POLISCOPE

The public record

PUNTAGORDA (CHARLOTTE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee

Monday, October 19, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

>> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Anybody on the committee have any announcements? Just want to welcome Jim to joining us as a regular. Next meeting will be November 16th 2026. Does anybody on the board right now know that they will not be in attendance? It is time for public comments if anybody in the audience or in the public would like to speak. You have three minutes and please come up to the podium and give us your name. The podium there over there podium public podium. >> My name is Joanna Shumsky and I'm in Punta Gorda Isles resident 33 Hibiscus Drive and I am here to ask maintenance Advisory board to conduct the study to implement an alternative seawall assessment for determining seawall maintenance taxes. Current assessment method is per unit and it is not equitable. Owners with 30ft of canal wall pay the same tax amount as owners with 150 or even sometimes 260ft. This year it is going to be $1,500 per unit regardless of the actual footage. Which is actually an increase of $850 since 2021 but I am willing to pay my fair share. To make the assessment more Includable charging owners by linear foot of the seawall would be more just. To draw an analogy owners would pay well maintenance taxes commercial rate with their actual linear footage just like we all pay different amounts of property taxes based on the size of the house value age etc.. The linear footage would determine the amount of taxes for maintaining the seawall. To make the tax assessment equitable you could make this tax just for everyone and proportionate to the actual footage of the waterfront. Thank you for considering this proposal. I've got a copy of this proposal if you would like to have a look at it. I'm only asking you to consider alternative ways of paying for the seawall and I have gotten some signatures from the neighbors. I have only so many because it's been so hot and I cannot stand in the sun for many hours so I would visit two houses a day or so. If you want any of these materials please let me know and I can leave them with you. I appreciate you hearing me out and reconsidering how the taxes of the seawall are assessed. I have a 30 foot wall and I pay $1,500 or will be paying this year. Someone with 150 is also paying $1,500. I am only speaking on behalf of many of my neighbors who have a similar situation not just individually on my behalf. Do you have any questions for me? Thank you you can leave me a copy of the documents please. And that's your proposal thank you that's your proposal. Thank you. Would anybody else like to speak? Any more public comments? We are going to open the meeting to the staff reports. I am sorry. I missed the minutes. I do that all the time. The approval minutes and does anybody on the committee have any comments additions changes for the last meeting? The minutes of last meeting have been approved and second and will be posted and will be approved as posted. Staff reports? Now you're on. >> Okay thank you. I can't hear back that way back your expenditure report let's go to the handout that isn't stapled. This printed at the start first week or so. In October so this ends our year. I wanted to make sure you had that where we came in under budget and things not all spent. From the 7.6 million down to 4.3 on total expenses for operating which just means I get to Re-appropriate next year you guys know about that. Just moved over. Could be related to some of it being the seawall stuff or material supply or not getting equipment purchased in time so it gets rolled over for 27. As you go down the other contingency was dealing with the FEMA carried over. Just wanted you to see the end of the year. To move on to the stapled page now you see a bunch of zeros. This is our 20 this is moving forward and this is our 27 budget. We are relatively same 7.6 million in operating. If you go down there to the bottom of the page and things allotted for. Our equipment and contingency still from that roll over hasn't been pushed through. It just stays there. I think we are going to be similar. With existing riff Raff they are doing from eon there is existing one more project which has actually been given the letter and there is an estimated date for that start which is good. We will talk about that later and your only project is dealing with the colony point one so that has not hit construction phase of course we are still in engineering consultant. Any questions with your maintenance or revenue report? So there is no so there is no questions permitted during the staff report that is the public comment but all of the documents that Mr. Storm is covering are available on the city website attached to the agenda for this meeting and they are publicly available. I will address how to get you copies of those afterwards but they are available on the city website attached to the agenda. Any questions any questions >> Thanks Harry. Good to move on then good to move on then? All right so on all right so on the same one comes the PGE utilization section. So ending the year would be your handout I am holding that staple. This brings you up to date where we are with the 26 coming in seawall replacement about 32%. Since we got started in April trying to end Ian's work was the progress. Then moving on to our seawall maintenance program. Seawall panel supplies building manufacturing seawall panels in our yard 53%. This should be that should be I'm sorry the third one should be riff Raff from we are in the process of getting the bid out so that is the amount 8.1 million for that. I don't that should have been that is including in here so that's wrong. Just ignore that one. You will see it on the other pages. In placement. Does that clear it up for you? This should be the end riprap or Irma riprap at 8.1. Not including Ian. Ian only has one more project so I have to get that column put back in. We dropped it from August. Not being in the meeting. I will get that one back in. Let me make a note of that. Sorry guys. I will get that I will get that line item back in for when we meet again November okay? We finished up complete that is just based off of the money value but all projects were complete. We got one big site done and we still got the two pending that is rolled over to 27 because they have pending out there for it so we will just roll that money over. The spoil site assessment that is just engineering for that pier any engineering consultant if it is for doing any plans or permits or doing our specifications. That wraps that up. Any questions there? >> The inlet dredging what still needs to be done there? >> As I discussed earlier we've got to get a bass and I think there was a little bit of Snook but there is a little bit of dredging that we already surveyed our sonar that we had the beginning of summer and they never got to it. Ian jumped right into the maintenance program so freeing up the barge to do that digging and that. That is the same barge that goes and does backfill. Let's hope this winter. No. We reread that one and we were clear there so we dropped Ponce and just had him and then they did this one on Mako Macedonia there. Magdalena. Okay okay >> And just and my Wahlberg I am aware that alligator is going to be dredged halfway through on the alligator Creek side. Do we have any plans of dredging the other side? Has that come up at all? >> I do need a sonar down in that area it hasn't come up at all. I do need a sonar in that area. Now it looks like they are going into at first they are not going to go into Buckley's pass now. I thought they just go right by. Exactly. That would be appreciated. I have got a contact over there at the Charlotte Administrative so it wasn't on the storm monitor side but it has been directed to the engineer side since it is a project now. >> So camping on to that have we noticed any issues that would require dredging on the Punta Gorda side? I haven't heard of any I haven't heard of anything but it would be a cautionary pro proactive kind of approach. Like we do on our perimeter so more like all of the inlets. We need to do it in 27 now we have the boat and service. We are going to have pontoon soon so we are going to get our equipment situated correctly and we can go out now. Close that one out yep all right thank you >> So are you on so are you on the next ENC well phase two? I mean we're getting close to actually finishing this up we're getting close to actually finishing this up? >> The highlighted one is on schedule for 1116 to start. Yes. This is our very last site for our work site. All of the others are done. They are just pending some riprap which is on hold because supplying the need is fast so they are roughly a few months behind for 45 days. Once they order and get a delivery so they use it all up and they have to wait. We have some sites that I think are just under a dozen. Might be ten sites total to get riprap yet but those are up and coming. This is the last 80ft of wall to get replaced. And they've got on the schedule. And then we will just go right into the seawall maintenance. This was ending of course back in August but my handout will bring you up to date. You can see the comparison. Moving along I didn't do a percentage on this but basically almost to the halfway point if it wasn't for waiting on backfill then the sod most of these would be past the halfway point. We had about 100 total here. About 3650 I would add another 1500 to that waiting on backfill sod and close out the project and will be out there another 1500ft. The contractor with those poor barges up in EGI is doing near 1300 to the 1500 depending on the month. When it wasn't raining he was pushing a good 1500 but dropped back a few hundred feet and waiting on some items to be able to plug along there. And make faster pace. Any questions on progress with the seawall maintenance? Excellent excellent. And just as a side note just to add with that I didn't print it up but there is a listing on the city website so you can go canal maintenance to the maintenance program and then you can see the estimated dates. They are a month behind so they post it. Then you can see what is coming up in the schedule. Start week approximate for them. Mr. Di hey Mark how many how many. >> Are utilizing just regular maintenance how many barges are we utilizing just for the regular maintenance? There's four on our PGE and there's one in BSI still we still have the five out there yeah BSI he's got BSI he's got about a few more months to finish up the footage. They were start over there but it's getting close. He will start running the 24/7 work in the past I guess that barge would finish up that footage move in and help southeast or southwest PGE. Right now that isn't going to happen. We are giving them 27 saw work and they will just jump right in there and keep them busy. All right (Laughter) all right? Let's see when it comes to the permitting and that I have nothing new. No presentations. You can see the latest updates through mid in their. I'm just scrolling I am just scrolling slow. Sorry. >> Further discussion about the this new cover that has emerged you know we got two of them we call one the dump truck cover and the other is the shower curtain cover the dump truck one was you know was included in a in it's approved but the other one hasn't been and I know it was before code enforcement for a while have you heard any status update on that what's going on with it yeah there's been no yeah there has been nothing come back through me or even that I have heard through the engineering service about it so I think nothing has come up with either changing what we currently have or going with that new curtain style pull over like you say but it's still a no so. >> If I guess I was expecting if there was something that canal maintenance and canal Advisory committee would probably hear something about or become at least involved in it. Yeah from this level from this level and path I haven't heard it come back down circulated so I think we pretty much had our discussion in it and it hasn't gone anywhere. Capital improvement onto capital improvement. >> Sorry I knew I'd get once okay so to bring you up okay so to bring you up through September actually this is through August so 820 permit was issued by state on that date and sent over to Army Corps on 827. Engineering reported coordinating internally about section 106 and not getting questions so far. Army Corps asked the USFWA and the MNFS if they were permitting the restoration area under the same permit as original project and received no answer. During that process the handout to U for 930 so the report given to me for October started from our engineering consultant. Army Corps and the RAI that they received from the Nmfs with restoration questions and our response was filed the same day no further updates. Basically where we are at is the state parks got that approval and on our side. Now that Army Corps was sitting out here waiting for all of this to get answered and brought back through now they have some questions they are posing back so we are getting the big circle here. Right now hopefully this will be cut shorter than what state ran us out and Army Corps gets on its page fairly quick. I will keep you updated on the progress. I haven't got a newest one from engineering consultant yet this month but if I did I would have brought it here. Most of the time it's the end of the month report they give us but he has been really on this one and wants us to get this moving to construction so fingers crossed. This is a Parks Department issue and they kind of washed their hands of it and now it's back to the Army Corps of Engineers again you nailed it yes you nailed it. Yes. Hopefully with this month and hopefully with this month and a half they will get back in order and by next month we have a better answer of where we stand. I thought our biggest jump and hurdle was this state parks when they stopped us but now it's coming back around Army Corps. It's probably tot dot your T's and cross your eyes. Anything else? Then of course the permit section there is nothing new on the agenda for going forward this year for the PGI. There is no new projects. We already went over we already went over Ian on the back. Any questions you guys may have for me? >> Just my same old question. Now we are just about complete we have one more piece of property left to do. This is going back a little bit to expenditures. Where do we stand with FEMA as far as our expenditures and all of that? Is there a quick answer to that? Do you want to step in Sam possibly do you want to step in Sam possibly? Yeah I'm not looking for a detail oh it's been handled by finance. Sam can give you a quick synopsis. >> Thank you. >> Sam Updike public works. We are actually having arbitration hearing with FEMA. I think it is going to be the first week in December and that is for two I think out of the 11 projects that FEMA has for Ian so things are moving. We should have some answers on how this is going to turn out by the end of that hearing. >> Do we have an idea of what kind of dollar value we are talking about with those two projects? >> I am thinking it is in the 10 to $11 million range is what is at stake in that hearing. >> Thank you. Done you done Mark? Thank you very much thank you very much I appreciate it. We have no judicial hearings at this meeting. Now staff comments? Mark do you have anything else? I do not Mr. I do not Mr. Wahlberg. Thanks. >> I have none. Jake Di none. >> Jim Ron none. >> Ron Ludwig none. Adjourn the meeting thank you with that we could adjourn the meeting. Thank you.

Harry G Walberg, Chair Jeffrey T D'amico, Vice Chair Jake Dye, Committee Member Ronald P Ludvig, Committee Member James A. Merritt, Committee Member CALL TO ORDER Roll Call Pledge of Allegiance Announcements Next Meeting - November 16, 2026 PUBLIC COMMENTS Anyone wishing to address the Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee on any subject may do so at the appropriate time during the meeting. Those who choose to speak must state their name for the record. Each person will be allowed to speak up to a maximum of three minutes. 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a Approval of the minutes: Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee Meeting of August 17, 2026 2. REPORTS 2.a Finance Report for September 2026 2.b Budget Utilization Report September 2026 2.c Seawall Replacement Status Reports for September 2026 2.d Permits Authorized by City Staff September 2026 2.e Punta Gorda Isles Capital Improvement Status Report September 2026 2.f Master Permit Agreement Status Report September 2026 2.g Seawall Replacement Status Report September 2026 PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE AGENDA 326 W. MARION AVE, PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950 OCTOBER 19, 2026, 1:30 PM

3. QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS 3.a There are no Public Hearings for this meeting 4. GENERAL BUSINESS STAFF COMMENTS MEMBER COMMENTS ADJOURNMENT If any person decides to appeal any matter considered at this meeting, he or she may need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Florida Statute 286.26, the location of this public hearing is accessible to persons with disabilities. If you are a person with disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Interpreters for the hearing impaired (TTY 941-575-5013) or non-English speaking citizens, and any other special accommodations can be requested by contacting the Human Resources Manager/Non-Discrimination Coordinator whose address is 326 W. Marion Avenue, Punta Gorda, FL 33950, whose telephone number is (941) 575-3371, and whose email address is humres@cityofpuntagordafl.com, at least two (2) calendars days prior to the meeting.

Showing the first 24,000 of 42,004 characters. The full document is at the source.

Harry G Walberg, Chair Jeffrey T D'amico, Vice Chair Ronald P Ludvig, Committee Member Jake Dye, Committee Member James A. Merritt, Committee Member CALL TO ORDER Roll Call Pledge of Allegiance Announcements Next Meeting - November 16, 2026 PUBLIC COMMENTS Anyone wishing to address the Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee on any subject may do so at the appropriate time during the meeting. Those who choose to speak must state their name for the record. Each person will be allowed to speak up to a maximum of three minutes. 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a Approval of the minutes: Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee Meeting of August 17, 2026 2. REPORTS 2.a Finance Report for September 2026 2.b Budget Utilization Report September 2026 2.c Seawall Replacement Status Reports for September 2026 2.d Permits Authorized by City Staff September 2026 2.e Punta Gorda Isles Capital Improvement Status Report September 2026 2.f Master Permit Agreement Status Report September 2026 2.g Seawall Replacement Status Report September 2026 PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE AGENDA 326 W. MARION AVE, PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950 OCTOBER 19, 2026, 1:30 PM 1

3. QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS 3.a There are no Public Hearings for this meeting 4. GENERAL BUSINESS STAFF COMMENTS MEMBER COMMENTS ADJOURNMENT If any person decides to appeal any matter considered at this meeting, he or she may need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Florida Statute 286.26, the location of this public hearing is accessible to persons with disabilities. If you are a person with disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Interpreters for the hearing impaired (TTY 941-575-5013) or non-English speaking citizens, and any other special accommodations can be requested by contacting the Human Resources Manager/Non-Discrimination Coordinator whose address is 326 W. Marion Avenue, Punta Gorda, FL 33950, whose telephone number is (941) 575-3371, and whose email address is humres@cityofpuntagordafl.com, at least two (2) calendars days prior to the meeting. 2

Title: Approval of the minutes: Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee Meeting of August 17, 2026 Funds: Recommended Action: Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee approval Summary: Regular Meeting Minutes of August 17, 2026 Department/Division: Public Works PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 10/19/2026 APPROVAL OF MINUTES EXHIBITS: 1. August 17, 2026, Minutes 3

CITY OF PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES AUGUST 17, 2026, 1:30 P.M. 120 LAISHLEY COURT PUNTA GORDA, FL 33950 MEMBERS PRESENT: Harry Walberg, Chair Jeffrey D’Amico, Jake Dye, Ronald Ludvig CITY STAFF PRESENT: Tommy Macy, Senior Project Manager; Marc Storm, Canal Maintenance Supervisor; Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder CALL TO ORDER Chair Walberg called the meeting to order at 1:31 p.m., followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. He indicated he may not be present at the September 21, 2026, meeting. PUBLIC COMMENTS There were none. 1) APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a Approval of Minutes: Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee Meeting of July 20, 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page July 20, 2026, Minutes Member Dye MOVED to approve the July 20, 2026, minutes, SECONDED by Member Ludvig. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2) REPORTS 2.a Finance Report July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page PGI Expenditure Report 07312026 PGI Revenue Report 073126 Marc Storm, Canal Maintenance Supervisor, briefly reviewed the report. Chair Walberg questioned whether the City was still waiting on Federal Emergency Management Agency funds. Marc Storm replied he would follow up on same. 2.b Budget Utilization Report July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page PGI Utilization 202608 4

Marc Storm briefly reviewed the report. 2.c Seawall Replacement Status Report July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page NW2_IAN Seawall Phase II_Replacement Status_05102682026 PGI REPLACEMENT SHCEDULE232408 Marc Storm briefly reviewed the report. Chair Walberg questioned how many barges the City would be using now that Hurricane Ian-related repairs were complete. Marc Storm replied the City would continue utilizing 5 barges. 2.d Permits Authorized by City Staff July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page PGI Canal Maintenance Report by City Staff 07312026 Marc Storm indicated there was no update on the report. 2.e Punta Gorda Isles Capital Improvement Status Report July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page PGI Captial Improvement Status 202608 Marc Storm briefly reviewed the report. 2.f Master Permit Agreement Status Report July 2026 Exhibits: Cover Page MasterPermitStatusPGI202608 Marc Storm indicated there were no updates on the report. 3) QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder, swore in all participants. 3.a Special Permit CCSP 04-25 Exhibits: Cover Page Agenda Package Combined Tommy Macy, Senior Project Manager, reviewed the application, noting staff recommended favorable consideration of same. Member Dye noted he would recuse himself from the discussion. Chair Walberg questioned where the single-family home was on the photograph. Tommy Macy replied the photograph did not depict the home, which was a new build. Discussion ensued regarding the location of the pilings. 5

NOTE: Member Dye left the dais at 1:52 p.m. Jake Dye, Keesling Construction, reviewed the process for installing the pilings. Member Ludvig questioned if an extension of the existing dock was being installed. Jake Dye replied affirmatively. Chair Walberg opened the floor for public comment, calling 3 times for same. Member Ludvig MOVED to close the public hearing, SECONDED by Member D'Amico. AYE: D'Amico, Ludvig, Walberg ABSTAINING: Dye MOTION CARRIED. Member D'Amico MOVED to approve the application, SECONDED by Member Ludvig. AYE: D'Amico, Ludvig, Walberg ABSTAINING: Dye MOTION CARRIED. NOTE: Member Dye rejoined the dais at 1:59 p.m. 4) GENERAL BUSINESS There was none. STAFF COMMENTS There were none. MEMBER COMMENTS There were none. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 1:59 p.m. Chair Board Recorder 6

Title: Finance Report for September 2026 Funds: Recommended Action: For informational purposes only, no action required Summary: The attached monthly reports provide updates on Expenditure and Revenue Reports for Punta Gorda Isles Department/Division: Public Works PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 10/19/2026 REPORTS EXHIBITS: 1. Punta Gorda Isles Expenditures Report 09302026 2. PGI Revenue Report 093026 7

PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL MAINTENANCE EXPENDITURE REPORT FY 2027 ACCOUNT NUMBER ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION 103-0000-581 . 99-03 PROJECTED CARRYOVER - END • ENDING RESERVES •• PUNTA GORDA ISL CANAL MNT 103-0960-572.12-01 REGULAR SALARIES & WAGES 103-0960-572 . 14-00 OVERTIME PAY 103-0960-572 . 21-00 FICA TAXES 103-0960-572 . 22-00 RETIREMENT CONTRIBUTION 103-0960-572 . 22-10 RETIREMT -DEFINED CONTRIB 103-0960-572 . 23-00 EMPLOYEE HLTH & LIFE INS 103-0960-572 . 23-02 DEP HLTH+ EMPL PD LIFE 103-0960-572.24-00 WORKMEN'S COMP PREMIUMS * PERSONNEL SERVICES 103-0960-572.31-14 ENGINEERING CONSULTANT 103-0960-572.32-00 ACCOUNTING & AUDITING 103-0960-572 . 34-00 CONTRACTUAL SERVICES 103-0960-572 , 34-08 CHANNEL MARKERS 103-0960-572.34-10 INLET DREDGE 103-0960-572 . 34-12 SEAWALL REPLACEMENT 103-0960-572.34-42 MANGROVE TRIMMING 103-0960-572 . 40-00 TRAVEL & PER DIEM 103-0960-572.41-00 COMMUNICATIONS SERVICES 103-0960-572 . 43-01 ELECTRICITY 103-0960-572.43-07 LOT MOWING 103-0960-572.44-05 CLOTHING & UNIFORMS 103-0960-572 . 45-01 FIRE/GENERAL LIAB INSUR 103-0960-572.46-00 REPAIR & MAINTENANCE SVCS 103-0960-572.46-08 R&M AUTOS/TRUCKS FLEET 103-0960-572 . 46-09 REPAIR/MNT EQUIP FLEET 103-0960-572.49-06 ADMINISTRATIVE CHARGES 103-0960-572 . 49-07 COMPUTER OVERHEAD 103-0960-572.49-08 COLLECTION COMMISSION 103-0960-572.49-13 LANDFILL FEES 103-0960-572.51-00 OFFICE SUPPLIES 103-0960-572.52-01 GASOLINE, OIL, LUBRICANTS 103-0960-572.52-21 DEPT MATERIALS & SUPPLIES 103-0960-572.52-22 SAFETY SUPPLIES 103-0960-572.52-44 SEAWALL PANEL BLDG MTLS 103-0960-572.54-00 BOOKS/MEMBS/TRAINING/EDUC * OPERATING EXPENSES 103-0960-572 . 63-00 IMPROVE OTHER THAN BLDGS 103-0960-572 . 64-01 AUTOS & ON-ROAD VEHICLES 103-0960-572.64-03 EQUIPMENT • CAPITAL OUTLAY 103-0960-572.90-01 RESERVE FOR CONTINGENCIES * CONTINGENCIES ** PG I CANAL MAINTENANCE ORIGINAL BUDGET 3,900,836 3,900,836 3,900,836 732,605 20,000 56,530 49,820 21,495 204,225 36,150 32,385 1,153,210 10,000 1,630 21,000 15,000 60,000 6,075,000 67,120 600 3,830 1,090 1,800 1,095 19,585 800 18,000 12,000 362,250 98,150 50,625 300 825 10,000 22,200 100 808,965 9,405 7,671,370 225,000 95,000 165,000 485,000 50,000 50,000 9,359,580 13,260,416 AM ENDED BUOGE:1' 3,9 00,6.36 3,9 00,836 3,9 00,836 7 32,605 20,000 56,530 49,820 21,495 2 04 , 22!:. 36.150 32,385 1,1 53,210 10,000 l. SJO 21,000 15,000 60,000 6,0 75,000 67,120 600 3,830 1.090 1.,800 1,095 19 , 585 800 18,000 12,000 3 62 ,7.50 98 ,150 5 0,625 300 825 1 0 , 000 22,200 100 8 0 8,965 9. 405 7,6 71,370 2 25.000 95 ,000 1 65,000 4 8 5,000 5 0,000 5 0,000 9,3 5 9,580 13,2 60 , 4.16 DATE PREPARED: 10/09/26 WORKSHEET NAME: YTD103EX ~-T-D ENCUMBRAN CES TOTAL % EXPENSES ( P.O. 1 S ) YTD + PO ' S SPENT 0 0 0 22,922 521 1,707 0 799 15,724 2,287 7,273 51,233 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2,517 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 440 0 53 0 3,010 0 0 0 0 0 0 54,243 54,243 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 22,922 521 1,707 0 799 15,724 2,287 7,273 51,233 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2,517 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 440 0 53 0 3 , 010 0 0 0 0 0 0 54,243 54,243 3 3 3 4 8 6 22 4 13 2 1 BALANCE 3,900,836 3,900,836 3,900,836 709,683 19,479 54,823 49,820 20,696 188,501 33,86 3 25,112 1,101,977 10,000 1,630 21,000 15,000 60,000 6,075,000 67,120 600 3,830 1,090 1,800 1,095 17,068 800 18,000 12,000 362,250 98,150 50,625 300 825 10,000 21,760 100 808,912 9,405 7,668,360 225,000 95,000 165,000 485,000 50,000 50,000 9,305,337 13,206,173 8

PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL MAINTENANCE REVENUE REPORT FY 2027 ORIGINAL ACCOUNT NUMBER ACCOUNT DESCRIPTION BUDGET 103-0000-325.30-00 SPEC ASSMTS - CANAL ASSMT 7,800,030 103-0000-361.10-00 INTEREST ON INVESTMENTS 155,750 103-0000-369.90-00 MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE 500 103-0000-389.90-01 PROJ CARRYOVER-BEGINNING 5,304,136 . 13,260,416 .. PUNTA GORDA ISL CANAL MNT 13,260,416 13,260,416 AMENDED BUDGET 7,800,030 155,750 500 5,304,136 13,260,416 13,260 , 416 13,260,416 Y-T-D % REVENUES REC'D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 DATE PREPARED: 1 0/0 9 / 26 WORKSHEET NAME : YTD103RV BALANCE 7,800,030 155,750 500 5,304,136 13,260,416 13,260,416 1 3 ,260,416 9

Title: Budget Utilization Report September 2026 Funds: Recommended Action: For information purposes only, no action required Summary: The attached monthly report provides updates on the monthly report of work completed and expenditures for seawall repair and maintenance Department/Division: Public Works PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 10/19/2026 REPORTS EXHIBITS: 1. PGI Utilization 202609 10

City of PUNTA GORDA Florida REPORTING PERIOD AS OF: September 14, 2026 PUBLIC WORKS PGI CANAL MAINTENANCE 1075 MONTHLY REPORT OF WORK COMPLETED AND EXPENDITURES FOR SEAWALL R&M DESCRIPTION: ANNUAL SCHEDULED WORK AMENDED SCHEDULED WORK CURRENT MONTH WORK YTD COMP WORK % COMP REMAINING QUANTITY QUANTITY QUANTITY UNIT Sep-26 $6,950,000 $6,950,000 BUD $750,014 $1,596,876 23% $5,353,124 Seawall Panels/Supplies $749,700 $749,700 BUD $18,976 $347,045 46% $402,655 $5,815,600 $6,069,490 BUD $6,134 $4,728,688 78% $1,340,802 $67,120 $67,120 BUD $51,920 $60,495 90% $6,625 $60,000 $60,000 BUD $0 $29,420 49% $30,580 $30,000 $41,803 BUD $0 $22,912 55% $18,891 Inlet Dredging NOTE: City seawall program has 15 worksites completed. Continued work on Hurricane Ian Seawall Replacement at approximately 98% complete with one worksite remaining. Inlet dredging pending work is at Bass and Snook Inlets and pending schedule timeframe from our marine contractor.Mangrove trimming complete. Spoil site Engineering Consulting work ongoing. Spoil Site Channel Permitting/Seawall Assessment FY - 10/01/2025 - 09/30/2026 Seawall Replacement Mangrove Trimming Hurricane Ian Seawall Replacement J:\960 Canal Maintenance\PGI Monthly Reports\Budget Utilization Reports\2025-2026\PGI Utilization 202609 11

Title: Seawall Replacement Status Reports for September 2026 Funds: Recommended Action: For informational purposes only, no action required Summary: The attached monthly reports provide updates on the Punta Gorda Isles Seawall Replacement Work Program FY 24/26 Department/Division: Public Works PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 10/19/2026 REPORTS EXHIBITS: 1. NW2_IAN Seawall Phase II_Replacement Status_091426 2. PGI REPLACEMENT SHCEDULE232409 12

START WEEK OF WALL PRIORITY LOCATION # ADDRESS ESTIMATED LENGTH ACTUAL LENGTH STATUS LOW 4023 VIA SEVILLE 2141/2181 112 243 C LOW 4024 VIA SEVILLE 2080/2100/2140 100 107 C LOW 4026 EL CERITO CT 2237/2255/2275 156 155 C LOW 4027 EL CERITO CT 2111 80 C LOW 4029 BELVEDERE CT 511/517 97 C LOW 4032 BELVEDERE CT 280/290 53 C 3/9/26 LOW 4034 DE LIDO CT 341/361 107 U 3/16/26 LOW 4035 DE LIDO CT 381 69 U 3/23/26 LOW 4036 DE LIDO CT 399 45 U 3/30/26 LOW 4037 DE LIDO CT 380/399 54 U 4/6/26 LOW 4040 BELAIRE CT 255 80 U 4/13/26 LOW 4041 BELAIRE CT 355/365/375 88 U LOW 4010 BOCA RATON CT 1751/1743 142 C LOW 4011 BELLE CT 1800/1799 220 C 3/9/26 LOW 4012 BELLE CT 1793 138 C 3/23/26 LOW 4013 BAL HARBOR BLVD 515/533/551 104 Ltr TOTAL 5019 4997 LTR Letter sent U Under Construction C Complete HN Home owner notified Revised 9/13/26 MARINE CONTRACTING GROUP PHASE II NW2 - SEAWALL REPLACEMENT WORK PROGRAM FY 2024/2025/2026 80 102 57 136 261 84106695845 13

Seawall Maintenance Replacement FY 23/24 Start Week Location # Wall Priority Address Estimated Length Actual Length Status 5/9/2025 1 SEVERE SWAN CT 1230 84 78 C 5/27/2025 2 SEVERE CASEY KEY 1523,1531,1537/USSEPA CT 5005 172 173 C 10/8/2025 3 HIGH OSPREY DR 1351, 1355, 1359, 1362 418 418 C 4/13/2026 5 HIGH DARIN DR 3631 174 174 C 5/11/2026 6 HIGH GULFVIEW RD 125, 135, 2101 117 126 C 2026 by Priority 3/9/2026 1 SEVERE KINGLET DRIVE 1436 174 174 C 4/12/2026 2 SEVERE VENEZIA Ct 242, 246 87 87 C 6/2/2026 3 SEVERE 601 SHREVE 209 209 C 6/15/2026 4 SEVERE 652 ANDROS CT 160 138 C 5/25/2026 5 HIGH CORONADO 1216 83 90 C 5/11/2026 6 HIGH CORONADO DR 1226 150 151 C 5/14/2026 7 MED SABAL DR 15,19,23,27 194 360 C 6/16/2026 8 MED RIO CT 2790/2770 184 184 C 6/3/2026 9 MED RIO CT 2795 184 114 C 6/22/2026 10 MED LUNA CT 2790/2770 318 U 6/29/2026 11 MED LUNA CT 2795/2775 244 U 12 MED BAL HARBOR BLVD 271 85 7/27/2026 13 MED PARTRIDGE DR 1260 72 72 C 6/15/2026 14 MED DIPPER CT 3518/3524/3530 220 U 7/6/2026 15 MED WHITE IBIS CT 3256 #3 230 U 6/29/2026 16 MED ALMAR DR 5143/5121 124 123 C 9/1/2026 17 MED TRINIDAD CT 3367/ 3370 182 U 8/5/2026 18 MED ST KITTS CT 3805/ 3811/ 3817/3823 313 U 19 MED RYAN BLVD 2611/2523 90 U 20 MED BERMUDA CT 3800 35 U 21 MED SABA CT 3805/3811 180 U 5/5/2026 22 MED LUCIA DR 802 197 318 C SOUTHEAST LOW SANPIPPER DR 3330/3322 110 U LOW RAVEN CT 1479/1485/1473/1467 151 U LOW SANDPIPPER DR 3400/3408 80 U LOW SEABREEZE 1200 42 U LOW PARTRIDGE 1222/1226/1230 318 LOW OSPREY CT 1304/1310 287 LOW OSPREY DR 1358/1352 269 LOW SWAN CT 1221 36 LOW SEAFAN DR 1419 100 LOW KITTIWAKE DR 1477 185 SOUTHWEST 14

Seawall Maintenance Replacement FY 23/24 LOW LA SALINA CT 1100 /AQUI ESTA 2285/2245 140 LOW CASEY KEY DR 1740/1746/1750 437 LOW SORROCO DR 1117/1111 116 NORTHWEST 1 LOW TROPICANA 123 106 LTR LOW TROPICANA 70 75 LTR LOW BAY CT 2710/2730/2750/2770 310 LTR LOW VENEZIA CT 261 146 LOW SANCHO PANZA CT 2830/2826 160 LOW PARISIAN CT 2612/2606 100 LOW PARISIAN CT 2642 94 LOW DON QUIXOTE DR 2800/ 2804 140 NORTHWEST 2 LOW GULFVIEW ROAD 158/166 86 LOW GULFVIEW ROAD 161/171 84 LOW VIA ESPLANADE 801 86 LOW EL CERITO CT 2219 80 LOW BOCA RATON 1796 120 LOW BOCA RATON CT 1756/1764/1748/1772 264 NORTHEAST 1 7/7/2026 LOW RIDING ROCKS LN 1226/1234/1238 228 U 8/26/2026 LOW VIA TRIPOLI 1111/ 1119/ 1123 190 U 8/7/2026 LOW MINEO 1335 135 U NORTHEAST 2 LOW APPIAN DR 1605/ 1615/1625 142 LOW PAMELA DR 704/720/730 282 LTR LETTER SENT TOTAL 9779 2989 U UNDER CONSTRUCTION MS 9/14/2026 C COMPLETE 15

Title: Permits Authorized by City Staff September 2026 Funds: Recommended Action: No action required for informational purposes only Summary: The attached report provides the report for permits issued by staff. Department/Division: Public Works PUNTA GORDA ISLES CANAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 10/19/2026 REPORTS EXHIBITS: 1. PGI Canal Maintenance Report by City Staff 09302026 16

Date: 10/9/2026 PGI Canal Maintenance Report Page 1 App Yr App Number Appl Type Appl Date Application Description Street No. Str Dir Street Name Str Suff Lot Block Sub Div Sec 26 199920 BCNL 9/1/2026 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 ******STATE LICENSE UPDATED; HOLD FOR 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 **CLOSED - ALL FEES & INSPECTIONS 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 **NEED ELE SUB TO SIGN APPLICATION & 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 **NEED NOC BEFORE FIRST INSPECTION** 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 **RCVD UPDATED APP W/ ELE SUB SIGNATURE 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 COMPLETED 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 INSTALL 6K BOATLIFT 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 NEED UPDATED STATE LICENSE 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 NOC SUBMITTED IN PERSON 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 SIGNED APPLICATION OR SUBLIST******** 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/1/2026, 2:27:30 PM APASTOR 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/1/2026, 2:29:44 PM APASTOR 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/21/2026, 2:20:43 PM AROSS 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/24/2026, 8:38:38 AM APASTOR 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/3/2026, 11:01:27 AM AROSS 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 BCNL 9/1/2026 9/9/2026, 8:43:24 AM APASTOR 2160 AQUI ESTA DR 0024 0010 PGI 005 199963 BCNL 9/4/2026 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 **BOTH MAIN AND SUB CONTRACTORS NEED TO 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 **NEED NOC BEFORE FIRST INSPECTION** 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 CONCRETE PILINGS WITH 2 NEW 8"BUTT 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 INSTALLING NEW 13K LIFT AND REPLACING 2 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 RENEW 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 2.5CCA PILINGS 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 BCNL 9/4/2026 9/4/2026, 9:02:53 AM APASTOR 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 17

Date: 10/9/2026 PGI Canal Maintenance Report Page 2 App Yr App Number Appl Type Appl Date Application Description Street No. Str Dir Street Name Str Suff Lot Block Sub Div Sec 26 199963 BCNL 9/4/2026 9/4/2026, 9:03:30 AM APASTOR 3360 BAL HARBORBLVD0182 0019 PGI 014 199965 BCNL 9/4/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE THE JOB IS COMPLETED 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 ELEC IS ZAP TECH ELEC 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 INSTALL 10K BOATLIFT 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 NOC PRIOR TO FIRST INSPECTION 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 NOC SUBMITTED VIA EMAIL 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 9/15/2026, 11:18:47 AM AROSS 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 BCNL 9/4/2026 9/4/2026, 9:59:14 AM SCARLAW 2833 DON QUIXOTEDR 0359 0026 PGI 017 200039 BCNL 9/9/2026 **NOC ENCLOSED** 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 BOAT LIFT ELECTRIC BY LIVINGSTON 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 CONCRETE DOCK AND INSTALL A DOLPHIN 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 ELECTRIC CHARLOTTE COUNTY 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 MODEL 207 13,500# BOAT LIFT 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 REPLACE EXISTING DOCK WITH AN 8' X 158' 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 BCNL 9/9/2026 9/9/2026, 8:27:19 AM APASTOR 955 SANTA BRIGIDACT 0175 0007 PGI 014 200040 BCNL 9/9/2026 **NOC ENCLOSED** 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 BOAT LIFT ELECTRIC BY LIVINGSTON 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 ELECTRIC CHARLOTTE COUNTY 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 INSTALL DOLPHIN MODEL 205 10,000# BOAT 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 LIFT & RESET PILING 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 BCNL 9/9/2026 9/9/2026, 8:33:12 AM APASTOR 132 CRESCENT DR 0006 0010 PGI 004 200041 BCNL 9/9/2026 **NOC ENCLOSED** 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 BCNL 9/9/2026 BOAT LIFT ELECTRIC BY LIVINGSTON ELECTRI 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 BCNL 9/9/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 BCNL 9/9/2026 MODEL 211 20,000# BOAT LIFT 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 BCNL 9/9/2026 REPLACE EXISTING LIFT WITH A DOLPHIN 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 BCNL 9/9/2026 9/9/2026, 8:39:07 AM APASTOR 1220 SPANISH CAYLN 0105 0014 PGI 011 200043 BCNL 9/9/2026 **NOC ENCLOSED** 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 BOAT LIFT ELECTRIC BY LIVINGSTON 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 18

Date: 10/9/2026 PGI Canal Maintenance Report Page 3 App Yr App Number Appl Type Appl Date Application Description Street No. Str Dir Street Name Str Suff Lot Block Sub Div Sec 26 200043 BCNL 9/9/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 CONCRETE DOCK AND A DOLPHIN MODEL 209 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 ELECTRIC CHARLOTTE COUNTY 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 REPLACE EXISTING DOCK/LIFT WITH A 7'X66' 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 16,000# BOAT LIFT 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 BCNL 9/9/2026 9/9/2026, 8:50:22 AM APASTOR 127 HIBISCUS DR 0018 0025 PGI 002 200044 BCNL 9/9/2026 **NOC ENCLOSED** 1422 VIA MILANESE 0081 0011 PGI 007 BCNL 9/9/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE COMPLETED 1422 VIA MILANESE 0081 0011 PGI 007 BCNL 9/9/2026 INSTALL A 7' X 30' CONCRETE DOCK AND 1422 VIA MILANESE 0081 0011 PGI 007 BCNL 9/9/2026 INSTALL HOMEOWNER'S 10'X12' FLOATING LIF 1422 VIA MILANESE 0081 0011 PGI 007 BCNL 9/9/2026 9/9/2026, 8:56:46 AM APASTOR 1422 VIA MILANESE 0081 0011 PGI 007 200104 BCNL 9/15/2026 CALL FOR FINAL ONCE THE JOB IS COMPLETED 761 VIA ESPLANADE 0023 0021 PGI 005 BCNL 9/15/2026 EXACT SAME FOOTPRINT 761 VIA ESPLANADE 0023 0021 PGI 005 BCNL 9/15/2026 NOC NOT NEEDED 761 VIA ESPLANADE 0023 0021 PGI 005 BCNL 9/15/2026 REPLACE 4 PILINGS FOR EXISTING LIFT IN 761 VIA ESPLANADE 0023 0021 PGI 005 BCNL 9/15/2026 9/15/2026, 10:00:39 AM SCARLAW 761 VIA ESPLANADE 0023 0021 PGI 005 200136 BCNL 9/18/2026 1589 SAN MARINOCT 0169 0023 PGI 014 BCNL 9/18/2026 1589 SAN MARINOCT 0169 0023 PGI 014 BCNL 9/18/2026 **NO HARD FILE** 1589 SAN MARINOCT 0169 0023 PGI 014 BCNL 9/18/2026 CALL FOR FINAL INSPECTION ONCE JOB 1589 SAN MARINOCT 0169 0023 PGI 014 BCNL 9/18/2026 COMPLETE 1589 SAN MARINOCT 0169 0023 PGI 014 BCNL 9/18/2026 EMAILED WPETERSON FOR REVIEW 9/18/26 1589 SAN MA

>> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Anybody on the committee have any announcements? Just want to welcome Jim to joining us as a regular. Next meeting will be November 16th 2026. Does anybody on the board right now know that they will not be in attendance? It is time for public comments if anybody in the audience or in the public would like to speak. You have three minutes and please come up to the podium and give us your name. The podium there over there podium public podium. >> My name is Joanna Shumsky and I'm in Punta Gorda Isles resident 33 Hibiscus Drive and I am here to ask maintenance Advisory board to conduct the study to implement an alternative seawall assessment for determining seawall maintenance taxes. Current assessment method is per unit and it is not equitable. Owners with 30ft of canal wall pay the same tax amount as owners with 150 or even sometimes 260ft. This year it is going to be $1,500 per unit regardless of the actual footage. Which is actually an increase of $850 since 2021 but I am willing to pay my fair share. To make the assessment more Includable charging owners by linear foot of the seawall would be more just. To draw an analogy owners would pay well maintenance taxes commercial rate with their actual linear footage just like we all pay different amounts of property taxes based on the size of the house value age etc.. The linear footage would determine the amount of taxes for maintaining the seawall. To make the tax assessment equitable you could make this tax just for everyone and proportionate to the actual footage of the waterfront. Thank you for considering this proposal. I've got a copy of this proposal if you would like to have a look at it. I'm only asking you to consider alternative ways of paying for the seawall and I have gotten some signatures from the neighbors. I have only so many because it's been so hot and I cannot stand in the sun for many hours so I would visit two houses a day or so. If you want any of these materials please let me know and I can leave them with you. I appreciate you hearing me out and reconsidering how the taxes of the seawall are assessed. I have a 30 foot wall and I pay $1,500 or will be paying this year. Someone with 150 is also paying $1,500. I am only speaking on behalf of many of my neighbors who have a similar situation not just individually on my behalf. Do you have any questions for me? Thank you you can leave me a copy of the documents please. And that's your proposal thank you that's your proposal. Thank you. Would anybody else like to speak? Any more public comments? We are going to open the meeting to the staff reports. I am sorry. I missed the minutes. I do that all the time. The approval minutes and does anybody on the committee have any comments additions changes for the last meeting? The minutes of last meeting have been approved and second and will be posted and will be approved as posted. Staff reports? Now you're on. >> Okay thank you. I can't hear back that way back your expenditure report let's go to the handout that isn't stapled. This printed at the start first week or so. In October so this ends our year. I wanted to make sure you had that where we came in under budget and things not all spent. From the 7.6 million down to 4.3 on total expenses for operating which just means I get to Re-appropriate next year you guys know about that. Just moved over. Could be related to some of it being the seawall stuff or material supply or not getting equipment purchased in time so it gets rolled over for 27. As you go down the other contingency was dealing with the FEMA carried over. Just wanted you to see the end of the year. To move on to the stapled page now you see a bunch of zeros. This is our 20 this is moving forward and this is our 27 budget. We are relatively same 7.6 million in operating. If you go down there to the bottom of the page and things allotted for. Our equipment and contingency still from that roll over hasn't been pushed through. It just stays there. I think we are going to be similar. With existing riff Raff they are doing from eon there is existing one more project which has actually been given the letter and there is an estimated date for that start which is good. We will talk about that later and your only project is dealing with the colony point one so that has not hit construction phase of course we are still in engineering consultant. Any questions with your maintenance or revenue report? So there is no so there is no questions permitted during the staff report that is the public comment but all of the documents that Mr. Storm is covering are available on the city website attached to the agenda for this meeting and they are publicly available. I will address how to get you copies of those afterwards but they are available on the city website attached to the agenda. Any questions any questions >> Thanks Harry. Good to move on then good to move on then? All right so on all right so on the same one comes the PGE utilization section. So ending the year would be your handout I am holding that staple. This brings you up to date where we are with the 26 coming in seawall replacement about 32%. Since we got started in April trying to end Ian's work was the progress. Then moving on to our seawall maintenance program. Seawall panel supplies building manufacturing seawall panels in our yard 53%. This should be that should be I'm sorry the third one should be riff Raff from we are in the process of getting the bid out so that is the amount 8.1 million for that. I don't that should have been that is including in here so that's wrong. Just ignore that one. You will see it on the other pages. In placement. Does that clear it up for you? This should be the end riprap or Irma riprap at 8.1. Not including Ian. Ian only has one more project so I have to get that column put back in. We dropped it from August. Not being in the meeting. I will get that one back in. Let me make a note of that. Sorry guys. I will get that I will get that line item back in for when we meet again November okay? We finished up complete that is just based off of the money value but all projects were complete. We got one big site done and we still got the two pending that is rolled over to 27 because they have pending out there for it so we will just roll that money over. The spoil site assessment that is just engineering for that pier any engineering consultant if it is for doing any plans or permits or doing our specifications. That wraps that up. Any questions there? >> The inlet dredging what still needs to be done there? >> As I discussed earlier we've got to get a bass and I think there was a little bit of Snook but there is a little bit of dredging that we already surveyed our sonar that we had the beginning of summer and they never got to it. Ian jumped right into the maintenance program so freeing up the barge to do that digging and that. That is the same barge that goes and does backfill. Let's hope this winter. No. We reread that one and we were clear there so we dropped Ponce and just had him and then they did this one on Mako Macedonia there. Magdalena. Okay okay >> And just and my Wahlberg I am aware that alligator is going to be dredged halfway through on the alligator Creek side. Do we have any plans of dredging the other side? Has that come up at all? >> I do need a sonar down in that area it hasn't come up at all. I do need a sonar in that area. Now it looks like they are going into at first they are not going to go into Buckley's pass now. I thought they just go right by. Exactly. That would be appreciated. I have got a contact over there at the Charlotte Administrative so it wasn't on the storm monitor side but it has been directed to the engineer side since it is a project now. >> So camping on to that have we noticed any issues that would require dredging on the Punta Gorda side? I haven't heard of any I haven't heard of anything but it would be a cautionary pro proactive kind of approach. Like we do on our perimeter so more like all of the inlets. We need to do it in 27 now we have the boat and service. We are going to have pontoon soon so we are going to get our equipment situated correctly and we can go out now. Close that one out yep all right thank you >> So are you on so are you on the next ENC well phase two? I mean we're getting close to actually finishing this up we're getting close to actually finishing this up? >> The highlighted one is on schedule for 1116 to start. Yes. This is our very last site for our work site. All of the others are done. They are just pending some riprap which is on hold because supplying the need is fast so they are roughly a few months behind for 45 days. Once they order and get a delivery so they use it all up and they have to wait. We have some sites that I think are just under a dozen. Might be ten sites total to get riprap yet but those are up and coming. This is the last 80ft of wall to get replaced. And they've got on the schedule. And then we will just go right into the seawall maintenance. This was ending of course back in August but my handout will bring you up to date. You can see the comparison. Moving along I didn't do a percentage on this but basically almost to the halfway point if it wasn't for waiting on backfill then the sod most of these would be past the halfway point. We had about 100 total here. About 3650 I would add another 1500 to that waiting on backfill sod and close out the project and will be out there another 1500ft. The contractor with those poor barges up in EGI is doing near 1300 to the 1500 depending on the month. When it wasn't raining he was pushing a good 1500 but dropped back a few hundred feet and waiting on some items to be able to plug along there. And make faster pace. Any questions on progress with the seawall maintenance? Excellent excellent. And just as a side note just to add with that I didn't print it up but there is a listing on the city website so you can go canal maintenance to the maintenance program and then you can see the estimated dates. They are a month behind so they post it. Then you can see what is coming up in the schedule. Start week approximate for them. Mr. Di hey Mark how many how many. >> Are utilizing just regular maintenance how many barges are we utilizing just for the regular maintenance? There's four on our PGE and there's one in BSI still we still have the five out there yeah BSI he's got BSI he's got about a few more months to finish up the footage. They were start over there but it's getting close. He will start running the 24/7 work in the past I guess that barge would finish up that footage move in and help southeast or southwest PGE. Right now that isn't going to happen. We are giving them 27 saw work and they will just jump right in there and keep them busy. All right (Laughter) all right? Let's see when it comes to the permitting and that I have nothing new. No presentations. You can see the latest updates through mid in their. I'm just scrolling I am just scrolling slow. Sorry. >> Further discussion about the this new cover that has emerged you know we got two of them we call one the dump truck cover and the other is the shower curtain cover the dump truck one was you know was included in a in it's approved but the other one hasn't been and I know it was before code enforcement for a while have you heard any status update on that what's going on with it yeah there's been no yeah there has been nothing come back through me or even that I have heard through the engineering service about it so I think nothing has come up with either changing what we currently have or going with that new curtain style pull over like you say but it's still a no so. >> If I guess I was expecting if there was something that canal maintenance and canal Advisory committee would probably hear something about or become at least involved in it. Yeah from this level from this level and path I haven't heard it come back down circulated so I think we pretty much had our discussion in it and it hasn't gone anywhere. Capital improvement onto capital improvement. >> Sorry I knew I'd get once okay so to bring you up okay so to bring you up through September actually this is through August so 820 permit was issued by state on that date and sent over to Army Corps on 827. Engineering reported coordinating internally about section 106 and not getting questions so far. Army Corps asked the USFWA and the MNFS if they were permitting the restoration area under the same permit as original project and received no answer. During that process the handout to U for 930 so the report given to me for October started from our engineering consultant. Army Corps and the RAI that they received from the Nmfs with restoration questions and our response was filed the same day no further updates. Basically where we are at is the state parks got that approval and on our side. Now that Army Corps was sitting out here waiting for all of this to get answered and brought back through now they have some questions they are posing back so we are getting the big circle here. Right now hopefully this will be cut shorter than what state ran us out and Army Corps gets on its page fairly quick. I will keep you updated on the progress. I haven't got a newest one from engineering consultant yet this month but if I did I would have brought it here. Most of the time it's the end of the month report they give us but he has been really on this one and wants us to get this moving to construction so fingers crossed. This is a Parks Department issue and they kind of washed their hands of it and now it's back to the Army Corps of Engineers again you nailed it yes you nailed it. Yes. Hopefully with this month and hopefully with this month and a half they will get back in order and by next month we have a better answer of where we stand. I thought our biggest jump and hurdle was this state parks when they stopped us but now it's coming back around Army Corps. It's probably tot dot your T's and cross your eyes. Anything else? Then of course the permit section there is nothing new on the agenda for going forward this year for the PGI. There is no new projects. We already went over we already went over Ian on the back. Any questions you guys may have for me? >> Just my same old question. Now we are just about complete we have one more piece of property left to do. This is going back a little bit to expenditures. Where do we stand with FEMA as far as our expenditures and all of that? Is there a quick answer to that? Do you want to step in Sam possibly do you want to step in Sam possibly? Yeah I'm not looking for a detail oh it's been handled by finance. Sam can give you a quick synopsis. >> Thank you. >> Sam Updike public works. We are actually having arbitration hearing with FEMA. I think it is going to be the first week in December and that is for two I think out of the 11 projects that FEMA has for Ian so things are moving. We should have some answers on how this is going to turn out by the end of that hearing. >> Do we have an idea of what kind of dollar value we are talking about with those two projects? >> I am thinking it is in the 10 to $11 million range is what is at stake in that hearing. >> Thank you. Done you done Mark? Thank you very much thank you very much I appreciate it. We have no judicial hearings at this meeting. Now staff comments? Mark do you have anything else? I do not Mr. I do not Mr. Wahlberg. Thanks. >> I have none. Jake Di none. >> Jim Ron none. >> Ron Ludwig none. Adjourn the meeting thank you with that we could adjourn the meeting. Thank you.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee
  • Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee — Packet
  • Punta Gorda Isles Canal Advisory Committee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: ab9dcd1bd2380ad96fae82545ada6222. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record