POLISCOPE

The public record

FLORIDA · STATEWIDEHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Education Pre-K - 12

Tuesday, February 3, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Education Pre-K - 12

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

People and votes

Alexis Calatayud

State Senator District 38

Open person dossier

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 28, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 88,148 stored characters

>>Chair Simon: GOOD AFTERNOON EVERYBODY, THE MEETING ON EDUCATION PRE-K-12 WILL COME TO ORDER, SPEAKER PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. >>Chair Simon: HERE. >>Vice Chair Calatayud: HERE. >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Burgess: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >> A QUORUM IS PRESENT. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU SPEAKER, SILENCE ALL ELECTRONIC DEVICES, ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK SHOULD COMPLETE AN APPEARANCE FORM AND HAND IT TO A MEMBER OF THE SERGEANTS OFFICE, SHOULD YOU WAIVE YOUR SPEAKING TIME YOUR POSITION WILL BE INCLUDED IN THE COMMITTEE MEETING RECORDS. TAKE-UP TAB TWO, SJR 1104 ON RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS BY SENATOR MASSULLO, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN YOUR BILL. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR, COMMITTEE AND IN A FREE SOCIETY IF WE ARE NOT ALLOWED TO EXPRESS THOSE FREEDOMS THEY WILL DIE. THIS PARTICULAR BILL IS A RESOLUTION THAT WILL GIVE YOU ALL SEE IN YOUR GOOD WAYS TO ALLOW IT TO MOVE FORWARD WILL BE ON THE BALLOT FOR THE VOTERS TO DECIDE ABOUT A PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT EXPRESSLY PROTECTING THE RIGHTS OF INDIVIDUALS TO ENGAGE IN VOLUNTARY RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS. IT CLARIFIES THE RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION BY STUDENTS AND SCHOOL PERSONNEL IS COMMITTED WHEN IT IS VOLUNTARY AND NOT COERCED. IT PROVIDES NO PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT OR EMPLOYEE MAY BE PENALIZED OR DISCRIMINATED AGAINST FROM ENGAGING IN UNLAWFUL RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION. ACTIVITY PRAYER OR INSTRUCTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS. PARTICIPATION REMAINS VOLUNTARY. IT REQUIRES PLACEMENT OF THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT ON A STATEWIDE BALLOT FOR VOTER CONSIDERATION AND AS YOU ALL KNOW AND JUST FOR THE RECORD REQUIRES 60% OF THE VOTING PUBLIC TO BE PASSED. AND IT TAKES EFFECT ONLY IF APPROVED BY THE VOTERS IN THE GENERAL ELECTION AND THAT MR. CHAIR IS THE RESOLUTION. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU SENATOR, ANY QUESTIONS ON THE BILL? SENATOR GAETZ YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Gaetz: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SEN. MASSULLO IF I COULD TAKE YOU TO THE BILL SUMMARY PLEASE PUT TOGETHER BY STAFF AND ASK YOU IF YOU AGREE THAT BILL SUMMARY IS FAITHFUL TO YOUR INTENT. IN THE FIRST PAGE OF THE BILL SUMMARY IT SAYS, AND I'M GETTING BACK HERE TO YOUR POINT THAT THERE IS NOTHING REQUIRED, THAT IT IS VOLUNTARY IT SAYS IN THE BILL SUMMARY THE PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT REQUIRES A DAILY MOMENT OF SILENCE AND SO FORTH AND UPON REQUEST SCHOOL PERSONNEL LED PRAYER SUBJECT TO SPECIFIED LIMITATIONS. AM I TO TAKE THIS TO MEAN THAT THIS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT IF IT PASSED WOULD REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO HONOR A REQUEST BY SCHOOL PERSONNEL TO LEAD PRAYER AT CEREMONIES AND EVENTS? >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. I DON'T THINK IT WOULD REQUIRE THEM TO LEAD PRAYER, IT WOULD ALLOW THEM TO LEAD PRAYER. THAT CURRENTLY IS IN OUR STATUTE. THERE'S NOTHING THIS PARTICULAR RESOLUTION ACTUALLY REQUIRES THAT ISN'T ALREADY IN THE STATUTE THAT WE PASSED IN THE LAST EIGHT YEARS. IT BASICALLY IS CODIFYING THOSE GOOD POLICIES INTO OUR CONSTITUTION. TO MEMORIALIZE THEM TO PROTECT THE FREEDOMS OF THE STUDENTS AND THE PERSONNEL. NOW, THE INTENT OF THIS PARTICULAR LEGISLATION WHILE IT ALLOWS PERSONNEL IT WOULD BE TOO FOSTER THE STUDENTS FREEDOM. BECAUSE THE INTENT OF OUR EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS ISN'T NECESSARILY FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PERSONNEL. THEY ARE THERE TO SERVE THE STUDENTS JUST AS WE ARE HERE TO SERVE THE PUBLIC AND THE CONSTITUENTS OF FLORIDA WHO TRUST IN THAT CARE ON US SO NO, IT WOULDN'T REQUIRE THEM TO LEAD PRAYER. IT WOULD ALLOW THEM IF THEY ARE ASKED TO DO IT. >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Gaetz:I LIKE THAT >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP, SENATOR GAETZ. >>Sen. Gaetz: I DON'T KNOW IF I CAN COMPETE, GOOD STUFF. THANK YOU MR. CHAIRMAN. THEREFORE I COULD BE READING IT WRONG BUT I DO THINK THE SUMMARY, THE BILL ANALYSIS SUMMARY, NOTHING SAYS THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT WOULD REQUIRE THAT UPON REQUEST SCHOOL PERSONNEL COULD LEAD PRAYER. UPON REQUEST OF THOSE PERSONNEL I GUESS SO THAT MAY BE SOMETHING YOU MIGHT WANT TO MASSAGE. AND MR. CHAIRMAN I APOLOGIZE. I WAS A SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS. WE HAD AN ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL IN ONE OF OUR HIGH SCHOOLS WHO DECIDED CATHOLICISM WAS WRONG. AND SO HE TOOK IT UPON HIMSELF TO BEGIN TO HAVE LITTLE MEETINGS WHERE STUDENTS PARTICULARLY CATHOLIC STUDENTS WOULD BE INVITED TO COME AND MAKE SOME CHANGES IN THEIR RELIGIOUS BELIEFS. IT GOT TO THE POINT WHERE HE WAS TAKING THEM DOWN TO THE BAYOU AND BAPTIZING THEM. I FIRED HIM. AND IT WOUND UP IN COURT, WE ONE BUT I WOULD FIRE HIM AGAIN. I THINK ANYBODY WHO WOULD USE THEIR POSITION AS A SCHOOL ADMINISTRATOR TO LEAD RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION IN SUCH A WAY THEY USE THEIR POSITION OF AUTHORITY AND RESPECT IN EFFECT TO UNDERMINE THE RELIGIOUS BELIEFS OF FAMILIES. IT GOT TO BE A PRETTY BIG DEAL AT OUR COMMUNITY AND IT WENT ALL THE WAY UP TO THE NATIONAL NEWS BUT I WOULD ASK YOU I APOLOGIZE FOR TAKING THE PERSONAL MOMENT BUT I WOULD ASK YOU TO COMMENT ON WHETHER OR NOT YOU BELIEVE IF THIS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PASSES THAT ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL WOULD WIND UP GETTING PROTECTED INSTEAD OF GETTING FIRED? >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU, I PERSONALLY WOULD HAVE FIRED HIM ALSO. I THINK IT'S OVERSTEPPING HIS BALANCE. THIS IS TO PROTECT THE FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION, NOT NECESSARILY COERCING SOMEONE TO BELIEVE ANY PARTICULAR THING THAT GOES BOTH WAYS. I KEEP READING THIS LINE THAT YOU'VE SAID AND IT REQUIRES THEM TO ALLOW. PERHAPS IT'S A PLAY ON WORDS BUT I WILL SEND YOU THE STATUTE THAT ARE CURRENTLY IN PLACE THAT BASICALLY HAS THE SAME LANGUAGE. >>Chair Simon: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, SENATOR BERMAN YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. SO YOU MENTIONED MOST OF THESE THINGS ARE ALREADY IN STATUTE SO WHY DO WE NEED A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT IF THIS IS ALREADY IN STATUTE? >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU, DO TO PROTECT OUR FREEDOMS, MOST OF THE THINGS WE HAVE IN OUR CONSTITUTION ARE THERE TO PROTECT OUR FREEDOMS AND THIS WOULD JUST BE ONE MORE THING AND IT'S PROTECTING RELIGIOUS FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION. IT'S NOT PROTECTING ANY PARTICULAR RELIGION. I PERSONALLY BELIEVE RELIGION IS A PERSONAL MATTER. THE EXPRESSION OF YOUR BELIEFS IS SOMETHING OUR CONSTITUTION ALREADY PROVIDES. WE ARE JUST CLARIFYING IT FOR AN EDUCATIONAL CIRCUMSTANCE. IN OUR STATE OF FLORIDA. SO THERE'S NO CONFUSION GOING FORWARD WHEN ANOTHER BODY MAY BE SITTING UP HERE TO THINK THAT IT'S PERHAPS NOT WHAT WE SHOULD BE DOING. >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS. I DO HAVE SOME APPEARANCE FORMS HERE. BEFORE WE GET STARTED WITH THE APPEARANCE FORMS I HAVE SEVERAL CARDS TODAY. THERE ARE A LOT OF SPEAKER CARDS FOR SEVERAL BILLS I WILL ASK YOU KEEP IT BRIEF, KEEP IT PITHY AND WE'RE GOING TO MOVE FORWARD. IF I FIND YOU ARE PONTIFICATING I WILL HAVE TO CUT YOU OFF. IF YOU AGREE WITH SOMEONE THAT CAME UP AND YOU DON'T HAVE ANYTHING FURTHER TO ADD TO THIS DISCUSSION PLEASE WAIVE AND SUPPORT OR NOT BUT WE DO WANT TO KEEP THIS MEETING MOVING AND EVERYBODY TRAVELED FROM A LONG WAY AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE WE ARE GIVING EVERYBODY A CHANCE TO SPEAK. FIRST WE HAVE MELISSA WILSON SPEAKING FOR THE BILL. MELISSA? DEVON BROWN SPEAKING AGAINST THE BILL, MELISSA, I'M SORRY. APOLOGIZE, I WAS MOVING A LITTLE FAST, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> IT'S WONDERFUL TO BE IN FRONT OF YOU TODAY AS A MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC AND A MEMBER OF THE FLORIDA BAR, A LICENSED ATTORNEY AND I AM FOR THIS BILL. I DON'T, I GUESS I COULD KIND OF WAVE BECAUSE I WOULD MIRROR WHAT HE SAID ON THIS PARTICULAR BILL. RELIGIOUS FREEDOMS SHOULD BE RECOGNIZED AND I BELIEVE THE RELIGIOUS FREEDOMS SHOULD ALSO MIRROR SECULAR AND EVEN THOUGH THERE IS SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE I DON'T BELIEVE IT WOULD CAUSE ANYBODY AS LONG AS IT'S ACROSS THE BOARD THAT IS NOT A SPECIFIC RELIGION, I DON'T BELIEVE IT WOULD AFFECT THE SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE AND I SUPPORT IT AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU, DEVON GRAHAM AND AFTER DEVON IT WILL BE ERIN DIPIETRO. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> I'M DEVON GRAHAM WITH AMERICAN ATHEISTS AND WE OPPOSE THIS BILL NOT BECAUSE WE ARE ANTI-THEIST OR EIGHT PEOPLE OF FAITH BECAUSE IT'S NOT TRUE, WE OPPOSE THIS FOR SEVERAL REASONS, ONE IT IS ALREADY IN STATUTE, TO THESE PROTECTIONS ARE COVERED BY THE US CONSTITUTION AND UPHELD IN THE COURTS OVER AND OVER AGAIN AND THREE BECAUSE THE INTENT BEHIND THIS BILL, DRIVING FORCE BEHIND IT IS CHRISTIAN NATIONALISM. THERE IS NEUTRAL LANGUAGE THROUGHOUT AND IF YOU GAVE ME THE LANGUAGE IN A CONTEXT FREE ZONE I WOULD VOTE FOR IT BECAUSE EVERY ONE OF US WANTS FREEDOM OF OURSELVES AND OUR CHILDREN TO PRACTICE RELIGION AND EXPRESS THEIR BELIEFS FREELY BUT WE DON'T LIVE IN A WORLD WITHOUT CONTEXT WE SEE AND HOW THE STATE DEALS WITH PEOPLE FROM MINORITY RELIGIOUS GROUPS EXPRESSING THEIR BELIEFS FROM THE GOVERNOR SAYING SOME RELIGIOUS GROUPS SATANISTS NOT SERVE AS SCHOOL CHAPLAINS FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WHO SHOULD KNOW WHAT'S IN STATUTE WITH SUPPORT OF THE CABINET DEMANDING THE INVESTIGATION INTO WHAT TO AS LINUX) SEE IF TAXPAYER FUNDS WITHOUT SAYING ANYTHING ABOUT THE CHRISTIAN SCHOOLS THAT RECEIVE 80% OF THOSE SAME FUNDS. THE SAME PERSON WHO YESTERDAY TWEETED THERE SHOULD BE AN INCREASE IN LAW ENFORCEMENT. >>Chair Simon: IF YOU CAN LAND IT AND STAY ON TOPIC. >> AGAIN WHEN WE JOINED AN INTERFAITH BILL AGAINST THIS HOUSE BILL WE WERE TOLD BY WE WERE HERE AS ENEMIES OF FAITH AND WE WERE HERE BECAUSE PEOPLE OPPOSE PRAYER THIS IS NOT REMOTELY TRUE. THERE ARE PEOPLE OF FAITH HEAR WHO DO NOT WANT THIS AND ACTED. SO AGAIN PLEASE OPPOSE. >>Chair Simon: ERIN DIPIETRO SPEAKING FOR THE BILL. >> THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. ERIN DIPIETRO WITH FLORIDA FAMILY VOICE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF JOINT RESOLUTION 1104. THIS RESOLUTION WILL ENSHRINE EXISTING STATUTE REPORTED WITHIN THIS RESOLUTION IS A PART OF THE EXISTING STATUTE TO ENSHRINE THESE PROTECTIONS IN OUR STATE CONSTITUTION IN PERPETUITY. RELIGIOUS FREEDOM, ESPECIALLY RELIGIOUS FREEDOM IN THE CONTEXT OF AN EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT MUST BE PARAMOUNT AND IS OF TOP INTEREST FOR THE STATE TO PROTECT AND ENSHRINE IN OUR STATE CONSTITUTION AND TO CLARIFY AS WELL THROUGH THE CHAIR TO SOME OF THE QUESTIONS ASKED EARLIER, THE PORTION OF THE AMENDMENT AS READING THE PARTICULAR LANGUAGE THAT WOULD ALLOW SCHOOL PERSONNEL TO PARTICIPATE IN PRAYER WOULD BE IN LINES 46 REGARDING SCHOOL PERSONNEL ALLOWED TO PARTICIPATE IN RELIGIOUS ACTIVITIES ON SCHOOL GROUNDS WHICH ARE INITIATED BY THE STUDENTS IF SUCH ACTIVITIES ARE OCCURRING BEFORE OR AFTER THE SCHOOL DAY. SO THEY WOULD BE OUTSIDE OF THE CONTEXT, THANK YOU. >>Chair Simon: WE HAVE A FEW FOLKS WAIVING, CHRIS PAGEL AGAINST, BILL BUNKLEY WAIVING IN SUPPORT. ANTHONY VERDUGO WAIVING AND SUPPORT. JOHN LABRIOLA WAIVING IN SUPPORT. ISABEL RODRIGUEZ WAIVING IN SUPPORT AND RYAN KENNEDY WAIVING IN SUPPORT. IS THERE ANY DEBATE ON THE BILL? SENATOR BERMAN YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. I'M GOING TO BE VOTING AGAINST THE BILL TODAY. AND I DO KNOW THESE THINGS ARE IN FLORIDA STATUTE RIGHT NOW AND I BELIEVE WHEN BOTH OF THESE IMPORTANT THINGS CAME UP FOR A VOTE I VOTED AGAINST THEM AT THE TIME SO I'M NOT HAPPY THAT THEY ARE IN FLORIDA STATUTE TO START WITH AND MY CONCERN THAT I RAISED WHEN THEY WERE ORIGINALLY PUT INTO STATUTE IS I WAS ONE OF EIGHT JEWISH CHILDREN IN MY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AND IF, WHEN THERE WAS PRAYER IT WAS NOT MY JEWISH RELIGION AND I ALWAYS FELT UNCOMFORTABLE AND I THINK THAT IS WHAT WE ARE VERY MUCH DOING IN THOSE STATUTES AND IF WE PUT IT IN THE CONSTITUTION IN PERPETUITY WE ARE MAKING THESE CHILDREN FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE IN PERPETUITY. YOU ARE TAKING THE MINORITY CHILDREN AND THEY ARE GOING TO BE EXCLUDED BASICALLY BY THIS PRACTICE. FOR THAT REASON REMEMBERING MY INNER CHILD AND HOW I FELT AT THE TIME WHEN I WAS SUBJECT TO A LOT OF THINGS THAT WERE NOT MY RELIGION, I WILL BE VOTING AGAINST THIS BILL AND I DON'T THINK IT'S SOMETHING WE SHOULD BE PUTTING IN OUR CONSTITUTION, THANK YOU. >>Chair Simon: SENATOR OSGOOD YOU ARE RECOGNIZED IN DEBATE. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. SEN. MASSULLO, I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO. I'M WRESTLING IN MY MIND COMING FROM 9 AND A HALF YEARS ON THE SCHOOL BOARD, IF YOU CAN ADDRESS THIS IN YOUR CLOSE, I'M NOT UNDERSTANDING. I FEEL LIKE THOSE RELIGIOUS EXPRESSIONS AND ALL THOSE THINGS ARE PROTECTED NOW. I KNOW THERE WAS LEGISLATION THAT CAME FORTH A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO WHERE SCHOOLS HONOR A MOMENT OF SILENCE FOR STUDENTS TO DO HOWEVER THEY FEEL THEY NEED TO DO DURING THAT MOMENT OF TIME. MY CONCERN AND WHY I'M GOING TO BE A NO TODAY IS BECAUSE I THINK PUTTING THIS ON THE BALLOT FURTHER HEIGHTENS THIS CLIMATE WE ARE IN RIGHT NOW WHERE I FEEL THAT RELIGION, MANY TYPES OF RELIGIONS ARE UNDER ATTACK. BC ANTI-SEMITISM, WE SEE BLACK CHURCHES BEING SHOT UP. IT'S A WHOLE BIG ORDEAL SO IF YOU COULD ADDRESS IN YOUR CLOSE MAYBE THERE SOMETHING SPECIFIC THAT HAPPENED BUT IN MY EXPERIENCE SCHOOLS ARE ALREADY DOING THIS. I'M A DIEHARD CHRISTIAN, NOT A CHRISTIAN NATIONALIST BUT A MISSION THAT BELIEVES IN THE 66 BOOKS OF THE BIBLE BUT I ALSO RESPECT SENATOR BERMAN WHO IS JEWISH, I HAVE MUSLIM PEOPLE SO I AM NOT UNDERSTANDING AND MAYBE YOU CAN TELL ME IN YOUR CLOSE WHAT HAPPENED THAT YOU FEEL WE NEED TO DO THIS AT THIS TIME. >>Chair Simon: ANY OTHER DEBATE? ALL RIGHT, SEN. MASSULLO YOU ARE WELCOME TO CLOSE ON YOUR BILL. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU COMMITTEE MEMBERS FOR YOUR QUESTIONS AND FOR YOUR OPINIONS AND THANK YOU FOR THE INDIVIDUALS FROM THE AUDIENCE THAT HAVE COME IN TESTIFIED AND FIRST OF ALL I WANT TO MAKE THE POINT THAT NUMBER ONE I RESPECT EVERYBODY'S RIGHT FOR FREEDOM, PARTICULARLY IN THE EXPRESSION OF RELIGION WHETHER YOU ARE AN ATHEIST, WHETHER YOU ARE ANY PARTICULAR FAITH, ALL THOSE SHOULD BE RECOGNIZED AND YOU KNOW, AS MUCH AS SOMETIMES WE DON'T LIKE TO HEAR FROM OTHER SIDES, I BELIEVE ALL THOSE SIDES WOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES. OFTEN TIMES WE TEND TO GATHER AROUND WHAT WE BELIEVE BECAUSE THAT'S WHERE WE ARE COMFORTABLE. BUT THIS PARTICULAR BILL ALLOWS EVERYONE TO HAVE THAT RIGHT. VOLUNTARILY. THEY DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO LISTEN TO WHAT SOMEONE ELSE IS SAYING THEY DON'T BELIEVE IN BUT THEY ALSO CAN PRESENT THEIR BELIEFS. AND I PERSONALLY BELIEVE THE RELIGION AS I'VE SAID BEFORE HERE AND ELSEWHERE IS A PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH WHOEVER, IF EVER YOU BELIEVE IN A HIGHER POWER. BUT WHY SHOULD WE RESTRICT THE MOST IMPRESSIONABLE PEOPLE IN OUR SOCIETY FROM THAT OPPORTUNITY TO EXPRESS THEIR RELIGIOUS BELIEFS WHICH IS OUR CHILDREN. AND THE REASON I THINK THIS IS IMPORTANT IS FOR THE VERY REASON WE'VE HEARD DEBATE AGAINST IT TODAY. IT IS IN OUR STATUTES. BUT IT'S SOMETIMES MISUNDERSTOOD. THIS ISN'T TO RESTRICT ANYONE. FROM EXPRESSION. IT'S TO ACTUALLY LIBERATE THEM TO EXPRESSION. EXPRESSION WE SHOULDN'T FEAR, NOT IN THIS COUNTRY, NOT IN THIS STATE. WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY AS LEGISLATORS TO CONTINUE TO LOOK AT THE PEOPLE WE SERVE. PROMOTING FREEDOM, PROMOTING LIBERTY. SOMEHOW PROTECTING THEIR WAY OF LIFE THE BEST WE CAN BY THE LAWS THAT WE PASS. PUTTING THIS IN THE CONSTITUTION ENSHRINES THOSE LAWS THAT WE'VE ALREADY PASSED. FOR THE FUTURE. IF WE FEEL THEY ARE IMPORTANT ENOUGH THEN THEY SHOULD BE IMPORTANT ENOUGH TO PRESERVE NOW AND WITH THAT I ASK FOR YOUR FAVORABLE SUPPORT. >>Chair Simon: SECRET CALL THE VOTE ON SJR 1104. >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Burgess: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >>Vice Chair Calatayud: >>Chair Simon: YES, BY YOUR VOTE SJR 1104 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. >>Sen. Massullo: THANK YOU COMMITTEE, HAVE A GREAT DAY. >>Chair Simon: LET'S TAKE UP THE TAB FIVE SB 1738 ON EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES BY SENATOR YARBOROUGH, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. >>Sen. Yarborough: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU FOR ADDING THIS TO THE AGENDA, 1738 REQUIRES THE OFFICE OF EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES AND OFFICE OF SAFE SCHOOLS AND THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION TO COORDINATE A STATE REVIEW OF REQUIREMENTS FOR EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES, DEVELOP RECOMMENDATIONS INTENDED TO IMPROVE TEACHER AND STUDENT SAFETY THROUGH A SCHOOL'S PHYSICAL PLAN. NAMELY THE BILL REQUIRES A REVIEW TO DEVELOP RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FACILITY DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PRACTICES THAT MAY REDUCE TEACHER TO STUDENT AND STUDENT TO STUDENT MISCONDUCT INCLUDING CONSIDERATION OF CRIME PREVENTION THROUGH ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN PRINCIPLES AND SPECIFY CONFIGURATIONS THAT INCREASE OBSERVABILITY AND ACCESS CONTROL. I HAVE AN AMENDMENT TO MODIFY THAT MR. CHAIR, THAT IS HOW THE BILL IS SPOKEN. >>Chair Simon: LET'S DO THIS BEFORE WE GO TO QUESTIONS, TAKE UP AMENDMENT 461370 BY SENATOR YARBOROUGH, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE AMENDMENT. >>Sen. Yarborough: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. I MENTIONED CRIME PREVENTION THROUGH ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN, THOSE ARE MORE APPROPRIATE IN RESIDENTIAL SCENARIOS SO WE WANTED TO REMOVE THAT AND NOT GET THAT CONFUSED WITH TRYING TO IMPROVE THE HARDNESS AND PLANNED SAFETY OF OUR SCHOOLS AND THE OTHER PART IS WE ARE TRYING TO BALANCE OUR EFFORT REQUIRING ANY SCHOOL SPACE TRANSPARENCY TO NOT GIVE RISE TO THE ELIMINATION OF SAFE SPACES IN THE EVENT WE HAD A THREAT OR EMERGENCY, THE AMENDMENT BALANCES ALL OF THAT. >>Chair Simon: ARE THERE QUESTIONS ON THE AMENDMENT? SEEING NONE, [COUGH] EXCUSE ME. WE HAVE ANY, NO APPEARANCE CARDS ON THE AMENDMENT, ANY DEBATE ON THE AMENDMENT? SENATOR YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE. ALL IN FAVOR SAY YEA. ALL OPPOSED SAME SIDE. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED, BACK ON THE BILL AS AMENDED, ANY QUESTIONS ON THE BILL AS AMENDED. WE DO HAVE ONE APPEARANCE FORM ON THE BILL AS AMENDED. CHRIS PAGEL. WAIVES AGAINST THE BILL. ANY DEBATE ON THE BILL AS AMENDED. ALL RIGHT, SENATOR YARBOROUGH YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE AS AMENDED. >>Sen. Yarborough: WANTED TO THANK YOU WE HAD CONVERSATIONS AND ALSO OUR GREAT STAFF SITTING BEHIND US IN THE EDUCATION SUITE HELPING TO PUT THIS TOGETHER. WE STARTED TALKING ABOUT THIS A YEAR AGO AND UNFORTUNATELY IT WAS BROUGHT TO LIGHT MORE BY THE SITUATION HAD IN DUVAL COUNTY ONE OF OUR HIGH SCHOOLS BUT WE'RE TRYING TO MAKE SURE YOUR TRADITIONAL CLASSROOMS MAY NOT YIELD THIS MUCH OF A CONCERN BUT IN SOME SPACES WHERE IT COULD BE LABS OR FILM STUDIOS, POST OFFICE SPACES, THINGS OF THAT NATURE WE HAVE HAD CIRCUMSTANCES IN OUR SCHOOL WHERE STUDENTS WERE TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF AND ALL THAT AND OF COURSE THE DISTRICTS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT HAVE ACTED SWIFTLY IN RESPONSE BUT WE DON'T WANT TO DO ANYTHING AS WE CONSTRUCT SCHOOLS AND IF WE HAVE TO REHAB EXISTING SCHOOLS THAT WE NEED TO MAKE SURE IT'S DONE TO BALANCE AGAIN THE NEEDS TO MAKE SURE ALL THE SPACES ARE TRANSPARENT BUT ALSO NOT GIVE RISE IF THERE WERE TO BE AN EVENT THAT IS A THREAT OR EMERGENCY AT A SCHOOL MAKE SURE THERE ARE SAFE SPACES WHERE STUDENTS AND FACULTY AND OTHERS CAN GO. SO I THINK THIS IS A BALANCE, IT'S A GOOD START. APPRECIATE YOUR END OF THE COMMITTEE'S CONSIDERATION AND ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. >>Chair Simon: CALL ROLL ON CS FOR SB 1438, I WOULD CRACK A JOKE ABOUT THAT. I AM STILL A LITTLE YOUNG. AFTER WE GET THROUGH THE BILL I WILL EXPLAIN. [LAUGHTER] >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Burgess: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >>Vice Chair Calatayud: >>Chair Simon: YES, BY YOUR VOTE CS FOR SB 1738 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. IT IS A SONG. IT'S A SONG, I'M NOT GOING TO SING IT FOR YOU. ALL OF THE YOUNG AT HEART OUT THERE UNDERSTAND. WELCOME SENATOR TRUENOW, TAB ONE SB 824 ON CHARTER SCHOOLS BY SENATOR TRUENOW, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE BILL. I KNOW YOU HAVE A DELETE ALL AMENDED, LET'S GO TO THE DELETE ALL, TAKE UP AMENDMENT 866576 BY SENATOR TRUENOW, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN THE AMENDMENT. >>Sen. Truenow: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. AND MEMBERS, ON THE BARCODE 866576, AFTER SEVERAL CONVERSATIONS WITH STAKEHOLDERS WE AGREE THE BILL ON TRANSPARENCY WOULD BE BEST FOR NOW. THE STRIKE ALL DOES THE FOLLOWING. REQUIRES SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO SUBMIT ANNUALLY TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION A COMPLETE LIST OF UNIMPROVED LAND BY JUNE 30 OF THE YEAR. THE LIST MUST INCLUDE PARCEL IDENTIFICATION ACREAGE, DATE OF ACQUISITION, CURRENT OR PLANNED USE IF ANY, MARKET VALUE, ASSESSED VALUE AND DATE. DISTRICT COMMISSION APPRAISAL WITHIN THE PAST 24 MONTHS. REQUIRES THE DEPARTMENT TO PUBLISH A STATEWIDE REPORT ON THEIR WEBSITE BY DECEMBER ONE OF EACH YEAR. AND AN AGGREGATE OF EACH DISTRICTS LANDHOLDING AND THAT IS THE BILL. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU SEN. TRUENOW. ANY QUESTIONS ON THE AMENDMENT? ANY QUESTIONS ON THE AMENDMENT? IS THERE ANY APPEARANCE CARDS, SEEING NONE SEN. TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE ON YOUR AMENDED. >>Sen. Truenow: WAIVE CLOSE. >>Chair Simon: ALL IN FAVOR SAY YEA, ALL OPPOSED SAME SIGN. WE ARE BACK ON THE BILL AS AMENDED, ANY QUESTIONS ON THE BILL AS AMENDED? SEEING NONE WE DO HAVE A FEW APPEARANCE FORMS. DELLA WAIVES AGAINST. CHRIS PAGEL WAIVES AGAINST, NATHAN HOFFMAN WAIVES IN SUPPORT. IS THERE ANY DEBATE ON THE BILL AS AMENDED? SEEING NONE SEN. TRUENOW YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO CLOSE ON YOUR BILL AS AMENDED. >>Sen. Truenow: THANK YOU FOR HEARING THIS BILL TODAY AND WE ARE TRYING TO TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE HAVE WITH THE CHANGES BEING MADE THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND WHAT CAN BE ACCOMPLISHED AND WITH THAT I ASK FOR YOUR FAVORABLE SUPPORT. >>Chair Simon: SPEAKER CALL THE ROLL ON CS FOR SB 824. >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Burgess: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >>Vice Chair Calatayud: >>Chair Simon: YES, BY YOUR VOTE CS FOR SB 824 IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. >>Chair Simon: SO AT THIS TIME WE ARE GOING TO TAKE UP TAB SEVEN AND EIGHT CONFIRMATION HEARINGS FOR APPOINTMENTS. UNLESS ANY SENATOR REQUEST A SEPARATE VOTE ON AN INDIVIDUAL APPOINTEE WE WILL TAKE UP ONE VOTE ON ALL THE APPOINTMENTS. IF THERE'S NO OBJECTIONS, ANY OBJECTIONS TO THE APPOINTEES? IS THERE A MOTION FOR RECOMMENDATION CONFIRMATION? SENATOR YARBOROUGH RECOMMENDS WE CONFIRM APPOINTEES ON TAB SEVEN AND EIGHT, SECRET PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Burgess: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: YES. >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >>Vice Chair Calatayud: >>Chair Simon: YES, BY YOUR VOTE CONFIRMATION OF APPOINTEES ON TAB SEVEN AND EIGHT IS REPORTED FAVORABLY. WE ARE GOING TO TAKE A BRIEF RECESS AS WE NAVIGATE BILL SPONSORS. [NO AUDIO] >> PASSED THE GAVEL AND TAKE UP TAB 6 SB 736 BY OUR PRE-K-12 CHAIR SENATOR SIMON. SENATOR SIMON ARE YOU READY TO BE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN YOUR PROPOSED BILL. >>Chair Simon: I AM READY, SPV 7036 IS A TARGETED EDUCATIONAL PACKAGE THAT STRENGTHENS SCHOOL TURNAROUND TOOLS, EXPANDS EARLY LITERACY SUPPORT AND MODERNIZES SEVERAL K-12 EARLY-MORNING POLICIES. THE BILL EXPANDS WHEN DISTRICTS MAY DECLARE AN EDUCATIONAL EMERGENCY BY ADDING LOW PERFORMING SCHOOLS, CLARIFIES TITLE I WITHHOLDINGS OR ALLOWABLE DISTRICTWIDE SERVICES INCLUDING STEM CURRICULUM AND RELATED LEARNING MATERIALS. ALLIANCE CHARTER SCHOOL RENEWAL AND DISMISSAL RULES AROUND THE SCHOOLS IMPROVEMENT PROCESS AND UPDATES SAFETY AND HEALTH POLICY BY UPDATING EPINEPHRINE USAGE TO COVER ALL PROVIDED DEVICES, I'M SORRY, ALL APPROVED DEVICES AND REMOVING AUTHORITIES TO TEMPORARY DOOR LOCKS DURING AN ACTIVE ASSAILANT INCIDENT. THE BILL UPDATES SUPPORT FOR EARLY LEARNING BY NARROWING BOLD SEAL TERMINATION AND DISQUALIFICATION TO CLASS I VIOLATIONS WHERE THE PROVIDER IS THE PRIMARY CAUSE. EXPANDING VPK SUMMER BRIDGE ELIGIBILITY FROM THE 10TH PERCENTILE TO 25TH PERCENTILE OF ASSESSMENT SCORES AND REQUIRES TARGETED MATH AND READING INTERVENTIONS BASED ON REGULAR SCREENINGS. THE BILL STRENGTHENS INSTRUCTION BY EXPANDING ELEMENTARY AGRICULTURE INSTRUCTION REQUIRED DEVELOPMENT OF APPLIED ALGEBRA COURSES THAT ARE TIED TO CAREER PROGRAMS AND MEET ALGEBRA ONE EXPECTATIONS AND EXPANDS ACCESS TO THE FLEXIBILITY AND FLEXIBILITY TO THE GATE PROGRAM. LASTLY THE BILL STRENGTHENS THE EDUCATOR PIPELINE BY UPDATING ELIGIBILITY OR EDUCATOR PREPARATION INSTITUTES AND THE TARGETED COMPUTER SCIENCE CERTIFICATIONS TO THEIR APPROPRIATE LEVELS. THAT IS THE BILL. >> THANK YOU SENATOR SIMON, QUESTIONS ON THE BILL, SENATOR BERMAN. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. ON LINE 111 AND 112 YOU ADD IN PERSISTENTLY LOW PERFORMING SCHOOLS TO THE DEFINITION OF WHAT WOULD BE AN EDUCATIONAL EMERGENCY. WHAT IS THE REASON FOR ADDING IN PERSISTENTLY LOW PERFORMING SCHOOLS WHEN WE HAVE F AND D SCHOOLS IN THAT EMERGENCY CATEGORY. >> SENATOR SIMON YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Chair Simon: LINES A TRIGGER WITH THE EXISTING STATUTORY CATEGORIES USED IN STATE SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT POLICIES SO THAT'S WHY WE ADDED IT AS AN ADDITIONAL TRIGGER. >>Sen. Berman: SO THIS WILL INCREASE THE NUMBER OF SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT CAN DECLARE AN EDUCATIONAL EMERGENCY TO ALMOST EVERY SINGLE DISTRICT. DOES THAT CONCERN YOU? >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Chair Simon: IT DOESN'T CONCERN ME TO THE EXTENT I AM LOOKING OUT FOR THOSE KIDS MAKING SURE ALL OUR DISTRICTS ARE PERFORMING AT A HIGH LEVEL AND IF THAT MEANS ADDING ADDITIONAL SUPPORTS TO THOSE STUDENTS EARLIER WHEN WE ARE SEEING SCORES THAT ARE NOT COMPARABLE I THINK THE STATE NEEDS TO MAKE THAT INVESTMENT. >> FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. THE BILL REMOVES LANGUAGE RELATED TO THE SCHOOL SAFETY REQUIREMENT RELATED TO TEMPORARY DOOR LOCKS, WHAT IS THE REASON FOR THAT REMOVAL? >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Chair Simon: LAST YEAR WE PASSED THAT DOOR LOCK ISSUE AND I GOT A CHANCE TO SIT DOWN WITH STAKEHOLDERS AND THERE IS A QUESTION AND I'M STILL HAVING THOSE MEETINGS WITH OUR FIRST RESPONDERS AS TO DO THEY HAVE ACCESS TO THE KEYS NECESSARY TO GET INTO THOSE CLASSROOMS IN TIMES OF THAT AN ISSUE ARISES ON CAMPUS. >> FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. IN LINES 819 THROUGH 825, IT TALKS ABOUT WE REMOVE THAT THE DEPARTMENT SHALL NOT ENTER INTO A BUSINESS OF PRODUCING OR PUBLISHING INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS FOR GENERAL USE IN CLASSROOMS. SO ARE WE CONTEMPLATING THIS STATE ACTUALLY PUBLISHING INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS? >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: IN THE CURRENT BILL WE ARE CONTEMPLATING THAT, WE ARE LOOKING AT THE RESEARCH. I KNOW TEXAS WAS ABLE TO PASS A SIMILAR PIECE OF LEGISLATION. I AM STILL HONESTLY WEIGHING THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THAT LEGISLATION AND WHAT THAT MEANS FOR THE STATE OF FLORIDA MAKING SURE WE ARE NOT PUSHING PUBLISHERS OUT, ONLY PROVIDING ONE OPTION FOR OUR DISTRICTS TO PARTICIPATE IN. THAT PROVISION IN THE BILL IS STILL BEING CONSIDERED. >> ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS, PRESIDENT GAETZ. >>Sen. Gaetz: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. I GUESS MY QUESTION IS AS WELL HAVING TO DO WITH THE TEXTBOOKS. WE HAVE A PROCESS NOW WHERE WE DO TEXTBOOK EVALUATION. I'M NOT NECESSARILY A BIG FAN OF THE WAY THAT PROCESS WORKS BUT WE HAVE A PROCESS FOR EVALUATING TEXTBOOKS AND INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS BEFORE IT GOES OUT INTO THE SCHOOLS. AND THAT PROCESS INVOLVES SUBJECT AREA EXPERTS INCLUDING TEACHERS FROM OUR STATE BUT ALSO OTHER SUBJECT AREA EXPERTS FROM TIME TO TIME. IF THE STATE IS GOING TO BECOME A PUBLISHER OF TEXTBOOKS, WHAT THIRD-PARTY EVALUATION WILL BE DONE TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE THE RIGHT KIND OF TEXT AND BY THE RIGHT KIND I MEAN RIGOROUS, ACCURATE AVAILABLE COST-EFFECTIVE TEXT FOR OUR SCHOOLS? >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION, I ABSOLUTELY AGREE WITH YOU. THERE NEEDS TO BE GUARDRAILS IN PLACE AND WE NEED TO PUT THOSE IN PLACE IF THE POLICY IS MOVING FORWARD. WE ARE STILL WEIGHING THE NEED FOR POLICY LIKE THIS IN ITS CURRENT STATE. AND WE'RE STILL WORKING THROUGH THIS POLICY SO YOU'RE RIGHT, THERE ABSOLUTELY NEEDS TO BE GUARDRAILS IN PLACE IF WE ARE GOING DOWN THIS TRAIL OF ALLOWING THE DEPARTMENT TO ESTABLISH MATERIALS. >>Sen. Gaetz: MR. CHAIRMAN MAY I FOLLOW-UP BRIEFLY? IT WOULD SEEM TO ME THERE WOULD HAVE TO BE SOME KIND OF EVIDENTIARY BASIS. WE NEED THE STATE TO PUBLISH TEXTBOOKS BECAUSE WE CAN'T FIND ANY TEXTBOOKS. THE TEXTBOOKS WE FIND AREN'T ADEQUATE. THE TEXTBOOKS WE FIND COST TOO MUCH MONEY, WE CAN'T GET THEM ON TIME. THERE SHOULD BE A REASON BASED ON EVIDENCE THAT WOULD SUGGEST WIND THE STATE NEEDS TO GET INTO THE PUBLISHING BUSINESS AND IF THERE IS A REASON MAYBE IT'S A GOOD REASON BUT THE MINUTE I DON'T SEE IN THE MATERIALS BEFORE US AND ARTICULATED REASON BASED ON THAT EVIDENCE. >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: I WILL SAY I DON'T DISAGREE WITH YOU. AND I'M THANKFUL, THANK YOU FOR REALLY LOOKING AT THIS POLICY AND THIS PROCESS DOING WHAT IT SHOULD DO WHICH IS FIND THE WEAK POINTS IN ALL PARTS OF LEGISLATION THAT COME BEFORE OUR COMMITTEES AND THAT'S WHY I SAY THERE'S STILL A LOT TO BE DESIRED AS WE MOVE FORWARD. >> FOLLOW-UP, THANK YOU, FURTHER QUESTIONS, SENATOR OSGOOD. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU SENATOR SIMON FOR THE GREAT WORK YOU DO IN THIS SPACE. I HAVE A FEW QUESTIONS AROUND THE SAME LINES. HAS THERE BEEN ANY ANTICIPATION OF A COST TO A DISTRICT THAT WOULD HAVE THE TRANSITION TO DEPARTMENT DEVELOPED MATERIALS INCLUDING LIKE THE TRAINING, A LOT OF TIMES THE MATERIALS REQUIRE ADDITIONAL TRAINING FOR STAFF FOR IT TO BE IMPLEMENTED EFFECTIVELY. >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: THEY WILL STILL RECEIVE THEIR ALLOCATION THEY CURRENTLY RECEIVE FOUR MATERIALS. I DO NOT HAVE THAT NUMBER AS WE PUSH FORWARD THE POLICY I WILL MAKE SURE TO GET THAT NUMBER TO YOU ON WHAT THE COST WOULD BE TOO THE DISTRICTS, THAT WOULD FLUCTUATE DEPENDING ON THE SIZE OF THE DISTRICT. >> SENATOR OSGOOD. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU, FOLLOW-UP. IS THERE ANY DATA ANYWHERE DEMONSTRATING IMPROVED STUDENT OUTCOMES IN DISTRICTS THAT HAVE USED DEPARTMENT DEVELOPED INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL? >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: THE DEPARTMENT ISN'T DEVELOPING ANY MATERIALS FOR USAGE AND THAT'S WHY THIS BILL IS BEING PRESENTED THOUGH THE DEPARTMENT CAN LOOK AT WAYS TO POTENTIALLY LOOK AT WAYS TO DEVELOP MATERIALS FOR THE DISTRICT. SO THERE IS NO DATA. >> FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU MR. TEAR SO HEARING YOU SAY THAT IS THE INTENT OF THIS PROVISION TO SUPPLEMENT LOCAL OPTIONS OR EVENTUALLY REPLACE THE STATE ADOPTED THIS. >> SENATOR SIMON. >>Sen. Simon: THERE IS NO EFFORTS TO REPLACE THE STATE ADOPTED THIS, THIS WOULD BE A SUPPLEMENT THIS FIX WOULD BE ALLOWED TO CHOOSE FROM. >> FOLLOW-UP? ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS? SEEING NO FURTHER QUESTIONS WE HAVE THE COUPLE OF PUBLIC TESTIMONY CARDS I BELIEVE BOTH WAIVING. CHRIS HEXYL, HOPE I GOT THAT RIGHT IS WAIVING AGAINST AS WELL AS GAIL OLENICK WITH THE FLORIDA EDUCATIONAL ASSOCIATION IS WAIVING AGAINST, THAT'S ALL THE PUBLIC APPEARANCE CARDS, ANY SENATORS WISHING TO DEBATE ON THE BILL, SENATOR BERMAN. >>Sen. Berman: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. I'M GOING TO VOTE AGAINST THE BILL TODAY BECAUSE OF THIS PROVISION REGARDING THE POTENTIAL ABOUT TEXTBOOKS. IF YOU MAKE A CHANGE IT'S QUITE LIKELY I WILL BE ABLE TO SUPPORT THE BILL AT THAT TIME BUT THE WAY IT IS RIGHT NOW I CAN'T SUPPORT IT., >> THANK YOU, SENATOR OSGOOD. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU AND I AGREE WITH SENATOR BERMAN. I LOVE THE BILL BUT I DON'T WANT TO GET INTO THE STATE BEING THE ONLY PROVIDER OF MATERIALS FOR EDUCATION, BECAUSE I FEEL IT DISCOURAGES INNOVATION AND COMPETITION SO I'M GLAD TO KNOW YOU ARE STILL WORKING ON THE BILL SO HOPEFULLY I CAN BE A GUESS BY THE TIME IT GETS TO THE FLOOR'S. >> ANY FURTHER DEBATE? SENATOR CALATAYUD. >>Vice Chair Calatayud: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU SENATOR SIMON FOR THE BILL AND AS MY COLLEAGUES HAVE MENTIONED, SOME CONCERN ON THE FINAL POSITION FOR THE TEXTBOOK ELEMENT. I'M GRATEFUL TO WORK WITH YOU. AS YOU MENTIONED THAT'S A PLACE WHERE WE ARE NOT THERE YET AND I'M GRATEFUL FOR THE ABILITY TO PARTNER WITH YOU ON GETTING TO THE RIGHT PLACE AND HAPPY TO SUPPORT TO MAKE SURE WE CAN GET THERE OVER TIME, THANK YOU. >> ANY FURTHER DEBATE, SEEING NONE SENATOR CALATAYUD SUBMITTED BE INCLUDED AS A COMMITTEE BILL, ANY OBJECTION? SEEING NO OBJECTION THE MOTION IS ADOPTED. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON SPV 7036. >>Sen. Berman: >>Sen. Davis: >>Sen. Gaetz: >>Sen. Osgood: >>Sen. Yarborough: >>Vice Chair Calatayud: >>Chair Simon: >>Sen. Burgess: YES, BY YOUR VOTE SPB 7036 IS REPORTED AS A COMMITTEE BILL. I HAVE COMPLETED MY DUTIES AND I WILL NOW PASS IT BACK TO SENATOR SIMON. >>Chair Simon: WELL DONE MY FRIEND AND I APPRECIATE IT. >>Sen. Burgess: WISH I HAD A SONG I COULD REFERENCE. >>Chair Simon: IT'S NOT 1738. LET'S TAKE UP TAB FOR SP 1620 ON PUBLIC EDUCATION SENATOR LEEK, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO EXPLAIN YOUR BILL. >>Sen. Leek: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. THIS IS THE SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS BILL OF RIGHTS TO CLARIFY EXTENDED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS OVERSIGHT OF THE RESPECTIVE DISTRICTS. THE BILL REQUIRES DISTRICTS TO PROVIDE BOARD MEMBERS WITH ACCESS TO ALL DISTRICT DOCUMENTS ALLOW MEMBERS TO REQUEST INFORMATION FROM THE SUPERINTENDENT AND STAFF, AUTHORIZES CONSULTATION WITH CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICERS AND ACCESS ANY BUDGET LINE ITEM OR FINANCIAL TRANSACTION DETAIL AND ALLOWS BUDGET INFORMATION SHALL BE POSTED ON DISTRICT WEBSITES. IT PERMITS STAFF WITHOUT SUPERINTENDENT RESTRICTION AND UNDER WHICH EMPLOYEES MAY REPRESENT THE BOARD AUTHORIZING TO APPROVE HIRING TO REPRESENT THE SCHOOL BOARD. THE BILL DEFINES GOOD CAUSE FOR REJECTING SUPERINTENDENT NOMINEES AND STRENGTHENS GUARDRAILS FOR SUPPLIERS AND FINALLY DISTRICTS WILL BE PROHIBITED FROM INCENTIVIZING EMPLOYEES TO SIGN NONDISCLOSURE AND CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS AND THAT IS THE BILL. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU SENATOR, QUESTION BILL, SENATOR OSGOOD, FEEL FREE TO GO BACK AND FORTH. >>Sen. Osgood: SEN. LEEK CAN YOU EXPLAIN ON THE ATTORNEYS FEES, HAVING EXPERIENCED ON THE SCHOOL BOARD THE ATTORNEY SUPERINTENDENT AND IN SOME DISTRICTS ARE THE ARBITERS, THE EMPLOYEES OF THE SCHOOL BOARD SO I'M TRYING TO FOLLOW WHEN YOU SAY A SEPARATE ATTORNEY BEING EMPLOYED TO REPRESENT THE SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS. >>Sen. Leek: HAPPY TO DO SO IF I MAY. FIRST LET ME START BY SAYING I EXPECTED THIS BILL WOULD CHANGE OVER TIME, THE HOUSE PASSED THEIR BILL. I CAN SEE PLACES WHERE WE MAY MOVE TOWARDS THAT BILL READ THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE TO YOUR QUESTION STRUCK ME AS ODD WHEN I LEARNED SCHOOL DISTRICTS HIRE AN ATTORNEY THAT ATTORNEY SOMETIMES REPRESENTS THE SCHOOL BOARD THAT ATTORNEY THEN SAYS IN SOME INSTANCES THEY CANNOT TALK WITH THE SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS CONFIDENTIALLY BECAUSE THEY HAVE A CONFLICT OF INTEREST WHICH BY THE WAY I THINK IS ABSOLUTELY CORRECT, THEY DO HAVE A CONFLICT OF INTEREST WHICH IS WHY THAT TYPE OF DUAL REPRESENTATION IS OFFENSIVE TO ME. THAT SAID, ONE OF THE THINGS I THINK WE CAN WORK ON HERE IS WHETHER THE BOARD NEEDS TO HAVE A FULL-TIME ATTORNEY OR NOT BECAUSE THAT COULD BE BURDENSOME FINANCIALLY ON SOME DISTRICTS SO I THINK THERE IS MOVEMENT THERE BUT THE ENTIRE IDEA WAS TO AVOID THE INHERENT CONFLICT OF INTEREST IN AN ATTORNEY REPRESENTING BOTH THE OVERSIGHT POLICYMAKING BOARD AND THE EXECUTIVE EFFECTIVE ELEMENT OF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. >>Chair Simon: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Osgood: FOLLOW-UP QUESTION, ANOTHER PART OF THE BILL TALKS ABOUT A BOARD BEING ABLE TO GO DIRECTLY TO STAFF. LET'S JUST SAY HYPOTHETICALLY A BOARD MEMBER GOES TO STAFF, GETTING QUESTIONS AND INFORMATION ABOUT AN RFP OR RFQ AND THEN THEY MAKE COMMENTS, HAVE YOU GIVEN ANY CONSIDERATION AS TO WHAT KIND OF PRESSURE THAT COULD POTENTIALLY PUT A STAFF MEMBER ON WITH THE BOARD MEMBER GOING DIRECTLY TO THE STAFF INSTEAD OF THROUGH THE SUPERINTENDENT. >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. Leek: I HAVE AND I UNDERSTAND IT'S A BALANCE WE ARE TRYING TO REACH. I AM CONTEMPLATING REASONABLENESS LANGUAGE BUT I ALSO LOOK AT IT FROM THE OTHER SIDE. I DON'T BELIEVE THAT STAFF SHOULD BE PROHIBITED FROM TALKING TO BOARD MEMBERS AND I UNDERSTAND THAT IS HAPPENING IN SOME PLACES, STAFF IF THEY ARE INCLINED TO A BOARD MEMBER SHOULD BE ABLE TO TALK TO A BOARD MEMBER BUT A BOARD MEMBER SHOULDN'T BE ABLE TO REQUEST TIME WITH THAT STAFF MEMBER WHETHER THAT STAFF MEMBER GRANTS OR NOT. I DON'T BELIEVE IT SHOULD BE A RULE THAT STAFF MEMBERS ARE UNAVAILABLE TO SCHOOL BOARDS. >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED SENATOR OSGOOD FOR A FOLLOW-UP. >>Sen. Osgood: WOULD YOU CONSIDER LANGUAGE THAT I WOULD NEVER BE ON THE SCHOOL BOARD AND HAVE ANYBODY TELL ME I COULDN'T TALK TO STAFF. THAT WOULDN'T HAPPEN BUT THE OTHER WAY IF YOU GIVE BOARD MEMBERS THAT AUTHORITY, THEN IT COULD POSSIBLY CIRCUMVENT THE SUPERINTENDENT'S AUTHORITY. ESPECIALLY IF THE STAFF HAVE ANOTHER AGENDA, WOULD YOU CONSIDER AN AMENDMENT TO CODIFY WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH WITH THIS? >>Sen. Leek: IF I MAY I WOULD HAVE TO SEE THE AMENDMENT FIRST BECAUSE THE ISSUE YOU ARE PAINTING IS THE TENSION I'M TRYING TO RESOLVE. I WANT STAFF TO BE AVAILABLE TO SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS IF THEY MAKE REASONABLE REQUESTS FOR INFORMATION. I DON'T WANT THE SUPERINTENDENT TO DIRECT THAT STAFF PERSON TO TALK TO A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER AND EQUALLY I DON'T WANT TO PUT THAT STAFF PERSON IN A POSITION THAT'S UNTENABLE SO WE ARE WORKING ON IT, THAT'S WHY I WOULD CALL REASONABLE ACCESS WHICH AT THE END OF THE DAY IS NOT A DEFINITIVE RESOLUTION BUT IT DOES PUT BOUNDS OF REASONABLENESS ON THE REQUEST. >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP. SENATOR BERMAN YOU ARE RECOGNIZED FOR A SERIES. >>Sen. : THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. WE RECEIVED A LETTER FROM THE SHERIFF IN VOLUSIA COUNTY I BELIEVE. AND ONE OF HIS CONCERNS IS THEY THINK YOU'RE GOING TO UNDERMINE THE AUTHORITY OF THE SUPERINTENDENT IN THIS BILL. I'D LIKE YOU TO SPEAK ABOUT THAT A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE I'M NOT SURE I AGREE WITH HIM BUT I'D LOVE TO HEAR YOUR INTERPRETATION OF THAT. >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >>Sen. : TRYING TO THINK HOW MUCH TROUBLE I AM GETTING GOING TO GET ENFORCING THIS BUT PRECISELY, I'M TRYING TO'S STRIKE A BALANCE BETWEEN THE SUPERINTENDENT'S AUTHORITY AND WHAT THE POLICYMAKING BOARD'S RIGHTS NEED TO BE. IN SOME INSTANCES YOU'VE SEEN AND I'VE HEARD ABOUT THIS FROM AROUND THE STATE WHERE SCHOOL ABOUT BOARD MEMBERS COME ON AND THE DISTRICT IS NOT ALIGNED WITH THEM AND THEY ARE DOING EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO THWART THAT SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER FROM DOING THEIR JOB WHICH IS BEING THE POLICYMAKING BOARD FOR THE DISTRICT SO I AGREE, THIS DOESN'T MY UNDERMINE THAT AUTHORITY BUT IT DOES SO INTENTIONALLY AND HOPEFULLY WITH PURPOSE AND DELIBERATELY SO IT'S A REASONABLE BALANCE BETWEEN THE TWO. >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP, ANY OTHER QUESTIONS. WE DO HAVE SEVERAL APPEARANCE FORMS. ALL SPEAKING, SHANE STORY SPEAKING FOR THE BILL. >> GOOD AFTERNOON HONORABLE MEMBERS, CHAIR, APPRECIATE YOU ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK REGARDING SENATE BILL 1620. I AM A FORMER ESE TEACHER ADMINISTRATOR FROM VOLUSIA COUNTY AND AS ONE OF THE THREE PEOPLE THAT WAS, THAT LEFT VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOLS FOR THE REFUSAL TO SIGN A NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT I APPRECIATE THE ATTENTION SEN. LEEK HAS BROUGHT TO THIS END SENATOR GAETZ. I WANT TO BEGIN BY THOSE NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENTS, MBAS WERE NOT USED TO PROTECT STUDENTS BUT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. SOME OF THE INFORMATION IS SAFEGUARDED THROUGH FEDERAL LAW WITH OTHER PRIVACY REGULATIONS AND NDA'S AND NOTHING TO STUDENT SAFETY, INSTEAD THEY SHIELD DISTRICT FROM SCRUTINY, SILENCE EDUCATORS AND DISCOURAGE WHISTLEBLOWERS. WHEN TRANSPARENCY IS REPLACED WITH SILENCE ACCOUNTABILITY DISAPPEARS. SENATE BILL 1620 RESTORES BALANCE BY ELIMINATING THE MISUSE OF THESE AGREEMENTS AND THE LINE ITEM BUDGET CANNOT BE UNDERSTOOD CANNOT BE AUDITED BY THE PUBLIC LAST YEAR THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ISSUED FINDINGS OF SCHOOLS FAILED TO ACCOUNT FOR PROPORTIONAL SHARED COST, FEDERAL DOLLARS INTENDED TO SUPPORT STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES ENROLLED IN PRIVATE AND CHARTER SCHOOLS AND AT THE SAME TIME THE DISTRICT SPENT TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO PURCHASE PROPERTIES IN DEBERRY, ONE OF WHICH IS NOW FOR SALE AS IT WAS FOUND TO BE UNBILLABLE AND THE SECOND HAS BEEN OPPOSED BY THE CITY GOVERNMENT ITSELF. WITHOUT CLEAR LINE ITEM BUDGETS THE PUBLIC CANNOT DETERMINE WHETHER THESE EXPENDITURES WERE NECESSARY OR ALIGNED WITH PRIORITIES. TRANSPARENCY IS NOT OPTIONAL WHEN PUBLIC DOLLARS ARE INVOLVED. THERE ARE OTHER ISSUES REGARDING THE USE OF IDA FUNDS OR FAVORITISM AWARDING CONTRACT BUT ONLY TO THE SAME CONCLUSION THAT WITHOUT TRANSPARENT LINE ITEM BUDGETS MEANINGFUL OVERSIGHT IS IMPOSSIBLE AND THIS IS COMPOUNDED WHEN OFFICIALS ARE OBSTRUCTED FROM DOING THEIR JOB. OUR SITTING SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER WAS DENIED ACCESS TO DISTRICT DOCUMENTS AND INSTRUCTED TO FILE PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST AND PAY FOR THOSE RECORDS. RECORDS REQUIRED TO FULFILL HER DUTY TO THE VOTERS AND I RECEIVED A RESPONSE REGARDING A PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST ON MY BEHALF. I REQUESTED INVOICES FROM THE P CARD EXPENSES. AN ISSUE THAT IS DEEPLY AT THE HEART FOR VOLUSIA COUNTY RESIDENTS ESPECIALLY DAYTONA, I WAS QUOTED $3150 FOR A CREDIT CARD IN PLACE. I BELIEVE THAT IS UNREASONABLE AND I THINK YOU SHOULD DO AND IF THAT HAPPENED TO ME THAT'S WHAT WOULD BE EXPECTED OF THE BOARD MEMBERS. FINANCIAL INFORMATION. >>Chair Simon: IF WE COULD START TO WRAP IT UP. >> YES, SIR. THE SCHOOL BOARD ATTORNEY REPRESENTING TWO DIFFERENT ENTITIES IS ALSO A SIGNIFICANT CONFLICT, HOW CAN A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER PULLED ACCOUNTABLE THE SUPERINTENDENT AND GET SOUND LEGAL ADVICE IF THAT SAME ATTORNEY REPORTS TO THE SUPERINTENDENT? IN CLOSING I SEE MY ENTIRE SCHOOL BOARD HAS SHOWN UP WITH THEIR ATTORNEY AND SUPERINTENDENT SO GIVEN THIS BILL IS ABOUT TRANSPARENCY AND HONESTY AND INTEGRITY I HOPE THEY LEND THEIR SUPPORT TO THIS BILL. >>Chair Simon: SYDNEY REAGAN SPEAKING AGAINST THE BILL. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED MISS REAGAN >> SYDNEY REAGAN HERE ON BEHALF OF SHERIFF MICHAEL CHIPMAN VOLUSIA COUNTY. HELLO CHAIR SIMON AND I'M WRITING TO EXPRESS MY STRONG OPPOSITION TO SENATE BILL 1620 RELATING TO PUBLIC EDUCATION. AS THE SHERIFF OF VOLUSIA COUNTY AND AS POLICE CHIEF FOR THE CITY OF DAYTONA BEACH I'VE WORKED CLOSELY WITH OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS FOR MANY YEARS. THROUGH THAT EXPERIENCE I'VE SEEN FIRSTHAND THE CHALLENGES THAT ARISE FROM INEFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP AS WELL AS THE POSITIVE IMPACT STRONG CONSISTENT LEADERSHIP CAN HAVE ON STUDENTS EDUCATORS AND THE BROADER COMMUNITY. IT IS CRITICAL SUPERINTENDENT ARE EMPOWERED TO EFFECTIVELY MANAGE THE DAY-TO-DAY OPERATIONS OF OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS. FROM A LAW-ENFORCEMENT PERSPECTIVE THEY UNDERSTAND THE IMPORTANCE OF A CLEAR CHAIN OF COMMAND. STAFF MUST HAVE A DIRECT AND WELL-DEFINED REPORTING STRUCTURE TO OPERATE EFFICIENTLY AND FOCUS ON STUDENT SUCCESS. THE CURRENT GOVERNANCE MODEL WHERE THE SCHOOL BOARD PROVIDES OVERSIGHT WHILE THE SUPERINTENDENT MANAGES DAILY OPERATIONS HAS PROVEN TO BE THE MOST EFFECTIVE STRUCTURE FOR BOTH STAFF ACCOUNTABILITY AND STUDENT OUTCOMES. VOLUSIA COUNTY SERVES AS A STRONG EXAMPLE OF WHAT EFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP CAN ACHIEVE WITH MORE THAN 60,000 STUDENTS ENROLLED AND OVER 8200 EMPLOYEES STRONG OUR SCHOOL DISTRICT EXPERIENCED UNPRECEDENTED SUCCESS IN RECENT YEARS EARNING AN A RATING FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE THE 2008 2009 SCHOOL YEAR. THIS PROGRESS IS DUE IN LARGE PART TO THE LEADERSHIP OF SUPERINTENDENT DOCTOR CARMEN BAUMAN WHOSE DEDICATION AND VISION HAVE TRANSFORMED THE DISTRICT. DOCTOR BAUMAN HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED NATIONALLY. >>Chair Simon: MISS REAGAN IF YOU CAN WRAP IT UP. >> DOCTOR BAUMAN HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED NATIONALLY AS THE 2025 SUPERINTENDENT OF THE YEAR BY THE ASSERTION OF SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENTS AND AS A WOMAN OF THE YEAR BY THE DISTRICT ADMINISTRATION LEADERSHIP INSTITUTE. BEYOND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENTS SHE HAS GUIDED THE DISTRICT TOWARDS SIGNIFICANT FINANCIAL IMPROVEMENT WHEN SHE ASSUMED LEADERSHIP THE DISTRICT FACED $50 MILLION IN DEBT IN LESS THAN FOUR YEARS THAT FIGURE HAS BEEN REDUCED TO ROUGHLY 16 MILLION. THANK YOU. >>Chair Simon: RUBEN COLÓN SPEAKING AGAINST. >> GOOD EVENING, RUBEN COLÓN AND I AM CHAIR OF THE VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD HERE TO SHARE CONCERNS ABOUT SENATE BILL 1620 BECAUSE IT DOESN'T SIMPLY REFINE OVERSIGHT, IT SHIFTS FLORIDA'S GOVERNANCE MODEL IN WAYS THAT WILL BE FELT IMMEDIATELY IN THE DAY-TO-DAY OPERATIONS OF OUR SCHOOLS. THREE OF MY FELLOW SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS AND SUPERINTENDENT ARE HERE TO SHARE THEIR THOUGHTS ON THE BILL. BEING ADVANCED BY A SINGLE MEMBER OF OUR BOARD. WHICH HAS PORTRAYED THIS AS AN ISSUE IN VOLUSIA COUNTY. IN MY EIGHT YEARS OF SERVICE TO BE CLEAR I'VE RECEIVED EVERY SINGLE DOCUMENT I HAVE EVER REQUESTED. AND THE SUPERINTENDENT HAS ALWAYS FACILITATED EVERY CONVERSATION WITH STAFF THAT I'VE EVER NEEDED AND I ASK FOR MANY. FLORIDA STRUCTURES PURPOSE WHILE THE BOARD GOVERNS AS A COLLEGIAL BODY AND THE SUPERINTENDENT IS THE BOARD'S EXECUTIVE OFFICER RESPONSIBLE FOR ADMINISTRATION AND MANAGEMENT, THAT SEPARATION IS THE GUARDRAIL THAT KEEPS ACCOUNTABILITY CLEAR AND A FOCUS ON STUDENT OUTCOMES AND IN VOLUSIA COUNTY THAT MODEL IS WORKING. WE HAVE AN AMAZING SUPERINTENDENT WAS DELIVERED RESULTS BUILT TRUST AND KEPT THE ORGANIZATION FOCUSED ON STUDENTS. I ALREADY TOLD YOU SHE WAS OUR NATIONAL SUPERINTENDENT OF THE YEAR. SB 1620 MOVES AWAY FROM THAT CLARITY IN THREE WAYS, FIRST IT GRANTS INDIVIDUAL NUMBERS FREE UNTIMELY ACCESS TO ALL DISTRICT DOCUMENTS INCLUDING NONPUBLIC MATERIALS AND EVEN INTERNAL LEGAL OPINIONS. THE CONCERN IS NOT ACCESS IN PRINCIPLE, IT'S THE LACK OF SAFEGUARDS. THE BILL DOES NOT ALLOW ACCESS IN THE SCOPE OF THE BOARD'S DUTIES DOES NOT LIMIT REQUESTS TO ITEMS PENDING BOARD ACTION AND DOES NOT ESTABLISH GUARDRAILS FOR HANDLING CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION AND I WISH I COULD TELL YOU MY EXAMPLE WAS ANECDOTAL, WE ARE USED TO THINGS BEING LEAKED RIGHT NOW. WITH THAT BEING SAID THE BILL ALSO AUTHORIZES INDIVIDUAL NUMBERS TO GO TO DISTRICT STAFF WITHOUT SUPERINTENDENTS PERMISSION, LET THAT SINK IN. THAT PARADES CREATES PARALLEL LINES AND WEAKENS CONSISTENTLY THE MANAGEMENT STAFF CAPACITY AND BLURS ACCOUNTABILITY. THIRD BECAUSE ONE BOARD MEMBER DID NOT AGREE WITH OUR BOARD ATTORNEY AND OUR CONSULTING OUTSIDE ATTORNEY GIVING THE PERCEPTION OF THERE BEING BIAS, ALL OF A SUDDEN THERE'S A VOTE THAT SAYS THIS WILL NOW FORCE RESTRUCTURING REPRESENTATION ON SCHOOL BOARDS IN DIFFERENT COUNTIES, THOSE COUNTIES INCLUDE BAY, BREVARD, COLUMBIA, ESCAMBIA, HAMILTON, LEE, LEVY, PALM BEACH, PASCOE, PINELLAS AND VOLUSIA, TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY MATTER BUT SO DO THE LINES OF AUTHORITY AND RESPONSIBLE INFORMATION HANDLING. SB 1620 AS DRAFTED EXPANDS INDIVIDUAL MEMBER POWER WITHOUT THE GUARDRAILS NEEDED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY PRESERVE ACCOUNTABILITY TO KEEP THE DISTRICTS FOCUSED ON STUDENTS. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU. SENATOR GAETZ YOU ARE RECOGNIZED FOR QUESTION. >>Sen. Gaetz: THANK YOU MR. CHAIRMAN. DO YOU FIND NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENTS TO BE A USEFUL TOOL TO PROMOTE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE AND FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY BOARD YOU WILL AGREE AGREEMENTS HAVE NO PLACE IN A GOVERNMENT INSTITUTION. >>Chair Simon: YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> IT'S SOMETHING WE NEVER HAD TO FACE AS A BOARD UNTIL ALL OF A SUDDEN CONVERSATIONS START GETTING LEAKED, CONVERSATIONS THAT WERE IN PROCESS, CONVERSATIONS HAD WITH THE BOARD IN ITS APPROPRIATE MANNER ALL OF A SUDDEN COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND IT'S ON SOCIAL MEDIA. UNTIL THAT HAPPENED, OKAY AND WE TRULY COULD NOT HOLD STAFF ACCOUNTABLE. THAT'S WHY WE'VE HAD TO DO THAT IN VOLUSIA COUNTY. >>Sen. Gaetz: THANK YOU MR. CHAIRMAN. >>Chair Simon: WE HAVE A ANOTHER QUESTION, SENATOR OSGOOD. >>Sen. Osgood: HAVING HERE HEARD YOU SAY YOU SERVED 9 AND A HALF YEARS ON THE SCHOOL BOARD YOU HAVE CLOSED-DOOR SESSIONS. YOU HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO LIMIT IT TO WHO'S IN THOSE CLOSED-DOOR SESSIONS AND I UNDERSTAND BECAUSE WE HAD A SIMILAR SITUATION WITH A BOARD MEMBER WHERE WE COULDN'T BRING OUR PHONES. BUT SIGNING A NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT I THINK IS, DID YOU GUYS THINK OF ANY OTHER OPTIONS INSTEAD OF SIGNING UP NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT? >> THERE ARE OTHER DISTRICTS WITH NDA'S AND WE CONSULTED THOSE DISTRICTS THAT HAVE NDA FOR THEIR EMPLOYEES. >>Chair Simon: FOLLOW-UP. THANK YOU MR. COLÓN. KRISTIN GOODRICH SPEAKING AGAINST. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED MISS GOODRICH >> MY NAME IS KRISTA GOODRICH AND I AM THE VICE CHAIR OF THE VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD AND AS A SECOND YEAR FIRST TIME ELECTED OFFICIAL I TAKE THIS RESPONSIBILITY SERIOUSLY AND APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK, I'M SPEAKING AGAINST THE BILL BECAUSE IT NEEDS A FEW MINOR CLARIFICATIONS TO AVOID UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES. FIRST ON LINE 64 AND 71 I RESPECTFULLY SUGGEST CLARIFYING INFORMATION REQUESTS APPLY ONLY AS THEY PERTAIN TO A BOARD MEMBER'S OFFICIAL DUTIES. WITHOUT THAT BOUNDARY DOCUMENTS OR STAFF ACCESS COULD BE MISUSED AND EMPLOYEES COULD BE PRESSURED TO SHARE INFORMATION THAT IS INAPPROPRIATE. PROTECTING STUDENTS MUST REMAIN OUR TOP PRIORITY AND SECOND ONLINE 79 REGARDING CONFIDENTIAL UNION INFORMATION I ASKED CLARITY ON ENFORCEMENT IF THAT PROVISION IS VIOLATED AND RAISE AN OPERATIONAL CONCERN WHICH YOU GUYS HAVE AS WELL WHEN DIRECTIVES FROM A BOARD MEMBER CONFLICT WITH THOSE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT WHICH WILL TAKE PRECEDENCE? WITHOUT CLARITY STAFF WILL BE CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE. VOLUSIA COUNTY WAS REFERENCED IN THE HEARING SO WE ARE PROVIDED WITH OPTIONAL WEEKLY MEETINGS FOR BOARD QUESTIONS AND TRANSPARENCY HAS BEEN MY EXPERIENCE. I SUGGEST THE BILL ALLOW FOR THOSE MEETINGS TO BE RECORDED SO WE CAN PROTECT EVERYONE INVOLVED AND FINALLY WHILE I AM OKAY WITH THIS BILL BYPASSING THE SUPERINTENDENT CANNOT THEN HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE FOR THE ACTIONS HAPPENING WITHOUT THEIR KNOWLEDGE SO I WANT TO ENSURE WE DON'T UNDERMINE THE SUPERINTENDENT AS YOU DISCUSSED OR BY ENABLING AUTHORITY TO BE USED FOR POTENTIAL PERSONAL CONFLICT AND WITH THOSE CONCERNS ADDRESSED I WOULD SUPPORT THIS BILL. I APPRECIATE CLARIFICATION OF ATTORNEY RULES AND REMOVAL OF THE NDA'S AND EFFORT TO CREATE MORE CONSISTENT TRANSPARENCY. I AGREE SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS SHOULD NOT BE CHARGED FOR GETTING DOCUMENTS TO DO THEIR JOB. I AGREE WITH TRANSPARENT GOVERNANCE STATEWIDE, I SIMPLY ASKED WE MAKE THESE FEW MINOR CHANGES IN THE LANGUAGE TO PROTECT AGAINST UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES SO OUR STUDENTS SAFETY IS ALWAYS PROTECTED, THANK YOU ALL. >>Chair Simon: JESSE THOMPSON SPEAKING AGAINST. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND THANK YOU FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK. MY NAME IS JESSE THOMPSON AND ON A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER FROM VOLUSIA COUNTY SINCE 2022 AND ARE ONLY SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER WHO HAS YOUNG CHILDREN IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS SO I SPEAK NOT ONLY AS AN ELECTED OFFICIAL BUT A PARENT AS WELL AND I WANT TO THANK SEN. LEEK FOR BRINGING FORWARD THE PARENTS BILL OF RIGHTS. SINCE THIS ORIGINATED IN THE VOLUSIA COUNTY I'D LIKE TO SHARE AS A BOARD MEMBER I'VE NEVER HAD AN ISSUE RECEIVING INFORMATION FROM MY SUPERINTENDENT, EVEN WHEN MY PERSPECTIVE WAS NOT THE POPULAR ONE. BUT I DO HAVE A FEW CONCERNS AND I ASKED THE COMMITTEE TO CONSIDER. LINES 59 THROUGH 62 THE BILL REFERENCES ACCESS TO ALL DOCUMENTS AND I AM CONCERNED WHETHER THIS COULD INCLUDE STUDENT OR STAFF PERSONAL INFORMATION AND WHETHER APPROPRIATE PROTECTIONS WILL BE CLEARLY DEFINED. ADDITIONALLY LINES 71 THROUGH 73 ALLOW BOARD MEMBERS TO SEEK INFORMATION FROM STAFF WITHOUT APPROVAL AND IN DISTRICTS WITH MULTIPLE BOARD MEMBERS THIS COULD RESULT IN CONFUSION AND I ASKED WHETHER A HIERARCHY OR PROCESS COULD BE CONSIDERED. THANK YOU FOR YOUR THOUGHTFUL CONSIDERATION, AS A PARENT I APPRECIATE YOUR ATTENTION TO THESE CONCERNS. >>Chair Simon: FINALLY JANIE HAYES SPEAKING AGAINST. >> GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIRMAN AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I STARTED MY CAREER 39 YEARS AGO AS A TEACHER IN VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOLS AND HAD MY EIGHTH YEAR SERVING AS A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER. I AM PERFECTLY FINE WITH THE CURRENT LAWS WE HAVE IN PLACE THAT GIVE ME THE RIGHTS I NEED IN ORDER TO DO MY JOB AND I FEEL I'VE BEEN DOING IT VERY WELL FOR EIGHT YEARS. MY BIGGEST CONCERN HERE AND I WANT TO GIVE EXAMPLES AS TO WHY, IS THIS FREE AND UNFETTERED ACCESS TO ANYTHING, EVEN THINGS THAT ARE NOT PART OF PUBLIC RECORDS. HERE'S A FEW LAWS IN PLACE THAT BASICALLY I EVEN BROUGHT THIS UP IN ONE OF OUR BOARD MEETINGS THIS BASICALLY IS ALLOWED TO SUPERSEDE THEM. IF YOU HAVE A STUDENT ON CAMPUS THAT HAS AIDS, THE ONLY INDIVIDUAL THAT'S ALLOWED TO KNOW THAT CHILD HAS AIDS IS THE PRINCIPAL AS LONG AS THE PARENTS HAVE GIVEN THAT PERMISSION. WE GO THROUGH BLOOD-BORNE PATHOGEN TRAINING EVERY YEAR AS EMPLOYEES SO WE KNOW HOW TO HANDLE ISSUES SO THERE WON'T BE A PROBLEM. I DON'T WANT ANYONE TO BE ABLE TO ASK FOR A LIST OF STUDENTS ON CAMPUS THAT HAVE AIDS. I DON'T NEED THAT TO DO MY JOB NOR DO I BELIEVE ANY OTHER BOARD MEMBER DOES. ON TOP OF THAT THIS COULD GIVE THEM ACCESS TO EMPLOYEE HEALTH RECORDS, THEY COULD ASK WHO'S BEEN TO SEE THE EMPLOYEE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM OR HOW A PERSON DISTRIBUTES THEIR CHECK, THEY COULD ASK TO READ INDIVIDUAL CHILDREN'S IEP'S. I DON'T NEED ANY OF THAT TO DO MY JOB AND WHEN IT COMES DOWN AND TALKS ABOUT AS A BOARD MEMBER YOU HAVING CONFIDENTIALITY FOR THE PHONE OR LAPTOP OR IPAD THEY GIVE YOU, I DON'T NEED CONFIDENTIALITY. HERE'S WHAT I'VE LIVED FOR 34 YEARS, WHENEVER I PUT IN PRINT, WHATEVER I SAY ON THE VIDEO I KNOW IT CAN BE PRINTED THE NEXT DAY IN THE NEWS OR FLASHED ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA. THEREFORE I GOVERN MYSELF ON WHAT I DO AND DO NOT SAY. WE HAVE ETHICS PIECES IN PLACE IN THE SUNSHINE LAWS AND THANK YOU FOR THE SUNSHINE LAW. HOWEVER WE HAVE SOMETIMES A BOARD MEMBER THAT DOESN'T FOLLOW THE SUNSHINE LAWS. AND I HAVE BROUGHT THAT UP IN PUBLIC AT A BOARD MEETING. THAT'S WHAT I'M SUPPOSED TO DO. WE ARE ALL BLOCKED FROM BEING ABLE TO SEE WHAT ONE BOARD MEMBER POSTS AND THAT BOARD MEMBER POSTS ON SOCIAL MEDIA ALL THE TIME ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING OR HER OPINION. YOU KNOW IF YOU GIVE YOUR OPINION PRIOR TO A BOARD MEETING YOU'RE ALREADY BREAKING THE LAW BECAUSE YOU'RE TELLING HOW YOU ARE GOING TO VOTE. I NEED SOME GUARDRAILS IN HERE. I NEED TO ENSURE OUR CHILDREN ARE PROTECTED, I NEED TO ENSURE OUR EMPLOYEES ARE PROTECTED. BECAUSE IF SOMEONE HAS AN ISSUE WITH A PRINCIPAL AND ASKED TO SEE PRIVATE INFORMATION ABOUT THE PRINCIPAL. THEY DON'T NEED THAT TO DO THEIR JOB. SO THANK YOU FOR HEARING US TODAY. >>Chair Simon: I DO HAVE ONE MORE, DONNA SPEAKING FOR THE BILL. YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. >> THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. AND MEMBERS, GOOD AFTERNOON. I AM DONNA ROSNER. I AM IN MY SECOND YEAR ON THE VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD AND I IN PARTICULAR AND REPRESENTING MYSELF. I WANT TO THANK SENATORS LEAK AND GATES FOR THIS EXCELLENT BILL. SOME OF THE TESTIMONY HERE HAS BEEN SURPRISINGLY PERSONAL. WHICH WAS NEVER THE INTENT OF THE BILL. MOST OF THE PROVISIONS IN THE BILL HAVE BEEN ASSUMED TO BE LOGICAL AND THERE'S BEEN SOME SURPRISE EXPRESSED THAT WE EVEN NEED A BILL THAT MAKES THESE PROVISIONS. I WILL ABBREVIATE MY COMMENTS BY SAYING THAT ONE EXPERIENCE ON VOLUSIA COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD KIND OF EPITOMIZES EVERYTHING THAT GENERATED THIS BILL THAT WAS THE NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT. IT WAS NEVER BROUGHT TO THE BOARD. IT WAS A DECISION MADE BY THE DISTRICT LEADERSHIP. I LEARNED ABOUT IT FROM OUTSIDE SOURCES. AND I IMMEDIATELY RAISED CONCERNS BECAUSE I'VE SPENT 30 YEARS IN PUBLIC POLICY AND IN LEGAL RESEARCH AND WRITING AND I KNEW THAT CREATING NEW DEFINITIONS FOR CONFIDENTIALITY VIOLATES BOTH THE CONSTITUTION AND FLORIDA STATUTE AND I RAISED THOSE CONCERNS WITH THE BOARD. MY OPINION OF COURSE WAS NOT PROPERLY CREDENTIALED. AND BECAUSE WE SHARE AN ATTORNEY, WITH THE SCHOOL DISTRICT, I HAD TO PAY FOR AN ATTORNEY OUT OF MY OWN POCKET TO COME IN AND OFFER AN ALTERNATIVE LEGAL OPINION. AND THEN I ASKED FOR COPIES OF THE 110 SIGNED NDA'S. AND I WAS CHARGED $76.10 TO RECEIVE THEM EVEN THOUGH I AM A SITTING BOARD MEMBER. SO THE ISSUES THAT ARE EPITOMIZED HERE ARE THE USE OF NDA'S. SHARING BOARD ATTORNEYS AND THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST THAT RESULTS FROM DOING THAT. AND ALSO THE FACT THAT I AS A BOARD MEMBER WAS CHARGED FOR COPIES THAT WERE EMAILED TO ME. THEY WEREN'T EVEN PRINTED. ADDITIONALLY, NOT HAVING ACCESS TO A LINE ITEM BUDGET IS A REAL ISSUE. FLORIDA STATUTE CURRENTLY ONLY REQUIRES SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO PUBLISH THEIR BUDGET IN PLAIN LANGUAGE. SO AS A RESULT WE GET BLOCKS OF SPENDING WITH NARRATIVES. AND AS A RESULT OF HOW THAT PLAYS OUT, OR AS AN EXAMPLE IN OUR BUDGET HEARING I ASKED OUR CFO HOW MUCH WE HAD SPENT ON OUTSIDE LEGAL EXPENSES AND HE COULDN'T TELL ME BECAUSE IT'S LONG DIDN'T TO A CATEGORY OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES. SO WE REALLY NEED TO HAVE ACCESS TO LINE ITEMS IN THE BUDGET. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR HEARING THIS BILL. IT IS EXCELLENT AND I ASKED FOR YOUR HELP AND YOUR SUPPORT. >>Chair Simon: THANK YOU. WE ARE ON TO DEBATE, ANY DEBATE. SENATOR OSGOOD YOU ARE RECOGNIZED IN DEBATE. >>Sen. Osgood: THANK YOU MR. CHAIR. SENATOR I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO AND I'M LISTENING AND IF I WAS IN VOLUSIA COUNTY SOME PEOPLE WOULD BE GETTING FIRED. I DON'T UNDERSTAND BEING A BOARD MEMBER AND CAN'T GET A LINE ITEM BUDGET AND A LOT OF THE OTHER THINGS I HEAR. BUT I'M GROSSLY CONCERNED. AFTER BEING A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER FOR 9 AND A HALF YEARS, PEOPLE ARE NOT HONEST, IT TAKES YOU TWO YEARS TO REALLY UNDERSTAND. AND I'M CONCERNED THIS ATTEMPT TO HELP VOLUSIA COUNTY OR HURTS OTHER SCHOOL DISTRICTS LIKE MINE. AFTER SPENDING 9 AND A HALF YEARS, SOME OF MY CONCERNS ARE WHEN BOARD MEMBERS START SOMETHING LIKE THIS COULD GIVE BOARD MEMBERS, IT COULD OPEN THE DOOR I THINK THAT YOU ARE NOT INTENDING TO OPEN. BOARD MEMBERS SHOULDN'T GO DIRECT STAFF. THEY SHOULD SEEK INFORMATION BUT WHEN I'M READING THROUGH THE BILL IT'S VERY AMBIGUOUS. I DON'T WANT BOARD MEMBERS MANAGING SCHOOLS AND DEPARTMENTS. I DON'T WANT BOARD MEMBERS INTERFERING WITH PERSONNEL DECISIONS. I DON'T WANT BOARD MEMBERS INTERFERING WITH THE DAY-TO-DAY OPERATIONS OF THE SCHOOLS. AND I'M SAYING THAT BECAUSE OUR SUPERINTENDENTS ARE NORMALLY APPOINTED AND HIRED BY THE BOARD. SO WHEN YOU OPEN A DOOR FOR BOARD MEMBERS TO START GETTING INVOLVED WITH ALL THOSE OTHER THINGS, IT'S UNFAIR TO THE SUPERINTENDENT WERE GOING TO COME BACK AND HOLD RESPONSIBLE FOR THOSE OUTCOMES. WHEN A BOARD MEMBER IS TALKING TO STAFF, STAFF A LOT OF TIMES IT'S PRESSURE AND THEY HAVE TO MAKE A DECISION. DO I PLEASE THE BOARD MEMBER OR DO I PLEASE THE SUPERINTENDENT. WHEN IT'S CLEAR THE STAFF IS THE STAFF OF THE SUPERINTENDENT THEY REPORT TO THE SUPERINTENDENT I JUST, WHAT I'M SEEING FOR ME IT MUDDIES IT. I'M THINKING ABOUT IF I AM A BOARD MEMBER AND I'M TALKING TO STAFF ABOUT MY POSITION ON THE BILL. THEN THAT STAFF MEMBER TALKS TO SENATOR CALATAYUD THAT'S ALSO A BOARD MEMBER ABOUT MY POSITION ON THAT BILL, WHERE DOES THAT POSITION WITH THE SUNSHINE? IT'S JUST A LOT OF THINGS GOING THROUGH MY MIND. I UNDERSTAND YOUR ATTEMPT AND WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO BUT THE BILL IS JUST VERY AMBIGUOUS AND FOR ME PERSONALLY THE WAY THAT IT IS I THINK IT WILL HURT MY SCHOOL DISTRICT. WHEN I HEAR VOLUSIA COUNTY, IT'S SOME LEADERSHIP DECISIONS THAT NEED TO BE MADE. IF THE SUPERINTENDENT REPORTS TO THE BOARD THEY COULD BRING AN ITEM TO GET RID OF THE SUPERINTENDENT IF THE SUPERINTENDENT IS NOT DOING ITS JOB. IF I'M A BOARD MEMBER SPEAKING OUT IN PUBLIC ONLY THE CHAIR SPEAKS ON BEHALF OF THE BOARD. I SPEAK IN THE PUBLIC AND REPRESENT MY OPINION WHICH IS SOMETIMES DIFFERENT THAN OTHER PEOPLE ON THE BOARD'S OPINION OR HERE EVEN IN MY CAUCUS BUT THERE ARE A LOT OF DYNAMICS WITHIN SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT HAVE THEM THAT I DON'T WANT TO PERHAPS HELP VOLUSIA AND THEN CAUSED MORE CHAOS AND CORRUPTION IN OTHER SCHOOL DISTRICTS. >>Chair Simon: ANY OTHER DEBATE? SENATOR GAETZ YOU ARE RECOGNIZED IN DEBATE. >>Sen. Gaetz: I JOINED SENATOR LEEK IN SPONSORING THIS BILL NOT BECAUSE I WANTED TO GET IN A FOOD FIGHT IN VOLUSIA COUNTY AND NOT BECAUSE I WANTED TO TRY TO SOLVE A PROBLEM IN VOLUSIA COUNTY IN A WAY THAT WOULD HURT OTHER SCHOOL DISTRICTS. INSTEAD I LOOKED AT SENATOR LEEK'S BILL. AND HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO OFFER COMMENTS TO IT THAT HE CONSIDER. I LOOKED AT HIS BILL FROM THE STANDPOINT OF BEING A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER WHICH I WAS. THE CHAIRMAN OF THE SCHOOL BOARD WHICH I WAS AND AN ELECTED SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS WHICH I WAS. THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS BILL IN MY JUDGMENT WOULD INTERFERE WITH THE SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS BEING ABLE TO OPERATE AS CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR OF THE DISTRICT BUT THERE IS PLENTY IN THIS BILL THAT ENSURES SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS HAVE ACCESS TO THE INFORMATION THEY NEED IN ORDER TO MAKE DECISIONS THAT GOVERN THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. THERE IS NOTHING IN THIS BILL I COULD FIND THAT SAYS BOARD MEMBERS CAN DIRECT EMPLOYEES AND TELL THEM WHAT TO DO. THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS BILL THAT SAYS THAT. THE BILL SAYS SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS CAN GO TO SOMEONE WHO WORKS IN THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND ASK QUESTIONS AND GO TO A SCHOOL PRINCIPAL AND GO TO THE HEAD OF THE ESE DEPARTMENT AND ASK QUESTIONS SO THEY HAVE INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO BE A GOOD GOVERNING MEMBER OF THE SCHOOL BOARD. THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS BILL THAT WOULD ALLOW SCHOOL

Meeting record textEducation Pre-K - 12

Skip to Navigation | Skip to Main Content | Skip to Site Map

FLHouse.gov | Mobile Site

Senate Tracker: Sign Up | Login

Go to Bill:

Session:

2026F

2026E

2026D

2026

2025

2025C

2025B

2025A

2024 Org.

2024

2023C

2023

2023B

2022A

2022 Org.

2022D

2022C

2022

2021B

2021A

2021

2020 Org.

2020

2019 I

2019

2018 Org.

2018

2017A

2017

2016 Org.

2016

2015C

2015B

2015A

2015

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Education Pre-K - 12

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: a00ec4b536157ba3a0e5131d6b1f084b. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record