POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners - Zoning

Thursday, April 18, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Board of County Commissioners - Zoning

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

cdmp. Seconded by commissioner bastien. The meeting is adjourned. MR. Attorney let's go ahead and start our zoning meeting. Can I have the zoning director read the statement and swear in the speakers if need be again . >> it would be prudent to do so because folks that MAY wish to speak on other zoning applications MAY not have stood up. The opening statement and the swearing in. >> eric silva, rer. In accordance with the code all items have been legally advertised in the newspaper, notice mailed and properties posted two. Additional copies are available in the chambers. Items to be called up to be heard by name of applicant. Please note board action on any item MAY be reconsidered and additional action MAY be taken on such an item at the same meeting. Applicants MAY wish to govern themselves accordingly. The rank-and-file on the hearing will include documents from the public and the department of rgulatory resources, when there is an appeal we also have the transfer for those harings. All documents are physically present today and available to interested prties and available to members of the board of county commissioners from the record during the hearing. Parties have the right of cross-examination. This statement along with the fact that all witnesses always warning shall include a transcript. There is an additional official translator for those individuals requiring such assistance. Will the clark swear in the witnesses? >> hand and raise your right hand. Do you solemnly swear the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth will help you GOD? Thank you. Interpreters. Do you swear or affirm you will make a true interpretation of the questions asked and testimony given? Thank you. >>vice chair: all right, anything else to read or are we good to move forward? I know that we have a deferral request. Do we just need a motion to defer? So just fyi, we have speakers on 3-d. Or is the item listed here? We do have quite a few speakers, about five or six but the item is being deferred. And you are? >> I will make a motion to defer on item 4. >>vice chair: doesn't work that way. You can't make motions. We will get to that. What's the item? We will get to that. Since so we are on zoning item 3d which we have a motion to defer. For those came and signed up to speak , it's a waste of time for you to speak now, you won't be able to speak again so thank you for coming down, sorry. But is there a motion to defer? it's been moved by commissioner bastien, seconded by... Seconded by commissioner cohen higgins . >> through the chair, for the item where there is a request to defer if the zoning director can read the title of the item and then I believe it is a request to defer to the next bcc zoning meeting which is MAY 24 . >> perfect, go ahead. >> so 296 legacy application number z202300037 , three protests and no waivers of support and request is to defer to MAY 23 and that was the same speakers at the podium, that was the applicant. >>. >>vice chair: 4 is 3d, congratulations, you made a motion. All in favor signify by saying aye. Motion carries and the item is deferred. Congratulations. We are now on the companion item we just heard in cdmp which is 3 age. Public hearing was already done so commissioner from the eighth district. >>commissioner cohen higgins: imovie item . >> I need to mention as noted in the cdmp portion the public hearing and board discussion will now be incorporated into the record for the zoning proceeding and if the zoning director wuld just read the title of this item prior to board spoke. >>vice chair: go-ahead director . >> application 3h, seven llc. Application number z2023000169, 2 protests and no waivers. MR. CHAIRMAN, we MAY want to add the conditions related to the no live oaks and the discussion regarding the pump station . >>vice chair: that is added into the motion. That is added in your motion. Any discussion on the item? >> I have two questions before you have the floor . >> the first one, do we have a resident arborist? I and commissioner regalado are the only ones commenting on both technical issues so I'd like to make sure that's the case. The second thing I want to support it by the way but point of clarification on the issue of there being PRESIDENT . My understanding is we can set precedent unless we approved an ordinance, a motion as we did for this particular item at the cdmp but I wanted to make sure nothing precludes, to me with all due respect to the CHAIRMAN To me something that would be a precedent for an ordinance or resolution that would be existing, what understood where there was a freestanding motion which I voted for but there being no precedent it doesn't preclude anyone else on this dais because there MAY be another unique situation that we MAY also have a motion to that point, am I correct or am I missing something? Are correct, it would be up to this board in a future circumstance to decide the extent to which past action applies. >>commissioner bermudez: let's be clear that's the case because when we use words like that we complicate the vote that we were having. And we clarified that at that point I would not be involved because I'm not precluded from trying it at some point. >> we have a motion, a second, all this stuff has been read. Mme. Clark please call the role , commissioner higgins. >>commissioner higgins: borehole pump station thing, that's taken care of in the cdmp application or is that part of the amendment here. >>commissioner higgins: appreciate that. >>vice chair: please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes . >>vice chair: congratulations. MR. Attorney let's go ahead and take item 3a, >> application 3 a, five cars llc, application z z20192000 z20192000231, we find no protests and no waivers in this application. I'd like to mention there was a request to waive the requirements of three trees. We had a requirement in the application for street trees, I want to qualify we took the applicant, he's agreed to plant the street trees within the lot so we will be providing the required number of trees. >>vice chair: that will require some ease. I have one speaker signed up. MISS Cecilia Mcgrath. She signed up for 3a as well. She left. Does the applicant need to put anything on the record? >> jorge rivera, we're in coherence with the staff recommendation. As to condition number 12 as mentioned of our ram, there is no longer a ramp there. It's quite a lot for us to get here but that ramp has been eliminated and as we spoke with staff we will be landscaping that area. >>vice chair: commissioner from the second district you are recognized . >>commissioner bastien: the applicant is requesting permit to an existing lot. For changes in the open spaces and landscaping area. And understand that the agreed to plant the trees, that was one of our concerns so with this in mind I moved to approve . >>vice chair: we have a motion and a second by commissioner bermudez. We have to clarify the motion. >> with respect to commission number 11 it would be modified to say that the applicant saw the required street trees within the law or within the street. >>vice chair: thank you for that. And then the condition number 12 has been resolved. Mme. Clark, please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously . >>chair: >>vice chair: congratulations, let's go ahead and take item 3b. >> christian empowerment center application z2021000138. We had no protests and no waivers to support this application . >>vice chair: public hearing is open, anybody wishing to speak . Then the applicant, how much time will you need? >> I'm representing the applicant. >> and your address . >> the firm's address is 217 biscayne blvd. >> I wanted to mention the applicant has agreed to accept our conditions set forth in the staff report. And thank you for your time today. >>vice chair: commissioner from the second district. >>commissioner bastien: thank you MR. Chair. I just have one question for staff. With the approval staff also notes this application requests it would impact water and sewer services and neighboring additional noise to the area. But if you added that impact that had been mitigated we would have more details on that. What exactly is being done to mitigate these impacts? >>vice chair: you have the floor, you are recognized for an evident flow conversation . >> the applicant has provided buffers for landscaping to meet the impacts. >> if I MAY we have the architect here as well who can tell you more about that landscaping buffer. >>vice chair: come on up. I introduced sylvia dorn who can speak a little bit about the landscaping buffers that have been included in the design of the project. >>vice chair: you are recognized. Please state your name. And address. >> sylvia dorn, architect 6720 brickell avenue you're asking about the landscaping buffer. >>vice chair: commissioner bastien has a question . >>commissioner bastien: what will you be doing to reduce the noise bought by the trust sections. >> we have a lot of landscaping and we hve more trees and we even have a lot of existing trees that are very old. Very large trees that don't protect the noise to the people. >> if I MAY clarify speaker is that a direct result of construction or the operation , it would be functioning as a church. >>commissioner bastien: but by the construction of the church, the cars that would be passing by. >>vice chair: they have to still abide by the county code and the times. >>commissioner bastien: exactly . >> everything would be done by code and by the ordinances. >>vice chair: thank you very much and we would expect nothing less. >>commissioner bastien: I've got it. I moved to approve the application for staff recommendation. >>vice chair: motion and a second by commissioner cohen higgins, please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously . >>vice chair: MR. Attorney, please type up 3c . >> application number 302200251, we had no protests and no waivers to support this application. >>vice chair: can we have a translator for MISS Milagros ? I will open discussion , is this on this item? >> this item is in my district. We had an interpreter first. >> in the meantime public hearing is open. I have no speaker signed up. So you will hear from, do you want to hear from him first? Then you are recognized. . >>commissioner hardemon: to staff, this application gives me quite a bit of hearted. I don't understand particularly how the staff that was being recommended is consistent with the neighborhood. >>. [Speaking spanish] >>commissioner hardemon: because when I look at the history of this property it seems to me this is an owner that has made a significant amount of changes to the property without permission. And seeing that she's here alone today I don't feel comfortable moving forward. I want to get at least some notice to the owners that maybe they should have their contractor or whomever was working with them to come and help articulate some things because I'm going to have questions of that person and I'm going to have questions of the owner that are significant and could lead to either acceptance or denial of this application. And so with that I would like to request a deferral on the item till te next meeting. >>vice chair: there is a motion to defer item 3c to the next full bcc zoning hearing, MAY 23. Second by commissioner cohen higgins. All in favor signify by saying aye. Motion carries. Can you explain to her ? And for the record I'm sure we need to close public hearing and all that good stuff. Because it was different, you are right. >>commissioner hardemon: of course we could have had public hearing. , show the item deferred. >> she has a question about when is the motion . [Speaking spanish] >> she didn't have any contractor, she just purchased the property . >>commissioner hardemon: I don't want her to say things like that on the record because there are conflicts in the evidence and I don't want her to talk through that you. >>vice chair: [Speaking spanish] So we are deferred. MR. Attorney, item 3e . >> went has industrial llc, application z202300039, no protests and no waivers to support this application . >>vice chair: public hearing is now open, no public speakers. The applicant how much time are you going to need? >> three minutes max for the presentation. >>vice chair: you've got the three minutes, go ahead, make it quick. >> basically the applicant is a moving company who purchases property and they want a station to move their vehicles there. The only non-use variance was actually for internal circulation, how do I do that? I apologize . >>vice chair: you have a clicker on the podium. >> property located at 3502 nw. 35th st. 6900 ft.B2, it's iu1 result from residential to iu1 in 2004. They had some extensive landscape variances which we are doing away with. They basically got rid of shrubs from 15 to 40, reduced the green belt to nearly 0 feet , changes in design and they were using it as storage. The current zoning request is basically in a perfect landscape situation. As I said the nonuse variance is to the dimensions of that property. This is the current site plan , here we go. There is another thing I want to show. The property does not actually leave any space on the south from the adjoining properties. The current site plan has a 4.3 foot buffer on the west and five on the east. Due to the fact that they can't turn around a 30 foot truck inside their parking diagonally and they would be either heading in headfirst and backing out of the property or vice versa. And there is 32 feet between the date location and the roadway in order to make sure they can safely stage before moving in. Staff believes that this is in agreement with the area and recommends approval. Additionally there was going to be a few conditions involved, three of them being operational in nature regarding durham, application of site plan and adding that additional point. If you have any points. >>vice chair: commissioner from district 2, you are recognized for a motion potentially. You MR. Chair. All questions have been answered and we concur with staff approval. >>vice chair: motion by commissioner bastien, seconded by commissioner cohen higgins. And any discussion on the item, seeing non-please call the role . >>clerk: [Roll call vote. Motion passes unanimously . >>vice chair: MR. Attorney let's take 3f. >> application z2023000146, no protests, no waivers . >>vice chair: public hearing is open and I have 2 speakers. This is gail strickland and cecelia Mcgrath. How much time are you going to need? >> five minutes. >>vice chair: commissioner, do you want to hear a full presentation? There is no one here to speak on this item. In the interest of time. >>commissioner higgins: I like to defer this item. >>vice chair: that saves some time. There is a motion and a second to defer by commissioner higgins, all in favor signify by saying aye. Show the item deferred to MAY 23. MR. Attorney let's take a 3g and go-ahead director, read your statement into the record. >> application z2023300154 , we've had no protests and no waivers of support . >>vice chair: show public hearing open, no speaker signed up. >> 30 seconds . >> 30 seconds works for me. >> before you today is an existing... Sorry. George navarro offices at 333 se. 2nd avenue on behalf of the jewish leadership academy and the family foundation this is an existing school. Where not asking to increase grade levels, we have to existing outdoor play areas as you all know they go outside during the summer months which is what our kids have recess. We're asking to install sheet structures, we've also had issues with soccer balls going on so we're asking for protective netting there. They are just simply to alleviate some of he setbacks, that's the crux of the request. >>vice chair: very reasonable request, commissioner from the second district. >>commissioner bastien: I have a few questions for you. Actually, are there currently houses in the lot that were just bought for the expansion? Quest for these two portions they are part of our campus and are currently improved with outdoor picnic areas for the kids and outdoor playground equipment so they are part of our school and there are no houses currently en route. >>commissioner bastien: when was this lot bought? >> they were purchased last year. These are part of the original school that was developed so the schools under the urban center, that was part of our campus. >>commissioner bastien: is the owner here? You are representing him . >> we have our construction team here building up the school. We're making some outdoor recreational enhancements . >>commissioner bastien: for the administration what efforts were made to notify residents? >> we send out notices to half a mile radius which included 5515 ntices by mail. >> one thing I'd like to stay because I know if the owner was here you would want us to mention before we commence construction we had a meeting in the neighborhood, we were meeting significant roadway improvements so we have been being a good neighbor in terms of making sure any issues that have come up during construction were quickly addressed. So we have been in contact with many members of the community regarding any road closures that currently passed. We did have a lot of communication. >>vice chair: thank you for being such a good neighbor, commissioner from the second district. >>commissioner bastien: last question, what are the impacts ? On 96th st. Of the area. >> there will be no impacts to that road because these parcels were part of our our original school we have already improved these areas. Their buildout as recreational areas. All we are doing is including a shade structure like you see in most of the county parks. We don't know the color yet but the shade structure, there is a ninja course which gets very hot. It's the only improvement we're making on those portions along 96th st. >> all my questions have been answered so I will move for approval as for staff . >> second by commissioner steinberg, do we have discussion on this? >> back in the day we had no slots and the sun would hit the metal slot. You've got to make them tough. It builds character. >>vice chair: no further discussion on the slide in the shade and all those things. Mdm. Clerk please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously . >>vice chair: congratulations MR. Navarro and thanks once again for being such a good neighbor. All right MR. Attorney let's take up item 3I and read your statement into the record . >> boost investment incorporated number z202 number z2023000263, no protests, no waivers to support the application . >>vice chair: public hearing is open. While there are no speaker cards this is in district 3. Do you want to take the microphone before the applicant? >> is there anything they'd like to put on the record? >>vice chair: english, spanish? You speak english? Do you want to give a presentation or is there anything you want to put on the record or just have the commissioner, commissioner from the third district. >>commissioner hardemon: staff recommendation? >> recommendation for approval with conditions. >>commissioner hardemon: so moved . >>vice chair: second by commissioner cohen higgins. Any further discussion, seeing non-please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously. >>vice chair: MR. Attorney let's take our last item, 3j. Read your statement into the record . >> natalia lemus and henry rodriguez application number z2023000386 . We had no protests and no waivers for this application. >>vice chair: public hearing is open, do you wish to put something on the record? Commissioner from the eighth district , public hearing is then closed. Commissioner from the eighth district you are recognized . >>commissioner cohen higgins: I've reviewed the application and thank you to the applicants. I see or resident homeowners are not represented by lawyers are lobbyists, I appreciate you taking the time to visit so I have no comments or changes to this application so I moved to approve consistent with staff recommendation, thank you. >>vice chair: motion and a second by commissioner bermudez, no discussion other than recognizing commissioner cohen higgins. >>commissioner cohen higgins: we saw dan, he was here just a moment ago. >>vice chair: mdm. Clerk please call the role. >>clerk: [Roll call vote] Motion passes unanimously. >>vice chair: congratulations. >>commissioner cohen higgins: congratulations. >>vice chair: any... >>clerk: motion passes unanimously. Other order of the day. >> moved to adjourn. >>vice chair: motion and a second by commissioner steinberg. Show us adjourned.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners - Zoning — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a39d254d924d9300504f8f15ccc4be71. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record