POLISCOPE

The public record

COLLIER COUNTY SCHOOLS · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Special School Board Meeting

Monday, June 18, 2018 · School board meeting record

The 30-second read

Summary pending

Meeting-wide summary not available

No meeting-wide AI summary is available yet. The item-by-item board record below uses the published agenda materials.

Why it matters

The board digest below separates planned business from source-backed outcomes.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

4 recorded votes3 split

Split votes (3)

Board Determination of Purchase of Instructional Materials/Textbooks

Motion: A motion was made to adopt the textbooks that did not receive objections and to consider the objected textbooks individually. The motion excludes the two textbooks that were withdrawn as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today

Moved by Erika Donalds · Seconded by Kelly Lichter

Total

5

Yes
2
No
3
Absent
0

How they voted (5)

Erika Donaldsyes
Kelly Lichteryes
Erick Carterno
Stephanie Lucarellino
Roy Terryno

Board Determination of Purchase of Instructional Materials/Textbooks

Motion: A motion was made to adopt the textbooks as presented minus the two textbooks removed from consideration as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today

Moved by Stephanie Lucarelli · Seconded by Erick Carter

Total

5

Yes
3
No
2
Absent
0

How they voted (5)

Erick Carteryes
Stephanie Lucarelliyes
Roy Terryyes
Erika Donaldsno
Kelly Lichterno

Other Purchase #18-175 Science Textbooks and Instructional Materials

Motion: A motion was made to approve OP #18-175 for the purchase of science textbooks and instructional materials.

Moved by Stephanie Lucarelli · Seconded by Erick Carter

Total

5

Yes
3
No
2
Absent
0

How they voted (5)

Erick Carteryes
Stephanie Lucarelliyes
Roy Terryyes
Erika Donaldsno
Kelly Lichterno

Unanimous votes (1)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Erick Carteryes
Erika Donaldsyes
Kelly Lichteryes
Stephanie Lucarelliyes
Roy Terryyes

Adjournment

Yes
5
No
0
Absent
0

School district

People and votes

Erick Carter

School Board Member

Open person dossier

4 recorded votes

  1. Recorded vote

    Adjournment - Voted yes on the motion “There being no further business, a motion was made to adjourn the meeting at 8:35 p.m.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  2. Recorded vote

    Board Determination of Purchase of Instructional Materials/Textbooks - Voted no on the motion “A motion was made to adopt the textbooks that did not receive objections and to consider the objected textbooks individually. The motion excludes the two textbooks that were withdrawn as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today”; the record reports failed.

    Official record
  3. Recorded vote

    Board Determination of Purchase of Instructional Materials/Textbooks - Voted yes on the motion “A motion was made to adopt the textbooks as presented minus the two textbooks removed from consideration as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  4. Recorded vote

    Other Purchase #18-175 Science Textbooks and Instructional Materials - Voted yes on the motion “A motion was made to approve OP #18-175 for the purchase of science textbooks and instructional materials.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
See all 4 roll calls with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

0 Monday, June 18, 2018 Special School Board Meeting Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Administrative Center 5775 Osceola Trail, Naples, FL 34109 3:30 p.m. (Time Certain) STATEMENT OF MEETING GUIDELINES FOR THE SPECIAL MEETING: All electronic devices, such as cell phones, must be turned to the silent setting when entering the board room. The Special Board Meeting has a twofold purpose: 1) to conduct a hearing on the objections to instructional materials adopted by the School Board on May 8, 2018; and 2) to have the Board deliberate and vote on the purchase of adopted instructional materials. In accordance with the Hearing Management Plan of the Appointed Hearing Officer, previously posted and attached to this agenda, the Hearing Officer will conduct the evidentiary portion of the hearing and will turn the hearing over the the Board Chair to commence the deliberation portion of the proceeding. During the evidentiary portion, in accordance with the Hearing Management Plan, public speakers will have three (3) minutes to address the submitted objections to the Board adopted textbooks and/or whether any given adopted textbook should be affirmed or set aside by the Board. Members of the public wishing to speak must complete a Speaker Registration Card and deliver it to the Executive Director of Communications and Community Engagement who will announce the names and order of the public speakers. Parents or Collier Residents who are presenting previously submitted objections shall follow the criteria and time limits set forth in sections III and IV of the Hearing Management Plan. The Hearing Officer will announce the names and order of the presenters of objections. To assist speakers, whether public speakers or presenters, a yellow caution light will appear on the timer when one minute remains, and a red light will appear when the time expires. The Hearing Officer shall work with the Executive Director of Communications to enforce the time limitations. During the deliberation phase of the hearing and during the second agenda item the District General Counsel, as parliamentarian, will work with the Board Chair on meeting guidelines issues that could arise. BOARD NORMS: • Agree to abide by meeting guidelines and structure • Remain on topic • Act in the best interest of the school district • Participate and show respect • Listen, be open, and honest • Agree to disagree respectfully • Be prepared for meetings • Start on time Opening of Meeting Subject Call to Order Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Procedural File Attachments Opening of Meeting Subject Pledge to the Flag Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Procedural File Attachments Opening of Meeting Subject Roll Call Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Procedural File Attachments Opening of Meeting Subject Statement of Meeting Guidelines for the Special Meeting Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Action, Procedural STATEMENT OF MEETING GUIDELINES FOR THE SPECIAL MEETING: All electronic devices, such as cell phones, must be turned to the silent setting when entering the board room. The Special Board Meeting has a twofold purpose: 1) to conduct a hearing on the objections to instructional materials adopted by the School Board on May 8, 2018; and 2) to have the Board deliberate and vote on the purchase of adopted instructional materials. In accordance with the Hearing Management Plan of the Appointed Hearing Officer, previously posted and attached to this agenda, the Hearing Officer will conduct the evidentiary portion of the hearing and will turn the hearing over the the Board Chair to commence the deliberation portion of the proceeding. During the evidentiary portion, in accordance with the Hearing Management Plan, public speakers will have three (3) minutes to address the submitted objections to the Board adopted textbooks and/or whether any given adopted textbook should be affirmed or set aside by the Board. Members of the public wishing to speak must complete a Speaker Registration Card and deliver it to the Executive Director of Communications and Community Engagement who will announce the names and order of the public speakers. Parents or Collier Residents who are presenting previously submitted objections shall follow the criteria and time limits set forth in sections III and IV of the Hearing Management Plan. The Hearing Officer will announce the names and order of the presenters of objections. To assist speakers, whether public speakers or presenters, a yellow caution light will appear on the timer when one minute remains, and a red light will appear when the time expires. The Hearing Officer shall work with the Executive Director of Communications to enforce the time limitations. During the deliberation phase of the hearing and during the second agenda item the District General Counsel, as parliamentarian, will work with the Board Chair on meeting guidelines issues that could arise. BOARD NORMS: Agree to abide by meeting guidelines and structure Remain on topic Act in the best interest of the school district Participate and show respect Listen, be open, and honest Agree to disagree respectfully Be prepared for meetings Start on time File Attachments Hearing Management Plan of the Appointed Hearing Officer.pdf (813 KB) Public Hearing on Objections to Board Adopted Instructional Materials/Textbooks Subject Opening Remarks by Hearing Officer Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Procedural File Attachments Public Hearing on Objections to Board Adopted Instructional Materials/Textbooks Subject Public Comments Concerning Submitted Objections on Instructional Materials/Textbooks Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Procedural Members of the public wishing to speak on the submitted objections to the previously adopted instructional materials must complete a Speaker Registration Card and deliver it to the Executive Director of Communications and Community Engagement who will announce the names and order of speakers. Public speakers will have up to three (3) minutes unless granted additional time by the Board Chair. All comments and questions are to be directed to the District School Board. To assist the speaker, a yellow caution light will appear on the timer when one minute remains, and a red light will appear when the time expires. The District General Counsel, as the Parliamentarian, shall work with the Board Chair to enforce the Meeting Guidelines. File Attachments Public Hearing on Objections to Board Adopted Instructional Materials/Textbooks Subject Parents/Collier County Residents Objections to Previously Approved Instructional Materials/Textbooks Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Presentation FEDERAL STATUTE: n/a FLORIDA STATUTE: 1006.28 SCHOOL BOARD POLICY: 2520 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Presentations of Parents/Collier County Residents who submitted objections to Board adopted instructional materials/textbooks. Click here to review submitted objections and to access contested science instructional materials . LEGAL APPROVAL: Jon Fishbane, District Legal Counsel, has reviewed the matter for legal sufficiency. CONTACT: Jennifer Kincaid, Executive Director, Elementary Programs (239) 377-0107 File Attachments Amplify Science - Middle School Earth Science Advanced - Doyle.pdf (136 KB) Amplify Science - Middle School Earth Science Advanced - Mogil.pdf (938 KB) Amplify Science - Middle School Life Science Advanced - Doyle.pdf (135 KB) Amplify Science - Middle School Physical Science Advanced - Doyle.pdf (143 KB) Elevate Science - 1st grade - Mogil.pdf (352 KB) Elevate Science - 2nd grade - Mogil.pdf (862 KB) Elevate Science - 3rd grade - Mogil.pdf (526 KB) Elevate Science - 4th grade - Doyle.pdf (98 KB) Elevate Science - 4th grade - Mogil.pdf (414 KB) Elevate Science - 5th grade - Mogil.pdf (640 KB) Elevate Science - Kindergarten - Mogil.pdf (318 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Earth Science - Doyle.pdf (189 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Earth Science - Flaugh.pdf (1,308 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Earth Science - Mogil 1.pdf (1,650 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Earth Science - Mogil 2.pdf (486 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Earth Science - Pind.pdf (179 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Life Science - Doyle.pdf (192 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Life Science - Flaugh 1.pdf (1,095 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Life Science - Flaugh 2.pdf (312 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Life Science - Flaugh 3.pdf (1,146 KB) Elevate Science - Middle School Physical Science - Doyle.pdf (249 KB) Essentials of Oceanography - Flaugh.pdf (995 KB) Essentials of Oceanography - Mogil.pdf (301 KB) Glencoe Biology - Flaugh.pdf (724 KB) HMD Environmental Science - Flaugh.pdf (1,433 KB) HMD Environmental Science - Mogil.pdf (1,952 KB) Human Genetics-Concepts and Applications - Flaugh.pdf (501 KB) Meteorology Today - Mogil.pdf (320 KB) Pearson - Earth Science - Flaugh.pdf (659 KB) Pearson - Earth Science - Mogil.pdf (338 KB) Board Deliberation and Vote Subject Board Determination of Purchase of Instructional Materials/Textbooks Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Action Recommended Action To be determined by Board Members subsequent to deliberation. FEDERAL STATUTE: n/a FLORIDA STATUTE: n/a SCHOOL BOARD POLICY: n/a EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The board will deliberate at the conclusion of the public hearing and determine which, if any, instructional materials/textbooks will be purchased. LEGAL APPROVAL: n/a CONTACT: Jennifer Kincaid, Executive Director, Elementary Programs (239) 377-0107 File Attachments Motion & Voting A motion was made to adopt the textbooks that did not receive objections and to consider the objected textbooks individually. The motion excludes the two textbooks that were withdrawn as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today Motion by Erika Donalds, second by Kelly Lichter. Final Resolution: Motion Fails Aye: Erika Donalds, Kelly Lichter Nay: Erick Carter, Stephanie Lucarelli, Roy Terry A motion was made to adopt the textbooks as presented minus the two textbooks removed from consideration as follows: HMD Environmental Science Meteorology Today Motion by Stephanie Lucarelli, second by Erick Carter. Final Resolution: Motion Carries Aye: Erick Carter, Stephanie Lucarelli, Roy Terry Nay: Erika Donalds, Kelly Lichter Board Deliberation and Vote Subject Other Purchase #18-175 Science Textbooks and Instructional Materials Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Action Fiscal Impact Yes Dollar Amount $1,663,580.00 Budgeted Yes Budget Source General Fund Recommended Action Approve OP #18-175 for the purchase of science textbooks and instructional materials. FEDERAL STATUTE: n/a FLORIDA STATUTE: n/a SCHOOL BOARD POLICY: n/a EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This is for the purchase of selected science textbooks and instructional materials to be used throughout the district. Purchases will be made from Florida School Book Depository, of Jacksonville, Florida. Florida School Book Depository (FSBD) has served publishers of Florida adopted and non-adopted instructional materials. FSBD also serves Florida schools and districts by providing a central source in the State for print and digital instructional materials at the lowest price and at no hosting cost to the state. FSBD offers a comprehensive list of programs in Florida along with customized services enabling districts to streamline their procurement processes for the greatest economic value. Partnering with publishers, FSBD stores products and coordinates the sale and distribution of these instructional materials throughout Florida from its distribution center in Jacksonville. Staff anticipates additional science instructional materials purchases will be brought before the Board for consideration when the State Science instructional Materials list is posted. Purchases for the selected science textbooks and materials is estimated at $1,561,451,48. Recommend an additional $102,128.52 for any variations to enrollment throughout the course of the year per the attached tabulation sheet. Purchases are exempt from the bidding process under provisions of FAC 6a-1.012(11). The total estimated exposure for the 2018-19 school year is in the amount of $1,663,580.00. LEGAL APPROVAL: n/a CONTACT: Dr. Peggy Aune, Associate Superintendent, Curriculum and Instruction (239) 377-0209 David Nara, Director, Purchasing (239) 377-0064 File Attachments 061818_18.175 Science Textbooks TAB.pdf (97 KB) Motion & Voting A motion was made to approve OP #18-175 for the purchase of science textbooks and instructional materials. Motion by Stephanie Lucarelli, second by Erick Carter. Final Resolution: Motion Carries Aye: Erick Carter, Stephanie Lucarelli, Roy Terry Nay: Erika Donalds, Kelly Lichter Adjournment Subject Adjournment Meeting Jun 18, 2018 - Special School Board Meeting Type Action Recommended Action Motion to adjourn. File Attachments Motion & Voting There being no further business, a motion was made to adjourn the meeting at 8:35 p.m. Motion by Erika Donalds, second by Erick Carter. Final Resolution: Motion Carries Aye: Erick Carter, Erika Donalds, Kelly Lichter, Stephanie Lucarelli, Roy Terry

Sources and limits

This meeting has been held, but no source-backed decision record is available yet. Agenda items remain proposals.

Not claimed by this page

  • No agenda facet is available for a complete inventory of planned business.
  • No packet or attachment facet is available for supporting materials.
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.

Canonical record: a3d19a36813e058efb62128717899ff4. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record