POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Jul 8, 2025 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, July 8, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Jul 8, 2025 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 72,479 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Good afternoon. I think it's time to call this to order. And with that, I am Russ Wynnum and I will turn it over to our clerk to do a roll call. >>[CALLING ROLL] >> Thank you. And I'll open by just reminding anyone in the audience that wishes to address the commission on an item on the agenda or a non agendized item during that period of time. There are blue speaker cards in the back. Feel free to complete one as best you can, hand it to one of these clerks up front here, and then they will slip them to me when the time comes so that we can call you and have you come to the lectern for addressing the commission. The next item on the agenda is approval of minutes. And we have two sets of minutes to consider. I'd like to break it into two separate pieces. The first one would be May 13, 2025. And I'm doing that because there are different groups of people that may participate in the vote. So May 13, 2025, looks like everybody is here and Luke Minor or Michelle is gone. So I will just say let's look at the first set, which was May 13, 2025. Is there any discussion or a motion? >> Mr. Chairman, I'll move approval of the minutes of May 13. >> I'll second. >> Is there any further discussion or comments? Seeing none. All in favor? >> Aye. >> Very good. Thank you. And then what I would like to do, assuming it's within my appropriate authority, would be to request that the next item be moved to the next agenda. Because if we don't do that, we will only have 3 commissioners that participated that will be here. So hopefully next time for the minutes that are on June 10, we will have 4 commissioners and have an appropriate majority. So is that all right? We'll go with a concurrence. I'm sure that's a concurrence item, right? I'm not sure, but I'm making that statement. >> It would be. I mean, this is not an action. In the sense that you're taking action on a project. Just continuing. >> Thank you very much. And before I go any further, I should actually turn to because we forget this oftentimes. Would staff introduce yourself so that we for the audience knows who's here. Thank you. >> I'm Gretchen Storr. I'm the assistant city attorney. >> Thank you. >> Josh Anthony, Assistant Public Works Director. >> Jeremy Pagan, director of Development Services. >> Lily Toy, Planning Manager of Planning Division. >> Very good. >> And we have our Senior Planner, David Schlegel in the audience who will be presenting on an item later today. >> Thank you. And the two people that really run the show down here. >> Jennifer Gannon, meeting clerk. >> Elizabeth Steadman, Administrative assistant. >> Thank you very much. So are there any announcements that need to be made at this time? Item number 3. >> None from staff at this time, Chair. >> Okay, moving on to item number 4, Planning commission items. The first one is the consent calendar. We don't have consent items. So we'll move on to Item 4B. Public hearings. In fact, 4B1: Use Permit Application UP-2023-01684, by Casa Park Homes, to expand a mobile home park. And I see Ms. Toy moving up to the lectern. And what I will do before we do that is disclose that I don't even know if it's the same owners at this point, but more than 10 years ago, I did some consulting work for a mobile home expansion at this exact same physical location and have done consulting work for both adjacent developments that are either impacted or involved. But that was a long, long time ago and certainly haven't been involved in anything a long time. So I will remain in my chair. With that, I will turn it over to Ms. Toy. >> Thank you very much, Chair. Good afternoon, commissioners. This item before you is a use permit for an expansion of an existing mobile home park. Before I go into the project itself, I just want to say I don't give any credit to myself for processing this permit to get it to here. It was our assistant planner, Drew Morgan, that worked on this. We let him go on vacation. So I decided to step up and kind of take the limelight. But I'm giving him credit for all the work. So with that, this site is at 11037 Erickson Way. It is located just southeast of the intersection of Lake and 273 Market Street. And it's off of a small street just on the south side of Lake called Erickson Way. Existing zoning is RM9, which is residential multiple family, nine units per acre. And it is general planned residential six to ten units per acre. So existing. The site contains 16 and a half acres. Five and a half of it is developed with mobile home, the existing 47 units. Currently, this was granted back in the 80s in the county. And so when it was annexed, it's remained as is pretty much since then. About 15 years ago, new owner took over. He's been making some improvements to the site, repaving the driveways, things like that. And as tenants have vacated, he's replaced the older units with newer units. And so today what's before you is an expansion of an area to the north west where they are proposing to expand the facility by 24 units. So Blue arrow shows the access point to the facility off Erickson way. And this highlighted yellow area is the area of additional units will consume. Looking at the site plan, we have 24 units highlighted in yellow. They're proposing a community area which is required by code for multiple family type developments. And there will be additional guest parking put in as part of this development which is required under our off street parking standards and also RV parking area to the very northwest site of this additional area. What was came to light is that under our general plan policies if we are to expand any type of multiple family beyond 50 units, fire was concerned about an emergency access to this development and what is being required is an emergency access road to the West. The parcel that you see that's highlighted where this access road will connect to is owned by Hilltop Springs, the residential living facility just located to the West. And the access road will be paved according to fire standards. All weather surface which will connect to the Woodcliff Drive and that is conditioned as part of the permit as draft condition. The easement will be required to be obtained before building permit or any grading permit is issued. The proposed density for this with the 24 additional units is 7.6 units. So it's consistent with the 6 to 10 units per acre of the general plan site. The site does have some slopes constraint, but that's not the part area that they are developing. They're adding amenities as I have pointed out. And so in conclusion, the proposal does is in character with the community and respecting neighborhood and in character with promoting compatibility with regards to CEQA. We did have a biological report done. There's no special status plants identified. There's no conditions required for migratory birds which is state federal guidelines. And so hence there is a buffer around any nest or maternity colony required during in season. And it does fulfill the criteria for infill development under CEQA under 15,332. So you'll find in your packet the findings are required for those infill development criteria. So it's consistent with the city's general plan goals and policies. And hence we recommend that the planning commission make the findings and approve the project subject to the conditions of approval presented to you. I am available to answer any questions at this time. >> Thank you, Ms. Toy. Questions or initial comments from commissioners? >> You kind of said you skipped over it. I just want to hear you new owners owned the property for 15 years. >> That's correct. >> Cuz when I went through there it. I think I counted three that looked updated in the current park and that may be the case. It just seems like more than three people in 15 years would have moved out of the park if he was updating those mobile homes. >> We don't control any of that. However, I do want to state that what I didn't go over and was probably in your staff report is that HCD, the State Housing Community development is charged with the operation of it. >> Yeah. >> They go through the state for everything other than the land use entitlement. >> Right. That was just a comment that I observed when I went out there. And have they talked to the adjacent property owner, the Springs, and what's the likelihood that they would give access? >> Yes, they have. And we've gotten a email from Hilltop Springs owners and saying that they are open to offering easement to them. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. Any other questions of staff before we go to public hearing? Okay, thank you. What we will do next is open the public hearing. Again, at this point I have one blue speaker card. If someone else wishes to speak, we would ask you to complete a card and bring it up here to one of the clerks. And so with the public hearing open, I will call upon Linda Cheatham to come up to either one of the lecterns, whatever you're most comfortable with, and address the commission and you will be given three minutes to make your comments. >> Good evening. I don't have a lot of questions because I live in the Woodcliff Estates area and not in the mobile home park. >> I'm sorry, excuse me. Do me a favor, get a little closer to the microphone. Thank you so much. >> That's better. Okay, thank you. >> My little disclaimer about the hearings going. Thank you. >> Okay, so I live like right behind the mobile home park, just on Woodcliff. One of my concerns is that are you going to be opening up the end of Woodcliffe for traffic to come down there out of the mobile home park because we were promised that that was going to be opened years ago and it's still closed off. So we don't have anything. But through Pepper Tree if we have an emergency in our neighborhood. So that's one of my questions. And I think I know now where they're going to be putting the new lots because that wasn't in the pamphlet. So do you discuss that now or do you do that later? The egress? >> Yeah. What I'd like to do is get comments from public and then I'm confident that we're going to be able to turn to staff and have them answer that question. I wrote it down. And then if there's any other further clarifications needed, they will call you up. Is that all right with you? >> Thank you. >> Very good. Thank you very much. The next card that I have is from Noah Starkson. So Noah. >> Hello, my name is Noah Starkson. I live on Woodcliff Drive, which is just south of this and our properties border on some of this. And I wanted to draw attention to some concerns I have and I think discrepancies because with what I just heard, 24 units being proposed, all of which on the northwest side. But this plan shows our highlighted 20. But we didn't talk at all about the four units on the south side which would be directly adjacent to the properties of me and my neighbors. That was a little concerning to not hear that addressed at all in this. That's where there's a large hill and grading needing to be done on this picture here. You see the line at the bottom is the property line. So they will have to put a pretty steep embankment or retaining wall right up against property line and fences. With that, I mean there comes some obvious concerns. I bought the house about four years ago knowing we have this beautiful open space right behind us. Now seeing some development added, even if it's in that area puts it right up against is a little concerning especially for our property values in the future. The one of the other concerns in the environmental impact or the I forgot what it was called. But as they looked at bats specifically it located like these three spots is where we decided to is where we were looking for bats, everything. None of them were on the south side. They were all on the north side. And I know for me personally I can go out on my deck any night and hear and see bats any night I go out there. So it felt like this plan may have been done or the responses and how the city is looking at planning for this does it doesn't reflect that southern portion that was in the plans that we see here. I'm not sure why it's not highlighted. But even if as I looked in, as I counted as we're talking here. That's 20 up top, not the 24 that's being proposed here. >> Make sure I hit everything. >> The other concerns are just around the oak trees especially. And again my concerns are not on the northern addition up there it's all this southern section. In those it's only four units being added. But the oak trees are going to have to get taken down there as well as a number of oak trees right up against that. If we're putting a retaining wall or a big embankment, that's going to affect those oak trees in a lot of ways. And so that was my other concern. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. Sorry about that. I always have to make notes or else it goes away. So with that I will see no other speaker cards. I'll close the public hearing, bring it back for commissioners to ask questions of staff and get clarifications first. I'll go ahead and hit the things that I wrote down that I heard. And the first one was opening or vehicular access Woodcliff to the South. Staff, are you able to bring up a. Go back to one of the previous exhibits and address that question. I know you guys are analyzing but I think simply put the question is was there consideration for requiring or providing access to Woodcliff to the South. >> Does everybody know what spot we're looking at? Okay. Where the two roads come together. The current future or current Woodcliff call it a knuckle in the transportation world. So the Springs facility was a multi phase project or is that still hasn't built their second phase. As part of that they have to construct their sewer line that goes down Woodcliff and then connects to the sewer that is in current Woodcliff Drive. It's part of the Pepper Tree subdivision. When doing that they were not conditioned to build the road. However, the city has. We have put street stallers to a project that is currently in the early design phases. So the city will actually construct that road when the developer builds the sewer line. Current time frame is not. We don't you know it's under development but figure the next couple of years. We should have that project delivered. >> To clarify what we see is part of a road easterly of the Springs. >> Correct. >> Would be extended southerly to tie into Woodcliff. >> Correct. And the city has already obtained the necessary right of way in that area. >> Okay. Anyone have any further questions on that item. So not a requirement of this development, but the city's working on a project to do so. >> Yes. >> Thank you. >> And the access road would stay because you still need it. It doesn't connect to. That's how you connect to Woodcliffe. >> Correct. >> Okay. >> Very good. Thank you. And then the next one was addressing, I think to break it up into separate questions. The number of units and did you inadvertently omit the discussion of the four proposed units along the southerly side of the development? >> I did, inadvertently. And let me point to you up here where those units will be. Right here. >> Yes. Thank you. Okay, so I think that there's concurrence with the commenter that there was a whoops there by staff and that there are four more units than what was original in the original presentation. And then there was a comment about being able to hear bats and was that considered? And I'm just wondering if that is addressed in that there are standard conditions of approval in all likelihood coming that'll say you can only remove trees in the non maternal, etc. season. I won't get my terms right. And if you don't do that, you have to send a biologist out there and verify that there are not any nesting bats before you remove oaks. >> That's great. That's all federally protected, so it is a standard condition. So if it's during bat nesting season, obviously, you know, they need to do surveys and things like that. And if they are found, then they've got to follow protocol as to when they can construct and how they, you know, maybe the bats and birds need to fledge before construction starts. >> Yeah. And as I recall, if it's before fledging, there are ways to scare them away, let them nest somewhere else. But once they've truly nested, then you work around them. >> That's correct. >> And you delay your construction or set buffer zones or things like that. Is that correct? >> That's correct. >> Okay, so are there any other questions from commissioners about the. That question or comment from public? Okay. Seeing none. And then oak tree removal along that same side, which what I will comment on is I don't see. And maybe it exists somewhere else. A preliminary landscaping plan. Will there be. I guess my question is, will there be some tree planting required along that side? Because the commenter talked about an embankment or a retaining wall. The preliminary design clearly shows an embankment. If in my bifocals I counted contours, maybe that's six feet vertically and there'll be an embankment. And will there have to be some tree planting along that side to offset the removal or is that not included? >> I am looking on page. >> I'm sorry, you say 35? Thank you. >> And if we're looking at what they're calling the C2.1, I am looking at the architectural plan area two at the very bottom and proposed. You can see the depth of that grading is about 40ft from the existing Park Road at the deepest and down 33 farthest to the East. And I see proposed 15 gallon trees in the front of the units, but none are proposed on the back. Probably because it's too steep. Typically it's not recommended to plant trees and steep slopes. >> I see what you're getting at. It might be circle note number 9 typically pointing to 4 trees along the front of the units. And then would it be accurate to say I'm not? Of course we might have to cross reference to the tree survey. But it's only showing one tree over existing tree over there in the corner. And Ariel suggests there's more trees. So the mapping here does not show the trees that are getting removed. Is that just for accuracy? I'm not offering commentary yet. >> Yeah. From what I could tell, it looks like three to four existing trees that will be removed. >> Yeah. Okay. I'm seeing the same thing. Okay. So at least I think it's clarified what's proposed at this point, what's in, what's out. Are there any further comments that will clarify that before we go into further commission comments? Okay, with that I'll turn to commissioners. Thank you. To the staff there. Any questions of staff or comments amongst ourselves? Please go ahead, Commissioner. >> Mine are just comments. So I know that in reading NPA is responsible for mobile homes parks, but other cities have taken that over. Has that ever been a consideration for you guys? Not that I'm aware of because I'm not sure how much MPA really comes and does their job where I feel like the city taking ownership of that would do a better job. So that's comment 1. And then I would just like to suggest for condition 18 where the common area that they do something more than just a fire pit, that they could really use some sprucing up to that mobile home park. So I would like to see something more extensive than some of the suggested items. Those are my comments. >> I'd like to add to that I visited the park the other day and I would concur that it needs some upgrading and if they're going to expand into a recreation area that it needs to be more specific than what we've got in front of us today. That's on condition 18. >> Commissioner Nance, Commissioner Ryan, >> The same idea. >> Yep, same. Just a question on the four houses or the proposed sites? Excuse me. On the South side, the 15 foot setback I'm reading on that packet, page 35, it is that setback, is that for these new pads or is that for the homes off of Woodcliff? Like what is that setback? >> That is a required minimum setback that they're showing. >> Right. >> Yep. And they are sending it back looks like almost twice as far. >> Okay, gotcha. And then with these proposed sites on the south side, are there. Are they gonna have to. Do they have to dig Plumbing, gas? >> Yes. All permanent utilities. >> And where does that tie into? Is it on the street? Is it in the mobile home park? Or where's all that trenching going to happen? >> That's not being provided in the details here but logic has it that they're going to extend it through the existing park road on the North side. So just tie into that. >> Yeah. >> Okay. And then the other question is that pond on the East side. I read the environmental report and it was mentioned that they, I think mallards like were resting in there, but there wasn't a lot of. I mean environmental impact report. You have a pond right there and there was. They didn't really park. >> Right. >> Ericson pond. >> Yes. >> Yeah. I'm just curious why the environmental impact report was just for this site, but then you have a water, you have a water source there. They didn't really even talk about how that was going to be impacted. >> Right. It's on a separate piece of property, not even owned by the property owner. >> I understand that 100. >> It's just they cannot impact it. They can't inspect it, they can't comment on it. >> Right. >> Any storm water has to stay on their site. >> Yeah. >> It cannot drain into that pond. >> Is that recreational or like who owns that, that water? >> It's private property. >> Yeah. >> It's been there for a long, long time. >> I'm sure it has. Yeah. Okay. And then this road that has this. What do we call the road that's going to be. That's going to hit the Woodcliff easement is that we're calling emergency access. >> Emergency access road. Yeah. >> So that's just going to be just the paved road. Is there going to be a gate that controls that or are residents going to be able to use that to go in and out or. >> No, it's only for emergency purposes only. They call it a Knox box where emergency vehicles have access with a remote and they can open that gate. >> Gotcha. >> Okay. >> That's all my questions. Thank you. >> Okay. Anything else before we circle back to. I think we had two comments that were specific to considering maybe a condition modification, but I would, I think it'd be appropriate to say any feedback on that from staff? The staff worked with the applicant for quite some time to get to this point. >> Yes, I just want to. I'm looking at condition 18 right now. It's very open ended. It's not requiring them to do anything one particular, but it looks like we could probably ask for something more finite. It says this area could include children's play area, swimming pool and or community room barbecue area with shade elements, turf play areas or similar improvements. Final plans to be reviewed and approved. But it's at the developer's final choice, it says. >> Yeah. My preference, just as one person would be hearing comments from commissioners would be for staff to propose perhaps a way to modify that condition that's a little better than us trying to do it from our, from our rockers to give it a little more specificity that will result in a little, you know, a little higher likelihood of some quality. >> Well, you know, this is just from my experience. We've approved some multiple family developments in, you know, the recent past. They've done things like a half basketball court and a small community room that is. I'm thinking of Altruist Crossing, which is the one over on Browning. K2 built that. I don't know if we want to go to that extent here. I would recommend shade element because people want to go outside, barbecue or a play area, something like that to that extent. All they're showing right now on the plan is a patio. Concrete patio. >> Yes, please, Commissioner. >> Exactly. That was my concern is it's all the way in the front of the, the project and it's tiny. I know when we did Linden Apartments, they did a playground in the center of it. And it just, I worry that that's going to be just an awning and maybe a barbecue for everyone to use there. And I would like to see something more than that. So your suggestion? I, I don't mind the shade, but if we could add like then turf. So there's a turf area there. But going back to the drawings, it doesn't look like it's going to be much more than a little awning. Of course. >> Yeah, we'll get a set of final plans. >> So we won't look at building plans for this project. That'll happen through hcd, but public works, we'll be looking at a set of grading plans. A final set of grading plans which will incorporate this element. So the condition as written is pretty open ended, which would allow us at the staff level to approve. But if this body wants something more specific, I would suggest the condition 18. We'd have to take away some of that open endedness so that upon plan review, when we review this final set of plans, we have something to judge it against. >> Yeah. >> Condition 18 ends with the owner's discretion, so I would like to at least throw that back to Citi's discretion. >> Are you saying the last. The developer's final choice and plans for common shall be provided with final plan review. >> Yes. But does that still give you. >> It doesn't mean we have to accept that at plan review. Okay. >> It gives you a chance to. >> Yeah, but it does help staff. You know, Lily can correct me if I'm wrong, but I mean generally the more open ended a condition is, the more flexibility we have during final plan review. But also that can be good and bad. >> Right. >> So if this body wants something a little more ironclad and that condition to be a little more objective and straightforward, that would help us at plan review. >> Well, my suggestion is taking off the barbecue part. That it needs to be something more than just a community grill. That's my suggestion. >> So I think perhaps I suggest the second to last sentence to replace it with. Instead of saying this may include, we should say this should minimally shall minimally include a turf area, shade element and a barbecue area. >> I would love that. I'm not saying we should demand that of the developer. I'm more just wanting to remove the. That they could barbecue area stands by itself and then it says and shade. So if we could just get rid of the barbecue line that says barbecue area. Just take that out, I'd be happy. >> Is that code? >> If I'm understanding you, Commissioner, it's because you're reading this and or a community room and or a barbecue area with a shade element. That's how you're reading. Grammar's tricky as we argue over commas or nots. >> Then at the very end it also says or similar improvements. >> Yes, you can go. >> Just give me a minute. I'm looking at the code section. In particular, the reference zoning code. Let's see here. 1831, 30C. Lily, do you know if that's is it, Is this specifically codified or what does this body have the purview to change? >> It is codified. >> Give us a second. I don't know why we are interesting to see Cross checking with the. >> So I'm just grabbing our zoning code here. It says common outdoor activity areas typically consist of landscape areas, walks, patios, swimming pools, barbecue areas, shade elements, playgrounds, turf or other such improvements as are appropriate to enhance the outdoor environment of the development. that's what our code says. The condition doesn't read exactly in that manner, but it does offer some flexibility and mentioned some of those elements. So I would say it's the purview of this body to. If we want to make that condition more objective and clear and perhaps narrower in scope, that would be your prerogative. >> How much area is this? No, I can see it on the thing, but what is that? How much space is that? >> The code requires a minimum of 80 square feet. So it's at minimum that. But likely. I don't have a scale with me, but it's probably a little bit bigger. >> Half the size of a single wide mobile, pretty much. >> No swimming pool? >> No. >> Yeah. >> Keynote. Is it Keynote 8. Is that right? >> Yeah. >> Right. >> So not to mention. But I suppose this body can assume it's at minimum what the code requires. 80 square feet, which isn't a whole lot. >> So I did hear Commissioner Willems say that perhaps she might make a motion that just strikes barbecue area. Which wouldn't prevent that from being included. >> No, not at all. >> But it prevents it from being just a barbecue, as our grammarian in the group from saying, no, it's just a barbecue area. And I say that tongue in cheek because now you're over my head. >> Yeah, no, I would be. I would like to make a motion just to remove the barbecue portion. >> Yeah. When we're ready. >> Yeah. >> So I think we're probably there. >> Let's have a couple. >> Commissioner Nash? Yes? >> Just a question. So the RV parking, the five spaces, I think it's number 5 in this five. So the recreational parking for recreational vehicles that's just unattended on. People just park their RVs there. They're not. The owner's not renting out those spaces. There's not hookups there. >> Yes, it's only for parking. They don't have storage. >> And that's regulated and that's correct. >> All that rented to you and I, if we have an RV and nowhere to park it. >> Yeah. And then just an opinion from staff. So those just kind of going back to those four spaces on the south side, just really been. You know, when I first look at this, when I got the packet, it just, it seems just really tight in there. And I did, you know, consider looking at the contour lines and all of that. And I don't know that just like in your opinion, because there's a lot of grading that's going to have to happen right. On these people's property line. And you're kind of just. They're kind of just stacking them in there on the north side. It seems like open space and they can do what they're asking to do. But to squeeze in these four spaces here, that just seems really tight overall. So, you know, you're in the business of, you know, looking at grading and moving earth and all that. Do you think it's even doable? And it's tight. It is right there on the line. >> Yeah. Well, they would, you know, certainly the codes all. And standards will all apply. Right. So they'll have to meet our grading ordinance and do it properly. They'll have to meet our setbacks, as Ms. Toy described. They're meeting in general plan conformance and density. So we're not allowing these units to exceed max density for this zoning district. Right. So, you know, yes, it can be done. You know, the engineer can it. But they will have to follow the codes and standards per what I just outlined. So we're not allowing, as far as I'm aware, any kind of variance to our codes. Any sort of narrower setbacks, any sort of exceptions will have to meet the same development standards anyone else would in the city. So if the property can fit it and they can meet all of our codes and standards, then, you know, we'd have. This body would have to make a finding that would that allow us to deny those 4 units. And I'm not sure where that finding would come from here off the top of my head, just some initial thoughts in response to your question, Commissioner Nance. But when we do get final improvement plans, the public works team will review and make sure that the grading is to standard and meets codes and regulations. And we'll plan, check it to setbacks and the like. It'll meet all pertinent development regulations. >> Okay, thank you. With that, I'd like to make one comment and then I was going to call for a motion and my comment is, the thing that came through for me on this project is, you know, East coast development in the US we had tiny homes and they meant a lot of different things. A lot of them were ADUs, a lot of them were converted basements, they were garages and backyards we developed in California and we did away with all that with our big, bigger, bigger, bigger, our different zoning theories. Yet we filled the niche of providing what I would call old school tiny homes by having mobile home parks and trailer parks. And over several decades ago, that fell out of favor for a lot of good reasons. But I would contend for a lot of reasons that are not good for our society. And so for years, my personal opinion is as we've been branding, you don't hear as much about it now, but we did a few years ago. This, this tiny home is a new thing. And I would look at everybody and say, no, it isn't. That's a trailer park. And a trailer park is a wonderful niche housing solution comes with some challenges, especially for fire and law enforcement and social services. I'm not discounting that. But we need more options for housing that are affordable. And again, full disclosure, I put my way through college living in a trailer park. My first home out of out of college was a single wide mobile home. Because of what was affordable for me and my family. It was a beautiful way to live. So I'm all in favor of it, quite frankly. And with that said, I'm hoping Commissioner Willem is ready to offer a motion that supports staff recommendation with striking two words out of condition 18, if that's what you said. >> So I'll make a motion to approve use permit application up 2023-01684 by CASA Park Homes to expand existing 47 unit unit mobile home park by 24 units on property located at 1137 Ericson Way in an RM residential multiple family nine unit per acre district with the condition 18 change to remove barbecue. >> And is there a second? >> I'll second the motion. >> We have a second. Any discussion or comments from staff before? >> Just to clarify, that's just removing the word barbecue or barbecue area with shade elements or just to be specific area. >> Just barbecue area. I would love the shade element, but barbecue area. >> Okay, thank you. >> Any other questions or comments before I call for a vote? All in favor say aye. >> Aye. >> Any opposed? Motion carries. Thank you. Thank you for everybody for your patience on that one. As we worked through that item. The next item on the agenda and I will do the blue card reminder for anybody that may wish to speak on the next item. And the next item is 4B2. Coming back again, standard conditions of approval for the City Redding. I believe we have Mr. Schlegel working his way up to the lectern. I will turn it over to you, sir. >> All right, thank you. Chair, Commissioners, members of the public, my name is David Schlegel, Senior Planner for the Planning Division. And bringing back to you today the standard subdivision conditions of approval update after getting direction to bring it back to local developers for workshop and some revisions. Just to reiterate, these are standard conditions that apply to all subdivisions in the city just to make sure that they're meeting city standards. They're current with our general plan policies, current with state laws, federal laws and the like which pertain to the development of subdivision. And a little bit more background on that. You know, we could simply cite our code, cite all the laws, and have some developer or somebody who may not develop that often go searching for that. But back in 2010 or even prior, the development community was finding that not to be ideal. And so the effort was made to create these standard conditions in one place. It's not going to maybe encompass everything that a subdivision might have to deal with for development, but the idea is that we're providing more streamlining and efficiency by keeping these all in one place, making sure developers are aware of what they're signing up for before they get their project entitled. And as time passes, there's reasons to update these standards. And as I talked about last time, this commission has the authority to make modifications under the subdivision ordinance. And some of those reasons are listed here. We have new adopted standards by the city since 2010, changes to city ordinances, changes to state law and policies over time, the recently Updated General Plan, 2045 EIR and all the policies in that journal plan and mitigation measures in the EIR. And one thing that probably didn't mention last time, but we have been made aware since adopting our General Plan, EIR is an option for CEQA streamlining with an exemption under Section 151A3, which actually mandates that projects that are consistent with city general plan densities be looked at for this exemption, essentially. And there's recent case law that directs cities and jurisdictions to do just that, making sure that if you have a newly adopted general planning IR and the project's consistent meets other qualifying factors, streamlining the project through not basically not doing the environmental review a second time, and making sure that there's no project specific effects which are peculiar to the project site or the project itself in doing so. Another criteria with using this streamlining exemption is making sure that environmental effects are limited to those that are identified in the initial study or other analysis. So every project that you're gonna see come forward as a subdivision is gonna have some type of an initial study or other analysis, whether it be there's something peculiar and we can't exempt it, or whether we're staff saying we think we could support the exemption because it's consistent with the general planning IR and things like that. So I just wanted to point this process out and one other key component of this is the general plan EIR mitigation measures, which we're recommending be incorporated into standard conditions. And then that if there's anything that can't be substantially mitigated through the general plan EIR, they'd be mitigated through uniformly applied development policies or standards. And that's obviously the more standard things you already see in our codes that do just that. The general plan EIR talks about those things in its analysis for the overall general plan for the city. Some of those things find their way before you today as these standard conditions are being recommended for amendment as policies and mitigation measures surrounding these topics here. Talked on this last time, and I kind of want to go fast here because we already talked about some of these changes. If you want to stop me, slow me down, please do. But yeah, talking about conditions that have been incorporated new and added onto the previous standard conditions that we had adopted in relation to our general plan update. There's wildfire air quality standard mitigation measures, biological resource impacts that the general planning EIR discusses that we want to make more standard. We've been applying them to projects as standard practice, but we figure we can find a way to make them actually standard and cultural and geologic resources. Some laws have changed over time and I'll touch on that in a little bit here. So what we did was with your recommendations. We went back to local developers and consultants with what we had drafted up and got a lot of good positive feedback. Sorry, going through hazardous materials and noise as well. Let's not discount those. And we had some recommendations and it was very productive and we very glad we have this opportunity to do that. One of the first changes you see in the packet is condition number nine, representing previously condition number nine and 13. We're recommending they be incorporated as one. Basically, there's a lot of redundancy between the two. And this makes it address all the concerns with essentially developing the site without fully having approved plans or an entitled project, for example. We did get a recommendation to change some language just before this meeting. And you see that under the text there that says condition number 9 and number 13 were combined. So we are recommending a change here for the record that the language where it says the developer must secure approval of subdivision improvement plans, add partial or full before that. The recommendation was that it be the appropriate improvement plans and strike subdivision from the record. However, working with Department of Public Works, that didn't make sense for us. So this is being recommended to you as a minor change to improve this condition number 9. Condition 15 was amended for clarity. This deals with drainage infrastructure and a lot of different rules and regulations involving that. But particularly city council policy 1806. We wanted to make sure it was clear how that policy was going to be applied to subdivisions in a standard way. This is an easy add, very good addition by the consultants to mention that water districts also care about irrigation water when it comes to subdivisions. As far as this public safety, fire condition, there's redundancy between 25 and 26. And we are recommending the that they be combined. And working with the fire marshal did not want to lose the language regarding easements and service for on lot hydrants or flag lots. So this is the recommended version. Reducing some conditions is good and making sure they're not redundant between one another. This was very positive for us. Condition number 21 is just adding some flexibility there at the end, just in case there's scenario where the city's paying for some portion of a project making, you know, having the old language didn't quite make sense. There might be some anomalies out there where this condition doesn't actually work. So we added some language for flexibility and this was reduced. Condition number 31 was reduced to just essentially remove language that's in the code. And the code's referenced there in chapter 1620. So we just removed a lot of the language that you can just go look up yourself. That was a good recommendation. Here we have, getting into the biological conditions, some good improvements to directly address. What we're trying to do for projects that would qualify is just to simply identify minimization measures that have been identified in a study in relation to the project and incorporating that into the project as a standard practice. We also wanted to reformat that section because there's a lot of subsections that deals with specific species or features. And in addition to that, referencing aquatic resources appropriately and removing the scenario of a ratio that we assume a resource agency would require of a project and just leaving it up to those resource agencies that have that authority. And I should point out here that the exhibit A is accurate. However, the strikethrough version in your packet doesn't reflect adequately that we're proposing to strike subsections A through D of former condition number 42. And that was because it was getting really into the weeds on what a resource agency might require of a project and really just want to defer to those agencies and making sure it's standard practice that the projects are in consultation with those agencies to do it the right way and get the proper permits. And this last one is has been reworked. Condition number 45 now has been split in two really because as we looked at it, there's different laws that categorize cultural and tribal cultural resources in two different ways. Public Resources Code section 21074 actually requires that consultation be done if tribal cultural resources identified by a tribe that has cultural affiliation to the site. And so that's also been incorporated into our general plan as a policy. And so we thought rather than combining the, the scenario where there could be cultural resources that aren't tribal cultural resources and tribal monitors and things like that, we split that off separately. And it doesn't have the full text here. So if you want me to reference that or read that, I can. But ultimately, what the second condition that's recommended here does is identify the proper methods to deal with findings, unanticipated findings of a cultural resource separate from an actual human remains of some kind. And so we wanted to make sure that was following step by step what the law says and consistent with our general plan as well. And I think we hopefully have something that you could consider for approval. Just want to point out that what you're doing today in potentially approving standard subversion conditions is not subject to CEQA can be seen with certainty that there's no possibility that updating these conditions would have a significant effect on the environment. In addition, any action taken to assure the maintenance and protection of the environment when applied to future projects is exempt from CEQA under section 15308 and hopefully covered everything. If not, I'm here for questions. At this time, staff's going to recommend that after carrying out a public hearing, this Commission approve the proposed standard subversion conditions of approval update as revised and adopt the Planning Commission resolution. With that, I'm happy to answer any questions. >> Thank you very much. I'll go ahead and ask my couple questions. First thing is I try to remember I have a note, but then I forgot. Just wanted to disclose. I did have conversations very briefly with Mr. Schlegel about this a couple days ago, a very brief conversation in preparation for this, as well as a conversation with Mr. Dormer, a consultant with Cher Dun Opsory. But those are the only outside of this setting conversations I had. I did then the next thing, I just wanted to be sure because we see that in the example project we just approved that the conditions end up getting presented in a different format than they're presented to us in that they are a checklist or there's checkboxes because that. That makes it easier to digest. As presented originally, I'm going to be the guy that will confess that I said, holy cow, the check boxes are going away because they weren't presented last time, but now I see that or I believe that they're actually going to be added. And so there's a whole bunch of things here that will only be applicable if staff determines they're applicable. Is that correct? >> Actually, no. For subdivisions we do not. So if we do bring back updates for use permit standard conditions, we would probably still have checklists in our practice. For subdivisions, it's not a checklist. However, I think the language is pretty much as applicable. You know, for instance, if a project has an environmental study that says do X, our standard condition is really just saying that you're going to do that essentially. >> Okay, thank you. And you anticipated why that makes my head hurt a little bit. And I see that you did make some changes there that clarifies that it's if something exists, then these things happen. Whereas what we saw last time didn't necessarily say that I think that was the intent. I'm going to let that go then and move on to my next item. And that is just for the benefit of all commissioners and public. What you said you pulled people together who participated in your little ad hoc study group. >> Yeah, I mean, we didn't have a large workshop. Sheridan Lapselage does a lot of subdivisions around here. Josh Johnson was there, got comments from yourself, Bruce Grove. And Josh Miller wasn't able to attend, but he is happy with the changes he mentioned to me. You know, if that's not enough, certainly not sure what else we could have done to get people there. But that was very productive for us. >> No, I appreciate that. I just think that it's good for everyone to know who was or wasn't. I was out of town and I probably caused a few eye rolls. I submitted written comments, but I submitted them in three different formats to make it easy. And that probably made it worse. But you guys have been very polite about that. Thank you. And then if I understood you correctly, there were two conditions, number 9 and number 42, that you said what we have in the package is not what you're proposing today. >> 9 should be. Correct. And I'm talking about the strikethrough version. I just realized before this meeting that it still shows subsections A through D of 42 as not being struck. >> Okay, thank you. Because we see it in three different presentations in the back, and the strike through version is not the one we should be looking at when we're making a decision on number 9. >> The final exhibit A is accurate for what we're meant. >> That's good. I'm going to be okay with that then but was there an anomaly in number 42? >> Well, no. Yeah, that is the anomaly is that subsections A through D and there's a last sentence in there that we referenced those subsections about to be read, recommending striking those. >> I think here you're saying that there are, I'll say, anomalies in the strikethrough version of the packet, but in the final black and white at the end, as we focus on that, it's as staff is recommending. >> Correct. >> Okay, good. And I said that because sometimes, rightfully so, you'll slip in a revision at the last minute, but you're not doing that. >> Well, we are asking for one minor revision to condition number 9. >> Yeah, sorry. >> Okay, then I didn't ask my question. Very well, then. So when I get to the black and white number 9, you're actually proposing something different. >> Yes. >> Okay. Sorry about that. >> That's probably important since we don't have a piece of paper on that. Is that correct? >> No, I can get you to the slide. >> Okay, very good. Thank you. You're seeing more and more of my neuroses of how I track things. >> Yeah. So just above the cutout for condition number nine, the language reads as we would propose it. So continuing the sentence where it says, prior to the start of any clearing, grading or any construction activities, the developer must secure approval of partial or full subdivision improvement plans that are consistent with the city's adopted construction standards, grading ordinance and other applicable regulations for grading. Yeah. We worked with the Department of Public Works to take the recommendation from the consultant to make something that would work for, I think, both parties. >> I'm not saying this is what's going to happen necessarily. But presuppose commissioners, they haven't spoken yet, but that can be dealt with by approving as presented with the change articulated by you in the presentation for number 9. Something like that is a way to wrap that up without having to worry about the wording beyond that. At least I understand where we are and that's all that I have at this point. So again, at this asking for clarifications of staff stage before we open the public hearing. Anyone else have clarifications? Thank you. >> Thank you for the presentation. Much better this time. Very easier to read. Can you go back to the CEQA slide at the start of the presentation? >> Yeah. Reading this section or so is this. >> Oh, sorry, that one. The CEQA go forward right there. Is this consistent with the new law that just took effect July 1st for CEQA? >> You know, actually, I haven't checked to see if this section has any amendments to it, but in reading, the digest of what's coming. >> Yeah. Well, I know that the infill map isn't going to be produced by the state of California until 2027. So until then, I understand it's the discrepancy of the developer in the city to get to those standards. So I was just wondering if there would be guidelines for that until they get that map in place. >> I'm sure there will be guidelines. One interesting thing is that the infill exemption that we normally use, I don't see any changes to that. So it's kind of a separate infill section of CEQA. Yeah. I mean, it's interesting. >> Yes. Well, I just wondered if it's going to apply to very specific areas. >> Since we're redoing it, it looks like it's through 2045 if it needed to be addressed. It just seems like a pretty large change. I'm just asking because that's your expertise. I'm just asking if it would affect that. >> I don't know if staff has really any like, formulated comments on it other than we've looked at it. And I think a lot of the infill policies that are coming are consistent with the general plan to that extent. >> Any other Commissioner? Bakovy, go ahead, please. >> So what was the catalyst to even revamp this policy? Because it looks like 2010. Like, what was the driving force who started the conversation? Why are we changing this? >> Yeah. I would say it started as a recommendation from consultants on helping us complete our general plan eir. And we were made aware of case law that said we shall actually look at exemptions like this for projects consistent with the general plan EIR and we realized that we're going to need to update our standards just to reflect policies that have been adopted in that new general plan. >> So that opened the books, right? The EIR opened the books, and then the books are open, like. Well, let's change a couple more things. >> Yes, exactly. We started looking at other things that have been changed since that time and which consultant was the one that. >> What was the spark or the driving force? Are they part of the. Were they part of the revision of this? >> We worked with PlaceWorks out of Sacramento. >> Is that a city? >> We contracted with a planning firm, planning consultant, environmental consultant to do CEQA. They did the EIR portion of the general plan, and they were paid for that work. And that work's now completed. >> But part of that. Out of that work, did they said, oh, you need to update this subdivision plan. >> Yeah. >> Kent Manual. And one of the principals with placeworks were having a discussion as that project came to a close. And you said, hey, you know, now that you have a new general plan air, it really makes sense to go back and update your standard subdivision conditions of approval. So the two match. >> Gotcha. Yeah. Okay, great. >> So it was a recommendation from that consultant. But it's also good planning practice. Now we have this nice new. I mean, our old General Plan was 20 to 25 years old. So upon adoption of that document, it made sense to now go back and do some cleanup and that's what this is. >> Okay, great. And just to piggyback on what the chair was asking, like the participants of this workshop, can you just say it's slower? You said Josh Johnson, who was the other ones that were part of this two folks from? >> Chair Dunlop Sawyer, Tim McLean, Mike Dormer. We had emails with Bruce Grove and Josh Miller. So, okay. No specific parts of this plan. >> I'm sorry. So, I mean, just full transparency. You've got developers saying, hey, the books are open. Let's change this and change that and it seems like it needed to be changed. It's just. I'm just a little concerned, that's all that you've got developer, local developers, like, actually writing public policy. I wouldn't care that we're gonna that way. >> Well, I mean, this is policy. But staff is recommending it because we agree that it's consistent with standards and laws. >> I agree. I'm just saying it's just the, you know, like, I mean, were there any commissioners other than the chair. Chair said he answered some questions regarding some of these things? >> No. In fact, everybody you saw the last time, May 13, who came up and spoke, I think maybe one didn't speak as Bruce Grove. >> Sure, they were there. >> And so it was working with them. >> Okay, and when you developed, like, when was the workshop? >> I would say it was probably three weeks after that planning commission hearing. I don't have the exact date. >> And is that just common practice? >> Well, in fact, the subdivision ordinance directs staff to work with the development community on these standard conditions. >> Okay. And do you work with the same developers or do you spread the wealth? You ask other developers to come in? >> I think it was a completely different contingent of developers when we did this in 2010. >> Okay. >> Yeah. >> Just trying to educate because I know people, like, pay attention to this stuff. I mean, I think you wanted to say something. >> Commissioner, I thought you were saying something, making a comment or something like that. Just trying to understand the transparency of this. So making sure that, you know. >> Yeah, I mean, we sent it to some additional developers and consultants didn't hear anything. >> Okay. >> Also ask that the developers who were on the email chain share it. But beyond that, that's the extent of the workshop. >> Okay. >> Okay, great. >> Yeah, I just had one on number 30. Can we go to that one real quick, please? So it says in the event. Now, I'm just going to the checklist one right here. So it says, in the event of any confusion, conflict, vagueness, typographical error, special circumstance for implementation of any standard or project specific condition is in question, Development services director has the authority, in accordance with that section to determine the appropriate remedy as necessary to ensure that the intent of the condition. So can you just. I mean, I've read it, but I'd just like to hear your explanation of that, like, confusion. Like, what does that look like? I guess it would look like what. >> This commission feels comfortable with that language saying. >> I mean, does the city attorney review it? Is there? You know, it's just very vague. I mean, it actually says vagueness in there. So it's just one person has, like, complete power to just make a decision based off of any of that. I'm sorry. >> That's how it works. >> If I may. I can let you know, this is basically every day of our plans. A lot of times we have to revisit that condition, and we generally do have some debate on what did this condition actually mean and how is this supposed to be interpreted. So there has to be someone to make that call. Now, the code, the subdivision ordinance, as well as our zoning ordinance, if there's a disagreement and an interpretation of that code, there is checks and balances. Also, is the ability to appeal and bring it back to the Board of Administrative Review or back to this body. And so maybe I'd like to think I have a lot of power, but generally I really don't. There's bodies above me where that appeal process can happen, happen. So it's just meant to say, well, someone has to make the call, the first call. If there's a disagreement later on after the project's entitled, and now we're starting to put plans together, someone's got to make the determination at staff level. >> Yeah, And I heard some comments from the commissioners. That's just how it's done. But have you ever seen litigation come out of that based off a decision that you've made or somebody else has made that then cost the city money? Because there is. You know, they don't agree with it and there's a lot of money at stake here. >> I mean, in my time in the City, I haven't seen that. Certainly it can happen. I mean, certainly people will threat litigation. >> Sure. >> But generally, no, we revisit conditions upon. I mean, this happens all the time because it's easy for a condition of approval to go through. And then when it actually comes down to developing plans and getting budgets and costs start coming into play, you're wrestling with, trying to figure out, what does that condition actually mean? What do I have to do to satisfy that condition? So that's just a daily interpretation we do every day. >> So I do feel more comfortable. I mean, I appreciate the explanation instead of just assuming things, but I do like it that, you know, I guess this would go to the Board of Appeals. That's what you're talking about. And if you weren't able to decide, like, you decide something, and they're like, well, this doesn't work. So the next step is the Board of Appeals. >> Yeah. >> The zoning c

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Jul 8, 2025 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: da6f44fd79e7772b03944f9bfd6c7556. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record