POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Tuesday, March 7, 2023 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 217,937 stored characters

>> test miami-dade. >> test miami-dade . >>chair: another day in paradise, I'm your CHAIRMAN Oliver gilbert and this is our presentation. Today we have a special presentation but I just want to say honoring this woman's lifelong public servant who I've known since I was a legislative aide in. Your are extraordinary service that's affected the entire country. She's our congressman but she's affected the entire country . It's beyond measure, it's beyond capture for words and it's my pleasure to hand the microphone over to danielle nay cava to honor our congressman, debbie wasserman schultz . >>mayor: it's the perfect day to honor a lifelong public servant, someone who has been a bellwether person for us, was sick stood strong for south florida but 22 years she represented her district . That is incredible. She's been a national leader, not just a local leader I'm going to call out some first is to be here with you today , debbie wasserman schultz you for your many years of service and redistricting took you out miami-dade county and we are sad to lose you . So we wanted to take this moment to say thank you on behalf of all our residents. 23 years representing southwest , northwest and northeast miami-dade county over the years . So truly the footprint has changed but the patient has never wavered. You were a bus in surfside you were phenomenal. You helped us with federal legislation . You MAY sure fema had needed to provide for the needs of our residents so affected, so damaged and hurt by that terrible history . But today it's women's history month and we have an outstanding woman leader. She's a dear friend . She's fierce, she's feisty. She steps up, she speaks out and she when first sworn in was the first jewish congresswoman and youngest female legislator in our states history . I remember writing the airplane with you to tallahassee, you were eating cold pizza . That's how hard you worked . You've dedicated your entire life for south florida. You stood up for justice, equality and opportunity here at home and across the nation . You've been a true leader for those most in need and introduce legislation the early act which was designed to increase breast cancer awareness while fighting your own battle with breast cancer. You worked diligently to protect our everglades, self florida's crown jewel, a precious resource and you taken bold action on climate change and safeguarding our clean air and water and you were instrumental during the champlain towers collapse. Fema, you chanted that committee . Helped to launch the federal investigation into the cause of the collapse and you have been advocating for reforms since then to ensure that kind of tragedy can never ever happen again. So your entire life dedicated to the cause , south florida families with an nationwide and globally . So it is my great honor with the members of the board of county visitors and our CHAIRMAN To proclaim today, tuesday, MARCH 7 2023 as us representative debbie wasserman schultz day . And I know others want to say a few words and we will invite you to say a few words yourself. >> I'm going to tell a story others don't know. Years ago we were confronting an issue in miami international airport where we had company that was not treating its employees particularly well. Treating them thoroughly and we were trying to get attention and the company was ignoring us here locally and decided it would be a good idea to have a congressional hearing not just about airport workers here around the country. They were very hard but sometimes their wages and benefits and hours are not the best and I was invited to speak in front of a congressional rain and it was my first time so I was very nervous. Congresswoman wasserman schultz took me up there, introduced me to the committee and really framed the issue in a way that eventually created change not just here at our airport . This company is all model . They unionize throughout the nation so your work in getting us on that congressional committee has changed the lives of miami-dade county residents working forever so thank you for your advocacy for when you need today into the nitty-gritty details doing that for us, we appreciate you and love you. >> there's not much I can add but you are a fighter and survivor and we appreciate everything you've done not just for miami-dade county but for all of us here at the federal level and you know, district 4 is what I represents an you represented it for a long time but I know you still care and will come to a lot of things in district for because it's a big part of the 22 years you represented miami-dade county and I will take up too much more time, I will pass it on to the wonderful commissioner bastien but we thank you and you deserve a lot more than a day named after you for all your candidacy and we look forward to continuing to partner work dishes improve the lives of our residents . [Applause] >>commissioner bastien: good morning and welcome . It's such a pleasure to see you this morning wish you a happy women's history month . You and I, we've come a long way during all these trips to washington dc to advocate for refugees and immigrants and those in search of safe. You've always been standing tall of voice for all of them and thank you for trailblazing the path for so many women not only here in the united states but all over the world. Thank you for being bold, smart and so courageous in your efforts to help all our voices, women's voices, men's voices, all our voices heard . >>commissioner mcghee: the touchstone that set off this was that you not only represent miami-dade county but I am not worried and in bearing witness while you are tempted by residents of miami-dade county anymore you represent every american, not just every floridian literally every american because the values of education healthcare, those things don't just exist in a vacuum so I appreciate your service and your continued service I hope you are still on to miami-dade county voters and residents even though we don't elect you anymore so thank you . >>mayor: we do have the ability to name days and you deserve much more than a day. I was remembering that my daughter-in-law had one of her first jobs working with you so we will talk a little later. We love you to say a few words . >>debbie wasserman schultz: last year was my 30th year in office and I was elected when I was 29 years old, the youngest ever elected to the legislature at the time. 22 of those years I've had the privilege of representing this county and during those years in the first part of the 2000s we had many hurricanes that came our way. I represented richmond in florida city and miami lakes northeast dade, coastal dade and I've been so proud and is then a privilege . Let me tell you there are 434 colleagues of mine, nearly all of whom when someone says where there from, no one knows where that is . Everyone knows where I'm from when I say the communities that I represent particularly miami and one of the things that I always make sure I say when I'm north is I'll tell people you should care about whoever represents you now in the united states congress and need because I'm going to represent you when you retire and move to my district in 15 or 20 years and everybody laughs because they know it's true. We are entitled by rams community everybody wants to either visit or lives in and I'm so proud of these women and you MISTER CHAIRMAN , the progress . We will thank the token man here in women's history month. I'm proud of the work we've been able to do, proud of the mayor for stepping up and taking care of your residents and holding the community get through the tragedy and always being there when we have an emergency or a crisis and really creating the shining community that miami-dade county is so thank you so much from the bottom of my heart , I appreciate it so much and we are a region so even though I don't officially represent constituents in miami-dade county we will keep pushing forward together to make progress. [Applause] >> look up here first. last one. ... [Inaudible] >>... [Inaudible]... [Inaudible]... [Inaudible]... >>clerk: [Rollcall] >>chair: hold on MADAM Clerk. If we can have everyone begin to take their seats and quiet down as the clerk calls the role . >>clerk: [Rollcall]... W have eight members present, we have a quorum . >>chair: please rise for the invocation and pledge of allegiance . Before we go into the invocation though let's have a moment of silence for kathy jackson . A lot of you might not know kathy jackson, she was the county auditor and she passed away and that reminds us , she reminds us of someone who dedicated her life to the service so while the residents generally won't know the things that she did, her service benefited many so let's have a moment of silence for her. ... GOD, today we petition your grace and your guidance . We say thank you for being the GOD that was, GOD that is and GOD that will be and thank you for blessing us with the ability to wake up, borrow some of your air, your strength to do your will for your people . keep us in your way and your well, order our steps and our words. Amen. To the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under GOD, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. >>chair: all right. Before we get started also today I know we're going to... We start with reasonable opportunity to be heard but I wish everybody a happy quorum in the jewish tradition. Happy quorum, good morning. Reasonable opportunity to be heard. We're going to call your name, give us your name and address and you have two minutes to speak on an item that is on the agenda. This is the vioxx I will give, the one blanket disclaimer I will gve . You have two minutes to speak on an item that's on the agenda . When you do that, name, address, two minutes . Also refrain from referring to any commissioner individually specifically. We are a body and refrain from insulting or being demeaning because we are a community . Thank you. Reasonable opportunity to be heard. Maria echevarria , cesar ebarca, jose correa, danielle acosta, odelle torres , sebastian correvado . [Inaudible] >>chair: were going to figure that out quietly pease. Give me your name and address and thank you . >>speaker: joel acosta. Good morning county commissioners. I come to you today not a part of any organization but as a long tenured resident of the city of doral. The city recently experienced a large fire at the cabana plant on FEBRUARY 12 2023. This event which firefighters all week to put out exposed many city residents to harmful levels of air quality. As such this led to an evacuation from the surrounding schools, parks and residents on FEBRUARY 17 2023 . The plant which processes approximately 972,000 tons of garbage a year began operation in 1982. Incredibly this plant services 60 percent of the county's residential waste. The county is responsible for paying 59 million in service fees and about 14 million and pass through costs for processing seven tons of garbage. While opening a trash incident in 2022 made sense today this can no longer be a viable option . This plant is surrounded by homes, schools, parks and businesses . When each of you were sworn in you all took a verbal oath to support , protect and defend the people of miami-dade county. This is your opportunity to faithfully perform these opportunities . On behalf of the many residents of doral who are either here in person or wearing white or watching virtually I am formally requesting that the county reconsider alternative sites for the new proposed incinerator plant . We do not want this plant in the city of doral . >>chair: thank you . [Applause] That's my apologies, I forgot to tell you one other also . First we don't clap out loud, just do like this . And you smile because so we will see your beautiful smiles and to see you with your hands up . If you disagree with what he said that the only hand signal you can use but you frown so we will be able to see your face and note you disagree but don't clap outlined. The presence of signs being held up in the chambers aren't allowed so if you have signs keep your signs down because we're going to be courteous for other people in the chambers, please. >>speaker: good morning to the board. First thank you for the opportunity, it's an honor to be here representing my beautiful city of doral. Three weeks ago we were a quiet community but like a dormant volcano something was about to wake and run its sleep. When we say in GOD we trust we were looking for a miracle that could shut down that garbage plant. . The fire took down the beast out of service and doral is now making national news . Before we were trying to tell you the plant was a home but now we are a united community knowing that the plant was still a bad idea. Before , I'm sorry. This smoke stack always putting out smoke. At night the lights lighting the sky. I am happy to rport that they are out. The smell is gone. Lots of peace and quiet. now it's time to take action . You have the power of the people . You were elected to make sound decisions and you can make history . If the county still wants a new plant , move it to a new location away from people and communities. However, a better idea would be to drive the county 20 waste using $1.5 billion ideas from recycling, compost and other solutions that are much better than covanta. >>chair: iq, name and address . >>speaker: odelle torres, northwest 66th street, thank you . >>speaker: 7825 northwest 114th place and I'm coming to you guys as a simple student. On FEBRUARY 12, 2023 the fire in covanta affected all of us . At first we didn't think much of it. It's at my school , less than one mile away we were all affected by it . I couldn't go to school and got sick, my friends got sick . My eyes are irritated alongside a dozen people so I am asking for the future of our kids , the future decision-makers of doral to move the plant just because of the safety of our students and for the safety of the future of doral. Thank you . >>chair: give me your name again . >>speaker: conzunduf . >>speaker: good evening MADAME Mayor, my name is rose marrero and I'm here to speak on the agenda item 8 p 17, I'm account manager for the employee insurance program provided by outside dental . We created the dental insurance industry in the united states and its family of companies is the largest in our nation across the national landscape miami-dade is one of our most important accounts . We serve 50,000 county employees, their families and retirees. We competed vigorously in the contract recommended today, I contract that reflects significant plan enhancement and $2.4 million in savings during the initial term. When you arrive at the item I would be pleased to answer any questions you might have. >>chair: thank you. >>speaker: good morning, I live in 6027 104 path, doral florida . And commissioners, good morning. I come here with no speech, I'm just talking as a citizen that's been affected by this fire in doral and this is the moment to amend that decision you guys made last year and the renovation to the plan that it was already out of date. This is the right moment to stop this, to do the right thing and move the plant to another place where it's not a big unity that's around so close by. >>chair: thank you . >>speaker: my name is anna and my daughter is valentina. I live in 100 365 northwest 66th street and I'm a mom of four kids ad we just moved from atlanta 10 months ago and we hve seen that drastic hurricane being affected . She's very allergic and since this happened she has had bruises, a very reactive allergy in her skin and we have been very affected . We would love for this plant to be moved because it's affecting our family, our community and do you want to speak how you feel about it? >>speaker: it was something big that happened. >>speaker: she's 13 . >>speaker: it's really affected me because I would get these allergy attacks and I would enter a panic and I couldn't stop scratching . I don't know . >>speaker: I don't know if I can show some pictures . >>chair: if you have them you can pass them up to the clerk and we will look at them. >>speaker: she has all the allergy reactions in her skin . So where is she ? >>chair: sergeant, thank you . >>speaker: my name is jose correa in doral. I'm here for the covanta item and pretty much I want to say a few things, I don't want to repeat what everybody else said . People said we got lucky because now it would burn down but the whole county got lucky that weekend . We had a cold font and all that smoke went from west to east . It would have been the normal wind we had in the area, you would have had a lot more people sick , a lot more evacuations. They closed the schools in one day. If we didn't have that cold front there would have been evacuations in the whole doral area so that's one thing you guys need to keep in mind. I've been coming to meetings like this signing petitions and most people say even here in the commission the plant was there before you guys and the approved residential zoning around it, fine. we didn't do the research when we bought but how about now? There's a bunch of committees around it and last year you guys approved to build on new one just across from it . If you look at the comparisons they did was from a plant in west palm beach, the residents in the area stood too close so I feel that you guys are putting our lives that danger . What if that fire ended up actually getting out of control and burning all the communities around it. I know nobody wants this trash in their counties . Just find a place that you guys know for sure that will not be later in the future approved communities around it. We're looking for the well-being o not just doral but miami-dade and to solve the waste problem. >>chair: young lady you can... Thank you . >>speaker: good morning mayor and commissioners, my name is sebastian sl, regional director at 1800 biscayne boulevard 33161 and I'm here to speak on the six the one item , we and our members are concerned about the future of the environment of our county. It's been a big problem for residents of doral and other municipalities . The disaster being incinerator reminds us what can happen with these kind of facilities . We cannot endanger our facilities. I am here asking the commissioner of miami-dade county if you would like to have an incinerator in your community and for that I wanted to highlight and encourage the commission to follow the mayor's lead which could be a much better way to manage this and would not expose our communities, children, our grandchildren and have a much better environmental future. >>chair: tank you .- >>speaker: so another JUNE 3, 2006 northwest hundred fifth place, doral florida . I'm going to talk about environmental issues we've had since a long time and which are magnified by the event that occurred in FEBRUARY 12. When dealing with air pollution, we can say that all of us live downstream . That means all of us receive the influence of any emission . And that's exactly what was demonstrated after the fire at the facility in doral three weeks ago. It took a while for the air-quality conditions that we are normally facing in doral were recorded in five out of seven of the air-quality monitors in the county. However , this one event in 40 years of controlled emissions coming from this facility is an awakening notice. In missions that have been gradually affecting more and more people especially those like us who live nearby the plant . Those events happened exactly in a moment where we had the perfect storm. Low rain, high speed of wind and the wind blowing to eery direction. So this was knocked only in dral but in the surrounding communities. It's time to make an informed decision on how to manage waste in the county without affecting not only doral but also the communities nearby. Lakes, all those communities face effect of this fire that essentially showed that doral covanta is not prepared for managing this . Make informed decisions . >>chair: thank you . >>speaker: raphael antonio gomez, southwest 82nd street, miami florida . I want to stand in full support with everyone back here in moving the plant to a different location, maybe out west past metrowest jail . Maybe a little bit west of that, maybe that would be a reasonable location, just throwing out the idea. I will read a prepared statement and then I will speak exclusively about the agenda item so I don't violate the rules . I have everything written down. The board of county commissioners is violating my first amendment rights. I come to every meeting and I'm never allowed to address the issues . I have a list of grievances from residents and business owners that work 9 to 5 and can't show up here. They asked me to bring my concerns but I never allowed to address those concerns. I demand the mafia of dade county commission amend its rules violating free speech and demand the county commission respect the first amendment and I'm going to read part two which is the agenda item and read the agenda item. I signed up to agenda item six b2 , discussion item regarding illegal animal dumping in south dade. I want to make it legal to dump the filthy animals of the county commission anywhere in miami-dade county, can we make that legal? Can we dump the filthy animals in the county commission. Expired . >>speaker: you see what I mean? There violating my first amendment. Crooked politicians . Don't serve me, I pay your salary . I pay a lot of taxes how . >>chair: were going to call the next list of names, selma garcia. Valentina valle, marie porras, christie fraga, event gonzalez, lisa burch dale and we have the vice mayor rafael pinero if we could have him come first. Magaly and seles , you all form a line and come on up . >>speaker: good morning honorable CHAIRMAN And members of the county commission as well as MADAME Mayor, my name is kristi fraga, 8401 northwest 53rd terrace . I'm here to address a pressing issue I believe should be given careful consideration by this esteemed body . As you know the county's waste-to-energy plants operated by covanta located within our city of doral caught fire FEBRUARY 12 and persisted for about two weeks . I want to thank the men and women of fire rescue for their prompt and diligent response and thank the county mayor and her team for her consistent updates and communications with our city's leadership team and want to thank each and everyone of you for taking my calls, listening to my pleas and for many who joined me on site and in our cmmunity to view the impacts of this on our community . For those of you who have not been I urge you to come and see it for yourself. This impacts our neighbors, schools, parks and businesses . The issue at hand now concerns the future operations and redevelopment of this plant . The issue of waste management is one we all face together as a county but for doral it's much more than the concerns of how trash will be processed, it is also a concern of health and quality of life. The plant has been a source of concern for many residents for many years. Just last year we were here in these chambers asking to be heard as a community . The plant is situated in close proximity to several residential areas and has been a source of increased traffic , horrible smells and negative impacts to ar-quality. The negative impact of this facility is on the health and well-being of the residents and cannot be overstated , independent studies have shown that exposure to hazardous air pollutants can lead to serious health risks such as cardiovascular and neurological problems. >>chair: we will give you a little more time. >>speaker: I'm wrapping it up right now. This plant has been operating 40 years and while some measures have been taken to address concerns of pollution these measures have not been adequate and effective enough . It is high time for the county to consider a long-term waste management solution and appropriate location for this plant. Doral is a growing city and one that has made many impacts in miami-dade county. Appreciate your consideration and we forward to haring fruitful discussion on item 6b1 . >>speaker: good morning, rafael pinero, vice mayor of the city of doral, 3316. CHAIRMAN Gilbert, vice CHAIRMAN Rodriguez and members of the board, MADAME Mayor it's an honor to be here with you today . I have come here to express ongoing frustrations our community has had for years with the covanta waste-to-energy facility in doral and while it is unfortunate an incident like the one that occurred FEBRUARY 12, it is our hope it will serve to set the course for a long awaited decision on the relocation of the plant . Our residents have placed complaints and communicated on their locations for years, their frustrations with the facility in terms of its negative effects on their quality of life, air-quality and property values . When the facility caught fire last month our neighboring residents, schools and visitors dealt with poor air quality and smoke emanating from the plant for almost a week . Prior to these incidents there has been also to fires in the facility so it is clear that social establishment should not be in direct proximity to residential communities and heavily populated areas such as our city of doral. We are now the same cty it was 20 years ago. Now we have a voice and a government willing to protect the quality of life of our residents . This facility has impacted the quality of life, elf, welfare and safety of residents, businesses and visitors . Therefore I urge you asked miami-dade county commission to consider and identify other areas outside the city to locate this facility. thank you so much and it's time to do what is right so I thank you for your time . >>speaker: my name is mackenzie martin and I'm climate justice director , 11 w. State road 84. My heart goes out to the community of doral experienced a blazing fire for an entire week from the covanta incinerator that the community had been complaining about the odor and asking for it to be shut down . Since 2019 there have been for fire incidents at the covanta incinerator and any one of those could have been the same situation that happened FEBRUARY 12 . This is a man-made disaster that we can prevent in the future by simply keeping the incinerator shut down permanently and moving towards a legitimate zero waste plan that does not include a brand-new incinerator in the county. We need to move towards zero waste land that creates jobs across the county in each municipality and ensures every resident in this county as clean air and clean land and is not exposed to pollution. And by zero waste strategies that aim to reduce waste, through source reduction and separate collections, composting and recycling and I know some are asking simply to move the incinerator but that would not fix the problem of the waste and pollution that exists . The community does not deserve this incinerator and neither does any other community. We have landfills nearly at capacity throughout the county that still cause pollution on our communities and commission I ask you today and this question was posed are you willing to allow a new incinerator in your district . Again, this humidity does not deserve this incinerator either so I'm asking that we move forward and bring forth solutions that move towards zero waste. >> good morning commissioners, MADAME Mayor, eva gonzalez, 10352 northwest 46th terrace. Here to speak on item 6b1. I've been before you at this podium on a number of occasions likewise as PRESIDENT Of the community coalition and I stand before you today still in my capacity as a member of this organization as a resident of this community. Last year I and many others stood up here and urge you not to renew covanta's contract. You renewed it. Pleaded with you not to act recklessly by supporting the decision to build a new garbage incinerator. Basically solidifying the county's future and waste management without understanding the technology, its pros and cons, without understanding the true impact of the waste management policy on all residents and without understanding the massive impact this decision is having and will have on the daily lives of so many families and residents in the city of doral. There is no way you can feel confident 60 days was sufficient to decide on the location . All we're asking for is you follow the recommendations of the experts that you all commissioned and hired. All we're asking is that you follow the recommendation of the experts that the county turned to for guidance on making this decision . All we ask is you are fair to all the residents and make a well thought out decision that is forward thinking and solid investment of taxpayer dollars . All we ask is you are fair to the residents of doral impacted by this decision. Being fair means a comprehensive site evaluation and all we are asking is you redo the vote of JULY 19. Redo it. Put your time ad energy into it, that's why we hire you and elect you, my apologies . >>speaker: my name is lisa burchfield , miami. I'm here today to talk about item 11 a 19 and basically my concerns about the house bills preempting local governments authority over and over again. I am a small business, I represent a number of small businesses in our community and I know this board has been and the mayor has been a real advocate for small business and it seems that 11 a 19 and I'm supporting te resolution to oppose that senate bill 346 and house bill 383 and any similar legislation continually preempting our local authorities support of our community ad ensuring that small business has a chance to survive and continue to thrive in miami-dade county. I appreciate everything we can do to go to tallahassee and send this message that we oppose these bills and maintain your efforts in managing your community in a way that you see fit which is important to our small businesses and keeping the dollars and jobs right here locally and giving us all the opportunity to continue to grow and be proud of our community, thank you. >>chair: thank you . >>speaker: [Speaking spanish . >>speaker: my address is 7760 103 roach court, doral . [Speaking spanish] I am a mother with two kids and I'm worried about this waste facility. [Speaking spanish] This is a hazard issue for the city . Ever since I moved I've been having health issues. I've had respiratory problems ever since 80 years ago . I've had surgery on my left lung . Although I was a very healthy woman all my life. Every time I go out for all walk my skin irritates. I've had many types of allergies on my skin. In my case the pollution is very remarkable . On sunday FEBRUARY 12 , the fire broke at the plant and FEBRUARY 14 I started having issues on my skin . My family, we all had issues, respiratory issues do to the fire and we had eyes irritated to . [Speaking spanish] We are one community, we are united and we ask you commissioners to take into account our voice and our health. Thank you. >>speaker: good morning, 4370 northwest 10 seventh avenue, doral florida and I am here as a member of the city council of doral and from one elected official to multiple others, I come here rpresenting a community that needs solutions. That needs to be visible. That needs a voice . I want to thank all of you that came to our community to look at the facility and look at what happened almost 3 weeks ago with its burning and those of you that are still in contact with us and those of you that have considered different options for a waste to energy facility I want you to look at behind me at all of the residents, our communities here asking for you to tell us and some of you came from the municipal governments. Some of you have been in our position and I want to thank our mayor and vice mayor for being here, for pushing this issue and I want to ask for three very important things. The first is to please refrain from operating the facility that was burnt. We think it's a danger and our priority is to protect that health and wellness of our community. We would ask that you move this facility not just away from our community but any community . I don't think moving its mile away to medley is going to be sufficient . This facility has to be moved away from proximity to any community and I want to ask you to please consider how we can come up with a future of zero waste. That has to be part of the long-term solution you for your consideration and that you support us in making sure our residents are safe and healthy, thank you. >>speaker: my name is gina romero, 43rd lane, doral florida . I have been against the incinerator for years one of my questions has always been whenever the county was for an assessment is, that we fire in covanta. We never forget the horrible moments we become aware that the contamination is . It's sad to see the lack of consideration for the residents and the next day the children went to school and the air was very clean.I after everything that has happened you know and respond to the residents that time is now for all of you commissioners to work together with all county residents and the administration in search of a solution we passed and one is in another country, another state and it could be limited here with great solutions and great success. You take control now you will never have more control over the future and continued is a problem to another community. Please save the families and children. We are open to discovering with you commissioners . >>chair: okay. MADAME Attorney we have two more sheets of public comment for reasonable opportunity to be heard but what I'm going to do is to spend this meeting so we can take a health trust and you have joined meeting and then he will be . >>county attorney: we just need a motion to recess this meeting . >> point of personal privilege, I want to the residents from doral for being here. >>chair: to your point of personal privilege, they're not going anywhere class I want to thank them for being here and taking the time to come out here . As the elected official who lives closest to this facility are being here. >>chair: when you have a personal privilege you will be recognized to your first , you don't just start talking recess with a motion and a second, always in favor by saying aye. MADAME Attorney . >>county attorney: we would be convening the special meeting, seconded, all those in favor say aye the meeting adjourned . I guess we need a motion to reconvene. The vice chair and bermudez, signified by saying aye. Show us back into public hearing we will continue with our list. When you hear a call, lines on either side of the podium and is your two minutes. Jackson , jackson cevedra, stephen gonzalez, dorothy brown , MISTER Perez, amanda prieto, anthony cabrera, shirley johnson and esther mccant . Okay. Chair, commissioners and mayor, thank you for this opportunity the ground. As long as 46 was less 33127 here in favor of agenda item 11 a 19 which of those is senate bill 346 and house bill 383 . This will any user and cz 7040 programs as well as mcc programs in the future goals for the small businesses also learning local preferences and as you know years ago the small business program for black businesses, women-owned businesses and his was overthrown which resulted in the current program we have which is our race gender control program and the state will be taking that away from us and these programs provide local opportunities for small businesses for years these programs are eliminated is left in jobs, local preferences and the responsible wages we believe in paying our employees a way that is in effect with miami-dade county we feel every small medium large business should be supporting this item will get rid of the program we currently like to know whenever the sponsoring commissioners decide to go to tallahassee because I understand is already gone for the first reading and only the reading is going to be moving fast, aready the small businesses for 53 and now they're coming after all small businesses in miami-dade and I'm pretty sure it would be impacting other counties as well. We can't allow this happening, small businesses are ready to to tallahassee and be left to work with his body to look this time forward t close it because it's taking away everything and thank you for the opportunity and remember small business matters in miami-dade county. Good morning member support, or, 64 three south miami. Represent fiends of the same day and bowl hold the line initiatives and preemption is. The problem we have with the covanta plant is the fact that we were not able to take any action to prevent the use of single use plastic you have plastics issue you have a waste issue so again 18 years ago that preemption did you resulting today so I'm here to support NOVEMBER 8, 2024 to try and prevent another preemption of our own water quality destiny is important that we are able to protect this game they it, restore it . Today the recommendations of the task force and which we are doing al of you also thank you for that. Own which to our water quality our own hands and get our municipalities in all the leadership wrking on all that. Some people is we also want to mention to the five, your wetland mitigation banking item. I think it is important to make the importance of buying land that we know you're going to need for restoration. There are 50,000 acres of land on the acquisition list, environmentally endangered lands acquisition list and we need to fully fund this program is somehow incorporated with the nation backing so we can , we know we need class. Let's purchase them, a lower quality this program. This program needs to be fully funded. As you again fight preemption . >>chair: thank you . >>speaker: my name is jackson civilian and I'm here to support agenda 11a19 and opposes no . >>chair: address please . >>speaker: 7302 w. 17th street . Like you say we are here supporting the small businesses. And in opposition to the bill 346 and house bill 383 because that's going to affect the small businesses in miami-dade is about small business and we want to work all the small businesses that are created and you know, they are people voting for everybody in this particular area in miami-dade . So we are like you say and supporting the agenda 11a19. >>chair: thank you very much . >>speaker: good morning , chair commissioners and mayor, my name is sharon fraser see stevens, northeast first place miami florida district 3. I want to say you, and you commissioner bastien. You did at 65 days of you being elected you cme back to the people you came to listen you to your constituents at the town hall meeting in conjunction with the mayor see something, a something . You came and you trust your constituents and we heard you loud and clear. You? You're district 3, kionne hardemon . I attended the ribbon-cutting, jean sees was in a community liberties where is housing community . Down south when they call our babies of the county , doral as an issue, when there's an issue in any of 37 cities issue in miami-dade county florida city . We thank you MISTER I love to thank my commissioners that's commissioner hardemon and commissioner bastien and mayor, please work with our commissioners because our community is, even your commissioner district 1 , housing crisis, affordable housing we need help in these three districts . As I live down south on the metrorail and see all the high-rises some of us don't want to live in a high-rise she wants to live in a duplex , one or two units but please, thank you so much commissioners . >>speaker: my name is anthony cabrera, 1146 . >>chair: you are a minor, right? You don't have to get your address . >>speaker: I want to thank you for your tireless efforts to bring efficiency and transparency to the residents of miami-dade county. I you concerned resident of vote to build a new waste management facility next to the current one and 97 that . When the class was first built in 1985 miami-dade county residents it has now in the area where it was built close to know people living . Fast-forward to te modern day and is in nearly 8000 people in his surroundings. The snow first concern . Regarding the building of the new facility the existing one of the nation of those fumes after trash is burn not only melt that hinders our quality of life . After the fire started on FEBRUARY 12 at the covanta plant in doral many residents such as myself were concerned with the air quality not to mention the numerous schools in close proximity . The fire covanta not only concerned resident because of the fact that it was a huge fire to let concerns with that preceded the fire to me and addition to her as waste management plan would further worsen the situation and release harmful fumes such as nitrogen oxide that could lead to a series of detrimental health issues. Longtime exposure can prove dangerous to the lives of people and surrounding areas. Police of the vast majority of residents who believe something should be said. I urge you to vote against the building of a proposed management facility next to the current one and consider moving the current one . >>chair: thank you . >>speaker: I live at 11390 southwest 91st terrace, my name is amanda cabrera and I'm speaking on behalf of miami water keeper. I like to the sponsor for 11a24 . State regulation as an important place in our system of checks and balances because florida contains a live range of global unique ecosystems , in one size fits all were here . That's why local policymakers have an important role in our communities . We draw on global expertise and institutional knowledge to 10 policies for our engine is also the balance of natural growth and planning to preserve our freshwater for this game a southern these resources are powerful drivers in our region. We support the state provided on the floor for environmental relation for local governments to take further policy action where ultimately these bills seek to him and the balance of power is a little older and the real work made a county in protecting our watershed. You very much uses 11a24. . >>speaker: MAY my name is esther mccant, north miami beach florida and ceo of metro modeling agency . I am el/relief funding for small businesses and in hnor of women's history encourage you to take a breath and being five months for your third baby after having relaxing beautiful works of julius and midwives to support you but now you're living in watching the news to hear miami-dade county there is a long was just late her newborn in the freezer. As I carried my baby I cannot will cost mom to do that. Was it post partum depression? Was it birth trauma? I never found out why she did it but I came to miami-dade we have a c-section rates, most of the guests occurring in miami gardens, thursday blacks and hispanics have the highest gas other than their white count and I found that racism actually persists here as well and many women of color do not feel cultural birthday in our miami hospitals when birth goes wrong if you need to crippling effects on social health, their ability to support themselves and function there are also more days associated is not long-lasting negative mental health impacts. If you ask from infants births occur. My work at metro modeling agency challenges us to address these issues through lust and advocacy. I am thankful for the funding available to continue seeing our conomy through these families will be supported. >>speaker: my name is nestor perez, here on behalf of florida rising. I have an attorney with earth justice addressing 45 00 biscayne boulevard, miami florida. Today we come here with our clients to ask the county to do the right thing and resend the ordinance passed last year citing a new facility and create a new facility in this county and in three clear danger presented by this community is on a daily basis in the case of doral, for decades . Clear danger is something represented in the 4 fires this facility has had in the past four years . This was one of them will control . What was clear danger into a full-fledged emergency. We're asking you do the right thing and end trash burning in miami-dade county once and for all . >>speaker: MADAME Mayor, MISTER CHAIRMAN commissioners, my name is sharon kendrick johnson, past chair of the commission for a . My address is nondisclosing items from districts six. Here to speak on 18, status of women in miami-dade county report. We want the auditor and by fiu metropolitan center putting together the status of women report. Every year they provide data on women and girls prsuant to the ordinance the commission for women will review the report come back later in the year with recommendations. We look forward to working with all. Please visit our display in the lobby highlighting women's history month. >>speaker: good morning commissioners, my latest radio holds and I'm here to address the issue currently a resident displaced and homeless . There are several items in which I speak but I namely talk because of the notification by some holes I will be speaking and addressing the discussion I am 2b1. I suffer from respiratory owners as a result of some of these conditions are the speaker of the city . I also suffer as a displaced rancher because mechanically says it is my rights to recovery facilities, clean air and clean water are circumvented when it is utilized circumstances that lead to a less unaffordable because some people cannot afford to a nasty funky places at the disparity of women raising children, disparity of latin americans who suffer from sickle-cell disease has an extensive impact . When I think about what's going on I live in miami gardens and the , the takeover of starving residents, the hispanics in the caribbean and those who are senior and older was over and don't understand what planet gentrification is left alone gerrymandering we live next to an incinerator to so I'm contacted by clean air and water . I like to thank artistic staff for taking the time to hear what we are hearing anything about property management and condo takeovers. Most of us who have been attacked for his own situation seems to get information on it but we legal representation , his invention leaves out the impact of not having recovery facilities . Do you know right now I'm currently listed as having all my home 1000 for our automated through the system that's just as a MAY I closed sir ? We'd like you to pay close attention to what the mayor is asking because there are issues only attorneys address in this affordable housing. >>chair: thank you so much . >>speaker: I'm in support of the myor . >>speaker: my name is dwight wells here in miami , my address is 1975 northwest 1/91 street miami gardens. I'm supporting 11a12 for the mayor to check traffic lanes. Bikers have the same rights as motorists and we had an issue where we have kids going over the expressway . >> dwight, give me one second . There's people coming up and the chair and called names let me call names in line 1st and we'll get back to you there is a list of people that signed up in order so I want to be respectful. We got michael rosenberg followed by carlos followed by marie porras followed by ashley thomas, krista tiwill, for brown and then like wells and then rita roesca and theophilus williams. MISTER Williams, you're my last one on this list so michael rosenberg , michael rosenberg, you are recognized. Name and address for the record, you have to minutes. >>speaker: I think commissioner cohen higgins and her staff for asking me here today to support the study for the animal sanctuary in the south and to the dumping problem in the redlands. We could use a dozen sanctuaries . Was asked today. I found the trust initiative . After learning animal shelter from 1972 2012 had been killing 60 to 80 only on every day , all of the during those four days I think change for the killing to go on forever as what is trust a suggestion went to the voters, raise your taxes $20 a year to say that number now is $11 per year. 55 percent of the voters agreed to do it, were as high as 75 percent voted yes elected officials did not respect that both the pet plan was never implemented . The plan has sat on the shelf for 10 years . He was very aggressive, proactive, stay and neuter programs to thousand surveys year is 25,000 per year to incur our animal over vision program went up a plan in place a situation would be worse and worse director stanford said the last few weeks every day is a cisis followed with we were in ninth straight . Are you hearing your director ? If that's not enough disease is spreading through the new shop that supposedly had the best agencies in the country but the problem is so severe it was . If you want to talk to me about it you can feel free but with that being said by kind of . I suggest a short-term solution to immediate emergency . >>speaker: my name is melissa guzman, 1890 northeast miami beach . I'm speaking on behalf of item 8l4, I started my business to get myself out of a wheelchair and then I continued pushed through this business to help people stay out of the wheelchair I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis this business is the purpose . A lot of people that look like me and let me my mission is to help people eat plant-based foods while is a choice and not obligation . I chose to apply for the grant and I was very fortunate to win so I am thankful and I have a lot of plans to help the community of miami florida to be better because we were in impoverished neighborhoods to help people eat affordable and healthy the include is my business and I continue to help people nourish themselves, give jobs to the community and things of that nature with this opportunity. ... >>speaker: good morning MADAME Mayor, chair. My name is full of brown, florida. Thank you for affording my company and my community the ability to pitch the fiu opportunity to win the grant . We appreciate you guys for affording us the opportunity. We haven't yet received our funds and we will sometime in the near future but we wanted to give you our position of how important that grant is for our community. It is important for me to afford others with disabilities myself so we wanted to use te funds to expand our business and sustain our business during this volatile time so we thank you for considering us and keeping us in mind as we appreciate the opportunity to have that grant awarded to us . >>speaker: good morning. My name is rita roesca, district number six and I'm one of the winners of yours is both author multiple times latin grammy nominee projects to create music and books for children migrants learners. Spanish english and three old to childcare educators and accompanying this award to keep distributing educational materials. I brought one of our books for each one of every commissioner so you can pass it to a child you love. Thank you thank you. >> my name is dwight wells , 1975 northwest 1/91 street, miami gardens 33056 , and founder of a nonprofit organization in miami called bikes not guns. Miami-dade county needs 01.0 international , I want to thank freddie ramirez for sitting with me and my team and gving the support over at miami gardens . I'm going to support 11 812 with the traffic instructions the mayor has said , due to the bikes being the same as motorists in miami-dade county , we get 132 is healthy as a happy one goal for MARCH the that we go to the outskirts of miami dolphin sadium where will you have fun, relax and get this will be keen and his staff for getting opportunities to go through this whether it be state of miami, along as miami-dade, navigating us. I asked the commissioners out of districts that's here in miami-dade county to support this is partly. We can bring more excitement and different things to this great city. I'm signing off, I the money for hearing me out. we love and respect, make it efficient for the kids in their community are going to be on the expressway. I just thank you all, thank you MADAM There and thank you MISTER Freddie ramirez , homeland security and everybody else. Founder of a company by and for human refugees in miami. One of the winners of the small business grant and I stand before you today with this grant is great opportunity for our community, this company is fine for women refugees with a we receive we would be able to more syrian refugees to grow their own business in miami-dade. >> my name is theophilus williams, 161 , we do have a lot of , we need recovery centers for some of those who right now is losing homes and can't afford to pay . And when I look at some of those who have 200 houses and condos being burned down, we don't have mercy housing for this is what we we got a lot of mental health . It is off the chain right now. We want to put back the focus we need a center , emergency housing center , a crisis center for those who need it in this community we can do it. If we stop housing for those for the red to pay , we need some of this public housing. We need that a now cost a lot of people are suffering a lot of them sitting on their cars, it just everything is in crisis right now and I'm asking the commissioner puts crisis center out , put some kind of rehab so we can get help for the people who need it who are lsing houses and rent is going. I asked the commissioner, put together to help the people. >>speaker: carlos dunlap, general court priestly 166 one year ago, I was here talking the same issue . Today, I want to say thanks to mayor daniela thanks to commissioner nunez. These problems. For our people but it's very important that commissioner knows that we can prevent you know what is happening to them. I request say just one thing , they take action, do something before it's too late . Please support the zero waste problem to the mayor . Thank you very much . >> thank you recall all the names on the final sheet that we have, and if your name is called speak into the microphone okay, reasonable opportunity is now closed. . >> do you as his vision work covers? On island houses and presentation by maria, is and operations regarding the status of women in the place report. You also have one which is of course but it's quite the commission partner was supposed to be coming down and he was supposed to introduce this are you supposed to introduce is? Is going to have to raise that , a lot more. Keep going. There, you should have started in that podium which is higher okay. >>speaker: commissioned officer, I was supposed to this I singing a song . >>chair: like girls from the world, beyond is on, you . >>. >>chair: is you can't do that use the documents let's get started . >> good morning health, safety education this year we) Were doctor marion is from national university , and presentation you have any questions we will be will answer, for this year was playing what is supposed, doctor was helpful in getting us to that end goal and in addition we and areas within our own county had before and improving our data quality working through this year and next year with that said I like to bring joe in. Presentation . >> good morning MISTER CHAIRMAN, MADAME Mayor are old my name is as is maria and assistant director the residential home center 1930 southwest one is our campus location. As you MAY know , we've been presenting these reports annually and the purpose of these reports is for us as a community, not just as commissioners and policymakers to continue monitoring the progress towards closing the gender gaps. Being a health and safety for this report we tried to gather as much current data as possible since the last report and explain how conditions have changed and improved or worsened for women in the head and fully post pandemic years as we talked 22 and 23 to the extent that it is on in the report me as you heard the whole four important areas that are included in the commission for elimination of all forms against which was adopted supporting that confession. Providing various metrics, again these are intended to be tracked across the community and for anna and the united states as a way to measure where we stand and how much progress we've made in advancing women and girls. Starting first with sme basic characteristics , obviously when we talk about the proportion of women in the population is representative of the overall population primarily hispanic , black or african-american women owned hispanic, these are the three largest community groups. There's one for I'm sorry about that. And what we know is in these basic population characteristics is some of the early indicators of how this portion of the impact of covid has been on women lead households with three children. Obviously los angeles, loss of income has produced higher poverty rates for some households when we talk 2021, the witch was the latest data available for us as we were in the report the disparities in earnings went beyond poverty but it is very important was staggering between women lead male lead house some of the issues that we have in the community are related to structural problems and when we talk about opportunities is unavoidable about education because it is is considered MISTER CHAIRMAN will I have more time? >>chair: don't say that you get. How much more time you think you need? >> meeting minutes, . >> listed for two minutes . >> in terms of opportunity we can talk about it without speaking first education as we know in education that women surpass men in bachelors and high degree jobs but the disparities in earnings across all educational attainment levels are in the digits bachelors degrees , 18 percent for those with degrees all one of the reasons is because the person or acquire different types of degrees. In art, humanities, and asian and we see the change has a different choices now for as other to them when they enter the stem, business degrees and others which have the potential to raise their earnings and reducing apps. With that said our still staggering in the previous report just to remind you big gaps for female male please residents of miami-dade county was a 20 percent 20 percent, I have been for the last two decades as a last piece of data from 2021 was reduced percent. Obviously we have a ways to go hopefully this is the beginning of a new trend that will see 2022 and 23 as new data . The other areas which we explored were held in city there is a lot more information in the report you can see but in general we see improvement in some areas and worsening in other indicators. You've heard from others about the maternal death rates that is high among black and hispanic women, we seen a decline in violence against women but that is increasing again. In conclusion we will continue working with the commission auditor to produce the report for as long as he needs us to work with the commission for women and other nonprofit organizations alongside all of you use a qualities in the future . >>chair: commissioner cohen higgins, you are recognized for a question, can you hang out for a second? >>commissioner cohen higgins: I want to doctor for the record, is extensive and comprehensive I don't know if the commission is best directed to you but I have a question on the 13 percent wage gap between men and women in miami-dade county . I want carification and need to stop and I'm not able to identify is at this time explain what that means, and a woman the same position will get a 13 percent more or are there a number of factors outside of equal walking into a position that's affecting this I can't imagine a situation where all ma

Showing the first 60,000 of 105,953 characters. The full document is at the source.

Miami-Dade Commission Agenda

--->

Legislative Survey ---> ADA Notice

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners Agenda

OFFICIAL

Version

Tuesday, March 7, 2023

9:30:00 AM

Commission Chambers

Disclaimer

Agenda Definitions

Printable PDF Format

County Commission Rules - Rule 6.05 DECORUM

"Any person making impertinent or slanderous remarks or who becomes boisterous while addressing the commission, shall be barred from further audience before the commission by the presiding officer, unless permission to continue or again address the commission be granted by the majority vote of the commission members present. No clapping, applauding, heckling or verbal outbursts in support or opposition to a speaker or his or her remarks shall be permitted. No signs or placards shall be allowed in the commission chambers. Persons exiting the commission chamber shall do so quietly.

The use of cell phones in the commission chambers is not permitted. Ringers must be set to silent mode to avoid disruption of proceedings. Individuals, including those on the dais, must exit the chambers to answer incoming cell phone calls. County employees may not use cell phone cameras or take digital pictures from their positions on the dais.

Miami-Dade County provides equal access and equal opportunity and does not discriminate on the basis of disability in its programs or services. If you need a sign language interpreter or materials in accessible format for this event, please contact the Miami-Dade County Agenda Coordinator�s Office at 305-375-2035 or [email protected] at least five days in advance.

When a resolution or ordinance is placed on the agenda at the request of a commissioner, the commissioner who requested the preparation of the item shall be designated as the prime sponsor. Any other commissioner who wishes to sponsor the resolution or ordinance shall be designated as a co-sponsor.

Pursuant to Rule 5.06(h), where a commissioner is listed as a sponsor, the first named commissioner is the prime sponsor and all other named commissioners are co-sponsors."

1A

INVOCATION AS PROVIDED IN RULE 5.05(H)

1B

ROLL CALL

1C

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

1D

SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS (SCHEDULED TO BEGIN AT 8:30 AM)

1D1

230037

Special Presentation

Oliver G. Gilbert, III, Prime Sponsor

SPECIAL PRESENTATION RECOGNIZING UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVE DEBBIE WASSERMAN SCHULTZ(Mayor)

3/7/2023

Presented

1E

CITIZEN'S PRESENTATIONS (5 MINUTES MAXIMUM)

1E1

230463

Citizen's Presentation

Oliver G. Gilbert, III, Prime Sponsor

CITIZEN'S PRESENTATION BY DR. MARIA ILCHEVA, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND OPERATIONS, FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY REGARDING THE STATUS OF WOMEN IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY 2022 REPORT [SEE AGENDA ITEM NO. 1I1]

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: dd6cb7a3b36bb00b3227bab36669295c. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record