POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Regular City Commission Meeting

Tuesday, January 22, 2002 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Sarasota City Commission met to discuss the Ringling Causeway bridge lighting, the location of a new transit transfer facility, and new zoning regulations for single-family homes. The Commission also addressed concerns regarding the 'Strong-Mayor' referendum and the maintenance of the city-owned 'urbaculture' site.

Why it matters

The Commission's decisions on bridge lighting, transit facility locations, and home construction standards directly impact local property aesthetics, public transportation access, and the cost of home renovations for residents.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 91,735 characters. The full document is at the source.

---- pages 41-80 ----

(Page 1) public hearing is to provide resolution to any outstanding questions or concerns for a particular issue; that the January 7, 2002, Commission Workshop addressed many of the public's concerns and questions; however, not all questions and concerns may have been resolved; that the current public hearing should be continued to a future meeting to provide the public an additional opportunity to voice any concerns or raise any questions to the Commission; that the efforts of CLAS, the St. Armands Circle Association, the St. Armands Merchants Association, and the St. Armands Residents Association to improve St. Armands Key and St. Armands Circle are appreciated and impressive; that in particular, the efforts of CLAS to seek a creative means to improve St. Armands Circle are appreciated.

Commissioner Martin continued that the revenues generated by the proposed St. Armands Circle Business NID will only improve the aesthetic perception and national recognition of St. Armands Circle; that the City must also ensure adjoining commercial and residential uses remain compatible; that few residential homes directly abut St. Armands Circle; that the City's regulations will still apply to St. Armands Circle if the proposed St. Armands Circle Business NID is created; that residents and property owners are encouraged to seek creative means to generate additional funds to construct important neighborhood improvements; that the Commission will have the final authority over any Business or Residential NID; that the only remaining concern is the limited amount of public input received during the current public hearing; that many citizens may not understand the full subject matter of proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342; that the current public hearing should be continued to a future meeting.

City Auditor and Clerk Robinson read proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 by title only.

MOTION: To reopen and continue the public hearing concerning proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 to allow the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk to advertise by newspaper and mailing the continuation of the public hearing concerning proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 to the February 4, 2002, Regular Commission meeting. OUTCOME: passed VOTE: Ayes 5 / Nays 0 / Absent 0 / Abstain 0 AYES: Martin, Palmer, Quillin, Servian, Mason NAYS: None ABSENT/ABSTAIN: None

City Auditor and Clerk Robinson stated that proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 will be appropriately advertised in the Sarasota Herald-Tribune; that notice of proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 will

(Page 2) be provided to local neighborhood and business organizations and associations.

Commissioner Martin asked if proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 will be advertised to authorize the creation of Special Business and Residential NIDs? City Auditor and Clerk Robinson stated yes.

Commissioner Palmer stated that allowing the creation of Business and Residential NIDs is an important matter; that the City could also authorize the creation of other types of improvement districts to accomplish similar goals; that the City must be cautious and must ensure the public clearly understands the nature and potential powers of Business and Residential NIDs; that in particular, the public must understand proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 will allow the creation of Business and Residential NIDs for any area of the City and not just St. Armands Circle.

MOTION: To reopen and continue the public hearing concerning proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 to allow the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk to advertise by newspaper and mailing the continuation of the public hearing concerning proposed Ordinance No. 01-4342 to the February 4, 2002, Regular Commission meeting. OUTCOME: passed VOTE: Ayes 5 / Nays 0 / Absent 0 / Abstain 0 AYES: Martin, Palmer, Quillin, Servian, Mason NAYS: None ABSENT/ABSTAIN: None

The Commission recessed at 8:46 p.m. and reconvened at 9:04 p.m.

11. CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS (AGENDA ITEM V) #2 (2912) through (3302) CD 9:04 through 9:11

The following people came before the Commission:

Stan Zimmerman, 2469 Novus Street (34237), stated that as a City resident and registered voter, he would like to address the upcoming "Strong-Mayor" referendum; that on March 12, 2002, City residents will have the opportunity to change the City's form of government; that the referendum is a massive rewrite of the City of Sarasota Charter (1996) (City Charter) and not just a few new words; that the "Strong-Mayor" referendum could change the entire character of the City and reduce the Commission to impotent bystanders unlike the current Commission which evaluates changes to the City's physical landscape such as the

(Page 3) height of megahouses, the location of new parks, and permitted density.

Mr. Zimmerman continued that the Commission has not undertaken an evaluation of the looming change to the political landscape; that the political landscape will be turned upside down if the referendum passes; that power as a Commissioner will be truncated and reduced to almost nothing; that the professional office of City Manager will be replaced by amateur-hour cronyism as the position would take direction from the "Strong Mayor"; that the "Strong-Mayor" referendum would massively redistribute power at City Hall; that the "Strong Mayor" would have control of the City budget, the Commission agenda, appointment, hiring, and firing of City employees, award of City contracts, and absolute control over the Sarasota Police Department (SPD); that the "Strong Mayor" would have an unprecedented concentration of power, greater than any other elected Mayor in the State if the City Charter change is approved; that the concentration of power would come at the Commission's expense; that the burden would fall on every citizen and taxpayer.

Mr. Zimmerman further stated that the Commission is asked to take a stand against the "Strong-Mayor" referendum; that the proposed change to the political landscape should be defeated through a Commission resolution; that the "Strong-Mayor" concept is threatening to strangle the democratic process in the City; that the Commission is asked to actively lead constituents and supporters among the neighborhoods to reject the "Strong-Mayor" referendum; that the citizens of the community look to the Commission for leadership; that the Commission is asked not to fail or abandon the citizens of the community to the clutches of a back-room gang intent upon an unholy concentration of power at the Commission's and community's expense; that the leadership of Commission to defeat the "Strong-Mayor" referendum is sought.

Charles Senf, 2346 Pelican Drive (34237), stated that the City is treating employees unequally; that a civil servant and general employee were honored at the current meeting as the Employee of the Month and the Employee of the Year; that the two employees would be treated differently if an objection is made to Staff's decision concerning the rights of employment; that employees could be suspended or terminated but can appeal the decision; that a Civil Service/General Employees Personnel Board (Board) was established which the current Director of Human Resources would like to disband; that the Board mediates the differences between management and employees; that if management

(Page 4) misunderstood the facts, the civil service employee would return to work; however, the general employee would not return to work; that the general employee would continue to endure the suspension or other employment action despite the overwhelming vote by the Board to reinstate or vacate the suspension or other employment action; that the general employee could then mediate in circuit court; that the City could spend several hundred thousand dollars fighting the decision of the Board; that the civil service employee would not need to take action in circuit court as the decision of the Board would be final and the employee would be reinstated; that the decision of the Board concerning the general employee would be sent to the City Manager who will make the final determination for the general employee; and asked the reason for the discrimination against the general employee?

12. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: APPROVAL RE: DESIRED LIGHTING POLE AND FIXTURE FOR THE RINGLING CAUSEWAY BRIDGE REPLACEMENT PROJECT - APPROVED PALMER RANCH STYLE LIGHTING POLE, ARCHETYPE OUTDOOR CUTOFF LIGHTING FIXTURE, AND REQUESTED STAFF TO SEEK APPROVAL FROM FDOT TO ALLOW 70 WATT HIGH PRESSURE SODIUM LAMPS (AGENDA ITEM VI-1) #2 (3285) through #3 (1815) CD 9:11 through 10:10

Dennis Daughters, Director of Engineering/City Engineer, David Whaley, Project Director, and Patrick Malone, Construction Manager, PCL Civil Contractors, Inc. (PCL), and Ellen Sears, Thompson + Sears Lighting, LLC, (Sears Lighting) came before the Commission.

Mr. Daughters stated that at the October 15, 2001, Workshop, the Commission requested PCL to review the existing street lights in the Palmer Ranch area and return with colored renderings of the Palmer Ranch street lights and other alternatives for consideration for the John Ringling Causeway Bridge (replacement bridge); that the two lighting pole configurations which may be considered are: 1) typical Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) conventional lighting poles and 2) Palmer Ranch type lighting poles; that the four lighting fixture configurations which may be considered are:

1. Typical FDOT cobra head fixtures 2. Palmer Ranch type fixtures

(Page 5) 3. Curvilinear cutoff series fixtures by Kim Lighting 4. Archetype outdoor cutoff fixtures by Kim Lighting

Mr. Daughters further stated that the two lamp choices which may be considered are: low pressure sodium (LPS) and high pressure sodium (HPS); that the Commission previously indicated a desire for the HPS lamp which is also PCL's recommendation.

Commissioner Martin stated that addressing the lighting impact to sea turtles is important; that the presentation regarding sea turtles should be provided prior to discussing the lighting.

Mr. Whaley stated that PCL worked with Staff regarding lighting pole and fixture types as well as LPS and HPS lamps; that the lighting fixture style and location would change depending on the use of LPS or HPS lamps; that the LPS lighting fixture would be marginally larger; that the lighting fixture decision is not independent of the type of lamp utilized.

Mr. Whaley displayed computer-generated photographs of lighting poles and fixtures on the Commission monitors and stated that the photographs indicate the PCL rendition of the Palmer Ranch style lighting pole with a rectangular fixture; that the Palmer Ranch style lighting pole is recommended; that the first two lighting fixture options are the traditional FDOT-style cobra-head lighting fixture and the Palmer Ranch style, box-type fixtures; that a high degree of horizontal light with the cobra-head lighting fixture is a concern; that the cobra-head lighting fixture is a poor choice if the concern is for the sea turtles; that the third and fourth options are the curvilinear cutoff series (Curvilinear) fixtures and the archetype outdoor cutoff series (Archetype) fixtures; that the Archetype lighting fixture is recommended; that the Palmer Ranch style lighting pole and the Archetype lighting fixture would be more attractive than the Curvilinear lighting fixture; that the Curvilinear lighting fixture would not have an aesthetically pleasing appearance in the opinion of the lighting consultant; that the Archetype lighting fixture shines light down instead of up or out which is the first step in attempting to address the sea turtle concerns.

Vice Mayor Quillin stated that the rendering of the Archetype lighting fixture in the Agenda backup material indicates the light flows downward and outward toward the edge of the bridge. Mr. Whaley stated that is correct.

(Page 6) Vice Mayor Quillin asked if the Archetype lighting fixture would provide lighting from the roadway to the walkway? Mr. Whaley stated yes.

Ms. Sears stated that the directive was to design to 1.0 average maintained footcandle (AMF) (10 lux) which is the slightly lower than the FDOT standard of 1.5 AMF (15 lux); that the FDOT has allowed a 1.0 AMF (10 lux) for the replacement bridge; that the lighting objective is to maintain even lighting, keep the lighting as low as possible, and create no dark areas on the replacement bridge; that lighting application should be uniform rather than at a high light level; that lighting application which is uniform rather than at a high light level is preferable for exterior applications; that a uniform lighting application which is well controlled will promote comfort; that travelling through light and dark spaces is uncomfortable; that the lighting will be directed toward the pavement rather than spilling over the replacement bridge; that in addition to the 1.0 AMF (10 lux), the lighting was designed to a 4-to-1 average-to-minimum uniformity ratio, indicating the replacement bridge will never be more than 4 times brighter than the darkest area of the walkway; that uniformity of lighting assures security and safety.

Vice Mayor Quillin stated that the placement of the lighting poles in the center of the replacement bridge is pleasing; and asked if the lighting poles would be placed 100 feet apart? Ms. Sears stated yes.

Vice Mayor Quillin stated that control of the lighted area is maintained by the 100-foot placement of the lighting poles; and asked if the rectangular Archetype fixture is recommended?

Ms. Sears stated yes; that any of the lighting fixtures presented would work; that the same optics and light level are present and only the housing differs aesthetically.

Vice Mayor Quillin asked if all the lighting fixtures presented have the same beam spread and asked if the Archetype lighting fixture on the Palmer Ranch style lighting pole is recommended?

Ms. Sears stated yes; that the AMF level can be reached with any fixture; however, the rectangular appearance of the Archetype lighting fixture is more aesthetically pleasing on the curved arm of the lighting pole.

(Page 7) Mr. Whaley stated that the spacing of the lighting poles is narrow so light spread is maintained; that the Palmer Ranch style lighting pole is more aesthetically pleasing the FDOT conventional lighting pole.

Vice Mayor Quillin asked if the lighting poles are reinforced to enable mast and flag installation?

Mr. Whaley stated no; that the large mast arms would create a larger size lighting pole which would not fit in the proposed site on the replacement bridge.

Vice Mayor Quillin stated asked if the reinforced lighting poles could be obtained?

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: dc3773cb83644a7246b665c9ac11042b. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record