POLISCOPE

The public record

PASADENA (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Meeting: June 22, 2020

Monday, June 22, 2020 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Meeting: June 22, 2020

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 120,826 stored characters

Yeah, we're alive. Thank you. Good afternoon and welcome to the city council and successor agency meeting of June 22nd. >> as you can see, we're still operating remotely. So bear with us. Appreciate the difficulties it poses for some people but we will press ahead and let's have a roll call. Thank mayor. Council member gordo your council member kennedy here, council member madison here Councilman Masuda council member mick austin. Yeah. Council member wilson here vise mayor hampton. Blessed to be here. Mayor torn. Yeah. There's a quorum of the council present. Thank you. Council member of the gotham. Would you lead us in the pledge please? Place your hand over your heart ready again? I personally see the flag of the united states of america. Which is why I invented indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. We have no ceremonial today. So we'll move directly to the consent calendar of mayor. Sorry. Yeah. Customary that you have been doing in the last several meetings at the beginning of the meeting you share with the council that we're going to adjourn. Yes. Thank you. Governmental. I appreciate the reminder. Okay. I'll adjourn our meeting. At the end in the memory of victims of kogut the cocaine epidemic. And we will continue to ask for guidance and inspiration with a moment of silence reflection. Thank you. Council member I neglected to do that. Are there on the consent calendar? Are there items that council members would like held for further discussion? Governor madison? I would like respectfully to discuss item number nine. Number nine I have a quick question on item number six that I sent to the city manager . >> let me just make sure that he answered. If he doesn't, then I need to get an answer. All right. While you're looking for that, you write me a challenge like a brief presentation given the response from the city manager on item number six, please. Mayor ok, thank you. Council member kennedy Mr. Borda, I wanted just a quick question. Q craig quickly responded when this matter is going to go back out to. Is there an answer to that? Mr. City manager when it's going to be rebid? Let me check with the board's director ahmed lee. You when item 1 is going back out bed at any point during the meeting. Sergeant ok. Mr. Wilson it's the 11:00 placement. Dancer council member board of question. >> item one will go out to bid next week. Item 11 ok. Move the balance along with second job is we. Do we have public comment on any of these items, Mr. Johnston? >> we have public comment. Item number six we just got something in for item number 8 which is a one sentence that I can read quickly and then item nine. So since item 6 9 that it will be all right. Want to read comment on the item 8 comes from juliette ryan davis pasadena. >> it's a one sentence. Please define it. Demilitarize the police department. That was relate to item eight. That's what came in. Ok. Thank you. >> Mr. Kennedy, you're gonna make a sweet motion move approval of the ballot. Ok. So that with the exception of item 6, 9 and 11 there there second Mr. Masuda purple color roll cast member gordo. Kennedy. Casimir madison. Yes. Councilman Masuda? yes. Council member mark austin. Council member wilson? Yes. Vise mayor hampton. Yes. Motion is approved without opposition. Thank you. >> we'll go to item 6 council member kennedy this is about the contract with the athina humane society. So before we go for a full blown presentation, the issue for me is one point three million dollars more than the previous year three hundred fifty thousand dollars more than the previous year. >> move approval the quick answer. Second question. Got that can by Mr. And other things. What's in the news item six, right? Yes, sir. I have a question masuda followed by vise mayor hampton Mr. City manager, what's going to happen next year with the contract? Thank you. >> council member masuda we do have a full staff presentation. If the council likes but let me just speak briefly answer the question and whatever the will of the council is as indicated in a staff report we've been contracting with the passing of main society for over a century and last year the humane society let us know that they came with a different methodology for allocating the total cost of their enterprise and that as a result pasadena and all the other municipalities that contract with them would be looking at significant increases in their annual contract. Our annual contract currently is one point to five million and the humane society proposed over seven hundred thousand dollar increase. So that's over a 50 percent increase our city and our. The other contract cities sat down with the humane society and negotiated a lesser increase but it's still a significant increase. So the item before you today increases the contract just under seventy five thousand dollars when it comes to animal control we're very limited in the choices that we have. Historically it's been either to contract with the passing the humane society or the county of los angeles county of los angeles hasn't had the best reputation in this in this field. And so traditionally we've stayed with the humane society. If the council approves this one year extension in that time we will once again explore how viable contracting with the county of los angeles is. They've made improvements in recent years to reduce the rate of animals that need to be euthanized to the point that they are more on par with the humane society. We also plan to explore options including forming a joint powers authority with the other contract cities, perhaps creating our own division to pursue. But we're cognizant about all the costs and the need to have a facility so it's conceivable that the end of a year we still come back and say for a variety of reasons the parsi humane society is still the the best way to go from a service delivery point of view but we know it would be at a significantly increased cost. So we'll certainly vet all of these options and great quality who works in housing department is working on special assignment for us on this high priority project. >> thank you, Mr. Mahmoud. Thank magoffin onsite vise mayor and then Ms. Magoffin, then Mr. Gordon. Thank you. These discussions are happening and I was wondering, Mr. City manager, will this be coming back to a public safety committee? Because I think the needs of what? Or maybe the average resident May not understand exactly what is in our contract now and what our contract and built does a lot of calling they say and to say oh, we don't do that. I'm so I think understanding what the needs of the community are number one one of the needs is always picking up dead animals. A lot of times you know, some people in their 80s are not what not they don't want to go outside and pick that animal. I pick them up from my neighbors all the time. But you made saudi sometimes dumplings dead skunks on the road for you know, for my days even maybe in a week or two. So just understanding the scope of work and what they what our community needs are as we're looking at a new contract or potentially a new provider would extremely helpful. And I think that discussion to be had in the public safety committee because this is where it came before. Is that part of your scope work your plan to bring it back to public safety committee meeting to have a discussion about the humane society that would be very appropriate to do? Oh yes. We will do guest for that benefit. That's my only request. Okay. Martin on the bouncer who's a resident of my district. She also sent out an e-mail to council members and I think maybe you May have been on it if you're not. Steve I'll to it. Over to you. She's been very active in this this realm and has a lot of expertise when it comes to animals and I don't think I would say that one person just someone who wants to help, you know, from the public aspect. Be great if you were not not a contractor or anything. I'm just saying that that she had someone else that would be great and please forward that on. Ms. Magoffin followed by council member gordon. Thank you, mayor. So Mr. City manager, this is this is really troubling that we have a hundred year relationship with a humane society and we've contracted with them all these years and it sounds like they're not for the staff report. They're not willing to share what their true costs are. How in the past have the court then determined have they given right in in the past the contract had always been negotiated. They previously didn't submit any sort of a cost analysis to the city. What happened with this most recent discussion of significant cost increases is pasadena and the other contracts that he's asked the humane society to provide cost information to us. They did provide us some information. We did meet with them. We walked through it. We had a lot of questions with their methodology. We don't necessarily agree with their methodology how they allocate costs but the fundamental change seems to be how the humane society has just decided to allocate out their revenue requirement. So in any given year the humane society would benefit from contributions that people make because these charitable donations cetera and the society was use a portion of that revenue towards the cost of animal control and furthering their mission. Recently they've decided that they're no longer going to do that and they feel that the animal control contracts from the cities need to support 100 percent of certain operations. For example, they expanded a couple of years ago. they expanded the services they offer and are now essentially asking to contract cities to support those expanded services through increases in their contract. It's largely just a philosophical change in how they see their role and who should be paying to to underwrite the costs of their services and how the endowment money that they receive than any other grants. Now that that doesn't go toward we operating expenses, they use that exclusively for something else. Historically it did as my understanding and now they're saying that they don't think that that should be the case going forward. That's really troubling. I mean do they have a charter obligation under their their charter or something? Not that I'm aware not not that I'm aware of and we did question them as to whether they were seeking to get out of the animal control business altogether. >> they've assured us that they they aren't seeking to do that. But there they're potentially driving away all the cities that contract with them. >> what about you know, they recently built a new building. Right. That's the expansion I was talking about. So who's paying for that? Are we paying for that pro-rata? Well, they they paid for it in the first instance but it does appear that by creating the expansion in their facility, they're offering new programing and they are they essentially said to us that are the increase in the contract costs is in part to support that new programing. >> and of course the contract cities we point out to the humane society that we didn't ask for that those aren't services we wanted to purchase . And I will say historically and I I personally negotiated contract for many years from the city standpoint we want sort of an all la carte contract where we contract for animal control visiting the parks to enforce the off leash, picking up that dead animal in the street that the vise mayor is mentioning and some other services. The humane society has traditionally said that they provide a broad range of services and we need to support those as well. So a lot of it is philosophical in what the city should be paying for. Very troubling to me. So I mean I support taking the year to further evaluate it. >> are the other cities doing the similar? Yes. >> we're. We're working in close coordination with one another and we're in consultation as a group with the county. >> ok, thanks. Let's go let's go to an issue that we were with for quite some time the level of service costs associated with providing those services, the desire to have the what you call the wild card. >> yes. All the card services. My recollection is Miss Mather was coming add to it. I don't want to put of course the public safety but given the workload if it's appropriate. Mike, what about that you've come to attack historically it's gone through the public safety committee. When it's gone to subcommittee is my recollection. >> I don't know that the he is obviously incorrect. Remember discussing the issue with cameras and also for licenses so we could have an update on how effective or not that has been. In terms of causing more people to have a dog with their pets or pet license, do we when it comes back or we will probably see sort of that recommendation. You know how we improve that. And finally, you know, I don't think we should rule out this los angeles. My recollection is that the city of los angeles has May have capacity in some of their centers. And you know, a good idea to check in with them. Well, maybe even built you some extra animal shelters. We'll certainly pursue that. >> one of the challenges with the county is the lack of any facility nearby. So you raise a good point. We'll proceed whether the city of L.A. Is a viable option. >> but you really have to shelter over over here by. 110 freeway there a number of shelters in the area that maybe suitable but you know, whether they're interested that's a different story. But I don't publish a book about we want. Ok, one other question. Are there any other municipalities in the area the san gabriel valley that provide their own service? Not that I'm aware of the things people since then will leave without saying. >> gabriel, maine, we May want to talk to investigate whether there are other cities but glendale, glendale now glendale ,glendale contracted about five years ago with the city humane society following a bit of a scandal at their local shelter. They bought into passing humane by providing them two million dollars upfront payment and they locked in a five year contract. It was actually less than our cost at our current one point two five million. Even though glendale is 40 percent larger by population so that's another thing that I questioned. Maybe they're cat people and they have fewer dogs but it didn't seem to make a lot of sense. So that would be another model as well. You know one function of shelter function and the other function on the enforcement of laws and animal control of both domestic animals, both wild animals and we didn't together with other city 538 to achieve both a better service and of their lesser cost. I would encourage us to do that. And that was one thought that perhaps we May contract with the humane society for the kennel lean but perhaps have positions that are akin to sort of a park safety specialist classification that can handle patrol and routine enforcement . The city of los angeles you use but not armed on unarmed peace officers. Well, on duty unarmed peace officers who are able to enforce law and at the same time. Provide the tools for so I will look at their model and look at the possibility by quickly even if we were to has a lot of that look at the idea providing shelter space. I don't know if this is an opportunity to think differently. We've struggled with this issue for so long that it's time we have a long term plan with a regrettably with or without the the humane society capacity. We've just gone up and down and the costs are tremendous and have increased so much over time that we have to look at it differently. Just as a reminder we had a the animal control, you know, come in and give report on the coyote problem. Remember you and I were having both problems with that so they did a great job. Just just as a reminder that nobody these. There's lots to be said. We're working with the humane society and they're going to try to just cost the response of the animal models. >> hopefully we can work out a model with them that make sense of the bipartisan model for example, where they provide the shelter service that we provide your services in different ways and possibly with another jurisdiction or just in-house, ok. But Mr. Wilson thank you, mayor. Yes, I am I am a bit troubled. We can't seem to figure this out and make me want to think and you've asked the question is do they maybe they want to get out of this business. It's worth asking since you're a not for profit organisation. I know the level of transparency of their finances is actually required to be available to the public. I assume that we've gone through that to see what part of their business this is and understand a the financial motivations. I assume that's happened, steve. Yes. >> and we did ask him the question that they wanted to get out of the business altogether. They've assured us that they don't. And we've seen the high level financial information. It's really what we wanted to drilling was to their methodology and their allocation model and they shared with us. But the the finance directors and city managers from the six contract cities or so we all had our concerns with their methodology and fundamentally in the and that's all it is is a methodology. It's not arithmetic where we can where we have to decide what the result is. >> I saw your work plan. They're going to evaluate alternatives. Is there a way to do any benchmarking with other cities or I assume there's a finance manual that says you're spot administer reality pays for these types of services that we can figure out whether they're in the ballpark or because they have a bit of monopoly here in this part of town. And as you mentioned with the consolidation of glendale, we benchmark this to the other way to look at what this is, to see whether this is market work additional benchmarks. I don't think we've done that. >> we can. We can look to see you know, we have this interesting symbiotic relationship with the humane society. We can take a look to see if what our community is pain measures up to other similarly situated communities. >> I think it's worth doing the homework a I see you've met with the ceo and tried to figure out what their objectives are so that we know what they're trying to accomplish and so it can be the guy but we're trying to accomplish. >> yes, we've had several conversations with the ceo and we had a meeting with I think the majority of their board or certainly their executive committee and city managers from all the contract cities where they walked us through their methodology and their numbers and I mean let me just give a quick for example. So if if a resident of the city of pasadena where to find a stray animal and take it to the passing of humane society passing humane society would say well where did you find this animal or where do you live? And if our resident said pasadena. Then they would ascribe the cost of the care for that animal to our contract. That is a change from what used to occur they're seeking to allocate out. Now if you will, every animal back to one of the contract cities. So what would be a get out of that business and we're no longer caring for animals. >> I guess I'd be interested to know what business they'd be in. I don't know enough about how you think about they seem so tightly intertwined with those private shelters or private shelters that don't do animal control. There's a lot of rescue, you know council members who have pets probably got their animals from a from a rescue. So there's a lot of private kennels nonprofit charitable that don't do animal control. So they would. So if they didn't do animal control they would still presumably continue to do the care for four animals in our community which they do quite well. Well, certainly I think you have a robust work plan and i think working with public safety and keeping the council informed this is a well-established institution. But obviously we have to look out for the best interests of the taxpayers thinking ok, any further questions for the staff? If not emotion move. Thank you vise mayor. Thank you. Second, Ms. Magoffin call. Before we do that, mayor, I'll read the public comment from carla taj. Tasha no I'm sorry. >> yeah, the motion opportunity seconded by madison. Ok. Thank you. Sorry about that. I didn't see that. Ok. This is from marla tauscher. I am an attorney practicing primarily in animal control. I strongly urge the council to approve a one year contract extension with pasadena humane society council should use that year to devise and implement an alternative to contracting dhs which does not involve contracting with the county los angeles for animal control services in any capacity. L.A. County animal control is one of the least transparent least transparent, most regressive high kill animal control agencies in the state of california. If not the country contracting with L.A. County will not only result in abuses of animals lives but also of the rights of their owners which will ultimately increase costs resulting from litigation. This is a golden opportunity for the city to create a truly humane no kill animal control agency that respects the lives of animals and their owners legal rights. Please do not squander this opportunity by taking what appears to be the easy way out. Please commit to implementing real and lasting improvements for animals and their owners in the city of pasadena. I am willing to help in any way I can and can enlist others with expertise in this area. That completes public comment on this item. So we have a motion from council member kennedy seconded from by Councilman Madison to approve the staff recommendation. Council member gordo? Yes. I have a question after the vote. Yes, ma'am. Kennedy yes. Councilman Madison? Yes. Councilman Masuda? Yes. Councilman Mike austin. Yes. Council member wilson yes. Vise mayor hampton yes. Mayor talk. Yeah. The motion is approved without opposition. Only the reminded me of the importance of the local program and policy. If we're going to look at a different model we have to keep that in mind because it is something that is important. People. and so that we look at different models. We should keep in mind the no kill policies of whatever agency including if we were to undertake the task on our because it will receive a lot of attention. Again, it is important. All right. Let's move to item nine. Mr. Martin, mayor. This is an important subject matter. The question of financial reserves and I have some questions about the sort of the form of the report and then some some questions about the substance. And I I want to be measured as I do that. But I found that this particular report cannot be so helpful and that's especially noticeable because the finance department's reports are usually so great. And I want to sort of temper my remarks by saying, you know, this May be because certain language is required as a matter of public accounting or what have you. But you know, I think what the report is talking about is the principal reserve funds that we have in the city. And as I read the report, we have an operating reserve and an emergency contingency reserve. So I just want to stop there and ask the city manager of the finance director one on the right track so far. Sure. >> Councilman Madison staff will apologize. That report is a little dense because it does use the vernacular of fund accounting. And let me turn it over to matt hawksworth. Bob ridley to explain in simple terms what various reserves are and what the recommendation before the council is visa v those reserves. Yeah. The short answer to your initial question is yes. That's correct. There's a 15 percent 5 percent with the terms that you referenced. Ok. It sounded like the city manager thought you were going amplifier translate. The reporter did you want to do that? Sure we can certainly do that. If they'll bring up a powerpoint we can walk through the terms that we use good. Good afternoon mayor and council member. This is poverty for the records and this item. I have a presentation that is very similar to the one we've given you for a number of years . This gas gatsby statement has been in place for 10 years now . So I I think I can go to a slide that May answer your question and then I'm happy to back up and cover some of the terminology and try to give you some clarity. So our policy adopted by city council in 2014 was that we would have an emergency contingency reserve of 15 percent of the general fund appropriations for 2020. That amount equals forty two point four million dollars and also a 5 percent operating reserve which would amount to fourteen point one million dollars for total this year of fifty six point six million dollars due to the commitment of the by the council of 700000 to the covered alternate care site. Seven hundred thousand dollars. And then the code with nineteen small business disaster fund of seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars we would reduce this 5 percent reserve by those two amounts which would give us twelve point seven million. However this year we are projecting that the at the actual revenue shortfalls will cause us to not have sufficient positive fund balance to fully fund the 5 percent and that is reflected by our projection of if we're two million dollars short the operating reserve would be funded at three point eight percent or ten point seven million. And if we turn out to be three million short the operating reserve would be funded at three point four percent or nine point seven million. While those seem like a fall off from where our target where we'd like our target to be that they are our target has been stated as a percentage to hit 20 percent overall reserves. That's the 15 percent emergency and 5 percent operating reserve reserve. However, because appropriations were up for 2020 both of these reduced the ten point seven million and the nine point seven million are actually representative of increases in dollar amount to our reserves. So I hope that answers the question. I'd be happy to go back to the terminology if you'd like me to . >> that's very helpful bob. Thank you. And I guess one question that comes directly out those remarks is if we know now that we will not be able to reach this goal, should we be addressing the commitment right now? >> in other words, the way I read the report and this is one of the confusing things about it I guess just baby steps first we're talking about the 2020 fiscal year which ends next week, correct? Yes. So we're at the very end of the fiscal year in question and we're realizing that because of the covered expenditures appropriations that the council made and the reduced revenues that we will not be able to make a quote unquote commitment which I think is essentially a as a way of saying we can put money into these reserves at the same level that we hope that that's an accurate statement. So I guess one question is just as a matter of process since we already know that should we be taking some steps here today as part of this action and if not, when will we be able to address the rest of this shortfall? So one of the things that bob and I talked about leading into this report is that there is this challenge we haven't had this challenge in the last number of years because we've had a very positive financial picture. So one of the things that we're committed to doing is bringing back to the finance committee in August or September as we wind up this fiscal year a review of this policy to identify that perhaps it would be more appropriate to establish these based on the adopted budget rather than the actuals. And so that way when we adopt the budget we would know what the number is at the beginning of the year rather than trying to true up to a number at the end of the fiscal year. And then like I said that would give something to plan forward to all year long. But then what? I think it's appropriate that we also look at all the things that go into this number to ensure that 20 percent continues to be the right number. When we established this 20 percent we didn't have a section 115 trust, we didn't have some other funds that we had set aside. We we currently hadn't had the front any money to any of the operating companies for debt service operations. So I think it's appropriate that we return to the finance committee and ultimately to the council with a comprehensive review of the reserve policy in August or September. And I know I'm certainly fine with adjusting it as we go and you could argue I suppose that you would not want to just incentivize frugality over the course of the year which if you established a fixed reserve at the start year you might do. But again, I'll leave that to the finance committee in the first instance. But I do wonder, you know here again if we're already at the end this fiscal year and we can already tell that our reserves are less I'm just a part of my concern is not misleading the residents or others about what our actual reserves are. So I guess if we had to answer that question right now, what would we say are the combined total of these two reserve funds? It's well I would. I would stated to components I would state one that we will fully fund the 15 percent at forty two point four million dollars and the operating reserve. Our goal is 5 percent or 14 million dollars. We believe that that will come up several million dollars short based on the two allocations of fund balanced previously mentioned and how the final revenues for the year end up. >> but in the end I think that we still have a very robust reserve. We still do have the section 150 trust fund as well which could be a further reserve to backstop the general fund. So despite not meeting our 20 percent I still think we're in a very healthy position. >> and of course council member madison we're not meeting that extra 5 percent reserve due to some really extraordinary circumstances and we also expect at least in part to receive some of the money back from from fema although sometimes it can take years to get the money back. I think it's a policy matter. It's it's important for the city to say that we have a commitment to a combined 20 present reserve. It helps maintain our triple a credit rating. We're dealing with some very extraordinary circumstances this fiscal year and into next fiscal year. But hopefully those will pass and we'll be able to stay with that strong financial statement that that has served the city so well. >> okay. >> why? You know, I'd still like to know what the answer is to you know, if we did a snapshot right now what the amount is in these two reserve funds. It sounds like it's a few million dollars less than the 56 million dollar goal. That's correct. We believe it currently it's between two to three million dollars less than the goal. Okay. So it became then 3 million and then the city manager's comments among others really go to my substantive question which is you know, we talk in our staff report about the windstorms of 2011 and this this idea of an emergency reserve. And you know, my reaction was my gosh, if covered doesn't fit the criteria for an emergency. I mean it is manifestly covered in the way it's impacted our city perhaps most directly in terms of our municipal services organization is because of the declaration of emergency both at the state and our city level . Yet we seem to be putting all of the burden into the operating reserve, not the emergency reserve. So maybe there's some accounting or other reason for that but I wonder if you could speak to that please. Sure. So while while the city while kobe 19 certainly qualifies as an emergency and we have declared an emergency we have not declared a fiscal emergency in the terms of a financial crisis for the city and the city council would need to declare a fiscal emergency in order to tap that 15 percent. And so the idea of the policy is that we could use the 5 percent without having to declare a fiscal emergency before we would have to tap into the additional 15 percent . >> are there some consequences declaring a fiscal emergency that would an impediment or would perhaps cause us to exercise our discretion and not do that because hello we're in a fiscal emergency. >> there's not anything specific. >> I just I would say that the creditors and rating agencies would look at the city far more closely if we were dipping into our reserves by declaring a fiscal emergency which certainly a number of cities have. But we have held off to that at this point the way our policy reads the 5 percent operating reserve. Generally it says that from time to time there May be a need to dip into that first 5 percent for some extraordinary purpose or for some reason that just make good sense. And at the 15 percent is what we would rely on really in the event of a catastrophe and certainly cove it is a catastrophe. But something like in an earthquake or other natural catastrophe and so it's really just the way that the semantics around. In the end it's all the same reserve dollars. And so it just seems to make sense to dip into the 5 percent bucket before dipping into the larger bucket. It sends the message that we always knew all along we May from time to time need to dip into the 5 percent reserve and that's what we're doing now. Again, we're fortunate that we have these reserves and that we don't need to press into the emergency reserve. Well and I'm remembering a staffer just shortly before the pandemic in a discussion at council about if you looked at all of our sort of reserves with a small bar in the city, it was in the area or even greater than 70 million dollars enough. >> we're talking about that section 115 or other sources. So I think you're talk. >> I think we time now is the 15 percent plus the 5 percent plus the 115 trust plus the unassigned fund balance and of course with the loss of revenues associated with the kobe nineteen shut down, we burned through that unassigned fund balance pretty quickly. So I think it'd be really important for us to get perhaps more fulsome report about all that. So we really have a good handle because this is something constituents are very interested in and you know, I'm still from missouri, if you will, on the the use of operating reserves versus emergency reserves. And for example, the report notes that in the fiscal year that's beginning next week the f y 2021 we intend to transfer some eight point five million dollars to cover rosewall operating company bonds. And I just I don't know how you can call those operating funds as opposed to an expenditure related to an emergency. Isn't operating and I don't know I'll think more about this like we all shared but just that I think that the public has an expectation that your operating reserves will be used for operations and the payment of long term debt is much more akin to sort of the rainy day fund that you need to access when there is an emergency. I mean that's really the need the rose bowl shut down right now because of the pandemic. So wouldn't that call for use of the emergency? Well, it's certainly a. >> it's better thought of the way you just described it. Whether it's the operating reserve or the emergency reserve, it's better thought of a reserve to go into only in the event of an extraordinary circumstance of which an emergency is. And it's eight point three million that we're taking from that operating reserve, the first five percent to support the rose bowl. We can recirculate Mr. Hawksworth. It put together a very nice memo on the fiscal impacts associated with the pandemic related shutdown and we can recirculate that to the council and it it touches upon these issues of the unassigned fund balance etc. I mean part of what I'm worried about is you know I know that for example, we're negotiating with some of our employee bargaining groups who at least based on my observation, you know, are are willing to share the burden and come together in this crisis and all. But you know, when we're using operating reserves to do things like provide small businesses with grants and pay off rose bowl debt, I can just hear it come that will then turn to employer and employees and other stakeholders. We're out of our operating reserves when in fact we should be using the real rainy day fund the emergency reserve because that's what's occasioned those expenditures. Plain and simple and you know, I just have to point out I don't want to pile on here but like you know, the fiscal impact statement at the end of this report says there's no fiscal back. And I just I just don't know how we can make that statement when we're noting in the report that we're gonna be millions of dollars short of our of our goals here in terms of the reserve, I suppose the reason is that it's not this report that creates the fiscal impact . But I mean it'd be nice to note somewhere that there's tremendous fiscal impact from all of us. But thank you. You've been generous to me in terms of the time. Thank you, Mr. Madison. Other questions for staff. Mr. Gordon? Yeah. Sam raises good good points. Know some of this has been concerned about the revenue loss and the impact of the budget. Mr. Madison certainly highlighting those issues. You know, we grieco if we were talking about reserves instruments that's the question neighborhood of 72 million. I don't think there's insufficient I think 70 to 72 million. Mr. City manager puts taking into account the 115 taken into particularly the sunnyside fund balance. And I don't think it's clear and transparent to the public that some of those the other same fund balance has in fact been used and we've tapped into what we believe to be reserve that the city could rely upon. I'm saying it wasn't appropriate. It certainly was appropriate. But it does feel that it matters and points out that there isn't sufficient clarity. You know b and frankly I don't feel comfortable that we are addressing the revenue shortfall. That's what Mr. Parsons absent corrected we raised this number last week or the week before the revenue loss update. I'll ask Mr. Hawksworth again the revenue loss for this fiscal year and the June 30th and the anticipated revenue loss would the following fiscal year 21 how much do you think it's 32 or 33 million, correct? Yes, sir. And you know and we you know, we solved for either by you or accounting for the losses in this year by dipping into some of the reserves or the unassigned on the family fund balance. Is that correct? Yes. Council member gordo as Mr. Hawksworth laid out and we're we're happy to walk through the financial presentations again in the current fiscal year we had a reduction in spending and we also essentially burned through our unassigned fund balance to cushion the blow of the cove in nineteen shut down . And so so you know, we begin to look at I'm concerned that and correct me if I'm wrong Mr. City manager Mr. Hawksworth but at some point we the council's going to be asked to dip into the reserves or make adjustments to the workforce or whatever it May be. >> to account for the anticipated already anticipated losses that make up that 32 to 33 million dollar revenue fund in 2021. Mike correct about that. So the 2021 budget that the council adopted is balanced and it shows positive net income of just under half a million dollars. Mr. Hawksworth and he'll be sending a packet out to the finance committee I think today or tomorrow for its meeting later this week. Continues to update his projections on revenues to the extent that the revenues May not come in as currently projected and put us in a position of not having positive net income, then the staff will return to the council with a plan to bring us back into balance. It's not my intent to ask the council to dip into its reserves to cover the budget. It's my plan to keep us positive in the black positive net income. And if that necessitates that we have to have a discussion about reductions that need to be made then so be it. The council will recall that with the adoption of the budget on top of what was already built in. You approved another one point eighty five million in reductions in the general fund to ensure we stay positive. So that's our commitment to you and Mr. Foxworth will continue to to monitor and track the revenues. We know that the finance committee will be monitoring the financial picture very closely throughout the year and we do anticipate needing to make several revisits on our budget more so than we would in a regular year. >> so the tracking. Well, let let me back up. So just so one clear the budget that was adopted and accounts for the anticipated loss in revenue between 2021. Correct. Yes. Based on what we know at the time and obviously to the extent that changes we'll need to revisit it. >> so. So right. And then that turns me into the point that we've discussed baked into that budget and baked into those revenue losses are assumptions and no, I I think it's important we track those assumptions. And Mr. Hartz with I don't know if maybe I missed it but you were going to put together one page and so that we could but I can follow the assumptions that are made into the revenue loss projections just to see if we're hitting them. I'd like to understand what they are. You know, we talked about them but it would be very helpful for me to have a one page or at least an understanding of the assumptions on the gop assumptions sales tax etc. So we can monitor and I don't know how often we can update those or whether it's you know, we'll just have to wait for the numbers but certainly we're going up monitor them in real time. I think would be helpful because I don't want to get to the point where we're cutting programs wholesale, where we're cutting programs or services that people in city rely upon. And so one of the things that I'll continue to advocate for is having discussions that we had to make cuts where when we look I don't want to get to the point where we're in crisis and then start talking about cutting services to seniors and to, you know, kids or families or services and street sweeping whatever it May be. And so two points one I would like help from his staff to better understand the assumptions and monitor those assumptions. Mr. I'm sorry. Sorry to interrupt. Sorry we've lost the mayor and Mr. Madison, are you from our meeting? I think that was unexpected. I didn't want you to continue on and that I can take it from here. I did want to I did want to jump in this afternoon we did create an attachment a which is a new look at the general fund revenues. It shows the projections. It shows the actual to the end of May and then it shows in verbiage the key assumptions that we're using. So it has some key assumptions so you will receive that this afternoon and then we can further dove into that on thursday afternoon. If you want to expand on it even further from there, we don't plan to rejoin the and then as at some point you know ,we don't want to be alarmed but we also want to be 100 percent reactive if we get to the point where we have to cut a million dollar revenue assumptions were offered two million dollars. I'd like to discuss a plan in advance. You know, certainly the city manager like I'm hearing you loud and clear, steve. You wouldn't pass for us just to dip into the reserve. But the question is what would you ask us to do in order to correct amelie revenue loss in the next fiscal maybe the council that says well, we're going to you know, we can't tolerate the cuts that you would recommend. I but we should have those conversations sooner rather later not wait for the moment when it counts. We've been pushed into a corner making a difficult decision that has a tremendous impact the quality of life for the people. Mr. I'd like to understand from the city manager what you know what the plan is in that regard or are we just going to wait and it goes well that which to me is not it is not an acceptable route. >> well, hope is not a strategy. So I appreciate your comments. No, certainly. We've already had some conversations internally with the departments and we do need to draw up some contingency plans. The commitment I made to the council was to always make sure that I present you a balanced budget. It's up to the council of course whether you want to take the actions necessary to balance it or use reserves to avoid any reductions. Thankfully we haven't had to to make any what I would consider serious reductions and since the passage of measure I. But we need to be realistic about how long the economy May stay in a downward trend. So as we proceed into the new fiscal year again about the budget for next year appears to be balanced but we can't be complacent. And so conversations with departments is around thinking about what if anything if we had to make adjustments what those would be again I'm a big advocate that we simply can't tell the departments to cut 5 percent or 10 percent and assume we can continue to do all the things we do so well today. It would probably be a much more difficult discussion about what are those essential services that we would do without. If we had to. And so that's ever present in our minds and we'll be thinking that out further and as necessary we'll be bringing that forward to the council through the finance committee rather than one member of the council. >> I'll tell you that in my view it's absolutely necessary. Think I think the presentation of the balanced budget by the staff when it's absolute necessary to make cuts is very painful, very difficult. I think it's better to have a contingency plan that's presented to the council. What is our plan? so if we lost the dollars, what would departments and the staff recommend? If it was two million dollars, if it was 3 or 5 million dollars whatever the increments that you think are appropriate, I do think it's important to get ahead of it and have a contingency plan that we can all understand. Hopefully we don't get there but I for one is much more focused on that discussion in advance and not wait till the moment in time when we have to have the discussion and have no choice. And then we're making very difficult decisions. That maybe art is that it should be so that that would be my suggestion to bring those contingency plans even if it's a framework. Steve, to help guide the council input the community on notice as to what May or May not happen if both revenue projections are incorrect. Indeed already the projections we made and this is not a criticism it's just been it's difficult to peg I understand that the projections we made at the beginning of the crisis turned out to be different than the projections in the actual revenues. Again, I know it's not not being critical. I know we had the where to start somewhere but the projections wrong. You know, we're probably not the only local government who discovered that. I mean. So to the extent we can start to mitigate understand I would suggest that council member gordo I think you'll see a slight improvement in what goes out with your pocket today with the finance committee but perhaps at the finance committee meeting we can have a broader discussion as to what extent the council wants to engage in identifying potential contingency reductions. >> thank you. Ok. We will continue that discussion at the finance committee this week. Any other questions on this matter? Their motion? I'm sorry we have public comment on this. Mr. Clark, we do play from ralph to eddie pasadena. I'm disappointed that this council faced with this is loosely related to the budget. I'm disappointed that this council faced with an unprecedented level of public comment decided to imply that we don't know what we're talking about and need schooling on how to read a municipal budget. You could have responded the committee's outrage and reexamined your stance on police funding. Perhaps we're not simply reacting to a fad as several of you led by council member kennedy seemed to imply. Perhaps we're seeing your ineptitude in addressing the issue of police violence and racism, deciding to take action and give you a hefty kick in the seat of your pants. The palestinian police department has murdered innocent people. No one went to jail for it. It happened again and again and still no one went to jail for it. And now we decide to raise our voices against a callous decision to increase the police budget in the midst of a nationwide movement to defund and demilitarize police and have been told that we need a lesson in public budgets one to one. This is condescending and shameful. Good luck to all of you and when you're up for reelection we will not forget. And that's the public comment for this item. All right. Thank you. Please call her roll. I don't think we had a motion or a second but we'll look at those little motions from council. >> I beg your pardon. Last time I took to series emotions this time items again. No candy makes the motion is there second? Mr. Masuda said the cast member gordon carlsberg. Kennedy? Yes. From madison? Yes. Casimir masuda? Yes. Else remember mark austin? Yes. Member wilson? Yes. Vise mayor. Hampton yes. Air torn ok. Yeah. The motion is approved without opposition. Thank you. We will now move to item eleven. I think council member wilson had a question about this money insurance and we are bringing in robert lowe who is someone who the city attorney's office has working with to to provide additional assistance with this item. Ok, Mr. Wilson. Yes. I guess it's really just a question. I understand that we're becoming part rejoining premium as I understand it and we believe that there will be an opportunity to I guess increase our ah ah coverage when mitt gets reduced our costs based off the other quotes there are the quotes we've received. I want to get a better sense of where we are and what we thought the opportunity would be under prism. It was very vague. I understand that the action here is just doing this kind of consortium of governments but we're interested in what the financial implications were. Thank Mr. Wilson. See who's gonna respond. Mayor michel barnier has had to step away on an urgent matter. Arlene gallardo, our risk and insurance administrator is here and also john rad. I think in the first instance arlene will try to respond and explain a little bit more about prism. This came online very late last week. It was an opportunity we felt we needed to jump on. and with that I'll turn to arlene. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you. I'm here to request that afternoon I should say May or members of the city council. I am here to request that council adopt a resolution authorizing the city of pasadena to join public risk innovation solution and management also known as prism for fiscal year 21. If such option is determined to be in the city's best interest as stated in last week's June 15, 2020 agenda report, the city's insurance broker alliance continues to market and explore beneficial ways to redesign the city's current liability program. Just to kind of recap a little bit. We are in an insurance market that was hardening in prior years that has recently compounded with cover 19 and civil unrest. These events and a history of increasing losses presented challenges with the city's insurance renewals in a hardened market insured face increased premiums, higher deductibles, cuts in capacity and limited coverage terms. Another contributing factor is social inflation which the rising cost of insurance claims due to societal trends increased litigation and jury awards that are climbing at an unprecedented rate. Additionally, public entities are experiencing significant losses not only in california but throughout the country. In order to find the most cost effective options with the broadest coverage possible staff in the line exploring risk sharing pool options keeping in mind that coverage is still being marketed and negotiated client received quotes for 20 million dollars and limits that are what that would allow the city to retain its general self-insured retention also known as an essay are of 5 million dollars. However, given the current social climate the city would be required to increase its law enforcement sbir from five million to seven point five million dollars. A link has been working with prism on and separately with prism on another option for the city to consider and is confident prism will provide the competitive premium and favorable terms such as a five million dollar they are including law enforcement at a more competitive premium. If so, the city would have to enter into a joint powers agreement with prism. If terms are agreeable and in the city's best interests for July 1, 2020 coverage we bring this item before council today for consideration since this is the final council meeting prior to July 1, 2020. So the next question May be well what is prism? Prism is a member directed risk sharing pool of public entities that was created in 1979 offering cost effective insurance solutions and risk management services for members. ninety five percent of california counties and 70 percent of california cities are presumed members. A list of city members can be found at the website link provided a few examples of such member cities include anaheim, sacramento, san diego, santa clara and south pasadena. Similar to pasadena, anaheim and santa clara also have stadium exposures. Sacramento, san diego are significantly sized cities in the state of california and south pasadena is geographically comparable as it is our neighboring city adjacent to the city of pasadena. It is staff's recommendation that the council find that the proposed action is exempt from california environmental quality act work pursuant to state secret guidelines section 1 5 3 7 8 and adopted a resolution authorizing the city of pasadena to join public risk innovation solutions and management prism for the city's general and access municipal liability insurance coverages effective July 1, 2020 to July 1, 2021. If such option is determined to be in the city's best interest. And lastly grant an exemption from the competitive selection process of the competitive bidding and purchasing ordinance. Pasadena municipal code charter 4.0 8. Pursuant to section 4.0 8 point 0 4 9 contracts which the city's best interests are served. The proposed insurance coverages are exempt from the competitive bidding process pursuant to the city charter 1 0 0 2 contracts for professional or union services. This concludes my presentation. The city's insurance broker robert lowe first vise President With the line insurance services and I welcome any questions the city council might have at this time. Thank you, Mr. Watson. So people of questions do we have quotes from non prism underwriters that we're able to be responsive to what I presume comes back in terms of what they can offer? Yes. So on slide 3 where we were mentioning how we have quotes that have 20 million dollar limits with a five million dollar sbir that we do have from non prism carriers but that would require that the city's sbir law enforcement svr increase from five million to seven and a half million due to the given social climate. >> what is it what is the cost of that premium going to you you mentioned. My understanding is the quotes for that first option noted is right now one point seventy seven five million but they are working the brokers are working on trying to get that top five million dollar option so that it can equate to a twenty five million dollars in limits. Hope I didn't lose you there but so right now. Yeah. What is that what we're paying for last fiscal year that was in total for the top total tower of the twenty five million dollar limit that would be I believe a 50 estimated 50 percent increase from last year expiring renewals get a 50 percent increase in kind of less less attractive coverage. Is that part of the bit where we're comparing to correct. Yes, if I May. My apologies. Good afternoon mayor and members of city council. This is robert lowe with the alliance insurance services are I had to directly answer the question that was just asked. No, it's not less attractive coverage. Essentially the coverage itself that we have an option on the table right now which is considered standalone is exactly the same coverage that the city purchased last year. The only exception is that the law enforcement retention is being pushed. Everything else stays at the 5 million. The law enforcement would need to seven point five million. Right. And I assume we've looked at the actuarial history to figure out what the actual costs would be about having to probably that retention increased retention from from the police department. I guess the other question if this prison group sounds like it's been around for a while. Why have we not considered this earlier? So this is arlene. I can't speak to prior years. I was here last year during the insurance renewal and we had a different broker at that time. At that time we were not presented with a risk sharing pool option. And as a result of the rfp we released late last year and with bringing the client on board as the city's new insurance broker we discussed the option of a risk sharing pool this year considering the insurance market and the challenges that we were going to face with renewals. So we needed primitive decision that this was an attractive historically you know that the markets change were reconsidering. >> is that fair? >> again, I can't. What the decision was in the past but that's what we're looking correct. This is robert again. Apologies for interrupting arlene. You know, I think historically from a risk appetite perspective it is a risk sharing. Poor. Correct. So as with arlene, I can't necessarily say what the risk appetite was in the past. What I do know from experience with working municipalities there are times where a municipality May not necessarily want to share risk with other peers. And if I'm making an assumption that that May have driven the reason in the past of why organizationally the city of pasadena had not explored tourism in the past I raised it by adopting those that were authorizing the staff to go ahead enjoying the risk sharing pool. I mean not just joined to become a member but it were authorized meant to staff to go ahead and actually execute. Put our insurance risk in that pool. That is practice if terms are agreeable to the city of pasadena. Yes. And if is the city's best interest I think just to give what rob just said that I'm not an expert on insurance. >> shouldn't we know what the difference is between being insured to a risk sharing pool versus traditional underwriter ? I didn't see any analysis around the council in boston as javon at the time. >> one of the things is that some of these discussions are still going on. So the discussion basically what the council is being asked to do is authorize the resolution so long as it's acceptable to staff. But again negotiations are still happening with prism. So the bottom line is it's still a question of whether they present the most favorable deal. Robert, explain he anticipates it to be the most favorable but that's something staff still needs to work through. >> I guess my concern is if there is material differences with respect to coverage or ability of claims to be paid by being part of a risk sharing pool as opposed to having a traditional third party underwriter, I think the council would want to know what those issues ritual aspects are of that type of coverage. Bob, how do we get comfortable with that? So this is arlene. What we're doing right now is we are working with a client and rubber. You can let us know but we're working with a client to get those

Council Meeting Recap - June 22, 2020

To access staff reports, please click on the link below to download Adobe Reader Version 6.0. http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readstep2.html

PURSUANT TO EXECUTIVE ORDER N-29-20 ISSUED BY GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM ON MARCH 17, 2020,

THE SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING FOR JUNE 22, 2020 AT 2:00 P.M. WILL TAKE PLACE SOLELY BY VIDEOCONFERENCE/TELECONFERENCE.

IN ORDER TO FACILITATE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION, CLICK ON THE FOLLOWING WEBPAGE:

https://www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/public-comment/

IF ASSISTANCE IS NEEDED BY PHONE, PLEASE CALL THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AT (626) 744-4124

LIVESTREAM WITH CAPTIONING IS AVAILABLE AT WWW.PASADENAMEDIA.ORG ,

AND ALSO AT WWW.CITYOFPASADENA.NET/COMMISSIONS/AGENDAS ,

TO HEAR A LIVE SPANISH TRANSLATION OF THE MEETING (LISTEN ONLY), PLEASE DIAL-IN 10 MINUTES PRIOR TO THE MEETING (1:50 P.M.):

TOLL-FREE DIAL-IN: (888) 585-9008

PARTICIPANT PASSCODE: 739-142-091, THEN #

IF YOU NEED A REASONABLE MODIFICATION OR ACCOMMODATION PURSUANT TO THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT

BECAUSE YOU ARE UNABLE TO PARTICIPATE ELECTRONICALLY AS SET FORTH ABOVE, CONTACT THE CITY CLERK�S OFFICE

AS SOON AS POSSIBLE AT (626) 744-4124 OR CITYCLERK@CITYOFPASADENA.NET .

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

DE ACUERDO CON LA ORDEN EJECUTIVA N-29-20 EMITIDO POR EL GOBERNADOR

GAVIN NEWSOM EL 17 DE MARZO DE 2020, LA REUNI�N ESPECIAL DEL CONSEJO DE LA CIUDAD PARA EL 22 DE JUNIO DE 2020 A las 2:00 P.M. SE EFECTUAR� SOLAMENTE POR VIDEOCONFERENCIA/TELECONFERENCIA.

CON EL FIN DE FACILITAR LA PARTICIPACI�N DEL P�BLICO, PRESIONE LA SIGUIENTE P�GINA WEB:

https://www.cityofpasadena.net/city-clerk/public-comment/

SI SE NECESITA ASISTENCIA POR TELEFONO, POR FAVOR LLAME A LA OFICINA DE LA SECRETARIA DE LA CIUDAD AL (626) 744-4124

ESTAR� DISPONIBLE LA TRANSMISI�N AL VIVO CON SUBTITULOS EN

WWW.PASADENAMEDIA.ORG ,

Y TAMBIEN EN WWW.CITYOFPASADENA.NET/COMMISSIONS/AGENDAS

PARA ESCUCHAR LA INTERPETACI�N AL ESPA�OL DE LA REUNI�N AL VIVO (S�LO PARA ESCUCHAR), FAVOR DE LLAMAR 10 MINUTOS ANTES DE LA REUNI�N (1:50 P.M.):

LLAMANDO GRATIS AL: (888) 585-9008

C�DIGO DE ACCESO DEL PARTICIPANTE: 739-142-091, LUEGO #

SI NECESITA UNA MODIFICACION O ACOMODACI�N RAZONABLE DE ACUERDO CON LA LEY DE ESTADOUNIDENSES CON DISCAPACIDADES PORQUE USTED NO PUEDE PARTICIPAR ELECTR�NICAMENTE COMO SE ESTABLECE ANTERIORMENTE, CONT�CTESE CON LA OFICINA DE LA SECRETAR�A DE LA CIUDAD LO ANTES POSIBLE AL (626) 744-4124 O CITYCLERK@CITYOFPASADENA.NET

SPECIAL MEETING

AGENDA

CITY COUNCIL AND THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY

TO THE PASADENA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION

JUNE 22, 2020

Public Meeting: 2:00 P.M.

Council Chamber, Pasadena City Hall

100 North Garfield Avenue, Room S249

PUBLIC MEETING � 2:00 P.M.

ROLL CALL, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE, AND CEREMONIAL MATTERS

PUBLIC COMMENT � LIMITED TO ITEMS ON THIS SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA AND WILL BE HEARD AT THE TIME THE ITEM IS CONSIDERED

CONSENT CALENDAR

Showing the first 24,000 of 120,826 characters. The full document is at the source.

Yeah, we're alive. Thank you. Good afternoon and welcome to the city council and successor agency meeting of June 22nd. >> as you can see, we're still operating remotely. So bear with us. Appreciate the difficulties it poses for some people but we will press ahead and let's have a roll call. Thank mayor. Council member gordo your council member kennedy here, council member madison here Councilman Masuda council member mick austin. Yeah. Council member wilson here vise mayor hampton. Blessed to be here. Mayor torn. Yeah. There's a quorum of the council present. Thank you. Council member of the gotham. Would you lead us in the pledge please? Place your hand over your heart ready again? I personally see the flag of the united states of america. Which is why I invented indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. We have no ceremonial today. So we'll move directly to the consent calendar of mayor. Sorry. Yeah. Customary that you have been doing in the last several meetings at the beginning of the meeting you share with the council that we're going to adjourn. Yes. Thank you. Governmental. I appreciate the reminder. Okay. I'll adjourn our meeting. At the end in the memory of victims of kogut the cocaine epidemic. And we will continue to ask for guidance and inspiration with a moment of silence reflection. Thank you. Council member I neglected to do that. Are there on the consent calendar? Are there items that council members would like held for further discussion? Governor madison? I would like respectfully to discuss item number nine. Number nine I have a quick question on item number six that I sent to the city manager . >> let me just make sure that he answered. If he doesn't, then I need to get an answer. All right. While you're looking for that, you write me a challenge like a brief presentation given the response from the city manager on item number six, please. Mayor ok, thank you. Council member kennedy Mr. Borda, I wanted just a quick question. Q craig quickly responded when this matter is going to go back out to. Is there an answer to that? Mr. City manager when it's going to be rebid? Let me check with the board's director ahmed lee. You when item 1 is going back out bed at any point during the meeting. Sergeant ok. Mr. Wilson it's the 11:00 placement. Dancer council member board of question. >> item one will go out to bid next week. Item 11 ok. Move the balance along with second job is we. Do we have public comment on any of these items, Mr. Johnston? >> we have public comment. Item number six we just got something in for item number 8 which is a one sentence that I can read quickly and then item nine. So since item 6 9 that it will be all right. Want to read comment on the item 8 comes from juliette ryan davis pasadena. >> it's a one sentence. Please define it. Demilitarize the police department. That was relate to item eight. That's what came in. Ok. Thank you. >> Mr. Kennedy, you're gonna make a sweet motion move approval of the ballot. Ok. So that with the exception of item 6, 9 and 11 there there second Mr. Masuda purple color roll cast member gordo. Kennedy. Casimir madison. Yes. Councilman Masuda? yes. Council member mark austin. Council member wilson? Yes. Vise mayor hampton. Yes. Motion is approved without opposition. Thank you. >> we'll go to item 6 council member kennedy this is about the contract with the athina humane society. So before we go for a full blown presentation, the issue for me is one point three million dollars more than the previous year three hundred fifty thousand dollars more than the previous year. >> move approval the quick answer. Second question. Got that can by Mr. And other things. What's in the news item six, right? Yes, sir. I have a question masuda followed by vise mayor hampton Mr. City manager, what's going to happen next year with the contract? Thank you. >> council member masuda we do have a full staff presentation. If the council likes but let me just speak briefly answer the question and whatever the will of the council is as indicated in a staff report we've been contracting with the passing of main society for over a century and last year the humane society let us know that they came with a different methodology for allocating the total cost of their enterprise and that as a result pasadena and all the other municipalities that contract with them would be looking at significant increases in their annual contract. Our annual contract currently is one point to five million and the humane society proposed over seven hundred thousand dollar increase. So that's over a 50 percent increase our city and our. The other contract cities sat down with the humane society and negotiated a lesser increase but it's still a significant increase. So the item before you today increases the contract just under seventy five thousand dollars when it comes to animal control we're very limited in the choices that we have. Historically it's been either to contract with the passing the humane society or the county of los angeles county of los angeles hasn't had the best reputation in this in this field. And so traditionally we've stayed with the humane society. If the council approves this one year extension in that time we will once again explore how viable contracting with the county of los angeles is. They've made improvements in recent years to reduce the rate of animals that need to be euthanized to the point that they are more on par with the humane society. We also plan to explore options including forming a joint powers authority with the other contract cities, perhaps creating our own division to pursue. But we're cognizant about all the costs and the need to have a facility so it's conceivable that the end of a year we still come back and say for a variety of reasons the parsi humane society is still the the best way to go from a service delivery point of view but we know it would be at a significantly increased cost. So we'll certainly vet all of these options and great quality who works in housing department is working on special assignment for us on this high priority project. >> thank you, Mr. Mahmoud. Thank magoffin onsite vise mayor and then Ms. Magoffin, then Mr. Gordon. Thank you. These discussions are happening and I was wondering, Mr. City manager, will this be coming back to a public safety committee? Because I think the needs of what? Or maybe the average resident May not understand exactly what is in our contract now and what our contract and built does a lot of calling they say and to say oh, we don't do that. I'm so I think understanding what the needs of the community are number one one of the needs is always picking up dead animals. A lot of times you know, some people in their 80s are not what not they don't want to go outside and pick that animal. I pick them up from my neighbors all the time. But you made saudi sometimes dumplings dead skunks on the road for you know, for my days even maybe in a week or two. So just understanding the scope of work and what they what our community needs are as we're looking at a new contract or potentially a new provider would extremely helpful. And I think that discussion to be had in the public safety committee because this is where it came before. Is that part of your scope work your plan to bring it back to public safety committee meeting to have a discussion about the humane society that would be very appropriate to do? Oh yes. We will do guest for that benefit. That's my only request. Okay. Martin on the bouncer who's a resident of my district. She also sent out an e-mail to council members and I think maybe you May have been on it if you're not. Steve I'll to it. Over to you. She's been very active in this this realm and has a lot of expertise when it comes to animals and I don't think I would say that one person just someone who wants to help, you know, from the public aspect. Be great if you were not not a contractor or anything. I'm just saying that that she had someone else that would be great and please forward that on. Ms. Magoffin followed by council member gordon. Thank you, mayor. So Mr. City manager, this is this is really troubling that we have a hundred year relationship with a humane society and we've contracted with them all these years and it sounds like they're not for the staff report. They're not willing to share what their true costs are. How in the past have the court then determined have they given right in in the past the contract had always been negotiated. They previously didn't submit any sort of a cost analysis to the city. What happened with this most recent discussion of significant cost increases is pasadena and the other contracts that he's asked the humane society to provide cost information to us. They did provide us some information. We did meet with them. We walked through it. We had a lot of questions with their methodology. We don't necessarily agree with their methodology how they allocate costs but the fundamental change seems to be how the humane society has just decided to allocate out their revenue requirement. So in any given year the humane society would benefit from contributions that people make because these charitable donations cetera and the society was use a portion of that revenue towards the cost of animal control and furthering their mission. Recently they've decided that they're no longer going to do that and they feel that the animal control contracts from the cities need to support 100 percent of certain operations. For example, they expanded a couple of years ago. they expanded the services they offer and are now essentially asking to contract cities to support those expanded services through increases in their contract. It's largely just a philosophical change in how they see their role and who should be paying to to underwrite the costs of their services and how the endowment money that they receive than any other grants. Now that that doesn't go toward we operating expenses, they use that exclusively for something else. Historically it did as my understanding and now they're saying that they don't think that that should be the case going forward. That's really troubling. I mean do they have a charter obligation under their their charter or something? Not that I'm aware not not that I'm aware of and we did question them as to whether they were seeking to get out of the animal control business altogether. >> they've assured us that they they aren't seeking to do that. But there they're potentially driving away all the cities that contract with them. >> what about you know, they recently built a new building. Right. That's the expansion I was talking about. So who's paying for that? Are we paying for that pro-rata? Well, they they paid for it in the first instance but it does appear that by creating the expansion in their facility, they're offering new programing and they are they essentially said to us that are the increase in the contract costs is in part to support that new programing. >> and of course the contract cities we point out to the humane society that we didn't ask for that those aren't services we wanted to purchase . And I will say historically and I I personally negotiated contract for many years from the city standpoint we want sort of an all la carte contract where we contract for animal control visiting the parks to enforce the off leash, picking up that dead animal in the street that the vise mayor is mentioning and some other services. The humane society has traditionally said that they provide a broad range of services and we need to support those as well. So a lot of it is philosophical in what the city should be paying for. Very troubling to me. So I mean I support taking the year to further evaluate it. >> are the other cities doing the similar? Yes. >> we're. We're working in close coordination with one another and we're in consultation as a group with the county. >> ok, thanks. Let's go let's go to an issue that we were with for quite some time the level of service costs associated with providing those services, the desire to have the what you call the wild card. >> yes. All the card services. My recollection is Miss Mather was coming add to it. I don't want to put of course the public safety but given the workload if it's appropriate. Mike, what about that you've come to attack historically it's gone through the public safety committee. When it's gone to subcommittee is my recollection. >> I don't know that the he is obviously incorrect. Remember discussing the issue with cameras and also for licenses so we could have an update on how effective or not that has been. In terms of causing more people to have a dog with their pets or pet license, do we when it comes back or we will probably see sort of that recommendation. You know how we improve that. And finally, you know, I don't think we should rule out this los angeles. My recollection is that the city of los angeles has May have capacity in some of their centers. And you know, a good idea to check in with them. Well, maybe even built you some extra animal shelters. We'll certainly pursue that. >> one of the challenges with the county is the lack of any facility nearby. So you raise a good point. We'll proceed whether the city of L.A. Is a viable option. >> but you really have to shelter over over here by. 110 freeway there a number of shelters in the area that maybe suitable but you know, whether they're interested that's a different story. But I don't publish a book about we want. Ok, one other question. Are there any other municipalities in the area the san gabriel valley that provide their own service? Not that I'm aware of the things people since then will leave without saying. >> gabriel, maine, we May want to talk to investigate whether there are other cities but glendale, glendale now glendale ,glendale contracted about five years ago with the city humane society following a bit of a scandal at their local shelter. They bought into passing humane by providing them two million dollars upfront payment and they locked in a five year contract. It was actually less than our cost at our current one point two five million. Even though glendale is 40 percent larger by population so that's another thing that I questioned. Maybe they're cat people and they have fewer dogs but it didn't seem to make a lot of sense. So that would be another model as well. You know one function of shelter function and the other function on the enforcement of laws and animal control of both domestic animals, both wild animals and we didn't together with other city 538 to achieve both a better service and of their lesser cost. I would encourage us to do that. And that was one thought that perhaps we May contract with the humane society for the kennel lean but perhaps have positions that are akin to sort of a park safety specialist classification that can handle patrol and routine enforcement . The city of los angeles you use but not armed on unarmed peace officers. Well, on duty unarmed peace officers who are able to enforce law and at the same time. Provide the tools for so I will look at their model and look at the possibility by quickly even if we were to has a lot of that look at the idea providing shelter space. I don't know if this is an opportunity to think differently. We've struggled with this issue for so long that it's time we have a long term plan with a regrettably with or without the the humane society capacity. We've just gone up and down and the costs are tremendous and have increased so much over time that we have to look at it differently. Just as a reminder we had a the animal control, you know, come in and give report on the coyote problem. Remember you and I were having both problems with that so they did a great job. Just just as a reminder that nobody these. There's lots to be said. We're working with the humane society and they're going to try to just cost the response of the animal models. >> hopefully we can work out a model with them that make sense of the bipartisan model for example, where they provide the shelter service that we provide your services in different ways and possibly with another jurisdiction or just in-house, ok. But Mr. Wilson thank you, mayor. Yes, I am I am a bit troubled. We can't seem to figure this out and make me want to think and you've asked the question is do they maybe they want to get out of this business. It's worth asking since you're a not for profit organisation. I know the level of transparency of their finances is actually required to be available to the public. I assume that we've gone through that to see what part of their business this is and understand a the financial motivations. I assume that's happened, steve. Yes. >> and we did ask him the question that they wanted to get out of the business altogether. They've assured us that they don't. And we've seen the high level financial information. It's really what we wanted to drilling was to their methodology and their allocation model and they shared with us. But the the finance directors and city managers from the six contract cities or so we all had our concerns with their methodology and fundamentally in the and that's all it is is a methodology. It's not arithmetic where we can where we have to decide what the result is. >> I saw your work plan. They're going to evaluate alternatives. Is there a way to do any benchmarking with other cities or I assume there's a finance manual that says you're spot administer reality pays for these types of services that we can figure out whether they're in the ballpark or because they have a bit of monopoly here in this part of town. And as you mentioned with the consolidation of glendale, we benchmark this to the other way to look at what this is, to see whether this is market work additional benchmarks. I don't think we've done that. >> we can. We can look to see you know, we have this interesting symbiotic relationship with the humane society. We can take a look to see if what our community is pain measures up to other similarly situated communities. >> I think it's worth doing the homework a I see you've met with the ceo and tried to figure out what their objectives are so that we know what they're trying to accomplish and so it can be the guy but we're trying to accomplish. >> yes, we've had several conversations with the ceo and we had a meeting with I think the majority of their board or certainly their executive committee and city managers from all the contract cities where they walked us through their methodology and their numbers and I mean let me just give a quick for example. So if if a resident of the city of pasadena where to find a stray animal and take it to the passing of humane society passing humane society would say well where did you find this animal or where do you live? And if our resident said pasadena. Then they would ascribe the cost of the care for that animal to our contract. That is a change from what used to occur they're seeking to allocate out. Now if you will, every animal back to one of the contract cities. So what would be a get out of that business and we're no longer caring for animals. >> I guess I'd be interested to know what business they'd be in. I don't know enough about how you think about they seem so tightly intertwined with those private shelters or private shelters that don't do animal control. There's a lot of rescue, you know council members who have pets probably got their animals from a from a rescue. So there's a lot of private kennels nonprofit charitable that don't do animal control. So they would. So if they didn't do animal control they would still presumably continue to do the care for four animals in our community which they do quite well. Well, certainly I think you have a robust work plan and i think working with public safety and keeping the council informed this is a well-established institution. But obviously we have to look out for the best interests of the taxpayers thinking ok, any further questions for the staff? If not emotion move. Thank you vise mayor. Thank you. Second, Ms. Magoffin call. Before we do that, mayor, I'll read the public comment from carla taj. Tasha no I'm sorry. >> yeah, the motion opportunity seconded by madison. Ok. Thank you. Sorry about that. I didn't see that. Ok. This is from marla tauscher. I am an attorney practicing primarily in animal control. I strongly urge the council to approve a one year contract extension with pasadena humane society council should use that year to devise and implement an alternative to contracting dhs which does not involve contracting with the county los angeles for animal control services in any capacity. L.A. County animal control is one of the least transparent least transparent, most regressive high kill animal control agencies in the state of california. If not the country contracting with L.A. County will not only result in abuses of animals lives but also of the rights of their owners which will ultimately increase costs resulting from litigation. This is a golden opportunity for the city to create a truly humane no kill animal control agency that respects the lives of animals and their owners legal rights. Please do not squander this opportunity by taking what appears to be the easy way out. Please commit to implementing real and lasting improvements for animals and their owners in the city of pasadena. I am willing to help in any way I can and can enlist others with expertise in this area. That completes public comment on this item. So we have a motion from council member kennedy seconded from by Councilman Madison to approve the staff recommendation. Council member gordo? Yes. I have a question after the vote. Yes, ma'am. Kennedy yes. Councilman Madison? Yes. Councilman Masuda? Yes. Councilman Mike austin. Yes. Council member wilson yes. Vise mayor hampton yes. Mayor talk. Yeah. The motion is approved without opposition. Only the reminded me of the importance of the local program and policy. If we're going to look at a different model we have to keep that in mind because it is something that is important. People. and so that we look at different models. We should keep in mind the no kill policies of whatever agency including if we were to undertake the task on our because it will receive a lot of attention. Again, it is important. All right. Let's move to item nine. Mr. Martin, mayor. This is an important subject matter. The question of financial reserves and I have some questions about the sort of the form of the report and then some some questions about the substance. And I I want to be measured as I do that. But I found that this particular report cannot be so helpful and that's especially noticeable because the finance department's reports are usually so great. And I want to sort of temper my remarks by saying, you know, this May be because certain language is required as a matter of public accounting or what have you. But you know, I think what the report is talking about is the principal reserve funds that we have in the city. And as I read the report, we have an operating reserve and an emergency contingency reserve. So I just want to stop there and ask the city manager of the finance director one on the right track so far. Sure. >> Councilman Madison staff will apologize. That report is a little dense because it does use the vernacular of fund accounting. And let me turn it over to matt hawksworth. Bob ridley to explain in simple terms what various reserves are and what the recommendation before the council is visa v those reserves. Yeah. The short answer to your initial question is yes. That's correct. There's a 15 percent 5 percent with the terms that you referenced. Ok. It sounded like the city manager thought you were going amplifier translate. The reporter did you want to do that? Sure we can certainly do that. If they'll

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Meeting: June 22, 2020
  • City Council Meeting: June 22, 2020 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: db157ff7480cd1ede75090a910515123. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record