POLISCOPE

The public record

MANATEE COUNTY SCHOOLS · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech published

School Board Workshop

Thursday, June 13, 2024 · School board meeting record

The 30-second read

Summary pending

Meeting-wide summary not available

No meeting-wide AI summary is available yet. The item-by-item board record below uses the published agenda materials.

Why it matters

The board digest below separates planned business from source-backed outcomes.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

School district

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 100,515 stored characters

i could not here. Soon enough. The story was done and the great spirit stood >> see place where the like this to come into the world. >> It seems I have great things to do and the great spirit wink that from and frog linked back. >> So >> again, I took the great spirit onto my back. But this time I had to carry Frog and Raven to as Raven could no longer fly. He done too much. You that fraud had to show the way. The load is very heavy, but I took them as I was told and did not complain. >> That must have been Taft. Toy Eagle. >> o Paolo Lee, look what really happened raving of it buy fresh salmon. >> You can stay quiet until the end of my story. 5 for 7. Make them slightly right. And you're not I could stay quiet. Just a bit of will power's on anybody can do it. You'll see. I re Vin. All right, >> Had carried the great spirit even and from as >> Good morning, everybody. Welcome to the JUNE 13 to 24 school board County Fish you want to call to order this meeting? Moved to the agenda movements that we added after publishing some of the >> presentations were updated and upload it. That was the only major agenda minutes. Moving public comments. I don't think we have any public comments. No one to sign up. Do want to to the board this workshop, the next workshop that we do I'd like to do a different public comment section I like have at the beach at every topic the public comment section after present we talking discussed, have public comment be able to sign up to be side of the line at which topic but there is nobody like today. There's nobody. So it really doesn't matter. But I'm little bit. We can change of the public comments. I'm sure they can comment after we discuss our topics in our items and things like that. So that will be for next time if there's any public >> item number 4 is our workshops item one are >> Workshop agenda today is a citizen Financial Oversight Committee annual report. We've got a folks here and I know. Chair going if you want to start us off. It's or if you want MISTER Chapman or doesn't matter to Yeah, they want to do that over to you little bit. >> Ford and superintendent, thank you for having us. I want to introduce Eric the Soviets trail. He's our newest member. And then this is our Vice chair. Now, Pauline Johnson Morning. And then we know MISTER Chapman teaser our lands on our yeah. We've been working on the to 23. Report. MISS Johnson was kind enough to put together for us and we sent it out to you. To look over. And we didn't know if you all have any questions concerns that you wanted to all are with us. >> So first. They all want. Thank you very much for what you guys do. Appreciate it. Don't get paid. He spent time on it. So thank you very much. Second, just to the I know that there's some recommendations, some charter recommendations and things like that. Which I we definitely need to adjust. And we've discussed this many times as a board. We need to look at some things center. We have a time in JULY. The whole workshop dedicated to on it. We're going to we've talked about it many times in many different workshops. I would like for today. Nothing. You guys give us or can they should give us the red light. But I'd like today to make sure that we're on. The actual. Report. All the other stuff with the charter and everything like that. What they've given to us. We'll just put right back on the workshop in JULY. If you want to come to that, absolutely definitely do with when they have questions. And I'd ask you to come back on the workshop. But I just want make sure we don't get derailed. Because we've already set time to really get into what the charter looks like and that sort of thing. I want to make sure that they and I obviously seen the recommendations in the chart or red light. But I want to make sure that for us is aboard. We don't get into. Well off the report. Have already our site in the next month actual audit committee. Committees, I believe, is going to the topics that we to discuss. So with that. Are there any questions from the board about the report or did you what do you want to start with question? Did you guys want to start presenting? Wolf? Think what any specific questions before they get anything? Presentation. >> just give a general good Thank you so much for having us here. Just want to say it's been up my first year on the committee has been a privilege to serve and really deep dive into this and learn more about it. The report Mariners a lot like the reports in the past. However, with this report, we decided to put the charts in the body of the report and not an appendix in the back. So you weren't flipping back and forth. So you'll see like has moved up to Page 4 as opposed to being in the back. So the schedule been dropped into the body. So that's a little bit easier to see. The comments and what they're referencing. And then the final page would be the Schedule c which just as a more detailed. Report. The mileage categories and how and where they respect. And that was provided by the district. >> I don't it's if you haven't, if you have a question but Grace hand and that can roll. You know, have >> you mind walking us through the report? >> Sure, I don't. I don't mind doing that. First page is the CHAIRMAN's letter. And then the next page and a half would be a summary of the entire report. Listen, the committee, the Mission, Financial Review conclusion is that a review of the financial records material aspects and the proper recording and tracking of the resolution revenue resolution expenses and operating reserves. So everything has reported. In accordance with the statute, then it goes into pages of analysis, which the first would be which would be the budget and the actual by category. Of the referendum. So there's a 2022 2023 budget that 58 Million 6. 25 7.60, actual expenses. 54 million. 3.28 For 71. Schedule Revenue and expense information between core expenses and resolution. Revenues, expenses and the defense. Then it just goes into the relevant outcome and results which are the highlighted items to increase student achievement. Concludes the letter grades Winx too more information on that graduation rights record and retain teachers and staff be the second. Shes got our year-over-year attention. All staff and then teachers. And then school year teacher separations. And then the 3rd point being expand career and tech net technical education and stem programs to repair students for the workforce, which is also the concentration. Of the committee focused on the steam expenditures for this year and then also check visits to the schools to see some of those items firsthand. And then the discussion and recommendations. And then finally a recognition of the district staff here. For the information that they have supplied to Austin working with us. And then the final the schedule c with more detail. Going to career and technical and critical mission. And then the arts which the first year the arts millage would be 20 to 23. That's contained on the last page. Not to. >> Interfere with what you're trying to for that moving to the JULY workshop. And I get that. But if there are recommendations in the report, yeah, that's fine. Feel I would like to hear them a great I was just about to say at the end of this, you have some >> discussion. Recommendations. >> On the report, we're absolutely okay to discuss things from the report. Absolutely. I just saw the charter charter revising small thing. I just want to make sure that. We've we've. We've got I just don't want start debating. How do we fix staying out charter this or that when we could be done that before? And we've got a time. Workshop to debate all that. And so I don't want to waste anyone's time here either. With the reporting through here giving support. But actually, I agree. You have some recommendations on here. You can absolutely, you know. Tell us why you of course. That that you could start with everyone. One of a question about the report, okay. >> Maybe for doctor was on. So on on Page 10. Other reports, schedule c. Under the Fair Grove Elementary mileage budget. The last. Lines says. 18 elementary stem teacher salary and the stem cordinator salary. We're also funded from the stem of entry funds. Does that mean that? Without the mileage that those teachers would not have salaries were not be funded or what exactly does that green? >> so MISTER Tatum, those are the additional teachers that are providing stem instruction as part of most schools as part of their specials rotation. Beyond your normal science classroom instruction. So right, that is staffing above what the district would be able to afford. If we did not have the mileage. >> Okay. I just say one thing for you. >> Have those stem classes before the millage in our elementary schools to see, you know, like that didn't exist. That's one of the things that we got out of this. >> So it that that occur, not that it. Somebody would put a false statement but it's actually true that those salaries are paid like not not a general fund money, but out of the of the mileage. That's 10 percentage of the millage money. >> Ignite the class just did not. And it would all around schools like we do now for chance. >> Okay, Let's get to nothing That's the only question e-mails have any questions for. They could have been to. >> I have on the cover letter. >> Or you have a MAY 22. 24 day. Should that not be? Could when you're actually? That would be suggestion on changing the date on that cover letter. Reflect that. Just for years and with Johnson with her tenure since you notice or poor. Mostly and on cover letter from this hair attendant says of there paragraph and additional the c 5 actually review. They 12% of this That the primary focus of this annual report as this time. Is that what that means? >> Correct said that addition to that we received from the district is this team and that would be available steam day that the 6.5 Million, the 12%. So do we did not receive the pages and pages of details like is the 51%. Salaries. You know, set aside for teacher pay. >> Okay. So schedule reflects the district provided you. Side of the U.S. This which was Trump 0.1 6%. All of other percentage is you didn't actually. Through a deep dive into you just it was just collective lay down a given. >> Right. So that data is the actuals However, that's an excellent point. And that's the goal of the committee for this next year would be to receive 100% of the mileage data and then run sampling analysis on that. And then one of the recommendations made on And then the focus of this next. The 23. 24. And then coming year, focus on charter schools. So each year taking a different emphasis to deep dive different category at the mileage to take a closer and harder look at. Charter schools being the next one. We'd like to Deep dive. But we would like to start with 100% of that data and then be able to Review and testing on that. For future years. >> And I know that's to the recommendations or >> right. And that's where it's going next. The recommendations sheet that separate from the report. >> So the second one, the bullet point as receive 100% of all of expenditures on current cases like, like, you're you're getting noticed, am right now requesting that your provided 100% of all of not just them and that way. You can separate what you want to see your bowl is that there are all direction that you want to go. Okay. >> Right. So that was just included in this recommendation. She outside of the work port, right that we're doing for 20 to 20 23, as you can see so we didn't think it necessary appropriate to include these recommendations. And with the body of the report for the school year. 22 23. Yes, moving forward right? All right. Okay. But sure just something to keep in mind is >> Of the up the if you're starting with the whole pie, right? The 100% remember that the the charter school slice comes out forest because that it depends on the proportion of students, right who are in charters for says District operated schools and then admin. All the other part, all the other slices of the pie that are not or payments to employees. Right. And a lot of that is governed by memorandum of understanding. So we talk about the 68% of the mileage. That is not or shorter. All of that is payments to employees. So that's data that can be provided. The committee. But really it again and I don't I don't get committee meeting. Be interesting to see what that. What that oversight would look like. My my initial thought released. Just checking calculations to make sure that people were. Pay based on formulas because all of that. Its payment to personnel. >> I guess the part that the charter part. They get up lot of money from the district. But this committee's not allowed to Where they're spending. And my my correct. >> You don't need >> Nobody gets see that right? I don't know stairs. >> I want to it's not an Nobody gets to see it. So it's all public money. Every transaction is is public record, right? So it's not it's not secret or proprietary But the level of oversight. Of the district, the level of oversight from the district is different. But it's not that anything is secret. >> I'm not implying that I I'm just saying that charters. You're not going to the same data the tale from charter school that you would from a school public school. I correct? I'm just curious about that. That's That's one of the questions that came up in some I just I don't know. Are we allowed to what the terms are using the funding for I know. Backup plan. There was a report provided to those on how much they got and what they actually used it for. And that's one discover that maybe some same for. Yeah, not appropriate things. And we corrected that. But I don't know late. I know they do a lot looking what to do to get from this down and arts already down to. We're not allowed to see that from charter schools. I don't know if there's a force why can't see. Come at real quick. You MAY have to get up to it. Might just ever. Yeah, got one right there. If Under that. >> Under the current referendum in the current statute, that oversight. Is not provided for. But should the referendum passing again? There's a new statute that will govern at the gives that accountability it requires that charter schools to be given the money. Requires districts to include charter schools, which we've already done. But it also requires that oversight and accountability. So should the restaurant said the referendum pass again. That oversight will be required. So thank you. >> Down the road and to facts >> Yeah, I'm thinking that that that's different from the sales tax revenue because sales tax, they have to provide how they're going to spend and then they get reimbursed. As opposed to hear they get the money. And go use it wisely. You know, is that going to change? Yeah. That. >> But they're not. They're not under. >> If we say 51% teachers, they don't have to follow those guidelines. Correct? Amanda, anybody that that those the statue and >> not the 51% that they do have to. It's got to operational. It has to be in in accordance with how. The the referee decision Lucia taking a building to building and our resolution does not say 51%. The right? It just says >> change the eccentric. Yes, but that will change over the next. All that we will have. That capability, it will be. 4th, we had the capability now that we can ask them. Can ask I just I just want to be clear. And I since I write do do with one issue where there was a concern. >> About charter school expenditure and that school fully complied with everything we asked of that. I think we've not encountered a situation at least since I arrived where someone has said on the work that we're not going to provide. Answers to your questions. Yeah, but it's not required which now it will be. Hopefully, >> Because that's part of recommendation is 100% of And I understand the 51% for staffing. Plus. Whatever goes so that and that we can't work out. That's just one of their recommendations. It's up to the board what and finance department, how they're able to accommodate the committee. MISTER Johnson, her experience. How do you? I want say thank you. First of all, as you really get a lot of work. Behind the scenes and putting this together and getting the data from the district and a lot of different things in to this report. You know, like committee members that's never really been on there. I think that's a nice touch. To be honest and the way you thing think putting schedules with the analysis. Is a and better format, in my opinion, like you said, you're not flipping through all the pain. Do this and just on the points that you included in this report. I think is give us a call your Thank you. And we didn't want to shorten it. We didn't want to just include the relevant information. >> You know, realizing that most reports like this MAY be a lot of people don't make it past Page 3. They read the summary analysis and then if they won a deep dive into the detail. But but I believe we've made it a couple pages shorter. Just want to, you know, hit the highlights. Yeah. And the majority questions have that they that they Lovell and of someone had no additional questions that Canalys reach out. There are some links, you know, to some state data they wanted to. Deeper dive. Things like. But grains graduation rates. Cetera. Now we're not going too much into next year. But one thing to just want to start next year with really defining. The amount of, you know, the referendum funds for the year and then explaining which is set and which is discretionary and non-discretionary and how those are, because I think that there is probably a misconception that all of it is you know, divided equally and things like the buckets for steam. They're not done based on Ft or need so just describing which buckets are discretionary and non-discretionary, like you said, how that pie is divided up with charter coming out. First, 51% to the staff just kind of defining that at the beginning of the report after the letter and then going into the analysis. >> I think there. I like that charge being in the middle of it. Not at the end to flip back and forth. >> Was there analysis or a way to measure how much went to stem? Versus how much went to arts? >> We did have reports where the arts spending was isolated. We did not break that out in the chart from the entire steam total. Like us, you know, additional pie chart. To far to see tear again The detailed totals on don't have that total from the pivot tables table at the arts. I should have asked that before this medium. Sorry. Now, now that the amount of excellent question because we did. >> Because the arts being new to that piece, we didn't kind of look at that. A little heavier. Some of the general, some expenses. And then, you know, of course, out of trips to the actual schools this year, I think, which oil before the committee really exciting to see. I think CHAIRMAN Hair actually went to the stem competition here locally sow it is one thing to really see it and work like we said, when you see the schools have the banners up. But then it says this was paid for. From, you know, arts mileage. That's an exciting thing, a tangible thing for a taxpayer to actually see. Where the funds are going. So some of the schools have had done that. You know, it's a nice thing you always want to. And to give you credit, you made that suggestion early on and I think. >> administration took that to heart. So come in. >> And appreciate it. Thank you. Because that made in the shade. You know, people saying it to us are saying, you know, you could be an Look that we know is paid for That's sponsored my child going here south. You know, it's always nice to. See exactly where the funds, you know, not everybody has the opportunity or the time. To come to a meeting or even to read an 11 page report. So some of those things when you're out with younger children, it's a really nice if you had to. Should be doing this. But if you had to guess, okay, because in the past about 7 million dollars would have gone to stem. >> How much of a reduction? Its stem. This last year, do you think happened? By moving money over just to the arts, much of the arts >> All right. So if you're looking at the actual from 21 to the charter school percent would be 15.1, 3. And that was increased to just under 18%. 17.9, 7. So that charter school percentage is going up. And then the at, you know, the dollar amount each year in the pie are going up. Just in here, it looks like the actual spent on charter schools. 2.7 million. I think she's asking about Oh, she's so it is so increasing. Charter resulted in a decrease in summer at changes. Yes. >> So we have less to spend. Right? So it's taking that additional us that reduction shared. >> Proportionately >> Now, I MAY. I believe that that bucket you know, just that bucket for steam. And so I don't you know, it wasn't done. I have 2 year by school, but there was significant decrease. All, you know, all the schools received a decreased budget, which the assumption would be. There's more money coming in this year for the total mileage. Why is my back and my budget smaller? So I do know that you know, the department's work. Confused by that thinking that they would just the assumption made that they would have more money to spend this year. And it was actually last because doctor, Weiss, on pointed out the charter school money is. Taking out first. And then the remaining >> To expand on >> thanks to the taxpayers Manatee County and thanks to the school board arts was added to. Plan to spend the arts mileage is is it's it's a >> you know, once you, for example, once you purchase a kill him. For a school for pottery and art, you don't need to buy another count, right? So some of those expenses are going to go down as non reoccurring expenses occur. Which is a positive because it really enhance the arts program. The state same on the stem side when we those was kits and and some of that equipment that is meant to last for a few years. So again. >> The there there are some non reoccurring expenses that occurred that are positive that enhanced the stand and arts education in this district because of mileage. And we're seeing the positive effects of that. So I so I just wanted to state that has it's not that schools are getting less steam funds. Some of that is because of of some of the expenses to really enhance those classrooms. And that educational experience of those expenses that shouldn't be reoccurring. And that's something see 5 has done very well is to look at those expenses and make sure that if film is bought one school, make sure it's not bought again at at the same school that that that there is some oversight to the expenses when it comes to steam. And that's some of the work we do in and see foxes to make sure that these expenses make sense that were not seen some of expenses occur every year that maybe shouldn't be in that they're going to the right places. Thank you. >> We do have reoccurring, of course, of which are the teachers with right. Teacher paper that yeah. All that paint and all those things that get used. But some of those, you know, I'm concerned that right? The biggest thing that really this district needed in this militarily helped was, you know, just like MISS The chairs. Cherian said >> Instruments, a sheet of music, stanza. Some of the IPads for graphic design classes. You know, those are meant to last a few years. So the goals, you know, that the role see fox really to make sure that we're not seeing, you know, 6 to being bought every year that they should have some some longevity ever have too many to this. Yes, run. I'm a former Bexar tone instrument I I wasn't strong enough to hold ironically. Omar Edwards is a tuba player, which kind of makes sense. I'm a bear Tony's the 2, but make. Yeah. I mean, they new workshop >> was there any? For the recommendations obviously mentioned. The majority. What you're looking for was anything else you like to be able to say we're we're. But you mentioned 2 big ones I use at home? >> Paid 9. >> Highlighted the ones going forward obviously, you know, we meet every other month. The you know, with with the data when the quarters close for meeting every other month, sometimes doesn't give the committee. And that time to discuss. Those are we're discussing it. You know, 2 and a half months after the close of that. So order to facilitate that, we just change on the date and the delivery of the report. And this year we did hold a special meeting. I don't think it's. It took us 3 meetings to finalize everything after feedback. So if you think every other month that would take 6 months to do so that's not conducive. So we have some recommendation on the timing in the delivery. Have so it is imperative if you to get that data quarterly and not annually, then you can be doing the work throughout the year with the committee and then just tagging on that 4th quarter at the end. So it's not labor intensive or the meetings are not as long to go through that. Usually 4th quarter for the district would be probably the smallest quarter of spending. >> Because usually expect a lot the school year. So most of those expenditures, Iran, then it would. Just move us to just and, you know, analyzing not asking for detailed the next meeting that adding that into the report. So hopefully have almost a working draft of the report throughout the year and the ad and 08:00am and then once the fte is issued and then receiving those schedules, then those totals can be compared to the schedules before data has put into that report. And just more on the timing of that so well mention that this past school year. 23. 24, we did receive that quarterly and that has been extremely helpful. >> I. I would just add thanks to >> The finance team a smiley the see folks getting a quarterly reports. We're going to. >> Do do it so that it's kind of So the chair doesn't have to ask, you know, as soon as we know the quarter report is done thanks to the hard work of the finance team will. We'll get that to see fox and then also what's the final you know, budget is reconciled and all that once the board and look at that to you right away as well. So I think people working better on on getting data and finances to see fox a more timely manner. So that as the vice chair they can keep this ongoing report going so that they don't have to look at one year's worth of expenses in a matter of a that they're kind of looking at it over over the course of the years. So will keep fine tuning that. But I think it's working and worked well this year. So coroner, sir. >> Some the quarterly reports that they're getting now includes everything or just a certain portion. >> Well, right now it's just steam table. Leave it to. You. Want us to work on their How to do go fund for Okay. Yeah. >> especially >> anything to And thank you name. >> Thank civic Takes a lot of your time. But I do like the the format of the report's kind of got like an executive summary and then there's more that there's more that of the height of some would like to dig deeper. So the tables are useful. We kind of showed the things that the millage is supposed to be looking at. So I thought it was a and improved format for previous reports of a look at. So thank you very much. So >> You know, I too. Thank you very much. I and it's somewhat your meetings and listen to some of them. And I know it was a. Was kind rough year. Lot of a lot of changes Yeah. And for the better. More detail wanted to. Spend more time looking at it. And I I commend that and I. Think that the public, if they have questions, you know, if they have reservations about the usefulness of the referendum, money, I think you'll have demonstrated that its. It's very worthwhile. Also thank you all for going to see what producing that that was an eye opener for me. When I got on the board, I did not really see some of the wonderful things going on our schools. And we've got some amazing. Opportunities because of because of this this team stem steam part of the of the referendum and thank you to the taxpayers. Thanks. Get up voting renewed this thing. I'm sorry. >> It it is hard to see from outset public perspective, you're driving on the street. You can see a building. You can new. They escape or whatever. But you can't walking the shift children there. Whatever charges, walk into a classroom and say. Look at these robots are building that are unbelievable. Right so I do think you you offered for going and doing those I think that's that's big to see it for saying if it's really and thank you for work. I know side one thing that I think we need to discuss maybe breaking my rule open can of worms. But just so you all know, I think something that in the next next month we had this audit talker workshop do about the sea fog. But about a committee is and said this to MISTER Daniels when he presented last time. The amount people involved all the committee. You know, I audit cyber, find it hard to find people and get to get involved. From a sea fog standpoint like I said, don't you want to get into this? Can now? But I would like to eventually. And you guys haven't asked us for the first time. He MAY not even have any opinion and they want to let us know. But do you feel like the committee has that like, is there enough? People there to really do the job? Are we or I watch some of the meetings there was like not a corner right? And so so which is the frustration you should people get there. You're like we do have enough to do anything here show. Is that a concern? The committee and again, you MAY not have an answer to that right now. >> No, I mean, you know, again, like you said, you know, it's the same committee of volunteers. You know some employed and there are commitments and some children in the schools. I know this year, meetings were set in stone. It was just, you know, the every other month. You know this, this first Wednesday at 2 o'clock. So worked at the last extensively with Laura Cox. We've actually changed our meeting days Sunday. We had, you know, our committee there and we worked on committing that around everybody's current calendar and commitment. And we have those meetings map through DECEMBER. So I feel, you know. That communication up front and we have those dates set so they won't be many conflicts like you said again, volunteers recruiting people for committees People having to resign or or moves? We lost a committee member to an out of this year so, you know, I think it's challenge is felt everywhere, including outside of this building in the workforce in general. So we've added a new member and we're actively recruiting. And I think without meeting time, I don't see that being asked challenging this year. And and the one meeting referenced, we were. All nervous about than we did end up attending a So we help that meeting. So actually held all of the required meetings and a special meeting this year. I am optimistic that that will work going forward, but we are always looking for committee members as well. No, I just wanted to say I sent along some information >> in this for about a really qualified person who wants who wants join the committee to hopefully have another one coming in. >> I did e-mail him. I have not heard back, ok? Trying to set up a time when we can meet wonderful. Pursue him because he pursued me. You know? So because it just drop. His reference cv and has like, yes, like 5 pages long. Yeah. Yeah. Something we know. So that's pretty exciting. And then. >> Also you are aware that it is possible to attend these meetings virtually and still and that person count as a quorum. >> For question about that, see us that so we can do it then because we were told no for the okay. It was it just 2 guys. I think around the JANUARY, FEBRUARY and Wilhelm that will help now to that. And he he's a hind that, yes, Thank. Want to attend virtually? We will count. So that will help with the quorum issues. Wonderful much. It will have to go through teams might correct. Correct. And go through our teams. >> All right. Myron Month so that we all day Find your clothes and as your liaison, it's been a real pleasure to work with all of you. I know there's times it's been a little frustrating, getting data. I think the staff are providing the data. Sometimes it wasn't time was wanted to be able to find out who knew. Andrea got it on to the report. MISTER. Now heard is that the Agnelli now we are trying to get him on the air. But I think this year hi has evolved into this committee, been very productive and especially into a diving all of the doubt of that, they did get. Did get permit hold sordid and looked and they brought in reports and ask about different things that they wanted to sample. So for me, I want to thank you all as Cox MISTER Main goal and and the Finance Department for everything that they've done to support this committee because I think that donor commendable job basically a short amount of time. That. And they are wrong with that. MISTER Chapman's been helpful on occasion. >> I had start You've been very supportive of this committee and I want to thank you, especially next time maybe will bring doughnuts. >> Makes it all keep >> All right. Yes, I think a very much and we will. >> This recommendation is in any other changes that MAY have just JULY goal know before the next school year. And I know you guys are, you know, looking for years, the other data things like that will discuss that. And you'll know by the time. >> AUGUST when have one more recommendation, should I just go ahead and fill it out all type it up and send it to you for JULY. >> This not on here, right? Yeah. Just yeah. And you're more than welcome to come in JULY as we discuss recommendations and whatever you you know. Yes. >> just if could just change cover letter date forest? Yes. Well, the as >> The JULY day. Do you have a date? >> The joint workshop. I don't have it maybe or if it you can send it out, Laura, that right that. My I mean, we haven't. Thursday the 25th time, really? I believe it's the 25th, paper calendar. Stellar and the 20 th-best maybe. Yeah. Okay. Lie. 25th. Not 9 o'clock. Off. The other to get. Thank you. Participation as well. Yeah, I think they'll be much appreciated. >> Moving to. Next topic will be budget workshop. As getting I think over to Doctor Weiss to start us off and we're going next. >> Thank you, This is the 3rd workshop where we are sending data on the 24. Proposed budget. So you have already seen capital budget You've also seen the school and district staff and plans. And final part of the presentation relates to the overall approach to the general fund the governor has signed the state budget so >> we we have more clear picture confirmation of >> the revenues that we're expecting them and expenditure plan. Just reminder of that, all of the data that you're going to see today, it's based on the financials as of MAY, 20th and that those numbers continue to change as we work through end of year and close out payment of purchase orders and all of those pieces. So these numbers MAY look a little different when we get to the end of JULY and we bring you the tentative budget and then of course, they'll change again for the final budget. But this is the best information that we have today. And I'm will turn things over to the sellers. I know that she's going Paulson every slide so that you can ask questions thank to our I'm very small, but very budget department. Being so far along in the at this point in the year. Thank you. >> good morning, Plourde I have with me today. Our senior budget analyst Amy Allen. Budget director is on a well-deserved vacation and it started today agenda is going to cover the budget process for next year. Can also go over the legislative changes and this the fefp revenue funding the millage fund and revenue. Some of the assumptions that we've made in the General Fund budget and then the General Fund Reserve history and at the district's general fund policy. All right. So in regards to our budget process, we've had we've already covered the most parts of the budget related to the staffing plan and then also the capital plan that was just this past. MAY now JULY's a very busy month on JULY. First, we're going to receive the final property values of from the property appraiser and then on JULY 19th is then when that Department of Education going to provide us with the final required local effort. So we will use this information to create the advertisement for the and then we've also then with that information present in a public hearing, the tentative millage and budget for fiscal year. 24 25 SEPTEMBER, we have the final budget. Also presented in a public hearing. Ok? So this is the primary budget as of MAY 12, but the data that we had as of MAY. 28, that is presented in a trim format which but measures the budget by the amount of incoming sources funds, specifically the beginning from balance for fiscal year. And 24 25 along with the revenues needs fund and the transfer sending each time. So the district's prelim in a budget as of MAY. 28 was 1.5, 8 billion. Now the 2 largest pieces of the budget make up 87% of the district's budget. And that is the Capital Fund and the General Fund. This year. The Capital Fund slightly surpassed the General as far as being 43% of the district's. But and this is due to the carryforwards of the construction projects over multiple years. And the new cops for the 2 Iowa men. She schools that we issuing the fall of 2024. And and what are up at 43% as the general fund for the operations of the district. >> understand the capital fund. That is so that would be. You know, trying to educate myself a little more on this. So that would be. Cops are included in there or not. Yes, okay. That would be 1.5, for capital expenditures, right? That would be 0.5 cent sales tax. Impact fees. A little bit of money from the state. I think we get to for like. They're able to experience some of the funds related to some of >> heartening. That kind of the things for safety. Yes. >> Okay. Great. That meant that I MISS Anything as far what like what? What sources of revenue. >> Those are the majority. Sources of revenue for the capital Times. Ok, thank Welcome. >> Any of the charter school money that is? Being used as a conduit any of that included in the general fund? >> For the incoming revenues? Yes, so what goes out will be in expenditure side. But this presentation of the budget is all of the revenue incoming sources. So correct. The charter school system someone in the public says she got a one point. >> 6 million 6 billion dollar budget. How much of that is ours as far the manatee public school. Our schools. >> I later on the couple slides later. I think it says, okay, yes, I think yes, yes. Okay. All right. Away. Fortunate share. I think it shows that with the charter school. Yeah. I just want make sure the public does not say you've got 1.6 increase this year, it will be increasing next year due to the increase enrollment for the charter schools. Projections and all I get just a quick comment about the budget. >> How many times we did hit this year? I don't think how many times you actually nailed like spend everything in your budget. Being and so there's a positions unfilled. There's things that happened. So I mean, I think last year was 1.3 8 and we didn't hit 1.3 this year means so yeah. I mean, just. It was mistake. >> Well, in a plane out that like we're talking about, like increases as a whole. A lot of this increase really is going to come from additional debt that this board is going to take track. So like you're if you're looking at is a look how much more you have. Please understand that. That is based on that the board already taken on but hasn't yet spent correct. And future debt that this board. >> Will be picking up. Well, perhaps be taking as your budgeting right now. >> And so, yes, it looks like an influx of funds that. There's this. That means that the same thing happened me. Borrowed in 20. 17 for high school and everything else. New schools then and it looks like a look at all extra money Please understand what that really means. So just, you know, there's people out there saying look at let me tell you why there's so much extra. You know, why capitalism, much higher now? >> Right. And that that has a as it is. >> The largest that fund is the largest of this district. It is for future construction projects and the death that goes along with those bill time. >> have a question on the Capitol. You said that part of that as carry forward. How much of that is carrying forward Zach Cunningham presentation so get end in the capital plan when use all year, that was like in 23. 24 the funds that are left there that those end up rolling over into the year one for 24. 25. >> So we presented that in the capital plan. Number ok, current, but yes. Come back and look at You're welcome. All right. So on to the highlights of the legislative changes and this is related to the fefp funding. >> So the state U.S. Are at the base student allocation. The bsa. It increased 191 dollars per fte student. That was a 3.7, 2 percent. So the increase total this 21.5 million of this increase 11 million goes towards the family Empowerment scholarship. And another 4 Million. This in the mandated program classroom other professional instructional professional salary allocation of 4 million leaving a discretionary increase of 6.5 million for the rest of the district's needs, which includes items like the instructional materials got the programs for the ap. A side be in cape and like a utility increasing the frs has a slight increase this year. And then there's also categorical programs also increased, which was safe schools, mental se, guaranteed transportation educational enrichment and the class size reduction. Depression. >> When you said that, increase of 21.5 million increase was 191 per student $191. 191 per student. Okay. And then when you get down to a t remaining increase, which is really what we have, we can choose where we're going to spend 6.5 million. How much is that per student? >> That would be. >> I could break. Haha. The other 40. 2,540 1500 prediction 160 160 sorry. Doesn't look right. If you got 21.591 6.5, Divide the 6th William, a. >> We can give you the figure later. Well, I just want you know, this is also come to and and further on a different slide. I get down to that per student. >> to take the difference between those 2 to like about 25%, the $191 is available for. Is that yes, the fair to say yes to the >> so the family empowerment scholarship. By the way, we've done this for money from How does that money flow? Does it? Flow to the school system and then a family applies for the scholarship and then the polls about from us and says, hey, somebody, a student district applied for this in our taking that that background or how does that work? You know. >> I'll be included in the funding for the district, the portion that is the family empowerment, its adjusted out. They actually even in the conference report called adjustment 4. The Family Empowerment scholarship. We'll see in the buckets where they literally actually take that out. So we don't get with that doesn't that's not in the flood to the way the charter schools. >> Ok? So it never comes to the It just flow separately to the to them fellowship, right funds into They must put in their parts when they want to at least the state wants to say how much is going Obviously spitting at by county where by districts to be able to first account for, I'm sure for their budget, but the state. >> That would also be included in the 1.5, 8, 5 billion And the total. >> No, it's not. Okay. All right. Thank I know I know we get the idea get this in a later slide. But I just connected now. >> The >> but week, the next do that. Said that specific. So. >> Commissioner turns point. Family Empowerment scholarship. Increased 11 Million. And what you're saying. And codes towards teacher salary increase. Oh, no. >> there's an increase that 11 million is for the family empowerment scholarship. Right then there's another 4 Million. That needs to go towards classroom. Teachers and the other instructional, a professional about family empowerment scholarship is. >> 21.5 million plus 11 million know. >> the increased said the district getting from the tsa 21.5 million out of that. 21.5 million, 11 million of that increase goes towards the family empowerment scholarships. Another 4 Million. >> I'm Jenna. Another Our ease towards towards the salaries. Yes, maintenance and increases pieces to that. Okay. So the toddler. So you take 21.5 months to 11, minus them honest. Gives us the 6.5 left I got But it does. So are of that scholarship. They buck, it's you have to spend at 10:00am I? >> Getting right. 4.9 goes towards teacher salary. >> Yes, It's partisan election. That bucket is actually. >> Has to be there and has a coat that was only place. It can be spent. Correct? Okay. And as for you're getting a 6 point 5%, there might as discretionary. That's what's left over for the. >> can work with. >> The 4 million is based the 4 main for the teacher salary increase occasions based on the number of teachers we have like, so not every district, 4 million, right? But you're not going happen and every customer gets their own pieces. And the conference report Euclid our But all the other districts are getting for theirs. >> I don't half of that. >> In addition to bsa increases. Counter grower goals. Also creased right okay. You can do all that my head there, That's part of that. And increased. >> You can kind of see that a little bit easier to put those increases on the bucket. The flow chart tell about. Okay. All right. So as we were talking about the mandated programs. That's what this slide is going to go over. So out of that, we have the base funding of the 326 Million. And we have 131.5 million going towards mandated programs specifically the charter school portion that has increased due to charter school projections increasing fte enrollment. Then also there's an increase for the programs for that ap Ace Cape. I be in moment I do to their base. Student allocation increasing as well. And big one time or one of the bigger ones that we were presented with last year was the roll-up of the categorical programs into the base funding. But the legislative mandates to provide for these programs are still in law. So any increase in the cost of these mandated programs? All right. This paid from any the sa increased that we are provided. So specifically I had mentioned on the last page, the classroom teacher and the other instructional professional salaries. There's that piece. But then there's also the instructional materials, the reading instruction and that caught teacher classroom supplies. So these mandated programs, all of those that hold last year's category culls. Plus, the charter school portion it share and ace. Those mandate programs. Total 131.5 million. Apologies leaving discretionary base, funding of 195 0.2 million. This calculates too. 4,767 per fte. So tear fact MISS For them. The question that you're asking me would Tay. The 5,003 that we are provided less this fte. C. Dollars total. This going towards the mandated programs out of for each student out of the 5,003 30 that weren't given for 24. 25. >> I get quick Doctor Rice probably maybe for >> so charter school year if yes, scholarship money. How does this state or anybody can answer? Yes. How did state predict? How many students are going to take advantage? Of it or go to charter. That to me is the biggest issue with the budget process is how can this and I MISS You this shooting. Could be off you notice because is that you do get breaking down per district and then look at the trends over. They say, oh, here's state average and how many kids are moving? Sandra? And they kind of make it easy for How do they come up with that? You're now to be increased by x. My kids going to charter Carter. >> So very broadly, there's a there's a modeling process that within the Department of Education and we we get the results of. The models being run different ways based on past enrollment. And then we do get some. And opportunity to say we think this model is most accurate for our district based on what we see. That's and then each district is submitting that. And that helps kind of put the state budget together. I think the key pieces that the choice landscape is changing so quickly. First of all, Florida empowerment is a new program. The charter peace. Part of enrollment increases. There is more charters coming on board. And so the modeling least from my perspective is less reliable. That used to be because Because ultimately each family is making independent choices about what option they want to choose. So you're correct. Sherman, right now it feels like there's more to this than science from, you know, from the firm in hour than perspective. And so. We have to make our staffing decisions based on what we think are going to happen as the board Staffing is the biggest part of the budget if we over project we have to correct it date him. And if we if we project been were scrambling to hire more teachers, which puts, you know, principals and schools, difficult situations. So it's it's using the past data, but understanding that that date is not as reliable as it once was and then getting all of our professionals around the table and making our best guesses as to where things are going. And having said that, we're we're monitoring weekly enrollment shifts and then making adjustments to staffing, you know, as needed. So it's it's it's not like you. You only get one shot at it. We're constantly monitoring. But but it is a challenge candidly, I think where the state is getting the fbs projections from. It to me is a little bit of a pick. Not you know, and again, it's new for them, too. So it's just, you know, a function of the changing landscape. And, you know, Esser funding was Elisa Nice backstop in the midst of all of this uncertainty. We will have that anymore. And so we have to be even more careful about how we budget Get back to MS. Ocean MAY have more info on the on the modeling that that's could have very broad view of it. >> Yes, and that's what I saw 2 and I I know that I'm at the beginning of the year. Charter schools themselves Self reporting projections for like 24 25 and that then gets pulled and sent dealing as well. So that's tar school he side of I mean, that's very >> subjective. I mean. To hopefully protect themselves higher. They're not business. People. On all-time. >> And you want you want to cut? I was going to add to that. You're reading there. You know, there charter school is independently, you know, mapping their enrollment Board members as you're aware, it's a buster. We saw some withdrawals from a charter school that impacted the enrollment at one or 2 charters in the spring in the bottom line is our doors are always open to students. And so that just adds a little bit more to the complexity. But right now, I think there are more of Nunes than does include home school. As well. Correct. It take the whole school take apart. Could be a part of that. Yes. >> What would that numbers inside of that? I MISS And it's not broken down debt. >> Private. That right. This is a fault in that same kind of right there along with private >> And that's not the one that's not traditional home education families who are not taking any scholar if you don't, doing their own thing. Those numbers are not We we we have but we don't track those numbers as a because they don't get anything >> I just want to verify the on that slide. It said the projection for next year is 40,950. That does not. I just want to verify. That does not include charter schools. Fbs. These are these are students walking through the mention middle and high, right are okay. >> Traditional call it that. Thank you everything. And that's one of the questions we've >> Asked about and pm that looking at. >> The number of students that we have versus charter. Yes, because that's that information will be there at the next one. Almonds. 10 members. Makes the difference right So when you're doing your 40,500 students who are by. >> a few under guy noves up by 400, some the this side from last slide. So 3rd bullet downside six-acre were at their bullet down faster teacher and other structural personnel salary increase. >> Tsi? 21.8 million. >> That's that's the total allocation. All right. So the last slide from the previous year. >> Just from this year's. That Ford is inside that. 21 point, correct? We do with the couple. Fortunately, >> back to Foreman's question about the 40,950. So our Web site, on the homepage of the school system website says we have. 52,000 students or so. So does that mean that approximately? Section was 41,011 1000 that our charter school students. When we went like if I want to go out and tell the public, this is how many students we have in our school district. And this is how many go to public schools. What were those numbers? Looks like the number is what we have about 41,000 that go to traditional public schools and we have about 11,000 or so to go to charter schools without the correct or >> I would imagine that would part of them up to me with that. That data that's on the Web. So you're you're right, the stream. So in general the all-in number that we use over 50,000 includes all the charters is ultimately the the board is responsible for approval oversight contracting. All of that. The other that 40,950 number. That's specifically in this. That is what we see. That is the projection that we used. When we staff schools for next year. Right? And that is our traditional 51 district operated sites that does not include he's got, you know, a few contracted sites with very small numbers of students because and then you've also got a couple of alternative sites that we directly staff. That staffing. Doesn't always run on on some of this strict formulas that you've seen because of the unique nature of the programming, but that that you but yes, ultimately 40, about 40,009 50. That's our projection for next year. And then you would add to that. Contracted an alternative sites and then you would add to that charter schools and that get you to the 50,000 plus number. Thank you. Was like >> All right. So on to the flow chart of the funds, funding Department of Education. So we begin with the in the lower right hand corner. It help to follow the formula along so in >> box on the second row. We have our basic fefp. The fp funding of 326 million and then we have the funding of the categorical programs, which is that, yes, he guaranteed the djj. And then we have the increase in mental health assistance, at and a safe school activities and the student transportation, all 3 of those are categories that the district's supplements quite a bit on to achieve of those particular programs. Then we have the education enrichment arrive at the gross state and local funding of 381 Million. That is in dc 3rd row at the end. For the adjusted net state funds of which in the 4th row. This is calculated by subtracting required local effort, which is 225 Million. And then we also subtract the Florida. I'm sorry. The family Empowerment Scholarship adjustment and we netted against the state funded discretion or supplement. Next? A 32.7 million to arrive at state funding. Actually, that's 123 million to operate. This is set up in the pattern and a flow chart that dog gives us as far as after that, we do have the class size reduction that is still a state funded as well too. That you know, 50.4 million. So when you add that to the their adjusted net state funding, the total adjusted net state funding is 172 Million. And then we have the remaining boxes in the 5th row and these this local effort to arrive at the total adjusted funding of 462 Million. Thank you. >> the sellers east. Yes on slide. So please, yes. Adjusted total funding. That's everything comes from from the state to to us to the right. Okay. After all, the calculations are >> Total funding. We've already discussed where some of these up that information goes. So I just wanted to at least put the flow chart of all of that finding. This is one massive way to look at all of that. You know, >> so if the general fund back on slide 4. Is approximately is 678 million dollars. >> Remember, there's beginning fund balance revenue sea, but you but almost want end the question of where you're going. And I have to pull out all of the beginning. Fund balance is to try to get to But this is in the general fund only >> so actually, question I'm trying to get to is the answer what percentage? Of the general fund funding that we? It's financed by the. But the state through required local effort. That's actually what i'd like to know how much was the percentage that we actually fun through the? For the one nil. And what percentage is that of the general fund is actually given to Israel is given to by the required local effort. I'm just curious. >> As a kid, I would actually have to go in get that calculation for you you know, and in this particular piece of the funding, we do have the referendum that is also in the general fund as well too. Pull out the fefp and have to get more of calculations for you on that >> We can do that. You right now a little more money in the You're welcome. The first box the fte students to 56 for 70. >> fight back out. The site prior 40,000. But we back out the at the nsa 4,751 which was shown on slide 6. That leaves 10,007 69, which I are charter schools. But that doesn't match with. School total on slide. 6. You start school twelves 3.75 Plus 47. 51 for empowerment. That's 49. 58. 0, 7, 6, And so we're better. 1500 students different. >> And over remember also in the counts, we have the contracted sites. There's the other program. So other programs. So I it's I don't think it's that close. I'd have to give get to a dissection of it. The contracted sites like the Easter SEALs. But then that specialty ones like then you have the other Sable? And I'm Some of those we do have there are some other figures that aren't as large that we're we're parsing out when have this discussion. But I can say is if you ever looked at the really big 190 pages of that comprehensive financial report scheduled. 21 actually does have a historic of the of all of the fte. Actually does break it out by elementary middle high. But then also the specialty programs that charter schools, that kind of a thing to say. At least that detail all the way through fiscal year 20 to 23 is available. Broken out on that page in that section that schedule. 21 schedule. 21, it's in the it's in the statistical section of of the actor. >> And that's something that could be. All right. That's interesting. Information to see. Is there a projection for this? 24 25 year on that. >> Are not have a summary of that. That we were I'm going share with you on the one's summarized and some of those categories that we can get to on Monday had to put point bracing for a briefing. >> And far because this goes back to the earlier conversation the e. Projections for fcs show significant growth. Our charters are indicating they're expecting significant growth. We don't see, too, for all of those things to happen. We would we would have to see. Significant reduction in students which we don't see in our actual enrollment data. And so if we back out all of those other things and I staff schools on what's left. You run the risk that if those forecast

Page 1 Minutes June 13, 2024 Workshop - 9:00 AM Manatee County School District 215 Manatee Avenue West Bradenton, FL 34205 www.manateeschools.net Times Indicated Are Approximate I) CALL TO ORDER Attendee Name Status Dr. Jason C. Wysong, Superintendent Joseph Ranaldi, Deputy Superintendent of Operations Derek Jensen, Deputy Superintendent of Instructional Services Rachel Sellers, Deputy Superintendent of Business Services Chad Choate, Chair Cindy Spray, Vice-Chair Gina Messenger, Board Member Mary Foreman, Board Member Richard Tatem, Board Member Stephen Dye, Board Attorney Present Minutes: Chair Choate called the Workshop to order at 9:01 AM. II) PUBLIC COMMENTS Minutes: There were no Public Comments. III) WORKSHOP 1. Citizen Financial Oversight Committee (CFOC) Annual Report Board Review School Board Chair Choate welcomed the CFOC Committee Chair Harrigan, Vice Chair Johnson. Also in attendance from the Committee was Member Barber and Member DiSilvestro. Committee Vice-Chair Johnson provided an overview of the annual report. The Board asked questions and held discussion throughout the presentation of the report. Additional information regarding Charter School accountability was provided by Committee Member Barber. Mr. Kevin Chapman, Executive Director of Administration, provided information regarding the amount of support the District financial team provided to the committee. After a request by the Vice-Chair, the committee stated an updated cover letter would be provided for the annual report.

Page 2 Committee Vice-Chair Johnson noted the recommendations within the annual report as well as new requests to the Board. Included in new requests: receive 100% of the Millage data from District Sources and receive the same data from Charter Schools in order to provide additional oversight. School Board Chair Choate stated that before any additional information was provided, there was an upcoming Workshop in July that would address concerns and additional requests regarding the Citizen Financial Oversight Committee. 2. Overview of the 2024-2025 Budget - General Fund Superintendent Wysong stated the information given at this workshop was the current projected budget. Superintendent Wysong deferred the presentation to Ms. Rachel Sellers, Deputy Superintendent of Business Services. Ms. Sellers summarized the previous workshop regarding the budget. She provided information regarding the projected general fund budget to include the following: • Budget Preparation Process • 2024-2025 Preliminary Budget - All Funds • 2024-2025 Legislative Changes • 2024-2025 Mandated Programs in Base FEFP Funding • 2024-2025 FEFP Budget Revenue • Revenue Funded by Local Taxable Value of Property • Millage Rates / Property Value • Significant Assumptions for 2024-2025 General Fund Budget • General Fund – Ending Fund Balance District Policy 6233 • General Fund – Fund Balance District Policy 6235 • General Fund – Reserve % of Fund Balance History (End of Fiscal Year) Also in attendance for input was Ms. Amy Allyn, Senior Budget Analyst. The Board asked questions and held discussion throughout the presentation. Additional information regarding the state projections related to Family Empowerment Scholarship and school enrollment data was provided by Superintendent Wysong. 3. Comprehensive District Technology Plan July 1, 2024-June 30, 2029 Superintendent Wysong provided an overview of the purpose of the five-year Technology plan. Information pertaining to the Five-Year Plan was provided by Chief Technology Officer, Mr. Scott Hansen and Mr. Ranaldi, Deputy Superintendent of Operations. The Board asked questions and held discussion. Board Member Foreman request ADA compliance training for all members, board members, committee members as well as board attorney. IV) ADJOURNMENT Chair Choate adjourned the Workshop at approximately 11:45 AM.

Page 3 ______________________________ Chad Choate, III Chairman NOTICE Any person who desires to appeal any decision made by the School Board with respect to any matter considered at the above-mentioned meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which an appeal may be based. School Board meetings are held in accessible locations. Auxiliary aids will be provided, upon written request received at least 48 hours prior to the meeting, to participants with disabilities.

I. CALL TO ORDER II. AGENDA AMENDMENTS 1. Agenda Amendments - added after publishing III. PUBLIC COMMENTS Public comment is not an open forum to discuss matters unrelated to education, to support or oppose candidates for public office, or to engage in commercial speech attempting to sell a service or product to the School Board or public. Also, public comment is not a forum to attack individual school system employees or Board Members. Any such complaints should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Finally, this is not a forum for addressing issues involving individual students. Because of privacy concerns, such issues should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Each speaker is allowed three minutes to address the Board. Speakers must stand at the podium and not approach the dais. This is a business meeting of the School Board and the public expects that we conduct it in an orderly, efficient, effective and dignified manner. We request that speakers keep this in mind when making your comments. We also request that the audience keep that in mind and not demonstrate approval or disapproval of what a speaker has said by clapping or booing. The Board appreciates the public's input and will listen attentively, consider each comment, and usually will not respond, enter into debate, or answer questions during comments on agenda items or during the public comments section. PUBLIC INPUT INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Before you begin speaking, please provide any handouts to the Agency Clerk. 2. Please identify yourself only by your full name for the record. 3. You have no more than three minutes to speak. Please stop speaking when the bell rings. 4. Florida Law requires all citizens to conduct themselves in an orderly fashion at public meetings. 5 . WARNING: Any individual who interferes with the expeditious or orderly process of a School Board meeting, will be subject to removal from the meeting pursuant to Section 1001.372(3) Florida Statutes at the discretion of the Chair. Orderly fashion is deemed as, at a minimum (1) no profanity (2) no vulgar language (3) no discourteous, disrespectful, or disparaging conduct. IV. WORKSHOP Agenda updated 6/11/2024 June 13, 2024 School Board of Manatee County Workshop - 9:00 AM Walter Miller School Support Center Board Room Times Indicated are Approximate 1

1. Citizen Financial Oversight Committee (CFOC) Annual Report Board Review 2. Overview of the 2024-2025 Budget General Fund - updated 6/11/2024 3. Comprehensive District Technology Plan July 1, 2024 - June 30, 2029 V. ADJOURNMENT 2

Showing the first 24,000 of 200,424 characters. The full document is at the source.

I. CALL TO ORDER II. AGENDA AMENDMENTS 1. Agenda Amendments - added after publishing III. PUBLIC COMMENTS Public comment is not an open forum to discuss matters unrelated to education, to support or oppose candidates for public office, or to engage in commercial speech attempting to sell a service or product to the School Board or public. Also, public comment is not a forum to attack individual school system employees or Board Members. Any such complaints should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Finally, this is not a forum for addressing issues involving individual students. Because of privacy concerns, such issues should be submitted in writing to the Superintendent for appropriate handling. Each speaker is allowed three minutes to address the Board. Speakers must stand at the podium and not approach the dais. This is a business meeting of the School Board and the public expects that we conduct it in an orderly, efficient, effective and dignified manner. We request that speakers keep this in mind when making your comments. We also request that the audience keep that in mind and not demonstrate approval or disapproval of what a speaker has said by clapping or booing. The Board appreciates the public's input and will listen attentively, consider each comment, and usually will not respond, enter into debate, or answer questions during comments on agenda items or during the public comments section. PUBLIC INPUT INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Before you begin speaking, please provide any handouts to the Agency Clerk. 2. Please identify yourself only by your full name for the record. 3. You have no more than three minutes to speak. Please stop speaking when the bell rings. 4. Florida Law requires all citizens to conduct themselves in an orderly fashion at public meetings. 5 . WARNING: Any individual who interferes with the expeditious or orderly process of a School Board meeting, will be subject to removal from the meeting pursuant to Section 1001.372(3) Florida Statutes at the discretion of the Chair. Orderly fashion is deemed as, at a minimum (1) no profanity (2) no vulgar language (3) no discourteous, disrespectful, or disparaging conduct. IV. WORKSHOP Agenda updated 6/11/2024 June 13, 2024 School Board of Manatee County Workshop - 9:00 AM Walter Miller School Support Center Board Room Times Indicated are Approximate 1

1. Citizen Financial Oversight Committee (CFOC) Annual Report Board Review 2. Overview of the 2024-2025 Budget General Fund - updated 6/11/2024 3. Comprehensive District Technology Plan July 1, 2024 - June 30, 2029 V. ADJOURNMENT 2

AGENDA ITEM NO. II.1 School Board of Manatee County June 13, 2024 - Workshop Title Agenda Amendments - added after publishing Executive Summary The Chair finds good cause to amend the agenda to include: Agenda amended on Tuesday June 11, 2024, to add GF Budget Workshop June 13, 2024 to Workshop Item Overview of the 2024-2025 Budget General Fund - Updated 6/11/2024 Contact Submitting Department: School Board Initiated By: Chad Choate 3

AGENDA ITEM NO. IV.1 School Board of Manatee County June 13, 2024 - Workshop Title Citizen Financial Oversight Committee (CFOC) Annual Report Board Review Executive Summary Ms. Susan Harrigan, CFOC Committee Chair will present the completed annual report for FY Ending 6/30/2023. Contact Submitting Department: Citizens Oversight Committee Attachments: CFOC Recommendations 6-13 Annual Report FY 2023 2024-06-06 Proposed Charter redline 4

The CFOC would like to make the following recommendations to the School Board. • Since the Charter school allocation is changing yearly, we would like to have all the historical information on the enrollment at charter schools for school years 2021 to present. The increase in enrollment will be used to substantiate the increase in millage dollars funded and this reasoning will be included with our 2023-2024 report. As soon as charter school spending is available, the committee requests that detail so testing can be done on this piece of millage spending. • To adhere to the Charter and the Resolution that the community voted for, the CFOC would like to receive 100% of the Millage fund expenditures for oversight. This would be sent to all members automatically on a quarterly basis, or otherwise requested by the chair. This will help facilitate review and testing of data and should help expedite our report. • The CFOC would like to make a recommendation to change the wording in the Charter to reflect that our annual report will be due by the 4th meeting after the AFR is approved. The current meeting schedule of every other month restricts the ability to deliver the report within 60 days of the AFR, as traditionally 4 th quarter/year-end data has not been made available to the committee prior to the issuing of the AFR. 5

May 22, 2024 Manatee County School Board 215 Manatee Avenue West Bradenton, FL 34205 Dear Members of the School Board, The Citizens’ Financial Oversight Committee (“CFOC”) has completed its review of the revenue, expenses and operating reserves of the one mill increase in the school ad valorem millage pursuant to “Resolution 2017-11” (the “Resolution”) for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2023. Our review included reviewing expense transaction details of the Manatee County School District (the “District”), compiling and summarizing detailed records into the data included in this report. We performed certain analytical procedures to verify our conclusions. Also, we relied upon representations of the District, and the internal audit procedures of restricted funds of the District in reaching our conclusions. In addition, members of the CFOC visited selected schools to observe programs with direct funding from the millage. As the chairperson of the CFOC I noted that the school buildings that I toured had bright, open spaces that made students feel at ease and welcomed an invigorating learning environment. I was extremely impressed at how our millage dollars were used to provide top notch experiences for all ages. The staff had been properly trained and the students entered the classrooms and participated with excitement. The children were eager to provide explanations of what they were learning and even how things were programed. I was truly impressed! Except as otherwise set forth herein, it is our finding that tracking and accounting of Resolution Revenue and Resolution Expenditures were in material compliance with the operating budget established by the District and approved by the Board for the twelve months ending June 30, 2023. In addition to the CFOCs review of financial records of the District, the CFOC has reviewed the available STEAM data totaling $6,551,175.86, roughly 12% of the millage funds collected. This data was used to identify relevant outcomes related to the use of the Resolution Revenue (as hereinafter defined) consistent with the stated goals of the Resolution. As illustrated within this report, the district has shown improvement in metrics related to goals set forth in the initiative. This improvement can be attributed to many factors including implementation of the referendum. That said, certain data and analysis being measured at this time are presented in this report. All charts and graphs presented were prepared and supplied by the school district. It is the CFOC’s opinion that all conclusions in this report are based on materially correct data. It is an honor to serve the taxpayers of Manatee County and the committee appreciates the opportunity to serve in this capacity and make a difference in the lives of our children, the future leaders of our community. Susan Harrigan, Chair Citizens’ Financial Oversight Committee 6

pg. 2 Creation of the Citizens’ Financial Oversight Committee The Citizens’ Financial Oversight Committee (“CFOC”) was created through the Manatee County School District School Board’s approval and adoption of Resolution 2017-11 on November 14, 2017, and the subsequent vote in favor of the one mill increase in the operating ad valorem millage by the constituents of Manatee County in the Special Election held on March 20, 2018. More specifically: (a) the ballot summary question language approved in Resolution 2017-11 stated the funds generated by the one mill increase to the operating ad valorem millage would be “overseen by an independent citizens’ committee”; and (b) paragraph 4 of Resolution 2017-11 provided as follows: “Provided the millage increase for Manatee County Schools is approved, a financial oversight committee appointed by the School Board shall issue an annual report to insure proper fiscal stewardship of the funds. In addition, the committee shall identify relevant outcomes and report results to the community. The School Board appointed the initial members of the committee in 2018 who serve subject to the committee charter approved by the CFOC and the School Board. Over the past two years, the Board has appointed subsequent members as terms have expired. As of June 30th, 2024, no member term is expiring. The current committee consists of the following members: Eric Di Silvestro term ending June 2027 Tom Ehren term ending June 2025 Catherine Ferrer term ending June 2025 Susan Harrigan, Chairman term ending June 2026 Michael Hartman, Vice Chairman term ending June 2025 Holly Johnson term ending June 2026 Pat Barber, MEA President no expiration Deanna Howell, AFSCME President no expiration Mission of the CFOC The Mission of the CFOC is to: (i) provide oversight to ensure proper fiscal stewardship of operating funds provided by the one mill increase in the operating ad valorem millage; (ii) identify and measure relevant outcomes from the deployment of the funds from the one mill increase; and (iii) report results to the School Board and the community. Operation and Organization of the CFOC The committee meets as a single body to review information provided by the District pertinent to its mission. Financial Review and Analysis We have completed our review of the Resolution Revenue, Expenditures and operating reserves of the Resolution Revenue. Our review included accessing audited financial records of the District, compiling and summarizing detailed records into the data included in this report. We performed certain analytical procedures to verify our conclusions. Also, we relied upon representations from the District, and the internal audit procedures of restricted funds of the District in reaching our conclusions. 7

pg. 3 Defining Terms • Resolution Revenue: Revenue generated from the one mill increase in the school ad valorem millage pursuant to Resolution 2017-11. • Core Revenue: All other general fund revenue • Resolution Expenditures: Expenditures restricted from the Revenue source of the one mill increase in the school ad valorem pursuant to Resolution 2017-11 • Core Expenditures: All other general fund expenditures Conclusions Our review concludes that the financial records of the District represent, in all material respects, proper recording and tracking of the Resolution Revenue, Resolution Expenditures and operating reserves related to the Resolution Revenue as presented in the following schedules (appendices to this report): • Resolution Budget vs. Actual Expenditures/Fund Balance by Project for the Year Ended June 30th, 202 3 (Schedule A) • Recap of Comparative Income and Expense Data and Analysis of Increase/Decrease for the Initial Year of Resolution Amounts (Schedule B) 8

pg. 4 Analysis Schedule A presents a comparison of budgeted Resolution Expenditures to actual Resolution Expenditures for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2023. Resolution Revenue budgeted but not spent in a given Project accounting category in the fiscal year ended June 30, 2023 was carried forward to the 2022-2023 budget as adjustments restricted to the Project accounting category the funds were originally budgeted for. Similarly, Resolution Expenditures more than the budgeted amounts were carried forward to the following fiscal year as adjustments in the 2022-2023 budget. Schedule A Referendum Expenditures - Budget vs Actual by Project for Year Ending June 30 th, 2023 Goal 2021-22 Actual % 2022-23 Budget % 2022-23 Actual % Expensed STEAM 12.13% $ 7,070,496 15.10% $ 7,111,465 12.13% $ 6,604,741 12.16% Instructional Staff 51.00% $ 24,131,008 51.54% $ 29,899,138 51.00% $ 28,263,312 52.02% AFSCME 6.00% $ 3,524,614 7.53% $ 3,521,546 6.00% $ 2,179,003 4.01% SAMP / School Administrators 6.00% $ 2,709,440 5.79% $ 3,517,546 6.00% $ 3,161,798 5.82% Paraprofessionals 5.00% $ 2,303,278 4.92% $ 2,931,288 5.00% $ 2,703,565 4.98% Charter Schools 16.87% $ 7,081,742 15.13% $ 9,890,109 16.87% $ 9,763,086 17.97% Non-Bargaining 3.00% N/A N/A $ 1,754,668 3.00% $ 1,652,965 3.04% 3% set aside for Fund Balance 3.00% $ 0.00% $ 1,758,773 0.00% $ - 0.00% Total 100.00% $ 46,820,578 100.00% $ 58,625,760 100.00% $ 54,328,471 100.00% 9

pg. 5 Schedule B presents comparative revenue and expense information and corresponding year over year change analysis. This chart illustrates the gap in the core funding filled by the resolution. Schedule B Recap of 2022 vs 2023 Core and Resolution Revenue and Expenditures Core vs Resolution Analysis Sum of 2022 Actuals Sum of 2023 Actuals Difference Year to Year 2022 vs 2023 Percentage Difference Revenues Core $ 428,278,388 $ 485,145,329 $ 56,866,940 13.28% Resolution $ 46,065,037 $ 58,625,760 $ 12,560,723 27.27% Total Revenues $ 474,343,425 $ 543,771,088 $ 69,427,663 14.64% Expenditures Core $ 420,213,283 $ 452,464,519 $ 32,251,236 7.67% Resolution $ 46,820,579 $ 54,328,471 $ 7,507,892 16.04% Total Expenditures $ 467,033,862 $ 506,792,990 $ 39,759,128 8.51% Difference Core $ 8,065,105 $ 32,680,810 $ 24,615,704 Resolution $ (755,542) $ 4,297,289 $ 5,052,830 Grand Total $ 7,309,563 $ 36,978,098 $ 29,668,535 Relevant Outcomes and Results Pursuant to the Resolution, the CFOC has identified relevant outcomes related to the use of the Resolution Revenue, consistent with the stated goals of the Resolution. In order to measure these outcomes, the CFOC has relied upon representations of the District. As illustrated within this report, the district has shown improvement in metrics related to goals set forth in the initiative. This improvement can be attributed to many factors including implementation of the referendum. “To increase student achievement…” Student achievement has continued to rise until the time of COVID where the District data did not improve at the same rate as previously (when using school grade as a proxy for student achievement). 2020-2021 school grades were only available if a District opted in. No conclusion can be drawn about the impact of Resolution Revenue on retention. Information related to the expansion of Career and Technical Education and STEM programs supported by the Resolution Revenue is being measured, including the number of programs added as well as student participation in these programs. 10

pg. 6 We have examined the grades of each school in the District from 2015 to 2023, as shown in the chart below. Though the District grade itself has remained consistent as a “B” for the last three years, 2016- ’17 thru 2019-20 (not illustrated in this report), individual school performance has improved. By the end of the 2018-2019 school year, all but two schools were a grade C or above. This information was provided by the Florida Department of Education website. We are assuming that school grades can be used as a proxy for student performance. Improvement is noted this year with no schools receiving an “F” school grade. However, District rating remained at a B for 2023, dropping state ranking to 31st in 2023 from 25th in 2022. Individual school grades and information about school grading can be found at the following websites: Department of Education (DOE) https://www.fldoe.org/ 2022-23 Guide to Calculating School Grades and District Grades https://www.fldoe.org/core/fileparse.php/18534/urlt/SchoolGradesCalcGuide23.pdf Academic Dashboard https://www.manateeschools.net/academicdb Number of Schools by Letter Grade including charter schools School Grade 2015- 2016 2016- 2017 2017- 2018 2018- 2019 2019- 2020 2020-2021* 2021- 2022 2022 - 2023 A 5 14 15 21 N/A 7 19 22 B 16 13 18 19 N/A 3 13 14 C 27 20 19 18 N/A 4 27 21 D 7 11 6 2 N/A 2 6 F 2 0 0 0 N/A 1 Total 57 58 58 60 N/A 14 62 63 *School & District Grades were opt-in only in 2021 11

pg. 7 The chart below shows the graduation rate in the district compared to the state from 2015-16 to 2022-23. Note Manatee County’s 2.75% increase going into 2019-2020 during the time of the COVID impact, but a widening graduation rate gap compared to the state’s increase that the county has yet to recover fully. The district experienced a 2% increase in the graduation rate in 2022-23. Graduation Rate by Year Year 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022- 23 Florida 80.7% 82.3% 86.1% 86.9% 90.0% 90.1% 87.3% 88.0% Manatee 83.5% 81.1% 85.4% 83.2% 85.8% 85.1% 80.3% 82.3% “To recruit and retain teachers and staff…” The recruitment and retention of teachers and staff with competitive salaries has been measured differently than in previous years. Data in the previous years was collected at different points during the year. For this report, the data below reflects retention at the beginning of the school year. The following chart was provided to the CFOC by the Administration showing teacher retention at the elementary, middle, and high school levels as well as MTC and cross-departmental teachers. Year over Year Retention of All Staff Year Number of Retained Staff at beginning of School Year Retention % 2019 5678 2020 5085 89.56% 2021 4800 84.54% 2022 4478 78.87% 2023 4430 78.02% Year over Year Retention of Instructional/ Teachers Year Number of Retained Teachers at beginning of School Year Retention % 2018-2019 2733 2019-2020 2500 91.47% 2020-2021 2385 95.40% 2021-2022 2299 96.39% 2022-2023 2289 99.57% 12

pg. 8 At the beginning of the school year on August 10th, 2022, 99.57% of teaching positions were filled. The chart above represents separations that occurred during the 2022-2023 school year, after the start date. The committee requested additional information regarding reasons why teachers left the school district and is represented in the data above and is classified by reason for separation. “Expand Career and Technical Education and STEM programs to prepare students for the workforce…” This is an area where extensive data is being collected by the District. Much of this information is internally generated by the District and utilized by District leadership, as opposed to the information being collected only at the request of this Committee. We have reviewed plans outlining the intended use of the Resolution Revenue for these areas and provided feedback where appropriate, and the District has made changes accordingly in response to this feedback. The relevant outcomes that we can measure at this time are the number of programs added and the number of students participating in these programs. A summary of the progress is included as Schedule C in the appendices. As mentioned previously, the CFOC is continuing to track and analyze data to reach conclusions about the success of these programs. The District has identified the following relevant outcomes that it is measuring: • Graduation Rates • Number of Industry certifications earned • On-the-Job Training experience The degree of planning that has gone into the deployment of Resolution Revenue to expand career and technical education and STEM programs by the District, as well as the identification of relevant outcomes it is measuring gives this Committee a high degree of confidence that we will be able to continue to collect consistent, reliable information on these programs as the information becomes available. It is encouraging that the District administration and staff overseeing these programs proactively identified relevant outcomes that they wanted to measure for their own purposes. 2022-2023 School Year Teacher Separations Count Certification 3 Death 5 Job Abandonment 1 Non-Renewal 23 Retirement 73 Resignation 307 Term During Probation 6 Grand Total 418 13

pg. 9 Discussion and Recommendations Consistent with the CFOC’s prior recommendation regarding maintaining increases in Core Expenditures consistent with economic conditions, the CFOC again recommends the School District consider Core Expenditure increases after accounting for inflation. Should there be a correlation between spending in certain areas and the success of the District, in the case of Instruction, there was likely no Core Expenditure increases net of inflation. Incremental increases in Resolution Revenue through an increase in tax assessed values alone will not be sufficient to fund the necessary increases in certain Core Expenditure areas. It is vital that the District takes a more hands on approach with measuring the relevant outcomes of the Resolution and using that information to guide their decision making. For this Committee to uphold its obligation under the Resolution, we need consistent, reliable information provided to us in a timely fashion during the year the expenses occur and in a format conducive to data analysis. 2022-2023 data was received by the committee on August 02, 2023, after the close of the fiscal year. This prevented the committee from overseeing expenditures in real time and fulfilling this caveat of the resolution. Supplemental information detailing year end accruals was delivered on June 06, 2024. Recognition of Staff We are grateful for the help of District staff members who have worked to provide the information presented, and we must work together to establish a more streamlined, recurring flow of information each and every quarter. We would like to specifically thank Rachel Sellers, Ryan Juengling, and Kevin Chapman for their efforts and guidance. 14

pg. 10 Schedule C 2022/2023 Career and Technical Education Millage Budget: In 2022/2023, the Career and Technical Education millage budget was utilized on the continued expansion of programs and replacement/upgrade of equipment at district middle and high schools. Multiple school’s received upgrades for their computer labs, 3D printers, interactive panel displays, large format printers and online curriculum. The Lincoln Medical Program received support to expand the skills lab and patient simulation area. Multiple schools received enhancements to their Agriscience land labs. Sugg and Nolan middle school’s received Garner Holt computers and animatronics kits. Funds were used to support new industry certification testing and training for Academy administrators. Millage funds also supported middle and high school participation in Career and Technical Student Organization (CTSO) national competition. 2022/2023 Science Millage Budget: Science millage funds spent in 2022/2023 were focused on expanding current programs into new schools, and to providing resources and materials needed for science teachers to engage in real-world, hands-on lessons. Progress Learning was added as a progress monitoring program for grades 6-12 as well as continued with Generation Genius, and the Discovery Education Experience. Gizmos (explore learning) were added for grades 6–12 which are online, real-world simulations and case studies for students to expand on not only their content knowledge, but to apply Nature of Science and Science & Engineering data analysis skills. Funds were used to upgrade equipment and add supplies to several secondary schools such as Manatee High, Sugg’s new campus, Haile, and Johnson K-8. Additional Science Woz Ed kits for many schools were upgraded and additional Woz Ed STEM kits were added to Ballard, Bashaw and Palm View. 2022/2023 STEM Elementary Millage Budget: During the 2022/2023 school year, the elementary millage budget was used to provide cutting edge technology for Elementa

Sources and limits

Published sources used on this page

This meeting has been held, but no source-backed decision record is available yet. Agenda items remain proposals.

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.

Canonical record: a9421b292b6fc95ee73b4d5002e83a65. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record