POLISCOPE

The public record

DADECITY (PASCO COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Historic Board - 24 Apr 2025

Thursday, April 24, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Dade City Historic Preservation Advisory Board met to discuss local historic property matters, including a fence permit issue at 37547 Church Street and updates to cemetery regulations. The board also addressed administrative items such as member resignations and future meeting scheduling.

Why it matters

The board's decisions on property modifications, such as the fence at 37547 Church Street, directly impact the aesthetic and historic compliance requirements for property owners in designated historic districts.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Historic Board - 24 Apr 2025. Location: Commission Chambers. Time: 05:30 PM. Agenda: Historic Board - 24 Apr 2025 - Agenda - Html Meeting of the Historic Preservation Advisory Board City Hall 38020 Meridian Ave Dade City, Florida Thursday, April 24, 2025 5:30 PM Historic Board Chair Laura Beagles Vice Chair Doug Sanders Board Member Scott Black Board Member Julie Ann Hale Board Member Jean Ward Board Member John Chandler Board Member Marilyn Perkins Hunter Board Member Brian Lee Swann Board Member Francisco Moreno-Orama City Officials Catherine Ralston, Community and Economic Development Director Evis Bushi, Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Isaiah Hollinshead, Planner II Craig Hanson, GIS Planner I REGULAR SESSION AGENDA Page A. MEETING PROCEDURES A.1. The Historic Preservation Board will be meeting in person. As an alternate option, the public may observe virtually. The virtual meeting will be in “watch/listen mode” only; no public comments will be taken virtually. Republished agenda to correct names, update Cemetery National Register Application Agenda Memo. To join the virtual meeting by computer or smart device: https://teams.microsoft.com/l/meetup-join/19%3ameeting_ZWEzZDlmYTItMTBmZC00MWZjLWI2ZGItMWRjZWNjNWJjZWFm%40thread.v2/0?context=%7b%22Tid%22%3a%2293e30c94-d7e7-4a24-a77e-f78f00386b17%22%2c%22Oid%22%3a%22607c9587-b31e-41c2-b851-4cebd6c2ff6f%22%7d This virtual meeting will be hosted via Microsoft Teams Town Hall. A Microsoft Teams account will not be required to join. Public Comment : If you are present in the Commission Chambers, you will be limited to three minutes to make your comments as is the usual rule of procedure for Planning Board meetings, except for matters heard in a quasi-judicial capacity. Public comments will not be taken virtually. Submission of Presentations: For security purposes, the City cannot accept jump drives or other USB devices. Please contact the City Clerk for more information. B. CALL TO ORDER B.1. Pledge of Allegiance B.2. Roll Call C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES C.1. Historic Board - 10 Feb 2025 - Minutes 4 - 8 D. PUBLIC COMMENTS E. OLD BUSINESS E.1. Jo Larkin Resignation E.2. Future Meeting Dates F. NEW BUSINESS F.1. 37547 Church Street Fence 37547 Church Street Fence Agenda Memo 9 - 14 F.2. Resolution No. 2025-02 Cemetery Rules and Regulations Review Resolution No. 2025-02 Cemetery Rules and Regulations Review Agenda Memo Resolution No. 2025-02 Cemetery Rules and Regulations 15 - 25 F.3. Cemetery National Register Application Cemetery National Register Application Agenda Memo NPS Form 10-900 NRHP Registration Form Draft 26 - 42 F.4. Historic Dade City Website Historic Dade City Website Agenda Memo Signed Historic Register Property Letter Historic Register Map 43 - 45 G. MEMBER COMMENTS H. PUBLIC COMMENTS (FOR ITEMS NOT ALREADY DISCUSSED) I. ADJOURNMENT J. FOOTER TEXT NOTE: ONE OR MORE CITY COMMISSIONERS, PLANNING BOARD OR RAC BOARD MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT AT THIS MEETING AND MAY PARTICIPATE ADDRESSING THE BOARD: Any person desiring to address the Board shall secure the permission of the Presiding Officer to do so. MANNER OF ADDRESSING THE BOARD: TIME LIMIT: Each person addressing the Board shall step up to the podium, shall give their name and address in an audible tone of voice for the records, and unless further time is requested and granted by the Board shall limit the address to three minutes . All remarks shall be made to the Board as a body and not to any member thereof. No person other than the person having the floor and the Board shall be allowed to enter into any discussion either directly or through a Board Member without the permission of the Presiding Officer. No question shall be asked a Board Member except through the Presiding Officer. APPEALS: Any person desiring to appeal any decision made by the Historic Preservation Advisory Board with respect to any matter considered at any meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and evidence upon with the appeal is based. DISABILITY: If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled at no cost to you to the provision of certain assistance within two (2) working days of your receipt of this notice. Please contact the Dade City Clerk’s office, P.O. Box 1355, Dade City, FL 33526-1355; (352) 523-5052 for further assistance and information. Document: Historic Board - 24 Apr 2025 - Minutes - Html Historic Board April 24, 2025 Commission Chambers Minutes MEMBERS PRESENT: Chair Laura Beagles Board Member Scott Black Board Member Julie Ann Hale Board Member John Chandler Board Member Marilyn Perkins Hunter Board Member Brian Lee Swann Board Member Francisco Moreno-Orama MEMBERS ABSENT/REGRETS: Vice Chair Doug Sanders Board Member Jean Ward Board Member Julie Ann Hale STAFF PRESENT: CITY OFFICIALS Evis Bushi, Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Isaiah Hollinshead, Planner II Craig Hanson, GIS Planner 1 1. MEETING PROCEDURES 1.1 The Historic Preservation Board will be meeting in person. As an alternate option, the public may observe virtually. The virtual meeting will be in “watch/listen mode” only; no public comments will be taken virtually. Republished agenda to correct names, update Cemetery National Register Application Agenda Memo. To join the virtual meeting by computer or smart device: https://teams.microsoft.com/l/meetup-join/19%3ameeting_ZWEzZDlmYTItMTBmZC00MWZjLWI2ZGItMWRjZWNjNWJjZWFm%40thread.v2/0?context=%7b%22Tid%22%3a%2293e30c94-d7e7-4a24-a77e-f78f00386b17%22%2c%22Oid%22%3a%22607c9587-b31e-41c2-b851-4cebd6c2ff6f%22%7d This virtual meeting will be hosted via Microsoft Teams Town Hall. A Microsoft Teams account will not be required to join. Public Comment : If you are present in the Commission Chambers, you will be limited to three minutes to make your comments as is the usual rule of procedure for Planning Board meetings, except for matters heard in a quasi-judicial capacity. Public comments will not be taken virtually. Submission of Presentations: For security purposes, the City cannot accept jump drives or other USB devices. Please contact the City Clerk for more information. 2. CALL TO ORDER Chair Beagles called the meeting to order at 5:35 P.M. 2.1 Pledge of Allegiance 2.2 Roll Call All members were present except Vice Chair Sanders, Board Member Ward, and Board Member Hale. Board Member Scott arrived a minute after roll call. 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Motioned by Board Member Swann, Seconded by Board Member Chandler. Motion to approve Minutes Motion approved unanimously. 4. PUBLIC COMMENTS 5. OLD BUSINESS 5.1 Jo Larkin Resignation The Historic Board is looking for new members, Chair Beagles distributed application forms. 5.2 Future Meeting Dates Chair Beagles presented dates, which were good with Board Member Hunter and Board Member Black. Board Member Swann mentioned a commitment for a meeting on Thursday, however there was consensus amongst the board for the scheduled meeting dates. 6. NEW BUSINESS 6.1 GIS Planner I Craig Hanson presented the background information regarding the construction of a 7-foot fence, noting that planning staff is currently awaiting a permit. Board Member Chandler clarified that the issue was that the fence had been constructed without a permit and asked whether the material resembled wood. City staff confirmed that the fence is made of synthetic material that will not decompose, as the board reviewed photos of the fence. Board Member Moreno-Orama expressed architectural concerns, noting that while the fence is visually appealing, it does not reflect the character of the neighborhood or the historic home. Board Member Swann agreed, stating that the fence is not in keeping with the historic character of the area. He recommended denial of the request and raised additional concerns about the fence’s height. Board Member Chandler mentioned he would visit the site following the meeting and stated a white-painted wooden fence would have been more appropriate, as the current brown color clashes with the white-painted house. Board Member Hunter agreed with previous comments and suggested that red brick or materials that better match the home would be more fitting. Board Member Chandler reiterated that the brown color stands out harshly against the home’s white exterior. Board Member Black asked if the current fence was the finished product. GIS Planner I Craig Hanson confirmed that the homeowner does not intend to paint the fence. Board Member Black expressed concern that the fence is clearly visible from Church Street and the sidewalk within the historic district. Chair Beagles stated that ideally, the board would have had input earlier in the process. While she acknowledged the value of fencing for safety, she felt the styling and color of the current fence are not in keeping with the historic setting. She opened the floor for public comment. Board Member Chandler cited the Land Development Code, noting a height limit of 6 feet in residential districts. Recalling his prior service on the planning board, he explained law enforcement visibility and the rationale behind limiting privacy fences facing streets, and discussed variances on corner lots. Lee Battle of 37603 Church Street, a next-door neighbor, spoke during public comment. He noted that the area is designated historic and that the fence is unlike anything he has seen in Williamsburg, VA. He emphasized that the fence exceeds height limits by a foot, obscures the bottom of the windows, and appears out of place. Blane McCullough of 35363 Sarah Lynn Drive stated that he agrees with the comments from the Board. He emphasized the importance of maintaining rules within historic districts and acknowledged that while the proposed fence appears durable—an improvement over many deteriorating wooden fences—the area’s historic character must be preserved. Blane McCullough noted that while it’s understandable for property owners to install a fence that suits their personal preferences, the impact on the overall streetscape must be considered. He expressed appreciation for the significance of the historic district and the need for the City to uphold its integrity. Board Member Chandler noted that the homeowner was not present and said he would have liked to ask questions of the contractor. He expressed sympathy for the homeowner, acknowledging that while a homeowner might be unaware of permitting requirements, a professional contractor should know better. He also questioned whether the contractor was licensed. Board Member Black asked whether the permit was being pulled by the contractor or the homeowner. GIS Planner I Craig Hanson responded that City Staff would follow up on the permit records to determine that. Board Member Black expressed interest in seeing a different fence style and asked whether this matter would go to the Planning Board. There was further discussion among the board regarding the permitting process, the potential for a variance application, and possible involvement of Code Enforcement. Board Member Moreno-Orama commented, from his professional experience in architecture, that it is common to see construction projects moving forward without required permits. Chair Beagles stated the fence, as presented, does not reflect the character of Church Street. She noted the board had provided sufficient feedback to recommend that the design is not in keeping with the historic aesthetic. Board Member Moreno-Orama added that the City’s website offers helpful photographs showcasing historic architectural styles, which could assist the homeowner in aligning with the area’s character. Board Member Swann pointed out that adjacent neighboring properties have appropriate fencing. 6.2 Resolution No. 2025-02 Cemetery Rules and Regulations Review Chair Beagles provided background on why the recently adopted Cemetery Resolution was being revisited, noting that the review was requested by City Clerk Angie Guy and the City Commission. Board Member Black emphasized that the rules should not negatively impact the Cemetery’s application to the National Register of Historic Places. He expressed support for the change allowing upright markers, noting that flat, ground-level markers make the Cemetery appear more commercial, while upright markers contribute to its historic character. He commended the City Commission for making that change a while back allowing different types of markers in the newer section. Board Member Swann agreed with Board Member Black, stating that upright markers better reflect the Cemetery’s historic nature. He thanked City Staff for being receptive to corrections and pointed out a typographical error on page 19 of the resolution, the Cemetery "wilt be open." The board appreciated his attention to detail. Chair Beagles clarified that there should be nothing objectionable in the resolution, and this meeting provided an opportunity for both the Commission and the advisory board to ensure mutual understanding. Board Member Moreno-Orama observed that the resolution's language regarding marker materials was vague and did not specify granite as a requirement. He pointed out there was text referencing temporary materials. Lee Battle of 37603 Church Street commented on the condition of some graves, noting chipped stones and marker damage likely caused by maintenance equipment. He recommended a thorough assessment of the Cemetery to identify and address areas in need of repair. Board Member Swann added that weed trimmers should not have metal parts that could damage grave markers, and that the proper equipment must be used to protect the integrity of the site. Board Member Hunter raised a concern regarding the tracking of grave site addresses and requested an update on maintaining accurate records. Chair Beagles responded that the Cemetery’s new software is capable of generating updates. Board Member Swann reiterated that the new software will address the database accuracy. Chair Beagles noted the importance of having an electronic system in today’s digital age and asked the board if there was consensus in support of the resolution. Motioned by Board Member Swann, Seconded by Board Member Moreno-Orama. Motion the Historic Board has no objections to the Cemetery Resolution and if any arise, the Board is to send a memo to the City Commission to amend the Resolution. Motion approved unanimously. 6.3 Cemetery National Register Application Chair Beagles remarked that the board had hoped to have Joy Lynn from the Heritage Museum and Vice Chair Sanders present to lend their expertise on the National Register application. However, she acknowledged that this process will be ongoing and collaborative and will continue to return to the board for review. GIS Planner 1 Craig Hanson emphasized that the City is not rushing the application and invited feedback from board members. Board Member Swann shared that he had spoken with Joy Lynn, and both she and the Heritage Museum team are actively involved and supportive of the application. He pointed out that the language used in parts of the application, such as references to “servicemen,” could be improved for inclusivity, recommending the term “service members” instead. GIS Planner 1 Craig Hanson also spoke about recent improvements in Cemetery technology. Chair Beagles emphasized that while the board is preparing an application rooted in the Cemetery’s historic significance, the way the City maintains, preserves, and presents it is just as important. She was optimistic about the opportunity to incorporate advanced technological elements, noting that this application is a unique chance to blend history with modern innovation. She highlighted the importance of the visual aspect of the application, suggesting that a strong visual narrative—alongside the stories of prominent pioneers—would help bring the Cemetery’s historical personality to life for reviewers. GIS Planner 1 Craig Hanson added that the City’s investment in the Chronicle and a digital Cemetery database signals its commitment to modernization. He noted that this initiative supports the application by demonstrating a long-term strategy for preservation and mapping. He also encouraged board members to contribute written content to enhance the submission. Board Member Moreno-Orama pointed out that the section of the application identifying the applicable National Register criteria was currently blank. He reminded the board that Criteria A and B focus on properties associated with historically significant individuals or events. If the application intends to emphasize the graves of individuals of “transcendent importance,” then the submission must be specific and well-documented. Board Member Swann agreed, noting that biographical information on prominent pioneers is currently lacking, but he and others are actively working on compiling it. Board Member Moreno-Orama suggested including contextual details such as military service—e.g., how many World War I and World War II veterans are buried at the Cemetery—to strengthen the historical argument. Board Member Swann added that the general standard for historic designation includes properties 50 years or older, and noted that many such graves would meet this criterion. There was further discussion amongst the board about the historic site at Church Street and 14th Avenue. Board Member Swann raised a question about the archival materials at the City’s storage facility at 38054 Pasco Avenue, specifically whether valuable historic photographs housed there had been preserved. 6.4 Historic Dade City Website GIS Planner 1 Craig Hanson explained City staff sent out 91 letters directing homeowners on the Historic Register to visit the Historic Dade City website. 7. PUBLIC COMMENTS (For items not already discussed) Blane McCullough, of 35363 Sarah Lynn Drive, thanked City staff and the board members for their dedication and for the opportunity to speak. He clarified his earlier comments regarding the Cemetery, stating that he believes City maintenance should be handled by internal personnel rather than outside contractors. He noted that the City currently uses a 54” and a 60” mower, with the overall maintenance workload comprising approximately 60% mowing and 40% weeding. Blane McCullough, who works for the City’s Public Works Department, presented a proposal involving decorative metal horse head toppers for stop signs at the intersection of Church Street and 14th Street. He explained that these metal horse heads, inspired by 1930s-era signage, would enhance the historic character of the area. He emphasized that Church Street is a high-traffic corridor, especially with nearby schools and visitors from out of town, and the addition would serve both aesthetic and cultural purposes. The plan includes placing the horse head designs perpendicular to oncoming traffic on all four stop signs. This would be Phase One of a larger proposal to introduce historically styled, corrugated stop signs across additional areas, potentially including the central business district. Blane McCullough discussed design options, including Americana and European influences, and described ideas for cement bases and broader support structures. Board Member Swann commented that Blane McCullough would be an excellent candidate for the Historic Preservation Board, though noted he lives outside city limits. Board Member Black expressed he would love to see these signs on Church Street and encouraged further discussion regarding how other municipalities have implemented similar historical signage. He mentioned that the timing aligns with budget season and noted the possibility of exploring grants to support the project. Chair Beagles voiced the board’s support, asking whether they were seeking formal approval, Blane McCullough discussed Public Works projects. Chair Beagles summarized that the proposal reflects the board’s goals to embrace and promote historic character. She supported moving forward with the concept and encouraged collaboration to develop a suitable prototype for future presentation and broader implementation. Blane McCullough concluded by sharing his vision for Dade City, and he said there are other little things he would like to attend to downtown. He described Dade City as a great place to get away, with unique buildings and streets, and expressed his desire to inspire the younger generation to appreciate and engage with their community’s heritage. Chair Beagles thanked Mr. McCullough for his thoughtful presentation and supported beginning with Phase One if this is productive. 8. MEMBER COMMENTS Board Member Chandler discussed an idea to place historical signage markers along the Hardy Trail. He said he walks the trail every day, often more than once, and has noticed more and more young families using it. He would like to see it become a walking destination that highlights local history. He envisioned placards telling visitors things they may not have known about the area—adding that the further you walk, the more interesting the experience becomes. Board Member Hunter agreed it would be a good idea to tie in the trail with the town’s history. Board Member Chandler mentioned the idea has already generated interest online, receiving 5,000 views and numerous shares from his comments on Facebook. Board Member Black said the initiative should pinpoint sites along the route that are worth highlighting and noted that the trail itself follows the old railroad track, which is historically significant. Board Member Chandler also volunteered to help plant drought-tolerant plants along the trail and mentioned he has a pickup truck to assist with the effort, though he noted dry soil has been a challenge. Chair Beagles encouraged the board to consider the trail and the cemetery as part of their “homework” to visit and reflect on before the next meeting. Board Member Swann said to piggyback off Board Member Chandler’s idea, he would like to see the City leverage its investment in the Chronicle software and its GPS capabilities. He suggested the City explore extending those capabilities to the trail and other historic properties. There was further discussion about potential mapping initiatives and how the software could support future historic area documentation. 9. ADJOURNMENT Chair Beagles adjourned the meeting at 7:23 P.M.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Historic Board - 24 Apr 2025 (2025-04-24)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: b4e9db8931f780790bd7a710e438a0ec. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record