POLISCOPE

The public record

BREVARD COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Brevard County Board of County Commissioners

Thursday, September 5, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

L.3. Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 1, Vice-Chair

The Brevard County Board of County Commissioners held a meeting to conduct zoning hearings and adopt the 2035 Water Supply Facilities Work Plan. The Board approved an ordinance amending the Comprehensive Plan to align with updated water, sewer, and conservation policies. Public testimony was provided regarding concerns over transparency, sewage treatment infrastructure, and development density.

Why it matters

This meeting establishes the long-term framework for water and sewer infrastructure development in Brevard County, which directly impacts future land use and utility planning for residents.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

20

Recorded outcomes

20

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

20 captured items have a publicly linked outcome. These 5 are the clearest resident summaries in the record.

Search all 20 meeting actions
  • Item L.3.

    L.3. Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 1, Vice-Chair

    Moved by John Tobia · Seconded by Rob Feltner

    approved - Commissioner Pritchett stated Sandra Sullivan started it; if she starts bringing scripture every meeting, she will bring one, too, and this will be great; Romans 8:28, “And we all know that all things work together for good for those who love God and to them who are called according to His purpose;” she noted a couple of things she wants to mention to everybody is that Brevard is such a great community and County; it is wonderful having people come out and giving their opinion on things; and by the time the Board gets done, hopefully everyone will move forward. She advised one never makes themselves any better by trying to make someone else worse; when one mocks them and ridicules them, it always comes back to the person; and she expressed her appreciation to all on how they have handled things. Upon motion and vote, the meeting adjourned 9:04 p.m. ATTEST: _________________________ _____________________________ RACHEL M. SADOFF, CLERK JASON STEELE, CHAIR BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BREVARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
  • Item H.1.

    Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. (All Districts)

    Moved by Rita Pritchett · Seconded by Tom Goodson

    approved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider an ordinance to adopt the WSFWP and related Comprehensive Plan Amendments. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan; this applies to all Commission Districts; to comply with the statutory requirements, the attached ordinance amends the potable water element with the Comprehensive Plan, with the updated 2035 Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and amends the various policies with the conservation, potable water, sanitary sewer, intergovernmental coordination of the capital improvements, and elements of the Comprehensive Plan for consistency with the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on April 4, 2024, the Board approved transmittal of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on June 18, 2024, Florida Commerce issued the objections, recommendations, and comments report; this report identified no objections, made no recommendations, and provided no comments that must be addressed prior to the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and related Comprehensive Plan Amendment to the Board; on August 12, 2024, the Local Planning Agency recommended approval of adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and the related Comprehensive Plan Amendments; and staff is here to answer any questions that the Board might have. Sandra Sullivan commented with this particular Item, the Board receives the hat; very seldom does it get the hat; this is about septic, the toilet to tap, as they call it; Senator Rick Scott vetoed the toilet to tap legislation, and Governor Ron DeSantis approved it; in this, the Board is making Comprehensive Plan changes to facilitate this; and she just thinks there should be a whole lot more transparency to the people about what the County is doing. She went on to say at a recent meeting, she left her house, and an Item was not on the Agenda; when she arrived here, it was an add-on for basically a study that she did a records request on; the County is doing another study to essentially put a new facility, according to this . . . she knows this is the Comp Plan, but the Comp Plan is enabling this; according to this study, the County is putting a sewage treatment plant in the vicinity of Titusville-Cocoa Airport Authority (TICO); the report talks about partnership funding, partnership potentially with a private sector person to do this sewage plant; and it just raises a question whether the Brightline acquisition for $388,000,000 is what it is talking about. She noted what is also being talked about is a new tax on the people; this is called a tax increment reinvestment zone; she has never heard of it; essentially, what it is for is it is a study that was done for Space Florida and for the Cape, so the County can find a taxing mechanism to essentially put this on ‘We the People’ for ‘We the Money Interest;’ there is Phase I, Phase II, Phase III, and how it is going to be done, with temporarily the Sykes Creek, of course; and this topic cannot be discussed without discussing the legislative change this year that changes so they can put Senate Bill (SB) 102, the live local, not so local, tax incentives, et cetera, and bonus density for developers on Space Florida; and she bets most people do not know that. She sated at a recent Lagoon meeting, it showed the tripling of the size of Merritt Island; of course, there are lots of flooding issues there; she provided the Board with her very creative artwork handouts; and she advised she is very much against this Plan change. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-21, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”, setting forth the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an appendix to the potable water element and amendments necessary to implement the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part I, entitled Conservation Element to Adopt New Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VI, entitled Potable Water Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies and Adopt New Policies and Adopt the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an Appendix to the Potable Water Element; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VII, entitled Sanitary Sewer Element to Revised Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XII, Entitled Intergovernmental Coordination Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies, specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XIII, entitled Capital Improvements Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI, entitled Glossary to Add New Definitions; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date.
  • Item H.2.

    Gerald Patterson (Raymond Burnette) requests a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1. (24Z00022) (Tax Account 2000981) (District 1)

    Moved by Rita Pritchett · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from GU (General Use) to RRMH-1 (Rural Residential Mobile Home), as petitioned by Gerald Patterson. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this Item is Gerald Patterson requesting a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1; the application number is 24Z00022; the Tax Account Number is 2000981; and this is located in District 1. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1, located on the west side of Blounts Ridge Road, north of Patty Lane, Mims, as requested by Gerald Patterson.
  • Item H.13.

    Villas of Sherwood Titusville, Inc.; Algarrobo Development, LLC; Sherwood Golf Club, Inc.; and TRSTE, LLC, (Jorge Ballarena) requests a change of zoning classification from, GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and PUD with two existing BDP’s, to all PUD and removal of two existing BDPs. (23Z00035) (Tax Accounts 2100937, 2113020, 2112021, 2113023, 2113024, 2100938, 2100939, 2100940, 2100942, 2100943, 2100952, 2100953, 2111319, & 2101061) (District 1)

    Moved by Rita Pritchett · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and Planned Unit Development (PUD) with two existing Binding Development Plans (BDPs) to all PUD and Removal of Two Existing BDPs, as petitioned by Villas of Sherwood Titusville, Inc., Algarrobo Development, LLC; Sherwood Golf Club, Inc.; and TRSTE, LLC. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request for change of zoning classification from GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and PUD with two existing BDPs to all PUD and removal of two existing BDPs; approved with a BDP incorporating the following 14 conditions: 1) The proposed development shall be limited to 187 SF units and 408 MF units. 2) Due to historical drainage patterns and flooding issues, a drainage study with and associated master drainage plan is needed prior to construction of the first phase of the development. 3) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-1446. PUD-Land Use Regulations; Sub-Section (d) Minimum lot area, frontage, and setbacks; accessory uses; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required 5,000 sf minimum lot area to 4,000 sf. (POD III Only). All affected lots shall have substantial relationship to a 15’ common open space tract directly adjacent to the affected dwelling units. 4) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-1446. PUD-Land Use Regulations; Sub-Section (d) Minimum lot area, frontage, and setbacks; accessory uses; Paragraph (3) - to reduce the required minimum 20 feet rear setback to 10 feet. (POD III). This is conditioned upon POD III containing a minimum of eighteen acres of common recreation and open space as defined by Brevard County Code. 5) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards.; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required minimum 50 feet wide right-of-way to a minimum of 30 feet with 10-foot easements on each side for POD III. The affected rights-of-way shall be private and maintained by the Homeowner’s Association. 6) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required minimum 50 feet wide right-of-way to a minimum of 30 feet with a 5-foot easement on each side for PODS I and IV. The affected rights-of-way shall be private and maintained by the Homeowner’s Association. 7) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (3)-to reduce the minimum 100-foot setback of the cul-de-sac right-of-way to the plat boundary to 15 feet with the inclusion of a 6’ high wall and landscaping in one (1) location (POD III). Landscaping shall consist of a minimum of 2 shade trees per 100 LF and 4 under-story trees per 100 LF. 8) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2883. General design requirements and standards; Sub-Section (d)-to replace the required 15’ perimeter buffer tract with a 15’ perimeter buffer easement, or 10' perimeter easement where adjacent to an existing drainage easement, and allow it to be disturbed for grading, landscape, and buffer improvements, including but not limited to walls, fences, retention slopes, walking paths, and utilities (POD III). 9) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat, the Developer shall: a. Execute an agreement, which may include, but is not limited to, a Proportionate Fair Share agreement, with the County addressing and/or mitigating any infrastructure deficiencies relating to the off site transportation impacts as identified in a traffic study that is caused by the development. The agreement may include provisions requiring the developer to design, permit, and construct the identified improvements at a cost to the developer that is proportionate to the project’s impact. In addition, the agreement will identify time frames for the necessary improvements, and monitoring and updating the traffic study as appropriate. 10) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat/and or Site Plan, the Developer shall demonstrate that adequate water and sewer services will be available to the development and are available prior to issuance of Certificate of Occupancy. 11) Address all staff comments regarding the PDP prior to, or concurrent with, site plan and subdivision submittals. 12) In accordance with Section 62-1301, if it is the opinion of the zoning official that an amendment to the PDP warrants Board evaluation, such modifications shall be submitted for Board approval. 13) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat and/or Site Plan, the Developer shall submit a road system condition assessment to include an evaluation of potential impacts on public safety. The study will be conducted per methodology provided for in County land development code or as otherwise agreed to with staff. 14) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat and/or Site Plan, the Developer shall submit a traffic calming study for the affected roadways and will identify necessary improvements to mitigate speeding and encourage preferred routing of traffic. The study will be conducted per methodology provided for in County land development code or as otherwise agreed to with staff.
  • Item H.3.

    Home Nation Cocoa, LLC (Roxanne Comino) requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11. (24Z00027) (Tax Account 2419394) (District 2)

    Moved by Tom Goodson · Seconded by Rob Feltner

    approved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from AU (Agricultural Residential) to RU-1-11 (Single-Family Residential), as petitioned by Home Nation Cocoa, LLC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Home Nation Cocoa, LLC requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11; the application number is 24Z00027; the Tax Account Number is 2419394; and this is located in District 2. Susan Martini stated when they purchased this property it was zoned as AU; they need it to be rezoned because it no longer qualifies per lot size for AU in the County; and they are going to do a single-family residence on there. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved request for change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11, on property located on the southeast corner of Lucas Road and Bevis Road, Cocoa.

Recorded votes

5 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (5)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Pritchettyes
Goodsonyes
Tobiayes
Feltneryes
Steeleyes
passed

H.1 Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan

passed

H.2 Zoning change GU to RRMH-1 (Patterson)

passed

H.3 Zoning change AU to RU-1-11 (Home Nation Cocoa)

passed

H.4 CUP for alcohol in PUD (Borrows West Hotel)

passed

H.5 Zoning change RU-1-7 to RU-1-11 (Futrell)

Money

  • $388,000,000 · Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. (All Districts)

  • $14,000, · Villas of Sherwood, Inc. & Sherwood Golf Club, Inc. (Jorge Ballarena) request a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (23S.05) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 4 to RES 15. (23SS00005) (Tax Account 2100937, 2100938, 2113021, 2111319) (District 1)

  • $35 · Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use Designation from AGRIC to RES 6. (24SS00002) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1)

  • $1 · JEN Florida 48, LLC, requests Adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 & CC. (Residential 1 per 2.5 acres) to RES 4 (Residential 4) and CC (Community Commercial). (23LS00001) (Tax Account 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, 3000829) (District 5)

People and votes

Rita Pritchett

County Commissioner

Open person dossier

8 motions · 4 seconds · 5 recorded votes

  1. MotionItem H.1.

    Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. (All Districts) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  2. MotionItem H.2.

    Gerald Patterson (Raymond Burnette) requests a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1. (24Z00022) (Tax Account 2000981) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  3. MotionItem H.13.

    Villas of Sherwood Titusville, Inc.; Algarrobo Development, LLC; Sherwood Golf Club, Inc.; and TRSTE, LLC, (Jorge Ballarena) requests a change of zoning classification from, GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and PUD with two existing BDP’s, to all PUD and removal of two existing BDPs. (23Z00035) (Tax Accounts 2100937, 2113020, 2112021, 2113023, 2113024, 2100938, 2100939, 2100940, 2100942, 2100943, 2100952, 2100953, 2111319, & 2101061) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  4. MotionItem H.5.

    Paul & Laurie Ann Futrell requests a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11. (24Z00028) (Tax Account 2802480) (District 5) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  5. MotionItem H.9.

    Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with a BSP to BU-1 with removal of the BSP. (24Z00023) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  6. MotionItem H.8.

    Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.08), to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 2 (Residential 2) to CC. (24SS00008) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  7. MotionItem H.7.

    Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 to TR-3 with an amended BDP. (24Z00005) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1). - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  8. SecondItem H.11.

    JEN Florida 48, LLC (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from GU & AU to PUD. (23PUD00005) (Tax Account 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, 3000829) (District 5) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  9. SecondItem J.1.

    Waivers of Subdivision Requirements, Re: Clover Townhomes (24WV00002, 24WV00003, 24WV00004, 24WV00006, 24WV00007) (District 2) Developer: Schwab Construction Group, Inc. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  10. Second

    Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use Designation from AGRIC to RES 6. (24SS00002) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  11. Second

    JEN Florida 48, LLC, requests Adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 & CC. (Residential 1 per 2.5 acres) to RES 4 (Residential 4) and CC (Community Commercial). (23LS00001) (Tax Account 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, 3000829) (District 5) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  12. Motion

    Villas of Sherwood, Inc. & Sherwood Golf Club, Inc. (Jorge Ballarena) request a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (23S.05) to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 4 to RES 15. (23SS00005) (Tax Account 2100937, 2100938, 2113021, 2111319) (District 1) - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  13. Recorded voteItem H.1

    H.1 Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan - Voted yes on the motion “Adopt Ordinance No. 24-21 amending the Comprehensive Plan and Water Supply Facilities Work Plan”; the record reports passed.

  14. Recorded voteItem H.2

    H.2 Zoning change GU to RRMH-1 (Patterson) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve request for change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1”; the record reports passed.

  15. Recorded voteItem H.3

    H.3 Zoning change AU to RU-1-11 (Home Nation Cocoa) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve request for change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11”; the record reports passed.

  16. Recorded voteItem H.4

    H.4 CUP for alcohol in PUD (Borrows West Hotel) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve CUP for on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification”; the record reports passed.

  17. Recorded voteItem H.5

    H.5 Zoning change RU-1-7 to RU-1-11 (Futrell) - Voted yes on the motion “Approve change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11”; the record reports passed.

See all 5 roll calls with named votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 196,809 characters. The full document is at the source.

Thursday, September 5, 2024 5:00 PM Brevard County Board of County Commissioners 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way Viera, FL 32940 Commission Chambers Minutes Zoning September 5, 2024 Rollcall Commissioner District 1 Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 2 Tom Goodson, Commissioner District 3 John Tobia, Commissioner District 4 Rob Feltner, and Commissioner District 5 Jason Steele Present: A. CALL TO ORDER 5:00 PM The Board of County Commissioners acts as a Quasi Judicial body when it hears requests for rezoning and Conditional Use Permits. Applicants must provide competent substantial evidence establishing facts, or expert witness opinion testimony showing that the request meets the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan criteria. Opponents must also testify as to facts, or provide expert testimony; whether they like, or dislike, a request is not competent evidence. The Board must then decide whether the evidence demonstrates consistency and compatibility with the Comprehensive Plan and the existing rules in the Zoning Ordinance, property adjacent to the property to be rezoned, and the actual development of the surrounding area. The Board cannot consider speculation, non expert opinion testimony, or poll the audience by asking those in favor or opposed to stand up or raise their hands. If a Commissioner has had communications regarding a rezoning or Conditional Use Permit request before the Board, Commissioner must disclose the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity, with whom the communication took place before the Board takes action on the request. Likewise, if a Commissioner has made a site visit, inspection, or investigation, the Commissioner must disclose that fact before the Board takes action on the request. Each applicant is allowed a total of 15 minutes to present their request unless the time is extended by a majority vote of the Board. The applicant may reserve any portion of the 15 minutes for rebuttal. Other speakers are allowed five minutes to speak. Speakers may not pass their time to someone else in order to give that person more time to speak. C. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Commissioner Rita Pritchett led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance. H.1. Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. (All Districts) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider an ordinance to adopt the WSFWP and related Comprehensive Plan Amendments. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan; this applies to all Commission Districts; to comply with the statutory requirements, the attached ordinance amends the potable water element with the Comprehensive Plan, with the updated 2035 Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and amends the various policies with the conservation, potable water, sanitary sewer, intergovernmental coordination of the capital improvements, and elements of the Comprehensive Plan for consistency with the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on April 4, 2024, the Board approved transmittal of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on June 18, 2024, Florida Commerce issued the objections, recommendations, and comments report; this report identified no objections, made no recommendations, and provided no comments that must be addressed prior to the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and related Comprehensive Plan Amendment to the Board; on August 12, 2024, the Local Planning Agency recommended approval of adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and the related Comprehensive Plan Amendments; and staff is here to answer any questions that the Board might have. Page 1 of 50 September 5, 2024 Sandra Sullivan commented with this particular Item, the Board receives the hat; very seldom does it get the hat; this is about septic, the toilet to tap, as they call it; Senator Rick Scott vetoed the toilet to tap legislation, and Governor Ron DeSantis approved it; in this, the Board is making Comprehensive Plan changes to facilitate this; and she just thinks there should be a whole lot more transparency to the people about what the County is doing. She went on to say at a recent meeting, she left her house, and an Item was not on the Agenda; when she arrived here, it was an add-on for basically a study that she did a records request on; the County is doing another study to essentially put a new facility, according to this . . . she knows this is the Comp Plan, but the Comp Plan is enabling this; according to this study, the County is putting a sewage treatment plant in the vicinity of Titusville-Cocoa Airport Authority (TICO); the report talks about partnership funding, partnership potentially with a private sector person to do this sewage plant; and it just raises a question whether the Brightline acquisition for $388,000,000 is what it is talking about. She noted what is also being talked about is a new tax on the people; this is called a tax increment reinvestment zone; she has never heard of it; essentially, what it is for is it is a study that was done for Space Florida and for the Cape, so the County can find a taxing mechanism to essentially put this on ‘We the People’ for ‘We the Money Interest;’ there is Phase I, Phase II, Phase III, and how it is going to be done, with temporarily the Sykes Creek, of course; and this topic cannot be discussed without discussing the legislative change this year that changes so they can put Senate Bill (SB) 102, the live local, not so local, tax incentives, et cetera, and bonus density for developers on Space Florida; and she bets most people do not know that. She sated at a recent Lagoon meeting, it showed the tripling of the size of Merritt Island; of course, there are lots of flooding issues there; she provided the Board with her very creative artwork handouts; and she advised she is very much against this Plan change. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-21, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”, setting forth the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an appendix to the potable water element and amendments necessary to implement the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part I, entitled Conservation Element to Adopt New Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VI, entitled Potable Water Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies and Adopt New Policies and Adopt the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an Appendix to the Potable Water Element; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VII, entitled Sanitary Sewer Element to Revised Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XII, Entitled Intergovernmental Coordination Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies, specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XIII, entitled Capital Improvements Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI, entitled Glossary to Add New Definitions; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.2. Gerald Patterson (Raymond Burnette) requests a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1. (24Z00022) (Tax Account 2000981) (District 1) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from GU Page 2 of 50 September 5, 2024 (General Use) to RRMH-1 (Rural Residential Mobile Home), as petitioned by Gerald Patterson. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this Item is Gerald Patterson requesting a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1; the application number is 24Z00022; the Tax Account Number is 2000981; and this is located in District 1. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1, located on the west side of Blounts Ridge Road, north of Patty Lane, Mims, as requested by Gerald Patterson. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.3. Home Nation Cocoa, LLC (Roxanne Comino) requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11. (24Z00027) (Tax Account 2419394) (District 2) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from AU (Agricultural Residential) to RU-1-11 (Single-Family Residential), as petitioned by Home Nation Cocoa, LLC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Home Nation Cocoa, LLC requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11; the application number is 24Z00027; the Tax Account Number is 2419394; and this is located in District 2. Susan Martini stated when they purchased this property it was zoned as AU; they need it to be rezoned because it no longer qualifies per lot size for AU in the County; and they are going to do a single-family residence on there. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved request for change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11, on property located on the southeast corner of Lucas Road and Bevis Road, Cocoa. Result: APPROVED Mover: Tom Goodson Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.4. Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC (Marbet Lewis) requests a CUP for the on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification. (24Z00030) (Tax Account 3030319) (District 4) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a CUP for on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification, as petitioned by Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this Item is Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC requesting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the on-premises consumption of alcohol in a Planning Unit Development (PUD) zoning classification; the application number is 24Z00030; the tax account is 3030319; and it is located in District 4. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved a CUP for on-premises Page 3 of 50 September 5, 2024 consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification on property located at the east end of Porada Drive, south of Viera Boulevard, Viera, as requested by Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.5. Paul & Laurie Ann Futrell requests a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11. (24Z00028) (Tax Account 2802480) (District 5) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a request by Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell for a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 (Single-Family Residential) to RU-1-11 (Single-Family Residential). Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell requests a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11; the application number is 24Z00028; the tax account is 2802480; and it is located in District 5. There being no comments or objection, the Board approved a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11 on property located on the west side of Vine Street, south of Milwaukee Avenue, Melbourne, as petitioned by Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.6. Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use Designation from AGRIC to RES 6. (24SS00002) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a request by Aaron Reninger for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use (FLU) designation from AGRIC (Agricultural) to RES 6 (Residential 6). Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, commented that Item H.6. and H.7. are companion applications; he is going to read them into the record together; however, separate motions will need to be made for each Item; Item H.6., is Aaron Reninger requests a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment 24S.02, to change the Future Land Use designation from AGRIC to RES 6; the application number is 24SS00002; the Tax Account Numbers are 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2202231, and 2002232; and they are located in District 1. He continued by saying Item H.7. is Aaron Reninger requesting a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 to TR-3, with an amended Binding Development Plan (BDP); the application number is 24Z0005; the Tax Account Numbers are 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2202231, and 2002232; and they are located in District 1. He mentioned that the application was advertised with an amended BDP; currently, there is no BDP; and currently, on the property when these items went to the Local Planning Agency (LPA) and Planning & Zoning (P&Z), both were recommended for denial. Page 4 of 50 September 5, 2024 Kim Rezanka, Lacy Lyons Rezanka, representing Aaron Reninger, advised this is a request for a change in the Future Land Use and a change of zoning on 17.01 acres; if the Board has read the Planning and Zoning minutes, there was quite a bit of distaste for this project; this client listened to what people said; he is now coming back and requesting to change the Future Land Use request to one to 2.5 acres, and the zoning to RRMH-2.5, so that means every lot would be two and a half acres; and they would only have six lots. She stated this is very compatible with what is out there; what is around it is one acre, two acres, and three acres; it is on a dirt road; the residents thought it was too dense; her client listened, so now they have asked to change it; right now it is an agricultural Future Land Use of five units to the acre, with an RRMH-1, which is one unit to the acre; and right now, they have an inconsistency, he could not build anything there anyway. She continued by saying they would like to suggest that this character of the area, this is compliant with the character of the area; he can do single-family homes; he is going to do a subdivision of six lots; it will be different than what he had planned before, but he is still hoping to do the tiny homes or manufactured homes, which are out there already, the manufactured homes, and to make it more affordable; with that, they are happy to answer questions, Mr. Reninger is here; and they believe that this will hopefully satisfy the residents, and help them realize that he does indeed want to be a good neighbor. She asked the Board to accept an amended application; she noted also with the BDP, they already had a BDP, but this would actually limit the development to six units to the acre; they would comply with the subdivision and plat code, which is Article VII of Chapter 62; apparently, there are some Code Enforcement actions out there that would have to be remedied and resolved prior to any building permits being issued, so there will be three conditions of a BDP; and they are here to answer any questions and to listen to the neighbors in case they do not like this deal. Bob Brooks commented he is the direct neighbor of Mr. Reninger’s property; he came here to go directly against the plan for the tiny home and/or mobile home development; this changes everything, so he does not have a lot to say at the moment; if it were to go to six homes, and he did a little bit of research on it, he thinks he would be behind that; again, he is the direct neighbor; he did not want 30 homes behind his house; and that is really all he had to say, because it changed gears in mid-stream. Chair Steele explained if the rest of the speakers come up and feel the same way as Mr. Brooks, he or she can say they waive in favor or against it, or they can speak, as it is up to them. Ken Harrison stated he is going to speak to this as if it was under the previous plan; the Code of Ordinances 62-1255, Brevard County, establishment of zoning classifications in consistency with Comprehensive Plans; 62-1255(a)(1)(c), current zoning is Agricultural; 62-1255(a)(8)(b) requested zoning is Residential 6; and the 1988 County Comprehensive Plan establishes specific Future Land Use designations, which are depicted on the Future Land Use Map within the Future Land Use element. He remarked this plan is further reinforced by the April 2007 Mims Small Area Study; both the 1988 Comprehensive Plan and the 2007 Mims Small Area Study determined the Future Land Use to be Agricultural and set limits to one dwelling unit per five acres west of Meadow Green Road; properties with approved RRMH-1, AU, and AGR zoning classifications prior to the study were retained and adopted; this property is located in this zoning classification area and an increase in density would be an encroachment into the existing neighborhood; and the subject property does not serve as a transition between areas with land use designations of six units per acre or existing land use designations equal to no more than one unit per acre. He added Administrative Policy 3 relates to traffic safety issues due to increased traffic, material reduction of property values due to higher density in tiny homes, and real estate comparable sales values for the subject area will decrease; proposed use is not consistent with the emerging or existing pattern of surrounding development as Page 5 of 50 September 5, 2024 determined through analysis of historical use patterns, actual development over the immediately preceding three years; six new block single-family residences were built in the last three years; two of them border the subject property; development approved, but not constructed, is one single-family residence at 4110 Hog Valley Road; the proposed use will result in a material violation of relevant policies; and wetlands destructions have occurred. He stated Policy 4, character of the neighborhood, the character of the neighborhood or area will be materially or adversely affected by the proposed rezoning or land use application; the proposed rezoning and land use will cause a 200 percent increase in traffic on Gandy Road; there are 14 single-family residences on Gandy Road; 30 more single-family residences will cause a burden in significant safety and convenience issues on an already poorly maintained dirt road that is only graded 12 times a year; the road is too narrow for two cars to pass each other at certain points; and it is poorly drained and unstable with loose soil. He pointed out the subject property is part of Indian River Park; Indian River Park is a clearly established residential neighborhood; platted in 1914, the south border is especially defined as the south line of the Bernardo Sequi Land Grant, and has been mapped as such since the Spanish land grants; the subject property’s south line is also the south border of Indian River Park; the north, west, and east boundaries are designated as agricultural land use with agricultural zoning; and to the south is public conservation with general use and agricultural zoning. He advised the requested zoning and FLU could change the subject property to commercial use, if rent is charged; there are no commercial use properties in the entire area; the area is not considered transitional; Administrative Policy 5, states if the residents of proposed zoning change utilize public transportation, it would have a significant impact; the physical quality of Gandy Road will suffer significant deterioration with a 200 percent increase in traffic on a poorly maintained dirt road; and problems with the width of the road. He noted loose soils of Gandy Road would cause a traffic safety concern for pedestrians; it is likely Gandy Road would suffer adverse changes from the type of traffic that would be generated; physical deterioration would occur from larger truck delivers; under Policy 6, the proposed rezoning and FLU is not consistent with all written land development policies set forth in the administrative policies, including potable water, sanitary sewer, and surface water; under Policy 7, the subject property contains mapped national wetlands inventory, St. Johns River Water Management District wetlands and hydric soils; per Section 62-3694(c)(1), residential land uses within wetlands shall be limited to not more than one dwelling unit per five acres; and the applicants have filled and cleared subject property without proper permits and are in clear violations of County Codes. Chair Steele noted he wants to make sure that everyone heard the changes that Ms. Rezanka made prior to the time that he or she speaks. Stephanie Knight advised it is kind of hard, because they already prepared for it, so had they known that in advance, they could have prepared for her new update. Commissioner Pritchett pointed out she would not have approved 30 lots out there; it would not fit; if they had some input with this, she was actually thinking if they could come up with something with six or eight, and they have come with six; if the residents have any idea of other criteria; she has a copy of the BDP; and she thinks it seems like a good fit for the residents, so if he or she has any other suggestions, she is all ears. Ms. Knight asked the main question is can that be changed; and she asked if he is having a BDP, can that just change. Commissioner Pritchett replied no, when it is binding they have to stick to it and cannot change it. Page 6 of 50 September 5, 2024 Ms. Knight asked without circumstances. Commissioner Pritchett responded unless they come back and get another Board to agree to it; and it would be like changing their zoning. Ms. Knight asked if everyone would have to do what they just did, they would all have to come back to the Board. Commissioner Pritchett replied affirmatively. Ms. Knight remarked her biggest concern to having what he is now asking for is again, what was said before, the wetlands; he has destroyed wetlands; if the Board would notice in some of the maps it was given by Mr. Harrison, the entryway to his property was wetlands, so all of that was destroyed in order to even get to his property; she understands he is now only wanting six houses for the amount of acreage that he has; but the fact is that he is now going over the wetlands that he has destroyed in order to even get to his property in the first place; and it kind of put a dirty taste in everybody’s mouth that had he not destroyed them in the first place, he would not even be able to get to his property. She pointed out if he would have done it the right way to begin with, this would not even be an issue and the residents would not even be asking for 30, three, six, or whatever the case may be; that would be her biggest concern, and not ever be able to change it; she does not like the fact that it is tiny homes; mobile homes are fine; but tiny homes bring in a whole different amount of people. Chair Steele exclaimed once again, he does not think tiny homes are even being talked about here. Ms. Knight stated he did mentioned tiny homes or mobile homes, so with that being said, with Code violations that he has already on the property, and the fact that he has to drive over the wetlands, other than that would just be the septic issues, which if he only has six for 17 acres, she guesses that would not be a septic issue. Alana Walsh commented she, of course, also was prepared to come and talk about the proposal for 30 homes; she thinks they had ample time and opportunity to let the residents know they were going to change the plan, and failed to do so; and she asked if it is still going to be like a mobile home park, are they still going to be rented out, or are they going to sell these properties. Chair Steele explained she can ask a question, but he does not know that the Board is going to answer that question right now; and it will look into that. Ms. Walsh remarked because that is one of the concerns if they are going to be rentals. Chair Steele stated to go ahead with the comments; and he asked if she is finished. Ms. Walsh pointed out she came prepared to talk about 30, and they did not know it was changing. Chair Steele advised when something like this happens and it happens for the better, which he thinks this does, she has to take it when she can get it, so if she has any other discussion in regards to what is on the table, go ahead and talk about it; and if not, the hearing will be continued and see where it goes. Page 7 of 50 September 5, 2024 Ms. Walsh stated as a community member, just the fact that it changed and they did not know is disheartening. Chair Steele stated yes, ma’am, it is frustrating sometimes, these things. Brian Walsh stated his main concern is if these are going to be rentals, if it is going to be ran in a traditional mobile home park, or single-family dwellings, which would be nice to have the answer to, just for crime and everything else that would be in the area. Chair Steele advised that Commissioner Pritchett is going to ask that question to the applicant. Patricia Frank commented she has lived out there for most of her 63 years; she has seen a lot of changes come and go; the impact that the extra traffic, dump trucks, semis, and heavy equipment that is going to have an impact Aurantia Road, Meadow Green, Harrison Road, and Hog Valley Road, because there is only one way in and one way out to Gandy Road, so it does not just affect Gandy, it affects all of the people that live along Aurantia, Meadow Green, Harrison, Hog Valley, and Gandy; they now have potholes in Aurantia Road that have yet to be fixed or maintained as it is; they cannot get it fixed; and now they are going to have more traffic on Aurantia Road, and how that extra traffic is going to impact the intersection where the Circle K is right there. She noted they have been doing improvements, Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) has been out there burying electrical lines, they have had a lot of work trucks, and there are a lot of places on Aurantia Road that needs repair; she asked what about them; she asked if taxes are going to be increased for repaving the road, because getting out to Gandy Road, all of this heavy equipment is going to have a negative impact on the infrastructure; she noted that is her questions and concerns; and she asked why should they have to pay for what gets torn up for this fella to bring his pipedream to fruition. She mentioned she would just like to see their growth be managed in a positive way. Corey Roberson explained he prepared a speech for today that was for the homes that was supposed to be on there; he thinks it was very inappropriate and ill-mannered to come here for a speech for an amendment that they made; he does not believe that is fair to the residents; he does not think a ruling should be made today on the rezoning of the property honestly; and he thinks it was a joke. Chair Steele stated he understands the residents’ emotions in response to applauding, but to just stop that tonight, as the Board has a lot of things to talk about and it would be better if the clapping was curtailed. Commissioner Tobia advised he understands the frustration of the change, whether it went his way or not. Mr. Roberson noted regardless of his way or anybody’s way, the fact of the matter is when people prep for court, he or she gets a timeframe; they came here in the beginning, made a statement, and they do not have any notice. Commissioner Tobia stated he has a question; he asked they dropped it from 30 to six, and is there a number in his mind that would fit well with that number. Mr. Roberson replied zero at the moment, because they were amending it at the time; right now he does not have a chance to look over it; first of all, when they make decisions, people of the community would like to get together and figure out what a best number would be towards it; he is not against a home or two homes on the property; but the fact of the matter is they amended Page 8 of 50 September 5, 2024 it. He went on to say at the beginning of this meeting when people come here prepared for something else, so no one has any idea other than what they just come up here and said in five minutes to try to change their plans after everybody came here with something else to say. Commissioner Tobia asked if right now he is okay with zero homes there. Mr. Roberson responded he did not say . . . it could be six, it could be, he could be okay with 10; but the fact of the matter is he has got to . . . Commissioner Tobia pointed out he has to make a vote . . . Mr. Roberson noted they are making a vote, so what he is saying is today, regardless, since they amended today, the Board is making a vote on the homes regardless of the amendment. Commissioner Tobia explained he does not know whether there will be a motion one way or the other; and he asked how many homes Mr. Roberson is okay with; he stated he is not okay with 30, he understands that; but he again asked how many he is okay with. Mr. Roberson replied two. Commissioner Pritchett stated what the Commissioners are supposed to do is to get the information and make a decision; the Board has to hear all of the speakers’ views, get all of the evidence, and then it is supposed to hopefully make the best decision it can; it is the Board’s job not to make an emotional decision, so as it listens to the speakers’ concerns, that is what he or she is going to try to do, try to make a good decision for this plot of land; it is 17 acres; and when the Board does this, he or she has to remember that the owner has rights as well as the neighborhood, so these are the things that have to be taken into consideration. She went on to add anything the speakers give the Board right now is really good so a decision can be made, if he or she is going to vote, or how he or she is going to vote, so that is what the Board is trying to gather from them tonight; nobody is for or against them; and the Board is just trying to make a good decision for the community. Commissioner Goodson inquired all that being said, could he ask the engineer to come back up here, or would he consider postponing this to the next Planning and Zoning meeting, giving these people time to discuss this proposal. Ms. Rezanka advised Mr. Reninger said that was fine; there are six lots now; he could do six lots now in theory; she understands their concerns; and they thought this would make them happy, they are still not happy, but they would be happy to come back next month if that is the Board’s preference. Commissioner Goodson stated he is not sure they are not happy; but they need an ample amount of time to do it, just like he would like the time to study a contract on buying a car or whatever; and he asked if he is willing to give them that time, what the rush is. Commissioner Pritchett noted she does not mind doing that either; it can be postponed to the next zoning meeting; but there are already people here, so if they want to talk, they can go ahead and maybe give their information right now if they want to, or they can come back later; when she went over the data the other day and spoke with staff, they knew they would not be able to get 30 in there; and there are water problems with salinity in the water. She mentioned six to eight lots do fit, so it is up to the residents if they want to wait four more weeks to wait on this, she is sure it will not hurt to do that; it does look like a fairly decent project right now; and Page 9 of 50 September 5, 2024 maybe the speakers will need a little more time to absorb it. Commissioner Feltner asked if the Board is going to continue with the cards. Chair Steele replied right now he is completely opposed to what Commissioner Goodson is saying, he would like to get this done tonight; but it is up to the Commission. Commissioner Feltner stated he did not want to interrupt the cards, but he has one question. Chair Steele pointed out if the Board tables it to next month, his intention is to not allow these people who have come here to speak; it is going to be a lengthy process; and he is having a difficult time understanding why six units would not make these folks happy. He asked if Commissioner Goodson is making a motion to continue the Item. Commissioner Goodson replied he is making a motion to continue the Item. Commissioner Pritchett remarked she will second the motion after the cards. Mr. Ball asked if he can interject for a second; and he suggested to continue the item to the next Zoning Board hearing, which is October 3, 2024. Yarnell Roman stated she came here because of the impact of the value of the properties; at the last meeting it was said, the values in the area range from $35 to $200,000; it was also said that the average value of the proposed project will be $150,000; she wants to put on the record that there is a mistake on this premise; they have recently sold properties in the area from 350,000 to $500,000; and examples of these are 4745 Gandy Road, 4199 Heida Lake, 4254 Hog Valley, 4706 Gandy Road, 4940 Harrison Road, and 4768 Harrison Road. She remarked there are three properties available for sale right now, 4970 Harrison Road for $340,000, 4540 Wellington Lane for $520,000, 5245 Blunt Ridge Road for $475,000; there have also been luxury homes recently built that are appraising for over $600,000, like 4705 Gandy Road, and 4155 Hog Valley Road; and new homes are going up with projected values of over $400,000 like 4241 Hog Valley Road and 4150 Hog Valley. She stated even the land value is more than the range established on the last meeting; as an example, 4776 Pine Needle Street with a sales price of $85,000 for an acre, so this information is important because the approval of any project cannot negatively impact the value of their properties; she wants to add the construction risk assessment; the following information has been provided by First Street, a government and private resource to provide climate risk data for informed decision-making; there is a fire factor in the area; the area where whatever project is proposed is currently on a severe fire risk factor of seven of 10; in the last 20 years more than 100 wildfires were recorded within just 20 miles of Gandy Road, having an impact of an average of 61 properties; and the a major risk of wildfire events in the next 15 years. She pointed out that in addition to property damage, wildfires can also cut off access to utilities, emergency services, transportation, and may impact the overall economic wellbeing of the area; with the limitations of proper evacuation routes they have now, the approval of these or any projects could turn into a major safety risk for the residents; and she thinks the responsible decision would be to just postpone and let the residents know what the correct project would involve, and give them another chance to speak, as they do not have the facts in order to say something. Valerie Lichtblau stated she had a whole different thing written-up because she did not plan on him changing it like that; she lives within 500 feet of the property the applicant is requesting to rezone; she has five acres, which is not in line with his now change of one-acre lots; she lives in a single-family home, which is adjacent to this property; she is against the rezoning of the Page 10 of 50 September 5, 2024 applicant’s property due to the flooding concerns on their little dirt road; one cannot even pass on the dirt road, as a person has to pull off; and every time it rains, just the 14 houses on the road puts damage on the road. She noted they do not come out and clean off the road as much as they should; it goes against the Mims Small Scale Study, which was designed to keep North Brevard rural; she does not know if he still wants to keep it agricultural or residential; she is also not happy that the residents came unprepared because he changed what he wants to do without notifying anyone or meeting with any property owners around that property; he has emailed one person before, but he could not email anybody to let them know he was changing it so they could tell how they feel about it; and they have no time to think about this now because he just changed it. Desiree Wimer commented her parents live within 500 feet at 4718 Gandy Road; without having time to research the new zoning request, it is hard to support something presented to them at the last minute; the owner does have a lot of contact information, including hers; he could have met or emailed them with any changes; and he actually requested having one of the meetings tabled so he could meet with them, and he did not follow through. She went on to say he bought the property knowing the current zoning, he knew what he purchased when he bought it; this is a rural agricultural area; the current zoning is correct, which she thinks that property would allow less than six homes; she has not seen anything to support changing the current zoning; and she is against changing the current zoning. Sandra Sullivan remarked obviously conversations have happened with the District 1 office and with staff, so knowing that they had some advanced notice that a different proposal would be put in place, this plan as put on the Agenda under Sunshine should have been either the applicant reapplying and it changed, or this should not have gone on this meeting today; this is like a fast one being pulled on the people; as residents of Brevard County, they expect transparency and accountability, and for the County to follow the State laws for Sunshine; and Sunshine requires five days’ notice or seven days’ notice. She went on by saying the County’s Policy is five days’ notice; these are Quasi-Judicial meetings; these are very serious for Planning and Zoning and should be treated as such; the fact that staff and even the District 1 office who indicated she would not have approved what there was, and there was conversations; this should not have been on the Agenda today; and she reiterated this should have been reapplied for and with transparency, or postponed to another meeting. Katie Delaney stated she really appreciates the suggestion about postponing this; she thinks that is definitely a great move since the people did not have time to prepare for what was being asked for tonight; being at the community meetings that she was at, where some of the residents were there talking about their concerns about this project, one of the major things they were talking about was the reason why this property was originally zoned for three homes is because of the flooding and the traffic issues that are back there; and she hopes the Board keeps that in mind when it moves forward. Commissioner Pritchett stated she would second Commissioner Goodson’s motion. Ms. Rezanka pointed out the zoning of this property is RRMH-1, which is one unit to the acre, or 17 units; the Future Land Use is Agricultural, which is five units to the acre; many of the lots in this area are exactly the same, and have one acre; there are five of these six parcels combined that are one acre; they could be built because it has been so long; and what they are asking for is what they can do now. She stated this came about yesterday in a meeting with Commissioner Pritchett; that was the earliest that they could get a meeting with her after Planning and Zoning; they did not notify the residents; but again, they thought his would not have been a problem based upon what they heard in the past; there was an email that Mr. Page 11 of 50 September 5, 2024 Reninger submitted to all of those who sent in opposition emails; on August 3rd he sent this; she will submit it for the record; and there were about 14 that he emailed, there was not just one. She continued by saying as to the values of the area, the lady did not identify herself, but from the card that was called, it was Ms. Roman; there is no indication she has any qualifications as an expert appraiser; she does want to state for the record, and she will submit these, that she has Property Appraiser market value sheets starting with James Stansell at 4775 Gandy; the market value is $31,460; she also has Robert Brooks at 5584 William Brim, $59,360; John Bauden $54,960; and she has several that she will submit for the record to show that her comments about the values in the area were indeed correct, as these are market values by the Property Appraiser. She advised regarding the claim that there are Code violations on this is incorrect; she is doing this to protect her client, because the statements that were made here are incorrect; Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) has been out to the site; she will also submit this for the record; she can give Commissioner Pritchett a copy so she has it as well; FDEP, as of September 3, 2024, says the inspection was made regarding dredging and filling within a wetland; an inspection determined these activities are occurring onsite; the inspection determined that although activities are occurring onsite, there were no wetland or other surface waters impacted observed on the property at the time of inspection; there are photos enclosed; she will submit this for the record; and anyone can request this if they want to. She noted this is a decrease in density; currently, the 17 units allowed by zoning, now requesting six; this is currently Agricultural Future Land Use and activities that have occurred on that property are Agricultural in nature, and are allowed by law; the comments about going through the wetland, there was a home on 4735, which is the access piece prior, and there was access there before Mr. Reninger purchased it; it is intended to be a platted subdivision; whether he rents or not, they are going to be platted; he may sell or rent; but it is not a zoning issue whether he sells or rents. She stated the Zoning Code under RRMH-2-5 allows manufactured homes, single-family homes, and tiny homes; tiny homes, again, $150,000 in value to start; she does not know what the Sunshine Law requires; Commissioner Pritchett did disclose, but she has not talked to the Commissioners, as that is the Sunshine Law, to her knowledge; this request seemed to make sense; Commissioner Pritchett could have made this request during this hearing at the end of the applicant’s presentation; the Board could have voted on that, as it can change with conditions and with permission from the applicant; this change is not that unusual; this happens in other hearings where the request is not compatible and the Commission or Council dislikes the request; and it would therefore ask for a change in density, lower in density. She exclaimed her client has said he is fine coming back on October 3rd, they are willing to do that; but she did want to state for the record and clarify the facts as they truly are; there are Code violations that may or may not be pending; her client has gotten no notice of them; she reiterated she will submit the FDEP record; and they will do the will of the Commission. Commissioner Goodson advised he would like to commend the developer/owner, as it was a very good decision for the Board to vote tonight and not give these people a chance, and come back in October and vote, whether the Board agrees with the residents or the applicant, it will be its vote at that time; he reiterated he just thinks the Board should just give these people the right to meet with the developer and attorney, and to get an understanding of what is being proposed, because things can get real screwy in this chamber; and he is not voting for this tonight, unless it is pushed back to October. Commissioner Pritchett explained she thinks a lot of people came in a little freaked out about 30 units, so she thinks that is why everybody’s a little intense; she agrees with Commissioner Goodson that just that little bit of time is needed for everybody to kind of figure out what is going on; she listened at her office, as that is what she does, she listens but does not render where she is at until she hears everything; the Board just heard the community; and they do not Page 12 of 50 September 5, 2024 like the project, so they are going to try a smaller number. She noted it was a good job everyone showing up, to get with the developer as he seems like a very nice person, and to get some nice families out there for them to keep the community good. Chair Steele called for a vote on the motion. There being no further comments or objections, the Board continued request for a Small Scale Plan Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02) to change the Future Land Use Map designation from AGRIC to RES 6, for property located south of Gandy Road between Hog Valley Road and Interstate I-95, Mims, to the October 3, 2024, Zoning meeting. Result: CONTINUED Mover: Tom Goodson Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Feltner, and Steele Nay: Tobia H.7. Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 to TR-3 with an amended BDP. (24Z00005) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1). Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 (Rural Residential Mobile Home) to TR-3 (Mobile Home Park) on a 17.01 acre parcel to develop a tiny home development that would allow mobile homes, tiny homes, and tiny homes on wheels, which subject parcel is currently undeveloped and has access on Gandy Road, a County-maintained roadway, as requested by Aaron Reninger. There being no comments or objections, the Board continued request of Aaron Reninger requesting a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 to TR-3 on 17.01 acres to develop tiny home development that would allow mobile homes, tiny homes, and tiny homes on wheels, which subject parcel is currently undeveloped and has access on Gandy Road, a County-maintained roadway, for property located on the southside of Gandy Road between Hog Valley Road and Interstate I-95, Mims, to the October 3, 2024, Zoning meeting. Result: CONTINUED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Feltner, and Steele Nay: Tobia H.8. Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.08), to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 2 (Residential 2) to CC. (24SS00008) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.08), to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 2 (Residential 2) to CC (Community Commercial), as petitioned by Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, commented Items H.8. and H.9. are companion applications; he is going to read those into the record together; however, the Board will have separate motions. He went on to say Item H. 8. Is Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. Page 13 of 50 September 5, 2024 requests a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment 24S.08, to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 2 to CC; the application number is 24SS00008; the Tax Account Number is 2317736; and it is located in District 1. He stated Item H.9. is for Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. requests a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with a Binding Site Plan to BU-1 with a Binding Site Plan with removal of the BSP; the application number is 24Z00023; the Tax Account Number is 2317736; and it is located in District 1. He pointed out when the zoning item was heard by Planning and Zoning, they recommended approval with a Binding Development Plan (BDP); and there were conditions included in that, one of them was to limit the BU-1 uses to retail, office, and personal services, and a 20-foot buffer along the east and south property lines. Chair Steele advised he is a little confused by that; and he asked if the BDP would come in after the zoning request would be approved. Mr. Ball replied no, because a BDP is used in conjunction to support the zoning action. Chair Steele stated so their recommendation is if the Board does that, they want a BDP that says this; but the Board does not need to go along with that, as it can do whatever it wants. Mr. Ball remarked correct. Kim Rezanka, representing Ibraham and Haroon Realestated, Inc., stated with her is the representative of that company, Dr. Basim Niazi, is present tonight in case the Board has questions or if there are additional conditions it wishes to add to the BDP that came up during Planning and Zoning; currently, there is a 4.74 acre project; the request before the Board is only on 2.68 acres; as the Board can see on what she handed out to it, it is the yellow square; and she just did this to show what is in the area. She went on to say Fairglen School to the north is actually an institutional use; even the zoning says it is something else, it is RES-1, and should be government managed lands institutional, but it is not; below is Tradewinds Manufactured Mobile Home Park, which is a rental community; there is commercial along the U.S. 1 corridor there; it is close to Haverty’s and the Apollo Motel; the Future Land Use Map (FLUM), as the Board can see, they are asking to change the Residential-2 to Community Commercial, which is adjacent to the west; and they are asking to change the zoning from TR-3, which is a trailer park, to BU-1, which would make the entire parcel, 4.74 acres, consistent and the same. She pointed out under 62-1255, the TR-3 could be in CC as well or Neighborhood Commercial; the BU-1 has to be in the CC; the concept here is a flex office space design of 27 units; that is the large sheet she provided to the Board; it is 27 units; it is intended to be small office, small retail, barber shops, real estate offices, and things like that; and it will have regular business hours, comply with any performance standards required by Code, and it is not intended to be any type of warehousing, as it is just small office space for individuals to rent. She mentioned there are three homes to the east; two will have minor adjacency; they currently, as the Board can see from the photograph, have trees buffering; they will attempt to maintain as many trees as they are able to; as the Board can tell, all that is going to be over there is a driveway and one tail-end of a building; the Comprehensive Plan analysis, which is assessable from U.S. 1; the U.S. 1 is generally commercially developed; it is an infill commercial development; it is not located in an established residential neighborhood; is along a commercial corridor; it will have to comply with performance standards, which is a site plan review stage issue; and there are no material violations of the Comp Plan policies per the County staff report. She reiterated the zoning request is from TR-3 to BU-1, and removal of the existing BSP; this was changed to TR-3 in April 1987; it has never been developed; the BU-1 existing from U.S. 1 is 250 feet deep currently; and they are asking it to go to the east end of the property. She noted currently the size of the TR-3 portion, the 2.68 acres, is too small to Page 14 of 50 September 5, 2024 even develop as TR-3, because one has to have 10 acres, so there is nothing that can be done with the property with the current zoning; again, they have shown the Board the concept plan; with that, they are here to answer any questions; they would request that the Board change the 2.6-acre Comp Plan designation from RES-2 to Community Commercial, and change the zoning of TR-3 to BU-1 with the removal of a BSP; and they agree to the conditions of the BDP as well. Commissioner Pritchett commented she has a quick question; people know much she loves natural buffers; they have that going; she has talked with staff and they think the smaller buffer is appropriate with this; she asked if Ms. Rezanka would consider that if there is any specimen-sized trees, like within a 50-foot area that they would get with staff on those; she stated she is not real sure, but it has some very beautiful canopies there; and she asked staff how would she word this. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, stated if the applicant would consider a condition that would have the 20-foot buffer as recommended by P&Z; but in that 50-foot boundary, if there are any specimen trees that they make all efforts to save those during construction. Ms. Rezanka advised Mr. Calkins said 20 and then he said 50. Mr. Calkins explained it is a 20-foot buffer he thinks what has been agreed to; but the concern, he thinks what the Commissioner is interested in, is when looking at the aerial photograph, there appears to be some canopy trees in there that if they can be saved during construction, she would like to make sure those are maintained and safe. Commissioner Pritchett asked the applicant to do their best to try to maintain and save those trees. Ms. Rezanka advised that is fine. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-22, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”, setting forth the Ninth Small Scale Plan Amendment of 2024, 23S.05, to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI(C), entitled the Future Land Use Map Appendix; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.9. Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with a BSP to BU-1 with removal of the BSP. (24Z00023) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from TR-3 (Mobile Home Park) with a BSP to BU-1 (General Retail Commercial) with removal of the BSP, as requested by Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. Page 15 of 50 September 5, 2024 There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request of Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. for a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with BSP to BU-1, with removal of BSP, and adding a BDP that limits BU-1 uses to retail, office, and personal services, and requires and 20-foot buffer along the east and south sides as recommended by Planning and Zoning, and within that 50-foot boundary if there are any specimen trees they will make all efforts to save and maintain those trees during construction, for property located north of Canada Drive, east of US Highway 1, Mims. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.10. JEN Florida 48, LLC, requests Adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 & CC. (Residential 1 per 2.5 acres) to RES 4 (Residential 4) and CC (Community Commercial). (23LS00001) (Tax Account 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, 3000829) (District 5) *The Board recessed at 6:06 p.m. and reconvened at 6:11 p.m. Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider adoption of a Large Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (2023-2) to Change the Future Land Use designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 and CC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated he is going to read Item H.10. and H.11. into the record; however, the Board will have to have separate motions for each; Item H.10. is JEN Florida 48, LLC requests adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 and CC; the application number is 23LS0001; the Tax Account Numbers are 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, and 3000829; and they are located in District 5. He continued by saying Item H.11. is JEN Florida 48, LLC requests a change of zoning classification from GU and AU to PUD, PUD application number is 23PUD00005; the Tax Account Numbers are 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, and 3000829; and they are located in District 5. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, advised on the PUD application associated with this request, there are 14 conditions; one of them, he would like to make a slight modification to; he spoke to the developer ahead of time on this; the County’s Fire Chief and everyone is in agreement with it; and he just wants to make sure that the Board understands what staff is doing. He went on to add condition number 10b currently reads, “Prior to approval of the construction plans and preliminary subdivision plat or site plan, a developer shall donate or convey to the County in fee simple three acres of land to be used for a fire station;” he pointed out it has come to staff’s attention with all of the fire stations, and in conversations with the City of Palm Bay and County staff, that the proposed location that they have, given that there are some planned fire stations in the City of Palm Bay, they may not provide the most sufficient service, so what staff wants to be able to do is, and the developers have agreed to this, to look at a different site potentially throughout their project; what he is asking for, with the Board’s permission, is to modify that condition to where it says ‘be’, staff would just insert ‘execute an agreement for the donation/conveyance to the County in fee-simple, three acres of land to be used for a fire station’ in that first sentence; and he thinks what that does is it gives staff the opportunity to work with the developer to find the appropriate location for that fire Page 16 of 50 September 5, 2024 station as they develop. Chair Steele noted okay, but he would like to add that when the County asked the developer to donate the three acres of land, they had no obligation whatsoever to donate this land, so they are completely doing it out of their own good will; as a result of that, the County is moving forward with a positive fashion; and what staff did with the City and trying to put it together, he thinks is extremely good; but he did want it noted that there was no mandatory need for a fire station at that site; and he asked if he is correct. Mr. Calkins replied that is his understanding. Kim Rezanka, representing JEN Florida 48, LLC and the developer owner/representatives Sun Terra Communities stated with her, representing the developer, is Richard German and Dan Edwards, and the engineer of record Poulos & Bennett LLC represented by Andrew Ivey are here to answer any questions; Planner Jesse Anderson is also here to answer questions; and the Transportation Engineer James Taylor with Kimley-Horn will actually present and answer questions as well. She went on to say as the Board knows, they came before it in May 2024 for the Future Land Use amendment transmittal hearing; at that time, and still today, they are seeking a Future Land Use amendment of 1,109.57 acres; the purpose is to allow a mixed-use development; and the PUD application is now before the Board. She noted when they met with the Board in May they said they would limit the density to three units to the acre; now that it has the PDP, that is exactly what it is doing, as well as the BDP will also limit it to three units to the acre; the request is for 1,082.57 acres for a Residential-4, limited to three units to the acre as stated in the BDP, and 27.33 acres of

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

20 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 12 of 20

Browse by category20 actions
  • Agenda item A.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board of County Commissioners acts as a Quasi Judicial body when it hears requests for rezoning and Conditional Use Permits. Applicants must provide competent substantial evidence establishing facts, or expert witness opinion testimony showing that the request meets the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan criteria. Opponents must also testify as to facts, or provide expert testimony; whether they like, or dislike, a request is not competent evidence. The Board must then decide whether the evidence demonstrates consistency and compatibility with the Comprehensive Plan and the existing rules in the Zoning Ordinance, property adjacent to the property to be rezoned, and the actual development of the surrounding area. The Board cannot consider speculation, non expert opinion testimony, or poll the audience by asking those in favor or opposed to stand up or raise their hands. If a Commissioner has had communications regarding a rezoning or Conditional Use Permit request before the Board, Commissioner must disclose the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity, with whom the communication took place before the Board takes action on the request. Likewise, if a Commissioner has made a site visit, inspection, or investigation, the Commissioner must disclose that fact before the Board takes action on the request. Each applicant is allowed a total of 15 minutes to present their request unless the time is extended by a majority vote of the Board. The applicant may reserve any portion of the 15 minutes for rebuttal. Other speakers are allowed five minutes to speak. Speakers may not pass their time to someone else in order to give that person more time to speak.

    CALL TO ORDER 5:00 PM

    Department: CALL TO ORDER 5:00 PM

  • Agenda item L.3.Other meeting itemsapproved - Commissioner Pritchett stated Sandra Sullivan started it; if she starts bringing scripture every meeting, she will bring one, too, and this will be great; Romans 8:28, “And we all know that all things work together for good for those who love God and to them who are called according to His purpose;” she noted a couple of things she wants to mention to everybody is that Brevard is such a great community and County; it is wonderful having people come out and giving their opinion on things; and by the time the Board gets done, hopefully everyone will move forward. She advised one never makes themselves any better by trying to make someone else worse; when one mocks them and ridicules them, it always comes back to the person; and she expressed her appreciation to all on how they have handled things. Upon motion and vote, the meeting adjourned 9:04 p.m. ATTEST: _________________________ _____________________________ RACHEL M. SADOFF, CLERK JASON STEELE, CHAIR BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BREVARD COUNTY, FLORIDA

    L.3. Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 1, Vice-Chair

  • Agenda item H.1.Other meeting itemsapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider an ordinance to adopt the WSFWP and related Comprehensive Plan Amendments. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this is adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan; this applies to all Commission Districts; to comply with the statutory requirements, the attached ordinance amends the potable water element with the Comprehensive Plan, with the updated 2035 Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and amends the various policies with the conservation, potable water, sanitary sewer, intergovernmental coordination of the capital improvements, and elements of the Comprehensive Plan for consistency with the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on April 4, 2024, the Board approved transmittal of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; on June 18, 2024, Florida Commerce issued the objections, recommendations, and comments report; this report identified no objections, made no recommendations, and provided no comments that must be addressed prior to the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and related Comprehensive Plan Amendment to the Board; on August 12, 2024, the Local Planning Agency recommended approval of adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, and the related Comprehensive Plan Amendments; and staff is here to answer any questions that the Board might have. Sandra Sullivan commented with this particular Item, the Board receives the hat; very seldom does it get the hat; this is about septic, the toilet to tap, as they call it; Senator Rick Scott vetoed the toilet to tap legislation, and Governor Ron DeSantis approved it; in this, the Board is making Comprehensive Plan changes to facilitate this; and she just thinks there should be a whole lot more transparency to the people about what the County is doing. She went on to say at a recent meeting, she left her house, and an Item was not on the Agenda; when she arrived here, it was an add-on for basically a study that she did a records request on; the County is doing another study to essentially put a new facility, according to this . . . she knows this is the Comp Plan, but the Comp Plan is enabling this; according to this study, the County is putting a sewage treatment plant in the vicinity of Titusville-Cocoa Airport Authority (TICO); the report talks about partnership funding, partnership potentially with a private sector person to do this sewage plant; and it just raises a question whether the Brightline acquisition for $388,000,000 is what it is talking about. She noted what is also being talked about is a new tax on the people; this is called a tax increment reinvestment zone; she has never heard of it; essentially, what it is for is it is a study that was done for Space Florida and for the Cape, so the County can find a taxing mechanism to essentially put this on ‘We the People’ for ‘We the Money Interest;’ there is Phase I, Phase II, Phase III, and how it is going to be done, with temporarily the Sykes Creek, of course; and this topic cannot be discussed without discussing the legislative change this year that changes so they can put Senate Bill (SB) 102, the live local, not so local, tax incentives, et cetera, and bonus density for developers on Space Florida; and she bets most people do not know that. She sated at a recent Lagoon meeting, it showed the tripling of the size of Merritt Island; of course, there are lots of flooding issues there; she provided the Board with her very creative artwork handouts; and she advised she is very much against this Plan change. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-21, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”, setting forth the adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an appendix to the potable water element and amendments necessary to implement the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part I, entitled Conservation Element to Adopt New Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VI, entitled Potable Water Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies and Adopt New Policies and Adopt the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan as an Appendix to the Potable Water Element; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part VII, entitled Sanitary Sewer Element to Revised Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XII, Entitled Intergovernmental Coordination Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies, specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XIII, entitled Capital Improvements Element to Revise Previously Adopted Policies; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI, entitled Glossary to Add New Definitions; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date.

    Adoption of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan and related amendments to the Comprehensive Plan. (All Districts)

    $388,000,000

  • Agenda item H.2.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from GU (General Use) to RRMH-1 (Rural Residential Mobile Home), as petitioned by Gerald Patterson. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this Item is Gerald Patterson requesting a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1; the application number is 24Z00022; the Tax Account Number is 2000981; and this is located in District 1. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request for a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1, located on the west side of Blounts Ridge Road, north of Patty Lane, Mims, as requested by Gerald Patterson.

    Gerald Patterson (Raymond Burnette) requests a change of zoning classification from GU to RRMH-1. (24Z00022) (Tax Account 2000981) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.13.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and Planned Unit Development (PUD) with two existing Binding Development Plans (BDPs) to all PUD and Removal of Two Existing BDPs, as petitioned by Villas of Sherwood Titusville, Inc., Algarrobo Development, LLC; Sherwood Golf Club, Inc.; and TRSTE, LLC. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request for change of zoning classification from GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and PUD with two existing BDPs to all PUD and removal of two existing BDPs; approved with a BDP incorporating the following 14 conditions: 1) The proposed development shall be limited to 187 SF units and 408 MF units. 2) Due to historical drainage patterns and flooding issues, a drainage study with and associated master drainage plan is needed prior to construction of the first phase of the development. 3) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-1446. PUD-Land Use Regulations; Sub-Section (d) Minimum lot area, frontage, and setbacks; accessory uses; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required 5,000 sf minimum lot area to 4,000 sf. (POD III Only). All affected lots shall have substantial relationship to a 15’ common open space tract directly adjacent to the affected dwelling units. 4) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-1446. PUD-Land Use Regulations; Sub-Section (d) Minimum lot area, frontage, and setbacks; accessory uses; Paragraph (3) - to reduce the required minimum 20 feet rear setback to 10 feet. (POD III). This is conditioned upon POD III containing a minimum of eighteen acres of common recreation and open space as defined by Brevard County Code. 5) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards.; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required minimum 50 feet wide right-of-way to a minimum of 30 feet with 10-foot easements on each side for POD III. The affected rights-of-way shall be private and maintained by the Homeowner’s Association. 6) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (1) – to reduce the required minimum 50 feet wide right-of-way to a minimum of 30 feet with a 5-foot easement on each side for PODS I and IV. The affected rights-of-way shall be private and maintained by the Homeowner’s Association. 7) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2956. Transportation technical guidelines and performance standards; Sub-Section (a) Roadway; Paragraph (3)-to reduce the minimum 100-foot setback of the cul-de-sac right-of-way to the plat boundary to 15 feet with the inclusion of a 6’ high wall and landscaping in one (1) location (POD III). Landscaping shall consist of a minimum of 2 shade trees per 100 LF and 4 under-story trees per 100 LF. 8) Approval of requested waiver from Sec. 62-2883. General design requirements and standards; Sub-Section (d)-to replace the required 15’ perimeter buffer tract with a 15’ perimeter buffer easement, or 10' perimeter easement where adjacent to an existing drainage easement, and allow it to be disturbed for grading, landscape, and buffer improvements, including but not limited to walls, fences, retention slopes, walking paths, and utilities (POD III). 9) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat, the Developer shall: a. Execute an agreement, which may include, but is not limited to, a Proportionate Fair Share agreement, with the County addressing and/or mitigating any infrastructure deficiencies relating to the off site transportation impacts as identified in a traffic study that is caused by the development. The agreement may include provisions requiring the developer to design, permit, and construct the identified improvements at a cost to the developer that is proportionate to the project’s impact. In addition, the agreement will identify time frames for the necessary improvements, and monitoring and updating the traffic study as appropriate. 10) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat/and or Site Plan, the Developer shall demonstrate that adequate water and sewer services will be available to the development and are available prior to issuance of Certificate of Occupancy. 11) Address all staff comments regarding the PDP prior to, or concurrent with, site plan and subdivision submittals. 12) In accordance with Section 62-1301, if it is the opinion of the zoning official that an amendment to the PDP warrants Board evaluation, such modifications shall be submitted for Board approval. 13) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat and/or Site Plan, the Developer shall submit a road system condition assessment to include an evaluation of potential impacts on public safety. The study will be conducted per methodology provided for in County land development code or as otherwise agreed to with staff. 14) Prior to County approval of a construction plan and/or Preliminary Plat and/or Site Plan, the Developer shall submit a traffic calming study for the affected roadways and will identify necessary improvements to mitigate speeding and encourage preferred routing of traffic. The study will be conducted per methodology provided for in County land development code or as otherwise agreed to with staff.

    Villas of Sherwood Titusville, Inc.; Algarrobo Development, LLC; Sherwood Golf Club, Inc.; and TRSTE, LLC, (Jorge Ballarena) requests a change of zoning classification from, GU, AU, EU, SR, RU-1-11, RU-1-13, RU-2-10, RU-2-15, and PUD with two existing BDP’s, to all PUD and removal of two existing BDPs. (23Z00035) (Tax Accounts 2100937, 2113020, 2112021, 2113023, 2113024, 2100938, 2100939, 2100940, 2100942, 2100943, 2100952, 2100953, 2111319, & 2101061) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.3.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from AU (Agricultural Residential) to RU-1-11 (Single-Family Residential), as petitioned by Home Nation Cocoa, LLC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Home Nation Cocoa, LLC requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11; the application number is 24Z00027; the Tax Account Number is 2419394; and this is located in District 2. Susan Martini stated when they purchased this property it was zoned as AU; they need it to be rezoned because it no longer qualifies per lot size for AU in the County; and they are going to do a single-family residence on there. There being no further comments or objections, the Board approved request for change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11, on property located on the southeast corner of Lucas Road and Bevis Road, Cocoa.

    Home Nation Cocoa, LLC (Roxanne Comino) requests a change of zoning classification from AU to RU-1-11. (24Z00027) (Tax Account 2419394) (District 2)

  • Agenda item H.4.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a CUP for on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification, as petitioned by Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated this Item is Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC requesting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the on-premises consumption of alcohol in a Planning Unit Development (PUD) zoning classification; the application number is 24Z00030; the tax account is 3030319; and it is located in District 4. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved a CUP for on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification on property located at the east end of Porada Drive, south of Viera Boulevard, Viera, as requested by Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC.

    Borrows West Hotel Developers, LLC (Marbet Lewis) requests a CUP for the on-premises consumption of alcohol in a PUD zoning classification. (24Z00030) (Tax Account 3030319) (District 4)

  • Agenda item H.6.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a request by Aaron Reninger for a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use (FLU) designation from AGRIC (Agricultural) to RES 6 (Residential 6). Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, commented that Item H.6. and H.7. are companion applications; he is going to read them into the record together; however, separate motions will need to be made for each Item; Item H.6., is Aaron Reninger requests a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan amendment 24S.02, to change the Future Land Use designation from AGRIC to RES 6; the application number is 24SS00002; the Tax Account Numbers are 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2202231, and 2002232; and they are located in District 1. He continued by saying Item H.7. is Aaron Reninger requesting a change of zoning classification from RRMH-1 to TR-3, with an amended Binding Development Plan (BDP); the application number is 24Z0005; the Tax Account Numbers are 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2202231, and 2002232; and they are located in District 1. He mentioned that the application was advertised with an amended BDP; currently, there is no BDP; and currently, on the property when these items went to the Local Planning Agency (LPA) and Planning & Zoning (P&Z), both were recommended for denial. Kim Rezanka, Lacy Lyons Rezanka, representing Aaron Reninger, advised this is a request for a change in the Future Land Use and a change of zoning on 17.01 acres; if the Board has read the Planning and Zoning minutes, there was quite a bit of distaste for this project; this client listened to what people said; he is now coming back and requesting to change the Future Land Use request to one to 2.5 acres, and the zoning to RRMH-2.5, so that means every lot would be two and a half acres; and they would only have six lots. She stated this is very compatible with what is out there; what is around it is one acre, two acres, and three acres; it is on a dirt road; the residents thought it was too dense; her client listened, so now they have asked to change it; right now it is an agricultural Future Land Use of five units to the acre, with an RRMH-1, which is one unit to the acre; and right now, they have an inconsistency, he could not build anything there anyway. She continued by saying they would like to suggest that this character of the area, this is compliant with the character of the area; he can do single-family homes; he is going to do a subdivision of six lots; it will be different than what he had planned before, but he is still hoping to do the tiny homes or manufactured homes, which are out there already, the manufactured homes, and to make it more affordable; with that, they are happy to answer questions, Mr. Reninger is here; and they believe that this will hopefully satisfy the residents, and help them realize that he does indeed want to be a good neighbor. She asked the Board to accept an amended application; she noted also with the BDP, they already had a BDP, but this would actually limit the development to six units to the acre; they would comply with the subdivision and plat code, which is Article VII of Chapter 62; apparently, there are some Code Enforcement actions out there that would have to be remedied and resolved prior to any building permits being issued, so there will be three conditions of a BDP; and they are here to answer any questions and to listen to the neighbors in case they do not like this deal. Bob Brooks commented he is the direct neighbor of Mr. Reninger’s property; he came here to go directly against the plan for the tiny home and/or mobile home development; this changes everything, so he does not have a lot to say at the moment; if it were to go to six homes, and he did a little bit of research on it, he thinks he would be behind that; again, he is the direct neighbor; he did not want 30 homes behind his house; and that is really all he had to say, because it changed gears in mid-stream. Chair Steele explained if the rest of the speakers come up and feel the same way as Mr. Brooks, he or she can say they waive in favor or against it, or they can speak, as it is up to them. Ken Harrison stated he is going to speak to this as if it was under the previous plan; the Code of Ordinances 62-1255, Brevard County, establishment of zoning classifications in consistency with Comprehensive Plans; 62-1255(a)(1)(c), current zoning is Agricultural; 62-1255(a)(8)(b) requested zoning is Residential 6; and the 1988 County Comprehensive Plan establishes specific Future Land Use designations, which are depicted on the Future Land Use Map within the Future Land Use element. He remarked this plan is further reinforced by the April 2007 Mims Small Area Study; both the 1988 Comprehensive Plan and the 2007 Mims Small Area Study determined the Future Land Use to be Agricultural and set limits to one dwelling unit per five acres west of Meadow Green Road; properties with approved RRMH-1, AU, and AGR zoning classifications prior to the study were retained and adopted; this property is located in this zoning classification area and an increase in density would be an encroachment into the existing neighborhood; and the subject property does not serve as a transition between areas with land use designations of six units per acre or existing land use designations equal to no more than one unit per acre. He added Administrative Policy 3 relates to traffic safety issues due to increased traffic, material reduction of property values due to higher density in tiny homes, and real estate comparable sales values for the subject area will decrease; proposed use is not consistent with the emerging or existing pattern of surrounding development as determined through analysis of historical use patterns, actual development over the immediately preceding three years; six new block single-family residences were built in the last three years; two of them border the subject property; development approved, but not constructed, is one single-family residence at 4110 Hog Valley Road; the proposed use will result in a material violation of relevant policies; and wetlands destructions have occurred. He stated Policy 4, character of the neighborhood, the character of the neighborhood or area will be materially or adversely affected by the proposed rezoning or land use application; the proposed rezoning and land use will cause a 200 percent increase in traffic on Gandy Road; there are 14 single-family residences on Gandy Road; 30 more single-family residences will cause a burden in significant safety and convenience issues on an already poorly maintained dirt road that is only graded 12 times a year; the road is too narrow for two cars to pass each other at certain points; and it is poorly drained and unstable with loose soil. He pointed out the subject property is part of Indian River Park; Indian River Park is a clearly established residential neighborhood; platted in 1914, the south border is especially defined as the south line of the Bernardo Sequi Land Grant, and has been mapped as such since the Spanish land grants; the subject property’s south line is also the south border of Indian River Park; the north, west, and east boundaries are designated as agricultural land use with agricultural zoning; and to the south is public conservation with general use and agricultural zoning. He advised the requested zoning and FLU could change the subject property to commercial use, if rent is charged; there are no commercial use properties in the entire area; the area is not considered transitional; Administrative Policy 5, states if the residents of proposed zoning change utilize public transportation, it would have a significant impact; the physical quality of Gandy Road will suffer significant deterioration with a 200 percent increase in traffic on a poorly maintained dirt road; and problems with the width of the road. He noted loose soils of Gandy Road would cause a traffic safety concern for pedestrians; it is likely Gandy Road would suffer adverse changes from the type of traffic that would be generated; physical deterioration would occur from larger truck delivers; under Policy 6, the proposed rezoning and FLU is not consistent with all written land development policies set forth in the administrative policies, including potable water, sanitary sewer, and surface water; under Policy 7, the subject property contains mapped national wetlands inventory, St. Johns River Water Management District wetlands and hydric soils; per Section 62-3694(c)(1), residential land uses within wetlands shall be limited to not more than one dwelling unit per five acres; and the applicants have filled and cleared subject property without proper permits and are in clear violations of County Codes. Chair Steele noted he wants to make sure that everyone heard the changes that Ms. Rezanka made prior to the time that he or she speaks. Stephanie Knight advised it is kind of hard, because they already prepared for it, so had they known that in advance, they could have prepared for her new update. Commissioner Pritchett pointed out she would not have approved 30 lots out there; it would not fit; if they had some input with this, she was actually thinking if they could come up with something with six or eight, and they have come with six; if the residents have any idea of other criteria; she has a copy of the BDP; and she thinks it seems like a good fit for the residents, so if he or she has any other suggestions, she is all ears. Ms. Knight asked the main question is can that be changed; and she asked if he is having a BDP, can that just change. Commissioner Pritchett replied no, when it is binding they have to stick to it and cannot change it. Ms. Knight asked without circumstances. Commissioner Pritchett responded unless they come back and get another Board to agree to it; and it would be like changing their zoning. Ms. Knight asked if everyone would have to do what they just did, they would all have to come back to the Board. Commissioner Pritchett replied affirmatively. Ms. Knight remarked her biggest concern to having what he is now asking for is again, what was said before, the wetlands; he has destroyed wetlands; if the Board would notice in some of the maps it was given by Mr. Harrison, the entryway to his property was wetlands, so all of that was destroyed in order to even get to his property; she understands he is now only wanting six houses for the amount of acreage that he has; but the fact is that he is now going over the wetlands that he has destroyed in order to even get to his property in the first place; and it kind of put a dirty taste in everybody’s mouth that had he not destroyed them in the first place, he would not even be able to get to his property. She pointed out if he would have done it the right way to begin with, this would not even be an issue and the residents would not even be asking for 30, three, six, or whatever the case may be; that would be her biggest concern, and not ever be able to change it; she does not like the fact that it is tiny homes; mobile homes are fine; but tiny homes bring in a whole different amount of people. Chair Steele exclaimed once again, he does not think tiny homes are even being talked about here. Ms. Knight stated he did mentioned tiny homes or mobile homes, so with that being said, with Code violations that he has already on the property, and the fact that he has to drive over the wetlands, other than that would just be the septic issues, which if he only has six for 17 acres, she guesses that would not be a septic issue. Alana Walsh commented she, of course, also was prepared to come and talk about the proposal for 30 homes; she thinks they had ample time and opportunity to let the residents know they were going to change the plan, and failed to do so; and she asked if it is still going to be like a mobile home park, are they still going to be rented out, or are they going to sell these properties. Chair Steele explained she can ask a question, but he does not know that the Board is going to answer that question right now; and it will look into that. Ms. Walsh remarked because that is one of the concerns if they are going to be rentals. Chair Steele stated to go ahead with the comments; and he asked if she is finished. Ms. Walsh pointed out she came prepared to talk about 30, and they did not know it was changing. Chair Steele advised when something like this happens and it happens for the better, which he thinks this does, she has to take it when she can get it, so if she has any other discussion in regards to what is on the table, go ahead and talk about it; and if not, the hearing will be continued and see where it goes. Ms. Walsh stated as a community member, just the fact that it changed and they did not know is disheartening. Chair Steele stated yes, ma’am, it is frustrating sometimes, these things. Brian Walsh stated his main concern is if these are going to be rentals, if it is going to be ran in a traditional mobile home park, or single-family dwellings, which would be nice to have the answer to, just for crime and everything else that would be in the area. Chair Steele advised that Commissioner Pritchett is going to ask that question to the applicant. Patricia Frank commented she has lived out there for most of her 63 years; she has seen a lot of changes come and go; the impact that the extra traffic, dump trucks, semis, and heavy equipment that is going to have an impact Aurantia Road, Meadow Green, Harrison Road, and Hog Valley Road, because there is only one way in and one way out to Gandy Road, so it does not just affect Gandy, it affects all of the people that live along Aurantia, Meadow Green, Harrison, Hog Valley, and Gandy; they now have potholes in Aurantia Road that have yet to be fixed or maintained as it is; they cannot get it fixed; and now they are going to have more traffic on Aurantia Road, and how that extra traffic is going to impact the intersection where the Circle K is right there. She noted they have been doing improvements, Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) has been out there burying electrical lines, they have had a lot of work trucks, and there are a lot of places on Aurantia Road that needs repair; she asked what about them; she asked if taxes are going to be increased for repaving the road, because getting out to Gandy Road, all of this heavy equipment is going to have a negative impact on the infrastructure; she noted that is her questions and concerns; and she asked why should they have to pay for what gets torn up for this fella to bring his pipedream to fruition. She mentioned she would just like to see their growth be managed in a positive way. Corey Roberson explained he prepared a speech for today that was for the homes that was supposed to be on there; he thinks it was very inappropriate and ill-mannered to come here for a speech for an amendment that they made; he does not believe that is fair to the residents; he does not think a ruling should be made today on the rezoning of the property honestly; and he thinks it was a joke. Chair Steele stated he understands the residents’ emotions in response to applauding, but to just stop that tonight, as the Board has a lot of things to talk about and it would be better if the clapping was curtailed. Commissioner Tobia advised he understands the frustration of the change, whether it went his way or not. Mr. Roberson noted regardless of his way or anybody’s way, the fact of the matter is when people prep for court, he or she gets a timeframe; they came here in the beginning, made a statement, and they do not have any notice. Commissioner Tobia stated he has a question; he asked they dropped it from 30 to six, and is there a number in his mind that would fit well with that number. Mr. Roberson replied zero at the moment, because they were amending it at the time; right now he does not have a chance to look over it; first of all, when they make decisions, people of the community would like to get together and figure out what a best number would be towards it; he is not against a home or two homes on the property; but the fact of the matter is they amended it. He went on to say at the beginning of this meeting when people come here prepared for something else, so no one has any idea other than what they just come up here and said in five minutes to try to change their plans after everybody came here with something else to say. Commissioner Tobia asked if right now he is okay with zero homes there. Mr. Roberson responded he did not say . . . it could be six, it could be, he could be okay with 10; but the fact of the matter is he has got to . . . Commissioner Tobia pointed out he has to make a vote . . . Mr. Roberson noted they are making a vote, so what he is saying is today, regardless, since they amended today, the Board is making a vote on the homes regardless of the amendment. Commissioner Tobia explained he does not know whether there will be a motion one way or the other; and he asked how many homes Mr. Roberson is okay with; he stated he is not okay with 30, he understands that; but he again asked how many he is okay with. Mr. Roberson replied two. Commissioner Pritchett stated what the Commissioners are supposed to do is to get the information and make a decision; the Board has to hear all of the speakers’ views, get all of the evidence, and then it is supposed to hopefully make the best decision it can; it is the Board’s job not to make an emotional decision, so as it listens to the speakers’ concerns, that is what he or she is going to try to do, try to make a good decision for this plot of land; it is 17 acres; and when the Board does this, he or she has to remember that the owner has rights as well as the neighborhood, so these are the things that have to be taken into consideration. She went on to add anything the speakers give the Board right now is really good so a decision can be made, if he or she is going to vote, or how he or she is going to vote, so that is what the Board is trying to gather from them tonight; nobody is for or against them; and the Board is just trying to make a good decision for the community. Commissioner Goodson inquired all that being said, could he ask the engineer to come back up here, or would he consider postponing this to the next Planning and Zoning meeting, giving these people time to discuss this proposal. Ms. Rezanka advised Mr. Reninger said that was fine; there are six lots now; he could do six lots now in theory; she understands their concerns; and they thought this would make them happy, they are still not happy, but they would be happy to come back next month if that is the Board’s preference. Commissioner Goodson stated he is not sure they are not happy; but they need an ample amount of time to do it, just like he would like the time to study a contract on buying a car or whatever; and he asked if he is willing to give them that time, what the rush is. Commissioner Pritchett noted she does not mind doing that either; it can be postponed to the next zoning meeting; but there are already people here, so if they want to talk, they can go ahead and maybe give their information right now if they want to, or they can come back later; when she went over the data the other day and spoke with staff, they knew they would not be able to get 30 in there; and there are water problems with salinity in the water. She mentioned six to eight lots do fit, so it is up to the residents if they want to wait four more weeks to wait on this, she is sure it will not hurt to do that; it does look like a fairly decent project right now; and maybe the speakers will need a little more time to absorb it. Commissioner Feltner asked if the Board is going to continue with the cards. Chair Steele replied right now he is completely opposed to what Commissioner Goodson is saying, he would like to get this done tonight; but it is up to the Commission. Commissioner Feltner stated he did not want to interrupt the cards, but he has one question. Chair Steele pointed out if the Board tables it to next month, his intention is to not allow these people who have come here to speak; it is going to be a lengthy process; and he is having a difficult time understanding why six units would not make these folks happy. He asked if Commissioner Goodson is making a motion to continue the Item. Commissioner Goodson replied he is making a motion to continue the Item. Commissioner Pritchett remarked she will second the motion after the cards. Mr. Ball asked if he can interject for a second; and he suggested to continue the item to the next Zoning Board hearing, which is October 3, 2024. Yarnell Roman stated she came here because of the impact of the value of the properties; at the last meeting it was said, the values in the area range from $35 to $200,000; it was also said that the average value of the proposed project will be $150,000; she wants to put on the record that there is a mistake on this premise; they have recently sold properties in the area from 350,000 to $500,000; and examples of these are 4745 Gandy Road, 4199 Heida Lake, 4254 Hog Valley, 4706 Gandy Road, 4940 Harrison Road, and 4768 Harrison Road. She remarked there are three properties available for sale right now, 4970 Harrison Road for $340,000, 4540 Wellington Lane for $520,000, 5245 Blunt Ridge Road for $475,000; there have also been luxury homes recently built that are appraising for over $600,000, like 4705 Gandy Road, and 4155 Hog Valley Road; and new homes are going up with projected values of over $400,000 like 4241 Hog Valley Road and 4150 Hog Valley. She stated even the land value is more than the range established on the last meeting; as an example, 4776 Pine Needle Street with a sales price of $85,000 for an acre, so this information is important because the approval of any project cannot negatively impact the value of their properties; she wants to add the construction risk assessment; the following information has been provided by First Street, a government and private resource to provide climate risk data for informed decision-making; there is a fire factor in the area; the area where whatever project is proposed is currently on a severe fire risk factor of seven of 10; in the last 20 years more than 100 wildfires were recorded within just 20 miles of Gandy Road, having an impact of an average of 61 properties; and the a major risk of wildfire events in the next 15 years. She pointed out that in addition to property damage, wildfires can also cut off access to utilities, emergency services, transportation, and may impact the overall economic wellbeing of the area; with the limitations of proper evacuation routes they have now, the approval of these or any projects could turn into a major safety risk for the residents; and she thinks the responsible decision would be to just postpone and let the residents know what the correct project would involve, and give them another chance to speak, as they do not have the facts in order to say something. Valerie Lichtblau stated she had a whole different thing written-up because she did not plan on him changing it like that; she lives within 500 feet of the property the applicant is requesting to rezone; she has five acres, which is not in line with his now change of one-acre lots; she lives in a single-family home, which is adjacent to this property; she is against the rezoning of the applicant’s property due to the flooding concerns on their little dirt road; one cannot even pass on the dirt road, as a person has to pull off; and every time it rains, just the 14 houses on the road puts damage on the road. She noted they do not come out and clean off the road as much as they should; it goes against the Mims Small Scale Study, which was designed to keep North Brevard rural; she does not know if he still wants to keep it agricultural or residential; she is also not happy that the residents came unprepared because he changed what he wants to do without notifying anyone or meeting with any property owners around that property; he has emailed one person before, but he could not email anybody to let them know he was changing it so they could tell how they feel about it; and they have no time to think about this now because he just changed it. Desiree Wimer commented her parents live within 500 feet at 4718 Gandy Road; without having time to research the new zoning request, it is hard to support something presented to them at the last minute; the owner does have a lot of contact information, including hers; he could have met or emailed them with any changes; and he actually requested having one of the meetings tabled so he could meet with them, and he did not follow through. She went on to say he bought the property knowing the current zoning, he knew what he purchased when he bought it; this is a rural agricultural area; the current zoning is correct, which she thinks that property would allow less than six homes; she has not seen anything to support changing the current zoning; and she is against changing the current zoning. Sandra Sullivan remarked obviously conversations have happened with the District 1 office and with staff, so knowing that they had some advanced notice that a different proposal would be put in place, this plan as put on the Agenda under Sunshine should have been either the applicant reapplying and it changed, or this should not have gone on this meeting today; this is like a fast one being pulled on the people; as residents of Brevard County, they expect transparency and accountability, and for the County to follow the State laws for Sunshine; and Sunshine requires five days’ notice or seven days’ notice. She went on by saying the County’s Policy is five days’ notice; these are Quasi-Judicial meetings; these are very serious for Planning and Zoning and should be treated as such; the fact that staff and even the District 1 office who indicated she would not have approved what there was, and there was conversations; this should not have been on the Agenda today; and she reiterated this should have been reapplied for and with transparency, or postponed to another meeting. Katie Delaney stated she really appreciates the suggestion about postponing this; she thinks that is definitely a great move since the people did not have time to prepare for what was being asked for tonight; being at the community meetings that she was at, where some of the residents were there talking about their concerns about this project, one of the major things they were talking about was the reason why this property was originally zoned for three homes is because of the flooding and the traffic issues that are back there; and she hopes the Board keeps that in mind when it moves forward. Commissioner Pritchett stated she would second Commissioner Goodson’s motion. Ms. Rezanka pointed out the zoning of this property is RRMH-1, which is one unit to the acre, or 17 units; the Future Land Use is Agricultural, which is five units to the acre; many of the lots in this area are exactly the same, and have one acre; there are five of these six parcels combined that are one acre; they could be built because it has been so long; and what they are asking for is what they can do now. She stated this came about yesterday in a meeting with Commissioner Pritchett; that was the earliest that they could get a meeting with her after Planning and Zoning; they did not notify the residents; but again, they thought his would not have been a problem based upon what they heard in the past; there was an email that Mr. Reninger submitted to all of those who sent in opposition emails; on August 3rd he sent this; she will submit it for the record; and there were about 14 that he emailed, there was not just one. She continued by saying as to the values of the area, the lady did not identify herself, but from the card that was called, it was Ms. Roman; there is no indication she has any qualifications as an expert appraiser; she does want to state for the record, and she will submit these, that she has Property Appraiser market value sheets starting with James Stansell at 4775 Gandy; the market value is $31,460; she also has Robert Brooks at 5584 William Brim, $59,360; John Bauden $54,960; and she has several that she will submit for the record to show that her comments about the values in the area were indeed correct, as these are market values by the Property Appraiser. She advised regarding the claim that there are Code violations on this is incorrect; she is doing this to protect her client, because the statements that were made here are incorrect; Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) has been out to the site; she will also submit this for the record; she can give Commissioner Pritchett a copy so she has it as well; FDEP, as of September 3, 2024, says the inspection was made regarding dredging and filling within a wetland; an inspection determined these activities are occurring onsite; the inspection determined that although activities are occurring onsite, there were no wetland or other surface waters impacted observed on the property at the time of inspection; there are photos enclosed; she will submit this for the record; and anyone can request this if they want to. She noted this is a decrease in density; currently, the 17 units allowed by zoning, now requesting six; this is currently Agricultural Future Land Use and activities that have occurred on that property are Agricultural in nature, and are allowed by law; the comments about going through the wetland, there was a home on 4735, which is the access piece prior, and there was access there before Mr. Reninger purchased it; it is intended to be a platted subdivision; whether he rents or not, they are going to be platted; he may sell or rent; but it is not a zoning issue whether he sells or rents. She stated the Zoning Code under RRMH-2-5 allows manufactured homes, single-family homes, and tiny homes; tiny homes, again, $150,000 in value to start; she does not know what the Sunshine Law requires; Commissioner Pritchett did disclose, but she has not talked to the Commissioners, as that is the Sunshine Law, to her knowledge; this request seemed to make sense; Commissioner Pritchett could have made this request during this hearing at the end of the applicant’s presentation; the Board could have voted on that, as it can change with conditions and with permission from the applicant; this change is not that unusual; this happens in other hearings where the request is not compatible and the Commission or Council dislikes the request; and it would therefore ask for a change in density, lower in density. She exclaimed her client has said he is fine coming back on October 3rd, they are willing to do that; but she did want to state for the record and clarify the facts as they truly are; there are Code violations that may or may not be pending; her client has gotten no notice of them; she reiterated she will submit the FDEP record; and they will do the will of the Commission. Commissioner Goodson advised he would like to commend the developer/owner, as it was a very good decision for the Board to vote tonight and not give these people a chance, and come back in October and vote, whether the Board agrees with the residents or the applicant, it will be its vote at that time; he reiterated he just thinks the Board should just give these people the right to meet with the developer and attorney, and to get an understanding of what is being proposed, because things can get real screwy in this chamber; and he is not voting for this tonight, unless it is pushed back to October. Commissioner Pritchett explained she thinks a lot of people came in a little freaked out about 30 units, so she thinks that is why everybody’s a little intense; she agrees with Commissioner Goodson that just that little bit of time is needed for everybody to kind of figure out what is going on; she listened at her office, as that is what she does, she listens but does not render where she is at until she hears everything; the Board just heard the community; and they do not like the project, so they are going to try a smaller number. She noted it was a good job everyone showing up, to get with the developer as he seems like a very nice person, and to get some nice families out there for them to keep the community good.

    Aaron Reninger (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.02), to change the Future Land Use Designation from AGRIC to RES 6. (24SS00002) (Tax Accounts 2002219, 2002228, 2002229, 2002230, 2002231, & 2002232) (District 1)

    $35

  • Agenda item H.5.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a request by Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell for a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 (Single-Family Residential) to RU-1-11 (Single-Family Residential). Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell requests a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11; the application number is 24Z00028; the tax account is 2802480; and it is located in District 5. There being no comments or objection, the Board approved a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11 on property located on the west side of Vine Street, south of Milwaukee Avenue, Melbourne, as petitioned by Paul and Laurie Ann Futrell.

    Paul & Laurie Ann Futrell requests a change of zoning classification from RU-1-7 to RU-1-11. (24Z00028) (Tax Account 2802480) (District 5)

  • Agenda item H.10.Land useapproved - *The Board recessed at 6:06 p.m. and reconvened at 6:11 p.m. Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider adoption of a Large Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (2023-2) to Change the Future Land Use designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 and CC. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, stated he is going to read Item H.10. and H.11. into the record; however, the Board will have to have separate motions for each; Item H.10. is JEN Florida 48, LLC requests adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 and CC; the application number is 23LS0001; the Tax Account Numbers are 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, and 3000829; and they are located in District 5. He continued by saying Item H.11. is JEN Florida 48, LLC requests a change of zoning classification from GU and AU to PUD, PUD application number is 23PUD00005; the Tax Account Numbers are 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, and 3000829; and they are located in District 5. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, advised on the PUD application associated with this request, there are 14 conditions; one of them, he would like to make a slight modification to; he spoke to the developer ahead of time on this; the County’s Fire Chief and everyone is in agreement with it; and he just wants to make sure that the Board understands what staff is doing. He went on to add condition number 10b currently reads, “Prior to approval of the construction plans and preliminary subdivision plat or site plan, a developer shall donate or convey to the County in fee simple three acres of land to be used for a fire station;” he pointed out it has come to staff’s attention with all of the fire stations, and in conversations with the City of Palm Bay and County staff, that the proposed location that they have, given that there are some planned fire stations in the City of Palm Bay, they may not provide the most sufficient service, so what staff wants to be able to do is, and the developers have agreed to this, to look at a different site potentially throughout their project; what he is asking for, with the Board’s permission, is to modify that condition to where it says ‘be’, staff would just insert ‘execute an agreement for the donation/conveyance to the County in fee-simple, three acres of land to be used for a fire station’ in that first sentence; and he thinks what that does is it gives staff the opportunity to work with the developer to find the appropriate location for that fire station as they develop. Chair Steele noted okay, but he would like to add that when the County asked the developer to donate the three acres of land, they had no obligation whatsoever to donate this land, so they are completely doing it out of their own good will; as a result of that, the County is moving forward with a positive fashion; and what staff did with the City and trying to put it together, he thinks is extremely good; but he did want it noted that there was no mandatory need for a fire station at that site; and he asked if he is correct. Mr. Calkins replied that is his understanding. Kim Rezanka, representing JEN Florida 48, LLC and the developer owner/representatives Sun Terra Communities stated with her, representing the developer, is Richard German and Dan Edwards, and the engineer of record Poulos & Bennett LLC represented by Andrew Ivey are here to answer any questions; Planner Jesse Anderson is also here to answer questions; and the Transportation Engineer James Taylor with Kimley-Horn will actually present and answer questions as well. She went on to say as the Board knows, they came before it in May 2024 for the Future Land Use amendment transmittal hearing; at that time, and still today, they are seeking a Future Land Use amendment of 1,109.57 acres; the purpose is to allow a mixed-use development; and the PUD application is now before the Board. She noted when they met with the Board in May they said they would limit the density to three units to the acre; now that it has the PDP, that is exactly what it is doing, as well as the BDP will also limit it to three units to the acre; the request is for 1,082.57 acres for a Residential-4, limited to three units to the acre as stated in the BDP, and 27.33 acres of CC, which will allow 398 acres, 390,000 square feet of retail, and this is for residents for goods and services that will also allow for the three-acre fire station; when they were before the Board in May, they offered two acres; the County came back and said they need three because they do not have sufficient fire capacity in the County at that area; and the developer has agreed to do that, to work with the County, and if they need it in a different location than right there on Babcock to serve Rolling Meadows or some other development, they are willing to work with the County as to wherever they find it best to put that three-acre fire station. She explained the PUD rezoning is for 3,241 units and the 398,000 square foot of retail; this is located north and east of Deer Run, south of Willowbrook Street, west of Babcock Street, known as County Road 507 in this area, and there is a 100-foot plus drainage ditch and right-of-way around the property as a buffer between Deer Run and all the way around the property, not on Babcock Street; there is a large strip of land to the north, about 100-foot wide at parts, owned by Sam Sartori and Jaric Holdings, and this does not allow them to annex into the City, so there is a strip of property and Willowbrook to the north; this has been a challenging project; they did have a community meeting; there were many concerns; and she is sure the Board will hear more tonight. She went on by saying there were many concerns as the Board heard at the meeting in May; growth is coming; this area has an abundance of development forthcoming, Rolling Meadows, Lotus, Cypress Gardens, and that is to name a few; and this will be gone through with the PowerPoint. She provided the Board with a PowerPoint presentation; she stated that is the location and request; currently the Future Land Use is one to two and one-half units to the acre; the location she described is shown on the slide; she noted the Board can see to the north of that yellow line is a strip of land that is not adjacent to the City of Palm Bay, and stops the adjacency; the area to the north says Willowbrook and Satori, that is Rolling Meadows that de-annexed from Palm Bay back into the County in 2019; she showed the Board the developments in the area so it would have a sense of what is out there; and she stated he or she can see that what is coming, what is out there, and it has density as great as 20 units to the acre. She remarked immediately to the north at Rolling Meadows is two units to the acre; this is three units to the acre; this is a transition from the Water Stone of five to 20 units to the acre; there is Parkway mixed use; Pete’s Holding, which is now called Lotus, is to the east; there is Emerald Lakes, Calumet Farms, and Ashton Park; and these are all very large developments coming in. She pointed out Sun Terra Lakes will provide a substantial amount of proportionate fair share fees and impact fees to help with the expansion of Babcock, the expansion of utilities, and this will help facilitate the fixing of Babcock Road; as she said, this is what that is going on in this area and what is happening in the area; and with that, she asked James Taylor to come up. James Taylor, Kimley-Horne, representing the applicant, commented one of the things they evaluate for a site like this undergoing a Future Land Use amendment and also a site plan evaluation is they do a number of analyses; one of them is mandated by the State where they look at roadway capacity, what the area looks like in the short-term, which is like a 10-year outlook, and then a long-term horizon; that study was performed and submitted, and approved by the staff; the main outcome of that report is the identification of a deficiency of Babcock Street from Micco Road to Grant in both of those long-term horizons; and it recommends, in order to mitigate that widening, that it will mitigate that deficiency that the roadway will need to be widened to four lanes in the future. He continued by saying they also do another study that kind of dials in to the operations at the driveways and at the intersections to make sure turn lane links are provided in the future that are adequate to serve the project, but also to serve the background volumes; that goes through a methodology beforehand so that staff agrees with the assumptions that they put into the methodology; that has been approved and it identified a study area of more than five miles in radius, what the background traffic assumptions would be, the project traffic assumptions, and how those trips will distribute through the area based on Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) latest regional travel demand modeling; it identifies roadway capacity like the previous study but for the build out of the project; and it also identifies intersection and driveway operational performances in mitigations that need to be in place to serve both the project and the background traffic. He mentioned this figure identifies that study area with the blue radius being a five-mile area; the percentages that are seen on the roadways that are coded in red, as identified as study area roadways, are the percentage of the external project trips that are going to see those roads in the future; every little, red dot there are intersections that are to be evaluated in the Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA); the little, blue dots are the proposed access at this point; the outcome of these studies is going to identify project impacts; the way it does that is it evaluates the background deficiencies before the project comes online, and also any new deficiencies as a result of the project; and that is the way that they quantify the project share of any mitigation that needs to occur. He advised the Board he will be standing by for any questions. Commissioner Goodson asked from the front gate of that project, how far north and how far south are they planning on four laning Wickham. Chair Steele asked if Commissioner Goodson means Babcock. Commissioner Goodson replied affirmatively. Mr. Taylor advised the deficiency that has been identified in the Future Land Use, which County staff has agreed to, is from Micco up to Grant; and that section definitely needs to be changed from two to four lanes. Commissioner Goodson inquired if that is four or five miles. Mr. Taylor responded that is a great question; and he would guess at least three. Commissioner Goodson asked by his map, he said a five-mile radius, right. Mr. Taylor replied yes. Commissioner Goodson stated that he is planning on four laning Babcock, he would assume five miles south and five miles north. Mr. Taylor explained the five miles is just an idea of how big the study area is for the site. Commissioner Goodson asked once getting past the circle he had on the map, it goes back to two lanes. Mr. Taylor responded yes. Ms. Rezanka stated as shown, there are going to be impacts; there are deficiencies in infrastructure; but that is what proportionate fair share is for, that is what Florida Statutes allow; that is anticipated in these exact circumstances; and there is not a reason to deny because there is deficient infrastructure, as the project just has to fix the infrastructure. She went on to say next is the actual, one of the pages from the PDP for the PUD zoning, is actually a seven-page document that is in the Board’s packet; this is just a portion of it; this also asks for several waivers, so in the BDP there are the waivers that are requested; they will go through those as well; she provided the Board a slide of the proposed development; she stated the yellow is residential, the light green is passive recreation, the middle color green is active recreation, the very dark area is wetlands, and the orange color is impacted wetlands; and the impacted wetlands are not substantial, she will have to give the Board those numbers. She noted the blue is stormwater, and the very dark, which is not here, but the Board will see the lake, which is kind of a grey color; that is a large lake that is intended to be recreation for the residents only; she provided a slide to the Board showing the buffering from the Deer Run neighborhood; she pointed out this is generally just to show, there is that existing canal of 100 feet; there is a proposed buffer tract of 50 feet; then there also are the lot lines and the setbacks; and just from property line to property line it is a minimum of 150 feet to the Deer Run neighbors. She commented this is average, what it should be at a minimum; then some of them will be different based upon, as the Board can see, where the houses are located; the yellow is the residential, so there will be some residential; but there is still going to be a buffer tract between the residential and the Deer Run neighbors; and also the neighbors to the north, there is the 100-foot right-of-way, plus the 100-foot property owned by Sartori. She remarked there have been questions regarding school impacts; there has been a concurrency review; there is going to be insufficiency in the elementary and middle schools; this developer, and all of the developers in the area have met with the School Board, and are continuing to work with the School Board, to locate new schools; currently there is capacity by bringing in portables for another few years; but ultimately, there is going to have to be redistricting and changes; as the Board knows, and as have been discussed, a proportionate fair share allows for school concurrency; and163.31806 specifically addresses the school concurrency impacts. She went on by saying there were concerns about fire and police response; there is an interlocal agreement with Palm Bay; there are mutual aid agreements; obviously, Sun Terra does want its residents to be safe; it has donated three acres; and there also will be additional impact fees from this project for fire, police, and Emergency Medical Services (EMS). She pointed out Palm Bay has planned as a priority to build a fire station; its number one priority is in this area; they currently have approved a temporary fire station at Sunrise Elementary, just to the south on the Kameha property, that they intend to bond next year and have it up and running in the not-too-distant future; future utilities, Palm Bay has agreed to provide utilities, water, and sewer; and the developer will be paying to bring those to the site. She stated this is the phasing plan; currently, one can see on the far right in the gray where it says Phase 11, and under that, that is Phase 1; that is adjacent to Babcock Street; Phase 1 is the fire station spot that if it is there, that will be the first phase; if it is moved someplace else, they will work with the County to get it up and running as soon as possible; but that site will be dedicated before anything else is permitted; and they will have the plats, but before the building permits are issued. She explained there are 10 phases planned here, plus Phase 11, the commercial; she provided the Board a slide of the waivers being requested; she stated these are to allow smaller lots sizes; there is a waiver to not require a storage facility on site, and a waiver to allow building separations to be smaller, assuming that there are no utility easements impacted; there is a waiver to permit ingress and egress connecting to spine roads from internal subdivisions; there is a waiver regarding usable, common, open space to include the lake as active recreation; and there is a waiver to reduce rear setbacks from 20 to 15; with that, they have the engineer, developer, traffic engineer, and the planner present today; and if the Board or the public has any other questions, they are happy to answer them. She advised they request approve of the change of the adoption of the Future Land Use amendment, the adoption of the PUD zoning with the PDP and the waivers. Joann Young commented she lives in the Deer Run community; she is a licensed real estate broker in the State of Florida since 2002; she is the owner of five bordering acres in Deer Run; this development will be in her backyard; they are an equestrian community; currently, they are building over $1 million homes in their neighborhood; and they are on two and one-half acres-plus. She went on to say currently, they are the only thing out there; the County’s Planning and Zoning staff stated in the last meeting, for this project, that it does not comply with the Brevard County Comprehensive Plan; she noted they are zoned AU Residential-1.2.5; as the Board knows, so far the only positive that Deer Run has in any of this, is the fire station, because currently, the closest is nine miles away, so they do pay higher insurance premiums for that reason; she is opposed to the density for this project, for the negative impact it will have on the values of Deer Run; and they are the closest neighbor to Sun Terra. She asked the Board to please vote no on the density, and have the developer conform to the plan on a compromise to RES-2 as was suggested by Planning and Zoning; she added, she does not know if this has been taken into consideration as a deficit in traffic, but when there is an accident on I-95, the traffic is rerouted to Babcock Street from Fellsmere to St. John’s Heritage Parkway; at that time, all of the I-95 traffic comes through Babcock, and many of the residents cannot even get out of their subdivisions at that time; she asked the Board to vote RES-2, at least as a compromise for the residents in Deer Run; and they have been there for 40 years. She stated yes, new development will be coming, and they welcome new development; but they just think that the density is way too high; the lot sizes are way too small; they still do not really know what an active recreation lake is going to have on it; she really did not know from Ms. Rezanka’s last conversation what active residential lake meant; and she asked what is going to take place on that lake, because that lake is right behind her house. Gloria Kanungo remarked she lives in the Deer Run Subdivision; she too, like Joann, is very concerned about the high density development going in, in Sun Terra; like Commissioner Pritchett said, she was so concerned about the neighbors in North Brevard and the density of that neighborhood going in that does not fit with the existing neighborhood; she hopes Commissioner Pritchett will consider the same for her southern neighbors; it does not fit; and it does not go with the County’s long-range zoning. She stated she would like to address the traffic density report that the engineer gave; she is questioning why they did not use the FDOT’s assessment that was done in June; this was done by the State and does address several concerns regarding the density of traffic that this development will cause; it will be a 1,500 percent increase in traffic on Interstate 95; they did not address Interstate 95 at all; the Board should have copies of this; and she can give the Board hers if needed. She continued by saying she would like the Board to consider that; Babcock Street is not the only thing that is impacted by this; Palm Bay has said they are going to provide sewer and water; but it is her understanding that this has to be done prior to the road being improved; she asked what time frame are the residents looking at; and she advised that has not been addressed to the residents at all. She commented the other thing she would like to talk about is the East Central Florida Regional Planning Council (ECFRPC), which, this again, was sent to Tallahassee to do an assessment of the impact that this will have on all of the precious environmental land that is adjacent to this property; she does not know if the Commissioners have read this; she hopes he or she would have; but it does cite several reasons; and it does not support this development. She stated she would like the Board to take that into consideration all of the wildlife that this would impact, not only on the local level, but it also talks about a State and regional level in Indian River County, not just Brevard; several species, she does not want to waste the Board’s time with that, but they also recommended studies to be done before any land clearing to look at habitat for several endangered species; and she would like to know if that is moving forward before any land clearing is done. She asked if the Board is going to address these concerns before it just blanket approves this high density; she noted high density is coming; but she asked if the County really needs 5,000 more homes within a five-mile radius; and it is not conducive with what is already there. She stated she recommended to the Board that it consider the compromise recommendation; she can leave these copies; and they were all done by the State of Florida. Chair Steele stated yes, ma’am, but he believes she put them in a false light; the ECFRPC did not recommend that this project be a Development of Regional Impact (DRI), those were just recommendations, number one; number two, the FDOT thing was just recommendations; the County has had its staff looking over this for a long period of time; he understands where Ms. Kanungo is coming from as there are documents out there; things could be studied to death; he expressed his appreciation to her; but he noted he does not think they should be put into evidence, they are not accurate. Ms. Kanungo advised just for the record, she totally disagrees with Chair Steele, because there is a conclusion basically stating that for the reasons above that the ECFRPC cannot support approval of the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) as proposed. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, pointed out to the Chair that the document is already part of the record. Cheryl Vadney stated she lives in Deer Run; she guesses it is a Palm Bay address, but it is unincorporated County; she is a New Yorker, she is a transfer, but she is not from New York City; she loves the life they have, it is very different; she is a suburban girl; she moved into the country; and she now deals with pigs, snakes, and a vast assortment of wildlife that the suburban girl would never have even seen and it is wonderful. She continued by saying her concern is the Future Land Use; someone, somewhere, the County, had a vision for south County; she asked how that vision just vanished; she advised when she moved here 24 or 23 years ago . . . everyone changes, everything changes; she has three closets of clothes because she loves change; but it is obvious to her that the changes that are proposed are inconsistent with the Future Land Use and with the beauty of south County; their homes are on 2.5 acres; it seems like a reasonable request to have something bordering on Deer Run; and she would beg the Commission to consider these lot sizes, as they are inconsistent with south County, with the beauty of south County. She noted she does not know if any of the Commissioners live in south County; if not, he or she does not know what is being missed; it is a wonderful way of life; it could be for others too who live in Sun Terra; she asked the Board to please consider a change in the density; she pointed out it can benefit south County; it has a lot of growth right now; they have Water Stone, and other developments coming in; they have I-95; they have all of these changes going on; and people really need to consider their resources here. She explained she stood here 23 years ago and asked this Commission to solve their flooding problems; and they still have a flooding problem. Sandra Sullivan commented as a Quasi-Judicial hearing, the Board’s job is to look at compatibility and concurrency, and if it does not comply, to reject the application; first, she wants to contradict Ms. Rezanka on her statement that this meets concurrency; per State Statute 163.3180, sanitary sewer, solid waste, drainage, and potable water are the only public facilities and services subject to concurrency requirements on a Statewide basis, so the Board is looking at making a Comprehensive Plan change; and according to the language, herein, the County is required to have that concurrency when it makes that Comprehensive Plan to the State. She provided the Board a handout showing all of this area on two sides, and in this block, there is one unit per two and one-half acres; she noted this proposal increases the density from 432 single-family units to 3,246 single-family, plus the commercial; one thing this audience probably does not recognize is that then they can add multi-family and Senate Bill (SB) 102 exemptions, and get under the radar, because it would not come before this Board, it would go straight to site planning; they can put in SB 102 affordable housing; and the residents will own nothing and be happy. She explained according to the County’s own concurrency evaluation procedures, Section 62-602, it talks about concurrency, again, sewer and water; it talks about before, now this is an application prior to site plan, the previous thing was Comprehensive Plan changes, that has been addressed; now, this is talking about site plan which comes after this Board; they would have to have a capacity certificate from the service proprietor for water and sewage; and she provided a copy of that for the record. She stated there is the letter from Palm Bay saying it will give them a new water reclamation facility and sewage; but there is no timeline, imagine that; this could be five, 10, or 20 years down the road; she asked who is going to pay for it; she stated, oh, yeah, impact fees; the County’s impact fees for transportation have not been updated in 23 years; the County has an $800 million deficit because the Commissioners have been kicking the can down the road, particularly District 1 and District 2 . . . Chair Steele advised the Board can hear her just fine; and she does not need to be yelling. Ms. Sullivan stated the Board has been kicking the can down and causing this crisis for the last eight years; for the other impact fees, they have not been updated in 32 years; the County has a crisis that is turning into a service failure for its Emergency Medical Services (EMS) and Emergency Medical Technicians (EMT); those impact fees have not been updated in 32 years; there is no way to fund the growth; and the Board is using the commitment of the 33 percent that was supposed to address their pay to fixing the growth. She noted there are flooding issues; she asked if the Board knows its rating for the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood discount in Brevard has gone from 25 percent down to 10 percent, because it is not protecting the flood plains and not fulfilling its obligations under the National Flood Insurance Program; there is State Statute that under concurrency requirements prohibits this change to the Comprehensive Plan without having the concurrency for sewage and water in place, number one; number two, this is incompatible with the surrounding area; and Chair Steele said to just bring the money in from the impact fees and tax the people more. Chair Steele passed the gavel to Vice Chair Pritchett. He advised first of all, the County has a three percent cap on its budget; as a result of that, it has difficulty paying EMT’s and other people additional monies; the only way the County is going to get anywhere to be able to increase its services in Brevard County is by impact fees and by additional funds that come in; he has been into real estate for 50 years, so he was there way before Deer Run was put into play; and he said 50 years ago that Deer Run was going to flood until the County gets additional subdivisions down there that is going to relieve the flooding. He continued by saying several months ago when Sun Terra came to Brevard County, and this is in his District, he sat down with staff and everybody else, and they worked diligently to understand exactly what they wanted to do; they met with the people down in these particular districts several times; in addition to the multiple problems that the County has with Interlocal Agreements on Babcock Street with Palm Bay and a variety of other things, it has a Heritage Parkway that sits out and ends in the middle of a field; there are tremendous traffic problems; there are tremendous problems in Babcock Street; and if people think this one is a big project, right behind it are two more huge ones that are much bigger than this. He advised it is coming no matter whether people like it or do not like it; the only way the County is going to be able to get anything done in this County to make the improvements that are needed to relieve the traffic is to ultimately get the Heritage Parkway connected in and move down the road; there have been comments stated by Ms. Sullivan tonight saying all of this wonderful stuff like she is some big legal attorney; she is not; the water and the sewer can be put in at the same time; if the County Attorney would like to answer that question, fine; but what the County has done is everything in its power to make sure that every ‘t’ is crossed and every ‘i’ is dotted to get this project done; and he completely stands behind this project because it is the only way he can see that the County is going to be able to get impact fees, do additional things, to improve the roads, to improve the flooding, and to move forward with making Brevard County a safer, better place to live. He pointed out yet tonight everybody is sitting up here, the eight or nine who spoke, and the County has had several meetings on this where it has had a lot more than these people speaking on this; if he is not mistaken, the County sent the plan up to Tallahassee, the Comp Plan change up to Tallahassee; Tallahassee approved it and sent it back; and he asked if that is correct. Mr. Ball replied staff sent it up for their review. Chair Steele asked and they sent it back to the County. Mr. Ball responded affirmatively. Chair Steele stated he does not need any comments from the audience. An unknown person is speaking from the audience advising Mr. Ball did not answer Chair Steele’s question. Chair Steele remarked he answered his question fine; they reviewed it and sent it back; he does not need anything from the people in the audience right now; he asked them to just let him finish, because this has to happen; and there are going to be some issues here tonight if there is any more stuff with the audience, so he wants to try to just finish this up. He stated he is completely behind this project; there is going to be other projects that are there; there will be additional things that need to be done; he reiterated the only way the County is going to ever be able to get this thing done is to get Babcock Street taken care of, the Heritage Parkway taken care of, and a variety of other things that are an absolute necessity to increase the amount of monies that come into Brevard County to do what it needs to do to make Brevard County a better place to live; and he asked with that if the Commissioners have any comments. *Commissioner Pritchett returned the gavel. Ms. Rezanka stated she does not know what else to say after that; they can address the concurrency issues; they have their planner and engineer; the only thing she would state is that the active recreation will have no motor boats; it may have kayaks and canoes; it will allow swimming if the water is clean enough, she does not know, she presumes it will be; regarding the payment for utilities, that is paid by the developer; and the developer is also going to have to pay for the roads, proportionate fair share, and for schools. She advised it is over and above impact fees, so it is not impact fees, it is not the taxpayers paying for this increase in service to meet the concurrency; as to compatibility, again, that issue was not raised by the Department of Commerce; they have shown that this is compatible with the growth in the area; the County’s Comprehensive Plan talks about RES-4 and to look at surrounding land uses, not adjacent land uses, so compatibility is much larger than what is next to a person; and with that, she requests the Board to approve the Future Land Use RES-4 as requested, the PUD zoning with the PDP and the waivers as requested.

    JEN Florida 48, LLC, requests Adoption of the 2023-2 Large Scale Plan Amendment to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 1:2.5 to RES 4 & CC. (Residential 1 per 2.5 acres) to RES 4 (Residential 4) and CC (Community Commercial). (23LS00001) (Tax Account 3000277, 3000368, 3000827, 3000829) (District 5)

    $1

  • Agenda item H.9.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a change of zoning classification from TR-3 (Mobile Home Park) with a BSP to BU-1 (General Retail Commercial) with removal of the BSP, as requested by Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. There being no comments or objections, the Board approved the request of Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. for a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with BSP to BU-1, with removal of BSP, and adding a BDP that limits BU-1 uses to retail, office, and personal services, and requires and 20-foot buffer along the east and south sides as recommended by Planning and Zoning, and within that 50-foot boundary if there are any specimen trees they will make all efforts to save and maintain those trees during construction, for property located north of Canada Drive, east of US Highway 1, Mims.

    Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with a BSP to BU-1 with removal of the BSP. (24Z00023) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1)

  • Agenda item H.8.Land useapproved - Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.08), to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 2 (Residential 2) to CC (Community Commercial), as petitioned by Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. Jeffrey Ball, Planning and Zoning Manager, commented Items H.8. and H.9. are companion applications; he is going to read those into the record together; however, the Board will have separate motions. He went on to say Item H. 8. Is Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. requests a Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment 24S.08, to change the Future Land Use designation from RES 2 to CC; the application number is 24SS00008; the Tax Account Number is 2317736; and it is located in District 1. He stated Item H.9. is for Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. requests a change of zoning classification from TR-3 with a Binding Site Plan to BU-1 with a Binding Site Plan with removal of the BSP; the application number is 24Z00023; the Tax Account Number is 2317736; and it is located in District 1. He pointed out when the zoning item was heard by Planning and Zoning, they recommended approval with a Binding Development Plan (BDP); and there were conditions included in that, one of them was to limit the BU-1 uses to retail, office, and personal services, and a 20-foot buffer along the east and south property lines. Chair Steele advised he is a little confused by that; and he asked if the BDP would come in after the zoning request would be approved. Mr. Ball replied no, because a BDP is used in conjunction to support the zoning action. Chair Steele stated so their recommendation is if the Board does that, they want a BDP that says this; but the Board does not need to go along with that, as it can do whatever it wants. Mr. Ball remarked correct. Kim Rezanka, representing Ibraham and Haroon Realestated, Inc., stated with her is the representative of that company, Dr. Basim Niazi, is present tonight in case the Board has questions or if there are additional conditions it wishes to add to the BDP that came up during Planning and Zoning; currently, there is a 4.74 acre project; the request before the Board is only on 2.68 acres; as the Board can see on what she handed out to it, it is the yellow square; and she just did this to show what is in the area. She went on to say Fairglen School to the north is actually an institutional use; even the zoning says it is something else, it is RES-1, and should be government managed lands institutional, but it is not; below is Tradewinds Manufactured Mobile Home Park, which is a rental community; there is commercial along the U.S. 1 corridor there; it is close to Haverty’s and the Apollo Motel; the Future Land Use Map (FLUM), as the Board can see, they are asking to change the Residential-2 to Community Commercial, which is adjacent to the west; and they are asking to change the zoning from TR-3, which is a trailer park, to BU-1, which would make the entire parcel, 4.74 acres, consistent and the same. She pointed out under 62-1255, the TR-3 could be in CC as well or Neighborhood Commercial; the BU-1 has to be in the CC; the concept here is a flex office space design of 27 units; that is the large sheet she provided to the Board; it is 27 units; it is intended to be small office, small retail, barber shops, real estate offices, and things like that; and it will have regular business hours, comply with any performance standards required by Code, and it is not intended to be any type of warehousing, as it is just small office space for individuals to rent. She mentioned there are three homes to the east; two will have minor adjacency; they currently, as the Board can see from the photograph, have trees buffering; they will attempt to maintain as many trees as they are able to; as the Board can tell, all that is going to be over there is a driveway and one tail-end of a building; the Comprehensive Plan analysis, which is assessable from U.S. 1; the U.S. 1 is generally commercially developed; it is an infill commercial development; it is not located in an established residential neighborhood; is along a commercial corridor; it will have to comply with performance standards, which is a site plan review stage issue; and there are no material violations of the Comp Plan policies per the County staff report. She reiterated the zoning request is from TR-3 to BU-1, and removal of the existing BSP; this was changed to TR-3 in April 1987; it has never been developed; the BU-1 existing from U.S. 1 is 250 feet deep currently; and they are asking it to go to the east end of the property. She noted currently the size of the TR-3 portion, the 2.68 acres, is too small to even develop as TR-3, because one has to have 10 acres, so there is nothing that can be done with the property with the current zoning; again, they have shown the Board the concept plan; with that, they are here to answer any questions; they would request that the Board change the 2.6-acre Comp Plan designation from RES-2 to Community Commercial, and change the zoning of TR-3 to BU-1 with the removal of a BSP; and they agree to the conditions of the BDP as well. Commissioner Pritchett commented she has a quick question; people know much she loves natural buffers; they have that going; she has talked with staff and they think the smaller buffer is appropriate with this; she asked if Ms. Rezanka would consider that if there is any specimen-sized trees, like within a 50-foot area that they would get with staff on those; she stated she is not real sure, but it has some very beautiful canopies there; and she asked staff how would she word this. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, stated if the applicant would consider a condition that would have the 20-foot buffer as recommended by P&Z; but in that 50-foot boundary, if there are any specimen trees that they make all efforts to save those during construction. Ms. Rezanka advised Mr. Calkins said 20 and then he said 50. Mr. Calkins explained it is a 20-foot buffer he thinks what has been agreed to; but the concern, he thinks what the Commissioner is interested in, is when looking at the aerial photograph, there appears to be some canopy trees in there that if they can be saved during construction, she would like to make sure those are maintained and safe. Commissioner Pritchett asked the applicant to do their best to try to maintain and save those trees. Ms. Rezanka advised that is fine. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Ordinance No. 24-22, amending Article III, Chapter 62, of the Code of Ordinances of Brevard County, entitled “The 1988 Comprehensive Plan”, setting forth the Ninth Small Scale Plan Amendment of 2024, 23S.05, to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan; amending Section 62-501 entitled Contents of the Plan; specifically amending Section 62-501, Part XVI(C), entitled the Future Land Use Map Appendix; and provisions which require amendment to maintain internal consistency with these amendments; providing legal status; providing a severability clause; and providing an effective date.

    Ibrahim and Haroon Realestate, Inc. (Kim Rezanka) requests a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment (24S.08), to change the Future Land Use Designation from RES 2 (Residential 2) to CC. (24SS00008) (Tax Account 2317736) (District 1)

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Brevard County Board of County Commissioners — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: ad36f088903143d511df5f425c756c28. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record