POLISCOPE

The public record

MARTINEZ (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Civil Service Commission

Monday, July 14, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Civil Service Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

WE WILL OPEN WITH A CALL TO ORDER. THIS ABILITY STATEMENT. AS YOUR APPOINTED GOVERNING BOARD, WE WILL TREAT EACH OTHER, THE PUBLIC WITH CIVILITY AND COURTESY. WE WISH TO REFLECT THE CONDUCT OF ALL CITY BUSINESS AND COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION. THIS INCLUDES RESPECT FOR EVERYONE'S FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINION WITHIN THE CITY'S SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION EVEN IF THAT OPINION IS DIFFERENT FROM OUR OWN. THE DECISIONS MADE TONIGHT WILL BE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE COMMUNITY AND NOT FOR [ INAUDIBLE ] NOW WE MOVE ON TO PUBLIC COMMENT FOR AGENDA ITEMS ONLY. IS THE ONE PERSON WE HAVE FROM THE PUBLIC ONLINE SHEET TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT ON ANY ITEMS ON THE AGENDA? >> THAT PERSON DROPPED OFF. >> THAT MAKES THAT EASY. WE WILL MOVE ON TO THE ACTION ITEMS . FIRST ONE IS APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FROM THE MAY 6th MEETING WHICH IS ATTACHED TO THE PACKET . I DID HAVE A COMMENT. BUT WE WILL SEE IF THERE ARE COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. I WAS NOT PRESENT AT THAT MEETING . >> MY LAST NAME IS SPELLED WITH 1C AND NOT TWO. ITIS THAT WAY THROUGHOUT THE DOCUMENT. A DISCUSSION FOR EACH OF THE ITEMS. THERE WASN'T ANY CAPTURING. BUT THERE WAS DISCUSSION. FOR EACH OF THE STAFF REPORTS FOR EXAMPLE, WE DID HAVE CONVERSATION AND THE COMMISSION DID HAVE QUESTIONS. THERE WAS FEEDBACK FROM STAFF FOR THE RESIGNATION OF THE COMMISSIONER AND SOME DIALOGUE ABOUT SERVICE. TALKING ABOUT THAT, THERE WAS A ONE LINE STATEMENT SAYING THAT HE RESIGNED . TOOK ACTION ON THE ITEM . I THINK FOR THE RECORD, FOR THE PUBLIC, THEY SHOULD SEE WE ARE ENGAGING. OTHERWISE IT LOOKS LIKE WE ARE JUST RUBBERSTAMPING STAFF AND NEVER HAD ANY DIALOGUE. I WOULD SUGGEST --DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO GO BACK AND AMEND THE MINUTES BUT I THINK IT WOULD BE HELPFUL TO INDICATE -- EVERYONE I WAS ASSOCIATED WITH THE DIFFERENT AMOUNTS OF DETAIL. SOMETIMES IT IS VERY DETAILED. OTHER TIMES, A SUMMARY. THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT QUESTIONS OR ABOUT MARIETTA. STAFF SAID THEY WOULD MAKE CORRECTIONS. WE HAD SOME DIALOGUE THAT WE LOOKED AT AND MADE CHANGES. I THINK THAT SHOULD BE DOCUMENTED. SO THAT IT IS CLEAR FOR THE RECORD. ORIGINALLY, WE WOULD DO VERY DETAILED MINUTES THEN WE WENT TO ACTION MINUTES. THAT IS GOOD FEEDBACK. >> I DON'T WANT TO BURDEN STAFF. AND WHAT THAT IS LIKE. BUT A FEW SENTENCES AT LEAST KIND OF COMMEMORATING WHAT WAS COVERED. 'S AND SOME NEWER, I THOUGHT THIS IS NORMAL. AT THAT THERE WOULD BE TO JUST THE FACT THAT WE ASKED ABOUT EDUCATION LEVEL. WE HAD SOME DISCUSSION POINTS. SO THE PUBLIC KNOWS THAT. >> GOOD FEEDBACK. THANK YOU. THAT WAS MY ONLY COMMENT ON THE MINUTES. SO A MOTION TO APPROVE THEM. I CAN'T MAKE THAT. CHAIR . I WASN'T THERE SO I DON'T THINK I CAN PARTICIPATE . >> I PROPOSE THAT WE [ INAUDIBLE ] THE MINUTES . >> I WILL SECOND THAT FOR LACK OF ANY OTHER PERSON WHO CAN. MOTION AND SECOND. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR, SAY AYE. >> AYE. >> ANYBODY OPPOSED? >> BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT HERE. MOVING ON TO THE SECOND ITEM. REVIEW WILL --REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF JOB DESCRIPTIONS AND COMMENT RECLASSIFICATION . THERE WAS A STAFF REPORT . DO YOU WANT TO SUMMARIZE THAT ? THERE WERE A COUPLE OF COMMENTS . >> I WILL STARTED OFF. WE HAVE THE SERIES OF ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE CLASSIFICATIONS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN REVISED IN MANY YEARS. WE CONDUCTED SURVEYS AND A JOB ANALYSIS WITH EACH INCUMBENT . AND WE ALSO WILL BE RECOMMENDING A RECLASSIFICATION TO ONE OF THE ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN POSITIONS TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE POSITION. IT WAS NECESSARY TO REVISE THESE JOB CLASSIFICATIONS TO ACCURATELY DESCRIBE THE DUTIES THEY PERFORM. AND IN ADDITION, TO REALLY LOOK AT THE EDUCATION UNEXPERIENCED BACKGROUND TO BE MORE IN LINE WITH WHAT IS IN THE MARKET. >> NO COMMENTS FROM YOU? >> MY QUESTION IS, I THOUGHT THE CHANGES WERE ALL REALLY GOOD. OBVIOUSLY THE DETAIL FLOWED WELL. ONE THING THAT IS A PET PEEVE OF MINE BECAUSE I HAD TO DO SO MUCH PROOFREADING EARLY IN MY CAREER, IS --AND A LOT OF AGENCIES DO THIS. GOING BETWEEN SINGULAR AND PLURAL ON DESCRIPTIONS OF THE ACTIONS OR THE DUTIES . I WROTE DOWN ONE EXAMPLE . PLANS AND ORGANIZED WORK ACTIVITIES. IT SHOULD BE PLANS AND ORGANIZES . SO SOME CONTINUITY. FOR ALL OF THOSE RESPECTS WHERE IT IS INCONSISTENT. AND WITHIN THE LIST, JUST PICK ONE . WHICHEVER WAY YOU GO, IT WOULD BE A GOOD IDEA . >> I LIKED A LOT THAT YOU ADDED FOR THE TWO AND THE THREE AND THE KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES AND THOSE SUBHEADINGS OF ADMINISTRATIVE PROFICIENCY AND PROBLEM SOLVING AND BATCHING THOSE IN WAYS THAT TO THE READER, IT IS MORE HELPFUL . IF I'M AN APPLICANT TRYING TO SEE WHAT THAT JOB REALLY IS, MOST AGENCIES JUST HAVE THOSE RIDICULOUSLY LONG LISTS OF BULLET POINTS THAT YOUR EYES GLAZE OVER AFTER A WHILE. SO THAT WAS NEW AND I THOUGHT THAT WAS A REAL IMPROVEMENT. IT IS REALLY ONLY THE TWO AND THREE LEVEL WHERE YOU EXPECT THE HIGHER LEVEL FUNCTIONAL SKILLS TO BE. SO THAT WAS GOOD. MY QUESTION ON THE TWO --AND YOU PROBABLY HAVE AN ANSWER RELATED AND I DIDN'T HAVE TIME TO GO LOOK AT IT. THE MQS, AND THIS MAKES SENSE, THAT YOU CAN'T PROMOTE INTERNALLY TO A TWO UNLESS YOU HAVE BEEN 18 MONTHS AS A ONE. AND YET THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENT FOR TWO IS JUST ONE YEAR AS A ONE OR THE EQUIVALENT . SOMEONE COULD COME IN FROM OUTSIDE HAVING THE EQUIVALENT OF YEAR ONE AND BE IMMEDIATELY APPOINTED TO A TWO . THERE WAS ALSO LANGUAGE THAT SAID ANOTHER REQUIREMENT IS THEY HAD TO PASS AN EVALUATION . I HAVE NEVER SEEN THAT LANGUAGE. IT IS NORMALLY WITH PASS PROBATION. AND THE DELETED LANGUAGE, THERE WAS A REFERENCE TO THE MOU EVALUATION. I WASN'T SURE WHAT THAT WAS ABOUT. >> SO THE MOU LANGUAGE HAS A SOMEWHAT DETAILED LIST OF FACTORS TO CONSIDER WHEN A REQUEST EITHER INITIATED BY THE EMPLOYEE OR THEIR SUPERVISOR IS SUBMITTED. AND IT TAKES INTO CONSIDERATION PAST HISTORY, PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS . YOU KNOW, OVERALL PERFORMANCE LEVEL AND ATTENDANCE. ALL OTHER THINGS THAT ONE WOULD CONSIDER IN ASSESSING A PERSON'S SUITABILITY FOR HIGHER LEVEL RESPONSIBILITY RESPONSIBILITY. ALSO, MAINTAINING SOME SORT OF RARENESS SINCE THIS IS OUTSIDE OF A STANDARD RECRUITMENT PROCESS THAT RESULTS IN A PROMOTION. SOTHAT IS REALLY MORE CONSISTENT WITH THE LANGUAGE OF THE MOU. >> I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING. MAY BE A REFERENCE TO THE MOU SECTION THERE MAYBE. >> CONSISTENT WITH THE STANDARDS. >> WHAT DOES THAT MEAN ? AN EVALUATION . IS THAT A LOGICAL EVALUATION? ARE WE TAKING A WRITTEN EXAM ? JUST A REFERENCE OF THE MOU LANGUAGE . OR SECTION OF THE MOU REFERRING THE MAYOR TO SEE IT. WOULD WE THEN HAVE TO MAKE THE MOU AVAILABLE TO THE APPLICANT? THE FLEXING FOR FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES WITH REGULAR STATUS WITH THE CITY. SO THAT AVENUE WOULD NOT BE -- THIS KIND OF PROMOTION WOULD NOT BE AVAILABLE TO EXTERNAL CANDIDATES TYPICALLY, IT WOULD BE -- THERE WOULD BE THE RECRUITMENT FOR THE FLEXING OPTION. TO FILL A POSITION THAT IS VACANT AT THAT LEVEL WOULD BE OPEN TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC AS A RECRUITMENT AND THEN THEY GO AND MEETING THE REQUIREMENTS AND DEMONSTRATING COMPETENCY IN THOSE AREAS , OR THE RECRUITMENT WOULD BE OPEN ON A PROMOTIONAL BASIS , YOU KNOW, TO AN INTERNAL CANDIDATE OR PREFERABLY HIGHER THAN ONE CANDIDATE. OR, ALTERNATIVELY , A CANDIDATE WAS IN A POSITION TO EVOLVE OR AN ASSIGNMENT AT HIGHER LEVEL RECOMMENDATION COULD BE MADE EITHER BY SUPERVISOR. OR THE HIGHER-LEVEL RESPONSIBILITIES TO GET FLEXED IN THE POSITION GETS ASSIGNED TO A HIGHER LEVEL. LEVEL THREE. >> I HAVE NEVER SEEN A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEING IN THAT [ INAUDIBLE ] VERSUS THE OUTSIDE. IT SEEMS LIKE A DISADVANTAGE . >> THAT IS A VERY GOOD POINT. AND WE SHOULD PROBABLY TAKE A LOOK AT AT THAT. WE HAVE NOTICED THAT WITH EXTERNAL RECRUITMENTS, WHEN WE BRING CANDIDATES , THEY OFTEN COME IN WITH MORE SIGNIFICANT EXTERNAL EXPERIENCE AND AN AGREEMENT WE HAVE LOCAL --THAT WE HAVE REACHED WITH LOCAL 324 IS TO ALLOW CONSIDERATION OF THE CANDIDATE'S EXPERIENCE FROM THE OUTSIDE TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS. SO WE DON'T WANT TO LIMIT THE ABILITY TO FLEX UNTIL THEY REACH THE 18 MONTHS OF EMPLOYMENT BUT TO CONSIDER THE EXPERIENCE FROM THE PRIOR AGENCY, IF IT IS RELEVANT EXPERIENCE. OR THE INTERNAL CANDIDATE . >> YES. >> THE 18 MONTHS COULD BE A COMBINATION . >> YES . >> AND I GUESS YOU HAVE THAT DISCRETION AND THE REQUIREMENTS CAN BE GENERALLY MET WITH THE COMBINATION OF THE EXPERIENCE. >> CORRECT . >> THEY WOULD STILL HAVE THAT EXPERIENCE. IT JUST SEEMED A LITTLE BIT ARBITRARY. THERE IS ONLY A GROUP OF CLASSIFICATIONS WITH THE FLEXIBLE PROMOTION BEING OFFERED AS AN OPTION. IT JUST SEEMED ARBITRARY WITH CANDIDATES THAT SOME CAN PUSH THAT SOMETIMES CAME IN WITH FIVE OR SIX YEARS OF EXPERIENCE WITH THEIR AGENCIES AND WE WOULD RESTRICT THEIR ABILITY TO MOVE UP. AND THEN THEY WANT TO WORK SPECIFICALLY IN THE AGENCY BUT THEY WILL BE STUCK WITH THEIR ABILITY TO PROMOTE BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T HAVE THE 18 MONTH SERVICE REQUIREMENT. THEY WOULD HAVE TO HAVE A REGULAR STANDING AND COMPLETED THE PROBATIONARY PERIOD BUT THEY WOULD HAVE TO SIT AND WAIT. SO RESOLVE THAT BY AGREEING THIS EXTERNAL MUST -- >> YOU HAVE YOUR MICROPHONE ON? I'M THINKING THIS SPEAKERS ARE NOT -- I GUESS WHAT I'M WORRIED ABOUT, IT SOUNDS A GOOD SOLUTION BUT THEORETICALLY COULD ANOTHER EMPLOYEE GRIEF? LANGUAGE SAYS THEY HAVE TO SIT IN THAT SEAT FOR 18 MONTHS. IF I HAVE ONLY BEEN IN THE SEAT FOR NINE MONTHS AND YOU PROMOTE ME BASED ON FIVE YEARS OF OUTSIDE EXPERIENCE, COULD ANOTHER PERSON THAT WANTED THE JOB AND HAS BEEN WITH THE CITY LONGER -- >> ANYBODY CAN REQUEST CONSIDERATION. IT IS INTERESTING YOU ARE BRINGING THIS. FOR THE CLASSIFICATIONS THAT ARE ELIGIBLE FOR THIS OPTION, WE ARE SEEING IT GO TWO WAYS. SO HOLDING PEOPLE BACK. ON ANOTHER HAND, WE HAVE SOME EMPLOYEES THAT WOULD BE ELIGIBLE. BUT PERHAPS NOT MOTIVATED TO MEET WHATEVER THE MILESTONES ARE FOR THEM TO BE GIVEN THAT CONSIDERATION . MAYBE A CERTIFICATION REQUIREMENT OR SPECIAL LICENSE . AND WE HAVE BEEN ASKED , WHAT CAN WE DO TO ENHANCE THEIR INTEREST AND YOU CAN'T REALLY MAKE SOMEBODY -- REQUIRE THEM TO --THEY WILL STILL BE AT THE LOWER LEVEL BUT WE ARE NOT DEVELOPING PEOPLE BECAUSE ONE PERSON MAY NOT BE INTERESTED. IN A WAY, WE ARE NOT STACKED BASED ON SENIORITY , RESERVING THE OPPORTUNITY FOR ADVANCEMENT. MAYBE NOT MOTIVATED. AND ANOTHER PERSON COMES IN AND IS MOTIVATED AND IS READY TO PURSUE THOSE REQUIREMENTS. >> I UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN BUT YOU COULD GET AGREEMENTS. WE MET AND CONFERRED . THEY ASKED FOR IT. WHAT WAS THE FIRST PART OF WHAT YOU SAID? >> WE MET AND CONFERRED WITH THE UNION. >> THERE IS A SIGNED LETTER OF AGREEMENT ATTACHED TO THE MOU THAT SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSES THAT . ABSOLUTELY. WE DEFINITELY WOULD NOT HAVE DONE IT . >>> I WAS HAVING TROUBLE HEARING YOU. SORRY. WE HAVE AN AGREEMENT THAT IS SIGNED AND DOCUMENTED. >> OKAY . >> THAT IS A GOOD ANSWER . >> ALWAYS . >> I THINK THAT WAS ALL OF MY QUESTIONS. YOU DIDN'T HAVE THE RECREATION SUPERVISOR HERE FOR CHANGES ? >> THERE ARE TWO SEPARATE STAFF REPORTS. >> SORRY. I'M MOVING AHEAD. >> DOES ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? >> I'M CURIOUS. WILL WE ELIMINATE THE POSITION OF ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN? YES. THAT IS THE CIVIL SERVICE RULES WORK THEY REQUIRE THAT WHEN THE INCUMBENT OR WHEN THE POSITION IS RECLASSIFIED, THE POSITION IS, THEY ARE BASICALLY SWAPPED . AND IT IS THE POSITION AND NOT THE CLASSIFICATION . SO THE CLASSIFICATION WILL REMAIN. WE STILL HAVE THE ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN ONE, TWO AND THREE AND WE HAVE OTHER INCUMBENTS AND OTHER AREAS. THE POSITION IS BASICALLY REPLACE ONE FOR ONE. THEY ARE ON THE SAME SALARY RANGE AS THE TECHNICIAN AS ALLOCATED SAME WAY AS THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE . SO A1, FOR ONE SWAPPED. NO PHYSICAL IMPACT ON THAT. JUST A MORE PROPER WAY OF CLASSIFYING A PARTICULAR EMPLOYEE. SO THERE IS THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE TO NOT A HIGHER SALARY RANGE? IT IS ONE, TO ONE. SO ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN ONE IS THE SAME AS ADMINISTERED OF AID ONE. AND ACCOUNTANT TWO IS THE SAME AS TWO AND THE SAME GOES FOR LEVEL THREE. IT IS A SLIDE . IT MAKES SENSE. YOU KEEP THE CLASSIFICATIONS. >> YES. AND WE DID A CLOSE LOOK AT THAT BECAUSE , WHAT STARTED THE WHOLE PROCESS WAS ACTUALLY THE REQUEST FOR RECLASSIFICATION. IT WAS ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN TWO THAT WAS AT ONE OF THE SITES. THE ONE WE WANTED TO CLASSIFY . AT THE RECLASSIFICATION OF ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN THREE. BUT NOTHING DOING SIMILAR TO WHAT THAT POSITION DOES. ALL OF THE POSITIONS IN THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT, THE SCOPE OF WORK IS VERY DIFFERENT. AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDES, WE HAVE ONE OF THEM AND ABOUT EVERY SINGLE PROGRAM AREA. WE HAVE ONE IN THE RECREATION DEPARTMENT. ONE AND PLANNING. ONE IN ENGINEERING . WHAT THEY DO IS FULLSCOPE ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT TO THOSE PROGRAMS . SO DEALING WITH PUBLIC AND PREPARING MEETINGS AND AGENDAS AND REPORTS AND DEALING WITH ALL KINDS OF FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS RELATED TO THE PERMITS PROCESSING AND ACCOUNTING FOR FEES COMING IN. NOT SO MUCH ACCOUNTING BUT BOOKKEEPING FOR THOSE THINGS. SO THAT IS WHAT KINDA PROMPTED THE WHOLE PROCESS TO START WITH . INADDITION TO THAT, IT WAS THE RECRUITMENT AND PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT. VERY HARD TO PERFORMANCE MANAGE WHEN YOUR DESCRIPTIONS ARE OUTDATED BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT REALLY ATTACHED TO WHAT THE PERSON DOES ON A DAILY BASIS OR EVALUATING THIS , THE SKILLS PRESENTED THROUGH THE DAILY WORK. >> THE FIRST SENTENCE IT SOUNDS LIKE DICTATING . >> YES. WE ARE VERY HAPPY THAT WE ARE ADDRESSING THAT. I DON'T EVEN KNOW -- NOBODY HAS BEEN DOING DICTATION HERE I DON'T THINK. I'M GOING TO GUESS FOR 20 YEARS. >> I LIKE DIFFERENT DEFINITIONS OF TECHNOLOGY . TRYING TO DESCRIBE DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGIES THAT WE USED TO DO. I THINK ONE OF THEM MAY BE FOR -- HAVING TO KEEP UP WITH WHAT THE LATEST IS AND LEARN IT. JUST EXPECTING IT TO STAY CURRENT AND WHATEVER TECHNOLOGY IS BEING USED. IT IS HELPFUL NOT TO KEEP HAVING TO ADJUST THIS BACK . I LIKE THERE IS ALSO SOCIAL MEDIA . MAYBE UNDER THE PURVIEW OF MARKETING. AND THE POST- IN-LINE WITH TAKING PICTURES AT EVENTS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT . IT DIFFERS FROM ONE ASSIGNMENT TO ANOTHER. THE PERSON THAT SUPPORTS THE RECREATION DEPARTMENT, THEY DO A LOT OF PUBLICATION , SOCIAL MEDIA. NOT THE ONLY PERSON BUT THERE IS A LITTLE MORE FOCUS. THEPLANNING DEPARTMENT ALSO HAS A LOT OF OUTREACH AND PUBLIC HEARINGS. SO KEEPING THE PUBLIC INFORMED. NOT AS MUCH WITH ENGINEERING. BUT WE WANT IT TO REFLECT THE DUTIES OF THE POSITIONS AND WHAT THEY HAVE BEEN FOR QUITE SOME TIME. OKAY, WE ARE GOOD . IF -- IF THERE ARE NO OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, WE CAN MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE . MOTION TO APPROVE THE STAFF REPORT WITH THE CHANGES OUTLINED . >> MOTION AND SECOND TO APPROVE THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE 1-2-3 JOB RECODIFICATIONS. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR, AYE. >> AND HE OPPOSED . APPROVAL. THIRD ITEM. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE RECREATION COORDINATOR JOB DESCRIPTION AND AMEND THE CITY'S CLASSIFICATION PLAN TO ELIMINATE THE SENIOR CITIZEN COORDINATOR AND SENIOR CITIZEN SUPERVISOR CLASSIFICATIONS. I'M GLAD YOU ARE ILLUMINATING SENIOR CITIZEN SUPERVISOR. AS A SENIOR CITIZEN, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHO YOU THINK YOU WOULD BE SUPERVISING . >> I ALWAYS WONDERED ABOUT THE TITLE . >> WE ARE VERY HAPPY. >> I CHUCKLED WHEN I READ THAT. >> ANY COMMENTS? >> NO . IT IS LONG OVERDUE. WE HAVE DONE A FAIRLY COMPREHENSIVE STUDY LAST YEAR WHEN THE REDECORATION STAFF WAS LOOKING AT WORKLOADS AND THINGS OF THAT NATURE . THERE REALLY AREN'T ANY AGENCIES THAT HAVE DESIGNATED SENIOR STAFF. MORE BROADLY DEFINED RECREATION PROFESSIONALS AND THEY DEAL WITH WHATEVER PROGRAMS MAY COME. THEY MAY HAVE SPECIFIC ACTIVITIES ASSIGNED AT THE SENIOR CENTER LOCATION BUT THEY DO OTHER THINGS. AND IT WAS REALLY AN ISSUE OF MAKING SURE PEOPLE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ROTATE THROUGHOUT THE ASSIGNMENT AREAS AND NOT LIMITED TO JUST THE SENIOR CENTER. THAT IS REALLY THE CORE OF THAT . THIS WAS DONE LAST YEAR. IT WAS DONE THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCEEDINGS WHERE THE POSITIONS WERE BASICALLY SWAPPED . WE JUST LEFT THOSE CLASSIFICATIONS ON THE BOOKS. SO WE WOULD GET YOUR INPUT ON THAT. OF LEOR AN AGREEMENT. SO WE WOULD BRING THOSE FROM THE CLASSIFICATION CLASS LIST. DID I READ FROM THE REPORT THAT YOU HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE THE SWAP AS THE AUTHORITY? >> I AM TECHNICALLY NOT THE PERSON. IT IS THE CITY MANAGER. YOU SAID TO DO IT THROUGH THE BUDGET. OTHERWISE, BRINGING CHANGES TO THE CLASSIFICATION PLAN . >> THE POSITION , THE BUDGET AUTHORITY TO DO THAT THROUGH THE BUDGET. THAT IS WHY THE CLASSIFICATION IS ON THE BOOKS. WE CAN JUST GET RID OF THE CLASSIFICATION FROM THE PLANS . >> THIS DID NOT REQUIRE ANY [ INAUDIBLE ] IT REPRESENTED BOTH . >> ANY QUESTIONS . I THINK A LOT OF POSITIONS ARE MOVING TOWARD THAT . IT IS A LOT MORE INCLUSIVE I WANT TO POINT THAT OUT. >> WE FOUNDED THE RECRUITMENT EFFORTS THAT THEY ARE TWO PATHWAYS BY WHICH SOMEONE GETS INTO THAT FIELD. A LOT OF PEOPLE AND RECREATION START AS A PART-TIME STAFF AND DO IT ON A SEASONAL BASIS OR NUMBER OF YEARS. AND THERE IS NO EASY PATH FOR THEM TO DO IT. THEY ARE VERY DEDICATED. THEY ARE VERY -- THEYARE VERY INTERESTED . IT IS A BARRIER. AND SO WE ARE HOPING THAT THIS WILL JUST MAKE THE RECRUITMENT EFFORTS A LITTLE BIT THAT ARE . >> I AGREE . THAT WAS MY OBSERVATION TOO. >> IT MAKES SENSE IN THESE KINDS OF FIELDS. DOING THIS A LONG TIME. AND WHEN THE POOLS ARE WIDE , WE START LIKING THE EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS. EVEN THOUGH IT MAY NOT NECESSARILY BE APPROPRIATE. IT IS AN ARTIFICIAL BARRIER TO A LOT OF PEOPLE. A LOT OF AREAS WILL ADD BACK EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS BECAUSE IT WOULD BE NICE TO HAVE A DEGREE . AND YOUR GETTING SUFFICIENT APPLICANTS EVEN WITH THAT RESTRICTION. THESE DAYS, MOST AGENCIES ARE HAVING TROUBLE FINDING THE POSITIONS AND A LOT OF AGENCIES ARE HAVING DEGREE REQUIREMENTS AND A LOT OF AREAS. >> FOR 40 YEARS, HAVE BEEN DOING THIS. I'M GLAD TO SEE WE ARE GOING TO MORE OPEN. THAT IS MY PERSONAL PREFERENCE AS WELL . I THINK WE FEEL THAT WE HAVE WAYS BY WHICH WE CAN DESIGN OUR RECRUITMENT TO IDENTIFY THE MOST QUALIFIED PEOPLE WITHOUT EVEN --WITHOUT THAT BEING A FACTOR. THAT IS WHY THE COMPETENCY IS OUTLINED IN THERE. WE CAN STILL LOOK AT CONSIDERING EDUCATION IF WE CHOOSE TO. WHERE THERE IS ALLOWANCE ALLOWANCE. BUT IT IS NOT A HARD STOP TO WHERE -- MAY HAVE SOMEONE WITH FIVE YEARS OF EXPERIENCE THAT WOULD HAVE THAT MUCH MORE EXPERIENCE IN SUMMARY WITH A COMBINATION OF THE EDUCATION AND A LITTLE BIT OF EXPERIENCE. I THINK IT WILL BE A MORE FAIR PROCESS. . ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ? >> MOTION TO APPROVE? >> . >> WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE --THE JOB DESCRIPTION AND CLASSIFICATION PLAN TO ELIMINATE THE SENIOR CITIZEN COORDINATOR AND SENIOR CITIZEN CLASSIFICATION . ALL THOSE IN FAVOR , AYE. >> OPPOSED . >> THAT IS 3-0 ON THAT ACTION. THAT GETS US TO COMMISSIONER COMMENTS LET'S SEE IF ANYONE HAS ANYTHING TO ADD . I TOLD STAFF, I'M THE CHAIR AND WAS ELECTED A FEW MONTHS AGO. DID WE EVER ELECT A VICE CHAIR ? >> WE MAY NEED ONE. I WILL BE OUT OF THE COUNTRY FOR THREE MONTHS IN AUGUST AND IN THE --WILL BE LIVING IN SPAIN AND DOING SOME TRAVELING AND STUDYING. I WAS TELLING STAFF. NOT THAT I WOULD WANT TO SLOW DOWN THE WORK BUT I WAS HOPING MAYBE YOU WOULDN'T HAVE ANY ITEMS YOU WANT APPROVAL FOR. IF YOU DO, I WON'T EVEN BE ABLE TO ATTEND REMOTELY. I CAN ATTEND REMOTELY VIA ZOOM. THIS WILL BE LIKE 4:00 IN THE MORNING FOR ME. LOVE YOU GUYS BUT I'M NOT GOING TO DO THAT. IF WE HAVE TO HAVE ANOTHER MEETING OR BUSINESS TO HANDLE , SOMEONE WILL HAVE TO BE APPOINTED. THE BYLAWS SAID WHEN THE CHAIR IS NOT AVAILABLE, THE VICE CHAIR WILL ACT . SO IF YOU NEED TO CALL A MEETING , THERE WILL HAVE TO BE THE APPOINTMENT OF A VICE CHAIR SO THEY CAN FULFILL THAT ROLE. . I THINK THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE DONE IN THE PAST. >> YOU ARE THE VICE CHAIR . >> I THINK IT HAPPENED ON TWO DIFFERENT OCCASIONS WITH THE SPECIAL SESSIONS . >> MAY BE THEN. >> SO JUST TO GIVE YOU A HEADS UP , DO YOU ANTICIPATE OR SEE ANYTHING COMING IN THE NEXT FEW MONTHS LIKE HEARINGS OR ANYTHING? I THINK AUGUST, WE PLAN TO BE RELATIVELY LOW FOR COUNCIL . THAT IS WHY THE MEETING WAS SCHEDULED AS A SPECIAL MEETING TO KIND OF GET THE BUSINESS DONE BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL TOOK THE NEXT STEP FOR US IN THE PROCESS IS TO PRESENT THESE ITEMS TO THE CITY COUNCIL . WILL THERE BE A MEETING IN AUGUST? NO BUT THERE IS ANOTHER MEETING ON JULY 30TH. SO THERE IS A MEETING TOMORROW -- I MEAN, THERE IS A MEETING THIS WEDNESDAY AND THEN IN TWO WEEKS. WE HOPE TO PRESENT IT THEN AND WE SHOULD BE GOOD UNTIL ALLISON GETS BACK. I WANT TO MAKE SURE, IF WE HAVE TO DO A LITTLE SIDESTEP. I DON'T EVEN WANT TO SAY IT. I WILL BE BACK . >> THAT IS EXCITING . >> I HOPE TO BE FLUENT . I KEEP TRYING . IF THERE ARE NO OTHER COMMENTS OR ANYTHING THAT STAFF NEEDS TO SAY, I THINK WE CAN ADJOURN . I DON'T HAVE A GAVEL TO HIT. BUT 6:02 P.M. . >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU ALL FOR THE STAFF REPORTS.

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA DATE: Monday, July 14, 2025 TIME: 5:30 PM PLACE: City Council Chamber – 525 Henrietta Street, Martinez CA 94553; via Zoom INFORMATION FOR THE PUBLIC Information regarding meetings, including agenda materials, schedules and more, please visit the City’s Meetings & Agendas webpage: https://www.cityofmartinez.org/government/meetings-and-agendas. REMOTE PARTICIPATION This meeting will be conducted in-person in the City Hall Council Chamber and shall be aired in real time via Zoom. The City cannot guarantee the public’s access to teleconferencing technology, nor guarantee uninterrupted access as technical difficulties may occur from time to time. If attending via Zoom, please join us by choosing any of the following options: 1. Via Mobile Phone or Desktop, using the Zoom App direct link. 2. Via Web Browser: https://cityofmartinez- org.zoom.us/j/93656270339?pwd=SbLf85UJ8yMAkbs1V0h73jm3LYTmre.1 Meeting ID: 936 5627 0339 Passcode: 243895 3. Via Phone by calling (669) 900- 9128 and enter the provided meeting details above. ADA ACCOMODATIONS In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and California law, the Council Chamber is wheelchair accessible and disabled parking is available at City Hall. If you are a person with a disability and require modifications or accommodation to attend and/or participate in this meeting, please contact the Human Resources at (925) 372-3522. Notification 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility.

CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL - Commissioners: Allison Piccard, Chair Ben Therriault Rhial Patel Alternate Commissioners: Debi Mackey Yasmin Zand CIVILITY STATEMENT - As your appointed Governing Board, we will treat each other and the public with patience, civility, and courtesy as a model of the same behavior we wish to reflect in Martinez for the conduct of all City business and community participation. This includes respect for everyone's First Amendment Right to voice their opinion on matters within the City's subject matter jurisdiction, even if that opinion is different from our own. The decisions made tonight will be for the benefit of the Martinez community and not for personal gain. PUBLIC COMMENT - Agenda items only. ACTION ITEMS 1. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FOR MAY 6, 2025, MEETING Civil Service 05062025 action items minutes - draft.docx 2. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE I, II AND III JOB DESCRIPTIONS AND INCUMBENT RECLASSIFICATION TO ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE II SR Administrative Aide Series Review and Revise 7-102025.docx Administrative Aide I Draft 7-3-25 - Strikethrough.pdf Administrative Aide I Draft 7-3-25 Clean.pdf Administrative Aide II Draft 7-3-25 Strikethrough.pdf Administrative Aide II Draft 7-3-25 Clean.pdf Administrative Aide III Draft 7-11-25 -Strikethrough.pdf Administrative Aide III Draft 7-11-25 - Clean.pdf 3. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE RECREATION COORDINATOR JOB DESCRIPTION AND AMEND THE CITY'S CLASSIFICATION PLAN TO ELIMINATE THE SENIOR CITIZEN COORDINATOR AND SENIOR CITIZEN SUPERVISOR CLASSIFICATIONS SR Senior Center Classifications 7-10-2025.docx

Recreation Coordinator Draft 7-11-25 Strikethrough.pdf Recreation Coordinator Draft 7-11-25 Clean.pdf Senior Citizen Supervisor Job Description.pdf Senior Citizen Coordinator Job Description.pdf COMMISSIONER COMMENTS ADJOURNMENT - I hereby certify the Civil Service Commission agenda was posted on July 11, 2025. Marta Goc, Commission Secretary

WE WILL OPEN WITH A CALL TO ORDER. THIS ABILITY STATEMENT. AS YOUR APPOINTED GOVERNING BOARD, WE WILL TREAT EACH OTHER, THE PUBLIC WITH CIVILITY AND COURTESY. WE WISH TO REFLECT THE CONDUCT OF ALL CITY BUSINESS AND COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION. THIS INCLUDES RESPECT FOR EVERYONE'S FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINION WITHIN THE CITY'S SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION EVEN IF THAT OPINION IS DIFFERENT FROM OUR OWN. THE DECISIONS MADE TONIGHT WILL BE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE COMMUNITY AND NOT FOR [ INAUDIBLE ] NOW WE MOVE ON TO PUBLIC COMMENT FOR AGENDA ITEMS ONLY. IS THE ONE PERSON WE HAVE FROM THE PUBLIC ONLINE SHEET TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT ON ANY ITEMS ON THE AGENDA? >> THAT PERSON DROPPED OFF. >> THAT MAKES THAT EASY. WE WILL MOVE ON TO THE ACTION ITEMS . FIRST ONE IS APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FROM THE MAY 6th MEETING WHICH IS ATTACHED TO THE PACKET . I DID HAVE A COMMENT. BUT WE WILL SEE IF THERE ARE COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. I WAS NOT PRESENT AT THAT MEETING . >> MY LAST NAME IS SPELLED WITH 1C AND NOT TWO. ITIS THAT WAY THROUGHOUT THE DOCUMENT. A DISCUSSION FOR EACH OF THE ITEMS. THERE WASN'T ANY CAPTURING. BUT THERE WAS DISCUSSION. FOR EACH OF THE STAFF REPORTS FOR EXAMPLE, WE DID HAVE CONVERSATION AND THE COMMISSION DID HAVE QUESTIONS. THERE WAS FEEDBACK FROM STAFF FOR THE RESIGNATION OF THE COMMISSIONER AND SOME DIALOGUE ABOUT SERVICE. TALKING ABOUT THAT, THERE WAS A ONE LINE STATEMENT SAYING THAT HE RESIGNED . TOOK ACTION ON THE ITEM . I THINK FOR THE RECORD, FOR THE PUBLIC, THEY SHOULD SEE WE ARE ENGAGING. OTHERWISE IT LOOKS LIKE WE ARE JUST RUBBERSTAMPING STAFF AND NEVER HAD ANY DIALOGUE. I WOULD SUGGEST --DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO GO BACK AND AMEND THE MINUTES BUT I THINK IT WOULD BE HELPFUL TO INDICATE -- EVERYONE I WAS ASSOCIATED WITH THE DIFFERENT AMOUNTS OF DETAIL. SOMETIMES IT IS VERY DETAILED. OTHER TIMES, A SUMMARY. THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT QUESTIONS OR ABOUT MARIETTA. STAFF SAID THEY WOULD MAKE CORRECTIONS. WE HAD SOME DIALOGUE THAT WE LOOKED AT AND MADE CHANGES. I THINK THAT SHOULD BE DOCUMENTED. SO THAT IT IS CLEAR FOR THE RECORD. ORIGINALLY, WE WOULD DO VERY DETAILED MINUTES THEN WE WENT TO ACTION MINUTES. THAT IS GOOD FEEDBACK. >> I DON'T WANT TO BURDEN STAFF. AND WHAT THAT IS LIKE. BUT A FEW SENTENCES AT LEAST KIND OF COMMEMORATING WHAT WAS COVERED. 'S AND SOME NEWER, I THOUGHT THIS IS NORMAL. AT THAT THERE WOULD BE TO JUST THE FACT THAT WE ASKED ABOUT EDUCATION LEVEL. WE HAD SOME DISCUSSION POINTS. SO THE PUBLIC KNOWS THAT. >> GOOD FEEDBACK. THANK YOU. THAT WAS MY ONLY COMMENT ON THE MINUTES. SO A MOTION TO APPROVE THEM. I CAN'T MAKE THAT. CHAIR . I WASN'T THERE SO I DON'T THINK I CAN PARTICIPATE . >> I PROPOSE THAT WE [ INAUDIBLE ] THE MINUTES . >> I WILL SECOND THAT FOR LACK OF ANY OTHER PERSON WHO CAN. MOTION AND SECOND. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR, SAY AYE. >> AYE. >> ANYBODY OPPOSED? >> BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT HERE. MOVING ON TO THE SECOND ITEM. REVIEW WILL --REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF JOB DESCRIPTIONS AND COMMENT RECLASSIFICATION . THERE WAS A STAFF REPORT . DO YOU WANT TO SUMMARIZE THAT ? THERE WERE A COUPLE OF COMMENTS . >> I WILL STARTED OFF. WE HAVE THE SERIES OF ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE CLASSIFICATIONS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN REVISED IN MANY YEARS. WE CONDUCTED SURVEYS AND A JOB ANALYSIS WITH EACH INCUMBENT . AND WE ALSO WILL BE RECOMMENDING A RECLASSIFICATION TO ONE OF THE ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN POSITIONS TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE POSITION. IT WAS NECESSARY TO REVISE THESE JOB CLASSIFICATIONS TO ACCURATELY DESCRIBE THE DUTIES THEY PERFORM. AND IN ADDITION, TO REALLY LOOK AT THE EDUCATION UNEXPERIENCED BACKGROUND TO BE MORE IN LINE WITH WHAT IS IN THE MARKET. >> NO COMMENTS FROM YOU? >> MY QUESTION IS, I THOUGHT THE CHANGES WERE ALL REALLY GOOD. OBVIOUSLY THE DETAIL FLOWED WELL. ONE THING THAT IS A PET PEEVE OF MINE BECAUSE I HAD TO DO SO MUCH PROOFREADING EARLY IN MY CAREER, IS --AND A LOT OF AGENCIES DO THIS. GOING BETWEEN SINGULAR AND PLURAL ON DESCRIPTIONS OF THE ACTIONS OR THE DUTIES . I WROTE DOWN ONE EXAMPLE . PLANS AND ORGANIZED WORK ACTIVITIES. IT SHOULD BE PLANS AND ORGANIZES . SO SOME CONTINUITY. FOR ALL OF THOSE RESPECTS WHERE IT IS INCONSISTENT. AND WITHIN THE LIST, JUST PICK ONE . WHICHEVER WAY YOU GO, IT WOULD BE A GOOD IDEA . >> I LIKED A LOT THAT YOU ADDED FOR THE TWO AND THE THREE AND THE KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES AND THOSE SUBHEADINGS OF ADMINISTRATIVE PROFICIENCY AND PROBLEM SOLVING AND BATCHING THOSE IN WAYS THAT TO THE READER, IT IS MORE HELPFUL . IF I'M AN APPLICANT TRYING TO SEE WHAT THAT JOB REALLY IS, MOST AGENCIES JUST HAVE THOSE RIDICULOUSLY LONG LISTS OF BULLET POINTS THAT YOUR EYES GLAZE OVER AFTER A WHILE. SO THAT WAS NEW AND I THOUGHT THAT WAS A REAL IMPROVEMENT. IT IS REALLY ONLY THE TWO AND THREE LEVEL WHERE YOU EXPECT THE HIGHER LEVEL FUNCTIONAL SKILLS TO BE. SO THAT WAS GOOD. MY QUESTION ON THE TWO --AND YOU PROBABLY HAVE AN ANSWER RELATED AND I DIDN'T HAVE TIME TO GO LOOK AT IT. THE MQS, AND THIS MAKES SENSE, THAT YOU CAN'T PROMOTE INTERNALLY TO A TWO UNLESS YOU HAVE BEEN 18 MONTHS AS A ONE. AND YET THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENT FOR TWO IS JUST ONE YEAR AS A ONE OR THE EQUIVALENT . SOMEONE COULD COME IN FROM OUTSIDE HAVING THE EQUIVALENT OF YEAR ONE AND BE IMMEDIATELY APPOINTED TO A TWO . THERE WAS ALSO LANGUAGE THAT SAID ANOTHER REQUIREMENT IS THEY HAD TO PASS AN EVALUATION . I HAVE NEVER SEEN THAT LANGUAGE. IT IS NORMALLY WITH PASS PROBATION. AND THE DELETED LANGUAGE, THERE WAS A REFERENCE TO THE MOU EVALUATION. I WASN'T SURE WHAT THAT WAS ABOUT. >> SO THE MOU LANGUAGE HAS A SOMEWHAT DETAILED LIST OF FACTORS TO CONSIDER WHEN A REQUEST EITHER INITIATED BY THE EMPLOYEE OR THEIR SUPERVISOR IS SUBMITTED. AND IT TAKES INTO CONSIDERATION PAST HISTORY, PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS . YOU KNOW, OVERALL PERFORMANCE LEVEL AND ATTENDANCE. ALL OTHER THINGS THAT ONE WOULD CONSIDER IN ASSESSING A PERSON'S SUITABILITY FOR HIGHER LEVEL RESPONSIBILITY RESPONSIBILITY. ALSO, MAINTAINING SOME SORT OF RARENESS SINCE THIS IS OUTSIDE OF A STANDARD RECRUITMENT PROCESS THAT RESULTS IN A PROMOTION. SOTHAT IS REALLY MORE CONSISTENT WITH THE LANGUAGE OF THE MOU. >> I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING. MAY BE A REFERENCE TO THE MOU SECTION THERE MAYBE. >> CONSISTENT WITH THE STANDARDS. >> WHAT DOES THAT MEAN ? AN EVALUATION . IS THAT A LOGICAL EVALUATION? ARE WE TAKING A WRITTEN EXAM ? JUST A REFERENCE OF THE MOU LANGUAGE . OR SECTION OF THE MOU REFERRING THE MAYOR TO SEE IT. WOULD WE THEN HAVE TO MAKE THE MOU AVAILABLE TO THE APPLICANT? THE FLEXING FOR FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES WITH REGULAR STATUS WITH THE CITY. SO THAT AVENUE WOULD NOT BE -- THIS KIND OF PROMOTION WOULD NOT BE AVAILABLE TO EXTERNAL CANDIDATES TYPICALLY, IT WOULD BE -- THERE WOULD BE THE RECRUITMENT FOR THE FLEXING OPTION. TO FILL A POSITION THAT IS VACANT AT THAT LEVEL WOULD BE OPEN TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC AS A RECRUITMENT AND THEN THEY GO AND MEETING THE REQUIREMENTS AND DEMONSTRATING COMPETENCY IN THOSE AREAS , OR THE RECRUITMENT WOULD BE OPEN ON A PROMOTIONAL BASIS , YOU KNOW, TO AN INTERNAL CANDIDATE OR PREFERABLY HIGHER THAN ONE CANDIDATE. OR, ALTERNATIVELY , A CANDIDATE WAS IN A POSITION TO EVOLVE OR AN ASSIGNMENT AT HIGHER LEVEL RECOMMENDATION COULD BE MADE EITHER BY SUPERVISOR. OR THE HIGHER-LEVEL RESPONSIBILITIES TO GET FLEXED IN THE POSITION GETS ASSIGNED TO A HIGHER LEVEL. LEVEL THREE. >> I HAVE NEVER SEEN A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEING IN THAT [ INAUDIBLE ] VERSUS THE OUTSIDE. IT SEEMS LIKE A DISADVANTAGE . >> THAT IS A VERY GOOD POINT. AND WE SHOULD PROBABLY TAKE A LOOK AT AT THAT. WE HAVE NOTICED THAT WITH EXTERNAL RECRUITMENTS, WHEN WE BRING CANDIDATES , THEY OFTEN COME IN WITH MORE SIGNIFICANT EXTERNAL EXPERIENCE AND AN AGREEMENT WE HAVE LOCAL --THAT WE HAVE REACHED WITH LOCAL 324 IS TO ALLOW CONSIDERATION OF THE CANDIDATE'S EXPERIENCE FROM THE OUTSIDE TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS. SO WE DON'T WANT TO LIMIT THE ABILITY TO FLEX UNTIL THEY REACH THE 18 MONTHS OF EMPLOYMENT BUT TO CONSIDER THE EXPERIENCE FROM THE PRIOR AGENCY, IF IT IS RELEVANT EXPERIENCE. OR THE INTERNAL CANDIDATE . >> YES. >> THE 18 MONTHS COULD BE A COMBINATION . >> YES . >> AND I GUESS YOU HAVE THAT DISCRETION AND THE REQUIREMENTS CAN BE GENERALLY MET WITH THE COMBINATION OF THE EXPERIENCE. >> CORRECT . >> THEY WOULD STILL HAVE THAT EXPERIENCE. IT JUST SEEMED A LITTLE BIT ARBITRARY. THERE IS ONLY A GROUP OF CLASSIFICATIONS WITH THE FLEXIBLE PROMOTION BEING OFFERED AS AN OPTION. IT JUST SEEMED ARBITRARY WITH CANDIDATES THAT SOME CAN PUSH THAT SOMETIMES CAME IN WITH FIVE OR SIX YEARS OF EXPERIENCE WITH THEIR AGENCIES AND WE WOULD RESTRICT THEIR ABILITY TO MOVE UP. AND THEN THEY WANT TO WORK SPECIFICALLY IN THE AGENCY BUT THEY WILL BE STUCK WITH THEIR ABILITY TO PROMOTE BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T HAVE THE 18 MONTH SERVICE REQUIREMENT. THEY WOULD HAVE TO HAVE A REGULAR STANDING AND COMPLETED THE PROBATIONARY PERIOD BUT THEY WOULD HAVE TO SIT AND WAIT. SO RESOLVE THAT BY AGREEING THIS EXTERNAL MUST -- >> YOU HAVE YOUR MICROPHONE ON? I'M THINKING THIS SPEAKERS ARE NOT -- I GUESS WHAT I'M WORRIED ABOUT, IT SOUNDS A GOOD SOLUTION BUT THEORETICALLY COULD ANOTHER EMPLOYEE GRIEF? LANGUAGE SAYS THEY HAVE TO SIT IN THAT SEAT FOR 18 MONTHS. IF I HAVE ONLY BEEN IN THE SEAT FOR NINE MONTHS AND YOU PROMOTE ME BASED ON FIVE YEARS OF OUTSIDE EXPERIENCE, COULD ANOTHER PERSON THAT WANTED THE JOB AND HAS BEEN WITH THE CITY LONGER -- >> ANYBODY CAN REQUEST CONSIDERATION. IT IS INTERESTING YOU ARE BRINGING THIS. FOR THE CLASSIFICATIONS THAT ARE ELIGIBLE FOR THIS OPTION, WE ARE SEEING IT GO TWO WAYS. SO HOLDING PEOPLE BACK. ON ANOTHER HAND, WE HAVE SOME EMPLOYEES THAT WOULD BE ELIGIBLE. BUT PERHAPS NOT MOTIVATED TO MEET WHATEVER THE MILESTONES ARE FOR THEM TO BE GIVEN THAT CONSIDERATION . MAYBE A CERTIFICATION REQUIREMENT OR SPECIAL LICENSE . AND WE HAVE BEEN ASKED , WHAT CAN WE DO TO ENHANCE THEIR INTEREST AND YOU CAN'T REALLY MAKE SOMEBODY -- REQUIRE THEM TO --THEY WILL STILL BE AT THE LOWER LEVEL BUT WE ARE NOT DEVELOPING PEOPLE BECAUSE ONE PERSON MAY NOT BE INTERESTED. IN A WAY, WE ARE NOT STACKED BASED ON SENIORITY , RESERVING THE OPPORTUNITY FOR ADVANCEMENT. MAYBE NOT MOTIVATED. AND ANOTHER PERSON COMES IN AND IS MOTIVATED AND IS READY TO PURSUE THOSE REQUIREMENTS. >> I UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN BUT YOU COULD GET AGREEMENTS. WE MET AND CONFERRED . THEY ASKED FOR IT. WHAT WAS THE FIRST PART OF WHAT YOU SAID? >> WE MET AND CONFERRED WITH THE UNION. >> THERE IS A SIGNED LETTER OF AGREEMENT ATTACHED TO THE MOU THAT SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSES THAT . ABSOLUTELY. WE DEFINITELY WOULD NOT HAVE DONE IT . >>> I WAS HAVING TROUBLE HEARING YOU. SORRY. WE HAVE AN AGREEMENT THAT IS SIGNED AND DOCUMENTED. >> OKAY . >> THAT IS A GOOD ANSWER . >> ALWAYS . >> I THINK THAT WAS ALL OF MY QUESTIONS. YOU DIDN'T HAVE THE RECREATION SUPERVISOR HERE FOR CHANGES ? >> THERE ARE TWO SEPARATE STAFF REPORTS. >> SORRY. I'M MOVING AHEAD. >> DOES ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? >> I'M CURIOUS. WILL WE ELIMINATE THE POSITION OF ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN? YES. THAT IS THE CIVIL SERVICE RULES WORK THEY REQUIRE THAT WHEN THE INCUMBENT OR WHEN THE POSITION IS RECLASSIFIED, THE POSITION IS, THEY ARE BASICALLY SWAPPED . AND IT IS THE POSITION AND NOT THE CLASSIFICATION . SO THE CLASSIFICATION WILL REMAIN. WE STILL HAVE THE ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN ONE, TWO AND THREE AND WE HAVE OTHER INCUMBENTS AND OTHER AREAS. THE POSITION IS BASICALLY REPLACE ONE FOR ONE. THEY ARE ON THE SAME SALARY RANGE AS THE TECHNICIAN AS ALLOCATED SAME WAY AS THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE . SO A1, FOR ONE SWAPPED. NO PHYSICAL IMPACT ON THAT. JUST A MORE PROPER WAY OF CLASSIFYING A PARTICULAR EMPLOYEE. SO THERE IS THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE TO NOT A HIGHER SALARY RANGE? IT IS ONE, TO ONE. SO ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN ONE IS THE SAME AS ADMINISTERED OF AID ONE. AND ACCOUNTANT TWO IS THE SAME AS TWO AND THE SAME GOES FOR LEVEL THREE. IT IS A SLIDE . IT MAKES SENSE. YOU KEEP THE CLASSIFICATIONS. >> YES. AND WE DID A CLOSE LOOK AT THAT BECAUSE , WHAT STARTED THE WHOLE PROCESS WAS ACTUALLY THE REQUEST FOR RECLASSIFICATION. IT WAS ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN TWO THAT WAS AT ONE OF THE SITES. THE ONE WE WANTED TO CLASSIFY . AT THE RECLASSIFICATION OF ACCOUNT TECHNICIAN THREE. BUT NOTHING DOING SIMILAR TO WHAT THAT POSITION DOES. ALL OF THE POSITIONS IN THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT, THE SCOPE OF WORK IS VERY DIFFERENT. AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDES, WE HAVE ONE OF THEM AND ABOUT EVERY SINGLE PROGRAM AREA. WE HAVE ONE IN THE RECREATION DEPARTMENT. ONE AND PLANNING. ONE IN ENGINEERING . WHAT THEY DO IS FULLSCOPE ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT TO THOSE PROGRAMS . SO DEALING WITH PUBLIC AND PREPARING MEETINGS AND AGENDAS AND REPORTS AND DEALING WITH ALL KINDS OF FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS RELATED TO THE PERMITS PROCESSING AND ACCOUNTING FOR FEES COMING IN. NOT SO MUCH ACCOUNTING BUT BOOKKEEPING FOR THOSE THINGS. SO THAT IS WHAT KINDA PROMPTED THE WHOLE PROCESS TO START WITH . INADDITION TO THAT, IT WAS THE RECRUITMENT AND PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT. VERY HARD TO PERFORMANCE MANAGE WHEN YOUR DESCRIPTIONS ARE OUTDATED BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT REALLY ATTACHED TO WHAT THE PERSON DOES ON A DAILY BASIS OR EVALUATING THIS , THE SKILLS PRESENTED THROUGH THE DAILY WORK. >> THE FIRST SENTENCE IT SOUNDS LIKE DICTATING . >> YES. WE ARE VERY HAPPY THAT WE ARE ADDRESSING THAT. I DON'T EVEN KNOW -- NOBODY HAS BEEN DOING DICTATION HERE I DON'T THINK. I'M GOING TO GUESS FOR 20 YEARS. >> I LIKE DIFFERENT DEFINITIONS OF TECHNOLOGY . TRYING TO DESCRIBE DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGIES THAT WE USED TO DO. I THINK ONE OF THEM MAY BE FOR -- HAVING TO KEEP UP WITH WHAT THE LATEST IS AND LEARN IT. JUST EXPECTING IT TO STAY CURRENT AND WHATEVER TECHNOLOGY IS BEING USED. IT IS HELPFUL NOT TO KEEP HAVING TO ADJUST THIS BACK . I LIKE THERE IS ALSO SOCIAL MEDIA . MAYBE UNDER THE PURVIEW OF MARKETING. AND THE POST- IN-LINE WITH TAKING PICTURES AT EVENTS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT . IT DIFFERS FROM ONE ASSIGNMENT TO ANOTHER. THE PERSON THAT SUPPORTS THE RECREATION DEPARTMENT, THEY DO A LOT OF PUBLICATION , SOCIAL MEDIA. NOT THE ONLY PERSON BUT THERE IS A LITTLE MORE FOCUS. THEPLANNING DEPARTMENT ALSO HAS A LOT OF OUTREACH AND PUBLIC HEARINGS. SO KEEPING THE PUBLIC INFORMED. NOT AS MUCH WITH ENGINEERING. BUT WE WANT IT TO REFLECT THE DUTIES OF THE POSITIONS AND WHAT THEY HAVE BEEN FOR QUITE SOME TIME. OKAY, WE ARE GOOD . IF -- IF THERE ARE NO OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, WE CAN MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE . MOTION TO APPROVE THE STAFF REPORT WITH THE CHANGES OUTLINED . >> MOTION AND SECOND TO APPROVE THE ADMINISTRATIVE AIDE 1-2-3 JOB RECODIFICATIONS. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR, AYE. >> AND HE OPPOSED . APPROVAL. THIRD ITEM. REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE RECREATION COORDINATOR JOB DESCRIPTION AND AMEND THE CITY'S CLASSIFICATION PLAN TO ELIMINATE THE SENIOR CITIZEN COORDINATOR AND SENIOR CITIZEN SUPERVISOR CLASSIFICATIONS. I'M GLAD YOU ARE ILLUMINATING SENIOR CITIZEN SUPERVISOR. AS A SENIOR CITIZEN, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHO YOU THINK YOU WOULD BE SUPERVISING . >> I ALWAYS WONDERED ABOUT THE TITLE . >> WE ARE VERY HAPPY. >> I CHUCKLED WHEN I READ THAT. >> ANY COMMENTS? >> NO . IT IS LONG OVERDUE. WE HAVE DONE A FAIRLY COMPREHENSIVE STUDY LAST YEAR WHEN THE REDECORATION STAFF WAS LOOKING AT WORKLOADS AND THINGS OF THAT NATURE . THERE REALLY AREN'T ANY AGENCIES THAT HAVE DESIGNATED SENIOR STAFF. MORE BROADLY DEFINED RECREATION PROFESSIONALS AND THEY DEAL WITH WHATEVER PROGRAMS MAY COME. THEY MAY HAVE SPECIFIC ACTIVITIES ASSIGNED AT THE SENIOR CENTER LOCATION BUT THEY DO OTHER THINGS. AND IT WAS REALLY AN ISSUE OF MAKING SURE PEOPLE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ROTATE THROUGHOUT THE ASSIGNMENT AREAS AND NOT LIMITED TO JUST THE SENIOR CENTER. THAT IS REALLY THE CORE OF THAT . THIS WAS DONE LAST YEAR. IT WAS DONE THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCEEDINGS WHERE THE POSITIONS WERE BASICALLY SWAPPED . WE JUST LEFT THOSE CLASSIFICATIONS ON THE BOOKS. SO WE WOULD GET YOUR INPUT ON THAT. OF LEOR AN AGREEMENT. SO WE WOULD BRING THOSE FROM THE CLASSIFICATION CLASS LIST. DID I READ FROM THE REPORT THAT YOU HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE THE SWAP AS THE AUTHORITY? >> I AM TECHNICALLY NOT THE PERSON. IT IS THE CITY MANAGER. YOU SAID TO DO IT THROUGH THE BUDGET. OTHERWISE, BRINGING CHANGES TO THE CLASSIFICATION PLAN . >> THE POSITION , THE BUDGET AUTHORITY TO DO THAT THROUGH THE BUDGET. THAT IS WHY THE CLASSIFICATION IS ON THE BOOKS. WE CAN JUST GET RID OF THE CLASSIFICATION FROM THE PLANS . >> THIS DID NOT REQUIRE ANY [ INAUDIBLE ] IT REPRESENTED BOTH . >> ANY QUESTIONS . I THINK A LOT OF POSITIONS ARE MOVING TOWARD THAT . IT IS A LOT MORE INCLUSIVE I WANT TO POINT THAT OUT. >> WE FOUNDED THE RECRUITMENT EFFORTS THAT THEY ARE TWO PATHWAYS BY WHICH SOMEONE GETS INTO THAT FIELD. A LOT OF PEOPLE AND RECREATION START AS A PART-TIME STAFF AND DO IT ON A SEASONAL BASIS OR NUMBER OF YEARS. AND THERE IS NO EASY PATH FOR THEM TO DO IT. THEY ARE VERY DEDICATED. THEY ARE VERY -- THEYARE VERY INTERESTED . IT IS A BARRIER. AND SO WE ARE HOPING THAT THIS WILL JUST MAKE THE RECRUITMENT EFFORTS A LITTLE BIT THAT ARE . >> I AGREE . THAT WAS MY OBSERVATION TOO. >> IT MAKES SENSE IN THESE KINDS OF FIELDS. DOING THIS A LONG TIME. AND WHEN THE POOLS ARE WIDE , WE START LIKING THE EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS. EVEN THOUGH IT MAY NOT NECESSARILY BE APPROPRIATE. IT IS AN ARTIFICIAL BARRIER TO A LOT OF PEOPLE. A LOT OF AREAS WILL ADD BACK EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS BECAUSE IT WOULD BE NICE TO HAVE A DEGREE . AND YOUR GETTING SUFFICIENT APPLICANTS EVEN WITH THAT RESTRICTION. THESE DAYS, MOST AGENCIES ARE HAVING TROUBLE FINDING THE POSITIONS AND A LOT OF AGENCIES ARE HAVING DEGREE REQUIREMENTS AND A LOT OF AREAS. >> FOR 40 YEARS, HAVE BEEN DOING THIS. I'M GLAD TO SEE WE ARE GOING TO MORE OPEN. THAT IS MY PERSONAL PREFERENCE AS WELL . I THINK WE FEEL THAT WE HAVE WAYS BY WHICH WE CAN DESIGN OUR RECRUITMENT TO IDENTIFY THE MOST QUALIFIED PEOPLE WITHOUT EVEN --WITHOUT THAT BEING A FACTOR. THAT IS WHY THE COMPETENCY IS OUTLINED IN THERE. WE CAN STILL LOOK AT CONSIDERING EDUCATION IF WE CHOOSE TO. WHERE THERE IS ALLOWANCE ALLOWANCE. BUT IT IS NOT A HARD STOP TO WHERE -- MAY HAVE SOMEONE WITH FIVE YEARS OF EXPERIENCE THAT WOULD HAVE THAT MUCH MORE EXPERIENCE IN SUMMARY WITH A COMBINATION OF THE EDUCATION AND A LITTLE BIT OF EXPERIENCE. I THINK IT WILL BE A MORE FAIR PROCESS. . ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ? >> MOTION TO APPROVE? >> . >> WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE --THE JOB DESCRIPTION AND CLASSIFICATION PLAN TO ELIMINATE THE SENIOR CITIZEN COORDINATOR AND SENIOR CITIZEN CLASSIFICATION . ALL THOSE IN FAVOR , AYE. >> OPPOSED . >> THAT IS 3-0 ON THAT ACTION. THAT GETS US TO COMMISSIONER COMMENTS LET'S SEE IF ANYONE HAS ANYTHING TO ADD . I TOLD STAFF, I'M THE CHAIR AND WAS ELECTED A FEW MONTHS AGO. DID WE EVER ELECT A VICE CHAIR ? >> WE MAY NEED ONE. I WILL BE OUT OF THE COUNTRY FOR THREE MONTHS IN AUGUST AND IN THE --WILL BE LIVING IN SPAIN AND DOING SOME TRAVELING AND STUDYING. I WAS TELLING STAFF. NOT THAT I WOULD WANT TO SLOW DOWN THE WORK BUT I WAS HOPING MAYBE YOU WOULDN'T HAVE ANY ITEMS YOU WANT APPROVAL FOR. IF YOU DO, I WON'T EVEN BE ABLE TO ATTEND REMOTELY. I CAN ATTEND REMOTELY VIA ZOOM. THIS WILL BE LIKE 4:00 IN THE MORNING FOR ME. LOVE YOU GUYS BUT I'M NOT GOING TO DO THAT. IF WE HAVE TO HAVE ANOTHER MEETING OR BUSINESS TO HANDLE , SOMEONE WILL HAVE TO BE APPOINTED. THE BYLAWS SAID WHEN THE CHAIR IS NOT AVAILABLE, THE VICE CHAIR WILL ACT . SO IF YOU NEED TO CALL A MEETING , THERE WILL HAVE TO BE THE APPOINTMENT OF A VICE CHAIR SO THEY CAN FULFILL THAT ROLE. . I THINK THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE DONE IN THE PAST. >> YOU ARE THE VICE CHAIR . >> I THINK IT HAPPENED ON TWO DIFFERENT OCCASIONS WITH THE SPECIAL SESSIONS . >> MAY BE THEN. >> SO JUST TO GIVE YOU A HEADS UP , DO YOU ANTICIPATE OR SEE ANYTHING COMING IN THE NEXT FEW MONTHS LIKE HEARINGS OR ANYTHING? I THINK AUGUST, WE PLAN TO BE RELATIVELY LOW FOR COUNCIL . THAT IS WHY THE MEETING WAS SCHEDULED AS A SPECIAL MEETING TO KIND OF GET THE BUSINESS DONE BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL TOOK THE NEXT STEP FOR US IN THE PROCESS IS TO PRESENT THESE ITEMS TO THE CITY COUNCIL . WILL THERE BE A MEETING IN AUGUST? NO BUT THERE IS ANOTHER MEETING ON JULY 30TH. SO THERE IS A MEETING TOMORROW -- I MEAN, THERE IS A MEETING THIS WEDNESDAY AND THEN IN TWO WEEKS. WE HOPE TO PRESENT IT THEN AND WE SHOULD BE GOOD UNTIL ALLISON GETS BACK. I WANT TO MAKE SURE, IF WE HAVE TO DO A LITTLE SIDESTEP. I DON'T EVEN WANT TO SAY IT. I WILL BE BACK . >> THAT IS EXCITING . >> I HOPE TO BE FLUENT . I KEEP TRYING . IF THERE ARE NO OTHER COMMENTS OR ANYTHING THAT STAFF NEEDS TO SAY, I THINK WE CAN ADJOURN . I DON'T HAVE A GAVEL TO HIT. BUT 6:02 P.M. . >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU ALL FOR THE STAFF REPORTS.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Civil Service Commission
  • Civil Service Commission — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a92edd873609e0e956af2b7d1eda4ae6. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record