POLISCOPE

The public record

OAKLEY (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Dec 17, 2019 - 06:29 PM

Tuesday, December 17, 2019 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Dec 17, 2019 - 06:29 PM

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 73,776 stored characters

>> [GAVEL] >> WELCOME TO THE DECEMBER 17TH MEETING OF THE OAKLEY CITY COUNCIL. ROLL CALL. >> RANDY POPE. >> SUE HIGGINS. >> MICHAEL KRIEG. >> CLAIRE ALAURA. >> KEVIN ROMICK. >> PLEASE STAND AND JOIN US BEFORE THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] >> ITEM NUMBER 2, PUBLIC COMMENT. WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER CARD. MR. DAN TORRES. >> GOOD EVENING, MAYOR ROMICK, COUNCILMEMBERS, CITY STAFF. MY NAME IS DAN TORRES. I'M A BUSINESS AGENT FOR SPRINKLER FITTERS LOCAL 483. ANYBODY HERE KNOW WHAT WE DO? ANY IDEA? >> [INAUDIBLE/OFF MIC] >> WE DO THE FIRE PROTECTION IN BUILDINGS, YES. SO, I'M HERE TODAY TO TALK TO YOU, LET YOU KNOW OF AN OPPORTUNITY, AN OPPORTUNITY TO GET INTO THE TRADES. WHEN I FIRST STARTED AND BECAME A REPRESENTATIVE OF THIS GREAT LOCAL, I SAT DOWN WITH SOME CITY COUNCILMEMBERS, AND THEY SAID, "HOW DO YOU GET INTO THE TRADES, DO YOU GOT TO KNOW SOMEBODY?" I DON'T HAVE AN AUNT, UNCLE, SISTER, COUSIN, BROTHER, I HAVE NOBODY IN THIS TRADE. I PAVED MY OWN PATH. AND, I WAS ABLE TO DO THAT BECAUSE OF AN OPPORTUNITY. AN OPPORTUNITY PRESENTED ITSELF, I TOOK THE BULL BY THE HORNS AND I RAN WITH IT. SO, I STAND BEFORE YOU TODAY TO LET YOU KNOW THAT APPLICATIONS FOR ARE NOW OPEN WELL, THEY ARE GOING TO BE OPEN IN JANUARY. AND, I HAVE THE FLYERS HERE. IT'S A GREAT TRADE. IT'S ALLOWED ME TO PURCHASE A HOME IN THE BAY AREA. IT IS NOT EASY WORK BY ANY MEANS, BUT IF YOU HAVE ANYBODY THAT LIVES IN YOUR COMMUNITY THAT IS INTERESTED IN A GOOD CAREER, SEND THEM TO US. MAY I HAND THIS OUT TO YOU GUYS? TO THE CITY OKAY. AND, IF YOU GUYS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, I WILL BE HERE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE. >> THANK YOU, VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU, FOR YOUR TIME. >> ITEM NUMBER 3 IS THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THERE ARE NO CONSENT ITEMS TONIGHT. ITEM NUMBER 5 IS THE PUBLIC HEARING. THE OAKLEY LOGISTICS CENTER. MR. MURRAY. >> GOOD EVENING, MR. MAYOR, MME. VICE MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC. I'M PLEASED TO PRESENT THE OAKLEY LOGISTICS CENTER PROJECT TO YOU TONIGHT. IT IS A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, IT IS A GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT, A REZONE, A VESTING TENTATIVE MAP, AND DESIGN REVIEW. >>> TO GIVE A LITTLE HISTORY OF THE SITE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT, THIS IS THE FORMER DUPONT CHEMICAL PLANT SITE. IT WAS IN OPERATION FOR WELL OVER 40 YEARS. THE PLANT WAS DEMOLISHED IN 1999, AND THE SITE HAS BEEN UNDER ACTIVE REMEDIATION SINCE ABOUT 2003, OVERSEEN BY THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL. AND, THE PROPERTY REDEVELOPMENT HAS LONG BEEN A PRIORITY OF THE CITY. SO, THIS HAS REALLY BEEN THE PLACEHOLDER SINCE INCORPORATION OF THAT LARGE JOB-21:33:40 PRODUCING PROJECT AND DEVELOPMENT THE CITY HAS LONG-AWAITED FOR, AND WE ARE AT THAT TIME NOW WHERE STAFF IS PRESENTING YOU THAT PROJECT. AND, NORTHPOINT IS THE APPLICANT. THEY ARE THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY AND THEY SUBMITTED THE APPLICATION A YEAR AGO TODAY. >>> SO, THE APPLICATION SUMMARY, THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, WHICH BASICALLY, OUTLINES THE TERMS OF THE DEVELOPERS RESPONSIBILITIES AND THE CITY'S, AND IT ALSO HAS A LIFE EXPECTANCY LONGER THAN WHAT YOUR NORMAL ENTITLEMENT WOULD BE. SO, IT SUNSETS 15 YEARS AFTER APPROVED. THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT, THE CHANGE IS TO AMEND THE LAND USE DESIGNATION FOR THE APPROXIMATELY 143 ACRE PROJECT SITE FROM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL/BUSINESS PARK/UTILITY ENERGY TO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL. AND, THE REMAINDER OF THE PROJECT SITE WOULD BE DELTA RECREATION. IN CONJUNCTION WITH THAT GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT, THE APPLICANT PROPOSING THAT WE REMOVE THE EXTENSION OF LIVE OAK AVENUE, WHICH IS CONTAINED IN FIGURE 3.1 OF THE GENERAL PLAN. >>> THE REZONE IS TO DESIGNATE THE ENTIRE APPROXIMATELY 375 ACRE SITE TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT FROM SPECIFIC PLAN 3. AND, THIS IS REALLY A CLEANUP. THE SPECIFIC PLAN 3 WAS ONCE A PLACEHOLDER. THE CITY ENVISIONED HAVING A SPECIFIC PLAN ON THE PROPERTY WHEN DUPONT OWNED THE SITE. THAT NEVER CAME TO FRUITION, SO THIS PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AND THE REGULATIONS THAT COME WITH IT REALLY CLEAN UP THAT ZONING INCONSISTENCY RIGHT NOW. THE VESTING TENTATIVE MAP IS TO SUBDIVIDE THE ENTIRE PROJECT SITE INTO EIGHT PARCELS. AND, THE DESIGN REVIEW IS REALLY FOR THE BUILDING ARCHITECTURE OF THE SITE DESIGN, LANDSCAPING, AND FENCING. >>> THE PROJECT SITE IS LOCATED AT 6000 BRIDGEHEAD ROAD. BRIDGEHEAD ROAD IS TO THE WEST OF THE PROJECT SITE, THE BNSF RAILROAD IS TO THE SOUTH, THE DELTA AND THE TWO MARINAS ARE TO THE NORTH, AND THERE'S FARMLAND TO THE EAST. >>> AND, THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT IMPLEMENTS SEVERAL POLICIES WITHIN THE GENERAL PLAN. SO, AS I STATED, SINCE 2002, WHEN OUR GENERAL PLAN WAS ADOPTED, THE SITE HAS LONG BEEN SLATED FOR THIS JOB- PRODUCING LIGHT INDUSTRIAL BUSINESS PARK USE, AND THE FINAL USE OF THE SITE IS REALLY, AS PROPOSED TONIGHT, IS CONSISTENT WITH OUR GENERAL PLAN. AND, THE GENERAL PLAN EVEN WENT SO FAR AS TO, SO FAR AS TO ENVISION THE SITE BEING DEVELOPED WITH A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY. SO, THERE'S PIECES IN THE GENERAL PLAN THAT YOU COULD LOOK AT THAT COULD POINT TO THIS DEVELOPMENT AS BEING CONSISTENT. AND, IN ADDITION, THE REMOVAL OF THE LIVE OAK EXTENSION HAS BEEN THOROUGHLY ANALYZED AS PART OF THE PROJECT. >>> THE REZONE, AS I SAID, THE PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT WOULD ALLOW FOR THIS DEVELOPMENT. IT PROVIDES THE FLEXIBILITY, AND THE ACTION, ULTIMATELY, WOULD CLEAN UP THE ZONING ON THE PROPERTY. >>> THE TENTATIVE MAP IS SHOWN HERE ON THIS EXHIBIT SHOWING THAT EIGHT PARCELS THAT ARE GOING TO BE CREATED. THERE ARE TWO MAIN ACCESS POINTS OFF OF BRIDGEHEAD ROAD, AND THEN, THE BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WOULD BE INSTALLED TO ACCESS THE REMAINDER OF THE PARCELS THAT ARE NOT ACCESSED DIRECTLY OFF OF BRIDGEHEAD. >>> THE DESIGN REVIEW ANALYZES THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE SITE. THE PROJECT AND THE STAFF REPORT CONTAINED THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN. THERE ARE CIVIL SHEETS, THE LANDSCAPING PLANS ARE GOING TO BE PROVIDED AT THE BUILDING PERMIT STAGE. CONCEPTUAL ARCHITECTURE HAS BEEN PROVIDED TO YOU. THE DEVELOPER IS VERY FAMILIAR WITH THIS TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT, THAT IS KIND OF WHAT THEY DO, THAT IS THEIR BREAD AND BUTTER. AND, THEY DON'T HAVE USERS IDENTIFIED FOR EACH BUILDING AS SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN FOLLOWING, BUT WE DO HAVE CONDITIONS THAT DO REQUIRE THE DESIGN REVIEW AND THE ARCHITECTURE TO BE APPROVED AT A STAFF LEVEL CONSISTENT WITH THE ARCHITECTURE THAT WAS PRESENTED IN YOUR PACKET TONIGHT. >>> THIS IS A SITE PLAN SHOWING THE SITE. I'M SORRY IT'S SO SMALL, BUT THE SITE IS 100 ALMOST 143 ACRES, SO IT'S HARD TO FIT ON ONE SCREEN. BUT, YOU CAN SEE CLOCKWISE AT THE BOTTOM LEFT CORNER, THERE IS A BUILDING 1, AND THEN, GOING CLOCKWISE, YOU HAVE BUILDING 2, BUILDING 3, BUILDING 4, AND BUILDING 5. >>> THIS IS SAMPLE ARCHITECTURE OF PROJECTS THAT THE APPLICANT HAS PROVIDED FROM DEVELOPMENTS THEY'VE DONE ACROSS THE NATION. AND, IT'S YOUR STANDARD HIGH-QUALITY, HIGH QUALITY DESIGN, TILT UP CONSTRUCTION. AND SO, WE CAN EXPECT DEVELOPMENT AND ARCHITECTURE CONSISTENT WITH WHAT IS SHOWN IN THESE PICTURES. >>> TO ADDRESS THE CEQA, THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT, WE PREPARED AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT. SO, JUST A COUPLE OF THE KEY DEADLINES DURING THAT PROCESS. WE DID A NOTICE OF PREPARATION THAT WAS PUBLISHED FOR 30 DAYS FROM FEBRUARY 20TH, TO MARCH 21ST. WE RELEASED THE DRAFT EIR AND PUBLISHED THE NOTICE OF AVAILABILITY FROM OCTOBER 16TH TO DECEMBER 3RD. IN DOING SO, WE RECEIVED EIGHT COMMENT LETTERS, TWO OF THE COMMENT LETTERS WERE RECEIVED AFTER THE COMMENT PERIOD ENDED ON DECEMBER 3. ONE OF THOSE COMMENT LETTERS FROM THE STATE LANDS COMMISSION WAS INCLUDED WITHIN THE FINAL EIR. A RESPONSE, THE OTHER WAS A RESPONSE TO THE CITY OF ANTIOCH, AND WE RESPONDED TO THEM DIRECTLY. I DID NOT HAVE TIME TO INCORPORATE IT INTO THE FINAL EIR. AND, WITH THAT, AND I WILL SAY THIS ON THE FOLLOWING TWO SIDES, BUT REALLY, WHAT WERE ASKING YOU TONIGHT IS TO CERTIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT. IT INCLUDES THE ADOPTIONS OF THE FINDINGS OF FACT, THE STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS, AND FINALLY, THE ADOPTION OF THE MITIGATION AND MONITORING REPORTING PROGRAM, WHICH IS REALLY THE DOCUMENT THAT SAYS, HOW DO YOU IMPLEMENT ALL THE MITIGATION MEASURES THAT ARE CONTAINED WITHIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT. >>> AND, JUST TO CLOSE BEFORE I GIVE A RECOMMENDATION, THE ANALYSIS WAS REALLY CENTERED AROUND, IN THE CEQA, AND ALL THE DOCUMENTS IN FRONT OF YOU TONIGHT, REALLY, FOUR, KIND OF, MAIN FOCUS AREAS. SO, THE FIRST BEING, THIS IS A LARGE-SCALE ECONOMIC DRIVER. WE SEE THIS AS A CATALYST, NOT ONLY FOR OAKLEY, BUT FOR THE REGION, AND THEY ARE PROPOSING TO BUILD ALMOST 2,000,000 FT. OF CLASS A INDUSTRIAL SPACE. WHICH, OAKLEY DEFINITELY DOESN'T HAVE, AND IT'S HARD TO FIND IN THE REGION ITSELF. AND, THE AMOUNT OF JOBS AND BENEFITS TO THE COUNTY AS A WHOLE ARE JUST GREAT. THE PROJECT WOULD IMPLEMENT, AS I SAID, A NUMBER OF THE GENERAL PLAN POLICIES. IT'S GOING TO INSTALL BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE, AS I MENTIONED, IT'S GOING TO FURTHER THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ORDERLY DEVELOPMENT OF THE CITY. AND REALLY, IT'S DEVELOPING THE PROJECT SITE IN THE VISION AND MANNER INTENDED IN THAT GENERAL PLAN. THE DELTA RECREATION AREA IS A SENSITIVE AREA, WE UNDERSTAND THAT, THAT'S BEING PRESERVED AS PART OF THIS DEVELOPMENT. AND LASTLY, THIS REALLY WILL COMPLETE, IF APPROVED, THE CLEANUP AND REMEDIATION THAT'S BEEN GOING ON FOR YEARS. THE PROJECT HAS BEEN ACTIVE, OR THE SITE HAS ACTIVELY BEING REMEDIATED SINCE 2003, AND WITH THE BUILD OUT OF THIS PROJECT AND THE ONGOING REMEDIATION THAT'S SUPPOSED TO FINISH UP EARLY NEXT YEAR, WILL ULTIMATELY PROVIDE THE CITY WITH A NEW AMENITY THAT IS NOT THERE RIGHT NOW. SO, WITH THAT SAID, AND I KNOW IT'S LENGTHY, BUT I JUST KIND OF WANTED TO RUN THROUGH THE RECOMMENDATIONS SO YOU HAVE THAT AND IT'S CLEAR. WE ARE ASKING THAT YOU CERTIFY THE OAKLEY LOGISTICS CENTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT, INCLUDING THE ADOPTION OF THE FINDINGS OF FACT, THE STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS, AND THE ADOPTION OF THE MITIGATION AND MONITORING REPORTING PROGRAM. WE ARE ASKING YOU THAT YOU ADOPT A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT TO AMEND THE LAND USE DESIGNATION OF THE 143.3 ACRE PROJECT SITE FROM LIGHT INDUSTRIAL/BUSINESS PARK/UTILITY ENERGY TO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL, WITH THE REMAINDER OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY BEING DELTA RECREATION, AND TO REMOVE THE PROPOSED EXTENSION OF THE LIVE OAK AVE. FROM FIGURE 3.1, 3 1 OF THE CIRCULATION DIAGRAM OF THE GENERAL PLAN. WE ARE ASKING THAT YOU WEAVE THE FIRST READING AND INTRODUCE AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE REZONING TO AMEND THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF THE 375.7 ACRE SITE FROM SPECIFIC PLAN 3 TO PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT P 1. WE ARE ASKING THAT YOU ADOPT A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE VESTING TENTATIVE MAP AND DESIGN REVIEW. AND, WE'RE ALSO ASKING THAT YOU WEAVE THE FIRST READING, AND INTRODUCE AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. >>> BEFORE I CLOSE, WE DID RECEIVE THREE LETTERS TODAY. I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS EACH ONE OF THEM SEPARATELY. ONE OF THE LETTERS WAS FROM THE EAST BAY REGIONAL PARK DISTRICT. THEIR ULTIMATE DESIRE IS TO HAVE A TRAIL THAT EXTENDS FROM THE EXISTING BIG BREAK REGIONAL SHORELINE TO THE ANTIOCH DELTA PIER. THIS LETTER BASICALLY OUTLINES A CONVERSATION THAT I HAD WITH THEM THIS MORNING COMMITTING THAT WE WILL MEET EARLY NEXT YEAR. ALSO, IT IS TALKING TO THE APPLICANT, AND THE APPLICANT IS ALSO IN AGREEMENT THAT WE WILL MEET AND DISCUSS THIS ISSUE FURTHER, AND I THINK IT IS IN EVERYONE'S INTEREST TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT A SOLUTION. >>> THE SECOND LETTER WAS RECEIVED BY LESAGE DRURY. THEY COMMENTED ON THE DRAFT EIR. THIS LETTER IS IN RESPONSE TO THE FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT. WE FEEL ALL THE ISSUES THAT ARE RAISED IN THIS LETTER ARE NOT NEW ISSUES. THEY ARE ISSUES THAT WERE PREVIOUSLY RAISED AND THAT WE RESPONDED TO ADEQUATELY AND GAVE THEM THOSE RESPONSES. SO, WE DON'T FEEL LIKE ANY ISSUES RAISED HERE ARE NEW OR EVIDENCE PRESENTED IS NEW THAT WE HAVE NOT SEEN. >>> AND, WE RECEIVED A LETTER TODAY FROM ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH N CARDOZO, AND THAT, LIKE THE LAST LETTER, WE FEEL LIKE ALL THE ISSUES RAISED IN THAT LETTER WERE ISSUES RAISED BY COMMENTS RECEIVED WITH THE DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT, COMMENTS THAT WE PREPARED FOR THOSE RESPONSES TO THAT WE PREPARED FOR THOSE COMMENTS, AND THAT THERE'S NO ISSUES PRESENT IN THIS LETTER THAT WOULD CAUSE US TO SAY THAT WE DIDN'T ANALYZE ANYTHING SAID WITHIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT. SO, WITH THAT SAID, STAFF IS AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS, AND THAT CONCLUDES MY REPORT. >> ANY QUESTIONS OF STAFF AT THIS TIME? COUNCILMEMBER ALAURA. >> THANK YOU FOR ALL OF THE INFORMATION, AND FOR ADDRESSING THE LETTERS THAT WERE RECEIVED TODAY. I DO HAVE SOME QUESTIONS. QUESTIONS WERE BROUGHT TO ME BEFORE THE MEETING, THE SPECIAL MEETING TONIGHT AS TO WHY THERE NEEDED TO BE A SPECIAL MEETING. I, IN MYSELF, HAD THAT QUESTION. AND, MR. MCMURRAY PREPARED A STATEMENT AS TO THE REASONS WHY, SO I WANTED TO READ THAT. IT MAY ANSWER SOME OF THE QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE HERE IN THE AUDIENCE AND FOR THOSE WATCHING AT HOME. >>> THE DRAFT EIR REQUIRED A 45 DAY PUBLIC REVIEW PERIOD. WE POSTED THAT FROM OCTOBER 16TH THROUGH SEPTEMBER 3RD. CEQA REQUIRES THAT WE NEED TO RESPOND TO COMMENTS AND PROVIDE THOSE RESPONSES ONLY TO PUBLIC AGENCIES, 10 DAYS PRIOR TO FILING THE EIR. IN ORDER TO GET THE PROJECT HEARD AND APPROVED BEFORE THE CALENDAR YEAR ENDS, WE HAD NO CHOICE BUT TO CALL A SPECIAL MEETING, SO WE HAD TIME TO PROPERLY RESPOND TO COMMENTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CEQA. KEEP IN MIND, THIS PROJECT WAS SUBMITTED ON DECEMBER 17, 2018. WE HAVE COMPLIED WITH ALL NOTICING REQUIREMENTS FOR THE CEQA AND THE PUBLIC HEARING, AND I FEEL CONFIDENT OUR REVIEW ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION IS COMPLETE AND THOROUGH. >>> PART OF THE SPECIAL MEETING WAS ALSO DICTATED BY THE REQUEST FROM THE APPLICANT TO HAVE THE PROJECT HEARD BEFORE 2020. AS THE CITY IS STARVING FOR HIGHER-PAYING AND QUALITY JOBS, WE CANNOT AFFORD TO SIT ON APPLICATIONS BECAUSE WE CAN. THAT HAPPENS ALL OVER THE STATE, AND ISN'T A PRACTICE WE BELIEVE IN. WE ARE ABLE TO ACCOMMODATE THE REQUEST WITH AN AGGRESSIVE SCHEDULE. THIS IS NOT OUT OF THE NORM FOR CITIES THAT WANT TO STREAMLINE AND EXPEDITE CATALYST ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS. ONE OF OUR STRENGTHS AS A CITY IS TO PROCESS APPLICATIONS QUICKLY, BECAUSE WE HAVE REMOVED BARRIERS AND STREAMLINED THE PROCESS. THIS IS A TREND STATEWIDE, AND WE ARE WAY AHEAD OF THE CURVE IN THAT RESPECT. SO, THANK YOU, MR. MCMURRAY, FOR THE REPLY TO THAT QUESTION. >>> I ALSO WANTED TO ADD THAT ALTHOUGH IT WAS AT THE REQUEST OF THE APPLICANT THAT WE SEE THIS BEFORE 2020, I FEEL, AND I HOPE THAT I CAN SPEAK FOR THE REST OF THE COUNCIL, THAT ALTHOUGH WE MOVE QUICKLY, WE STILL MOVE CAUTIOUSLY, AND THAT WE DO OUR PART TO ANALYZE ALL OF THE INFORMATION THAT IS BROUGHT TO US, AND DON'T DO THINGS JUST TO RUSH THEM AND GET THEM OUT THE DOOR BECAUSE SOMEBODY ASKED US TO. AND, I JUST TO ADD THAT BEFORE WE CONTINUE. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? ANYTHING ELSE YOU NEED? >> NOT RIGHT NOW. >> SO, WE HAVE RECEIVED, AND YOU COMMENTED ON, ALL THE COMMENTS THAT WERE RECEIVED ONLINE PRIOR TO THIS MEETING? >> CORRECT. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. IF THERE ARE NO COMMENTS, WITH THE APPLICANT LIKE TO COMMENT? COME ON UP. >> [INAUDIBLE/OFF MIC] >> YES, WE WILL ADDRESS YOUR BLUE CARD WHEN WE GET TO THAT PART OF THE MEETING. NO COMMENTS FROM STAFF UP HERE. >> GOOD EVENING, MR. MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. IT'S A PRIVILEGE TO STAND UP HERE AND PRESENT OUR PROJECT TO YOU ALL. IT'S BEEN A LONG YEAR TO PREPARE THIS, AND WE'VE WORKED REALLY HARD, AND WE ARE TRULY EXCITED TO BE SHOWING YOU WHAT WE HAVE PLANNED FOR THE PROPERTY. AND, WE ENCOURAGE QUESTIONS. WE'D LOVE TO KIND OF SHOW YOU WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT. SO, THANK YOU. THANK YOU TO THE MEMBERS OF THE STAFF. WE DO APPRECIATE THE TIMELY AND THE EXPEDITIOUS PROCESS THAT WENT ON HERE. THE STAFF IS TOP-NOTCH FIRST RATE HERE AT OAKLEY, SO THANK YOU AGAIN. THE NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. ACTUALLY, I CAN DO IT FROM HERE. >>> SO, A LITTLE BIT ABOUT NORTHPOINT. FIRST OF ALL, MY NAME IS JED MOULMONT, I'M BASED IN ST. LOUIS, BUT OUR COMPANY IS LOCALLY IN KANSAS CITY. WE HAVE OFFICES IN CINCINNATI AND CHICAGO. WE ARE PRIMARILY AN INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPER. WE STARTED, WE WERE FOUNDED IN 2012, AND OUR PRIMARY FOCUS IS IN INDUSTRIAL REAL ESTATE, CLASS A INDUSTRIAL REAL ESTATE. WE HAVE A VERY STRONG ROOT IN TECHNICAL EXPERTISE BETWEEN THE MEMBERS OF OUR FIRM. I'M JOINED TONIGHT BY BRENT MILES AND ANDREW GREMLOW, BOTH WITH NORTHPOINT. BRENT HEADS UP OUR LEASING PLATFORM, AND ANDREW HEADS UP A LOT OF OUR CONSTRUCTION. SO, WE ARE MEMBERS OF THE TEAM THAT IS PLANNING THIS OAKLEY PROJECT. >>> YOU KNOW, OUR EXPERIENCE ACROSS THE COUNTRY IS KIND OF, COAST TO COAST. WE'RE, YOU KNOW, FROM PHILADELPHIA, NEW YORK, ALL THE WAY OUT TO SACRAMENTO WE HAVE PROJECTS CURRENTLY. OVER OUR SHORT, YOU KNOW, 7 TO 8 YEARS OF BEING IN BUSINESS, WE'VE REALLY BEEN PROBABLY THE MOST ACTIVE PRIVATELY HELD INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPER IN THE COUNTRY. WE DEVELOP APPROXIMATELY 12,000,000 FT. PER YEAR. THIS YEAR, WE WILL LEASE NEARLY 14,000,000 FT. OF NEW INDUSTRIAL SPACE ACROSS THE COUNTRY, WHICH REALLY KIND OF LEADS THE PACK, ESPECIALLY FOR PRIVATELY HELD FIRMS. IT'S SOMETHING WERE VERY PROUD ABOUT, AND WE WILL TALK TO YOU MORE ABOUT OUR PLANS FOR THE OAKLEY PROJECT HERE. YOU KNOW, WHAT THAT EQUATES TO IS ABOUT 1500 TO 1800 ACRES DEVELOPED ANNUALLY THAT WE ARE CONTINUALLY LOOKING FOR AND PUTTING BACK INTO PROJECTS. IT ALSO EQUATES TO ABOUT 1.2 BILLION IN ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION. SO, THAT IS ABOUT 100 MILLION A MONTH THAT WE'RE BUILDING COMING OUT OF THE GROUND WITH. SO, IT'S REAL NUMBERS, IT'S REAL BUILDINGS, AND WE, YOU KNOW, WE'RE REALLY EXCITED TO BRING THAT LEVEL OF ACTIVITY HERE TO OAKLEY. >>> THIS SLIDE KIND OF CAPTURE SOME OF OUR INDUSTRIAL CLIENTS THAT WE CATER TO ACROSS THE COUNTRY. YOU WILL SEE SOME BIG NAMES ON THERE. WE ARE GM, GENERAL MOTORS, LARGEST LANDLORD ACROSS THE COUNTRY. CHEWY.COM, WHERE YOU BUY YOUR PET FOOD, THEY LEASE MILLIONS OF SQUARE FEET FROM US, ALONG WITH AMAZON, HOME DEPOT, LOWES, HOSTESS, MANY, MANY BIG NAMES UP THERE, AND A LOT OF INTEREST HAS BEEN CAST ALREADY TOWARDS OAKLEY AND PLANTING THEIR FLAG HERE. >>> SO, A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT WHO WE ARE. WE ARE ROOTED IN TECHNICAL EXPERTISE. ALL OF OUR PROJECT MANAGERS ARE ENGINEERS BY TRADE. ANDREW IS A CIVIL ENGINEER, I AM AN ENGINEER, ALMOST ALL OF OUR PROJECT MANAGEMENT TEAM, SO WE TAKE A VERY TECHNICAL FOCUS. AND, THAT REALLY COMES TO THE ROOT OF WHY WE LIKE BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT, AND I'LL TALK ABOUT THAT A LITTLE BIT LATER. WE HAVE IN-HOUSE ARCHITECTURE, WE HAVE IN-HOUSE CIVIL ENGINEERING, WE HAVE IN-HOUSE DATA ANALYTICS. SO, WE BRING ALL THAT IN-HOUSE, AND I'LL TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE DATA ANALYTICS TO WHY WE LIKE OAKLEY, WHY WE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY. WE'VE MAPPED, REALLY, ON A 1 MILE X 1 MILE GRID, LABOR AND LOGISTICS AND TRANSPORTATION METRICS, WHICH ARE IMPORTANT TO OUR USERS, WHICH ARE IMPORTANT TO INDUSTRIAL REAL ESTATE. AND, ONE OF THE LARGEST FACTORS FOR A TENANT TO LOCATE IN A COMMUNITY IS THE LABOR, AND THE SECOND, PROBABLY BEING THE LOGISTICS. AND, WHAT WE'VE DONE IS A HEAT MAP, AND WE FOUND THAT OAKLEY AND CONTRA COSTA COUNTY IS A BRIGHT RED GLOWING STAR ON THE MAP, MEANING THERE IS A TON OF LABOR HERE, AND USERS LOVE THAT. AND SO, WE FEEL STRONGLY ABOUT OUR INVESTMENT IN OAKLEY. WE FEEL STRONGLY ABOUT ATTRACTING TENANTS HERE BECAUSE OF THE LABOR. SECONDLY, BECAUSE OF THE LOGISTICS OFF OF THE IMPROVED HIGHWAY 4, AND BE ABLE TO SERVE THE GREATER BAY AREA, AND REALLY, THE, YOU KNOW, THE WEST COAST, TO SOME DEGREE. >>> SO, JOSH MENTIONED WE SUBMITTED THIS PROJECT ABOUT A YEAR AGO TODAY, I THINK A YEAR AGO EXACTLY, SO IT'S BEEN A LONG PROCESS. WE ACTUALLY PUT THE PROPERTY UNDER CONTRACT SEPTEMBER 2018. SO, THERE HAVE BEEN MANY DEVELOPERS COME BEFORE US, YOU KNOW, KICKING TIRES, SO TO SPEAK, ON THIS PROPERTY, TRYING TO DO SOMETHING WITH IT. ONE OF THE PRIDES I TAKE IN THIS PROJECT IS THAT IT IS VERY, VERY DIFFICULT. IT HAD MANY LAYERS OF COMPLEXITY, BOTH FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL, THE HISTORICAL USE OF IT, TO WHERE WAS THAT, YOU KNOW, THE DIFFERENT THINGS, THE DIFFERENT HISTORY OF THE PROPERTY, AND TO OVERCOME THAT, AND TO PUT IT BACK INTO PRODUCTIVE REUSE. THAT'S WHAT GETS US EXCITED ABOUT DOING BROWNFIELD PROJECTS. THAT'S WHAT REALLY EXCITES US ABOUT THIS PROJECT. >>> SO, MOVING FAST FORWARD HERE, IN FEBRUARY, WE HAD OUR NOTICE OF SCOPING. AGAIN, IN MARCH, WE HAD OUR 30-DAY PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD, WHERE THE PUBLIC WAS ABLE TO COME AND LOOK AT THE PROJECT AND KIND OF FEEL OUT WHAT WE WERE DOING. WE PRODUCE THE DRAFT EIR AT THE END OF THIS YEAR IN OCTOBER. AND, AS JOSH MENTIONED, IT WRAPPED UP HERE ON DECEMBER 3RD WITH THE COMMENT PERIOD ENDING, AND THEN, HERE WE ARE TONIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU. >>> SO, THIS IS JUST A LITTLE AERIAL SHOWING WHERE THIS IS THAT. AGAIN, JOSH KIND OF WENT THROUGH THIS, BUT IT IS NORTH OF BNSF RAIL TRACKS, EAST OF THE BRIDGEHEAD ROAD, AND JUST SOUTH OF THE LAURITZEN MARINA. >>> SO, THIS IMAGE DEPICTS THE DEVELOPMENT AREA VERSUS THE NONDEVELOPMENT AREA. AND, JOSH MENTIONED THAT TONIGHT WE ARE ASKING FOR THE PROPERTY TO BE REZONED. THE PROPERTY IN ORANGE WILL ACTUALLY BE THE DEVELOPMENT AREA, WHERE THE BUILDINGS ARE AT, AND IT WILL BE REZONED AS THE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL USE. THE PROPERTY THAT IS OUTSIDE OF THAT ATTACHED, THAT IS THE WETLAND AREA, AND THAT IS THE DELTA RECREATION AREA. SO, THIS IS A 375 APPROXIMATE ACRE SITE, WE ARE ONLY DEVELOPING ABOUT 150 OF THAT. THE REST IS PRESERVED. >>> THIS IS A HISTORICAL IMAGE OF THE DUPONT FACTORY. SO, IT WAS MENTIONED THAT, I THINK, THE DUPONT FACTORY CLOSED DOWN IN 1998. DTSC HAD A CONSENT ORDER OVER THE PROPERTY, I WILL TALK TO THAT A LITTLE BIT LATER, BUT YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE HISTORICAL IMAGES IN THE 1950S AND THE 1980S. YOU KNOW, THIS WAS A THRIVING FACTORY, A THRIVING PLANT FROM DUPONT. WHEN IT CLOSED DOWN, A LOT OF THOSE JOBS WENT BY THE WAYSIDE. SO AGAIN, THIS IS VERY EXCITING TO BRING, BRING THOSE JOBS BACK, BRING THAT INVESTMENT BACK TO THIS PIECE OF PROPERTY. >>> THIS IS A MAP OF WHAT ALL GOES INTO ENVIRONMENTAL REMEDIATION ON A PROPERTY. SO, THE SITE HAD A CONSENT ORDER PUT ON IT BACK IN 2003, WHICH IS BASICALLY A CONSENT FROM DTSC THAT SAYS, YOU MUST CLEAN THIS PROPERTY UP, AND YOU MUST CLEAN IT UP TO THE STANDARDS. THE STANDARDS THAT WERE SET ESSENTIALLY, GIVE US THE ABILITY TO DEVELOP WHAT WE WOULD LIKE TO DEVELOP, WHICH IS INDUSTRIAL STANDARDS. YOU COULDN'T DO RESIDENTIAL HERE, YOU COULDN'T DO ANY TYPE OF LIVING USE, IT HAS TO BE AN INDUSTRIAL OR MANUFACTURING-TYPE USE. SO, THIS IS JUST AN IMAGE SHOWING THE DIFFERENT PLUMES. IT SHOWS THE MONITORING WELLS, IT SHOWS THE CHARACTERIZATIONS OF THE SITE, WHAT THEY MADE AT THE SITE ANTI KNOCK AGENTS, THEY MADE TEFLON, THEY MADE SOME ASPHALT MIXTURES THAT NEEDED TO BE REMEDIATED, NEEDED TO BE CLEANED UP. SO, WE ARE HAPPY TO SAY THAT WHEN WE PUT THE PROPERTY UNDER CONTRACT, WE LOCKED ARMS WITH KENMORE'S, AND WE PUSHED THE REMEDIATION SCHEDULE A YEAR BEFORE WHEN IT WOULD HAVE BEEN CLEANED UP AS PART OF OUR CONTRACT WITH KENMORE'S. WE AGGRESSIVELY ACCELERATED THAT. WE FUNDED PARTS OF THAT. WE FUNDED ABOUT $1 MILLION AHEAD OF SCHEDULE TO PUSH THAT WORK TO MAKE IT HAPPEN SOONER BECAUSE WE BELIEVED IN THE SITE. THERE ARE, AS YOU CAN SEE, THE MONITORING WELLS ARE ALL OVER THE PROPERTY, WHICH MONITORS GROUNDWATER. IT ALSO MONITORS VAPOR GAS INTRUSION. MANY OF THOSE MONITORING WELLS, I'M HAPPY TO REPORT, WILL BE ABANDONED, BECAUSE OF THE LEVELS AND THE CLEANUP WAS SUCCESSFUL. >>> THIS AGAIN, IS ANOTHER IMAGE SHOWING SOME OF THE DIFFERENT REMEDIATION TECHNIQUES AND REMEDIATION AREAS FROM THE OLD MANUFACTURING PORTIONS OF THE SITE. ALL OF THE REMEDIATION WAS REALLY BROKEN DOWN INTO TWO PHASES. PHASE I IS COMPLETE AS OF LAST FALL. PHASE 2 WILL BE COMPLETE AS OF ABOUT MARCH 2020. PHASE 2 IS A VERY, VERY SMALL AREA, AND DOES NOT CONFLICT WITH ANY DEVELOPMENT. SO, I AM HAPPY TO REPORT THAT IS WELL UNDERWAY, AND DTSC IS VERY HAPPY WITH THE PROGRESS MADE AT THE PROPERTY. >>> SO, BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT IS ONE THING THAT WE'VE TAKEN A CONCENTRATION IN OVER THE LAST 18 MONTHS. I WANT TO JUST SHOW YOU, YOU KNOW, WE'RE NOT SAYING THAT, YOU KNOW, WE ARE TIRE KICKERS AND THAT WE ARE NOT ABLE TO HANDLE THESE SITES. THESE ARE REAL EXAMPLES OF PROPERTIES THAT OVER THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS THAT WE HAVE SUCCESSFULLY TACKLED, WE'VE CLOSED, AND THEN, WE'VE MADE SIGNIFICANT CAPITAL INVESTMENT AND BROUGHT JOBS BACK TO THESE HISTORICAL MANUFACTURING PLANTS THAT WERE CLOSED AND ABANDONED. WE'VE REDEVELOPED SOME OF THESE EXAMPLES, THEY ARE IN LATER SLIDES. WE'VE REDEVELOPED SOME AIRPLANE HANGARS IN DALLAS. WE'VE REDEVELOPED THE HARLEY-DAVIDSON FACTORY IN YORK, PENNSYLVANIA. WE'VE REDEVELOPED LANDFILLS IN ST. LOUIS. WE'RE WORKING ACTIVELY TO REDEVELOP OTHER SITES ALL OVER PENNSYLVANIA, AND COAL MINES, YOU KNOW, ALL OVER THE EAST COAST AND PHILADELPHIA WERE SOME OLD CHEMICAL AND OIL MANUFACTURING COMPANIES. SO, THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE DO DAY IN AND DAY OUT, WHICH IS WHY WE BELIEVE WE WERE THE RIGHT FIT FOR THIS PROPERTY. >>> HERE ARE A COUPLE OF EXAMPLES OF SOME OF THOSE SUCCESS STORIES. I WILL DRAW YOUR ATTENTION TO HANOVER RIDGE. SO, THAT WAS A FORMER MINE, I BELIEVE, AND NOW, THAT IS A THRIVING BUSINESS PARK WITH CHEWY.COM, ADIDAS, AND PATAGONIA AS THE TENANTS IN THAT PARK. WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF SUCCESS STORIES WITH COMMUNITIES WHERE WE'VE HAD REDEVELOPMENT, JOBS LOST BECAUSE OF THE CLOSURE OF PLANTS, NOW, WITH THESE NEW INDUSTRIAL PARKS AND TENANTS, JOBS WERE BROUGHT BACK, GRADUATION RATES HAVE WENT UP, MORE PEOPLE ARE GOING TO WORK, BETTER WAGES, BETTER TAXES, OVERALL IMPROVED CONDITIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY. >>> HERE ARE TWO MORE SLIDES, DALLAS GLOBAL ARE THE AERONAUTIC HANGERS THAT WE REDEVELOPED IN DALLAS. NOW, THERE IS A 2,200,000 FT. FACILITY FOR HOME DEPOT THERE. ON THE RIGHT IS A FORMER LANDFILL. THAT WAS REDEVELOPED A COUPLE YEARS AGO. WE HAVE AMAZON, WE HAVE CDW LOGISTICS, BERLIN PACKAGING, AND SEVERAL OTHER TENANTS. I SAY WE HAVE CLOSE TO 20 TENANTS IN THAT PARK, VERY SMALL REGIONALLY-BASED TENANTS IN ST. LOUIS. >>> THIS IS OUR PROPOSED SITE PLAN AS JOSH HAD MENTIONED. SO, APPROXIMATELY 2,000,000 FT. OF BUILDINGS. PHASE I IS BUILDING NUMBER 1 AND ALSO BUILDING NUMBER 2, AND SO, WE WOULD PLAN TO START BOTH BUILDINGS IMMEDIATELY IF WE WERE APPROVED TONIGHT. AND, WHEN I SAY IMMEDIATELY, THE MONTH OF JANUARY WE WOULD PLAN TO START ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION ON THE PROPERTY. WITH TONIGHT'S APPROVAL, WE HAVE A TENANT WILLING TO TAKE BUILDING NUMBER 1 FULL AND COMPLETE LEASED, WHICH IS A GREAT SUCCESSFUL STORY TO HAVE THE FIRST BUILDING 100% LEASED OUT OF THE GATE. OBVIOUSLY, THAT IS DEPENDENT ON TONIGHT. BUILDING NUMBER 2, WE WOULD BUILD THAT SPECULATIVELY, SO WE WOULD DO THAT WITHOUT A TENANT IN MIND. WE ARE VERY CONFIDENT THAT WE CAN MAKE THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT AND ATTRACT TENANTS INTO THAT BUILDING. ONCE WE HAVE THAT BUILDING AT LEASED, WE WOULD KIND OF, PLAN TO ROLL AROUND THE PARK BUILDINGS 3, 4, AND 5. WHEN WE GET ONE BUILDING 50% LEASED, WE WOULD START THE NEXT BUILDING. SO, WE WOULD HOPE THAT THIS PARK WOULD BE BUILT OUT IN 3 TO 4 YEARS IS OUR HOPE, BUT WE HAVE DONE IT A LOT FASTER. IT ALL DEPENDS ON THE CONDITIONS AND THE MARKET. >>> SO, ABOUT 2,000,000 FT. , THE NEXT SLIDE KIND OF CAPTURES SOME OF THE ECONOMIC DATA. SO, WE DID RUN INDEPENDENT ECONOMIC STUDIES, BOTH FROM NORTHPOINT INTERNAL STUDIES, AS WELL AS A STUDY BY ECONOMIC PENDING SYSTEMS INC. BELOW. SO AGAIN, 2,000,000 FT. THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT FOR NORTHPOINT IS ABOUT $185 MILLION, SO THAT'S JUST FOR THE SITE IMPROVEMENTS AND BUILDINGS. A LOT OF TIMES, THE TENANTS WILL MATCH THAT CONTRIBUTION WITH WHAT THEY PUT PHYSICALLY INSIDE THE BUILDING. THOUGH, MANY TIMES, THE MATERIAL HANDLING EQUIPMENT, THE RACKING, THE SYSTEMS AND THE TI FIT OUTS THAT GO IN THE BUILDING IS JUST AS MUCH AS WHAT WE INVEST IN THE BUILDING ITSELF, SO THAT COULD EASILY GROW TO OVER $300 MILLION PRETTY QUICKLY IN THE INVESTMENT IN THE COMMUNITY. >>>SO, WHAT THAT MEANS FOR THE CITY. SO, THERE IS ABOUT A $350,000 + EXCESS FUNDING TO THE GENERAL FUND HERE IN OAKLEY. THERE IS ABOUT $400,000 ANNUALLY THAT GOES TO THE FIRE DEPARTMENT. THERE IS $475 MILLION OF ECONOMIC ACTIVITY IN THE COUNTY, THAT IS JUST FROM GENERALLY, THE DEVELOPMENT, THE JOBS THAT ARE PRODUCED, ALL OF THE ANCILLARY JOBS, SECONDARY JOBS THAT COME WITH A DEVELOPMENT LIKE THIS. AS FAR AS THE JOBS NUMBERS, WE PROJECT 725 CONSTRUCTION JOBS, 1890 DIRECT JOBS, THOSE ARE JOBS IN THE BUILDINGS THEMSELVES, 490 INDIRECT JOBS, THOSE OR MAYBE, SERVICE-ORIENTED JOBS, OR JOBS THAT COME IN AND OUT OF THE FACILITY ON A DAY-IN/DAY-OUT BASIS, BUT THEY ARE NOT PHYSICALLY IN THE BUILDING. AND THEN, ANOTHER 470 INDUCED JOBS, WHICH IS SIMILAR TO THE INDIRECT JOBS. SO, ALL IN, THAT WOULD GROW THE OVERALL COMPENSATION BY ABOUT $190 MILLION ANNUALLY GENERATED FROM THIS PROJECT. >>> THESE ARE A FEW EXAMPLES OF OUR BUILDINGS. I KNOW JOSH HAD A FEW WITH THESE ON OUR SLIDES, BUT REALLY, WHAT WE WANT TO PORTRAY HERE IS, CLASS A INDUSTRIAL WAREHOUSING IN LIGHT INDUSTRIAL BUILDINGS. SO, THESE ARE ALL CONCRETE TILT WALL CONSTRUCTION OF THE HIGHEST QUALITY, AND ESFR FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS. THEY HAVE STOREFRONT AND OFFICE PANELS ON THE CORNERS AND IN MIDPOINTS OF THE BUILDING. THEY ARE SET UP SO THAT ONE TENANT CAN TAKE THE ENTIRE BUILDING, OR THAT WE COULD BREAK IT DOWN AND DO 5-6 TENANTS IN A BUILDING IF WE HAVE TO. SO, THEY ARE VERY CUSTOMIZABLE, WE CAN DEMISE THEM IN A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT WAYS. >>> HERE ARE A FEW EXAMPLES OF THE OFFICE TENANT IMPROVEMENTS. SO, MANY TIMES WE WILL HAVE, LIKE I SAID, 1-2, MAYBE 4-5 TENANTS IN A BUILDING, AND EACH CUSTOM OFFICE PLAN WILL BE TO WHATEVER THAT TENANT NEEDS. MAYBE THEY HAVE A MANUFACTURING COMPONENT AS WELL, AND WE WOULD DO, WE WOULD ASSIST THEM IN THEIR RACKING, THEIR CONVEYING SYSTEMS, AND THEN, THEIR MANUFACTURING COMPONENTS THAT THEY BRING IN. >>> AND LASTLY, I WILL JUST LEAVE YOU WITH A RECENT SUCCESS STORY, A VERY RECENT PROJECT IN BELTON, MISSOURI, THIS IS OUR HOMETOWN. BUT SIMILAR, A SIMILAR STORY, IT WAS A UNDERUTILIZED SITE, WE WERE ABLE TO CONTROL IT, PUT IT BACK INTO REUSE. AND, I'M HAPPY TO SAY THAT WE HAVE A FIRST TENANT THAT IS SIGNED UP FOR THIS PARK. THAT WAS ANOTHER LOCAL BUSINESS IN KANSAS CITY THAT WE LOCATED TO THIS BUILDING, THE CITY OF BELTON, MISSOURI, JUST OUTSIDE OF KANSAS CITY. SO, WE WOULD WANT TO DO THE SAME THING HERE. WE WOULD WANT TO START CONSTRUCTION IMMEDIATELY, ROLL UP OUR SLEEVES AND ATTRACT TENANTS, BUSINESS, AND JOBS TO THE COMMUNITY. SO AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK, AND AGAIN, THE CITY OF OAKLEY IS TOP-NOTCH AND FIRST-CLASS, AND AS WELL AS THE STAFF. AND SO, WE APPRECIATE THAT, AND WE ARE EXCITED TO GET STARTED WITH THE REAL WORK. I'D LOVE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT ANYONE MAY HAVE. >> QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME OF THE APPLICANT? >> NOT RIGHT NOW. >> OKAY. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> AT THIS TIME, WE WILL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING. THE WAY THE PROCESS WILL WORK IS, YOU WILL HAVE I WILL CALL YOUR NAME OUT, YOU WILL HAVE THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK. THE GREEN LIGHT WILL GO ON, THE YELLOW LIGHT WILL GO ON AS A WARNING THAT YOU HAVE ONE MINUTE LEFT, THE RED LIGHT WILL GO ON AT THE END OF THREE MINUTES, AT WHICH TIME, YOU SHOULD END UP YOUR TESTIMONY AND MOVE ON. MS. SARAH DUDLEY. >> HI, GOOD EVENING. CAN YOU HEAR ME? >> YES. >> HI. THANK YOU. I'M SARAH DUDLEY, I'M REPRESENTING OAKLEY RESIDENTS FOR RESPONSIBLE DEVELOPMENT. OAKLEY RESIDENTS IS A COALITION OF LABOR UNIONS, THEIR MEMBERS, AND FAMILIES, WHO LIVE, WORK, AND RECREATE HERE IN OAKLEY AND THE SURROUNDING AREAS. AND, THIS IS THE LAST THING I WILL READ. OUR MEMBERS, SOME OF OUR LOCAL MEMBERS HERE ARE JOHN ESCOBAR, JOHN HEAT, KEVIN BURBANK, CHRIS STODDARD, DAVID ROACH, AND ELIAS RIVERA. MEMBERS MAY ALSO WORK ON THE PROJECT ITSELF. THEREFORE, THEY WOULD BE THE FIRST IN LINE TO BE EXPOSED TO ANY HEALTH AND SAFETY IMPACTS ON THE SITE, AND I THINK WE'VE TALKED ABOUT HOW IT'S CONTAMINATED. WE REVIEWED THE COMMENTS SUBMITTED ON THE DRAFT EIR AND ON THE FINAL EIR, EXPERT REPORTS, NUMEROUS LETTERS RECEIVED FROM AGENCIES INCLUDING THAT AIR DISTRICT, THE DEPARTMENT OF TOXICS AND SUBSTANCE CONTROL, AMONG OTHERS, AND WE'VE DETERMINED THAT THESE LETTERS AND EXPERT REPORTS PROVIDE SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THERE ARE UNEXPLORED IMPACTS THAT WERE NOT RAISED IN THE DRAFT EIR AND WERE NOT RESOLVED IN THE FINAL EIR. AND, THE PROPER WAY TO ADDRESS THOSE IMPACTS IS NOT IN A FINAL EIR BUT IN A RECIRCULATED DRAFT EIR THAT ADDRESSES THOSE IMPACTS. NOW, I ONLY HAVE A COUPLE OF MINUTES, SO I DON'T HAVE TIME TO GO THROUGH EVERY ONE OF OUR CONCERNS, THOSE RAISED BY THE STATE AGENCIES, SO I'M GOING TO JUST TALK ABOUT A FEW. >>> FIRST, IS AIR QUALITY. AS YOU MAY KNOW, THE AIR DISTRICT, OUR AIR DISTRICT, YOUR AIR DISTRICT, RECOMMENDED THAT A HEALTH RISK ANALYSIS BE PERFORMED FOR THIS PROJECT. A HEALTH RISK ANALYSIS IS AN INTERESTING DOCUMENT. IT CONNECTS WHAT CAN BECOME THE ABSTRACT INFORMATION ABOUT ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTANTS AND SHOWS THE ACTUAL CANCER RISK TO THE COMMUNITY. A PRELIMINARY SCREENING, AND A MORE REFINED SCREENING WOULD BE REQUIRED, BUT A PRELIMINARY SCREENING SHOWS THAT THIS PROJECT DURING CONSTRUCTION OPERATION WOULD HAVE AN EXCESS CANCER RISK OF 21 IN 1 MILLION. NOW, MAYBE 21 PEOPLE DOES NOT SOUND LIKE A LOT, BUT THAT IS ACTUALLY TWICE, A LITTLE OVER TWICE THE, WHAT THE AIR DISTRICT CALLS ITS THRESHOLD OF SIGNIFICANCE. AND, THAT'S A SCREENING LEVEL HRA, AND INDICATE THAT A MORE REFINED LEVEL SHOULD BE PERFORMED, AND THEY TYPICALLY ARE PERFORMED IN A DRAFT EIR, PARTICULARLY, WHEN THEY RECOMMEND IT. >>> TWO, I WANT TO TALK VERY BRIEFLY, ABOUT BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. THIS SITE IS AN INTERESTING SITE BECAUSE IT HAS CONTAMINATION ON IT, IT IS HEAVILY CONTAMINATED IN PARTS, BUT ALSO, SINCE THE DOW CHEMICAL PLANT CLOSED, IT'S BECOME THE HOME OF OVER 60 SPECIES OF WILDLIFE. NOW, YOUR DRAFT EIR ONLY TALKS ABOUT 40, THERE'S ACTUALLY BEEN 60, AND AT LEAST 11 OF THEM ARE WHAT WE CALL SPECIAL STATUS, WHICH MEANS THEY ARE PROTECTED UNDER STATE OR FEDERAL LAW TO SOME DEGREE. MANY OF THOSE SPECIES, MOST OF THEM, IS THAT THEY HAVE A LOW TO MODERATE PROBABILITY OF OCCURRING. WE HAD A BIOLOGIST GO THREE TIMES TO THAT SITE AND THEY FOUND, ACTUALLY FOUND AND SAW SOME OF THESE SPECIES THAT ARE SAYING THESE ARE LOW TO MODERATE, INCLUDING JUST TWO WEEKS AGO, DUSTING PEREGRINE FALCONS, THEY WERE FORGING PEREGRINE FALCONS. SO, THESE ARE IMPACTS THAT NEED TO BE EXPLORED AND EXAMINED IN THE EIR. >>> THE LAST THING I WILL SAY ABOUT THAT IS, YOU KNOW, YOU HAVE A HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN, AND YOUR EIR REFERS TO IT A LOT, BUT MANY OF THESE SPECIES JUST AREN'T COVERED BY THAT HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN. IT DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE NOT IMPORTANT. >> [TIMER DINGS] >> THANK YOU, SO MUCH. I AM HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU. >> CHRIS LORENTZEN. >> GOOD EVENING, MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL. MY NAME IS CHRIS LORENTZEN. MY SISTER HAS AN MARGARET AND I CO-OWN LORENTZEN YACHT IN THE HARBOR LOCATED JUST NORTH OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT. OUR GRANDFATHER PURCHASED THE PROPERTY IN 1942. IT'S BEEN IN THE MARINA SINCE 1959. WE'VE BEEN IN BUSINESS NOW FOR 60 YEARS. WE FEEL THAT, I GREW UP IN ANTIOCH, WENT TO HIGH SCHOOL AND JUNIOR HIGH IN ANTIOCH, AND I'VE WATCHED ALL THE JOBS GO AWAY. I'VE WATCHED THE JOBS LEAVE DUPONT IN 1999, I'VE WATCHED JOBS ALONG THE CORRIDOR ON WILBUR AVE., CROWN ZELLERBACH, LOUISIANA-PACIFIC, ALL THE JOBS HAVE LEFT IT ALL THOSE PEOPLE NOW GO SOMEPLACE ELSE TO WORK AND THEY ARE ONE HIGHWAY 4 EVERY DAY. WOULDN'T IT BE NICE IF WE HAD JOBS THAT STAYED IN OAKLEY? THEY ARE PROPOSING OVER 1890 JOBS . WOULDN'T IT BE NICE IF SOME OF THOSE PEOPLE ACTUALLY STAYED IN OAKLEY AND WERE ABLE TO RECREATE IN OUR BUSINESS AND RECREATION, FISHING, AND THAT SORT OF THING. I AM ALL IN FAVOR OF HAVING JOBS STAY LOCAL. I'M IN FAVOR OF JOBS STAYING ALONG THE WATERFRONT, AND I THINK THIS IS A GREAT STARTING POINT FOR ANY NEW DEVELOPMENT ALONG THE WATERFRONT. THANK YOU, SO MUCH. >> PAIGE BENNY. >> GOOD EVENING, MY NAME IS PAIGE BENNY, AND I AM HERE ON BEHALF OF OF THE LABORERS INTERNATIONAL UNION OF NORTH AMERICA, LOCAL UNION NUMBER 324, ALSO KNOWN AS LIUNA, CONCERNING THE FINAL EIR FOR THE PROPOSED OAKLEY LOGISTICS CENTER PROJECT. AS STATED IN OUR WRITTEN COMMENTS, IT'S EVIDENT THAT THE FEIR CONTAINS NUMEROUS ERRORS AND OMISSIONS THAT PRECLUDE ACCURATE ANALYSIS OF THE PROJECT. THE FEIR FAILS AS A INFORMATIONAL DOCUMENT, AND FAILS TO IMPOSE ALL FEASIBLE MITIGATION MEASURES TO REDUCE THE PROJECT'S IMPACTS. WE THEREFORE, REQUEST THAT THE COUNCIL NOT CERTIFY THE EIR, AND INSTEAD, REQUIRE THE OAKLEY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT TO ADDRESS THE SHORTCOMINGS IN A NEW REVISED DRAFT EIR, AND RECIRCULATE THE DOCUMENT PRIOR TO CONSIDERING APPROVALS FOR THE PROJECT. SQL REQUIRES THE LEAD AGENCY TO EVALUATE COMMENTS ON THE DRAFT EIR AND PREPARE WRITTEN RESPONSES IN THE FINAL EIR. THE FEIR'S RESPONSES TO COMMENTS MUST BE DETAILED AND MUST PROVIDE A REASON TO GOOD-22:10:12 FAITH ANALYSIS. FAILURE TO PROVIDE SUCH A RESPONSE RENDERS THE EIR LEGALLY INADEQUATE. HERE, SEVERAL OF THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO OUR COMMENTS RAISED FOR THE DRAFT EIR OBJECTIVELY FAIL TO MEET THESE LEGAL STANDARDS. >>> FIRST, WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THE CITY'S RESPONSE TO OUR COMMENTS REGARDING VEHICLE COLLISION IMPACTS TO WILDLIFE IS ADEQUATE, BECAUSE THE CITY CLAIMS THAT THIS IS A STATEWIDE ISSUE, AND FAILS TO PROVIDE SUBSTANTIVE ANALYSIS TO DEMONSTRATE THAT THE IMPACT IS LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT. THE PROJECT PROPOSES TO ADD AN ADDITIONAL MINIMUM OF 4292 VEHICLE TRIPS PER DAY, WHICH OVER THE COURSE OF THE PROJECTS CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION WILL RESULT IN INCREASED WILDLIFE FATALITIES DUE TO THE FACT THAT VEHICLE COLLISIONS KILL WILDLIFE. THE CITY'S FAILURE TO PROVIDE A SUBSTANTIVE ANALYSIS TO DEMONSTRATE THAT THE IMPACT IS LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT RESULTS IN AN INADEQUATE RESPONSE FOR EXPERT COMMENTS. >>> THE SECOND, WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THE CITY'S RESPONSE TO OUR COMMENTS REGARDING THE PROJECTS TRAFFIC IMPACT IS ADEQUATE, BECAUSE THE CITY HAS NOT CONDUCTED A TRAFFIC GENERATION ANALYSIS THAT ANALYZES A MIX OF USES PERMITTED IN THE PROPOSED ZONE CHANGE. >>> LASTLY, THE CITY IMPROPERLY DEFERS MITIGATION FOR SIGNIFICANT GREENHOUSE GAS IMPACTS. A LEAD AGENCY MAY NOT CONCLUDE THAT AN IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT AND UNAVOIDABLE WITHOUT REQUIRING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ALL FEASIBLE MITIGATION MEASURES TO REDUCE THE IMPACTS OF A PROJECT TO LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT LEVELS. HERE, THE FEIR CONCLUDES THAT THE PROJECT'S GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS WILL BE A SIGNIFICANT UNAVOIDABLE IMPACT YET FAILS TO MAKE MITIGATION MEASURE 4.1 5C A REQUIREMENT. IN MITIGATION MEASURE 4.1 5C, THE FEIR CONTAINS A LIST OF MITIGATION MEASURES THAT MAY BE USED TO REDUCE THE IMPACTS OF GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS. YET, MITIGATION MEASURE 4.1 5C IS NOT REQUIRED TO BE IMPLEMENTED, BUT RATHER, WILL POTENTIALLY BE IMPLEMENTED LATER ON. BY FAILING TO IMPOSE FEASIBLE MITIGATION MEASURES THAT WOULD REDUCE THE PROJECTS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS IMPACTS, AND ALLOW FOR THE LATER IMPLEMENTATION OF MITIGATION MEASURE 4.1 5C, THE FEIR IMPROPERLY DEFERS MITIGATION FOR GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION IMPACTS. THE CITY MAY THEREFORE NOT APPROVE THE PROJECT UNTIL ALL FEASIBLE MITIGATION MEASURES ARE THE IMPLEMENTED THANK YOU. >> [TIMER DINGS] >> SEAN WRIGHT. >> MAYOR ROMICK, COUNCILMEMBERS, I JUST WANT TO SAY, I AM HERE ON BEHALF OF YOUR NEIGHBORING CITY, AS THE MAYOR OF ANTIOCH, TO SAY THANK YOU TO STAFF FOR ALL THE WORK THAT YOU GUYS HAVE DONE ON THIS PROJECT. THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE REGION. AND SO, TO BE ABLE TO CREATE 2000 JOBS IN OUR REGION, RIGHT NOW, THOSE 2000 JOBS ARE TRAVELING UPWARDS OVER AN HOUR ONE WAY, SOMETIMES AN HOUR AND A HALF. YOU TALK ABOUT CUTTING DOWN ON CARBON EMISSIONS BECAUSE OF THOSE TRAFFIC TRIPS, BEING ABLE TO STAY HERE LOCAL, IF BEYOND THAT. ITS THOSE 2000 FAMILIES THAT NOW HAVE PARENTS THAT GET TO LIVE AND WORK WHERE THEY LIVE, RIGHT? THEY GET TO PARTICIPATE NOW WITH THEIR SONS AND DAUGHTERS IN SPORTS, THEY GET TO BE PART OF THE COMMUNITY, THEY GET TO EAT AT OUR RESTAURANTS THAT STRUGGLE BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A LUNCH CROWD. IT'S ALL OF THAT IMPACT THAT DRIVES COMMUNITY, AND I'M SO HAPPY AND GRATEFUL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY THAT THIS PROJECT BRINGS, NOT JUST TO OAKLEY, BUT TO THE ENTIRE REGION. AND SO, ONE BEHALF OF THE CITY OF ANTIOCH, AND ON BEHALF OF MYSELF, I'M HERE TO SUPPORT, AND HOPE THAT YOU GUYS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE TO REALLY CREATE JOBS FOR, NOT JUST YOUR COMMUNITY, BUT OUR ENTIRE REGION. SO, THANK YOU, ALL. >> PAUL SEIGERT. >> GREETINGS MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL. MY NAME IS PAUL SEIGERT. I AM A DIRECTOR ON THE DIABLO WATER DISTRICT, AND I'M ALSO RUNNING FOR COUNTY SUPERVISOR. AS FAR AS THIS PROJECT IS CONCERNED, THIS IS NOT THE PROJECT THAT I ENVISIONED HAPPENING ON THE DUPONT PROPERTY. I WAS EXPECTING SOME SORT OF HIGH-PAYING MANUFACTURING-TYPE JOBS. THE WAREHOUSE JOBS ARE BEING TECHED OUT AS FAST AS MR. BEZOS CAN MAKE THAT HAPPEN. HOWEVER, IF YOU DO MOVE FORWARD WITH THIS, WHICH I'M GUESSING THAT WE WILL HEAR, ONE OF MY GOALS AS COUNTY SUPERVISOR IS TO HAVE RENEWABLE ENERGY IN CONTRA COSTA BY THE YEAR 2030. AND, YOU'VE GOT 2500, I'M SORRY, 2,500,000 FT. OF ROOFTOP THAT WOULD SUIT AND DO A GREAT JOB AT PROVIDING SOLAR FOR US. I ALSO AGREE WITH SOME OF THE OTHER COMMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN MADE EARLIER, AND, YEAH SO, I ACTUALLY WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST THAT YOU DO NOT MOVE FORWARD WITH APPROVING THE FINAL EIR. AND, THAT MAYBE YOU COULD CONSIDER BRINGING IN A PLANNING COMMISSION AND HAVING FURTHER DISCUSSIONS AND HAVING A BROADER CONVERSATION. BUT, I DO UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS ON THE PLATE NOW, AND IT WILL PROBABLY BE MOVING FORWARD, AND I WOULD LOVE TO WORK WITH YOU AS A SUPERVISOR TO GET SOLAR PANELS ON THERE, AND TO LOWER EMISSIONS AS POSSIBLE, AS LOW AS POSSIBLE, AND IT WOULD BE GREAT TO SEE YOU GUYS SEE YOU TAKE SOME VERY BOLD ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIONS THAT I DID NOT SEE AS OPTIONS, MITIGATIONS FOR THE PROJECT. THANK YOU, VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU, MR. WRIGHT. [INAUDIBLE/OFF MIC] >> THANK YOU, MAYOR AND COUNCILMEMBERS. THIS HAS SUPPOSEDLY BEEN IN THE PIPELINE FOR A WHILE. I MANAGED TO HEAR NOTHING ABOUT THE PREVIOUS HEARING THAT WAS NOT WITHSTANDING. THERE IS MANY THE NEGATIVE ISSUES TO THIS, THINK OF THE NOISE, POLLUTION, ALL THE DIESEL TRUCKS IN AND OUT, YOU CAN CALL IT A LOGISTICS CENTER, A FULFILLMENT CENTER, WHATEVER FANCY NAME YOU WANT TO DRESS IT UP, IT'S STILL A WAREHOUSE PROPERTY. THERE'S GOING TO BE HEAVY TRUCKS COMING OUT POSSIBLY 24 HOURS A DAY DEPENDING ON HOW THEY STRUCTURE IT, SITTING AND IDLING WHILE THEY'RE LOADING, POLLUTING THE AIR, CREATING NOISE. WHAT ABOUT THE DAMAGE AND NEGATIVE IMPACT THAT HEAVY TRUCKS DUE TO THE ROADWAYS AROUND HERE? THERE WILL BE INCREASED TRAFFIC ACROSS THAT BRIDGE WHICH BARELY HANDLES IT AS IT IS BEING ONLY TWO LANES. THERE ARE NEARBY RESIDENCES AT SANDY POINT, AND JUST BECAUSE SOMEBODY IS POOR ENOUGH TO NEED TO LIVE IN A TRAILER PARK DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY SHOULD BE HAVE THEIR HEALTH IMPACTED OR DAMAGED. I BELIEVE A BETTER USE FOR THE PROPERTY WOULD BE A REALLY LIGHT INDUSTRIAL OR AN OFFICE PARK. THIS IS BECOMING A TOWN OF GAS STATIONS AND STORAGE UNITS, LET'S NOT ADD WAREHOUSES. I MEAN, AS AN EXAMPLE, UPS HAS A DISTRIBUTION CENTER ABOUT 45 MINUTES DOWN THE ROAD AND IT'S ON A MOUNTAIN HOUSE AND IT IS WAY IN THE MIDDLE OF NOWHERE WHERE IT IMPACTS NO ONE. AND SO, THAT WOULD BE THE PRIMARY OBJECTION WHERE THERE IS SURROUNDING RESIDENTIAL AND IT IS JUST, I DON'T THINK IT IS A GOOD USE AND YOUR OWN MISSION STATEMENT SAYS THAT YOUR GOAL IS TO BUILD AN ENHANCE QUALITY COMMUNITY AND I DON'T THINK THAT PROJECT FOLLOWS YOUR MISSION STATEMENT AND I URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER AND DO SOMETHING ELSE WITH THE PROPERTY. THANK YOU. >> GOOD EVENING. I AM HAPPY THAT COUNCILMEMBER ALAURA ATTENDED THIS IS PERCEIVED AMONG SOME AS A RUSH TO CONSTRUCTION I'M NOT HEARING WHY AM HEARING DATES OF 2003 AND 2008. I DON'T THINK THAT WE HAVE TO HAVE THE READING RIGHT NOW I THINK OF YET ANOTHER READING IN JANUARY THAT WOULD BE RESPONSIBLE. WE HEARD ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT AND WE HEARD ABOUT WHAT'S INVOLVED THE CANCER RISK AND ENVIRONMENTAL ENDANGERED SPECIES AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ON THE COMMUNITY AND THE NEIGHBORS AND I DON'T SEE OBJECTIONS TO THE CITY OF ANTIOCH ADEQUATELY ANSWERING THE TRAFFIC AND WAS IT SOMETHING THAT SUCCEEDED NEARBY AND I DON'T KNOW IF THE TRUCKS ARE GOING TO LEVITATE OVER INTO THE FREEWAY BUT HOPEFULLY, THEY'RE GOING TO GET THERE BUT IF YOU HAVE THE TRUCKS OVER IN THE INTERSECTIONS AND HOPEFULLY THEY'RE GOING TO GET THERE BUT AS A DEVELOPER THE ONE QUESTION I HAD WAS IS THERE A TENANT AND IF THERE IS A TENANT THEN I THINK THE COMMUNITY HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW WHO THAT TENANT IS AND COMMENT ON WHO THAT DEVELOPER IS BEFORE THEY VOTE AND I HEARD THE DEVELOPER WAS IN KANSAS CITY I HAD A HARD TIME WITH ANY HEADQUARTERS AND THAT WAS MY CONSIDERATION SO MY SUGGESTION IS GO THROUGH STAFF AND LISTEN TO THE EXPERTS THAT ARE THERE AND REEVALUATE THIS AND BRING IT BACK AGAIN TO THE COUNCIL PEOPLE RATHER THAN HAVING FOR THE FIRST THREE. >>[INAUDIBLE] >>COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM STAFF? >>CAN WE DIRECT OUR ANSWERS TO HAVE A PAGE THAT THAT'S ON? >>YES, IT IS ON THE PAGE IT IS IN RESPONSE TO THE DRAFT ITSELF. THE EIR ITSELF HAS A WHOLE DRAFT THEOLOGY THAT WAS PREPARED. >> I DON'T HAVE A SPECIFIC PAGE THAT I CAN LOOK AT? BECAUSE >>IF YOU CAN HOLD ON JUST ONE SECOND. >>YEP. >>SO, IN THE FINAL EIR DOCUMENT, WHICH WAS ATTACHMENT 4 TO THE STAFF REPORT WHICH IS AND PAGES TWO 18 TO 21. AND, IF YOU LIKE TO, WE ALSO HAVE DIANE MOORE, WHO IS THE BIOLOGIST WHO ASSISTED IN THE PREPARATION OF THAT CHAPTER. SHE CAN ALSO ADDRESS, YOU KNOW, ANY SPECIFIC QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE. YOU KNOW, THE SITE IS AS COMPLEX AS YOU'VE HEARD. PART OF THE SITE IS LOCATED WITHIN THE HABITAT CONSERVATION AREA AND PART OF IT IS NOT, AND THE RESEARCH AGENCY IS ALL SIGNATORY TO THE CONVERSATION PLAN AND THEY HAVE ALL SEEN THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT IN ITS DRAFT FORM AND WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY COMMENT FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL AGENCY. >>WELL, ARE YOU SATISFIED WITH THAT? >>WELL, I THINK TO EXPAND ON THAT QUESTION, WOULD WE BE ABLE TO GET MAYBE THE BUYER LOGISTICS TO EXPAND AND CLARIFY WHAT IT IS THEY FOUND WITH THAT AND ALL THE OTHER BIOLOGICAL SUGGESTIONS? >>I'M SURE THAT MRS. REESE CAN DO THAT. >>THANK YOU. >>I BELIEVE THE SPECIES WAS 4960 AS WAS INDICATED BY THE SPEAKER. >>I'M DIANE MOORE WITH MORE BIOLOGICAL CONSULTANTS, AND I HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH IN PROJECTS WITHIN HCP NOT JUST IN ANTIOCH BUT IN OTHER TOWNS I'VE PROBABLY DONE ABOUT 75 ESR'S AND I'M THIS PROJECT IS NOT THAT UNUSUAL WITHIN THE HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN AND AS YOU KNOW THE HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN HAS ABOUT 28 DIFFERENT SPECIES AND AS YOU KNOW THOSE SPECIES WERE A LARGE PART OF THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN AS FAR AS THE SPECIAL SPECIES THAT POTENTIALLY WILL OCCUR WITH THOSE HABITATS PRESENT. IN ADDITION TO THOSE SPECIES, THE HDP DOES HAVE SOME COMPLIANCE DIVISIONS FOR BIRD LIKE THE BIRD TREATY ACT OR THE STATE GAME CODE THAT PROTECTS BIRDS THAT ARE NESTING. AND SO, THERE IS A LOT OF DISCUSSION FOR THE NUMBER OF SPECIES WITHIN THE COMMENT LETTERS. IDR. SMALLWOOD HE IS, YOU KNOW, HE IS AN INCREDIBLE BIOLOGIST. OBVIOUSLY, HE IS A NOTABLE BIRD PHOTOGRAPHER AND I WOULD LOVE TO GO BIRDING WITH HIM SOMEDAY. THE INTERESTING THING ABOUT THIS PROJECT IS WE DO HAVE 25 ACRES ARE OUTSIDE OF THE HCP. WHEN WE DID FIRST EVALUATE THIS PROJECT THE CONSERVANCY'S AND THE AGENCIES AND THE US FISH AND GAME CONSERVATION WILDLIFE, EVEN FOR THIS LITTLE AREA OUTSIDE OF THE HCP AS LONG AS THE HABITAT TYPES WERE SIMILAR TO THOSE OUTSIDE OF THE HCP AND SO WE SAID YES WE HAVE A LITTLE PROJECT BEFORE IT WORKED WELL SO ULTIMATELY LET'S DO THAT. AND, THE 24 ACRES WHICH IS THE MINORITY OF THE PROJECT SITE WAS ALSO ALL BUILDING FOUNDATIONS AND JUST GRASSLANDS AND HABITAT TYPES COMPLETELY CONSISTENT WITH THOSE THAT WERE IN THE HCP AND WE HAD TO DEVELOP A [INAUDIBLE] AND THAT REQUIRED A SMALL EXTENSION OUTFALL IN THE DELTA AND AT THAT POINT WE REALIZE WE HAD TO ADDRESS THIS AREA OUTSIDE OF THE HCP WITH A STANDARD CEQA PROCESS AND WE HAD TO GET THE U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE THE NATIONAL RESEARCH WILDLIFE SERVICES IN THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS TO BUILD THIS THIS WILL GO THROUGH EXTENSIVE AND FURTHER PROGRAMMING AND, YOU KNOW, CONDITIONING BASED ON THOSE PERMITS. YOU KNOW, THE DELTA IS, YOU KNOW, SUPPORTS A LARGE NUMBERS SPECIES, AND I UNDERSTAND THAT MOST OF THE 60 SPECIES THAT ARE LISTED BY DR. SMALLWOOD ARE THE MIGRATORY BIRDS ARE ACTUALLY COVERED BY THE HCP. AND, THERE IS GOING TO BE A LOT OF CARE TAKEN WITH RESPECT TO BIRDS. I LOVE BIRDS. AND, WE ARE CUTTING TREES DOWN IN THE WINTER, THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO DO AND THERE WILL BE SPECIAL TREES PLANTED ON THE SITE AND [INAUDIBLE] AND I SAW THEM MYSELF AND DAYS WILL REQUIRE SPECIAL EDUCATION [INAUDIBLE] AND WHEN I LOOK AT THINGS, YES, A LOT OF BIRDS COULD OCCUR ON THE FRINGE OF THE SITE RIGHT WHERE IT KISSES THE DELTA, BUT THAT'S A SMALL PORTION OF THE SITE AND THE CONSTRUCTION WILL BE DONE AT A TIME SENSITIVE, YOU KNOW, TIME OF YEAR AND I JUST THINK THIS HAS BEEN FABULOUS PROJECT TO WORK ON AND THAT WE HAVE WORKED WITH FABULOUS AGENCY IS IN THE PROCESS OF WORKING ON IT. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >>THANK YOU. >>WHILE YOU ARE THERE, IT SEEMS THERE COULD BE POSSIBLY A LOT OF ANIMALS GETTING RUN OVER BY VEHICLES? >>WELL, ACTUALLY, IT WAS INTERESTING. I HAVE NEVER ADDRESSED IN RESPONSE TO COMMENTS WITH WILDLIFE COLLISIONS AND WHEN I SAW THAT I THOUGHT, OKAY, I'M NOT EVEN QUITE SURE WHERE TO START ON THIS AND THE CEQA CONSULTANTS HAD THAT SAME COMMENT BEFORE. BUT, I THOUGHT IT WAS INTERESTING THAT THE ANTIOCH MAYOR POINTED OUT THAT LOCAL PEOPLE NOW ARE ALL GETTING IN THEIR TRUCKS AND DRIVING ELSEWHERE AND KILLING WILDLIFE DAILY TO GET WHERE THEY'RE GOING. YOU KNOW SO, THAT CAN EITHER KEEP GOING OR WE CAN BUILD THE PROJECT, AND I SEE IT AS A WASH, AND MAYBE WE SHOULD HAVE INCLUDED THAT IN RESPONSE TO COMMENTS BUT MAYBE WE SHOULD NOT HAVE INCLUDED THAT UNTIL THE MAYOR SPOKE BUT I APPRECIATE THAT THOUGHT. BUT, IT IS KIND OF A SPECULATIVE COMMENT. I MEAN, TRAFFIC IMPACTS HAPPEN EVERYWHERE, AND UNLESS THERE IS SOME NOTABLE WILDLIFE MOVEMENT CORRIDOR AND REALLY CLOSE PROXIMITY TO THIS SITE IN WHICH THERE IS A LOT OF KNOWN ISSUES WITH WILDLIFE AND TRAFFIC, I KIND OF SEE THIS IS A COMPLETELY NON-ISSUE. >>ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU. >>MR. POPE, QUESTIONS? >>THANK YOU. I JUST HOPE THAT THE APPLICANT COULD ANSWER SOME OF THESE QUESTIONS IN THE COMMENTS I LIKE TO START WITH THE ROOFTOP SOLAR COMMENT. YOU GUYS HAVE GOT A LOT OF SOLAR ROOF UP THERE AND IN CONJUNCTION WITH CALIFORNIA PG&E AND THE LOCAL MCE ENERGY PROVIDER. COMMON >>I'M GLAD THAT YOU ASKED THAT I HAD A CONVERSATION MY CONVERSATION YESTERDAY THERE WERE ACTIVELY ENGAGING IN THE FIRM THAT GTSC BROUGHT UP THIS EARLIER. THE SOLAR HAS NOT WORKED IN MANY OF THE STATES WE TRIED IN AND MOSTLY BECAUSE THE SUNSHINE BUT YOU DO HAVE A LOT OF THAT OUT HERE SO WE HAVE LOOKED AT THAT AND WE DO THINK IT'S AN OPTION AND WE WILL DO OUR BEST TO MAKE IT PART OF THE PROJECT. WE NEED TO HAVE FURTHER STUDY AND WE NEED TO FIND A PROVIDER OR A CONTRACTOR OR SOMEONE THAT IS AN EXPERT IN THAT IN ORDER TO MAKE IT PART OF THE PROJECT, BUT, WE WILL LOOK INTO THAT, FOR SURE. >>IF YOU HAVEN'T YET, MCE IS LOOKING FOR LOCAL SOLAR PROJECTS TO INVEST IN AND I'M SURE THEY WOULD BE HAPPY TO EXPLORE THE PROJECTS FOR ONE YEAR AND WE WOULD BE HAPPY TO HOUSE IT. >>ABSOLUTELY. >> I'M NOT SURE THESE QUESTIONS ARE DIRECTED AT YOU SO YOU CAN GO AHEAD AND SIT DOWN. THE COMMENTS ABOUT TRUCKS IDLING IN CALIFORNIA THEY CANNOT SIT IN IDLE, THEY HAVE TO BE SHUT OFF. I THINK THAT WAS EXPLORED IN THE REPORT AS WELL. >>>WE HAD TO PUBLIC COMMENTS ABOUT NOT MEETING TIMELINES, THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OPINION IS THAT WE'VE MET THE TIMELINES? >>YES, COUNCILMEMBER POPE. NOT ONLY HAVE WE MET THE TIMELINES BUT WE WENT ABOVE AND BEYOND MEETING THE TIMELINES. >>OKAY, THANK YOU. >>THIS ISN'T COMMUNIST CHINA I DON'T MEAN TO BE FLIPPANT BUT WE DON'T OWN THE PROPERTY AND THE CITY DOESN'T OWN THE PROJECT AND FOR WHAT IS THIS IS A LAWFUL PROJECT AND I WOULDN'T WANT GOVERNMENT TO INTERFERE IN ANY PRIVATE BUSINESS ANY MORE THAN IT ALREADY DOES. AND SO, WE DON'T TELL PEOPLE WHAT THEY CAN AND CANNOT BUILD UNLESS IT FITS UNDER THE CONSTRAINTS OF THE LAW. >>>I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS OF OUR NEIGHBORING MAYOR IN SUPPORT OF THE PROJECT AND THIS IS POTENTIALLY BENEFICIAL, I AGREE. I SPENT A LOT OF TIME READING THE REPORTS. I SPENT A LOT OF TIME READING THE LETTERS IN RESPONSE TO THE REPORTS. I SPENT A LOT OF TIME READING THE RESPONSES TO THE RESPONSES TO THE LETTERS OF THE REPORTS, I'M SATISFIED THAT THIS IS A THOROUGH REPORT. I SIT ON THE HABITAT CONSERVANCY BOARD. THIS IS CALIFORNIA. WE HAVE SOME OF THE MOST STRINGENT WILDLIFE PROTECTION LAWS IN THE WORLD, AND, ALL THE HABITAT AGENCIES, ALL OF THEM, NONE OF THEM ARE OPPOSED TO THIS. I THINK WE'VE GONE ABOVE AND BEYOND. I THINK THAT'S ALL THE NOTES I HAVE. >>MAYOR ALAURA. >> THANK YOU. I APPRECIATE THE ANSWERS FOR ALL THE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ANIMALS. I DO HAVE SOME FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS ABOUT THE POINTS THAT WERE RAISED ABOUT AIR QUALITY AND TRAFFIC. COULD YOU, I GUESS, EXPAND ON THE AIR-TRAFFIC QUALITY REQUIREMENTS AND, I GUESS, THE HOOPS, AND THE LEGAL TEST THAT THIS PROJECT HAD TO GO THROUGH IN ORDER TO GET WHERE IT IS TODAY? >>YOU KNOW, I COULD GIVE A BRIEF OVERVIEW, BUT I WOULD BE MORE BENEFICIAL TO BRING UP ROD SIMPSON AND HE CAN GIVE YOU A BETTER ANALYSIS OF WHAT THE [INAUDIBLE] AND THE OUTCOME IS. >>THANK YOU. >>GOOD EVENING MAYOR AND COUNCILMEMBERS, ROB STENCIL WITH PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT. I THINK, TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, YOU ARE JUST ASKING GENERALLY WHAT THE PROCEDURE WAS FOR AIR-QUALITY ANALYSIS IN THE AIR? >>AND ABOVE THE STANDARDS WHAT THIS PROJECT LOOKS LIKE COMPARED WHAT WAS REQUIRED. >>RIGHT COLOR FOR THE DISTRICT ARE REQUIRES METHODOLOGY FOR WHAT IT IS FOR THE AMOUNT OF A PROJECT AND SO WE RAN THE AIR-QUALITY MODELING FOR CONSTRUCTION AND PREPARATION WE CAME UP WITH THE EMISSIONS ESTIMATES AND WE IDENTIFIED POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS THE REQUIRED MITIGATION THAT BROUGHT THOSE DOWN TO A SIGNIFICANTLY BETTER LEVEL AND IN TERMS OF THAT AIR RECONSTRUCTION THAT IS ALL AFFORDABLE WHAT WE HAVE ALL THE FEASIBLE MITIGATION MEASURES BUT WE JUST HAVE TO BRING IT DOWN DURING THE CONSTRUCTION PHASE. ALL OTHERS ARE LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT. THAT IS THE AIR-QUALITY SIDE OF THE EMISSIONS IS ALSO THE GREENHOUSE GAS REQUIREMENTS. AND SO, WE ALSO MODELED FOR GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS AND PROVIDED THOSE ESTIMATED EMISSION LEVELS AND COMPARED THOSE TO THE AIR DISTRICTS AS THEY WERE APPLIED AND THE SIGNIFICANT AND UNAVOIDABLE GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS FOR THE PROJECT FOR THE 28/30 LEVEL. FOR THE MITIGATION MEASURES WE CAN LOOK AT THE SIGNIFICANT UNAVOIDABLE IMPACTS FOR GREENHOUSE GASES BUT THERE IS A MITIGATION MEASURE IN THERE ALREADY FOR THAT. >>>AND THEN, THE THIRD AREA THAT WAS BROUGHT UP HERE TONIGHT WAS A HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT, AND THAT IS RELATED TO TOXIC AIR CONTAMINANTS, MOST NOTABLY DIESEL AND PARTICULATE MATTER AND THOSE [INAUDIBLE] THE STATE PRODUCES METHODOLOGY FOR THOSE TYPES OF ANALYSIS BUT ALSO, THEY PROVIDE GUIDANCE FOR WHEN YOU NEED TO DO THAT LEVEL OF ANALYSIS. AND SO, IT IS NOT THAT THE EIR DID AN ANALYSIS ON HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENTS AT ALL BUT WE ALSO DID AN ANALYSIS ON WHETHER OR NOT IT WAS EVEN WARRANTED. AND SO, THERE IS FURTHER DISCUSSION YOU ARE WHY THAT IS WHEN THERE'S NOT A FULL ERA WARRANTED. >>THANK YOU. THE NEXT CLOSEST RESIDENTIAL TO THIS IS HOW FAR WAY? >>IT WOULD BE THE MOBILE HOME PARK, AND THAT WAS WITHIN 1000 FEET. >>OKAY. AND, THEY WERE, IT'S NOT EVEN WITHIN THE REQUIREMENTS OF HAVING TO BE NOTICED, CORRECT? >>NO, THEY WERE NOT NOTICED. >>THE REQUIREMENT TO BE NOTICED IS USUALLY 300 BUT WE HAVE A 500 FOOT STANDARD. SO, I WILL LOOK AT THAT. I, I APPRECIATE ALL OF THE SPEAKERS TONIGHT AND THE INFORMATION. IT WAS A VERY THOROUGH REPORT, DRAFT, FINAL, THE QUESTIONS THAT CAME IN, THE POINTS THAT WERE BROUGHT UP IN THE, I GUESS WE CALL THEM REBUTTALS AND THE ANSWERS OF WHAT WAS BROUGHT UP TONIGHT. I DO FEEL THAT THE RESEARCH HAS BEEN DONE AND DUE DILIGENCE HEADS TO DO DILIGENCE HAS BEEN MADE AND REACHED AND IF THE PROJECT MOVES FORWARD TONIGHT AND IF, NO DOUBT, THERE WILL BE EYES AND EARS WATCHING TO MAKE SURE THAT THE STANDARDS THAT AFFECT OUR ENVIRONMENT OR INFECTED AIR TRAFFIC THAT INFECT THE ENVIRONMENT, OR OUR WILDLIFE AND I WILL BE THE FOLLOWING MITIGATIONS THAT ARE RECOMMENDED WOULD BE PUT IN PLACE. AND, AS THIS PROJECT WOULD AFFECT US ECONOMICALLY AS A CITY AND AS A REGION, I HAVE NO DOUBT THERE WOULD ONLY BE A POSITIVE FOR A COMMUNITY. THERE IS SO MANY PEOPLE, AS YOU KNOW HAVE COME INTO THIS AREA AND THEY CRY FOR JOBS AND THIS IS ONE OF THOSE, I GUESS, BLESSINGS AND IT DEPENDS IDEAS ON WHAT PEOPLE WANT THEY WANT TO DO A REVERSE COMMUTE OR NO COMMUTE IN THE DIFFERENTLY AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT. TO CLEAR THROUGH A SOMEWHAT AS SILLY AS [INAUDIBLE] TO BE ABLE TO GET LIVING WORKING WAGE JOBS HERE IN THIS AREA. SO, I FEEL LIKE THE RESEARCH IS DONE AND I FEEL LIKE THIS IS A PLUS TO OUR COMMUNITY, AND, I'M HOPING THAT THE OTHERS WILL AGREE BUT I FEEL LIKE IT'S SOMETHING I SHOULD SUPPORT. >>MR. CREDE. >>ON OF THE CONCERNS THAT I'VE HEARD TONIGHT WHICH I FELT WAS PRETTY SIGNIFICANT WAS THAT SOME FOLKS HAVE A CONCERN THAT THIS WAS A RUSHED DECISION AND I WOULD JUST SAY FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. WE HAVE A LOT OF A THOUGHT PROCESS ON HOW THE DECISIONS ARE MADE IS A LONG THOUGHTFUL PROCESS AND I LIKE TO HEAR FROM BACK IN THE DAYS WHEN THE PLANT WAS RUNNING AND SINCE IT HAS SHUT DOWN I THINK EVERYBODY WHO HAS BEEN HERE FOR AND NOT VERY LONG REALIZE THAT THIS IS THE EVENTUAL OUTCOME THAT WILL HELP ME LOOK INTO THE CITY, I DON'T WANT THAT RETURNING TO MARSHLAND ON THAT STUFF ARE RUNNING INTO THE DELTA. PUTTING HUGE SLABS THERE AND PAINTING IT IS THE BEST SOLUTION FOR THIS LAND. AND, WE'VE GONE THROUGH A VERY LONG AND CAREFUL AND THOUGHTFUL PROCESS IN MY MIND. I READ THIS DOCUMENT IN STREAM DETAIL ANDI THINK IT WAS A WELL THOUGHT DECISION AND I JUST WANT MAKE SURE THAT WE MAKE ALL THE RIGHT MOVES TO MAKE SURE WE'RE DOING THIS IN A THOUGHTFUL AND A CONTROLLED WAY AND I HAVE NO RESERVATIONS ABOUT MOVING FORWARD WITH IT. >>AND, TO FOLLOW UP ON WHAT [INAUDIBLE] SAID, THIS WASN'T A QUICK BEDTIME READ. THIS WAS, WHAT, ALMOST 500 PAGES FROM JUST THE BEGINNING TO THE END. AND SO, THE FACT THAT THAT WAS A READ WOULD PUT YOU TO SLEEP PRETTY QUICKLY. BUT, IT WAS A READ THAT WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH BEFORE FOR 20 YEARS WE LOOKED AT THE DUVAL PROPERTY FOR [INAUDIBLE] WE WORKED WITH THE PONTE TWO PROJECTS WITH THE PINE AND WE WORKED WITH MORRIS. WE HAVE BEEN WITH A NUMBER OF LANDOWNERS ON OUR ORGANIZATION PREVIOUS DEVELOPERS IN THE PASSWORD ARE CLOSE AND WE WERE NOT THIS FAR A LONG, BUT WE WERE REALLY CLOSE TO THAT PROJECT FELL THROUGH. SO THAT ONE HAS FELT THE DIFFICULTY OF WORKING WITH IN THE STATE AND ALL OF THE [INAUDIBLE] TO REDEVELOP THIS PROPERTY. IT'S BEEN BROUGHT UP A NUMBER OF TIMES AS FAR AS THE JOB DEVELOPMENT AND IT'S NOT JUST THIS AREA IT IS A FEW GROCERY STORES IN THE CITY WILL COME UP WITH THIS BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS, IS THERE IS NO LONG-TERM GOOD JOBS IN THE CITY OF OAKLEY. AND SO, MAKING THIS STEP AND PROVIDING IT, AS MAYOR WRIGHT BROUGHT UP, HE SAYS THE FAMILY THAT I CAN EQUATE WHEN I SMELL IT WHEN THEY KEEP THOSE JOBS AND THE PEOPLE KEPT THOSE LOCAL JOBS THAT NOW THIS IS ALL GONE WITH THE EVOLUTION OF OUR ECONOMY. AND SO, NOW WE ARE HOPING TO GET BACK INSIDE AND BRING THAT BACK UP HERE, AND THIS IS JUST THE STARTING POINT. THE REDEVELOPMENT IS THE ENTIRE CORRIDOR IF YOU LOOK ALONG THAT GATEWAY OR THAT ROADWAY AND HE'S JUST BASICALLY STORING CARS THERE RIGHT NOW THAT'S BASICALLY WHAT HE IS DOING RIGHT NOW, AND YOU CAN SEE THE FOUNDATION FOR THOSE EMPTY BUILDINGS THAT ARE IN THE CORNER AND WE ARE A MAJOR JOB SITE THAT WE CAN KEEP FAMILIES HOME AND KEEP FAMILY SPENDING MORE TIME WITH EACH OTHER. THIS I

Minutes of the Special Oakley City Council Meeting held December 17, 2019 1) Call to Order and Roll Call 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council Mayor Kevin Romick called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. in the Oakley City Council Chambers. In addition to Mayor Romick, Vice Mayor Sue Higgins and Councilmembers Randy Pope, Michael Krieg and Claire Alaura were present. 2) Pledge of Allegiance 2.1 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Mayor Kevin Romick) Mayor Romick led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. 3) Public Comment Dan Torres, on behalf of Sprinkler Fitters Local 483, shared that his union workers handle fire sprinklers and he understands that not everyone may know how to get into trades. He shared that applications for fire sprinkler fitting apprenticeships will open in January. He commented it is not easy work, but if anyone is interested in a good career, to please contact their union. 4) Consent Calendar None. 5) Public Hearing 5.1 Oakley Logistics Center - An application requesting 1) Certification of the Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations; 2) Adoption of the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and approval of 3) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 04- 18) to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan; 4) a Rezone (RZ 08-18) to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 5) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 05-18) to create eight parcels within the 375.7-acre subject property; 6) Design Review (DR 12-18), including the Final Development Plan, for the project’s design, including site plans, architectural elevations, conceptual landscape plans, and other physical development; and 7) Development Agreement (DA 01-18) for the proposed development between the City of Oakley and the project applicant. The project site is located at 6000 Bridgehead Road (APN’s: 037-020-008, -009, -010, and -014 through -022) (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director)

Community Development Director Joshua McMurray presented the staff report. He addressed three letters the City received today: 1) East Bay Regional Park District would like a trail from Big Break to the Oakley/Antioch Pier; staff has connected with the District and agreed to meet and discuss the matter further early next year; 2) Lozeau Drury submitted a letter including issues previously raised and previously responded to; there are no new issues or evidence; and 3) Adams Broadwell submitted a letter including issues that have already been addressed with responses to comments; there are no issues provided that were not already analyzed in the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR). Councilmember Alaura thanked Mr. McMurray for the information and for addressing the letters received today. She commented that she received inquiries why a special meeting was necessary and she asked Mr. McMurray to prepare an explanation why the special meeting is needed. She read his comments which included that the DEIR required a 45-day review period which was provided October 16-December 3, CEQA requires staff to respond to those comments and respond to public agencies 10 days prior to certifying the EIR, staff had no choice but to call a special meeting before the year end to have proper time to respond to comments in accordance with CEQA, staff has complied with all noticing requirements for CEQA and the public hearing, and the applicant requested the item be heard before 2020 which the City accommodated with its streamlined application process. She commented that it was a big request from the applicant that it be approved before 2020, but she feels that the City has moved quickly, but cautiously, and the City doesn’t just move things out the door because an applicant has requested it. Applicant Jed Momot, Chief Strategy Officer with NorthPoint Development, was joined by Brent Miles, Chief Marketing Officer, and Andrew Griesemer, Development Manager, both also with NorthPoint Development. Mr. Momot shared that NorthPoint was founded in 2012 with its focus on industrial real estate, it is probably the most active privately held developer in the country, working with known companies such as GM, Chewy.com, Amazon, Lowe's, and Home Depot, among others. He mentioned its project managers are engineers by trade. He commented that NorthPoint mapped a grid matrix for labor and transportation; the largest factor for a community is labor and the second largest factor is logistics, and Oakley stands out for both. He shared that the project was submitted a year ago today, the property came under contract in September 2018, the project has had layers of complexity, but they are excited to take on the brownfield project. He mentioned the Notice of Scoping was issued in February 2019, followed by a 30-day period, and the DEIR was issued in October 2019 with a comment period ending December 3. He provided images of the site and a map of the environmental remediation. He explained the use must be industrial; it cannot be residential. He also explained that when they put the property under contract, they worked with Chemours to accelerate clean up by 1 year, funding of which they provided $1mil, and remediation will happen in two phases; Phase 1 was completed last fall and Phase 2 will occur next year. He shared that they have other industrial properties across the country which they have remediated to provide new industry. He also shared that they plan to start active construction in January for buildings 1 and 2, if approved tonight. He mentioned building 1 will have a tenant and he is certain they would attract a tenant for building 2, then they would work to seek leases for buildings 3, 4 and 5 which they anticipate the build out to be in the next 5 years, if the economy remains steady. He shared that NorthPoint is making a $185 mil capital investment in the project which does not include tenant contributions and improvements, and their study shows that this project would provide $350k to the City’s General Fund, $400k to fire, create $475 mil in economic activity, provide 725 construction jobs, 1890 site jobs, 490 indirect jobs and 470 induced jobs of which the community would benefit $190 mil annually from the project. He mentioned the building will be

Class A industrial and customizable. He thanked the City Council and staff for being top notch to work with. Online Comments Liz Elias commented the City is in violation of the requisite number of days in which to hold hearings and accept public input per CEQA and it is unacceptable to ramrod a project through without proper input and consideration. She requested the City follow the laws. Betty Sisco commented that she opposes the project for many reasons, but particularly because the City has not allowed the proper amount of time for public hearings. She requested the project not be allowed to go forward at this time. Email Comments Paige Fennie with Lozeau Drury, LLP submitted comments on the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR), available for review in the City Clerk’s Office. Sara Dudley with Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo submitted comments on the FEIR, available for review in the City Clerk’s Office. Sean Dougan with the East Bayy Regional Park District submitted comments on the DEIR regarding future trail access from the Big Break Regional Trail to the Oakley/Antioch Pier Trail. Public Comments Sara Dudley, on behalf of the Oakley Residents for Responsible Development, expressed concern that members who work on the project will have exposure to health and safety impacts. She commented that comments, reports and letters were reviewed and they have determined that substantial evidence provides that there are unexplored impacts that were not raised in the DEIR and were not resolved in the FEIR. She requested the DEIR be recirculated to properly address the impacts. She expressed concern regarding air quality in relation to risk of cancer (health risk analysis) and contamination of biological resources including over 60 wildlife species, 11 of which are special status. She commented that the impacts need to be examined. She mentioned many of the species are not covered by the Habitat Conservation Plan. Chris Lauritzen commented that he and his sister co-own Lauritzen Yacht Harbor which has been in business for 60 years, north of the project. He shared he has watched jobs leave (i.e., DuPont, Crown Zellerbach, Louisana Pacific) and it would be nice to have jobs in Oakley and recreation in their business (i.e., fishing). He commented he is in favor of local jobs and industry along the waterfront. Paige Fennie, on behalf of Laborers International Union of North America Local Union 324, commented that there are numerous errors and omissions in the FEIR that preclude an accurate analysis of the project. She mentioned the FEIR fails as an informational document and fails to address mitigation measure to reduce project impacts. She requested the City Council not certify the EIR, but rather have the document recirculated. She indicated the responses to comments fail to meet legal standards in FEIR. She expressed concern that the EIR fails to properly address the vehicle collision impact to wildlife, traffic impacts, and greenhouse gas impacts (the document refers to mitigation measures that “may” be used).

Sean Wright, Mayor of Antioch, thanked staff for its work on the project. He commented that this is an opportunity for the region; it should bring approximately 2,000 jobs to the area, expand use of community resources (i.e., restaurants), and improve quality of life for residents who could be employed locally and not have to commute. He shared that he is grateful for the opportunities this project may provide and on behalf of the City of Antioch and himself, he supports this project for the region. Paul Seger shared he is a Director for Diablo Water District and he is running for County Supervisor. He commented that the project is not what he envisioned on the DuPont property; he was expecting high-paying manufacturing jobs rather than warehouse jobs, but if the project moves forward, his goal for when he becomes Supervisor is to have renewable energy in Contra Costa by 2030, and this 2.5 million square feet of rooftop would provide a great opportunity for solar. He requested the City Council not approve the FEIR and consider bringing in a Planning Commission to review and having broader conversation. He mentioned he understands if it will be moving forward and would love to work with the City when he becomes Supervisor to get solar panels on the project and lower emissions. He commented he would like to see the City take bold environmental action which he did not see in the mitigation measures for the project. Liz Elias commented that the project has supposedly been in the pipeline, but she had not heard about it until recently. She requested the City Council consider the negative impacts including noise, pollution, increased traffic, especially on nearby residences. She mentioned diesel trucks going to and from the warehouse, possibly 24 hours a day, sitting idle while being loaded, could pollute air, create noise and damage roads. She indicated there could be increased traffic across the bridge. She expressed concern for nearby residences at Sandy Point and mentioned their health should not be impacted or damaged because they reside in a poor community. She suggested a better use for the project site would be light industrial or an office park and mentioned this is becoming a city of gas stations and storage units; it doesn’t need warehouses. She suggested a less impactful location may be much like the UPS distribution center in Mountain House which is located in a remote area. She commented that this project does not follow the City’s mission statement and she urged the City Council to consider doing something else with the property. George Fuller commented he has not heard a valid reason why it has to move forward tonight and suggested bringing the item back in January upon considering the environmental and wildlife impacts and objections, as well as traffic impacts. He commented he is glad to hear there is a tenant in place and the public should know who the tenant is and have an opportunity to comment on the tenant. He recommended the City Council send the report back to staff to go through the objections, listen to experts, reevaluate, and bring it back for consideration. Vice Mayor Higgins inquired if staff has addressed and responded to the comment regarding 60 wildlife species being impacted and if mitigation has been addressed. Mr. McMurray responded that responses to comments were addressed in the DEIR; the EIR has an entire chapter on biology prepared by a qualified biologist. Vice Mayor Higgins inquired if there is a specific page in the report where the information is located. Mr. McMurray referred her to FEIR (attachment 4 to staff report), pages 2-18 through 2-21. He mentioned Diane Moore, the biologist who assisted in preparing that chapter is available for any

questions. He explained the project is unique in that part of the site is in the Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) area and part is not. He mentioned all resource agencies received the report and had no comments. Councilmember Alaura inquired if the biologist could expand and clarify. City Attorney Derek Cole commented that the number of special species is 40, not 60, as was indicated by the speaker. Biologist Diane Moore responded that the project is unusual in that a small portion of it is outside of the HCP in which the species are selected as special status by the agency. She mentioned 28 species have been identified and migratory birds are also protected. She explained that 24 acres are located outside the HCP which consist of habitat types consistent with those in the HCP. She mentioned a storm drain outfall needed to be addressed through the standard CEQA process and goes through extensive permitting and future conditioning. She also mentioned mitigation measures will be required and taken. Councilmember Alaura thanked her for a very thorough response. Vice Mayor Higgins inquired if it is possible that a lot of animals will be run over by vehicles going to and from the project site as a speaker suggested. Ms. Moore responded that she has never responded to this type of comment. She mentioned traffic impacts happen everywhere to wildlife; therefore she sees it as complete non-issue. Councilmember Pope inquired if rooftop solar has been considered. Mr. Momot shared that he and Mr. Griesener had a conversation yesterday about solar and they will discuss it with DTSC. He mentioned they would need to further study it and also would need a provider, a contractor and expert. Councilmember Pope commented that MCE is looking for local solar projects and would likely be happy to explore and the City would love to house it. He also commented in response to a speaker’s concern regarding trucks sitting idle that may cause air pollution that trucks cannot sit idle by law and he believes this was explored in the report. He inquired if all time lines have met legal requirements. City Attorney Derek Cole responded that staff has met the time lines in legal compliance, and have gone above and beyond. Councilmember Pope apologized for being flippant in his response to a public comment that the project is not a quality project. He mentioned that this is not communist China; the City approves projects under law and this project is lawful; the City doesn’t tell people what it can and can’t build if it fits within the law. He added that he agrees with the Antioch Mayor that the project is mutually beneficial to both Oakley and Antioch communities. He mentioned he is satisfied that this is a thorough report. He shared that he sits on the Habitat Conservancy board and California has the most stringent wildlife protection laws in the world, none of the habitat agencies have opposed and he believes the report goes above and beyond. Councilmember Alaura commented she appreciates answers about animals. She asked if staff can expand on air quality and traffic approvals.

Mr. McMurray introduced Rod Stinson, Air Quality Specialist with Raney Planning. Mr. Stinson mentioned the procedure for air quality is included in the EIR. Councilmember Alaura commented that standards have been met, but perhaps he can expand on where the project falls compared to what is required. Mr. Stinson explained they ran air quality modeling for construction and operation and came up with emission estimates, compared them to thresholds of significance from the air district, and identified potentially significant impacts requiring mitigation that brought them down to below less than significant level, except for during construction, the air quality impacts are significant and unavoidable, but they have all feasible mitigation measures included, but it wasn’t enough to bring it down; all others were less than significant. He explained they modeled for greenhouse gas emissions, compared them to the air district’s thresholds of significance, and there are significant and unavoidable greenhouse gas emissions from project operations for the 2030 level thresholds and they could not be brought down below significant levels; therefore, mitigation measures have been included. He addressed the health risk assessment and explained state guidance provides emission levels, but also when an analysis is required. He mentioned there is discussion in the FEIR explaining why a health risk assessment is not warranted for this project. Councilmember Alaura inquired how far away the closest residential area is to the project. Mr. McMurray commented that it is within 1000 feet and it was not noticed. Councilmember Alaura commented that 300 feet is required, but Oakley has a 500 foot standard. Mr. McMurray confirmed that is correct. Councilmember Alaura thanked staff for a thorough report and response. She expressed that she feels the research and due diligence has been done and there are many eyes and ears that will watch to make sure standards will be followed and mitigations recommended will be put in place. She commented that the project will be positive for the community; many people are coming to the area and there is a cry for jobs which this project would provide. She mentioned this project will provide an opportunity to clear freeways somewhat and get living wage jobs in the area. She expressed support for the project. Councilmember Krieg mentioned a concern expressed tonight that he feels is significant is that there has been a rush to make a quick decision about this project. He explained it is impossible to rush it in California with such strict regulations and it requires a long, thoughtful process. He shared that he has lived here since the plant was operating and everyone has known this is the type of project that would eventually come and is the best solution for this land. He mentioned a well, thoughtful decision has been made and staff has worked appropriately; therefore, he has no concerns with moving forward with it. Mayor Romick commented that this report is not a quick bedtime at approximately 5,000 pages. He mentioned it has been 20 years since the City incorporated and the City has always looked at the DuPont property for future projects. He mentioned there have been a number of developers interested in the property and more recently, just a few years ago, there was a

potential developer but it fell through. He shared that each one has felt difficulty working with the state to redevelop the property. He mentioned there is a job and housing imbalance in Oakley, but not many long-term good jobs in Oakley; this project will provide it. He commented that the Wilbur corridor used to be full of jobs which are now gone and he is hoping to bring them back; this is starting point of that gateway and an opportunity to keep families close to home and spending time with each other. He mentioned he has seen other reports in his time on the City Council and Planning Commission; the reports are not done overnight, they are controlled heavily by rules and regulations, and he is satisfied NorthPoint has met all requirements. He called for a motion on each item separately. It was moved by Councilmember Pope and seconded by Vice Mayor Higgins to certify the Oakley Logistics Center Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations and adopt the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) It was moved by Vice Mayor Higgins and seconded by Councilmember Alaura to adopt a Resolution approving the General Plan Amendment to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan, as conditioned. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) It was moved by Councilmember Krieg and seconded by Vice Mayor Higgins to waive the first reading and introduce an Ordinance approving the Rezone to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1), as conditioned. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) It was moved by Councilmember Alaura and seconded by Councilmember Krieg to adopt a resolution approving the Vesting Tentative Map and Design Review, as conditioned, and waive the first reading and introduce an ordinance approving the development agreement. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0) City Manager Bryan Montgomery announced it might take a couple of minutes for the room to clear before the next item is heard. 6) Regular Calendar 6.1 Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the Approval of a Downtown Revitalization Loan Program Loan of $50,000 to Gail & Christian Knight for a New Restaurant Building to be Finished at 3685 Main Street in Downtown Oakley (Dwayne Dalman, Economic Development Director) Mayor Romick announced that Councilmember Alaura recused herself from this item. Economic Development Manager Dwayne Dalman presented the staff report. He mentioned the owners anticipate initially to be open for dinner Monday-Thursday, then next spring they plan to also be open for brunch, and possibly by summer, be open for lunch. He also mentioned they have 4 parking spaces in the lot on site and have sufficient parking in the surrounding area so they would like to convert the 4 parking spaces to an outdoor dining area. He shared it is staff’s recommendation that the City Council approve the loan with two conditions; one, the funds for

the outdoor improvements not be provided until the Council has approved the design review, and two, repayment for the original loan will begin immediately upon the business commencing. Councilmember Krieg inquired if the City would not be violating any loan program parameters by approving the loan. Mr. Dalman responded that the program gives leeway and meets all requirements. Applicants Gail Knight expressed that giving back is a key part of their mission and they plan to have hosted charitable events. She explained that the outdoor seating will have fencing, landscape and lighting and approval of these funds will allow them to provide it. She commented she is confident that they will be successful and thanked staff. Applicant Christian Knight shared he is a 4th generation Oakley resident and this opportunity will bring something to Oakley that they have longed for and something they want the community to be proud of and excited to have here. He shared that the outdoor patio will provide a fun family atmosphere and he hopes the City Council will approve the loan. Public Comment Liz Elias expressed concern with the City acting as a bank. She mentioned she is not sure it is entirely unheard of, but has concern of the source of funds. With that said, she mentioned she would like to see this type of restaurant rather than another fast food establishment in Oakley. George Fuller mentioned he was before the City Council 5-6 weeks ago discussing loans when Mayor Romick confirmed that the City makes loans and Vice Mayor Hardcastle inquired where the applicant Naim Zalmaiyar was and why the City continues to make loans. He mentioned City Manager Bryan Montgomery mentioned he gives misinformation, but he expresses concern about loans made in the past. He suggested the City let the banks handle loans; if the banks feel it is a good investment, they will loan the money. He mentioned he is not sure everyone is looking forward to a tavern. He suggested the City use the funds to put in an elevator at the Oakley Entrepreneur Center and let the private developers do their things. He commented that the City should worry about fire, police, parks and roads, but not loans to private developers. Councilmember Krieg commented that this is the type of facility the City needs in its Downtown, it sounds like a place he would like and is needed to make things happen in the Downtown; therefore he supports it and he believes it is a good investment of funds. Councilmember Pope commented that the City Council receives criticism that it only approves gas stations and storage units and the City has not spent any money on private development. He added that the City Council is also criticized for not providing places for families to go. He explained that this will help provide a place for families to go. He mentioned he is a skeptic to lend City funds and does not want to see this situation be routine; this is an exception to the rule; however, because of the amenities, our weather, and being able to sit outside, he would look forward to it and supports it. It was moved by Vice Mayor Higgins and seconded by Councilmember Krieg to approve the loan to Gail and Christian Knight for $50,000, as conditioned. Motion was unanimous and so ordered. (5-0)

7) Closed Session 7.1 CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-EXISTING LITIGATION Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1) Matamoros v. Arrellano et al. Contra Costa Superior Court Case No. MSC 19-00027 Mayor Romick announced the City Council will be going into closed session. The Council approved a license agreement by unanimous vote. 8) Adjourn There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:25 p.m. Respectively Submitted, Libby Vreonis City Clerk

Showing the first 24,000 of 7,084,412 characters. The full document is at the source.

AGENDA Oakley City Council Tuesday, December 17, 2019 6:30 PM Oakley Council Chambers located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, California 94561 MISSION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley exists to build and enhance a quality community and to serve the public in a friendly, efficient, responsive manner. VISION STATEMENT: The City of Oakley will be recognized as a model of civic participation and a vibrant Delta community where families live, work, play, shop and visit. Agendas are posted in Oakley at Oakley City Hall-3231 Main Street, outside the gym at Delta Vista Middle School-4901 Frank Hengel Way and outside the Library at Freedom High School-1050 Neroly Road; agendas are also posted on the City’s Internet Website www.ci.oakley.ca.us. A complete packet of information containing staff reports and exhibits related to each item is available for public review prior to an Oakley City Council and/or City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency/Oakley Public Financing Authority meeting at Oakley City Hall, 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Oakley City Council, Oakley City Council Acting as the Successor Agency to the Oakley Redevelopment Agency or Oakley Public Financing Authority regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection, during regular business hours, at the front counter in the Main Lobby of the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561. Agendas may be picked up at the Oakley City Hall located at 3231 Main Street, Oakley, CA 94561 for no charge. To request information regarding placement on the City’s agenda e-mail distribution list, please contact us at (925) 625-7000. We provide social media options to stay connected to City Hall through Facebook, Twitter, Next Door and Instagram. Other opportunities to connect with City Hall include Peak Democracy, Oakley OnDemand and Constant Contacts. Please contact us at (925) 625-7000 for additional information or visit our website at www.oakleyinfo.com If you have a physically challenging condition and require special accommodations, please call the City Clerk’s office at (925) 625-7013. Please keep cell phones/electronic devices turned off during the meeting. Please be advised that City Council meetings are video recorded and attendees may appear on video. 1

1. Call to Order and Roll Call 1.1 Call to Order and Roll Call of the Oakley City Council 2. Pledge of Allegiance 2.1 Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag (Mayor Kevin Romick) 3. Public Comment 4. Consent Calendar 5. Public Hearing 5.1 Oakley Logistics Center - An application requesting 1) Certification of the Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations; 2) Adoption of the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and approval of 3) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 04-18) to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan; 4) a Rezone (RZ 08-18) to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 5) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 05-18) to create eight parcels within the 375.7-acre subject property; 6) Design Review (DR 12-18), including the Final Development Plan, for the project’s design, including site plans, architectural elevations, conceptual landscape plans, and other physical development; and 7) Development Agreement (DA 01-18) for the proposed development between the City of Oakley and the project applicant. The project site is located at 6000 Bridgehead Road (APN’s: 037-020-008, -009, -010, and -014 through -022). (Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director) Suggested Action: Staff recommends the City Council approve the Oakley Logistic Center project with the following actions: 1) Certify the Oakley Logistics Center Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations and adopt the 2

Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program 2) Adopt a Resolution approving the General Plan Amendment to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan, as conditioned 3) Waive the first reading and introduce an Ordinance approving the Rezone to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1), as conditioned 4) Adopt a resolution approving the Vesting Tentative Map and Design Review, as conditioned 5) Waive the first reading and introduce an ordinance approving the development agreement. Staff Report 1. Vicinity Map 2. Public Hearing Notice 3. (1 of 2) Draft EIR for the Oakley Logistics Center 3. (2 of 2) Draft EIR for the Oakley Logistics Center 4. (1 of 2) Final EIR for the Oakley Logistics Center 4. (2 of 2) Final EIR for the Oakley Logistics Center 5. Response to City of Antioch Comment Letter dated December 12, 2019 6. Applicant's Plans 7. Citizen Planning Advisor Comments 8. Economic Planning Systems Analysis dated December 11, 2019 9. Proposed EIR Certification Resolution 9A - Exhibit A to OLC EIR Certification Resolution 10. Proposed General Plan Land Use Amendment Resolution 10A - Exhibit A to OLC General Plan Land Use Amendment Resolution 11. Proposed Rezone Ordinance and Adoption of the Final Development Plan 11A - Exhibit A to OLC Rezone Ordinance 11B - Exhibit B (1 of 2) to OLC Rezone Ordinance 11B - Exhibit B (2 of 2) to OLC Rezone Ordinance 12. Proposed Vesting Tentative Map and Design Review Resolution 13. Proposed Development Agreement Ordinance 13A - Exhibit A to OLC Development Agreement Ordinance 6. Regular Calendar 6.1 Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the Approval of a Downtown Revitalization Loan Program Loan of $50,000 to Gail & Christian Knight for a New Restaurant Building to be Finished at 3685 Main Street in Downtown Oakley (Dwayne Dalman, Economic Development Director) Staff Report 1. Resolution 7. Closed Session 3

7.1 CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-EXISTING LITIGATION Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1) Matamoros v. Arrellano et al. Contra Costa Superior Court Case No. MSC 19-00027 8. Adjourn 4

STAFF REPORT Approved and Forwarded to the City Council DATE: December 17, 2019 TO: Bryan Montgomery, City Manager FROM: Joshua McMurray, Community Development Director SUBJECT: Oakley Logistics Center - An application requesting 1) Certification of the Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations; 2) Adoption of the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and approval of 3) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 04-18) to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan; 4) a Rezone (RZ 08-18) to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 5) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 05-18) to create eight parcels within the 375.7-acre subject property; 6) Design Review (DR 12-18), including the Final Development Plan, for the project’s design, including site plans, architectural elevations, conceptual landscape plans, and other physical development; and 7) Development Agreement (DA 01-18) for the proposed development between the City of Oakley and the project applicant. The project site is located at 6000 Bridgehead Road (APN’s: 037- 020-008, -009, -010, and -014 through -022). Summary This is an application by NP Oakley, LLC. (“Applicant”) requesting 1) Certification of the Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations; 2) Adoption of the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and approval of 3) a General Plan Amendment (GPA 04-18) to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan; 4) a Rezone (RZ 08-18) to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre 5

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 2 of 17 subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1); 5) a Vesting Tentative Map (TM 05-18) to create eight parcels within the 375.7-acre subject property; 6) Design Review (DR 12-18), including the Final Development Plan, for the project’s design, including site plans, architectural elevations, conceptual landscape plans, and other physical development; and 7) Development Agreement (DA 01-18) for the proposed development between the City of Oakley and the project applicant (“Project”). The project site is located at 6000 Bridgehead Road (APN’s: 037-020-008, -009, -010, and -014 through -022). Staff recommends the City Council approve the Oakley Logistic Center project with the following actions: • Certify the Oakley Logistics Center Environmental Impact Report, including adoption of Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations and adopt the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program; and • Adopt a Resolution approving the General Plan Amendment to amend the land use designation of the 143.3-acre project site from Light Industrial (LI) /Business Park (BP) /Utility Energy (UE) to Light Industrial (LI) with the remainder of the subject property being Delta Recreation (DR), and to remove the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue from Figure 3-1, Circulation Diagram, of the General Plan, as conditioned; and • Waive the first reading and introduce an Ordinance approving the Rezone to amend the zoning designation of the 375.7-acre subject property from Specific Plan (SP-3) to Planned Unit Development (P-1), as conditioned; and • Adopt a resolution approving the Vesting Tentative Map and Design Review, as conditioned; and • Waive the first reading and introduce an ordinance approving the development agreement. Existing General Plan and Zoning General Plan – The following are excerpts from the Oakley 2020 General Plan:  Existing: o (BP) Business Park - The Business Park designation is intended to provide space for office uses in a larger campus-like setting. Research and development, corporate offices, professional and administrative offices, and select light industrial uses are encouraged, though heavy industrial uses are strictly prohibited. Development in this designation should be characterized by large- 6

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 3 of 17 scale, attractive, park-like settings with common parking and consistent architectural themes. Business Parks should be comprehensively designed with a significant emphasis on aesthetics. Complimentary retail and commercial uses may be allowed only as secondary uses in a larger office development. o (LI) Light Industrial - The Light Industrial designation allows for uses such as processing, packaging, machinery, repair, fabricating, distribution, warehousing and storage, research and development, and similar uses which emit limited amounts of smoke, noise, light, or pollutants. These uses should, when possible, be combined in development projects that incorporate various uses to minimize travel and transport for goods and services related to and required to support the industrial use. This approach is also designed to help reduce regional commuter traffic by providing employment opportunities for residents of Oakley within the City Limits. o (UE) Utility Energy - The Utility Energy designation allows for power plant uses involved in the clean production of electricity utilizing the best available combustion turbine technology. The structures associated with this land use designation shall be aesthetically designed, including landscape buffers, and produce no significant adverse affects, including excess noise, dust, and glare on surrounding land uses. o (DR) Delta Recreation - This land use designation encompasses the lowlands of the San Joaquin Delta along the City’s northern edge. Most of the land designated Delta Recreation is currently within the 100-year flood plain as mapped by FEMA, which means the area is subject to periodic flooding. Due to the proximity of the Delta, these lands have substantial recreational value and offer important opportunities for public access to the Oakley waterfront, including parklands and trails offering public access. Agriculture and wildlife habitat are also considered appropriate uses of these areas. Additional uses that may, at the City’s discretion, be allowed within this designation include but are not limited to marinas, shooting ranges, duck and other hunting clubs, campgrounds, golf courses and other outdoor recreation complexes. Conditional uses allowed in the Delta Recreation land use designation shall be limited to those low- to medium-intensity establishments that do not rely on urban levels of service or infrastructure, and which will not draw large concentrations of people to flood-prone areas. Specific regulations for development within the Delta Recreation designation are provided within the Goals, Policies and Programs section of this Element. 7

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 4 of 17  Proposed: o (LI) Light Industrial - The Light Industrial designation allows for uses such as processing, packaging, machinery, repair, fabricating, distribution, warehousing and storage, research and development, and similar uses which emit limited amounts of smoke, noise, light, or pollutants. These uses should, when possible, be combined in development projects that incorporate various uses to minimize travel and transport for goods and services related to and required to support the industrial use. This approach is also designed to help reduce regional commuter traffic by providing employment opportunities for residents of Oakley within the City Limits. o The remainder of the subject property will be designated as Delta Recreation (DR). Zoning  Existing: The existing zoning on the property is Specific Plan (SP-3). This Specific Plan designation was applied to the property as a placeholder that would have allowed for the development of a Specific Plan on the property. Several years back, the City and then owner of the property DuPont were working towards developing a Specific Plan. That plan was never fully developed or adopted and thus this current zoning designation is simply a placeholder that doesn’t have any accompanying development standards or use regulations. The proposed project would clean this up.  Proposed: Planned Unit Development (P-1) District – P-1 District allows for project specific development regulations, including minimum lot sizes, setbacks, and uses, as specified in OMC section 9.1.1002. Existing Conditions and Surrounding Land Uses The subject property consists of approximately 375.7 acres located in the northwest portion of the City of Oakley, adjacent to State Route (SR) 160, on Bridgehead Road, north of Main Street and the Burlington Northern Santa Fe (BNSF) railroad right-of- way. The subject property is situated along the southern bank of the San Joaquin River. The area immediately to the west of the subject property and south of Wilbur Avenue, is located within the City of Antioch city limits. Figure 1 below shows a street view of the subject property from the intersection of Wilber Avenue and Bridgehead Road. The subject property includes 12 existing parcels, identified as Assessor’s Parcel Numbers (APNs) 037-020-008, -009, -010, and -014 through -022. While the entire subject property is approximately 375.7 acres, development of the logistics center would only occur on approximately 143.3 acres within the southwestern portion of the subject property. The 143.3-acre development area is hereinafter referred to as the 8

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 5 of 17 project site. The remaining 232.4 acres of the subject property are hereinafter referred to as the remainder area, and would remain natural, less some potential soil borrowing on areas that are both immediately adjacent to the 143.3-acre project site and outside of any wetland or marsh areas. Figure 2 on the following page shows an aerial of the subject property. Figure 1. Street View of Project Site from the intersection of Wilber Avenue and Bridgehead Road Figure 2. Aerial of Subject Property and Adjacent Properties 9

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 6 of 17 Project Description Proposed General Plan Amendment The proposed General Plan land use designation amendment is to change the area within the project site from (BP) Business Park, (LI) Light Industrial and (UE) Utility Energy to (LI) Light Industrial. As stated in the Oakley 2020 General Plan, “The Light Industrial designation allows for uses such as processing, packaging, machinery, repair, fabricating, distribution, warehousing and storage, research and development, and similar uses which emit limited amounts of smoke, noise, light, or pollutants. These uses should, when possible, be combined in development projects that incorporate various uses to minimize travel and transport for goods and services related to and required to support the industrial use. This approach is also designed to help reduce regional commuter traffic by providing employment opportunities for residents of Oakley within the City Limits.” In order to establish the proposed project, the applicable land use designations would need to be amended to an industrial designation, such as the LI designation. Proposed Rezoning Amending the applicable land use designation to LI would allow for a rezoning application to change the applicable zoning district, but only to one of the zoning districts found to be compatible with LI, which include General Commercial (C) District, Light Industrial (LI) District, or Planned Unit Development (P-1) District. The P-1 District allows for any land uses permitted by an approved final development plan which are in harmony with each other, serve to fulfill the function of the planned unit development, and are consistent with the General Plan. The applicant has proposed the Planned Unit Development (P-1) District, which in this case would allow for the proposed project. Proposed Vesting Tentative Map The project proposal includes a Vesting Tentative Map to subdivide to create eight parcels within the 375.7-acre subject property. The subdivision includes the extension of Wilbur Avenue and 4 new streets that provide access to all of the parcels. The Vesting Tentative Map Exhibit is depicted as Figure 3 on the next page: 10

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 7 of 17 Figure 3. Vesting Tentative Map Exhibit Proposed Design Review The Design Review Ordinance has different levels of Design Review procedures for review and approval of a Design Review Permit. Oakley Municipal Code section 9.1.1604(d)(1)(a) requires that an application for any structure that is above ground or alters the existing grade in any commercial, industrial or public and semi-public zoning district, including plans to modify the facade or color of a structure significantly be referred to the Planning Commission for review and approval as a public hearing item.1. The proposed new development fits the criteria above and requires Design Review. The proposed Design Review covers all of the physical development of the project, such as house floor plans and elevations, lot siting, colors and materials, landscaping, and walls/fencing. Proposed Development Agreement The application includes a Development Agreement between the City of Oakley and the project applicant. Chapter 3 of Title 9 of the Oakley Municipal Code outlines the public hearing notification and approval process for Development Agreements. 1 City Council acts as the Planning Commission per Ordinance No. 06-09 11

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 8 of 17 Analysis General Plan Amendment The City of Oakley 2020 General Plan designates the entire subject property as Light Industrial (LI), Business Park (BP), Utility Energy (UE) and Delta Recreation (DR). The area proposed to be developed is designated Light Industrial, Business Park and Utility Energy. Program 5.1.L in the Economic Development Element of the General Plan targets the Project site for economic development and seeks to develop the area with business park and/or light industrial uses. This Program states that development of this property may be pursued through a comprehensive business park master plan or Planned Unit Development zone. In order to implement the economic development goal in the General Plan with the Project, the applicant seeks to amend the General Plan in two areas. First, the applicant seeks to remove the land use designations of “Utility Energy” and “Business Park” that exist on a portion of the site and replace them with “Light Industrial.” A portion of the site is already designated Light Industrial. This change will allow the entire developable area of the site to have the same designation of “Light Industrial.” The remainder of the site will remain “Delta Recreation” and will not be developed. Consistent with the “Light Industrial” development standard in the General Plan, a maximum of 50 percent of the property is proposed for industrial uses (approximately 150 acres). Second, the applicant seeks to remove on Figure 3-1 Circulation Diagram the proposed extension of Live Oak Avenue through the Project site. No other text or information can be found in the General Plan discussing this proposed extension. Rezone The City’s zoning map identifies the property as Specific Plan (SP-3). That SP-3 zoning was a placeholder for a one-time contemplated Specific Plan that never came to fruition. As contemplated in the General Plan (Program 5.1.L), the applicant seeks to rezone the property to Planned Unit Development to allow flexibility to develop light industrial and related uses consistent with the General Plan and as set forth in the Project. The proposed Rezone would bring the project into conformance with the requested General Plan amendment as well as provide text and regulations to implement the new Planned Unit Development zoning. The purpose of the Planned Unit Development Logistics Center District (P-1 Logistics Center District) is to allow the logistics, transport, and distribution of goods to be carried out by various operators on a commercial basis. It is the intent of this P-1 Logistics Center District to allow flexibility in type, design and layout of buildings; to encourage a more efficient use of land reflecting changes in land development; to encourage the expansion of urban areas incorporating the best features of modern design while conserving the value of the land; and to provide a procedure which 12

Oakley Logistics Center December 17, 2019 Page 9 of 17 relates the type, design and layout of development to the particular site and the particular demand at the time of development. No residential structures are permitted or conditionally permitted in the P-1 Logistics Center District. Vestin

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Dec 17, 2019 - 06:29 PM — Minutes
  • Dec 17, 2019 - 06:29 PM

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a6b75b32b57850332ed740705dbb94ca. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record