POLISCOPE

The public record

BREVARD COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Brevard County Board of County Commissioners

Tuesday, January 25, 2022 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Waiver Request, Re: Waiver of Wall Requirement for Waste Management (21WV00022)(District 1)

The Brevard County Board of County Commissioners approved various administrative items, including land development plats, binding development plans, and infrastructure maintenance contracts. The board also authorized the acceptance of federal health relief funds and approved several budget adjustments.

Why it matters

Residents should care because these decisions impact local land development, public infrastructure maintenance, and the allocation of county resources in their neighborhoods.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

24

Recorded outcomes

23

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

23 captured items have a publicly linked outcome. These 5 are the clearest resident summaries in the record.

Search all 24 meeting actions
  • Item F.1.

    Waiver Request, Re: Waiver of Wall Requirement for Waste Management (21WV00022)(District 1)

    Moved by Rita Pritchett · Seconded by Bryan Lober

    approved - Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, stated Item F.1., is a request for the Board to consider granting a waiver of Section 62-3202 h (10) which requires a six-foot masonry or solid wall when a development of commercial is adjacent to residential zoning classifications. Ken Talbert stated he and his wife have two pieces of property adjacent to the Waste Management property, 245 and 255 North Burnett; he thanked the Board for allowing him the opportunity to voice his feelings on this; he expressed his appreciation for Waste Management and the job they do; he mentioned as far back as he can remember with this property, Waste Management has always done an excellent job; he also wants Waste Management to know he and his wife have no other complaints about their service; but he and his wife are in favor of the wall. He explained the reason for wanting the wall is because the trucks are geared towards a beep when they are backing up and their property is right adjacent to that; before the sun is up they can hear them beeping and honking the horn occasionally; occasionally one guy is yelling to another guy; that is usually pretty early in the morning, before the sun comes up; they think a wall would be a benefit to maybe buffer some of that a little bit; occasionally a little trash blows over onto their property, and it is not the end of the world, but it is a factor that maybe a wall would assist with that also; and the third thing is it is not just the voices and the noise factor, it is just occasionally, and it is very important to him. He advised it is not very often that this happens but he might as well put it out there, and once and a while the odor is a little tough on them; when they empty all the trucks they park them back in the area where he is at; it is natural it comes from the landfill and there is going to be some odor from time to time, but it is not a major concern; and he figured he had the opportunity he might as well throw it out there. He noted their relationship with Waste Management has been very positive as far as service goes; since the opportunity presented itself, they thought they ought to voice their opinion for the wall; they think it will improve the quality of the property; and it may have a positive impact on their concerns; and he will let his wife take it from here. Betty Talbert stated her family has owned the land for over 60 years; as her husband had stated, they have had a good relationship with Waste Management, however over the years, they have had the noise of the trucks backing up, horns blowing as early as 5:30 or 6:00 a.m.; they believe a wall would help buffer the sound as well as any loose trash which could come this way; and because of the increase in population they are building a lot of apartments on Pluckebaum Road and she is sure the Board is aware of that. She went on to say she does not know what the future will hold as far as the increase in employees and trucks which could adversely affect her; she would also be concerned of the negative impact more trucks and more shifts might have on the value of the property; and she believes a wall would help in respect to that. She noted if Waste Management should ever sell their company, they do not know if the next owners would be as conscientious or respectful, so they are asking for the wall for now and also as protection in the future in regards to property values. David Bassford stated he is the representative for the applicant; as it was stated this site has been there for a while; with this proposal, just shy of 20 years ago, they came in and developed the site; as he understands it, a wall was not part of the Code requirement then; what they are trying to do now is memorialize and actually install some of the things that were permitted back in 2002/2003; there was a formal employee parking lot that was proposed over on the west parcel that has now been lot-combined and that was never constructed as either concrete or asphalt for the employee parking, nor was the additional area for the garbage trucks; and part of the reason for the request of this waiver is there is a chain link fence right now and an existing 24-foot vegetative buffer along the west and the south of the west parcel, and in talking with staff, one of the things they wanted to do was maintain that vegetative buffer for aesthetics. He went on to say they will end up losing some very large trees if they take out the chain link fence and install the wall; one of the proposals is to enhance the existing vegetation so it should help with some of the things the speakers described; however, they are not changing the existing use or doing anything different than what is there now; and instead of it being stabilized parking, they are doing asphalt parking. Commissioner Pritchett advised she does not have any questions; she was trying to see if there was anyone who had any heartburn with this; typically she likes going with the natural buffers because it is better on the environment and there are a lot of trees there; the concern she has now is what the property is being used for; she would ask the Board to table this for one meeting because she needs to do a little more work on it; and she noted she is not necessarily for denying or approving it, she just wants to meet with staff and see if there is something that she needs to discuss differently with him. Mr. Bassford responded if it is a matter of potential particulates and or trash, if there is not slats in the existing chain link fence, they can certainly add those; and it is not a matter of cost it is just a matter of why tear out the nice trees to just put in a wall. Commissioner Pritchett stated that usually gives her the same struggle. Mr. Bassford advised he is certainly sensitive to what Mr. and Mrs. Talbert said because he hates noise altogether. Commissioner Pritchett asked if this could be tabled to the Zoning meeting. The Board tabled consideration for a waiver request of a wall requirement for Waste Management, to the February 3, 2022, Planning and Zoning Meeting.
  • Item F.2.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1, (District 4) Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC.

    Moved by Curt Smith · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Del Webb at Viera – Phase 1, Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.
  • Item F.3.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2 Developer: The Viera Company District 4

    Moved by Curt Smith · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Aripeka at Viera – Phase 2, Developer: The Viera Company, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.
  • Item F.5.

    Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust (District 1)

    Moved by Curt Smith · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - The Board executed a Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust, for property located at 79.16 acres, on the south side of State Road 46, approximately 635 feet east of Turpentine Road, Mims.
  • Item F.6.

    Approval Re: Right-of-Way Use Agreement for the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association - District 5

    Moved by Curt Smith · Seconded by John Tobia

    approved - The Board executed and approved the Right-of-Way Use Agreement with the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association to permit improvements to be installed and maintained in the public right-of-way.

Recorded votes

12 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (12)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Pritchettyes
Loberyes
Tobiayes
Smithyes
Zonkayes
continued

F.1 Waiver Request: Wall Requirement for Waste Management

passed

F.2 Final Plat and Contract Approval: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1

passed

F.3 Final Plat and Contract Approval: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2

passed

F.5 Binding Development Plan: The Heather Calligan Trust

passed

F.6 Right-of-Way Use Agreement: Oak Forest at Melbourne HOA

passed

F.7 Permission to Bid: Detention Center Kitchen/Laundry Maintenance

passed

F.8 Sanitary Sewer Easement: Jijoco Retail Center

passed

F.9 Resolution and Performance Bond Release: Sendero/Sierra Cove

passed

F.10 Public Transportation Grant Amendment: Valkaria Airport

passed

F.11 Resolution and Lease: Community Services Council of Brevard

passed

F.12 Acceptance of HRSA Provider Relief Fund Phase 4 Funding

passed

F.13 Budget Change Requests

Money

People and votes

John Tobia

12 seconds · 2 motions · 12 recorded votes

  1. SecondItem F.2.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1, (District 4) Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  2. SecondItem F.3.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2 Developer: The Viera Company District 4 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  3. SecondItem F.4.

    Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with James Eric Preece (District 5) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  4. SecondItem F.5.

    Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust (District 1) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  5. SecondItem F.6.

    Approval Re: Right-of-Way Use Agreement for the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association - District 5 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  6. SecondItem F.7.

    Permission to Bid Re: Brevard County Detention Center Kitchen and Laundry Equipment Preventative Maintenance Services - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  7. SecondItem F.8.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC - District 2. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  8. SecondItem F.9.

    Adopt Resolution and Release Performance Bond: Sendero Cove and Sierra Cove at Addison Village, Phase 3 - District 4 Developer: The Viera Company - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  9. SecondItem F.10.

    Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment 1, AWOS Installation at Valkaria Airport - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  10. SecondItem F.11.

    Approval, Re: Resolution and Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc. (Districts 1, 2 and 3) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  11. SecondItem F.12.

    Re: Acceptance and Authorization of Department of Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) Provider Relief Fund Phase 4 Funding - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  12. SecondItem F.13.

    Approval, Re: Budget Change Requests - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  13. MotionItem I.2.

    Housing Assistance Eligibility Modification - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  14. Motion

    EEL Malabar Scrub Date Correction - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  15. Recorded voteItem F.1

    F.1 Waiver Request: Wall Requirement for Waste Management - Voted yes on the motion “Table consideration for a waiver request of a wall requirement for Waste Management to the February 3, 2022, Planning and Zoning Meeting.”; the record reports continued.

  16. Recorded voteItem F.2

    F.2 Final Plat and Contract Approval: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1 - Voted yes on the motion “Grant final plat approval and authorize Chair to sign final plat and Contract for Del Webb at Viera – Phase 1.”; the record reports passed.

  17. Recorded voteItem F.3

    F.3 Final Plat and Contract Approval: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2 - Voted yes on the motion “Grant final plat approval and authorize Chair to sign final plat and Contract for Aripeka at Viera – Phase 2.”; the record reports passed.

  18. Recorded voteItem F.5

    F.5 Binding Development Plan: The Heather Calligan Trust - Voted yes on the motion “Execute a Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust.”; the record reports passed.

  19. Recorded voteItem F.6

    F.6 Right-of-Way Use Agreement: Oak Forest at Melbourne HOA - Voted yes on the motion “Execute and approve the Right-of-Way Use Agreement with the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association.”; the record reports passed.

  20. Recorded voteItem F.7

    F.7 Permission to Bid: Detention Center Kitchen/Laundry Maintenance - Voted yes on the motion “Approve permission to bid, award, and execute a preventative maintenance service contract for the kitchen and laundry equipment.”; the record reports passed.

  21. Recorded voteItem F.8

    F.8 Sanitary Sewer Easement: Jijoco Retail Center - Voted yes on the motion “Accept the Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC.”; the record reports passed.

  22. Recorded voteItem F.9

    F.9 Resolution and Performance Bond Release: Sendero/Sierra Cove - Voted yes on the motion “Execute and adopt Resolution No. 22-002, releasing the Contract and Surety Performance Bond.”; the record reports passed.

  23. Recorded voteItem F.10

    F.10 Public Transportation Grant Amendment: Valkaria Airport - Voted yes on the motion “Execute and approve the Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment No. 1 for AWOS installation.”; the record reports passed.

  24. Recorded voteItem F.11

    F.11 Resolution and Lease: Community Services Council of Brevard - Voted yes on the motion “Execute and adopt Resolution No. 22-003 and approve the Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc.”; the record reports passed.

  25. Recorded voteItem F.12

    F.12 Acceptance of HRSA Provider Relief Fund Phase 4 Funding - Voted yes on the motion “Approve retaining the full balance of HRSA Funds and authorize necessary administrative actions.”; the record reports passed.

  26. Recorded voteItem F.13

    F.13 Budget Change Requests - Voted yes on the motion “Approve the Budget Change Requests.”; the record reports passed.

See all 12 roll calls with named votes

People and organizations named

Being named is not a position. A person gets a dossier link only when the record resolves their identity.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 128,911 characters. The full document is at the source.

Tuesday, January 25, 2022 9:00 AM Brevard County Board of County Commissioners 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way Viera, FL 32940 Commission Chambers Minutes Regular January 25, 2022 A. A. CALL TO ORDER 9:00 AM Commissioner District 1 Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 2 Bryan Lober, Commissioner District 3 John Tobia, Commissioner District 4 Curt Smith, and Commissioner District 5 Kristine Zonka Present: C. C. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Commissioner Curt Smith, District 4 Commissioner Smith led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance. D. D. MINUTES FOR APPROVAL: November 9, 2021, Regular; December 2, 2021, Zoning The Board approved the November 9, 2021, Regular meeting and the December 2, 2021, Zoning meeting minutes. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Curt Smith Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F. F. CONSENT AGENDA (The entire Consent Agenda will be passed in one motion to include everything under Section F.) Commissioner Tobia asked for Item F.14., appointments/reappointments to be pulled for discussion. F.2. Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1, (District 4) Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC. The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Del Webb at Viera – Phase 1, Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.3. Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2 Developer: The Viera Company District 4 The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Aripeka at Viera – Phase 2, Developer: The Viera Company, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka Page 1 of 35 January 25, 2022 F.4. Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with James Eric Preece (District 5) The Board executed Binding Development Plan with James Eric Preece, Trustee, for property located at .26 acres, on the south side of Franklyn Avenue, approximately 320 feet east of Palm Avenue, Indialantic. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia F.5. Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust (District 1) The Board executed a Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust, for property located at 79.16 acres, on the south side of State Road 46, approximately 635 feet east of Turpentine Road, Mims. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.6. Approval Re: Right-of-Way Use Agreement for the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association - District 5 The Board executed and approved the Right-of-Way Use Agreement with the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association to permit improvements to be installed and maintained in the public right-of-way. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.7. Permission to Bid Re: Brevard County Detention Center Kitchen and Laundry Equipment Preventative Maintenance Services The Board approved permission to bid, award, and execute a preventative maintenance service contract for the kitchen and laundry equipment at the Brevard County Detention Center; and authorized the County Manager to execute all necessary contract(s), contract amendment(s), and extension(s) upon review and approval of the County Attorney’s Office, Risk Management, and Purchasing Service, and to execute all necessary Budget Change Requests. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.8. Approval, Re: Dedication of Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC - District 2. The Board accepted the Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC. Result: APPROVED Page 2 of 35 January 25, 2022 Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.9. Adopt Resolution and Release Performance Bond: Sendero Cove and Sierra Cove at Addison Village, Phase 3 - District 4 Developer: The Viera Company The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 22-002, releasing the Contract and Surety Performance Bond dated May 18, 2021, for Sendero Cove and Sierra Cove at Addison Village, Phase 3 – Developer: The Viera Company. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.10. Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment 1, AWOS Installation at Valkaria Airport The Board executed and approved the Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment No. 1, AWOS installation at Valkaria Airport; and authorized all necessary Budget Change Requests associated with this amendment. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.11. Approval, Re: Resolution and Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc. (Districts 1, 2 and 3) The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 22-003, authorizing the lease of real property to a not-for-profit corporation organized under the laws of the State; and executed and approved the Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc., for utilization of the kitchens and the lunch rooms at Cuyler Park, Mims, Port St. John Community Center, Port St. John, Cocoa West Recreation Complex, Cocoa, Woody Simpson Park, Merritt Island, Joe Lee Smith Park, Cocoa, and South Mainland Community Center, Micco. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.12. Re: Acceptance and Authorization of Department of Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) Provider Relief Fund Phase 4 Funding The Board approved retaining the full balance of the HRSA Funds, in the amount of $172,955.86; authorized the Brevard County Fire Rescue, Chief of Finance, to digitally sign the attestation documents; and authorized the County Manager, or designee, to sign subsequent Budget Change Requests, administrative actions, and transfers needed to cover eligible Page 3 of 35 January 25, 2022 expenses or lost revenue. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.13. Approval, Re: Budget Change Requests The Board approved the Budget Change Requests. Result: APPROVED Mover: Curt Smith Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.1. Waiver Request, Re: Waiver of Wall Requirement for Waste Management (21WV00022)(District 1) Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, stated Item F.1., is a request for the Board to consider granting a waiver of Section 62-3202 h (10) which requires a six-foot masonry or solid wall when a development of commercial is adjacent to residential zoning classifications. Ken Talbert stated he and his wife have two pieces of property adjacent to the Waste Management property, 245 and 255 North Burnett; he thanked the Board for allowing him the opportunity to voice his feelings on this; he expressed his appreciation for Waste Management and the job they do; he mentioned as far back as he can remember with this property, Waste Management has always done an excellent job; he also wants Waste Management to know he and his wife have no other complaints about their service; but he and his wife are in favor of the wall. He explained the reason for wanting the wall is because the trucks are geared towards a beep when they are backing up and their property is right adjacent to that; before the sun is up they can hear them beeping and honking the horn occasionally; occasionally one guy is yelling to another guy; that is usually pretty early in the morning, before the sun comes up; they think a wall would be a benefit to maybe buffer some of that a little bit; occasionally a little trash blows over onto their property, and it is not the end of the world, but it is a factor that maybe a wall would assist with that also; and the third thing is it is not just the voices and the noise factor, it is just occasionally, and it is very important to him. He advised it is not very often that this happens but he might as well put it out there, and once and a while the odor is a little tough on them; when they empty all the trucks they park them back in the area where he is at; it is natural it comes from the landfill and there is going to be some odor from time to time, but it is not a major concern; and he figured he had the opportunity he might as well throw it out there. He noted their relationship with Waste Management has been very positive as far as service goes; since the opportunity presented itself, they thought they ought to voice their opinion for the wall; they think it will improve the quality of the property; and it may have a positive impact on their concerns; and he will let his wife take it from here. Betty Talbert stated her family has owned the land for over 60 years; as her husband had stated, they have had a good relationship with Waste Management, however over the years, they have had the noise of the trucks backing up, horns blowing as early as 5:30 or 6:00 a.m.; they believe a wall would help buffer the sound as well as any loose trash which could come this way; and because of the increase in population they are building a lot of apartments on Pluckebaum Road and she is sure the Board is aware of that. She went on to say she does Page 4 of 35 January 25, 2022 not know what the future will hold as far as the increase in employees and trucks which could adversely affect her; she would also be concerned of the negative impact more trucks and more shifts might have on the value of the property; and she believes a wall would help in respect to that. She noted if Waste Management should ever sell their company, they do not know if the next owners would be as conscientious or respectful, so they are asking for the wall for now and also as protection in the future in regards to property values. David Bassford stated he is the representative for the applicant; as it was stated this site has been there for a while; with this proposal, just shy of 20 years ago, they came in and developed the site; as he understands it, a wall was not part of the Code requirement then; what they are trying to do now is memorialize and actually install some of the things that were permitted back in 2002/2003; there was a formal employee parking lot that was proposed over on the west parcel that has now been lot-combined and that was never constructed as either concrete or asphalt for the employee parking, nor was the additional area for the garbage trucks; and part of the reason for the request of this waiver is there is a chain link fence right now and an existing 24-foot vegetative buffer along the west and the south of the west parcel, and in talking with staff, one of the things they wanted to do was maintain that vegetative buffer for aesthetics. He went on to say they will end up losing some very large trees if they take out the chain link fence and install the wall; one of the proposals is to enhance the existing vegetation so it should help with some of the things the speakers described; however, they are not changing the existing use or doing anything different than what is there now; and instead of it being stabilized parking, they are doing asphalt parking. Commissioner Pritchett advised she does not have any questions; she was trying to see if there was anyone who had any heartburn with this; typically she likes going with the natural buffers because it is better on the environment and there are a lot of trees there; the concern she has now is what the property is being used for; she would ask the Board to table this for one meeting because she needs to do a little more work on it; and she noted she is not necessarily for denying or approving it, she just wants to meet with staff and see if there is something that she needs to discuss differently with him. Mr. Bassford responded if it is a matter of potential particulates and or trash, if there is not slats in the existing chain link fence, they can certainly add those; and it is not a matter of cost it is just a matter of why tear out the nice trees to just put in a wall. Commissioner Pritchett stated that usually gives her the same struggle. Mr. Bassford advised he is certainly sensitive to what Mr. and Mrs. Talbert said because he hates noise altogether. Commissioner Pritchett asked if this could be tabled to the Zoning meeting. The Board tabled consideration for a waiver request of a wall requirement for Waste Management, to the February 3, 2022, Planning and Zoning Meeting. Result: TABLED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Bryan Lober Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka F.14. Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s) Page 5 of 35 January 25, 2022 Commissioner Tobia stated he really does not have an issue with any of the applicants, it is more of the process; on August 6, 2019, action was taken by unanimous vote, and the Board of County Commissioners imposed term limits of eight consecutive years or 10 years in a 16 year period for all advisory board appointees; there are a couple that cause some concerns for him in terms of policy; there is one and there was a note made that this committee did not meet for three consecutive years during the appointees prior term, thus an eight year term limit was not constructively exceeded; he would look at that differently; if a board is not meeting for three consecutive years, he is thinking one of two things, either do away with the Board altogether or find appointees that want to meet more often, so they can provide counsel to this Board; and he does not think inactivity is an excuse to extend term limits. He mentioned another appointee is up here who has been serving consistently since 2009; he knows there is an exception, it requires supermajority, but that requires some sort of special need and he does not know that any of the Board has advertised these and not received responses back accordingly; it is not reflected in any of the requests; with the Construction Licensing Board, he has some concerns because these people make decisions that have impact on business owners; and he does not think there should be people with extended periods of time that may render a decision that would carry on longer than those eight years. He went on to say he respects the decision that the Board made; he has not put anyone forward past that eight years or the 10 of 16, even though it has been requested; he consistently lets these people know that the Board voted in such a way that imposes term limits; he will do it, but it becomes very difficult when he says no, and these individuals run to another Commissioner to explain why they are so useful, and then another Commissioner appoints these people; this requires a supermajority vote to be valid per Section 2-213(3); but for future reference, he will not be voting for any term-limited appointee per the Board; therefore this would then have to run the table with everyone else; and he noted this is not a reflection on any of these appointees individually, it is a reflection on the Board. He noted the Board put forth a policy; it is very difficult to follow that policy and then have everyone else abjectly disregard it; he reiterated he is going to say this again because he has respect for these appointees and he greatly appreciates what they have added to this; however, this would be the District 2 appointee and the District 4 appointee who would not meet the requirements and require a supermajority. He noted the last names are Fusscas and Durham that he, in good conscience, cannot vote for it. Commissioner Smith commented he recognizes Commissioner Tobia’s concerns; he has a couple different thoughts; this particular board that he is speaking of, it is essential to have institutional knowledge in decision making; the Licensing Board does need that as it is construction oriented; he does not have an abundance of people beating down his door to volunteer for this; it is important to have people serving that have the institutional background that comes from having served for beyond the eight years; the Board is lucky in these cases where there are people who are so skilled and have such background, and are willing to serve the community for no pay, they are volunteers; and he has never been comfortable with term limits for a volunteer position, but he is extremely in favor of term limits for the elected officials. He mentioned he thinks Brevard County has 64 boards that the Commissioners have to appoint people to; he has said this before, there is not always a plethora of people that are standing in line waiting to serve; most people have a life, and routines, and it is hard to get them away from those routines to serve the community; and having said all of that, he does understand there are term limits in this particular case, but he also understands that there are waivers available and that is to the option of the Board to decide to exercise the waivers. He noted he likes the system the way it is and he will not support this. Commissioner Lober stated he thinks there are two separate questions that are contemplated or that have been raised by Commissioner Tobia; the first obviously deals with just a straight exceeding of term limits; the other deals with whether or not to count years in which the board Page 6 of 35 January 25, 2022 simply has not met; he does not necessarily have an issue if Commissioner Tobia wants to bring forth either a discussion or action item on particular boards, if he is looking to dissolve them because they simply are not necessary; and as to the one appointment that he has, who had three years of technical service, where the board never met, he explained it was not his cause that the board never met, these people just simply show up when they are told to show up. He went on to say to have someone on paper as serving where there were no votes taken and no discussion had, he does not see that as really going to the core of what he was trying to accomplish when he put up the Agenda Item in the first place, to institute term limits; he is very skeptical as to waiver requests when it comes to certain advisory boards, but certain advisory boards have been beating his door down to get on, whether it is the TDC, the EDC, the Charter Review, or Redistricting; he had no problem filling those, but there are others; for instance the one he did ask for the waiver on, where the Committee has not met for three consecutive years during the term; and he just does not see that going toward the issue that he was seeking to remedy. He noted obviously in hindsight, people would do things differently; in hindsight he probably would have built something into that Agenda Item, going back a couple of years, to allow for that; when he sees term limit waiver requests, as to the boards that are hard to fill, he does not have an issue with that; he trusts the individual Commissioners in trying to see if they can fill them; his office has advertised for a number of different committees and some were filled based upon those advertisements; there are some that are advertised and no one requests for it; and that leaves very little choice, either do not appoint anyone or appoint the person who is still desiring to serve. Commissioner Pritchett stated if Commissioner Tobia finds more boards to dissolve she is totally in on it; she thinks there probably are way too many boards; she is in complete agreement with that; for elected officials, she thinks that is kind of funny, the Board has term limits, but voters vote people out so that is a natural thing; when the Board appoints people, these are probably the ones that would be more concerning; the thought is it is an advisory committee, but going through COVID-19, it is hard finding people to serve on boards; and she is going to vote with the Commissioner of the District for what they feel they need. Commissioner Tobia stated he just wants to remind the Board that institutional knowledge is not always a good thing; in all honesty it is not a minimal requirement; in fact, a board member he received an email from, if it does not border, it certainly exceeds Sunshine; the email begins, “Thank you for your response Commissioner Tobia, Commissioner Smith and I wanted…”; this is an individual who probably has been through Sunshine training, hopefully five or six times, and blatantly disregards it with this email; he knows he should not be saying this, but the reality of the situation is these people have one cardinal rule and it is broken in the first sentence of the email; and he does not always see institutional knowledge as a positive. He noted he thinks fresh blood is probably a good thing; he appreciates Commissioner Lober advertising, and he does not know that this position was advertised; he is going to continue to vote no on this one; however, more important than exceeding the term limits is what Commissioner Pritchett mentioned, doing away with some of these boards. He advised he tried this a year or so ago and he does not think he even received a second on this one; Katherine Wall, Assistant to the County Manager, has done an amazing job; he does not know if it is public yet, he thinks he said there were 50 or 60 boards, he was off by about 30, apparently there are like 90 of these boards; he would challenge the Board to go through it, sees who is on it, and if the board has ever advised this Board for anything; and he will ask again for a list of all the boards that are statutorily required, because he does not want to do away with any boards that are required by the State; but to continue to have boards with no purpose, that do not meet for years, and are not needed, is not only a waste of the members time, but it is a waste of staff time and potentially puts the Board into some jeopardy with these types of emails, that fall outside of Sunshine; and he noted he will be bringing a list back to the Page 7 of 35 January 25, 2022 Board, and tasking Ms. Wall to send that list out to all of the Board Members, because she probably already has that delineated. He advised he will continue with a no vote on this Item and he certainly understands everyone’s disregard for term limits. Chair Zonka commented she thinks the waiver is in place for a reason and she thinks it should be applied more to those boards that the Board Members have not been able to fill; she thinks that is the exception, of course; obviously the Board wants to make sure Planning and Zoning and that sort of board has members that show up; she knows that was the discussion this Board had regarding those waiver requests; she believes in term limits as well; she thinks the Board needs to give other people a chance; there are some important boards, as far as Budget and that sort of thing; she knows plenty of people would be interested in it, if the Board Members worked really hard; she knows her office works really hard to try to advertise in order to get people to volunteer for the boards; she thinks it is the Commissioner’s job to argue the point, since the Board supported this, if one believes that a member needs to stay on; and yes it sounds tedious, it takes time, but if someone can justify why someone is being reappointed for the 100th time, then she will support it, but as for now she will not support any extension without a good argument. She noted she thinks District 2 has the strongest argument at this point; the board has not met in three years, and one can look at the board to see if it needs to remain in place, but the guy has not been providing any input, so it is not like he is going in biased or that the Board is tired of hearing from him; he has not served in a meeting in three years; and she mentioned she would support the District 2 appointment, but that is the only one. She noted her appointment on this Agenda Item is a new appointment because they replaced someone who did not come to meetings; and that is something her office is trying to make sure of, that the people who are on these boards are showing up. Commissioner Smith stated he likes the idea of having the ability to remove one of these people because sometimes they do get old and crusty; sometimes they are just there because they do not have anything else to do in their life; the County needs people who show up, that are responsible, and serve a useful purpose; that is why he likes the waiver; when there is a person that meets the criteria of showing up, being the Chair, being respected by his or her peers to be elected to Chair; that says a lot for him that the people who work with that individual support what he or she is doing; that is the case with his appointee; he has been on the board since 2009; he knows the ins and outs of most of this stuff; and his fellow board members have elected him to be the Chair, again. He stated that is why he chose to reappoint him; if the next Commissioner decides that he is too long in the tooth, then he or she can remove him; there are people he has removed because he thinks they had been there too long; however, it is not the case in this particular instance. He commented that is the reason he chose the waiver and to reappoint him; he will admit some people are just there too long; and he does not feel that is the case in this particular instance. Chair Zonka inquired if Commissioner Smith’s office advertised or tried to get someone else to fill that slot. Commissioner Smith responded negatively. Chair Zonka noted that is the only things she does not like about it; and Commissioner Smith presents a good argument as far as why he wants to keep him, but she thinks other people deserve a chance to serve on these boards. Commissioner Smith noted for argument sake, if he is happy with the job he or she has done, and he thinks that he or she adds a lot to the quality of the board, why would he want to. Chair Zonka responded while that is a good argument, it is against the Board’s policy; he Page 8 of 35 January 25, 2022 probably should have spoken up more strongly against the policy if he wanted to have that. Commissioner Smith noted he does not disagree with the policy; he thinks it is an opportunity for the Board to clear out dead wood and he does not particularly think this guy is dead wood. Commissioner Lober stated apparently it is not going to matter how he votes on this one since it needs a supermajority; he does feel kind of conflicted with respect to Commissioner Smith’s appointee; he does like referring to the Commissioner in whose District the selection or vote in hand impacts; but then again he also supports the prospect of term limits; seeing how his vote does not matter, this is one of those coin-toss votes; and he will go ahead and support Commissioner Smith’s decision, but it is not going to change anything with respect to the outcome. Commissioner Pritchett commented maybe if the Board allows a little time on this and comes back to allow some time for advertisement to see if other people jump in on it; she knows Mr. Fusscas brings a lot of wisdom to a board; she does not want to disrespect him either; and she does not know if there are other people or not, or even if that board is necessary. She reiterated to give a little time to advertise and see if anyone signs up to take those places; she stated she is having a hard time finding anybody to fill boards; having someone like Mr. Fusscas who is willing and definitely brings a lot to the table; they really give the Board a lot of help with research; and that is her thought. Commissioner Smith commented he thinks that is wise council. Commissioner Lober noted it sounds like there are enough votes for everything except the one individual from Commissioner Smith, so if the Board wants, he can make a motion to approve all but that; he explained he is just trying to read the tea leaves; and he would be willing to support it but he does not think Commissioner Smith’s appointee has the votes. Commissioner Smith stated he does not object to advertising it; if he gets some superstar that applies, or even a good quality first stringer he would consider appointing that person; and that raises another question, what if he does not and the Board has just cut this person off. Chair Zonka noted Commissioner Smith would then probably have a good argument as to why he should keep him on. Commissioner Smith noted that is why he said that was wise council. Chair Zonka stated Mr. Fusscas is probably one of the finest human beings in this County; he is smart, committed, kind, compassionate individual with a ton to contribute; and she knows it is hard to not support him. Commissioner Smith noted he could say the same about Mr. Durham; Mr. Fusscas is an appointee of his, on a board or two and he would put Mr. Durham in that same class; Mr. Durham is not as active with the rest of the Commission, like Mr. Fusscas is; maybe the Board does not even know him; and he will be happy to advertise and see what comes up. Commissioner Lober stated he will go ahead and make a motion; and he is not going to move to reject Commissioner Smith’s appointment. Chair Zonka noted maybe Commissioner Smith can pull those appointments. Page 9 of 35 January 25, 2022 Commissioner Lober stated it is even cleaner if Commissioner Smith pulls it. Chair Zonka asked which appointments are being pulled. Commissioner Smith responded R.J. Durham. Chair Zonka asked and Mr. Fusscas, so those appointments do not have to be rejected. Commissioner Lober responded for Chair Zonka to tell him because he thought there may be enough votes for Mr. Fusscas. Commissioner Smith responded he thinks Mr. Fusscas should be pulled in fairness. Chair Zonka commented that way he can at least stay in place until the Board has decides, once it has been advertised. Commissioner Lober agreed with that; he stated he will pull Mr. Fusscas and Commissioner Smith has pulled Mr. Durham; and he moved to approve taking no action on the two that were pulled. The Board appointed/reappointed Robert Beatty, MD, to the Emergency Medical Services Review Committee, with said appointment to expire December 31, 2023; Kerry Gardner to the Contractors Licensing Board (Non-Construction), with said appointment to expire on December 31, 2023; David Foley to the Contractors Licensing Board (General) with said appointment to expire on December 31, 2023; and Leanne Chaney and Laura Petruska to the Suntree/Viera Public Library Advisory Board, with said appointments to expire December 31, 2023. Result: APPROVED Mover: Bryan Lober Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka G. PUBLIC COMMENTS Charles Trapp stated he wants to talk about predatory towing: he is a recent victim; he understands that the Board is currently considering substantial rate hikes for the towing services in Brevard County; he does not begrudge anyone the opportunity to earn a fair wage, but he feels that some protections should be put in place for people that are victims of predatory towing; if the Board allows increase without monitoring the effects that predatory towing people have on the common person, it offers them the opportunity to increase that pain; and it is a financial thing. He finds with predatory towing, when someone tows a vehicle and they do not have the right to do so, and the person tries to address it with the local law enforcement, they consider it a civil matter to go to court to get one’s money back, which he is planning on doing; however, when a crime is committed and someone’s vehicle has been taken, people lose control of something that they own, or their private property has been removed from their possession and they no longer have access to it, that is pretty eye-opening; in Miami-Dade and Hillsborough County there are class-action law suits, and Morgan and Morgan is doing the Hillsborough County one, because they are trying to get help for victims of such practices; and in this case, he feels when a lawyer has to get involved there is something not happening with the people that set the rules. He advised maybe something can be done when rate increases are requested; maybe somebody can look at the opposite side and what is going to be the effect of the people who do not follow the rules, because there are people who Page 10 of 35 January 25, 2022 do not follow the rules; as a Brevard County citizen he just wants to put it out there that there is an opposite side of that coin; he is in the automotive business and he deals with a lot of tow truck drivers; until recently he thought they were all above board, they are all decent human beings and doing a good job; unfortunately, he has found just recently, that they are not all like that; unfortunately as he started to do some research, it is not just him, it is more of a common problem than he would have imagined; and he just wanted to bring that to the Board’s attention. Commissioner Smith stated he acknowledges Mr. Trapp’s concern and he agrees with him; he can only imagine how helpless one would feel when they park legally, and when the individual comes out, they do not know if their car has been towed or stolen; when it is found out that it has been towed, now the onus is on the owner of the vehicle to their car back, hire a lawyer, pay the fine, and pay the towing fee; he agrees there has to be some kind of protections in the Board’s considerations; and the Board has to protect the people. Mr. Trapp advised he appreciates that. Commissioner Lober stated he completely agrees that what is being discussed would be incredibly frustrating; the item that was brought forth deals essentially just with rates; and whether the Board lowers rates, keeps them the same, or raised the rates, he does not know that the rates themselves are going to necessarily impact whether or not someone is going to tow a car illegally. Mr. Trapp commented he understands that; he has no objection to people earning a good wage; he understands the rates have been this way for quite a while; he does not have a problem with the need for a raise in the rates; there are some bad apples out there; and he thinks maybe there should be some way to weed them out or maybe if there is a process put in place where if someone crossed certain lines, then they could be taken off of the list; he knows the counties and cities call them; and he suggested, if the towing people break certain boundaries then they would no longer qualify for special treatments or services. Commissioner Lober advised if the Board wants he would be happy to reach out to the Sheriff or Florida Highway Patrol (FHP) because they have a station not too far from his house, to see what the criteria is for getting on the list; and he thinks that may be a more direct route to resolve it through the people who are actually determining who to call for particular tows. Chair Zonka responded in the affirmative. Commissioner Lober advised he will follow up with Brevard County Sheriff’s Office (BCSO) or FHP, and he will probably bring it back at the next meeting if he can get ahold of someone beforehand. Commissioner Pritchett asked Mr. Trapp to check in within her legislative aide so she can get in contact with him. H.1. Creation of Proposed Chapter 46, Article XI, Landscape Irrigation, Relating to Watering Schedules consistent with St. Johns River Water Management District model ordinance - Public Hearing Amanda Elmore, Assistant Natural Resources Management Director, stated this is a public hearing for the creation of a proposed Chapter 46, Article XI, Landscape Irrigation, relating to watering schedules consistent with St. Johns River Water Management District (SJRWMD) Model ordinance; this is just mirroring the language and it allows the County to remain eligible Page 11 of 35 January 25, 2022 for Cost share grants District-wide cost share grants up to 25 percent for shovel-ready projects; and they are in an application cycle now. Rick Heffelfinger stated he was before the Board last year; he really does not like when the Board mandates, or creates ordinances to try to force people to do things; if there is a water problem then that should be done; he finds that it is all about the money because the SJRWMD refuses to give any Brevard grant proposal any consideration unless it does this; to him that is coercion; he sent the Board a letter; and he is asking the Board to stand against that. He went on to say if the County needs to do water restrictions, then talk about that, but do not fold to, what he calls being extorted; he gives to SJRWMD, everyone in Brevard does, because it is a taxing authority; they take his money, they are supposed to do what is right about the water, and then they say unless people pass this law and restrict themselves SJRWMD will not give the money back; as far as he knows they will not even consider a grant; and he thinks that is wrong. He asked if that is even legal; he stated SJRWMD is strong-arming the people; they have his money and they will not give it back; maybe he has a good idea; he wanted to dig a pond on his property; he suggested the Board write up a really good proposal, ask for a grant, send it up there, and let them say no way; the Board could then talk to the Governor and say it is being strong-armed by another branch of the government; and he reiterated it is wrong. He advised he wants the Board to stand and say it is not going to do it, put the grant forward anyway, let them say no, and then go to court; he does not know if coercion is legal or not; it may not be illegal, but it is wrong; and he would hope that the Board would take that into consideration and make a stand. He mentioned he tried to throw some words into the letter he wrote because in the past SJRWMD would say they would give five extra points for the grant proposal; that used to be their policy, if people do something for them they will get five extra bonus points; that is coercion and a little sleazy; that is fine, if they would still consider the grant; now they are saying that did not work, they could not get the people to fold, so they add laws to make sure people do not water their grass more than twice during a certain period and then take it down to once; and if the people will not do it, then they will not even consider the grant. He noted if the people want their money back they have to conform to SJRWMD; what happens after they do this and accept this one, they say they will put it on the board and there will not be a penalty, and everyone’s happy; but what about the next year, they get that ordinance and guess what, they put a penalty on people; and that is where this is going. Sandra Sullivan stated she attended the Satellite Beach meeting when this was discussed; they had a different conclusion on the enforcement part, and that they were required to enforce; she does not know why that municipality, when they implemented it, had a different opinion on that; and she noted she also wants to talk about something related to this. She mentioned Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) issued information last year that their projections are the County is going to run out of drinking water to meet future demand and that the County needs to think about renewing sewage water to be cleaned to become drinking water; groundwater conservation is important and she appreciates that; she also appreciates one of the largest users of groundwater is Home Owners Association (HOA) common areas; and when thinking about strategic decisions, addressing those largest users is a way to get the most bang for the buck. She continued by saying she does not see anything in the Ordinance about running sprinklers in the rain, for example when it is pouring rain and the sprinklers are running in the HOA common areas; here are a couple considerations, adding a rain censor clause for all new development in the Planning and Zoning, requiring new development agreements to reference this Ordinance along with the rain censor requirement, strengthen aquifer recharge areas by amending the Comprehensive Plan for a stronger low-impact development ordinance for the upcoming Comprehensive Plan changes; Pinellas County for Tampa Bay have much stronger Low Impact Development (LID) components than Brevard County; and Brevard County should be leading the way with the Indian River Lagoon (IRL). Page 12 of 35 January 25, 2022 Commissioner Lober stated for the folks that are watering their lawns when it is raining, he sees it too; he thinks it is stupid and wasteful, but he does not believe the purpose of bringing this Item up today is to address things that are stupid or wasteful, it is to continue to have a system in place that allows the County to receive State grant funding; he is not saying that the ideas brought forth are not interesting ideas to debate at a future meeting on a different Agenda Item, he would be happy to talk about them, or look at any proposal that is brought up in either direction; and as far as Satellite Beach having the conclusion that they have to enforce it, he cannot speculate as to why they have a different conclusion, all he can say is County staff and legal have said there is no obligation to do anything by way of enforcement with this. He noted he would not be supportive of doing this if the County had to do enforcement, for a couple of reasons; first, he thinks it is a regulation that if the County were to enforce, actually does begin to have teeth, but if the County is putting in place some form of a mandate that has no repercussions, it is not really a mandate, except on paper, and all it does is save taxpayer dollars by allowing the County to continue to draw from a pool of money that the County otherwise would not be entitled or able to draw from; the other thing is it costs money to enforce things and if the entire goals of doing this is to save money or allow money to come from the State that otherwise would have to come from those who live in Brevard County; and it would be foolish to do that and spend money enforcing it, which would offset the gain being received from the State. He mentioned as far as the suggestion from the first speaker that the Board take a stand and bring it to the Governor after the County gets the short end of the stick from SJRWMD, anyone can talk to the Governor, anyone on the dais and anyone in the audience; it is all about the money and there is no question about that; he thinks the Board was pretty blunt about it at the last meeting when this came up that the entire purpose of this is to continue to get State grants; there are some uphill battles that he has been happy to fight; he thinks the Commission has taken some stands that would be considered uphill battles, and that is fine, but when talking about something that really has no non-frivolous cause of action for the it to even file a lawsuit about, he does not know what the Board is expected to do; and no one has even suggested a potentially meritorious cause of action that the County would be able to challenge some like this. He noted it is great for one to stand on principles but when one knows to complete certainty that nothing is going to be accomplished by filing a lawsuit, other than getting the attorneys in trouble for filing something they know is frivolous and has absolutely no chance of any degree of success, that is just not the way to go; he is supportive of this; it is all about the money; and he would rather have the money come from the State than from those who live in Brevard County. The Board executed and adopted Ordinance No. 22-01, creating a new Article XI, in Chapter 46 of the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, “Landscape Irrigation”, related to watering schedules consistent with St. Johns River Water Management District model ordinance. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Bryan Lober Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Lober, Tobia, Smith, and Zonka Recess The Board recessed at 9:51 a.m. and reconvened at 9:58 a.m. I.1. EEL Malabar Scrub Date Correction Commissioner Tobia stated this is an evolving scenario; the town of Malabar had a special meeting last night; he and the County Attorney attended but neither one spoke; he would like to Page 13 of 35 January 25, 2022 deal with a couple things that were brought up, recap where the Board was last time, and then after listening to the speakers decide whether or not to move forward with any motions; before that he wants to dispel some of the rumors that he thinks are floating out there, through partially the County’s fault, and he wants to take that off the table; there is the thought by many residents in Malabar that the County is doing this merely for profit; apparently the County is selling the tonnage of trees; and he advised when the County takes the trees down, it has one of three options, leave the trees there which unfortunately creates fire issues, take it to a landfill which takes up space and is expensive, or sell a portion of the tree to offset the cost of removing them, whereas the County does not make very much money at all for doing that. He advised this decision is not a decision that is coming down to any profit margin; there was talk at the end about white vans going out there and surveying, which he thought was kind of interesting; there is some genuine concern, and he understands a little bit of that, that the County is just going to go down there and mow down the trees without a permit; while in all honesty that had crossed his mind for half of a second, and although he does not have control of that, he would absolutely never or even get close to voting to circumvent a permit that was necessary; that causes all sorts of problems with the County; if one was necessary he would never vote to disregard a permit of any legal body; and that should take those two off the table. He continued by saying, thankfully, the 100,000 tree rumor he believes has been dealt with; it is still many trees, but it is a small percentage of that 100,000 that was discussed; one other thing that came up last night that is very important to mention is that the nesting season starts pretty soon, March 1, and goes through June 30; nothing can be done during that period, therefore there is need some need to move forward; that is what came forward at last night’s meeting; and he appreciates the tenor of the not only the people who were speaking on the other side, but also the members of the Malabar Town Council because it certainly did not raise to the level that staff had to deal with previously. He added he thinks things were improving, at least with the attitudes there. He went on to say to recap where the Board was at the last meeting, it, through a motion, directed Mr. Knight, EELS Director, to forego continuing public meetings; these individuals and City Council members are more than willing to contact the Board Members or show up at these meetings, as they apparently have; the County has rescinded transferring the Malabar Scrub Lease to the Town of Malabar; it agreed to install a six foot chain link fence; and then instructed the County Attorney to reach out to the State for directions and possible other actions to take place; and the reason it is coming back is because he made an error and said February 24 instead of January 24, though he did say immediately after the Special meeting, so he misspoke. He mentioned his error was understood by the town; in fact in the meeting notes for last night, they have a timeline and in the timeline they got the intent correct where they put down January 25; there will be a motion dealing with that, a slight change instead of a chain link fence, it will be a barricade; it would be January 25 and he does not want anyone to think he is springing this on anyone, it was his error and the town was aware of it by their own accord; and he noted with Chair Zonka’s approval he would like to listen to the speakers and then potentially make motions based on what is presented by the public, as well as potential members of the Town Council. Commissioner Lober mentioned this is one of those Items that the last time it came up he did not speak; there are four things that he wants to mention; first is the conspiracy theory that the County is doing this to make money on selling the trees; he does not know what it is with trees and conspiracy theories but they are all over the place; Commissioner Smith can certainly relate to that; he and Commissioner Smith had received a nasty letter from an attorney about the tree issue on Rockledge Drive where it was suggested that the County was trying to butcher the trees to reduce the value of the properties so when septic was placed in there, if that comes to pass, that the eminent domain and acquisition cost would be lowered; just crazy stuff; and trees and conspiracy theories seem to go hand to hand, and he does not know why. He continued by saying that he does not know if the County recovers some of the cost of Page 14 of 35 January 25, 2022 dropping the trees and going through this process by virtue of selling them, that it would be in the net positive; he is not sure if staff has a strong opinion one way or the other; he would think the County would recover some of the costs by selling the trees but he does not know that it would even cover the cost of dropping them; and he asked if staff knows. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, advised staff does not know; they have not run any estimates on that; but they think if there is a profit it would be very low. Commissioner Lober continued by saying the County may be in the negative nonetheless, it does not sound like there is a huge profit incentive; the emails that he has received have frankly pushed him more in Commissioner Tobia’s direction than he was at the last meeting, just based on that fact that there is a ton of misinformation out there; one of the emails that he thinks everyone on the Board received, said that the County was looking at removing 140,000; that is about 10 times as much as staff told him; he thinks the number was between 10,000 and 20,000 that he heard from staff; and why not go to 1.4 million, if one is going to make it up, then make it big. He went on to say when people came to the last meeting to discuss the issues and why this is necessary, they mentioned the Cooper’s Hawk; he was thinking about it afterwards and it occurred to him that he does not think there is any sort of agreement with the birds of prey whereby they are going to stop eating the Scrub Jays while this is being debated and discussed; he cautioned everyone that whatever is done there is a time line; the land exists because there is a threat to the population there and if the County is just twiddling its thumbs, potentially waiting months and months for another governmental entity to do the right thing, or stop doing the wrong thing, the Cooper’s Hawks are going to continue to munch and nom on the Scrub Jays; he does not think that is the way to do it; and he thinks whatever is going to be done, it needs to be in the near future. He stated he is not just looking at this from an environmental perspective, but first and foremost, from what benefits his constituents in District Two; EELs property and funding exists, not to provide additional money for Parks and Recreation facilities; it is not a goal of EELs to essentially increase recreation at the cost of environmentally sensitive actions or environmentally beneficial actions; there is a reason that the property is named what it is named, there is a reason that it was designed and envisioned when the funding was produced, and that was to keep the Scrub Jays in an area where they are able to do what they do, survive, reproduce, and continue to exist for a period of years; therefore, it is not lost on him that people are talking about other usages of the land, are talking about usages that were not the primary use envisioned by the funding that set this aside in the first place; and he will leave it at that to see where this goes. Matt Stinett stated he is the Town Manager of the Town of Malabar; he is in attendance after direction from counsel last night to ask the Board to direct County staff to work with him to get the permit issued for the tree thinning in the Malabar Scrub Sanctuary; at this time the County does not have a valid permit submitted to the Town of Malabar; he believes that is partially because of the town’s permitting requirements, which were changed last year, and were not intended to deal with conservation type work; they are a bit excessive for the type of work that Mr. Knight has proposed; and last evening's Planning and Zoning meeting he was directed to address that for future projects; and council wanted to focus on getting this project through because of the tight time line the County is on, so he was given the levity to negotiate and talk with County staff on modifying those permit requirements for this project, specifically. He mentioned at a previous Town Council meeting, Mr. Knight had informed the Council he was going to be holding some public workshops on the project to try to find some kind of balance; of course those were cancelled; Council was looking for those results in order to make its decision on modifying the permit for last night; since those meetings did not happen, this was the only action they could take; and he believes Mr. Knight can attest that collaboration and good faith is his mode of operation. He added he has had a positive working relationship in the past, prior to Page 15 of 35 January 25, 2022 this; he has personally been out of the State for military duty for the past year and was not a part of the process of putting this together; and he thinks there is an opportunity here if everyone could just hit the reset button and he could work with County staff to get a permit in place so the County can begin its work. Commissioner Tobia stated he is certainly not attempting to be adversarial and he does not want to treat him in such a way that County staff was treated when they went over there; he mentioned it was not by Mr. Stinnett personally, but by other people that he may work for or with; he heard certain things by Mr. Stinnett’s board and he has a question; and he asked if the primary concern of the Town and the elected officials is the trees or the Scrub Jays. Mr. Stinnett responded the primary concern of his Council was more the lack of public input; obviously the sign went up, there was a permit that was submitted last year, and he does not think it was fully understood what level of project this is going to be; Council received a rash of concerned citizens wanting to know what was going on; Council raised a flag and asked what was going on; and there has been a lot of misinformation going around, which has led to heated conversations on both sides. Commissioner Tobia asked Mr. Stinnett if he does not believe that the December 6, 9, 17, 20 and January 3 meetings, all open to the public, were enough. Mr. Stinnett noted there has been a lot of public engagement since then. Commissioner Tobia asked if he is arguing it has not been enough. Mr. Stinnett noted he is not saying that now; he thinks it has and he thinks that is why Council has given him the direction to essentially color outside of the lines for this project. Commissioner Tobia stated he appreciates the position that Mr. Stinnett is in; he thinks he is doing a very good job weighing the two; there was talk on Mr. Stinnett’s Council about a compromise and he believes the talk was they, a couple members of Council and actually a couple members of the public, were okay with cutting down 99 percent of the trees; and he asked if Mr. Stinnett recalls that. Mr. Stinnett responded affirmatively. Commissioner Tobia commented he understands that Mr. Stinnett is probably going to be under direction of these people, and he asked, if the one percent of the trees that they want to keep up, and his primary concern is that of the Scrub Jay population, is there any scientific basis for the decisions of those one percent, when it comes into consideration of the Scrub Jay population, or will the one percent be for recreational purposes. Mr. Stinnett answered the 99 percent number is a speculation; the truth behind it is they are very close; the Trails and Greenway Committee members are in attendance to talk about it; but he thinks that is the reality they have all come to after the public engagement that has happened over the last few meetings; and they are really talking about doing the same game plan and just want to make sure the County is not just cutting trees without purpose; there may be a few trees in there and maybe Mr. Knight knows exactly what trees he is cutting down, however he does not believe that Mr. Knight had specifically identified every single tree that he is going to cut down; and he mentioned they just wanted some involvement in it and he thinks they have had that and are very close to being on the same page. He added there needs to be a conversation on the technical aspects of it. Page 16 of 35 January 25, 2022 Commissioner Tobia stated he may disagree; he thinks the level of involvement has been above and beyond; he greatly appreciates Mr. Stinnett being there; he is doing a great job given the situation that he is in; he thanked him for showing up; and noted he does not want anyone to think the Board treated him in a bad fashion. He mentioned he is very cognizant of the feelings of staff members that work within parameters; and he thanked Mr. Stinnett for his service. Commissioner Pritchett thanked Mr. Stinnett for being brave enough to show up; she stated she wants to establish that this is Federal property and the County has been given the responsibility of caring for this property and the stipulation of bills; she knows Mr. Stinnett knows the County’s goal is to try to do what it was told to do by the voters, as far as protecting the Scrub Jays because it was purchased for the Scrub Jays; and she knows that is not in the argument. She noted the County did have a permit to do this and the Town of Malabar had given the County that permit; she knows Mr. Stinnett understands the County had to go after funding to try to finish out what it needed to do on the property; before there was an agreement to do this project without a lot of pushback; it is not like it is a new thing, it has been out there for a long time; she has a concern now, that it almost looks like the City is trying to make a little more money off the County with a new permit because there is more of a cost to take down trees; and she asked if the City Council denied the extension of the permit or if that was administratively done. Mr. Stinnett commented it was administratively done because the permit was expired for over three months. Commissioner Pritchett stated typically with counties and cities that can happen; and she asked if he is allowed to administratively extend it after he has time to digest this a little bit; and she inquired if he is able to go back and extend this permit. Mr. Stinnett advised no he does not have that administrative authority because once it is expired it is invalid

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

24 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 12 of 24

Browse by category24 actions
  • Agenda item F.1.Other meeting itemsapproved - Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, stated Item F.1., is a request for the Board to consider granting a waiver of Section 62-3202 h (10) which requires a six-foot masonry or solid wall when a development of commercial is adjacent to residential zoning classifications. Ken Talbert stated he and his wife have two pieces of property adjacent to the Waste Management property, 245 and 255 North Burnett; he thanked the Board for allowing him the opportunity to voice his feelings on this; he expressed his appreciation for Waste Management and the job they do; he mentioned as far back as he can remember with this property, Waste Management has always done an excellent job; he also wants Waste Management to know he and his wife have no other complaints about their service; but he and his wife are in favor of the wall. He explained the reason for wanting the wall is because the trucks are geared towards a beep when they are backing up and their property is right adjacent to that; before the sun is up they can hear them beeping and honking the horn occasionally; occasionally one guy is yelling to another guy; that is usually pretty early in the morning, before the sun comes up; they think a wall would be a benefit to maybe buffer some of that a little bit; occasionally a little trash blows over onto their property, and it is not the end of the world, but it is a factor that maybe a wall would assist with that also; and the third thing is it is not just the voices and the noise factor, it is just occasionally, and it is very important to him. He advised it is not very often that this happens but he might as well put it out there, and once and a while the odor is a little tough on them; when they empty all the trucks they park them back in the area where he is at; it is natural it comes from the landfill and there is going to be some odor from time to time, but it is not a major concern; and he figured he had the opportunity he might as well throw it out there. He noted their relationship with Waste Management has been very positive as far as service goes; since the opportunity presented itself, they thought they ought to voice their opinion for the wall; they think it will improve the quality of the property; and it may have a positive impact on their concerns; and he will let his wife take it from here. Betty Talbert stated her family has owned the land for over 60 years; as her husband had stated, they have had a good relationship with Waste Management, however over the years, they have had the noise of the trucks backing up, horns blowing as early as 5:30 or 6:00 a.m.; they believe a wall would help buffer the sound as well as any loose trash which could come this way; and because of the increase in population they are building a lot of apartments on Pluckebaum Road and she is sure the Board is aware of that. She went on to say she does not know what the future will hold as far as the increase in employees and trucks which could adversely affect her; she would also be concerned of the negative impact more trucks and more shifts might have on the value of the property; and she believes a wall would help in respect to that. She noted if Waste Management should ever sell their company, they do not know if the next owners would be as conscientious or respectful, so they are asking for the wall for now and also as protection in the future in regards to property values. David Bassford stated he is the representative for the applicant; as it was stated this site has been there for a while; with this proposal, just shy of 20 years ago, they came in and developed the site; as he understands it, a wall was not part of the Code requirement then; what they are trying to do now is memorialize and actually install some of the things that were permitted back in 2002/2003; there was a formal employee parking lot that was proposed over on the west parcel that has now been lot-combined and that was never constructed as either concrete or asphalt for the employee parking, nor was the additional area for the garbage trucks; and part of the reason for the request of this waiver is there is a chain link fence right now and an existing 24-foot vegetative buffer along the west and the south of the west parcel, and in talking with staff, one of the things they wanted to do was maintain that vegetative buffer for aesthetics. He went on to say they will end up losing some very large trees if they take out the chain link fence and install the wall; one of the proposals is to enhance the existing vegetation so it should help with some of the things the speakers described; however, they are not changing the existing use or doing anything different than what is there now; and instead of it being stabilized parking, they are doing asphalt parking. Commissioner Pritchett advised she does not have any questions; she was trying to see if there was anyone who had any heartburn with this; typically she likes going with the natural buffers because it is better on the environment and there are a lot of trees there; the concern she has now is what the property is being used for; she would ask the Board to table this for one meeting because she needs to do a little more work on it; and she noted she is not necessarily for denying or approving it, she just wants to meet with staff and see if there is something that she needs to discuss differently with him. Mr. Bassford responded if it is a matter of potential particulates and or trash, if there is not slats in the existing chain link fence, they can certainly add those; and it is not a matter of cost it is just a matter of why tear out the nice trees to just put in a wall. Commissioner Pritchett stated that usually gives her the same struggle. Mr. Bassford advised he is certainly sensitive to what Mr. and Mrs. Talbert said because he hates noise altogether. Commissioner Pritchett asked if this could be tabled to the Zoning meeting. The Board tabled consideration for a waiver request of a wall requirement for Waste Management, to the February 3, 2022, Planning and Zoning Meeting.

    Waiver Request, Re: Waiver of Wall Requirement for Waste Management (21WV00022)(District 1)

  • Agenda item F.2.Contractsapproved - The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Del Webb at Viera – Phase 1, Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Del Webb at Viera - Phase 1, (District 4) Developer: Pulte Home Company, LLC.

  • Agenda item F.3.Contractsapproved - The Board granted final plat approval in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Contract for Aripeka at Viera – Phase 2, Developer: The Viera Company, subject to minor changes, if necessary, receipt of all documents required for recording, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Aripeka at Viera - Phase 2 Developer: The Viera Company District 4

  • Agenda item F.4.Land useNo recorded outcome

    Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with James Eric Preece (District 5)

  • Agenda item F.5.Land useapproved - The Board executed a Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust, for property located at 79.16 acres, on the south side of State Road 46, approximately 635 feet east of Turpentine Road, Mims.

    Acceptance, Re: Binding Development Plan with The Heather Calligan Trust (District 1)

  • Agenda item F.6.Contractsapproved - The Board executed and approved the Right-of-Way Use Agreement with the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association to permit improvements to be installed and maintained in the public right-of-way.

    Approval Re: Right-of-Way Use Agreement for the Oak Forest at Melbourne Homeowners Association - District 5

  • Agenda item F.7.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board approved permission to bid, award, and execute a preventative maintenance service contract for the kitchen and laundry equipment at the Brevard County Detention Center; and authorized the County Manager to execute all necessary contract(s), contract amendment(s), and extension(s) upon review and approval of the County Attorney’s Office, Risk Management, and Purchasing Service, and to execute all necessary Budget Change Requests.

    Permission to Bid Re: Brevard County Detention Center Kitchen and Laundry Equipment Preventative Maintenance Services

  • Agenda item F.8.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board accepted the Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Sanitary Sewer Easement for the Jijoco Retail Center from Jijoco, LLC - District 2.

  • Agenda item F.9.Contractsapproved - The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 22-002, releasing the Contract and Surety Performance Bond dated May 18, 2021, for Sendero Cove and Sierra Cove at Addison Village, Phase 3 – Developer: The Viera Company.

    Adopt Resolution and Release Performance Bond: Sendero Cove and Sierra Cove at Addison Village, Phase 3 - District 4 Developer: The Viera Company

  • Agenda item F.10.Budget and financeapproved - The Board executed and approved the Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment No. 1, AWOS installation at Valkaria Airport; and authorized all necessary Budget Change Requests associated with this amendment.

    Public Transportation Grant Agreement Amendment 1, AWOS Installation at Valkaria Airport

  • Agenda item F.11.Contractsapproved - The Board executed and adopted Resolution No. 22-003, authorizing the lease of real property to a not-for-profit corporation organized under the laws of the State; and executed and approved the Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc., for utilization of the kitchens and the lunch rooms at Cuyler Park, Mims, Port St. John Community Center, Port St. John, Cocoa West Recreation Complex, Cocoa, Woody Simpson Park, Merritt Island, Joe Lee Smith Park, Cocoa, and South Mainland Community Center, Micco.

    Approval, Re: Resolution and Lease with the Community Services Council of Brevard County, Inc. (Districts 1, 2 and 3)

  • Agenda item F.12.Budget and financeapproved - The Board approved retaining the full balance of the HRSA Funds, in the amount of $172,955.86; authorized the Brevard County Fire Rescue, Chief of Finance, to digitally sign the attestation documents; and authorized the County Manager, or designee, to sign subsequent Budget Change Requests, administrative actions, and transfers needed to cover eligible expenses or lost revenue.

    Re: Acceptance and Authorization of Department of Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) Provider Relief Fund Phase 4 Funding

    $172,955.86

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Brevard County Board of County Commissioners — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a8c49ab766e81b34e2cfd4d07bd51a25. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record