POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners - Zoning

Thursday, September 24, 2020 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Board of County Commissioners - Zoning

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

>> five-minute break. >>> the five-minute time limit is up. Madam Clerk, can you give us a roll call, please, to see if we have quorum present? >> commissioner bovo? >> commissioner levine cava? Commissioner diaz? >> here. >> commissioner heyman. >> back again. >> commissioner higgins? Commissioner jordan? >> here. >> commissioner martinez? >> living the dream. >> commissioner monsteam? Present. >> commissioner moss? >> here. >> vice Chairwoman Sosa? Chairwoman Edmondson? >> here. >> I also see we've been joined by commissioners bovo and commissioner levine cava. >> thank you. >> present. >> present, thank you. >> that makes 11. >> yes, we have 11 members present. >> being -- . Okay, thank you. All right. We'll move right on in to our cdm zoning meeting. Again I have to go through the introduction and that's to our residents watching and the public. Participating in today's meeting, thank you once again for joining us. This virtual environment has been structured to emulate a regular board of county commissioners meeting, therefore all rules of procedures will be adhered to. Commissioners are asked to use the raise-hand icon found in the participant tab and remain muted until recognized by myself or the vice chair. I will take the comments in order the hand is displayed. I am also respectfully asking commissioners not to speak out of turn because it causes confusion during this type of virtual platform. If you are leaving even temporarily, please announce it so that we can keep track of quorum. Mr. Attorney, you can guide us through now. >> yes, Madam Chair, and at this point, it would be appropriate to have the design director read the introductory statement. >> will zoning is being held using technology made pursuant to the governor's executive orders. This meeting has been structured to emulate an in person meeting in accordance with the code of miami-dade county all items to be heard today have been legally advertised in the newspaper. Notices have been mailed. And the properties have been posted. Ese advertisements and notices have advised interested parties on how they May virtually attend and participate in this meeting. Items will be called up and heard by agenda number and name of applicant. The record on file for the hearing on each application includes documents from the public agencies, the department of regulatory and economic resources, and where there is an appeal from the community zoning appeals board, the transcript for those hearings. The hearing file and all documents submitted to be shown today are available to all interested parties and commissioners and May be accessed online via county's website at https//miami-dade.Gov/zoning- commissioners.Asp. Interested parties who wish to speak on an application must have registered in advance. Registered attendees can speak on the respective items by joining the zoom virtual meeting as provided in their meeting rej gistration or confirmation e-mails or by calling in live by phone. Registered speakers will be queued in and allowed to speak at the appropriate time. Persons who are joining the meeting by phone and are recognized to speak May unmute themselves when instructed by dialing star 6 on the phone. As each application is called, the clerk will be asked to swear in the witnesses wish to speak on that application. All speakers must provide their name and address and indicate for the record that they have been sworn in prior to making their comments. Parties have the right of cross examination. In addition, there is an official translator present for those individuals requiring such assistance. Interested parties who registered to speak and also wish to introduce documents or visual materials must have submitted such materials in advance by the deadline stated in the advertisements and notices. At the appropriate time these materials will be displayed on scene for members of the board and team to view. Nonregistered parties can view or listen to this virtual meeting via a live broadcast on miami-dade television through the county's online webcasting portal, or by calling a dedicated phone line. After the meeting an archived report May be accessed on the county's website. All rules of procedure will be followed. Commissioners who wish to make comments or ask questions should use the raise hand icon and be recognized by a chair person to speak. If a commissioner needs to leave even moment trailer, please announce it to e help ensure we have quorum at all time. In addition any commissioner who leaves the meeting during an item and is unable to continue listening will not be able to vote on the item consistent with due process items. Voting will be done by roll call. Zoning staff and other county personnel are available to answer any questions. This statement along with the fact all witnesses have been sworn shall be included in any trapt of the proceedings at this time with your permission, Madam Chair, please chair in the witnesses and I will then call in the first application. >> okay. Madam Clerk. >> do we have the witnesses on the line ready to go? Do we have the witnesses ready to go? [Witnesses sworn] I see you on mute, but, sir, I recorded it, thank you. >> Madam Chair, we do have one deferral. >> we have two deferred items, correct? >> at the request of the applicant, an item is requested to be deferred from this meeting. >> okay. >> I can read that out. >> which item is that? Appeal item number 1 christian holdings investments, llc. >> do we have someone that will come up and ask for a deferral? >> the applicant is present. Mr. Rivera, can you please unmute Mr. Mayol? >> is he on? Mr. Mayol? Can we move on, Mr. Attorney, and then he can come on later, I guess, whenever he gets here. >> yeah, with the representation -- it sounds like we have him. >> he's on now. >> I was muted, Madam Chair. Again, juan mayol, 701 brickel avenue. Our lady of the rosary school, we have been speaking to one of the neighbors who objected to this application when it went before the community council. We think we have found a way to address their concerns. Unfortunately, because of the circumstances that we are all living in, it's been very difficult to get that meeting going, so we consulted with him yesterday and received confirmation that he would have no objection to the deferral and we would ask the item be deferred until the next hearing date so we can have an opportunity to meet with the neighbors. Thank you. >> commissioner suarez, are you going to accept the deferral? >> yes, ma'am. >> second. >> so you move deferral and it's been second. Anyone wish to record no on appeal item number 1's deferral? That item is deferred until -- >> Madam Chair, if I May clarify for the record. >> yes. >> the applicant requested deferred the next available zoning meeting. This will nevertheless require re-advertisement because under the circumstances, we don't know exactly where or when that will be. >> okay. We're in the process of scheduling that now, the zoning meeting. It will probably be held right now -- I guess I can say because we've been scheduling everything at the dade county auditorium. I did have a suggestion from someone about the port, but I want to make sure that this is a place where it's easier to get to. So our next meeting will be at the dade county auditorium. >> thank you, Madam Chair. In light of -- since there are certain protocols that we'll need to establish for a zoning hearing this will still need readvertisement because we're going to have to make some adjustments. >> a memo will be coming out shortly to my colleagues. Okay. So that item has been deferred. Until the next cdmp zoning meeting. >> Madam Chair, point of order, I'm not sure that vote was taken on the deferral. >> okay. I think I had a motion and a second. Anyone wish to record no? I thought I did. Okay. So that item is deferred until the next meeting, which is when -- >> Madam Chairwoman? >> which is when, Mr. Attorney? >> I don't believe we have enough time to readvertise for what would otherwise be the October zoning meeting so we would be looking at November. >> okay. So at the November meeting. >> you currently have a regularly scheduled zoning hearing for November 18th. >> okay. Commissioner suarez, is that okay with you? Did commissioner suarez leave? Okay. I think he left us. So that will be November 18th. Do we have to approve this agenda, or we do it one by one? >> with zoning you can have the zoning director call them up one by one. >> okay. So we'll abide by the agenda as written and we'll take the two deferred items first -- the three deferred -- >> Madam Chair? >> commissioner diaz? >> thank you, Madam Chair. Once again, in case I might have to step out, I just wanted to alert ahead of time. I will stop the meeting at some time and let you know. Thank you. >> no problem. I also noticed with you raising your hand commissioner higgins' hand is up. I hope I didn't Miss Her on something she wanted to say. >> Madam Chair, I just wanted to inform you there is a tpo subcommittee meeting that was publicly noticed that's at 12:30. It did not get canceled, so I will be stepping off at 12:30 and will be back as quickly as possible. We hope to be done quickly and I'll be back at 1:00, but wanted to advise you of that. Thank you. >> okay. Because I know there was a tpo meeting scheduled for today that was canceled. >> this is a task force meeting that did not end up being canceled, so it's publicly noticed. So I'll leave for a bit, but I'll be back as quickly as possible. Thank you. >> deferred item a. >> Madam Chair? >> commissioner martinez? >> just one question, since you and commissioner higgins were talking about that. I had to change my schedule to make sure I went to the tpo meeting. Does anybody know why it was canceled? They just said a scheduling conflict. >> it was canceled because of the agenda, are and they felt that we would go over the 2:00 with this long of an agenda. >> I'm sure you'll try not to. >> it I'm going to do my -- I'm going to do my best. Okay. I think the next one is zoning item a? >> if we could have the item read. >> green land realtor's inc., z2018000188. There are no protestors and no waivers. Jose, can you please let the board and commissioner -- and chair know how many speakers there are, including the applicant and additional speakers. Thank you. >> Madam Chair, can you hear me? >> I can hear you. >> perfect. Madam Chair, for deferred item a, the only registered speaker is the applicant's representative, jonathan cruz. >> okay. Can we bring Mr. Cruz up? >> at this time, I'd like to bring up jonathan cruz. If you can please unmute your microphone. Mr. Cruz. >> yes, I'm here. You can hear me? >> yes, we hear you. >> perfect. >> how much time do you think you'll need, Mr. Cruz? >> probably about ten minutes. >> okay. That sounds good. Go ahead. Were you sworn in, Mr. Cruz? Does he have to be sworn in? >> the attorneys -- is he an attorney? >> no, I'm not earn an attorney. >> okay, then, yes, you need to be sworn in. >> Madam Clerk? [Witness sworn] >> you have ten minutes, Mr. Cruz. >>> my name is jonathan cruz, from nbc design address 6187 northwest 167th street, miami, florida. >> go ahead. >> we initially started the process back in 2018 to ask for a few variances. The main one being putting the building in the back of the property instead of the front as required by the special design district. The problem with that is that all of the businesses there currently have that same setup that we are approaching, and if we go ahead and change that to the noranda regulations and move it to the front, that would cause various problems for the business owner, the main one being the front parcel of the land, there is an alley going across the pot of land -- plot of land and the front part is a lot smaller. If we were to put the building in the rear, that would only leave us with a building of approximately a little bit over 6,000 square feet and our client needs a minimum of 10,000 square feet, which we're almost there with what we are proposing. The other issue that we see is there are various apartment buildings that have been developed within the recent years, and that would create a problem with traffic if the parking was to be in the rear of the property. Our client has a lot of customers that come in and out and those apartments obviously -- it's quite a few apartments that are there now, have, you know, their own set of traffic and it would just create a mess of flow for people to get in to the beauty supply store. The other thing is that we see that walmart across the street -- actually on the same side, sorry. -- has that same set up. They have their parking in the front and the main building is toward the back. So -- and if you can, I don't know if you can pull up our presentation there. >> it's up. Go ahead. >> perfect. >> so, yeah, that's the design that we're proposing. The other problem that we foresaw with putting the building toward the front is that there is an fpl power line running across the front of the property, and if we were to put that building in the front, then that would create an issue because -- so that would be another incurred cost, which is, you know, a hefty cost and we expect that to be over $100,000 and possibly even more than that. Can you go to the next page? There you can see the alley that we're talking about in front of the building. So if we were to put that same building in the front, you can see it won't fit. It's just not going to work there. And I think that pretrial detention center much covered everything. I have the developer here, as well. Is he allowed to state some words? >> yes, if it's within your ten minutes. >> perfect. >> yes, hi, my name is the owner of this company. When I went to purchase this building -- let me tell you a little bit of history about my company. My company name is elegant beauty plies. My supplies. We have 37 stores in the state of florida. We chose to open a store noranga. When I picked the property, I noticed most businesses were in the back, and they just built a walmart recently, I think it was last year in June, and they built the walmart to the back and the parking lot was in front as we're requesting. And now, I was surprised that we have to do the zoning -- didn't even know it was a different zoning designation. So we invested -- we started investing in this property. We did the plans and you know, there is a lot of cost involved, and if we have to go to the front, for sure we would have to cancel this project so we just need your help approving this knowledge pro et cetera today. Thank you. >> thank you. >> okay. So now that that's done, commissioner moss? Public hearing is closed. Commissioner moss? >> thank you, Madam Chair. I'd like to hear from staff. Staff, you made a recommendation. Could you kind of walk us through your recommendation at this time? >> yes, commissioner moss and board of county commissioners. we looked at the nature of the variances, the number of variances being requested, and there is eight in total. It really is such a departure of what we're trying to achieve from the urban mixed use for urban centers, that we're obligated to recommend against it. It really -- this building -- again, it's not inconsistent with the existing structures that are on the ground to -- along U.S. 1. In fact, the building directly to the south is configured in the same way. Those are were developed beforehand, but we do feel that it is quite feasible to the build the same type of building structure and meeting the urban center standards by placing the building along the road, having the parking in the rear and having those appropriate architectural features. So with that, we recommend denial. >> so the issue that they talked about in reference to the alley issue, how can that be addressed? Can they just close the alley? Are you familiar with that -- >> yeah, I'm not, to be honest. We looked -- looking at the site, we didn't see any issue with an alley on the site per se. >> okay. How does that promote the community urban design and designations we're trying to promote along the major molds along U.S. 1 close to the bus way? And how does that factor in to my desire to create a little mini dades up and down U.S. 1? Up and down U.S. 1 from. >> from an intensity standpoint, this property does have the ability to go up to 15 stories. It does have the ability to be developed with an intensity of up to 125 units per acre. So, again, from our perspective, at an under utilization of site.~o~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~o~~~~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~oo~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~~o~~o~o~o~~~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~~~o~~~o~~~o~o~~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~~~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~o~o~~o~~~o~o~o~o~~o~o~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~~~~o~~~~~o~~o~o~o~~o~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~o~o~~o~~o~~~~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~o~~~o~~~o~~~o~~~o~~o~~o~~~o~~~o~~~~~o~~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~o~o~~~~o~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~o~~~~o~~~o~o~~o~~~~o~~o~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~o~~o~~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~o~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~o~~o~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~o~~~~o~~o~~~~o~~o~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~~~o~~o~~~o~~~~o~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~o~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~o~~~~o~o~~~~o~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~o~~o~~~~~o~o~~~o~~~o~o~~o~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~o~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~o~~~~~o~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~o~o~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~o~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~o~~~~~~~o~o~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~o~~~o~~~o~~~~o~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~o~~o~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~o~~o~~~~o~~o~~~~o~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~o~~o~~~~o~~o~~~~o~o~~o~o~~~o~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~o~~~o~o~~o~~~o~~~o~~o~~~o~o~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~o~o~~o~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~~~~~~>~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~o~o~~~o~~~~~~o~~o~~~~~~~~o~~o~~o~o~o~~~~o~~o~~o~~~~o~o~~~~o~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~o~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~o~o~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~o~o~~o~o~o~~~~~~o~~~~o~~~o~~~~o~o~~~o~o~~~o~o~~o~~o~~~~~o~~~o~~~~~~~~~ into this hoa the December 11 proceeding it was used falsely in the approval process and therefore tainted the whole procedure. The rezoning process and statements made by Ms. Kristin and Ms. Gordon in public records the transcript cannot be taken back and prove their pathological liars and con artists and missed opportunities to tell the truth and even the Chairman Who exercise no oversight against the group who claim to represent the homeowners association for over four years, six months, counting up to now. Who was a very familiar with? He said so himself page 42 and page 82 November 13. Ms. Christian and Ms. Bacshould have no place in the rezoning because they of their criminal conduct. Other members of the staff play the part in this weather knowing or not knowing should be disciplined for they were implicated in this also. No one did their homework for over four years. That is pure carelessness giving recognition and credibility to an hoa that does not exist. The Chairman And councilmembers and three ladies falsely tip the scale with false statements and fraud perpetrated by this illegal hoa in this gain of self-proclaimed officers. The shows there was no procedure. This is a requirement for all land-use. It was not committed to in this process were serious life-changing decisions are made. The residence of 71st street deserve the highest equal and justice just like any affluent area when it comes to rezoning issues which will affect the tranquility of this decision that will forever change the environment on 71st street coming in and out seven days a week 9:00 until 6:00 P.M. Every day after working five days a week. Three individuals, [Audio lost] This can be proven by number of residents who lived directly across from this development who suffer the most by this import-export business seven days a week with trucks coming in and out in front of their home. The residents who live on 71st street please stand up, which we can't do at this moment. Page 13, also Ms. Kim, she stage right next to me and I live on 71st street. She has audio problems so she cannot speak up. She never met these ladies. No one on the street knows these ladies. Those other two ladies we do not know. The people on this block never met. Mrs. Barr replied, we met with them, a bold faced lie. They have no integrity. Ms. Christian and kathleen are pathological liars. This practice is a crime under florida state statute. This has been going on over four years and everything they have been involved in the community council should be re-examined to see what they have contaminated because they committed crimes against the county, the residents, and taxpayers of miami-dade county and should be made an example of two prevent others from doing the same. Some very bad ladies. They found a loophole in the process with shortsightedness of the council members and Chairman Morgan. We are second by these three women's actions. This is not a one-time lapse of judgment. Instead, it appears is deception that was orchestrated over the years and the same can be said about the councilmembers themselves. We deserve a higher standard from them and miami-dade to deliver accountability and take action to uphold the standards. These are the persons who became complicit implicating this false representation of the illegal hoa and the public transcript to establish it. Number one of number 13. Mister Frederick, the chairperson, Ms. Johnson, councilmember. Page 44 and 92. Mr. Dickerson. The economic resource clark. Page 93. Number four, councilmember Ms. Carolyn florence. Page 32, Ms. Christian who concocted this game. Page 44, 91, 92, mid kathleen gordon. Page 71, 72, 74, Mr. Juan carlos munoz. Page 58, 70, 71, those are the names of the persons who tainted the process with the hoa illegitimate November 13, 2019 for the December 11, 2019 still no value of this group annual redemption by them. Number one, the Chairman Again asked, are you part of the homeowners association? They both said yes on page 12 and 13. Ms. Barr said, yes, page 12 and 13. Ms. Gordon said, yes, page 12 and 13. In conclusion, the rezoning process were persons are placed under oath to tell the truth or nothing but the truth and if not is committing a crime of perjury. The statements of these persons who participated were far from that and evidence is on the transcript. These two hearings are about false misrepresentation, information misrepresentation, negligence, misrepresentation, no oversight, no value of said hoa or person. It's outright fraud. Ms. Christian, gordon, bach should be arrested and cover the cost of all three hearings. You, Madam Chairperson, and commissioners , use this hearing to restore integrity and trust back into the process . Thank you very much. Representing the appellate or something? Appellate . Afraid I gave him too much time. Filed the appeal. The other representative -- wish I could stay, have to leave the meeting for one hour. I will be back at 2:00. Is up. Principle she had to leave as well. This because I need to leave? Knew we had a long agenda. We will be here until the end of the agenda. I have no idea when we are going to vote. . Let me ask if I might to the attorney on this. This gentleman was quite well-prepared . It reminds me of the jailhouse lawyer. He just put together things and showed by example what he was stating . If this is a gross impropriety of something where people under oath misrepresented and stuff like that -- everything because we don't know. I happen to know one of the people he's talking about and they live in that area. Through this? Who am I trying to get now? The auditor you now have the representative . Representative. The property owners attorney Mister Bermudez. He is here for the record. Tell us if he needs to be sworn in. Am the attorney for the entity vf acquisitions llc. [Audio lost] I assume all of you -- I will try to keep it shorter than that, Madam Chair. Staff has recommended approval. Actually, if you go across the board you will see the neighborhood characteristics. Yes there is residential there, but truthfully there's also industrial all around. In fact, there's already an area where trucks are parked at all times of the day that would be very different of a business that would have smaller, newer bays and would probably look a lot nicer. I'm not going to go through the whole recommendation you have in front of you. The recommendation is for .[Audio lost] -- negative comments made. Go to the next slide if you don't mind. Part of this process was obviously reaching with the community and community council at the request limiting some things that could be permitted to be done in the area. The list is there. Point that out for all of you so you know they work with the community council and the residents. In fact, it's not only are limitations on the things that could be done in the district, but also on top of that the times and exits of the entries and the times the trucks can come in in the area closest to Mr. Name. Next slide. This is very important because Mister Yearby makes a reference. This area many years ago before many of us were around in the 1960s this particular parcel was rezoned to industrial. If you look at the area we are talking about today, it's this little area that's.76 of the parcel. What we are talking about today is trying to square out the parcel so there can be a nicer property, so you can create jobs, so there can be something good for the neighborhood. For some odd reason there's a misperception by Mr. Yearby that it's the whole parcel we are talking about and it's not. We're just talking about the corner which is.76 of an acre and about 11 percent of the property. I want to be very clear that in fact this wouldn't have gone through the project would have been done in any case with the exception of that portion. Next slide. Same again. You can see the location map. I just wanted to point that out because at the first community council hearing, there was confusion because there was perception we were talking about the complete parcel which is pointed out here, when in fact it's the small portion on northwest 71st street. Next slide. This shows what it would look like. We would be bringing something commissioner jordan mentioned that's very important is we would be bringing jobs, landscaping to an area that does not have much landscaping. I believe the area that Mr. Yearby is concerned with there's 36 trees planted be planted in the area just on that portion. Again, this is just to give you an idea. We are not talking about large trucks. It's not a project on an extremely large scale. Next slide. The expected total impacts of the project development, this goes into some of the questions the commissioners had right before, is these two holdings, the expenditure the total about $31 million. This would be the number of expected jobs that would be supported during that process. They expected jobs post construction is to 66. We are not talking about something that will not ring jobs to the neighborhood. I know earlier today you are considering the storage facilities incorrectly so the storage facilities only have 2-24 employees. We are talking about 266 jobs that would be created in the area. Next slide. Again, this is the annual tax contribution which would be substantial. It's. It's estimated 116,004 an area. Obviously, the hourly mean wage $19.35. Total annual wages, again, reiterated the fact this is good for the economic development of an area that essentially right now, and I would even argue this will not only bring jobs to the area, but it will also make the area a lot nicer than it looks right now. Next slide. This is just a synopsis of the proposed project. The most important thing is they are ready creating and retaining miami-dade jobs, good jobs. It attracts businesses that would create jobs in miami-dade county. It's also minority ownership group developing this. This is something we have been delayed because of the fact we were supposed to go in March right before covid hit. We are very anxious to get the ball rolling as owners. The quicker we get this done the quicker the jobs come into play. After covid, I think that will be more important than ever. Next slide. This is the calculation taken from f-dot. Truthfully, at this point, that is not really an issue, but we wanted to let you know the number of trips that would be generated. You can see the maximum allowed development 320 square feet would increase the traffic by less than 1 percent based on the daily florida department of transportation count. Next slide. Mr. Yearby made reference to other members of his community including Ms. Barr. My comment was basically based on, as I check every day before our hearing in front of council, whether anybody objected before that.[Audio lost] want to point out again.[Audio lost] I did not go to the meeting to be fair with the developers. As a matter fact, it took place at a church right by the community, which I believe is called dayspring missionary baptist church. The pastor was kind enough to have the meeting there. Next slide. With all due respect to Mr. Yearby, he apparently, you know, [Audio lost] Back after the two hearings will rickford to speak to him, I you know we are trying do something good for the property. Only 11 percent of it is not zoned iu. You have staff who has given a recommendation of approval. You have staff that correctly has gone ahead and make sure the crawford covenant covered the concerns of the community. You have a community that met with the applicant. You have a community council, and I'm not here to defend them, but we went through two hearings. They did their job. The midst ormade sure the concerns of the community were heard. Whether or not Ms. Barr and the others that were there paid the dues in tallahassee for the homeowners association, happened to be neighbors. That's why they were there. They requested the meeting between the first and second meeting and felt comfortable enough to support the item. County staff, including county attorney's office was there at both of the hearings. With all due respect, and I respect Mr. Yearby's concerns, his opinion. i do not agree nor will I accept the fact that references were made to individuals who were his neighbors been complicit in some sort of nefarious plan. This is the way the process was supposed to work . There's a positive recommendation of staff for the item. There was meetings with the community. Community council did their job and made sure the community was met with. It just so happens when individual doesn't like -- I will point out when last time we are talking about 11 percent of a parcel that's already y zoned industrial. The second thing I will reiterate is this is very important for an area that needs jobs. 264 jobs, good jobs. In fact, I will add d the buffering that will be required by your staff is going to make this facility probably a lot nicer than probably any other facility in the area when it comes to the green area, green space and landscaping. Truthfully, for all the reasons outlined in the master plan and zoning analysis by your own staff, and actually by the community council,, we would hope you would deny the appellant's request for a reversal of the community council decision and that the application be approved, honestly subject to the crawford covenant so we can go about the business of creating a beautiful facility that I think Mr. Yearby will appreciate once it's built. Also, getting people in the neighborhood back to work and growing miami-dade county the way it should be grown. Thank you. Public hearing is now closed. Commissioner monestime. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is the beauty of zoning. This is the first time I'm hearing about this item. Even reading the material I find it to be a very complicated item. It is indeed complicated. I have heard good things on both sides. Very, very -- by the way, no discredit to the applicant, but I congratulate Mr. Yearby as a citizen, a neighbor, for being so engaged d, for taking the charge not only of appealing this item before the board, but to make such a strong presentation. The only thing I was hoping for is that he had spoken a little bit more about the property itself f and the impact of it to the area. I heard a lot about many people I know that serbin community council and homeowners association as well. Not enough about the impact of the e development itself. To the developers representative, attorney, I do have a lot of questions about this item and of course you have heard the requests of some of our members s to leave this meeting early. I think it is in everybody's interest if you would agree to do for this item. I would ask the attorney whether I can meet with staff and ask some of my questions in the presence of the attorney, and whether you were the applicant could be be.[Audio lost] That's what my.[Audio lost] . I have tons of questions about this item, this obligation, Madam Chair. is that a motion? An item [Audio lost] . [Audio lost] Community council hearing part of our record they go over that with you we would have to stick to what's in the record, but having applicant present that would be -- lost] By this developer or ot. Director answer that based on the facts on the ground. Rest of the property is currently zoned by u1 , the light industrial district. They have the right for industrial office uses, manufacturing, and other specific uses . Some outdoor storage as possible. It's the iu1 wand light industrial. Watching this meeting, u1 is what? Lot size of 7500 square feet so meaning this is the frontage of that larger piece. So basically the developer is trying to rezone the front piece which is also ru1. Today on the remainder of the property? Remainder of the property, which one combined with this parcel is approximately five acre give or take parcel. The subject application is only.76. A portion of the existing industrial area which has this remnant ru1. , sir, if in fact this is an industrial area, and the property is all vacant and the objective is to change the character of the property, why change ? Why is the application for zoning just for that little piece and not for the entire five acres? Rezoning is only on the residential portion. They already have the iu1 zoning. They have the right to the industrial. It's a unique situation where everything north of northwest 71st street is industrial. Northwest 71st street, everything north is industrial. Everything to the south is residential . Years ago, before all of our time, there were several rezoning's to industrial on the north side. This ended up leaving the old remnant ru1's on the north side , which is actually the residential use encroaching into the industrial area rather than vice versa, which is unique. The land-use of this subject application from the comp plan perspective is industrial. We see this is really an adjustment to square off the property. I want to also point out to the board there is a provision in the zoning code that when you have an individual parcel that has mixed zoning, in this case the iu1 and ru1, the director does have the ability to move the zoning district, the predominant zoning district, administratively. That request did come to us. We looked at that and we considered that , but due to the fact it was near residential we said, you know, we are not going to do that . we want this application to go before the community council just because of the proximity to the residential , but where we see this as a positive is you currently have this old industrial vacant parcel. With the industrial standards that we have in the code today , it forces the property owner to put in a minimum of a 10 foot masonry wall along the south property. Whenever you are across from residential, industrial to residential community either eight-foot or 10 foot green buffer plus masonary wall. In this case, the property is large enough that it would be a 10 0 foot wall. The existing industrial properties along the frontage currently don't have that because they were developed prior to the standards. This we feel would enhance the neighborhood and provide the adequate buffering. Done that in office? You could have done that administratively I mean. Discretion for the director to shift zoning on a partial where you have multiple zoning. Again, we elected not to do it and felt it was in the best interest of the community to go through a public hearing because of its proximity to residential. Nevertheless, we are supportive. There's a borderline . The code recognizes that because you have situations where you have these remnant parcels left over from the 50s and 60s where the environment has changed , so there is some of that discretion. I just want the board to understand that kid that was something considered. Comment of yours that you think it would serve the community and you could have done that administratively. [Audio lost] This property is definitely when the designated ru1. For the record, I want to clear that and emphasize that. Is it attached to one, or belong to the same owner as .[Audio lost] From the residential property, the residential units, on the east, west and south of that lot that the developer is trying to rezone, there is no currently single-family adjacent to it. Is adjacent to it to the east, west and north. That is correct. Correct. There is another remnant parcel of ru1 adjacent to the east, but not currently being used for residential. The entire block north of northwest 71st is being used for industrial. . So there is another remnant of properties that are still ru1, but not being used ru1. Is that because it's vacant? Industrial uses that are on that property. Current code? I wouldn't assume so. From the aerial map, again, not the applicant's property, another property, which also has the same configuration and situation, there appears to be some industrial use where it's zoned ru1. And I want to reemphasize again, so call the currently habitable residential units across the street of the property that is before us. . Attached to the current property that is before us, the entire block, that side of the road, everything is currently industrial properties . Have explained in the back of the document that you provided to us that the department department platting and traffic review criteria. Suggest that is built is going to create a buffer to which property is it going to create a buffer? To the residential properties? In what way? Properties that are adjacent to residential, or across the street, so in this case across the street. It always requires masonry wall and 10 foot wide, depending on the property. In this case, code mandates when they come in for a building permit they have to have a 10 foot wide green space buffer from the road back, so the front of their property back 10 feet green, plus landscaping , shrubs and trees spaced out every 25 feet. In addition, they need to have the masonary wall. Applicants have not requested to waive the requirement in any way. That is mandated by the code. You can answer for me, or should I go to the applicant representative ? The property, the development that will go there, I know it's an industrial development , but what kind of industry is being placed on that side? What kind of business? Is seeking the rezoning and provided a covenant with restricted uses which leads standard industrial uses like warehouses, office, light manufacturing , but have provided a comprehensive list of industrial and quasi-industrial uses that would be prohibited. They worked in consultation with

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners - Zoning — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: aca7f238b294bcae564620a731ad5220. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record