POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Tuesday, February 1, 2022 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 152,808 characters. The full document is at the source.

c1 [Captioner standing by.] [Music] >> we are getting people slowly come on in. Wow. You have a very special presentation today, don't you. >> I do. I do. >> it is a great group of ladies, it is great presentation. 60 years. >> 60 years. >> hey. 60 is the new 40. With that said and done. >> you two [Indiscernible] [Laughter]. >> I'm going for -- >> we will save this group over here. With that said and done, okay. Commissioner higgins. I know there is a very special and great presentation. Why don't you lead us off. >> thank you MR. Chair. Good morning, everybody. I am just so proud and happy that we are here this morning to celebrate a wonderful group of women who have been leading the charge throughout the ountry since 1920. That's the league of women voters. A group of which I am a proud member of. For those of you that don't know, in 1920 the 19th amendment was passed and the league of women voters was formed then. So, we talk about change, but it has actually happened in our lifetime and happened to people we know. League was formed about advocating for change but in particular making sure women felt comfortable felt comfortable. They have taught me so much. So we have so many wonderful members. What is most important is the league is nonpartisan and in these days where sometimes debate can get pretty rough. It is so good to have a oice at the county or up in tallahassee or wash ton that advocates for the issues for the people. Whether that is their education or districting. And doing it in such a professional manner. I am proud of being a league of women voters member and I am thrilled to be with you today and to thank you for all you do every day to make sure we are educated about issues that matter and advocate to our elected officials to make change happen. We oh, a lot to you and I owe a lot to you. MR. Monestime is in the house. Thank you. Before I actually -- don't tell anybody declare today the 60th anniversary of the league of women voters day. I will turn it over to my colleagues because I know they know you as well and I know we have a very famous member in the house. Hat would be our mayor. MR. Chair, I don't know if you want to go next MADAM Mayor. All right. We will give it to the mayor. >> thank you. Commissioner I am so happy you brought his opportunity to show case my civic organization. Yes, thank you. And I like to tell people while I have a [Word?] Degree I learned politic from the eague of women voters and look at me now. I joined the league when I moved to miami over 40 years ago. I have been an active member for many years served alongside our school board [Word?]. We got grants under my leadership under the league of women voters on civic [Indiscernible]. It has been a beautiful. Beautiful history and the process the league uses to get to the possessions they take on consensus building is remarkable and I have taken that with me wherefore I go. I am so very proud to stand with you and honor you are so enlightened you even let men be members. Yes, and yes and ome served on the board. Absolutely. Who is next? >> after that. >> wonderful I love the league I ot to work with you when I was a school board member and we all have different experiences. I was so happy to find a civic organize saeurgs willing to sue. Normally they are hesitant. But no. You guys were front and center with a complaint. In that case, it was about the changes made in florida law that limited our ability to limit our high school students to vote and we took it all the way to the supreme court and it was some difficult years where sadly we lost a lot of students who did I want just didn't register and took on what seemed like an easy task getting the state of florida recognize a digital registration to vote, but that took a decade. So, it has been a minute. But thankfully, now we can afford, you know, the students the opportunity to do it in a myriad of different ways. I want to thank you for your commitment and all the time spent at the table registering whether it is high school students or recently, you know, people who just became citizens. I have been there with you guys doing that. It really is a labor of love. I know it is a lot of time and a lot of time away from your families. Tremendous advocacy and it does change people's lives. We know if they don't register they won't consider it and we loose them after a certain amount of time. Thank you for that. Thank you for suing. [Laughter]. >> florida law is better for it. Thank you. [Applause] >> I don't think I have ever heard that before. Have you? >> I will be brief. I want to thank you all for advocacies. The issues you wear about aren't specific to women. They help shape what florida is and who we are. That type of advocacy is important. In that way, you are not just representing women. You are representing us all. Thank you very much. >> thank you. >> everybody has their reasons for [Word?] The league of women voters. I love the league of women voters that was my first ever invitation to speak. I remember that -- oh. >> catalyst miami was born from the league of women voters. So, thank you ladies. >> there you go. >> no. I'm not going to go back to the lawsuit. Commissioner mcghee. [Laughter]. >> I'm good. >> okay. So thank you ladies, you are very special. What you have done, thank GOD you did it. And you continue to do and represent in the best of ways. We are very proud of you. for that reason, we have the presentation. >> we most certainly do. Ladies of the league, come on up. Okay. And so, come over here. On behalf of the mayor, our CHAIRMAN Of the board of county commissioner our vice CHAIRMAN And all the rest of us, we want to thank you for your service and we want to officially declare the 60th anniversary of the league of women voters in miami-dade county. Congratulations and thank you. [Applause] >> okay. Shall we have a few words from the league? Who would like to speak, let's go. Thank you. Thank you o much. >> on behalf of the league of women voters this means absolutely the world to us. Who have worked with our organization it truly is so incredible to see the progress of the league. Thank you all so much. It means the world to us. >> you are very welcome. >> all right, ladies, thank you, thank you. Okay. We ready? There you go. All right. Our next presentation, I guess all of us but especially these three standing next to me right now have a presentation and I know we have a procedural matter later on. And then after we open the meeting and so on, we can deal with the resolution. For right now. I would like a very dear friend of mine. A person I have known for basically my career in the political world and he has a great history. Those of you that know him, he is the type of person that takes on every challenge and does not look away from it. Says what he believes in and stands y it. I have always admired the principles he brought when he left portugal and got on a ship and didn't know if it would make its destination. He did so and is really the store of immigrant and success of one too. We all care about him. So it is time to bring you up. My deer friend alberto cravalho. I know he is going on to other pastures, but he is going to be missed here in dade county. With that who wants to lead us off. >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN, some of us will look at MR. Carvalho and think of the superintendant of the year. Some will think of extraordinary teacher and activist for children and families all throughout our county. I look at him and think we are brothers. He is one of my best friends and our tprpbd ship was born not of -- we don't like to play golf together. We like to change the community together. I love the way the CHAIRMAN Said he is going on to other pastures. Not greener pastures nothing is better than us. We are miami-dade county. I am not only great for for my son and my family but the residents of this community. When we stand here all together and you will get several presentations together. We stand here not representing the 13 people that sit on a dias and make decisions we are representing the 2.8 million people for the people you have benefitted and loved. I want to say thank you for me. Commissioner. [Applause] >> without a question, your press sense is going to be missed without question every house hold in miami-dade county has been effected in a positive way because of your leadership. The leadership that comes to mind that we know of you due to your diligence and hard ork in the community is servant leadership. Because of that, you have increased the educational gains, grown our community as it relates to generational wealth because of education. On a personal note, the relationship I have with you and what you have done for me and my family and my friend in helping us over a decade would never go unrecognized. With that said, I want to say personally thank you on behalf of the residents but also on behalf of my son, daughter and wife who couldn't be here this morning also. [Applause] >> so, we all put in -- the reason the chair said there would be multiple presentations is we all put in for different presentations when alberto announced he was leighing us. You all MAY love him but I got to spend the most time with him. There you have it. As a former school board member. My colleagues complain I am a little aggressive. He can tell you that I am on best behavior. When I got elected to the school board it was like a bull in a china shop. [Laughter]. >> and he was wonderful about it. And we went through some difficult times. We had very difficult times at the district. I think everybody focuses on the awards and how great our students are doing, but we were in the trenches when they cut the education budget by a billion dollars and we had to make very difficult choices. He did everything that he could with the support of the board to make sure we kept every single teacher and ensured every single student was receiving resources. It wasn't just a difficult moment. It was difficult years and there was a lot of things that had to change. As someone who was there, I want to thank him for his fortitude even when he sent me here to the county to fix me the [Word?] And nicknamed me a hurricane when I came back. We got it done. It wasn't always easy but we got things done for our students and on a personal note, as many of you know, iran for a position on the chool board when I my daughter was diagnosed with autism and a lot of people didn't now that a few weeks after that article came out, my son was also diagnosed. Albeto was not only wonderful helping me through that process but allowing us to really change the dynamics in terms of the services with e provide for children on the spectrum and their families. He was always supportive and ready to lead and done an amazing amount of work in miami-dade county. I always told folks he couldn't stay forever and people were shocked when he heard he was leaving. He was made superintendant very young. It only made sense that he would go on to bigger districts where he could make a lot more changes. I look forward to that. Obviously [Word?] Made a soerpblg for the best superintendant in the united states and they found him. I am excite today see what ou do in california. I'm sure they will love you. You are always miamiian don't sell your place. We love you. >> I heard they don't wear suits anymore they wear sandals and short shorts. It is interesting because although in service, we know how important the school system is, I think I am the newest parent of all of us here. The way that I interacted with the school system changed once I became a parent. And it is very interesting to me, my wife became a teacher and after that, I heard everything about the school system from that day and then everything after that changed again once I became a parent. And at that time, ou know, started fighting. And it was beneficial to me to be able to reach out to you and say how do I navigate these waters. Undoubtablely I understand that your children's education is probably the most important decision you ake and no decision is right or wrong. It is just different. Because of the confidence that I have in the miami-dade county school system. The public school system and he role this gentleman has played in it. I feel like we made an important and great decision for our children. It is so interesting to me because my children -- one of them recognizes who the superintendant is. At five years old I couldn't do that. I couldn't identify anybody beyond my mediate family. So I am just -- I am grateful for that. I am thankful for that. It is our loss that we are going to miss you. And now that we are going to MISS You, I just hope that the new superintendant which is wonderful as well is able to have such a meaningful impact on our community like you have. Thank you very much. >> thank you. Continue this way. >> well, when we are done writing this current chapter of miami-dade county story, it will be stated that alberto crvalho is, was one of the best strongest and most strategic architect in our community. And, I say that because I remember my kids grew up in con tkpwre tkpwraeugsal schools. When my wife and I were decided to make that switch and allow them to know their community better, the larger society better in high school, we didn't hesitate a minute to transition them to our public school system. And today, they are both professionals in our community. And, makes -- all of us very proud and that's because of you, sir. That's because of you. So, our community loves and appreciates you because you have impacted -- you have made the greatest impact in our community. You have impacted our children. I know you and I cried together when there are issues in our community that we would try to present that we could not because certain things are not beyond our control. And, but, we see the effect as well of what you have done. And we [Indiscernible] Of you. The great hing about you is you know it is always good to leave while at the top, and you are currently at the top. And of course, you are the envy of all other school systems in our country and that's right. And again, I think it will be stated again, I know it will be that you are one of the best and strategic change architects our community has ever known and thank you for that. [Applause] >> well, this is -- it is a sad day for us. It is a wonderful day for you because you are going on to help more children and MS. Regalado said we all knew you couldn't stay forever. I don't think you are wholly leaving us either. That is really what great leaders do. They create a legacy that lives long past when they were part of an organization. You are leaving us a wonderful school system. More importantly, you have left us with thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands of residents who know what it means to live decently in our community. To work hard to make this place better and there is literally an army of people that have graduated from miami-dade public school system that is are working here in our communities and make a difference whether it is in our hospitals or as a teacher, an attorney. They are here and they are here to stay in part due to your great leadership. It isn't just about education but about integra ity we know the kids f la are going to e better off once you are done with them too. Congratulations on moving and we are sorry to see you go [Applause] >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN and superintendant and it is bittersweet to see you leaving miami-dade county public schools and leaving this community. It is sweet to know what you have been able to accomplish here. We have noun each other for a good 20 year ifs not more when I was in the state house and you were deposition superintendant I think. We have not always been on the same side. But the reality is we have both been on the same side of the children of this community. Pushing children instead of eeninging the bar down to children, you elevated that bar and made sure you gave the children the resources no matter what the community they live ed in to push them up. That's what a leader does. You believed in your teachers and staff and this is why we have one of the best education systems in the country. And that is a testimony to your leadership to you believing in the people around you and empowering the right people. MR. Superintendant, my friend, thank you, thank you, thank you for your years of service in this kphaoubty. Thank you for fighting the fight in tallahassee.Community. Thank you for fighting the fight in tallahassee. Making sure that the bcb issue is never forgotten. You continuously fight for that. We appreciate your service and we wish you GOD speed. GOD bless you my friend. [Applause] >> MR. Superintendant, if I were truly the strong mayor, I could keep you here. Because I have been asked on -- I have been asked -- I told you during the martin luther king parade multiple people didn't really want to talk to me except please couldn't I make you stay. And i was sad to tell them I did not have that power. We will have to amend the charter. But, I also have a very personal connection to you as a prson, you are an extraordinary person, we all know that. What you have over come in your own life. You are the e pit my of the american dream and story. That has been a beacon of hope for so many. You have proven time and time again make the changes necessary. It is truly amazing that you are beloved not only by the children but by the teachers, administrators by your vendors, by the public. Universally recognized what you have done for our community. With all of that. Maybe not everybody knows as well that you are a great dancer. So I just want the record to reflect, yeah. I think our parties are better. We will find out. But, we will MISS You so much. Thank you o much, MR. Superintendant. >> okay. Now we have a couple of presentations. But, before we do I know this is very hard for you. It is extremely hard. Some of us are facing our departure in 9 months. But, when you love the community the way you do, that I know you do, this is extremely hard. You made a decision for you and your family that I will always respect, but I'm like the mayor I want you to stay here. With that, why don't you say some words. >> thank you very much, MR. Chair, MADAM Mayor, commissioners and quite frankly so many friends I see in the audience including [Name?] Who was my associate superintendant. So many people I developed relationships with. True friendships. Kindred hearts. You are brothers and sisters. You have served together in so many roles. Many of you are close, close friends. Close friends. My sister of many years, my late night agony. My early morning joy. And you are right MR. Chair. This is a tough moment that is an emotional roller costar. It is bittersweet. But it was said in life you make decisions that are sometimes not necessarily as convenient for you but have the potential to move the needle of humanity. But, that's what I am doing. No body pushed me out. I cannot be ushed out. No body forced me out. I cannot be forced out. I think that's -- [Applause] >> I think the system is in remarkable condition. A rated school system for multiple years. We just announced graduation rates and that rate was 58 percent when I started this work with my team. It is now as of two weeks ago, 94 percent. [Applause] >> I leave this school system with zero f zero d rated schools. [Applause] >> number one school system in america in advanced placement performance. Recognized arguably as the best urban district in america. I owe that to our teachers, our leaders, supporters. This county commission, our school board there has never been a ime when we didn't come here asking for support for your advocacy on big issues. Whether it was a bond referendum or referendum for teacher salary that is you did not support. My success, our district's success has been your success. I close by saying thank you, thank you, thank you for all of your words. I have educated some of your children. I actually signed their diploma. It is time to elevate the dignity of humanity and the potential of the kids in los angeles. The reason hy I am there is because what we did here. They would not want me there if they did not want miami's results. [Applause] >> and, east cost or west coast, they are beautiful children with all the same GOD given talent and community that needs to be surfaced. The journey will continue here. I am not selling my house. It is my house. I am moving to los angeles and I will be the superintendant in los angeles, but in as much as icon tin use to open my heart to la. My heart will never close to our community of miami-dade. My last sentence. Only in america. [Applause] >> only in america could a poor undocumented first o graduate high school out of six undocumented once homeless blocked away from where today I serve today as superintendant in miami-dade. Thank you and GOD bless you all. >> thank you and now we have two presentations. >> it is actually ironic. One of the first things I got to the school board is limit proclamations because they were taking too much time. Ere we use them to honor people that were spectacular. We couldn't let you get away without making it alberto carvalho day. There you go signed by all of us. >> and thank you. And one of our colleagues who was actually heading o tallahassee right now commissioner sosa said tell you tell the soup, I want to make sure he will always be able to come home. And so on behalf of miami-dade county commission, we now present to you the key to the county. So while you are in california, you always have a key back home. [Applause] [Music] >> sergeant t arms. Ladies and gentlemen, please take a seat. One more time. I need everybody to sit down, please. Take your seat. On my left, please sit down. Sorry for a little bit of a delay. We got everything fixed. Equipment. So let's do the -- hold on. MADAM Clerk call it out please. >> good morning. Commissioner higgins. Commissioner hardemon, commissioner heyman, commissioner higgins, commissioner martinez, commissioner mcghee, commissioner monestime, commissioner regalado, kphegs tpher so to and sosa will be out of today's meeting. Have is CHAIRMAN Gillbert. >> CHAIRMAN Diaz. >> you have 10 members present, you have a quorum. >> thank you. Koultd you lead us in prayer.Could you >> GOD of everyone, every time and every place, today we petition your grace, guidance and wisdom. Help us your resources and land for your people, amen. >> CHAIRMAN. >> MADAM Attorney, good morning. Madams attorney. >> good morning MR. Chair. >> I do have a motion also, MR. Chair. >> okay. There is a motion that the commissioner -- are we okay? We open the meeting, we have quorum? >> yes, sir. >> okay. >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN, and thank you to my colleagues here. At this particular moment, I make a moment 11a5 sub taout and to defer to 2/15,/2022. >> second. >> I have a motion, point of order. >> give me one moment. I have a motion by commissioner mcghee and second by commissioner martinez. Oint of order? >> I need to know what the practical effect of this is on the amendments that were added on the last time and procedurally this puts us because I have some concerns. >> yes, MR. Vice chair. >> MADAM Attorney, I wanted to get clarification so everybody could hear it. Anybody somebody could at least hear things and come back and whatever, that's good too. >> MR. Chair, this is an in essence two motions the first motion is to recorr the item. 11a5 substitute that was approved aat the time last commission meeting. The vice chair 11a5 substitute was approved as amended. There were a number of amendment that is were proffered the motion to reconsider if approved would null identify the board's prior action. The item hat was aboard the board n JANUARY 19th would the amendment would be the item before this board. The next motion if I understood commissioner mcghee he would like to defer item 11a5 substitute to the FEBRUARY 15th meeting. And then at that point in time, that substitute would be before the board, and, you know, at that point any motion is appropriate on the 15th for the board to under take. >> so, yeah. Basically, it goes back to -- the first -- to bring it back and defer two motions. At that time, the person could either meet with the mayor or o over different things and accept the different amendments and bring it back. How would that work. >> that's correct MR. Chair t sponsor could amend is item further. We could prepare substitute number two if he should decide to meet with the mayor between now and when the item comes back on the 15th and that can incorporate the abmendments that were previously approved. And the additional amendment the sponsor wishes to present the body. >> thank you MADAM, attorney. I got t cleared. I wanted to make sure that was the case. >> MR. CHAIRMAN, to the making of the motion and sponsor of the item. This is my trepidation. I wouldn't have voted for the original item. The amendments are why the original item was pal kwraoubl. So i don't know if I am in the support of reconsidering the original item if I don't have assurances that all of the amendments are going to be back on the item and additionally -- this is -- I'm not much for kicking the can down the road here. We need to know with regard to this item. Are we going to be able to put the maintenance facility there and colocate that with the entertainment district. If we are I am up for all the time you need. If we are not, I am not for deferring this decision. >> thank you. >> you are recognized commissioner mcghee. >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN and absolutely I can tell to commissioner gillbert the amendments that were brought about on 1/19. All of those amendments will remain. None of those are going away. Secondly due to the nature of a veto that happened on a saturday which forced us to do more workover the weekend and bring us here on a tuesday in addition to the conversation with the community leaders last night on the zoom call with her staff, my staff and the clergy and other leaders of the south. We came to the conclusion those of us on that call that a negotiation must continue to happen. In my understanding and reading the veto she had trepations in three areas the first area was throrpbt we had sufficient amount of timeidations in three areas the first area was throrpbt we had sufficient amount of time to negotiate that was dealt with and hand handled while talking with commissioner monestime. We ere able to modify the item to include an additional time period of up to 180 days. Secondly as it relates to whether or not the maintenance facility is oing to be or not going o be on the particular site, that is not a question that today I have an answer for. But, what I can tell you is I am not opposed to the maintenance facility going on this site alongside the entertainment district. That is why more negotiation is needed. I do know also after speaking with the mayor twice in preparation for the item 11a5, I do know she brought forth a package, a facility that was actually built out in canada that maintained a maintenance tpa sellty and other items she wanted. I did say to her without a question that is something we can negotiate and I am not oppose today the maintenance facility. I am saying allow for the interested parties to negotiate the terms of what it looks like, where it will be, and how it will come about. I then positioned to the mayor and gave her two other projects that were built out in las vegas and other areas how a maintenance facility can benefit the community in a way that does not leave an eyesore in the community. As it relates to your question, I am not oppose today it. I am saying negotiation can continue and should cntinue. Lastly. You brought up the question about the acreage. I can tell you as we look through the packages and I poke with the mayor, originally, we were at zero. We didn't want this to be a copartnership because of the fact that we were looking to bring about economic development to our community. A community that has been left out for the past 30 years. A community that needs an economic development injection into its arm to push the south forward. That was the mission. When I met with the mayor, I said that to her. That I m willing based upon the reports and experts I have been able to speak with from across this country and some of the reports rovided that I am willing to come off the zero, zero that was found within the original legislation and at least begin negotiations with 8 acres. Based upon the report she provided to this dias is at minimum they need 8 structures on that property that comes up to about 6 acres. From that particular moment, what we also realized was if six is what is being called for with the specification of those structures, I did not think 8 was unreasonable. Instead of going 8, the mayor and I met and she said I need 20 at minimum 15. That's what she said. I said, you know, last night on the phone call with all the numbers -- many of the numbers from the south. I said you know what MADAM Mayor, I will move from 8 to 15 acres what you asked for. During the call last night the mayor made it very clear, she wanted something that was closer to 15. And that is what I agreed to do at the floor. That is exactly what I did -- that is exactly agreed to at the floor. So, MR. Vice CHAIRMAN, I hope that answers your question. >> thank you MR. CHAIRMAN. And that was a lot of detail. I think the mayor is reaching for the microphone. Independent of that. This is where we are. We were at zero, now we are -- we were at 8 and now we are at 15. The administration. What is the least amount of acres. >> let me stop a little bit of this. I don't think this is a moment to negotiate this. I think is a moment to allow a vote to take place and let them negotiate this clear. I don't think he is going to go n public record and say something that is not correct. To the actual vote. I will entertain two of my colleagues, go ahead. >> actually still had the to take place, but I am not for this idea that we are going to get this and it is going to drag out and impasse. That's why I am asking for clarification from the administration. It MAY effect how some of us actually vote. We definitely want to find a way to be deferential to our colleague, so that's why we are asking for this information. >> commissioner monestime followed by commissioner heyman. >> thank you MR. Chair. I think it is that business to ry to negotiate a deal on this die I can'ts. I am always against that -- I don't know. But, what I need to understand first. I need the county attorney's office to tell me whether procedurally this is properly before us. The commissioner from district 9 suggested arlier -- made the statement earlier, there is a veto message at [Word?]. And my understanding is the vie -- the consideration of the saoe toe is supposed to be the first thing before us and now, we are negotiating the item again. So, is this procedurally properly before us. I know a reconsideration is always given priority in some cases. Why in this case is it up for veto. I could have lost 11 years when I could have used that every time to expand my negotiation with the administration. >> you are recognized attorney. >> you are correct that the veto is the first matter the board should consider. However, a motion to reconsider the underlying item ay be made prior to a motion to over ride the veto. Right now, the motion on the table is to reconsider 11a5 substitute from your prior meeting. That is properly before you. And should that motion be successful. The next motion would be a motion to defer. >> now, you stated earlier that if the board accepts -- votes in tpaeur of this reconsideration, the board's last action what does that nullification mean? I mean, is it just, you know a deferral f the item? Is it a new item should be drafted. Is it that giving the commissioner more time to negotiate with the mayor, what oes that full if I education mean. >> should it be approved 11a 5rbgs substitute as was before this board on JANUARY 19th is the item now before the board today. And the board could make any motion with respect to 11a5 substitute at that time including a motion to defer. >> my position at the last board meeting commissioner is I supported the item simply because I understand there was no convenient [Word?] Place. There was no finality to the decisions. It is liking asking the mayor to report something back. But at this time, I think this is honestly -- this reassures my position earlier that this is one approach to this. Like I said last time. I have brought many deals to the administration that are negotiated prior to bringing an item to the board and [Indiscernible] You need two willing parties. From the last item, the mayor -- the administration stated clearly, they are not willing to negotiate on this item. So, I think if you don't get this -- if the board entertains this veto today I think that will be your best alternative. Pushing the mayor's hand in negotiating to you over an item. They don't want to negotiate, I don't see what that accomplishes. Basically, what I am trying to say is the following, they have to be willing to negotiate with you. So, what are the [Word?] Of this transaction. You are at an impasse before it begins. That's why I don't want to negotiate here. I don't think I can support the reconsideration of this item. >> commissioner heyman. >> thank you MR. Chair. MADAM Attorney, and then I would like to hear from the mayor briefly. Briefly on both actually. A veto is before us, and that is the first thing. We have had situations before where someone calls a question, makes a motion, and then you have to entertain something just because it came up first. Procedurally, there is a way of doing things. I am just concerned about it. We seem to recreate and reinvent what has worked and what has been a structure in our government all along. I am please today hear from the long explanation how much effort went into negotiations now when we did amendments and it was set forth on something, but it wasn't concluded. I have heard your explanations. I understand what you want commissioner mcghee. I see this beyond your district to all transportation in south dade because that's how some of us voted on the past for it. As a smart plan for the whole region and that was sold my commissioner moss as economic development without bankrupting the smart plan dollars for every other option in some other places. I didn't have a dog in the fight. North dade is kored by its three districts. It is not one district on transportation. My concern MADAM Attorney is holding up this veto and taking up a reconsideration first, what does that do time wise? Because, we can say anything here, but you can't lock in what comes before us if something comes before us or anything else guaranteed the next date. Is that correct? >> any item can be amended. This board can amend any item going forward. Would you like me to address your first question as well. >> sure. >> you are correct that the first subs at that difficult item this board should consider is the veto. A motion to reconsider is procedural and that takes precedence over the veto. >> understood, but okay. We can make motions before everything else and throw us askew on anything. >> hank you commissioner martinez. >> wait. Briefly since we heard a good compelling argument. >> commissioner hey hey you have more questions. >> yes, thank you MR. Chair. Briefly to the statement that there was no negotiations as of yesterday. I heard that it was like seemed to be almost proposed split and wasn't agreed. Mayor, where were we? Were you an agreeing negotiating party or not. That would make an answer for me. >> I ust need to start by emphasizing I was the commissioner in the south. Have I been a strong advocate for economic develop in the south. Have I made it very clear that I support the economic development concepts nd proposals that are coming forward from the commissioner mcghee. But, what I had to do and I think we clearly laid it out in the veto, hi to take that step in time because the resolution as it was passed did not give us what we need today build the transportation infrastructure committed to by the smart plan. We will always consider conversations. I think that the veto is to start fresh. I am prepared to start fresh. I think we will get there shortly and I am prepared to consider the negotiations. We cannot delay further on this transportation intphra tprubg khur. >> thank you. >> commissioner martinez. >> good morning. The way I understood it MADAM Attorney, this is right now if the reconsideration is accepted there is no item in front of us. >> if the reconsideration is approved 11a5 substitute is before you. Stkpwhraop then he requested a referral. >> and any motion can be made after the fact. Commissioner mcghee has requested referral. >> I was just guessing so the commissioner could get with the mayor and come to some agreement and we could never see this in our current form and we could vote it up or down again. Am I wrong? Is that -- >> if it is approved it is up to the sponsor. The item will come back and the sponsor could present it as is or with amendment z as presented at the last meeting that. Would happen on FEBRUARY 15th, not today. >> I don't think two weeks is going to kill anything. If I comes back or not. That's why I supported he motion to reconsider and a deferral because it is two weeks from now. They can't get together in two weeks what is in front of us again. Thank you. >> guys, I gave everybody one shot. I will give everybody one shot. But we can't consider on. We need to take the vote commissioner cohen higgins. >> thank you MR. Chair. The way I see this and I want to thank the district commissioner what seems to be and strong concessions here. At our last meeting we spent almost an hour on this particular item. My concern with the motion to reconsider now is not only undoing all of that even though he said he would accept all of those. My concern is if the item comes before us and we vote again. The mayor vetoed the item for a specific reason and it is the first mayor veto we have had. This one was vetoed and the concern I hear coming from the administration administration is number one time which deferral would complicate that and an issue of acreage. The administration as I understand it is indicating they need 20 acres you conceded ou will grow to 15. In in my mind I am listening to you and my colleagues. This becomes a dispute or disagreement over five acres. If that is accurate, I am open from either the attorneys or you as district commissioner on how we can most efficiently get to resolve on those five acres without crippling or compromising the transit solutions that you and I both DECEMBER prebgtly need and want for the residents of south dade. I am going to propose I will is entertain a motion to reconsider 11a5 with all of the amendments that this board discussed but also with the addition of the acreage being provided to the administration so they can move forward with the project. At least 15 acres moving forward so they are not delayed. That is the proposal I have. I don't know if that is acceptable or growable to the administration. I do see this as a compromise I would like to lay on the table. Thank you so much, MR. Chair. >> with that. We could go on and on. >> just 20 seconds. >> hold on one second. Hold on. Commissioner mcghee is want to -- >> as you -- >> r. Monestime, one second, please. Please hold. >> MR. Monestime response and then I will give you the floor. >> thank you. Absolutely that is very much acceptable those terms. >> okay. Commissioner monestime. >> commissioner mcghee this is what I am worried. The development agreement is not just about the land. There is many, many other components. My issue is that when this item comes back, it comes back at another -- as another resolution seeking to continue negotiation with the mayor. That's my issue. I think if we go -- if the item -- if the item is deferred indefinitely and you enter negotiation the developer enters negotiation with the mayor you come back with a deal that you and the mayor agree on before this board. I agree with that. Bringing this back as an item okay we agree on the size of the property that should be developed but there is no development agreement on it. I'm not ready for that. It is not just about the land r five acres or 20 acres or 30 acres. I need to know this item comes back here and there is a eal that was negotiated by your office, by your administration, by the developer in question and then we help you bring -- well economic development. >> commissioner, it was just a second. And I allowed you to say what you did. >> thank you MR. Chair. >> ladies and gentlemen, at this point. I think there was a [Word?] Made by one commissioner nd accepted by another moving forward. This is a very awkward position for me. Honestly, I just want things to work out. Sometimes we have had issues here where we have stopped and negotiated and it has come out for the good. So, this is one way to stop the proceeder I guess and allow it. I have commissioner higgins followed by ommissioner hardemon. They have not spoken. >> the attorney has priority for clarification. >> of course she does. >> I don't have priority but I. >> in my eyes you do. >> thank you. I would like to clarify, if I understand commissioner mcghee's consent what is now on the table would be a motion to reconsider follow hreed by a motion to approve 11a5 substitute as amended to include all the amendments that he originally made to the item on JANUARY 19th plus the additional amendment suggested by commissioner cohen higgins regarding the acreage on the site. I want to clarify what is motions on the table. >> MADAM Attorney, that is correct. >> okay. Before we move forward. MADAM Mayor, she has been waiving her and quite a bit. >> thank you MR. Chair and commissioner mcghee for coming forward to work together to resolve this matter and to everyone who has had a chance to reply. I believe that the statement made by commissioner cohen higgins with 15 as a minimum does accommodate our needs. Would ask we also specify that the department -- the administration can come back immediately with the 20 acres, up to 20, because we cannot delay this bus project while we are negotiating the entire process. We need to move forward on the bus facility if we can work on identifying that acreage and not delaying it while we are doing negotiation. That will give us the flexibility that we need and the matter be heard on MARCH 1st that will give us enough time to work through the details. >> thank you MADAM Mayor. Commissioner higgins. You need to add more and commissioner hardemon, I will entertain, I think there is a motion to my right. I got it. Okay. Everybody has to speak at least once. And the senator too. Commissioner higgins. >> thank you MR. Chair, good morning, everybody. As I see it, we have two things going on and we have a very large piece of property that will allow us to achieve two goals. Advancing an efficient operation of our transit system in the most cost effective manner and it has been evaluated over the course of two years by the department. And then we have another just about 30 acres -- 27 acres that can be used for some interesting and innovative economic development. It could be whatever the folks in the south of south dade believe is right for the residents. We have two separate things and right now they are trapped in one item. A deferral that brings this back where the transportation item is connected to the economic development evaluation. He item as we amended it -- the mayor didn't come back with a report for six months which leaves our bus maintenance facility trapped for six months. We do need to get to the point. The mayor has been very clear and let's remember that actions as my mother said actions speak louder than words and the mayor has acted with her veto. And you know she listens to us very thoughtfully and allowed us to pass a few things she doesn't agree with. In her actions she has stated very clearly these 20 acres are need ed. It is not 15, it is 2. And for me, until we have two separate items where the 20 acres are moving forward as quickly and organized as possible we need to get our submission to the fta. We have done our environmental studies to have that trapped is what we passed last time as the mayor and commissioner mcghee are negotiating on the entertainment complex and that report might not come back for six months. We can do both things. We can look for a good economic opportunity that involves opportunity on the 27 acres and MADAM Mayor if you can get it to 18 and a half I would respect you could do so responsibly so commissioner mcghee could use as much as possible for the economic development. I cannot vote for two weeks. I don't think any of these issues will be resolved. Think it needs to be considered in a thoughtful fashion. Thank you MR. Chair I appreciate the time. >> thank you. Commissioner hardemon and then the vice CHAIRMAN And then commissioner regalado and garcia. Senator got you. >> first a few questions for our county attorney. Please help me understand what we are considering. First, my question. When we look at what the mayor vetoed, what is the title of that item that she vetoed? >> you want me to read the title? >> at least -- yes so it can be distinguished from what motion commissioner mcghee is making. >> the item that was approved was 11a5 substitute and it was a resolution directing the mayor to take steps necessary pursuant to 120. >> 11a5 substitute the motion made today was a motion to reconsider what? >> 11a5 substitute was adopted as amended by this board on JANUARY 19th and the motion to reconsider was to reconsider that item that the board adopted. >> so we are reconsidering the motion -- or the item that the mayor has already vetoed. >> your rules allow or a reconsideration of the item. If that item is reconsidered, then that item is back before you and the mayor's veto of the item is mute. >> and I guess that's the part that I am having trouble finding the support for within at least our procedures. Can you help direct me to the space where you find the support that helps me understand that? Because, I am reading from page 6 it says not withstanding any other rule of the commission [Indiscernible] Provided in rule 5.05c and not be deferred to a future meeting. Four, not be subject to a motion to reconsider. Except at the same meeting. Five not required first reading. Six not required publication and/or additional public hearing and not be amended if the item requires special pblication. I would agree that it could be subject to a motion to reconsider, but at the same meeting. But I don't think that is the same meeting that motion occurred on. Help me understand where you find the support so I am right in my procedure. >> yes, commissioner hardemon subparagraphs one, two, and three that you read. Those deal with the motion to over ride such that and then 4 through 7 actually deal with he underlying item that was vetoed. >> show me which page are you reading from? >> I am reading -- you are reading from subsection e. >> correct. Part 8. >> correct. And so, the portion that deals with not be subject to a motion to reconsider except at the same meeting. That is to -- that refers back to the item that was actually vetoed. Meaning this meeting. To the extent that the item that was vetoed. If a board wishes o reconsider it. They could do so today and that's consistent with the board's other rules regarding reconsideration which allow this board to reconsider any item whether it is at the ame meeting or the subsequent meeting. This meeting today is the same meeting. That is also been consistent with this board's past practice when we had similar situations with respect to ob/c/ opo'' ' 33s{}| ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? _ h 08x __ _ ?_ xx888x8x8__ _x8_x _ @` x ??|/ 5~ 5v 5~5v5v 1~5v5v1v5~5~ 2v5~ 5v5~ 5~ 5v5~ 5v5v5~ 5~ 4~5~5v5v5~5v5v5~ 5v1v5~5v5~5v5~5v 5~5v5v5v 5~5v5v5~1~5v 5v5v5v 5v5~5v 5~5v5~5~ 5v5~ 5~5v5~5~5v1~ 2v5v5v5v5~ 5~5v5v 5v2v1~5v 5~ 5v5~5~ 5v5~5v 5~5v5~1~ 5v5~5v 5v5v5v5v5~ 5v5v5v5v5v5v 5~5v5~5v 5v 5~ 5v5v5~5~5v 5v5~ 5v5v5v 5v1~5~5v5v5v5v5~5v 5v5v5v 5v5~ 5~5v5v5~ 5v5~5~5v 1v 5v 1v5v5~ 5~5~5v5v1~5v5~ 5v 5~ 5v5v 5~5~ 5~5v 2~5v5v5v1~ 5~5v5v 5v2~5v5~5~5v5v5~5~5~ 5~ 5v5v5~5v 5~5~5~ 5v5v5~5~ 1~5v 5~ 5v 4v1v5~ 5~ !~)~!~!~ 5~1~5v5v5~ 5v1~ 5~ 5v 5~1v 5~1~ 0v5~5~ 1~5v 1~5~ 5v5~ 5~5v5~ 5v5~5~ 5~5~1~1v 5v5~5v5~ 5~ 5v5~ 5~ 4v 5~5~ 5~5v 5v5~ 5~ 4~5~ 5~5~ 5v 5~5~5v5~ !~!~+~!~!~!~!~!~!~ !~!~!~!~!~!~!~-~%~!~!~!~!~+~!~!~ -~ !~!~!~!~ -~ !~!~!~!~!~!~ !~-~!~!~ !~!~!~!~!~ ppp0@ pppppppp``` `@ 00p0pp0ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp0pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppa5@5@5 a8 `=@Ppp @`ppppp !~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~)~!~!~)~)~!~!~)~/~!~ !~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~ !~!~!~!~-~ #~#~ !~ b@b@b3BBCaCaap pPppp8p8p8p8p8p8p8pXppppXp0p0pppp ppp4Pp4p0p0p0p0p0pp ppp p p b @ c @ a@ ` aaa`ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp@ ppppppp Apppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp p '<'< ppppppppppppppppp ~?~? Ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp @pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppPppppppppPPpppPpPPppPPPppppPpppp pPpppppPppppppPp ppPPpp PppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppPpPpppppppppppppppppppppp00000000000000000000ppppppppppppppppPPPPpppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp pppppppppppppppppppppppppppPpPp0g@@ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppPPpppppppppppppppppPppp p Cx#< c@pppPppppppp pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppPpppppppppppPppPppppppPpppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp@p@p@p@pLp@pLp@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@p@pLp@p@p@p@p@p@p@pppppppppppppp`@ ! C (_ gca` CCa pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp ?M >> then we change the item and defer it then there is no obligation to negotiate just as if we support the veto there is no obligation to negotiate. there's nothing on the table right now that would lead us to the point of negotiation so I'm confused that both of the parties involved are saying the negotiation is going to continue because there can be no negotiation without the authority of this body. So it doesn't make sense. >> okay. >> with that, MADAM Attorney, she wanted to answer your questions. Go ahead. And then I'll follow to the vice-CHAIRMAN. >> yes. >> I mean, senator and then vice-CHAIRMAN. >> I think it's important to clarify. The motion as stated currently is first a motion to reconsider. And then I understood chair mcghee -- the motion to amend today would be to include all the amendments that were before this board substitute as aapproved last meeting plus the additional amendments that have been discussed. Hich at the end we could -- we would like to re restate for the record to make sure that everybody understands what those amendments are. So I hope that clarifies it, commissioner regalado. I believe the motion is to amend. >> so we would have to amend and vote again so that there would be an obligation o negotiate. Now, what I never understood about this item and I said it when we voted it on it the first time around we have procurement systems. We have an unsolicited proposal and an rfp. This is like an other. So my question to the attorney is -- and I said this at the beginning, that there is no end to it. Like what happens if you reach an impasse. So clearly sent to negotiate. That was effectuated. We reached an impasse. And the solution to that impasse was a veto. That veto brought us here and now, we're negotiate ing again and send sending it back how do we ensure -- you guys could talk for another two weeks and then the mayor could veto. So is there going to be in this amended item some sort of vehicle to deal with impasse that does not bring us back to this board to play mini mediator? >> cmmissioner, regalado, I think both parties the veto party and the amending, the person that made the is the maker of this motion in the first place have come, I think to somewhat of a consent based on what commissioner -- if also a way to negotiate and a way to get clarity and done, I don't think two weeks is going to really -- commissioner gilbert: that completed makes sense so we're not -- we're doing something -- that's not procedural gymnastics, that's procedural fiction. We just -- we made that up. So I think if we're going to do this we should wave the rule and then do it. So if we're going to do that. With regard to whether we're going to be back here in the same position I think we probably are but I think that the best way of not being back here is to give them actual time to negotiate. Time that won't complicate our issues, and time that -- so instead of FEBRUARY, I think the MARCH date would be a better date, if we're going to defer it to the MARCH day. Then if it comes back in MARCH and need to reconsider this there needs to be finality. We know what the deal breakers are. So we need some aggreance that the deal breakers won't be deal breakers. I know said 15 acres needed at minimum, the mayor is saying they need a minimum of 20, I don't know they need 20, they need at most 20. So at most they should be able to get 20. If they can't at most get 20 then yeah, we will be back here again because I don't want to be back here now, it's 15, now, it's 17 but we really need 19 and a half so we can't build a thing. That would just be a waste of time. So at most 20 and let's reconsider this and let's get onto the rest of the business. >> these kind of procedural issues and questions that are being raised and even after commissioner regalado and senator garcia raised the points that they raised and of course commissioner hardemon made me question -- discussion on the mayor's veto versus a motion to reconsider. And the proposal that I put toward was in an effort to make a compromise between both parties and so I'd like to hear from the administration on whether or not that proposal is agreeable. If it is not I am interested, of course in getting to the veto because I believe that that is the business at hand and we have spent almost 2 hours now on this motion to reconsider that the lawyers on this have real question about whether or not it's proper and the reality of if it's reconsidered that the mayor will likely veto it and bring us back to the position where we are again which I absolutely don't want under any sort of circumstances. So, you know, if there is not an agreement somehow that can be reached where the administration gets the land that they need to move forward without delay on the bus maintenance facility, then I'm not going o be able to support the motor vehicles to re reconsider because of all of the reasons that have been stated so far. Thank you so much. CHAIRMAN Diaz: okay. With that I think we're done. Thank you, MADAM Mayor to answer the question, I think you already did but go ahead. >> I've listened very careful carefully. I appreciate all of the comments. This obviously is a very convoluted and complex discussion. I stand at the ready to negotiate. I'll do that, I think the cleanest thing is just move on start with a fresh item. I'll be there tomorrow. This is what I told the commissioner. I'll be there tomorrow starting the conversation but think we need to start clean. There's too many moving parts. It's too complicated we just need to know that we can move forward with our bus facility and with economic development and I am prepared to do that after you sustain my veto. CHAIRMAN Diaz: so clarify the motion commissioner mcghee. chairman diaz: I think it's time for us to move forward and I do respect the -- hear from a lot but I think we need to move forward. >> thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN and absolutely, MR. CHAIRMAN the motion that I previously ade in the amendments that were adopted that cohen higgins brought up I agree with those and that's pretty much where e are. As it relates to the negotiations it is reality that we are close. I've actually agreed to the items that the mayor made mention of in her veto and this is -- and I agree with the vice chair that coming back in MARCH, I do believe well have the between the two parties a resolution as it relates to this matter. And so for those reasons I'm asking for that particular motion to stand and also amended so we can come back in MARCH and finish this up. But like you said earlier this short brief period is not going to set us back at all. It just allows for them to come back one more ime to come together to get this thing resolved. And it does appear in my humble opinion based upon everything we've seen and verything we've heard that those 2 parties are very close to making this work and there hasn't been any objection thus far that I'm seeing from the 15 at minimum, 20 max, language that was actually proposed. So I don't see an issue here I just see an opportunity for us to go ahead and push that date to MARCH like vice-CHAIRMAN Stated so we can allow for them to do what they need to do. CHAIRMAN Diaz: I have a motion by commissioner martinez -- i mean by commissioner Mcghee, seconded by commissioner martinez as stated by my two come lesion -- [Multiple speakers]. >> what is the motion. CHAIRMAN Diaz: okay. >> only to reconsider. Known of those other things are what we're vote ing on, please. CHAIRMAN Diaz: right now. Okay. That's a good question to clarify, wlled. >> the first motion is a motion to reconsider. CHAIRMAN Diaz: okay. On the re reconsideration I have a motion by the commissioner mcghee, seconded by commissioner martinez. Go ahead and do roll call. [Roll] 0c 08b 8 0c 'g8g8g8g8g8sssq8p8

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners - Regular — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a97309f21aaba11f80b30d714946fc7f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record