POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - SPECIAL MEETING

Thursday, December 12, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - SPECIAL MEETING

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

testing. Testing. Caption test. Sprinkler, please call the rollcall. Quiet down , please stop, commissioners . >> of money to all. The clerks office has was a notification senator garcia will be absent from today's meeting. Commissioner bastien? Commissioner bermudez? Commissioner cabrera? Commissioner cohen higgins? Commissioner gilbert? Commissioner gonzales? Commissioner hardemon? Commissioner higgins? Commissioner regalado? Commissioner steinberg? Vice CHAIRMAN Kionne mcghee? CHAIRMAN Roderigo. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: present. >> we have seven mmbers present. We have a quorum. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: all right. Please rise for the invocation by commissioner gilbert followed by the pledge. >>> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under GOD, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: good morning. Let's get started. MADAME Attorney? Do you have something you need to read on the record? >> a special meeting has been called to consider matters relating to concentration officers at this meeting the board MAY take action to improve ordinances, resolutions, reports or other documents and discussion items related thereto. That MAY enter the board rules another applicable lobby placed on the agenda for the special meeting. You have two items listed on your agenda. There are no additional changes to the agenda so at this time it would be appropriate to extend the reasonable opportunity for the public to be heard on special items number one and two. Rodriguez, Chair: let's go ahead and open up reasonable opportunity for the public to be heard on both of the items. Do I have any registered speakers? Just one? All right. We have got our clerk . Is our clerk here? Not the clerk but is it his deputy? General counsel? >> good morning MR. Chair everyone. I believe the clerk is on his way but I know we are in a hurry to get things going so if I can read a statement for him? The general counsel for the clerk of courts and comptroller in chief deputy. So CHAIRMAN Rodriguez and members of the board, thank you. The clerk wanted to state this is a significant and historic organizational change for the county and its residence. He would like to take the opportunity express his gratitude to CHAIRMAN Gilbert and current CHAIRMAN MR. Rodriguez. CHAIRMAN Commissioner rodriguez. Commissioners cabrera and regalado are union representatives in the county administration, their collaborative efforts with each of our new constitutional officers have been instrumental in ensuring a smooth transition. And wanted to have his eyes shared commitment to recognizing a supporting most valuable resources which are our employees. It is crucial to reassure them that their years of service in their insurance and retirement benefits will remain the same and uninterrupted during the transition and into the future . I want to think on a personal matter the county attorneys office and assistant county attorneys who we have been working with around-the-clock to get this done. We are very happy we brought it to fruition. The clerk looks forward to the continued partnership with all the different partners here navigate this important milestone for the county. Lastly, he respectfully requested the board consider allowing the mayor to execute any pending county service interlocal agreement finalized during the holiday season. the board MAY know, there are the interlocal agreement that is in front of the board today deals with the most important issue which was basically the transfer of all employees. But as we move forward there are other interlocal agreements which are crucial that we execute in order to have a smooth transition. So therefore he asked these agreements be presented to the board for ratification during the first official meeting. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: thank you. With no other public speaker signed up to speak on either special item 1 or two. So with that reasonable opportunity is now closed. Right? Let me close reasonable opportunity. MADAME Attorney, is there anything else to be set on this. >> I think now we are on the items and I believe you wanted to take special item number two up first? >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: yes. And I believe the sheriff . >> I will move te item MR. Chair. Chair: the item has been moved, it has been seconded. Any discussion? That was on item number two. >> I am happy to move them all if you prefer. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: we have a motion, we have a second on item number two which is the sheriff interlocal agreement. Is there any discussion on item number two which is the sheriff . MADAM Mayor, I will recognize you in a second. Seeing none, oay. MADAME Attorney, will you be brief? We have a motion and second and are about to take a vote. MADAM Mayor, I am srry. >> I will be brief. I want to say how proud I am to be here today to finalize these agreements as we transition to the new constitutional offices. We worked very hard, including my staff under a tight deadline to reach a final agreement with the sheriff's office. And all of them. Our goal throughout this entire process has been to ensure seamless continuity of the services of the constitutional offices that we provide to the public. And it's critical we ensure continuity for the workforce, especially our first responders who provide vital public safety functions. Must of what we sought to preserve is reflected in the final agreement and while we were hopeful the collective bargaining agreement when transition over fully to the new sheriff's office, that wasn't the will of the constitutional office. The same time we recognize the importance of finalizing this agreement today in order to ensure continuity and stability. Thank you MR. Chair. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: thank you MADAM Mayor. All right. Commissioner cohen higgins, you are recognize. >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: on our agenda if I'm not mistaken is all five interlocal agreements for all five constitutional offices under one item. Is that how we are doing this this morning? >> we have two items. Special item number one does include the interlocal for the four constitutional offices ..Do not include the sheriff and special item number two is the interlocal agreement between the county and they sheriff. >>Eileen Higgins: >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: okay. What time did we get the item between the county and the sheriff? >> the agenda printed late last night at 1:00 A.M. >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: just to be clear, this is what we received at 1:00 A.M. . That is one agenda item? I want to make sure I am on the same page with what is before the body this morning. This is one of the two items we are voting on right now? This is what I have delivered to my office as the item that hit the agenda 1:00 A.M. This morning. This is the sheriff great agreement between miami-dade county and the sheriff's office? That's what was delivered. It is 1600 pages. >> both items are voluminous because there are multiple appendices that are attached . similar to if you were to printed that is what it would look like. >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: can someone, either the attorneys, I have not been briefed since 1:00 A.M. This morning to 9:40 am on what is in this, what consequences it has, wy it is we have to approve this this morning. We as a body constantly complain about items hitting our agenda with little time to review it. This is my understanding is eight extremely consequential decision and vote so I need for my comfort level better understanding of what it is we are voting on here I understand it is the interlocal agreement, but I don't know what is contained within it. So if someone could give me an outline, cliff notes I would greatly appreciate that summary. >> commissioner gilbert, this is your item. Would you like the attorneys to? >> Oliver Gilbert: thank you for your thoughtfulness commissioner cohen higgins. The reason we got in last night is because we finished it. We have been negotiating this for a while . The sheriff stands radiate in tallahassee. We can contact her b phone if necessary. It's a difficult agreement to get through. Every employee that is covered by a union, a cba the sheriff is going to hire them. Share is not necessarily, she is not recognizing the cba or unions but she is guaranteeing their benefits, 10 year, almost other things. We will be seeing an amended budget from the sheriff, I guess sometime later in JANUARY that addresses some of the needs we knew would happen which is why we set aside of reserves. There are provisions in there about basically govern how we relate to each other. How we handle purchasing, how we do all those things. And those things aren't necessarily just unique to the sheriff. Exist for several constitutional officers . It's a law of pages, but to that extent it governs security fr the employees . Those are for my perspective the most important provisions. There are employees listed in the appendix that will not be covered but those are non- exempt employees. The sheriff would let them know by , I think it is DECEMBER 20. DECEMBER 20 who they are. But it's a very small amount of positions she wants to recalibrate. There are things we have put into the police department that we don't actually always pay for winning inter-agreements and say we are going to do in-kind services. When we say we want to do more beach patrols. All of those things are going to be reassessed and reevaluated and she's going to bring this back the amount it takes to do those things. Because now when we do in-kind we are not doing in-kind. We are doing in-kind is a county commission. Of the sheriff has eight statutory obligation to balance her budget. Overspend. We knew it would be complicated but the county decides. And with the department that size. Nearly $900 million budget. We complicate it. It is in fact complicated. This is a baseline. We will be seeing substantially, a substantial amount of items that come before us again regarding the relationship between this county government come essential county gvernment. The sheriff is of this county also. It's a new relationship and this is how we begin . >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: thank you for that. It's my understanding the sheriff's office has shy of 5000 employees that are going to shift from the county over to that department. Can someone from the administration -- my concern on the 5000 employees and we are being asked to approve something that is extremely dense and substantive. Is there any communication to this board regarding how the 1600 pages affect those 5000 employees? She whether there is any, I want to make sure our employees, officers, all the support staff receiving exactly what they anticipate . That is the message I need communicated at any level this morning . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized through the chair, thank you for the question commissioner. It is a grave concern of the administration as well as the county that we take care of all our employees. All those employees will transition over. The sheriff agreed to maintain their benefits, their longevity, their status as well as compensation through that transition. It is true though, however, once those employees whether transitioning to the service or another constitutional officer are no longer county employees so they will serve at the pleasure of that new constitutional officer as now they serve with the pleasure of the mayor. But they will be protected through the agreements and the terms and conditions which the sheriff has agreed to adopt. We hope and pray they have a smooth transition, everybody makes it to the other side and they are happy on the other side. We also negotiated one other aspect in the deal that I would like to commend the clerk for recommending which is in the event we have eight employee who transitions to the other side and they decide rca job in the county and would like to come back within 12 months we allowed them to come back to the county and not be penalized or harmed. And vice versa. If there is an employee the sheriff's office and they see this great opportunity in the county or a county employee sees a great opportunity in the sheriff's office they can also do that in 12 months. We did everything we could to protect their interest and protect the commitment they made to serve in this community throughout their careers . >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: and is my understanding the four other constitutional offices are accepting the collective bargaining agreements but the shares office is not. Is there any consequence of that decision? Of the 4600, 3400 of them are under one union for example in the vast majority are unionized in some way. In excess of 90 percent or the failure to accept the bargaining agreement affect our team members, county employees , county family in what way? >> I do want to correct one thing I said to the chair. There are between eight and 12 employees who are exempt nonbargaining that the sheriff has determined will not transition in this document. Should I think commissioner gilbert said this. She is committed to letting them know by DECEMBER 20 who they are. So I did MISS Begone everyone being transitioned. Your second question was the impact of the nonbargaining the bargaining . I think I'm going to splendid this way and I will ask the county attorney to helped me if I MISS Speak. Right now the implications are if they do not certified the unions then it is possible those employees would not be covered. The unions recognize and acknowledge that for all five constitutional offices they need to file an application in order to be acknowledged. We have spoken with them extensively. We have all collaborated on how we support one another. But ultimately the obligation will be only unions to file those petitions and work through the process of being certified. Not only for the sheriff but also the other constitutional offices. In the way we design this agreement that you have in front of us is the county position as each of the constitutionalists are a successor employer. Successor employer means the new office will retain not only the people, the money, the fte but the terms and conditions of employment which are defined in the collective bargaining agreement. Those terms and conditions will be adhered to status quo until such time. Says that should not be the case. So they are protected under the status quo until such time perks as otherwise . >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: what is the deadline by law in which we have to approve these agreement? >> commissioner, the sheriff the statute regarding contemplates it would be an interlocal agreement prior to the generous haven't the establishment of the office . For all the other constitutional offices there is no statutory requirement for them to be in agreement. So I's at the discretion of this board. The mou attached here that exist , and I will have marlon explain, those do create timelines for us on these issues as well. >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: so there is not a deadline other than before JANUARY 7? Because that is what I heard. >> so the county has mou or memorandum of understanding that it has entered with the unions, particularly 199 and gsa local 100. In those there is a deadline of JANUARY 7 for the constitutional officers to agree to certain terms in order for the union to waive certain provisions in the cba. >> through the chair . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner gilbert if you can be recognized as a sponsor. >> Oliver Gilbert: commissioners, there are other deadlines that come pursuant to the rights of the employees. Rate instance, the layoff letters. 31st? >> DECEMBER 17 . >> Oliver Gilbert: that another deadline. By DECEMBER 17 the employees have to be notified about whether they are going to have a jb. Those layoff letters were there might not be strict constitutional timelines for all the constitutional officers . For those employees we have to do something before dcember 17 . >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: I appreciate that. However, it's my understanding there is not clarity on whether or not that is a hard and fast rule. I believe the attorneys for all the constitutional officers are present. Is my understanding the shares office and interpretation is the layoff letters do not have to go off by DECEMBER 17. Is there an interpretation or is this a hard and fast written rule? >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized. The collective bargaining agreements with gs af , there is a 21 date requirement for layoff notices . In the event the county is eliminating the positions . And so the question would be whether this event constitutes a separation for the purposes of those provisions . >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: thank you for clarifying that. Have you been a vice for one of the constitutional officers that there is a different interpretation is the way you explained it where it doesn't trigger a DECEMBER 17 deadline? >> I would defer to the attorneys for the pba and sheriff's office on their interpretation. Yes. There are different ways of interpreting the language as to whether this event constitutes a layoff that would require those notices. >> Danielle Cohen Higgins: I'm not trying to belabor the point. My point is a simple oe. We have known for years that this date was coming. Have an item of this magnitude and size placed on our agenda at 1:00 A.M. Before 930 A.M. Meeting ask us to vote on it for me creates tremendous readiness. I have not reviewed it. Good conscience I cannot vote on this. Unless I have additional time to review and understand its effects on our employees, especially the factor bargaining agreements will not transfer over, that's not something I understand. The consequences of which I do not appreciate yet, I cannot vote on this this morning. Thank you MR. Chair. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner from district 12, you are recognized. >> let me just say first of all I do concur with my colleague , commissioner cohen higgins. it's a very bad habit . We have known this day was coming for a long time. She is not here today, my colleague would bring it up constantly why are we not discussing these issues and why are we not talking about these issues. Now we find ourselves at the 11th hour. I agree with commissioner cohen higgins. Unless we get a speed reading class I don't see how anyone is going to review 1600 pages. Having said that, I do feel comfortable moving forward because I spoke to the sheriff, I have spoken to the administration. As commissioner gilbert said, these deadlines are important. The concern is moving forward on other items. The best policy is getting stuff to us in time to review it as a legislative body. I'm going to be supportive because I think it's important. Some of them are here. By the way, I want to be clear on this. As much as I supportive of protecting the jobs of county employees, the constitutional officers that are here today in the sheriff who is online via zoom have a right to make their own decisions. That is why this occurred. We can't also as a legislative body think we can tie the hands of the new constitutional officers in a permanent fashion. You mentioned perk and I hope you explained the perk process to my colleagues because the law has changed in the last couple of years and there is no guarantee, by the way, there are just no guarantees. While I believe we need to protect as many of the jobs as possible, believe the constitutional officers have to have the flexibility to make the decisions in the best interest of what they are doing. Going to be supportive of it but I hope everybody on the body understands the relationship not only for the administration but all of us with these new constitutional offices is different than what it was before. We have to acknowledge reality, whether we like it or we don't. In my case I have no problem with it. Eiffel comfortable, I appreciate the administration taking time to brief us on these offices, we also discussed and I know there is ongoing conversations and I appreciate the work seminar colleagues have done to make sure this gets done on time. I will be supportive of the item, but I hope as we move forward I we know something is happening let's try to deal with it earlier rather than later. And I am sure my colleague who is here now I don't have to paraphrase her comments because she said that over and over and over for the last two years. And I agree with her. That is why we are here having this discussion. I am supportive of this item and I'm going to vote for it. i feel comfortable our lawyers and representatives of the offices have done the work that needs to be done . Again, they are here publicly. At least four of the five are here publicly in the sheriff is on thing. They have a right to also be able to make decisions in the best interest of the communities they see fit. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner from district 7, you are recognized . >> I was listening to all of you and I think I will echo some of your comments. I want to clarity on something. From the inception of this, one of the things I have focused on is a lot of these deadlines are manufactured. Might understanding of this is always been the deadline we face now I a labor deadline. The issue is the employees. Our conversation about services are separate and apart from that. We could enter into a month-to-month agreement regarding services rendered. We decided to join these two issues because it is more expedient. Because it's easier for us to jump on the labor deadline and say by the way, you have to agree to all our services because it would provide clarity for miami-dade county government. And I have been very clear about that point to the constitutional officers . I think that they have all done a tremendous job and I want to thank all of you. You entered this at the end of the game and you all really hustled to approve these agreements. Like I said when this interlocal was presented to us it was supposed to be presented a year ago and the idea was the candidates were supposed to review it and there was supposed to be a process so we didn't have this now appears in less 11th hour discussion. Like if I had a nickel every time a commissioner complained about 1:30 A.M. Agreement that we got in in email. I have been up since 6:00 A.M. Going to the dcuments trying to figure out what is changed from the last time we saw them. And it's exhausting. Neck concerns me not just because it takes up our bandwidth because it lessened the power of the body by making us a ministerial rubberstamp. Really at the end of the day that's what bothers me. I don't have a problem. I will stay up. I will stay up all night reading. We can sit here and go through it. When it takes from us the ability to truly participate in the discourse, I think it hurts this body. That being said, my understanding is with the exception of the sheriff, the other constitutional officers have signed off on labor as sccessor employees. Now, they have the right to reopen those agreements as they should and will end renegotiate those agreements in a timely fashion. And I will say this about those agreements having spent a lot of time reading them. As someone who negotiated labor agreements of the school board, I think it's important for everyone to consider when these agreements are negotiated they are usually not negotiated by the largest person in the room. By that I mean in some of their agreements it says you can't move an employee without two weeks notice from one place to another. And as commissioner higgins knows, that is because the elephant in that room or water and sewer and transit and waste management. They have routes and you can't change someone's routes in less than two weeks because it's impossible for us to run a government that changes a route in 24 hours. Does that work for elections? Probably not. You could probably make a change in where someone is physically out within 48 hours or 24 hours . If you are in elections where property appraiser or the tax collector but they were the little guys in the room. They have less employees. When they look at these agreements clearly they got whiplash because there were a lot of things that didn't fit for them. They sit down to negotiate these things with the unions they will be able to have a true seat at the table, which is what I think the legislature intended when they made them independent. So it's not just the look of independence that they are separating from us. It is also their ability to negotiate with their unions and set terms that works for the day-to-day that works for them. An opportunity they did not really have as they were part of the county. That will give them an 11 a of eficiency and control over the departments that would help employees, not hurt them. At the same time by signing their agreements everybody wakes up on JANUARY 7 knowing they have a job, they are going to the same office and everything is going to be okay. That's what this entire conversation is about. It's about us insuring the members of our county family are not scared about how they are going t pay their mortgage JANUARY 1 and FEBRUARY 1. They know they are ging to be employed by the same people who have always employed them, that they are going to get paid what they always got paid and that their jobs remain pretty much the same. That's really what we are doing here. Unhappy disappoint that for the ones who have signs with labor. In terms of the sheriff this is a different conversation. Obviously the sheriff has provided us with information what she is asking for is more time to negotiate that. My understanding is she's available over zoom. I spoke to her briefly this morning. i just want clarity on the record as to how that exactly is going to break and how much time legally do we have in order for them to have some sort. What are we looking at in terms of time for that particular negotiation beyond what has been presented to us today to the attorneys . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized. Need clarification on the question? >> through the chair. Commissioner, today the agreement we have before you but the sheriff has negotiated the transition of the employees as well as the continuation of services at the status quo until such time we can delineate all the service-level agreements with the sheriff . I want to say we gave ourselves 90 days post execution to 180 days post execution to finalize the details on the contracts or services the sheriff will be providing back to the county. >> Raquel Regalado: like I said, I'm not that worried about that. Which is fine, I understand. Night concern is on the labor peace. On the labor peace I think there is a lack of clarity here. One thing is representation made. The labor agreement being presented to us from the sheriff is not the same as the labor agreement that is being presented to us on the other constitutional officers. correct? Yes, correct. >> so when we talk about the sheriff there is a series of representations that have been made that she will keep the employees and they will remain the same that she's a successor employer but she is not accepting the terms that were negotiated in the labor agreement. She is not taking the agreement. They have taken the agreement. The others have said we are taking the place of the counting in this agreement. My understanding, correct me if I'm wrong. That is what I want clarity on . >> you are recognized. >> I did not want to interrupt. She's taking the employees minus a number between eight and 12 which is not confirmed that are exempt. They are non-bargaining who she does not want to hire. She will notify those employees that she does not want to hire by DECEMBER 20 . It's DECEMBER 20. That they will not be joining the miami-dade sheriff's office. That is to correct your first statement. Your second statement around nt accepting the collective bargaining agreements. In this agreement there is no acknowledgment of the collective bargaining agreement. What she did do and what she did agree to issue would accept the terms and conditions of employment that have governed these employees until such time on whether or not those unions are valid. And so the status quo would remain until such time as opined on whether or not they are a successor employer in the collective bargaining units would remain. Regalado: so we are punting to the state to buy more time? >> this was a bequest of the sheriff. It was not our designer. We negotiated in good faith with all five constitutional offices. The foreign the one item have all come to agreement not only with the county but they have also come to agreement with the bargaining units and terms and conditions of the relationship and those employees which we are grateful for. We think it is the right thing to do and in the best interest of the community, the employees as well as the county because it limits our risk. Sheriff agreement we did the best we could to come to terms and conditions that would not put us in a compromised position due to the deadlines and so that is where we landed . >> Raquel Regalado: okay. That's my understanding. These are two separate things and I think everyone has done their best. I understand the sheriffs position that she has not had enough time but I also understand the pba position, right? That they would like to provide the employees with a certain amount of certainty the other constitutional offices have opted to give their employees. In terms of the reopening of the sheriff labor areement, what is that reopening date? What does that look like? >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized to answer the question. There is none, right? >> they are taking the agreement negotiated by miami-dade county when the mayor was the sheriff. There the successor employee and they take that agreement. What is the opening and how soon can they reopen it to renegotiate it without doing what they are doing now? There is no labor agreement. There is no opening because there is no labor agreement. The terms contained without actually accepting the agreement. If there is going to be a reopener , if this doesn't play out and hopefully it will. That doesn't play out that doesn't happen. It would come when they reestablish themselves but there is no agreement to reopen. To another point, the reason why I believe the administration and the sheriff actually tight services with labor is because the labor provides the services. We are not going to come up with deadlines and budgets and all the stuff for a service. The budget are dictated by the labor that actually exists to do it. . It would make sense for us to try to find them. I really do appreciate you wanting more detail and I appreciate all the union to have been calling me this morning and texting me. I don't disagree with you. It is important to note the sheriff is not actually bound legally by agreements the county entered . Te sheriff is not bound legally by agreements the county entered. We enter agreements based on our shared values . She is an elected official by the same people who elected us. She has the right to evaluate them and go through the process. Do I believe it is in the best interest of not just the employees but the residents, and businesses to have employees have a collective voice in bargaining? I believe that is the case and I am hopeful she will come to that. But that is a policy decision we make and they have now elected a different person to make that policy decision. And so it's not whether I like it. It is what it is. The challenge we also have as we did enter into agreements. Finding a way to work with the sheriff so we avoid the $180 million separation fee that we MAY have to pay , finding a way to do that is altogether in our best interest in the sheriff and trust. Ultimately we have to pay those fees it is coming out of the general fund. We say big words like separation fee but in the real world left call in taxes paid by the residents of miami-dade county. We have to avoid that. That's why we need to get into an agreement before the sheriff takes office . >> Raquel Regalado: thank you. Commissioner gilbert, I appreciate that, however, I respectfully disagree on a few points. Number one, like I said, the case of the other four constitutional officers and sheriff, we lumped in the services because it is convenient to us. There is no direct correlation between the services we provide them in the services they provide to the public. There are implications of that but we could get their own services . Would it cause a certain amount of chaos? 100 percent. Have they done the right thing by agreeing to be the successor employee in taking on the labor agreement negotiated by them? Right thing and they are providing the employees that povide the services to the residence we represent with certainty and clarity. I mentioned the reopener because they have taken those contracts with the understanding they get to reopen them and they will renegotiate that and they have decided to wait for that we know cushy asian and sign mou with the union so that they could work through that process . Each of those constitutional officers can wait until 2026 or they can reopen JANUARY 8 they have signed mou used to do that and to have that process. What they say you are taking an agreement not negotiated by you as a successor employee and that impacts your office when I'm adding to that statement is you also have the legal right to reopen that agreement and renegotiate that. We are not taking that right. Im separating the two because it is important that they in my opinion have done the right thing in the rush to do the right thing and I think we are all appreciative of that. But they are not without tools they are not without independence and they can renegotiate those terms and they will do that. In case of the sheriff there is a direct correlation between the services they provide to us in the residence of miami-dade county and what happens to the restructuring of that. It's a very different thing. By the way, I am the person that for four years amended every single contract we approved for the office of the sheriff so the sheriff can get out of every single agreement. I am that person. I am not without a clear understanding of the statutory rights. The sheriff also, unlike the other constitutional officers , has the statutory right to decide who their top brass is. They can move all of that and await other constitutional officers cannot. There is a certain amount of statutory right given in one of the things negotiated when the statute was approved by the state was a you services by three years. When we talk about the services the sheriff uses it's a very different conversation than what we are talking about when we talk about the four constitutional officers. I think these two things are separate. The only thing I am putting out there is I appreciate the sheriff has agreed to the employees and to the services they are being provided, however, I caution us because we are not giving the employees who are currently employees of miami-dade P.D. The certainty the other employees in the constitutional offices have gotten because we are not accepting the labor agreement. The reason I spoke of the reopener is my understanding is similar to the other constitutional officers the sheriff could accept the labor agreement. Could become the successor employee in reopen and renegotiate JANUARY 8 . >> commissioner, great point you are making . >> Raquel Regalado: that's the only clarity I want from staff is when could say. when could they began the reopener and renegotiation of the agreement. Exploit can someone answer that question? >> anyone of the constitutional officers can begin negotiations with any of the respective unions on JANUARY 7. There is nothing precluding them having a conversation starting negotiations on JANUARY 7. Currently re-renegotiate all the time. >> let me answer the question. Commissioner. >> Raquel Regalado: on the sheriff, I'm good with everything, I'm glad everyone has done their due diligence. On the sheriff piece before we vote I would like to hear from the unions impacted by what we are being presented. I think they are the ones in a unique position where they will have to tell their employees yes you have a job, yes it is the same job generate seventh you had on JANUARY six but asterix . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner? That is the question I just heard. Do we have someone from that union here to answer that question? Can someone come to the podium, please? . >> good morning. My name is andrew. General counsel of the south florida association 10680 north 26th st. 33172. I apologize. The question specifically you want me to address because there is a lot being talked about . >> Raquel Regalado: what are you going to tell your employees as to what we vote on today? Are you going to explain they keep their title, they keep their pay but they did not keep the terms of the labor agreement . >> first off , just procedurally we are not in support of this as the commissioners have said. 1499 pages not wanting him we haven't had an opportunity to vent this, we haven't had an opportunity to review in any great detail. We are concerned the other constitutional have taken a different approach than the sheriff has. I don't want to get into any legal strategy . Our opinion differs as to what the obligation of the sheriff and her team are going to be on JANUARY 7. I want to make sure our members are comfortable at least at a minimum. Sheriff has except all the employees covered by protective bargaining agreement. I would point out the 8 to 12 employees are going to be notified they are not being moved over and these are not under collective bargaining agreement but most likely are our members so we have an obligation towards them. It's kind of the inverse. There not being a bias it will not be taken over. for the agreement itself . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: that is a very long-winded answer. At the end of the day want to go through the process we will file a certification to become certified. There is nothing precluding the sheriff from does discussing and negotiating before that happens we would welcome that. Would hope that would be something the sheriff and her team would be amenable to the sooner we can get that done more comfort level we will have. Right now this is not ideal . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: MR. Richards because you are standing up there is much less time than counsel did . >> give us a second that he will. Let me first say we reached an agreement with all the constitutional officers we have yet to meet with the sheriff who reached an agreement reached an agreement on a mou for interlocal. What is at stake here? I'm old enough to know this fortunately. Laser 50 to 70 year . Thousands of hours of county administrators and uion leadership. Your families, your rank and file. That is called a contractor group that enforces te contract was elected by them. Into their own people. A 30 year employee. that is the leadership of their union. The question is, is the contract going over? Is the union been recognized and are the employees going over? It's three central issues as commissioner regalado said. Those are hard things to discuss because the law is complicated. We want to first lb the five we reached agreement with our honorable and so are their lawyers and we worked our butts off on them day and night to have those three things checked off the box. Again, we look forward. Shows a wonderful history to work with the sheriff. We have not had that meeting yet. We didn't know what was going on last night. Want to thank commissioner gober and all the commissioners trying to fill us in on quickly as possible on the mssive document. The question becomes when people go to bed at night, 30 year employees that work on closures with 30 year employees tat support our incredible police department. I'm a citizen aboard here in this community. I love paying taxes in dade county. Pay them in one lump sum. Paid them in ejector, still too old to do the credit card. We have to do this carefully. I can't opine on wat you should do today because I haven't seen it. We were not part of the discussions last night and i understand that. I don't know what to say. They are coming at it two different ways and we disagree respectfully with the sheriff attorneys at the moment. I said respectfully. I believe she is saying under the doctrine of status quo, this is all I do. This is my alleged expertise. I believe she is saying under the doctrine of status quo all the terms and conditions of the contract will be honored. And the employees will be honored. But there is questions when you breach a contract t have an arbitration. Who is going to go to the arbitration? Recognizing the union or not? Who is going to pay for the attorney? Who is going to pay for the attorney to go to those things ? We have a lot of hard questions of whatever road you travel today, I believe, and I know I have that from the 13 of you in the mayor's office and newly elected officers awaiting the meeting with the sheriff, that we will navigate through that. But this is a different approach the sheriff's office is taking. It's completely the opposite saying, I think she is legally bound to honor the contract. Don't know where she is going to be with the recognizing of the union. And as we sit here today, the reason cc is not here is we are voting on the mou we have with you. We have an mou being voted on that says , at least to the extent have persuasion, all the constitutional officers , they are independent, they will recognize the union, take the contract, etc. The contracts are up in 26. I believe it is JUNE 1 or MAY. We have 18 months. Of course we are going to the bargaining table. Mary regalado asked us the other day some issues, would you come talk to us. That man's history, his word, his integrity will be there the second he calls us. Get there ahead of you even though ion famous for being late. Want to do this right. Our people are going to bed at night, people want to wake up and see their same potted plant in their cubicle and bust there but helping a citizen missed the bus route. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: thank you MR. Richards. Appreciate you. You are recognize. >> Raquel Regalado: thank you. To close, colleagues, I would tell you I think we should support the four constitutional officers that a finalized these agreements and I think in the case of the sheriff if the sheriff wants more time I think we should amend that item to provide her with more time to continue these negotiations and provide everyone else more time. I do not think we should finalize this. Instead we should meet on JANUARY 6 and on JANUARY 6 take up the item on the sheriff. I don't think we should say we are not going to she's a successor employee , she takes the paper doesn't take the terms. You cannot bifurcate those things. That does not provide employees with any sort of comfort as to their positions . Understand the sheriff once more time and I think is a body we can give her more time. We have a statutory obligation. But if we are going to use perk the kickball than we kick the ball with perk but we do not rubberstamp this knowing there is no certainty. We need certainty. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: thank you commissioner. All right. We have a motion and second on the floor. I assume. On item number two which is a sheriff item. I assume commissioner gilbert but I should assume you are not accepting a friendly amendment from commissioner regalado. >> Oliver Gilbert: MR. CHAIRMAN, MAY I be recognized? B1 you are recognized. Oliver Gilbert: this is an odd situation because most items I bring her items I paid parental leave your they are items I can see. That is not the case here. This is not a necessity. I'm involved in negotiations because we need to get something done. All the comments that commissioner regalado made, that commissioner cohen higgins made especially. But commissioner bermudez, I appreciate your comments but to what end? What we are saying is, and I appreciate the opinion . But not entering into an agreement a substantially worse for the eployees than entering into the agreement. We act like we are not going to have leverage. In the real world we still have to have thousands of negotiations with the sheriff, including for money coming back here. We are going to have leverage to push the cause believe the pba we talk about the police department. There are the unions there. I believe the core principle that employees don't have a true ability to negotiate but for their ability to collectively negotiate. I believe that. I that is a principle we established we can use that we are actually having these discussions . But to not pass something right now, I just think that's reckless. I think that's reckless. And I think it's dangerous . And so when we look at how we are going to operate, not just physically but operationally , the thing that gives the employees , soon to be the ime date mds oh . Soon to be mds oh, the thing that gives them the most amount of uncertainty right now is disagreement. Would love the agreement? No. That is why we deferred several of the issues within an obligation, but the confirmation from the sheriff and administration in this board we will continue to speak about these things. We understand it is not in fact perfect. But it's what we have. I can't in good conscience allow the perfect to be the enemy of the good. Because I know that if the employees leave without this small uncertainty. It's not the certainty they had with the cba, it's not the certainty provided in the unions. As were their rights to agree. I thank them for that. It's not that level of certainty. But it's more certainty that they will have if we don't actually pass something. CHAIRMAN, I will end with this. We all know we have to do a budget amendment sometime soon for the sheriff office. We can have these conversations again . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: thank you commissioner. We have a motion and second. >> all the question. >> Raquel Regalado: but we are voting on the constitutional, the two things. Just sheriff . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: just sheriff. Commissioner steinberg? >> Micky Steinberg: I just need some clarity. When it comes to what the commissioner gilbert just said, I want to understand the consequences if we don't pass this today for the employees and does the administration support the agreement? I want to kind of get some clarity. I know there are different bargaining units within each department. Want to make sure we are protecting the employees so I want to make sure there are not any unintended consequences if we do pass this or don't pass this. Chair: chief edwards, you are recognized if you are the one that is going to answer the question. Please be precise anyone 2 to sentence answer. Passed by the 17th those employees will receive a pink slip from this county, right? >> it will be at risk, yes. Is not the answer? >> I believe the attorney has an answer. >> can you repeat your question. >> Micky Steinberg: I wanted to know what the consequences were if we didn't pass this today and does the administration support it? >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized for a brief answer. Cntractual assurance regarding a seamless transition of employees if you don't pass this agreement today. That is the general answer in one sentence . >> Oliver Gilbert: can I translate that, please. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner gilbert . >> Oliver Gilbert: she said there is no contractual obligation for employees what she is saying is we might have to pink slip the employees and they might have to be rehired by the sheriff and the consequence of pink slipping the employees is $180 million . >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner gonzalez, you are recognized. >> I have been listening to the conversation and I appreciate a lot of what commissioner regalado said and I agree with a lot of what commissioner gilbert said. Want to clarify some things and mickey's question hit it on the head. Today, I'm just talking about the sheriff now. We are potentially looking at the possibility of pink slipping lease officers. Is that correct? >> the answer to that is yes. >> Robert Gonzalez: can I get a real answer. Yes or no, not a legalistic answer from the attorneys. >> can you get repeat the questions. I'm getting questions on both sides . >> Robert Gonzalez: if we do not pass this today, and I'm just talking about the sheriff, if we don't pass this today we are looking at police officers receiving pink slips? After the 17th? Is that correct? >> yes. >> Robert Gonzalez: and I know this is not ideal, I know this is not ideal, however, what the sheriff is asking for as far as not accepting the 8 to 12 individuals, these are individuals appointed positions. They are appointed by the mayor and now they would be appointed by the sheriff or chosen by the sheriff. Is that correct. >> they are currently nonbargaining positions and they will be considered for offers of employment by the sheriff speaker got it. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: we have a motion and a second. >> Raquel Regalado: point of order? To the attorney really quick. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: commissioner, you are recognized. >> Raquel Regalado: thank you. If we agree to a version of what is being presented and by time until generally six right now we are saying we have to make a decision as to the employees transferring and the pay is transferring. If we agree to that portion of it then no one would be pink slipped on the 17th but we have to final agreement by JANUARY 6. What would be the time we have to have a final agreement? >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized for an answer. >> this agreement already covers for the transition where the sheriff would be honoring all of the leave balances and compensatory time . >> Raquel Regalado: if we bifurcated it and said we accepted we are taking the employees that they are keeping the method pain culd we bifurcate the rest of this item and what would we have to approve it by? My understanding is we would have to approve it by JANUARY 6. The only thing forcing that deadline we are up against is the accepting of the employees and their terms. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: you are recognized chief edwards . >> commissioner, what we did with this particular item I we solely focused on the labor peace. We rode into the item we will take 180 days for the rest. The only thing you were opining on right now is the labor peace because of the deadline looming . >> Raquel Regalado: could we bifurcate that labor peace and say we wanted to come back? We want the sheriff to come back with the agreement by generally six. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: that is the entirety . >> that is the item you are voting on. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: going to call the question. All in favor sgnify by saying aye. All opposed know. Show the item passed. we are now on item number one. To read anything onto the record? >> this is a resolution for the other four. >> Anthony Rodriguez, Chair: we have a motion and second motion b commissioner gilbert, second by commissioner regalado. Any discussion on the remaining for? All in favor signify by saying aye ? All opposed nay. Pasco the other four constitutional offices. Congratulations we have an interlocal with all five. There is a motion by commissioner gilbert and a second by commissioner bermudez to adjourn the first special meeting. All in favor of adjourning for special meeting signify by saying aye. All opposed nay. All right. Now we will go into our second meeting. I think it might be from back here. Whoever is exiting the chamber will exit quietly. All right. We are starting the second meeting. Adam attorney? If you need to read something on the record. >> we are now in the second special meeting which has been called to consider matters relating to the county acceptance of an easement for

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - SPECIAL MEETING — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: ab7a87c9d041a026dbc2b8214f89e6ad. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record