POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Climate Resilience Committee Meeting

Monday, June 1, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Committee members proposed a greenway development program that would offer bonus height and floor area incentives to developers who build or fund greenway infrastructure. Additionally, members discussed a resolution to direct the City Manager to assess potential sites for 'sponge parks' to address flood management and urban canopy coverage.

Why it matters

These proposals would link building height bonuses to greenway and park construction, affecting developers and residents in T6, D-zone, and T5 transects.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 4, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 107,910 stored characters

welcome to the city of miami's climate resilience committee for JUNE 1st. We have a packed agenda and uh, the most people here that we've seen in a long time. So thank you for your attendance. All right. We'll get started with a roll call from our right. Good evening, grant musser., allison weinstock. Sadie perez. Aaron demeo. Wayne pathman pathman law. Ava jean. Nick atkinson. >> city attorney's office. Hi. >> sonya brubaker, chief resilience officer for the city of miami. Miriam flores for the office of resilience sustainability. Welcome, nick. And um and thank you to gigi who is uh, still here with us this evening but has served us for a while now. So thank you so much for all your service and help. So we'll move to item two which is public comment uh, which is limited to two minutes per person. If anyone here would like to make a public comment please approach. Hello good evening. I'm katrina morris I live in coconut grove. Um and I'm asking that the crc gets involved with the tree committee for chapter 17. Um some oversight would be greatly appreciated. Um I'm also really happy to to look at the the greenways and the sponge parks. Um I think these are real you know, I think that green infrastructure at this point, um the the verdict is in the studies have been done green infrastructure is cost effective and um creates benefits for humans mental and physical health and um really helps in an urban environment, um, to keep us, you know, breathing and drinking clean water and not flooding and not having runoff into our uh, bay every time it rains. So I appreciate the work you're doing. Thank you katrina. And just one moment we'll do another roll call for silvio please. Silvio pupo. >> casco. Thanks. >> good evening CHAIRMAN Members of the board my name is mel meinert. I live at, uh, on virginia street but I'm here representing friends of the commodore trail, which is the five and a half miles of potholes and death defying crosswalks through coconut grove. But we've also been an active participant in the greenways, uh, legislation that you're going to have that you're going to hear from today. But um, we are supportive but we want to make. I'm here today. We're very supportive of the of the effort, but I want to make it very clear and I would like the board to ask the city staff to make sure that on the record we have some very clear understanding of what is involved, especially with respect to ncd three that's coconut grove. We have worked with city staff to ensure we hope to ensure that the up zoning or the additional bonus height that is part of the greenways program has been cut out of the ncd three t five and below uh measures so that we are protecting coconut grove from being up zoning. We understand there's a trade off that we won't receive funding from that program, but that's an active piece that we're doing. I ask then that you ask the city staff to describe exactly where within the coconut grove area ncd three that up that bonus height would be available under the t six provisions of that uh of the proposal. So we're asking we understand that the bonuses are available only in t six which is a very limited set of properties. We expect then that they'll be able to produce a map that shows where that is. And those areas we expect are already in areas which have very high buildings and are fully built out already. So we most important is the priorities throughout the city of miami to protect the local neighborhood character because if we lose the local neighborhood character then what's the point of all these build of all this good intention anyway? Okay thank you. Thank you. Hello. >> okay. Hello my name is michelle yee. Um, do you need my address? Yes. Okay. Um office is 2937 southwest 27th avenue, suite 301 33133 zip code? Um, I'm I work as a student research assistant at fiu restoring florida's wetlands and seagrasses as such, I also work organizing youth in climate and environmental awareness through gen clio. It was fiu alongside uf that helped develop the urban tree canopy assessment in 2021, which promised to increase miami's tree cover to 30% and as soon as and as I am soon to graduate I wonder what the urban forest that was promised. And so with the hottest summers on record, compounding adequate tree cover is crucial for the well-being of the community across all sectors. And so I'm here to urge this committee to continue advising on tree protections as they are reflective of the climate crisis occurring at our shorelines and provide great relief to a landscape already experiencing record long dry seasons shorter and more intensive um hydro periods all at the mercy of developers and lobbyists. The city of miami's tree trust fund, once audited, was found to have not used the majority of allocated funds to meet its own law of using 80% of the fund to replace and restore miami's lost canopy 57,000 of that was intended for hurricane irma cleanup efforts, though it was never submitted. And so where did this money go? Commissioner pardo's office recently released a statement admitting to illegally cutting down 15 trees at one site for an alleged temporary pickleball court but was later discovered to be reserved for construction of of luxury units. This unfortunately is a failure of leadership and a severe lack of representation in one of the nation's top cities threatened by climate change. This is why we need the climate resilience committee's continued advocacy to ensure the city is following its own rules to protect our trees and so while immensely grateful for the creation of the tree committee, it is essential to be transparent with the public on the city's relation to its own tree ordinances. Miami is witnessing a slew of environmental indicators in the midst of many unprecedented and underreported natural disasters. And so as a as a citizen as a student I'm asking you guys to please represent us and thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Hello. >> good evening. My name is angelina alvarez. My address is 2937 southwest 27th avenue. So I'm here to represent. I'm speaking on behalf for those who cannot speak for the trees. So I want to tell a little story that time sure flies. About a year ago I was standing right here in the same city of miami fighting against changes to the tree ordinance that would have made it easier for developers to cut down trees. I remember the relief of the people when we left that room. They were happy because the commissioners listened to the constituents. Today I want to emphasize how important it is that we protect the tree ordinance and ensure that it is not weaken. Our canopy is under pressure and the policies are safeguarded need to stand strong. I'm asking this committee to continue leading on this issue to keep offering guidance, pushing accountability and making sure our urban forest remains a priority. I MAY not I might sound like a broken record but trees are essential for our living. They cool our neighborhoods, they reduce flooding and they give us shade on days when when heat feels unbearable which is a lot of days here in miami they are not decorations and they are climate infrastructures. That's why I urge this committee to take an active and formal role in the city in the city's tree committee and stakeholder process for chapter 17. This is just not a tree issue. It is a climate issue. One of your core responsibilities is to recommend political policy that helps miami withstand extreme heat, flooding and environmental degradation. There is no climate resilient strategy without protecting and expanding our urban canopy. If the city is serious about climate resiliency, then the crc must take an active role and demand the data most move the workshop forward and ensure that any further changes is strengthened not weakened. Miami's ability to withstand climate change. Every tree removed without accountability makes this city hotter, more vulnerable and less resilient. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Hey. >> I would stay later but I got to go after this. So albert gomez, district two resident I just wanted to thank for the consistent support of the crc around the biscayne bay marine health summit and it was a resounding success. Uh, and of course I got in the mail my two uh, my bay, uh, license plates that help fund restoration efforts. I think your waterfront authority has an important role right now right near aria on 22nd in edgewater. They had a massive discharge of waste into biscayne bay. We saw some beautiful manatees, a mother and her calf floating over the debris. I would like to see if maybe city of miami would take it personal since it came out of their outfall and uh and we can maybe send some people to go over there and clean that up as opposed to leaving it to residents. Now that said I, I went ahead and shared with MISS Flores um, a little document that I put together um on how to access the I build permit uh, guideline and how every permit has different codes that are linked within I build and the girgis system. Uh, it is nothing more than a query and referencing those codes. Uh, in general you don't need an individual code, you just need the code designator and a time frame and then you can pull all of the data that was requested by you with a unanimous vote to request that the existing tree removal permits and all approved tree removal permits since the founding of the tree giveaway program so that we can kind of balance and audit the true numbers that are that are canopies at right now so that you can have informed decisions ahead of your workshop. I really hope you guys set that into date and and thank you always. Excuse me albert, you said you shared something with MISS Flores. Uh, miriam. I am miriam. Yeah. >> I know when right now. Didn't receive anything. Right now usually has to go up to two satellites and then comes down but you'll get it in your inbox, I guarantee it. Um but thank you again. Thank you. All right. Um and there were any online. Oh let's do roll call hi jenny lee. Jenny lee molina. Thank you miriam we have online submittal. Yes. Okay. Just downloading it again to see if any additional came through and we do we have around nine okay. All right first one is from maria gonzalez. Um she says subjects on greenways benefit and as I read these along the way and if I MISS Pronunciate the words the name please forgive me. Okay going back and maria gonzalez first ones good evening chair and members of the climate resilience committee I'm marcy the climate resilience committee to become an active participant in the both the city's tree committee and the upcoming stakeholders process regarding revisions to chapter 17. The issues being discussed extend far beyond landscaping or esthetics. They directly affect miami's ability to address rising temperatures ,stormwater management, air quality and overall climate resilience. As the advisory body changes with advanced advancing policies that strengthen miami's environmental sustainability resilience, the crc has both an opportunity and a responsibility to engage in this process. Trees are critical infrastructures they reduce urban heat, absorb stormwater, improve air quality and help mitigate the impacts of climate change. Any policy affecting the protection, removal or replacement of tree falls squarely within the crc mission. For that reason, I was concerned to hear suggestions that the committee should remain on the sidelines of discussion involving tree policy. Miami experiencing significant canopy loss throughout many neighborhoods including the removal of mature, protected and specimen trees, residents continue to raise concerns about inconsistent permits decisions, questionable arborist assessments and a lack of transparency regarding how approvals are granted. This is where the crc can provide tremendous value before any meaningful discussion about changes are granted. This is where the crc can provide tremendous value before any meaningful changes can be made. Chapter 17 the tree trust funds contributions and the cumulative impacts on canopy coverage urban heat and flooding vulnerable data driven policies require data public trust requires transparency. The crc should also support the proposal tree workshops forward as soon as possible. The workshop provides an essential opportunity to staff, committee members and the public to review facts, identify trends and better understanding of the consequences of current policies before considering future amendments. If miami is serious about climate resilience, then decisions affecting the urban forest can occur in isolation. The crc should be fully engaged in the discussion, insist upon complete and public accessible information. Ensure that any amendments to chapter 17 strengthen protections for the urban canopy rather than weaken them. Every acre of canopy loss increases the heat exposure, reduces stormwater absorption, diminishes the city resilience and climate change the decision being made today will shape miami's environmental future decades. I respectfully urge this committee to take actions role in process and help ensure transparency, accountability climate resilience remains in the center of the of the conversation. Second person samantha wilson good evening, CHAIRMAN Of city of crc. The crc is both the authority and the obligation to be directly involved in the shaping tree policies in miami. I'm here to ask that you use trees as part of the peripheral concerns there are front line climate defense in chapter 17 must be treated as climate policy. Miami urban cavity b is under pressure. The tree rules are increasing oversight and consistent and the public has limited visibility into how and these decisions are being made. That has to change. The crc should be requiring city staff to produce complete transparent data on all tree permits and removals including species size, location mitigation measures, replanting commitments and tree trust fund usage and evaluate how the cumulative loss of trees is driving up heat and worsening flood risk across the neighborhood. The tree workshop cannot be pushed aside or delayed. It is a foundation of any current credible policy conversation before chapter 17 is revised any way this committee needs to see numbers, understand the trends and make that information available to the public through genuine community engagement process. Miami resilience depends on the decisions made in rooms like this one. Samantha no same person aurora al qaida as a landscape architect working on climate resilience public spaces in miami, I strongly support the sponge program. The initiative recognizes that parks can function as essential infrastructure managing stormwater, reduce urban heat and provide high quality public space. Done well, sponge parks can deliver multiple benefits for flood protection and water quality, improving biodiversity, community gathering and long term public health. I encourage the city to prioritize strong landscaping, architect designs, leadership, interdisciplinary collaborations and ongoing maintenance and monitoring to ensure these spaces succeed over time. Dennis tuno. Good evening CHAIRMAN And crc. I urge the crc to take active and formal role in the city street committee and ongoing stakeholder engagement. It looks like this was copied over again. Urban forestry is not a separate issue from climate resilience. It is one of the most important foundations of crc mission is to help miami prepare and adapt to challenges climate change including extreme heat, flood and sea level rise. Environmental degradation trees are among the most effective and cost efficient tools available to address these challenges to reduce urban heat, improve stormwater management, enhance public health and strengthen neighborhood resilience. For this reason, the tree committee works is directly relevant to crc responsibility. The tree committee provides experience on tree preservation removals mitigation canopy management while the crc brings a broader climate resilience perspective needed to evaluate how these decisions affect miami's long term sustainability, these bodies should work collaboratively independently to city considers potential changes to chapter 17 the crc should ensure. Ensure the dishes are informed by complete, accurate and public accessible data. This includes information on tree removal permits, protected specimen tree removal mitigation requirements, replanting efforts, tree trust contributions and the cumulative impacts of canopy coverage heat vulnerability flood also encourage crc to support moving the tree workshop forward as soon as possible before before policy changes are considered, both the committee and the public deserves an opportunity to review the status and understand the current trends, evaluate the impacts of canopy loss and climate resilience. I'm going to go to second page now. All right this is from jesse johnson. Good evening chair and crc. My name is jessica johnson I miami resident community organizer, the founder of miami canopy watch and the column that has grown into a citywide movement documenting illegal tree removals, permit violations, systematic destruction of miami's urban canopy in real time. I'm here because what we are documenting every single day is not just a tree crisis it is a climate crisis and the committee has both the authority and responsibility to act. I urge this committee to take an active formal role in the city's tree committee and community stakeholders engagement process related to chapter 17. One of your core mandates is to recommend changes to city code policy that will help miami withstand growing threats extreme heat flooding, environmental degradation there is no climate resilience strategy that does not begin with protecting expanding our urban canopy trees are not decorative their infrastructures and right now miami is losing them faster than anyone else in this room is willing to admit. When miami canopy watch is documenting daily mature trees removed without permits across every district specimen trees lost without independent arborist review no public transparency across our removal decisions are made and the tree trust fund with no meaningful public accounting. This committee must demand the city staff provide complete, accurate and public accessible data on all tree permits removals including the number, type, size, location, tree, every tree being removed, full accounting of mitigation planning obligations, tree trust fund obligations and expenditures analysis how these removals are impacting canopy coverage heat index flooding. without data there is no accountability. Without transparency there's no trust and without both there is no policy without having the plan tree workshop must move forward without delay. We can't evaluate chapter 17 recommend meaningful changes or engage the public in good faith without. First understanding what the data actually shows. I also want to address directly the suggestions that this committee should not play a role in tree policy with respect that position is indispensable. Every tree removed without accountability makes the city hotter more than food flood prone and less survivable for the residents who cannot afford to leave when the next hurricane comes next person lindsey kane. Hello. I'm writing and urge the committee to allow the climate resilience committee to have an active voice involvement with the tree committee. Removals in the city have actively increased temperatures and heat is being felt by the residents and will lead in the long term to health crisis in the city from mariella lopez it is. It is a must that the committee takes active and decisive actions to take formal role in the city street trust committee act stakeholders and engagement process related to chapter 17. This is real climate issues as well as our canopies and green space enabled to survive the reality of what is to come and level sea rise and city ignoring how to mitigate mindful and realistic flood flooding situation which most more soil, more shade and less cement helps in the process of sustained or someone reverse a process allowing rainwater and sea level to drain itself through the real soil and vast strong rooted trees. The community speaking out and are fighting hard to have the city and this committee to take a real look at reality, know the deep pockets of developers that come and go and leave the mess to citizens taxpayers that are that after taxpayers that after live with the aftermath not the developers. It is time we all work together in the process of development and being inclusive to our natural habitats and wildlife to learn that we can come together to build mindfully and soulfully. This is not hard to do just have the will and the generosity to do so. Sandy moise good evening crc I urge the committee to take an active role in city street committee and community stakeholder engagement process related to chapter 17. This is to this is not just three issues. This is a climate issue. One of our core responsibilities to recommend changes city code policies and will help miami withstand the growing threats of climate change extreme heat flooding, environmental degradation trees are one of the most immediate and effective tools we have to address those threats, which is exactly why involvement is essential. I was deeply concerned to hear that the member of the committee does not believe the crc should play a role in policy impacting our trees respectfully, there is no climate resilience strategy that does not include the protection or expansion of our urban canopy. Miami is facing a full blown tree crisis. We are seeing increasing tree removals including protection of specimen trees. We are seeing inconsistent in times questionable arborist reports and we are seeing a lack of transparency around how decisions are being made. Which brings me to the most critical of the crc must play the climate resilience committee must ensure the city staff provides all requested data on tree permits and removal complete, accurate and publicly accessible without data there is no accountability. Without transparency there is no trust and without both there can be no meaningful policy. The committee should insist on full disclosure removal permits and approvals data on the numbers, type, size, locations and trees being removed leave leave wrong word accounting of mitigation replanting and tree trust fund contribution analysis of how these removals are impacting canopy coverage heat flooding equality importance of crc must ensure that these planned tree workshops move forward without delay. We cannot evaluate the policy recommended changes chapter 17 engage in meaningful stakeholder process without first understanding the data and the trends and impacts. If the city is serious about climate resilience then the process must include crc and start with facts provided by staff reviewed by the committee in the tree workshop and shared with the public at the community engagement stakeholders process, the crc must take an active role, demand the data, move the workshop toward and ensure the future changes. Chapter 17 strengthen not weaken miami's ability to withstand climate change every tree removal without accountability makes the city hotter, more vulnerable, less resilient. I urge you to step into this responsibility. Thank you. Sandy moise michelle baptiste regarding the city of miami trees and threats to cut the trees I'm writing in miami residents to strongly urge the protection of our trees, especially the four native and threatening mahogany trees in edgewater. We must preserve these trees because they are in irreplaceable and provide more long lasting benefits and many made constructions ever will. These trees are valuable resources to cooling our cities, enhancing air quality, reducing hazardous flood impact and reaching the city of miami school 30% canopy over covered by 2030. We cannot lose them now or never. Thank you. We're done. Follow up question. You had a little time remaining on your public comment but can you make it brief? Okay I would like please the city to clarify if the greenway provisions for bonus height or density provide density or bonus height in situations where properties would not otherwise get it. Thank you. All right. Well thank you all for making taking time out of your day to attend and give public comment and get here through the rain and um you know, I think we we've we hear the comments and I think we should talk about them later possibly during open discussion, but I'd also just point you all to the meeting minutes from the last meeting where I read off a a direct message from melissa fernandez steers um, as far as the tree committee and its timeline and um and we can talk about that during open discussion and how we want to proceed. Is that okay? All right. So we do have a we do have a pretty packed agenda. Let's let's move to the next item then which is approval of our minutes from APRIL 30th to I have a motion to approve those minutes. Motion to approve. All right. >> and a second second. All right. All in favor. Aye. Any opposed. All right. Minutes are passed so we'll move to item four which are presentations. So we have uh two main topics tonight. The first is greenway benefits program. [Applause] Can you guys see the presentation on your screen everyone yeah okay awesome. Okay. Hi everybody. Good evening. Thank you so much for having me tonight. My name is samantha maldonado, uh, planner two with the city of miami planning department. And I'm here tonight to talk about some proposed amendments to our codes related to greenways. So these are going to be greenway development requirements and um incentives. So just to provide a little bit of the background of the benefits and the purpose obviously everybody here knows the benefits of greenways. They help connect the city. They provide alternative and recreational transportation routes, they improve public health and promote active living, introduce active uses and they also boost our local economies. So the purpose of the legislation here tonight is to promote um development along greenways to support greenway reinvestment development and construction and also to improve existing greenways. So here's an outline of the proposed amendments which I'll go into. The first is an update to the miami 21 zoning code. We're updating our definitions. We're updating the public benefits program and for the third one we are introducing new greenway frontage requirements for properties along greenways. And the second piece is an amendment to the city code. We have an update to the parks and open space trust fund um where we're going to clarify the process for the allocations and expenditures for contributions from um properties along a greenway. So the first update is greenway definitions we are just updating um a couple of definitions. So greenway and the definition of frontage in our zoning code um to basically ensure that all of these specified greenways are going to be available to use the different programs, uh in terms of the incentives and also that they are going to be required to comply with the design guidelines. And we're updating the definition of frontage to include greenway as a frontage type. Next going into the greenway um public benefits. So it's we're not exactly changing the benefits that are already existing in the code. Um so for the only transects under the zoning code this is impacting is t six also the d zone and t five. So basically um the program is to allow sites within a half mile of a greenway or fronting a greenway to um to receive these sort of public benefits like the bonus height and the floor area up to the allowed amount if they participate in the greenway public benefits program, which is either constructing the greenway in front of the site or paying a cash contribution now we're through this program. We're only allowing half of the floor area. So if you're a site um fronting a greenway for example, you can only do um half of the bonus height which you would normally be allowed through the greenway program. So you either have to construct the greenway or pay out and then for the remaining 50% you still have to participate in the public benefits program which is the normal program under miami 21 which you're allowed to use anywhere in the city. And here's a map exhibit I put together to show the different sites eligible for the greenway public benefits again the purple is the d one industrial zones, the orange is the t five zones and the pink is the t six. I wanted to address the concerns we had from public comment today um as they relate to coconut grove and cd three. So just to clarify we aren't changing anything that's already currently allowed in the grove so that means t five um inside coconut grove and cd three is not allowed to use um the current public benefits program or or this new one so that's not changing at all. The only update we're making is for t six and coconut grove. You're still allowed to use the public benefits program. Now you just have a different option. So basically what this program does is provides a new mechanism through which you can unlock the bonus height and the fl r. So that was an overview of the proposed public benefits program. Next I'll get into our new requirements for sites [Laughter] Fronting a greenway. So again this is just for sites that are fronting the greenways that we as a city have designated and called out under the definition. So that could include um for example the underlying the commodore trail um also the ludlam trail, the river greenway and flagler trail. So if you're fronting one of these greenways, the developer has to construct the greenway in front of the building for an equal amount of frontage length in front of your greenway and this is going to be across the city. So there's a couple alternatives to the greenway construction. So if you don't want to do the construction um or if it's not feasible for you as a developer, we're still offering that cash contribution towards the parks and open space trust fund, but the money has to be used for the greenways. If you don't want to use that program, you're still allowed to use the public benefits program which I mentioned a couple slides ago a couple minutes ago, um to unlock the benefit height and then provide your benefits that way. Lastly we have an opt out provision. Um, so basically if the um the proposed construction or cash contributions are not feasible for the site then it's going to be a pretty simple opt out which again stay with me sounds a little bit silly. Um the reason we're doing this is because of a florida statute europe you might be familiar with called sb 180. Um it's a preemption law that comes from the state basically telling us that we're not able to make the zoning code or um we're not able to make the development regulations for uh for the city any more restrictive or burdensome than they currently are. So what this program comprehensively does is introduces kind of a pilot program through through the public benefits program and through the frontage requirement program while still allowing an opt out so that we're still complying with the florida statutes. Next I'll go over some of the design standards that we're proposing for greenways. So if you're frenching the greenway you have to provide things like articulation. Um if you have a long frontage at least 100 linear feet, then you have to break up the facade with different architectural elements or art or civic space. Um and you have to provide an enhanced pedestrian realm. And then lastly if you're a greenway or if you're providing the greenway then you have to include all these certain design standards. So it has to be a paved multi-use path of an average 14ft width, provide canopy trees irrigation, provide lighting design, street furnishing, um curb ramps and traffic calming and safe crossing enhancements. If your greenway intersects a vehicular roadway. And here's the exhibit just to show you guys a little bit of what that would look like in the city. So here's the sites that would be required to construct the adjacent greenway. Lastly we have an update to chapter 62 um for the parks and open space trust fund. So referring back to the greenway public benefits program and also just the normal greenways standards if you're fronting a greenway, um, we're updating the parks and open space trust fund to say that any contributions that are specifically coming from these two greenway programs, um, have to be spent on greenways and then the greenway corridor from which the contribution was generated has to be prioritized. So this would kind of help make sure that any cash coming from the sites along a respective greenway will go towards that greenway. And then we've also updated the allowable expenditures only for greenways. This doesn't impact the expenditures for parks. Um so for the greenways can only be spent on greenway construction greenway improvements operations and maintenance and also the design costs. So the last thing to kind of introduce and to discuss is the greenway costs and the next steps. So for the public benefits program based on kind of the stakeholder and industry feedback, we came up with a number for the public benefits at about $200 per square foot and that would only be for the public benefits. However when the greenway construction is required like if you're actually fronting the greenway and you need to you have to construct it but let's say it's not possible and you're doing the option to pay the cash contribution. Um, we're still working out the cost schedule for each greenway because it's just the different greenways costs a lot of different money. And then lastly next steps, um in this legislation we're going to pick up this wednesday and then commission later this month hoping for adoption in JULY. That concludes my presentation. Um thank you guys so much. Happy to answer any questions and take any feedback you guys might have. Thank you.. >> thank you samantha. Um I don't have any questions as of now, but I think that projects like the underline and the commodore trail and the miami loop which all of this kind of contributes to with the miami river greenway uh baywalk are amazing public benefits and also are important thing for mobility for people to get around to to get to work, to get to school, to get to their job like in a safe manner. So um, I've supported the underline for a long time. I've supported the commodore trail and I I'm you know, was happy to hear that they passed the bike master plan last week and I think that this is an important thing that could also work with the bike master plan. In fact one of the segments of the greenway I think was one of also the priority segments. The one going north looked like it aligned with what I saw on the city's bike master plan. So I think we should support this. I think this is a good mechanism to get funding to pay for that, especially given conversations of removing property taxes. And just like we saw at our presentations last month on canopy park, there's there's certain benefits that can be created, um, which allow for these amazing things like canopy park to get built and I feel like more of these types of things are going to allow for those, uh, allow for that infrastructure that we're going to need to to be built. Anyone else have comments questions. Chair what are you what are you looking for from us just that we make a recommendation or was this just a presentation? What would you like to see? It was just if you guys had any anything to discuss or any comments any feedback concerns or if you just want to express your support that's completely fine with me. I think we should express support similar to how we've done for waterfront projects that we've reviewed in the past with a simple just statement of we saw the presentation on this day and we support it for for whatever reasons. Um. Well I'm happy to make a motion that we support the the greenway amendments brought forward the meeting of JUNE 1st, um, support the recommendations and and the efforts that you all are making. Do you think we should add any y anything or. Or just keep it simple. I'm okay with keeping it simple. Yeah I think keeping keeping it simple the why the why is pretty lengthy. Like many of the comments we got from the public. So um you know, I mean we could certainly say mobility heat, um water, you know, resiliency. Alternative alternative mobility. Yeah, you know, for those reasons, but it's. So would you amend your motion to include those four things and I'll just put like a bullet point of those four items. Yeah. Okay. So do we have a second on that motion or any comments or questions. I'll second the motion. Okay. >> second so all in favor I. Any opposed or abstain? No. Okay. Wonderful. Well thank you so much for your time this evening and for the the hard work in putting this together. I think it's going to be amazing to get to use that greenway as it gets built. Thank you everybody have a good rest of your evening. All right so let's move to our our second and third presentations of the evening which are uh, spongy urbanism developing a vision for south florida and florida's sponge parks lessons and benefits. So this is the um the second meeting in a row we've had on this topic. I uh at our last meeting we we saw those two great examples and also heard some of the benefits of sponge parks. And also this was an item that I asked for about a year ago when we had the, uh, our budget recommendations that we crafted for 2025. This was one of the items that we had proposed then. So this is kind of a um, a continuance of that subject and and then later in the agenda we have the sponge resolution hopefully to vote on. So welcome this evening. Thanks so much for being here. Thank you so much for having me. Um, great. So we're going to do this presentation together. Um so my name is tom klein and I'm the director of the center for urban and community design at the university of miami and I think I've seen all of you before. So thanks for having me back. Um, for those who don't know um sorry it looks like my slides are a little off. Let me go. Okay. That's better. Thank you. Uh, so for those who don't know what the center for urban and community design is all about, um, we were founded in 1992 in the aftermath of hurricane andrew with the mission of fostering a collaborative and interdisciplinary approach to create and strengthen resilient communities. We as a center at the university seek to integrate research, teaching and service encouraging interdisciplinary thought and action. And in this way we assist and lead faculty, alumni students in the production of research publications, community partnerships, workshops, charrettes and many other activities. This takes on many forms so we can engage in community workshopping. We can do design work and planning and design work in a pro bono or a low cost manner for communities and nonprofits and various stakeholders. And we also oftentimes get asked to engage in special projects, which is what we're talking with you about today, which we're very excited about. And with that, I have a little bit of an introduction to sponge parks and spongy urbanism as a whole. So what is a sponge park? Um, I share these images with you today because they show two very different scales of what a sponge park can be. So the image on the left is a forest park in bangkok by kunjung kunjung who is the founder of turin scape and the father of sponge parks. Um as you can see it's quite large. It's designed to manage the stormwater for a very large dense district in a in a in a major global city whereas the image on the right hand side is from the gowanus canal sponge park by susannah drake with sasaki and you can see this one right here is very, very very small. I think it's probably smaller than most of our backyards. Um but they're both performing a similar task in that they're both focused on how we can use natural based infrastructure to perform as a sponge for our stormwater to manage our stormwater to reduce the velocity of that water, to clean it before discharging it back into our waterways. So at a high level sponge parks, um, it's a framework for how we live with water in urban places. It was first popularized as I said by kong zhengyu who is a chinese landscape architect and unfortunately passed away this past year. But it's also a hybrid approach in that it uses both green infrastructure or nature based infrastructure and gray infrastructure to perform the redundancy is what makes it resilient. In turn it um acts as an amenity. It reduces runoff, it slows, cleans and recharges stormwater. It improves regional water quality and decreases nuisance flooding in our streets all while providing amenities for people and enjoyable places for people to use. And here are some different examples of some of the types of things we see with sponge parks. Some of them are coastal, some of them are inland. They change in the types of program they offer whether they're active or passive. Um and they just help create beautiful respite in our cities. And with that I'd like to pass the microphone to robert. Thank you tom and thank you all for having us here today. So I'm going to share a few examples of how this has been accomplished in florida. And um excuse me I'm robert cologne. I'm a resiliency coordinator to with miami-dade county, the department of environmental resources management and we're the division of environmental risk and resilience. So we help the county adapt to different climate stressors and shocks including extreme heat, sea level rise and flooding. And I'm also a 2026 landscape architecture foundation fellow for leadership and innovation, and I'm researching how to scale nature based solutions throughout specifically south florida. So why do we need sponge parks compared to other places you might hear we can build a wall to hold water out, but that's not the case in south florida because we live on an ancient limestone reef. When we build a seawall here it's to keep the land in not to keep the water out because the water can go right underneath those walls. And this really stresses out our canal system that we use to drain our entire region from lake okeechobee down to here because it's gravity operated as sea level rises come up on the tidal waters, they can come above the headwaters and the gravity doesn't do its job to get that water out. So we really have to start finding places to put the water within our landscape as it was for thousands of years. So the county is currently working to eliminate barriers to implementing this and one of them is a research study. I'm actually joined by our private investigator doctor troxler here as well today harnessing the power of nature for flood protection and community benefits. So like tom mentioned green infrastructure provides a great host of benefits not just drainage. So of course there's esthetics, public health, water quality. We currently treat water quality and flood control as opposing forces. You can move the water fast or you can clean it and sponge parks help eliminate that conflict by letting the water fall in place. So what we're doing in this study is we're visualizing modeling and looking how we'll scale green infrastructure in the little river basin, which is part of the little river adaptation action area of the city of miami has participated in. So we're trying to align these green infrastructures with community priorities. So it really represents what the people want when these things are instituted. And this is a collaboration with fiu, the county dover colon partners, their urban planners, the everglades law center, miami water keeper and the south florida water management district. So our goal is to put all the modeling all the language into one thing that we can all understand and use because sometimes we look at things a little bit differently. So these are some examples of renderings that have come out of this process. And I want to be clear that none of these are currently design projects or construction projects, but these are just visualizations of how sponge parks and other sponge infrastructures even parking lots could look throughout south florida. But lucky for us we know it works because we have seen this implemented all throughout florida and specifically in south florida in our miami beach at bayshore park just up the street from where I live they recently opened a 19.4 acre massive sponge park that is actually plumbed to eventually take the water from the neighborhood to a fairly large 85 acre watershed. And this was a remediated brownfield. This is an area that has very high groundwater. It's coastal all the restrictions that sometimes lead people to say that's not possible here. This project really exemplifies that it is possible and even though it's a wetland, it's also urban and hosts a lot of active recreation and passive recreation has a lot of interactive water features. Flood waters can often be so dirty that there are hazard here. They're so clean you can touch it and play with it and let your kids get in it. And my dog drinks that water all the time. Up in tampa they also recently opened the macdill 48 park. What I find very interesting about this one is resilience and conservation funds were used to make this happen. So for a $51.4 million project, the city of tampa only had to pay for about a quarter of it have come from resilient florida funds and a quarter coming from the southwest florida water management district. We have our own analog the south florida water management district who collaborates with us to look at initiatives like this all the time and would be happy to work with the city of miami. Again. Wonderful with this one. It's in the center of the urban core, eliminating this myth that something cannot be natural within the boundaries of the city. On a much smaller budget but incredibly ingenious .The ripple eco art project in martin county was funded through arts funding because it hosts arts and public spaces and educates people about the environment. Often we can't find very large parcels of land to make sponge parks happen, but they stitch together for very small neglected county parcels totaling just over two acres and those two acres of stitched together parcels support the watershed of over 20 acres remediating the water quality and flooding so they've reduced nitrogen pollution 34% and phosphorus 72%. And these are the primary pollutants that are harming biscayne bay and why the biscayne bay is currently under the reasonable assurance plan to make sure we can get the water quality up to the standard it needs to be and all of our municipalities have to participate in that. So again, this is something that can provide multiple functions and save us money in the long run. And these are stitched together underground through pipes. So like tom said it's green but also uses conventional infrastructure as well. So the water starts in a bio detention wetland which means it's temporarily wet. This can fill up hold water and slow it down and then it's conveyed across the neighborhood through a bioswale that also has a pavilion and a cistern providing more passive recreation. That conveyance takes it to a larger bio retention pond where it has a residency time meaning how long the water sits there. Usually we want to get it off the land as fast as possible and that residency time is the primary agent that removes the pollution from the water. And as you can see this is much more beautiful than a traditional sod into the retention pond that we often see in south florida. And then finally it goes through an outlet stormwater polishing, which just means it goes through one more round of plants to make sure we get all the pollutants and any remaining chemical pollution before it goes into the indian river lagoon. And as you can see there, some of the educational signage that supports its arts funding. A much, much larger regional example in tampa from decades ago it's about as old as I am. Is al lopez park a park that I grew up going to all the time? And this was also created with southwest florida water management district. So this combines a very large series of dry to wet spaces. So it has bio retention meaning areas that are permanently wet, programs that go along with that are floating plazas, fishing and birding piers educational signage. But as you go around there's detention again areas that can hold water and then be dry at different times so kids can play around in the forest when it's not raining and this can fill up when it is. I think this has also benefited from arts funding. It has a wetland art trail, elevated walkways and upland swales that connect the upland to those wetlands and on the highest ground presumably from scooping out that soil to construct those wetlands is the upland programing. So they have the traditional parks program that we associate with our cities and regional parks such as a community center, playgrounds, dog parks and this sort of eliminates the myth that having sponge park means turning everything into a wetland. Taking the soil out to make that wetland allows us to elevate the things that matter the most to us that we want to always be dry. We don't want our plaza to be wet or our community center full of our gyms, our senior programs. We don't want them underwater. And one final example is giralda plaza in coral gables and I used to show this one because not everything is a big lush wet wetland and not everyone is that big either. So giralda plaza uses structural soils meaning it's a really sturdy soil that doesn't get compacted so the water can continue to flow through it over time. But this is really based on some astonishing research out of fiu that shows that in the everglades tree islands connect down to our high water table and through their pumping through their leaves, they can lower the water really significantly allowing for more storage in the soil underground meaning when it rains they're somewhere underground for the water to go when we don't have tree roots, when they don't have the right amount of soil it can't get there and that's when it ends up in a pipe and we have to pay for that pipe and we have to pay to clean that water as well. So this is really astonishing that in a really really urban setting nothing is more urban than a a stone lined plaza. You can still have this natural infrastructure doing its job. So please feel free to reach out to me personally through my email or contact durham on social media to follow along with these initiatives. Thank you. Great. >> so that leads me to the last bit of our presentation which is to introduce you all to the sponge park studio that we're running at the university of miami this fall. So you should have a copy of this flier in your packet. So I apologize for the screen not being that legible. Um, but this this project which we're calling spongy urbanism in south florida is really a truly interesting I'm just really excited about this because it's so collaborative and it's bringing together so many stakeholders. Um, and I think we're going to do something truly unique together this fall. So at its core it's a collaboration between the university of miami school of architecture and the university of pennsylvania weitzman school of design. We anticipate having 30 to 40 students across institutions including architecture, landscape architecture, urban design planning, engineering and environmental science students. And we also have a really large instructor team. So these are the faculty you can see on the screen here including teresa pinto who is sitting here in the front row and can answer questions as well. Uh, and then matthias bau with the university of pennsylvania. But in addition to that, we have so many great collaborators who'll be joining us throughout the semester including robert from the county. Um, some key dates and course information here. So the course will run from AUGUST 17th through DECEMBER 1st. We don't have a final review date yet but that's coming. We're going to study the region at two scales. So the first scale is to think about the region so the sponge city and what it would look like for south florida to be a truly spongy region. And then we're also going to zoom in and we're going to look at the site scale and think about what a sponge park in south florida looks like. I think we've shown you some great examples some from here and some from elsewhere. But what does it really look like for us to engage in spongy urbanism holistically and systemically in the region? We're going to be hosting students from penn at the end of SEPTEMBER in which we're going to go into the community. We're going to have workshops, we're going to have tours and you all are invited to join us in these events. Um we're also going to do a water as leverage workshop as a part of those site visits and you will all be receiving an invite to join us for that. Um, on the weekend of SEPTEMBER 26th 27th we don't have the dates fully sorted yet. And then a week later, um, we our students along with students from penn and some community stakeholders will be taking a trip to rotterdam and to visit with tu delft and some of our collaborators on the other side of the atlantic. Um and um after that we're going to identify next steps. Um we'll have a report out. We'll have some public presentations maybe we'll be invited to to share this work with you all in some capacity. Um, and then hope to continue evolving this project as we move forward. And I just wanted to end with some images that kind of showcase the breadth of expertise and experience you'll have among our faculty, among our collaborators and the types of projects and things that we've done as a group and the things we're excited to do with you all. And with that I'm open to questions. Thank you guys so much. Um, really excited about this initiative and could could you just touch one more time when you said, you know, at the end that part of this is about uh, part of this resolution of sponge is about looking and encouraging, uh, the commission to proactively work with this studio. So could you mention kind of how you think that might work and how it's working with other municipalities? Yeah, absolutely. So um, we've identified with robert we've identified a park site in biscayne gardens that's going to be one of the sites that we explore. Um we have a large collection of students and researchers who are participating in this project and so we would love to have a site or sites within the city of miami that we could also explore. Additionally we're collaborating with north bay village on a site that's coastal and provides its own set of challenges that we're really excited to dive into. Awesome. >> um, I think that this item we're going to just transition into the vote in a minute, but do you guys have any comments or questions for our presenters? Yes. Very impressive. Um yeah. Amazing presentation. It really excited to see this and I know this is something the CHAIRMAN Has been talking about quite often and I want to create a bit of a culture change here and especially with staff um in the city and I want to make it okay to ask right and make it more straightforward to ask how can both staff and the community get help with what they're doing, especially really incredible endeavors like this? So on that note, um, how do you think and I think you just answered that so would it be giving you a list of parks? Would it be sharing like, you know, maybe our most vulnerable flood flood prone area? What can we do today? Um and CHAIRMAN The same goes goes for you because this is your expertise here. What do you think we can do to help really move this forward in some meaningful way and maybe even a pilot for one of our parks or waterfront parks which we need to consider for budget recommendations. Um, so you know, what do you think would would be a good ask to help kind of dovetail all of this together? So if like if you look at the sponge resolution item five says report to the city commission within 180 days with a sponge program assessment including candidate site maps across all three site pathways. And I describe what those pathways are because there's different uses for sponge parks. Yeah. Um that's in the warehouse statement acquisition cost estimates and available leveraged funding. The leveraged funding we just heard from robert was incredible in making some of those happen. Um a crs improvement pathway toward a score below five which is actually a a a a policy initiative in one of the already adopted city of miami. Um documents and evaluation of potential gray cip cost deferral a summary of academic and intergovernmental partnership opportunities. Um, these wonderful people in front of us, uh, or others as well and a review of maintenance monitoring and stewardship funding best practices. So that's I think that, uh, part of the timeliness of this is that it would go to commission and and hopefully be supported, which I think it will um and then be able to be done in time that a city of miami site can be identified to participate in the studio, which I think is going to be, you know, pretty incredible with all of the different stakeholders involved. I think what comes out of this is going to be a really a really great work product. Just to add really briefly. >> we're going to give them a list of of CHAIRMAN Just to clarify, we're going to be sharing some data with them to select a site and then get back to the commission on. Well like as far as we like the sponge resolution recommends for the commission would vote hopefully and pass sponge which directs the city manager to work with staff and then come back to commission on this item five and the first I'll read it just the first line again. So report to the city commission within 180 days with a sponge program assessment including candidate site maps across all three site pathways. So that is a little longer than when the studio starts. But we also need to be realistic with what we're asking here. So hopefully you know once this passes there's some level of finding a site. Um but even if there isn't a site identified at that time, you know, there's there's maps out there of of where these can possibly go and I'm sure they could even identify it. But you know, I don't I don't want to come up with a bunch of what ifs. I feel like yeah, the process will will play out. And yeah, I think that that makes sense. I mean the two things that come to mind is if we're able to share like some of our flood data that we have and number two, I know that we made a map of some of the mangrove parks last year we shared with stanford. Alyssa made that list .Um, if that's helpful. Um, I'm sure that you know, staff can get that out your way. Um, could you talk a little bit about water credits, carbon credits, stormwater runoff like some of the environmental maybe economics implications of other things that that are possible with something like this? Sure. >> and really quickly just to your last comment, I would also suggest that we, you know, remove our assumptions on where these things might belong. We often think it floods in this location so it should be there but maybe we need to catch the water upstream or maybe there is a stressed out pump that if it had a sponge park near it that would really take the pressure off of that pump. So I think a great ask would just be leave that to be an open process and to take time to really thoughtfully find where those locatio

Climate Resilience Committee Meeting — June 1, 2026 - 5:12 PM

Showing the first 24,000 of 107,910 characters. The full document is at the source.

welcome to the city of miami's climate resilience committee for JUNE 1st. We have a packed agenda and uh, the most people here that we've seen in a long time. So thank you for your attendance. All right. We'll get started with a roll call from our right. Good evening, grant musser., allison weinstock. Sadie perez. Aaron demeo. Wayne pathman pathman law. Ava jean. Nick atkinson. >> city attorney's office. Hi. >> sonya brubaker, chief resilience officer for the city of miami. Miriam flores for the office of resilience sustainability. Welcome, nick. And um and thank you to gigi who is uh, still here with us this evening but has served us for a while now. So thank you so much for all your service and help. So we'll move to item two which is public comment uh, which is limited to two minutes per person. If anyone here would like to make a public comment please approach. Hello good evening. I'm katrina morris I live in coconut grove. Um and I'm asking that the crc gets involved with the tree committee for chapter 17. Um some oversight would be greatly appreciated. Um I'm also really happy to to look at the the greenways and the sponge parks. Um I think these are real you know, I think that green infrastructure at this point, um the the verdict is in the studies have been done green infrastructure is cost effective and um creates benefits for humans mental and physical health and um really helps in an urban environment, um, to keep us, you know, breathing and drinking clean water and not flooding and not having runoff into our uh, bay every time it rains. So I appreciate the work you're doing. Thank you katrina. And just one moment we'll do another roll call for silvio please. Silvio pupo. >> casco. Thanks. >> good evening CHAIRMAN Members of the board my name is mel meinert. I live at, uh, on virginia street but I'm here representing friends of the commodore trail, which is the five and a half miles of potholes and death defying crosswalks through coconut grove. But we've also been an active participant in the greenways, uh, legislation that you're going to have that you're going to hear from today. But um, we are supportive but we want to make. I'm here today. We're very supportive of the of the effort, but I want to make it very clear and I would like the board to ask the city staff to make sure that on the record we have some very clear understanding of what is involved, especially with respect to ncd three that's coconut grove. We have worked with city staff to ensure we hope to ensure that the up zoning or the additional bonus height that is part of the greenways program has been cut out of the ncd three t five and below uh measures so that we are protecting coconut grove from being up zoning. We understand there's a trade off that we won't receive funding from that program, but that's an active piece that we're doing. I ask then that you ask the city staff to describe exactly where within the coconut grove area ncd three that up that bonus height would be available under the t six provisions of that uh of the proposal. So we're asking we understand that the bonuses are available only in t six which is a very limited set of properties. We expect then that they'll be able to produce a map that shows where that is. And those areas we expect are already in areas which have very high buildings and are fully built out already. So we most important is the priorities throughout the city of miami to protect the local neighborhood character because if we lose the local neighborhood character then what's the point of all these build of all this good intention anyway? Okay thank you. Thank you. Hello. >> okay. Hello my name is michelle yee. Um, do you need my address? Yes. Okay. Um office is 2937 southwest 27th avenue, suite 301 33133 zip code? Um, I'm I work as a student research assistant at fiu restoring florida's wetlands and seagrasses as such, I also work organizing youth in climate and environmental awareness through gen clio. It was fiu alongside uf that helped develop the urban tree canopy assessment in 2021, which promised to increase miami's tree cover to 30% and as soon as and as I am soon to graduate I wonder what the urban forest that was promised. And so with the hottest summers on record, compounding adequate tree cover is crucial for the well-being of the community across all sectors. And so I'm here to urge this committee to continue advising on tree protections as they are reflective of the climate crisis occurring at our shorelines and provide great relief to a landscape already experiencing record long dry seasons shorter and more intensive um hydro periods all at the mercy of developers and lobbyists. The city of miami's tree trust fund, once audited, was found to have not used the majority of allocated funds to meet its own law of using 80% of the fund to replace and restore miami's lost canopy 57,000 of that was intended for hurricane irma cleanup efforts, though it was never submitted. And so where did this money go? Commissioner pardo's office recently released a statement admitting to illegally cutting down 15 trees at one site for an alleged temporary pickleball court but was later discovered to be reserved for construction of of luxury units. This unfortunately is a failure of leadership and a severe lack of representation in one of the nation's top cities threatened by climate change. This is why we need the climate resilience committee's continued advocacy to ensure the city is following its own rules to protect our trees and so while immensely grateful for the creation of the tree committee, it is essential to be transparent with the public on the city's relation to its own tree ordinances. Miami is witnessing a slew of environmental indicators in the midst of many unprecedented and underreported natural disasters. And so as a as a citizen as a student I'm asking you guys to please represent us and thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Hello. >> good evening. My name is angelina alvarez. My address is 2937 southwest 27th avenue. So I'm here to represent. I'm speaking on behalf for those who cannot speak for the trees. So I want to tell a little story that time sure flies. About a year ago I was standing right here in the same city of miami fighting against changes to the tree ordinance that would have made it easier for developers to cut down trees. I remember the relief of the people when we left that room. They were happy because the commissioners listened to the constituents. Today I want to emphasize how important it is that we protect the tree ordinance and ensure that it is not weaken. Our canopy is under pressure and the policies are safeguarded need to stand strong. I'm asking this committee to continue leading on this issue to keep offering guidance, pushing accountability and making sure our urban forest remains a priority. I MAY not I might sound like a broken record but trees are essential for our living. They cool our neighborhoods, they reduce flooding and they give us shade on days when when heat feels unbearable which is a lot of days here in miami they are not decorations and they are climate infrastructures. That's why I urge this committee to take an active and formal role in the city in the city's tree committee and stakeholder process for chapter 17. This is just not a tree issue. It is a climate issue. One of your core responsibilities is to recommend political policy that helps miami withstand extreme heat, flooding and environmental degradation. There is no climate resilient strategy without protecting and expanding our urban canopy. If the city is serious about climate resiliency, then the crc must take an active role and demand the data most move the workshop forward and ensure that any further changes is strengthened not weakened. Miami's ability to withstand climate change. Every tree removed without accountability makes this city hotter, more vulnerable and less resilient. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Hey. >> I would stay later but I got to go after this. So albert gomez, district two resident I just wanted to thank for the consistent support of the crc around the biscayne bay marine health summit and it was a resounding success. Uh, and of course I got in the mail my two uh, my bay, uh, license plates that help fund restoration efforts. I think your waterfront authority has an important role right now right near aria on 22nd in edgewater. They had a massive discharge of waste into biscayne bay. We saw some beautiful manatees, a mother and her calf floating over the debris. I would like to see if maybe city of miami would take it personal since it came out of their outfall and uh and we can maybe send some people to go over there and clean that up as opposed to leaving it to residents. Now that said I, I went ahead and shared with MISS Flores um, a little document that I put together um on how to access the I build permit uh, guideline and how every permit has different codes that are linked within I build and the girgis system. Uh, it is nothing more than a query and referencing those codes. Uh, in general you don't need an individual code, you just need the code designator and a time frame and then you can pull all of the data that was requested by you with a unanimous vote to request that the existing tree removal permits and all approved tree removal permits since the founding of the tree giveaway program so that we can kind of balance and audit the true numbers that are that are canopies at right now so that you can have informed decisions ahead of your workshop. I really hope you guys set that into date and and thank you always. Excuse me albert, you said you shared something with MISS Flores. Uh, miriam. I am miriam. Yeah. >> I know when right now. Didn't receive anything. Right now usually has to go up to two satellites and then comes down but you'll get it in your inbox, I guarantee it. Um but thank you again. Thank you. All right. Um and there were any online. Oh let's do roll call hi jenny lee. Jenny lee molina. Thank you miriam we have online submittal. Yes. Okay. Just downloading it again to see if any additional came through and we do we have around nine okay. All right first one is from maria gonzalez. Um she says subjects on greenways benefit and as I read these along the way and if I MISS Pronunciate the words the name please forgive me. Okay going back and maria gonzalez first ones good evening chair and members of the climate resilience committee I'm marcy the climate resilience committee to become an active participant in the both the city's tree committee and the upcoming stakeholders process regarding revisions to chapter 17. The issues being discussed extend far beyond landscaping or esthetics. They directly affect miami's ability to address rising temperatures ,stormwater management, air quality and overall climate resilience. As the advisory body changes with advanced advancing policies that strengthen miami's environmental sustainability resilience, the crc has both an opportunity and a responsibility to engage in this process. Trees are critical infrastructures they reduce urban heat, absorb stormwater, improve air quality and help mitigate the impacts of climate change. Any policy affecting the protection, removal or replacement of tree falls squarely within the crc mission. For that reason, I was concerned to hear suggestions that the committee should remain on the sidelines of discussion involving tree policy. Miami experiencing significant canopy loss throughout many neighborhoods including the removal of mature, protected and specimen trees, residents continue to raise concerns about inconsistent permits decisions, questionable arborist assessments and a lack of transparency regarding how approvals are granted. This is where the crc can provide tremendous value before any meaningful discussion about changes are granted. This is where the crc can provide tremendous value before any meaningful changes can be made. Chapter 17 the tree trust funds contributions and the cumulative impacts on canopy coverage urban heat and flooding vulnerable data driven policies require data public trust requires transparency. The crc should also support the proposal tree workshops forward as soon as possible. The workshop provides an essential opportunity to staff, committee members and the public to review facts, identify trends and better understanding of the consequences of current policies before considering future amendments. If miami is serious about climate resilience, then decisions affecting the urban forest can occur in isolation. The crc should be fully engaged in the discussion, insist upon complete and public accessible information. Ensure that any amendments to chapter 17 strengthen protections for the urban canopy rather than weaken them. Every acre of canopy loss increases the heat exposure, reduces stormwater absorption, diminishes the city resilience and climate change the decision being made today will shape miami's environmental future decades. I respectfully urge this committee to take actions role in process and help ensure transparency, accountability climate resilience remains in the center of the of the conversation. Second person samantha wilson good evening, CHAIRMAN Of city of crc. The crc is both the authority and the obligation to be directly involved in the shaping tree policies in miami. I'm here to ask that you use trees as part of the peripheral concerns there are front line climate defense in chapter 17 must be treated as climate policy. Miami urban cavity b is under pressure. The tree rules are increasing oversight and consistent and the public has limited visibility into how and these decisions are being made. That has to change. The crc should be requiring city staff to produce complete transparent data on all tree permits and removals including species size, location mitigation measures, replanting commitments and tree trust fund usage and evaluate how the cumulative loss of trees is driving up heat and worsening flood risk across the neighborhood. The tree workshop cannot be pushed aside or delayed. It is a foundation of any current credible policy conversation before chapter 17 is revised any way this committee needs to see numbers, understand the trends and make that information available to the public through genuine community engagement process. Miami resilience depends on the decisions made in rooms like this one. Samantha no same person aurora al qaida as a landscape architect working on climate resilience public spaces in miami, I strongly support the sponge program. The initiative recognizes that parks can function as essential infrastructure managing stormwater, reduce urban heat and provide high quality public space. Done well, sponge parks can deliver multiple benefits for flood protection and water quality, improving biodiversity, community gathering and long term public health. I encourage the city to prioritize strong landscaping, architect designs, leadership, interdisciplinary collaborations and ongoing maintenance and monitoring to ensure these spaces succeed over time. Dennis tuno. Good evening CHAIRMAN And crc. I urge the crc to take active and formal role in the city street committee and ongoing stakeholder engagement. It looks like this was copied over again. Urban forestry is not a separate issue from climate resilience. It is one of the most important foundations of crc mission is to help miami prepare and adapt to challenges climate change including extreme heat, flood and sea level rise. Environmental degradation trees are among the most effective and cost efficient tools available to address these challenges to reduce urban heat, improve stormwater management, enhance public health and strengthen neighborhood resilience. For this reason, the tree committee works is directly relevant to crc responsibility. The tree committee provides experience on tree preservation removals mitigation canopy management while the crc brings a broader climate resilience perspective needed to evaluate how these decisions affect miami's long term sustainability, these bodies should work collaboratively independently to city considers potential changes to chapter 17 the crc should ensure. Ensure the dishes are informed by complete, accurate and public accessible data. This includes information on tree removal permits, protected specimen tree removal mitigation requirements, replanting efforts, tree trust contributions and the cumulative impacts of canopy coverage heat vulnerability flood also encourage crc to support moving the tree workshop forward as soon as possible before before policy changes are considered, both the committee and the public deserves an opportunity to review the status and understand the current trends, evaluate the impacts of canopy loss and climate resilience. I'm going to go to second page now. All right this is from jesse johnson. Good evening chair and crc. My name is jessica johnson I miami resident community organizer, the founder of miami canopy watch and the column that has grown into a citywide movement documenting illegal tree removals, permit violations, systematic destruction of miami's urban canopy in real time. I'm here because what we are documenting every single day is not just a tree crisis it is a climate crisis and the committee has both the authority and responsibility to act. I urge this committee to take an active formal role in the city's tree committee and community stakeholders engagement process related to chapter 17. One of your core mandates is to recommend changes to city code policy that will help miami withstand growing threats extreme heat flooding, environmental degradation there is no climate resilience strategy that does not begin with protecting expanding our urban canopy trees are not decorative their infrastructures and right now miami is losing them faster than anyone else in this room is willing to admit. When miami canopy watch is documenting daily mature trees removed without permits across every district specimen trees lost without independent arborist review no public transparency across our removal decisions are made and the tree trust fund with no meaningful public accounting. This committee must demand the city staff provide complete, accurate and public accessible data on all tree permits removals including the number, type, size, location, tree, every tree being removed, full accounting of mitigation planning obligations, tree trust fund obligations and expenditures analysis how these removals are impacting canopy coverage heat index flooding. without data there is no accountability. Without transparency there's no trust and without both there is no policy without having the plan tree workshop must move forward without delay. We can't evaluate chapter 17 recommend meaningful changes or engage the public in good faith without. First understanding what the data actually shows. I also want to address directly the suggestions that this committee should not play a role in tree policy with respect that position is indispensable. Every tree removed without accountability makes the city hotter more than food flood prone and less survivable for the residents who cannot afford to leave when the next hurricane comes next person lindsey kane. Hello. I'm writing and urge the committee to allow the climate resilience committee to have an active voice involvement with the tree committee. Removals in the city have actively increased temperatures and heat is being felt by the residents and will lead in the long term to health crisis in the city from mariella lopez it is. It is a must that the committee takes active and decisive actions to take formal role in the city street trust committee act stakeholders and engagement process related to chapter 17. This is real climate issues as well as our canopies and green space enabled to survive the reality of what is to come and level sea rise and city ignoring how to mitigate mindful and realistic flood flooding situation which most more soil, more shade and less cement helps in the process of sustained or someone reverse a process allowing rainwater and sea level to drain itself through the real soil and vast strong rooted trees. The community speaking out and are fighting hard to have the city and this committee to take a real look at reality, know the deep pockets of developers that come and go and leave the mess to citizens taxpayers that are that after taxpayers that after live with the aftermath not the developers. It is time we all work together in the process of development and being inclusive to our natural habitats and wildlife to learn that we can come together to build mindfully and soulfully. This is not hard to do just have the will and the generosity to do so. Sandy moise good evening crc I urge the committee to take an active role in city street committee and community stakeholder engagement process related to chapter 17. This is to this is not just three issues. This is a climate issue. One of our core responsibilities to recommend changes city code policies and will help miami withstand the growing threats of climate change extreme heat flooding, environmental degradation trees are one of the most immediate and effective tools we have to address those threats, which is exactly why involvement is essential. I was deeply concerned to hear that the member of the committee does not believe the crc should play a role in policy impacting our trees respectfully, there is no climate resilience strategy that does not include the protection or expansion of our urban canopy. Miami is facing a full blown tree crisis. We are seeing increasing tree removals including protection of specimen trees. We are seeing inconsistent in times questionable arborist reports and we are seeing a lack of transparency around how decisions are being made. Which brings me to the most critical of the crc must play the climate resilience committee must ensure the city staff provides all requested data on tree permits and removal complete, accurate and publicly accessible without data there is no accountability. Without transparency there is no trust and without both there can be no meaningful policy. The committee should insist on full disclosure removal permits and approvals data on the numbers, type, size, locations and trees being removed leave leave wrong word accounting of mitigation replanting and tree trust fund contribution analysis of how these removals are impacting canopy coverage heat flooding equality importance of crc must ensure that these planned tree workshops move forward without delay. We cannot evaluate the policy recommended changes chapter 17 engage in meaningful stakeholder process without first understanding the data and the trends and impacts. If the city is serious about climate resilience then the process must include crc and start with facts provided by staff reviewed by the committee in the tree workshop and shared with the public at the community engagement stakeholders process, the crc must take an active role, demand the data, move the workshop toward and ensure the future changes. Chapter 17 strengthen not weaken miami's ability to withstand climate change every tree removal without accountability makes the city hotter, more vulnerable, less resilient. I urge you to step into this responsibility. Thank you. Sandy moise michelle baptiste regarding the city of miami trees and threats to cut the trees I'm writing in miami residents to strongly urge the protection of our trees, especially the four native and threatening mahogany trees in edgewater. We must preserve these trees because they are in irreplaceable and provide more long lasting benefits and many made constructions ever will. These trees are valuable resources to cooling our cities, enhancing air quality, reducing hazardous flood impact and reaching the city

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Climate Resilience Committee Meeting
  • Climate Resilience Committee Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: d349075bf18dfa0fa517877b47505001. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record