POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, January 18, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 124,838 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch. >> District one Council vice chair, hopefully Curtis. District 2 Randy Gabbert district 3 and Mary. District 4 with that Hanna winds. And Council chair Deborah take Sanders. District 6 Gina Driscoll district 7 John Muhammad. And district day Richie Floyd. >> We're about to call to order the 1/18/2020 for City Council meeting beginning with the roll call. There it is you're ever. On to marry her and what's here. Sanders your school. >> Thank you we would minister it here. We now have an invocation by Bishop manual sites of Bethel community Baptist Church and following that we would have the pledge of allegiance to everyone join me in standing please. Good morning, everyone. Happy New Year. We thank you GOD for this day. It truly is a day that you've made. And we had joyful and glad to be in it. We come now asking for special blessing. Upon these elected officials on whom we depend on GOD to carry out the dna duties that govern us from the greatest to the small is from the oldest to the youngest from the richest to the poorest. We asked you bless their families. Bless their going out and coming in give them wisdom understanding as to what you will is for them and for us. We actually have a father to best everything that's being done and it shall be done to make this city a better one. We asked you have mercy on those poor and struggling. We asked will guide for the heartfelt compassion from those who are fluent we asked a lot that this meeting will bear that through. And then everyone both here and in the audience really satisfied that goodness and mercy shall prevail. We asked these blessings now in the name of our Lord and savior a man and. And to operate which it stands one nation. >> Missile with liberty and justice. Thank you Bishop Sykes for that wonderful prayer and we're so Presence. He also remembers we had before as an agenda. With the addition of cb 14 acb 15 resolution confirming Council and there are appointments in a governmental agencies, a city committee committees out entertain a motion for approval. We adjust with the additions now that we have a motion to second to approve the agenda clerk can you please open the machine for voting. Council members please cast your votes. Seeing that are present council members there voted can you please tell me that the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with councilmember gather be. Thank you council members now we have a consistent force today do we have any. No cars and no speakers in zoom in and zoom move can now that we have a motion a second to approve the consent agenda seeing that there are no requests for discussion and MADAM Chair. Re question speak, okay, but isn't I did have one common on the cb 2. Before we we vote, and it's just a good news item this is part of our tree planting to to plant trees and both the child's Park and around our our city and I'm glad we're moving forward with this. Thank you. Thank you councilmember by noon. Discussions there can you please open the scene from voting council members can you please cast your vote. The thing that are present council members have voted can you please tally in and that's the votes. I'm sure the motion to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously with council member Garrett being absent. Thank u next and we have open form clear can you please read the rules now. If you wish to address to the Council on subjects other than public hearing. Work items listed on the agenda please sign up with the clerk. Only the individual wishing to speak a sign that open for a seat. Only said his city residents owners of property. Business owners in the city or their employees may speak all issues discussed and open for must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you're speaking to an item on the agenda you MAY only speak once during the open form when it comes up on the agenda. North provide an opportunity for all citizens to adjust Council. Each individual be given 3 minutes to speak and after which the microphone will be muted. If you wish to address to the council through the zoom meeting us use the raise hand feature been in the zoom app or inter star 9 on your phone at the time the agenda item is address. When it's your turn to speak up and you did in acts to state your name and address at the conclusion of your comments or when you've reached a 3 minute. Time and that you would unit all raised hands will be lowered after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation use normal rules apply, including the 3 minute time limit on comments the requirement that any presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum fly public comment is disrupted by violations of the rules of decorum the chair is authorized to accept public comment by alternate means including my email only and I'm sure we do have speakers. So as a clerk who's going to call the names 2 of the time and we ask that you go to either podium and before speaking we ask that you identify your name and your address when you have 3 minutes to speak. MADAM Chair, first 2 speakers. >> Down the groom and Ron. Dinner a diner. Please go to the podium state your name and address for the record you have 3 minutes to address City Council my name is done lagrone a little 2620 13th Street North here in Petersburg and I appreciate the opportunity to come and talk to the council. Mere words stated priorities of providing below market rate housing avenues for energy wealth creation for descendants of the historic gas plant neighborhood. Are both lofty and appropriate I do not believe that the currently negotiated agreement with race Hines accomplishes either of these goals. The primary mechanism for creation of intergenerational wealth in our society has long been through homeownership through appreciation in home values over time. Residents of the gas plant neighborhood and their descendants have long been denied access to homeownership through redlining restrictive covenants and other mechanisms. The current raise Heinz deal proposes a billing. 1200 housing units at below market rate rents. Yet less than 50%. These would be designated for residents making less than 100% of the city's average income. No the units would be designated for purchase. After 20 years, the developer can sell the units at market rate reaping the increased value. Israel units with us failed to provide an avenue for Welsh generation to low-income occupants. She is re Heinz is not obligated to provide the housing during the early phases of construction. If this fails to address the city's acute need for low-cost housing. It should be amended to demand the below market rate housing be constructed at the beginning of the project, not overreach duration. It should also provide a mechanism for home ownership by all occupants. What's more none of the unit should be available to those making more than a 100% of the city's am I. The current agreement allows race Hines to opt out of building any or all of the affordable units instead paying a poultry penalty of only $25,000 per unit not constructed that penalty should be set at the actual cost of construction. The current proposal, this fails to meet the needs of St. Petersburg for low-cost housing Northam mayors objectives and should be renegotiated. Thank you. >> Good run diner I live and break waters Boulevard. I'm here again as a concerned member of our Kunz of our community concern for our best interests. I think it is crucial to revisit the key points of the rays Heinz deal. I am concerned that is a misconception circulating including among some City Council members that this deal it's a billion agreement with the rays paying half. Leaving the city and the county responsible for the Dist the difference implying this is costing the city $300 million. I believe it's essential clarified that the actual cost of the city's one billion of taxpayers funds and $800 million of the county funds $2.4 billion. The city is barring with interest $700 million. It's also offering free real estate taxes which is going to cost us million and is providing free use of the property and to further attract attendees we're selling the balance of the land for a $105 million which is conservatively estimated to be worth anywhere from 700 million to $900 million. It only adds up to one billion in St. Petersburg taxpayers funds resources that would otherwise be available for so many other high Prairie needs inner cities. I think it is a essential to recognize that one of the other goals that we had was to honor the legacy. The gas plant and affordable housing which was central as well and then the proposed deal regarding race Hines they do not have to build one you did of affordable housing instead they can buy their way out of deal for $25,000 a unit. Well baseball is undoubtedly a civic asset and we want to keep it here. It can come at any cost does anyone think that having a stadium in this location creates more than billion in value. Acosta more than $25,000 per Saint Pete household. How on earth can civic pride be worth that much. This deal needs to be renegotiated. And if you think the public is in favor of it read what's in the Tampa Bay times today. There's an opinion piece along with letters to the editor, the public does not want this deal. And I feel strongly that your responsibility is to do what is in the best interests of the public. There's 2 speakers Rob David Dahl and Peter Kent. Please go to the podium state your name and address for the record you have 2 minutes to address City Council. Good afternoon. Chairperson think Sanders and counselors. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Robert please Sir Robin David at 4, 8, 3, no ice for dry stuff. My name is Robyn David of and I'm a member of the social justice action team at the League of women voters in St. Petersburg area. We have studied this project and consulting with community partners for the past 12 months. We have read economists interview journalist and studied other cities with private stadiums financed by public dollars. I've included a copy of our published article in the catalyst in your packet. We are not opposed to a new stadium. We support the creation of a vibrant new neighborhood bar parking lot now stand but after studying the 2 term sheet and finance plan. We are deeply concerned with the consequences of diverting public dollars belonging to 114,000 families living in our city to pay for the current plan. And while some argue that tariffs tax increment financing in bed taxes or not not public assets. Economists disagree. MISTER Hippa rights in the Florida bar journal tiff benefits. Benefits private sector development with the use of public revenues, private development should not be supported by investments the public funds. Tips can boost economic growth at a cost of higher taxes to meet their rising costs. Professor Zimbalist an included his article for you that Smith College writes that the fact is that diverting taxes, including property tax tips and bed taxes create a fiscal hole that has to be felt either by spend lower spending on services or by increase local taxes each having a depressing effect on local economic activity. Here's the critical problem. Families working 2 jobs to pay rent and seniors on fixed income cannot afford to. Higher taxes for them means not being able to buy a house not being able to build generational wealth or for seniors giving up other necessities does our city have other demands the next 30 years. Well according to the sun is stormwater plan and I'm quoting. We will all have to chip in to build a more reliable and resilient infrastructure. If chipping in is a euphemism for paying more in taxes and fees then we need to be cautious and committing large amounts of public dollars to non essential activities. We urge you to carefully examine this lopsided deal and work to make it better. There is no hurry. The Baltimore Orioles just signed a 15 year lease extension to give the City Council in Baltimore and the Baltimore Orioles time to work out an equitable development deal. St. Petersburg can extend the lease entropic enough field and do the exact same thing for their taxpayers. Thank you. >> I'm Peter Kent, a resident a kidney Petersburg I'm grateful to have this opportunity to discuss rate ideal you I've had 5 discussions and the Tropicana field redevelopment issues with about 50 of MAY. Yes, but colleague to Decker college over the past 3 years. West winds e at the end of a 5th talks we asked you to Indies to pretend that they were City Council members vo yes or no to accept a great Heinz field. 92% voted to reject it. I emailed you my slides for that for your presentation. Last week. Let me summarize their key reasons number one corporate welfare to billion years in return on investments. There's a perception that of the proposed deal is essentially a one billion corporate welfare to the right rate times billion years from the city were minimal returned to the city taxpayer. To the land appraisal. Recently an sales there's a need for new land appraisal. Accounting for the current zoning in the surrounding the man and expected to bring the 90 this 86 acre land value to between 600,000,001 billion not a 105 million the richest putin 3 the rates low stadium investment. While the rays are nominally putting fight 700 million into the investment. For the stadium is reduced by the expected 600 million that they received from the stadium naming rights over 30 years meaning that their net investment is a 100 million versus a 600 million from the city County. For the economic impact, there's a lack of historic. Employment or housing demand Jen off from the current stadium, which is supported by research on a 130 similar stadiums legal considerations, the cra extensions required that the downtown district be considered to be slighted slum or blighted there's no way that the downtown can be still considered slum are blighted. So there's no way that the district can be extended this means that there's million of downtown tif taxes that are into paying off these bonds are not going to be available because it's not going to be legal. The city is acting as a master developer. The city continues to own the land and sells the parcels to the Heinz one of one of the time. When you have Heinz It also is paying a million worth of infrastructure on this project which is normally the developers expense. The city is the developer not Hines and yet Heinz is walking away with half a billion dollars of developer profits on this public opinion. He respected 82% of voting against it and and other polls are showing you people. Similar dislike for this project and I'd like to speak on the House and get out you time. Next the speaker's MADAM Chair, Peter Flynn and Catherine pelley. Please go to the podium state your name and address for the record. You have 2 minutes to address City Council. My name is Pat flaying that Peter fine my address is 12 oh one 86 Avenue North. I will go to the Unitarian Universalist congregation in Saint Pete, which is a member of fast in St. Petersburg we have an affordable housing crisis for families earning under 80%. Am I families who make less than $65,000 a year. Can't afford to live in the city anymore. Every week I hear that another member of my church who has had their rent raised between 5100%. They are making the hard choice to leave Saint Pete. Every year fast holds a big gathering that we call the Nehemiah action. This It will be in Saint Pete at the First Baptist Church on Gandy Boulevard on Tue. Apr. 30th at 07:00pm. We have invited mayor Welsh and we'd like to also invite all the Saint Pete City Council members please be present to show that you want to be part of the solution to the affordable housing crisis. At the mayor's event night out in child's Park on Dec. 5th. He told multiple members of fast that he was willing to meet with us and you feel about the affordable housing crisis since then we've sent him a letter on Dec. 21th suggesting 2 days to meet with him. We called his office. We were asked to fill out an official meeting request form we did all that we've called and emailed him and his assistant multiple times, no reply. We even met in person this week and was told that the mayor's assistant was not available and we left another message, no reply. MISTER Curtis we'd like you to be our representative since the mayor is not here today to help us secure a meeting with mayor Welch we have offered 2 days that he's tells us he would be willing to look at but no reply. So we'd like to give you a call after this meeting to follow up so you could help us secure meeting with him please do thank you. >> Thank u next speaker is Good afternoon. I'm Kathryn Philip Ellie. I have lived in St. Petersburg at 5836 30th Avenue North for 30 years. I have lived in Saint Pete for 44 years. When I came as a Catholic school teacher making only $10,000 a year. My rent was a $150 for furnished little apartment across from admiral Farragut if I were not to sign the entire lease. I would have had to pay $300 during in-season just for my internship those prices do not exist anymore. I am a member of fast for the past 19 years will be celebrating our 20th anniversary. My congregation of Saint Matthews even though it's in largo I drive across parish boundaries to worship there. We have been a member of fast since its beginning. All of us have heard and no we are in a crisis state for affordable housing. Appeared at Saint Joseph's Catholic Church before he ran for his office to be elected. MISTER Curtis was there present. We asked him will you commit to a number of affordable housing and have it in perpetuity he said you know the former mayor I think he said 2,500. I'm going to double that. Well that would be 4,000 or 5,000. We have yet to see it in writing or confirm in a meeting that he is willing to stand by that that's why we are again here asking for your influence, your pressure, your awareness, your stamina to make things happen. MISTER Curtis, those dates again are Feb. The 15th and Feb. 20th. One is a Thu. Night, one is Tue. Night that is Feb. 15th and Feb. 20th we're going to do it after hours so at Bethel community Baptist Church at 07:00pm. Again that letter was sent to him back in DECEMBER and we have tried numerous ways both in person electronically to meet with the mayor. I understand he's the decision-maker but I also know that you are decision makers as well. We need you to stand up and to advocate for affordable housing. 80% am I for the penny money that has been allocated. And that the building is in perpetuity. We expect you to rise to the occasion and make this happen. And I look forward to seeing you at the Nehemiah action on Apr. 30th that bus. Next to speak out and share dealing games in Jeremy tobar please go to the podium state your name and address for the record and you have 2 minutes to address City Council. >> Hey Council my name is doing games. I'm not 1, 2, 0, on doctor Martin Luther King junior Street North. I'm a face in Florida here on behalf of progressive people of faith and rent burden residents in the city. Thanks for chance u's open forum to use our voices I spoke last week about the community benefits advisory Council on the good opportunity we I just want to come back today and say that I'm a little bit worried about the application of this project. >> I think we all know that the 4 members are chosen for the committee isn't quite a representation of people out might have lived in the gas plant when it was originally raise and people that live in the area now I also want to bring up that the community benefits rising Council can't even speak to community members right now I understand there's some obstacles of that as well. And so many council members don't understand the deal very well or understand what they're there to vote on. You know expressed fears that most of what they're talking about is already baked in set aside and also funding for the stadium is being. Barred from discussion of these meetings even though construction jobs and other benefits from the construction of the stadium are being considered community benefits so it's just I worry that like the last thing we want to look like to the rest of Florida is performing as right where the only I said this last week for the only city that has gotten something so precious and special entered and our municipal court and I worry that we'll squander it if we don't if we're not careful process. So I'm not a lawyer but with within whatever constraints. You all are and please be creative in the following 2 things take into consideration. The input gathered in DECEMBER and the major tease from your Advisory Council that overwhelmingly Leanne against the currently proposed report impact reports when you vote on this story gets more redevelopment of spring. Secondly the cba sees being urged from within their Council to revisit a set of bylaws that might prevent them from talking to residents should any of you be involved in this process or you voting on this process. I urge you to consider that without information from the community without grass roots research and the narrative truths of people that live in the city. The advisory Council will continue to do the same thing that they've been doing for the last 2 Tuesdays which is sitting there confused day. Obviously have a lot to read and a lot to learn and if we can talk to them, we're going to spend for Tuesday's in those chambers with them asking endless questions about these impact reports. You've heard from us on the mayor's tours you've heard from us here on the stand for about a year you've heard from us and rallies and protests outside and you still find it important that we pass this project through Advisory Council. Residents are going to come into chambers again after months of making it clear where we stand on this deal I would really hope the city takes it seriously and you do all your power to vote in favor of the people when it comes to this redevelopment thanks for your time. My name is Jeremy to relive it for 17 lead away snow. Olay's gentleman, the council it hopes of revitalizing the downtown this area took a huge leap of faith we built the stadium without even having a team to occupy it. Some will claim that the effort was a success. A downtown cp has gone through a huge transformation to become a city known for its arts its food and more. However the team is also profited immensely growing from million to over a billion in valuation. The proposal in front of you now disregards all of that good will and effort made by this area and its citizens. Before the currency MS. Even fully paid off the city is being asked to go into even greater amounts of debt for 30 more years. This team wants even more money to be diverted into their profits. They want exemption from paying taxes. They want exemption from paying rent and they want huge discounts on city-owned land. And reasonable proposal would be one that requires the team to now pay their fair share of the building the taxes and the land being asked for in this proposal in an overwhelming amount of the people who would be paying for this new building agree that the current proposal is in no way a fair deal for them. The stadium will spend almost its entire life vacant and empty. The busiest a teams in the nation might coast 3 million fans this season. That's roughly the same number of customers a walmart Supercenter serves in a year. And while we can debate the value of the stadium to the community. It's absurd to seriously maintain that it's an investment that deserves billions of taxpayer dollars. I strongly urge all of you to stand against approving this proposal as it's been put to you and that's a decision that safeguards all of us who would call Saint Pete home. Thank you. >> I think tears past Emanuel sites please go to the podium state your name and address for the record have 2 minutes to address City Council. That afternoon once again. I'm here to just talk about a few things that I hope will just be common sense. First of all many of you are elected by people who lived here for most of their lives. Generationally and now those people who voted for you, I'm not being represented fairly and justly and so they're being forced out. I'm not certain if the people who are moving here at the expense and expediting of the city. Well even care about your service going forward and that they elect more who will rubber stamp everything that's going on. The second thing is I'm one of the founders of fast. So that means for more than 2 decades. I have been a part of trying to get the city to be fair to the poor and a grant housing for people that were in need more than 20 years. And yet. We've seen. No results. One of the sit downs with the mayor and with the commission was to ask for pennies for Pinellas some of that to be set aside along with land for future building. Think about the agony. Hundreds of millions for billionaires. That's got to be one of the biggest mistakes. And remember billionaires in business to make more begins. They really don't care about this city and the fate of the poor. Another irony is the city owns the property. Now we know how they got it. But they only and rather they using that to me the vast and growing need for housing for people. If you we don't have the industry to support the kind of jobs that the buildings are. Now going forward now now being created but just a. There is a let of luxury apartments and kondo's a unit. They're building it didn't deliberate speed. And yet the poor those persons, 16,000 on the housing road. Having to wait and see just what the future's going to hold. The last thing I'll say is this I have never refuse to allow a candidate to speak in Bethel because we are voting church. Imagine how I feel now allowing people to get up and make promises. That makes me look. >> We're now close open form and move to a league items beginning with items I one and I 2 and joining us is assistant city attorney Ken mccallum. Good afternoon everybody. I'm here today and the 2 items for you these are both from the legal department, the first one I won this is a involving a workers compensation washout claim from former employee a ruse. MISTER News kyiv was a police officer with the St. Petersburg Police Department and he was injured on the job back in NOVEMBER of 2021. The struggle with the suspect rented up injuring his back resulting in surgery. He later was to have a service connected disability, it was granted in Mar., 23. He no longer works for the Police Department he has since relocated overseas and has had to come back to the states and at least 4 occasions for further treatment. None of the workers compensation rules ultimately we MAY be responsible for that. It's estimated he will need at least $289,000 in future medical treatment I should add MISTER What is key in his 30's and furthermore he's going to need a lumbar fusion it appears in which case permanent total disability is likely to be granted by the courts which would be over $1 million in future exposure over the course of his life. We've been able to resolve this case fairly washout settlement of $75,000 which encompasses attorney's fees and get him off of our books going for approval, second. Motion a second front item I one thing no further discussion clerk would you please open machine for voting. Now some members please ensure votes seeing none all council members present and voting can you please to announce the vote. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve agenda item I one passes unanimously with councilmember gabbard being apps thank you. Thank you all move on to the next item which is I 2. This is the case of Terri Powell versus the city of St. Petersburg this is a liability It is set for trial in MARCH here in Petersburg in Circuit court. MISTER Powell's a 64 year-old gentleman who was on his way to work at 3 in the morning 16th Street 30th Avenue North. Unfortunately, one of our police Here's a red light there's a high speed impact. We previously had forwarded both photographs and video surveillance from a neighboring business which caught the accident on film. MISTER Powell has suffered significant injuries to his spinal column, there was a traumatic brain injury concussions he said subsequent strokes which are unlikely to be related to the accident. But ultimately this is not a case that we think is was trying front of a jury after mediation and numerous negotiations this case has been resolved under the sovereign immunity cap for 125,000 move approval second. Now that we have a motion to second fried to a requests to speak can you please open the machine for voting. Council members please count out cast your votes. We've seen it all council members have voted can you please town announce the vote. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve agenda item I 2 passes unanimously with councilmember gathered being absent. Thank you thank you, everybody appreciate you would now have item I 3 with assistant city attorney And good afternoon, MADAM Chair Council. I'm here to seek resolution the case in general and white versus the city of St. Petersburg this was an actually occurred back on Feb. Second 2020 a police cruiser struck MS. White the intersection of 15th Avenue South and 28 Street was a big impact and forwarded the photographs tree all $60,000 in medical bills out of pocket we could sell for 59 5. Both drivers were hospitalized and answer more questions. If you wish, but 9 bubble, second. Every emotion in second for I 3 with no requests to speak can you please open the machine for voting. Council members please found cast your votes. Now that I present council members are voting can you please town announced the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve agenda item I 3 passes unanimously with councilmember Aberdeen absence. Thank you. Thank you, I'm sure thank you counting. Que. We will now move to report items beginning with f. That has an a and b and we're asked to vote on a and b separately. And joining us is our capital improvements department city architect manager MISTER I will contend good afternoon Council. As the clock to prepare the. The powerpoint. >> Will be presenting both ef one and ef 2. Both of these are these resolutions are related to the same project. This is the deuce is rising townhome development and just so that Orient the public on this and the location of the site as you know and we've been involved in this project for quite some time. The parcels is 2.7 acres and fatality. Fronting on 22th. Street south to the east Fairfield Avenue down the middle and 23th. Street south on the on the West. So within that there's 2 developments that we designing one townhomes which is on the western half approximately 1.6 acres. Both Northside and Southside of Fairfield and then the commercial side all along the frontage 22th Street South. So just to give you a little bit of background and where we've been and where we are project started several years ago. Where we went out the solicitation of a design builder horse was awarded the work. But in APRIL of 21. We approved ahead City Council approved. The first step of this which was the partial design faced a preconstruction services conceptual design schematic design and construct ability review. That's part of that we were all so focused developing construction documents for the first gmp which was the roadway improvements right away improvements on Fairfield that First Amendment I was brought to Council in Dec. 21 that proposal was approved that work has since been completed. All those utilities serve both the town homes and the potential future, commercial and all that work was done in coordination with the 22th Street South redevelopment project so a lot of work went into that. Phase effectively the site hasn't been touched since then we've been working the balance of the design. So the second Amendment in MAY of 2022 Council approved the balance of the preconstruction services so with that we were off and running on the full design services for the combine Project at the time. It was both the town homes and the commercial element. So early on in the we received an initial gmp that really caused us to to pause and really consider you know where we're going with this project that the initial gmp proposal came in significantly over budget and I don't think I need to go into detail explaining why that happened and it happened throughout the construction industry in Tampa Bay, there's a number of reasons for it. The escalation and costs the availability of labor. So there's a there was you know a lot of concerns and in FEBRUARY of 23. We received a direction from administration. Tullow let's just focus on the townhomes let's move forward with that element of the work. Let's not. Pulled the commercial completely off the table but let's get the residential started so with that we focused on completing those drawings, receiving a gmp proposal which also came in significantly higher and for most of last years through the fall. We've been working very diligently with horse and our team and James Jackson, our project managers here as well to try to understand what caused those increases and try to come up you know just level set this project and make sure that we're doing all the outreach that we needed to do look at that the submarket's and all the reasons why these numbers with challenging to us and getting into the cost that we can reasonably recommend to move forward, which is where we are today so the gmp proposal has stepped through that in a second. So this this resolution there's 2 parts of this resolution. The first is the approval of an of the inner fun loan in the amount of 5,980 thousand from the economic stability fund and the supplemental to the deuces commercial project and the second part of this resolution is the acceptance of the gnp proposal for the 24 affordable workforce, townhome units and the amount of 13,126 thousand $98. A part of that resolution again the approval that this what's what will be the 3rd amendment to horse. And there's items associated with Second resolution, one is. Rescission of 750,000 from the general fund it's supplemental appropriation to the project and the second is rescission of 1.3 million. From the South Saint Pete redevelopment district the Southside cra the supplemental appropriation to the project as well. Orient you to the project and exactly what we're building the 24 townhomes as you can see an highlighted in yellow. These will be fee simple home ownership. Mixed makeup 2 bedrooms and 3 bedrooms for the of the 2412 will be 2 bedroom and the others will be 3 of the 3 bedrooms about 1700 close 1800 square feet. The 2 bedrooms about 1600 square feet. And so you can see the the the layout of the site with financial long Fairfield the rear of both of the parcels is where the park is going to be each unit has 2 spaces for parking. Our attention is a vaulted under the parking lot. So all of this has been now fully we're in for permitting here's a layout of the units themselves. Just to kind of step you on what are in these units these are designed as open floor plans as you can see a level one to the All the units have 2 and a half passes a half bath on the ground floor. Impact rated Windows it's designed to current code, it's got a residential fire. Sprinkling there's a walk-in pantry in each of these units. There's a convertible closet that goes is provided there to allow for a future lift ada lift if ever as needed those requests from the ada community. There's an enclosed rear yard open front yard. All of the appliances are energy star. Laminate flooring all throughout in of all of the as I said the windows and the doors are all hardened. We feel like this has been a you know the effort in the design with MISTER Howard architect and the team really has resulted in some units that I think will be you know This is an image looking to the east on Fairfield and you can see kind of the profile of what would be the commercial in the background. Here's a image looking to the West along Fairfield from the front. This is an image You know right on Fairfield looking directly at the units in the mix the each building. 12 buildings, each of the buildings have 4 units 2 3 bedrooms and 2, 2, bedrooms in in this building. So you can see what that looks like and then a street level view. And a view from the back so the rare will will be fenced the parking associated with each of the units. So just step into the gmp itself. I'm the the gop is comprised of a number of a broken element of the project for the cost of the work itself. It's about million. Then the general conditions which is the cost to to support the work from the contractor, their labor. The cost of you know the you know set up of trailers and all those superintendent inspections. That's at it and then the contractors contingency so there's a sub total of 11.2 million. And then the balance of the factors with a negotiated fee. The insurance professional liability insurance is required because of the design build component and then the performance bond for a total subtotal of 12,326 thousand and on top of that we've got a city can contingency that we put in all of our projects for an unforeseen conditions. 500,000 and 2 that we've also have $300,000 as an owner's contingency for the soil remediation now go into that a little bit more in the Report item but we made the decision to go ahead and include that work itself with horse. Her son's team we've got a contractor that we've already done. Established a relationship was a remediation contract is qualified to do the work and will step through that as well. So the 13 1126 thousand 98 is the total sum of the gnp and how do we get to the funding on The project appropriations today, 4.6 million has been appropriated and then just below that you'll see the available. Other sources are the general fund arpa 6.5 millions available. The requested fun transfer mentioned as part of the first resolution the requested transfer from the South Saint Pete cra 5 of the 1300 thousand. And then the requested inner fund loan of 5.9 8 million dollars to a total of 19.1 million. And the fun uses to date we've we've spent about 4 point $5 million that included the all the work on Fairfield including all the design. Both portions of the project obviously. And then you add to that the course gmp and then there's a number of items that we still have left in the forecast which we do in all of our projects we've got some utility work to still resolve. Both with Duke energy in some of the other servers. Our inspections for the soil monitoring. The cities just cause for our own project administration or inspections. Permit fees and then overall a contingency for the in its entirety so that we can make sure we don't ever come back in and we can cover all the anticipated costs here. So here's the plan to finance an Thomas is here to answer any questions as we get into the q and a section but effectively establishes you know the method of how to cover this long-term economic stability. And you know just a quite a bit of information here but as you can see based on the loan repayment from the sales at the bottom based on an assumption of what those costs could be on her arm on a per unit basis. There's about a net proceeds of million after the commission's that could its interest that would offset the loan from the economic stability, so this is just a real quick summary of that and will be plenty of time to go through it and then each of you have questions. Just wanted to kind of move moving forward on the project and how we are going going alternate least sell the parts of the town homes where we are today obviously wear asking for approval of gmp number 2 the next step is to execute the agreements get all of bonds and insurance which we expected to fairly quickly. Preconstruction meetings we've already had certain. Meetings with the construction manager and our remediation contractor. So the first the very first step is a remediation and we're only going to remediate the soil that's contaminated on the residential were not touching any of the commercial. The residential also is going to be done completely we're going to haul away the contaminated soil bring in you clean fill all of that it's going to be done before the contractor steps one foot and on the site and then construction looking to start in the MARCH APRIL time frame with the completion sometime in the next summer. On the sales of the homes and the Hoa I'm the homes will be sold to qualified first-time home buyers. Again the the split into Cepeda that's 50% at 80%. Am I and 50% of the units at a 120% in my household. The city's already contracted with a realtor who has already made some. Outreach within the community to pre screened buyers. The final outcome and qualification and underwriting to be performed by the city. The sale price is anticipated to be the lesser of the actual cost or the appraised value and down payment assistance or subsidies will ensure that affordability there will be a resale that they'll be in place to ensure the long-term affordability and the recapture of the investment and again we have a staff of any unmarked the can kind of go into the details of that and then the homeowners Association will will be required and so we've city legal has retained an Hoa attorney that's been assisting us with this and so that will have to be developed established as we go forward. So the next item report f 2 an amendment to the 5th Amendment to the stand Tech agreement effectively for the monitoring services associated with this remediation it's $80,590. This is continuation a number of. Of proposals and amendments that we've already had with stantec over the year to do all of the sampling all of the negotiations with the fdp the project is us has been submitted to the fda up and he's going through that that process of approval we've in source removal plan approved from the fdp for the residential. They are aware that this is a Remediation a lot of cooperation lot of discussion with the fdp has been going on the intent is that at the end of the remediation they're going to give us a certificate saying that we've got a clean site effectively so we're doing all those of us in the right way we've got to Subcontractor again as I mentioned that is the the amount of the the allowance which was initially. We feel very strongly that would be within that for the residential is now in the horse gmp and we've also been working over the last year on the brownfield site rehabilitation agreement. We have up to OCTOBER of this year to enter into agreement I think we'll we'll get there well before then but all of the costs associated with this effort from this calendar year forward will be eligible for Florida tax credit reimbursement. The tax credits something that is in the the statute with the d e p and it provides the city and any other developer. An income tax credit that could dent for us and for purposes of project in probably something that we would go back to the secondary markets and find the buyer for those however it does in the case of this project provides up to almost a 100% of the expenditure because there's his ability take into account. The fact that this is an affordable housing project. But there's a lot here we've got a lot of folks I can answer the multitude of questions myself and James been working on it on the design and construction side we can answer all the questions about the project itself. So with that happy to entertain questions. Thank you for the presentation we do have requests to speak councilmember Driscoll. Thank you and thank you for the presentation and the update that has so much detail in it really helps us to understand. Up to this point and where we need to go from here and why. If this had been. If we had from the beginning. They cost was going to be at this point now we we MAY worked on a different strategy from the beginning but here we are when I had my meeting with city staff too. Go over this and was given this change and this and the need was explained. I suggested that rather than burning over $7 million that. We look at this housing piece eerie to see if there is funding that would make sense to move over into this is that we wouldn't have to borrow as much. If any I'm glad that there were some that was identified so I appreciate city staff taking my suggestion and looking at that because this certainly aligns with the mission of the South Saint so I and I feel comfortable with is I have a couple of questions >> how much funding do do we need how much do you need for the commercial component of this. So we did not proceed to finalize a commercial documents okay. We by the time we started we were into schematic design had that initial cost estimate and I don't have the numbers exactly in front of me, but. It was significant as well and the fact that we were said look undrafted way and we we we really need to focus on what was most critical time. I could go back and see where we were on those numbers, but it's been over a year now and the numbers likely will change so I don't have a really good answer for that just yet. >> Yet councilmember and good afternoon City Council and if I could just kind of comment on that generally I mean I think as you know, when we heard from our speakers this morning, how important for double housing, instead everybody right and so that was the priority and that's why we set it aside at this point related to the commercial I think there's a couple things to consider one is the costs which will will have to come back to the others I think we really need to wait and see what happens at the gas plant there's been some with the community and the rays Hines team about maybe a minority incubator on the site at the gas plant. So that could impact you know what might happen here on this site related to the commercial so I think we're going to wait and see a little bit have those discussions go forward before we come back to Council and talk about a potential second part of this. >> Thank you I know that the Percy's from the sales of the 10 houses are supposed to go toward helping to fund that commercial component so. If we are going to stick with the original plan I'd like to see what that's going to look like because we're not going to be pulling in quite as much so we'll need a game plan eventually that I agree that it's an important to to focus on the the housing first is the greatest need and these are beautiful. They this we're creating. Eicher neighborhood that I believe people will be proud to live in the commercial aspect is important in the affordable housing game as well because it helps to build wealth. It helps you create jobs that allow people to for things like a moderately priced housing. Also with upcoming are ongoing and upcoming discussions on transit oriented development and changes that I hope are going to be coming soon to the zoning for this general area in the warehouse arts district that is going that puts this development in the middle of the next great Saint Pete's story. And it gives that access to transit it gives the access to jobs and once you once as we see that area build up develop into a more complete neighborhood then the folks who live in these town houses will have. Access to even more jobs as well as services and entertainment that don't exist there today. So this one of those rare instances where the city is a bit ahead of the game and looking ahead to the future making sure all residents have an opportunity to take part in it. With the so come take the remediation. And again I I understand that there's kind of a question mark on the commercial aspect but is there ever a case when. That's where contamination is a factor in any type of commercial activity. Food and beverage where so when you make that is there ever I mean I understand why we certainly we need clean. So for residents. But front commercial activity you've got people who are there for long periods of time. As well we're going to remediate the commercial we're not it's not that we're not going to do which is not going to be a part of this phase. It's still part of the fte p submission it's every we've got a very clear understanding of the limitations. And how far the commercial contamination has spread. The remediation standards for residential a much higher than commercial. So on the on the residential where we have to do certain things that on the commercial there MAY be other ways to handle it based on parking lots that would pave over certain sections so we will it once we know that the commercials going forward it will help us understand that section remediation and that's it for whatever reason the commercial doesn't go forward we would still need be committed to remediate that portion of the parcel for whatever use it will it will ultimately have so it's just not part of the current the current process. i thank you. >> for really good. The resolutions can they be taken up together do we need to vote on them separately separately a first empty okay thank you to now move approval of item f one a Thank you councilmember Floyd. >> Thank I got a couple of quick >> The first is about the resale restrictions just wondering if anyone can speak to that. Good afternoon council Mark vanlue housing development manager housing We are we haven't fully worked out the sale agreement, the terms for these units which will include the affordability restrictions but these units are intended to be restricted a minimum probably 30 year term of affordability restriction would be included in those terms. Okay assume that's like resale to someone to 80 or one 20% of them I based off of. Yeah we have to be resold another qualified Meyer. Or if it's usually is included in those terms is if the unit is sold on the open market. It the the investment by the city would be recaptured at that point typically we have a first right of refusal. So that we can ensure that is resold to a qualified buyer if that's what city wants to do at that point. Ok cool thank you for I want to something of the purposes been assessed recently like for the value of the land there. But a lot of utility updates and rehabbing. No it has not. Okay, okay. We can get that information to COUNCILMAN It's been a little while We've had the assessment and to be honest with you I I don't want to speculate off the top of my head on want it was it's fun of it, but we can get you the last phrase. A lot's changed since then even, but it'll be interesting to see that. You know without any land value looks like we're going to spend about $800,000 per townhome it's pretty significant price. I know you all are doing the best you can with this project and I understand the need for it. Going down that line is there any. Information yet about with sale price would look like. >> Yes I worked up a full spread of the sale price will ultimately depend on the income of the buyer and the household size and so will ensure that for h buyer each qualified buyer. The purchase price or that they will pay will be affordable to them meaning 30% of their income more or less for their housing costs and the subsidy will be adjusted to make that happen. So we don't ultimately know until we saw the units exactly what each unit will sell for what we did is ran the spread of, you know one per one person household up several person household. What those income levels are and what the sale price would look like and then we picked the basically middle of the road of that to demonstrate the numbers that state that the revenue from the sale of those units will be enough to. Reply from the economic stability fund. So it could be slightly North over slightly south of that also we're using today's numbers, today's income numbers, but by the time we saw these units will be into a years so those income limits will likely go up meaning that the sale price would also go up and generate more revenue market you remind us are right. Well, what does a price estimates were on the. On the spreadsheet that we should have words. >> And while I was looking at that COUNCILMAN Mark you can correct me if I'm wrong but it also depends councilmember on the interest rates. So if interest rates go down between now and the time of the sale that can also impact a salesperson to. So the the 30 to 80%. Am I with 60,000 down payment 223,000 that correct and the my with 60,000 down payment assistance be 317,000. Okay, so I'm sorry what was the first 1, 2, 10223,000 23. And 324 2 yeah. I mean those are reasonable prices that of just tell you though like the thing that I struggle with is that like it looks like a subsidy. Just on the cost of construction is going to be potentially $500,000 per unit. You know that could be that could subsidize 5 other affordable housing units on a different project and so. We talked about this ahead of time so none of this is a surprise for you, but it's like I'm struggling too. Say is this what's most impactful for our money I support like the generally in that. I think it's a good idea to put town homes in this area the way the project on this Ben admirable honestly, but I really like we have to just look back and say like is this the most effective use of our money to get affordable housing in the city. That's up right now and I know that's not a surprise If I could just respond to that council member just for all council members and for the public or anybody in attendance. We certainly understand where you're coming from. This is a significant subsidy, a more significant than what we would typically do. I think there's a couple reasons for that you know first of all 22th Street South is the historic heart of the black community in St. Petersburg there's been some progress made but not enough. This particular property has a history of failed development. For these reasons we feel that it's important enough for us to step in with taxpayer money to make this happen and that this can be a real catalyst. On the deuces and so based on the location and the failed attempts in the past. We think that the subsidy is worth it, although we certainly understand your argument your concern. Yeah I get that I I'd like to see us like. We've been committed to this plan for a long time and it came back to us with the higher than expected price. You know, I mean I would like to see us maybe pump the brakes see what else is possible at the site because I do agree the development at the site is important and this is the kind that we would like to do, but yeah I struggle with that the costs right now is really how I would like to leave it at this and I'd like to hear from our son my colleagues so thank you for answering my questions. Thank you councilmember hand once so first of all thank you for the presentation and for the one on ones before this because I know that I want to thank you first bringing the cost down from that 33 million I can only imagine the heartburn it's heartening for us now the 3030 33 million. Really been shocking to see that number. So I think you offer being diligent in trying to bring this down to something that's more digestible even though it's difficult. For those that don't know that this has been going on. This 2007. I think it's when we bought this land right. I mean my understanding is was it was purses with cbd g money for 2.2 million dollars back then nothing has happened is that I yeah that that's there was also I think some job Corps revenue in some cdbg money, but yes, generally that I write and then we have to pay that money back because. The jobs that were supposed to be created were not created and I'm just curious. The total money that we're putting into 19 million does that include the cost of the land that was paid or doesn't include that it does not include that said subsidies higher per unit and and I'm glad councilmember Floyd said what he said because that was exactly my reaction and we had this discussion it's 24 and the impact this 24 townhomes and that's a lot of money and how can you there's so much need and how can you spread the need to more people that city would have been more people there would I think been great if you want to create that an environment that is gonna help commerce and businesses and as we're talking about what's happening. You know further down south on 22th Avenue with the density in the growth in that area so you know having more than 24 County probably been a good thing to reduce the cost. But the the subsidy is higher than even the $800,000 if any including the land. Cost and whatever has been spent I mean from what I'm looking at the numbers that are here. So I I mean I just want to make sure that look at this point and some of us are late to the stance people only been on this for the last couple years. And that's what you do you and hear things and you try to make the best of what you inherit. But this is not something that can be replicated anywhere you can't you can run a business like this you can you would have money to pay for anything if this is how we paid for things to be impossible. So this is an anomaly I get the reason family to support it. But you know it's something that I think we all have to be conscious for we want to do the greater good. For everyone to provide affordable housing, but we can't do it at this cost that's what this does unsustainable. And I want to be clear that I think everybody in City Council pride when they saw the numbers were completely shocked but we're at a point where we have to do something with this and we're lucky actually have the arpa money the arc of money is helping us. We don't get are providing all the time and that's making this much easier to do so thankfully. We have million of federal money that's coming in because otherwise. I'm not even sure how it happened so and support it and I think it's going great, I want to see that area flourish but I don't think it's an approval of this is how we do business all the time and just why put that out there I I think that we all and I think that's what councilmember flu is saying we agree on on the purpose and the goal. But you there's no way you can get anything done if this was a cost every time you're that is. Your point is well taken and I want to assure you that we see this is an anomaly too. You know another property that could be similar is the safety college property where we're already working on an alternative route there as opposed to the route we've taken here. So I just want to say we do agree with and I and I know and I and for the record I know that when we had the one on ones I mean administration was that you are having a hard time with that than I get it because I know that it's hard to justify. I mean the private sector there's no way they're paying 800 to a million dollars per accountable. Because town homes are going up in my neighborhood for less than that. You know they're making a profit so they're not paying that for the townhome so anyhow that's my $0.2 so thank you for your work on it though thank you councilmember mountaineer. Thank you MADAM Chair and thank you Ralph for the for the presentation. I I just missed start off where councilmember him was left off because I'm I just just. The wheelhouse from for me to to get there just from a financial point of view. I do have a lot of questions and let me just start off by

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: d946372018e0523c8845fca1d60e4002. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record