POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, January 20, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 117,679 stored characters

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch district one hopefully burdis. >> District 2 Council vice chair Randy Gabbert district 3 and not marry. Lisette can away. Deborah big Sanders. And Council chair Gina Driscoll district 7 Lisa Wheeler Bowman. And district day Richie Floyd. >> Good afternoon everyone will call to order the Jan. 20th 2022 meeting of the St. Petersburg City Council. We'll start with the roll call please for this here and bird on to marry air. And what's. Driscoll here. We were building Floyd here. If we could all please stand for the invocation followed by the pledge of allegiance. Joining us for today's invocation is minister Leon Carol from Pinellas community church. >> Good afternoon everyone, thank you for having me thank you then we bow hands heavenly father we come before you humbly today as keen to bless the proceedings of this meeting and as we do so far that is what I think each and every member that is standing here to serve this Council as they've taken many very past to get here father and ultimately was your divine hand of appointment that has led them here today to serve this city and with that in mind but I just pray that there be unity and open hearts and open minds as you know the challenges in the issues that lay before this Council today. I pray GOD that you just give them clarity you give them wisdom and strength and conviction as they go forth to lead us into a better tomorrow I thank you things even less. This city with and this Council with and other things that you continue to do for us and I future the most holy impresses Jesus name we pray. The men. The United States of America and to the Republic which is stand one nation and if that in the visible with liberty and justice. >> Thank you MISTER Harrell for the lovely invocation thank you for joining us today. Council members we have an agenda before us with a couple of changes. We are adding item d one a proclamation for national mentoring month. Also a change item c b 8 has been moved to reports with those Entertain a motion for approval. For approval. That can. We have a motion in a second. Saying that there's no further discussion will the clerk please open the machine for voting, just one confirmed it was council member and it was that made the initial motion. Well PRESIDENT Council members please cast your votes. They met all PRESIDENT Council members have voted will the clerk please tallying announced the votes. I'm sure the motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with council member Garrett been absent. We have a consent agenda before us I'll entertain a motion for approval of the consent agenda moved. I can. We have a motion in a second to approve today's consent agenda. Seeing that there are no requests to speak with the clerk please open the machine for voting. All present council members please cast your votes. They met all present council members have voted by the clerk please telling announced the votes and chair of the motion to approve the consent agenda passage of time. Remember Gabbert think absent. Thank you. We'll go next to open forum. MADAM Clerk do we have any speakers for today's open forum. MADAM Read the statement first open statement and we do have some hardest hit are Sir effect thank you. If you wish to address City Council, the subjects other than public hearing because I did issue items on the agenda please sign up with the clerk. Only individuals wishing to speak we signed the open for in cheek. Well, the city residents as a property business owners in the city where their employees me speak all issues discussed and are open for must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you're speaking to an item on the agenda. You MAY only speak once during the open for him when it comes up on the agenda in order to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address Council. Each individual be given 3 minutes to speak and after which the microphone will be muted. If you wish to address City Council to zoom meeting you misuse the raise hand feature button and the zoom app interest or 9 on your phone at the time the agenda item is addressed. When it is your turn to speak, you will be muted and asked to state your name and address. At the conclusion of the comments when you have reached the 3 minute time limit. You will be muted. All raised his we'll be load after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation used normal rules apply including the 3 minute time limit on comments. The requirement that any prison that Ariel presentation material must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum if life public comment is disrupted. I violations of the rules of decorum is the chair is authorized to accept public comments. Alternate means including by email only and we do have some speakers me. Thank you bill called the first 2 speakers and once served your name has been called. We do have 2 podiums here from which he MAY speak. The sketch of the empty one. Thanks. >> Call the first 2 speakers at least a black shoe and I believe is Jenna Kaufman and Kaufman please state your name and address for the record and you will have 3 minutes to address City Council. Yes, thank you. MISTER Clerk. Lisa Blackshear 39 to k Street South. Before My presentation I just want to thanks for the record that I stand in solidarity with captain Christian and I think Saint Pete pier, Dolphin cruises attended the Dec. 16th meet in. And it was I don't. It was voted on to explore the option Given Tampa. They watch a cease and desist order for operate in as an l c when they have a non-profit this is a Tampa Bay water keeper had by the way that Tampa Bay watch. MISTER Clerk. >> See on here again, I'm I'm going to be here every week advocated for cross walks in the cleanup of leaking the glory. And this is a legislative districts of a 6, 5, I'm here you have the link mcgorry. >> Picnic Park on this project was partially funded by the wind water conservation fund through the us Department of interior and the National Park Service and well the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. So. Just like that the city of St. Petersburg has an ample not have jurisdiction when it comes to the maintenance. >> And the upkeep of the lake and the lake is in decline and has been I can hear in NOVEMBER advocating for clean up. Obviously take their had his stormwater department out there there was a a men's room at the inn use integrate all to remove that debris from the park. Advocating for council members fix Sanders MADAM Chair just small to allocate in the f y 23, fiscal for harvester which is the correct machinery to remove the debris in the diligent matter. This is kept as we're talking about and they need to be removed from the room, their respective other to the budget. >> I'll ask you to if we can have the administration actually take aerial footage of the lake to know how to come up with a sustainable plan to maintain the lake respect of of administration here you have a boardwalk in decline and you also see encroachments of vegetation on an easement this is against municipal code. And it's not up to code. And I just want to play in. Here's a picture of me in my normal civic engagement routine talking to MR. Zeidan Christopher deliveryman cookies as attempt to clean about the lake and I do what I think the administration for this event last week in slowing down 9th Street. I did notice several days ago. There is an Allowed the cars to know what their speed is and yesterday when I see it. There was a cart of the 27 miles per hour. So it is working and what everyone though was here matters of the game that matters and people come down here, you know. >> Thank you to the City Council to let me speak. I wanted. Address affordable housing. We are in a crisis. Our governor is doing the best he can with no keeping you know our population under so like you know from offending us too much and bringing in other viruses to our area. I have on my name is Adam summary. I'm from I live at 2, 5, 0, 58 Street North in St. Petersburg I I appreciate this opportunity to address housing and it's getting worse because all other states are in crisis as well with all the tornadoes in you know people choosing their homes and I see a High rise buildings going up through the expensive. I'm on a fixed income I can afford too much money. I always worked. But the nearby says security doesn't cover a whole lot. And I would like to have something available our seniors, so they don't have to live on the street. I didn't move to Florida to live on the Had I I thank you very much for your work and I know it's a big taste because you have a lot of people here that you got to take care of and I appreciate letting me stay here from the bottom of my heart, thank you. >> Makes 2 speakers, MADAM Chair caught up for William Kilgore please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to a City Council. Carlos Correa 3, 4, 5, 5th avenue North. I'm here with a St. Petersburg tenants union to talk about the $750,000 that the city is considering giving to the contemporary arch I have to buy the property on Russell Street South. Tenants all over St. Petersburg are feeling the impacts of the current housing crisis exacerbated exacerbated by the pandemic there's a desperate need for permanently affordable housing for working people not affordable housing only stays affordable for 30 years like this property want what happens after those 30 years are up. Well this property is in the hands of chaff after the 30 years expire. Those units will most likely go up to the market rate of rat which at this rate will drive out any working class tenants who live there. That's a problem and that's what we're seeing now on this is already a rapidly gentrify area people who have lived. Places decades are seeing exorbitant rent increases and being displaced from their homes since their founding in 1992 chop is filed over 500 evictions including nearly a dozen during the pandemic how will chaff guarantee that none of these tenants are displaced like they promise what this really is a transfer of wealth from the public to the private sector draining public resources for only temporary affordability we do need to invest in housing. But the real because of this the real core issue is that housing is treated as a as a commodity rather than human right in order to ensure poor permanent affordable forward ability of the church the city should off use the power of eminent domain to purchase the property themselves, you know the city knows what eminent domain is from the Tropicana field and I'm just 2 days ago, someone who was born and raised in Saint p who was born in the gas plant was evicted from their home and I'm going out on to the streets, you know the place came blocked lock everything up and they had to go so that's what's happening in our city. The private sector has not been able to ensure that people can stay in their homes. So we should not be giving away taxpayer dollars You know a private entity like chop off who has previously thrown out people on to this some people out on to the streets. During a pandemic so thank you. >> Thank u next speaker please. But as William Kilgore with the St. Petersburg tenants union I reside in the Ponce de Leon neighborhood here in Saint Pete. I again I'm I'm a here to on that yeah that reports a f 2 about the funding for the 12 units ever on Russell Street. You know said the thing is is look you know, I'm not against. Funding for affordable housing obviously but that the issue the real issue where what lies here is this. The idea that we're subsidizing. You private entity in order to take care of it that the housing issue so look we're we're looking at $750,000 that's over half of the amount chaff is paying for these 12 properties why are we why do we not have Cole ownership in this arrangement. You know that's the thing and you have these covenants where they you know agreed to keep these units affordable for 30 years. You know when that 30 years is up right this is you know chaff could decide to sell it. They they made, you know boost those rants back up you know so it's a it's a bad It's like a really when you talk about putting a band-aid everyone says rang controls like a bandit it's not intended to be a long-term solution, but this is really a band-aid you know when you look at it, you know we need to be looking at things social housing land trust we need to be looking at the city having public ownership. You know over more land in places too keep permanent affordability this is an issue in bla tenants union has it written about this and talk about this extensively in their city which is obviously l a's had a housing boom a lot longer than Saint Pete. You know so they've had this sort of structure where they you know they subsidize. You know private entities to you know to keep housing affordable for for certain number of years and then what happens right and then that time comes up in and all of a sudden. Those units are boosted up to market rate. You know so that's something that you know we really need to be looking at. When we're looking at you have proper tease, I know there you know technically a nonprofit, but you know they they do they are connected with the for-profit llc yeah nonprofit doesn't. I mean you're you know just doing this out of that kind of see your heart and all So I think we you know we need to be be looking at that. You know in and take note the chaff has evicted people during the pandemic they filed. 500 evictions actually says that the stay was in the past decade at since their inception who knows it could have been many many more so that's the thing I just wanted to raise awareness about that and bring that to your attention we need social housing. We need public options. We need to stop subsidizing you know private industry, a private entities in relying on them to provide housing because thus far they failed because that's what we've been doing that's kind of been business as usual. And that needs to change and we need to get a public option. In in housing and keeping housing permanently affordable. Thank you very much. >> Please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to address City Council. My name is Joseph maturo a little 1, 3, 5 92nd Avenue Northeast here in St. Petersburg my own preferred yachts which is a company that started back in 1984 downtown Saint Pete. Been around Rain in business for a long time. My concern is. I've had a request for a slip of the same people this Marina for quite a long time. My office is actually located over the Hart bridge Marina. Build a floating office there we've been. Now part of the waterfront community for quite a long time. My concern is I don't understand how the process at the same people this Marina been on the waiting list for a long time. I see other people going ahead of me and I'm supposed to be one of the top names on the list. I don't know what the system is so my concern is what is that system and how does this work. You know I don't understand how it could be right at the top of the list and see people jump over me and get a slip. So I'm hoping the council takes us up and kind of looks into it. It's a MISS Treats not the way it should be there should be a list or should be a procedure should be a following. But again you know see that there's a transparency and I don't think that's the case. The Saint Pete this Marina are the same people chose going on right now I have an exhibit there. I thought it was important enough for me to leave the boat show to come here to address this issue because the family not the only one I know other people have had the same issue with being on the waiting list. You know those docks are so doggone important to our future here in downtown St. Petersburg this is a boating community and a lot of industry is you know circles around the of the boating community. I think is really really important that we take care of those folks that are here local. There's some people got slips they're they're not even part of this community. And I just scratch, my head. So that somebody can kind of look into this and give us some sort of explanation. I for one will be greatly appreciative thank you all for your time. >> Good Eugene in the middle congratulations. You're graduating is do you counsel people. Thank you so much a share the same thing as you all share is the ability to stand out. The names are been chained 5515 pine circle, Northeast. But I do share the same as you guys putting yourself out there. Open yourself up for community to do what you think's best for St. Petersburg so for you new people on for generation native of St. Petersburg on the captain and peer Dolphin cruises down at get a My great grandfather was the the ferry captain before the sunshine Skyway is even built. And I spoke at these meetings a few times with some of my my issues first of all I want to state that I'm not scared of competition. There's another captain hear that used to be right next to me for a year and a half we work together. Their boat had Dolphin cruises their boat sunset cruises advertise but they're a different boat. It was McDonald's and Burger King rather than McDonald's McDonald's. But the reason I'm here today is to follow up on what happened last meeting 1216. You all took it upon yourself and listen to me and I appreciate that and you unanimously passed a motion for a cease and desist for Tampa Bay watch. As you know that you guys subsidize there their center and then they were and there. Lisa says that they there are a lot of one vessel to be dock behind. Doc Ford's for educational purposes. And the city agreed that they were not doing Education's they moved into commercial slip. And they said well we made them pay for that commercial slipped laced passed up 22 other businesses and then now they are acting as a commercial entity. It does say in their lease that if they lose they're not for-profit status that their lease is terminated. And it doesn't say the least who who comes up with that term or whatever, but I think it's pretty obvious that I'm competing against a business that subsidized by the city of St. Petersburg and it makes it nearly impossible. Again I'm not scared of competition. You know I want to be an ambassador for city I want to take people out and show good time. If they stay I'm not going to do that I'm not gonna be able to compete against business set up that way and if they leave they can still going clean up the Bay. And they're right now from Jan. 3rd until probably next week we're down because I'm putting 10's of thousands of dollars in my boat to build up my business. In Tampa Bay watch just sits there and watches should be really interesting for their donate ers to know that they sit there and read books and hang out they're not doing anything to clean up the Bay or help the Bay. They just coach and grab customers off the pier which is in commercial. If you're a commercial lease or of the city Marina we're not a lot of advertise on the other side of those fences. If you've been down there with a black fences and all our boats are parked right there. We can't go the other side. We can't do that. But they're allowed to so they're allowed to get all that traffic. So it's I'm not asking not to compete. I'm asking for fair competition, I'm asking to not compete against somebody that subsidized by the city. Thank you. Thanks for listening to we have any other speakers. Yes we do have 2 more speakers next 2 speakers, Chris waters and Michael Miller. Once you get either podium please state your name and address for the record you have 3 minutes to address City Council. Good afternoon. My name is Chris waters, I'm a resident of the Broadwater maximum arena area here in St. Petersburg I'm also here on behalf of captain Christian and peer Dolphin cruises this is something that was brought to my attention and it doesn't take much to look into this to realize that if it you know, smells funny that it's something that probably funny it's not a whole lot of secret here it's doesn't take much to look into their activities. What they're doing how they're holding themselves out and who they're competing with in blatant unfair advantage that they hold by being subsidized by the city. But having all these additional rules that you know are granted permission to break. This is a private business somebody exactly like our city and every all of our residents, our cities strive to be they want to be successful and build something up and here he is in the middle of having this dropped on him want to to further something that he said when they were at behind Doc Ford's they were moved to appear not only did they jump over other business owners to get a slip there with no no procedure no nothing it was a something what was done again without a lot of transparency. But here they are right next to him. Claiming you know eco adventure and it's almost like they draft their website just enough to leave a veil over what they're doing mean read read their website read how they advertise their events. It's a it's a it's a it's an odd way to phrase what they're doing which is selling Dolphin in sunset tours and Christmas snow to ers on their boats and I'm just very strange and again if it doesn't pass the smell test. There's probably something there it doesn't take much for this one. For them to be competing directly next to him and under cutting all of his prices were going to because of the city subsidizing this non for profit believe there's air quotes for the record. He's this is a private business it's going to go under. Again I'm a local attorney here and you don't have to be an attorney to look at this and say something's not right. And unfortunately the consequences are going to happen a lot quicker than maybe on the council's even prepared for last time I thought appropriate measures were taken when there was talk of an immediate cease and desist I'm surprised city lawyers have not looked deeper into this generally they don't want to be litigating these issues but having this open is is likely going to go that direction is no doubt. But it shouldn't have to it's very obvious. What's going on it doesn't take the mind of a lawyer to look at this and say something's not right so again I would implore that the council look into this and take this matter seriously. There are 20 plus members that are local businesses that have tried to be getting the slips in downtown Saint Pete, and they were jumped the moment that that vote was kicked out a Doc Ford's and was position here because of they were commercial activities. The writing was on the wall I have reviewed the least that they signed it specifically says if they were doing something commercial that the city would have their sole discretion in terminating their lease. I think that's the option here that should be most seriously considered thank you very much for me today. Councilmember thank you Mike Miller, 1416, 51st Avenue Northeast. A 5th generation St. Petersburg and a 20 year veteran of the Coast Guard just retired. I'm here on behalf of Christian of a chain as well, I'm having a nonprofit run up against him is like on the Coast Guard run up against Cito in tow. There's no way that seatow or 2 we'll be able to survive. The Coast Guard went out on every single call. If you're supporting her giving money to a nonprofit that's running right up against Business he's going to he's going to lose that battle, there's no way that he can sustain himself, running up against funded city money. Just can't happen. Thank you. >> Thank you to have any more speakers more speaker MADAM Chair bill wars. Please state your name and address for the record you have 2 minutes to address City Council. Thanks Bill Thank you PRESIDENT 21 by a grand shore a local business owner, myself but I'm a captain of spent my entire life on the water. A family begin the voting and known Christian is family for a very long time. I kind of hate to be saying I'm back here. You know I was just here in DECEMBER with Christian spoke to guys to try and bring this to your attention that. It it's it's very clearly something's wrong here you're dealing a good organization Tampa Bay. Watch I think there are great and today there are good. You know. Stuart of the city in the water and the bay and they do good things but in this case. How they managed to get a boat into the docks that were just built a Doc Ford's that were for private use only they were given the ability and their lease too have a floating classroom after weeks of of complaints and advertisements from them on Dolphin cruises ins and sunset son. Winter you know holiday parties that clearly that vote was operating as a commercial vessel, they're charging people their advertising on the pier which right away is is is not fair to anybody and they had a front row spot will the city the city Marina said you know pay we agree so you guys as the city of admitted the Tampa Bay watch is not acting as a not for profit charity and to deep floating classroom, right, however, those words come together. They said no they are commercial business. So great so then at that moment, Tampa Bay lot should be at the bottom of the list behind the 22 other business owners that are on that list look at that list is a few pretty high profile individuals in this town that were passed up. And that's not right. Right as long as soon as they became a commercial business. They should be in line with everybody else. And that's not what happened they were stuck directly next to Christian and now they advertised off its a 100% of business they sell water. They some Dolphin. Tours a check out the birds wildlife they want to get out see the Bay which is great, but unfortunately just jumped everybody they're directly competing with Christian. And then I was here last the last meeting when you guys said we're going to look into this the managers will be held accountable. The of the marina. You guys are going to sit down with and go through what the process was how did we just jumped 20 other businesses you know how are they allowed to be operating there also advertising at a center that we pay for us citizens. They're now advertising and sending people back to their boat to go out and pay for for Dolphin cruises site. I think you know like like like someone also said here that that doesn't smell right, something obviously is going on. You know there's been you know comments made by unnamed sources that you know they're willing to fight this legally and go after Christian which I think is a very poor sounding. Charity nonprofit entity here you know this is not right what's happening. The worst because I'm sure. Thank you for before we move on wanted to just ask a quick question of the administration to follow up because we have had. Some comments about the slip into law and this is something that came up in DECEMBER and we asked at that time for an update from from city staff could you give us. Time certain when we will have that update so that we can. Hash this out and make some clarification Zen and all understand what's truly happening here. Yes, MADAM Chair, so. Our intention is to bring a report on the Feb. 3rd Council agenda. Chris balestra and his team and Josie only are working on that currently. And I will mention so we'll be ready for the Feb. 3rd meeting to have a report on these various issues. Now tomorrow is the deadline for all that backup materials I ask a little forbearance of Council for us too put that on the agenda tomorrow. But give us until the ads and the leaves Fri. To have the backup material submitted to Council so the us you'll still have a week to review that prior to that the council meeting but. It there's a lot to unpack and we're working through that we just want to make sure that the information that we is the best at it. You know we can give you at that time. All right that's fair. I appreciate that and I appreciate the the commitment having that discussion on Feb. 3rd. All right. Thank we'll go ahead and. Get to our next item which is item d one a proclamation for national mentoring month. And to give this proclamation today I'd like to give a big warm welcome him to our deputy mayor Stephanie Iowans good afternoon deputy mayor. chair Driscoll good afternoon members of the council. I am pleased to be before you today to present this proclamation to de Pere Bushman would you like to join me please who is accepting on behalf of Pinellas County schools, the Office of strategic partnerships family and community relations. So welcome and I will read the proclamation. JANUARY 20, 22. Well mark the 20th anniversary of national mentoring month. An annual campaign to focus attention on the need for mentors as well as how each of us can work together to increase the number of mentors to help ensure positive outcomes for our young people and whereas St. Petersburg honors bottom tier mentors who support young people by showing up for them every day and demonstrating their commitment to helping them thrive. And where as mentoring programs in Pinellas County can make our communities. And our state stronger by driving impactful relationships that increase social capital for young people and provide invaluable support networks and where has during covid 19 pandemic mentoring programs have stepped up to fill gaps for young people and families connecting them with resources and ensuring that mentoring relationships continue virtually to ensure that physical distancing does not mean social disconnection. And where's mentoring plays a pivotal role. In career exploration and supports workplace skills by helping young people set career goals equipping mentors with the skills needed to support the professional growth of young people and drives positive outcomes for young people and businesses and whereas entering promotes healthy relationships and communication, positive self esteem emotional well-being and growth of the young person and their relationships with other adult. And where students who meet regularly with their mentors are more than 52% less likely then their peers to skip a day of school and youth who face an opportunity gap but have a mentor. I 55% more likely to be enrolled in college. And those who did not have a mentor. And whereas youth who meet regularly with their mentors are 46% likely than their peers to start using drugs. And 27% less likely to start drinking. And whereas almost half of today's young adults report having a mentor in their youth. And those rates appear to have been rising steadily over the past several dis decades. And whereas national mentoring month. Is the time of the year to celebrate elevate and encourage mentoring across our city and state and recruit caring adult mentors in St. Petersburg now therefore I on behalf of Kenneth t Welsh mayor the city of St. Petersburg and on behalf of the citizens. That's St. Petersburg here by for claim. Jan. 20 22. As national mentoring month. In the city of St. Petersburg. Thank you so much for your service and the work that you do for you. >> Thank you deputy Marin and thank you for everything that you do for you think it really matters and I'm glad to take time for us all to recognize that great work today. >> We'll go next to the new ordinance is item e e one. Report proposed ordinance number 1, 1, 2, 3, dash the in order to prove to the occasion and 11 foot-wide North slash South alley between lots 2021. Mcadoo's we platted in 1921, located between commercial adding South first Avenue South in the edge district within the in town with redevelopment area sitting 4th conditions for the vacation to become effective and providing for an effective date. The public hearing for this I didn't scheduled for Feb. The 10th. And we do have a card. >> Thank you before we get to our speakers we will. And conducted cities presentation. Good afternoon. >> Good afternoon council members for the record my name is Cheryl Berg a low staff planner with development review services. This ordinance is related to a request for an alley vacation. The alley is located southwest of commercial Avenue South between central av and First Avenue South. The applicant owns the land to the east and west of the alley. Which on this image is outlined in red. The alley is currently a dead-end alley which is being used as part of a parking lot. The alley does not connect directly to first Avenue South. And the surrounding land uses are commercial. Here's some photos of the alley. I'm the one on the left number one is a view to the alley from commercial av South. And for the number 2 on the right is a view to the alley from the sidewalk on first Avenue South. Here's a view from the alley on the left across first Avenue South towards the trop and the photo on the right is a view from the alley looking eastward along commercial Avenue South which again is between central av and First Avenue South. The purpose of the vacation is to effectuate the redevelopment of the adjacent lot says the moxy hotel. The site plan for the hotel was unanimously approved by the cra on Dec. 12th, 2020. And is also supported by the edge district. This image shows where the alley is located outlined in yellow and there's a leader. That's a subject Ali pointing to it. In I've also noted on the drawing the proposed walkway to the right of the vacated alley which is outlined in that. The drc heard the application and voted unanimously to recommend its approval. On 2/5/2020. And this is because the alley vacation meets the criteria for vacations as set forth in the land development regulations. There's recommended conditions of approval which are included in the ordinance and also a reply of the area is required as part of those conditions. So it's now 2022. So there's been a delay. Between the drc needing between introduction of the ordinance. In 2020 the applicant put the project on hold and considered other development alternatives because of financing limitations at the time. None of those alternatives were found by them to be better and so the project was resumed in late 2021. So back at the drc hearing there were no public comments the edge district supports the plan and the vacation of the alley there were not. There were no comments from Ko co. Back in 2020 early 2020. I'm sorry could you pause for a moment. And if you could let us know when your friend is silence that would be great. Well continue then. Thank so the only comments we really received were back in early The a budding property owners on Central Avenue. Had concerns at the time before the walkway through the site was proposed. He was concerned that there should be a connection a pedestrian connection. From central through the mid block toward first Avenue South. The applicant has included that pedestrian walkway on their site plan as I showed you a few slides back. And that property owner also wanted to work with. Now the developer on making. The northern alley which about central Abbott pedestrian walkway. Both of those things should be addressed during the site plan process. And then recommended action on this by the administration is approval because again the vacation does meet the criteria as set forth in me land development regulations. That's the end of my presentation. Thank you so much. And I believe we had at least we have one speaker on this item making it nearly. Please state your name address for the record you have 3 minutes to address Council. All right good afternoon MISS Meili and though well you know that okay. Hello my name is making mcneely a my address is 1, 0, 0, 1, 62nd place out. I live in the greater Pinellas point community. I am a student with St. Petersburg college in their public policy backer of program. I'm in my last year and this is a this project was a part a class assignment. And so. I'm here today to speak on this first meeting item. As Michelle went through her presentation. The applicant apply for. We take this off a bit. Vacationing. So that they could have a site redevelopment of that particular site and as it shows that it was approved by the lead development regulations, the city comprehensive plan as well as the special interest groups which included the as district and the entire redevelopment list. Upon further research into the upper to this action item. I saw that the press and the media including the Tampa Bay times as well as the Tampa business journals and others were already boasting about this new moxy hotel. The House set on the 1.6 acre parcel and talked about the different combinations and how it would bring into our city what they call fun. Hunters which is what the merry men with the Marriott is calling their new target market. Yet the development what will will be the result of the approval of this particular vacationing. It without the approval of this vacation and it MAY put a halt in the in this groundbreaking Hotel in all of the news media that has surrounded this particular item. Although none of the articles discuss what seems to be a minor detail. I for one know that the approval of the vacation means a lot more to our city. Our economy our workforce in the city's vision which is to be a city of opportunity where the sun shines and all who come to live work in play. And so when I thought about that particular vision. It was people are coming to play who's going to work there and who's going to play there. The weekly challenger state in an article titled I am the story of the gas plant neighborhood. Back in Mar. 19 83. Mark Johnson was a staff writer for the Times wrote that the panelists Port Authority selected the guests play area in Saint Pete as the site for its stadium and even held a symbolic groundbreaking ceremony and this was before the franchise had even been awarded. Also Bob parks and in of the aisle of the Burg what his article groundbreaking announce for the moxy Hotel in its collective development which I chose to be the title of this presentation. He said the groundbreaking o cedar Avenue is slated for 2, 2, which is core to of 2022. So listening to reading those articles and thinking back on the history of how sometimes people are putting the media's putting the cart before the horse. And you get a chance to finish. Thank you. Thank you and good luck with your project. All right we have a motion in a second. >> Any discussion saying that there's no requests for discussion on this item. Well the clerk please open the machine for voting. Councilmember Hannah weights. I just have a question on the ordinance I saw that there was number 2 was missing. Requests someone. >> Are you speak your your friend is section 2 or a month and the engineer you memo dated Jan. 14th 2020 shall be addressed part of the redevelopment of the site. It's not in the ordinance I was just wondering. >> Good afternoon. Yes, thank you for bringing that to our attention I did catch that for the next package that should have been removed, I'm sorry Elizabeth Abernathy director of planning and development services. There was a lot of discussion about that at the drc whether that condition should stay in or out to beat that. But because that condition relates to the east-west Ali and not the north-south Ali we determine that. Addressing not comment would come through the replay at process in the site plan review process and I was moving quickly to get over here. So it was an oversight and they they will match in the package is coming to second reading the ordinance is correct. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. >> Saying that there are no further requests to speak. And then we do have a motion in the second with the clerk please open the machine for voting. All present council members please enter your votes. Thing that a PRESIDENT Council members have voted for the clerk please tallying announced the votes. And I'm sure the motion to approve is in I'm the one passes unanimously councilmember Gabbert being absent. All right. Thank you. We'll go next to reports with item f one. 6 months Lanka purchase agreement with Rico usa. If we don't need a presentation on this item I'll entertain a motion for approval before prove. I can well good made the motion. Motion is made by council member fig Sanders seconded by. Councilmember really ramen. We have a motion in a second seeing that there are no requests for discussion will the clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes seeing we're seeing now present council members have voted by the clerk please telling announced the votes. And sure the motion to approve the agenda item f one passes unanimously that council member Garrett Hampson. Next item f 2. We actually have 2 resolutions to approve today. Under this report item for that introduction welcome Rob Curtis. Afternoon City Council Robert is assistant city administrator to pleasure to be with you all this afternoon. Do have a request before you today to assist contemporary housing alternatives of Florida. With the acquisition of 3 properties on Russell Street South. We do have a powerpoint presentation for you. So again we are requesting approval to financially support the acquisition of 3 properties and 12 dwelling units by contemporary housing alternatives of Florida with $750,000 in city funding these properties are located on Russell Street South. Each property consists a summary block structure with 4 dwelling units for a total of 12 units under the funding agreements, the units would be reserved for household that 60% of area median income with a 30 year Ford ability period. Contemporary housing is scheduled to close with family first homes Florida llc on Feb. 14th. And I want to thank contemporary housing for participating in this transaction. The city administration became aware that family first Florida homes of Florida is disposing of all their assets in St. Petersburg there are large property owner in St. Petersburg when we heard this news we reached out to family first and had discussions with about potentially finding some partnerships and relationships. We reached out to contemporary introduce them to family first and they moved very quickly on this private market transaction to get a closing date on Feb. 14th. And to maintain long-term affordability on these properties if contemporary housing was not willing to do this these properties would be sold on the market and there would be no control over the rants or the households that live there and there would be no guarantee that the residents that live there now would be able to remain there. The sales price is one 0.2 7 5 million. And we anticipate approximately 300 to 400,000 in rehab that needs to be done. This rehabs very important. We've asked in temporary housing. To to really show what can be done on Russell Street with these properties we want them to be a leader on Russell Street in showing well maintained affordable housing for the household. And so this rehab portion is very important to the overall program. These are the structures here they're all very similar. These are the 3 properties. And there's a row of them are Russell Street, this is 3 of the 3 of them you can see where the property is located here. In my opinion, one of the reasons I was most interested in these properties and this transaction is a very important location on Russell Street. There's there's other structures like this there's been a history of deferred maintenance on Russell Street. The city owns property on 18th Avenue South in Russell Street that we're currently working on potential affordable townhomes it's very close to 10 entering Plaza. It's also very close to Queens borough Avenue which has also had history of deferred maintenance so we really think that contemporary housing can be a leader here and show what can be done with good management for affordable housing on Russell Street. We do have to request for you today and these are the funding mechanisms in the resolutions. So City Council a previous previously approved the ability for the city administration to borrow from the economic stability fund to fund affordable housing projects. There's currently a maximum cap of $5 million on this funding instrument. City Council previously approved million loan for the area development on 54th Avenue North between 4th Street and first Street. We are requesting an inner fun loan in the amount of $750,000 which would leave 3.2 5 million remaining for potential future future borrowing against the economic stability fund. Once we complete that inner fund loan. Then we would enter into an agreement with contemporary housing for a grant of $750,000 to assist them with the acquisition in rehab of the properties and those are the 2 resolutions before you today. These are the main business points of the agreement we've covered the sale price. There will be a declaration of restrictions that's recorded restricting the units to 60% of area median income for a period of 30 years. Currently for a family of 3 that's an income of $39,900 and you're looking at a rental price point of about $900 a month. We will provide the funding to contemporary housing. The existing tenants will not be displaced. We'll conduct inspections on the property as part of the agreement will have a list a rehab items and repairs that need to be completed as part of the funding agreement and the housing and community development Department will have the ability to review tenant applications for income compliance and also conduct ongoing inspections to make sure the properties well maintained. We don't anticipate noncompliance but in a case of non-compliance there would also be terms for liquidated damages where the city's funding would be received back to the city. These are the main terms of the loan from economic stability. It's a 0% low. It's a 10 year term. Essentially we will pay $75,000 annually over 10 years back into economic stability. Starting in OCTOBER of this year. So that's how the loan is repaid and its repaid through the housing capital improvement fund which is funded annually in the budget. The temporary housing is a local entity, they formed in 1992, they manage your own over 700 housing units and we have entered into some recent agreements with They have recently completed 3, 2 unit residences in the South St. Petersburg cra that we've participated in funding and those units are restricted at 80% am Iran. And these are the structures themselves in my opinion they're very nice. Well maintained. It looks like a single-family home, but there's actually a unit in the rear that can be accessed at the back of the property so this is 2 units. This is also 2 units. And this is 2 units and we've been very happy with the agreements that we've entered into recently with contemporary housing and they perform very well. So we are requesting approval of for the inner fun loan and resolution be authorizing the funding agreement we do have Joe level air here and Jake's towers from contemporary housing, if there's any questions for them or myself, thank you so much. Thank you. >> All right, we have a motion in a second, I'm sorry MADAM Chair, these resolutions need to be taken separately the first one should be be and approval of the Center for mom resolution want to vote on that the new to the next. Council members they order of the approval of resolutions will be switched. We're not compared to compared to what's listed on the proposed agenda order. So we'll voting on item f to be first. Yes MISTER Clerk, MADAM Chair actually on the. Name the generous on the guys that are in the correct order on that agenda that you have on the bias and the correct on that in the packet as well online. So it would that you're voting on first thing you want to be it's just the odors wrong listed on there. The amount of chair. >> As the a and b is reversed in a few places it would be helpful to clarify bit. And yes Aleutian air b. For this purpose, it's more important more important to identify the resolution as the surf and rip loan resolution. If you want to refer to its on your printed agenda. That would be fine but it is different on your agenda order as well as I believe on the online. A joke, hey so what we're going to do. In her friend is first rate. We have we're going to vote on the resolution for the inter Fenn loan first. Ok, I'm looking at ok can you clarify what I just made a motion to Well you didn't specify so what I'm asking for now to mend the motion. 2 for approval. The resolution for the inter fun loan. So that's not what I would approve on I was looking at the resolution approving funding not to exceed I will take that one of seconded to come second because the inner fun loan would need to be approved before that we have to we have to release the money. And then except the money you've got to throw the pass and then catch the path. Ok either way move rubble. Of the inner fun Should do. Yes that's right guys we have a motion for approval of the in Finland. And we have a second from councilmember Wheeler Berman. We speak and MISTER Curtis you. Were you trying to help clarify or did you have something out Chair we're here to answer questions. Thank you, thank you councilmember fig Sanders. Thank you chair. >> So my question hopefully will suffice we're both going across the board but more importantly I want to. State that I have I think 2 or 3 of affordable duplexes are in my district and I have 2 of them and they're absolutely beautiful. I appreciate the effort of trying to provide actual affordable housing into in our district. In in our city. What I need to with this particular transaction it says that no tennis will be displaced, but wasn't what was not provided is what does that transitional period looks like if they're not going to be displaced where would they be in the meantime during the renovation and if a resident has come to the end of their lease during the renovation process would they still be guaranteed. I'm a resident at the same rate. Yes, we're not going to displace everybody we're going to we're going to keep everybody at the 60% and my rent threshold. Until contemporary housing takes ownership and starts to understand the income levels of the current tenants we won't know for sure. But we we that most of the tenants will qualify at 60% am I and that will not be an issue if they happen to be slightly over 60% am I we will let them stay. They will be charged a 60% and my rent until they vacate the space during rehab nobody will be The rehab interior why should not be that extensive where anybody has to be relocated. So we're there. The date of their lease witness, the first effective date of the 6% am I guarantee. >> So as soon as. Contemporary housing takes ownership of the property. That the rant will be at the 60% and my that day for okay all right. And it's not is not up on the renovation but when they take over. Yeah I just knew that clarification thank you so much for us to go to thank you chair. All right, thank you councilmember riller Bowman, thank you MADAM Chair. Rather just had a question. >> Why is this 30 years and why isn't it. You know 30 years for 60% am I instead of like the 99 years are whatever. So thank you councilmember so as we've discussed before affordability periods a lot of times are tied to different funding sources. Right now where we use a 99 year perpetual leases with penny for Pinellas when we do land acquisition. That's not the case here in my opinion I think for the structure of this deal. A 30 year Ford ability period is very strong. For this particular deer the deal that we're asking you to enter into. For example are affordable and workforce housing. Next a study report from 39 showed that to subsidize the 60% and my unit, they anticipated that you'd be looking at a $154,000 per unit subsidy. We're much less than that and we have a very strong 30 year for ability period. So I feel very good about the terms. Thank you. Councilmember Floyd. All right a few questions that some of the other council members already covered but. Let's just start with so right now are these classes affordable or have any price controls on them currently under the current ownership, no Sir. >> is there a possibility that residence rents will be when they when the new ownership takes over they being charged less than the My threshold right now doing a storm based on what we can tell there in the us the 60% am I range now my understanding from contemporary housing of Florida is that they will keep those rent as is at that level is that is that accurate. >> All One more So the current owner of this property is going to is seeking to liquidate their assets in the city. This came up because you know we were actually let me frame it this way. What happens if don't approve this today is it just going to go likely to a market based just There's no nothing to do to protect to make sure affordability other than something like this. Yes councilmember and I mean that is our concern and that's why we tried to step in immediately and coordinate this transaction because otherwise it will just be sold to a market rate owner and we would have no control over the relevance. Okay. Thank you. >> And we have any speakers on this item. Billy some next year. The state your name, the dress for the record you have 3 minutes to address Council. Thank you Jaleesa Blackshear 39 10:00am o k streets oath. As you remember them, Colin I just want to clarify what we will talk about am I with the dollar amount means. Family of 4 people. We talk about household income up to mind that's translated in as $43,620 and this is per the city's affordable housing, a plan that they publish 3 people which would be including myself up to $39,900 a year. 29 years old with a bachelor's degree and have yet to the $18,000 year threshold. When we talk about a family of 2 that's $35,460 a mother and a child and I when we talk about one as far as the household income of up to 60 am I it's $31,000 so I would axe Council not to approve this today to revisit to file a motion to revisit and several months when there's an actually transparent affordable housing. A report from child because I just understand how we continue to approve resolutions with the term affordable housing. But yet individual legislator cannot to find what affordable housing needs. And if I make in. $39,000 a year I'm not going to live in Russia Street here, I'm not doing it. So there is a certain demographic that is there I have the trust and contemporary hausen to solve a long-term problem with only a 30 year lease to the city, I mean the Dolly gets a 99 year leases and they just started subsidizing their membership. 4 months ago, so I just wanted to add that I am against this. Thank you. So on to marry. Thank you MADAM Chair. >> So Ron how did we come up with the $750,000. So it really negotiated between contemporary housing us based what their revenue's going to look like based on those rental price points. You know again. This was at the request of the city administration we wanted to be proactive very happy that can temporary housing would partner with us. We feel that the out based on the sales price and the necessary rehab is fair. Ok thank you. And the rehab seems like it's pretty just doing the math $400,000.12 units through $3,000 per unit. We're not going to displace anybody. I think a lot of the costs could be mechanical equipment and also the stairs we've we've we've got some issues here with the stairs. That we don't believe or code compliant they MAY need to be completely rebuilt. And that's going to be a significant costs driver. >> And on and rest resolution that to be. The 4th whereas clauses talks about to. Agree not to displace existing tenants can you talk a little bit about when can they displaced tenants what if there is a bad actor somebody that moves in that's criminal or or something like that. We're going to have to deal with that in the agreement we're certainly going to want to see existing leases at a minimum and would like to see But we'll work through that with contemporary housing. You know we're not going to force can temporary housing in perpetuity you know have tenants that maybe aren't paying rent. But we're certainly going to be fair about it. All right well, thank you well I. I'm in support of both of these resolutions, thank you for the presentation. I went into. Thank you. MISTER Curtis and the folks from chaff are collaborating on this project. Very happy to see that this is happening in these particular. This particular property. I've I've been to this property I've been in one of the with the current owner. I know that they do so they do need some work. But they are actually in a fantastic location. Easy access to transportation and. You know some of the amenities in the area, it's not that far from downtown for Work downtown and that increasingly cannot afford to live there. So long term I think this is this fantastic asset think about the families who live there right now. And and being able to have the the security of being able to stay but then also have improvements made to the apartments without getting having their rent increased to where they can't afford it anymore is we need more of that and so I'm absolutely thrilled. This is moving forward when the city foot talks about funding for affordable housing, it's not always just about building something new. We all know that in order to solve this this problem in order to truly address this crisis we have we also have to look at our existing housing stock. And looking for ways that we can improve that make it better quality and more affordable. 4. Folks who are already living here in St. Petersburg. You know making these are improvements to what we've already got is truly part of the solution and I'm fully supportive of this partnership to make good quality. Affordable housing that folks can be proud of more attainable from our people so thank you for that. >> For the resolution to approve the inter friend loan amount of 7750 $1000 from the economic stability fund. To the affordable housing fund we do have a motion in a second and seeing that there are no further requests for discussion will the clerk please open the machine for Council members please enter your votes saying that all present council members have voted. Well the clerk please telling announced the votes. And CHAIRMAN Motion to approve or deny that too. As it relates to the inter fun passes unanimously with council member Garrett being absent. Thank you and next, I'll entertain a motion for the approval of the resolution for funding not to exceed $750,000 2 chaff to support staff's acquisition of 12 affordable housing units located on Russell Street South. >> Move approval. We have a motion and a second. And seeing that there are no request for discussion with the clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes saying that all PRESIDENT Council members have voted with the clerk please telling announced the votes. For the motion to approve the agenda item f to the passes unanimously with council member Thank you could you display the results for us terrific thank you thank you City Council. Yes, thank you and thanks all for being here to answer questions and for all that you do. City Council will move next to item f 3. Which was originally consent. Consent item b 5. Why at this. You're Correct okay. That's 3 which was originally cb 5 resolution for task order 21 dash one. For Jacobs engineering good afternoon. MISTER Palin char and coun

Agenda textCity Council

City Council — January 20, 2022

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a1ac74cec81b201835c750ddad3a5d27. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record