS A ISSUE FOR MANY BUT THE FACT WE ARE OUT THERE AND GOING TO BE PROVIDING SERVICES AND EVEN THOUGH PEOPLE ARE MAKING PERSONAL REQUESTS FROM HIM FOR BOOKS ON ALL KINDS OF STUFF. A PARTNERSHIP, ONE THING I LOVE IS SEEING THE ART EXHIBIT IN THE LIBRARY. THIS IS THE LAST DAY FOR THE CURRENT EXHIBIT. WE WILL HAVE 6 EXHIBITS THIS YEAR TOTAL. TOMORROW IS A NEW EXHIBIT, SO IF YOU DIDN'T SEE THIS ONE THERE IS A NEW ONE TOMORROW. I LOVE SEEING ART IN THE LIBRARY AND COMMUNITY RESPONDED TO IT. WE ALWAYS HAVE THE REGULAR PROGRAM, STORY TIME, SEASON AUTHOR PROGRAM COMING UP. THIS IS GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO MEET NATIONALLY AND INTERNATIONALLY RECOGNIZED TALENT. [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] BLUE IS COMING UP AND CAR CARE BASICS WILL CONTINUE. WE HOPE TO OFFER ROBOTS. YOU COME AND PLAY WITH THESE IN THE LIBRARY BUT WE HAVE A ACTUAL CLASS THREE DAY SERIES WHERE WE TEACH THEM HOW TO BUILD, PROGRAM AND DO ALL THAT STUFF. I DON'T TEACH IT BECAUSE I CAN'T TURN IT ON. THIS MONTH IS OCTOBER IS DISCOVER AND GO MONTH. DO YOU KNOW WHAT DISCOVER AND GO IS? IT IS A GREAT WAY TO CELEBRATE THE PARTNERSHIP WITH MUSEUM AND CULTURAL VENUES SO WITH YOUR LIBRARY CARD YOU CAN GET MUSEUM TICKETS ALL OVER THE AREA AND RIGHT NOW YOU CAN GET FREE BART PASS SAID TO MANY OF THE BAY AREA VENUES FOR THIS MONTH ONLY. THE MUSEUM IS NOT ONLY EDUCATION AL AND A LOT OF FUN AND IT IS ONE OF THE WAYS LIBRARY CARD CAN TAKE YOU ANYWHERE BECAUSE IT TAKES YOU EVERYWHERE. UP FROM THE COUNTY WE HAVE A NEW WEBSITE COMING. I SHOULDN'T SAY THIS, BUT I SAY STUFF I SHOULDN'T SAY ALL THE TIME. I HAVE APOLOGIZED FOR THE WEBSITE FOR 10 YEARS SINCE I HAVE BEEN WITH THE COUNTY AND NOW WE ARE GETTING A NEW ONE. IT IS GOING TO BE GREAT. IT WILL LAUNCH NOVEMBER 19. WILL HAVE A NEW CATALOG, A NEW WEBSITE, IT WILL BE USER FRIENDLY, YOU CAN USE YOUR PHONE, YOU WILL BE ABLE TO NOT SEE A THOUSAND THINGS FOR ONE BOOK TITLE. IT WILL BE INCREDIBLE. AND SO THAT WILL BE UP AND IT STILL IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL IT IS FULLY LAUNCHED IN DECEMBER. LIBRARY CARDS, I'M EXCITED. THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THAT WE HAD NEW LIBRARY CARDS AND THAT WAS PART OF OUR EQUITABLE ACCESS. WE ELIMINATED FINES THIS YEAR AND WE ALSO HOPE TO ENGAGE AND ATTRACT REENGAGE OUR PATRONS. WE HAD DORMANT CARDS FOR A LONG TIME AND WE HAVE. END OF SEPTEMBER SO WE LAUNCHED IN SEPTEMBER, THE END OF SEPTEMBER WE HAD 2600 NEW CUSTOMERS SIGN UP FOR CARDS. 9900 CAME IN FOR JUST NEW CARDS LIKE I WANT A NEW CARD. OVERALL 177 PERCENT INCREASE. SO, REALLY HAPPY. WE ARE SEEING MORE PEOPLE EXCITED ABOUT THE LIBRARY BECAUSE WE ARE MORE THEN BOOKS. TONIGHT I'M EXCITED. MAYOR ALAURA YOU ALREADY HAVE YOUR CARD. AWESOME. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> THAT'S AWESOME. I HAVE CARDS AND I E-MAILED EVERYONE AND I HAVE THE POPPY CARD FOR KEVIN AND THE POPPY CARD FOR SUE AND ASTRONAUT CARD FOR RANDY SO WE SEE WHAT IS POPULAR. I WILL GIVE YOU GUYS YOUR CARDS AND AT SOME POINT IF I CAN GET A PICTURE WITH THEM I WOULD REALLY APPRECIATE THAT. THAT WOULD BE AWESOME. BUT OTHER THEN THAT, YOU GUYS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? >> [MICROPHONE NOT ON] CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR BOOK RETURN. I HEARD LAST WEEK THAT THE BERKELEY LIBRARY HAD A BOOK RETURN THAT WAS 74 YEARS OVER DUE. IT IS A GOOD THING THEY DIDN'T CHARGE A FINE, SURE THEY PROBABLY COULD HAVE FINANCED THE WHOLE OPERATION FOR A YEAR ON JUST A BOOK THAT IS 74 YEARS OLD. I KNOW SPEAKING OUT OF TURN HERE FOR THE CITY AND WHAT NOT, BUT BECAUSE OF YOUR SHORT TIME SUMMER WITH THE TEENS AND MORE ACTIVE WE CAN KEEP THEM, MAYBE AS WE LOOK TOWARDS NEXT SUMMER WE CAN LOOK AT THE LIBRARY AND THE REC DEPARTMENT WORKING TOGETHER TO EXTEND THOSE PROGRAMS AND USE OUR NEW RECREATION CENTER TO CONTINUE THOSE PROGRAMS AND SO WHEN 4 WEEKS ARE UP AND THERE IS STILL A LOT OF SUMMER TO GO AND SCHOOL HASN'T STARTED, THERE ARE WAYS WE CAN KEEP THOSE TEENS THAT YOU ATTRACTED AND KEEP THEM ACTIVE. >> I LOVE THAT BECAUSE ALL YEAR THEY NEED A PLACE. THAT IS WHAT WE ARE SEEING AND EVEN THOUGH WE ARE IN A HIGH SCHOOL, PEOPLE THINK WE ARE IN A HIGH SCHOOL, IT IS NOT THE PLACE FOR IT. THEY CAN'T DO WHAT THEY DID SO I LOVE THAT IDEA. WE'LL TALK. >> AND THEN AS FAR AS THE SENIORS AND THE LIBRARY AND SENIOR HAVING TROUBLE GETTING THERE, MAYBE SHOULD REACH OUT TO TRI DELTA TRANSIT AND SEE IF WE CAN SET UP A MONTHLY PROGRAM WHERE THEY CAN MEET AT THE SENIOR CENTER AND WE JUST BUS THEM DOWN TO THE LIBRARY ALL AT ONE TIME. SPEND A COUPLE HOURS IN THERE AND PROVIDE BUS SERVICE BACK OR WHATEVER TRANSPORTATION WE CAN ARRANGE THROUGH THE PROCESS. >> OUR BUS SERVICE IS A REAL ISSUE BECAUSE ON SATURDAY'S THERE IS NO SERVICE AT ALL SO THOSE ARE A LOT OF BARRIERS SO THAT IS A FANTASTIC IDEA. YEAH. >> ONCE AGAIN, GREAT JOB WITH WHAT YOU HAVE DONE. IMPRESSED WITH THE FACILITY HAVE AND THE AMOUNT OF EVENTS YOU PUT ON. >> OUR TEAM DOES A GREAT JOB. WE HAVE A GREAT TEAM. >> I WANTED TO SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH AND I WANTED TO ASK THE EMBARGO ON A BOOK, IS THAT A ONLINE BOOK? >> IT IS THE THE TWO MOST MAJOR PUBLISHERS AND DONT WANT TO SAY THEIR NAMES BUT FOR EVERY LIBRARY SYSTEM THE NEW PLAN-CONTRA COSTA COUNTY WE WOULD GET-IT IS THE BEST SELLERS AND I DON'T WANT TO THROW-I DON'T HAVE THE EXACT, BUT I THINK WHAT I REMEMBER IT IS LIKE THE JAMES PATTERSON SO HIS PUBLISHER SO THEY WILL GIVE ONE OF THE E BOOKS FOR 4 WEEKS AND THEN THEY SELL US MORE. THE E BOOKS COST-WE HAVE TO BUY THOSE E BOOKS AND THEY COST JUST AS MUCH AS A PHYSICAL COPY, WHICH IS CRAZY. THEN WE ALSO HAVE TO PAY A SERVICE FEE TO MAINTAIN THE--WE ARE WILLING TO DO THAT. OUR E BOOK-I WANT TO SAY THIS LAST YEAR IT WENT UP 113 PERCENT IN THE PAST YEAR SO WE KNOW WE ARE PUTTING MORE MONEY IN THE E BOOKS BUT IF THEY-THOSE TWO MAJOR PUBLISHERS DO MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT, WE ARE DEFINITELY GOING TO SEE A SHIFT IN LIBRARIES ACROSS THE NATION AND WHAT THEY CAN PROVIDE. WE WILL SEE. IT IS A WAY TO MAKE MONEY. I DON'T KNOW IF I SAY ALL THAT. BUT THAT IS MY PERSONAL OPINION. >> THANK YOU ANDREA AND YOLANDA FOR THE PRESENTATION. WE ARE PART THE SUMMER READING PROGRAM TOO, SO CAN ATTEST FOR PEOPLE USING THE LIBRARY IN THE PHYSICAL FORM AND ONLINE SO THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU BOTH DO. >> THANK YOU, AND LET ME GIVE YOU GUYS YOUR CARDS. >> YOU WANT TO DO A QUICK PICTURE RIGHT NOW? >> SURE. >> WE CAN. >> THANK YOU. THERE IS A KEY CHAIN NOW SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO YOUR LIBRARY CARD. >> OKAY. WE'LL MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENTS. PUBLIC COMMENTS COULD BE MADE FOR ANY ITEMS EVEN NOT ON THE AGENDA BY FILLING OUT A BLUE CARD. PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO ABOUT 3 MINUTES. THIS LITTLE LIGHT INDICATOR WILL START AT GREEN, AT YELLOW WILL TELL YOU YOU ARE IN THE MIDDLE OF YOUR TIME AND THEN IN THE RED YOU NEED TO CONCLUDE YOUR THOUGHTS. IF YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO GET EVERYTHING OUT THAT YOU WANT TO SAY, WE'LL ALWAYS HAVE E-MAIL READILY AVAILABLE AND SO YOU CAN ALWAYS E-MAIL THE REST OF YOUR THOUGHTS IF YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO GET THEM OUT IN THAT TIME. I DO HAVE ONE BLUE CARD AND THAT IS MARGARET FLOWER. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR GRANTING ME THIS OPPORTUNITY. I NEVER THOUGHT IN MY 92 YEARS THAT I WOULD BE STANDING HERE, BUT MY NEIGHBORS ARE IN TROUBLE AND I NEED TO COME HERE ON THEIR BEHALF. YOU ARE ALL FAIRLY FAMILIAR WITH OUR BACKGROUND HERE AT SUMMER CREEK PLACE AND YOU KNOW THAT WE HAD A LOT OF PROBLEMS. OUR MAIN CONCERN IS THAT WHERE EVER WE HAVE BEEN, OR WHO EVER WE TALK TO, THEY ALWAYS SAID, THERE IS NOTHING WE CAN DO. IT HAS BEEN SAID OVER AND OVER FROM THE TAX CREDIT ALLOCATIONS COMMITTEE, FROM SENIOR LAWYERS WITHOUT EVEN LOOKING INTO THE PROBLEM. IT IS SAID BY A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT ORGANIZATIONS AND YOU MAY KNOW THAT ECHO HAS COME TO OUR AID, AND LAST YEAR-LAST DECEMBER WE WERE FACED WITH A HORRENDOUS RENT INCREASE AND ECHO WAS ABLE TO DROP IT DOWN TO $50 RATHER THEN $163, BUT THE OWNERS HAVE BEEN GIVING US RENT INCREASES EVERY QUARTER SINCE THEN, SO WE NOW ARE PAYING $200 MORE THEN WE DID A YEAR AGO, AND THAT EQUATES TO A 25.97 PERCENT INCREASE IN JUST 10 MONTHS. THAT'S PRETTY STIFF FOR ANYBODY TO TAKE. YOU SHOULD ALSO KNOW THAT OUR LEASE CARRIES A RIDER THAT ENTITLE LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT LEASE RIDER, AND THAT WE HAVE A LETTER FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT STATING THAT OUR FACILITY IS NOT A HUD FACILITY. SO, THEREFORE WE ARE CONFUSED. BECAUSE THE OWNERS CONTINUE TO USE THE SCHEDULE PREPARED TOGETHER WITH HUD AND THE TAX CREDIT COMMITTEE IN SCHEDULING THE-TO THE UPMOST ADVANTAGE FOR TAX CREDITS, HOWEVER, THEY TOTALLY IGNORE THE LOW INCOME PORTION OF THAT SAME SCHEDULE. SO, FORTUNATELY ECHO STILL KEEP WORKING WITH US AND IT IS SLOW AND HOPEFULLY PROGRESS IS MEAD. WE HAD MEETING SCHEDULED TO WHICH YOU AND THE OWNERS WERE INVITED--NOBODY CAME AND THAT WAS A BIG DISAPPOINTMENT. WE ARE ALL ON FIXED INCOMES. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THAT, BUT A FIXED INCOME 30 YEARS AGO THIS DOESN'T DO IT FOR TODAY. NOR DOES MANY OF THEM 10 YEARS AGO. ONE OF THE MAJOR FACTORS I WANTED TO GET ACROSS IS THAT IN THE LAST 2 WEEKS 10 PERCENT OF OUR TENANTS HAVE HAD TO LEAVE BECAUSE THEY CAN'T PAY THE RENT, AND WE ARE DESPERATE. IT IS TABLE. SOON THERE IS GOING TO BE HOMELESS ON THE STREETS OF OAKLEY. >> UNFORTUNATELY YOUR TIME IS UP BUT DID YOU SUBMIT THIS? >> I DID. >> WE DO HAVE THIS FOR THE RECORD AND WILL MAKE SURE ALL THE COUNCIL DOES READ IT. I KNOW IN THE PAST WE HAVE SAID THAT THERE IS NOTHING WE CAN DO AND I KNOW THAT THAT HAS SEEMED LIKE A SLAP IN THE FACADES I READ IN YOUR LETTER. IT WASN'T INTENDED TO BE THAT WAY. MAYBE A BETTER ANALOGY INSTEAD OF A NOSE DOCTOR FOR A FOOT PROBLEM WOULD BE THAT IT IS AS THOUGH THE CITY-IF WE WERE TRYING TO CONTROL THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. WE HAVE NO JURISDICTION TO DO THAT AND NO AUTHORITY. SAME WITH RENT AND HOW IT IS CONTROLLED. WE DON'T HAVE AUTHORITY TO DO THAT. IT ISN'T THAT WE DON'T WANT TO HELPING, IT IS EVEN IF WE COULD, WE DON'T HAVE JURISDICTION TO DO THAT. HOWEVER, THERE IS NOTHING THAT WE CAN'T DO TO TRY TO SUPPORT YOU AND HELP YOU, SO I WILL NOW TURN IT OVER MAYBE TO OUR CITY ATTORNEY TO SEE IF THERE IS ANYTHING THAT FURTHER COULD BE DONE FOR US TO SUPPORT THEM IN THEIR EFFORTS. >> I THINK THE MAYOR ANALOGY IS A APT ONE. THINK OF THE PROBLEM THAT WAS PRESENTED AS A PROBLEM YOU WILL SEE A CARDIOLOGIST FOR, WE ARE A PODIATRIST. WE HAVE NO JURISDICTION, WE HAVE NO ABILITY TO CONTROL ANY OF THE MATTERS THAT ARE RAISED. IT IS BECAUSE WE ARE PURELY A LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND WE HAVE NO CONTROL OVER WHAT IS ULTIMATELY A HODGEPODGE OF FEDERAL AND STATE PROGRAMS THAT ARE RUN BY FEDERAL AND STATE AGENCIES WORKING WITH FEDERAL AND STATE GRANT PROGRAMS. WE LITERALLY HAVE NO SAY, WE HAVE NO INFLUENCE, AND THERE IS NOTHING THE CITY CAN DO AND KNOW THAT HAS TO BE FRUSTRATING FOR EVERYONE IN THE ROOM AND THIS ISSUE HAS COME UP MULTIPLE TIMES BUT AGAIN, YOU DON'T-IF YOU HAVE A HEART PROBLEM YOU DON'T GO TO A PODIATRIST AND THAT IS THE BEST ANALOGY I CAN USE. I BELIEVE IN THE PAST OUR STAFF HAS PREPARED A LIST OF PHONE NUMBERS AND CONTACTS WITH THE VARIOUS AGENCIES THAT DO HAVE JURISDICTION. I CAN'T TELL YOU THAT WORKING WITH THE FEDERAL AND STATE GOVERNMENT IS ANY PRIZE, BECAUSE I KNOW IN MY OWN PRACTICE WHEN I HAD TO CALL STATE AND FEDERAL AGENCIES, IT HAS BEEN A FRUSTRATING THING, SO I CAN EMPATHIZE WITH EVERYONE IN HERE, BUT THERE IS JUST LITERALLY NOTHING WE AS A CITY CAN DO AND I KNOW ALL OF US AT THIS TABLE, AT THE DAIS FEEL VERY SORRY ABOUT THAT. >> MAY I RESPOND? >> SURE. >> I'M AWARE OF EVERYTHING YOU SAID AND I COVERED IT IN THIS DOCUMENT HERE, BUT THERE IS I THINK SOMETHING THAT THIS BODY CAN DO. THEY CAN PICK UP THE PHONE AND CALL SOMEBODY WHO MAY KNOW SOMEBODY WHO HAS THE AUTHORITY TO WORK WITH THE STATE TAX CREDIT BUREAU AND SEE WHAT COULD BE DONE FROM THAT ANGLE. I APPRECIATE THAT VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU, WE'LL TAKE THAT SUGGESTION AND SEE IF THERE IS SOMEBODY WE CAN CONTACT TO HELP YOU OUT. >> THANK YOU. >> WE'LL MOVE ON TO CONSENT CALENDAR. I HAVE NO OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT CARDS. I AM GOING TO PULL 3.1. >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> I'M ONLY PULLING 3.1 BECAUSE I AM ABSTAINING SINCE I WANT HERE LAST WEEK. SINCE I PULLED IT ALREADY. BUT GO AHEAD. >> MOVE APPROVAL OF 3.1. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> AND I ABSTAIN. THANK YOU. PUBLIC HEARINGS. 4.1. ACACIA APPLICATION REQUESTING APPROVAL OF 1, GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT GPA03-18 TO AMEND THE LAND USE DESIGNATION FROM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL, HIGH DENSITY TO MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL, LOW DENSITY. TWO, REZONE R Z07-18 FROM SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT. THREE, VESTING TENTATIVE MAP TM04-18 TO SUBDIVIDE APPROXIMATELY 13 POET 4 ACRES INTO 108 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LOTS WITHIN A GATED COMMUNITY AS WELL AS ONE PRIVATE STREET LOT, 12 PRIVATE DRIVE LOTS, TWO WATER QUALITY LOTS AND THREE LANDSCAPE LOTS. AND 4 DESIGN REVIEW D R 11-18 FOR HOME DESIGN SITE LANDSCAPING FENCE PLANS AND SITE DESIGN. THE PROJECT SITE IS LOCATED AT 5360 MAIN STREET, APN033-030-OO1 AND 033-03 O-027. I WILL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING AND RECEIVE THE STAFF REPORT FROM MR. MCMURRAY. >> THANK YOU MADAM MAYOR, MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL. GO OVER THE APPLICATION SUMMARY AS YOU JUST DESCRIBED, MAYOR. THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT IS TO CHANGE THE LAND USE DESIGNATION IN THE GENERAL PLAN FROM SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HIGH DENSITY TO MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL LOW DENSITY. THE REZONE REQUEST IS FROM THE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL R 6 ZONE DISTRICT TO THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT P1 DISTRICT. THE VESTING TENTATIVE MAP IS SUBDIVIDE THE 13.4 ACRES CONSISTING OF TWO PARCELS AND 108 LOTS AND FOR DESIGN REVIEW OF THE HOME LAND LANDSCAPING FENCE PLAN AND SITE DESIGN. THE PROJECT IS LOCATED AT 5360 MAIN STREET CONSISTING OF TWO PARCELS 13.4 ACRES. ONE OF THE PARCELS FRONTS MAIN STREET, THE OTHER PARCEL FRONTS ON HONEY LANE. ALL OF THE SURROUNDING LAND USES ARE SINGLE FAMILY HOMES. THE GENERAL PLAN CURRENT DESIGNATION OF SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HIGH DENSITY PERMITS RESIDENTIAL LAND USES MAXIMUM DENSITY OF 5.5 DWELLING UNIT PER ACRE. THE CURRENT REQUEST WOULD AMEND THAT TO MULTIFAMILY LOW, WHICH WOULD BASICALLY ALLOW FOR A SLIGHT INCREASE IN DENSITY AND IT WOULD ALSO ALLOW FOR THE REZONE TO ACCOMMODATE THE RESIDENTIAL USE PROPOSED. THE REZONE IS FROM R 6 SINGLE FAMILY ZONE DISTRICT TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT AND THE PURPOSE IS TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY TO THE DEVELOPER IN CREATING THEIR OWN DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS TO FIT THE AGREEMENT AS PROPOSED AND STAFF WAS CAREFUL TO CRAFT THE REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS AND THOSE ARE WITHIN THE REZONE ORDINANCE AND BASICALLY THAT WOULD ONLY ALLOW IF APPROVED TONIGHT THE PROJECT THAT IS PRESENTED IN FRONT OF YOU AT THE DENSITY PRESENTED. THIS IS A PICTURE OF THE TENTATIVE MAP SUBMITTED. AGAIN, IT IS 13.4 ACRES 108 SINGLE FAMILY LOTS, IT IS IMPORTANT TO MENTION THAT THIS IS A GATED HOA MANAGED SUBDIVISION. ALL THE STREETS FRONT YARD LANDSCAPING AND WATER QUALITY BASINS WOULD BE MAINTAINED BY THE HOA. THE MINIMUM LOT SIZE FOR THIS SUBDIVISION IS 3375 SQUARE FEET. THE APPLICANT IS PROPOSING TWO STORY HOMES RANGING IN SIZE FROM 2165 TO 2473 SQUARE FEET. THE DESIGN REVIEW AS MENTIONED REALLY ANALYZES THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE SITE. THERE ARE A NUMBER OF SHEETS INCLUDED IN THE APPLICANT PLANS ATTACHED TO THE STAFF REPORT THAT ENCOMPASS THE DESIGN REVIEW. THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN REALLY SHOWS THE PRODUCT TYPE AND VARIATION OF THE PRODUCT TYPE AS PLOTTED. THEY HAVE PAID CAREFUL ATTENTION TO PROVIDE SOME SIDE YARD ACCESS FOR R V AND BOATS. I THINK THERE IS 5 LOTS HERE THAT CAN ACCOMMODATE THAT AND THERE WAS REAL CAREFUL SITE PLANNING VERY EARLY ON THAT ALLOWS FOR INCREASED SIDE YARDS, SETBACK ALONG THE SOUTH PROPERTY LINE TO RESPECT THAT EDGE CONDITION OF THE EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY TO THE SOUTH OF THE PROJECT. IN ADDITION TO RESPECTING THE EDGE CONDITION ON THE NORTH SIDE, AND LARGER LOT SINGLE FAMILY THAT EXISTS TO THE NORTH, THOSE REAR YARDS ALONG THAT NORTHERN PROPERTY LINE HAVE LARGER REAR YARD SETBACKS SO THERE IS CAREFUL ATTENTION TO TRY TO BE AS RESPECTFUL TO THE SURROUNDING LAND USES THAT EXIST TODAY. THIS IS THE LANDSCAPE PLAN THAT WAS PROVIDED IN THE STAFF REPORT. YOU CAN SEE THEY PAID CAREFUL ATTENTION TO PROVIDING STREET TREES. ONE THING TO NOTE THAT IS NOT TYPICAL WITH A SINGLE FAMILY SUBDIVISION IS PROVIDING REAR YARD LANDSCAPING AND THE LOTS ON THE NORTH SIDE ABUTTING THE NORTH PROPERTY LINE IN CONVERSATIONS THEY HELD AT LEAST ONE COMMUNITY MEETING AND FALLOWED WITH PEOPLE THAT HAD CONCERNS BUT THEY ARE AGREE TO PLANT PLANTS IN ADDITION TO INCREASED FENCING ALONG THE NORTHERN PROPERTY LINE. I SAID PLANTS BUT MEANT TREES. TREES AND IRRIGATION TO PROVIDE SCREENING IN THE BUFFER. EACH ENTRANCE OFF HONEY AND MAIN STREET WOULD BE GATED WITH DECORATIVE SIGNAGE AND DECORATIVE STAMPED ASPHALT. THIS IS A COLOR RENDERING OF THE STREETSCAPE SHOWING THE THREE ARCHITECTURAL ELEVATIONS, THE PRAIRIE, THE CRAFTSMEN AND EARLY CALIFORNIAN. THIS PROJECT WAS ANALYZED UNDER THE CAL ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT. A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION WAS PREPARED AND PUBLISHED. WE RECEIVED TWO COMMENT LETTERS ONE FROM CONTRA COSTA COUNTY MOSQUITO CONTROL DISTRICT AND WATER CONVERSATION DISTRICT. THE STAFF REPORT DID REFERENCE THOSE LETTERS IN RESPONSE TO COMMENTS WERE INCLUDED IN THE STAFF REPORT. WE PREPARED THOSE AFTER THE STAFF REPORT WAS PUBLISHED SO THEY WERE PROVIDED TO YOU BUT BOTH COMMENTS ADDRESSED OR BOTH LETTERS AND THEIR COMMENTS WERE ADDRESSED IN THE RESPONSE TO COMMENTS AND THOSE RESPONSE TO COMMENTS WERE PROVIDED TO BOTH DISTRICTS AND THEY WERE HAPPY WITH THOSE COMMENTS. THE PROPOSAL WILL INCREASE THE ALLOWABLE DENSITY TO THE PROJECT AT 8.1 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE. THE MAXIMUM DENSITY ON THE SITE IF THE PROJECT IS APPROVE WOULD BE 9.6, BUT AS CRAFTED IN THE ORDINANCE, THAT IS CAPPED AT 8.1 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE. IT WILL CONTINUE TO ALLOW FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOMES, WHICH DOMINATES THE SURROUNDING AREA TODAY. THE REZONE P1 DISTRICT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE MULTIFAMILY LOW DESIGNATION AND WOULD ALLOW FOR THE SINGLE FAMILY PRODUCT TYPE AS PROPOSED. THE TENTATIVE MAP ALLOWANCE ANALYSIS, THE PROJECT MEETS ALL THE REQUIREMENTS WITHIN THE OAKLEY MUNICIPAL CODE AND SUBDIVISION MAP ACT. DESIGN REVIEW ANALYSIS, AS MENTIONED BEFORE, THIS IS A HOA GATED SUBDIVISION SO THAT WILL REALLY RESULT IN POSITIVE IMPACTS AND QUALITY ESTHETICS THROUGH PROACTIVE ENFORCEMENT OF THE CCNR BY THE HOA ITSELF SO IT REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY THAT YOU WOULD NORMALLY SEE IN A NON HOA MANAGED SUBDIVISION AND THE OVERALL IMPACT TO THE MAINTENANCE OF THE ROADS. IN SAYING THAT, NO ONE STORY HOMES ARE BEING PROPOSED AS THESE ARE SMALLER LOTS AND CREATE SOME CHALLENGES WITH MEETING ALL THE DESIGN GUIDELINES AND THOSE ARE DETAILED IN THE STAFF REPORT. WITH THAT SAID, STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION IS TO ADAPT THE MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION TO APPROVE THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT, WAVE THE FIRST READING AND INTRODUCE THE ORDINANCE APPROVING THE REZONE AND TO ADOPT A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE TENTATIVE MAP AND DESIGN REVIEW AND WITH THAT SAID, MY PRESENTATION CONCLUDES AND AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS AND KNOW THE APPLICANT IS HERE TO ALSO ANSWER QUESTIONS AS WELL. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FIRST FOR STAFF? GO AHEAD SUE. >> WE GOT A NOTE FROM A RESIDENT AND IT IS ASKING FOR EMERGENCY ACCESS OR EVACUATION ONLY EXIST FROM THE PROPOSED NEIGHBORHOOD BY MALACO OR GRAHAM COURT FOR SAFETY. HOW WOULD THAT WORK IF THERE IS ONE WAY IN AND ONE WAY OUT THERE? WELL, THERE IS THIS WAY AT HUNDRED A LANE AND MAIN. >> THERE ARE TWO ENTRANCES AND EXISTS FOR THE PROJECT. ONE OFF MAIN STREET AND ONE ON HONEY LANE. WE DID SEND THE PROJECT TO THE EAST CONTRA COSTA FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT. THEY DIDN'T COMMENT ON THE PROJECT BUT HAD A OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW THE PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE AND PROVIDED A LETTER SAYING THEY HAVE TO ADHERE TO THEIR REGULATIONS AS WELL AND AFTER IF THE PROJECT IS APPROVED THE APPLICANT WILL HAVE TO SUBMIT THEIR PLANS TO THE FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL, SO WE FEEL THERE IS ADEQUATE INGRESS AND EGRESS OUT OF THE SITE AND DOESN'T NEED TO BE ADDITIONAL EMERGENCY VEHICLE ACCESS POINTS IN ADDITION TO THE ACCESS POINTS ALREADY PROVIDED. >> I I KNOW LOOKED AT IT, THE TRIPS PER CARS, OFF OF MAIN- >> USUALLY IT IS TYPICAL THAT ONE HOME PRODUCES ONE PEAK HOUR TRIP, SO THEY DID A TRAFFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS AND THAT WAS TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WHEN WE DID THE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. >> THANK YOU. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME? OKAY. SO, I DO HAVE PUBLIC TESTIMONY. COUNCIL MEMBER HIGGINS MENTIONED WE GOT A E-MAIL LETTER [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] IT IS NOTED. THERE WAS ANOTHER LETTER FROM EAST CONTRA COSTA FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT REQUESTING THAT IF THE PROJECT DOES HAPPEN, THE IMPACT FEES THE DEVELOPER TO PARTICIPATE IN THE FIRE DISTRICT COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT WAS A REQUEST FROM THEM. I HAVE ONE BLUE CARD FROM JOSEPH SULLIVAN. >> GOOD EVENING. THANK YOU FOR HEARING ME. I LIVE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD VERY CLOSE TO THIS PROPOSED AREA THAT IS THEY WANT TO DEVELOP MORE HOMES. LIKE TO START BY TELLING YOU ABOUT MY SELF. I MOVED TO OAKLEY IN 1995 AND BOUGHT A BRAND NEW HOME OFF OAK GROVE COURT. SINCE THEN WE HAVE SEEN SOME QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUES IN THE AREA DUE TO THE OVER-BUILDING OF RESIDENTIAL HOMES. I COMMUTE, MY BUSINESS IS IN CONCORD, MY BUSINESS IS IN CONCORD BECAUSE THERE IS NO PLACE TO PUT MY BUSINESS OUT HERE. I OWN A SMALL MANUFACTURING COMPANY AND WE DON'T HAVE A PLACE FOR BUSINESSES. THERE IS EVERYONE IS COMMUTING AND BY PUTTING MORE HOMES IN THIS AREA IS GOING TO REDUCE THE QUALITY OF LIFE. IT IS GOING TO PUT HUNDRED HOUSES IN, IT PUTS A HUNDRED TO 150 MORE CARS COMMUTING DURING THE COMMUTE HOURS. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE CITIES AND SURROUNDING CITIES PUT A MORATORIUM ON RESIDENTIAL BUILDING UNTIL WE GET DECENT INFRASTRUCTURE OUT HERE AND KEEP JOBS IN THE AREA AND REDUCE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE ON HIGHWAY 4. THE WIDENING OF HIGHWAY 4 IS GREAT, BUT I STILL DRIVE 25 MILES AND TAKES ME A HOUR TO HOUR AND A HALF TO GET TO WORK EVERY DAY. I LOSE 2 TO 3 HOURS OF MY LIFE ON THE ROAD EVERY DAY BECAUSE THEY PUT MORE AND MORE HOUSES OUT HERE AND THERE IS NO JOBS. I WOULD LIKE AS I SAID BEFORE, A MORATORIUM AND SEE OAKLEY TAKE THE LEAD AND SAY COME ON PEOPLE, OUR QUALITY OF LIFE IS GOING TO POT. THIS ISN'T WHAT OAKLEY WAS 15 OR 20 YEARS AGO OR BRENTWOOD OR ANTIOCH. PEOPLE ARE SPENDING MORE TIME ON THE ROAD. THE ROADS ARE GARBAGE. I TALKED TO A GENTLEMEN AT THE CITY JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO ABOUT HOW LAUREL WAS GETTING TO UPGRADE WHERE THEY ARE BUILDING HOUSES, BUT THEY ONLY GOT HUNDRED YARDS TO GET TO MAIN STREET AND WERE NOT GOING TO FIX IT. I SAID WHAT IS THE PLAN? THE ROAD IS IN BAD SHAPE RIGHT THERE AND BAD SHAPE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF MAIN AND THEY SAID WELL WE DON'T HAVE A PLAN AND FIX AS THEY GO. WE ARE TEARING UP THE CARS DRIVING ON THESE GARBAGE ROAD BUT I PAY MY TAXES. WHERE ARE THE TAXES GOING? WE NEED TO FIX THE ROADS AND DON'T NEED TO PUT MORE ON THE ROADS CAUSING A WORSE QUALITY OF LIFE. I MOVED TO OAKLEY BECAUSE I'M A SMALL TOWN FARM BOY FROM MIDWEST AND WANTED A SMALL TOWN ENVIRONMENT WHERE THERE IS COMMUNITY. NOW THERE IS NO COMMUNITY. IT IS RIGHT UP IN YOUR DRIVEWAY, RIDE IN THE GARAGE AND CLOSE THE DOOR AND THAT'S IT BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE TIRED BECAUSE THEY SPEND ALL THE TIME ON THE ROAD. I'M A FORTUNATE, ONLY HAVE TO GO 25 MILES, WHAT ABOUT THE PEOPLE DRIVING 60 MILES? QUALITY OF LIFE IS DECREASING BECAUSE TOO MANY HOMES AND NO JOBS. I WOULD LOVE TO PUT MY BUSINESS OUT HERE, BUT I CAN'T BECAUSE THERE IS NO BUILDINGS. THANK YOU FOR HEARING ME. >> THANK YOU. (APPLAUSE) >> DID YOU HAVE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] YES, MR. MONTGOMERY. >> I THOUGHT I MIGHT BE WISE TO LET THE APPLICANT TO MAYBE SPEAK. HE MIGHT ANSWER QUESTION BEFORE THEY COME FORWARD AND JUST TO ADD TO WHAT THE GENTLEMEN OR MAYBE TO CLARIFY, LAUREL ROAD FROM MELLOW WOOD TO MAIN IS ALL MOST COMPLETED AND DESIGNED. THERE IS A CERTAIN PLAN FOR IT AND WILL BE BID IN THE SPRING AND BUILT NEXT YEAR, SO THERE IS CERTAINLY A PLAN FOR THAT. OAKLEY ROADS ARE ACTUALLY FROM A PAVEMENT CONDITION INDEX OR HIGHEST IN THE COUNT Y. SO WHILE THERE IS ROOM TO IMPROVE, THE ROADS ARE VERY HIGH QUALITY. >> THANK YOU. YES, I HAVE MANY OF THE SAME SENTIMENTS BUT BEING ON THIS SIDE OF IT AND TAKING THE TIME TO UNDERSTAND WHAT SOME OF THE BARRIERS ARE, HAS OPENED MY EYES. EVERYONE IN THE AREA ALL THE OTHER CITIES WE ARE ALL WORKING TOGETHER TO TRY TO BRING JOBS TO THIS AREA, HOWEVER, THERE IS BIG BONUSES AND BUSINESSES THAT GET INCENTIVES FROM BEING ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE BAY AND IT IS UNFORTUNATE BECAUSE CITIES DON'T HAVE THE MONEY TO MAKE INCENTIVES AND IT IS SLOW BECAUSE THERE ISN'T MONEY TO THAT. FOR US TO PUT A MORATORIUM ON HOUSING WOULD BE VERY DIFFICULT AND A LOT OF THE OWNERS OF THE LANDS HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO SELL TO DEVELOPERS AND THOSE DEVELOPERS THEN HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO DEVELOP AND IF WE WERE TO PUT A MORATORIUM ON THEM YOU WOULD SEE LAWSUITS LEFT AND RIGHT THAT WE DON'T HAVE MONEY TO PAY FOR. WHILE I UNDERSTAND THE FRUSTRATION, AND IT IS UNFORTUNATELY YOU DON'T FEEL THE SMALL TOWN FEEL THAT USED TO BE HERE, I CAN GUARANTEE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO STILL DO, WHO STILL FEEL OAKLEY IS A GREAT PLACE TO LIVE. I HAVE BEEN HERE JUST-SORRY, YOUR TIME IS UP. BUT I KNOW I HEAR YOU AND HAVE THE SAME SENTIMENTS AND THOSE ARE THINGS WE ARE WORKING ON ALONG WITH OTHER CITIES AND TRYING TEW TRACT JOBS AND BUSINESSES TO COME OUT HERE AND YOU WOULD BE SURPRISED, THERE IS A LOT OF COMMERCIAL AVAILABLE OUT HERE FOR PEOPLE TO DEVELOP ON IT IS MONEY AND LOCATION NEEDS TO BE SOMEWHAT ATTRACTIVE TO THEM. I WILL GO AHEAD AND NOW CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND WE WILL DELIBERATE. I CAN ALSO HEAR FROM THE--SORRY, HEAR FROM OUR APPLICANT. WOULD YOU LIKE TO APPROACH? >> GOOD EVENING MADAM MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. MY NAME IS STEPHEN MILLER WITH SIGNATURE HOMES. WE ARE EXCITED TO BE HERE TONIGHT WITH OUR ACACIA PROJECT AND EXCITED TO BRING IT FORWARD. AS JOSH HAS DONE PRETTY THOROUGH JOB COVER ING THE DETAILS OF THE PROJECT, >> RATHER THEN REPEAT A LOT OF WHAT HE DESCRIBED, I THOUGHT IT MIGHT BE HELPFUL TO GIVE BACKGROUND ON SIGNATURE HOMES. SIGNATURE HOMES WAS STARTED IN 1983, IT IS FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED. IT IS BASED OUT OF PLEASENTON SO WE HAVE LOTS OF FRIENDS AND FAMILY EMPLOYEES THAT DO LIVE IN OAKLEY. OVER THE LAST 35 YEARS OR SO, WE HAVE BUILT A LITTLE OVER A 11 THOUSAND HOMES IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA AND MOST RECENTLY HERE IN OAKLEY, WE COMPLETED THE ORCHARD PROJECT, WHICH IS AT EMERSON RANCH AND THAT WAS A GREAT EXPERIENCE. THE HOMES WERE VERY WELL RECEIVED, AND NOW WE ARE COMING FORWARD WITH A ACACIA PROJECT AND EXCITED ABOUT THIS NEIGHBORHOOD. A GATED COMMUNITY THAT WE THINK WILL BE A GREAT PLACE FOR FAMILIES TO GET TO KNOW EACH OTHER, TO CREATE COMMUNITY AND TO RAISE THEIR CHILDREN. IT IS A GREAT LOCATION CLOSE PROXIMITY TO BOTH SCHOOLS AND PARKS WITHIN WALKING DISTANCE TO BOTH. IN ADDITION AS JOSH MENTIONED, IT WILL BE MANAGED BY A HOA TO INSURE THE HIGH STANDARDS OF DESIGN THAT WE HAVE WILL STAY IN PLACE NOT JUST WHEN THE HOME OWNERS MOVE IN, BUT FOR YEARS TO COME AND SO WITH THAT, WE ARE EXCITED ABOUT THE PROJECT AND WE ARE EXCITED ABOUT CONTINUING THE TOO BUILD A RELATIONSHIP WITH THE COMMUNITY OF OAKLEY. I HAVE WITH ME OUR ARCHITECTS OUR PLANNER AND MYSELF TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE. THANK YOU. >> STAY THERE FOR JUST A SECOND. ANY QUESTIONS RIGHT NOW FOR-? >> [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] >> DID YOU NOT GET THAT ONE? >> NO, THE FIRE DISTRICT WROTE A COMMENT LETTER ASKING IF YOU ARE GOING TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CFD? >> YES, WE ARE. >> JUST TO ADD THE PROJECT AS A HAS THAT CONDITION IN THERE AND THE PROJECT WILL PAY THE IMPACT FEES AS WELL. >> I HAVE A QUESTION, YOU SAID THERE WERE ONE COMMUNITY MEETING WITH SURROUNDING RESIDENTS? >> YES. >> ABOUT HOW WELL WAS THAT ATTENDED? Y I THINK THERE WAS BETWEEN 15 AND 20 PEOPLE AND THEN WE HELD A FOLLOW-UP MEETING WITH SOME OF THE RESIDENTS THAT HAD PARTICULAR CONCERNS THAT THEY IDENTIFIED AND SO WE DID A FOLLOW-UP MEETING WITH THEM. >> OKAY. WE CAN GO BACK TO THAT MAP. SO, YES THAT ONE. SO, THE RESIDENTS ON HONEY LANE I WOULD ASSUME THAT EVERYONE TOUCHING THE PROJECT THEY WERE INFORMED, HOW ABOUT ON THE OTHER SIDE OF F STREET WERE THEY INVITED AS WELL? >> YES. >> SOME FOR EVERYONE BACKING ON RAY AVENUE? >> YES, PER THE CITY STANDARDS WE DO A MAILING OUT TO EVERYBODY WITHIN 500 FEET RADIUS OF THE PROJECT. >> OKAY. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME FOR THE-THANK YOU. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. >> I NOW WILL CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING AND WE CAN DELIBERATE. MR. ROMICK. >> WE ARE ALL UNDER A CITY OFFICIAL WE ARE ALL UNDER PRESSURE FROM THE STATE TO BUILD. GOVERNOR NEWSOM PROMISED 500 THOUSAND NEW HOUSES A YEAR. UNFORTUNATELY FOR US HE HASN'T MET THE GOAL YET, BUT THERE WERE 18 BILLS HE SIGNED JUST THIS MONTH LOOKING TO INCREASE HOME BUILDING AND THEY PLAN TO HAVE EVEN MORE OF THEM OUT NEXT YEAR. EACH ONE TAKING A LITTLE BIT OF OUR LOCAL CONTROL AWAY AND SEIZING TO THE STATE SO THEY ULTIMATELY WILL BE THE DECIDER OF WHERE I HOW HOUSES GET BUILT AND HOW MANY ARE BUILT AND WHAT THEY LOOK LIKE SO WE ARE UNDER CONSTANT PRESSURE FROM THE STATE OFFICIALS TO BUILD. WE HAVE A GENERAL PLAN THAT SAYS THIS IS HOW WE BUILD AND FALL TOW THE GENERAL PLAN. THIS ONE TAKES A LITTLE LIBERTIES WITH IT, BUT THE NUMBER OF HOUSES ADDED IS NOT THAT MUCH MORE THEN WAS ORIGINALLY PLANNED. WE ALL VERY MUCH AWARE ESPECIALLY ALL IN EAST COUNTY ARE VERY MUCH AWARE OF THE JOBS HOUSING IMBALANCE WE HAVE. I SIT ON A NUMBER OF TRANSPORTATION ORGANIZATIONS THAT WAS IN CHARGE OF WIDENING HIGHWAY 4 AND BRINGING BART OUT HERE AND WE ARE VERY MUCH AWARE OF WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE TO CONTINUE THE GROWTH HAPPENING OUT HERE AND HOW CAN WE KEEP UP WITH THE TRANSPORTATION, SO WHEN WE ARE SITTING UP HERE IN A VACUUM UNAWARE OF WHAT IS GOING ON, WE ARE VERY MUCH AWAY AND IN TUNE WITH THE PRESSURES COMING FOR US. WE KNOW WHAT NEEDS TO GET DONE IS JUST HOW DO WE INCENTIVIZE AND GET SOMEONE TO LOOK AT EAST COUNTY AND SAY THIS IS WHERE I WANT TO GO? UNFORTUNATELY ALL OF US, WE HAVE A REPORT FROM MR. DAMEN LATER TONIGHT TO TALK ABOUT WHAT HE IS DOING IT TO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND HOW TO REACH OUT THERE. THE FOUR CITIES JOINED TOGETHER IN THE SAME QUEST IDENTIFYING AREAS THAT MAKE SENSE FOR LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND HOW TO ATTRACT FUTURE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL TENANTS ALL OF THEM TO BRING TO EAST COUNTY IS WE JUST CAN'T FORCE IT AND IT ISN'T A SITUATION IF YOU BUILD IT THEY WILL COME, WE CAN'T AFFORD TO BUILD TILT-UPS OR POP-UPS AND SAY COME OUT HERE AND RENT FROM US BECAUSE WE CAN'T AFFORD TO DO IT, WE DON'T HAVE THE MONEY FOR IT AND WE CAN'T GAMBLE THE CITY'S MONEY THAT SOMEBODY WILL WANT TO COME OUT IN THE LONG RUN, SO THERE IS LOTS GOING ON DURING THIS PROCESS AND WE ARE VERY MUCH AWARE WHAT IS GOING ON AND AS THE MAYOR SAID, PUTTING A MORATORIUM ON THERE WOULD JUST INVOLVE A LITANY OF LAWSUITS THAT WE WOULD LOSE VERY QUICKLY. THE STATE WOULD PROBABLY STEP IN, AND PROBABLY TAKE EVEN MORE CONTROL, MORE LOCAL CONTROL AWAY FROM US IF WE TRY TO DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT AND SO, WITH ALL THE PRESSURE COMING FROM US FROM MULTIPLE DIRECTIONS, WE ARE LOOKING TO GROW. WE ARE NOT LOOKING TO GROW, BUT IT IS A NECESSITY TO HANDLE THAT. THIS SPECIFIC HOUSING AS STATED IN STAFF REPORT, THEY ARE LOOKING FOR FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS. UNFORTUNATELY AS PEOPLE LOOK FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE BAY AREA, EAST COUNTY HAS IT COMPARATIVELY SPEAKING TO THE FURTHER WEST YOU GO AND IF THEY DON'T STOP HERE THEY MOVE FURTHER AND FURTHER TO THE VALLEY WITH THE SAME COMMUTES SO THE COMMUTES THAT WERE A HOUR AND A HALF FROM OAKLEY ARE 3 HOURS COMING FROM STOCKTON OR OAKDALE JUST EXACERBATING THE PROBLEM WE HAVE IN THE 9 COUNTY BAY AREA AND EXTENDED BAY AREA AND INTO THE VALLEY TO SOME EXTENT. IT IS A DILEMMA NO ONE HAS COME UP WITH A PERFECT RESOLUTION, BUT KNOW WE UNDERSTAND IT AND WE ARE WORKING TOWARDS TRYING TO ACCOMMODATE AND TRYING TO WORK WITH ALL THE TRANSPORTATION ISSUES THAT WE HAVE. I MEAN, THE STATE SAW TO IT, THE PUBLIC VOTED ON SB1 THAT WOULD SUPPLY SOME EXTRA DOLLARS FOR BUILDING THE BIG PROJECTS. THERE IS A LOT GOING ON OUT THERE TRANSPORTATION WISE. IT JUST TAKE AS LONG TIME TO GET THINGS DONE BECAUSE OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS SET UP HERE IN CALIFORNIA, BUT WE ARE AWARE AND DO NOT HAVE OUR HEADS IN THE SAND. WE KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON, WE KNOW OAKLEY WAS CHANGING AND KNOW EAST COUNTY IS CHANGING. I GROUP IN HAYWARD 50 YEARS AGO IN SAN LORENTO 50 YEARS AGO WHEN IT WAS CABBAGE FIELDS AND APRICOTS AND PEACH ORCHARD AND BECAUSE EVERYONE WANTS TO LIB IN THE BAY AREA AND WORK IN THE BAY AREA IT PUTS A LOT OF PRESSURE ON THE CITIES AND COUNTIES TO FIGURE OUT THE BEST WAY TO BUILD IN A MANNER THAT WE CAN KEEP UP WITH THE NEEDS AND DEMANDS OF ALL THAT GOING AROUND US. >> THANK YOU. IT WAS JOSEPH SULLIVAN. I GOT THAT RIGHT? I LIKE TO INTRODUCE YOU TO DUANE DULMAN, OUR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR. WE HAVE HUNDREDS OF ACRES IN OAKLEY LOOKING FOR PEOPLE TO BUILD BUSINESSES. ONE PARCEL ALONE IS 125 ACRES. WE CAN HAVE SOME VERY LARGE CUSTOMERS COME INTO OAKLEY, PEOPLE LIKE YOU, BUSINESS OWNERS, SMALL BUSINESSMAN, OPPORTUNITY IS HERE AND WE WOULD LOVE TO STEAL YOU AWAY AND SHORTEN YOUR COMMUTE AND SURE HE HAS SEVERAL PROPOSALS FOR PLACES FOR PROPERTY OWNERS ARE LOOKING FOR TENANTS AND ANY OF YOUR FRIENDS AS YOU TALK TO OTHER BUSINESS OWNERS, TELL THEM ABOUT HOW GREAT OAKLEY IS. IT IS AN EXCITING TIME AND I AGREE WITH YOU WHOLEHEARTEDLY. I HAVE NO IDEA WHY THESE BUSINESSES KEEP BUILDING BUSINESSES IN THE MOST EXPENSIVE PLACES TO LIVE WHERE THEIR EMPLOYEES HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO COMMUTE FOR HOURS AND HOURS AND HOURS. SILICON VALLEY, IT JUST-SAN FRANCISCO IS JUST INSANE. WHEN THEY CAN BUILD HERE CHEAPER AND HAVE THEIR EMPLOYEES THAT ARE CHOOSING TO LIVE OUT HERE BECAUSE THIS IS WHERE THEY CAN AFFORD, THEY HAVE GOOD SCHOOLS, IT IS SAFE, AND NOT HAVE TO COMMUTE ALL THE WAY OUT-THEY HAVE BETTER EMPLOYEES. PROBABLY DON'T HAVE TO PAY AS MUCH, PROBABLY SAVE MONEY TOO BECAUSE HOUSING IS LESS EXPENSIVE AND EVERYTHING ELSE. SO, PLEASE COME TO OAKLEY. CITY MANAGER TALKED ABOUT LAUREL ROAD, WE HAVE BEEN PUSHING HARD ON LAUREL ROAD RECOLLECT WE MADE LAUREL ROAD ONE OF OUR PRIME OBJECTIVES, PRIORITIES SEVERAL YEARS AGO AND HAVE BEEN PUSHING HARD ON IT AND WE'LL GET ALL THE WAY TO MAIN STREET NEXT YEAR ACCEPT FOR ONE SHORT PIECE WHERE THE PROPERTY OWNERS ARE HOLDING OUT. THERE IS GREAT FUNDS THERE AND THEY DON'T WANT TO DO ANYTHING UNTIL SOMEBODY BUYS THE WHOLE THING AND THE ONLY ALTERNATIVE IS EMINENT DOMAIN AND NOT A FAN OF EMINENT DOMAIN. I HAD TO VOTE AN A COUPLE EMINENT DOMAIN ISSUES AND DON'T LIKE THAT OR WANT TO DO THAT SO LAUREL ROAD WILL BE A BEAUTIFUL ROAD WITH SAFE STREETS SIGNALIZED CONTROLLED INTERSECTIONS/CROSSWALKS FOR PEDESTRIAN, BICYCLE LANES VERY SOON. VERY SOON. I'M GLAD TO HEAR THE PROJECT IS GOING TO BE IN THE COMMUNITY FACILITY DISTRICT GIVING ADDITIONAL ONGOING REVENUE TO THE FIRE DISTRICT. THAT IS A PROBLEM WE STRUGGLE WITH HERE WITH EMERGENCY SERVICES PARTICULARLY THE FIRE SERVICES. >> THIS DEVELOPMENT WILL HELP PAY FOR FIREFIGHTERS. THE RESIDENTS WHO LIVE HERE ARE GOING TO PAY MORE FOR ADDITIONAL FIREFIGHTERS THEN MOST OF THE REST OF THE RESIDENT OF OAKLEY BECAUSE ALL THE REST MOVED IN A LONG TIME AGO WHEN WE DIDN'T HAVE TO PAY NEARLY AS MUCH. SO, WE CAN THANK THEM FOR PAYING FOR OUR ENHANCED EMERGENCY SERVICES. AGAIN, THE SIS I AGREE WITH MUCH OF WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT THE DENSITY AND PEOPLE AND I ACTUALLY SAT DOWN WITH THE DEVELOPER PROEZ POING THIS PROJECT AND WE TALKED ABOUT WHERE IS THAT POINT WHERE WE ARE CROWDING MORE PEOPLE INTO LESS SPACE BREAKS OVER, BECAUSE I MOVED OUT TO OAKLEY SHORTLY AFTER OAKLEY BECAME A CITY, AND IT WAS BIG PARCELS, BIG HOUSES, LOTS OF ROOM, AND MY DEVELOPMENT WAS PROBABLY ONE OF THE LAST ONES WHERE THEY COULD BE BUILT LIKE THAT. THE REASON IS WE VOTERS WE ARE ELECTED OFFICIALS WHO REPRESENT US KEEP PASSING THINGS WHICH INCREASE THE EXPENSE OF BUILDING HOMES SO THE POINT NOW WHERE I THINK THE PROJECT THEY ARE PAYING NEAR A HUNDRED THOUSAND PER HOUSE BEFORE THEY CAN MOVE A SHOVEL OF DIRT. BEFORE THEY CAN PAY THE LAND OWNERS TO PURCHASE THEIR PROPERTY. BEFORE THEY CAN BUY LUMBER, BEFORE THEY HIRE CARPENTERS OR ELECTRICIANS OR ROOFERS. 100 THOUSAND DOLLARS. YOU CAN BUY A HOUSE IN MANY STATES IN THE NATION FOR THAT MUCH. AND WE HAVE IS A LOT OF PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA LOOKING FOR PLACES TO LIVE. IF WE DON'T PROVIDE THAT, THE STATE HAS SAID AND HAS PASSED AUTHORIZING LEGISLATION TO TAKE THAT AUTHORITY AWAY FROM US AND THEN THEY'LL BUILD IT. SO WE LOSE ALL LOCAL CONTROL. SO, WE DO OUR BEST. WE TRY TO MAKE THE PROJECTS ATTRACTIVE. WE TRY TO MAKE IT A PLACE WHERE WE WOULD WANT TO RAISE OUR FAMILIES. PROJECT WE WOULD WANT TO LOOK AT AS WE DRIVE BY. A PLACE THAT IS GOING TO INCREASE THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY VALUES. IT IS GOING TO BRING MORE PEOPLE TO OAKLEY WHICH ARE MORE CUSTOMERS FOR THE BUSINESSES WE ARE TRYING TO ATTRACT. THIS IS NOT THE TYPE OF PROJECT THAT AND STAY UP AT NIGHT AND DREAM ABOUT WHAT WE CAN BUILD IN OAKLEY, BUT IT IS DIFFERENT TYPE OF PROJECT THAT ATTRACTS NEW YOUNG FAMILIES, NEWLY MARRIED YOUNG CHILDREN JUST STARTING OUT. YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE BIG EXPENSIVE PLACE. THEY CAN MOVE HERE, OR THE SENIORS. WE HEARD FROM SENIORS TODAY STRUGGLING TO AFFORD HOUSING. MAYBE THIS IS A MOVE DOWN MOVE FOR SENIORS. THE KIDS HAVE MOVED ON AND GOT JOBS OF THEIR OWN AND THEY ARE MOVE TO A SMALLER AFFORDABLE HOUSE WHICH TAKES PRESSURE OFF THE OTHER HOUSES BY SUPPLY AND DEMAND FORCES COSTS DOWN INSTEAD OF UP. AS WE HEARD FROM OUR DEVELOPER ON THE PROJECT NEXT TO THE LUCKY'S, THERE IS LIKE A 2 YEAR WAITING LIST FOR SENIORS TO GET INTO THAT HOUSING. THAT IS UNHEARD OF AND I THINK WE OWE IT TO OUR SENIORS BECAUSE THEY PAID THEIR DUES TO DO WHAT WE CAN TO HELP THEM LIVE THEIR GOLDEN YEARS, BECAUSE YOU KNOW WHAT WE ARE ALL GOING TO BE SENIORS SOME SOONER THEN OTHERS. I HOPE OUR CHILDREN WILL TREAT US AS KINDLY AS WE ARE TRYING TO TREAT OUR SENIORS. OUR ELDERS. I THINK I PONTIFICATED ENOUGH. I HAVE ONE THING, GLAD MR. HARDCASTLE ISN'T HERE. HE ANNOUNCED RETIREMENT FROM THE COUNCIL A COUPLE WEEKS AGO. I LIKE TO PROPOSE WE NAME THE UNNAMED STREET HERE HARDCASTLE LANE. >> THANK YOU. SUE. >> I'LL SAY A LOT OF DITTOS. I WANT TO SAY WE HAVE BEEN VERY DILIGENT WITH OUR SB1 MONEY PAVING THE ROADS AND MR. ROHANI HAS KEPT UP ON THAT REALLY WELL AND WE WORK DILIGENTLY IN OUR 2020 PLAN COMING UP AND WE HAD LOT OF OPEN SESSIONS, WE HAVE ONLINE INPUT. I ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO KEEP COMING TO THOSE SESSIONS AND TONIGHT WE WILL GO OVER ON CLIMATE JUSTICE AND THAT WILL HELP INVOLVEMENT AND TRANSPARENCY IN WHAT WE ARE DOING. I TOO GREW UP ON A FARM IN IOWA. IT WAS-YEAH. AND SO WHEN I MOVED TO OAKLEY I LIVE ACROSS FROM THE HORSES AND THEY MAY NOT ALWAYS BE THERE, BUT GETTING IN THE SEAT I LEARNED OAKLEY HAS A HUGE MAP YOU CAN LOOK AT WHEN YOU COME TO PLANNING SESSIONS THAT TELLS WHERE THE COMMERCIAL IS, WHERE THE RESIDENTIAL IS AND WHAT IT WILL LOOK LIKE AS YOU GO AND BEFORE YOU BUY YOU CAN SEE HOW IT HAS BEEN PLANNED OUT. IT IS PLANNED OUT. I LIKE THIS DEVELOPMENT. I LIKE THE IDEA THAT IT IS GATED. I USED TO LIVE IN QUAIL VALLEY AND I KNOW THE NEIGHBORHOOD VERY WELL AND I LIKE IT. >> THANK YOU. SO, AS COUNCIL MEMBER POPE STATED, THIS ISN'T HIS IDEAL PROJECT, IT IS ALSO MY IDEAL HOWEVER IT IS DIFFERENT TYPE OF PROJECT THAT FULFILLS A DIFFERENT NEED. NOT EVERYBODY OUT HERE CAN AFFORD THE ACREAGE OR SIDE YARD OR BACKYARD. THOSE DOWN SIZING THIS MAY BE A OPTION, THOSE JUST STARTING OUT EQUALLY A OPTION FOR THEM TOO. BECAUSE IT IS A HOA, IT WILL BE GATED ON BOTH ENDS AND IT WILL BE UNDER STRICT HOA RULES AND CCNR, SO I HAVE FAITH THAT THIS WILL BE A WELL KEPT COMMUNITY, AND THAT BECAUSE OF THAT THERE WILL BE LITTLE OR NO NEED FOR THE CITY TO PROVIDE MONIES IT GO TOWARDS MAINTENANCE THERE. I DO KNOW THAT THIS WILL BRING MORE TRAFFIC AS PEOPLE DO. THERE IS TRAFFIC EVERYWHERE. IT IS UNFORTUNATELY, SO I HOPE THAT IN DESIGNING THE INGRESS AND EGRESS IN AND OUT OF THE NEIGHBORHOODS ON BOTH ENDS IS DONE WITH CARE AND WE WILL DEFINITELY BE A PART OF UNDERSTANDING HOW THAT IS GOING TO BE DONE. AND I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT EVEN THOUGH THIS DENSITY COULD GO TO 9.6 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE IT IS NOT MAXIMIZING THE AMOUNT OF HOUSING THAT IT COULD HAVE, SO THERE ARE SOME COMPROMISES THERE THAT I APPRECIATE. WITH THIS CHANGE IN ZONING AND HOUSING, IT VERY WELL COULD HAVE BEEN A APARTMENT BUILDING, BUT THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE KNOW WOULDN'T FIT IN THIS COMMUNITY AND WOULDN'T FIT IN THAT AREA SO GLAD THAT IS NOT THE DIRECTION THIS PROJECT IS GOING AND THEY ARE KEEPING IT SINGLE FAMILY HOMES SO THERE IS SOME SPACE. AS MUCH SPACE AS YOU CAN ON A LOT THAT IS A LITTLE OVER 3 THOUSAND SQUARE FEET. I DO APPRECIATE THE COMPROMISES THAT HAVE BEEN MADE. AND AGAIN, YES THERE ARE A LOT MORE PEOPLE COMING INTO OAKLEY. THAT IS BECAUSE EVERYONE HEARD IT IS A AWESOME PLACE TO LIVE, AND OUR GOAL IS TO KEEP IT A AWESOME PLACE TO LIVE FOR EVEN THOSE COMING IN AFTER US AND THE WAYS WE ARE GOING DO THAT IS BY TRYING TO IMPROVE ROADS AND INFRASTRUCTURE AND IF YOU HAVE TIME MR. SULLIVAN WE WILL GO OVER PROJECTS LATER ON THIS EVENING IN THE WORKS INCLUDING ALL LAUREL AND THAT IS WHERE OUR MONEY IS GOING. THAT IS WHERE GRANT MONEY IS GOING, THAT IS WHERE IMPACT FEES ARE GOING SO YOU WILL BE ABLE TO SEE WHERE YOUR DOLLARS GO, ALL OUR DOLLARS GO. SO, WITH THAT I BELIEVE WE HAVE ALL PUT OUT THEIR OUR FEELINGS ON THIS PROJECT. THERE IS NO OTHER DELIBERATION. I WILL TAKE A MOTION IF THERE IS ONE. >> THE STREET NAMING, IS THERE A PROCEDURE FOR NAMING STREETS OR CAN WE ATTACH THAT TO TONIGHT'S ACTION? >> WE DO HAVE A FORMAL PROCESS FOR NAMING STREETS. I WOULD JUST ALSO PROBABLY WANT TO DIFFER TO THE DEVELOPER BECAUSE I KNOW THERE IS MULTIPLE PROPERTY OWNERS HERE AND THEY MIGHT HAVE A INTEREST IN WHAT THE STREETS ARE NAMED AS WELL SO YOU MIGHT WANT TO CONFER CAN THEM TOO. >> OKAY. GREAT. I MOVE WE APPROVE. >> SECOND. >> ALL IN FAVOR? >> AYE. >> IT PASSES. THANK YOU. WE MOVE TO THE REGULAR CALENDAR, 5.1. WAVE THE FIRST READING AND INTRODUCE AN ORDINANCE ADDING SECTION 2.1.009 TO OAKLEY MUNICIPAL CODE REQUIRING ELECTRONIC FILING OF CAMPAIGN STATEMENTS AND STATEMENTS OF ECONOMIC INTEREST. MRS. VREONIS. >> GOOD EVENING MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL. THIS EVENING BEFORE YOU IS A PROPOSED ORDINANCE TO REQUIRE E-FILING FOR CAMPAIGN STATEMENTS AS WELL AS STATEMENTS OF ECONOMIC INTEREST. STATE LAW ALLOWS CITIES TO MANDATE E-FILING FOR CAMPAIGN STATEMENTS IF THE FILER MAKES EXPENDITURES OR RECEIVES CONTRIBUTIONS TOTALING $2 THOUSAND PER YEAR PER CALENDAR YEAR, EXCUSE ME. AS LONG AS THE ORDINANCE IS ADOPTED, WHICH WOULD OUTLINE SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THE STATE LAW, I WON'T GO THROUGH ALL THOSE REQUIREMENTS AS THEY ARE OUTLINED IN THE STAFF REPORT AS WELL AS THE ORDINANCE, BUT IN ADDITION TO THAT, WE ARE ALSO ASKING THAT THE REQUIREMENT TO FILE FORM 700, THE STATEMENTS OF ECONOMIC INTEREST ALSO BE ADDED TO THE ORDINANCE JUST SO IT IS CLEAR TO THE PUBLIC AND TO THOSE FILERS HOW THE FILING SHOULD BE FILED. SOME OF THE BENEFITS OF THE E-FILING, THEY ARE CERTAINLY TRANSPARENCY WITH IT. IT DOES PROVIDE THE PUBLIC ACCESS THROUGH THE CITY'S WEBSITE TO VIEW ANY OF THE FILINGS. THERE IS ALSO CONVENIENCE AND EFFICIENCY WITH E-FILING. WE FIND THE STAFF LEVEL THAT A LOT OF TIMES WITH THE PAPER FILINGS THERE ARE AMENDMENTS THAT NEED TO BE MADE WITH THE SYSTEM IT WOULD ACTUALLY TAKE THE FILERS STEP BY STEP THROUGH EACH QUESTION REQUIRED TO BE COMPLETED ON THE FORMS, AND IT DOZENT REALLY ALLOW YOU TO MOVE FORWARD UNLESS YOU COMPLETED THOSE REQUIRED SECTIONS. THERE IS CERTAINLY LESS MARGIN FOR ERROR IN TERMS OF COMPLETING THE FORMS. THERE IS ALSO THE EFFICIENCY ASPECT IF YOU ARE NOT HAVING TO FILE AN AMENDMENT, YOU ARE NOT HAVING TO COMPLETE THE FORM AGAIN IF THERE IS OVERSIGHT ON THE FORM AND ALSO NOTING HAVE TO MAIL OR BRING IN A PHYSICAL WET SIGNATURE FOR US. THE FPPC HAS APPROVED ONLY TWO COMPANIES TO PROVIDE E-FILING. STAFF LOOKED AT BOTH OF THOSE COMPANIES AND RECEIVED PRICING, RECEIVED DEMONSTRATIONS AND NET FILE IS THE VENDOR THAT OFFERS THE PROGRAM THAT APPEARS TO BE MOST COST EFFECTIVE AND ALSO PROVIDES THE PLATFORM THAT APPEARS TO BE MOST USER FRIENDLY FOR STAFF AND FURTHER FILERS. IT IS CURRENTLY USED BY 130 PLUS AGENCIES IN CALIFORNIA. SOME MORE LOCAL ARE THE CITY OF RICHMOND AND COUNTY OF CONTRA COSTA. AS I UNDERSTAND FROM SPEAKING WITH OUR REPRESENTATIVE WHO IS HERE TODAY FROM NET FILE, ANTIOCH IS ALSO REVIEWING THIS ON THEIR AGENDA THIS EVENING. WE HAVE APPROXIMATELY 50 FILERS AT THIS TIME AND WE UNDERSTAND THAT NOT EVERYONE MAY FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH E-FILING AND MAY NOT BE USED TO THAT SYSTEM. STAFF IS HAPPY TO PROVIDE ONE ON ONE FILING AND NET FILE ALSO PROVIDES ONE TO ONE PHONE TRAINING WHERE THEY WILL WALK EVERYONE THROUGH THE SYSTEM SO THAT ISN'T JUST CURRENT FILERS BUT THAT WOULD BE LET'S SAY ANYONE RUNNING FOR OFFICE AS WELL, ANY TREASURERS THEY ARE VERY OPEN TO PROVIDING THAT TRAINING. WITH THAT SAID, I JUST WANT TO PROVIDE A OPPORTUNITY FOR TOM DEPERT, THE VISE PRESIDENT AND COO OF NET FILE JUST A FEW MOMENTS TO PRESENT MORE INFORMATION REGARDING NET FILE. >> GOOD EVENING MAYOR AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR ALLOWING US TO BE HERE TONIGHT TO TELL YOU ABOUT OUR SYSTEM. FIRST OF ALL, MY NAME IS TOM [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] NOT ONLY AM I VICE PRESIDENT AND CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER OF NET FILE, ALSO THE OWNER OF NET FILE TOO SO THE GOOD NEWS IS THE BUCK TRULY DOES STOP WITH PEE BEING THE COO OF THE COMPANY. I'LL GIVE YOU INFORMATION ABOUT WHAT THE SYSTEM WILL DO FOR YOU. IF I CAN GET YOUR ATTENTION HERE. SO, FUNDAMENTALLY NET FILE HAS BEEN AROUND 20 YEARS. WE WERE FOUNDED IN 1998 AND THE FIRST COMPANY TO ELECTRONICALLY FILE A CAMPAIGN STATEMENT IN CALIFORNIA IN THE YEAR 2000 AND SINCE THEN OUR COMPANY DEALS WITH APPROXIMATELY 70 PERCENT OF ALL ELECTRONIC FILINGS FILED THROUGH THE SECRETARY OF STATE WITH COMMITTEES WITH STATE FILING REQUIREMENTS. IN 2003, WE JUMPED INTO THE AGENCY SYSTEM PLATFORM THROUGH THE COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA WHO WAS OUR FIRST CLIENT THAT WANTED TO DO WHAT THE STATE WAS DOING AT THE COUNTY LEVEL BECAUSE THEY WERE TIRED OF MANUALLY REDACTING AND POSTING FILINGS ONLINE AND THEY CONTACTED THE SECRETARY OF STATE BACK THEN AND THE SECRETARY OF STATE HAS A CLOSED SYSTEM SO THEY RECOMMENDED THEY REACH OUT TO US BECAUSE WE WERE THE LARGEST PROVIDER OF THE E-FILING PORTION OF IT. FUNDAMENTALLY SINCE THEN WE HAVE NOW OVER A 160 AGENCIES USE ONE OF THREE E-FILING SYSTEMS AND HUNDRED PROFESSIONAL TREASURERS USING THE TREASURER AS WELL. WE INVESTED IN A ELECTRONIC FILING SYSTEM FOR STATEMENT OF ECONOMIC INTEREST THROUGH THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO. I GOT A CALL FROM THE CLERK OF THE BOARD BACK THEN ASKING ME IF I COULD DO FOR STATEMENT OF ECONOMIC INTEREST WHICH IS WHAT WE DO FOR CAMPAIGN FILINGS. THEY WANTED TO PUBLICLY DISCLOSE THE FILE DOCUMENTS ONLINE BECAUSE THE COUNTY WAS GETTING ABOUT 400 MEDIA REQUESTS A YEAR SO IT TOOK 6 MONTHS TO BUILD IT OUT BECAUSE A FORM 700 IS A MUCH MORE SIMPLE STATEMENT THEN A CAMPAIGN STATEMENT AS YOU ALL ARE AWARE BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO FILE THOSE YOURSELVES. LIKE LIBBY SAID WE HAVE HUNDRED CITIES IN CALIFORNIA USING THE SYSTEM AND SEVERAL LIKE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY USE BOTH. THE FILER GETS THIS FREE. FILERS THAT HAVE-HAVE QUITE A FEW ISSUES TO CONTEND WHEN YOU DEAL WITH CAMPAIGN STATEMENTS AS YOU ALL KNOW. A FILER THAT USING CAMPAIGN FILER SYSTEM THE SYSTEM HELPS THEM IN THE FILING PROCESS. NOT ONLY IS IT FREE FOR THE FILER BUT ALSO DOES THINGS LIKE ACCUMULATE TOTALS FOR THE TOTALS, DOES ALL THE CALCULATIONS IN THE SYSTEM AND IT EVEN PUTS THE ACTUAL DETAILS ON THE CORRECT SCHEDULE. THERE IS NUMEROUS ADVANTAGES FOR THAT. WE ASSIST THE FILER, ANYBODY WANTING TO LEARN WITH ACCESS TO THE THE FREE FILING SYSTEM THAT WANTS TO LEARN HOW TO USE IT ON OUR WEB SEAT YOU CAN GO TO DETAILED PAGE AND REQUEST TELEPHONE TRAINING AS A FILER TO HOW TO USE THE SYSTEM. COUPLE OTHER THINGS TOO THAT ALL YOUR DATA IN THE SYSTEM IS SAVED FOR FUTURE FILINGS SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT RE-CREATING ANYTHING. IF YOU NEED TO AMEND THE FILING IT IS A VERY EASY BECAUSE IT IS DATABASE PROGRAM SO ONE THE BIGGEST ADVANTAGE FOR THE SYSTEM IS IT HELPS THE FILER. ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE EQUATION IS HOW IT HELPS THE CITY. PAPERLESS FILINGS ARE GREAT FOR THE CITY. NUMBER ONE, YOU DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT PAPER. NUMBER TWO, YOU ELIMINATE THE POSSIBILITY FOR AMENDMENTS TO OCCUR FOR THE MAJORITY OF YOUR FILINGS. ON FORM 700 WE CAN SAY HUNDRED PERCENT OF YOUR FILINGS WILL BE ACCURATE TO A POINT WHERE YOU WILL NOT HAVE TO SEND OUT A AMENDMENT LETTER FOR A MISSING REQUIRED DATA. COME PAIN STATEMENTS ALL MOST HUNDRED PERCENT THERE ARE SOME THINGS THE SECRETARY OF STATE ALLOWS A FILING TO OCCUR THAT MAY POSSIBLY NEED TO BE AMENDED, BUT YOU'RE CAPTURING OVER 99 PERCENT OF THE ERRORS THAT COULD OCCUR BY USING THE ELECTRONIC FILING SYSTEM ONE OF THE OTHER THINGS THAT IS GREAT ABOUT ELECTRONIC FILING ESPECIALLY FOR A AGENCY SUCH AS YOURSELF THAT WANT TO MANDATE THIS IS ALL THE DATA THAT GOES INTO CREATING THE FILINGS COULD BE PUBLICLY DISCLOSED ACROSS FINDINGS SO IF YOU WANT TO KNOW WHO CONTRIBUTED TO A PARTICULAR COMMITTEE OR WHERE A PARTICULAR VENDOR WAS BEING SPENT MONEY WITH BY A COMBINATION OF DIFFERENT COMMITTEES IT IS EASY. THAT IS A BIG ADVANTAGE THERE. THE SYSTEM DOES COME WITH UNLIMITED TRAINING AND SUPPORT, SO AND WE DO PRIDE OURSELVES ON THAT. WE ARE SMALL COMPANY BASED IN MARIPOSA CALIFORNIA AND WE HAVE SATELLIGHT OFFICES THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA AND WE ARE QUITE PROUD OF WHAT WE DO EVEN THROUGH OUR SUBJECT MATTER IF I HAD TO EXPLAIN TO THE KIDS FRIENDS WHAT WE DO I SEE THE EYES ROLE IN THE HEADS. WE ARE THE LARGEST FISH IN A VERY SMALL POOL, QUITE PROUD TO BE IN THAT POSITION. OTHER THEN THAT, NOTABLE ITEMS, TREASURER IS USING THIRD PARTY SOFTWARE EASILY HAVE ACCESS TO ELECTRONIC FILINGS SYSTEM. IF YOU USE TREASURERS PROFESSIONAL TREASURERS BY DEFAULT THEY KNOW HOW TO USE OUR SYSTEM OR ACCESS TO THE E-FILING PORTION. LOCAL TREASURERS HAVE MORE THEN ONE E-FILING [STREAMING CUT OUT] >> WE ARE REMODELING TRAFFIC SIGNAL. THE [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] MAJOR ARTERIAL CARRIES THOUSANDS OF VEHICLES EVERY DAY SO WHAT WE DESIGN WE HAVE BUILT WILL LAST THE TEST OF TIME FOR THIS COMMUNITY FOR MANY YEARS TO COME AND WE ARE VERY PROUD OF THAT. HAVING SAID THAT, WE DONT JUST SIT IDLE, THERE ARE OTHER SECTION OF [INAUDIBLE COMMENTS] THAT NEEDS IMPROVEMENTS. THE NEXT SECT

Minutes of the Regular Joint Meeting of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Oakley Public Financing Authority held October 22, 2019 1) OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Oakley Public Financing Authority Mayor Claire Alaura called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California. In addition to Mayor Alaura, Councilmembers Sue Higgins, Randy Pope and Kevin Romick were present. Mayor Alaura announced Vice Mayor Hardcastle is unable to join this evening. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Fernando Flores, 3rd Grade Student at Ironhouse Elementary School) Third grade Ironhouse Elementary School student Fernando Flores led the Pledge of Allegiance. The City Council thanked him. 1.3 Update Provided by Contra Costa Library Commission Appointee Yolanda Pena- Mendrek Contra Costa Library Commission Appointee Yolanda Pena-Mendrek and Oakley Community Library Manager Andrea Freyler presented an update to the City Council. Ms. Pena-Mendrek mentioned she and Ms. Freyler will provide an update what has been happening with the Library for at least the past six months. She mentioned the Library had a very nice summer program that served many people. She provided several handouts to the City Council and mentioned she will address some of it, instead of reading all. She shared that the Library is the pulse of the community; it is where everything takes place. She shared that online books are available, fun, convenient and great when traveling. She explained the mission is still to bring people together and to that effect, they need buildings such as the new Library in Pittsburg and the remodeled Library in El Cerrito (due to fire damage) which are bringing in more patrons. She mentioned the Library wants to make it convenient to have books for everyone to read. She shared that people who are unable to read are shown to struggle in life; therefore, the Library offers Project Second Chance where adults are able to learn to read and write, and can share books with their children. She shared information regarding Project Equitable Access in which the Library is no longer charging fines to encourage patrons to return books. She mentioned libraries are bringing in new patrons who attend different activities provided by libraries; it is not only depository for books, but a place where people get together. She indicated the County will continue to maintain and promote libraries and the programs they offer. She commented that some online book publishers are playing games to make more

money; they only give library a brief period of time to have the book and limit its availability. She mentioned the Library is working with the publishers to remove that obstacle so people have access to the books. She also commented that if the Library is a place where people feel safe and come to interact with others in the community, they are successful. She shared that the Summer Reading and Lunch program at the libraries was successful; 14,119 pledged to read, 7,810 people finished summer reading which was a 10% increase from the summer of 2018; 10 libraries hosted special events including a space station with guest NASA, 5,453 enriching, fun reading programs, and 5,973 meals were served to children 0-18 years old. 1.4 Update Provided by Oakley Community Library Manager Andrea Freyler Ms. Freyler thanked Ms. Pena-Mendrek for her update. She shared that the Oakley Library is 1 of 26 libraries in Contra Costa County and in the summer, Oakley’s reading program is offered only for 4 weeks because Freedom High School uses the Library for school registration; therefore, the Library offered something different every day to do which included an all abilities story time this year. She shared that Cardboard Creations was held during Spring Break and the children who participated used their skills through a creative process and it teaches skills such as focus, perseverance, and collaboration. She mentioned an extension of that which is offered all year is Lego Mindstorms on Saturdays where children have an opportunity to build robots, Teen Tuesdays, and the Maker Program where children sewed sock puppets and used tools to build rescue robots. She commented that teens expressed that was the only place they had to hang out and relax over the summer. She mentioned in 4 weeks, they offered 48 programs and had 739 participants. She explained summer is over, but the Library continues to offer programs with partners such as Chabot Space & Science Center, Livermore Shakes, and car care basics with Fast Eddie's. She shared Library staff is visiting local schools and every other Friday they visit the Senior Center. She shared upcoming events including: Art Guild of the Delta, Season of Authors, Storytime, and Howl La La Boo. She mentioned October is Discover & Go month (including free BART passes this month to some events) and the Library’s new website and catalog will launch before end of the year. She shared the Library offers new library cards and since their launch in September, 2600 new customers have signed up for cards and 9900 came in the Library to get new cards, providing a 177% patron participant increase. Councilmember Romick congratulated Ms. Pena-Mendrek regarding the successful program for book returns. He shared that a book was returned to a Berkeley library that was 74 years overdue. He mentioned because of the short time during the summer that the Library has with teens, it would be great to keep them more active. He suggested the Library and Recreation work together to extend the summer programs and keep teens engaged longer in the summer perhaps at the Recreation Center when the Library is unavailable due to Freedom High School registration. Ms. Freyler responded that she loves the idea. Councilmember Romick suggested that the Library reach out to Tri-Delta to inquire if a monthly program can be set up to bus seniors to and from the Library. Ms. Freyler responded that there is no bus service on Saturdays so there are barriers to reach the Library; therefore she believes that is a fantastic idea. Councilmember Romick commented he is impressed with everything the Library does throughout the year and thanked Ms. Freyler for her work.

Ms. Freyler responded that the Library has a great team. Councilmember Higgins thanked Ms. Freyler and inquired if there is an embargo on online books. Ms. Freyler explained that the top two publishers allow the Library one e-book for 4 weeks, then will sell it more, and e-books cost just as much as a physical copy. She further explained that the Library also has to pay a service fee to maintain the link. She commented that the increase of cost impacts what the Library can provide. Mayor Alaura thanked Ms. Pena-Mendrek and Ms. Freyler. She shared that her family is part of the summer reading program and she can attest that people use the Library in its physical form as well as online. 2) PUBLIC COMMENTS Margaret Flaugher thanked the City Council for an opportunity to speak. She explained that her neighbors are in trouble and she is here on their behalf. She shared that she knows the City Council is familiar with the background at Summer Creek Place and her major concern is that the residents continue to be told by everyone they reach out to that there is nothing that they can do to help. She mentioned residents have contacted the tax credit allocations committee, senior lawyers, and other organizations, and ECHO has come to the residents’ aid; ECHO was able to get the rent increase dropped to $50 rather than $163, but the rents increase every quarter, resulting in a 25.97% increase in 10 months which is stiff. She explained the lease carries a low-income housing tax credit rider, but residents received a letter from HUD stating the facility is not a HUD facility, leaving residents confused. She mentioned the owners continue to use the schedule prepared by HUD and the tax credit committee to their advantage for tax credits, but they ignore the low-income rent of that same schedule. She expressed disappointment that the City Council and owners were invited to a meeting held by residents but have not attended. She shared that in the last two weeks, 10% of tenants have had to leave because they cannot pay the rent. She expressed they are desperate and soon there could be more homeless on the streets of Oakley. Mayor Alaura mentioned her comment time is up and the Council has her written comments for the meeting record. She commented that Ms. Flaugher’s written comments indicate the Council has stated in the past there is nothing it can do which seemed like slap in face. Mayor Alaura mentioned that the Council’s response was not intended to be a slap in the face. She provided an analogy: the City cannot control the school districts because it has no jurisdiction and it is the same here; the City has no jurisdiction over rents and how rents are controlled. She clarified that it is not that the City does not want to help; it doesn’t have jurisdiction to do so, but it will help and support the residents. City Attorney Derek Cole commented that the Mayor’s analogy is correct; the City has no jurisdiction because local government has no control, no say and no influence over federal and state agencies. He mentioned this issue has come up multiple times. He explained if you have a heart problem, you don’t go to a podiatrist. He mentioned staff has provided contact for state and federal agencies and he understands from experience that it is no prize to contact them, but unfortunately it is that way.

Ms. Flaugher commented there is something the City Council can do; it can call someone who may know someone who has authority to work with the state tax credit bureau. Mayor Alaura responded that the City Council will take that suggestion. 3) CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held October 8, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Waive the Second Reading and Adopt an Ordinance Regarding Text Amendments to Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 (Noise Control) Related to Excluding Residential Related Sites and Uses from Receiving Permits for Sound- Amplification Equipment (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) 3.3 Waive the First Reading and Introduce an Ordinance Adopting Editorial Corrections in relation to Various Uniform Building Codes Which are Adopted by Reference (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 3.4 Acceptance of Work Associated with the Laurel Road Widening (Rose to Mellowood) Project - Capital Improvement Project Number 196 (Kevin Rohani P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.5 Award of Construction Contract to ANDERSON Striping & Construction, Inc. for the Fiscal Year 2019/20 Street Restriping Project Capital Improvement Project Number 234 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Mayor Alaura pulled item 3.1. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the remainder of the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0) Item 3.1 Mayor Alaura commented she pulled item 3.1 to abstain since she was not here last time. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the remainder of the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0) 4) PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Acacia - An application requesting approval of: 1) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 03-18) to amend the land use designation from Single-Family Residential, High Density (SH) to Multi-Family Residential, Low Density (ML); 2) a Rezone (RZ 07-18) from Single-Family Residential (R-6) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 3) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 04-18) to subdivide approximately 13.4 acres into 108 single-family residential lots within a gated community, as well as one private street lot, twelve private drive lots, two water quality lots, and three landscape lots; and 4) a Design Review (DR 11-18) for the home designs, site landscaping,

fence plans, and site design. The project site is located at 5360 Main Street (APN’s: 033-030-001 and 033-030-027) (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Community Development Director Joshua McMurray presented the staff report. He referenced two comment letters received and responded to by staff of which the City Council was provided copies. Councilmember Higgins commented that the City Council received a letter from a resident who expressed concern regarding emergency access from the proposed neighborhood. She inquired how emergency access would work if there is only one way in and one way out. Mr. McMurray explained that there will be two entrances and exits to the neighborhood (Main Street and Honey Lane). He added that the project was sent to East Contra Costa Fire Protection District and while the Fire District didn’t provide comment, it had an opportunity to review the public hearing notice and provided a letter stating the neighborhood must adhere to its regulations. He mentioned that after the project is approved, plans would have to be submitted to the Fire District for review and approval so staff feels there is adequate ingress and egress from the site and that additional access is not needed. Councilmember Higgins inquired about the trips per car off of Main Street. Mr. McMurray responded that it is typical trip that 1 home produces 1 peak hour trip and a traffic impact analysis was taken into account when staff performed the environmental review. Mayor Alaura mentioned that one public testimony email letter was received and noted, and the Fire District submitted a letter requesting impact fees and a community facilities district for fire services in the neighborhood. Public Comment Joseph Sullivan commented that he has lived in the neighborhood close to the proposed development since 1995. He expressed concern regarding the quality of life residents have due to overbuilding homes which produce more cars on the road, adversely impacting commute traffic. He explained he commutes to his small manufacturing business in Concord because there is no place for his business in Oakley. He mentioned he would like to see Oakley take the lead on a moratorium on more houses being built until more infrastructure and jobs are available. He commented that the roads are garbage and he was told Laurel Road will be completed except a portion to Main Street. He inquired where his taxes are going. He explained he is from a small farm town in the Midwest and he wants to keep a small town environment in Oakley where there is community. He explained now there is no community; residents return to their homes, go in their garages and close the door because residents are tired because they are spending all of their time on the road. He expressed he is fortunate to only have to go 25 miles rather than 60 miles or more that commuters drive, but the quality of life for residents is decreasing because there are too many homes and no jobs. He also expressed he would love to put his business in Oakley, but he cannot because there are no buildings. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented that the applicant may want an opportunity to speak as he may answer questions before they come forward. He clarified that Laurel Road (from Mellowood Drive to Main Street) is almost completed and designed. He shared there will be a bid in the spring and it will be built next year. He mentioned there is always room to

improve roads, but Oakley’s roads are very high quality; on a pavement condition index, Oakley roads are the highest in the County. Mayor Alaura commented she has many of the same sentiments, but being on that side of it and taking the time to understand what some of the barriers are, has opened her eyes. She mentioned all of the cities are working together to try to bring jobs to this area; however, there are bonuses and businesses that receive incentives from being on the other side of the Bay and it is unfortunate because cities here don’t have the money to make incentives and it is slow because there isn’t money for that. She further explained that property owners have the right to sell to developers and developers have the right to develop; if the City steps in to try and prevent that by imposing a moratorium, it would likely face a number of lawsuits which it doesn’t have money to pay for. She expressed that she understands Mr. Sullivan’s frustration and it is unfortunate that he does not feel the small town feel, but many still do. She mentioned she hears him, shares some of the same sentiments, and the City is working with surrounding cities to try and attract new business and jobs, but the money and location need to be attractive to bring business. Mayor Alaura closed the public hearing. The applicant, Steve Miller with Signature Homes shared that Signature Homes started in 1983 and is family owned and operated out of Pleasanton; the company has many friends, family and employees who live in Oakley. He mentioned Signature Homes completed the Orchard Project at Emerson Ranch and he is excited about the Acacia project which will be an HOA managed community in a great location close to both schools and parks. He commented that Signature Homes hopes to continue to build its relationship with Oakley. Councilmember Pope inquired if the neighborhood will have a community facilities district (CFD). Mr. Miller confirmed it will have a CFD. Mr. McMurray added that the project is conditioned to have the impact fees as well. Mayor Alaura asked Mr. Miller to confirm if one community meeting was held with surrounding residents and if it was well attended. Mr. Miller confirmed one community meeting was held and15-20 people attended. He added that a follow up meeting was held to address specific concerns. Mayor Alaura inquired if residents on Honey Lane, the other side of the street, and everyone backing on Raye Avenue were invited. Mr. Miller confirmed they were all invited in compliance with the City’s standards to provide mailed notice to property owners within a 500 foot radius of the proposed project. Councilmember Romick commented that in California, city officials are under pressure by the state to build. He explained that Governor Newsom promised 500 thousand new houses a year and signed 18 bills just this month to increase building and there are more bills proposed for next year. He also explained that each bill is taking local control away and giving it to the state. He further explained that the City has a General Plan and it is what the City follows for build; this project adds some additional homes, but not much greater than what was originally planned. He

shared that he sits on transportation agencies and is aware of what needs to happen to keep up with growth; the Council is not in vacuum; it knows what needs to get done, but the issue is how to incentivize and attract business to East County. He mentioned a report will be forthcoming from Dwayne Dalman, the City’s Economic Development Manager, tonight. He explained that the four East County cities are in discussion to identify areas for light industrial, but the cities can’t force it and can’t afford to build for them to come; there is no funding and the cities can’t gamble funds. He commented that placing a moratorium on build would invite lawsuits and the state may step in and take away more local control; therefore, there is pressure from multiple directions and growth is necessary to attract business. He also commented that East County has more affordable housing compared to the rest of the Bay Area or people move to the valley and commute even further, congesting roads even more. He expressed he understands it is a dilemma with no perfect resolution, but he understand the issues and the cities are trying to work on it. He shared that SB 1 funding is for big transportation projects, but it takes a long time to get things done due to California’s environmental laws. He recognized East County is changing as are other areas of the Bay Area where everyone wants to live and work which places pressure on cities to figure out the best way to build in a manner that can keep up with needs and demands. Councilmember Pope introduced Mr. Sullivan to Dwayne Dalman, Economic Development Manager. He commented that Oakley has many parcels available to build business; the opportunity is here and he would love to steal Mr. Sullivan away from Concord and shorten his commute. He asked Mr. Sullivan to please tell other business owners about Oakley. He mentioned he doesn’t understand why businesses build in the most expensive places to live where employees must commute when they can build here cheaper, it is safe, there are good schools, and have employees closer to home and work which would likely save them money. He also mentioned Laurel Road is a priority and is going to get to Main Street next year except one short piece where a property owner is holding onto it until someone wants to buy the entire piece. He shared the alternative is eminent domain which he is not a fan of. He mentioned the infrastructure is coming soon with safe streets signalized, controlled intersections and crosswalks for pedestrians, and bicycle lanes. He expressed he is glad to hear the project will include a CFD to provide ongoing revenue for fire service; it will help pay for firefighters; and residents here will pay more than other residents for fire services so they should be thanked. He commented he spoke with the developer regarding crowding more people into less space because when he moved to Oakley there were larger lots, but he understands that when the land is purchased, it already costs the builder $100k to build. He mentioned many people are looking for places to live and if Oakley doesn’t provide housing, the state can take local authority away and then build it for Oakley. He explained that the City Council and staff are trying to make projects attractive, a place where they would want to live and to bring more people to Oakley as customers for the type of businesses Oakley wants to attract. He mentioned this is not the type of project he would dream about, but it attracts people to Oakley that can afford it which may include new families or downsizing for seniors; with supply and demand, it will free up other housing, forcing costs down instead of up. He expressed that he is glad Councilmember Hardcastle is not here this evening so he can propose to name a street within the project Hardcastle Lane. Councilmember Higgins commented that the City Council is diligent with using SB 1 money to keep up with road improvements. She mentioned the City has open sessions and online input for the community to participate, to provide transparency, and invite community involvement. She shared that she also grew up in a farm area and Oakley has a map how the City is planned out so residents know where commercial and residential development will occur before they

purchase their homes. She mentioned she likes the development and that it is gated. She shared she used to live in Quail Valley, knows the area well and likes it. Mayor Alaura commented that this is a different project that fills a need for a starter home or downsizing, it will be HOA managed and gated, it will have strict CCR’s, and she has faith it will be a well-kept community where the City will have little or no need to provide funding for its maintenance. She also commented it will bring more traffic, but the ingress and egress is expected to be designed with care and the City Council will decide how it is to be done. She mentioned she appreciates that the developer is not maximizing the amount of housing it could have and she appreciates that compromise. She explained with the change in zoning, the housing could have been an apartment building, but she is glad that is not the direction the project is going; the developer is keeping it single-family homes that will provide some space. She commented that she hopes more people are coming to Oakley because people are hearing what an awesome place Oakley is to live and she wants to keep it that way. She mentioned they hope to keep Oakley an awesome place to live by improving roads and infrastructure. Councilmember Pope inquired if the street naming can be attached to the action of the Council tonight. Mr. McMurray responded that there is a formal process for street naming and deferred to the developer, indicating he knows there are multiple property owners present this evening; therefore, the developer may wish to confer with them. It was moved by Councilmember Pope and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to adopt the resolutions and waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0) 5) REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Waive the First Reading and Introduce an Ordinance Adding Section 2.1.009 to the Oakley Municipal Code Requiring Electronic Filing of Campaign Statements and Statements of Economic Interests (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) City Clerk Libby Vreonis presented the staff report. Tom Diebert, Owner, Vice President and COO of NetFile, provided additional information regarding services NetFile provides. Councilmember Romick commented it is about time; he has been waiting for e-filing to happen in the City. Councilmember Higgins inquired if it would outsource the Clerk’s job. City Manager Bryan Montgomery commented the City Clerk has many other tasks to keep her busy. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0)

5.2 Fiscal Year 2019/20 First Quarter Report on the Capital Improvement Program (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Public Works Director Kevin Rohani presented the staff report. He discussed the Laurel Road/Rose Avenue Intersection Improvement Project, the Laurel Road Widening Project (Rose Avenue to Mellowood Drive), the Laurel Road Reconstruction Project (Mellowood Drive to Main Street), the Downtown Train Platform Station and Parking Lot Phase 1 Project, the New Fire Station #55 Construction Project, the Athletic Field at Nunn-Wilson Park Project, the Vintage Parkway Repair and Rehabilitation Project, the Fiscal Year 2019-2020 Street Repair and Resurfacing Project, the Oakley Civic Center Emergency Generator Project, the Main Street/O’Hara Avenue Intersection Improvement Project, the Delta de Anza and Marsh Creek Trail Connection Safety Improvements Project, the Police Locker Room and Detective Room Expansion Project, and the Empire Avenue/Gateway Drive Signalization Project. Councilmember Higgins inquired if the parking lot for the train platform will be built before 2021. Mr. Rohani explained that the railroad was going to have their own consultant but then asked the City to use its consultant and it takes time to coordinate, but they email each other daily. He further explained that there are multiple agencies on the railroad side working with them and he would expect at this pace, in the third quarter of 2020 to have the design completed, but he can’t say at this point if parking lot and platform will be concurrent. He mentioned construction is expected by 2021. Councilmember Romick commented that he has been in contact with BNSF, Amtrak and the JPA. He explained that BNSF owns the railroad and it has to be cleared with them first. He added BNSF is on its own time schedule which does not necessarily coordinate with the City's schedule. He mentioned he reached out to JPA and it is a go, but is taking longer than everyone is used to at the City. Mayor Alaura mentioned the City Council decided for the crosswalk at Cloverbrook to be removed and it has been removed. She inquired what other measures are being taken to encourage crossing at the new signal (at Rose Avenue and Laurel Road). Mr. Rohani mentioned staff has placed barricades, had conversations with residents regarding safe crossing, and will continue to monitor the area. He mentioned it will take time for change because it is a matter of convenience, but the crosswalk was not safer. Mayor Alaura inquired if notices were provided to the neighborhood residents. Mr. Rohani confirmed residents were notified and they continue to be engaged on Oakley on Demand and through phone calls. He mentioned the signal was just turned on last week, he is receiving positive feedback on the traffic flow, and he expects things will settle in time. Mayor Alaura commented that she wants to ensure no one gets hurt and everyone is aware where to cross (at the signal light). She shared that when she is commuting through the intersection, she is not certain the signal is a time-saver because everyone is commuting to school in the morning, but it feels like things flow easier with the signal. Mr. Rohani mentioned there are dedicated left turn lanes at Rose Avenue and Laurel Road to alleviate cut through traffic in the neighborhood, especially near Cloverbrook.

Mayor Alaura expressed that she is glad an emergency generator is coming here. She mentioned PG&E has announced periodic power shut offs (throughout California) and while Oakley is less likely to be impacted, during an event, the generator will allow power at City Hall. She proposed for a future agenda that an emergency generator for the Recreation Center area be considered as it could be used as a place for people to gather that is not attached to City Hall in the event City Hall cannot be occupied. She thanked Mr. Rohani for his work. Mr. Rohani thanked the Mayor for her support. 5.3 Economic Development Update (Dwayne Dalman, Economic Development Manager) Economic Development Manager Dwayne Dalman presented the update. He discussed attraction, retention and projects. He explained staff meets and talks with property owners and brokers, creates attraction plans for each property or center and implements the plan by co- marketing on City sites and with outreach activity. He shared the City’s new marketing materials. He mentioned the City’s main attraction sites are at Bridgehead and Main, along the Main Street corridor and along the Laurel corridor. He identified 7 shopping centers and 6 projects that could attract more businesses. He explained attraction challenges include competition and lack of inventory. He shared efforts to retain business in Oakley include the Oakley Entrepreneur Center which provides trainings and workshops and also provides business work space. He also shared the business promotion effort to visit VIB’s (very important businesses) and to shop local. He mentioned he completed GrowthWheel Business training and is partnering with the Chamber of Commerce. He also mentioned he is working on special projects for city property involving requests for proposals and tenant management. Councilmember Romick commented that he appreciates Mr. Dalman’s work; he knows it is difficult to attract retail and for 20 years the City has been trying to reach out in an environment where Oakley does not have rooftops, it has retail competition on Lone Tree, it has the wonderful Delta but only 180° access, and it has only a small strip of visibility from HWY 160. He mentioned he understands the job here is more challenging than in neighboring cities; Oakley has land, but it is more expensive to build from the ground up; and Oakley needs a sugar-daddy who can help build Oakley up and who has same vision. He commented that he likes the Small Business Saturday event on November 30, between Black Friday and Cyber Monday, because most of Downtown Oakley contains small businesses. He mentioned he spoke with the Chamber and it is willing to partner to advertise. He suggested posters can be placed inside the businesses and the City’s website can include a link for local businesses to let people know what is available in Oakley. He commented that although he gets yelled at for it, the best thing the Council did was to slow traffic down in Downtown Oakley so people see what business is in Oakley rather than Oakley being a pass through point to shop in other cities. He suggested that maybe the City should look at ways to further slowdown traffic so people notice businesses and are attracted to them. He expressed appreciation to Mr. Dalman for the work he has done and his effort. Councilmember Pope responded “ditto”. Mayor Alaura also responded “ditto”. She thanked Mr. Dalman for his work. She shared that the networking event held and created by a recent Leadership graduate brought in executives from Netflix, Uber, Coca-Cola and Tesla to speak and motivate others how to reach their goals. She

expressed hope that executives may return to their companies and consider Oakley for future development. She thanked Mr. Dalman and the resident who helped put it together. 5.4 Amendment to Chapter 6.02 of the Oakley Municipal Code Related to Reimbursement for Adjustment to Public Utilities in Streets and Sidewalks (Derek Cole, City Attorney) City Attorney Derek Cole presented the staff report. He requested Section 6.2.702 be revised to omit reference to “public works project” and replace it with “public transportation project”. He also requested Section 6.2.702 be revised to reflect the word “Infrastructure” with a lower-case “i”. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to waive the first reading and introduce the ordinance. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (4-0) 6) REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager City Manager Bryan Montgomery mentioned East Contra Costa Fire Protection District has a “key facts” flyer, copies of which are located in the City Hall lobby; the Fire District encourages residents’ participation and comments online or by mail. He announced the Harvest Festival will be held at Civic Center Plaza from 12 p.m.-4 p.m. on Saturday, the Hometown Halloween Decorating Contest (entry deadline is October 21 and voting will be open October 22-October 28), and Friday Night Bites will be held November 4 in Civic Center Plaza. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Higgins reported she attended the League of California Cities’ Annual Conference and during the General Assembly meeting, members voted to approve a resolution to call upon the federal and state governments to address the devastating impacts of international transboundary pollution flows from Mexico into the southernmost regions of California and the Pacific Ocean. She also reported she learned about Airbnb’s and how the Town of Truckee has handled them. She mentioned the City can request on the Airbnb website who has Airbnb properties in Oakley which is important because the City should capture tax revenue (transient occupancy tax) from these properties. She mentioned the renters of Airbnb’s do not always pay attention to local rules regarding trash and noise. She also mentioned the City should capture a photo when the Airbnb is posted because the property may be advertised with an address one time and not the next and sometimes the photos show the inside of the home and the next time the outside; by capturing the photos, the City can show the property is being advertising as a short-term rental to establish that the Airbnb owes tax revenue to the City. She mentioned loss of local control was discussed in almost every session she attended at the conference. She also reported that she attended the 5th Out of Darkness Walk which raised

$40k and was well-attended. She mentioned she had a conflict with another meeting which is why she could not attend the meeting with the Summer Creek Place residents, but she replied to emails and she reached out to Supervisor Burgis through Dawn Morrow and will reach out to Senator Glazer to see if he can do anything about the state tax board. Councilmember Pope reported the next Habitat Conservancy meeting will be held October 28 at 2pm at Pittsburg City Hall. Mayor Alaura reported that the East County Family Justice Center is now open and provides services for domestic violence, child abuse and elder abuse. She thanked Francine McMahon with Daub 4 Kids Bingo in Oakley for fulfilling the entire wish list for the East County Family Justice Center. She also reported she attended the Contra Costa Mayors’ Conference where the presentation topic was the Contra Costa Electric Vehicle Readiness Blueprint; she learned what cities need to do to be prepared and mentioned the City may need to set aside or find funding for that when it comes along. She announced she attended the 10th Annual Mayors’ Healthy Cook-Off Challenge and Oakley came in first with help of Chef Tonnelier at Oakley Bistro. She mentioned the trophy is being engraved and should be on its’ way soon. She thanked Chef Tonnelier for his help and expressed hope that the next Mayor will participate in the event next year. (b) Requests for Future Agendas Councilmember Romick requested staff prepare a summary by January 2020 regarding the 18 housing bills recently signed into law by Governor Newsom. He mentioned he would like the summary to include information regarding what the bills will do, the impact of those bills moving forward, and what type of restrictions may be placed on the Council’s decision making process. Mayor Alaura mentioned she believes the League of California Cities may already have some of this information available and it and may be able to assist. 7) WORK SESSION 7.1 General Plan Work Session-Environmental Justice and Climate Change (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Community Development Director Joshua McMurray introduced the topic. He mentioned this is the third work session held in a series. He also mentioned staff received an email from Contra Costa County Climate Leaders and it was provided to the City Council. He added that he spoke with Beth Thompson, Principal with De Novo Planning Group, and he and she feel they can incorporate most of what they said into the General Plan Update. Ms. Thompson provided a presentation regarding environmental justice and climate change. She discussed the process of the General Plan Update and explained that SB 1000 requires cities to address environmental justice if they have “disadvantaged communities”. She explained that the General Plan must address the following in relation to environmental justice: pollution exposure and air quality, public facilities, food access, safe and sanitary homes, physical activity, civil or community engagement, and improvements and programs that address the needs of disadvantaged communities. She shared a map of areas in Oakley identified as disadvantaged communities and explained that these areas were selected because of population characteristics and pollution indicators and she suggested potential General Plan

policies and actions for both. She discussed community input for Focus Area 1 showed that top concerns are lack of community services, noise, access to affordable and nutritious food, need for aesthetic improvements, lack of sale and affordable housing, and a disparity between subareas; and top needs are public safety, public facilities, parks and recreation, safe and affordable housing, and maintenance and renovation. She also explained that Government Code 65302 requires the General Plan to address climate adaptation and resiliency strategies applicable to the City and to provide vulnerability assessment that identifies risks that climate change poses to the City. She identified goals, policies and measures that the General Plan must include and discussed the potential effects of climate change. She provided three sea level rise scenarios. She discussed potential General Plan policies and actions to plan for and address climate change effects. In conclusion, she provided the General Plan Update Schedule. Councilmember Romick commented he is concerned residents in the Neroly to Main area on the west side of the presentation map would be concerned if they were considered disadvantaged because that area has custom-built homes that are probably valued at a million dollars. He mentioned he understands pollution, but since most of the pollution causing things along Wilbur Avenue no longer exists, he is trying to figure out how air pollution or whatever may affect them would impact the area to consider it disadvantaged. Ms. Thompson explained it is due to the way the census tracts are drawn and this area includes a sliver of Oakley and a large portion of Antioch that is lower-income or more disadvantaged as identified by the State; therefore, the entire area is a disadvantaged community as defined by the State, but the City can take a closer look to see if it is truly disadvantaged. Councilmember Romick inquired why schools and trails were not included if looking at the physical activity; i.e., the Antioch/Oakley shoreline park (90% of the park is in Oakley). He explained the sports leagues utilize the school fields for recreation and they would have added 10-11 more places. Ms. Thompson responded they can be added in. Councilmember Higgins requested clarification regarding how Oakley has hazardous water. Ms. Thompson responded that there are two different issues; there is hazardous ground water where the ground water basins exceed maximum contaminate loads and there are impaired water bodies and these are any water body list under the Clean Water Act which includes all Delta waterways; the rivers and streams that feed into the Delta have an unidentified toxin present and increased sediment load. She explained that all jurisdictions as part of their storm water permit process with the regional water quality board have identified a number of measures to reduce the daily load. She further explained that the Cal screen tool takes a number of factors and rates and ranks the census tracts based on the factors so any jurisdiction that is proximate or impacted by an impaired water body gets a high score. Councilmember Higgins inquired if it still receives a poor score if residents are not drinking the water and get their water through Diablo Water District. Ms. Thompson responded yes, because of broader indicators; it doesn’t always take into account local conditions such as how you get the water. She explained in a lot of agricultural areas there is use of pesticides so with use within the City you don’t see those applied, but because of the broader area and broader pollutant indicators, you see a higher score where you do not necessarily at the sublevel see the same effects.

Councilmember Higgins inquired about the core area that was considered not to have enough food resources. She commented that she would think the area has more access to food since it is near Raley's and has easier access to food than other areas of the City such as Summer Lake. Ms. Thompson responded there is not a food desert identified in this area, but there is on East Cypress. Councilmember Romick inquired if there is a way to include the homes to be built in the East Cypress area near the levee in the process of assessing flood potential. Ms. Thompson explained that they don’t have control over the model tools to change them, but unless there is an extreme scenario, those homes shouldn’t be impacted. She shared the Summer Lake area is not impacted almost under every scenario. She inquired if he is referring to the Delta Cove project. Councilmember Romick commented that the Delta Cove project is not impacted with the rising level like Summer Lake. Ms. Thompson responded that is how the model looks at it and in most scenarios, Summer Lakes is protected, but the Council can ask future developments to look at different model scenarios and have them identify whether or not their proposed improvements would provide protection. She mentioned state-wide trajectories and global projections for the change in greenhouse gas emissions can also be examined. Mr. McMurray explained that the East Cypress corridor is not subject to policies placed in the General Plan; the existing development is already entitled so they have been approved with existing entitlements and are not subject to new entitlements. Ms. Thompson indicated she will come back in December or January to discuss mobility. Mayor Alaura thanked her for her work. She requested staff post the presentation online and link the meeting video where the presentation begins. 8) CLOSED SESSIONS None. 9) ADJOURN There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:14 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk

Showing the first 24,000 of 1,000,236 characters. The full document is at the source.

AGENDA REGULAR JOINT MEETING OF THE OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY AND SPECIAL MEETING OF THE OAKLEY PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY Tuesday, October 22, 2019 6:30 PM Oakley City Council Chambers, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561 MISSION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley exists to build and enhance a quality community and to serve the public in a friendly, efficient, responsive manner. VISION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley will be recognized as a model of civic participation and a vibrant Delta community where families live, work, play, shop and visit. Agendas are posted in Oakley at Oakley City Hall-3231 Main Street, outside the gym at Delta Vista Middle School-4901 Frank Hengel Way and outside the Library at Freedom High School-1050 Neroly Road; agendas are also posted on the City’s Internet Website www.ci.oakley.ca.us. A complete packet of information containing staff reports and exhibits related to each item is available for public review prior to an Oakley City Council and/or City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority meeting at Oakley City Hall, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Oakley City Council, Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency or Oakley Public Financing Authority regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection, during regular business hours, at the front counter in the Main Lobby of the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Agendas may be picked up at the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561 for no charge. To request information regarding placement on the City’s agenda e-mail distribution list, please contact us at (925) 625-7000. We provide social media options to stay connected to City Hall through Facebook, Twitter, Next Door and Instagram. Other opportunities to connect with City Hall include Peak Democracy, Oakley OnDemand and Constant Contacts. Please contact us at (925) 625-7000 for additional information or visit our website at www.oakleyinfo.com If you have a physically challenging condition and require special accommodations, please call the City Clerk’s office at (925) 625-7013. 1

Please keep cell phones/electronic devices turned off during the meeting. Please be advised that City Council meetings are video recorded and attendees may appear on video. 1. OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Oakley Public Financing Authority 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Fernando Flores, 3rd Grade Student at Ironhouse Elementary School) 1.3 Update Provided by Contra Costa Library Commission Appointee Yolanda Pena-Mendrek 1.4 Update Provided by Oakley Community Library Manager Andrea Freyler 2. PUBLIC COMMENTS At this time, the public is permitted to address the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority on non-agendized items. PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES. In accordance with State Law, however, no action or discussion may take place on any item not appearing on the posted agenda. The Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority may respond to statements made or questions asked or may request Staff to report back at a future meeting on the matter. The exceptions under which the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority MAY discuss and/or take action on items not appearing on the agenda are contained in Government Code §54954.2(b)(1)(2)(3). Members of the public should submit any Speaker Cards for Public Comments in advance of the Mayor calling for Public Comments. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar items are typically non-controversial in nature and are considered for approval by the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority with one single action. Members of the audience, Staff or the Oakley City Council/ Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority who would like an item removed from the Consent Calendar for 2

purposes of public input may request the Mayor remove the item. Members of the public should submit any Speaker Cards related to the Consent Calendar in advance of the Consent Calendar being considered. 3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Public Financing Authority Meeting held October 8, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Minutes 10-08-19 3.2 Waive the Second Reading and Adopt an Ordinance Regarding Text Amendments to Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 (Noise Control) Related to Excluding Residential Related Sites and Uses from Receiving Permits for Sound-Amplification Equipment (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Ordinance 3.3 Waive the First Reading and Introduce an Ordinance Adopting Editorial Corrections in relation to Various Uniform Building Codes Which are Adopted by Reference (Derek Cole, City Attorney) Staff Report 1. Proposed ordinance-redlined version 3.4 Acceptance of Work Associated with the Laurel Road Widening (Rose to Mellowood) Project - Capital Improvement Project Number 196 (Kevin Rohani P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Resolution 2. Notice of Completion 3.5 Award of Construction Contract to ANDERSON Striping & Construction, Inc. for the Fiscal Year 2019/20 Street Restriping Project Capital Improvement Project Number 234 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 1. Resolution 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Acacia - An application requesting approval of: 1) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 03-18) to amend the land use designation from Single-Family Residential, High Density (SH) to Multi-Family Residential, Low Density (ML); 2) a Rezone (RZ 07-18) from Single-Family Residential (R-6) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 3) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 04-18) to subdivide approximately 13.4 acres into 108 single-family residential lots within a gated community, as well as 3

one private street lot, twelve private drive lots, two water quality lots, and three landscape lots; and 4) a Design Review (DR 11-18) for the home designs, site landscaping, fence plans, and site design. The project site is located at 5360 Main Street (APN’s: 033-030-001 and 033-030-027). (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Suggested Action: Staff recommendation: 1) Open the Public Hearing, 2) Receive the Staff Report, 3) Receive Questions from the City Council, 4) Receive Public Testimony, 5) Close the Public Hearing, 6) Deliberate, 7) Summarize the Deliberation, 8) Adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration, 9) Adopt a Resolution approving the General Plan Amendment, 10) Waive the first reading and introduce an Ordinance approving the Rezone, and 11) Adopt a resolution approving the Vesting Tentative Map and Design Review. Staff Report 1. Vicinity Map 2. Public Hearing Notice 3. Initial Study with Mitigated Negative Declaration 3a. Errata Sheet 4. Applicant’s Plans 5. Citizen Planning Advisor Comments 6. Proposed General Plan Land Use Amendment Resolution 6a - Exhibit to General Plan Land Use Amendment Resolution 7. Proposed Rezone Ordinance 7a - Exhibit to Proposed Rezone Ordinance 8. Proposed Design Review Resolution 5. REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Waive the First Reading and Introduce an Ordinance Adding Section 2.1.009 to the Oakley Municipal Code Requiring Electronic Filing of Campaign Statements and Statements of Economic Interests (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Staff Report 1. Proposed Ordinance 5.2 Fiscal Year 2019/20 First Quarter Report on the Capital Improvement Program (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) Staff Report 5.3 Economic Development Update (Dwayne Dalman, Economic Development Director) 5.4 Amendment to Chapter 6.02 of the Oakley Municipal Code Related to Reimbursement for Adjustment to Public Utilities in Streets and Sidewalks (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 4

Staff Report 1. Ordinance 6. REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency (b) Requests for Future Agendas 7. WORK SESSION 7.1 General Plan Work Session-Environmental Justice and Climate Change (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Staff Report 1. White Paper - Environmental Justice 2. White Paper - Climate Adaptation 8. CLOSED SESSIONS 9. ADJOURN 5

Minutes of the Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Meeting held October 8, 2019 1. OPENING MATTERS 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority Vice Mayor Doug Hardcastle called the meeting to order in the Oakley City Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California at 6:30 p.m. In addition to Vice Mayor Hardcastle, Councilmembers Sue Higgins and Kevin Romick were present. Vice Mayor Hardcastle announced Mayor Claire Alaura was absent due to a family emergency and Councilmember Randy Pope was absent due to his police duty. Vice Mayor Hardcastle made a public service announcement that PG&E has not informed the City that it will be subject to a power shut off and if the City is notified, it will be 48 hours in advance of the shut off in which the City will post information on its website, provide through its email distribution lists and also include on its message board at City Hall. He suggested residents prepare in advance for any emergency situation where they could be without food and water for 2-3 days regardless of a power shut off. 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Girl Scout Troop #33784) Members of Girl Scout Troop #33784 led the Pledge of Allegiance. The City Council thanked them. 1.3 Swearing in of the Oakley Police Department Explorers (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) Chief of Police Eric Christensen provided information regarding the Explorer program. He introduced the Explorers and thanked Officer Casey Minister for managing the program and Gabriela Banos-Galvan, You, Me, We=Oakley! Program Coordinator, for her role in the program. Chief Christensen congratulated Explorers Juliette Sartain and Daniel Romero for their promotion to Sergeant Explorers. City Clerk Libby Vreonis administered the oath of office to the Explorers. 6

2. PUBLIC COMMENTS None. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR 3.1 Approve the Minutes of the Regular Joint Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency and Special Meeting of the Public Financing Authority Meeting held September 24, 2019 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.2 Award of Construction Contract to DC Electric Group, Inc. for the Installation of the Emergency Generator for the Civic Center Emergency Generator Project – Capital Improvement Project Number 228 (Kevin Rohani, P.E., Public Works Director/City Engineer) 3.3 Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute a Termination of the Deferred Improvement Agreement Concerning 2131 O'Hara Avenue (Derek Cole, City Attorney) 3.4 Appointment of Michael Syrett to the Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.5 Notice of Vacancy of One Seat on the Oakley City Council and Approval of an Appointment Process to Fill the Vacancy for the Remainder of the Term which shall expire in November of 2020 (Libby Vreonis, City Clerk) 3.6 Text Amendments to Oakley Municipal Code Chapter 4.2 (Noise Control) Related to Excluding Residential Related Sites and Uses from Receiving Permits for Sound-Amplification Equipment (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Vice Mayor Hardcastle pulled item 3.5 from the Consent Calendar. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve the remainder of the Consent Calendar. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) Item 3.5 Vice Mayor Hardcastle announced he received a public comment from George Fuller regarding item 3.5. 7

Mr. Fuller commented that in 2013, the City made a loan in the amount of $935k to a private developer and he believes its first increment was provided to the developer in the amount of $343k, then four years later the City determined the funds were embezzled and a warrant was made for the developer’s arrest. He also commented the City is spending money to construct a parking lot for the private developer of the medical building on Main Street of which project seems to be a bouncing ball, and the City provided a $74k loan to a private developer for a business at 4 th and Main Streets. He inquired how the City can say that a minimum $44k is too costly to hold an election to fill the vacancy seat and approve an appointment process when constituents are seeking a vote. He shared that in his opinion, an appointment of 1 day is too many and a year is a lifetime. He requested the City Council vote no on item 3.5. Councilmember Higgins commented that initially she was in favor of an election process for transparency; however, she considered the candidate may have to run for the seat twice within approximately 1.5 years because he or she would run in March and then possibly again in November for the next four-year term which is a lot of burden to place upon someone. She explained an election could be closer to $100k and the City is very frugal with money. She also explained that she has been elected for a reason which includes the decision who to appoint. Councilmember Romick commented that loans have been made and money spent on specific items that cannot be spent on elections because they are designated for other purposes. He mentioned it is financially difficult to campaign and the candidate would potentially engage in two campaigns which could be burdensome. It was moved by Councilmember Higgins and seconded by Councilmember Romick to approve item 3.5. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS 4.1 Twin Oaks Senior Residence Mixed-Use Project (CUP 02-19, DR 07-19, and DBA 01-19) – Request for approval of a Conditional Use Permit, Design Review, and Density Bonus Housing Agreement to construct a mixed-use project including 130 affordable senior apartment units and 5,667 sq. ft. of commercial space located at 2605 Main Street (Ken Strelo, Principal Planner) Vice Mayor Hardcastle opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Ken Strelo presented the staff report including changes outlined by staff. 8

Moe Mohanna, Principal and Owner of M.H. Development Company, provided a presentation regarding the project and explained the rent structure and its regulation by agencies. Ernie Vasquez, Partner and CEO of SVA Architects, provided information regarding the project design. Councilmember Higgins inquired if fire escapes will be provided for the third floor of the building and how people who may be immobile would evacuate during an emergency situation. Mr. Vasquez responded that there is a waiting space near the elevator and the fire department would assist with evacuations. Councilmember Romick commented that he understands the percentages in which rents are calculated. He inquired who sets the rents. Mr. Mohanna explained the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) sets the rents. Councilmember Romick commented that if residents have concerns regarding rents for this housing, they would not come to the City to address the concerns because HUD sets the rents. Mr. Mohanna confirmed the City if not the agency to address the rents. He explained that HUD publishes rents and over time there could be rent increases and operating expense increases, but notice will first be published and provided to tenants. He explained that community facilities district charges are significant in Oakley and therefore it is likely that rent increases will be necessary to cover costs. He also explained that rents are dictated by HUD and what the market maintains, but are not under City control. Councilmember Higgins inquired if pets will be allowed. Mr. Mohanna responded that small pets will be allowed and a small park area will be located in the back of the project site for pet use. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that it seems like a well-regulated business. He inquired if the management company could implement a rent increase if it wanted to; i.e., by $500/month. Mr. Mohanna explained the project will be over regulated by the State, the lender, the investors and their company (through its asset management company and third party auditors) and there is no freedom to charge whatever they want. He added the financial penalties for doing so are significant. 9

Vice Mayor Hardcastle inquired how many people can occupy a unit. Mr. Mohanna responded that the maximum occupancy per unit is 2 people for a senior community, regardless of the size of the unit. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that affordable and low-income housing are often confused. Mr. Mohanna explained that the tax credit program is called the “low-income tax credit program” as termed by Congress for 50% rents that range from $1100-$1300 which is not low-income, but affordable. He opined that Congress created the term “low-income” to help the program sell better. He added that a market study was conducted for this site and it showed the demand is 1,110 units; however, they can only provide 130 units; therefore, he anticipates a much greater demand than supply. Vice Mayor Hardcastle called for public comments. Diane Spurrier commented she is a resident at Summer Creek Place in Oakley and more low-income, affordable housing units are needed as residents at Summer Creek Place are being forced out due to rent increases while corporate is receiving the tax breaks and incentives. She expressed she does not believe HUD rates are being used because of the significant increases recently implemented. She explained with the majority of homeless people now being seniors, Oakley needs fixed-income housing, not affordable housing because it is not affordable for someone on a fixed income. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented the developer would have to have their own money rather than government loans to build it to make it affordable for people with low or no income. Councilmember Romick inquired if staff has set up contact information available for anyone needing to address rent increases. City Manager Bryan Montgomery responded that he has spoken with Ms. Spurrier many times and she has been meeting with housing representatives. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that the City does not set rents. Ms. Spurrier commented that the City can reach out to other agencies. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that was addressed at the last meeting. Ms. Spurrier responded that no one from the City showed up to their meeting, but Dawn Morrow from Supervisor Diane Burgis’ office attended the meeting and 10

wondered why the issue was not addressed earlier in which a resident provided her a letter that was written a year ago. Vice Mayor Hardcastle suggested Ms. Spurrier could also contact Assemblymember Jim Frazier. He thanked her for her input. Two online comments were received. Mike Stewart and Charles Daggett both expressed support for the project. The public hearing was closed. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve item 4.1 with changes as outlined by staff. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 5. REGULAR CALENDAR 5.1 Resolution of Support for the Contra Costa Transportation Authority’s (Authority) proposed Draft Transportation Expenditure Plan (TEP) (Bryan Montgomery, City Manager) Deputy Executive Director Tim Hale with the Contra Costa Transportation Authority (CCTA) presented the CCTA 2020 Transportation Expenditure Plan. Councilmember Higgins inquired if CCTA is asking every City for support and if financial support is being requested. Mr. Hale responded that CCTA will place the measure on the ballot and therefore will be financially responsible, but it needs the support of the majority of cities with majority population for the county-wide measure. Councilmember Higgins inquired if Oakley is CCTA’s first ask. Mr. Hale responded that Oakley is not CCTA’s first ask; they are approximately ½ way through presentations with the cities. Councilmember Romick commented he is on the CCTA Board and thanked Mr. Hale for doing a great job presenting the information. He explained the cities’ support helps to place the measure on the ballot. Vice Mayor Hardcastle commented that he likes the plan and inquired how the money will be kept from the State. 11

Mr. Hale explained the ballot measure is for a local tax and the State cannot take the money generated by the tax. Councilmember Higgins inquired what type of tax is being proposed. Mr. Hale responded a local sales tax is being proposed. Vice Mayor Hardcastle thanked Mr. Hale for his presentation and called for public comments. Antonio Acevedo, Field Representative for Local 152 Carpenter’s Union, expressed support for the ballot measure. Mark Fuchs, Executive Director of the Carpenters Training Committee for Northern California, expressed support for the ballot measure with approval of a joint apprenticeship program. It was moved by Councilmember Romick and seconded by Councilmember Higgins to approve item 5.1. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (3-0) 6. REPORTS 6.1 CITY MANAGER (a) City Manager None. 6.2 OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL/OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL ACTING AS THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE OAKLEY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY (a) Reports from Council Liaisons to Regional Committees, Commissions and Boards AND Oakley City Council/Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency Councilmember Romick reported he attended a Reclamation District 2137 meeting today in charge of the Dutch Slough Tidal Restoration Project and the heavy equipment located near the project is not being used for building houses but rather to restore marsh land; the equipment should be removed toward end of November. He explained Marsh Creek is being rerouted through a channel. He explained the project involves a unique process of creating marsh land out of sand and beginning this month, wood habitat structures will be installed for turtles, followed by tulie planting November through February. He mentioned that 175 acres on the Burroughs property will be for mitigation of the swainson hawk. He also reported he attended a 12

kayak tour of Big Break last week and applied what he learned to the restoration project. He expressed that he hopes the two areas can connect eventually to provide a unique destination of 3,000 acres of open space along the Delta. Councilmember Higgins reported she attended the first Joint Park Use meeting with the schools which was held the same time as the community meeting with the Summer Creek Place residents which was the reason she could not attend the latter. She shared that the joint use areas were reviewed during the meeting including use and condition and another meeting will be held to further discuss the sites. She mentioned the school district

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Oct 22, 2019 - 06:32 PM — Minutes
  • Oct 22, 2019 - 06:32 PM

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: dd9d383477076e651e7b9ac65f0f230e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record