POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Commission Workshop

Monday, July 8, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

City Commission Workshop

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

People and votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Workshop Re: EDCM -1- 07/08/24 MINUTES OF THE SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION WORKSHOP MEETING OF JULY 08, 2024 PRESENT: Mayor Liz Alpert, presiding, Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch, Commissioners Erik Arroyo, Kyle Scott Battie, and Debbie Trice, City Manager Marlon Brown, City Attorney Robert Fournier, and City Auditor and Clerk Shayla Griggs ABSENT: None 9:02:07 A.M. The Workshop was called to order by Mayor Alpert at 9:02 A.M. 9:02:14 A.M. 1. PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION RE: ENGINEERING DESIGN CRITERIA MANUAL (EDCM) UPDATE (AGENDA ITEM I-1) City Engineer Nikesh “Nik” Patel, Engineering, Acting Assistant City Engineer Alexandrea “Alex” DavisShaw, Chief Transportation Planner Alvimarie Corales, Senior Transportation Planner Corinne Arriaga, Engineering, came before the Commission. 9:02:29 A.M. Mr. Brown provided a brief introduction. 9:03:52 A.M. Mr. Patel provided a brief overview and referred to a PowerPoint presentation displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Engineering Design and Criteria Manual Update City Commission Workshop.” 9:05:57 A.M. Ms. Corales presented and referred to various slides displayed on the Chambers monitors. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left the Chambers at 9:10 A.M. 9:12:10 A.M. Ms. Arriaga presented and referred to various slides displayed on the Chambers monitors. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs returned to the Chambers at 9:12 A.M. 9:15:37 A.M. City Manager Brown requested Staff take their time to go through and explain in more detail Context Classifications since this is more complicated, and Ms. Arriaga continued, provided more details, and referred to various slides displayed on the Chambers monitors. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left her seat, distributed to the Commission a copy of the PowerPoint presentation, and returned at 9:18 A.M. 9:28:36 A.M. Ms. Corales continued, provided a brief overview, and referred to various slides displayed on the Chambers monitors entitled “Utility Engineering”, “Solid Waste”, “Next Steps”, and “Project

Workshop Re: EDCM -2- 07/08/24 Schedule.” 9:33:06 A.M. City Manager Brown stated that the Commission has the PowerPoint presentation and will receive an electronic copy, and requested the Commission reference the page number of the PowerPoint presentation or the Engineering Design and Criteria Manual (EDCM) to ask questions. 9:33:40 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo thanked Staff and posed questions addressed by Ms. Arriaga, Mr. Patel, Ms. Corales, and the City Manager. City Manager Brown left the Chambers at 9:42 A.M. 9:43:27 A.M. Questions posed by Commissioner Battie were addressed by Mr. Patel, and Ms. Corales provided input. 9:44:54 A.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch commended Staff for the job well done; that the EDCM is well-written, and well organized. City Manager Brown returned to the Chambers at 9:46 A.M. 9:46:47 A.M. Questions posed by the Vice Mayor were addressed by Ms. Corales, the City Manager, and Ms. Arriaga provided input, the Vice Mayor provided photographs to Staff which were displayed on the Chambers monitors and posed questions addressed by Mr. Patel. City Auditor and Clerk Griggs left the Chambers at 10:10 A.M. and Deputy City Auditor and Clerk Lori Rivers, Office of the City Auditor and Clerk, came before the Commission. 10:11:44 A.M. Commissioner Trice commended Staff, spoke to the topic, and posed questions addressed by Mr. Patel, Ms. Arriaga, and the City Manager provided input. Deputy City Auditor and Clerk Lori Rivers left the Chambers at 10:18 A.M. and returned at 10:19 A.M. 10:25:39 A.M. Discussion ensued regarding café seating, sufficient pedestrian passageway versus possible restrictions presents a challenge for businesses to have sufficient seating to be effective, many of the encroachment issues are caused by the public moving chairs since business owners know a five-foot passageway should be maintained, Engineering Staff spot checking to ensure compliance, possibly increasing the pedestrian path to seven feet. 10:32:31 A.M. Commissioner Trice continued to pose questions which were addressed by Mr. Patel.

Workshop Re: EDCM -3- 07/08/24 10:34:09 A.M. Question posed by the Mayor was addressed by Mr. Patel. 10:35:11 A.M. Commissioner Arroyo continued to pose questions which were addressed by Mr. Patel, Ms. Corales, and the City Manager. 10:46:37 A.M. Mayor Alpert spoke to the topic. 10:47:30 A.M. Commissioner Battie continued to pose questions which were addressed by the City Manager, Commissioners Arroyo and Trice provided input, and Commissioner Battie spoke to the topic. 10:57:25 A.M. Vice Mayor Ahearn-Koch continued to pose questions which were addressed by Mr. Patel, Ms. DavisShaw, and the City Manager provided input. 11:03:37 A.M. 3. ADJOURN (AGENDA ITEM II) Mayor Alpert adjourned the Sarasota City Commission Workshop of July 08, 2024, at 11:03 A.M.

WORKSHOP CITY COMMISSION MEETING CITY HALL 1565 First Street Sarasota, Florida July 8, 2024 City Commission Chambers 9:00 AM I. AGENDA ITEMS: I.1 Presentation and Discussion Re: Engineering Design Criteria Manual (EDCM) Update I.1 Agenda Request Form.pdf 20240708_ENGINEERING DESIGN CRITERIA MANUAL UPDATE CITY COMMISSI.pdf 7-8-24 Items Received.pdf II. ADJOURN Meeting Notice 7-8-24 City Commission Workshop Notice.pdf City Commission Rules of Procedure CC.RulesofProcedure.AdoptedApril15-2024.pdf AGENDA CALL MEETING TO ORDER MEETING NOTICE CITY COMMISSION RULES OF PROCEDURE 1

Shayla Griggs City Auditor and Clerk Notice to the Public The City of Sarasota is committed to providing qualified disabled individuals an opportunity to participate in meetings of the City Commission. The City of Sarasota prohibits discrimination in all services, programs, or activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, sex or gender, marital or familial status, religion, sexual orientation, veteran status, or genetic information. Persons with disabilities who require assistance or alternative means for communication of program information such as Braille, large print, audiotape, etc., should contact: The City of Sarasota ADA Coordinator, Jake Brown, at (941) 263-6299 or by email at adacoordinator@sarasotafl.gov. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in a meeting should contact the ADA Coordinator at (941) 263-6299 at least two business days prior to the date of the meeting as to the nature of the auxiliary aids and/or service necessary. Every effort will be made to provide such aid or service to the extent that they are reasonable, do not result in undue financial or administrative burden, and do not alter the fundamental nature of the meeting. Consideration will be given to the individual's preferred aid or service. However, alternatives may be provided if in the City's determination such alternatives provide an effective means of communication. For the benefit of individuals utilizing hearing aids with a T-coil, the City Commission Chambers and SRQ Media Studio are outfitted with a Hearing Induction Loop for enhanced hearing assistance. Proceedings will be electronically recorded. Should an individual feel that a verbatim transcription of the proceedings may later be needed, said individual has the burden and expense of arranging for same. Copies of the electronic recording may be purchased from the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk. 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 119,289 characters. The full document is at the source.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION WORKSHOP MONDAY, JULY 8, 2024, 9:00 A.M. DISCLAIMER: THIS FILE REPRESENTS AN UNEDITED VERSION OF REALTIME CAPTIONING WHICH SHOULD NEITHER BE RELIED UPON FOR COMPLETE ACCURACY NOR USED AS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. ANY PERSON WHO NEEDS A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT OF THE PROCEEDINGS MAY NEED TO HIRE A COURT REPORTER. 09:02:04 [ SOUNDING GAVEL ] 09:02:05 >>Mayor Alpert: GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. 09:02:07 I'M GOING TO CALL THIS MONDAY, JULY 8, 2024, CITY COMMISSION 09:02:13 WORKSHOP TO ORDER. 09:02:14 WE HAVE ONE AGENDA ITEM, WHICH IS THE PRESENTATION AND 09:02:21 DISCUSSION REGARDING THE ENGINEERING DESIGN CRITERIA MANUAL. 09:02:28 PLEASE TAKE IT AWAY, STAFF. 09:02:29 >>Marlon Brown: MAYOR, IF YOU DON'T MIND, I'LL BEGIN. 09:02:32 GOOD MORNING, MAYOR AND COMMISSIONERS. 09:02:34 OBVIOUSLY THIS ITEM, THE REASON WE ONLY HAVE ONE ITEM IS 09:02:38 BECAUSE OF HOW IMPORTANT THIS IS, HOW COMPLICATED IT IS AND 09:02:43 COMPLEX. 09:02:43 I KNOW THAT YOU'VE RECEIVED A NUMBER OF E-MAILS FROM 09:02:46 INDIVIDUALS EXPRESSING DIFFERENT COMMENTS ABOUT THE EDCM. 09:02:50 THIS IS NOT A ONE AND DONE. 09:02:53 OBVIOUSLY, WITH THE WORKSHOP, WE WANT TO SHARE WHERE WE ARE 09:02:55 WITH THE EDCM. 09:02:56 GET YOUR, YOU KNOW, COMBINED DISCUSSION OF IT. 09:03:00 THE INTENT IS TO COME BACK AT A REGULAR CITY COMMISSION 09:03:03 MEETING TO GET YOUR DIRECTION AND THEN SET THIS FOR PUBLIC 09:03:05 HEARING SOMETIME LATER ON. 09:03:07 AGAIN, THERE ARE MANY OPPORTUNITIES AFTER TODAY FOR THE 09:03:11 PUBLIC AND INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE AN INTEREST TO PROVIDE THEIR 09:03:15 COMMENTS. 09:03:15 YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO TAKE THOSE IN AND THEN ADDRESS THOSE 09:03:18 ACCORDINGLY AND THEN STAFF WILL THEN SET FOR PUBLIC HEARING 09:03:22 ONCE WE PUT THIS ON A REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING. 09:03:25 WITH THAT, I'LL PASS IT ON TO MR. PATEL AND HAVE EVERYBODY 09:03:29 INTRODUCE THEMSELVES THIS MORNING. 09:03:30 >>Mayor Alpert: THANK YOU SO MUCH. 09:03:31 >>Nik Patel: GOOD MORNING, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, CITY 09:03:34 COMMISSIONERS. 09:03:34 I'M NIK PATEL, CITY ENGINEER, FOR THE RECORD. 09:03:41 >>Alvimarie Corales: ALVIMARIE CORALES, CHIEF TRANSPORTATION 09:03:43 PLANNER. 09:03:43 >>Corinne Arriaga: CORINNE ARRIAGA, SENIOR TRANSPORTATION 09:03:45 PLANNER. 09:03:46 >> ALEX DAVISSHAW, ACTING ASSISTANT CITY ENGINEER. 09:03:52 >>Nik Patel: TODAY WE'RE UPDATING YOU ON THE ENGINEERING 09:03:55 DESIGN CRITERIA MANUAL, EDCM, LAST ADOPTED IN MARCH OF 2002. 09:04:01 THE EDCM GUIDES THE CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION OF THE

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:04:04 RIGHT-OF-WAY AND LAND DEVELOPMENT IN OUR CITY. 09:04:07 IT'S A KEY COMPONENT OF THE STRATEGIC PLAN APPROVED BY THE 09:04:11 CITY COMMISSION ON JANUARY 2022. 09:04:17 AS MANDATED BY CHAPTER 29.5 OF THE CITY CODE, THE EDCM 09:04:22 PROVIDES A COMPREHENSIVE STANDARD FOR ALL DEVELOPMENT UNDER 09:04:25 THE CITY ENGINEER'S JURISDICTION, ENSURE THE PROJECT ALIGNS 09:04:30 WITH OUR CITY'S VISION AND REGULATION. 09:04:32 THE EDCM SHOWS CONSISTENCY WITH LOCAL STANDARDS AND THE 09:04:39 FLORIDA GREEN BOOK, WHICH PROVIDES MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR 09:04:42 DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, AND MAINTENANCE OF THE PUBLIC 09:04:45 INFRASTRUCTURE ON THE LOCAL AND COUNTY RIGHTS-OF-WAY. 09:04:48 IT PROMOTES CONTEXT BASED PLANNING, CONSIDERING COMMUNITY 09:04:55 NEEDS AND ACCESSIBILITY FOR ALL. 09:04:56 FURTHERMORE, THE FLORIDA STATUTE AUTHORIZES THE FLORIDA 09:04:59 GREEN BOOK AND MANDATES THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 09:05:03 MUST CONSIDER AND MAINTAIN CONSISTENCY WITH THE LOCAL 09:05:06 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT FEASIBLE. 09:05:10 THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS UNDERSCORES THE IMPORTANCE OF OUR 09:05:13 LOCAL PLANNING EFFORTS. 09:05:17 OUR TRANSPORTATION CHAPTER SPECIFICALLY ACTION STRATEGY 2.1 09:05:22 REQUIRES ALL ROADS DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION TO ALIGN WITH THE 09:05:26 EDCM. 09:05:27 THIS ALIGNMENT BACKED BY STATE LAW ENSURES THAT ALL WORK 09:05:31 WITHIN THE CITY, WHETHER IT'S BY CITY STAFF, PRACTITIONERS 09:05:35 OR GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES REFLECT OUR CITY'S STRATEGIC VISION 09:05:39 AND GOALS. 09:05:40 THUS, THE EDCM SERVES AS OUR KEY TOOL FOR IMPLEMENTING BOTH 09:05:45 LOCAL PRIORITIES AND STATE MANDATES IN OUR INFRASTRUCTURE 09:05:49 DEVELOPMENT. 09:05:50 THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION. 09:05:51 I NOW TURN IT OVER TO CHIEF TRANSPORTATION PLANNER CORALES 09:05:55 FOR FURTHER DETAILS. 09:05:57 >>Alvimarie Corales: GOOD MORNING AGAIN. 09:05:59 ALVIMARIE CORALES, CHIEF TRANSPORTATION PLANNER, FOR THE 09:06:02 RECORD. 09:06:02 TODAY, THE AGENDA INCLUDES THE EDCM TOPIC AREAS, PUBLIC 09:06:07 INVOLVEMENT AND TRAINING THAT HAS BEEN ACCOMPLISHED AND DONE 09:06:10 IN THE PAST COUPLE OF YEARS. 09:06:13 THE CHAPTER TAKEAWAYS, NEXT STEPS AND THE PROJECT SCHEDULE. 09:06:17 STARTING WITH THE EDCM TOPIC AREAS, THE EDCM COVERS 09:06:22 SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS, STREET DESIGNS, STREETSCAPE WHICH 09:06:26 IS A NEW CHAPTER, BUT IT USED TO BE PART OF THE STREET 09:06:29 DESIGN CHAPTER, WHICH IS CHAPTER 3. 09:06:31 IT ALSO INCLUDES STORMWATER DESIGN, UTILITIES, ENGINEERING, 09:06:35 EROSION AND SILTATION CONTROL AND SOLID WASTE, WHICH IS A 09:06:39 NEW CHAPTER AS WELL. 09:06:40 WHAT THE EDCM DOES NOT COVER IS BUILDING FACADES AND MASSING 09:06:48 REQUIREMENTS, TRANSIT SERVICE IMPROVEMENTS, PARK AND OPEN 09:06:52 SPACE PLANNING, LAND USE ZONING AND BUILDING STRUCTURAL 09:06:55 REQUIREMENTS. 09:06:56 WE ALSO ACCOMPLISHED A COUPLE OF PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT 09:07:03 ACTIVITIES AND A WORKSHOP.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:07:06 AND THE FIRST ONES WERE THREE STAKEHOLDER FOCUS GROUPS THAT 09:07:10 WERE DONE IN SEPTEMBER OF 2022. 09:07:13 THE FIRST ONE WAS WITH DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN COMMUNITY. 09:07:16 THE SECOND ONE WITH PARTNER AGENCIES. 09:07:18 AND THEN THE THIRD ONE WITH COMMUNITY GROUPS AND 09:07:21 ASSOCIATIONS. 09:07:21 WE ALSO HELD THREE PUBLIC MEETINGS AND THREE SURVEYS. 09:07:29 ALONG 2022 AND 2023. 09:07:34 STAFF ALSO ATTENDED A SERIES OF NEIGHBORHOOD ORGANIZATION 09:07:37 MEETINGS. 09:07:38 WE SENT OUT E-BLASTS AMONG OTHER ITEMS. 09:07:41 AND THEN ALSO ATTENDED THE ATTAINABLE HOUSING COMMERCIAL 09:07:44 CORRIDORS OPEN HOUSE TO SHOW HOW EVERYTHING TIES INTO THAT 09:07:49 AS WELL. 09:07:49 THE MOST RECENT ACTIVITY THAT WE DID WAS A PRACTITIONERS 09:07:54 WORKSHOP. 09:07:55 THIS WAS IN FEBRUARY 2024 WHERE CITY STAFF AND PRACTITIONERS 09:08:01 WERE INVITED FOR A DAY OF LEARNING ABOUT THE EDCM UPDATES, 09:08:06 WORKING ON TEST CASES, AND PROVIDING FEEDBACK. 09:08:10 THAT WAS THE LATEST ONE. 09:08:13 GOING INTO THE CHAPTER TAKEAWAYS, WE'RE GOING TO START WITH 09:08:18 CHAPTER ONE, WHICH IS THE INTRODUCTION. 09:08:20 THIS CHAPTER DESCRIBES THE RULES AND EXPECTATIONS FOR THE 09:08:24 MANUAL USE, EXPLAINS THE PERFORMANCE BASED AND CONTEXT BASED 09:08:28 APPROACHES TO DESIGN AND THEN DESCRIBES THE MANUAL'S PURPOSE 09:08:31 AND STRUCTURE. 09:08:31 IN THIS CHAPTER, IT CLEARLY DEFINES WHAT IS THE EDCM, WHO 09:08:40 USES THE EDCM AND WHEN IS THE EDCM USED. 09:08:45 IT ALSO CLEARLY DEFINES THE KEY TERMS. 09:08:49 SHALL, WHICH DENOTES A PRACTICE THAT MUST BE DONE OR A 09:08:52 CONDITION THAT MUST BE FOLLOWED. 09:08:54 SHOULD DENOTES A PRACTICE THAT IS RECOMMENDED ALTHOUGH OTHER 09:08:57 PRACTICES MAY BE USED. 09:08:59 MAY DENOTES AN ALLOWED PRACTICE THAT CARRIES NO REQUIREMENT 09:09:02 OR RECOMMENDATION. 09:09:04 GUIDANCE OR RECOMMENDED PRACTICE AND STANDARD OF REQUIRED 09:09:08 PRACTICE. 09:09:08 THIS CHAPTER ESTABLISHES THE LEVEL OF PRECEDENCE FOR THE 09:09:14 EDCM WHICH STARTS WITH THE FLORIDA STATUTE AND THE CITY CODE 09:09:17 OF ORDINANCE. 09:09:19 THIS CHARGES THE CITY WITH PRESERVING THE HEALTH, SAFETY, 09:09:22 AND WELFARE OF ITS COMMUNITY THROUGH REGULATION. 09:09:26 YOU ALSO HAVE ZONING CODE AND EDCM THAT GO HAND IN HAND. 09:09:32 THE EDCM WAS UPDATED TO AVOID ANY CONFLICTS WITH THE ZONING 09:09:36 CODE AND IF CONFLICT EVER WERE TO ARISE, THE HIGHER STANDARD 09:09:40 PREVAILS. 09:09:41 AND IT WOULD TAKE PRECEDENCE. 09:09:43 FLORIDA GREEN BOOK, AS MR. PATEL MENTIONED, AND F.D.O.T., 09:09:51 A.A.S.H.T.O. AND OTHER STUDY DOCUMENTS. 09:09:54 THE EDCM CONTAINS LANGUAGE AS TO WHICH MANUALS TO USE 09:09:57 DEPENDING ON THE SECTION AND TOPICS THAT ARE BEING COVERED.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:10:02 THE TECHNICAL DEVIATION PROCESS IS QUITE A FLOW CHART. 09:10:08 THE PROCESS INCLUDED IN THIS CHAPTER AT THE PRACTITIONERS' 09:10:16 WORKSHOP, WE GOT FEEDBACK FROM MOST OF THE PRACTITIONERS 09:10:19 THAT ATTENDED. 09:10:20 THEY FELT LIKE THE CURRENT PROCESS TOOK LONG AND REQUIRED 09:10:23 DETAIL STUDY REGARDLESS OF WHETHER IT WAS A PHYSICAL 09:10:26 LIMITATION OR DESIGN MODIFICATION. 09:10:27 SO WE TOOK THAT FEEDBACK INTO ACCOUNT AND CREATED TWO TYPES 09:10:31 OF TECHNICAL DEVIATIONS. 09:10:33 THOSE CAN BE FOUND ON PAGE 20, BUT JUST TO GIVE YOU A BRIEF 09:10:39 DESCRIPTION ON THAT, TYPE ONE IS WHEN THE SHALL CONDITION 09:10:43 CANNOT BE MET. 09:10:43 THIS TYPE REQUIRES DETAILED DOCUMENTATION OF WHY THESE 09:10:47 CANNOT BE MET. 09:10:48 A TYPE TWO IS WHEN THE PRACTITIONER CAN MEET A SHALL 09:10:52 CONDITION BUT IS PROPOSING A DESIGN MODIFICATION. 09:10:54 THIS REQUIRES A DETAILED DOCUMENTATION WHERE IT DEMONSTRATES 09:10:57 HOW THE PROPOSED DESIGN WILL PERFORM AT THE SAME OR HIGHER 09:11:01 LEVEL THAN THOSE BEING SPECIFIED IN THE MANUAL. 09:11:03 BOTH TYPES CAN BE APPROVED BY THE CITY ENGINEER. 09:11:08 AND IF IT'S A NO, THEN IT WOULD BE APPEALED TO THE CITY 09:11:12 MANAGER. 09:11:13 PREVIOUSLY, THE CITY MANAGER HAD APPROVAL OF THE TECHNICAL 09:11:18 DEVIATION. 09:11:18 PER CHAPTER 2, SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS, THIS OUTLINES 09:11:25 REQUIREMENT FOR SUBDIVISION LAYOUTS. 09:11:28 IN THIS CHAPTER, YOU MAY RECALL THAT IN NOVEMBER WE TALKED 09:11:32 ABOUT A NEW PLATTING PROCESS. 09:11:35 SINCE THEN, BASED ON RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE CITY 09:11:38 ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, THE PLATTING PROCESS HAS BEEN REMOVED 09:11:41 FROM THE EDCM AND WILL BE INCORPORATED INTO THE ZONING CODE. 09:11:46 IN THIS CHAPTER, LIKE I MENTIONED, SUBDIVISION REGULATION IS 09:11:51 WHAT REMAINED. 09:11:53 THIS PROVIDES GUIDANCE ON HOW TO DIVIDE THE BLOCKS TO CREATE 09:11:57 ACCESS AND CONNECTIVITY TO LOTS, PUBLIC SITES AND OPEN 09:12:00 SPACES. 09:12:01 AND THEN I'LL HAND IT OVER TO SENIOR TRANSPORTATION PLANNER 09:12:06 ARRIAGA TO CONTINUE THE PRESENTATION. 09:12:10 >>Corinne Arriaga: THANK YOU. 09:12:12 GOOD MORNING, MADAM MAYOR AND THE REST OF THE COMMISSION, 09:12:15 I'LL BE EXPLAINING CHAPTER 3, STREET DESIGN, WHICH EXPLAINS 09:12:19 THE CITY'S CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION, AND IT RECOMMENDS 09:12:22 GUIDANCE AND SETS CRITERIA FOR DIFFERENT STREET ZONES. 09:12:25 IT INCLUDES RENDERINGS AND CROSS SECTIONS THAT ILLUSTRATE 09:12:29 HOW THE DESIGN ELEMENTS CAN BE COMBINED TO SERVE DIFFERENT 09:12:32 FUNCTIONS OF THE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION AS WELL AS 09:12:34 RECOMMENDING GUIDANCE FOR SELECTING INTERSECTION TREATMENTS. 09:12:40 SOME KEY TAKEAWAYS THAT WERE DIFFERENT FROM THE 2002 VERSION 09:12:46 WAS HOW WE ARE ORGANIZING OUR RIGHT-OF-WAY. 09:12:48 SO YOU'LL SEE HERE THAT THE RIGHTS-OF-WAY ARE ORGANIZED BY 09:12:51 AREAS. 09:12:52 THEY HAVE A TRAVEL AREA AS WELL AS A FRONTAGE AREA.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:12:56 EVEN FURTHER, THESE AREAS ARE ORGANIZED BY ZONES. 09:12:59 SO YOU CAN SEE HERE THAT WE HAVE AN AMENITY ZONE WITHIN THE 09:13:02 FRONTAGE AREA, ON-STREET BICYCLE ZONE WITHIN THE TRAVEL 09:13:07 AREA, PEDESTRIAN ZONE WITHIN THE FRONTAGE AREA, A BUILDING 09:13:12 SHY ZONE WHICH IS WITHIN THE FRONTAGE AREA, WHICH REALLY 09:13:16 JUST CREATES A BUFFER BETWEEN THE BUILDING FACADE AND THE 09:13:21 PEDESTRIAN ZONE. 09:13:22 TRAVEL ZONE, TRANSIT ZONE AND ALLEY ZONES WHICH CAN ALL BE 09:13:26 IN THE TRAVEL AREA. 09:13:27 EVEN FURTHER, THE ZONES CAN INCLUDE FEATURES WHICH ARE ALL 09:13:30 DESCRIBED IN CHAPTER 4 AND STREETSCAPE. 09:13:33 SOME FURTHER ADDITIONS ARE LIGHTING. 09:13:40 WE INCORPORATE DARK SKY LANGUAGE WHICH REALLY JUST INFORMS 09:13:44 SOME RECOMMENDATIONS ON MAKING SURE THAT WHEN WE ARE PUTTING 09:13:48 LIGHTING IN THE AREA THAT IT IS FACING DOWNWARD AND NOT IN 09:13:52 PEOPLE'S WINDOWS ARE AFFECTING OUR NATURAL ENVIRONMENT 09:13:56 NEGATIVELY. 09:13:57 SOME NEW TOPICS, YOU'LL SEE IT IS A VERY LONG LIST. 09:14:00 SOME HIGHLIGHTS, THESE ARE THINGS THAT WERE NOT INCLUDED IN 09:14:04 OUR 2002 MANUAL. 09:14:07 WE INCLUDE CRITERIA FOR TRAILS. 09:14:09 WE PROVIDE GUIDANCE ON DIFFERENT TYPES OF STREETS, LIKE 09:14:13 YIELD STREETS AND SHARED STREETS. 09:14:15 THERE IS CRITERIA FOR BICYCLE FACILITIES, TRANSIT 09:14:19 FACILITIES, SOME GUIDANCE AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AUTOMATED 09:14:23 VEHICLES. 09:14:23 WE HAVE LANGUAGE ABOUT ACTIVATED ALLEYS, PARKLETS, CURB 09:14:29 MANAGEMENT ZONES, SO LOADING AND UNLOADING AREAS, SPEED 09:14:32 MANAGEMENT, INTERSECTION SELECTION MATRIX. 09:14:36 SO IF YOU ARE DESIGNING A ROADWAY THAT INVOLVES AN 09:14:39 INTERSECTION, WHAT INTERSECTION IS THE BEST FOR THAT AREA 09:14:41 BASED OFF OF THE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION AS WELL AS OTHER 09:14:44 ELEMENTS. 09:14:45 AND THEN QUICK BUILDS. 09:14:47 YOU'LL SEE SOME IMAGERY ON THE RIGHT THAT DEPICTS SOME OF 09:14:51 THOSE DIFFERENT TOPIC AREAS. 09:14:56 NOW WE'RE GOING TO GET A LITTLE BIT MORE INVOLVED IN CONTEXT 09:15:01 CLASSIFICATION. 09:15:01 THIS IS PROBABLY THE BIGGEST CHANGE. 09:15:06 THIS IDENTIFIES HOW EACH STREET IS CATEGORIZED BASED ON THE 09:15:09 SURROUNDING LAND USE, TRAVEL PATTERNS, USER TYPES AND ITS 09:15:13 ROLE IN THE TRANSPORTATION NETWORK. 09:15:15 THE CHARACTERISTICS VARY BASED ON THE CONTEXT AND THAT 09:15:18 REALLY INVOLVES WHAT THE TARGET AND DESIGN SPEEDS ARE. 09:15:21 THE MODAL EMPHASIS AS WELL AS THE FRONTAGE AREA WIDTHS. 09:15:25 SO HOW WIDE IS THE BUILDING SHY ZONE IN CERTAIN CONTEXT. 09:15:30 HOW WIDE IS THE PEDESTRIAN ZONE, AND THAT ALL DEPENDS ON HOW 09:15:33 THE LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION IS LINKED. 09:15:37 >>Marlon Brown: MS. ARRIAGA, TAKE THE TIME TO GO THROUGH 09:15:41 THIS SECTION SINCE IT IS THE MORE COMPLICATED. 09:15:46 JUST MAKE SURE YOU WALK THROUGH THIS IN MORE DETAIL. 09:15:49 ALL RIGHT?

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:15:51 >>Corinne Arriaga: ABSOLUTELY. 09:15:53 IF YOU HAVE A BOOK, THOSE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATIONS CAN BE 09:15:56 FOUND ON PAGE 50 THROUGH 56 AS WELL AS THE FRONTAGE ZONES 09:16:01 WHICH HAVE PAGE NUMBERS AS WE GO THROUGH EACH CONTEXT 09:16:04 CLASSIFICATION. 09:16:05 SO A GENERAL OVERVIEW OF CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION IT PROVIDES 09:16:09 A HIGH-LEVEL PLANNING GUIDANCE TO THE APPLICATION OF 09:16:12 ENGINEERING PRINCIPLES. 09:16:14 BASICALLY, IT LINKS TRANSPORTATION AND LAND USE, SO HOW ARE 09:16:18 WE CREATING STREETS THAT ARE COORDINATED WITH THE 09:16:21 SURROUNDING USE AND HOW PEOPLE USE THEM. 09:16:24 THIS ALLOWS FOR THE COMMUNITY CHARACTER TO BE AT THE CENTER 09:16:27 OF THE DESIGN CRITERIA, AND IT ALSO IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE 09:16:31 FLORIDA GREEN BOOK AND THE FLORIDA DESIGN MANUAL. 09:16:33 SO WE ARE REALLY ALIGNING WITH F.D.O.T. ON THEIR APPROACH TO 09:16:38 STREET DESIGN. 09:16:40 AS YOU CAN SEE HERE, THESE ARE THE DIFFERENT CONTEXTS THAT 09:16:43 THE CITY HAS DEVELOPED THAT ALIGN WITH FLORIDA BUT ARE 09:16:48 DEVELOPED BASED ON OUR UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS. 09:16:52 WE HAVE THE DOWNTOWN CORE, URBAN VILLAGE, URBAN GENERAL 09:16:55 MIXED USE -- SORRY, URBAN GENERAL COMMERCIAL MIXED USE, 09:16:59 URBAN GENERAL RESIDENTIAL, SUBURBAN COMMERCIAL OR 09:17:02 INDUSTRIAL, SUBURBAN RESIDENTIAL AND SPECIAL DISTRICT. 09:17:04 SO THE MAIN FOCUS OF THE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION IS TO HAVE A 09:17:12 MODAL HIERARCHY. 09:17:13 SO EACH CONTEXT AND EACH ROADWAY HAS AN EMPHASIS AND WHAT 09:17:18 THAT HELPS ESTABLISH IS TO PLAN AND DESIGN FOR VULNERABLE 09:17:22 ROAD USERS FIRST. 09:17:24 IT CREATES STREETS THAT ARE SAFE AND EFFECTIVE FOR ALL 09:17:28 TRAVELERS AND THE DESIGN SERVES ALL AGES AND ABILITY. 09:17:32 WHAT THIS REALLY MEANS IS WE'RE TAKING THIS IDEA OF PUTTING 09:17:35 OUR VULNERABLE ROAD USERS FIRST AND THEN TYING IT INTO HOW 09:17:39 OUR STREETS ARE DESIGNED. 09:17:41 THESE ARE THE INDIVIDUAL CONTEXT CLASSIFICATIONS WHERE WE'LL 09:17:47 GO INTO A LITTLE BIT MORE DETAIL ON HOW THEY ARE DEFINED AND 09:17:51 WHERE YOU CAN FIND IN THE BOOK MORE DESCRIPTION. 09:17:54 SO THIS IS THE DOWNTOWN CORE. 09:17:56 ON PAGE 50, YOU'LL BE ABLE TO FIND MORE OF THE DEFINITION, 09:18:00 THE TARGET DESIGN AND SPEED FOR THESE ROADWAYS, AND THEN ON 09:18:04 PAGE 61 IS THE FRONTAGE WIDTHS FOR THESE CLASSIFICATIONS. 09:18:09 SO THE DOWNTOWN CORE STREETS ARE LOCATED IN THE MOST 09:18:13 DEVELOPED PARTS OF THE CITY. 09:18:14 THEY ALIGN VERY CLOSELY WITH THE DOWNTOWN CORE AND DOWNTOWN 09:18:17 EDGE ZONING DISTRICTS, AND THEY ARE ADJACENT TO THE TALLEST 09:18:22 BUILDINGS AND HAVE MIXED USE AND COMMERCIAL LAND USE. 09:18:26 A GOOD EXAMPLE IS LEMON AVENUE. 09:18:28 YOU CAN SEE IN THE IMAGE THERE'S ACTIVATED GROUND FLOORS 09:18:31 WITH HIGH DENSITY COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS. 09:18:34 OUR NEXT CONTEXT IS URBAN VILLAGE. 09:18:43 THESE ARE LOCATED IN SMALL URBAN CENTERS OUTSIDE OF THE 09:18:46 DOWNTOWN CORE. 09:18:48 THEY SERVE COMMERCIAL AND MIXED USE DEVELOPMENTS.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:18:50 THEY ARE NOT HIGH DENSITY, BUT THEY ATTRACT A LOT OF 09:18:55 PEDESTRIANS AND BICYCLISTS AND VULNERABLE ROAD USERS AND 09:19:01 VISITORS. 09:19:01 SO A GOOD EXAMPLE IS ST. ARMANDS CIRCLE. 09:19:04 YOU CAN SEE IT HAS SHORT BLOCKS AND ALSO HIGH FOOT TRAFFIC. 09:19:07 THE URBAN GENERAL COMMERCIAL MIXED USE IS PART OF AN URBAN 09:19:18 GRID NETWORK AND SERVES A VARIETY OF LOWER DENSITY USES. 09:19:21 IT'S OFTEN CONNECTED TO URBAN RESIDENTIAL AREAS AND HAS 09:19:24 BUSINESSES ALONG THE STREET. 09:19:26 A REALLY GOOD EXAMPLE IS DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. WAY. 09:19:29 YOU CAN SEE IT HAS THAT DIVERSE MIX OF HOUSING WITH GROUND 09:19:32 FLOOR COMMERCIAL USES BUT IT'S LOWER DENSITY THAN OUR 09:19:35 DOWNTOWN CORE USE. 09:19:37 URBAN GENERAL RESIDENTIAL, THIS IS PART OF THE GRID NETWORK 09:19:43 BUT THE LAND USES ADJACENT ARE DIFFERENT BECAUSE THEY 09:19:47 INCLUDE SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES AS WELL AS DUPLEXES, QUADPLEXES 09:19:51 AND TOWNHOMES. 09:19:53 A GOOD EXAMPLE IS 6th STREET AND GILLESPIE PARK 09:19:56 NEIGHBORHOOD. 09:19:57 YOU CAN SEE THAT IT HAS ACTIVE RESIDENTS BUT ITS PROXIMITY 09:20:00 IS VERY CLOSE TO MAJOR COMMERCIAL AND RETAIL CENTERS. 09:20:04 SUBURBAN COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL, THIS SERVES A LOW-DENSITY 09:20:10 COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL AREA. 09:20:12 IT IS CHARACTERIZED BY LARGE LOTS, DISCONNECTED ROADWAYS AND 09:20:16 SEPARATION FROM RESIDENTIAL LOT. 09:20:18 OUR 12th STREET NEAR WASHINGTON BOULEVARD IS A PERFECT 09:20:22 EXAMPLE. 09:20:22 IF YOU'VE EVER BEEN THERE, OUR PUBLIC WORKS AND UTILITIES IS 09:20:25 OUT THERE. 09:20:26 YOU CAN SEE THERE'S TRUCK TRAFFIC ON THERE AND IT SERVES LOW 09:20:29 DENSITY AND INDUSTRIAL AREAS. 09:20:31 SUBURBAN RESIDENTIAL IS LOCATED EXCLUSIVELY IN THE 09:20:39 RESIDENTIAL AREAS. 09:20:40 IT HAS SUBURBAN STREETS GENERALLY WITH SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES 09:20:43 ON EITHER SIDE AND THERE COULD BE MULTIFAMILY USES. 09:20:47 THE STREETS IN THIS CONTEXT TEND TO BE PART OF A 09:20:50 DISCONNECTED ROAD NETWORK. 09:20:52 A GOOD EXAMPLE IS PRAIRIE VIEW BOULEVARD LOCATED NORTHEAST 09:20:55 OF DOWNTOWN. 09:20:56 IT INCLUDES SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES ON BOTH SIDES OF THE STREETS 09:20:59 AND LARGER LOTS. 09:21:00 THE LAST CONTEXT WE HAVE IS SPECIAL DISTRICT. 09:21:08 IT HAS UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS AND FUNCTIONS DON'T ADHERE TO 09:21:12 STANDARD CONTEXT. 09:21:13 THEY MAY HAVE SPECIFIC MIX OF USERS OR TRAVEL PATTERNS AND 09:21:16 THE TARGET SPEEDS IN THE CONTEXT ARE SELECTED BASED ON 09:21:20 PROJECT CHARACTERISTICS. 09:21:21 THIS EXAMPLE IN THE IMAGE IS THE NEW COLLEGE FLORIDA CAMPUS. 09:21:25 WE EXPECT STUDENTS TRAVELING TO AND FROM BUILDINGS, SO LOTS 09:21:29 OF CROSSINGS AND MOSTLY BY FOOT. 09:21:31 SO THE CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM ISN'T -- NOBODY HAS TO 09:21:40 GUESS WHAT ROADWAY THE CONTEXT IS.

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:21:42 IT'S ALREADY BEEN ESTABLISHED BASED OFF OF AN ANALYSIS. 09:21:45 APPENDIX D PROVIDES THAT TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM ON HOW THAT 09:21:49 WAS ESTABLISHED AS WELL AS THE STATIC MAP. 09:21:52 ADDITIONALLY, ON THE SARASOTA.FL WEBSITE, WE HAVE THE 09:21:57 INTERACTIVE MAP WHERE PEOPLE CAN GO IN AND CLICK ON ANY 09:22:01 STREET AND IT IDENTIFIES A CONTEXT AND GIVES YOU THE 09:22:04 FRONTAGE WIDTHS AND DOESN'T REALLY LEAVE ROOM FOR 09:22:07 QUESTIONING WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO. 09:22:10 FOR THAT -- FOR CONTEXT CLASSIFICATION, THERE ARE SOME 09:22:15 UPDATES THAT WILL NEED TO OCCUR, WILL NEED TO FOCUS ON THE 09:22:18 TRANSPORTATION CHAPTER OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IN ORDER TO 09:22:20 INCORPORATE THESE ELEMENTS. 09:22:23 LIKE I SAID, THE ONLINE MAP REALLY PROVIDES THAT GUIDANCE 09:22:26 FOR PEOPLE, NOT JUST DEVELOPING IN THE CITY, BUT FOR CITY 09:22:31 STAFF TO BE ABLE TO REVIEW THOSE DEVELOPMENTS AS WELL AS FOR 09:22:35 FOLKS IN ENGINEERING OR CAPITAL PROJECTS WHO ARE DEVELOPING 09:22:40 PROJECTS FOR THE CITY. 09:22:41 AND THEN THIS IS JUST AN UP-CLOSE VIEW OF THE MAP IF YOU DO 09:22:47 DECIDE TO GO TO THE WEBSITE AND VIEW IT. 09:22:49 YOU CAN SEE HERE WE HAVE UPDATED IT BASED OFF OF SOME 09:22:52 RECOMMENDATIONS. 09:22:53 THE PRIMARY STREET GRID HAS A BACKGROUND SHADOWING ON THOSE 09:22:59 ROADWAYS SO THAT WAY YOU ARE AWARE THAT IT IS A PRIMARY 09:23:02 STREET AND THAT YOU MUST FOLLOW THE ZONING CODE FOR THOSE 09:23:05 REQUIREMENTS. 09:23:06 THERE'S ALSO SOME OVERLAYS, SO IT IDENTIFIES THE OVERLAY 09:23:09 DISTRICT SO THAT WAY PEOPLE ARE AWARE THAT IF THIS ROADWAY 09:23:12 THAT YOU ARE DEVELOPING OR RECOMMENDING STREET DESIGN FOR 09:23:17 YOU MUST LOOK AT THE OVERLAY DISTRICT TO SEE WHAT THOSE 09:23:20 CRITERIA ARE AS WELL. 09:23:22 ANOTHER ADDITION THAT WASN'T HERE BEFORE IS HOW TO APPLY THE 09:23:29 CRITERIA. 09:23:29 SO WE HAVE THE STANDARD DRAWINGS WITH MINIMUM CRITERIA 09:23:34 LOCATED IN APPENDIX A. 09:23:36 WE LIKE TO PROMOTE THAT AS A STARTING POINT AND HAVE PEOPLE 09:23:41 NOTE THE PREFERRED CRITERIA WHERE IT'S APPLICABLE. 09:23:44 WE UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE SOME CONSTRAINED RIGHT-OF-WAY 09:23:47 IN THE CITY. 09:23:48 SOME 30 OR ONLY 40 FEET. 09:23:51 SO WE HAVE DEVELOPED CROSS-SECTIONS FOR THOSE SPECIFIC 09:23:54 RIGHT-OF-WAY. 09:23:54 THERE ARE INSTANCES -- THERE MAY BE INSTANCES WHERE IT'S NOT 09:23:59 FEASIBLE TO BRING THE CROSS SECTION INTO COMPLIANCE. 09:24:02 THIS COULD BE THE LACK OF RIGHT-OF-WAY OR IF IT IS AT A 09:24:05 PARCEL LEVEL, IT MIGHT NOT BE FEASIBLE FOR THEM TO UPDATE 09:24:09 THEIR LITTLE SECTION OF THE ROADWAY WHILE THE REST OF THE 09:24:12 ROAD REMAINS INCOMPATIBLE. 09:24:13 SO THE CITY ENGINEER CAN APPROVE AN ESCROW FUND TO DEPOSIT 09:24:17 IN LIEU OF CONSTRUCTING AN INCOMPATIBLE CROSS SECTION. 09:24:22 PROCESS IDENTIFIED IN CHAPTER 29.5. 09:24:25 THERE WAS ALSO FEEDBACK THAT WE HEARD AT THE PRACTITIONERS' 09:24:29 WORKSHOP ABOUT HOW YOU CAN DEVELOP THE TYPICAL STREET

file:///C/Users/JJohnson/Desktop/24-07-08-SCC-CommissionWorkshop.txt[7/8/2024 3:23:52 PM] 09:24:33 SECTIONS, IF YOU WANT TO START OFF WITH THE APPENDIX A 09:24:37 TYPICAL SECTION, WHERE DO YOU GO FROM THERE? 09:24:39 SO A PROCESS FOR DEVELOPING THE TYPICAL STREET SECTION WAS 09:24:42 INCLUDED IN THE BOOK AND THAT CAN BE FOUND ON PAGES 57 AND 09:24:46 58. 09:24:46 THERE IS A VERY SMALL IMAGE OF IT. 09:24:48 I'M NOT GOING TO GO THROUGH IT BUT IT REALLY HELPS PEOPLE 09:24:51 IDENTIFY IF THEY HAVE EXTRA RIGHT-OF-WAY, WHAT CAN THEY ADD? 09:24:55 MAYBE A BIKE LANE. 09:24:56 MAYBE EXTRA WIDTH ON THE SIDEWALK, THOSE KINDS OF THINGS. 09:25:00 THE NEXT CHAPTER WE'RE GOIN

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Commission Workshop — Minutes
  • City Commission Workshop
  • City Commission Workshop — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: db6d8f28e0f149687c698b766a31ed6f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record