POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Art in Public Places Board - Regular Meeting

Monday, February 9, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Art in Public Places Board - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 122,212 characters. The full document is at the source.

otro 2020 de. [Music] Okay. >> good evening, raymond pereira, office of the city attorney. Any person who receives compensation or remuneration or expenses for conducting lobbying activities is required to register as a lobbyist with the city clerk prior to engaging in lobbying activities before city staff boards, committees or the city commission. A copy of the applicable ordinance is available at the office of the city clerk. Miami city hall located at 3500 pan american drive, miami, florida 33133. Thank you. Thank you very much. You have a roll call please. Yes, chair. Board member christina cuervo. Board member nelson delgado, board member maria napoli. Board member gary feinberg. Here board member juan valadez. Here. >> board member jacqueline roach. Here. >> board member odalis deery. Here chair francisco. Here vice chair olga here we do have chrome. Thank you florence. You're welcome. >> chair do we have absence waivers for today? Yes we do. We have one request for absent waiver and that is board member christina cuervo. Thank you. Can you make a motion? I make a motion to accept christina cuervo's absence waiver. I'll second. Thank you. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Thank you. Do we have any minutes to approve? No we don't. >> thanks. Are we swearing in any public. For all those who will be testifying, please rise and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly affirm the testimony you will be given today is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Thank you. Please be seated. Thank you. >> thank you. Um, andrea, are we changing the order of anything tonight? No. >> no changes to the order of the items. I'd like to ask to change one and two to the end and then we'll we'll discuss. Okay. >> we are requesting to defer item number four which is the ethics refresher. Okay. >> alrighty. Any other deferrals? No. >> okay. >> um, please can someone make a motion to, uh, defer item number four. Is there a reason we're deferring this? Just out of curiosity? Hello, this is raymond office of the city attorney just to prepare the presentation to have a more formal presentation for the board at the next meeting. Okay, I make a motion to defer to the next meeting for the ethics refresher. Thank you. Any second. Second. Thank you very much, MR. Martinez. And is this move to the next meeting in MARCH? It is continued to the next meeting? Yes. Sorry. Thank you. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Motion passes. So if there's no there are no other deferrals and we're not changing order. Um, please can you continue with item number three? Item number three file id 18740a resolution of the art in public places board of the city of miami, florida pursuant to chapter 62 article 16 of the city code of miami, florida as amended accepting the art in public places and a report for the 2025 calendar year making findings and providing for a for an effective date. Thank you. >> is there anything that you would like to discuss on the on the annual report? Any comments or any issues any. No items? No I read it I'm ready to sign it. Um. As as the chair. Um. Uh okay. Does anyone have any comments on the on the annual report? No no comments. On the annual report in the agenda packet. Okay. If there are no comments um. Please can someone please make a motion to accept? Sure. Approve. Sorry. So make a motion to approve aip resolution 18740a resolution of the art in public places board of the city of miami, florida pursuant to chapter 62 article 16 of the code of the city of miami as amended. Accepting the art in public places annual report for the 2025 calendar year, making findings and providing for an effective date. Thank you any second. Second. >> second by MISS Napoli. All those in favor say aye. I. I approved. Is there recorded um. Lawrence? Yes. >> motion passes. Thank you. Excellent. >> thank you. All right. I think we can continue with item number five. Moving on to item number five file id 18184a resolution of the art and public places board with attachments pursuant to chapter 62 article 16 entitled art in public places of the code of the city of miami, florida as amended approving the removal or modification of a public art piece by artist carola bravo antonio maceo park field new field restrooms located at approximately 5135 north west seventh street making findings containing a severability clause and providing for an effective date. This item was deferred from the last meeting um as the board knows it was presented to the board in JANUARY. The item request to remove or modify the artwork by carola bravo. The artwork was um finished this in 2020. In 2025 um the mural cost $15,000. Here's an image of the mural as it stands it's been completed. Following feedback from the community and request from the district one commission office, we are requesting to remove the artwork, the commission the artwork from our collection. Um the artist has provided a letter regarding. Her intent and concept for the mural. This was read and presented to the board at the last meeting. Would the board like to read the letter again or is it okay to move on to the next slide? What has changed since the last meeting? So um we have we were asked to get an estimate for the the total to cover the artwork. Uh, we have estimated the artwork um to the artwork removal at $3,000 for repainting the wall and around $2,600 for removing the anti-graffiti coating on the artwork. So the total estimate to remove it will be, uh, $5,600. We have um reached out to district one office and I believe the intent is to move forward with the decommissioning of the mural. So I did meet with commissioner gabella as requested. Um I met with him a couple of weeks ago uh, concerning this item. Uh, we failed in a way that we try not to. He said he had no prior knowledge of this work before it was before the work had started. And you know, I know we always want to know from the districts that they approve before we approve and somehow this didn't happen. The artwork went through the artist selection process. It went through the pack and the board process. The district had an appointed pack member um who reviewed and um recommended approval on the mural. So so the commissioner said he he knew nothing about this. Nothing. Um, what they want to do is this is only two walls of a four walled structure. Um, they would just like to go ahead and paint it out the same color as the other two walls. He said they could cover the cost. Okay, the district to paint it out as far as the replacement, uh, they're not in favor of the mangoes. Um, they don't feel that has any connection to antonio maceo. So to go forward they would like to possibly consider another concept from the artist that does celebrate and commemorate the man. Okay. >> the second proposal came about following a meeting with the commissioner's office and the artist and city staff. Um, so the idea was contemplated at that meeting and that's how the concept came about. The mangoes. Yes. >> well. >> so we can go back to the artist and communicate um, this to her and um, perhaps she can, um, propose a different concept. That's it seems there's a miscommunication between the pack member that is appointed by the commissioner and the commissioner's office and so staff should clarify whatever miscommunication there is, you know, between them because if if you're saying that the pack knew but the commissioner didn't know. So there needs to be a communication not just for this example but in the future for all projects that the commissioner is at least aware um commissioner of the district is at least aware of uh all the items, all the public artworks. Okay. >> I have a question. [Laughter] I have a question. Does the commissioner, wherever that work is, always have to sign off on the work or isn't that what we do like? I'm confused. >> it goes before the professional advisory committee. The pack makes a recommendation to the board and the board provides final approval. So the commissioner got involved because the people in that area didn't like the mural. But we've always can we get some approval from the district before we approve. That's I believe that's the point of. Having I don't I mean just to to I don't know if an approval from a city commissioner for an artwork I think a heads up like okay, this project is happening in your district. It's a it's a park that's in your district the pack that the commissioner appointed and and staff sorry and the board appointed um have you know decided on this on this art and now it's going to go to the public art board for you know, for review and approval. That way if the commissioner has any objections or anything that's really relevant they can bring it up. I don't think that I wouldn't think that the commissioner needs to approve each, you know, project before we do though. Well there has to be some buy in. Heads up maybe a heads up or at least some some. Just so we don't have this situation again. I think that what's unique about this situation is that there's a political reference. Right. So antonio maceo is a cuban hero and that's the park is named after him the the artist who we we um, commissioned to to do this work is a venezuelan artist and she used as inspiration for the piece she used a sculpture um a memorial that exists in cuba also honoring antonio maceo that when we reviewed it that seemed logical to us that there's a you know, a memorial that is to him. She used that as inspiration and hence her artwork. What happened was that at the um ribbon cutting there were members of the community who were personally offended by the work because the memorial in cuba was built, you know, post-revolution and therefore um facilitated by the current regime in cuba. And so they don't see that as an exemplary memorial that should be honored. Right? So they do want to honor antonio maceo, but not the piece of artwork that was used as an inspiration and was being referenced and is referenced in carolla's piece and hence they requested that this be removed and that is why the commissioner is now involved and asking us to decommission the piece. Um but yes, typically there is not an approval process an approval that is required for the commissioner. But I do agree with my fellow board members that there should be a little bit more communication in the process to let the commissioners know hey, this is happening in your in your district and maybe the pac member that was assigned didn't realize that that was part of their responsibility. So I think that we should know whether it's the pac member's responsibility who's who's elected by the commission or whether it's staff's responsibility to make sure that every commissioner is aware of a new work being installed in their district. Yeah. >> as pac members are onboarded they um they are notified that that is part of their responsibilities. But following this incident we have um now started to um implement extra communication with commissioner's office prior to bringing items to the board even if their pac member makes a recommendation of approval. I believe the gentleman is coming from the commissioner's office. Correct? Correct. I just wanted to clarify that. I'm sorry if you can come to the mic and speak into the mic and please say your address. Thank you. I'm sorry. I just wanted to clarify that, um, my name is frank castaneda. I'm chief of staff to commissioner miguel angel gabriela and. Uh, we're sorry that this happened but basically the the artist unknowingly selected something that was used by fidel castro to celebrate the revolution and, uh, it was the first uh, niversary of the of the revolution was based on on that piece of work and it was used for this art which it was in our opinion a very nice art. The problem was the the the initiating factor that created the the artwork and that created a whole lot of problems for us. And you know, we're sorry about what happened and we would want to participate more to make sure stuff like this doesn't happen. But that's that's basically what happened .And thank you. >> thank you for the clarification. Yes I'm jose sanchez from legal policy advisor. Also state your name. Jose sanchez legal and policy advisor and commissioner governor's office I just want to clarify the matter of the thing about the mangoes. The reason why the artist because the artist doesn't know I guess cuban history is came up with. The thing was in a conversation in our office she was asking about events in antonio marcello's life. So I mentioned the protest which happened in a place that's called mangoes of aragua. It's the name of the place. It has nothing to do with the fruit. I mean it MAY have been that there were fruit trees in there but that's not the essence it's the mango. The essence was antonio maceo protesting the end of the ten year war against spain and the people from the western part of cuba that were um, you know, like they wanted to make peace with the spanish and marcel didn't want to do it. So he protested to the spanish governor that was that's the essence of the protest. It happened to be in a place called mango. That's why there is really not a connection with the fruit. Uh, to marcel the connection is with the name of the place where the protest took place. So that's why that's not also representative of marcel the first one it was that is uh how do they call it the sculpture complex or whatever was something that fidel castro created. He was the one that inaugurated the thing at the closing of a communist party congress so that that was totally negative for the community. Right. >> so my understanding of the mangoes is that it's a map. I do want to clarify that corolla's concept was to um she uses the color of the fruit as an allegory correlation to the event but she is highlighting the actual location where the protests happened that was the concept for for her modified mural. Maybe she can put the famous there is a famous picture of maceo sitting in the hammock with the spanish general martinez campos arguing about why the war should continue and then you see the trees you know, like mango I mean where the hammocks are hanging was probably the famous mango trees of the location but if she could like make maybe like uh I don't know a silhouette or something the picture is can be found in the internet, you know, like marcel sitting in the hammock and the other guy sitting in the in the hammock something that will relate to marcel more than the map which I don't know how many people would even know about or care about the map. So you're asking for something more representative of. More representative of marcel that has to do with marcel and has nothing to do with the how do you say like the castro government taking over the legacy of the cuban freedom fighters, which is something that the castro dictatorship loves to use to do they call themselves like the successors of the mambises and that the revolution started in 1868 and he finished the revolution in 1959. So he has he tried to include marcel marti all these people into his dictatorship and we need to separate and make sure the mambises stand like marcel marti gomez that they stand in by themselves as you know people in the war of independence I have absolutely nothing to do with the castro dictatorship and of course we want to see the um we want to see the the artwork before and I think it will be good policy to have the district commissioner, uh, whatever district it is be the one that signs off and gives the final approval to the um to the art recommended by the board so that if there is any issue you got the signature of the commissioner there and the commissioner and his staff review the art and can say hey, this is good. No, this is not good. It would avoid extra expense. It would avoid uh extra problem because in any event it is in the commissioner's district where they are is going to be placed so it's rather better I mean better policy. Um, you know, a best practice to have the person in charge of the district be the one that signs off and approves. Uh, the other thing. In our meeting in our meeting with the commissioner, uh, frank and um staff, um, that was brought up and the commissioner said he is um, looking into replacing the pack member to someone that can better represent the cuban community and the community of his district in a more efficient way. So yeah, but actively also. Yeah, that was discussed in that meeting. But the thing is you can have somebody who doesn't know like everything maybe some people here don't know, maybe some people here do know but I think that the decision should be at the commissioner level rather than at a board level. I think the board should, you know, provide the commissioner with the our proposed artwork and the commissioner should be the one to make the final decision .That way we avoid the hassles that have come up in these things because you know you have one member per district you know, like recommended and that person MAY or MAY not know. So having the commissioner and the staff in the commissioner's office review the the the whatever the paperwork, the artwork that's being proposed and making the final decision will be better than having a board make the final decision and there MAY be a mistake by the person that the commissioner has. So it should be whatever whoever happens to be the district commissioner of the district where the artwork is going to be placed, review it and say yes or no. So I think in general as a process rule I think that that's problematic. I think that there's there it is important for this board to have a certain independent authority to avoid censorship issues and other and other issues that could come up in other scenarios. I think that it's important that the commissioners have um, good relationships with who they appoint to this board and that if they are very concerned about the artwork that's going to be installed in their districts that that they remain in contact with their voting representative. Um I. Um. >> definitely with all the sensitive issue that with the cuban community um we all work in this board without no compensation whatsoever. I think at the time of all of us it's important, um, following what MRS. Cuervo actually not was a proposal but coming in our last meeting where she said that every single commissioner should be more interest on what we do here. I think these to avoid these mistakes because it's nothing but a mistake. Uh, I think that we should, uh, um, suggest that's the right word. I think to the commissioners when a commission a commissioner is involved within the public art call, they have to they should appoint someone that gets involved with us as a board and then all this wasted time it will not happen. My personal opinion. But but don't we already represent a commission district like isn't that why we're here? So why would we add a person per project if if that's already. >> not asking out anybody I'm asking that if it's the commissioner is involved in in a particular artist call that it come from the um the the not the board but it comes from the office of the public art that that commissioner office should have someone involved I don't know with your the manager office or with us in our meetings until until the art is approved because evidently the pack either is not capable or what they are using or they don't find out what exactly the commissioner office is looking for. I think the the more communication we as a board has with the commissioner that is involved in an artist call it will avoid all of this. Thank you. Um all of the public art processes in the miami code um it's not really up to this board to transfer the power from this board to the commissioners. The commissioners decided in the miami code to give the final approval of public art to this board that was decided by the commissioners of the city of miami. Um, the code establishes that each commissioner shall nominate one member to this board. District one your member is not here today. For example, um the commissioner of each district should, um, work together with their board member on the public art board on the public art that's going to be installed in in the in their district. In addition we separately we created or after that we created the professional advisory committee where we have public art experts and also one member appointed by the city commissioner so that that member MAY provide that direct input, you know, on a case by case basis and the commissioner MAY decide hey, for this project I'm going to nominate this person to be my pack member for this project because they're an expert in cuban history like you are for example. And so that way the pack member that's assigned to that specific project can inform the artist better of what the scope is and what's required and what you know what to do or what not to do. Um, and even you know, uh, explain what the commissioner and what what the commissioner feels should be and what what what what the commissioner is hearing also from the people who live in the district. So there's already a lot of places for the commissioner's office to participate in the selection of public art. I just think that there should be more communication for this particular example. I mean let's say there's two steps. Step one is removing what's what's currently there that's that's fine I think that we can all agree to that. We we had already agreed to that in the last meeting. The thing is that you know yeah we can paint it white or gray or whatever color but you know but it's still a missed opportunity for public art and for beautification of of of an important part and and maybe an important message that that that this that this art piece can can deliver. So you know what what we should have done during this month, indra, is we should have worked staff should have worked with the pack with carola bravo the artist and with the commissioner's office not waiting until we're all here but you know but actively work to to resolve this because I what I'm hearing from from from the gentleman is that there's just a [Laughter] Miscommunication and if we can get carola bravo and the pack with clear instructions from the commissioner's office on what the direction should be if we can get them all in a room they could probably have an alternative. Hey we can you know why don't we do this? And so you know, I don't know why this has to wait an entire month to get here and for us to propose this. I mean, I think that we should we should be working more with the commissioner's office. We should be working more with the artists. Um, you know. Yeah, we can slap a coat of paint on this. We should let's approve that so that we can remove it and we avoid, you know, all the problems that it's causing. But it's going to be a blank wall, you know? And so there's an opportunity here that's my my point of view. But then the artists meet with the commissioner. Yes host yes. And they and they discuss this latest concept. Following that meeting with the artist the commissioner and city staff, the artists um, shared this uh ,second proposal with us and with the commissioner's office. So this is the one we we've seen this second proposal. Yes. >> and when was the meeting with the commissioner prior to that? Yes. Okay. So there hasn't been a meeting since this proposal. We have attempted to follow up. We have um. That's that's my point is that we're not I mean we're leaving it to I don't know who to resolve these things. These are very um these are executive things like somebody needs to take charge and pick up the phone and call carola bravo and get her to a meeting in the city's office and talk to the commissioner's office and coordinate one week the following week until it's done. Can we not bring the same exact thing? This is exactly the same. That was before this board last month. We're going to make a decision right now to paint the walls white, and that just means that we didn't do our job one entire month lost. Can we ask the commissioners chief of staff if we can this could be possible you know. Now that we have you here maybe we can, you know, find a resolution. What we want to do is paint that wall with beautiful art. So how can we do that? You know. Okay, so far from what I understand that you have said here you're approving the removal that is painting it white. Sure sure sure. So now we would need to come up. >> I mean speak. Speak for yourself I'm sorry I'm sorry okay sorry I apologize. You're right. Uh, so that would be what what's being done today is to remove the artwork, paint it white and then we would need to come up with the new art that's going to be. So our frustration is that this is what came before us a month ago and we did not vote to we did not support as a board to remove to to remove it because we wanted an option of a replacement. And so our frustration is that a month came back came back and we still don't have a replacement. And we still didn't get consulted on on things. That's that's a problem with the miscommunication that has plagued these things from the very beginning. Right. We need to have a meeting everybody and say hey we agree on this. We like this. We you know this is fine. This is bad. This is good. So so who who will be responsible for meeting from your office with carola bravo to come up with a new. What will you can do is contact our office, set up a meeting with our, um, receptionist so that the commissioner can be there. Uh, the chief of staff myself the people in the office can be there and the artists can come in and then we can discuss the different options. So whose responsibility is it to make this meeting happen? It should not be our board. It needs to either be your staff or your staff. You know either the commissioner staff or the art and public places staff. So following the last meeting I followed up with the commissioner's staff and email saying that the this board had deferred the item and had additional questions such as would the commissioner just simply like it removed? Would they like to do a new call to artist? I then followed up with the commissioner's office again um and then and then again the commissioner's office at that time um or the second time that I followed up I was told by staff that they would just like to proceed with having it removed and then that's when we I brought it forward at the last at the last meeting we moved forward um I followed up again or I followed up again. I received a phone call back from a staffer. Um, and I believe the commissioner was also on that as well. They talked about the email they had received from the board. Um, and then we uh I I we we did our due diligence in trying to find an estimate of what it would cost just to replace it or to paint it white. Um and so I did make attempts to reach out to the commissioner's office and we did speak with them. >> I think the best thing is just to call our main line to 505430 and set up a meeting so that, uh, you know, like it'll be coordinated with the office, it'll be put on calendar, it'll show up in everybody's calendar and everybody will attend. I think that's the the easiest, uh, logistical way to get it done. MAY I ask um, replacing this is going to cost give or take between 15 and $20,000. What I see there um, well, plus the removal if we do it in two steps. >> the cost of removal. The cost of removal is something else. So I mean the cost of of of the cost of modifying this the cost of another artwork for for this for this location would cost between 15 and $20,000. Is that something that the commissioner's office can contribute with. Um that we have to discuss with the commission what you know what he wants to contribute, right. >> that was also something that I asked staff to discuss with the commissioner's office regarding regarding budget for for for this particular project. >> that was part of our request to the commissioner's office as well. Okay. >> sorry. >> we will. Sorry just for the record because the microphone picks it up for the. Record, frank castaneda the district one office will cover it. Thank you. Um. You'll cover the removal or you'll cover also the replacement. Both both and the replacement. Thank you very much. Thank you sir. That really, um, takes care of a lot of the complications. I think that now what's required is probably a few meetings with carola bravo and some direction. Indra based on the process are are you required to do another artist call or can we they continue working with carola bravo. We can modify carola can, um, submit a new modification a modification to the artwork. Did she get any feedback on the second concept? She was not given any feedback on the second concept.. >> all right. But actually I wanted to make sure that we understand that I think we should look in a different way of managing this dealing directly with the commissioner's office because some commissioners are very cooperative with the art business but some are not they don't think it's important and we should make this happen a little bit more smoother. That's my personal opinion. For the record board members board member christina cuervo is present. Thank you. >> sorry I'm late. Thank you. >> christina I know we had an absence [Laughter] Waiver and so I appreciate it for. >> you coming so I can leave. No. >> now you have to stay. >> now I have to stay. >> well, I did give up a seat for you to. Okay. Okay. >> well, thank you for giving me my absence waiver, but I tried my best, so. That's okay. That's okay. Thank you very much. >> go ahead. Um. >> would the board, uh, like to to have the pack review her new proposal or would the board like to be, um, the final deciding body after carola and the commissioners? >> I think this has to go through the through the the same process and the pack and and it just has to run through the process correctly. Um um uh please yes. No additional comments. I don't I don't think we need to bring the pack into it. I would love MISS Bravo to meet with these gentlemen directly and share with them directly her her proposals like maybe she could come up with two new proposals. I mean, these gentlemen are really knowledgeable and, um, I'm sure they could work with her to create a new one. So yeah. So it wouldn't be a racing artwork, it would be replacing the artwork by the same artist. Okay. >> can I make a motion? Are there any other comments? No. Um so what I understand that we're going to do here is we're going to approve the removal and. And the next. Step and. >> the next step a modification of. It the modification okay. Okay so I would like to make a motion to pass the for sorry aip resolution number 18184 which is a resolution of the art and public places board with attachments pursuant to chapter 62 article 16 entitled art in public places of the code of city of miami, florida as amended approving the modification of a public art piece by artist carola bravo at antonio maceo park new field restrooms located at approximately 5135 northwest seventh street making findings containing severability clause and providing an effective date and further specifying that the district one commissioners office will pay for will fund the modification of the new artwork and will work with artists carola bravo on a new uh, piece which should come before this board for final approval. Second. >> roll call board member olga granda. >> yes. I'm sorry vice chair olga granda. Thank you. >> yes. Board member maria napoli. Yes. >> board member christina cuervo. Yes. >> board member gary feinburg. Yes. >> board member juan valadez. Yes. >> board member jacqueline roach. Yes. >> board member odorless dairy yes. Chair francisco henriquez .Yes. >> chair if I MAY to clarify that includes the removal of the artwork. Yeah I was I had that question too I think um can you repeat your question or clarify your question? Me in the motion or. >> does the motion include the removal of the artwork in addition to the new. I think what's specific to for juan and I is that it is a modification not a removal. So by the same artist the artist is modifying the artwork right? It cannot just be removed and left blank. So I guess my answer would be no it isn't the it's simply a removal is not approved by this board only a replacement is approved by this board. Got [Laughter] It. Thank you. But there is the step to paint over. Yes she could just paint over it with the new paint. You know not. We're just trying to avoid a prolonged period of time in which there is a blank wall. Motion passes 8 to 0 and this decision is final unless the division of hearing boards receives an appeal within 15 days. Thank you. Thank you very much. Item number six file id 18550a resolution of the art in public place. Excuse me. I'm apologies .Andrea. Um, since the gentlemen are here and they're from district one as well. Um, if possible if we could, uh, move to item number eight and then we can circle back in case we need any feedback, um, from them. Okay. I will read the item into the record item number eight file id 18869a resolution of the art in public places board with attachments pursuant to chapter 62 and article 16 entitled art in public places of the code of the city of miami, florida as amended authorizing the city manager to negotiate and execute in a form acceptable to the city attorney an agreement between the city of miami and miami freedom park llc to establish an art in public places master plan for miami freedom park generally located at 4000 northwest 14th street and 19 zero zero dash 19 five zero northwest 37th avenue making findings containing a severability clause and providing for an effective date. [Applause] Thank you. I van steiner, assistant director planning department maybe my powerpoint will come up in just a second instead of having to look at my inbox. Excuse me chair I'm sorry. Do you have the annual report? I can go ahead and scan it. Thank you. While we're waiting. Right. >> so this is the miami freedom park ape master plan. I think this is, um, much anticipated. Um, so this is a request to authorize the city manager to execute an agreement to establish a master plan specific to miami freedom park, um, or more specifically the special area plan for the whole park. Um, so miami ape master plan in your program guidelines specifically speak toward um, artwork at tourist oriented locations. Um specifically speaks to major facilities sports venues and then outlines criteria where that artwork should anticipate its location and that is major entry and exit points, visitor areas, plazas, principal facades, perimeter areas and then um areas visible to surrounding neighborhoods. The master plan and program guidelines for the board also specifically talk about parks in list criteria for parks. And so our special area plan for my for miami freedom park does also include a public park. Um the program um the master plan and the program guidelines specifically speak to special area plans and um urban design framework for public art and special area plans. Uh it specifically asks that all planning documents associated with an sap should contain a set of prioritized public art goals and opportunities, um, that include the following identifying and defining public art goals guidelines opportunities that include examination character connections, history and culture. Outline criteria for placement of public art including appropriate materials and scales. Classify and classify and identify highly visible placement opportunities and integration for public art that promote pedestrian interactions. Incorporate works of art into architecture that activates facades and public realms and describe programing ideas for temporary public art installation. So essentially your um ape master plan and program guidelines for sap specifically call for us to have a master plan for those sap uh the the city um along with miami freedom park llc have been working on a master plan agreement that would um, outline all of these criteria set forth in your program guidelines. Uh, the agreement specifically asks that there be a consultant paid for at the expense of miami freedom park llc and that consultant shall have to demonstrate the following minimum criteria and that is of course having um previous experience experience in public art, knowledge of municipal planning and development processes, um the ability to work on budgets, experience working with artists and artists professionals experience developing responsive and equitable public art. So these are the things that are listed in this agreement. So the consultant must be a qualified public art consultant. Um we also established a steering committee to provide strategic direction and accountability and stakeholder representation throughout the entire process. Um their purpose and their duty is really to guide the project's vision and goals and to ensure alignment with adopted plans such as your master plan and program guidelines as well as the city code. They also provide oversight and decision support. Um they help resolve issues and manage risk as they arise. They support transparency by serving as a clear forum for any dialog that happens and then they help build consensus and then champion champion the implementation. Um so that helps to ensure that the likelihood of the site specific or the special area plan master plan is actually successful and implement it um the steering committee is made up of the following representatives. So include somebody specifically appointed by district one. Um then of course uh ownership representation um some city um representation as well because this does incorporate the outside of the administration building as well as the public park. Um, a member from your board, a pack member and then a qualified art professional and art community representative. So the idea is that we're balancing all the needs of the stakeholders within the steering committee. Um, the steering committee would also have support from aipp staff as well as the consultant um legal staff from the applicant as well as any city legal staff as we would need that. And then um, there's they have the ability to if they need like a technical working committee to have one um on a project of this size and I probably don't foresee one but who knows um topics to be addressed within the master plan. So the master plan agreement specifically um uh outlines the topics that the consultant will address. So in addition to the things that are in your that are outlined in your public art master plan and your program guidelines, um it creates a public art project background purpose and vision. Um uh curator framework um mapping so that we can understand the locations that art MAY go um we've also asked for them to include research. So a summary of research conducted in connection with the development of the plan. So a series of case studies that would be similar to miami freedom park and what other cities and what are best practices across the country. We've asked that they conduct stakeholder interviews. So these are three specific stakeholder groups. So the city of miami district one office themselves uh city staff including um any type of plan planning dream um city or anybody else the city manager would want to have and that and then of course a specific stakeholder um interview solely with the developer group. Um we've also included one community engagement outreach meeting. So this will be an opportunity to um reach out to the community, have them come in and engage with with them on what type of public art they would like to see in miami freedom park. Um additional topics to be addressed. We also have asked for them to incorporate a communication and educational plan. As you're aware, a portion of the 1.5% that is given to public art specifically goes toward um education and supporting public art. So this would be a way to incorporate an advocacy plan and an educational plan for the greater um special area plan um then also methodology, strategy, art typology. So they would be looking at what types of art are appropriate in different locations and setting forth criteria or um making a recommendation on those types of criteria to follow for those things. And then um usually there's an associated estimated budget that goes along with each types of those art and different in those locations. Um, this is the timeline of course. Uh the idea is to finalize the agreement sometime this month. Um, and then uh, to have a kickoff next month. Um, research of course stakeholder outreach would be in MAY and then actually drafting and finalizing the plan. We hope to have it back in front of you in SEPTEMBER for adoption of course. Um, if there's anything at that time that you would you would like to change or make a recommendation, you can make that conditional um or ask to be changed at that time this would be the master plan and kind of the guiding documentation or the guiding document and the implementation plan for public art in miami freedom park. Do you have any additional questions? You go back to the list of the membership of the steering committee. Sure. >> and my question is how will these people be selected and appointment more more specifically you know not the city people right? So community representative art community representative qualified art professionals how would those people be selected? Um so currently we have asked that the city manager appoint those um of course the pack member we did include a pack member so you would be appointing that pack member. I think it I think you guys have permanent pack members and then one additional pack member from um from district one already. So district one is already appointing somebody specific to the project. And this is this is a minimum. So I think that we can add um at any time or if there are people that any group thinks that is important to have at the table, I think that we can add that. And it is the developer who chooses the consultant. Yes. And do we already have somebody they've proposed? Either here. Hi good evening everyone. Iris and brian dombroski with offices at 333 southeast second avenue. We have not yet selected the consultant because we wanted to make sure that this got adopted and what the scope would be. We have a few people we've interviewed that are waiting anxiously and probably watching this evening, but we needed to make sure that the scope was all encompassing so that we have not yet finalized the selection. My last question is do we have an idea of the value of the art and public places contribution based on the value of the project? Um we do not yet know that number construction cost goes up every day and since it's 1.5% relative to the cost of construction it goes up momentarily. Um, so we don't know yet that number we do have a development that's proposed over the next 12 years. It's going to be coming in in various different phases, which is why the city and our team felt that a master plan kind of coordinating looking at the big picture as opposed to coming in building by building um was a better avenue to be able to look at it, take a step back and then focus in. Thank you thank you. This master plan covers the soccer component as well. Yes. >> so the entire the entire parcel. The entire leased premises it's 131 acres 73 of it is the leased premises the miami freedom park has as well as the abutting public park since they're kind of both integrated into each other, the city asks that the public park um would also be integrated into the master plan. The city is responsible for doing the art and public places selection of the actual art for the park, but it's part of the master plan. It will all be incorporated holistically. And master plan is the is the stadium the administrative buildings for the city and the public park. Not the administrative building. The surroundings of the administrative building the administrative building I believe already has a call to artists that's been issued by the city um planning department but the surrounding areas around it the open spaces. Yes. And it also includes the retail component, the office component, the hotel component. Since this is a large development, all those different components will also be a participant. What is this board will be involved in the indoor public art as well like for instance the hotel etc. No. Well the hotels do also have to satisfy um ape compliance in relative to the construction cost of each hotel. So they are a component of of the development and they are included in the master plan. Why wouldn't the city administration building be part of the master plan? So the inside of the the we've already we've already done the call to artists for the inside of the building and that is specifically because um at this time there we're trying to make sure that art gets incorporated. Um or there's been a request to incorporate art as part of the architectural features of the building. And so in order to explore that we need it to go ahead and release the call to artist. You mentioned that the costs are going up constantly. Absolutely right. But what's the latest estimate? The latest estimate based on the current building permits that we have. So right now if anybody's driven up or gone around 37th avenue you've seen the beautiful building. Um currently right now it's about I would say almost 5 million in art. Um I don't remember right now off the top of my head all I know it's about 5 million in ape art. Um, the cost of construction. It's the garage, it's the stadium, it's the roads, um, and so forth. So it's about currently right now it's at about 5 million with what you see out there plus all the permits that are coming in in the near future. When when do you believe we could have some sort of estimate or like a planning for. That's going to be in the master plan. So one of the things that the consultants is going to be doing is coming up with like a budget overall of the development now again it'll be a budget. Some things MAY change between now and in seven years when we actually build the building, but it will give you a budget going forward. That's one of the components that the city requested be included. So when I've worked on these in the past we've specifically we've what's happened is the consultant has come back. They've said okay we think a piece of iconic art should go here and an estimated budget for that should be between you know, $3,000,005 million. Um, and so they're making that kind of recommendation and so that's what we've asked to be incorporated into here is that they would give an approximate estimated budget. And can you go back to the very beginning when you described this whole master plan agreement and the s a p so is this contemplated in special area plan that you would do a master plan agreement or is this something explain how we've got how we got here because maybe I missed that beginning of yes. >> so in your app master plan in your program guidelines um so for example the program guidelines say you know you shall have a pack and this is how the pack shall function. It also says that in saps you should have a planning document that addresses these items which is essentially a master plan. I mean it doesn't call it a master plan but I don't know what else you would call this criteria. I think that's smart. So I think it's [Laughter] That this makes sense in that sense. And is the city administration not considered part of the sap? It is. It is but [Laughter] It's just been the city's direction to pull it out of this. So we because of where we are because of where we are in construction of that we've been asked or we're moving forward with the call to artist for the internal portion. We did pull out the external portion of it so that it could be included in the in the master plan. And that direction comes from who. It comes from city administration. Maybe your point is like how do you divvy up between the interior and the exterior? But I guess that's that if the exterior would be part of this. Yes. Is what you're saying. >> yeah. I mean I think that um part of my questions are because we've been asking particularly the chair has been asking about this for over a year, um, kind of you know, in anticipation of why aren't we getting more information? Why why isn't this coming before us? And so already we're seeing, you know, this divvying up and things happening that we've been trying to get ahead of and to understand and you know, it's I think it's hard for us to understand why things are happening in this order. I think it would have made sense to us for it all to have been part of one master plan. So um so I think precisely because we were trying to say hey, why isn't this happening? You know, we're all driving by and seeing it going up, you know why isn't it coming? Why isn't it coming? Um, so I think there's a at least for me there's a bit of a frustration as to why isn't it all together? Why isn't this same process happening with the inside of the building? Um, I mean indra knows because I sent an email in shock as to why the call to action came out last week when we specifically at the last board meeting said we want to see what like we want to discuss what will happen with the city. That's what. I that's what I don't understand. Before a call to action we specifically said that at the last meeting and then poof last week we got an email that said call to action has been has been sent out and I understand that there was direction for it but at the same time like we have to approve what you know what artists will be accepted and the next steps. So it's like. >> so I think. Not only that let me let me let me let me add to that um uh first of all I think a master plan is a good idea. Um, I think we should have started there. >> I agree. Um, we put the cart before the horse, you know? Whatever. Um, but last meeting it was discussed that there was a very high amount for the city of miami building and and and we were alarmed and we were so alarmed that we requested um I don't know if that's the word, but we said we gave a directive to staff that you were not to issue a call to artist until you had come before this board again and explained the amount, the reasoning you know everything and we could you know, we could go back and forth and to say now that oh, you were in a hurry because it's last minute and so we had to get it done because of architectural things. I mean you did exactly what the board asked you not to do. You went exactly against what we requested in the last meeting. So so now what? So it's like we we ask you please do not issue a call to artist and you go and issue a call to artist. So what do we what do I mean? Are you the board of art in public places is city staff the board of art in public places. If we request that the city staff not issue a call to artist, why did you issue a call to artist? Explain really why. If I MAY. If no. Sorry. Excuse me. Sorry. This was this was a question to city staff. Why why issue a call to artist for the city of miami building without coming back to this board? If we had discussed. So your program guidelines explain how artists are then released. It then goes through the process and then comes to you. So within that framework we released a call to artists. We tried to do it in a way that would both honor what the board asked for as well as what city administration was doing as well. So all we did at this stage was do a call to artist for artists that would be interested potentially in doing a [Laughter] Project inside the administration building. That's it. That's all we've done. >> you haven't even explained to us what the project is. That's the whole point. You can't be going out and doing call to artists if this board tells you expressly not to not to issue a call to artists. I mean if we had not said anything I understand you're moving along but we did and so this is like this is like on purpose. This is a willful disregard of of of what we requested at this board I don't understand that was the direction of this board. And I understand that there's a framework and so you can advance because that's your framework. But then then there becomes a point a moment in that framework in which we have to approve so we can stop it by not voting for it precisely because you have decided to disregard, you know, our request to to modify that process just a little bit, you know, give us information like we want to be a part of it and you've decided nope, we're going to keep going. It's like well we can just stop it in its tracks like that makes no sense. So I think that all of the information that you guys want to see and the things that you want to do are still on the table and you're still able to do them. But [Laughter] Then it's but the work that you're doing could potentially be complete waste that gets thrown out. I just I disagree I disagree that that doing a call to artists in a format that is not part of a bigger picture honestly that is not part of this ap. I don't know if it's an option, but I'd like to know if it's an option that we require that the building be part of this master plan. Maybe you can answer that. That's why I was trying to say if it pleases the board, we're happy to incorporate it. >> I mean I think we're. I think that that would kind of like hopefully resolve the issue. We can collaborate with whomever they select. We can talk to them. This is going to take us like six months. This isn't like a an easy thing to do. So we're happy to collaborate with the planning department and whomever is selected or work with their architect also happens to be our architect. So there's synergy there with some of that stuff and to the extent that we are happy to collaborate on that and kind of be able to advance on that. Thank you. Thank you. So yeah. That makes sense. Yeah. >> any other comments before I'd like to make a final comment but any other comments on this on this item I think that the personally in my opinion I think that the master plan is a is a very good idea. I think that it's long overdue. Um thank you very much. Thank you for coming today and and and for starting this this process um I believe if if that's the site plan then then it should include all the buildings in the site plan etcetera. Um uh but really with with with staff um we really have to think about this process because I, I mean. You know, to disregard really what we've what we've asked you to do in this way like so just you just disregarded it like like like we didn't even mention it at all. Um, it complicates things. It complicates things a lot. You know, it's very difficult for us to do our job, um, when we have to constantly be working to, you know, clarify, uh, what you're doing. I just want to leave for for the record, this is this is this is this is not the way to go. You can see that, uh, the council for for for freedom park. Um, you know, it's a good a good suggestion to include the city building in the master plan. You know, why is that coming from council? Why is that not coming from our own city staff? Um, if I MAY again please. We were limiting ourselves to just the park so that was something that initially came from our end not necessarily city staff because city staff has a different timeline. Each building was going independently so I don't want to say that you know, we're happy to incorporate because we want to be collaborative but initially it was not incorporated right because we were only dealing with the open spaces. So I just want to be clear on that it wasn't it was our part to I just want to be clear. I have another question to city staff why is there a separation in the city administration building project between the interior and exterior and how did like how is that money being split and allocated? [Laughter] You know like again there's still so many details that seem strange. Like who did like it because my understanding is that the money is a percentage. There isn't a clarification in our rules that say that has to go inside. So where did that happen? This master plan is for the project. What's the plan for the city building like if you guys already have a call to artists out what's the plan? What's in the well if you have a call to artist it means you already have a plan for what you're going to do. What is your plan? We don't know it yet. What's the plan for the city building? We do have it as a as a discussion item as the board requested. So we have the call to artists with the locations that were selected by the administration. Does it change now artists. If we're going to incorporate. Combining it. >> does that call to artists disappear now like what happened to. Yeah so the master plan can set forth uh criteria for call to artists. So I mean typically when I've worked on public art master plans that incorporate large that are large scale like this, they will have um pieces that will say this is the criteria for this type. It should go back to the ap the your public art board. This is a temporary art installation here the criteria once you approve that master plan it usually says then that temporary installation can be run by staff. So you wouldn't see that again because now that criteria is set out um and some will say just go back to the pack. Some will say this should only be local artists. Some parts will say this should be an international artist. So all of that kind of gets spelled out in the master plan right? So the plan comes before the call to artist. Biological so. The master plan could incorporate the the call to artists that we've already done as a step one and then list out criteria for step two and then step three. I think the challenge for us is we come back to that. We feel that we have not approved the plans that is in your call to artists. So we you know yeah that's that's our challenge. Is that reviewed here right. And I mean if had anybody asked me three years ago before I worked at the city of miami what we needed to do, I would have said you need to do a master plan and I would have asked that it be built into the sap as per your program guidelines. That did not happen. So we are now here and we're doing the best that we can to ensure that we have a cohesive art program for the entire site that takes into consideration our developer, our city needs as well as what our public wants. And so at this point we're moving forward the best that we can do. I think that if you guys have conditions to the agreement, I think that you've already heard from the developer. Um, and i think that, you know, as city staff we can you can make that as part of your condition to the agreement. It doesn't feel like a cohesive project if you city staff has already decided to carve out a portion and do whatever they want with it without it being part of a plan or something that's come before this board. I disagree that we're doing whatever we want with it. There have been areas identified for potential art. There has been no budget or anything anything associated with that. I think that we also know that that projects go to the pack and the pack say oh this is this is really interesting and this is really interesting. It might work better on this site or if you both did smaller projects and we come up with a better we come up with a better project through that process. So we're so far early I don't think that any of the things that you want to see or you want to happen or where you think there should be specifically items or areas that are specific inside the building for local artists or international artists or different types I don't I think that's all still relevant and feedback th

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Art in Public Places Board - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: aa0f9f7224179f0f2dbe74123cae306b. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record