POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Regular City Commission Meeting

Monday, August 12, 2002 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Sarasota City Commission met to discuss various city projects, including the vacation of a public right-of-way for Selby Botanical Gardens, the creation of a 'Celebrate Sarasota' committee for the city's 100th anniversary, and the issuance of water and sewer revenue bonds. The Commission also addressed public input regarding the Lido Beach Pool and various zoning and infrastructure requests.

Why it matters

The Commission's decisions on land use, infrastructure funding, and committee oversight directly impact city development, public service availability, and the allocation of municipal tax dollars.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 233,532 characters. The full document is at the source.

BOOK 52 Page 23662 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. MINUTES OF THE SPECIAL SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION MEETING AUGUST 12, 2002, AT 6:00 P.M. PRESENT: Mayor Carolyn J. Mason, Vice Mayor Lou Ann R. Palmer, Commissioners Richard F. Martin, Mary J. Quillin, and Mary Anne Servian, City Manager Michael A. McNees, City Auditor and Clerk Billy E. Robinson, and City Attorney Richard J. Taylor ABSENT: None PRESIDING: Mayor Mason The meeting was called to order in accordance with Article III, Section 9(a) of the City of Sarasota Charter at 5:58 p.m. City Auditor and Clerk Robinson gave the Invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. 1. PROCLAMATION RE: PROCLAIMING THE WEEK OF AUGUST 19 THROUGH AUGUST 26, 2002, AS “FLOOD AWARENESS WEEK” IN THE CITY OF SARASOTA CD 6:02 through 6:03 Mayor Mason requested that Timothy Litchet, Director of Building, Zoning and Code Enforcement, join her and the Commission at the table for the presentation. Mayor Mason read in its entirely the Proclamation declaring the week of August 19 through August 26, 2002, Flood Awareness Week in the City of Sarasota and indicating that the City recognizes the importance of providing information to residents concerning reducing flood hazards and resultant damage experienced during severe weather; that Sarasota County's Flood Awareness Committee has scheduled public outreach activities to promote awareness and increase knowledge of flood risk, the availability of flood insurance, and flood protection methods during the week of August 19 through August 26, 2002; that the City is participating in the effort to provide flood awareness information; that the City encourages the citizens of the City of Sarasota to increase their knowledge to protect themselves and property from severe weather. Mr. Litchet stated that now is the time of year for everyone to start worrying about storms and tropical storms; that the City is working closely with Sarasota County to sponsor a Flood Preparedness Exposition (Expo); that the Expo will be held on Saturday, August 24, 2002, from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., at the Potter BOOK 52 Page 23663 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Building located on the Sarasota County Fairgrounds, which is next to Robart's Arena; that encouragement is given to everyone to come and visit the Expo; that 30 exhibits will be on display at the Expo; that emergency management equipment will be on display; that door prizes and gifts will be distributed during the Expo; that the Expo is being held to help everyone get ready for the storm/tropical season; that pamphlets and brochures with helpful information on storm awareness is available to the public at the Office of the City Auditor and Clerk and the Building Department; that everyone is encouraged to be on alert and prepared for tropical storms. 2. CHANGES TO THE ORDERS OF THE DAY - APPROVED CD 6:03 through 6:05 City Auditor and Clerk Robinson presented the following Changes to the Orders of the Day: A. Remove Consent Agenda No. 2, Item No. III-B-1, Adoption Re: Proposed Resolution No. 02-1524, the Agreement between the State of Florida Department of Transportation and the City of Sarasota for the Traffic Signal Maintenance and Compensation Agreement, per the request of Traffic Control System Analyst Hegel. B. Remove Scheduled Presentations, Item No. V-3, Presentation Re: Request of the Indian Beach Sapphire Shore Neighborhood Association for Commission assistance in the purchase of property in the neighborhood for a park, per the request of Charles Hegener, Director, Indian Beach Sapphire Shores Neighborhood Association. C. Add New Business, Item No. VIII-6, Approval Re: Request of Beverly Scott for a masonry wall construction and landscape planting on the northerly boundary line of Whitaker-Gateway Park, per the request of Commissioner Servian. Vice Mayor Palmer stated that the Commission has been requesting the reason for adding new items after publication of the Agenda and asked if Item No. VIII-6 concerning the request of Beverly Scott could have been placed on the Agenda for the September 3, 2002, Regular Commission meeting. BOOK 52 Page 23664 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Commissioner Servian stated that the request has been languishing for 18 months to two years; that an item concerning the request was originally on the Agenda for the current meeting but removed; that some agreement has now been reached; therefore, a request was made to place the item on the Agenda so the final agreement can be presented to the Commission at the September 3, 2002, Regular Commission meeting. Commissioner Quillin asked if the request was reviewed by Staff and the Administration? Commissioner Servian stated yes. On motion of Commissioner Martin and second of Commissioner Servian, it was moved to approve the Changes to the Orders of the Day. Motion carried unanimously (5 to 0): Martin, yes; Palmer, yes; Quillin, yes; Servian, yes; Mason, yes. 3. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 1: ITEM NOS. 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, AND 8 - APPROVED (AGENDA ITEM III-A) CD 6:05 through 6:07 Vice Mayor Palmer requested that Item No. 2 be removed for discussion. Commissioner Quillin requested that Item No. 5 be removed for discussion. 1. Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute the Federal Building Special Category Grant Award Agreement #SC355, Addendum to Grant Award Agreement #SC355, and Restrictive Covenants 3. Report Re: Progress of the Downtown Sarasota Mobility Study 4. Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute a contract between the City of Sarasota and Hilb, Rogal & Hamilton of Sarasota, (RFP #02-55M) for Excess Workers’ Compensation coverage for a period of one year 6. Approval Re: Authorize the administration to negotiate and the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute a contract between the City of Sarasota and David W. Johnston and Associates, Inc., (RFP #02-46M) for the John Ringling Causeway Park - 7. Approval Re: Designation of U.S. 41 as a Florida Scenic Highway from north Manatee County line to the south Sarasota County line BOOK 52 Page 23665 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. 8. Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute Modification #2 to the State-Funded Grant Agreement (Contract #01-UI-07-09-68-02-009) between the City of Sarasota and the Department of Community Affairs, for the Urban Infill and Redevelopment Assistant Grant Program (Comprehensive Newtown Redevelopment Plan) City Auditor and Clerk Robinson stated that Item No. 2 will be considered under New Business as Item No. VIII-7, and Item No. 5 will be considered under New Business as Item No. VIII-8. On motion of Commissioner Martin and second of Commissioner Servian, it was moved to approve Consent Agenda No. 1, Item Nos. 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, and 8. Motion carried unanimously (5 to 0): Martin, yes; Palmer, yes; Quillin, yes; Servian, yes; Mason, yes. 4. CONSENT AGENDA NO. 2: ITEM 1 (RESOLUTION NO. 02R-1524) - REMOVED UNDER CHANGES; ITEM 2 (ORDINANCE NO. 02-4398) - ADOPTED (AGENDA ITEM III-B) CD 6:07 through 6:09 2. Adoption Re: Proposed Ordinance No. 02-4398, an Ordinance calling a referendum of the qualified electors of the City for the purpose of determining whether or not the Charter of the City shall be amended to add a prohibition against discrimination on the basis of age, disability, gender, marital status, national origin, race, religion, sexual orientation or veterans status in the areas of housing, employment and public accommodations; to provide that all City contracts must be approved by the City Commission unless exempted by ordinance; to require the City Auditor and Clerk and City Attorney to prepare an annual budget; to require that a citizen’s initiative petition which proposes an amendment to more than one section of the Charter shall be required to contain a clear and concise summary of the material components of the proposed amendment; to add provisions to the Charter consistent with applicable state law to specifically address the scheduling of a Referendum on a proposed Charter amendment; the approval of ballot language and the effective date of an BOOK 52 Page 23666 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. amendment if approved by the voters; scheduling said referendum for November 5, 2002; setting forth the text of the proposed Charter amendments and the title and summary of the proposed amendments to appear on the ballot; providing an effective date for said Charter amendments, if approved; etc. (Title Only) City Auditor and Clerk Robinson read proposed Ordinance No. 02- 4398 by title only. On motion of Commissioner Vice Mayor Palmer and second of Commissioner Servian, it was moved to adopt Consent Agenda No. 2, Item No. 2. Mayor Mason requested that City Auditor and Clerk Robinson proceed with the roll-call vote. Motion carried unanimously (5 to 0): Martin, yes; Mason, yes; Palmer, yes; Quillin, yes; Servian, yes. Mayor Mason requested that City Auditor and Clerk Robinson explain the public hearing sign-up process. City Auditor and Clerk Robinson stated that all persons wishing to speak at the public hearings are requested to complete a Request to Speak form; that speakers at the non quasi-judicial public hearings will have five minutes to speak; that speakers will be timed and will be advised when one minute remains; and repeated for the benefit of those present in the Chambers the Pledge of Public Conduct as adopted by the Commission as follows: We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will avoid personal attacks. All individuals wishing to speak during the public hearings were requested to stand and were sworn in by City Auditor and Clerk Robinson. 5. NON QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARING RE: PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 02-4389, TO CONDITIONALLY VACATE THAT CERTAIN PORTION OF THE 60-FOOT WIDE SOUTH PALM AVENUE RIGHT-OF-WAY GENERALLY DESCRIBED AS BOUNDED ON THE NORTH BY THE SOUTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF MOUND STREET (S.R. 45, U.S. 41) AND EXTENDING UP TO APPROXIMATELY 873 FEET SOUTHWARD AND BOUNDED ON THE SOUTH BY THE WATERS OF HUDSON BAYOU; ETC. (TITLE ONLY)(APPLICATION NO. 02-SV-03, APPLICANT CHARLES BAILEY, JR., ESQUIRE, REPRESENTING THE MARIE SELBY BOOK 52 Page 23667 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. BOTANICAL GARDENS, INC.) - PASSED ON FIRST READING AS CONDITIONED (AGENDA ITEM IV-A-1) CD 6:09 through 8:28 Mayor Mason opened the public hearing and requested that the Applicant come forward. Charles Bailey, Jr., Esquire, law firm of Williams, Parker, Harrison, Dietz & Getzen, representing The Selby Botanical Gardens, Inc. (Selby Gardens), Dr. Meg Lowman, Executive Director of the Gardens, Robert Scully, Chairman of the Gardens' Board of Trustees and Thomas Peter, Director of Facilities of the Gardens, came before the Commission. Mr. Peter distributed copies of letters and signed petitions in support of a conditional vacation of the portion of South Palm Avenue near the Selby Gardens. Attorney Bailey stated that several representatives for Selby Gardens are present in the audience; and introduced Martin Copper, Martin Faust, William Lambrecht, Caren Lobo, Dr. Allison Menezes, and Robert Silverman to the Commission. Attorney Bailey referred to an architectural design from the Selby Gardens Master Plan adopted approximately six years ago displayed on the Chamber monitors, and stated that the Selby Gardens occupy a two-block area bounded by Mound Street/US 41 to the north, Orange Avenue to the east, Hudson Bayou to the south, and Sarasota Bay to the west; that Street Vacation Application No. 02-SV-03 as incorporated in proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389 requests a conditional vacation of a portion of South Palm Avenue; that the goal of Selby Gardens is to construct a cul-de- sac turnaround at approximately mid-block of the vacated portion of South Palm Avenue. Dr. Lowman referred to computer-generated slides displayed on the Chamber monitors throughout the presentation, and stated that Selby Gardens' 25th Birthday was recently celebrated; that Selby Gardens is internationally recognized for research and conservation; that Costa Ricans may be more knowledgeable about Selby Gardens than local residents; that Selby Gardens' pledge for the next 25 years is to become a source of pride for Sarasota, an important tourist destination, and a community center for all; that Selby Gardens is one of the last remaining areas of green space in Sarasota; that South Palm Avenue bisects BOOK 52 Page 23668 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. the property; that the street vacation would afford Selby Gardens the opportunity to develop additional greenspace into a children's garden and improve the display area for plants; that past master planning efforts for Selby Gardens depict the closing of South Palm Avenue; that several revised past master plans have not come to fruition due to the lack of ownership of surrounding properties; that the Selby Gardens has now acquired all the surrounding property; that a master site plan was developed in 1996 with the aid of City Staff, a neighborhood committee, Selby Gardens staff, volunteers, and researchers; that the cul-de-sac is a vital piece to the master plan; that the hope is for the construction of a beautiful conservatory and expanded children's garden; that the street vacation would allow Selby Gardens the opportunity to develop additional greenspace; that education programs are conducted for children of all ages for several area schools; that school children partake in photography and display the photographs at Selby Gardens every year; that new programs are beginning with high school nature students; that the current children's center is small; that Selby Gardens would like the opportunity to offer nature to children of all ages. Dr. Lowman continued that the Sarasota community is very interested in the arts and music; that Selby Gardens has expanded programs for the benefit of the community; that the Sunday Music Afternoon Concert Series held from mid March to the end of May was a success; that the research and Conservation Department has partnered with Myakka State Park to construct walkways and develop education programs at the park; that Selby Gardens has developed programs for organizations in 24 countries; that the Selby Gardens Staff has worked very hard to document the ecological systems of the world; that Selby Gardens has become well known through work performed with the Jason Project and the National Geographic Magazine. Dr. Lowman further stated that Selby Gardens summarizes programs offered to the community in the following three categories: 1. Greenspace in Downtown Sarasota. 2. Historical characteristics with the Christy Paine Mansion. 3. The collection of over 500 rare or endangered species of plants. Dr. Lowman stated further that the hope is to improve the opportunities to enjoy the bayfront; that several discussions BOOK 52 Page 23669 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. have occurred with City Staff regarding enhancements to the rounded corner of Mound Street/US 41 near the bayfront; that the desire is to enhance the dead-end of South Palm Avenue for families to come and enjoy; that several programs funded by the State have been a success; that Selby Gardens' perimeter will be enhanced by a beautiful open fence which will allow the public to view different kinds of plants; that the hope is to enhance the entry into the gardens; that traffic configuration will not be moved or changed; that Selby Gardens' desires to develop a new area such as a conservatory for the rare and endangered species of plants in the master planning progress; that a display house currently exists for orchids and bromeliads; however, the area should be more dynamic and interactive for visitors; that Selby Gardens' hope is to convey to visitors a message regarding sustainable architecture and utilizing the best possible green ways of living within the climate and ecology of Florida; that parking garages could be constructed with a green house at the top; that careful timber selection is suggested for construction; that the Selby Gardens can assist in educating the public during visits through the gardens. Attorney Bailey referred to a list of seven public benefits in support of the street vacation displayed on the chamber monitors as follows: 1. Consolidation of the East and West Campuses. Attorney Bailey stated that a reduction in the physical barrier between the east and west portions of the campus is necessary and will be accomplished by the installation of the cul-de-sac. 2. More functional access to Selby Gardens. Attorney Bailey stated that the requested street vacation is paved but terminates into a dead-end north of the Hudson Bayou; that vehicles using the southern end of the pavement must turn around in the parking lot; that the cul-de-sac will provide a passenger drop-off area, includes a wide enough radius to accommodate rescue vehicles, and will be located sufficiently to the south of Mound Street/US 41 to provide for stacking capacity for vehicle access from Mound Street/US 41. 3. Better utilization of land. BOOK 52 Page 23670 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Attorney Bailey stated that the area to the south of the proposed cul-de-sac provides greater utility to the property; that the area in the interim will be utilized with landscaping and later for vertical improvements. 4. Enhanced security. Attorney Bailey stated that Selby Gardens has a large number of rare and endangered species of plants; that in some cases, the gardens is the only place the species exist in the entire world; that a very high level of security is required for the property. 5. Preservation of utility corridors. Attorney Bailey stated that existing utilities within the right- of-way will not be disrupted; that easements will be given back to the utility companies and the City; that any future relocation of the easements will be at the expense of Selby Gardens. 6. Existing right-of-way used on limited basis by general public. Attorney Bailey stated that Selby Gardens is the owner of all the property adjacent to the subject right-of-way; that South Palm Avenue provided access to the former residential properties; that the road is now mainly utilized as access to the property; that bicycle traffic occurs occasionally but is limited; that the pavement of South Palm Avenue does not extend to the bayou; that vegetation exists between the end of the pavement to the bayou. 7. Existing right-of-way not required to preserve the street grid system. Attorney Bailey stated that preservation of the street grid system is important to the City; that Selby Gardens is aware of the City's concern of keep the street grid system of the City intact; that a southern extension of South Palm Avenue is not contemplated; that extending the southern part of South Palm Avenue would require a bridge over the bayou; that the residents of the Bay Point Park Neighborhood may view a bridge over the bayou as an intrusion into the neighborhood. Attorney Bailey continued that traffic will not be redirected from one parallel street to another; that the requirement to construct the cud-de-sac is one of the conditions precedent to BOOK 52 Page 23671 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. the actual street vacation; that Selby Gardens is in the process of developing an official master plan for adoption by the City. Attorney Bailey referred to a June 19, 2002, memorandum, from Dennis Daughters, Director of Engineering/City Engineer, included in the Agenda backup material and stated that the memorandum indicates Selby Gardens should provide a 20-foot wide access easement and construct a 12-foot wide pathway for the City's Bayfront Multi-Use Recreational Trail (MURT); that City Staff is of the opinion the street vacation is of limited public benefit or detriment; however, the loss of public use of the South Palm Avenue right-of-way could be mitigated if the MURT were provided; that discussions were held with City Staff regarding the MURT; that the MURT has not been officially adopted as to the placement, width, cost, or the manner in which the City will acquire the land; that the MURT only exists on public property and three private properties which are the Ritz-Carlton Hotel and Condominiums, the Sarasota Bay Club and Florida Power and Light (FPL) property; that the City has not demonstrated sufficient priority for the MURT to exercise condemnation powers; that several obstacles concerning the MURT are the manner in which the MURT will be funded, who will assume liability of the MURT, and who will maintain the MURT; that the installation of the MURT will consume a large amount of property; that Selby Gardens is a world-class facility but the smallest of its kind. Attorney Bailey referred to a site plan of Selby Gardens with an overlay of the proposed MURT displayed on the Chamber monitors and stated that the proposed MURT would extend along the Mound Street/US 41 frontage and consume approximately 10,500 square feet of Selby Gardens' property; that the standard of the MURT involves a 12-foot ribbon of concrete for skaters, walkers, joggers, etc., and a 4-foot horizontal clearance on each side with a 16-foot buffer between the concrete and the road; that the City has not adopted a standard for the MURT; that the City Staff has been accommodating as to design of the MURT; that the proposed street vacation of South Palm Avenue would increase the square footage of property for Selby Gardens by approximately 49,000 square feet; however, the proposed street vacation is still encumbered with utilities; that 27,000 square feet of the 49,000 will be left intact; that 7,850 square feet will be carved out of existing property with the installation of the cul-de-sac; that Selby Gardens has patiently acquired parcels over a number of years; that the three most recent acquisitions varied significantly in price per square foot; that the parcel BOOK 52 Page 23672 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. purchases totaled approximately $2.3 million; that the average price per square foot is approximately $36; that the MURT would require approximately $378,000 worth of the Selby Gardens' property; that the Selby Gardens is committed to remaining in Sarasota and has provided the community with the best use for the site; that Selby Gardens has a tremendous amount of debt on the property; that 10,500 square feet of property for the MURT would be a significant sacrifice; that the installation of a MURT would create a remnant of land on the north side of the Selby Gardens' property; that trees and buildings are current obstacles in the MURT pathway; that the alternatives to the ending point for the MURT could be discussed further. Attorney Bailey distributed copies of petitions from supporters to the Commission and stated that a letter in opposition of the street vacation dated May 3, 2002, from Lisa Illianna is included in the Agenda backup material; that Ms. Illianna resides in Hudson Harbor Condominiums located on the east side of Orange Avenue. Dr. Lowman stated that a meeting was held with the residents of the Bay Point Park Neighborhood and several residents in the condominiums adjacent to Selby Gardens; that several questions concerning noise were discussed; that two annual special events are held for fundraising; that five to six events are held annually for research programs; that activity at Selby Gardens, such as string quartets on a Sunday afternoons is low key; that the Gardens has limited parking. Attorney Bailey stated that Selby Gardens is not in a position to donate any property for the MURT; however, the Selby Gardens is willing to discuss the issue further. Vice Mayor Palmer asked the legal ramification, if any of the easement of South Palm Avenue? Attorney Bailey stated that South Palm Avenue has been platted several times in the past; that the area is one of the oldest in the City; that the underlying land was in fee-simple ownership; that South Palm Avenue was a platted street intended to provide access to the parcels being sold by the developer of the area; that Selby Gardens is burdened with the street until the City determines a street vacation is in the public interest. Vice Mayor Palmer asked if the easement was donated to the City by the property owners? BOOK 52 Page 23673 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Attorney Bailey stated that the property was donated to the City by means of a dedication. Vice Mayor Palmer asked if Selby Gardens is a member of the Transportation Management Organization (TMO)? Mr. Peter stated that Selby Gardens has been active with City Staff and involved with the Trolley, but not the TMO at this time. Dr. Lowman stated that a meeting was held with the TMO Executive Director due to encouragement from City Staff; that Selby Gardens anticipates working with the TMO. Attorney Bailey stated that a recent meeting with the TMO was very constructive; that the belief is the public has been unaware of the existence of the TMO until a recently. Vice Mayor Palmer stated that the hope is Selby Gardens will participate in the TMO; that the triangle parcel of land on the curved corner of Mound Street/US 41 which partly belongs to the City, State, and Selby Gardens is a physical barrier which is difficult to beautify; and asked if a partnership could be formed regarding the parcel. Attorney Bailey stated that the status of the land is unclear; that land fillings occurred on the parcel in the late 1960s to early 1970s; that Selby Gardens is willing to participate with the City and State regarding the beautification of the parcel of land. Vice Mayor Palmer asked if Selby Gardens is willing to work with the City cooperatively in developing the MURT even though not willing to dedicate any land to the MURT at the present time? Attorney Bailey stated yes; however, Selby Gardens is not in a position to dedicate property to the MURT. Commissioner Martin referred to the computer-generated slide depicting the improvements around Mound Street/US 41 and stated that the enhancements are attractive; that he frequently visits South Palm Avenue to view different vines for planting ideas; and asked if the enhancements along Mound Street/US 41 will include some of the similar vine designs displayed on South Palm Avenue? BOOK 52 Page 23674 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Mr. Peter stated that the area along Mound Street/US 41 from South Palm Avenue to Orange Avenue and south on Orange Avenue is currently in the permitting stage with the City; that enhancements, irrigation, and lighting will be installed as a see- through type of garden with a fence; that Selby Gardens' Horticulture Department is currently in the process of deciding the type of plants to install; that the area provides an opportunity to change garden elements and install plants which can be described to the public; that the hope is to enhance the bayfront at the same time. Dr. Lowman stated that South Palm Avenue will not be fenced off; that the public can still view the vine design ideas; that the new fence will also have a theme of vines of bio-diversity. Commissioner Martin stated that the street vacation is contingent upon the development of a master plan and the approval of a site plan; and asked the anticipated completion date for both? Mr. Scully stated that the first step of the improvements at Selby Gardens is the street vacation; that the integrity of the property should be in place before financial support can be sought for the master plan. Commissioner Martin asked if a parking area will be created on the corner of Mound Street/US 41 and Orange Avenue? Mr. Peter stated that parking for Selby Gardens will not be increased at this time; however, the possibility of a parking garage on the corner of Mound Street/US 41 and Orange Avenue will be discussed in the future with the City. Commissioner Martin stated that the corner of Mound Street/US 41 and Orange Avenue is not pedestrian and bicycle friendly and is the main issue regarding the MURT for the area; that cutting or rounding the corner should be evaluated during the development of the master plan. Attorney Bailey stated that Selby Gardens suggested widening the sidewalk as an alternative to the MURT. Commissioner Martin stated that discussions with City Staff regarding possible alternative designs for the MURT are appreciated; that the MURT is important to the Commission. Commissioner Quillin stated that enhancements to Selby Gardens are very exciting; that discussions have occurred with the Executive BOOK 52 Page 23675 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Director of the Gardens regarding the MURT; that the area on Mound Street/US 41 is personally envisioned as a multi-use plaza which will be integrated into Selby Gardens; that the area is lovely; and asked if Selby Gardens is in the process of obtaining a fence permit? Attorney Bailey stated that Selby Gardens donated property to the State for the installation of a sidewalk; that the sidewalk does not utilize the entire donated property; that Selby Gardens has requested permission from the State to install a fence closer to the sidewalk. Commissioner Quillin asked the reason the requested area for the fence cannot be utilized for the MURT? Attorney Bailey stated that the width of the MURT is the issue; that the request to the State is to place the fence closer to the sidewalk, not a request for property; that the fence includes moveable sections attached to permanent columns; that the fence issue must be resolved soon; that grant funding for the project expires on August 31, 2002. Commissioner Quillin stated that a State right-of-way currently exists along Mound Street/US 41; and asked the amount of additional space necessary for the MURT? Mr. Peter stated that the area along Mound Street/US 41 meanders; that the widest part of the current sidewalk is 10 feet; that the existing area would not work for a MURT. Commissioner Quillin stated that the current sidewalk is a straight line; that the MURT does not have to be a straight line; that 20 feet of cement is not the perception of a MURT. Attorney Bailey stated that 20 feet of cement was misspoken earlier; that the width of the MURT is 12 feet of cement; that City Staff indicated the possibility of the MURT meandering. Commissioner Quillin stated that long-range planning for Selby Gardens is a concern; that an agreement between the City, State and Selby Gardens is necessary for the MURT. Attorney Bailey stated that the area requested for the installation of the fence could be available for some type of MURT. BOOK 52 Page 23676 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Commissioner Quillin stated that the area on both sides of South Palm Avenue could be designed as some type of open area plaza; that Selby Gardens could possibility design the landscaping for the MURT section on Mound Street/US 41. Dr. Lowman stated that Selby Gardens' architect designed the curved triangle beach area on Mound Street/US 41 into an interactive space with benches; that the area could become an interactive plaza; that hope is to assist with the developing of the unattractive curved triangle beach area; that the MURT could narrow beyond the curved section of Mound Street/US 41 toward Selby Gardens; that pedestrians and bicyclists may wish to slow down to look at the plant designs. Commissioner Quillin stated that the perception for a plaza is an open area with heavy landscaping to coordinate with Selby Gardens from the curved triangle beach area of Mound Street/US 41 to Orange Avenue; that benches could be installed for visitors exiting the property who may be waiting for a trolley. Mr. Scully stated that Selby Gardens is prepared to lend expertise and provide guidance for a plaza type effort for the curved triangle beach area of Mound Street/US 41. Commissioner Quillin stated that South Palm Avenue is a beautiful tree-lined street; that installing pedestrian sleeves to Selby Gardens is a suggestion; that the intent of the area for the future should be in writing. Commissioner Servian stated that extending the MURT from the northern end of the City limits to Siesta Key is the intention of the City; that the area on Mound Street/US 41 in front of Selby Gardens is an important section to complete the connection; that a long-range goal of the City is to connect the Downtown with the Bayfront; that the willingness of Selby Gardens to assist the City with the obstacles existing for the curved triangle beach area of Mound Street/US 41 is pleasing; that developing the area will benefit Selby Gardens and the City; that assistance from Selby Gardens is necessary for the success of the MURT; that cooperation is necessary to assist the City in providing a pedestrian safe and friendly environment. Mayor Mason requested Staff to come forward for the City's presentation. BOOK 52 Page 23677 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Karin Murphy, Senior Planner II, Planning Department, came before the Commission and stated that the presentation from representatives of Selby Gardens was very detailed with a general preliminary outline for the placement of future structures; that Street Vacation Application No. 02-SV-03 as incorporated in proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389 requests a conditional vacation of a portion of the 60-foot wide South Palm Avenue public right-of-way generally described as bounded on the north by the south right-of-way of Mound Street/US 41 and extending to approximately 873 feet southward and bounded on the south by the waters of the Hudson Bayou; that the street vacation is the first step to Selby Gardens' long-range master planning process; that City Staff held several discussions with Selby Gardens Staff concerning long-range planning; that number of issues are evaluated for a street vacation as follows: - Required access to other properties. Ms. Murphy stated that legal counsel indicated Selby Gardens has aggregated all the properties which were provided access by South Palm Avenue. - Utilities within the easement. Ms. Murphy stated that a number of easements exist on South Palm Avenue; that language to relocate and/or provide easements for the existing utilities is included in proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389. - General public interest in the street vacation. Ms. Murphy stated that the Staff Report included in the Agenda backup material indicates the street vacation does not cause a public detriment; however, the public benefit is limited without a proffer for the MURT; that a June 17, 2002, memorandum, from Michael Connolly, Attorney, City Attorney's Office, included in the Agenda backup material indicated the requested MURT does not require major conditional use or a rezoning approval; that the MURT is a legislative item; therefore, the City cannot exact the MURT; that the Staff Report provides the MURT as an example of one of the ways in which the public benefit might be served; that the Commission may utilize the MURT example in weighing the decision regarding the street vacation; that the Staff Report indicates Selby Gardens intent to assist the City with the MURT; that language for a proffer is difficult without a site plan; that several unanswered question exist regarding the amount of BOOK 52 Page 23678 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. dedicated land necessary for the MURT; that Staff will have the ability to review for the possibility of a MURT at site plan stage. Ms. Murphy continued that its July 3, 2002, meeting, the Planning Board/Local Planning Agency (PBLP) held a public hearing and found Street Vacation Application No. 02-SV-03 as incorporated in proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389 consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan, also called the Sarasota City Plan, 1998 Edition (City's Comprehensive Plan); that the application satisfies the criteria for approval in the Zoning Code (1998 ed.); that the application was filed prior to the effective date of the Zoning Code (2002 Ed.) and is being processed under the Zoning Code (1998 ed.); that the PBLP recommended the street vacation without the MURT dedication; that the PBLP voted unanimously to recommend Commission approval of proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389 subject to the following conditions which must be satisfied prior to the effective date of the street vacation: 1. The Applicant shall execute and record a Utility Easement in favor of the City for the purpose of maintaining and repairing any existing water, sewer, drainage and re-use facilities within the portion of right-of-way proposed to be vacated. 2. The Applicant shall execute and record a Utility Easement in favor of the TECO/Peoples Gas Company for the purpose of maintaining and repairing any existing gas facilities within the portion of right-of-way proposed to be vacated. 3. The Applicant shall execute and record a Utility Easement in of the Verizon Florida, Inc., for the purpose of maintaining and repairing any existing telephone facilities within the portion of right-of- way proposed to be vacated. 4. The Applicant shall execute and record a Utility Easement in favor of Comcast Cablevision of Southwest Florida, Inc., for the purpose of maintaining and repairing any cable facilities within the portion of right-of-way proposed to be vacated. 5. The Applicant shall execute and record a Utility Easement in favor of the Florida Power and Light Company for the purpose of maintaining and repairing any existing electrical facilities within the portion of right-of-way proposed to be vacated. BOOK 52 Page 23679 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. 6. A condition precedent to the effective date of the street vacation of the area of right-of-way shall be the approval by the City Commission of the City of an updated Selby Gardens Master Plan by adoption of a resolution. 7. A condition precedent to the effective date of the street vacation of the area of right-of-way shall be the approval by the City Commission or the PBLP, whichever has final approval authority pursuant to the terms of the Zoning Code (2002 Ed.) of the Site Plan submitted by Applicant to implement the Master Plan for Selby Gardens. 8. A condition precedent to the effective date of the street vacation of the area of right-of-way shall be the final and completed construction of a cul-de-sac within the area of right-of-way in complete compliance with any and all relevant codes at a location consistent with the Selby Gardens Master Plan. 9. The City shall record a Notice of Effective Date of Street Vacation at such time as the Applicant has achieved adoption of the updated Selby Gardens Master Plan Ms. Murphy further stated that the Administration recommends passing proposed Ordinance No. 02-4389 on first reading with a condition of a proffer of the easement for and construction of the MURT. Vice Mayor Palmer stated that Selby Gardens has indicated the willingness to work with the City regarding the MURT; that the commitment for the MURT could be included in the language of the proposed Ordinance. Ms. Murphy concurred and stated that bringing the street vacation forward at this time allows Selby Gardens engineer and designer to incorporate the City's goals for the MURT, plaza space, and landscaping in the curved triangle beach area of Mound Street/US 41. Vice Mayor Palmer stated that the PBLP added a condition to require the Applicant to maintain the historical prospective of BOOK 52 Page 23680 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. the entrance and brick pavement up to the future cul-de-sac; that the condition is not indicated in the proposed Ordinance. Ms. Murphy stated that the Agenda backup material was distributed prior to the revised proposed Ordinance which requires the additional condition concerning the brick pavement. Sam Freija, Transportation Engineer, Engineering Department, came before the Commission and stated that the word "walk" was mentioned several times during the presentation; that City Staff is attempting to accomplish the goals and action strategies of the City's Comprehensive Plan by promoting walk ability; that the belief is Selby Gardens is of public benefit; however, the legal counsel for Selby Gardens failed to mention the public benefit for the actual street vacation; that City Staff conducted an analysis which indicated no public benefit or detriment from the street vacation; that City Staff suggested pursuit of the MURT through the street vacation could provide the public benefit. Mr. Freija referred to the architectural design from the Selby Gardens Master Plan displayed on the Chamber monitors and stated that legal counsel for Selby Gardens described the MURT as 12- foot concrete strip running through the greenery; that massive concrete for a future parking area is not a comparison to the 7,000 square feet of concrete for the MURT; that the definition of the MURT is a trail utilized for walking and bicycling; that a national standard currently exists for a MURT; that the MURT must be 20 feet away from Mound Street/US 41 for safety; that the mention of 16 feet of concrete is not accurate; that the width of the MURT is only 12 feet which can be varied; that City Staff is requesting an assurance for the commitment to rather than an actual design of the MURT, from Selby Gardens at this time; that the several aspects of extending the MURT north have been gridlocked; that a contractor has been hired by the City to design the MURT; that the MURT is already constructed and functioning in some areas such as in front of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel and Condominiums and the Sarasota Bay Club. Mr. Freija continued that the right-of-way in front of Selby Gardens on Mound Street/US 41 is 49,500 square feet; that legal counsel for Selby Gardens indicated the MURT would utilize approximately 10,500 square feet of Selby Gardens' property; therefore, the street vacation will increase Selby Gardens' property by approximately 22,500; that the 22,500 square feet of remaining property is a 2-to-1 ratio compared to the requested property for the MURT; that future intentions to gate the entrance to Selby Gardens on South Palm Avenue was discover BOOK 52 Page 23681 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. through discussions with Selby Gardens staff; that the complete use of the cul-de-sac by the public as indicated by legal counsel for Selby Gardens is inaccurate based on Selby Gardens' future intentions; that the understanding is the admission area will be at a gated entrance on South Palm Avenue. Mr. Freija further stated that pedestrians and bicyclists currently avoid Mound Street/US 41 and cut through Selby Gardens from Orange Avenue to access the Bayfront; that Selby Gardens staff has indicated the Orange Avenue access will be closed completely with a wall; that the public will be trespassing if attempting to cut through the property at Orange Avenue; that the intention of City Staff is to provide a safe access for the pubic to and from the Bayfront through the installation of the MURT. BOOK 52 Page 23682 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. The following people came before the Commission: Clarence Price, 4479 Ascot Circle South (34235), a member of the Marie Selby Gardens Associates (Associates), a group of supporters of Selby Gardens, and a volunteer of 14.5 hours a week at Selby Gardens, stated that a few minutes will be taken to speak on behalf of the Associates, the greeters at the Visitor Center, the docents at the Christy Paine Mansion, and the visiting public; that Selby Gardens is regarded as a jewel in downtown Sarasota but is a very small gem with 8.5 acres open to the public; that South Palm Avenue, a portion of which Selby Gardens is asking the City to vacate, takes up over an acre of space; that the vacation of South Palm Avenue is very important to the realization of the Master Plan for Selby Gardens and will result in the availability of an additional 3 acres for development; that Staff and Associates of Selby Gardens have spoken to many individuals, perhaps into the hundreds, who are in favor of the street vacation and would like to move forward with the street vacation; that Selby Gardens currently serves not only the local citizens of Sarasota but also people from all over the United States and the world; that Selby Gardens is known not only for beauty, tranquility, and history but also for the many events and meetings which Selby Gardens hosts; that the research is world renown as is Selby Gardens' concern for protecting the rain forests and other environmental matters; that many of the facilities such as the greenhouses, the herbarium, and the orchid and bromeliad display house are antiquated and require replacement and relocation elsewhere on the property; that having the property divided by South Palm Avenue is unrealistic, does not serve the public, and restricts expansion; that consideration of the request to better Sarasota in the future is requested. Marjorie Schmiel, 1209 Holly Fern Lane (34239), stated that she is a volunteer at Selby Gardens, having begun as a Display House Guide and becoming involved with the internship program after eight years which has been enjoyable; that becoming acquainted with all the wonderful people at Selby Gardens has been a goal and the most fun; that a significant number of supporters of Selby Gardens came to the current meeting and should be introduced individually; that the City has a real treasure in Selby Gardens; that Selby Gardens is also a world treasure; that Selby Gardens is the smallest working botanical garden in the United States; that in addition to all of the display houses and the grounds' beauty, Selby Gardens has a beautifully functioning research department which has collections including rare and endangered plants kept in the six greenhouses; that Selby BOOK 52 Page 23683 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. Gardens also features a herbarium which has many pressed plants, a number of which are on slides or preserved in other ways; that Selby Gardens has one of the best collection of flowers in the world; that Bruce Holst, Director of Collections, is present in the audience and is in charge of the flower collection; that anyone wishing to have a bromeliad identified can send the plant to Selby Gardens for identification, which is another reason for Selby Gardens' importance; that the Bromeliad Identification Center will identify the plant; that Harry Luther, Bromeliad Specialist, is present and knows more about bromeliads than anyone in the world. Ms. Schmiel continued that John Beckner, Orchid Identification Center, is not present but recently made a presentation on public radio concerning a new orchid which has been identified by the Orchid Identification Center; that many things can be learned at the Visitors Center; that Selby Gardens also has an ecology program for which Bruce Rinker, Director of Research and Conservation, is responsible; that Dr. Lowman was the head of the program prior to becoming the Executive Director of Selby Gardens; that many other topics regarding Selby Gardens can be discussed; however, time is limited; that an invitation is extended to the public to come and see Selby Gardens; that the Commission is urged to give Selby Gardens a chance to utilize all the property which Selby Gardens has fought for over 27 years to acquire; that Selby Gardens requires every inch of the property since all the facilities, including the research department, should be located on the same campus; that presently the Research Department is located across US 41 from Selby Gardens; that all the facilities of Selby Gardens could be located on the same property if the street vacation of South Palm Avenue is approved; that Selby Gardens is the City's and the world's treasure. Dr. Bob Windom, 5450 Eagles Point Circle #403 (34231), stated that he has been a citizen of the City for many years; that in the 1960s, he practiced medicine in the City and made a number of house calls over the years to Christy and Helen Paine who lived in the house which is now a major part of Selby Gardens; that no one in the old days could have imagined Selby Gardens growing into such a magnificent center for the community and the country; that by serving on the Advisory Counsel, a great deal has been learned about the activities at Selby Gardens; that the Commission is encouraged to seriously consider moving forward and vacating South Palm Avenue so the dreams can become a BOOK 52 Page 23684 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. reality for Selby Gardens; that the Commission is requested to make a decision so Selby Gardens can expand further. Jarod Prentice, 811 South Palm Avenue (34236), stated that a distinction should be made between public parks/preserves and true botanical gardens; that botanical gardens are cultural institutions recognized as a part of the national museum system and offer a view of global and local biological diversity; that a botanical garden by definition is an institution organized to maintain plant collections to serve educational, scientific, aesthetic, or economic purposes; that the term "public garden" is an all-encompassing phrase to describe all public gardens such as arboretums, horticulture gardens, and public parks/preserves; that true botanical gardens differ from public gardens as the focus of a botanical garden is research, education, and conservation, including land acquisitions; that a botanic garden is research based, meaning plants can be cataloged and collections used to obtain a variety of genetic material; that scientific communities are comprised of arborists and botanists to ornithologists and zoologists; that the general public communities consist of artists and horticultural societies, students, and teachers; that the requirement for botanical garden may be unseen; however, tourism, population dynamics, and the possible loss of nature support the reason for the existence of botanical gardens. Mr. Prentice further stated that botanical gardens provide a place for the rejuvenation of the human spirit; that botanical gardens can provide the general public with places to escape, commune with nature, and give a vision of a better world; that the overall effect on people visiting botanical gardens is to feel better about themselves and the world; that being an accredited horticulturist through academia and a naturalist by life experiences, all these aspects have been provided to him by Selby Gardens which has provided an educational institution for his current internship and a destination place for a class field trip last year; that seeing the anticipation of taxonomists work towards classifying the new species of orchid recently identified and working directly with local plant societies in outreach efforts and to promote conservation to increase bio- diversity have been positive experiences; that outreach and promotion of conservation to increase bio-diversity are major and important missions of true botanical gardens and is also true for Selby Gardens; that botanical gardens must continue to grow in the future and provide educational programs; that Local and State government officials must continue to support the efforts of facilities like Selby Gardens; that the inspiration BOOK 52 Page 23685 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. for future generations regarding conservation education should continue so all can have air to breathe. Ann Esworthy, 303 Church Street (34272), 27-year volunteer at Selby Gardens, stated that Virginia Salomon who is in attendance but will not be speaking has been a volunteer at Selby Gardens longer than herself; that both of them began as volunteers working with plants and realized the importance of having people be aware of the happenings at Selby Gardens; that both of them started a program at Selby Gardens to train guides to greet the public and explain the function of Selby Gardens; that at the time, the City did not realize all the activities at Selby Gardens in the same way as people in other parts of the world; therefore, an auxiliary group was formed with five other ladies and called the Selby Gardens Associates (Associates), which has enhanced the image of Selby Gardens within the City; that the Associates started the Orchid Ball, decorated the museum and the grounds at Christmas time, and began a speakers bureau to speak about Selby Gardens to make the City aware of the rare treasure Selby Gardens is to the City; that the City is now aware of Selby Gardens; that being part of a volunteer group with now over 800 members has been a privilege; that the volunteers are dedicated to making things work well; that maintaining cooperation between the City and Selby Gardens is very important. Michael Pender, Jr., 4803 Winchester Drive (34234), stated that he is on the Advisory Committee for Selby Gardens, is a long time resident of Sarasota, and is a supporter of many of the local scientific and cultural organizations; that Sarasota is considered one of the premier places to visit due to the cultural amenities and all which is offered here; that the community greatly prospers by the economic base the cultural institutions bring to Sarasota; that Selby Gardens is a scientific center with great international significance and influence; that he accompanied Dr. Lowman to India last summer and had the opportunity to meet with many scientists from around the world, many of whom spoke about the conferences in Sarasota and the scientific finds displayed and presented to them; that the scientists have high opinion of Selby Gardens and Sarasota and look forward to visiting again to learn more; that scientists, children, and tourists come from all over the world to see, learn, and enjoy the wonders of nature on display at Selby Gardens; that Selby Gardens offers many fine programs; that expanding the wonderful botanical programs offered is in BOOK 52 Page 23686 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. the best interest of Selby Gardens as well as the community, which is the reason the Commission is requested to consider approving the street vacation; requested that all the people present in the audience to support Selby Gardens but not speaking to stand; and the majority of the audience rose to demonstrate support for Selby Gardens. Michael Saunders, 1801 Main Street (34236), was no longer present in the Chambers. Brenda Patten, 720 South Orange Avenue (34236), former member of the Board of Trustees of Selby Gardens (Board), stated that during her tenure on the Board, she had the privilege and opportunity of participating in the process of selecting an architect to design the proposed master plan for Selby Gardens; that Selby Gardens had issued a request for proposals and was astounded at the quality of architects who responded; that one architect had just won the equivalent of the Nobel Prize in architecture and was interested in the project, not for the money but rather for the opportunity to participate in designing a world class conservatory for a botanical garden; that vacating South Palm Avenue is the first step in a new master planning process for Selby Gardens; that no changes will take place at Selby Gardens for many months if South Palm Avenue is vacated at this time; that South Palm Avenue will remain an entry street until the master planning process is completed; that Selby Gardens' expansion will not occur until the master plan is brought to the Commission and approved and the funds raised for construction; that the architects and designers could begin to use all the collective creative energies to develop many alternatives for a world class facility if South Palm Avenue is vacated at this time; that the master planning process cannot begin without knowing the status of South Palm Avenue; that the Commission is encouraged to approve the street vacation of South Palm Avenue and defer any decision concerning the MURT since the master plan will come back for a full review by the City Staff and approval by the Commission; that attempting to design the MURT at this time prior to receiving input from Selby Gardens' architects and the City's consultants is premature; that the MURT is apparently the primary issue at this time; that the Commission could approve the street vacation with a condition to defer consideration of the MURT until the master plan is presented to the Commission for review; that Selby Gardens and donors are willing to pay for the ideas and creative input of the architects and professional planners; that the Commission is requested to provide the flexibility to work with the professionals to design a campus of which everyone will be very BOOK 52 Page 23687 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. proud; that any action concerning the MURT should be deferred until the master plan is presented for consideration. Philip Dasher, 928 Boulevard Of The Arts (34236), Chairman of the Sarasota County Bicycle/Pedestrian Committee (Committee), displayed a chart of the County's 1999 Bicycle Plan indicating proposed connectors in the City on the Chamber monitors and stated that the MURT is extremely important as a connector; that the Committee was involved in the planning and construction details of the connectors; that the critical connector between Orange Avenue and the Bayfront is indicated in the chart as utilizing South Palm Avenue through Selby Gardens and to Orange Avenue; that only one opportunity is presented to make the connector happen; that the connector will be lost forever if not part of the street vacation; that the MURT is envisioned as running from Orange Avenue north to the University of South Florida; that most of the MURT is completed; that some critical areas, for example, around the Sarasota Quay, exist; that solutions for the critical areas are being sought; that the MURT serves the entire County; that the Bayfront belongs to all; that the connection will be lost forever if South Palm Avenue is vacated without the connection. Mr. Dasher continued that Selby Gardens is a wonderful addition to the City but is not a charity; that the quid pro quo should be the City receives something for the property being vacated; that too much property has been given to developers so an additional profit can be made; that now is the time to consider the benefit for the general public; that another gated community will be created if South Palm Avenue is vacated and gated without public access; that the Parks + Connectivity Master Plan was reviewed by the PBLP and will be presented shortly to the Commission; that the Committee also reviewed the Parks + Connectivity Master Plan and made comments; that the Parks + Connectivity Master Plan clearly demonstrates the necessity for the MURT along the Bayfront at the Selby Gardens property; that the MURT as indicated in the Parks + Connectivity Master Plan should be developed; that a short sidewalk is not sufficient; that a MURT is for multi-uses and is utilized by everyone, including pedestrians, children, people with baby carriages, in- line skaters, etc.; that the Bayfront is a jewel; that to not have the connector and to approve the street vacation without the connector would be a detriment to the public interest; that a quid pro quo is required; that the connection is within reach; that the chart indicates the connectors necessary and the off- BOOK 52 Page 23688 08/12/02 6:00 P.M. and on-road facilities; that obtaining off-road facilities near the Downtown area is almost impossible; that connectivity is the major concern in the County's Bicycle Plan and is a major element of the Parks + Connectivity Master Plan; that the issue is connectivity, which is the means of going from one part of the City to another safely. Mr. Dasher further stated that Andres Duany, Principal, FAIA, Duany Plater-Zyberk & Company (DPZ), who developed the Downtown Master Plan 2020, indicated distinctly the City must be pedestrian and bicycle friendly; that the City is not pedestrian and bicycle friendly; that extending the MURT on the Bayfront in the vicinity of Selby Gardens would be a major step in becoming pedestrian and bicycle friendly. Mayor Mason asked if anyone else had signed up to speak and seeing none, requested that the Applicant come forward for rebuttal. Attorney Bailey stated that City Staff indicated Selby Gardens had not presented a case for the public benefit of the street vacation; that se

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a1e4fb69eacebe0321eb519fb5f52497. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record