POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Life Enrichment Subcommittee

Tuesday, April 9, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Life Enrichment Subcommittee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

Just every now and then, some of it, if I wait for my family, that I'm going to retire in my own coffee shop. They got me all for this bar in the evenings. Look just like dress for it. All right. Welcome, everyone, to the Life Enrichment subcommittee meeting. We're going to get started. Thank you, everybody, for your patience. We'll start with item number one public comment for non agenda items. Are there any is there any public comment? Will you allow me to speak on that? To me, the importance then will you do it when the topic comes, when the topic you think you should to any interview on that you just had to wait 30 seconds. Okay. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Bruce. Also Pittsburgh's Mr. Bicycle. The bicycle community in Pittsburgh requests that when the green cords open, we take the curb in front of small in front of John Henry Johnson Park, ready to prohibit parking there so that the bicycle lanes can be maintained. The bicycle community also requests that we build a bridge over the canal to connect to the Delta. D ends the trail via the paved maintenance road for the canal, which is on the other side of the canal from the from John Henry Johnson Park. We removed the crosswalk at John Henry Johnson Parkway. Just Bronte explained to me that we removed it so that people would look both ways rather than seeing, Oh, there's a crosswalk, I'll just start walking across it so it's safer. I fear that we're going to get somebody off by a car on West Cleveland Road because there isn't all that much heartache. And this is a big, fancy, nice facility. We're going to get a lot of people there. So connecting to the Delta at the end of the trail that will allow people to bicycle from our BART station on an off road path all the way to this site. We could advertise that as a good thing. And if somebody gets killed by being hit by a car while they're crossing West Leland Road, I fear I will get a bridge over West Cleveland Road also. But I'm I'm I figured that that's what it's going to take to get a bridge over West Cleveland Road to across the street. So thanks very much for allowing me to comment on this. It is a life enrichment subject that I'm just brought up. Thank you. All right. So for two, a courts request for qualifications. Very well. Okay. All right. Deferred during the courts is a $9 million cutting edge indoor facility, 45,000 square foot of indoor gymnasium, five basketball multi purpose courts. And there was a groundbreaking held in September of 2023. The facility is going to be located inside of John Henry Johnson Park, which is located on Leland Road across the former football. We put out an RFP for an operator of the facility. What we were looking for and the recommended for an operator were three things, not more than three things. But essentially these were kind of the three areas that we really want to focus on, which is experience, experience and operating a similar facility enhancement enhancing public offering and maximizing event activity and operating efficiency and blend of the lens of tournaments, different sports, open gym rentals, birthday parties, because we want to maximize this facility available as potential based on the RFQ because it was I would say a marquee is a market which is a request for qualifications based on the Q This is the timeline and speed of activities currently we are in. Right or down here we can see we're somewhere in between that we're a little bit behind schedule, but we are anticipating to move those right along from this based on the recommendations that happened today. So with the process, we had two firms attend the PROPOSERS conference and that was something that the Council had brought forward that one of our other are fees that we did earlier. So we've made that kind of standard to do a proposers conference for all of our P's and Q's that we do. So we had two firms attend that conference. We have three firms submit. One firm withdrew after the deadline, and then there was a panel that evaluated two submissions based on the following criteria was identified in B, R, and Q, Operational philosophy, management structure, our experience and qualifications management approach and methodology for those budgeting capital ability and a facilitator made up the panel. The panel was comprised of staff and the community, so there was you want the names or I know just was where they came from. So you had recreation staff, you had staff from economic development and planning as well as community representative who had A background in B, c, y o, c, c, And then on day one we had one other panelist that wasn't able to participate. It was one of them, Oh, sorry, and a developer to try to go around the table. All right. So in submission, ranking of the two firms, as you can see, they both scored extremely high in all areas. We it was very pleasant to receive two very qualified proposals were very qualified entities. It shows a lot about this facility. It shows a lot about our community that we actually have not actually, but that we have something really good to offer industry that there's a need. There's a demand, and that folks outside of our area are looking for this. So as you can see that those are the max points and where everyone scored and again, these are average points. Thank So recommendation and next steps the staff is recommending that firm be is the most qualified to take this on. And what we would like to do is begin negotiations on agreement for operations, go for the proposals shared with the subcommittee and give a little background for the group here on the Hill. They're just looking at the proposal. We're actually part of the overall agenda that I was just tuning in. Yes, watching this, I'd be like, okay, turned out, does anyone know what was proposed? Okay, let me pull the market because I don't know any subsequent. But it's just you can say this has been a document. Both documents were shared with the subcommittee. They are fully aware of what were in the proposals for both A and B and certainly what I heard feedback from the panel members that talk to me were that both firms are excellent selections, so there wasn't a wrong choice election, whichever way. And it was a difficult decision to really figure out what when it came down to what is it each each in its own right, it basically stood out and one of the reasons, again, based off of the the overall average and then even just community mindedness and really making sure that the corporate community is why selection why recommended the over in question that we do have actually representatives from both from A and B and the audience. But if there's any questions that you might have your question I think I had a question around the and this is for the markets. But yes, the length of experience in the area of operating again for a facility like this, well, it's been in operation. You started in Oakland back in 2013. So 11 years I've been to see 13 year operations. Okay. And over a decade, obviously in 2015. But but had been operating for companies since before that. All on March one, we were able to create a business that's scattered throughout the area and programing. So there's that. And then we are both local. So, you know, the Bay Area. So that's important to think about our demographic here and questions about that. And then are you going to talk about next steps or. Yes, so next steps is South would like to begin negotiating negotiating with a firm be okay. And what we would do is we sit down, work out, make sure we understand fully the economics, the the agreement, bring it back to the subcommittee or concurrence and then take it to the full council for adoption. And we are unfortunately, but fortunately, the construction is taking longer than we wanted with someone who wants to be under construction by now. So we have a bit of time to work that out. We were hopeful right now we'd be looking at almost finished building, but that what happened is upon evaluation, we originally were on the west side of John Henry Johnson, moved over to the east side. The east side is lower and what we would like to build the building is the way the water would run into the port and use the water and basketball courts as a bad thing. So we figured, you know what, Let's go through an engineer. So they're actually going to be built on top of where it is now. So that way we don't have to worry about any water intrusion going into the creeks and, you know, or having somebody apple squeegee, you know, we just pulled out. So that's what's caused the delay. We're still targeting trying to get it done by the end of this year. That is what we're talking with the developer who's, you know, has the contract with the contractor and everything ready to go. And as we know, this developer can move dirt quickly. So adding five feet shouldn't be an issue because it will go from the old golf course and just bring external. Well, I'm excited. I know you have to know that sign on Leland. And I'm like, Oh, you coming? So this is nice to see the progress toward that. So this is the arc we want you on our P. This is the So Still learning center how we proceed the one at first and the other in great question what we we're really going for here as staff recommended to the council we wanted qualified entities to run this. It wasn't a who's going to be the cheapest or anything of that nature. It really was what we wanted and what we are two excellent firms that have experience running facilities, which is also a plus. The last thing we want is somebody to come in. We just say, Oh, sure, I can do this, you know, where do I put it? This, you know, we want something to look as good today as it does ten years from now. And what's great is both entities have that experience where the panel went and into both and got a feel for, you know, their facilities. So again is that's why we were trying to get qualified. We want to make sure they understand what it takes to run a facility also bring in tournaments have there's you know, community elements. You know, we don't want everyone just sort of drive by. We wonder what's in there. So and that's really what came across and what has been relayed to me. You know, some of that programing, local programing is what looked to be higher than from it kind of all over again. Not saying, well, I don't have any questions. I trust the panel. I know the panel went through some extensive research. So I be you guys made a decision for whether we'd like the recommendation for you to so that they will go back to me and say, all right, let's sit down. Let's get this done. Let's and then bring it back. And ultimately the council right now we want to move quickly just so that's all lined up and during construction, if there is any opportunities for that firm to go, who was there any way you can make sure either this should be here or let's make sure, you know, they can be a part of the process, which is nice going into this. From my end, I again trust the panel opposed the information passed on to us prior to this meeting, and I feel comfortable and confident that the panel made a good decision for the residents. So, yeah, okay, that's recommendation. Yeah, I would agree. And I appreciate the rigor around, you know, having that both the conference, the board just kind of laying out what you're looking for so that they could make a good showing. That's obvious when you look at the way that it's been scored and we appointed about what the strengths were. So I really appreciate that and I appreciate what collected by trying to make it. Maybe we're trying to get away from maybe somebody may know one or the other. We were trying to give it as much of a fair and balanced review for tomorrow. I don't know which ones they're I don't know. But three, I don't know. I'm over here. Ten or 12. Yes. You know, 50, 50. All right. And we will continue on o program. No, I just didn't like the topic. I apologize. We'll go over to item 38 Cultural Diversity initiative. Other than copies of these or these are just a handout. These are that we wanted to share with you and certainly explain to the two of to the Tudor confirms we will be getting in contact with you tomorrow. And so you're certainly welcome to stay, but you don't have to stay through the other agenda item. Okay. So much of the time, I think it seems like a good game name. I am bringing this item back. Culture and diversity Initiative. And just to recap, this was a huge agenda item requested by the City Council in September of 1920 to 2022, and they wanted to explore the possibilities of creating a culture and diversity initiative board to provide criteria and processes for local organizations to seek assistance for funding for future events and staff research. The costs for local organizations, utilize city facilities to host up or launched local culture on diversity events, as well as alternative ways for the city to support the promotion of the local culture. Because of the events to various media available to the city and staff, findings were presented at the 1994 Subcommittee on Public 21st, and currently the city promotes events on its media platforms such as Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and the city's digital science. And we also promote events and activities on the city website, as well as on the many monitors inside a city hall and at the Moda Center. And for this service that is provided by the city typically do not charge and fees and the organizations are required to provide the artwork and the narrative and our cost to staff time, which is $110 an hour according the masterpiece schedule, which is already included in the Recreation Department's annual budget after staff did the research. As you can see on this slide, we presented three options that the subcommittee could consider and making recommendation on. And option number one was for organizations to apply for national assistance and begin allocated thousand dollars from the general fund plans program and organizations could receive up to $500, and this would assist not 20 organizations if the maximum amount of $10,000 is given. And option number two was for organizations to do a plan for the use of city facilities and the value of the I'll give you this may not exceed $500. So that will be discussed, which is rental. And again, we will be using general funds to allocate $10,000 for this program and this again will assist for 20 organizations if the full value is given. And option number three was for organizations to apply for advertising assistance. And the cost associated with this effort is four start time. Option three is actually already being performed by the city's outreach coordinator under the equation Department. In order to make a more informed decision, the subcommittee's requested for more data and along the lines of the subsidies and other costs made worse. The city currently offers to almost all the nonprofit organizations who want events and activities in Pittsburgh and based on their request and on this slide and the next slide stop listed the events that would qualify for the category of the culture and most of the oriented activities and listed the department's who supported these events, as well as the subsidies awarded to them. So the subsidies would be the the VEBA also forbids the planning fees, the rental of the facilities as well as staff time because you can see it was recreation and then they would all stop playing. But those costs were actually absorbed by each individual department's perspective of budget. So we've been provided subsidies for over $22,000 for those events that would qualify as cultural and events for the fiscal year 2223. To go back to the presentation on February 1st and March 20th, staff presented three options to the subcommittee as shown on this slide, and that would be option number one to provide financial assistance and allocate 10,000 from the general fund. And option number two would be to provide facility use assistance and allocate $10,000 from the general fund. And option number three would be to continue to provide assistance at the events that we have been doing currently to continue the same practice and now seeks recommendation based on this data that things would appear this to bring this full circle. Member Lopez gave us direction, but it was a meeting that you weren't available for. So in discussions with council around which that can you please just bring this back, just so we can make sure both of you have input at the same time? We just didn't want to not have full subcommittee members. So that way little bit of your mind. All right. I'm pretty much already weighed in on this one. I want to make sure that that's acknowledged as long as you a try to hold that. So thank you for showing me and make you so right now. Yes. Okay. I just wonder if you want me to switch or not. Oh, okay. I appreciate the table because I the last time we looked at this, I couldn't tell what we were spending. So this recommendation would save us money as a city. And secondly, technically, yes. So we would be creative and can pretty much nonexistent be all right. I think we come up with this one or the one before the one before that one. Yeah. So technically the overall budget would be reduced to 10,000 because what we've shown has shown is what we spent last year for events. You know, there was a one at one time that money was set aside, but people were asking so often that we ran out of money quickly. So we kind of, for lack of a better word, kind of choose to see what's the most benefit to the community. That reaches a lot of people. Obviously, we promote cultural culture and diversity in these amazing events. So as I mentioned, all of the efforts are absorbed in each respective budget depending on who's providing assistance in this format, it's more formalized. We'll still have to apply. And so we were proposing 10,000 and what Councilmember Lopez and I get why she said it, because she wants to promote our facilities, which is great, as you can see, you know, facilities are being used on the planet. They are air. Yeah. Depending on the event and I'm not sure how many calls it gets, but I think the city manager's office probably just call for two. It seems like a four facility or just helps. A lot of times it would be we're just wonderful folks or we're going to use bottles. And so it may not always be a facility that they need to help or renting. It may just be we're holding an event here, right? One could be what on MLK when we sometimes would start out out front, you know, and then walk over to the school. Right. You know, know how do you know? There's not really a facility charge, but you know, so how do they get a band there? It's right there. Yeah, but sometimes you'll have to monitor that. I to and mind you, these are these are definitely not true costs. These are. Yes, We kind of just kind of look like how many officer and I'm just put together and said, well actually are these substantially. Yeah it is a true cost. No I mean on the on here is not this is not because we just estimated Yeah it's what the time is for staff. Yeah. Different people are paid their level like in a public place to sit up and to take down. And in order to get this list together we have individuals sometimes provide escorts. Yeah, no, I get you. But this program would bring an absolute cap, right? Or would there still be wiggle room or discretionary fees anyway, there's always room within the city manager unless the council sets a very specific qualms about that, obviously. So it doesn't go against them. Yeah. So option one, there's no facility for just giving them funds for something they want to do. Option two, they can use the money toward a facility, not necessarily for other types of expenses. Then option three is what we do already, which is advertising cost. So this is sort of like the when I look at this, are we saying I just feel like option three, if we're doing it and we have the staff, I would like to see that continue to support the groups if we're doing it already. And so I'm like, okay, but then are there numbers and relation to how much actually actually bills or that's what I'm saying this, this spreadsheet you're building on her time. Yeah, we build the time in. So currently there's no separate tab that would showcase the true expense for Ashley's time for early. We weren't tracking it that way because when our records her her time, she, she just records that she worked here. She doesn't record that she work an hour and a half. I'm doing this at just like PD has not They're recorded that they were 3 hours I know from the for the the traffic control and it could be five different CDs with five different rates because their levels of service or their levels are different. And if we were to choose option one or option two, would option three go away for the existing nonprofit benefiting from YO for going through the exercise of having a formal setup? Well, that was the whole point. And we would create an actual casino or advertising. I mean, anything we could get would be her hourly rate like everything else. Yeah, we reach out to the public and that is substantially by the hourly rate is where periodically the city updates everybody's hourly rate. It's like any business would as well. And we try and throw in all of those costs so that way that she would be or whomever it is would be charged charging their own, it would be a full burden, right? Yeah, that's the target. I know what you meant. But I think when I look at so we helped 18 organizations last year and then with this new subsidy we would help 20. So two additional ones. But they were caps, but they would not have as much money available. If you all are proposing a budget amount, I imagine that we know that we can afford this. This is not going to cause a hardship for us as a city. You are correct. How long were you doing that process? Yeah, 30 years at least that I can attest to. And there's never been controlled. Oh, it's usually been in the city managers or office where they kind of. All right, you know what you have? We've got this event going on. Once we do. So I'm having a hard time with it because we've been here for a long time. And so we've been doing this for a long time as a community. But over time, as we're growing, we do have to. It costs money to do these thing. Yes, there's there has to be a bit of a about rail. Yeah. Just so otherwise it just somebody could come back every week and say I want to do this, I'd like to do this. And you need a little bit of balance. Yeah. And the requirement is for them to be a nonprofit and open up the event for the community, Correct? That's the law. Yes. Which is why I want options here, because people are already asking for more events, as is from the city. Well, this would be a nice way to streamline and I'll be directly. Where does that leave people like the people that want to do the marches and things like that where they don't necessarily need a facility, but they want support. So so I was going to suggest you can do a blend. So if we know we're spending 22,000 was just round it for the sake of roving and looking at the city manager hoping it's okay, 25 let's say 25,000 at 25, use option one to allow them the option to use it for facility and or something else. Because like you said in marches, they don't want a facility. But at the same time when the money's gone, the money's gone, right? So you do either y or maybe even the nonprofit, the option, I'm sure, one, two or three. Yeah. And the other the other thing, though, the other part of this proposal to be able to distribute these funds to as many people as possible. Part of this proposal says an organization that receives funding will not receive it in the next round because you we want to give an opportunity to someone else. And there are certain organizations who provide for three or four events in the city in one year because they're you know, they either do something cultural, maybe something religious, whatever it is, it could be the same organization. So they'll be limited to that one time in that year, and then we'll skip a year because every other year, every two years or every two years, which would be tough, fine, you know, and I like it. I can think of a list. I don't know. There's an organization that the the MLK does they count on in. Yeah and very much I think a great thing for the community. So I think we have to balance that because I would hate to discourage or not have one, but we set rules. We have to be consistent with those rules across the board. Yeah, Yeah, I would. I don't understand how we want to be inclusive. A good option three should just be baseline services that we give to people. If we could be that that is the other 10,000 of the budget that's existing based on time that's provided to help the organizations. And if you have option a hybrid of option one or two, you have the choice of either if you set the budget at that amount, we end up at the same place, or maybe we can do a combination. I want to give the organization the option with a guaranteed advertising spot or that actual event. I think that's what I so just so we're clear on allocate additional funds. Yeah, right. Because you would have to or make it part of the 110. No what I'm saying is that option three that would be available to these organizations if they wanted it, if they wanted support advertising very bit because they get it anyway. Oh not, not as part of their $500. So we were we were proposing one option. If we do three, we stick with three the whole way. Because what happens is if they're receiving assistance, there's still a cost to them. And so, you know, if you do, let's say a blend of one and two where you give the people an option to do a a facility or a service in addition to that cost. Now you're saying you can only apply for one every other year, But since we're still doing this, you can get advertising every year. So it doesn't what's going to happen is, I think, larger because they don't know formal submission versus just the ads. Yeah, okay. That's I get what you're saying. I was thinking if you the year you get your subsidy, that's when you get your advertising. There is an opportunity if you wanted to monetize it on those off years for those groups and if they want to advertise they can pay a fee on those off the air. Okay. So you're saying charge them they want. So they're basically buying ads and by had some pretty good structure for them. Would it be lower? And I don't know what it would be, but I mean, we you know, they're a nonprofit and, you know, just having a discussion here around it. So trying to figure out a way I get your point, Councilmember Lopez, about wanting to advertise our facilities and not being used, but I know that not all the organizations use them and they need support for other things. And so I just wanted to doesn't give that flexibility for our community. And so because this is the culture and diversity and inclusion, like you want to have something that, you know, that works for folks. It's not just about the dollar amount. It could be what it's used for. So that's why I was thinking, you know, hybrid. Do you split the baby between option to and option one? I don't know. Option three, I was thinking that just the baseline service, if you give somebody a subsidy, we'll help you promote that event that you're doing at our facility or that we're supporting you on that particular year. But on the off year, I would be I was thinking I wasn't thinking about the off years when they want to do it. You know, that could be something that they either pay for or are we continue to do it for them? It sounds like it's cost prohibitive or just is still has it doesn't feel equal and somewhere. Yeah I and if I'm doing too much also tell you that because you all know how this works you know I don't want staff to be overly well I think the whole purpose of the asked originally by former council members or former subcommittee members was just to ensure that there's a means for our community to be able to have these events to promote culture and diversity in our community, that there is a purchasing patient from the city, whether that's financial, whether it's venue, whether it's in-kind, like staff time, and whether showing that the research she has proven that we do do that. We do provide that service to our to our community in and we do it in partnership with these organizations who take on the the work. You know, it's it's not easy to organize an event, but they take their time and they organize the event, but they need a little help from us. So whether we advertise it or we ask public works to set it up and dismantle whatever the set up is or paid to escort the march, we provide that. But everything that we provide, there's a cost to the general public because we have to pay staff, we have to pay for the maintenance of the facility, just the use of the facility is more than $500. Yeah. So if we formalize it, which obviously is an option and we threw it out there just to show what it would look like, yeah, it might prevent some of these events from happening because they can't afford. So we continue with option three, which has been working for all these years. You know, I was saying it's not work like they said. Yeah, I think for now, unless something changes, Option three is a good option I like option three if it's working and advertising is expensive. And so that's why I was like, this is something that we continue to provide if we were to go with these particular ones. And I get the spirit of why I was asked or the intent of it, and it just doesn't seem like a month later, 10,000, those 5000 like we're given 22 or we go back to that slide, which looks like the one with all of the list. So some of that includes labor too. Yeah, that some of the asks are different. So yeah, you know, it could be as small as advertising. So it's not very much it's minimal if for example the portrait of and bailing Willie Brown, that was a small event. They didn't ask for much about Speaker's chairs. Yeah, but if you if you look at to go that they're like what Yeah. So like if you look at the rally that involved those four departments to participate whether it's Vegas for the for the event or public works as time recs time PD's time. So it varies Juneteenth is almost 30 $500 because that's a big event. But we certainly wouldn't want to not have these events if our system is preventing them from doing it. What's the potential? The potential cost? Yeah. Or the limits or the. Yeah, the limits are limiting their ability to be able to hold the events. Yeah. So the ones being proposed may prevent groups from doing what these events would be a more interesting ways you could set up a 20,000 or $25,000 budget or recommend that you put in for budget. And then quarterly we give updates to this committee and here's the submittals that have come in and what we've funded, just so you can feel like there is there's a good understanding and we didn't want to belittle, you know, there may be a Juneteenth that maybe what Trump said on their 30 $500, the other one might be 500, but it's just trying. But working within the budget itself, you know, we work with this subcommittee on how we're trying to create and promote more cultural diversity, inclusive events, and do that in a way that isn't limiting. And but we set a budget and so we really know if it's 25,000, around 6000 a quarter is really what we want to try and be with our social. Yeah, and to be fair to the public, when he's out and then he's out until the next round of budget. Right. And is there on the question and I like the conversation is there a limit. So you just get to ask once as an organization per year, how do we do it. Right now it's it's open and on a case by case scenario and similar you so the series of rallies and other events, I would hate to have to go back to that organization say pick one right because you know there are you know Juneteenth Cesar Chavez, MLK are all great events and one eight or just something that's provided by one organization. Oh, I see. So on this slide, one organization provides the first the second little social past. And you go back here. There was one month that they did the literacy rally and where where's the funds typically coming from? The role that General Fund has within the city budget that we sometimes, sometimes track is sometimes it's right, sometimes even like PD or PD one at the march and stuff, they they basically they're not necessarily bringing in other folks, so they don't move things around. We shift things around to try and put it in our normal operating day so that it doesn't necessarily impact the general funds as much. And that's why, you know, of these numbers are actually better other than a year where it's significantly impacted us. We were just super high maker because again, it spent 20 to 25000. You're talking about an overall right now budget at 60 million. So it has not really impacted us. No. I can think of the organization that we told know. So why was this even brought out? Because I think the key to this is the future agenda. I don't want to try to do anything. I thought this was impacting. I thought it would become an issue that, you know, maybe the way you got to I mean, I think the majority feel that they wanted, you know, former subcommittee members just want to make sure that that we were doing screenings. Yeah. You know so I look at couple but I had the same question. I was like, you know, if it's working and but I understand the whole idea behind inclusive. And so I'm wondering about like how do we do the outreach so people know about it to apply, you know, can we do a better job doing outreach so that organizations know what's available and maybe that can help with the it's letting people know that. Yes. And Sam, and it's a question I'm not saying your name did a great job of finding more of the organizations and really the council been directing us. We need to understand who are in the community in which there are regulations. And we have that database which will continue to grow. So about 70, 70, 70 or so organizations, we can do a mailer once or twice a year. Just as a reminder, you know, there is, you know, there are potentials for funding availability depending on certain events. You know, we could create some of that. And we've actually been utilizing that list a lot more. So, for instance, Keller just announced today that that our the Bidders conference is coming up for this coming year. And we sent that we received the notice, we sent it to that service list today to make sure that they knew to again inform them of other options as well. And when people rent these facilities, they're able to do that online, right? This like these rentals are available online or not yet we don't want your request is online. So all reservation requests go through an online form. Right. So my question behind that is we don't have any information there yet that says if you're a nonprofit, you may qualify for x and x. We will know we do not have that on there. And all of these folks here, with the exception of the senior center, the senior center has a nonprofit rate that we do offer. They get that one time a year and they know of that. But as far as all of the others, again, it's not like really I mean, we sort of there's no facility fee for that. So the help that they received was that time. So the public works and that's all staff time and the waiver. But it's not necessarily that ability to be or a discounted fee. And part of the reason is we want them to have a conversation with staff so that we know exactly what they're doing. The last thing we want is for them to just sign up on line. Next thing you know, they're having things that they shouldn't be doing at an event. So you'd like to have certain controls on them. And a lot of the ones that are public works, a lot of times it's not even the facility, but they want use of the stage. They want the stage and they may need like extra garbage bags or things like that, even more so than the facility cost. Well, if it's not really a backup mass and these numbers seem to be steady years and years, I guess. Yeah, not I mean, but you know, I also want to respect, you know, what former council members, what they were trying to do. And I think some governments around, you know, the number of asks or maybe people that are, you know, like if they have a sound plan, like do you evaluate where people come in and they say, oh, we want to import an engineer, we need this. The system is like, is there a program manager or somebody that sort of evaluates that? But I think that probably just way there was a problem, they don't even know what they are out there. I think the problem will be how you screen guidelines is if you start making exceptions, we're in hot water without it. Right at the end, you know? Yeah. And some organizations are putting on three or four tons per year and we move that they would be at a disadvantage, which would really significantly impact our that we are we getting complaints don't know I know and I thought that's one those and you're right if we started setting guidelines they have to be consistent right and then we're going to create problems when there aren't any. Right. Right. And then sometimes organizations that aren't even listed on there, they just want assistance with advertising. They have their own fire. Actually basically takes it and tries to buy it on the thing. What if we did something like setting a cap like a 30,000? Since it doesn't seem like we're really going much above that. Does it have some guidelines, an official guideline that like 30,000? Yeah, we can do that within the budget. We'll work with them. I think so, yeah. Not too many rules, but just a budget of 30,000. And what I would propose that we utilize of the subcommittee to give you updates. Yeah. So that way if you feel something's getting a little out of control, then you can keep a check on it. But I like the 30,000 because Sam created a list of all these people that we have an outreach to like. There might be other things in a community that organizations don't know about that they have this available to them. So I think that way you may get more increased demand. And, you know, our city is becoming more diverse, really. So action or, you know, it's often three plus three plus that. Yeah. Okay. Thank you for the role that you see. That's why we like these subcommittees and you are And so the last thing is just going back to your own to believe it was a program activity. So thank you, Jordan, for making something with us. Just wanted to share with you this is a list of the survey responses. So after our events are not events but our activities, we have a survey that automatically goes out, ask a couple of questions to all participants in those programs, primarily the youth programs. So this I pulled from the last six months the surveys. And overall we we get between a four and five. Obviously those are on the high end by the time I'm not low. But this kind of gives you some of the the end. But when we read through these a lot of it, we already know because we do talk to the folks that are out there participating. Some of it is things when you look at especially the junior MBA, you'll see something about the coaches or the coach wasn't well versed or whatever. They're volunteer coaches, but there were things that we do as we get these. We do change along the way and for the next season. So even for this year with the junior MBA, the lot at the end of the season, we actually did find some referees to assist us and they started running our and they'll be doing that for actually all of our leads regarding sports going forward. So that's going to make some sense. It was nice. So currently what we just wrapped up, like I said, is the junior NBA program. Currently we're operating youth baseball just stops for a year and we wrapped up youth baseball our season. We just started Youth Baseball, which was delayed a few weeks because of the rain. They had their first game and opening season this past Saturday. We also gave them hotdogs. We gave those out for free just kind of as a fun thing to do that for ages 3 to 5, we have Twilight groups happening, which is for the 14 to 24 year olds in volleyball is on Sundays. We are adaptive classes for adults on Wednesdays, Adult softball baseball. And I was going to have a hand out for you, but it wasn't ready yet. We actually are doing the recreation guy. We were supposed to have a draft ready today, but we'll have that for you by next week. So you'll see everything. So adult softball and baseball is also kicking off. So those are the current programs that we have right now. And then coming up, we have a little medical school. We just signed a contract with them. So that will be offered. And then junior achievement, which we haven't had in Pittsburgh in a very long time. So we're excited for that youth soccer league for ages 6 to 14 Junior Giants, which is a Bring youth baseball program that'll be starting soon. The junior NFL program starts. We're taking registration for that. Our shows kick off next month. We also in June of each year, our parks, we're going to be doing a rec on the go, which every Saturday will be in a different park. So really feature what you can do in our park and highlight our parks. So that goes in tune with parks, Make work better, which is a national campaign. So really highlight parks and the parks systems. We've Got a bunch more going as well, like first Fridays kick off in June and so on and so on. And I could go on forever. But we are working on a index, but like a kind of like a long card which will have a calendar of events that will go from May all the way through October. So you can see kind of what's coming up so that those are going to the Premier this week will have those and then the guide at the end of the week and then Ashley just wrapped up and printed, which I think you guys will get at the next council meeting, the 2023 annual report. So that's all I have, any questions on holding and I think the longest now I've always had this in my mind for a while. I know that it's very little sports, but we thought about maybe like a music program. Yes. The one challenge with music programs, at least in the committees, and is we have to house the women. So what we've been trying to do is work with California theater to do that. But Pittsburgh Performing Arts, they actually do have a music program. They do drums, they do drums, keyboard. I think one of the instruments like clarinet, if not clarinet, but I know a guitar. It's kind of low class for the families know. I'm not sure. I don't think they are. Is there are they are they are in private. So most likely, I don't know. They have a pretty good band, a pretty big following that. Their classes are huge. They also do partner with a lot of nonprofit. So like in the summertime, I know they've partnered with Sears and Asia to do programing and they had their older students come over and do programing at no cost within those programs. What are we doing? Food trucks This summer? I, i September. Many have a different committee, so we actually don't do food trucks. It's not a city event. We assess that's another one of those is this thing with the organization, the group that does oh I got the part I was part of. It's been part of our our event. But that's not something that we paid for. So it's not necessarily arts and outside organization that does that event. He at the end of last season you have to end early because of the construction going on whether and he hadn't found a location that was suitable in Pittsburgh. So that's kind of where we are. I did follow up with him and find out if he's going to be able to do that and sure. But then the car shows downtown London, those are remaining okay. And they had food trucks that are, I guess any way we can get like we're down there outside, that's can you show that to the list, come to our community meetings and we. Sure that's all you mean just like during the car show? Yeah. Oh, we can make that happen. I mean, not at all like a temporary, but I know when I made that as a temporary one, I was like I said, ask me shortly. Yeah, I saw it in Palm Springs and I loved it. They're like, We do this, you're going to play. That's what I'm hearing. I'll play. Okay. I never play. Oh, it's easier, but it's so big. They did it as a fundraiser for Pell, but they took like one dead end part of the street and they had to play pickleball with a cart. And you played so you could play the car, but we don't have to do it like that. But I just know we have tons of people that play pickleball. I mean, it might be a great fundraiser or are you trying to do something just north of the old folks on this street? MM That's why I might not have a crowd. The road. We never. Yeah. Set up the series sports potentially that I'll have series. I have one right now you can do better. So I'm like I have one of our pool right now and we did it and behind Ed's office in that parking lot. That's right. I don't think of the actual guard on the street where the stalls are the other concrete. Yeah, I think it's flat. I don't. I think it is pretty. There was like a small tennis and it's a one way. So, yeah, you could. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I would say that's good. It was a draw. You should have saw this line back and it was hilarious. People really like pickleball. Yeah. Pickleball. Huge. Come to the Marina center any Monday or Friday. Sunday morning. I had no idea, but You know, might be a way to get other people pickleball now that was the age that you guys usually get at senior are anywhere from 18 and up. Oh wow. I don't remember but they might be I love seeing it and I mean I saw people out there playing I didn't think would play and people were like, here, take my money. You know? Yeah, I'll pay for the kids. You know, I want to play with you, sergeant someone. So and it was it was just so much fun. And so I know we have a growing pickleball group from different to have a lot of you can do it there but they're partial there as well. So anything else? A fun little old. No, no, I love I love I love our channel. I love with the survey information. You know, it's always good to do things from a place of data to figure out where you can think what you're doing, where you know, well, where you want to can do better. But I think this helps the public know that we're really, you know, we're being intentional and we'll be more proactive in getting this to you folks after these programs and more subcommittee staff reports or remarks. We're going to do I have them? I oh, there was one. I know that you want me to discuss the last time we were in here. So I invited the Mexican consulate to pay a visit to Pittsburgh. And so they're projecting coming in sometime in May. They gave me some, I think four or five days. Some days. As for me, the ones that work be because as in the ninth, I'm just stuck in for most of the day. And so the purpose of that is to promote diversity. We do have a sister city with with Mexico and a lot of our population is also Mexican heritage. But it would be nice for the consulate to bring some of the events that they actually hosted at the consulate events ranging from music events to like Frida Kahlo Exposition. So it would be nice if at least members of the committee don't feel like they're too far away from from an embassy or consulate. And the goal is to get them to post about the consulate base here so that our residents can have to travel over there. And it'll also bring more out of town people into the city to to at least come and partake in whatever events or business they call it mobile consulate days, and maybe they can partake in the whole renting of facilities to to have these events here. And and promote accessible services. Certainly. So very cool. Yes. And the goal is to invite more other other countries to to come into Pittsburgh and commingle with with their expats living here. And very cool things that we we will adjourn the meeting with you to you probably think, oh, my money and I'm never going to.

65 Civic Avenue Pittsburg, CA 94565 P: (925) 252-6900 F: (925) 252-4814 pittsburgca.gov AGENDA LIFE ENRICHMENT SUBCOMMITTEE Tuesday, April 9, 2024 5:30 PM City Hall First Floor Conference Room 65 Civic Avenue Pittsburg, CA 94565 Subcommittee Members Dionne Adams, Councilmember Angelica Lopez, Councilmember Community Advisory Commissioners on CDBG Jennifer Cruz, Commissioner Roland Fernandez, Commissioner 1. Public Comment for Non-Agenda Items 2. Recreation a. Dream Courts Request for Qualifications (Councilmember Adams, Councilmember Lopez) – Staff will review and discuss the submissions received. Subcommittee feedback requested. b. Program and Activity Update (Councilmember Adams, Councilmember Lopez) – Staff will provide an update of past, current, and upcoming Recreation programs and activities. 3. Community Services a. Culture & Diversity Initiative (Councilmember Adams, Councilmember Lopez) – Review information presented on 03/20/24. 4. Subcommittee and Staff Reports or Remarks 5. Adjournment

Dream Courts Request For Qualifications Item 2a Presented Life Enrichment Subcommittee 4.9.2024

Pittsburg Dream Courts • $9,000,000 cutting edge indoor facility • 45,000 sq. ft. indoor gymnasium • 5 basketball/multipurpose courts • Groundbreaking held September 2023

Recommended Preferred Operator Experience Experience in operating similar facility Enhance Enhance public offerings and maximize event activity and operating efficiency Blend Leagues/tournament, variety of sports/rec offerings, open gym, and rentals/birthday parties

Schedule of Activities RFQ Issue Date December 11, 2023 Responder’s Conference January 11, 2024 at 5pm at Marina Center – 340 Marina Blvd. Pittsburg, CA 94565 in Classroom 1 Last Day for Submitting Inquiries January 18, 2024, by 4:00 p.m. Responses to Inquiries January 25, 2024, by 4:00 p.m. RFQ Submittal Deadline February 8, 2024, by 4:00 p.m. Interviews and Facility Tours Scheduled Week of February 19, 2024 Anticipated Award Date March 2024

Process 2 firms attended the Proposers Conference 3 firms submitted 1 firm withdrew after the deadline Panel evaluated 2 submissions based on: • Operational Philosophy • Management Structure • Firm Experience & Qualifications • Management Approach & Methodology • Proposed Budget & Capital Ability • Facility Tour

Submission Ranking Max Pts. Firm A Firm B Cover Letter 5 4 4 Operational Philosophy 5 3 4 Management Structure 10 7 8 Firm Experience & Qualifications 20 15 18 Management Approach & Methodology 20 15 18 Proposed Budget & Capital Ability 20 12 16 Facility Tour 20 17 19 OVERALL TOTAL AVERAGE 100 79 91

Recommendation & Next Steps Staff recommends Firm B as the most qualified Next Steps: Begin negotiations on agreement for operations

Item No. 3a Life Enrichment Subcommittee Meeting Culture & Diversity Initiative April 9, 2024

Background • On 09/19/22, City Council requested a future agenda item: • Create Culture and Diversity initiative to provide criteria and processes for local organizations who seek assistance and funding for events. 2

Promotion of Eventscwalden8910@yahoo.com Railroad and California Buchanan at Highlands Ranch Park 5 cwalden8910@yahoo.com

Options: Option 1 Up to $500 Assistance • Organization apply for funding • $10,000 allocation will fund up to 20 organizations Option 2 Facility Use Up to $500 Value • Organization apply for funding • $10,000 allocation will fund up to 20 organizations Option 3 City Controlled Advertising • Organization apply for advertising • Staff time cost 7

8 Event City Facility PW Rec PD Pl. Subsidy African Baby Shower Senior Center    $732 Guillermo Bust Dedication Railroad Ave & Muniz Plaza   $2,159 Summer Kick Off Event Marina Green/ Central Harbor Park   $1,169 African American Baby Shower John Buckley Park   $644 Literacy Rally & Celebration John Buckley Park   $1,116 Youth Relay March Railroad Ave - 3 rd and 8 th Street   $1,834 Breast Cancer Awareness Tea Senior Center  $1,680 Portrait unveiling of Willie Brown City Hall  $500 Pray Pittsburg (worship) Overflow CCC parking lot  $1,116 Homecoming Parade Pittsburg Marina – Pittsburg HS    $1,116 Thanksgiving Giveaway Courthouse Parking Lot   $1,116 Family Harvest Farm festival 1300 Power Avenue  $600 African American Wellness Program Senior Center  $745 List of Events

9 List of Events contd. Event City Facility PW Rec PD Pl Subsidies MLK March and Rally City Hall to Pittsburg HS     $1,616 Cesar Chavez Day March City Hall to Pittsburg HS     $1,616 Good Friday Procession 8 th, Cumberland, 6 th Streets   $475 National Day of Prayer   $1,116 Juneteenth City Park   $3,456 Total Fees Waived $22,806

Recommendation • Option 1 – Provide financial assistance and allocate $10,000 from the General Fund • Option 2 – Provide facility use assistance and allocate $10,000 from the General Fund • Option 3 – Continue to provide assistance at events • Continue the same practice 12

SUBMISSION A

RFQ Pittsburg Dream Courts February 8, 2024 On behalf of LLC I am pleased to submit this proposal in response to the Request for Qualifications to provide Pittsburg Dream Courts Management and Operations Consultant Services. We hope to enter into a long term agreement to manage Pittsburg Dream Courts. We are committed to investing our time, expertise, relationships and money to ensure the success of the project and positively impact the local community. We are uniquely qualified to outperform expectations in this special opportunity. We are adequately briefed on this project based on the information that is publicly available. We are clear on the specs of the buildout, the location, the relationship to the City, the support of Discovery Homes, the requirement for financial sustainability, the impact in the community, where there is flexibility and not, the timeline and the overall goals and vision for the development. We pride ourselves on our speed and adaptiveness, and are comfortable and flexible with the terms and conditions of this RFQ. Our ability to provide timely services is evident by our history, illustrated in acquiring three recent facilities: Anaheim - formerly American Sports Center - August 2020 Oakland - formerly - May 2022 Ladera - formerly Ladera Sports Center - September 2022 In all three cases, we earned the opportunity to assume control of the lease and turnaround distressed situations. All three in- stances happened immediately without any advance notice, had stringent requirements, required unprecedented speed and had complex considerations. Several distinct factors separate us from other applicants and would benefit the City, including: Proximity - We are currently operating a similar size facility that is 30 minutes away. Personnel - We have a best in class team, high functioning across each business segment. Infrastructure - We have refined and battle tested systems, policies and procedures. Size - Big enough to have national reach, leverage, control and small to be nimble, caring, connected. Experience - We have 15 years of invaluable trial and error, learnings and relationships. Business Model - We balance basketball and volleyball, boys and girls, youth and high school, elite and non-elite, club and recreational. Reputation - We have consulted for global brands, advised on facilities and programming, and received awards for community impact, workplace culture and entrepreneurship. We are excited for this prospective opportunity and appreciate the consideration. We are available to meet in person at any of our facilities and to discuss our unique capabilities. LLC CEO

SUBMISSION B

Dear City of Pittsburg Recreation Department, We understand you are in search of a qualified firm to provide management for the Pittsburg Dream Courts, a 45,000 square foot basketball/multi-sports facility. Please accept this letter as an official declaration that the accepts the requirements of the RFQ and requests to contract with the City of Pittsburg to provide management services for the Dream Courts facility. Our team successfully manages a facility similar to The Dream Courts. In 2015, we established , a 40,000 square foot, state-of-the-art basketball/multi-sport facility in Walnut Creek. We oversaw the build-out and have also managed the facility and all programming since its inception. We have operated our facility in a fiscally responsible way (profitable in every year of operation). Of equal importance, we have programmed the at peak-capacity since day-one, attracting local, regional, and national level events (like Steph Curry’s SC30 Select Camp). We attract nearly 300,000 visitors per year, an accomplishment not many facilities can consistently replicate. This success has bolstered the City of Walnut Creek’s economy so much so, that we now have an official partnership with the City’s Visitor’s & Convention Bureau as they recognize the importance of our facility to the local economy. The has matured into a very efficient business and is bursting at the seams, requiring us to find additional facilities to accommodate the overflow, The Dream Courts comes at the perfect time for us to replicate the success of the . Given the maturity and stability of the , our team is ready to immediately shift its focus to the Dream Courts, and will have no problem meeting the requirements of the proposed schedule, ensuring that Dream Courts is fully programmed for its opening in Summer of 2024. Lastly, we should note that, in addition to the , our management team collectively owns and operates five other youth basketball organizations. We are well versed in operating camps, tournaments, leagues, teams, facilities, sponsorships, fundraising, and more. We have every possible facet of programming in a sports facility covered and are excited to bring our 40+ years of sports management experience to assist the City of Pittsburg and its Dream Courts! Best Swishes, COVER LETTER

BOARD OF DIRECTORS Our board would continue to play a vital role in oversight and management of the Dream Courts. Chris and Frank . would be specifically assigned to focus on the immediate build-out of large-scale events at Dream Courts. CEO Mike would shift his focus to Dream Courts. Just as he has with the , Mike would be tasked with driving revenue and fostering relationships with key business partners. Mike would focus on creating corporate partnerships and identifying regional and national level event partners to drive large events. Mike would also be tasked with establishing a working relationship with the City of Pittsburg’s Rec Department and Visitor’s Bureau to ensure we are in lock-step in ensuring all Dream Courts activities are also focused on accomplishing the City’s goals. GENERAL MANAGER Steve would be re-assigned to serve in a similar role at Dream Courts. We would promote one of our assistant managers to back-fill his position at the . At Dream Courts, Steve’s focus would be building out our back-end administrative systems, all local programming and the marketing of them, and staffing the facility. NEW HIRES We would hire 1-3 additional full-time employees and 20-30 part-time employees to help us quickly scale the business and operations at Dream Courts. We will consider promoting from within and also searching for great local talent to fill these positions. MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE -CONT 7

”Warriors Basketball Academy has had a relationship with the since their facility opened in 2015. Their competence as a facility operator has given us the confidence to partner with them on a variety of community programs that served underrepresented groups. We also conduct camps & clinics each year at their facility and our experience with them has never been anything less than first class.” DAVID KRICHAVSKY VICE PRESIDENT, YOUTH BASKETBALL NBA DKrichavsky@nba.com • 917-375-3734 "We invited the to serve as a member of the Jr. NBA’s Flagship Network as we believe they are among the very best out there, both in facility management and program operation." The NBA G League Ignite is thankful to have established the roots of our program at the . The management played an integral role in the development of our players, providing resources, support, and organization that matched NBA standards. Anyone contemplating teaming up with staff gets our resounding endorsement. JEFF ADDIEGO VICE PRESIDENT, YOUTH BASKETBALL GOLDEN STATE WARRIORS JAddiego@warriors.com • 510-867-4789 We encourage you to contact the references listed below who can provide first-hand testimonials on our ability to successfully manage a facility and how our ability to do so has positively affected their businesses. ANTHONY McCLISH GENERAL MANAGER, G-LEAGUE IGNITE NBA mcclish.15@gmail.com • 419-296-3633 REFERENCES & TESTIMONIALS 11

DAY Morning/Afternoon 9:00 am-3:00 pm Afternoon/Evening 3:00 pm-8:00 pm Evening 8:00 pm-10:00 pm School Days (M-F) Adult Drop- In/Open Gym Youth Team Practices Youth Programming Adult Leagues Saturdays BIG EVENTS - Youth Tournaments, Leagues, & Games Birthday Parties Sundays BIG EVENTS - Youth Tournaments & Games Youth Team Practices Youth Programming Adult Leagues School Break (M-F) Summer Camps & Clinics Youth Team Practices Youth Programming Adult Leagues Providing a State-of-the-Art facility that feels clean, safe & secure at all times Providing first-class programming options for the community Providing outstanding customer service to traditional and B2B customers Establish strong relationships with key partners locally, regionally & nationally Operate at an annual profit by establishing strong revenue channels & by being efficient and strategic with expenses We plan to take a similar approach to managing The Dream Courts as we have with the . On a daily basis, we will strive to build the business by: Based on our experience on how to best maximize uses, we would aim to program the facility as follows: MANAGEMENT APPROACH & METHODOLOGY DREAM COURTS PROJECTED PROGRAMMING SCHEDULE 12

Thanks to our experience and existing network, we are extremely confident in our ability to quickly ramp programming and activities and ensure the Dream Courts facility is heavily trafficked from the get-go. Below are some strategies we would use to generate business. Big Events: Based on our current operations we are very confident we will fill Dream Courts on at least 40 of the 52 weekends each year. We will do this by: Reaching out to our existing contacts/event organizers and let them know we are in a new area and would like to work with them to program events in the new space Repurposing our current events, moving them from other satellite facilities, into this facility Working with East Diablo CYO to serve as a home for their East County Parish basketball and volleyball games Working with the Pittsburg Visitor’s Bureau and local hotels to solicit large corporate events that need exhibition hall space. Working with the Pittsburg Visitor’s Bureau to solicit National Level youth events with 500+ teams Leverage the traffic provided from Big Events to attract corporate partners and sponsors as an additional revenue channel Community Programming: Utilize current marketing list (which has a lot of crossover) for local programming Paid advertising on social media Work with local partners to spread the word Establish strong relationships with community influencers to help spread the word Do a great job and rely on customer testimonials/word-of-mouth marketing Use our assets as a founding member of the Jr. NBA Flagship Network to reach local families ECO System Use our current contacts to inform local organizations that we are available to assist with court space for practices, games and team events. Some such organizations would include: Local CYO Parishes Local Club & AAU Basketball Teams Local Club & AAU Volleyball Teams P.A.L. Leagues K-12 Athletic Departments Special Olympics/Unified Teams Work with our contacts at the Golden State Warriors to bring their camps to Dream Courts MANAGEMENT APPROACH & METHODOLOGY 13

Annual Budget Summary Gross Revenue $966,000 Total Expenses $830,976 Net Revenue $135,024 PROPOSED BUDGET & CAPITAL ABILITY Below is a sample budget for the Dream Courts facility. Given our experience running a similar size facility in the Bay Area, we are very confident in our ability to accurately project revenue and expenses. Our current facility operates at an annual net profit and has done so since its first year! Additionally, we are in the unique position to save on a number of overhead management costs, as we will be able to expense them across multiple facilities. That said, this budget is intentionally conservative from a revenue standpoint. This ensures us that the facility can, if needed, sustain itself in the worst-case scenario of having to rely mainly on court rentals as the main source of income. Creating the model this way allows us to ensure annual profitability. Below is a sample budget summary showing annual Net Revenue. Please see Appendix A for more detail. 15 CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE CITY OF PITTSBURG We are aware that this facility needs to contribute financially to the City of Pittsburg through one or more of the following channels: Establishing events that generate significant T.OT. Tax contributions Establishing events that generate additional Sales Tax contributions Paying a monthly lease/rights fee Revenue/profit sharing There are numerous ways to structure contributions to the City. And, with many other deal points still to be determined through a healthy and collaborative conversation, we believe it is in the best interest of both parties to wait until the negotiation phase to determine the best structure for this partnership.

APPENIX A DETAILED BUDGET - DREAM COURTS 16

Showing the first 24,000 of 48,562 characters. The full document is at the source.

Just every now and then, some of it, if I wait for my family, that I'm going to retire in my own coffee shop. They got me all for this bar in the evenings. Look just like dress for it. All right. Welcome, everyone, to the Life Enrichment subcommittee meeting. We're going to get started. Thank you, everybody, for your patience. We'll start with item number one public comment for non agenda items. Are there any is there any public comment? Will you allow me to speak on that? To me, the importance then will you do it when the topic comes, when the topic you think you should to any interview on that you just had to wait 30 seconds. Okay. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Bruce. Also Pittsburgh's Mr. Bicycle. The bicycle community in Pittsburgh requests that when the green cords open, we take the curb in front of small in front of John Henry Johnson Park, ready to prohibit parking there so that the bicycle lanes can be maintained. The bicycle community also requests that we build a bridge over the canal to connect to the Delta. D ends the trail via the paved maintenance road for the canal, which is on the other side of the canal from the from John Henry Johnson Park. We removed the crosswalk at John Henry Johnson Parkway. Just Bronte explained to me that we removed it so that people would look both ways rather than seeing, Oh, there's a crosswalk, I'll just start walking across it so it's safer. I fear that we're going to get somebody off by a car on West Cleveland Road because there isn't all that much heartache. And this is a big, fancy, nice facility. We're going to get a lot of people there. So connecting to the Delta at the end of the trail that will allow people to bicycle from our BART station on an off road path all the way to this site. We could advertise that as a good thing. And if somebody gets killed by being hit by a car while they're crossing West Leland Road, I fear I will get a bridge over West Cleveland Road also. But I'm I'm I figured that that's what it's going to take to get a bridge over West Cleveland Road to across the street. So thanks very much for allowing me to comment on this. It is a life enrichment subject that I'm just brought up. Thank you. All right. So for two, a courts request for qualifications. Very well. Okay. All right. Deferred during the courts is a $9 million cutting edge indoor facility, 45,000 square foot of indoor gymnasium, five basketball multi purpose courts. And there was a groundbreaking held in September of 2023. The facility is going to be located inside of John Henry Johnson Park, which is located on Leland Road across the former football. We put out an RFP for an operator of the facility. What we were looking for and the recommended for an operator were three things, not more than three things. But essentially these were kind of the three areas that we really want to focus on, which is experience, experience and operating a similar facility enhancement enhancing public offering and maximizing event activity and operating efficiency and blend of the lens of tournaments, different sports, open gym rentals, birthday parties, because we want to maximize this facility available as potential based on the RFQ because it was I would say a marquee is a market which is a request for qualifications based on the Q This is the timeline and speed of activities currently we are in. Right or down here we can see we're somewhere in between that we're a little bit behind schedule, but we are anticipating to move those right along from this based on the recommendations that happened today. So with the process, we had two firms attend the PROPOSERS conference and that was something that the Council had brought forward that one of our other are fees that we did earlier. So we've made that kind of standard to do a proposers conference for all of our P's and Q's that we do. So we had two firms attend that conference. We have three firms submit. One firm withdrew after the deadline, and then there was a panel that evaluated two submissions based on the following criteria was identified in B, R, and Q, Operational philosophy, management structure, our experience and qualifications management approach and methodology for those budgeting capital ability and a facilitator made up the panel. The panel was comprised of staff and the community, so there was you want the names or I know just was where they came from. So you had recreation staff, you had staff from economic development and planning as well as community representative who had A background in B, c, y o, c, c, And then on day one we had one other panelist that wasn't able to participate. It was one of them, Oh, sorry, and a developer to try to go around the table. All right. So in submission, ranking of the two firms, as you can see, they both scored extremely high in all areas. We it was very pleasant to receive two very qualified proposals were very qualified entities. It shows a lot about this facility. It shows a lot about our community that we actually have not actually, but that we have something really good to offer industry that there's a need. There's a demand, and that folks outside of our area are looking for this. So as you can see that those are the max points and where everyone scored and again, these are average points. Thank So recommendation and next steps the staff is recommending that firm be is the most qualified to take this on. And what we would like to do is begin negotiations on agreement for operations, go for the proposals shared with the subcommittee and give a little background for the group here on the Hill. They're just looking at the proposal. We're actually part of the overall agenda that I was just tuning in. Yes, watching this, I'd be like, okay, turned out, does anyone know what was proposed? Okay, let me pull the market because I don't know any subsequent. But it's just you can say this has been a document. Both documents were shared with the subcommittee. They are fully aware of what were in the proposals for both A and B and certainly what I heard feedback from the panel members that talk to me were that both firms are excellent selections, so there wasn't a wrong choice election, whichever way. And it was a difficult decision to really figure out what when it came down to what is it each each in its own right, it basically stood out and one of the reasons, again, based off of the the overall average and then even just community mindedness and really making sure that the corporate community is why selection why recommended the over in question that we do have actually representatives from both from A and B and the audience. But if there's any questions that you might have your question I think I had a question around the and this is for the markets. But yes, the length of experience in the area of operating again for a facility like this, well, it's been in operation. You started in Oakland back in 2013. So 11 years I've been to see 13 year operations. Okay. And over a decade, obviously in 2015. But but had been operating for companies since before that. All on March one, we were able to create a business that's scattered throughout the area and programing. So there's that. And then we are both local. So, you know, the Bay Area. So that's important to think about our demographic here and questions about that. And then are you going to talk about next steps or. Yes, so next steps is South would like to begin negotiating negotiating with a firm be okay. And what we would do is we sit down, work out, make sure we understand fully the economics, the the agreement, bring it back to the subcommittee or concurrence and then take it to the full council for adoption. And we are unfortunately, but fortunately, the construction is taking longer than we wanted with someone who wants to be under construction by now. So we have a bit of time to work that out. We were hopeful right now we'd be looking at almost finished building, but that what happened is upon evaluation, we originally were on the west side of John Henry Johnson, moved over to the east side. The east side is lower and what we would like to build the building is the way the water would run into the port and use the water and basketball courts as a bad thing. So we figured, you know what, Let's go through an engineer. So they're actually going to be built on top of where it is now. So that way we don't have to worry about any water intrusion going into the creeks and, you know, or having somebody apple squeegee, you know, we just pulled out. So that's what's caused the delay. We're still targeting trying to get it done by the end of this year. That is what we're talking with the developer who's, you know, has the contract with the contractor and everything ready to go. And as we know, this developer can move dirt quickly. So adding five feet shouldn't be an issue because it will go from the old golf course and just bring external. Well, I'm excited. I know you have to know that sign on Leland. And I'm like, Oh, you coming? So this is nice to see the progress toward that. So this is the arc we want you on our P. This is the So Still learning center how we proceed the one at first and the other in great question what we we're really going for here as staff recommended to the council we wanted qualified entities to run this. It wasn't a who's going to be the cheapest or anything of that nature. It really was what we wanted and what we are two excellent firms that have experience running facilities, which is also a plus. The last thing we want is somebody to come in. We just say, Oh, sure, I can do this, you know, where do I put it? This, you know, we want something to look as good today as it does ten years from now. And what's great is both entities have that experience where the panel went and into both and got a feel for, you know, their facilities. So again is that's why we were trying to get qualified. We want to make sure they understand what it takes to run a facility also bring in tournaments have there's you know, community elements. You know, we don't want everyone just sort of drive by. We wonder what's in there. So and that's really what came across and what has been relayed to me. You know, some of that programing, local programing is what looked to be higher than from it kind of all over again. Not saying, well, I don't have any questions. I trust the panel. I know the panel went through some extensive research. So I be you guys made a decision for whether we'd like the recommendation for you to so that they will go back to me and say, all right, let's sit down. Let's get this done. Let's and then bring it back. And ultimately the council right now we want to move quickly just so that's all lined up and during construction, if there is any opportunities for that firm to go, who was there any way you can make sure either this should be here or let's make sure, you know, they can be a part of the process, which is nice going into this. From my end, I again trust the panel opposed the information passed on to us prior to this meeting, and I feel comfortable and confident that the panel made a good decision for the residents. So, yeah, okay, that's recommendation. Yeah, I would agree. And I appreciate the rigor around, you know, having that both the conference, the board just kind of laying out what you're looking for so that they could make a good showing. That's obvious when you look at the way that it's been scored and we appointed about what the strengths were. So I really appreciate that and I appreciate what collected by trying to make it. Maybe we're trying to get away from maybe somebody may know one or the other. We were trying to give it as much of a fair and balanced review for tomorrow. I don't know which ones they're I don't know. But three, I don't know. I'm over here. Ten or 12. Yes. You know, 50, 50. All right. And we will continue on o program. No, I just didn't like the topic. I apologize. We'll go over to item 38 Cultural Diversity initiative. Other than copies of these or these are just a handout. These are that we wanted to share with you and certainly explain to the two of to the Tudor confirms we will be getting in contact with you tomorrow. And so you're certainly welcome to stay, but you don't have to stay through the other agenda item. Okay. So much of the time, I think it seems like a good game name. I am bringing this item back. Culture and diversity Initiative. And just to recap, this was a huge agenda item requested by the City Council in September of 1920 to 2022, and they wanted to explore the possibilities of creating a culture and diversity initiative board to provide criteria and processes for local organizations to seek assistance for funding for future events and staff research. The costs for local organizations, utilize city facilities to host up or launched local culture on diversity events, as well as alternative ways for the city to support the promotion of the local culture. Because of the events to various media available to the city and staff, findings were presented at the 1994 Subcommittee on Public 21st, and currently the city promotes events on its media platforms such as Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and the city's digital science. And we also promote events and activities on the city website, as well as on the many monitors inside a city hall and at the Moda Center. And for this service that is provided by the city typically do not charge and fees and the organizations are required to provide the artwork and the narrative and our cost to staff time, which is $110 an hour according the masterpiece schedule, which is already included in the Recreation Department's annual budget after staff did the research. As you can see on this slide, we presented three options that the subcommittee could consider and making recommendation on. And option number one was for organizations to apply for national assistance and begin allocated thousand dollars from the general fund plans program and organizations could receive up to $500, and this would assist not 20 organizations if the maximum amount of $10,000 is given. And option number two was for organizations to do a plan for the use of city facilities and the value of the I'll give you this may not exceed $500. So that will be discussed, which is rental. And again, we will be using general funds to allocate $10,000 for this program and this again will assist for 20 organizations if the full value is given. And option number three was for organizations to apply for advertising assistance. And the cost associated with this effort is four start time. Option three is actually already being performed by the city's outreach coordinator under the equation Department. In order to make a more informed decision, the subcommittee's requested for more data and along the lines of the subsidies and other costs made worse. The city currently offers to almost all the nonprofit organizations who want events and activities in Pittsburgh and based on their request and on this slide and the next slide stop listed the events that would qualify for the category of the culture and most of the oriented activities and listed the department's who supported these events, as well as the subsidies awarded to them. So the subsidies would be the the VEBA also forbids the planning fees, the rental of the facilities as well as staff time because you can see it was recreation and then they would all stop playing. But those costs were actually absorbed by each individual department's perspective of budget. So we've been provided subsidies for over $22,000 for those events that would qualify as cultural and events for the fiscal year 2223. To go back to the presentation on February 1st and March 20th, staff presented three options to the subcommittee as shown on this slide, and that would be option number one to provide financial assistance and allocate 10,000 from the general fund. And option number two would be to provide facility use assistance and allocate $10,000 from the general fund. And option number three would be to continue to provide assistance at the events that we have been doing currently to continue the same practice and now seeks recommendation based on this data that things would appear this to bring this full circle. Member Lopez gave us direction, but it was a meeting that you weren't available for. So in discussions with council around which that can you please just bring this back, just so we can make sure both of you have input at the same time? We just didn't want to not have full subcommittee members. So that way little bit of your mind. All right. I'm pretty much already weighed in on this one. I want to make sure that that's acknowledged as long as you a try to hold that. So thank you for showing me and make you so right now. Yes. Okay. I just wonder if you want me to switch or not. Oh, okay. I appreciate the table because I the last time we looked at this, I couldn't tell what we were spending. So this recommendation would save us money as a city. And secondly, technically, yes. So we would be creative and can pretty much nonexistent be all right. I think we come up with this one or the one before the one before that one. Yeah. So technically the overall budget would be reduced to 10,000 because what we've shown has shown is what we spent last year for events. You know, there was a one at one time that money was set aside, but people were asking so often that we ran out of money quickly. So we kind of, for lack of a better word, kind of choose to see what's the most benefit to the community. That reaches a lot of people. Obviously, we promote cultural culture and diversity in these amazing events. So as I mentioned, all of the efforts are absorbed in each respective budget depending on who's providing assistance in this format, it's more formalized. We'll still have to apply. And so we were proposing 10,000 and what Councilmember Lopez and I get why she said it, because she wants to promote our facilities, which is great, as you can see, you know, facilities are being used on the planet. They are air. Yeah. Depending on the event and I'm not sure how many calls it gets, but I think the city manager's office probably just call for two. It seems like a four facility or just helps. A lot of times it would be we're just wonderful folks or we're going to use bottles. And so it may not always be a facility that they need to help or renting. It may just be we're holding an event here, right? One could be what on MLK when we sometimes would start out out front, you know, and then walk over to the school. Right. You know, know how do you know? There's not really a facility charge, but you know, so how do they get a band there? It's right there. Yeah, but sometimes you'll have to monitor that. I to and mind you, these are these are definitely not true costs. These are. Yes, We kind of just kind of look like how many officer and I'm just put together and said, well actually are these substantially. Yeah it is a true cost. No I mean on the on here is not this is not because we just estimated Yeah it's what the time is for staff. Yeah. Different people are paid their level like in a public place to sit up and to take down. And in order to get this list together we have individuals sometimes provide escorts. Yeah, no, I get you. But this program would bring an absolute cap, right? Or would there still be wiggle room or discretionary fees anyway, there's always room within the city manager unless the council sets a very specific qualms about that, obviously. So it doesn't go against them. Yeah. So option one, there's no facility for just giving them funds for something they want to do. Option two, they can use the money toward a facility, not necessarily for other types of expenses. Then option three is what we do already, which is advertising cost. So this is sort of like the when I look at this, are we saying I just feel like option three, if we're doing it and we have the staff, I would like to see that continue to support the groups if we're doing it already. And so I'm like, okay, but then are there numbers and relation to how much actually actually bills or that's what I'm saying this, this spreadsheet you're building on her time. Yeah, we build the time in. So currently there's no separate tab that would showcase the true expense for Ashley's time for early. We weren't tracking it that way because when our records her her time, she, she just records that she worked here. She doesn't record that she work an hour and a half. I'm doing this at just like PD has not They're recorded that they were 3 hours I know from the for the the traffic control and it could be five different CDs with five different rates because their levels of service or their levels are different. And if we were to choose option one or option two, would option three go away for the existing nonprofit benefiting from YO for going through the exercise of having a formal setup? Well, that was the whole point. And we would create an actual casino or advertising. I mean, anything we could get would be her hourly rate like everything else. Yeah, we reach out to the public and that is substantially by the hourly rate is where periodically the city updates everybody's hourly rate. It's like any business would as well. And we try and throw in all of those costs so that way that she would be or whomever it is would be charged charging their own, it would be a full burden, right? Yeah, that's the target. I know what you meant. But I think when I look at so we helped 18 organizations last year and then with this new subsidy we would help 20. So two additional ones. But they were caps, but they would not have as much money available. If you all are proposing a budget amount, I imagine that we know that we can afford this. This is not going to cause a hardship for us as a city. You are correct. How long were you doing that process? Yeah, 30 years at least that I can attest to. And there's never been controlled. Oh, it's usually been in the city managers or office where they kind of. All right, you know what you have? We've got this event going on. Once we do. So I'm having a hard time with it because we've been here for a long time. And so we've been doing this for a long time as a community. But over time, as we're growing, we do have to. It costs money to do these thing. Yes, there's there has to be a bit of a about rail. Yeah. Just so otherwise it just somebody could come back every week and say I want to do this, I'd like to do this. And you need a little bit of balance. Yeah. And the requirement is for them to be a nonprofit and open up the event for the community, Correct? That's the law. Yes. Which is why I want options here, because people are already asking for more events, as is from the city. Well, this would be a nice way to streamline and I'll be directly. Where does that leave people like the people that want to do the marches and things like that where they don't necessarily need a facility, but they want support. So so I was going to suggest you can do a blend. So if we know we're spending 22,000 was just round it for the sake of roving and looking at the city manager hoping it's okay, 25 let's say 25,000 at 25, use option one to allow them the option to use it for facility and or something else. Because like you said in marches, they don't want a facility. But at the same time when the money's gone, the money's gone, right? So you do either y or maybe even the nonprofit, the option, I'm sure, one, two or three. Yeah. And the other the other thing, though, the other part of this proposal to be able to distribute these funds to as many people as possible. Part of this proposal says an organization that receives funding will not receive it in the next round because you we want to give an opportunity to someone else. And t

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Life Enrichment Subcommittee
  • Life Enrichment Subcommittee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: d9e95eb42694fb595f593f2640385031. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record