POLISCOPE

The public record

MARTINEZ (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission Special Meeting

Tuesday, November 25, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission Special Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 77,957 stored characters

GOOD EVENING AND I WILL CALL THIS NOVEMBER 25 MEETING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF MARTINEZ TO ORDER, PLEASE JOIN ME IN STANDING, IF YOU'RE ABLE, IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. THANK YOU. CLERK, WILL YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL? >> OKAY WE HAVE COMMISSIONERS CULIK-CARO PRESENT GUSTOFSON PRESENT JOHNSON PRESENT KLOPP PRESENT PAROLEK PRESENT SONNIKSON PRESENT VICE CHAIR JOSEPH EVANS PRESENT AND CHAIR JASON MARTIN PRESENT. >> THANK YOU. I WILL NOW READ A CIVILITY STATEMENT AS APPOINTED GOVERNING BOARD WILL TREAT EACH OTHER AND THE PUBLIC WITH PATIENCE, CIVILITY AND COURTESY AS A MODEL OF THE SAME BAYVIEW WE WISH TO REFLECT IN MARTINEZ FOR THE CONDUCT OF ALL PARTICIPATION. THIS INCLUDES RESPECT FOR EVERYONE'S FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINION ON MATTERS WITHIN THE CITY SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION EVEN IF THE OPINION IS DIFFERENT FROM OUR OWN. DECISIONS MADE TONIGHT WILL BE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE MARTINEZ COMMUNITY AND NOT FOR PERSONAL GAIN. AND WITH THAT, BEFORE I MOVE ON TO PUBLIC COMMENT ANY CHANGES TO THIS EVENING'S AGENDA? >> THERE ARE NO CHANGES. >> VERY GOOD, OPEN COMMENT FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA, ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK? SEEING ON ANY MEMBERS VIRTUAL THAT WISH TO SPEAK? >> THERE ARE NO HANDS RAISED. >> VERY GOOD I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT. CONSENT THE APPROVAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ACTION MINUTES FROM OCTOBER 28, 2025. COMMENTS OR CHANGES FROM ANY COMMISSIONERS. WITH THE DATA DO I HAVE A MOTION? >> MOVED TO APPROVE THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ACTION MINUTES DATED OCTOBER 28, 2025. >> DO I HAVE A SECOND? >> I SECOND. >> CLERK WILL YOU CALL THE ROLL? CULIK-CARO AYE GUSTOFSON AYE JOHNSON AYE KLOPP ABSTAIN I MISSED TO THE MEETING. >> YOU CAN STILL VOTE. >> OKAY. >> PAROLEK YES JOSEPH EVANS AYE JASON MARTIN AYE. MOTION PASSES. >> VERY GOOD REGULAR AGENDA ITEM RECEIVED AND PARTICIPATE IN PLANNING COMMISSIONER TRAINING SERIES NUMBER ONE CONDUCTED BY REPRESENTATIVES OF THE AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA CHAPTER NORTHERN SECTION ON THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION, LAND-USE FRAMEWORK, RECENT LEGISLATIVE CHANGES AND BEST PRACTICES AND I'M VERY EXCITED FOR THIS EVENING'S AGENDA ITEM, ONE THING I WISH I HAD WHEN I WAS A NEW COMMISSIONER SO I HOPE OUR NEWER MEMBERS AND EVEN MYSELF BECAUSE YOU CAN LEARN SOMETHING NEW EVERY DAY CAN GET SOMETHING OUT OF THIS THIS EVENING, WITH DATA DO WE HAVE A STAFF REPORT? THANK YOU CHAIR MARTIN. WE ARE VERY FORTUNATE THIS EVENING, WE HAVE TWO REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION THAT ARE PRESENT THIS EVENING TO CONDUCT THE FIRST OF HOPEFULLY MANY PLANNING COMMISSIONER TRAININGS . WE ALSO HAVE A NUMBER OF PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA IN ATTENDANCE AS WELL IN PERSON AND ONLINE. I WOULD LIKE TO QUICKLY INTRODUCE THE TWO PRESENTERS AT THIS EVENING WHO ARE JEFF BOND, DIRECTOR ELECT API CALIFORNIA NORTHERN SECTION AND JEFF BRADLEY THE PLANNING COMMISSION TRAINING COORDINATOR WITH APA , AS WELL. AT THIS POINT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO THEM AND AS THEY ARE COMING UP I WILL SHARE THERE WILL BE A COUPLE OF OPPORTUNITIES BUILT INTO TONIGHT'S PRESENTATION AND TRAINING WHERE THERE ARE OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE COMMISSION AND THE PUBLIC TO ASK QUESTIONS AND WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO DO SO, SO THINK IT. >> THANK YOU BOTH FOR JOINING THIS EVENING, APPRECIATE IT AND WELCOME TO ALL THE PEERS FROM OTHER COMMISSIONS THAT HAVE JOINED AS WELL. THANK YOU, CLOSE TO THE HOLIDAY HERE I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE WATCHING THIS LATER SO THIS IS A SESSION FOR PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FOR PEOPLE INTERESTED IN HOW PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FUNCTION. I WILL GO THROUGH A SERIES OF SLIDES AND THEN HAND IT OVER TO MY COLLEAGUE WHO WILL CONTINUE ON WITH THE PRESENTATION. WE WILL HAVE A BREAK AND IF , I WILL GET STARTED HERE. SO, THERE WE GO. SO I WILL BE COVERING THE LOCAL PLANNING PROCESS PART OF THE PRESENTATION. A LITTLE BIT ABOUT MYSELF, I HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN LAND-USE AND PUBLIC LESSEE IN CALIFORNIA ALMOST 40 YEARS NOW. A FEW MONTHS AGO I RETIRED AS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR OF THE CITY OF ALBANY AND ADVOCATING 19 YEARS COVERING A WIDE RANGE OF PLANNING NOT JUST LAND-USE PLANNING BUT ALSO HOUSING, SUSTAINABILITY AND PARKS AND RECREATION. A WHOLE GAMUT OF COMMUNITY PLANNING. AS PART OF THE CELEBRATION OF MY RETIREMENT IT WAS POINTED OUT I PROBABLY ATTENDED OVER 1000 MEETINGS IN THE CITY OF ALBANY, CITY COMMISSIONS SO I DO BRING A LITTLE BIT OF EXPERIENCE TO THE PRESENTATION THIS EVENING. SO, I THINK YOU ALL KNOW WHY YOU'RE HERE AS PLANNERS , YOU ARE, YOU ARE PLANNING FOR THE FUTURE GENERATIONS FUTURE RESIDENTS, FUTURE FAMILY MEMBERS PERHAPS AND THAT IS AN HONORABLE THING YOU ARE DOING. WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR YOUR COMMITMENT TO DOING THAT AS IT DOES TAKE QUITE A BIT OF TIME AND EFFORT AND TIME AWAY FROM YOUR FAMILIES. FIRST OF ALL, THE PURPOSE OF A PLANNING COMMISSION. IN MY MIND PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ACTION OF COMMUNITY CHANGE. AS YOU KNOW OR MAYBE NOT KNOW THE ESTABLISHMENT PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE STATE LAW ESTABLISHING STATE LAW ALSO WRITTEN INTO ALMOST EVERY CITY CHARTER AND EVERY MUNICIPAL CODE , WE HAVE A STATUTORY RESPONSIBILITY TO HELP PLAN THE COMMUNITY AND IN MANY CASES YOUR SCOPE GOES BEYOND STATUTORY RESPONSIBILITIES INTO OTHER AREAS SUCH AS TRANSPORTATION PLANNING OR SUSTAINABILITY AND SO FORTH AN IMPORTANT PART OF WHAT YOU DO IS LISTEN TO THE COMMUNITY CAPTURE THE ESSENCE OF WHAT THE COMMUNITY IS CONCERNED ABOUT AND HELP COMMUNICATE THAT TO CITY COUNCILMEMBERS THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT AS I'M SURE YOU DO TO TAKE THE TIME TO LISTEN TO STUDY THE DETAILS OF THE PROJECTS AND PLANS AND POLICIES THAT COME BEFORE YOU. SO LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF A PLANNING COMMISSION AND THEY DO VARY FROM CITY TO CITY, SOME CITIES HAVE A VARIETY OF SUBCOMMITTEES THAT MAY BE DESIGN REVIEW OR HISTORIC PRESERVATION . OTHERS WILL BE CONSOLIDATED WITH A PLANNING COMMISSION SO AS WE ARE TALKING THINK ABOUT IT IS NOT JUST STRICTLY SPEAKING THE PLANNING COMMISSION BUT A VARIETY THAT TOUCHED THE PLANNING PROCESS IN THE COMMUNITY, THESE PRINCIPLES ARE FOR THOSE TYPES OF COMMITTEES AND ADVISORY BODIES. THE ESSENCE OF WHAT YOU DO IS TO HOLD STUDY SESSIONS ON PLANS OR PROJECTS AND PERHAPS THAT EVOLVES INTO FORMAL PUBLIC HEARINGS WHICH ARE MANDATED BY STATE LAW WITH MUNICIPAL CODE OR BOTH AND ULTIMATELY YOU WOULD BE MAKING RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL ON THOSE ITEMS WHERE THE CITY COUNCIL IS THE DECISION-MAKER AND IN SOME CASES COMMISSIONS WILL SERVE AS THE APPEAL BOARD FOR A DECISION THAT A STEP PERSON WOULD NORMALLY MAKE IF A APPLICANT OR MEMBER IS NOT HAPPY WITH THAT DECISION YOU WOULD BE CALLED UPON TO MAKE THAT, TO POLLED OR REVERSE THE DECISION OF STAFF. ONE OF THE IMPORTANT THINGS THAT I THINK PLANNING COMMISSIONS CAN DO ARE UNIQUELY POSITIONED TO DO AND WE MENTIONED THIS EVENING WE ARE FROM THE BEGINNING OF THE MEETING SETTING THE TONE OF CIVILITY, RESPECT AND PROBLEM SOLVING. AND AGAIN PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE A GREAT PLACE TO DO THAT, I THINK THAT IS AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN THIS ERA WITH PUBLIC DECISION-MAKING THAT WE ARE GOING THROUGH IN OUR STATE AND COUNTRY I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING TO REINFORCE SO ONE OF THE REALLY IMPORTANT THINGS AND SOMETIMES THIS IS NOT DISCUSSED AS MUCH AS IT SHOULD WHEN PEOPLE COME TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION. YOUR ROLE WITH CITY STAFF. I WANTED TO SPEND A COUPLE OF MINUTES TALKING ABOUT THAT. WHEN I TALK ABOUT CITY STAFF IT'S NOT JUST STAFF MEMBERS WHO ARE EMPLOYED BY THE CITY BUT ALSO CONSULTANTS. CONSULTANT CAN TAKE A COUPLE DIFFERENT FORMS AND THE WORK I DID AND WE WOULD HIRE A TECHNICAL CONSULTANT SOMETIMES TO RESOLVE A TECHNICAL ISSUE SO MAYBE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT IF A DRIVER IS POSITIONED PROPERLY YOU COULD HIRE TRANSPORTATION TO HELP WITH THAT. WE SOMETIMES HIRE CONSULTANTS TO HELP WITH THE EBB AND FLOW OF BUSINESS AND PERHAPS THE CONSULTANT BRINGS SPECIALIZATION THAT WE IN SMALLER CITIES IN PARTICULAR DID NOT HAVE WITH GENERAL PRACTITIONERS SO AS I TALK ABOUT THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF STAFF IN THE BACK OF YOUR MIND KEEP IN MIND CONSULTANTS FALL INTO THAT. SO THE STAFF RESPONSIBILITY TO BE A TECHNICAL RESOURCE FOR YOU TO MANAGE THE PROCESS FROM SOMEONE SUBMITTING AN APPLICATION OR SOMEONE STARTING AN IDEA FOR POLICY OR PROGRAM AND PULLING THOSE , THAT INFORMATION TOGETHER BRINGING IT TO THE COMMISSION FOR A DECISION. ONE THING THAT COMES UP FREQUENTLY THAT IS SOMETIMES A LITTLE BIT OF A RUB AND A SOURCE OF TENSION IS THAT STAFF DOES NOT ACTUALLY WORK FOR PLANNING COMMISSION STRICTLY SPEAKING THE WAY THE CHART WORKS IS IN 95 OR 99% OF THE CITIES IN CALIFORNIA STAFF WORKS FOR THE CITY MANAGER. THERE ARE TIMES YOU CAN APPROPRIATELY GIVE DIRECTION TO STAFF, LET'S SAY YOU ARE STRUGGLING WITH A PROJECT TRYING TO DECIDE WHAT THE RIGHT THING TO DO IS AND YOU MAY WANT TO DIRECT STAFF, CAN YOU DO MORE WORK IN THIS PARTICULAR AREA SO WE CAN MAKE AN INFORMED DECISION, THAT IS APPROPRIATE DIRECTION TO STAFF. IN OTHER CASES YOU MAY WANT TO TELL STAFF HEY, INSTEAD OF WORKING ON THE HOUSING ELEMENT IMPLEMENTATION YOU WANT TO WORK ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CLIMATE ACTION PLAN. THAT IS A DECISION THAT BELONGS WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE CITY LED BY THE CITY MANAGER. SO THAT DISTINCTION IS IMPORTANT, SOMETIMES IT'S A SOURCE OF FRUSTRATION OR TENSION AND I WANT TO FLAG GOT OUT AS A PLACE WHERE YOU CAN MAKE SURE THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES AND RELATIONSHIPS ARE CLEAR YOU CAN MAKE THE SUGGESTION FOR STAFF OR MAKE THE SUGGESTION TO SAY THE CITY MANAGER OR WHOEVER'S IN THAT LINE OF DECISION-MAKING. THE OTHER THING I WOULD SAY ABOUT YOUR WORKING RELATIONSHIP WITH STAFF IS KEEP LINES OF COMMUNICATION OPEN. IT IS A GREAT RELIEF TO US AS CITY STAFF PEOPLE TO GET A CALL IN ADVANCE OF LIKE A I HAVE A TECHNICAL QUESTION. I THINK YOU DID THE MATH WRONG ON A EVALUATION IT'S NICE TO GET THE CALLS IN ADVANCE SO WE CAN REALIZE WE MADE A MISTAKE AND WE WON'T UP TO THAT AND FIX IT TONIGHT BABY YOU DO NOT MAKE A MISTAKE AND WE CAN SPEND A MINUTE OR TWO TO CLARIFY THIS IS HOW WE DO THE MATH AND SET THOSE ISSUES ASIDE. IT'S NICE TO KNOW IF I HAVE A BIG ISSUE WITH THE PROJECT HERE IS MY ISSUE JUST BE PREPARED TO HAVE THOSE DETAILS AT YOUR FINGERTIPS. THAT IS GREAT TO HAVE AND WE HAVE A SLIDE UP AND READY TO BE ABLE TO PUT ON THE SCREEN TO TALK THROUGH SOME OF THE ISSUES WE KNOW YOU HAVE AND THAT MAKES THE MEETING GO MORE SMOOTHLY , WE'RE NOT FUMBLING AROUND WITH STAFF PEOPLE AND WE ARE ABLE TO GET TO YOUR QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS MORE QUICKLY. A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIPS AND STAFF I THINK IT IS REALLY IMPORTANT BOTH THE COMMISSION AND STAFF IN DIFFERENT WAYS ARE INTERFACED WITH APPLICANTS AND WITH THE COMMUNITY. JUST BEING AWARE THOSE ARE DIFFERENT LINES OF COMMUNICATION OFTEN GOING ON AT THE SAME TIME. AND A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS. PART OF THE JOB IS TO RESEARCH ISSUES. SO FEEL FREE AS A COMMISSIONER POINT OUT TO STAFF REALLY WOULD LIKE YOU TO DO A DEEP DIVE ON SOMETHING HERE. YOU KNOW THE COMMISSION NEEDS TO UNDERSTAND A PARTICULAR ISSUE OR QUESTION. AND FINALLY A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS THE ROLE OF STAFF IS TO SOMETIMES KEEP YOU OUT OF TROUBLE. IT IS TEMPTING SOMETIMES THE CLASSIC EXAMPLE IS THE COMMISSION STARTS TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING AND YOU START TO VEER OFF AND TOPIC OUR JOB AS STAFF SOMETIMES IS LIKE YOU ARE STARTING TO TALK ABOUT SOMETHING THAT'S NOT ON THE AGENDA , LET US DO THAT. WE ARE NOT TRYING, WHEN WE SAY THE PROFESSIONAL PLANNERS ARE TRYING TO STOP THE CONVERSATION WE ARE JUST TRYING TO KEEP IT IN THE TIME AND PLACE WHERE IT SHOULD BE HAPPENING SO EVERYBODY IN THE COMMUNITY KNOWS IT'S HAPPENING. SAME WITH ROBERTS RULES OF ORDER'S. ALL OF A SUDDEN DIFFERENT IDEAS FLOW AROUND WITH THREE OR FOUR MOTIONS ON THE FLOOR WHAT'S GOING ON HERE LET YOUR STAFF HELP YOU. NEXT I'M GOING TO TRY IN A COUPLE OF MINUTES TO COVER A COUPLE THOUSAND PAGES WORTH OF ETHICS LAWS AND THE MOST IMPORTANT THING I CAN SAY ABOUT THIS IS PROBABLY THE MOST CONSERVATIVE INTERPRETATION ONE CAN HAVE WITH THESE LAWS AND PRACTICES, YOU KNOW DIFFERENT CITY ATTORNEYS, DIFFERENT PLANNING MANAGERS DIFFERENT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTORS HAVE DIFFERENT PHILOSOPHIES ABOUT THIS. SO WHAT I AM SAYING IS WHAT I TOLD PEOPLE IN THE CITIES I HAVE WORKED IN OVER THE YEARS IT MIGHT BE DIFFERENT BUT I'M PUTTING IT OUT SO YOU ARE AWARE OF THE BROAD PARAMETERS OF SOME OF THESE ETHICS REQUIREMENTS. THIS IS A GREAT PLACE TO PICK UP THE PHONE TO SAY HEY I'M NOT SURE IF I'M DOING THE RIGHT THING CAN I TALK ABOUT THIS? IS THIS MEETING APPROPRIATE? FOUR THINGS TO TOUCH ON FIRST IS ASSEMBLY BILL 1234, A PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT PASSED 10 OR 15 YEARS AGO. REQUIRES YOU TO GO THROUGH AN ONLINE TRAINING IF YOU'RE SEEKING TO BE REIMBURSED FOR ANY EXPENSES THAT OCCUR AS A PLANNING COMMISSION OR SO IF YOU GO TO CONFERENCE AND YOU WANT TO BE REIMBURSED YOU HAVE TO HAVE GONE THROUGH THIS TRAINING. TO MY KNOWLEDGE THERE ARE A COUPLE PLACES THAT ARE PRETTY EASY , THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES AS ONLINE TRAINING AND THE STATE FAIR POLITICAL PRACTICE COMMITTEE HAS A ONLINE TRAINING BOTH OF THEM ARE PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD IT HAS BEEN A COUPLE YEARS SINCE I HAVE TAKEN THE TRAINING BUT IT IS NOT A BIG DEAL AND IT IS GOOD PRACTICE NOT SEEKING REIMBURSEMENT IT'S NOT A BAD IDEA TO KEEP THESE THINGS FRESH. SO OKAY. JUMPING AROUND A LITTLE BIT THE BROWN ACT THIS IS EVERYBODY'S FAVORITE LAW NOT REALLY BUT IT IS A GOOD LAW IT MAKE SURE THE DECISIONS YOU MAKE AND EVERYBODY MAKES AND CITY COUNCILS ARE OPEN AND TRANSPARENT. TO SUMMARIZE THE LAW BASICALLY ANY TIME THE MAJORITY VIEW DISCUSS IN ANY FORM IN ANY MEDIUM OF COMMUNICATION IN ANY SEQUENCE ONE AFTER ANOTHER IT'S A MEETING THAT'S THE CONSERVATIVE ANALYSIS AND THE CONSERVATIVE APPROACH TO WHAT THE BROWN ACT SAYS. THE CONGREGATION ONE OF THE CITY ATTORNEYS SET FOR A WHILE IF ONE COMMISSIONER SENDS A PIECE OF COMMUNICATION TO A QUORUM WITH THE REMAINING COMMISSIONERS THAT CONSTITUTES A MEETING. THAT IS A VERY CONSERVATIVE INTERPRETATION BUT NONETHELESS IN THAT ATTORNEYS OPINION THAT WAS A CONGREGATION OF COMMISSIONERS TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING THAT WAS WITHIN SUBJECT MATTER. YOU CAN DO OTHER THINGS, YOU CAN ATTEND OTHER MEETINGS PUBLICLY NOTICED. YOU CAN TALK ABOUT THE WEATHER , SUPPORTS, YOU CAN DO OTHER THINGS BUT IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT BUSINESS AS A PLANNING COMMISSION OR YOU NEED TO HAVE THAT AS A PUBLIC NOTICED MEETING AND POSTED DEPENDING ON THE NATURE OF THE ACTION YOU'RE TAKING YOU MIGHT NEED TO TAKE ACTION WITHIN A CERTAIN RADIUS OF WHAT THE ADDRESSES NEXT IS CONFLICT OF INTEREST. THERE'S ABOUT 500 PAGES WORTH OF INFORMATION AND VARIOUS HANDBOOKS OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST BUT I CAN SUMMARIZE PRETTY QUICKLY IF YOU'RE LOOKING AT A APPLICATION TO DO THINGS IN A PARTICULAR LOCATION THE FIRST IS WITHIN 500 FEET, BASICALLY THERE PRESUMPTION IF YOU HAVE A PROPERTY INTEREST, YOUR HOME , WHERE YOUR BUSINESS IS LOCATED IF YOU ARE THE PROPERTY OWNER WITH RENTAL INCOME ANY SORT OF FINANCIAL INTEREST THERE IS PRESUMPTION YOU HAVE CONFLICT OF INTEREST. THERE MIGHT BE SOME EXCEPTIONS WHERE YOU CONTINUE TO PARTICIPATE , BUT THE BEST PRACTICE IS NOT TO PARTICIPATE IN THAT DECISION NO REASON TO TAKE THAT CHANCE IF THERE IS A VIOLATION YOU WILL BE FINED PERSONALLY IT CAN ALSO RESERVE REVERSE THE DECISION MADE AND HAVE A COUPLE EXAMPLES OF THAT IF WE WANT TO GET INTO THAT, SO THAT IS, WHERE STANBACK ANOTHER GOOD REASON TO CALL STAFF AND SAY YOU CAN SEE WHAT THE DISTANCES TO MAKE SURE THERE'S NOT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST. NEXT IS 1000 FEET SO THERE IS A GRAY AREA BETWEEN 501,000 FEET AND IN SOME CASES THERE IS NO CONFLICT OF INTEREST , LET'S SAY SOMEBODY IS BUILDING A HOUSE, SINGLE-FAMILY HOME, 800 FEET FROM YOUR HOME PROBABLY NOT AN IMPACT LEGALLY YOU CAN'T PARTICIPATE IN THAT BECAUSE THERE IS NO CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE. WITH A FINANCIAL BENEFIT TO YOU BUT SAY IT IS A BIG BOX RETAIL, COSCO, THAT PROBABLY DOES HAVE AN IMPACT FINANCIALLY ON THE VALUE ON YOUR REAL ESTATE INTEREST WHICH YOU SHOULD RECUSE EVEN THOUGH YOU'RE OUTSIDE THE 500 FEET. GENERAL AT 5000 FEET THERE IS THE PRESUMPTION IN THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST THERE COULD BE SOME EXAMPLES. I CAN'T THINK OF ONE OF THE TOP OF MY HEAD BUT THERE COULD BE RARE EXAMPLES WHERE YOU WOULD STILL HAVE CONFLICT OF INTEREST OUTSIDE OF 1000 FEET PICK UP THE PHONE, CALL STAFF, CALL THE CITY ATTORNEY AND GET SOME DISCUSSION . LASTLY THE BROWN ACT AND SOCIAL MEDIA AND PUBLIC RECORDS , EGG AND EVERYTHING IS A PUBLIC RECORD. WHETHER IT IS A PIECE OF PAPER OR CORRESPONDENCE, IT IS AN EMAIL , WHATEVER'S ON YOUR PHONE IF IT HAS TO DO WITH CITY BUSINESS TEXT MESSAGES WITH YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT A COMMISSION MEETING COMING UP , THAT IS PUBLIC RECORD. AND SO THE ADVICE SOCIAL MEDIA IF YOU THUMBS UP SOMEBODY'S POST THAT HAS TO DO WITH SOMETHING IN THE COMMUNITY YOU ARE SERVING, THAT IS COMMUNICATION THAT BECOMES PUBLIC RECORD CONCEIVABLY BECOMES A VIOLATION OF THE BROWN ACT WITH THE MAJORITY GOING THUMBS UP OR THUMBS DOWN OR I'M NOT SURE THAT STARTS TO BE AN INDICATION OF A VIOLATION OF THE BROWN ACT AND THE PUBLIC RECORD CAN BE USED AGAINST YOU. THE OTHER THING TO BE AWARE OF AND THE HOPEFULLY VERY RARE CASE THAT THERE IS , THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS TO WHAT IS PUBLIC RECORD SO SOMETIMES DRAFT DOCUMENTS ARE NOT PUBLIC RECORD BUT IN THE CASE OF LITIGATION THERE CAN BE A SUBPOENA ISSUED AND THINGS THAT ARE NOT TECHNICALLY PUBLIC RECORD ARE SUBPOENAED AND BECOME PART OF THE COURT RECORD WHICH IS THEN PUBLIC . AGAIN BE VERY CAREFUL I HAVE HAD A SITUATION OVER THE COURSE OF MY CAREER WHERE SOMEONE WAS COMMUNICATING INFORMALLY WITH SOMEBODY DID NOT CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC RECORD PURSUANT TO PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST IT WAS A SUBPOENA AND IT DID NOT LOOK GOOD. THERE WAS A SIDE CONVERSATION GOING ON SO BE SUPER CAREFUL ABOUT SOCIAL MEDIA. THAT'S THE ADVICE OF ANY PLANNING COMMISSION OR ANY COMMISSIONER IN ANY PUBLIC REALM. I'M GOING TO GRAB MY WATER BOTTLE FOR A SECOND YEAR. ALL RIGHT. ON TO THE NEXT TOPIC. AGAIN THIS IS SOMETHING WE COULD SPEND A LOT OF TIME TALKING ABOUT. AT THIS MOMENT IN TIME TALKING ABOUT EQUITY IN THE CONTEXT OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS AND POLICIES CARRIES SOME POLITICAL SENSITIVITY, NO QUESTION ABOUT THAT. THE ISSUE IS STILL OUT THERE IN COMMUNITIES WITH ENGAGING EVERYONE , TRYING TO BE RESPONSIVE TO EVERYONE AND THAT GETS TO COMING UP WITH POLICIES AND PROGRAMS. AND THERE IS A LOT OF DIFFERENT RESOURCES AND A LOT OF TECHNIQUES IN TERMS OF ENGAGING PEOPLE TO ENSURE WE ARE HEARING ALL THE VOICES WHEN DECISIONS ARE MADE. THE THREE-MINUTE PUBLIC HEARING FORMAT YOU HAVE TO USE AT A FORMAL PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING IS SORT OF THE MOST AWKWARD AND CLUMSY OF ALL TYPES OF PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT. IT WOULD BE NICE TO BE ABLE TO SIT DOWN AND HAVE A CONVERSATION OR BE AT A PUBLIC EVENT OR WORKSHOP, ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT WAYS OF DOING IT SO IN TERMS OF EQUITY IT IS JUST REALLY IMPORTANT TO BE AWARE OF THE IMPORTANCE OF ENGAGING WITH THE COMMUNITY, LISTENING TO THE COMMUNITY TO BRING THAT BACK DECISION-MAKING PROCESS. I WILL SAY THAT THE PROFESSIONAL PLANNERS THAT YOU HAVE HERE ON STAFF AND CONSULTANTS AND SO FORTH FOR DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES, WE HAVE A CODE OF ETHICS THAT REQUIRES WE GIVE ATTENTION TO ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND RACIAL EQUITY SO WE SEE THAT IN OUR PROFESSION AND WE ARE PROUD OF THAT, WE REALIZE IT IS A SENSITIVE ISSUE NATIONALLY, BUT NONETHELESS THAT IS SOMETHING WE CONTINUE TO SEE AND FEEL AS A PROFESSION THAT IT IS VALUABLE AND LEADS TO BETTER DECISIONS TO THE COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE. THERE MAY BE OTHER COMMUNITIES WITH ORGANIZATION CODE OF ETHICS FORMAL OR INFORMAL, THOSE ARE AS WELL POLICIES AND PROGRAMS AND COMMUNITIES I HAVE WORKED IN THERE'S USUALLY AN EQUITY ANALYSIS AS PART OF EVERY STAFF REPORT. GETTING CLOSE TO THE END OF MY PART OF THE PRESENTATION, A COUPLE MORE THINGS I WANT TO MENTION. WE WILL TALK IN A FEW MINUTES ABOUT HOUSING LEGISLATION. BEFORE WE GO THERE, A LITTLE BIT OF CONTEXT. THERE ARE LOTS OF DIFFERENT LAYERS TO THE LAWS AND PROGRAMS AND POLICIES THAT US COMMISSIONERS AND WE HAS TO DO ALL THE TIME AND THIS HIERARCHY IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND. DOES START FROM THE TOP FROM THE CONSTITUTION AND ROLLS ON DOWN TO DECISIONS YOU MAKE ON A DAILY BASIS. THE IMPORTANT THING ABOUT THIS HIERARCHY IS THE HIGHER LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT PREEMPT THE LOWER LEVELS, LOCAL GOVERNMENT DOWN AT THE BOTTOM SO WHAT WE ARE EXPERIENCING IN A COUPLE AREAS IN CALIFORNIA RIGHT NOW IS SAY FOR EXAMPLE THE BEST EXAMPLE IS HOUSING REGULATION, STATE LEGISLATURE IS ACTIVELY IN THE AREA OF HOUSING POLICY OPPOSING FOR BETTER OR WORSE, ZONING CHANGES ON CITIES AND THEY ARE DOING THAT BECAUSE THIS HIERARCHY GIVES THEM LEGAL AUTHORITY TO PREEMPT ANYTHING THAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO DO AT THE LOCAL LEVEL, SOMETIMES THERE'S A LOT OF DISCUSSION ABOUT ELECTRIFICATION REQUIREMENTS AND NEW CONSTRUCTION, THAT'S ANOTHER AREA WHERE STATE AND FEDERAL LAW AND THE TERM IS OCCUPY THE FIELD , THERE ARE REGULATIONS ABOUT ENERGY EFFICIENCY THAT KIND OF HAMSTRING HOW WE IN THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CAN REGULATE SOME OF THOSE ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASURES THAT WE LIKE TO DO LOCALLY IF WE COULD THE NEXT SLIDE SAYS THIS IS IN PROPER ORDER. LAST LIGHT AND THEN IT WILL TAKE A BREAK. THREE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF PLANNING DECISIONS TYPICALLY MADE IN DECISIONS FIRST IS THE CITY COUNCIL IS THE FINAL DECISION-MAKER APPROVING THE GENERAL PLAN FOR MY COLLEAGUE ABOUT GENERAL PLAN SPECIFIC PLANS ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS, US PLANNING COMMISSIONERS HAVE A ROLE IN MAKING , AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN TAKING PUBLIC COMMENT AND CRAFTING THE DRAFT OF THE DOCUMENTS LEGISLATIVE DECISION FINAL DECISION THE SECOND IS THE QUASIJUDICIAL TYPICALLY THE ACTION TAKEN BY PLANNING COMMISSION WHATEVER THAT MAY BE YOUR TAKING THE POLICIES AND PROGRAMS APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL THE LEGISLATIVE ACTS AND APPLYING GHOST APPLICATION SUBPOENAED TO YOU AND YOUR BASICALLY MAKING SURE THAT THE PROJECT COMPLIES WITH PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANS. THE SCOPE OF HIS CITIES AND PLANNING COMMISSIONS CAN DO WITH THE QUASIJUDICIAL FIELD IS CHANGING PRETTY DRAMATICALLY IN CALIFORNIA PARTICULARLY IN THE CONTEXT OF HOUSING. 10 OR 15 YEARS AGO WE HAD DISCRETION ABOUT WHETHER SOMETHING WAS COMPATIBLE WITH DESIGN GUIDELINES THAT WERE VERY SUBJECTIVE. I LIKE THAT, THAT IS OKAY, THAT WAS AN OKAY REPRESENTATIVE TODAY WE SEE MORE MANDATES OR OBJECTIVE STANDARDS WERE IT IS ALL METHOD THEY MEASURE THREE FEET, SIX FEET, WHATEVER THE STANDARD IS SO THE QUASIJUDICIAL IS LESS SUBJECTIVE OPTIONS IN SOME OF THESE QUASIJUDICIAL DECISIONS TODAY. FINALLY MINISTERIAL HAS CHANGED DRAMATICALLY OVER THE LAST DECADE OR SO, THIS USED TO BE BASICALLY REALLY SIMPLE PROJECTS , BASIC STUFF SOMEBODY BUILDING A GARAGE OR REMODELING A HOUSE OR SOMETHING THAT IS APPROVED BY STAFF, IT IS A NO-BRAINER OR MAYBE IT'S SIMPLY A BUILDING PERMIT AND IT'S NOT A BIG DEAL AT ALL THERE'S NO NEED TO TAKE TIME OR SEND PUBLIC NOTICES TO NEIGHBORHOODS SO FORTH A LOT OF THINGS THAT USED TO BE IN THAT QUASIJUDICIAL CATEGORY ARE DROPPING TO MINISTERIAL AND ALL OF A SUDDEN I HAD THE EXPERIENCE A FEW YEARS AGO OF IMPROVING A FAIRLY LARGE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT AT THE STAFF LEVEL AND IT FELT VERY AWKWARD LIKE I'M NOT SUPPOSED TO BE DOING THIS BUT THE NEW STATE LAWS ARE TELLING ME STEP UP IT IS YOUR JOB FOR BETTER OR WORSE. AND AGAIN THAT IS A TREND WE ARE GOING WITH , WITH CHANGES IN STATE LAW MOSTLY IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING. SO, AT THIS POINT WE WILL TAKE A QUICK BREAK. I WOULD BE DELIGHTED TO FIELD ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE ALSO INVITE MICHAEL IF YOU WANT TO MAKE ELABORATIONS. YOU DON'T HAVE TO, BUT IF I SAID ANYTHING , I RESPECT MICHAEL'S KNOWLEDGE ON THIS AS WELL AND THEN MY COLLEAGUE JEFF BRADLEY. I WILL START WITH COMMISSIONERS. >> FIRST OF ALL, THANK YOU VERY MUCH, QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM ANY COMMISSIONERS? WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT A MINISTERIAL VERSUS POSITIVE HOW DO YOU KNOW WHEN TO ELEVATE? WHAT GUIDING LANGUAGE DOES THAT FEEL LIKE THIS IS NOT SOMETHING WE DECIDE ON A STAFF LEVEL? IT IS AND IF THERE SOMETHING SPECIFIC ABOUT MARTINEZ MICHAEL CAN JUMP IN BUT IT IS SPECIFIED IN THE MUNICIPAL CODE OR STATE LAW SO FOR EXAMPLE THE EXAMPLE I GAVE A MOMENT AGO ABOUT AFFORDABLE HOUSING STATE LAW WAS CLEAR IT WAS AFFORDABLE HOUSING WE MET THE CRITERIA THIS IS MINISTERIAL APPROVED BY STAFF IT WAS BLACK AND WHITE TEXT STRAIGHTFORWARD THERE WAS NOT ANY GRAY AREA AT ALL. I WILL SAY SOMETIMES I HAVE IN NON-HOUSING WHERE STATE LAW DOES NOT MANDATE I HAVE HAD A COUPLE OCCASIONS WHERE IT WAS NORMALLY MINISTERIAL TO PROVE A SIGN PERMIT OR SOMETHING I LOOK AT IT LIKE THIS IS A REALLY UGLY SIGN. I'M NOT COMFORTABLE WITH THIS. ON OCCASION HAVE BUMPED IT UP TO COMMISSION LIKE BEFORE I TURN THIS DOWN I GIVE THE APPLICANT A CHANCE AND GIVE THE COMMISSIONERS A CHANCE TO TALK ABOUT IT BUT THAT IS PRETTY RARE. FOR THE MOST PART IF THE CODE SAYS THIS IS A MINISTERIAL DECISION THAT'S WHERE IT NEEDS TO GO. >> WITH THE LAST EXAMPLE DOESN'T WORK BOTH WAYS? DOES THE COMMISSION HAVE RIGHT TO CALL MINISTERIAL TO THE PURVIEW OF THE COMMISSION? >> YOU WOULD NOT KNOW ABOUT IT. NOW, AN APPLICANT, LET'S SAY USING MY EXAMPLE I DENY THE APPLICANT COULD APPEAL TO YOU THEN YOU WOULD HEAR ABOUT IT SOONER. GENERALLY IN THE PROCESSING APPLICATIONS WE DON'T RAISE THE BAR IN THE PROCESS. YOU DON'T RAISE THE BAR WE ASKED STAFF HAVE THAT DISCRETION. TO CORRECT MYSELF A LITTLE BIT IN THE CODE BOOKS I HAVE WORKED WITH THE CODEBOOKS GIVE PLANNING DIRECTOR DISCRETION TO ELEVATE SO THAT'S THE AUTHORITY I WILL BE USING TO BRING IT TO THE COMMISSION IF IT DOES NOT GIVE THE AUTHORITY ? I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE TWO POINTS BASED ON THE DISCUSSION WE ARE HAVING. FIRST A MARTINEZ ANTIDOTE WE DENY VERY FEW PROJECTS. WE WANT TO BE KNOWN AS DEVELOPMENT FRIENDLY JURISDICTION THIS IS JUST AN EXAMPLE JEFF WAS GIVING SECONDLY I WANT TO TALK MORE ABOUT QUASIJUDICIAL DISHES AND SO, WHEN A COMMISSION IS MAKING A QUASIJUDICIAL DECISION WHILE NOT BASED ON OBJECTIVE STANDARDS LIKE MINISTERIAL ACTION WOULD BE THERE IS SUBJECTIVITY IMPOSED THE CODE WILL CALL OUT FINDINGS THAT NEED TO BE MADE BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND ANY DECISION THAT WOULD BE MADE NEEDS TO BE BASED UPON YOUR ABILITY TO MAKE OR NOT MAKE ONE OR MORE OF THOSE FINDINGS SO YOU HAVE TO HAVE EVIDENCE THAT IS PUT INTO THE RECORD WITH THE REASONING BEHIND YOUR DECISION AND THE DISCRETION YOU ARE IMPOSING ON A PARTICULAR PROJECT. >> I HAVE A QUESTION. YOU MENTIONED GRAY AREAS. CAN YOU GIVE US AN EXAMPLE OF A GRAY AREA? YOU WERE SAYING IT IS VERY CLEAR, THEN YOU MENTIONED THERE ARE SOME GRAY AREAS. >> IN THE CONTEXT? >> BETWEEN MINISTERIAL? THE DISCUSSION WE HAVE NOW. THE GRAY AREA WOULD BE IF THERE WAS AGAIN OF THE CODE GIVES THE STAFF THE AUTHORITY TO ELEVATE SOMETHING. THAT IS KIND OF A GRAY AREA OTHERWISE IT IS REALLY NOT INTENDED TO BE A GRAY AREA. AND YOU KNOW IF THERE ARE SOME AMBIGUITIES IN THE CODE FOR WHATEVER COMMUNITY MIGHT BE STRUGGLING WITH THESE ISSUES I WOULD RECOMMEND MAKING IT REALLY CLEAR LIKE THERE WAS A CERTAIN NUMERICAL THRESHOLD WHETHER SIZE OR WHATEVER THE PARAMETERS WOULD BE THAT MAKES IT CLEAR IF IT IS MINISTERIAL OR NOT THEN GET THE PLANNING STAFF AN OPTION TO ELEVATE. SORRY IF I WAS A LITTLE MISLEADING. >> I WAS FOLLOWING UP WITH WHAT YOU WERE SAYING. SO, THE ELEVATION WHAT DOES THE STAFF BASE THIS ON WHEN THEY DECIDE TO ELEVATE TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION? WHAT IS THE CRITERIA? >> FIRST OF ALL IT IS VERY RARE IN MY CAREER I'VE ONLY DONE THIS A COUPLE TIMES AND IT WAS MOSTLY BECAUSE I WAS TRYING TO BE COURTEOUS TO THE APPLICANT AND THAT , RATHER THAN RATHER SAY YOU ARE DENIED NOW YOU HAVE TO PAY A FEE TO FILE APPEAL AND THAT TAKES 30 OR 60 DAYS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT IF WE FUNDAMENTALLY ARE NOT AGREEING AND STAFF CANNOT GET TO A PLACE WHERE WE WANT TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL NOT SAYING LET ME CORRECT THAT NOT RECOMMENDING WE ARE APPROVING SIGNING OFF IF WE'RE NOT IN A PLACE TO DO THAT, THAT'S THE SCENARIO I HAVE USED THE ELEVATION. AGAIN AS A COURTESY YOU DON'T HAVE TO DO IT. AND THERE HAVE BEEN OTHER OCCASIONS WHERE AGAIN THIS IS VERY RARE, BUT SIMPLY DESIGN DENY THE APPLICATION AND SAY IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT THEN YOU WILL APPEAL IT BUT IT IS MORE OF A CUSTOMER SERVICE COURTESY IN MY MIND IS WHY I HAVE DONE THAT. >> WHAT I WOULD ADD TO THAT IS THAT IT COULD BE IF IT IS A DECISION THAT IS INHERENTLY A POLITICAL DECISION THAT STAFF DOES NOT WANT TO BE THE FACE OF THAT DECISION WANTING A VARIETY OF INDIVIDUALS OR COMMISSIONERS TO OPINE ON WHATEVER THE DETERMINATION MAY BE. THANK YOU. >> COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS? I WILL GIVE IT BACK TO THE PRESENTATION. DO WE WANT TO OPEN TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC? SURE WE CAN DO THAT DO ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WISH TO ASK QUESTIONS? PLEASE STEP FORWARD. YES PLEASE. >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. I HAD SOME QUESTIONS ON YOUR PREVIOUS SLIDE ABOUT THE QUASIJUDICIAL. IF YOU'RE WORKING WITH A RUN-OF-THE-MILL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT THAT IS QUASIJUDICIAL I WOULD ASSUME BECAUSE IT IS NOT LEGISLATIVE OR MINISTERIAL? >> NO PROJECTS CAN TAKE ALL THREE FORMS. SO EVEN A RUN-OF-THE-MILL PROJECT MIGHT REQUIRE REZONING SO THAT IS A LEGISLATIVE DECISION OR IT COULD BE STRICTLY MINISTERIAL BECAUSE IT FITS. IT DEPENDS ON THE PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES. >> IF YOU HAVE A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT YOU WILL KICK IT UP TO COUNCIL TO APPROVE. >> RIGHT OR I HAVE A PROJECT WHERE THE ZONING MAP IS 80 YEARS OLD AND THE KIND OF THE YOU KNOW THE LAYOUT THE VISION 80 YEARS AGO DOES NOT WORK FOR MODERN DEVELOPMENT SO AS PART OF THE PROJECT IT WAS AMONG OTHER DECISIONS TO BE MADE THERE NEEDED TO BE ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT TO GET THE APPROVAL PROCESS. >> THAT MAKE SENSE. WHAT ABOUT DESIGN REVIEW BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS THAT FALL UNDER THESE CATEGORIES. >> IT VARIES CITY TO CITY SOMETIMES REVIEW BOARDS ARE DECISION-MAKING IN WHICH THEY PLAY A QUASIJUDICIAL ROLE, OTHER TIMES THEY WOULD BE ADVISORY TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION IN WHICH CASE THEY ARE ADVISORY STILL SUBJECT TO MEETING REQUIREMENTS AND PUBLIC RECORDS AND SO FORTH BUT ALL THEY ARE DOING IS MAKING A RECOMMENDATION. NOT UNLIKE HOW SOMETIMES PLANNING COMMISSION MAKES RECOMMENDATION TO THE CITY COUNCIL. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. >> YOU ARE WELCOME THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTIONS. >> ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC HERE THAT WISH TO ASK A QUESTION? ONLINE MAYBE? >> NO HEADS ARE RAISED. >> WE WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT FOR THIS SECTION. TURN IT BACK OVER TO STAFF AND THE PRESENTATION. >> KEEP ROLLING? OKAY. >> I WILL SAY WE DO HAVE SNACKS AND DRINKS FOR THOSE WHO ARE PRESENT PLEASE FEEL FREE TO HELP YOURSELVES AND YOU CAN GET UP AT ANY POINT. >> HAVING A LITTLE TROUBLE GETTING THE NEXT SLIDE DOWN AND MY POINTING IT IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. THERE WE GO. OKAY, SO I MENTIONED EARLIER THAT I COVERED HUNDREDS OF PAGES OF STATE LAW IN ABOUT FIVE MINUTES NOW LOOK OVER HUNDREDS OF PIECES OF LEGISLATION IN FIVE MINUTES. THERE IS A LOT GOING ON IN THE STATE LEGISLATURE. THIS BEGAN ABOUT NINE YEARS AGO OR EIGHT YEARS AGO KIND OF THE , THE WORD THAT COMES TO MIND IS A BLIZZARD OF NEW LEGISLATION. SOME OF THIS A LOT OF IT HAS DRAMATICALLY CHANGED HOW PLANNING WORKS PARTICULARLY FOCUSED ON HOUSING HOW PLANNING WORKS IN CALIFORNIA. SOME OF THEM HAVE NOT BEEN IMPACTFUL AT ALL AND NONETHELESS EVERY YEAR THERE ARE DOZENS OF COMPLEX PIECES OF LEGISLATION THAT COME THROUGH. THEY ARE NOT ALWAYS THOUGHT THROUGH SUPER CONSISTENTLY WITH WHAT IS ON THE BOOKS SO IT IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST CHALLENGES THAT WE AS PLANNING STAFF HAVE HAD OVER THE LAST DECADE, ABSORBING THIS CONSTANT STREAM OF YEARS ANOTHER 50 LAWS YOU NEED TO READ AND FIGURE OUT WHETHER IT IMPACTS THE PROJECTS YOU ARE PROCESSING WITH POLICIES AND PROGRAMS THAT YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR AND MANY OF THEM DO. IT IS NOT DONE YET, 26 IS AROUND THE CORNER. YOU WILL GET A BUNCH OF NEW ONES NEXT YEAR. SO HANG ON. A COUPLE OF THEM I WILL GO THROUGH THREE OR FOUR SLIDES OF SOME OF THE HIGHLIGHTS RIGHT NOW ONE OF THE HIGHLIGHTS ONE OF THE PIECES OF LEGISLATION YOU WILL SEE IN THE NEWS A LOT IT DOES NOT APPLY IN CONTRA COSTA BUT NONETHELESS IT IS IN THE HEADLINES ALMOST EVERY DAY SB 79 CARVES A CIRCLE AROUND LARGER TRANSIT STATIONS IN EIGHT COUNTIES IN CALIFORNIA EIGHT URBAN COUNTIES ALAMEDA, SAN FRANCISCO, AND IN THE BAY AREA I FORGET WHAT THEY ARE IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. ANYHOW IT DRAMATICALLY INCREASES THE DENSITY OF DEVELOPMENT AND AUTHORIZES TRANSIT AGENCIES TO BE THEIR OWN PLANNING DECISION-MAKERS WITHIN THE LAND WITHIN THOSE HALF MILES OF THEIR TRANSIT STATIONS. SO WE WILL SEE HOW THIS PLAYS OUT. IT IS A COMPLICATED NEW LAW. I READ IT ONCE AND IT WAS A LITTLE CHALLENGING TO MAKE ITSELF PERSONALLY BUT REALLY SMART PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT AND PREPARE GUIDELINES FOR THE PLANNING PROFESSION ON HOW TO IMPLEMENT THIS LAW A FEW OF THE OTHERS WE CAN RUN THROUGH A FEW OF THESE SB 684 IS TALKS ABOUT THE MINISTERIAL STAFF DECISION MINISTERIAL APPROVAL SUBDIVIDING LARGER PARCELS INTO SMALLER PARCELS FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT , HISTORICALLY THAT BE SOMETHING THE PLANNING COMMISSION WOULD SEE OR CITY COUNCIL DEPENDING ON PROCEDURES LOCALLY NOW THAT IS A MINISTERIAL ACTION BY CITY AND STAFF. 8507 TALKS ABOUT WHICH ONE IS THAT? ADAPTIVE REUSE OF BUILDINGS FROM COMMERCIAL TO RESIDENTIAL USE THE FOUR LAWS THAT ARE MOST SIGNIFICANCE AND YOU CAN SEE OVER AND OVER AGAIN IN YOUR COMMUNITIES BEING USED ARE THE FOUR ON THE SCREEN, FIRST IS STATE DENSITY BONUS LAW. THIS IS A LAW BEEN AROUND A LONG TIME BUT IT HAS BEEN AMENDED ALMOST EVERY YEAR IN THE LAST 10 YEARS OR SO AND IT IS A VERY POWERFUL LAW THAT BASICALLY SAYS IF A RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT AS A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING WITH A LOW THRESHOLD OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING THEY START TO GET INCENTIVES AND CONCESSIONS AND BASICALLY WAIVERS TO CITY ZONING STANDARDS. AND IT IS A COMPANY GET A FORMULA LIKE READING A TEXT TABLE IT DEPENDS ON THE NUMBER OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS IN THE PROJECT AND THE LEVEL OF AFFORDABILITY TO THE NUMBER OF THESE INCENTIVES AND CONCESSIONS THAT CITIES HAVE TO GRANT BUT IT IS A POWERFUL STATE LAW NEARLY EVERY MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT IN CALIFORNIA USES THIS DENSITY BONUS LAW AND IT IS CONSTANTLY BEING AMENDED. NEXT IS THE HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY ACT AND THIS IS A OLD LAW AMENDED IN RECENT YEARS. THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROVIDED A MEMO TO HELP UNDERSTAND THE DETAILS OF HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY AND THE MEMO RUNS 42 PAGES. I LOOKED AT IT THIS AFTERNOON. THE HEART OF IT BASICALLY SAYS IN ORDER TO DENY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT YOU HAVE TO MAKE SPECIFIC FINDINGS AND WRITING BASED ON PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE THAT THERE IS A VERY SPECIFIC ADVERSE IMPACT ON PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY THAT WOULD OCCUR AS A RESULT OF THE PROJECT. THAT IS A VERY HIGH BAR TO JUMP OVER SO AGAIN IT MAKES IT VERY DIFFICULT ON COMMUNITIES TO SAY WE DON'T THINK THIS IS A GOOD IDEA AND A LOT OF THE EXPEDITIONS AND THE BASIS WE USE TO DECIDE WE DON'T WANT TO PROVE THIS WE NEED TO SCALE BACK, THIS LAW MAKES IT MORE DIFFICULT TO DO THAT NOW. SB 35 IS THE LAW THAT SAYS IF IT IS AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN MOST COMMUNITIES IT IS A MINISTERIAL APPROVAL AND THAT HAS BEEN AROUND, THAT WAS ONE OF THE FIRST BIG CHANGES STATE HOUSING LAW IN 2017 AND AGAIN YOU SEE THIS ALL THE TIME IF THERE IS AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA IT'S PROBABLY APPROVED THROUGH SB 35. FINALLY SB 330 THIS IS A LAW THAT WAS FIRST ADOPTED IN 2019 AND DRAMATICALLY CHANGES THE PACE OF PROCESSING HOUSING APPLICATIONS. IN PARTICULAR IT LIMITS THE PUBLIC MEETINGS TO FIVE THE NUMBER OF PUBLIC MEETINGS TO FIVE AND THINK THROUGH THAT, THAT PUTS A LOT OF PRESSURE ON CITY STAFF, ON PLANNING COMMISSIONS , ON CITY COUNCILS TO REALLY THINK THROUGH PROJECTS , LISTEN TO THE COMMUNITY AND MAKE A DECISION QUICKLY. YOU DON'T HAVE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A BUNCH OF STUDY SESSIONS AND ANYTHING THE CITY ORGANIZERS CONSTITUTE AS A MEETING SO IT'S NOT JUST HAY IT IS A FORMAL PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING IF YOU HAVE A INFORMAL WORKSHOP WITH TREATS FOR PEOPLE TO COME BY THAT CAN CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC MEETING IN A LOT OF CASES SO SB 330 COMPELS YOU TO MAKE DECISIONS QUICKLY AND THE OTHER PART OF SB 330 IT ESTABLISHES WHEN THE APPLICATION COMES IN IT LOGS DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS AND FEES AND SO FORTH SO AGAIN WHEN THAT COMES IN THE DOOR YOU ARE REVIEWING THAT PROJECT ON THE BASIS OF WHAT WAS ON THE BOOKS THE DAY IT COMES IN THE DOOR SO SOMETIMES THESE COME IN AS A SURPRISE, YOU MIGHT BE WORKING ON LET'S DO AMENDMENTS TO DESIGN GUIDELINES OR TO THE FEE STANDARDS AND THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN SOMEBODY WALKS IN , THOSE THINGS YOU HAVE BEEN WORKING ON DO NOT APPLY. NEXT, A FEW MORE TO RUN THROUGH. I WOULD SAY ONE OF THE PIECES OR SERIES OF PIECES OF LEGISLATION WITH THE BIGGEST IMPACT ON THE GROUND IN TERMS OF HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA AND VARIOUS EDU LAWS THAT ARE PASSED A SERIES OF THEM BACK IN 2016 EVERY YEAR IT SEEMS LIKE IT GETS TWEAKED A LITTLE BIT HERE AND THERE. IT MORE OR LESS ALLOWS PEOPLE TO BUILD THE EDU WITH SOME EXCEPTIONS ANYWHERE YOU WANT ON A PIECE OF PROPERTY. I WON'T GO INTO THE DETAILS OF THAT, BUT AGAIN THERE ARE GOOD HANDBOOKS PUT OUT BY HOUSING COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT THAT PROVIDE THE DETAILS OF THAT. AND AGAIN THAT IS ANOTHER MINISTERIAL APPROVAL . IT SURPRISES AND DISAPPOINTS PEOPLE I KNOW THAT. A PERSON MIGHT BE SITTING IN THE BACKYARD ONE DAY AND THEN NOTICE THEIR NEIGHBOR BUILDING A TWO-STORY ADU ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE FENCE AND THEY WILL CALL UP OR CALL YOU OR CALL CITY STAFF AND SAY WHAT'S GOING ON THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS AND THERE'S NOTHING WE CAN DO THAT COMES OUT OF STATE LAW WITH A SERIES OF LEGISLATION THAT BEGAN IN 2016. SB NINE IS A LAW THAT WAS PASSED A FEW YEARS AGO. IT GOT A LOT OF ATTENTION, ALLOWS FOR SUBDIVIDING SINGLE-FAMILY LOT INTO SMALLER LOTS IT HAS NOT GOT A LOT OF TRACTION INITIALLY AT LEAST BUT HEARING FROM OTHER COMMUNITIES STARTING TO SEE SOME PEOPLE USE THIS AS A WAY TO SUBDIVIDE THE PROPERTY. SO IT COULD BECOME SOMETHING THAT YOU WILL HEAR ABOUT FROM TIME TO TIME 2097 WAS A PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT BASICALLY SAID ANYTIME YOU HAVE A FAIRLY BUSY BUS STOP , 20 MINUTE HEADWAY MEANING BUS SERVICE EVERY 20 MINUTES OR SO RUSH-HOUR YOU CAN NO LONGER REQUIRE PARKING WITHIN HALF A MILE OF THE BUS STOP SO IN SOME CITIES LIKE THE CITY I WORKED IN, IN ALBANY THAT IS THE WHOLE CITY. THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN A LITTLE POCKET IN THE CORNER BUT IT WAS NOT WORTH , IT WOULD BE TOO CONFUSING TO EXPLAIN WHY ONLY THESE FEW BLOCKS HAVE PARKING REQUIREMENTS. SO THAT WAS IMPORTANT LEGISLATION AND THEN MY COLLEAGUE GEOFF BRADLEY WILL TALK MORE ABOUT GENERAL PLANS BUT THERE HAVE BEEN A SERIES OF PIECES OF LEGISLATION CHANGING WHEN NEEDS TO GO TO THE GENERAL PLAN FOR A LONG TIME MANY YEARS IN MY VIEW IT WAS A STATIC LAW WITH BASIC REQUIREMENTS OF THE GENERAL PLAN AND YOU COULD DO A GENERAL PLAN AND IT MIGHT LAST 15 OR 20 YEARS AND IF IT WAS A GOOD PLAN AND VISIONARY YOU DID NOT NEED TO MAKE BIG CHANGES , BUT TODAY WITH THE LEGISLATURE ACTIVE WE HAVE A LOT MORE THINGS YOU NEED TO INCORPORATE INTO YOUR GENERAL PLAN WITH TIMELINES TO DO THAT. SO THAT WILL BE SOMETHING COMMISSIONS WILL HEAR ABOUT, PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY WILL HEAR ABOUT AND ULTIMATELY THEY WILL NEED TO GO TO CITY COUNCIL. AND FINALLY WITH THAT I WILL HAND IT OVER TO GEOFF BRADLEY TO CONTINUE THE PRESENTATION BEFORE I SIT DOWN ANY QUICK QUESTIONS FOR THE HOUSING LEGISLATION? REGARDING THE HOUSING LAW SPECIFICALLY HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY DOES IT INCLUDE DENIAL FOR YOU KNOW SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF PUBLIC PROTEST OR COMMUNITY RESISTANCE THE PLANNING COMMISSION BEING REPRESENTATIVES OF THE PUBLIC THEY CANNOT REALLY VOTE AGAINST WHAT THE PUBLIC IS ASKING FOR SO HOW DOES IT ADDRESS THAT? >> ASKING YOU TO VOTE AGAINST WHAT THE PUBLIC WANTS , THEY'RE TELLING YOU TO, NOT ASKING. THAT IS , THAT IS THE REALITY. THE , UNLESS YOU CAN MAKE THOSE VERY SPECIFIC FINDINGS THAT THERE IS A PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE OF SIGNIFICANT IMPACT , YOU CAN HAVE A ROOM FULL OF PEOPLE SAY THIS IS THE WORST PROJECT THEY HAVE EVER SEEN AND TO FOLLOW THE LAW YOU WOULD NEED TO VOTE TO APPROVE IT. >> . >> STAFF WOULD NEED TO FIND QUANTITATIVE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE CLAIM FROM THE PUBLIC TO VALIDATE RESISTANCE TO THE PROJECT? >> THAT IS RIGHT AND YOU WOULD ALMOST CERTAINLY HAVE AT LEAST A THREAT OF LITIGATION, IF NOT REAL LITIGATION IF, IN FACT EVIDENCE WAS QUESTIONABLE. SO IT WOULD REALLY HAVE TO BE SOMETHING, YOU KNOW I WOULD THINK IF SOMEONE IS PROPOSING TO BUILD HOUSING ON SAY A TOXIC SITE OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT WHICH IS SO OBVIOUS , THAT WOULD BE CLEARLY WHAT THE LAW WAS INTENDED TO DO PERHAPS ENVIRONMENTALLY PARTICULARLY ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE OTHER EXAMPLES , BUT IF IT IS LIKE THERE MIGHT BE SOME , WHO KNOWS MAYBE TRAFFIC IMPACT OR IT'S GOING TO BE WHATEVER THE CONCERN IS, NOISE IS A LITTLE HIGHER THAN WHAT PEOPLE WOULD LIKE TO HAVE IN THE COMMUNITY, THAT IS PROBABLY NOT GOING TO SURVIVE A LEGAL CHALLENGE. THAT'S WHERE YOU WOULD WANT TO HAVE THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AND STAFF PAYING ATTENTION IN DETAIL TO THOSE FINDINGS AND THEN MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO YOU. THINK IT. >> ANY OTHER COMMISSIONERS COMMENT OR QUESTION? >> I'VE A QUESTION ON AB 2997, YOU MENTIONED NO PARKING IS REQUIRED IF HOUSING IS WITHIN I GUESS HALF A MILE OF A BUS STOP THAT HAS REGULAR INTERVALS AND THAT WAS STATED AS EVERY 20 MINUTES. IS THAT BETWEEN CERTAIN HOURS? >> RUSH-HOUR. I FORGET THE TERMINOLOGY THAT THEY USE BUT ESSENTIALLY RUSH-HOUR BUS SERVICE AT A 20 MINUTE RATE THAT WOULD CONSTITUTE MAJOR TRANSIT STOP. I CAN ALSO ADD TO THAT THE LIQUID FOR MAJOR TRANSIT STOP SPECIFIES PEAK PERIODS WHICH IS 8:00 UNTIL 6:00 P.M. AND IT ALSO APPLIES TO MAJOR TRANSIT STOPS WHICH IS BEYOND BUS STOPS AND INCLUDES MAJOR TRANSIT RAIL SUCH AS THE AMTRAK STATION DOWNTOWN WHICH IS THE ONLY MAJOR TRANSIT STOP NONE OF THE OTHERS CONSTITUTE THAT THRESHOLD. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> LET'S REOPEN PUBLIC COMMENT TO SEE IF ANYBODY IN THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO ASK A QUESTION OR MAKE A COMMENT. ANYBODY PRESENT? YES, PLEASE. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION. A LOT OF THEM, THANK YOU FELLOW COMMISSIONERS, WALNUT CREEK PLANNING COMMISSIONER. MY QUESTION IS I WOULD LIKE TO HEAR YOU EXPOUND A LITTLE BIT. WHAT I SEE IS WHEN YOU SHOW THE PYRAMID AT THE BOTTOM YOU KNOW AND THE , THE BLIZZARD AS YOUR SET OF BILLS THAT COME EVERY YEAR WILL PROBABLY CONTINUE. SO I GUESS FROM A PLANNING COMMISSIONER'S PERSPECTIVE WE SEE A LOT OF CONTROL FROM THE STATE , THE DECISIONS ARE BEING TAKEN OUT OF OUR HANDS SO WE ARE PINCHED BETWEEN THE LEGISLATIVE AND MINISTERIAL I WOULD SAY. WHAT CAN WE DO AS COMMISSIONERS TO MAKE AN IMPACT, AS WE SEE OUR ABILITY TO MAKE DECISIONS BEING STRIPPED FROM A SODA BEST. NO JUDGMENT THERE JUST CURIOUS WHAT YOU THINK IN YOUR LONG YEARS OF SERVICE WHAT CAN WE DO? >> YOU KNOW ULTIMATELY, STATE LEGISLATORS ARE WRITING THESE PIECES OF LEGISLATION AND VOTING FOR THEM. SO, THE , WALNUT CREEK IS PROBABLY LARGE ENOUGH CITY THAT YOU HAVE A LOBBYIST AT LEAST PART-TIME THAT MIGHT HELP REPRESENT THE CITY IN SACRAMENTO AND DIFFERENT THINGS. I WOULD START POSING THE QUESTION TO THAT PERSON. THERE ARE PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS THAT WILL WEIGH IN ON THIS LEGISLATION, OUR ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION STATEWIDE LETTERS TAKES POSITIONS, THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES DOES THE SAME. SOMETIMES THOSE POSITIONS ARE DIFFERENT, THE LEAGUE REPRESENTS A BROAD SPECTRUM OF CITIES SO NOT IT CAN BE VERY CONSERVATIVE VERY PROGRESSIVE CITIES WITHIN THE LEAGUE 'S UMBRELLA OF RECOMMENDATIONS TO STATE LEGISLATORS. YOU KNOW I THINK THEN TALKING TO INDIVIDUAL LEGISLATORS IT HAS CHANGED MY VIEW GRASSROOTS WORK. OF IF YOU TOOK MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY WHEN A LOCAL LEGISLATORS HAVING AN EVENT GO AND SAY LOOK THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION IS GREAT, THE OTHER IS NOT SO GOOD, TALK TO THE LEGISLATIVE STAFF, AS WELL. INVITE THE LEGISLATORS TO COME TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING OR CITY COUNCIL MEETING. THAT MAKES SENSE. THANK YOU. >> I WOULD ADD THERE ARE MANY JURISDICTIONS THAT HAVE ADOPTED LEGISLATIVE PLATFORMS AND THAT ENABLES SELECT INDIVIDUALS TO TAKE POSITION STATEMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE CITY WHEN WORKING WITH THE OFFICES WITHOUT THE NEED TO GO TO THE FULL CITY COUNCIL FOR THE BUY IN , TO SUBMIT A LETTER AS WELL. >> ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT TO MAKE QUESTION OR COMMENT? FLIPPING OVER TO THE VIRTUAL COMMUNITY. >> THERE ARE NO HANDS RAISED. SOME VERY GOOD WE WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT TURN IT BACK OVER TO STAFF. THANK YOU, GEOFF. GEOFF BRADLEY. GEOFF DID ALL THE HARD HEAVY STUFF , NOW WE CAN MOVE INTO THE FUN PLANNING STUFF THAT YOU SIGNED UP TO BE ON THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR. WE FLIP COINS THAT'S HOW IT WENT. OKAY. >> OKAY. BEFORE I GET TO THE GENERAL PLAN WANT TO GIVE A CHAT ABOUT SOME TERMINOLOGY. TALKING A LOT ABOUT POLICY PLANNING WHICH IS BIG PICTURE PLANNING, LONG-TERM PLANNING , IT GOES BY A LOT OF DIFFERENT NAMES. YOU WILL HEAR ABOUT A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MOSTLY IN CALIFORNIA WE HAVE STANDARDIZED ON THE GENERAL PLAN WITH SOME CITIES THEY STILL HAVE A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. SO, THE GRANDDADDY OF THEM ALL WITHIN THE POLICY PLANNING ARENA IS THE GENERAL PLAN. IT IS DESCRIBED AS THE FOUNDATIONAL BLUEPRINT OR EVEN THE CONSTITUTION OF HOW THE CITY DEALS WITH ITS DECISIONS ON LAND USE , EVERYTHING WITHIN THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT. SO BY DEFINITION IT IS A LONG-TERM DOCUMENT AND TYPICALLY YOU READ ABOUT IT AND PLANNERS TALK AND SAY GENERAL PLANS SHOULD BE FORECASTED OUT 20 YEARS AS TIME GOES ON WITH THE RATE OF CHANGE WE EXPERIENCE IT IS SPEED IT UP THAT IS OUT OF DATE. WE SEE THE GENERAL PLANS NOW AFTER LIKE EIGHT OR 10 OR 12 YEARS, THEY REALLY NEED A MAJOR REFRESH SO I THINK EVEN THOUGH IT IS LONG-TERM I THINK THE PLANNING HORIZON IS STARTING TO SHRINK A LITTLE BIT AND CITIES MIGHT HAVE TO BE A LITTLE MORE OPEN TO AMENDING THEIR GENERAL PLAN MORE OFTEN THAN THEY DID IN THE PAST OR DOING FULL ON COMPETENCE OF UPDATES. THE IMPORTANT THING ABOUT THE GENERAL PLAN WHILE THE ZONING CODE HAS BETTER PR , HAS BETTER CREDIBILITY WITHIN THE PUBLIC PEOPLE INTUITIVELY UNDERSTAND THE ZONING THEY TALK ABOUT THE ZONING , THEY KNOW THE ZONING OF THE PROPERTY AND THE GENERAL PLAN FEELS LIKE A BIG FLUFFY PILLOW FLOATING OUT ABOVE EVERYTHING. THE GENERAL PLAN IS REALLY THE FOUNDATIONAL DOCUMENT AND THE ZONING CODE IMPLEMENTS THE GENERAL PLAN AND WE WILL GET INTO THAT A LITTLE MORE HERE SO GEOFF HAD THE UPSIDE DOWN PYRAMID I HAVE THE REGULAR PYRAMID IN MIND THE PLAN IS AT THE TOP SOMEONE SHOULD LIKE THAT. PUBLIC SPEAKER. FOR WALNUT CREEK SO LIKE I SAID THE ZONING MAP THE ZONING CODE IS ADOPTED BY IT HAS THE FORCE OF LAW. THE GENERAL PLAN DOES NOT HAVE THE BUILT IN ENFORCEABILITY. IT IS UP TO THE PLANNING COMMISSIONERS AND CITY COUNCILMEMBERS TO INTERPRET IT AND UNDERSTAND IT AND APPLY IT IN WAYS AND HELP THE CITY MOVE FORWARD. SO AS YOU GO DOWN THE PYRAMID YOU HAVE THESE OTHER THINGS THAT ARE HOLDING UP AND SUPPORTING THE GENERAL PLAN YOU HAVE SUBDIVISION ORDINANCES CONDITIONAL USES AND VARIANTS ALL WITHIN THE ZONING CODE FINALLY A BUILDING AND PLANNING REGULATIONS. SO, THAT KIND OF MOVES UP AND DOWN FROM LONG-TERM TO SHORT-TERM , TO THE VERY BIG PICTURE, VERY LONG-TERM, VERY DAILY AND PRECISE AND SPECIFIC DETAILS. AND THE GENERAL PLAN IS, IT DOES HAVE SOME STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS PLACED ON IT BY THE STATE. AND THE MAIN SORT OF STATE FOCUSED IS COVERING CERTAIN TOPICS. THEY WANT EVERY CITY, EVERY COUNTY IN CALIFORNIA TO COVER SEVEN MANDATORY TOPICS. PROBABLY WHEN YOU ARE DOING YOUR FINDINGS FOR LIKE A USE PERMIT OR REZONE YOUR PROBABLY PRESENTED WITH GOALS AND POLICIES WITH THESE DIFFERENT ELEMENTS EVERYTHING FROM LAND-USE, TO CIRCULATION, HOUSING, NOISE, OPEN-SPACE, CONSERVATION AND SAFETY. I JUST LEARNED THIS TODAY, THANKS TO MICHAEL THAT HERE IN CONTRA COSTA COUNTY EVERY CITY AND COUNTY HAS A MANDATORY REQUIREMENT TO HAVE AN 1/8 MANDATORY ELEMENT WHICH IS GROWTH MANAGEMENT. AS FAR AS I CAN TELL SOME QUICK GOOGLE SEARCH CAME OUT OF LATE 80s KIND OF JOINT EFFORT WITHIN THE COUNTY TO PASS A VALID MEASURE TO INCREASE SALES TAX POSSIBILITY. >> YES BASED ON SALES TAX MAZER FOR TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT. JURISDICTIONS HAVE URBAN LIMIT LINES, SOME AGREEMENT TO DO SOME JOINT PLANNING AROUND TRANSPORTATION SO THAT IS UNIQUE TO THIS COUNTY. MOST JURISDICTIONS DO NOT HAVE THAT , THAT AS A MANDATORY ELEMENT. SOME JURISDICTIONS IN CALIFORNIA WOULD HAVE THAT AS A OPTIONAL AMENDMENT WHICH YOU WILL SEE A LIST ON THE RIGHT, THESE ARE JUST IT COULD BE ALMOST ANYTHING THERE IS A HUGE VARIETY OF OPTIONAL ELEMENTS BUT THESE ARE EXAMPLES IN FACILITIES ECONOMIC DESIGN, HISTORIC RESERVATION , WATER, HEALTH AND RECREATION , YOU CAN SEE HOW DIFFERENT CITIES WOULD BE ATTRACTED TO DIFFERENT TOPICS THAT THEY WOULD WANT TO ELEVATE TO THAT GENERAL PLAN LEVEL OF CONSIDERATION. TWO ADDITIONAL ELEMENTS CAN SOMETIMES BE REQUIRED BASED ON LOCAL CONDITIONS AND THAT IS ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ELEMENT AND AIR QUALITY. SO WE THINK ABOUT CONSISTENCY THE GENERAL PLAN IS USUALLY THOUGHT OF THE GENERAL PLAN ITSELF HAS TO BE CONSISTENT AND THAT IS CONSIDERED TO BE HORIZONTAL CONSISTENCY FOR THE LAND-USE ELEMENT CONSISTENT WITH CIRCULATION WHICH IS CONSISTENT WITH THE OPEN-SPACE ELEMENT ET CETERA AND VERTICAL CONSISTENCY IS WHEN IT'S MORE LIKE GOING BACK TO THE PYRAMID HAVING THE GENERAL PLAN BE CONSISTENT WITH ALL THE OTHER PLANS POLICIES AND DOCUMENTS THAT SEEK TO IMPLEMENT THE GENERAL PLAN. SEWAGE VERY INTRICATE PROCESS TO MAKE ALL THOSE THINGS ARE CONSISTENT WITH EACH OTHER MOVING IN THE SAME DIRECTION. SO, GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS ARE KIND OF A BIG DEAL, WHETHER THE CITY INITIATING SOMETHING SEEING A NEEDED TO RESPOND TO OR IF A DEVELOPER COMES IN AND WANTS TO CHANGE THE GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION ON A BIG PIECE OF PROPERTY AND THE WAY THE GENERAL PLAN SORT OF DEALS WITH CHANGES LIKE HEY I AM THIS BIG LONG-TERM DOCUMENT FAIRLY FLEXIBLE. YOU ARE NOT CHANGING ME EVERY TUESDAY NIGHT RIGHT? UNDER STATE LAW YOU CAN AMEND THE GENERAL PLAN FOR TIMES A YEAR SO YOU HAVE TO PICK YOUR MOMENTS SOME CITIES WILL KEEP A GRAB BAG OF AMENDMENTS AND KEEP A RECORD OF THEM AND PUNCH THEM TOGETHER. AND SORT OF TAKE YOUR SHOT AND AMEND THE GENERAL PLAN BECAUSE YOU CAN ONLY DO THAT FOUR TIMES A YEAR AND A LOT OF CITIES FOUND WITH THE RECENT HOUSING CYCLE WHICH WAS CHALLENGING WITH THE INCREASED ARENA NUMBERS YOU CAN GET INTO A CYCLE WITH IF YOU ARE ADOPTING HOUSING CERTIFIED AND YOU GET COMMENTS AND YOU GET CERTIFIED AGAIN YOU COULD RUN OUT OF CHANCES TO DO IT. THAT IS VERY RARE AND I'VE NEVER SEEN THAT HAPPEN BEFORE, BUT THE IMPORTANT THING IS THINK OF IT WHEN YOU ARE DOING GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT , UNLIKE OTHER PLANNING PROCESSES IT NEEDS TO BE ABLE TO STAND THE TEST OF TIME BECAUSE SOMETIMES YOU MAY NOT BE ABLE TO IMMEDIATELY GO BACK AND REVISE IT. IT IS IMPORTANT TO KEEP IT CURRENT, RELEVANT AND CONFORM WITH STATE MANDATES. THE EXCEPTION TO THIS IS THE HOUSING ELEMENT ITSELF WHICH RECEIVES EXTRA SPECIAL ATTENTION FROM OUR FRIENDS IN SACRAMENTO AND THE BLIZZARDS OF NEW BILLS WE SEE THAT IS ON A MANDATED UPDATE CYCLE. YEARS AGO IT USED TO BE A FIVE-YEAR CYCLE MORE RECENTLY IT WENT TO EIGHT YEARS CYCLE SO ALL THE CITIES IN THE BAY AREA WILL BE REVISING THEIR HOUSING ELEMENT ON A EIGHT YEAR CYCLE AS FAR AS WE CAN SEE UNLESS SOMETHING CHANGES AT THE STATE LAW LEVEL. SORRY I SAID THAT THIS WAS GOING TO BE FUN. I VEERED OFF INTO THE DIFFERENT REALM. THE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS ARE IMPORTANT BECAUSE YOU WANT THE GENERAL PLAN TO BE A LIVING BREATHING DOCUMENT THAT YOU FEEL GOOD ABOUT BASING LAND-USE DECISIONS ON . WHETHER APPROVING PROJECTS OR CRAFTING DENIAL FINDINGS. IT HELPS THE COMMUNITY INCLUDING THE PLANNING COMMISSION TO MAKE BETTER INFORMED DAILY DECISIONS. THE PROCESS OF CHANGING THE PLAN ITSELF IS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO DO COMMUNITY OUTREACH BECAUSE UNLIKE DEVELOPERS STANDING WITH A PROJECT INVITING PEOPLE TO THE PUBLIC MEETING THIS IS A CITY SAYING HEY WE ARE LOOKING AT THIS WITH FRESH EYES, WE WANT YOUR INPUT, NOW IS A CHANCE FOR YOU CAN MAKE A SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE. THE LAST ONE IT MIGHT BE A LITTLE TOO OPTIMISTIC . WE SAY AVOID CONFUSION THAT CAUSE DEVELOPMENT DELAYS OF LITIGATION BUT I CANNOT PROMISE THAT. THAT IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST CASE SCENARIO. YOU HAVE TO BE OPTIMISTIC TO BE A PLANNER. SO LET ME MOVE TO A SPECIFIC PLAN. OBVIOUSLY MORE SPECIFIC THAN GENERAL PLANS BUT WHEN YOU SEE THE WORD SPECIFIC DON'T THINK OF A SPECIFIC TOPIC, THINK OF A SPECIFIC PART OF YOUR CITY. A GEOGRAPHIC AREA. A NEIGHBORHOOD OR A BUNCH OF ACREAGE ON THE EDGE OF TOWN NOBODY KNOWS WHAT TO DO WITH. THINK ABOUT GEOGRAPHY AND LAND WHEN YOU SEE SPECIFIC LAND. SO WE SAY IS THE ONLY PLANNING DOCUMENT I THINK THAT'S A LITTLE TOO STRONG. IT IS ONE OF THE NON-NON-GENERAL PLAN DOCUMENTS THAT IS DEFINED IN STATE LAW SO AS A RESULT THERE IS SORT OF A PACKAGE OF RULES AND REGULATIONS THAT COME WITH IT. OBVIOUSLY LIKE ANY OTHER PLANET HAS TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE GENERAL PLAN BECAUSE THE GOAL OF ANY SUBSERVIENT PLAN TO THE GENERAL PLAN IS TO IMPLEMENT AND SUPPORT THE GENERAL PLAN. IT HAS EVEN THOUGH IT IS SPECIFIC ON A GEOGRAPHIC AREA IT HAS A COMPREHENSIVE FOCUS ON THE AREA. SO YOU'RE LOOKING AT HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION, LOOKING AT WHATEVER THE LAND-USE PROGRAM IS FOR THE AREA. WE TALK ABOUT DIFFERENT NAMES FOR POLICY PLANNING IN GENERAL SPECIFIC PLANS GO BY A LOT OF NAMES. SUCH AS AREA PLANS, MASTER PLAN, THE CORRIDOR PLAN AND THE REASON FOR THAT I HAVE FOUND IS BECAUSE THE SPECIFIC PLAN REQUIRES IMPLEMENTATION SECTION THAT IS VERY DETAILED INVOLVING COST ESTIMATES FOR EXPECTED PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS, BY THE TIME YOU ARE DONE WITH ALL THE ENGINEERING, THE COST OF THE SPECIFIC AND COULD BE WAY UP HERE WITH THE PRECISE PLAN THAT IS NOT HAVE THE REQUIREMENT IT COULD DO ALL THE OTHER THINGS THE SPECIFIC PLAN COULD MINUS THE TECHNICAL COMPONENTS WHEN YOU SEE PLANS LIKE THAT, THEY ARE LIKE A SPECIFIC PLAN, BUT A LITTLE BIT WATERED-DOWN BASED ON STATE STANDARDS. THE BENEFIT OF THAT, OF COURSE IS THE SPECIFIC PLAN BECAUSE THEY HAVE REQUIRED IMPLEMENTATION THEY TEND TO GET IMPLEMENTED MORE SUCCESSFULLY THAN THE PLANS THAT DON'T INCLUDE THAT. SO, THIS IS JUST A QUICK OVERVIEW TO GIVE SOME EXAMPLES OF A SPECIFIC PLAN THAT COULD COVER THE ENTIRE DOWNTOWN , A MAJOR TRANSPORTATION CORRIDOR, AN AREA OF THE CITY THAT WOULD BE OF BENEFIT OF NEW DEVELOPMENT AND IT COVERS ALL THE NORMAL TOPICS THAT WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT TONIGHT WITH ZONING, SUBDIVISION RULES, PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN THE AREA , ANTICIPATE FUTURE PUBLIC BENEFITS THAT THE CITY MAY WANT TO NEGOTIATE WITHIN DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS DIVIDING DETAILED DEVELOPMENT DIRECTION AND PROVIDES COMPLIANCE WITH BROAD POLICY CONCEPTS GENERALLY COMING IN FROM THE GENERAL PLAN. SO THEN WE GO TO ZONING ZONING OBVIOUSLY IS VERY DETAILED LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT REGULATION, THE IDEA IS TO DIVIDE A JURISDICTION INTO MANY DIFFERENT ZONING DISTRICTS OR ZONES AND ASSIGN A DIFFERENT DEVELOPMENT REGULATION TO EACH ONE. WHAT WE DO MOSTLY IN THE BAY AREA IN CALIFORNIA IS CONSIDERED TRADITIONAL EUCLIDEAN ZONING WHICH IS FROM A 1926 SUPREME COURT CASE IN A VILLAGE OF EUCLID IN OHIO ON THE BANKS OF LAKE ERIE AND OTHER VERSIONS THAT HAVE EVOLVED SINCE THEN INCLUDE FORM-BASED ZONING WHERE THE EMPHASIS IS NOT SO MUCH ON CONTROLLING EXACTLY WHAT THE LAND-USE IS WITHIN EVERY BUILDING AND PROPERTY, BUT REALLY HAVING A VISION FOR WHAT THE CITY WANTS THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT TO LOOK LIKE. WE WANT THREE-STORY BUILDINGS PULLED UP TO THE STREET ON BOTH SIDES TO CREATE A NICE URBAN ENCLOSURE , PEOPLE FEEL COMFORTABLE WALKING BIKING DRIVING DOWN STREET TREES EVERY 40 FEET, VERY MUCH MORE BASED ON PHYSICAL DESIGN OF BUILDINGS AND IT IS MORE OPEN ON WHETHER IT IS RETAIL ON THE GROUND FLOOR OR PERSONAL SERVICES WAREHOUSING WE ARE FLEXIBLE. IT IS MORE OF A EUROPEAN CONCEPT WHERE IN PARIS IT SEEMS LIKE EVERY SINGLE BUILDING IS LIKE FIVE AND HAVE STORIES AND THEY LINE UP AND HAVE THE SAME ROOF WITH BEAUTIFUL SIDEWALKS AND GOES ON FOR MILES AND MILES AND THE LAND-USE CHANGES AND SOMETIMES THEY ARE THE SAME SOMETIMES THEY ARE DIFFERENT AND IT IS MORE ORGANIC ON THE LAND-USE SIDE, THEY ARE MORE PERSPECTIVE ON THE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION SITE AND THEN BECAUSE THEY ARE TOTALLY DIFFERENT SOME CITIES WANT TO GO INTO FORM-BASED ZONING BECAUSE IT SOUNDS EXCITING AND FUN AND ALL THE COOL KIDS ARE DOING IT. IT WINDS UP BEING MORE OF A HYBRID APPROACH BECAUSE OUR EUCLIDEAN ZONING IS PRETTY DEEPLY BAKED IN TO PLANNING AND REAL ESTATE REALITY THAT WE HAVE IN CALIFORNIA. SO AGAIN, SOUND LIKE A BROKEN RECORD ZONING ORDINANCES HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE GENERAL PLAN. THEY LIST PERMITTED USE AND USES THAT REQUIRE SPECIAL USE PERMITS OR SOME THAT ARE ALLOWED JUST BY RIGHT IT IS ALMOST A TECHNICAL TERM WHEN WE SAVE BY RIGHT IT MEANS THAT THE USE OF THE PROPERTY FOR THE USE IS NOT IN QUESTION. UNLIKE A FIRE USE PERMIT. SO, ZONING AND IT IS IN THE CITY MUNICIPAL CODE AND THE BUILDING CODE IS ADOPTED BY THE CITY AND THEY KIND OF WORK TOGETHER BUILDING CODES ARE SORT OF FILTER DOWN FROM THE STATE LEVEL AND ADOPTED, UPDATED AND ADOPTED EVERY THREE YEARS. BUILDING CODES GET MORE DETAILED INTO ELECTRICAL PLUMBING HEATING SPECIFICATIONS AND WHEN WE THINK ABOUT MINISTERIAL APPROVALS A GOOD PLACE TO WRAP YOUR HEAD AROUND THAT IS ALMOST 100% OF THE WORK THAT HAPPENS IN THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT IS MINISTERIAL AND IT IS KIND OF THE SOURCE OF A FUNNY LITTLE FRICTION THAT PLAYS OUT IN ALMOST EVERY PLANNING DEPARTMENT WHERE THE DEPARTMENT TALKS ABOUT HOW THEY DON'T REGULATE UGLY AND THE PLANNERS WONDER HOW THEY HAVE TO APPROVE EVERYTHING STRICTLY ON A STEREO BASIS BUT IT IS A DIFFERENT WAY OF THINKING ABOUT THINGS BUT IT GOES TO SHOW IT WORKS. GENERALLY. AND OF COURSE ZONING CODES REGULATE THE COMPATIBILITY OF NEIGHBORING LAND USES. I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT WITHIN THE LAST 10 OR 15 YEARS CONVENTIONAL ZONING HAS COME UNDER PRETTY STRONG CRITICISM GETTING CARRIED AWAY ON SEPARATING DIFFERENT TYPES OF RESIDENTIAL DENSITY FROM EACH OTHER WITHIN AN ACADEMIC CIRCLE AND SOME VERY PERSUASIVE BOOKS RESEARCHING THE HISTORY OF ZONING IN THE UNITED STATES WHICH HAS BEEN USED TO SEPARATE PEOPLE BASED ON RACE AND ECONOMIC CATEGORIES AND THERE IS A EXCELLENT BOOK ON THE TOPIC CALLED THE COVER OF LAW I THINK EVERY PLANNER AND EVERY PLANNING COMMISSIONER SHOULD READ IT. SO, ZONING COMES WITH A LOT OF NUANCE AND COMPLICATED PROCESSES . THESE ARE SOME OF THEM, CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS A VARIANCE ON CONFORMED USE , OVERLAY ZONES I DON'T KNOW WHAT A FLOATING ZONE IS. DON'T KNOW HOW THAT GOT IN THERE. ZONING MORATORIUM, THE CITY WILL SEE SOMETHING HAPPENING THAT IT DOESN'T LIKE, THROW DOWN A LIGHTNING BOLT TO SAY I HAVE A MORATORIUM ON THAT STUDY IT AND COME BACK WITH SOME ZONING REGULATIONS. SINCE THE ZONING IS ADOPTED BY ORDINANCE AND IT IS THE LAW OF THE JURISDICTION IT IS ENFORCED ACCORDINGLY WITH INSPECTIONS AND CITATIONS, ADMINISTRATIVE CIVIL OR CRIMINAL PENALTIES RARELY SEE ZONING CODE ENFORCEMENT GO TO CRIMINAL PENALTIES , MOSTLY ATTORNEYS ARE NOT REALLY UP FOR THAT, BUT TECHNICALLY IT IS ON THE BOOKS. THIS IS A BASIC ROADMAP OF THE TYPICAL PROJECT PROCESS THAT COMES THROUGH THE PLANNING COMMISSION STARTING WITH A PREDEVELOPMENT MEETING WHERE THE APPLICANT SITS DOWN WITH THE PLANNERS TO SEE IF IT'S THE RIGHT TRACK THEIR FILLING OUT THE RIGHT FORMS IS IT EVEN POSSIBLE AND THEN THEY SUBMIT THE APPLICATION AND THERE IS A REPORT PREP WITH PUBLIC NOTICE THE STAFF IS HITTING THEIR DEADLINES, BRING TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION, PLANNING COMMISSION HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING AND AT THE END OF THAT HOPEFULLY THEY MAKE A RECOMMENDATION IF IT'S GOING TO CITY COUNCIL AND CITY COUNCIL CAN HEAR IT AND APPROVE IT OR DENY IT. DEVELOPMENT AND AGREEMENTS ARE SPECIAL , THEY ARE NOT USED VERY OFTEN. THEY ARE MOSTLY FOR LARGE PROJECTS WHERE THE PROPONENTS FEEL THE NEED TO HAVE A MORE THAN NORMAL LEVEL OF PREDICTABILITY OF WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN WITH THE LOCAL REGULATORY STRUCTURE SO ONE OF THE MAIN THINGS DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT DOES THAT BENEFITS THE APPLICANT IS THAT IT WILL FREEZE THE ZONING RULES THAT THE PROJECT WAS DESIGNED AND APPROVED UNDER SO EVEN IF IT TAKES 10 OR 15 OR 20 YEARS TO BUILD THEIR NOT GETTING HIT WITH CHANGES DURING THA

Action Minutes Planning Commission Regular Meeting Tuesday, November 25, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. Via Video/Teleconference Page 1 of 3 * Full details are available via audio/video recording on our website. Microsoft Internet Explorer browser is recommended for video-viewing compatibility or enable Adobe Flash on your default browser. Commissioners on Video Conference City Staff on Video Conference Chair Jason Martin Vice Chair Joseph Evans Commissioner Helena Culik-Caro Commissioner Susan Gustofson Commissioner Rochelle Johnson Commissioner John Klopp Commissioner Rob Parolek Commissioner Paul Sonnikson (Alternate) Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Michael P. Cass, Planning Manager Brandon Northart, AICP, Associate Planner Imanol Tovar, Planning Technician Dee Dee Fendley, Administrative Aide III Call to Order Meeting called to order at 7:00 p.m. Public Comment (01:45 in video) None Consent Calendar (02:05 in video) 1. Approve the Planning Commission Meeting Action Minutes, dated October 28, 2025. Speakers: None Public Comment: None Closing Comments: None Motion to: Approve Motion by: Vice-Chair Evans Seconded By: Commissioner Gustofson Motion passed 6-0 Jason Martin Aye Rochelle Johnson Aye Joseph Evans Aye John Klopp Abstain Helena Culik-Caro Aye Rob Parolek Aye Susan Gustofson Aye Paul Sonnikson (Alternate) Regular Items (03:05 in video) 2. Receive and participate in Planning Commissioner Training Series #1, conducted by representatives of the American Planning Association, California Chapter - Northern Section, on the roles and responsibilities of the Planning Commission, land use framework, recent legislative changes, and best practices. Speakers: • Michael P. Cass, Planning Manager, introduced two representatives from the American Planning Association,

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, November 25, 2025 Page 2 of 3 California Chapter, Northern Section - Jeff Bond, AICP, Director Elect and Geoff Bradley, AICP, Planning Commission Training Coordinator. • Mr. Bond and Mr. Bradley gave a presentation regarding the roles and responsibilities of the Planning Commission, land use framework, recent legislative changes and best practices. • Commissioner Johnson asked how one would know if the ministerial or quasi-judicial approval process should be used. • Commissioner Culik-Caro asked for an example of a “gray area” regarding which approval process to use. Public Comment: • A meeting attendee asked if a “run of the mill” project would fall in the quasi-judicial category. He asked if Design Review recommendations would fall under a certain category. • Brendan Moran, Walnut Creek Planning Commission, stated certain decisions are being taken out of the hands of local jurisdictions by the State. He asked what Planning Commissioners can do to make an impact on this issue. • Courtney Jones, Antioch Planning Commission Vice-Chair, asked what are the most impactful aspects of a General Plan. She asked if there is a mandate stating that General Plans must span 20 years. Closing Comments: • Vice-Chair Evans asked if there is a denial clause in the Housing Accountability Act, if there is too much public protest over a project. • Commissioner Gustofson asked if there are certain hours of the day related to housing not requiring parking if it is within ½ mile of a bus stop that runs at least every 20 minutes. • Commissioner Parolek asked if the City has any form-based code overlays. • Commissioner Culik-Caro asked if it is a problem that a mandatory element of the General Plan can only be amended up to four times a year. She asked what a local jurisdiction can do if there is a State law change and the General Plan has already been amended four times. Commission Items (1:51:42 in video) Comments/ Updates None Planning Manager Items (1:51:49 in video) Comments/ Updates Planning Manager Cass provided the following updates: • The draft Inclusionary Housing Ordinance was introduced by the City Council earlier this month. It was supported as recommended by the Planning Commission and is scheduled to return for a second reading on December 10th and will go into effect 30 days thereafter. • The Planning Commission will not be meeting in December.

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, November 25, 2025 Page 3 of 3 • He reminded the Commissioners and members of the general public the importance of shopping local. • He thanked the Planning Commission for a great year with a lot of positive change and movement forward. Communications (1:54:00 in video) Comments/ Updates None Adjournment (1:54:06 in video) Chair Martin adjourned the meeting at 7:54 p.m. Jason Martin, Chair Dee Dee Fendley, Administrative Aide III

PLANNING COMMISSION SPECIAL AGENDA DATE: Tuesday, November 25, 2025 TIME: 6:00 PM PLACE: COUNCIL CHAMBER - 525 Henrietta Street, Martinez, CA 94553; and via Zoom INFORMATION FOR THE PUBLIC Information regarding meetings, including agenda materials, schedules and more, please visit the City’s Meetings & Agendas webpage: https://www.cityofmartinez.org/government/meetings-and-agendas. REMOTE PARTICIPATION This meeting will be conducted in-person in the City Hall Council Chamber and shall be aired in real time via Zoom. The City cannot guarantee the public’s access to teleconferencing technology, nor guarantee uninterrupted access as technical difficulties may occur from time to time. If attending via Zoom, please join us by choosing any of the following options: 1. Via Mobile Phone or Desktop, using the Zoom App direct link: https://cityofmartinez-org.zoom.us/j/94808575124 Via Web Browser, from https://zoom.us/join a. Webinar ID: 948 0857 5124 b. Passcode: 054388 2. Via Phone by calling (669) 900-6833 and enter the meeting details provided above. PUBLIC COMMENTS Public comments can be made in person at the meeting or submitted in writing. Written comments must be received by 12:00 p.m., the day of the meeting. For information on how to submit written comments, please visit the City’s Meetings & Agendas webpage linked above. ADA ACCOMODATIONS In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and California law, the Council Chamber is wheelchair accessible and disabled parking is available at City Hall. If you are a person with a disability and require modifications or accommodation to attend and/or participate in this meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at (925) 372-3512. Notification 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility. AGENDA CONTINUED TO PAGE 2

CALL TO ORDER - PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL - Commissioners Helena Culik-Caro, Susan Gustofson, Rochelle Johnson, John Klopp, Rob Parolek, Paul Sonnikson (Alternate) Vice Chair Joseph Evans and Chair Jason Martin CIVILITY STATEMENT - As your appointed Governing Board, we will treat each other and the public with patience, civility, and courtesy as a model of the same behavior we wish to reflect in Martinez for the conduct of all City business and community participation. This includes respect for everyone's First Amendment Right to voice their opinion on matters within the City's subject matter jurisdiction, even if that opinion is different from our own. The decisions made tonight will be for the benefit of the Martinez community and not for personal gain. PUBLIC COMMENT - For items not on the agenda. Non-agenda public comment is limited to matters which are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Commission, and which are not action items listed elsewhere on the agenda. CONSENT 1. Approve the Planning Commission Meeting Action Minutes, dated October 28, 2025. Action Minutes, dated October 28, 2025 REGULAR 2. Receive and participate in Planning Commissioner Training Series #1, conducted by representatives of the American Planning Association, California Chapter - Northern Section, on the roles and responsibilities of the Planning Commission, land use framework, recent legislative changes, and best practices. COMMISSION ITEMS PLANNING MANAGER UPDATES COMMUNICATIONS ADJOURNMENT - Adjourn to a Planning Commission Regular Meeting on Tuesday, December 9, 2025, at 7:00 p.m. By November 21, 2025, a true and correct copy of this agenda was posted on the City Hall Kiosk, located at 525 Henrietta Street, Martinez, CA 94553, and on the City website at www.cityofmartinez.org. , Administrative Aide III

Showing the first 24,000 of 77,957 characters. The full document is at the source.

GOOD EVENING AND I WILL CALL THIS NOVEMBER 25 MEETING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF MARTINEZ TO ORDER, PLEASE JOIN ME IN STANDING, IF YOU'RE ABLE, IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. THANK YOU. CLERK, WILL YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL? >> OKAY WE HAVE COMMISSIONERS CULIK-CARO PRESENT GUSTOFSON PRESENT JOHNSON PRESENT KLOPP PRESENT PAROLEK PRESENT SONNIKSON PRESENT VICE CHAIR JOSEPH EVANS PRESENT AND CHAIR JASON MARTIN PRESENT. >> THANK YOU. I WILL NOW READ A CIVILITY STATEMENT AS APPOINTED GOVERNING BOARD WILL TREAT EACH OTHER AND THE PUBLIC WITH PATIENCE, CIVILITY AND COURTESY AS A MODEL OF THE SAME BAYVIEW WE WISH TO REFLECT IN MARTINEZ FOR THE CONDUCT OF ALL PARTICIPATION. THIS INCLUDES RESPECT FOR EVERYONE'S FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINION ON MATTERS WITHIN THE CITY SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION EVEN IF THE OPINION IS DIFFERENT FROM OUR OWN. DECISIONS MADE TONIGHT WILL BE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE MARTINEZ COMMUNITY AND NOT FOR PERSONAL GAIN. AND WITH THAT, BEFORE I MOVE ON TO PUBLIC COMMENT ANY CHANGES TO THIS EVENING'S AGENDA? >> THERE ARE NO CHANGES. >> VERY GOOD, OPEN COMMENT FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA, ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK? SEEING ON ANY MEMBERS VIRTUAL THAT WISH TO SPEAK? >> THERE ARE NO HANDS RAISED. >> VERY GOOD I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT. CONSENT THE APPROVAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ACTION MINUTES FROM OCTOBER 28, 2025. COMMENTS OR CHANGES FROM ANY COMMISSIONERS. WITH THE DATA DO I HAVE A MOTION? >> MOVED TO APPROVE THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ACTION MINUTES DATED OCTOBER 28, 2025. >> DO I HAVE A SECOND? >> I SECOND. >> CLERK WILL YOU CALL THE ROLL? CULIK-CARO AYE GUSTOFSON AYE JOHNSON AYE KLOPP ABSTAIN I MISSED TO THE MEETING. >> YOU CAN STILL VOTE. >> OKAY. >> PAROLEK YES JOSEPH EVANS AYE JASON MARTIN AYE. MOTION PASSES. >> VERY GOOD REGULAR AGENDA ITEM RECEIVED AND PARTICIPATE IN PLANNING COMMISSIONER TRAINING SERIES NUMBER ONE CONDUCTED BY REPRESENTATIVES OF THE AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA CHAPTER NORTHERN SECTION ON THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION, LAND-USE FRAMEWORK, RECENT LEGISLATIVE CHANGES AND BEST PRACTICES AND I'M VERY EXCITED FOR THIS EVENING'S AGENDA ITEM, ONE THING I WISH I HAD WHEN I WAS A NEW COMMISSIONER SO I HOPE OUR NEWER MEMBERS AND EVEN MYSELF BECAUSE YOU CAN LEARN SOMETHING NEW EVERY DAY CAN GET SOMETHING OUT OF THIS THIS EVENING, WITH DATA DO WE HAVE A STAFF REPORT? THANK YOU CHAIR MARTIN. WE ARE VERY FORTUNATE THIS EVENING, WE HAVE TWO REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION THAT ARE PRESENT THIS EVENING TO CONDUCT THE FIRST OF HOPEFULLY MANY PLANNING COMMISSIONER TRAININGS . WE ALSO HAVE A NUMBER OF PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FROM OTHER JURISDICTIONS THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA IN ATTENDANCE AS WELL IN PERSON AND ONLINE. I WOULD LIKE TO QUICKLY INTRODUCE THE TWO PRESENTERS AT THIS EVENING WHO ARE JEFF BOND, DIRECTOR ELECT API CALIFORNIA NORTHERN SECTION AND JEFF BRADLEY THE PLANNING COMMISSION TRAINING COORDINATOR WITH APA , AS WELL. AT THIS POINT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO THEM AND AS THEY ARE COMING UP I WILL SHARE THERE WILL BE A COUPLE OF OPPORTUNITIES BUILT INTO TONIGHT'S PRESENTATION AND TRAINING WHERE THERE ARE OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE COMMISSION AND THE PUBLIC TO ASK QUESTIONS AND WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO DO SO, SO THINK IT. >> THANK YOU BOTH FOR JOINING THIS EVENING, APPRECIATE IT AND WELCOME TO ALL THE PEERS FROM OTHER COMMISSIONS THAT HAVE JOINED AS WELL. THANK YOU, CLOSE TO THE HOLIDAY HERE I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE WATCHING THIS LATER SO THIS IS A SESSION FOR PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FOR PEOPLE INTERESTED IN HOW PLANNING COMMISSIONERS FUNCTION. I WILL GO THROUGH A SERIES OF SLIDES AND THEN HAND IT OVER TO MY COLLEAGUE WHO WILL CONTINUE ON WITH THE PRESENTATION. WE WILL HAVE A BREAK AND IF , I WILL GET STARTED HERE. SO, THERE WE GO. SO I WILL BE COVERING THE LOCAL PLANNING PROCESS PART OF THE PRESENTATION. A LITTLE BIT ABOUT MYSELF, I HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN LAND-USE AND PUBLIC LESSEE IN CALIFORNIA ALMOST 40 YEARS NOW. A FEW MONTHS AGO I RETIRED AS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR OF THE CITY OF ALBANY AND ADVOCATING 19 YEARS COVERING A WIDE RANGE OF PLANNING NOT JUST LAND-USE PLANNING BUT ALSO HOUSING, SUSTAINABILITY AND PARKS AND RECREATION. A WHOLE GAMUT OF COMMUNITY PLANNING. AS PART OF THE CELEBRATION OF MY RETIREMENT IT WAS POINTED OUT I PROBABLY ATTENDED OVER 1000 MEETINGS IN THE CITY OF ALBANY, CITY COMMISSIONS SO I DO BRING A LITTLE BIT OF EXPERIENCE TO THE PRESENTATION THIS EVENING. SO, I THINK YOU ALL KNOW WHY YOU'RE HERE AS PLANNERS , YOU ARE, YOU ARE PLANNING FOR THE FUTURE GENERATIONS FUTURE RESIDENTS, FUTURE FAMILY MEMBERS PERHAPS AND THAT IS AN HONORABLE THING YOU ARE DOING. WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR YOUR COMMITMENT TO DOING THAT AS IT DOES TAKE QUITE A BIT OF TIME AND EFFORT AND TIME AWAY FROM YOUR FAMILIES. FIRST OF ALL, THE PURPOSE OF A PLANNING COMMISSION. IN MY MIND PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ACTION OF COMMUNITY CHANGE. AS YOU KNOW OR MAYBE NOT KNOW THE ESTABLISHMENT PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE STATE LAW ESTABLISHING STATE LAW ALSO WRITTEN INTO ALMOST EVERY CITY CHARTER AND EVERY MUNICIPAL CODE , WE HAVE A STATUTORY RESPONSIBILITY TO HELP PLAN THE COMMUNITY AND IN MANY CASES YOUR SCOPE GOES BEYOND STATUTORY RESPONSIBILITIES INTO OTHER AREAS SUCH AS TRANSPORTATION PLANNING OR SUSTAINABILITY AND SO FORTH AN IMPORTANT PART OF WHAT YOU DO IS LISTEN TO THE COMMUNITY CAPTURE THE ESSENCE OF WHAT THE COMMUNITY IS CONCERNED ABOUT AND HELP COMMUNICATE THAT TO CITY COUNCILMEMBERS THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT AS I'M SURE YOU DO TO TAKE THE TIME TO LISTEN TO STUDY THE DETAILS OF THE PROJECTS AND PLANS AND POLICIES THAT COME BEFORE YOU. SO LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF A PLANNING COMMISSION AND THEY DO VARY FROM CITY TO CITY, SOME CITIES HAVE A VARIETY OF SUBCOMMITTEES THAT MAY BE DESIGN REVIEW OR HISTORIC PRESERVATION . OTHERS WILL BE CONSOLIDATED WITH A PLANNING COMMISSION SO AS WE ARE TALKING THINK ABOUT IT IS NOT JUST STRICTLY SPEAKING THE PLANNING COMMISSION BUT A VARIETY THAT TOUCHED THE PLANNING PROCESS IN THE COMMUNITY, THESE PRINCIPLES ARE FOR THOSE TYPES OF COMMITTEES AND ADVISORY BODIES. THE ESSENCE OF WHAT YOU DO IS TO HOLD STUDY SESSIONS ON PLANS OR PROJECTS AND PERHAPS THAT EVOLVES INTO FORMAL PUBLIC HEARINGS WHICH ARE MANDATED BY STATE LAW WITH MUNICIPAL CODE OR BOTH AND ULTIMATELY YOU WOULD BE MAKING RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL ON THOSE ITEMS WHERE THE CITY COUNCIL IS THE DECISION-MAKER AND IN SOME CASES COMMISSIONS WILL SERVE AS THE APPEAL BOARD FOR A DECISION THAT A STEP PERSON WOULD NORMALLY MAKE IF A APPLICANT OR MEMBER IS NOT HAPPY WITH THAT DECISION YOU WOULD BE CALLED UPON TO MAKE THAT, TO POLLED OR REVERSE THE DECISION OF STAFF. ONE OF THE IMPORTANT THINGS THAT I THINK PLANNING COMMISSIONS CAN DO ARE UNIQUELY POSITIONED TO DO AND WE MENTIONED THIS EVENING WE ARE FROM THE BEGINNING OF THE MEETING SETTING THE TONE OF CIVILITY, RESPECT AND PROBLEM SOLVING. AND AGAIN PLANNING COMMISSIONS ARE A GREAT PLACE TO DO THAT, I THINK THAT IS AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN THIS ERA WITH PUBLIC DECISION-MAKING THAT WE ARE GOING THROUGH IN OUR STATE AND COUNTRY I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING TO REINFORCE SO ONE OF THE REALLY IMPORTANT THINGS AND SOMETIMES THIS IS NOT DISCUSSED AS MUCH AS IT SHOULD WHEN PEOPLE COME TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION. YOUR ROLE WITH CITY STAFF. I WANTED TO SPEND A COUPLE OF MINUTES TALKING ABOUT THAT. WHEN I TALK ABOUT CITY STAFF IT'S NOT JUST STAFF MEMBERS WHO ARE EMPLOYED BY THE CITY BUT ALSO CONSULTANTS. CONSULTANT CAN TAKE A COUPLE DIFFERENT FORMS AND THE WORK I DID AND WE WOULD HIRE A TECHNICAL CONSULTANT SOMETIMES TO RESOLVE A TECHNICAL ISSUE SO MAYBE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT IF A DRIVER IS POSITIONED PROPERLY YOU COULD HIRE TRANSPORTATION TO HELP WITH THAT. WE SOMETIMES HIRE CONSULTANTS TO HELP WITH THE EBB AND FLOW OF BUSINESS AND PERHAPS THE CONSULTANT BRINGS SPECIALIZATION THAT WE IN SMALLER CITIES IN PARTICULAR DID NOT HAVE WITH GENERAL PRACTITIONERS SO AS I TALK ABOUT THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF STAFF IN THE BACK OF YOUR MIND KEEP IN MIND CONSULTANTS FALL INTO THAT. SO THE STAFF RESPONSIBILITY TO BE A TECHNICAL RESOURCE FOR YOU TO MANAGE THE PROCESS FROM SOMEONE SUBMITTING AN APPLICATION OR SOMEONE STARTING AN IDEA FOR POLICY OR PROGRAM AND PULLING THOSE , THAT INFORMATION TOGETHER BRINGING IT TO THE COMMISSION FOR A DECISION. ONE THING THAT COMES UP FREQUENTLY THAT IS SOMETIMES A LITTLE BIT OF A RUB AND A SOURCE OF TENSION IS THAT STAFF DOES NOT ACTUALLY WORK FOR PLANNING COMMISSION STRICTLY SPEAKING THE WAY THE CHART WORKS IS IN 95 OR 99% OF THE CITIES IN CALIFORNIA STAFF WORKS FOR THE CITY MANAGER. THERE ARE TIMES YOU CAN APPROPRIATELY GIVE DIRECTION TO STAFF, LET'S SAY YOU ARE STRUGGLING WITH A PROJECT TRYING TO DECIDE WHAT THE RIGHT THING TO DO IS AND YOU MAY WANT TO DIRECT STAFF, CAN YOU DO MORE WORK IN THIS PARTICULAR AREA SO WE CAN MAKE AN INFORMED DECISION, THAT IS APPROPRIATE DIRECTION TO STAFF. IN OTHER CASES YOU MAY WANT TO TELL STAFF HEY, INSTEAD OF WORKING ON THE HOUSING ELEMENT IMPLEMENTATION YOU WANT TO WORK ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CLIMATE ACTION PLAN. THAT IS A DECISION THAT BELONGS WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE CITY LED BY THE CITY MANAGER. SO THAT DISTINCTION IS IMPORTANT, SOMETIMES IT'S A SOURCE OF FRUSTRATION OR TENSION AND I WANT TO FLAG GOT OUT AS A PLACE WHERE YOU CAN MAKE SURE THE ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES AND RELATIONSHIPS ARE CLEAR YOU CAN MAKE THE SUGGESTION FOR STAFF OR MAKE THE SUGGESTION TO SAY THE CITY MANAGER OR WHOEVER'S IN THAT LINE OF DECISION-MAKING. THE OTHER THING I WOULD SAY ABOUT YOUR WORKING RELATIONSHIP WITH STAFF IS KEEP LINES OF COMMUNICATION OPEN. IT IS A GREAT RELIEF TO US AS CITY STAFF PEOPLE TO GET A CALL IN ADVANCE OF LIKE A I HAVE A TECHNICAL QUESTION. I THINK YOU DID THE MATH WRONG ON A EVALUATION IT'S NICE TO GET THE CALLS IN ADVANCE SO WE CAN REALIZE WE MADE A MISTAKE AND WE WON'T UP TO THAT AND FIX IT TONIGHT BABY YOU DO NOT MAKE A MISTAKE AND WE CAN SPEND A MINUTE OR TWO TO CLARIFY THIS IS HOW WE DO THE MATH AND SET THOSE ISSUES ASIDE. IT'S NICE TO KNOW IF I HAVE A BIG ISSUE WITH THE PROJECT HERE IS MY ISSUE JUST BE PREPARED TO HAVE THOSE DETAILS AT YOUR FINGERTIPS. THAT IS GREAT TO HAVE AND WE HAVE A SLIDE UP AND READY TO BE ABLE TO PUT ON THE SCREEN TO TALK THROUGH SOME OF THE ISSUES WE KNOW YOU HAVE AND THAT MAKES THE MEETING GO MORE SMOOTHLY , WE'RE NOT FUMBLING AROUND WITH STAFF PEOPLE AND WE ARE ABLE TO GET TO YOUR QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS MORE QUICKLY. A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIPS AND STAFF I THINK IT IS REALLY IMPORTANT BOTH THE COMMISSION AND STAFF IN DIFFERENT WAYS ARE INTERFACED WITH APPLICANTS AND WITH THE COMMUNITY. JUST BEING AWARE THOSE ARE DIFFERENT LINES OF COMMUNICATION OFTEN GOING ON AT THE SAME TIME. AND A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS. PART OF THE JOB IS TO RESEARCH ISSUES. SO FEEL FREE AS A COMMISSIONER POINT OUT TO STAFF REALLY WOULD LIKE YOU TO DO A DEEP DIVE ON SOMETHING HERE. YOU KNOW THE COMMISSION NEEDS TO UNDERSTAND A PARTICULAR ISSUE OR QUESTION. AND FINALLY A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS THE ROLE OF STAFF IS TO SOMETIMES KEEP YOU OUT OF TROUBLE. IT IS TEMPTING SOMETIMES THE CLASSIC EXAMPLE IS THE COMMISSION STARTS TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING AND YOU START TO VEER OFF AND TOPIC OUR JOB AS STAFF SOMETIMES IS LIKE YOU ARE STARTING TO TALK ABOUT SOMETHING THAT'S NOT ON THE AGENDA , LET US DO THAT. WE ARE NOT TRYING, WHEN WE SAY THE PROFESSIONAL PLANNERS ARE TRYING TO STOP THE CONVERSATION WE ARE JUST TRYING TO KEEP IT IN THE TIME AND PLACE WHERE IT SHOULD BE HAPPENING SO EVERYBODY IN THE COMMUNITY KNOWS IT'S HAPPENING. SAME WITH ROBERTS RULES OF ORDER'S. ALL OF A SUDDEN DIFFERENT IDEAS FLOW AROUND WITH THREE OR FOUR MOTIONS ON THE FLOOR WHAT'S GOING ON HERE LET YOUR STAFF HELP YOU. NEXT I'M GOING TO TRY IN A COUPLE OF MINUTES TO COVER A COUPLE THOUSAND PAGES WORTH OF ETHICS LAWS AND THE MOST IMPORTANT THING I CAN SAY ABOUT THIS IS PROBABLY THE MOST CONSERVATIVE INTERPRETATION ONE CAN HAVE WITH THESE LAWS AND PRACTICES, YOU KNOW DIFFERENT CITY ATTORNEYS, DIFFERENT PLANNING MANAGERS DIFFERENT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTORS HAVE DIFFERENT PHILOSOPHIES ABOUT THIS. SO WHAT I AM SAYING IS WHAT I TOLD PEOPLE IN THE CITIES I HAVE WORKED IN OVER THE YEARS IT MIGHT BE DIFFERENT BUT I'M PUTTING IT OUT SO YOU ARE AWARE OF THE BROAD PARAMETERS OF SOME OF THESE ETHICS REQUIREMENTS. THIS IS A GREAT PLACE TO PICK UP THE PHONE TO SAY HEY I'M NOT SURE IF I'M DOING THE RIGHT THING CAN I TALK ABOUT THIS? IS THIS MEETING APPROPRIATE? FOUR THINGS TO TOUCH ON FIRST IS ASSEMBLY BILL 1234, A PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT PASSED 10 OR 15 YEARS AGO. REQUIRES YOU TO GO THROUGH AN ONLINE TRAINING IF YOU'RE SEEKING TO BE REIMBURSED FOR ANY EXPENSES THAT OCCUR AS A PLANNING COMMISSION OR SO IF YOU GO TO CONFERENCE AND YOU WANT TO BE REIMBURSED YOU HAVE TO HAVE GONE THROUGH THIS TRAINING. TO MY KNOWLEDGE THERE ARE A COUPLE PLACES THAT ARE PRETTY EASY , THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES AS ONLINE TRAINING AND THE STATE FAIR POLITICAL PRACTICE COMMITTEE HAS A ONLINE TRAINING BOTH OF THEM ARE PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD IT HAS BEEN A COUPLE YEARS SINCE I HAVE TAKEN THE TRAINING BUT IT IS NOT A BIG DEAL AND IT IS GOOD PRACTICE NOT SEEKING REIMBURSEMENT IT'S NOT A BAD IDEA TO KEEP THESE THINGS FRESH. SO OKAY. JUMPING AROUND A LITTLE BIT THE BROWN ACT THIS IS EVERYBODY'S FAVORITE LAW NOT REALLY BUT IT IS A GOOD LAW IT MAKE SURE THE DECISIONS YOU MAKE AND EVERYBODY MAKES AND CITY COUNCILS ARE OPEN AND TRANSPARENT. TO SUMMARIZE THE LAW BASICALLY ANY TIME THE MAJORITY VIEW DISCUSS IN ANY FORM IN ANY MEDIUM OF COMMUNICATION IN ANY SEQUENCE ONE AFTER ANOTHER IT'S A MEETING THAT'S THE CONSERVATIVE ANALYSIS AND THE CONSERVATIVE APPROACH TO WHAT THE BROWN ACT SAYS. THE CONGREGATION ONE OF THE CITY ATTORNEYS SET FOR A WHILE IF ONE COMMISSIONER SENDS A PIECE OF COMMUNICATION TO A QUORUM WITH THE REMAINING COMMISSIONERS THAT CONSTITUTES A MEETING. THAT IS A VERY CONSERVATIVE INTERPRETATION BUT NONETHELESS IN THAT ATTORNEYS OPINION THAT WAS A CONGREGATION OF COMMISSIONERS TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING THAT WAS WITHIN SUBJECT MATTER. YOU CAN DO OTHER THINGS, YOU CAN ATTEND OTHER MEETINGS PUBLICLY NOTICED. YOU CAN TALK ABOUT THE WEATHER , SUPPORTS, YOU CAN DO OTHER THINGS BUT IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT BUSINESS AS A PLANNING COMMISSION OR YOU NEED TO HAVE THAT AS A PUBLIC NOTICED MEETING AND POSTED DEPENDING ON THE NATURE OF THE ACTION YOU'RE TAKING YOU MIGHT NEED TO TAKE ACTION WITHIN A CERTAIN RADIUS OF WHAT THE ADDRESSES NEXT IS CONFLICT OF INTEREST. THERE'S ABOUT 500 PAGES WORTH OF INFORMATION AND VARIOUS HANDBOOKS OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST BUT I CAN SUMMARIZE PRETTY QUICKLY IF YOU'RE LOOKING AT A APPLICATION TO DO THINGS IN A PARTICULAR LOCATION THE FIRST IS WITHIN 500 FEET, BASICALLY THERE PRESUMPTION IF YOU HAVE A PROPERTY INTEREST, YOUR HOME , WHERE YOUR BUSINESS IS LOCATED IF YOU ARE THE PROPERTY OWNER WITH RENTAL INCOME ANY SORT OF FINANCIAL INTEREST THERE IS PRESUMPTION YOU HAVE CONFLICT OF INTEREST. THERE MIGHT BE SOME EXCEPTIONS WHERE YOU CONTINUE TO PARTICIPATE , BUT THE BEST PRACTICE IS NOT TO PARTICIPATE IN THAT DECISION NO REASON TO TAKE THAT CHANCE IF THERE IS A VIOLATION YOU WILL BE FINED PERSONALLY IT CAN ALSO RESERVE REVERSE THE DECISION MADE AND HAVE A COUPLE EXAMPLES OF THAT IF WE WANT TO GET INTO THAT, SO THAT IS, WHERE STANBACK ANOTHER GOOD REASON TO CALL STAFF AND SAY YOU CAN SEE WHAT THE DISTANCES TO MAKE SURE THERE'S NOT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST. NEXT IS 1000 FEET SO THERE IS A GRAY AREA BETWEEN 501,000 FEET AND IN SOME CASES THERE IS NO CONFLICT OF INTEREST , LET'S SAY SOMEBODY IS BUILDING A HOUSE, SINGLE-FAMILY HOME, 800 FEET FROM YOUR HOME PROBABLY NOT AN IMPACT LEGALLY YOU CAN'T PARTICIPATE IN THAT BECAUSE THERE IS NO CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE. WITH A FINANCIAL BENEFIT TO YOU BUT SAY IT IS A BIG BOX RETAIL, COSCO, THAT PROBABLY DOES HAVE AN IMPACT FINANCIALLY ON THE VALUE ON YOUR REAL ESTATE INTEREST WHICH YOU SHOULD RECUSE EVEN THOUGH YOU'RE OUTSIDE THE 500 FEET. GENERAL AT 5000 FEET THERE IS THE PRESUMPTION IN THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST THERE COULD BE SOME EXAMPLES. I CAN'T THINK OF ONE OF THE TOP OF MY HEAD BUT THERE COULD BE RARE EXAMPLES WHERE YOU WOULD STILL HAVE CONFLICT OF INTEREST OUTSIDE OF 1000 FEET PICK UP THE PHONE, CALL STAFF, CALL THE CITY ATTORNEY AND GET SOME DISCUSSION . LASTLY THE BROWN ACT AND SOCIAL MEDIA AND PUBLIC RECORDS , EGG AND EVERYTHING IS A PUBLIC RECORD. WHETHER IT IS A PIECE OF PAPER OR CORRESPONDENCE, IT IS AN EMAIL , WHATEVER'S ON YOUR PHONE IF IT HAS TO DO WITH CITY BUSINESS TEXT MESSAGES WITH YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT A COMMISSION MEETING COMING UP , THAT IS PUBLIC RECORD. AND SO THE ADVICE SOCIAL MEDIA IF YOU THUMBS UP SOMEBODY'S POST THAT HAS TO DO WITH SOMETHING IN THE COMMUNITY YOU ARE SERVING, THAT IS COMMUNICATION THAT BECOMES PUBLIC RECORD CONCEIVABLY BECOMES A VIOLATION OF THE BROWN ACT WITH THE MAJORITY GOING THUMBS UP OR THUMBS DOWN OR I'M NOT SURE THAT STARTS TO BE AN INDICATION OF A VIOLATION OF THE BROWN ACT AND THE PUBLIC RECORD CAN BE USED AGAINST YOU. THE OTHER THING TO BE AWARE OF AND THE HOPEFULLY VERY RARE CASE THAT THERE IS , THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS TO WHAT IS PUBLIC RECORD SO SOMETIMES DRAFT DOCUMENTS ARE NOT PUBLIC RECORD BUT IN THE CASE OF LITIGATION THERE CAN BE A SUBPOENA ISSUED AND THINGS THAT ARE NOT TECHNICALLY PUBLIC RECORD ARE SUBPOENAED AND BECOME PART OF THE COURT RECORD WHICH IS THEN PUBLIC . AGAIN BE VERY CAREFUL I HAVE HAD A SITUATION OVER THE COURSE OF MY CAREER WHERE SOMEONE WAS COMMUNICATING INFORMALLY WITH SOMEBODY DID NOT CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC RECORD PURSUANT TO PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST IT WAS A SUBPOENA AND IT DID NOT LOOK GOOD. THERE WAS A SIDE CONVERSATION GOING ON SO BE SUPER CAREFUL ABOUT SOCIAL MEDIA. THAT'S THE ADVICE OF ANY PLANNING COMMISSION OR ANY COMMISSIONER IN ANY PUBLIC REALM. I'M GOING TO GRAB MY WATER BOTTLE FOR A SECOND YEAR. ALL RIGHT. ON TO THE NEXT TOPIC. AGAIN THIS IS SOMETHING WE COULD SPEND A LOT OF TIME TALKING ABOUT. AT THIS MOMENT IN TIME TALKING ABOUT EQUITY IN THE CONTEXT OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS AND POLICIES CARRIES SOME POLITICAL SENSITIVITY, NO QUESTION ABOUT THAT. THE ISSUE IS STILL OUT THERE IN COMMUNITIES WITH ENGAGING EVERYONE , TRYING TO BE RESPONSIVE TO EVERYONE AND THAT GETS TO COMING UP WITH POLICIES AND PROGRAMS. AND THERE IS A LOT OF DIFFERENT RESOURCES AND A LOT OF TECHNIQUES IN TERMS OF ENGAGING PEOPLE TO ENSURE WE ARE HEARING ALL THE VOICES WHEN DECISIONS ARE MADE. THE THREE-MINUTE PUBLIC HEARING FORMAT YOU HAVE TO USE AT A FORMAL PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING IS SORT OF THE MOST AWKWARD AND CLUMSY OF ALL TYPES OF PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT. IT WOULD BE NICE TO BE ABLE TO SIT DOWN AND HAVE A CONVERSATION OR BE AT A PUBLIC EVENT OR WORKSHOP, ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT WAYS OF DOING IT SO IN TERMS OF EQUITY IT IS JUST REALLY IMPORTANT TO BE AWARE OF THE IMPORTANCE OF ENGAGING WITH THE COMMUNITY, LISTENING TO THE COMMUNITY TO BRING THAT BACK DECISION-MAKING PROCESS. I WILL SAY THAT THE PROFESSIONAL PLANNERS THAT YOU HAVE HERE ON STAFF AND CONSULTANTS AND SO FORTH FOR DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES, WE HAVE A CODE OF ETHICS THAT REQUIRES WE GIVE ATTENTION TO ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND RACIAL EQUITY SO WE SEE THAT IN OUR PROFESSION AND WE ARE PROUD OF THAT, WE REALIZE IT IS A SENSITIVE ISSUE NATIONALLY, BUT NONETHELESS THAT IS SOMETHING WE CONTINUE TO SEE AND FEEL AS A PROFESSION THAT IT IS VALUABLE AND LEADS TO BETTER DECISIONS TO THE COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE. THERE MAY BE OTHER COMMUNITIES WITH ORGANIZATION CODE OF ETHICS FORMAL OR INFORMAL, THOSE ARE AS WELL POLICIES AND PROGRAMS AND COMMUNITIES I HAVE WORKED IN THERE'S USUALLY AN EQUITY ANALYSIS AS PART OF EVERY STAFF REPORT. GETTING CLOSE TO THE END OF MY PART OF THE PRESENTATION, A COUPLE MORE THINGS I WANT TO MENTION. WE WILL TALK IN A FEW MINUTES ABOUT HOUSING LEGISLATION. BEFORE WE GO THERE, A LITTLE BIT OF CONTEXT. THERE ARE LOTS OF DIFFERENT LAYERS TO THE LAWS AND PROGRAMS AND POLICIES THAT US COMMISSIONERS AND WE HAS TO DO ALL THE TIME AND THIS HIERARCHY IS IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND. DOES START FROM THE TOP FROM THE CONSTITUTION AND ROLLS ON DOWN TO DECISIONS YOU MAKE ON A DAILY BASIS. THE IMPORTANT THING ABOUT THIS HIERARCHY IS THE HIGHER LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT PREEMPT THE LOWER LEVELS, LOCAL GOVERNMENT DOWN AT THE BOTTOM SO WHAT WE ARE EXPERIENCING IN A COUPLE AREAS IN CALIFORNIA RIGHT NOW IS SAY FOR EXAMPLE THE BEST EXAMPLE IS HOUSING REGULATION, STATE LEGISLATURE IS ACTIVELY IN THE AREA OF HOUSING POLICY OPPOSING FOR BETTER OR WORSE, ZONING CHANGES ON CITIES AND THEY ARE DOING THAT BECAUSE THIS HIERARCHY GIVES THEM LEGAL AUTHORITY TO PREEMPT ANYTHING THAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO DO AT THE LOCAL LEVEL, SOMETIMES THERE'S A LOT OF DISCUSSION ABOUT ELECTRIFICATION REQUIREMENTS AND NEW CONSTRUCTION, THAT'S ANOTHER AREA WHERE STATE AND FEDERAL LAW AND THE TERM IS OCCUPY THE FIELD , THERE ARE REGULATIONS ABOUT ENERGY EFFICIENCY THAT KIND OF HAMSTRING HOW WE IN THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT CAN REGULATE SOME OF THOSE ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASURES THAT WE LIKE TO DO LOCALLY IF WE COULD THE NEXT SLIDE SAYS THIS IS IN PROPER ORDER. LAST LIGHT AND THEN IT WILL TAKE A BREAK. THREE DIFFERENT LEVELS OF PLANNING DECISIONS TYPICALLY MADE IN DECISIONS FIRST IS THE CITY COUNCIL IS THE FINAL DECISION-MAKER APPROVING THE GENERAL PLAN FOR MY COLLEAGUE ABOUT GENERAL PLAN SPECIFIC PLANS ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS, US PLANNING COMMISSIONERS HAVE A ROLE IN MAKING , AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN TAKING PUBLIC COMMENT AND CRAFTING THE DRAFT OF THE DOCUMENTS LEGISLATIVE DECISION FINAL DECISION THE SECOND IS THE QUASIJUDICIAL TYPICALLY THE ACTION TAKEN BY PLANNING COMMISSION WHATEVER THAT MAY BE YOUR TAKING THE POLICIES AND PROGRAMS APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL THE LEGISLATIVE ACTS AND APPLYING GHOST APPLICATION SUBPOENAED TO YOU AND YOUR BASICALLY MAKING SURE THAT THE PROJECT COMPLIES WITH PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANS. THE SCOPE OF HIS CITIES AND PLANNING COMMISSIONS CAN DO WITH THE QUASIJUDICIAL FIELD IS CHANGING PRETTY DRAMATICALLY IN CALIFORNIA PARTICULARLY IN THE CONTEXT OF HOUSING. 10 OR 15 YEARS AGO WE HAD DISCRETION ABOUT WHETHER SOMETHING WAS COMPATIBLE WITH DESIGN GUIDELINES THAT WERE VERY SUBJECTIVE. I LIKE THAT, THAT IS OKAY, THAT WAS AN OKAY REPRESENTATIVE TODAY WE SEE MORE MANDATES OR OBJECTIVE STANDARDS WERE IT IS ALL METHOD THEY MEASURE THREE FEET, SIX FEET, WHATEVER THE STANDARD IS SO THE QUASIJUDICIAL IS LESS SUBJECTIVE OPTIONS IN SOME OF THESE QUASIJUDICIAL DECISIONS TODAY. FINALLY MINISTERIAL HAS CHANGED DRAMATICALLY OVER THE LAST DECADE OR SO, THIS USED TO BE BASICALLY REALLY SIMPLE PROJECTS , BASIC STUFF SOMEBODY BUILDING A GARAGE OR REMODELING A HOUSE OR SOMETHING THAT IS APPROVED BY STAFF, IT IS A NO-BRAINER OR MAYBE IT'S SIMPLY A BUILDING PERMIT AND IT'S NOT A BIG DEAL AT ALL THERE'S NO NEED TO TAKE TIME OR SEND PUBLIC NOTICES TO NEIGHBORHOODS SO FORTH A LOT OF THINGS THAT USED TO BE IN THAT QUASIJUDICIAL CATEGORY ARE DROPPING TO MINISTERIAL AND ALL OF A SUDDEN I HAD THE EXPERIENCE A FEW YEARS AGO OF IMPROVING A FAIRLY LARGE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT AT THE STAFF LEVEL AND IT FELT VERY AWKWARD LIKE I'M NOT SUPPOSED TO BE DOING THIS BUT THE NEW STATE LAWS ARE TELLING ME STEP UP IT IS YOUR JOB FOR BETTER OR WORSE. AND AGAIN THAT IS A TREND WE ARE GOING WITH , WITH CHANGES IN STATE LAW MOSTLY IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING. SO, AT THIS POINT WE WILL TAKE A QUICK BREAK. I WOULD BE DELIGHTED TO FIELD ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE ALSO INVITE MICHAEL IF YOU WANT TO MAKE ELABORATIONS. YOU DON'T HAVE TO, BUT IF I SAID ANYTHING , I RESPECT MICHAEL'S KNOWLEDGE ON THIS AS WELL AND THEN MY COLLEAGUE JEFF BRADLEY. I WILL START WITH COMMISSIONERS. >> FIRST OF ALL, THANK YOU VERY MUCH, QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM ANY COMMISSIONERS? WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT A MINISTERIAL VERSUS POSITIVE HOW DO YOU KNOW WHEN TO ELEVATE? WHAT GUIDING LANGUAGE DOES THAT FEEL LIKE THIS IS NOT SOMETHING WE DECIDE ON

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission Special Meeting — Minutes
  • Planning Commission Special Meeting
  • Planning Commission Special Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a08e0f4ddd9e4f8a658c37158895e716. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record