POLISCOPE

The public record

GAINESVILLE (ALACHUA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Historic Preservation Board

Tuesday, April 7, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The board unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting.

The Historic Preservation Board deferred several new construction projects to allow for design revisions and further community input. The board also requested that future demolition permits near the historic Bailey Plantation include requirements for cultural resource surveys to protect potential subsurface artifacts.

Why it matters

Property owners and developers in historic districts face delays and additional design requirements for new construction, while residents near the Bailey Plantation may see increased oversight on demolition projects to preserve archaeological history.

What happens next

Next meeting: Tuesday, May 5, 2026.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

3

Recorded outcomes

3

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

3 captured items have a publicly linked outcome.

Search all 3 meeting actions
  • Item C1

    The board unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting.

    Approval of March 3, 2026 Minutes

  • Item E4a

    The board deferred the application at the request of the applicant to allow time to find a design solution acceptable to the board.

    COA-26-000-032 (1024 NE 4th Street)

  • Item E4b, c, d

    The board deferred three new construction applications to allow the architect to address concerns regarding building scale, roof shapes, porch design, and site planning, and to incorporate feedback from neighbors.

    New Construction Applications (COA-26-000-025, 026, 027)

Recorded votes

4 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (4)

Voting yes on all of these (9)

Ackrillyes
Asneryes
Fileryes
Hauckyes
Hazenyes
Reevesyes
Rudolphyes
Warinneryes
Wilsonyes
continued

COA-25-000-070 1024 NE 4th Street

continued

COA-26-000-026 New Construction

continued

COA-26-000-027 New Construction

continued

COA26-000-025 New Construction

People and votes

Anthony Ackrill

Present at this meeting

4 recorded votes

  1. Recorded vote

    COA-25-000-070 1024 NE 4th Street - Voted yes on the motion “Motion to defer COA 26-000-032 upon request of applicant, to try and find a solution that would be acceptable to the HP Board.”; the record reports continued.

  2. Recorded vote

    COA-26-000-026 New Construction - Voted yes on the motion “Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000-027.”; the record reports continued.

  3. Recorded vote

    COA-26-000-027 New Construction - Voted yes on the motion “Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000-027.”; the record reports continued.

  4. Recorded vote

    COA26-000-025 New Construction - Voted yes on the motion “Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000-027.”; the record reports continued.

See all 4 roll calls with named votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

1 City of Gainesville Historic Preservation Board MINUTES April 7, 2026, 5:30 p.m. City Hall, Roberta Lisle Kline Conference Room (Room 16) 200 East University Ave Gainesville, FL 32601 Members Present: Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, George Wilson _____________________________________________________________________ A. CALL TO ORDER - 5:30 pm B. ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA Moved by Bill Warinner Seconded by Elizabeth Hauck Motion: The Historic Preservation Board adopt the agenda. Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson Approved (9 to 0) C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Historic Preservation Board Approve the Minutes from the March 3, 2026 Meeting (B) Recommendation: The Historic Preservation Board approve the minutes from the March 3, 2026 meeting. Moved by Elizabeth Hauck Seconded by Bill Warinner 2 Recommendation: The Historic Preservation Board approve the minutes from the March 3, 2026 meeting. Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson Approved (9 to 0) D. PUBLIC COMMENT Dotty Faibisy inquired as the the status of the Wilhelmina Johnson Center designation report. Staff noted that it is in progress and that a draft would be shared with her to get any further input. E. PUBLIC HEARING 1. Swearing in of the Public 2. Requests for Deferral 3. Continued Items 4. New Items a. 2026-271 PH1 – COA-25-000-070 1024 NE 4th Street (B) Moved by Elizabeth Hauck Seconded by Vivan Filer Recommendation: Staff recommends that application COA26- 000-032 be approved with the following conditions: Condition 1: The modern door and sidelights be replaced with a period appropriate door and sidelights, preferably one that matches the door and sidelights that was recently removed. Condition 2: A replica of the 48-pane bay window will be reinstalled in place of the window series that now exists. The replica may have a black frame in order to match the rest of the windows in the house. Motion to defer COA 26-000-032 upon request of applicant, to try and find a solution that would be acceptable to the HP Board. 3 Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson Approved (9 to 0) b. 2026-272 COA26-000-025 New Construction Parcel 14276-002- 001 (B) Moved by Michelle Hazen Seconded by Vivan Filer Recommendation: Staff recommends that application COA26- 000-025 be deferred to the following Board meeting, so that the following can be addressed: 1. An overall street elevation (sketch) should be provided to show the three properties together, including the neighboring structures, so that a proper analysis of street and building rhythm and scale can be made. 2. A site plan that shows the three buildings together, with the proposed ADUs, and showing the existing buildings to the rear of these lots, so that a proper analysis can be done of how the new buildings will relate to surrounding existing buildings. 3. If ADU’s are a part of this proposal, the design of the ADU should be submitted with the application for the main structure. 4. House A needs improvements made to the roof shape, front window placement and sizes, and front porch configuration as it relates to the front windows. 5. Dimensions need to be added for the front porch, and the front porch should not look like an afterthought to the design of the overall structure. 6. Material notes should be added to the actual elevation sheet, especially for siding, roof, and window material. Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000- 027, in order for the architect to continue working on the drawings and to consider comments made by adjoining residents and the HP Board. Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson 4 Approved (9 to 0) c. 2026-273 PH3-COA-26-000-026 New Construction Parcel 14279- 001-000 (B) Moved by Michelle Hazen Seconded by Vivan Filer Recommendation: Staff recommends that application COA26- 000-026 be deferred to the following Board meeting, so that the following can be addressed: 1. An overall street elevation (sketch) should be provided to show the three properties together, including the neighboring structures, so that a proper analysis of street and building rhythm and scale can be made. 2. A site plan that shows the three buildings together, with the proposed ADUs, and showing the existing buildings to the rear of these lots, so that a proper analysis can be done of how the new buildings will relate to surrounding existing buildings. 3. If ADU’s are a part of this proposal, the design of the ADU should be submitted with the application for the main structure. 4. House B needs improvements made to the roof shape, front window placement and sizes, and siding configuration to be consistent on all four elevations. Board and batten is preferred for House B, with a beltcourse to separate floors. 5. Dimensions need to be added for the front porch. 6. Material notes should be added to the actual elevation sheet, especially for siding, roof, and window material. Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000- 027, in order for the architect to continue working on the drawings and to consider comments made by adjoining residents and the HP Board. Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson Approved (9 to 0) d. 2026-274 COA-26-000-027 New Construction Parcel 14250-001- 000 (B) 5 Moved by Elizabeth Hauck Seconded by Vivan Filer Recommendation: Staff recommends that application COA26- 000-027 be deferred to the following Board meeting, so that the following can be addressed: 1. An overall street elevation (sketch) should be provided to show the three properties together, including the neighboring structures, so that a proper analysis of street and building rhythm and scale can be made. 2. A site plan that shows the three buildings together, with the proposed ADUs, and showing the existing buildings to the rear of these lots, so that a proper analysis can be done of how the new buildings will relate to surrounding existing buildings. 3. If ADU’s are a part of this proposal, the design of the ADU should be submitted with the application for the main structure. 4. House C needs improvements made to the front window placement and sizes. 5. Dimensions need to be added for the front porch. 6. Material notes should be added to the actual elevation sheet, especially for siding, roof, and window material. Motion to defer all three new construction applications, including COA-26-000-025, COA26-000-026, and COA 26-000- 027, in order for the architect to continue working on the drawings and to consider comments made by adjoining residents and the HP Board. Aye (9): Anthony Ackrill, Trey Asner, Vivan Filer, Elizabeth Hauck, Michelle Hazen, James Reeves, Nigel Rudolph, Bill Warinner, and George Wilson Approved (9 to 0) F. OTHER BOARD BUSINESS 1. 2026-275 Oakview Properties to be Demolished (B) The Board was concerned about the application to change the zoning and wants to be kept in the loop whenever the Planning staff completes their analysis. The Historic Preservation Officer will be releasing the 90-day demolition hold, but the HP Board wants comments added to the demolition permits: “because of the proximity of these parcels to the historic Bailey Plantation, there are likely subsurface artifacts from the 6 Bailey Plantation era, and that a 1st Phase Cultural Resource Survey should be considered during any future ground-disturbing activities.” Recommendation: This item was informational only for the Board. G. STAFF UPDATES The 5th Annual Historic Preservation Awards ceremony will take place at the Matheson History Museum, on Wednesday, May 20. Reception at 5:30 p.m., program at 6:00 p.m. H. NEXT MEETING DATE - May 5, 2026 I. ADJOURNMENT - 8:49 p.m.

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

3 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 3 of 3

Browse by category3 actions
  • Agenda item C1Other meeting itemsapproved

    The board unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting.

    Approval of March 3, 2026 Minutes

  • Agenda item E4aOther meeting itemsapproved

    The board deferred the application at the request of the applicant to allow time to find a design solution acceptable to the board.

    COA-26-000-032 (1024 NE 4th Street)

  • Agenda item E4b, c, dLand useapproved

    The board deferred three new construction applications to allow the architect to address concerns regarding building scale, roof shapes, porch design, and site planning, and to incorporate feedback from neighbors.

    New Construction Applications (COA-26-000-025, 026, 027)

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Historic Preservation Board — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: da74ec01375133299713b558701eb263. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record