POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Power Company Advisory Subcommittee

Wednesday, March 22, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Power Company Advisory Subcommittee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

All right. Well, I'm David Evans. I'm city manager, and we'll just go around the room, introduce each each other here, and then we'll jump into the agenda, which would be of. I'm Maria Elliot, assistant city manager, and Angelica Lopez, Councilmember Diane Adams, Councilmember Doug Buchanan, Power Company Manager. If you see and as a share of Main Street officer Island. And Megan Jack, Executive Assistant City Manager. Fantastic. Mr. Buchanan. All right. Thank you. Congratulations. I suppose the nature of the subcommittee. Excellent. It was. No, Look, I'm Dr. Campbell, our company manager for Power Company Entergy. And I'm an engineer. And to the generation that's for so long time, the history of supporting City of Pittsburgh since 1998 for various energy projects and employees for five years and I can digressed for just a second. I have some short term supplies. Grandfather of the 50th anniversary of the town's department store, which is where I have some papers located downtown. Sorry. Yes, sir. It's the location of the lumber on the road. Start so around. And as you can see, the champions have always been the snappy dressers there. I'd like to introduce Vanessa and talk a little bit about yourself. You do my introduction. This was Vanessa, and she. She's our sales administrative officer. So think of the context of business manager and we've been working together since 2004. I was for and she's my right hand man in just overall Pittsburgh Power Company is a very lean type of agency. I'm not sure you're going to get into it, but just overall. So, you know, Doug is is our power manager over PVC. And I know he's going to get into the same day on the energy. And Vanessa, you know, knows the numbers, knows the books, knows the history is an absolutely fantastic, amazing. And boy, that is really been an incredible asset to us for quite a while. Almost two decades. I was hired by you in 2005. Yes. I mean straight of analyst. Yes. And she keeps us on track. Sure. Even today I'm pretty. You need to do this contract that's been six years with the city. That's a period. So it's a very lean organization. Regarding your tender, there's a lot of material here and this was more to be a take away them hitting each point hard it more just for your general information to prompt questions and what I'd like to do I think is jump around a little bit and to the point where we leave the rate case. I don't remember for we like to leave that so last. That will be the most substantive discussion today. And what we'll do is provide an overview of what we do, see what I remember this all came about in 1997. A very aggressive city manager went over as it was in the capacity at that time. Actually, we started that with Praxair, which was in 95, 96, charcoal and came in 96. And so September 23rd, 1996 was the resolution where we started. DC And the summary sort of back story is that we're just calling around Mike Woods for some opportunity. With the closure of the Maryland Naval Shipyard in Vallejo, the Navy was closing the shipyard and up all the utilities in the city of Valero, the city they basically took over the islands. However, Vallejo did not want the electric gas distribution systems. That was the capability and given a number of energy projects that were occurring in Pittsburgh at that time. Volta Energy Center was for those early, early transbay the city saw it as an opportunity to participate in the Navy. The rest of themselves will be electrical gas distribution and as I understand the story, everybody dropped out with the exception of the city, Pittsburgh, for which it offered $70,000 for the rights to the franchise, maybe said we can't process the paperwork for that kind of money. Apparently, we obtained a ceremonial and we've been operating successfully ever since. And it's been challenging because a lot of the infrastructure on our island when it goes back to World War two. So it's quite challenging. Anyway, we've been operating successfully, to give you a sense of it. It's about a year or last year, I think to be almost last year as well. So million dollar business, the gross revenue, it's comprised of residential and commercial industrial. What's interesting about that is 90% of our load electric load is commercial industrial and about 10% is residential, but 90% of the complaints that we obtain in the franchise also obtain energy required from what's called the Western area of Public administration. It's a federal agency goes by water and they manage all of the normal. Many of the Bureau of Reclamation, dams of Hydro in California. We also operate the vulnerable system in Oregon that's going to close anyway with that hydro source from them. We've historically had low energy costs. We're going to get into that when we talk about the replacement of water. So we've kind competitors in the ratepayers, customers, but hydro power was long story. So that in a nutshell is kind of the utility operation. There's a total of nine of us, you know, six crew and three of us myself when I saw that from all so so Tonya Taylor Thornhill We're just nine of us in debt just to sort of help out the island itself. So you have the Leo And so just to get a little reference point, I believe that the station right down here, so the power and one 15,000 volt or 15,000 lines come in here are transformed down or step down, whichever way, 12 to 12000 volts and then it's distributed throughout here. Obviously most of it is industrial. And then we've got some residential right there maybe behind that. But there's so Doug and his crew and his team all, you know, keep track of this and what, 90% of it's underground. 90%. Yeah. So there are volts with 12,000 volt lines, you know, in various states of condition, given the age of some of it. Natural gas comes in across that bridge. And, you know, it's it's a it's a full utility enterprise like anyone else. You know, they have to service and they have to do all the billing. They have to do you know rate case of will get into. But it is something that will try and get you all out here as a subcommittee to the island to actually give you a little bit better of a view of what they deal with the works. Yeah. And then obviously the more bunched up is, you know, various dry docks around here that really consume a lot of power on the ship. So we like big boats. So they recharge their it's a lot of fun stories to tell, but to see this evening maybe when a lot of Toronto reopens them. So I just thought we'd give you a visual of the island. It's like a baby run by not those in that area. Everything's going to show up. How much reach does it have? I'm sorry? so is it or how many acres of it reach or how are you? You're obviously, you know, two square miles that give you an idea of Pittsburgh is I believe we're 13 to 15 square miles in one senses, just for Yeah. So it's it's a great opportunity, actually. It's a very good $1 investment. Sounds like an. Oh, it is. It's an operating utility since 1997 and we're now going to jump out a little bit. Those we've embarked upon an initiative to expand utilities footprint coming to Pittsburgh and elsewhere. Okay, that's item six. But actually, it's a combination of things where we've begun supporting the city, as you say, in the development of new energy projects here. So the idea being the PTC was begin to serve new load Pittsburgh and potentially elsewhere. And we vetted this. We have the legal right to do that. You know, was a publicly owned utility period, as we call ourselves and have been supporting a number of different projects for new projects. While this is the tech park development YieldCo, which is a little bit coal was diamond generating, who wants to commit some applications for battery storage and those and we also turned our attention to the water plant or PPC would serve all our plants and we would develop additional renewable energy sources for fuel. So solar field and solar. Right. And to give you a little bit more color, something I'm especially proud of, I was the development manager of the Go to Energy Project for Bethel, Calpine, and that's the power plant next to Delta Diablo. So off of our sea lane and Pittsburgh area timeline, sometimes you'll see a little bit of a steam room in the mornings. It's all cozy and these efforts sort of tie together in different ways. But we're also developing support for your strategic plan that begins to describe what our vision is for expanding the service territory for the city. So we're a little bit behind on that, but it's coming in maybe to give you some reference from a dollar perspective. And that's a it's been a while since I've thought of all these numbers over the line. You to fill in the blanks are with Las Vegas Energy Center, which is the first power plant that came online in Pittsburgh. That's on Third Street. So if you take Third Street all the way down from the downtown going towards the steel mill, you'd run into to the power plant that was originally the city issued. In our event, it's very power company then to build a power plant and do other various power projects. The winning contractor was a company called Enron, which you may or may not have heard of. So for those guys in the room, they we worked with them to get the Finance Energy Center, then known as Pittsburgh District Energy Facility, approved through the Energy Commission, and they then sold that to Calpine. And Calpine was the actual one who developed and built it with all the approvals were done through Enron and part of the off ramp or sale, if you will. The city had a component of the Pittsburgh Power Company where we received 15.6 million in cash, which back in 2000 was quite a bit of money and still would be quite a bit of money, plus about $9 million worth of other community benefits. The truck bypass road that basically you can take from Harbor Street to Pittsburgh, gaining a highway with a of road that goes around the central edition. Trucks used to go straight down through Central Edition and all of that. And so it was a way to pull those away from the community. The street linear park was built because both the Delta Energy Center lost the Dallas Energy Center. Power lines go to the middle of downtown. You just don't know. They're all underground. And, you know, we were specially built, was not particularly proud of between the two projects. Also it was phenomenal schools. So how do we get from here to there and so we embarked upon putting Doc Banks what we referred to as the eighth Street corridor fuel cycle of the railroad, right of work. And we put with Enron, California, that also jointly participated, put the electrical belt banks first. So at 1.8 miles and I think we contributed 1.3 million for the park. So I think that's the number. And we were told by H.A. it couldn't be done. Doesn't happen. Never, never happened. It was 20 years ago and they couldn't wait to get their hands on. So next time you're at the post office or happened to be going down street. So almost 1400 megawatts of capacity on interstate. And I think with the Delta Energy Project, this is the number of games at about 25 million over the last 20 years or so, 25 years to do that. Ed Yes, I thought it was around that that's behind the postal records, behind the postal actually, and super the piping. Yes, up to a million. And it's not really a little over a million a month. A year here. A year, Yeah. So so basically what you had here is you have an energy center up here. You have Delta Energy Center right here. Their power lines come like this. And we kind of joke dysfunction junctions over here, but they run down each street underneath the ground and then they hook up after the park into the great. And so you had about 25 million from Los Gatos Energy Center, about 25 billion to the community out of Delta Energy Center, which is still being paid off. And then that spurred, I believe it was December of 2004. This is seven was taxpayer. Yeah. Transbay when I got a call from the guys that were behind the Enron project, they've gone to a different company and they said, hey, we got this idea, an opportunity we want to bounce off. You know, Pittsburgh, we think this is a perfect opportunity to take power. There's a huge power need in San Francisco, and right now there's just this huge amount of power lost in the AC lines. When you go from Pittsburgh down to San Jose and back up. And so we think there's a better way to do it. The Tell telephone independent system operator is looking for a new power line. We think we can do it from Pittsburgh because that substation right there, so many power plants plug it into it and we're thinking 400 megawatts can go underneath the delta, underneath the pop up over in San Francisco. So what do you guys think? You know, and then, you know, it became a six year project to get it commercially operational. And it was a $525 million project. We were instrumental in getting it approved. And it will generate for the city over a 40 year period, somewhere around $100 million in just payments. Wow. So, you know, this enterprise for $1, this power is bringing in 150 plus million. We're not even counting property tax, sales tax, just millions upon millions. So it really has been an amazing investment. And why part of the strategic strategic plan that Doug is working on and looking at the new projects, we're looking for that next layer. All right. How can we keep keep it doing, keep it going? You know, the tech park potentially, you know, other opportunities, even if we start small with the water treatment plant, you can I'm bouncing around here because when you look at all the rate increases that are happening, we all pay. I and we understand why, you know, energy costs are going up. There's everything else there. Maybe we think there's a way to see the water treatment, plant money, city hall, potentially money. And that will save the ratepayers of Pittsburgh. So we're looking at how do we now step in starting small, but there may be opportunities with other projects as well to make jobs here, hold down costs where we can for the water treatment plant, make an impact in Pittsburgh similar to what we've done over in Vallejo. So through tax revenue streams that have come in to PPC or variable on all kinds of various job programs, so future Bill, we just looked at it yesterday and then for so it's it's been a way to get money back into the community. A good place to break a question some that stuff. So do you anticipate in the near future some residents will just be on or off shore? And I'm sorry, do you anticipate in the near future residential units within Pittsburgh might be service potentially? You know, we've had drive by comments, discussion with Discovery Homes, that sort of thing for new load. Yes, the there currently aren't any plans to attempt to acquire unique customers or opportunity out of service existing ones. This is all for all world just becomes too costly and cumbersome to attempt to do down or even new PGE can be difficult and it can be costly. And if you look at it from the standpoint they have to plan for growth and always be, you know, they're sort of that last line they must serve. And so if they see, oh, Pittsburgh, you're building 5000 units, they have to start making sure that they've got contracts for power, they've got all that service ready to go. And so if suddenly Pittsburgh steps in, oh, we'll take 2000 units here off your books. While they may have already entered into contracts and so they have departing load fees or fees that help compensate that because they need to, you know, as they're the bigger big utilities trying to plan. And so that comes into the equation when we get into the rate base, you know, there's a two or 3% of kilowatt charge suddenly, you know, we still if we get involved with offering card to anyone, we want to make sure we're at or below what you get from PGE. Otherwise you're not helping the resident. And so that's certainly an equation that we have to constantly work out. If we suddenly went into a subdivision and, you know, supply power, we have to make sure it's competitive. We don't want to suddenly go, Oh, aren't you glad you're buying power from us? And yes, you know, PGE would have been doing this. We're going to cheaper, but sorry, we're here. You know, that's not a good way. And you would have a roomful of people that wouldn't be very happy with it, especially because any subsidized programs for those making underneath a certain amount of. Well, we have we have all those. You have to get. Well, yeah, yeah. You we we operate under a full blown curve because of a lot of different elements or what we call a whole range of things. We cover. We've been suspended all of the late fees. We can very stop shutoffs insurance for nonpayment. We applied for and received state. We're called cap funds to address some of the utility issues in the state. So that was helpful. And we're even running into it now. Like every cent, everyone who has a gas meter, you know, gas just went crazy the last couple of months and we're trying to be as creative as possible to help out our ratepayers on their island. You know, and, you know, this is almost we're getting to where we're probably about ready for the utility, the rate schedule and representations. You know, gas is different than electricity in that the way we structure our gas, we pass through the commodity. So whatever we pay that gets spread through to our customer base and then we have a basically a delivery charge, what it costs for and our electric's a little different in that it's a set rate that encompasses not only a cost for our cost of goods sold, which is electricity, but also our cost to own our administration. All of that and we have a flat rate. We don't do time abuse, which does, you know, either lower depending at the time of day passes flat and which is nice for folks if they, you know, want to just use their energy whenever they need to. But it's it it causes a challenge when we see such a huge fluctuation in commodity cost. And so that's something that, well, you'll see in a few moments in slides here. What we're trying to be a little more nimble on. It's not something that we've lost money per say, you know, but we are margins where we usually would like to keep this. We can take that money and reinvest into the system has been much narrower. And so we're trying to figure out our best way and we'll work with the subcommittee on those ideas. So do we want to jump into the rate case because there was no response? And so we'll walk through this presentation and certainly sorry, I didn't like it. You touched on it nicely there in the time I've been here for the cost of energy or gas or workers were relatively predictable until we got into the drought. You know us from purchasing software called supplemental power when there was no hydro, they both soft power for us in the market to do that. And it's always more expensive. I'll give you a sense of that year and a half ago, our total cost of the liquid energy returned $0.11 per kilowatt hour. What was January was 21. Last question. Same with gas was October was about $0.84 burned. In January it was $3.06 avoided. Folks, whole construction. It was in this situation, 21 was probably 70% less. And so as a publicly owned utility, we don't make a profit, which yeah, it's a it's cost based analysis. And we've kind of held steady with fixed rates as we were getting all this volatility and you're pointed out we're that's really shown up for us for we heard those is capital reserves. We don't have essentially depleted or working capital through. Well we have about 30% reserves that are sustainability ordinance. It was the amount of bulb that that we take and invest into the annually into the utility. And what that did is we basically smoothed out for our customers this spike in rates now. And what you see here is sort of on slide two, you know, we rate, you know, we basically did one rate hike in July 1st, effective July 1st, 2019, and that set our rates for residential $0.21 a kilowatt hour. And we didn't do any kind of other rate increases until we're talking to you right now for effective first rate. So basically, you know, they haven't seen a raise in 22. Yeah, we went into our share last year, so that was to go from 21 to 22.9, basically a kilowatt hour. So we did one rate increase in four years and we're proposing for the second one basically to come in July. So we were very consistent with that. And currently the bundled rate is three and a half cents versus our 22.9 cents per kilowatt hour. The average home uses how many for a once in a market? 400 400 or 400. So, you know, that's 400 times or $0.11, you know. Yeah. So those actually go that table is what we use for the 2223. So those numbers are pretty old. So we just cannot catch up with pensions. You know, those people are increasing their rates. So what? Children look very uncertain when you cover have make the presentation. But we're just getting into the details now. So you know, the rates that we presenting today, they are not the final rates because we are still finalizing our operating budget. But we would just like to take this opportunity to walk you through a rate making process. So our annual rate case is prepared along side with our operating budget, our business model and your intention is service based costing model. So the rates that we charge must cover to all our operating costs and plus from capital know capital investment and some we serve. So the board adopts the rates once a year and we gotcha and reconciliation at the end of each year. If we are in the financial surplus, we would usually hold the rates for another year. If we are running short, we will ask the board for a rate increase, either meeting year at the end of the year. So we didn't do a rate case for three years during the this year. It is not because we are slacking off or even shelter in place or no gathering or public meetings if they pose a challenge to us. But we there was not the reason to increase the rates. We didn't increase the rate because we managed to grow our sales by 28% by putting in major facility upgrades for our commercial customers. So we focus on increasing our load rather than the rates for three years and our rate that was approved in 1920, it was still good for three years and then we were hit by the megadrought starting in 2019, Energy price has skyrocketed and the and the board adopted one rate a rate case in 2022 and 4.3. So that's the that's the reason highlighted in blue. So despite the big jumps from the previous rates that we are still substantially below par. And these are the rates on Cheyenne twice at that time for residential for residential customers, we have 32% below consumers rates and for commercials we are around like 11% or 20% depends on which class they are in. So across the board we are an average of 15 to 30% of the locations. But then so here are some graphs showing that, you know, coming into January 2023, under the combination of cold weather and low price and use of natural gas storage has been depleted completely and the natural gas price has rose more than 300% in this January compared to the January of last. So it was in January 2022, it was $0.84. And in January 2023, one three $3.45. And this is just commodity charge. And that's before all the transmission cost increased on the distribution cost. So on the electricity side, we three, we were in the megadrought and you know, three months ago, according to the scientists, we are still in a drought. So the electricity wholesale price, it rose to all time highs under a combination of low hydro supplies, financial crisis and also the high demand for electricity due to the colder weather and storms. So this is this graph actually shows a perfect correlation between the hydro, hydro electricity supplies and our energy price. So when hydro power is low energy price, it just goes to the highest because hydro power is basically will buy from the Central Valley hydro project. And this the lowest energy price that is the lowest energy we can get in. You know, if we don't get any hydro energy allocations, then we would have to purchase everything from the market. That is that's more expensive. Sorry. And how expensive it gets. This is a slide that they're suggesting we need to add in to the presentation and this is shows how much GM has increased their rates in the last three years and how often the rates have increased. So they could increase their rates between within a month or within every three months. So in the last three years they have increased rates by 48% in total. And that's what you that's what's that your Pittsburgh that's what the water treatment center that everybody who live in the PJM service territory is paid. So I just the one that they have is rolling rate systems which if you see the California Public Utilities Commission. So if their revenue falls below a certain percentage, they will increase their rates up to a predetermined range. So this might be something that we could consider in making process. And just to sort of emphasize, we had one increase in last year and they've had how many was at least a dozen, 15 them to you. And their increase today so far has been 48% since 2019. If they just increase the rates this month, as I said, the reason February's no longer good, they just increase them in March. Yeah. And so certainly our our customers have enjoyed rather stable, consistent rates. Yeah. Now certainly gas has been a different factor because I said, you know, we're more commodity, we fluctuate than our attempts to try and work with the customer base and keep a nice consistent cost. You know, and as they're alluding to though, our costs are going up. So now this is actually we have to look at raising rates again. Yeah. And I mean, with climate change and the different things that are happening and like all the utilities, their rates are going up because we're having the heart in the system so that we don't have fires and that sort of thing. So this is not all of the cost of the commodity, it's the capital infrastructure that is needed to actually deliver. And then the state is growing. So we have to have infrastructure to meet the load and demand is coming online. Yeah. And so within the next tranche, so because of the skyrocketing and everything that you just mentioned, so that the rates that we adopted for 2022, 23 and are the longer sufficient to cover Island Energy's basic expense. So we have seen the highest building of the last 16 years. Our building is usually is $1.2 billion a month, but we have some of the lowest margins because the energy part, the energy course has 70% of our revenue. So so in some requests for some recourses, the energy commodity cost has exceeded the total electric rate that we charge for that class. So we are in a situation that the more we sell, the more we lose. So and also the situation gets worse during the winter when we have really low hydro allocations. So we are looking at the business to charge our operating costs and this is the budget comparison between fiscal year two, 23 and 24, just the energy price alone, which is on second line in the table, it has rose by 43%, 3.3 to 4.7. That's that it used to cause us $0.10 to buy energy now is $0.17. And last month it was 21. So and if you look at this other operating expenses, stabbing costs only rise like on the increase 11%. That's mainly because the cost of living adjustment and also some union contract negotiations. So the 3% and the 4% stand by adjustments is already factored in here. So but if you look at other operating, we are actually managed to reduce our operating expense by running the operation more efficiently by using in in-house talents rather than hiring outside consultants. We talk about this project a while ago, so it's come to come to order, order! We have joined data into AGI system, so we said it probably would cost us $50,000 if we go outside consulting. And now the job was done with the help of from the cache of its I.T department and all this from the city staff to help out over there and also our utility tech Bradley And they finished the project at the mark of $10,000. So that save us $40,000 right off the back end to do with about 80 hours of overtime to 80 hours overtime. So when we took over the system and then it was all plat maps and paper ready to automate that and now to order about two. So before you move all this sense of something we look at, all of this is under new capital improvement, 300,000 increase the table a sense of what we're faced with a very few pieces of equipment that we can purchase or transformers, which those that are under 100,000. We just want to switch those or almost two years ago, I was 260,000 plus for those two. So we're having to be clever in terms of our capital allocation. So the point I'm making is 300,000 is more of an incremental increase than significant. Yeah, for utility $300,000, I would have to say that on the capital improvement, it's almost nothing is very thin on the capital side. But yes, do have contingency in there as a contingency, you know. Okay. I would yes. This is why this is sort of the first phase as we do. You you all caught up with what we do and we hear from you like let's make sure you have enough or continuous here. You're investing in a contingency. We always budget for the worst and we always budget under more harsh conditions. So the electric rate that we expect to be is usually higher than next. You know, the energy costs that it would cause us to do. So everything is based on you know, it's it's a former revenue collection. That's why it's necessary to do the annual reconciliation and adjustments. Okay. I'm just it just looks I mean, yes, what it is, is Apple is doing a series of management system. This is me and doing all the everything We just there are only two things we don't do. We don't clean the toilet. We don't we know that we pretty much doing everything else but it is reporting those things. So so but I love the transparency. So yeah, great people covers everything that happens in the office and six people cover everything that happened on this, including the new project development and repairs, outages and everything. So that's why I always say is my people running a Facebook page and we are held to the same standards to any company owned utilities or investor owned utilities. We don't get any public compliance requirements on the Y assignment vacation plans. We're yeah, we're held to the same standards of franchise like P is paid to the city of Aleppo. All of those concept E all of the utilities pay so so we have to be thinking outside of the box for new rate structure. As Spirit mentioned, if we can make the the energy cost of pass through them, the utility will be shielded from all this energy price frustrations so that we are proposing that the energy price is calculated monthly based on the actual energy charge of that month and the delivery rate covering our operating costs will be calculated annually and will be adopted by council along with our operating budget. So the monthly rate will be the energy rate plus the LIBOR rate, and it's the same rate structure that we use for gas system since 1997. It's something we are looking at. We need to do some more research research and see whether utilities do this for of gas. We could find this model for Edison. Does it they do have a they have a delivery rate of theirs. So they they do it. But it's of course it's it's they have all these other pieces and that's what you know. So we're looking at it. It may not come into play this year. In our rate case, we may either wait six, you know, we want to make sure we do that. Plus a lot of education would have to go into them because the folks in Maryland have gotten probably used to their nice flat rate. So whenever they turn around their utilities and start rate. Yeah. So, you know, there's a lot of steps behind it. It's not something we'll just rush into. Is there any way that the delivery rates can be contracted? Probably out, yeah. But that's the delivery is actually paying for all our operating costs. My staffing cost older we did look at privatizing a couple times over the last 25 years and actually our initial four years that we are Island energy we had an outside private entity run it and frankly the standards plus investment in the system more so to what we felt needed to happen by having internally are standards for safety and crew supplies. You know, just everything is at the level that we have in the corporate. And everybody can go to the same training. So it really does help because if we we need to some people came over now that can handle the lines, but at least they can come over and help do some other things where a private company, it was a nickel and dime and they just kept on That's where they got you was the change orders or any kind of extras. So so we really found that this is a more cost effective model. And plus you spend your your hours managing them. Yes. On top of that. And also a private company that they doing this, they don't necessarily care about, you know, the quality of service and the service on the islands. Actually, there was a decision that to hire the project comfortable. That's a decision that they made in 2010. And they decided to the island and under the house. So after that was a decision that we would still benefit benefiting from today. Yeah. So where are we now? So let's at the the rate the range of rates under the two different restructure. So the first table shows that if we're under the commodity pass through structure the first Okay. The second column that's the delivery rate over a given request And then the third column, that's the third, fourth, fifth column, that's okay. So under the commodity pass through the delivery rate, so that's what, you know, everything around it. And then what Vanessa's done through her models and her rate case models, probably on that binder lines and lines in my spreadsheet, you know, whether we have a high hydro energy rate, an average in a row and she's of blended the two to try and see All right this is the most likely scenario what we have to pay. And then on the second table, she basically looked at what we currently do now. So we have, you know, 20 to 23 rates, most like you would see very similar. CO This is a 12 and you get to 28, 2950 when you're 2850 for the residential and you can see the same rates. It's roughly how she comes up with that fixed rate right now it's sort of that midpoint of assuming a high energy rate from five or six. So what would that do if we raised these current numbers in effect? Well, they're sizable increases the extent, but still below current PGE, these rates that we have is that for February or March, March, as long as interest rates for pretty 18% below for residential, then PGE 9% below for general commercial, and then the larger commercial customers are still 6% below industry by ten 11%. So even with that kind of rate increase, we're still trying to achieve what we have a goal which is being below do more to get the most amount of time because quite a bit. But this is going to change some of the so many numbers. Yeah because I'm yes and you should know that we're going to we I just like break the waves down into different hydro conditions. So under the high hydro condition, energy rates will be at their lowest. So we're looking at $0.12 per kilowatt hour under a high hydro condition and it will jump to $0.17 if it is under average hydro condition. One. And then if it's a more under low hydro condition, it will jump to $0.21. And that's the highest we see for delivery rates. Basically, we advocate our operating costs or what can ask them across traditional residential has can only shoulder about 10% of our operating costs, even because 90% of our staff time, because there is such a small loan, we only have about 180 houses on the island. So they they could not take on more locations of the operating costs. So general commercials, which accounts for almost 80% of our total load, they both of our operating cost implications and associated capital improvement costs. So there's yeah, so this will be the allocation rate and large commercial as they usually they will invest on their own system upgrades. So that's why there is their deliberate use of loan and we would barely spend any time or energy on straight line maintenance. That's why it's right. Your site has the lowest allocation in terms of operating costs. So if you at the delivery rate and the energy in together under different hydro conditions, you would see that on average our high hydro scenario and which you would see is a $0.24 for the residential. But if it under a low hydro you jump up to $0.33. So the difference is $0.11 between the two different hydro conditions. And if we go with a conditional fixed rate structure and we we will usually go with the average hydro energy rate. That's right. This is a copy done here. And if we compare the proposed rate to our current rate, that the increase is all in double digits and it's in 20%, it's it's very important. So I would say it's very hard to sell to the customers, our business and residents on the island even we are still substantially below. So, you know, and so I was in that's probably the curse of not doing more incremental increases, probably. Yeah. You know, but you know, especially when you look there were pennies going to 45 or 48%. You know, we're unfortunately proposing a roughly 34 residential because it's just because we also know that we're selling below cost right now that way. Yeah. So this is the question my which of these rate making proposals you should go to go with as we're talking through it is that it will this open. Yes and no. We probably would like to go here but we need to do more research. Yeah. We need to get more comfortable on. Okay. So that will be a later. Yeah. I think we may be a year early on this. Okay. You know, Vanessa's ready now because she's got all the data, but I think we need a little bit

Pittsburg Power Company 65 Civic Avenue, Pittsburg, CA 94565 | Tel: (925) 252-4850 | Fax: (925) 252-4851 Page 1 of 3 AGENDA PITTSBURG POWER COMPANY ADVISORY SUBCOMMITTEE Wednesday, March 22, 2023 5:00 PM Pittsburg City Hall First Floor Conference Room, 4B 65 Civic Avenue Pittsburg, CA 94565 Subcommittee Members Dionne Adams, Councilmember Angelica Lopez, Councilmember 1. Public Comment for Non-Agenda Items 2. Pittsburg Power Company – Island Energy Introduction • A Brief History • Utility Operation on Mare Island – Island Energy • Utility Rate Structure – a New Proposal • City PPC Project Development Support • PPC Strategic Plan 3. Utility Operations; Island Energy Pittsburg Power Company (PPC) is a California joint powers authority and operates the electric and gas utility distribution system on Mare Island, Vallejo under the name of Island Energy. Customer class includes residential (10%), along with commercial and industrial (90%). The utility manages approximately 1,050 electric and gas meters. Power is delivered to Island Energy via a 115 kv PG&E line from the Western Area Power Administration (WAPA), a federal agency managing hydroelectric delivery under an ongoing full- service contract. Natural gas is procured from California’s Department of General Services (DGS) and delivered over PG&E’s gas transmission system. Natural gas commodity cost is a pass-through to Island Energy customers.

Pittsburg Power Company Advisory Subcommittee Meeting Agenda March 22, 2023 Page 2 of 3 Current Island Energy activities include – • Daily System Operations and Maintenance, Utility Management • Large Customer Support Projects – Gas and Electric o Mare Island Dry Docks o ALCO Iron and Metals o Kindred Motorworks o Touro University o Mare Island Operating Company o Concord Naval Weapons Station • Safety Inspections and Protocol • Customer Service, Billing • Utility-specific Procurement Plan – in Development • Local Renewable Generation Procurement – In Development 4. Utility Rate Structure – Bi-Annual Rate Adjustments • PPC currently operates under an annual fixed-rate tariff. • Soaring and volatile energy costs since January 2022. o Severe drought – WAPA supplemental energy supply costs. o Gas pricing – 300% increase • Utility capital reserves used to smooth volatility. • Cost-based bi-annual adjustments proposed, w/restoration of capital reserves.

Pittsburg Power Company Advisory Subcommittee Meeting Agenda March 22, 2023 Page 3 of 3 5. City Project Development Support PPC has historically supported major power project developments in Pittsburg including: • Delta Energy Center • Los Medanos Energy Center • Trans-Bay Cable • Hanergy Global Solar Group • LS Power Battery Storage Project • Energy Delivery Solutions (EDS) New projects include: • AVAIO Data Hub (Tech Park) • Hilco (UPI) • Diamond Generating Co. • PPC to Serve Water Treatment Plant and City Hall – In Development 6. PPC Strategic Plan PPC is developing a Strategic Plan to expand PPC utility operations beyond Mare Island to serve new electric load in the City of Pittsburg and potentially elsewhere. Activities to Date – • A written plan is in development. • PPC and its Engineering Team have performed a regional High Voltage transmission system analysis study to assess PPC’s ability to serve new Avaio Data Hub (and other) project loads over PG&E’s transmission system. • PPC, with support from its outside regulatory council (Cameron Daniels, P.C.) and power marketer consultants (Robertson-Bryan, Inc.) have developed an energy pricing model to forecast and plan for energy delivery to new commercial and industrial customers in Pittsburg. • Residential service requires different analysis when compared to industrial loads. 7. Upcoming Resolution and Staff Reports for PPC Governing Board Approval 8. Non-Agenda Items 9. Adjourn

Showing the first 24,000 of 38,367 characters. The full document is at the source.

All right. Well, I'm David Evans. I'm city manager, and we'll just go around the room, introduce each each other here, and then we'll jump into the agenda, which would be of. I'm Maria Elliot, assistant city manager, and Angelica Lopez, Councilmember Diane Adams, Councilmember Doug Buchanan, Power Company Manager. If you see and as a share of Main Street officer Island. And Megan Jack, Executive Assistant City Manager. Fantastic. Mr. Buchanan. All right. Thank you. Congratulations. I suppose the nature of the subcommittee. Excellent. It was. No, Look, I'm Dr. Campbell, our company manager for Power Company Entergy. And I'm an engineer. And to the generation that's for so long time, the history of supporting City of Pittsburgh since 1998 for various energy projects and employees for five years and I can digressed for just a second. I have some short term supplies. Grandfather of the 50th anniversary of the town's department store, which is where I have some papers located downtown. Sorry. Yes, sir. It's the location of the lumber on the road. Start so around. And as you can see, the champions have always been the snappy dressers there. I'd like to introduce Vanessa and talk a little bit about yourself. You do my introduction. This was Vanessa, and she. She's our sales administrative officer. So think of the context of business manager and we've been working together since 2004. I was for and she's my right hand man in just overall Pittsburgh Power Company is a very lean type of agency. I'm not sure you're going to get into it, but just overall. So, you know, Doug is is our power manager over PVC. And I know he's going to get into the same day on the energy. And Vanessa, you know, knows the numbers, knows the books, knows the history is an absolutely fantastic, amazing. And boy, that is really been an incredible asset to us for quite a while. Almost two decades. I was hired by you in 2005. Yes. I mean straight of analyst. Yes. And she keeps us on track. Sure. Even today I'm pretty. You need to do this contract that's been six years with the city. That's a period. So it's a very lean organization. Regarding your tender, there's a lot of material here and this was more to be a take away them hitting each point hard it more just for your general information to prompt questions and what I'd like to do I think is jump around a little bit and to the point where we leave the rate case. I don't remember for we like to leave that so last. That will be the most substantive discussion today. And what we'll do is provide an overview of what we do, see what I remember this all came about in 1997. A very aggressive city manager went over as it was in the capacity at that time. Actually, we started that with Praxair, which was in 95, 96, charcoal and came in 96. And so September 23rd, 1996 was the resolution where we started. DC And the summary sort of back story is that we're just calling around Mike Woods for some opportunity. With the closure of the Maryland Naval Shipyard in Vallejo, the Navy was closing the shipyard and up all the utilities in the city of Valero, the city they basically took over the islands. However, Vallejo did not want the electric gas distribution systems. That was the capability and given a number of energy projects that were occurring in Pittsburgh at that time. Volta Energy Center was for those early, early transbay the city saw it as an opportunity to participate in the Navy. The rest of themselves will be electrical gas distribution and as I understand the story, everybody dropped out with the exception of the city, Pittsburgh, for which it offered $70,000 for the rights to the franchise, maybe said we can't process the paperwork for that kind of money. Apparently, we obtained a ceremonial and we've been operating successfully ever since. And it's been challenging because a lot of the infrastructure on our island when it goes back to World War two. So it's quite challenging. Anyway, we've been operating successfully, to give you a sense of it. It's about a year or last year, I think to be almost last year as well. So million dollar business, the gross revenue, it's comprised of residential and commercial industrial. What's interesting about that is 90% of our load electric load is commercial industrial and about 10% is residential, but 90% of the complaints that we obtain in the franchise also obtain energy required from what's called the Western area of Public administration. It's a federal agency goes by water and they manage all of the normal. Many of the Bureau of Reclamation, dams of Hydro in California. We also operate the vulnerable system in Oregon that's going to close anyway with that hydro source from them. We've historically had low energy costs. We're going to get into that when we talk about the replacement of water. So we've kind competitors in the ratepayers, customers, but hydro power was long story. So that in a nutshell is kind of the utility operation. There's a total of nine of us, you know, six crew and three of us myself when I saw that from all so so Tonya Taylor Thornhill We're just nine of us in debt just to sort of help out the island itself. So you have the Leo And so just to get a little reference point, I believe that the station right down here, so the power and one 15,000 volt or 15,000 lines come in here are transformed down or step down, whichever way, 12 to 12000 volts and then it's distributed throughout here. Obviously most of it is industrial. And then we've got some residential right there maybe behind that. But there's so Doug and his crew and his team all, you know, keep track of this and what, 90% of it's underground. 90%. Yeah. So there are volts with 12,000 volt lines, you know, in various states of condition, given the age of some of it. Natural gas comes in across that bridge. And, you know, it's it's a it's a full utility enterprise like anyone else. You know, they have to service and they have to do all the billing. They have to do you know rate case of will get into. But it is something that will try and get you all out here as a subcommittee to the island to actually give you a little bit better of a view of what they deal with the works. Yeah. And then obviously the more bunched up is, you know, various dry docks around here that really consume a lot of power on the ship. So we like big boats. So they recharge their it's a lot of fun stories to tell, but to see this evening maybe when a lot of Toronto reopens them. So I just thought we'd give you a visual of the island. It's like a baby run by not those in that area. Everything's going to show up. How much reach does it have? I'm sorry? so is it or how many acres of it reach or how are you? You're obviously, you know, two square miles that give you an idea of Pittsburgh is I believe we're 13 to 15 square miles in one senses, just for Yeah. So it's it's a great opportunity, actually. It's a very good $1 investment. Sounds like an. Oh, it is. It's an operating utility since 1997 and we're now going to jump out a little bit. Those we've embarked upon an initiative to expand utilities footprint coming to Pittsburgh and elsewhere. Okay, that's item six. But actually, it's a combination of things where we've begun supporting the city, as you say, in the development of new energy projects here. So the idea being the PTC was begin to serve new load Pittsburgh and potentially elsewhere. And we vetted this. We have the legal right to do that. You know, was a publicly owned utility period, as we call ourselves and have been supporting a number of different projects for new projects. While this is the tech park development YieldCo, which is a little bit coal was diamond generating, who wants to commit some applications for battery storage and those and we also turned our attention to the water plant or PPC would serve all our plants and we would develop additional renewable energy sources for fuel. So solar field and solar. Right. And to give you a little bit more color, something I'm especially proud of, I was the development manager of the Go to Energy Project for Bethel, Calpine, and that's the power plant next to Delta Diablo. So off of our sea lane and Pittsburgh area timeline, sometimes you'll see a little bit of a steam room in the mornings. It's all cozy and these efforts sort of tie together in different ways. But we're also developing support for your strategic plan that begins to describe what our vision is for expanding the service territory for the city. So we're a little bit behind on that, but it's coming in maybe to give you some reference from a dollar perspective. And that's a it's been a while since I've thought of all these numbers over the line. You to fill in the blanks are with Las Vegas Energy Center, which is the first power plant that came online in Pittsburgh. That's on Third Street. So if you take Third Street all the way down from the downtown going towards the steel mill, you'd run into to the power plant that was originally the city issued. In our event, it's very power company then to build a power plant and do other various power projects. The winning contractor was a company called Enron, which you may or may not have heard of. So for those guys in the room, they we worked with them to get the Finance Energy Center, then known as Pittsburgh District Energy Facility, approved through the Energy Commission, and they then sold that to Calpine. And Calpine was the actual one who developed and built it with all the approvals were done through Enron and part of the off ramp or sale, if you will. The city had a component of the Pittsburgh Power Company where we received 15.6 million in cash, which back in 2000 was quite a bit of money and still would be quite a bit of money, plus about $9 million worth of other community benefits. The truck bypass road that basically you can take from Harbor Street to Pittsburgh, gaining a highway with a of road that goes around the central edition. Trucks used to go straight down through Central Edition and all of that. And so it was a way to pull those away from the community. The street linear park was built because both the Delta Energy Center lost the Dallas Energy Center. Power lines go to the middle of downtown. You just don't know. They're all underground. And, you know, we were specially built, was not particularly proud of between the two projects. Also it was phenomenal schools. So how do we get from here to there and so we embarked upon putting Doc Banks what we referred to as the eighth Street corridor fuel cycle of the railroad, right of work. And we put with Enron, California, that also jointly participated, put the electrical belt banks first. So at 1.8 miles and I think we contributed 1.3 million for the park. So I think that's the number. And we were told by H.A. it couldn't be done. Doesn't happen. Never, never happened. It was 20 years ago and they couldn't wait to get their hands on. So next time you're at the post office or happened to be going down street. So almost 1400 megawatts of capacity on interstate. And I think with the Delta Energy Project, this is the number of games at about 25 million over the last 20 years or so, 25 years to do that. Ed Yes, I thought it was around that that's behind the postal records, behind the postal actually, and super the piping. Yes, up to a million. And it's not really a little over a million a month. A year here. A year, Yeah. So so basically what you had here is you have an energy center up here. You have Delta Energy Center right here. Their power lines come like this. And we kind of joke dysfunction junctions over here, but they run down each street underneath the ground and then they hook up after the park into the great. And so you had about 25 million from Los Gatos Energy Center, about 25 billion to the community out of Delta Energy Center, which is still being paid off. And then that spurred, I believe it was December of 2004. This is seven was taxpayer. Yeah. Transbay when I got a call from the guys that were behind the Enron project, they've gone to a different company and they said, hey, we got this idea, an opportunity we want to bounce off. You know, Pittsburgh, we think this is a perfect opportunity to take power. There's a huge power need in San Francisco, and right now there's just this huge amount of power lost in the AC lines. When you go from Pittsburgh down to San Jose and back up. And so we think there's a better way to do it. The Tell telephone independent system operator is looking for a new power line. We think we can do it from Pittsburgh because that substation right there, so many power plants plug it into it and we're thinking 400 megawatts can go underneath the delta, underneath the pop up over in San Francisco. So what do you guys think? You know, and then, you know, it became a six year project to get it commercially operational. And it was a $525 million project. We were instrumental in getting it approved. And it will generate for the city over a 40 year period, somewhere around $100 million in just payments. Wow. So, you know, this enterprise for $1, this power is bringing in 150 plus million. We're not even counting property tax, sales tax, just millions upon millions. So it really has been an amazing investment. And why part of the strategic strategic plan that Doug is working on and looking at the new projects, we're looking for that next layer. All right. How can we keep keep it doing, keep it going? You know, the tech park potentially, you know, other opportunities, even if we start small with the water treatment plant, you can I'm bouncing around here because when you look at all the rate increases that are happening, we all pay. I and we understand why, you know, energy costs are going up. There's everything else there. Maybe we think there's a way to see the water treatment, plant money, city hall, potentially money. And that will save the ratepayers of Pittsburgh. So we're looking at how do we now step in starting small, but there may be opportunities with other projects as well to make jobs here, hold down costs where we can for the water treatment plant, make an impact in Pittsburgh similar to what we've done over in Vallejo. So through tax revenue streams that have come in to PPC or variable on all kinds of various job programs, so future Bill, we just looked at it yesterday and then for so it's it's been a way to get money back into the community. A good place to break a question some that stuff. So do you anticipate in the near future some residents will just be on or off shore? And I'm sorry, do you anticipate in the near future residential units within Pittsburgh might be service potentially? You know, we've had drive by comments, discussion with Discovery Homes, that sort of thing for new load. Yes, the there currently aren't any plans to attempt to acquire unique customers or opportunity out of service existing ones. This is all for all world just becomes too costly and cumbersome to attempt to do down or even new PGE can be difficult and it can be costly. And if you look at it from the standpoint they have to plan for growth and always be, you know, they're sort of that last line they must serve. And so if they see, oh, Pittsburgh, you're building 5000 units, they have to start making sure that they've got contracts for power, they've got all that service ready to go. And so if suddenly Pittsburgh steps in, oh, we'll take 2000 units here off your books. While they may have already entered into contracts and so they have departing load fees or fees that help compensate that because they need to, you know, as they're the bigger big utilities trying to plan. And so that comes into the equation when we get into the rate base, you know, there's a two or 3% of kilowatt charge suddenly, you know, we still if we get involved with offering card to anyone, we want to make sure we're at or below what you get from PGE. Otherwise you're not helping the resident. And so that's certainly an equation that we have to constantly work out. If we suddenly went into a subdivision and, you know, supply power, we have to make sure it's competitive. We don't want to suddenly go, Oh, aren't you glad you're buying power from us? And yes, you know, PGE would have been doing this. We're going to cheaper, but sorry, we're here. You know, that's not a good way. And you would have a roomful of people that wouldn't be very happy with it, especially because any subsidized programs for those making underneath a certain amount of. Well, we have we have all those. You have to get. Well, yeah, yeah. You we we operate under a full blown curve because of a lot of different elements or what we call a whole range of things. We cover. We've been suspended all of the late fees. We can very stop shutoffs insurance for nonpayment. We applied for and received state. We're called cap funds to address some of the utility issues in the state. So that was helpful. And we're even running into it now. Like every cent, everyone who has a gas meter, you know, gas just went crazy the last couple of months and we're trying to be as creative as possible to help out our ratepayers on their island. You know, and, you know, this is almost we're getting to where we're probably about ready for the utility, the rate schedule and representations. You know, gas is different than electricity in that the way we structure our gas, we pass through the commodity. So whatever we pay that gets spread through to our customer base and then we have a basically a delivery charge, what it costs for and our electric's a little different in that it's a set rate that encompasses not only a cost for our cost of goods sold, which is electricity, but also our cost to own our administration. All of that and we have a flat rate. We don't do time abuse, which does, you know, either lower depending at the time of day passes flat and which is nice for folks if they, you know, want to just use their energy whenever they need to. But it's it it causes a challenge when we see such a huge fluctuation in commodity cost. And so that's something that, well, you'll see in a few moments in slides here. What we're trying to be a little more nimble on. It's not something that we've lost money per say, you know, but we are margins where we usually would like to keep this. We can take that money and reinvest into the system has been much narrower. And so we're trying to figure out our best way and we'll work with the subcommittee on those ideas. So do we want to jump into the rate case because there was no response? And so we'll walk through this presentation and certainly sorry, I didn't like it. You touched on it nicely there in the time I've been here for the cost of energy or gas or workers were relatively predictable until we got into the drought. You know us from purchasing software called supplemental power when there was no hydro, they both soft power for us in the market to do that. And it's always more expensive. I'll give you a sense of that year and a half ago, our total cost of the liquid energy returned $0.11 per kilowatt hour. What was January was 21. Last question. Same with gas was October was about $0.84 burned. In January it was $3.06 avoided. Folks, whole construction. It was in this situation, 21 was probably 70% less. And so as a publicly owned utility, we don't make a profit, which yeah, it's a it's cost based analysis. And we've kind of held steady with fixed rates as we were getting all this volatility and you're pointed out we're that's really shown up for us for we heard those is capital reserves. We don't have essentially depleted or working capital through. Well we have about 30% reserves that are sustainability ordinance. It was the amount of bulb that that we take and invest into the annually into the utility. And what that did is we basically smoothed out for our customers this spike in rates now. And what you see here is sort of on slide two, you know, we rate, you know, we basically did one rate hike in July 1st, effective July 1st, 2019, and that set our rates for residential $0.21 a kilowatt hour. And we didn't do any kind of other rate increases until we're talking to you right now for effective first rate. So basically, you know, they haven't seen a raise in 22. Yeah, we went into our share last year, so that was to go from 21 to 22.9, basically a kilowatt hour. So we did one rate increase in four years and we're proposing for the second one basically to come in July. So we were very consistent with that. And currently the bundled rate is three and a half cents versus our 22.9 cents per kilowatt hour. The average home uses how many for a once in a market? 400 400 or 400. So, you know, that's 400 times or $0.11, you know. Yeah. So those actually go that table is what we use for the 2223. So those numbers are pretty old. So we just cannot catch up with pensions. You know, those people are increasing their rates. So what? Children look very uncertain when you cover have make the presentation. But we're just getting into the details now. So you know, the rates that we presenting today, they are not the final rates because we are still finalizing our operating budget. But we would just like to take this opportunity to walk you through a rate making process. So our annual rate case is prepared along side with our operating budget, our business model and your intention is service based costing model. So the rates that we charge must cover to all our operating costs and plus from capital know capital investment and some we serve. So the board adopts the rates once a year and we gotcha and reconciliation at the end of each year. If we are in the financial surplus, we would usually hold the rates for another year. If we are running short, we will ask the board for a rate increase, either meeting year at the end of the year. So we didn't do a rate case for three years during the this year. It is not because we are slacking off or even shelter in place or no gathering or public meetings if they pose a challenge to us. But we there was not the reason to increase the rates. We didn't increase the rate because we managed to grow our sales by 28% by putting in major facility upgrades for our commercial customers. So we focus on increasing our load rather than the rates for three years and our rate that was approved in 1920, it was still good for three years and then we were hit by the megadrought starting in 2019, Energy price has skyrocketed and the and the board adopted one rate a rate case in 2022 and 4.3. So that's the that's the reason highlighted in blue. So despite the big jumps from the previous rates that we are still substantially below par. And these are the rates on Cheyenne twice at that time for residential for residential customers, we have 32% below consumers rates and for commercials we are around like 11% or 20% depends on which class they are in. So across the board we are an average of 15 to 30% of the locations. But then so here are some graphs showing that, you know, coming into January 2023, under the combination of cold weather and low price and use of natural gas storage has been depleted completely and the natural gas price has rose more than 300% in this January compared to the January of last. So it was in January 2022, it was $0.84. And in January 2023, one three $3.45. And this is just commodity charge. And that's before all the transmission cost increased on the distribution cost. So on the electricity side, we three, we were in the megadrought and you know, three months ago, according to the scientists, we are still in a drought. So the electricity wholesale price, it rose to all time highs under a combination of low hydro supplies, financial crisis and also the high demand for electricity due to the colder weather and storms. So this is this graph actually shows a perfect correlation between the hydro, hy

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Power Company Advisory Subcommittee
  • Power Company Advisory Subcommittee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: abeef6e4a20f836600c075d1caca1e61. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record