POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Mar 14, 2023 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Tuesday, March 14, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Mar 14, 2023 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 78,586 characters. The full document is at the source.

Ladies and gentlemen, were going to wait for a few more moments.We are waiting for one more commissioners so no need to hurry, we will be starting probably here at about five minutes. [ CAPTIONER ON STAND BY ] >>All right, thank you everyone. we've got a recording class. I will call the planning commission for March 14, 2023 to order and if we could do a roll call please. >>[ ROLL CALL ] >>Okay, with that will move on to item 2 approval of minutes. >>A motion to approve the minutes as delivered. >>Second >>Okay. We have a motion and a second any further discussion on the minutes? Seeing non, those in favor >>Seeing none, i will move on to announcement items. none from staff ? >>No announcement, okay and is that people practice after all. Onto the next item for planning commission items consent calendar seeing none and 4B public hearing seeing non-will move the strata commission consideration. So does is item 5A which is our general plan updateFor the city to receive a presentation on each of the draft elements then solicit input for member of the public in attendance as well as a planning commission so not being holding a public hearing today but we will be taking comments from the public and also number when we will move attachment and general plan update of the drought parts trails and recreation elements >>Mr. German if I may rephrase few things because this is a little bit difference process. If you will the rest of the elements of the general plan mostly because there is another commission who hold responsibility for viewing parks trails at open space and that is community service advisory commission. I understand that the commission has reviewed this element in detail has recommended thatIt will be adopted as is 100% so this is a little bit different while we certainly will take it the input of the public which is certainly appropriate and Annie constrained is a commissionStaff would not beAnd position as a we move forward with the draft documentsAs it goes public. >>Okay, >>Thank you. >>So, with that will get to the presentation today. >>I am the community project manager with the community service department so, thank you Kent for explaining the CSAC things so I'm going to present at the draft parks trails and recreation elements of the at the general plan starting a little bit about the process to update. So, we heavily involved with the CSAC but we also had a 20 members advisory group so that came from all sort of nonprofit community groups, government, organization facility users, recreational businesses and city staff and we started with the 2000 general plan as a vessel line. So what we did was call we took that general plan and to see of all of this polices our goals were irrelevant and we decided that most of those were so great that does carry that forward and essentially they did a series of updates and modification to those we had for group meetings between January and December 2022 and several staff meeting and reviewers of the some notable inclusions and some background in a few of the key areas and that phrase will go and just kind of discussed like is that general somatic changes, so what we did was so we added larger focus on communityWell-being quality of life focus inclusively and the environment so, we will move on and it hard to follow in a strikethrough underlined version, and a week gave you want but essentially we rate that just reorganized some goals so it had this cascading effect and goals one through six so it's a little confusing so I'll just address the new goals as they are so goal are want as our public awareness and education goals basically about the benefits of parks and recreation and some addition that we may is there where is this policy is listed here as we go through the yellow is essentially most of the changes that we've made and you can see that most of those are kind of for " " word cementing and adding thing said that fit our somatic values and dead the speak community benefits throughPark design and programming so that is most want so goals are to we added a focus on volunteers and community partnership we also added are to G and environmental enhancement to the plan which has been a sound funding source for projects like our properties one restoration project our near pond open space and R2 agent, which also put emphasis on partnership and innovation that is innovative recreation feature in infrastructure and that collaboration was business and other partnership. Go RCT " " our city is a largely the same what a little bit of focus on invasive species in our environmental team there's so, will go for which is our history and culture and Park development goal updates here places new emphasis on collaboration and public art, so we had a goal are 4C which promotes and encourage consultation and partnership our 4D which focuses on education and preservation or enhancement of local art and part design so finding those of future and how we can incorporate them into our part design our discussion of part-time so basically the different type of park and the feature or size of dues the specific parks so it is important to note though that the city has since at least the general plan of the 1970s we had a level of service goal for part so since 2000 wended to any 20 general plan to goals being 10 acres per 1000 our current level of services 6.7970 that's including soccer linesHere? Actually modified via modify the goal itself it was cerebral dented to address access to other facilities and it now includes trails and other recreation amenities within a 1/2 mile walkable likable distance F. So we also added our five which artist it is we didn't add we modified our 501 cities Meadows to increase part acreage and quality and essentially just added a bullet point to encourage developers to dedicate land above the minimum requirements and we have had a few examples of that paying for both the developer and the city in Highland Park and Salt Creek Heights are five and was updated to focus on inclusive " that's inclusivity.Will move on to our six so this is the goal for impact from not new developments so it's a largely carry over but we did a policy our 6C which addresses a park development for us but just really makes this plan consistent away the city's nexus to study. also deleted a policy from this goal which outline credit provisions from private Park development so this is consistent. Also with the nexus the study were those are not contained in the city level of service moving on area seven don't have a slide for that but our seven and our eight are essentially encouraging the county to provide recreational facilities for County residents basically a regional park system that is hauled over from the last general plan our nine this is impacted by parks to I just sent to development, so essentially it's house as a park site affect its neighbor and live the message a few of this to include different the restriction to or charge on what we would do develop a park, so most notably that's our 980 where we added the restriction in color and temperature of liking those will be several totally kind of written out in the master plan departs trails open space as master plan when that comes out anhour and 90 which addresses the necessities parking when use or some type of permitting requirements like site development permit or some other development is neighborhood focused and has plenty of the street parking and we don't believe use is going to do is dictate that it needs a 30 stall parking lot. We will move on, more notes on that so adequate screening for parking was also was put in the " " put in there so that something that we also do need to balance with something that will get to go hours 13, which is our accepted standards that's crime prevention through environmental design so we do have a balance screening with line of sight and natural surveillance goal Ari 10 so adequate funding mechanism for implementation and so really what we have here. This is already here. It was a consider was added instead of established but so consider it as adequate funding mechanism were added goal are 10E say that was to add new and existing parks into landscape maintenance districts where feasible goal or 11 and are 12 to in conjunction with each other because they are essentially citywide and original variant of the same thing which is a regional trail system that you know it's our overreaching trail plan but we want to have so we have a CD version of that and then collaborating with the city and other agencies version of that goal or 11 the citywide version it has most of the subs potential change and that updates here focus on the active verb transportation role that our trails play in addition to recreational role so your Saturday morning walk on the river trail is in the same spot and someone's 925 commuter route on their bicycle so we need to recognize that trail can do both of those things and assign them to that level where it's going to have that dual uses so what we did to also highlight that was we added some bullet points to our 11 a which are some new futures standard. And lastly our stating which is our safety and sustainability goal, so this is more modified goal. The prior or the priority is essentially safety and sustainability whereas it used to be a safety and vandalism. We think that vandalism as a focus is better handled by design and enforcement which is part of the goal because so it's a little different take on debt as like how were going to get there to address that as I said before we used the crime prevention through environmental design standard as sort of a thing is that we want to get in here and implement because so there group emphasized that the importance of this " " of that they accept ahead standard for safer filling parks and we use policy are taking D and E to put that into effect here so the goal focus on using standard set in the design assessing and improving existing facilities using those standards. So for the park users over others a statement " " sustained a sustainability goals also included our 13 G which was to provide buffer zones for fire axis so fire equipment stacking like that our 13 H consider stopping that " establishing landscape and vegetation management program is taking eye which is updating the city is a management ordinance and those are the substantial charges that we made through. >>So I think that we could probably do here and give them some of the elements also have seen more modification and have more speaker requests as well we can go through and ask questions that really just informative questions. We may have on here from that of the public and then we can give some of our feedback and comments but did Mr. mangle if I could just turn the activate that again because it was you mentioned previously >>The recreation element is different. You've given us some direction to staff we have tried to incorporate where we could comment and that you will be and which will be known the public review draft general plan that's going to be attached to the draft environmental impact report probably does summary data elements is a little bit different as I mentioned because you do have a community service advisory commission that isTask explicitly by the city Council to look at parks and recreation policies and standards from staff perspective it would beInappropriate just to ignore it at this stage a standing body appointed by city Council who hasSupported the document as written . So what I suggest is youVery well and the public very well may have issues with certain segment of it we can carry that forwardWhen the Council actually is looking at your recommendation so again when the EIR calms out knowing the public review comes out when we have more public hearings, >>Okay and my only question was because we didn't get that the first time before us that wasn't mentioned to us so we did a very briefly I think we ask of you question gave a couple of comments on the first time. The concern was that the information was incomplete, that's why we want of full documentation which was it still didn't get an still just now which was requested a couple of months and my only concern without why wasn't the case previously but it seems to be now hasAlways been case >>We just didn't think about this particular conversation at the time >>Okay that's all I just want this say for the record because the planning commission >>I would think is that what we have this nothing against the community service advisory commission it's Commissioner of theAt most the respect may have different option and so just want to make sure that doesn't get conveyed if that case did you know were kind of told that beginning. But where is the steering committee for this general plan yet, again don't overriding anybody orOverwriting anybody or ignoring disease act because I've been there I know how it goes to when get ignored as a commissioner so but I think that's fine way just to we go ahead and gain question directly. >>Commissioner Green >>Is specifically in I think RB 11 B or possibly a can you give a little more clarification to that you will use improvements? That would be possible for folks to I mean it's fantastic that the can the rate that such consideration is that Saturday morning walkers and commuters use the same spaces and use it differently. I noticed you mentioned like lighting and I see trailhead improvements, does the will use include expansions? What happens? >>Yes got some of original functions way now so like I bought up the Sacramento River trail there are certain things that are built into trail system that make them not work that way so that could be like excessively, narrow trail or trail that you have to drive so like a recreational loop so things that are well integrated into neighborhoods provides that that opportunity by bicycle commuting so that's really where that's going in that has ability to get where you want to go versus just kind of walk around and still you have to know your recreation experiences but as well-connected it gets over obstacles like creeks that makes it so for youTo get down to them and connects you in no larger. So it's really just about integrating trails into that they can also be part of us. >>Okay got think you >>Commissioner? >>This is just between our four and are firing this section about part planning and development and that's about in school I did didn't see any specific? >>Where you on again? The lease to between four and five? >>Definitely good question so if you look at our 5H that is establish agreements with local skirts essentially that's part of our joint use agreement system so that's what we do now, we try to work in partnership with them to get us access and help you know get them and development process things like that so examples but check oh God they are actively looking at new school campus so we've done some property you know acquisition and sealed to them they will be able to build the school campus with agreement that we are allowed to use their facilities for our recreational program >>Okay, so when we thought you said there's six points 79 I think is that about does that those school joint's facilities count toward that? >>Yes God they can at discounted rate but it has to have the agreement in effect and we only have last time, I checked with city of those and they do count but just because we did get a very small fraction use of the difficult you know of, >>Socha we discount that rate with that 6.79 acres >>Okay, >>And then I'm curious from 2002 2020 or narrow was our original goal? 10 acres. Thousands the >>1970 or so that last one I could find in 2000 >>Okay and so in 2000 yes it was then >>Got it and so that point we've got 6.17 on how visible do we think in this next 20 years? >>It might be to get then well it's always our goal so were going to keep working towards that since the part master plan in 2018 and now we've gone from 6.51 to 86.79*6.79 so were definitely making progress but also populating is going to have an effect so that they DO if you know things like that. It is within our plans to get going up but it's also population of excess population increase. >>Got it. And similarly you know I know a lot of the development ends up being kind of Dia Perry Perry " " perhaps of the city and also some of the older neighborhoods don't necessarily have as much " " Access to park facilities and wondering if there is a goal or policy in here that talks about kind of equitable just distribution of parks and given you know some of these older neighborhoods that currently don't have accented those >>We do have a goal butI've got a have to remind myself which one it is but we do have that really the half-mile metric that were talking about so getting access to park or facility within a half-mile so thatAs the angle are five and that is about participation so it's not 100% visible in every single location to ensure that that something that we have to strive for reallyServe everyone >>You know, Erin I would just add that you know as much as the policies and goals help provide a nice framework you know a lot of this obviously have driven by opportunities that we have and so one of things that I try to do is type have like short-term midterm and long-term view of likely need to be building things now that we need to acquiring things you know10 to 20 year timeframe and then we need to be acquiring things for the 50 to 100 years time frame and so we have some acquisition that we've made sometimes probably I don't know 50 years ago somebody came to me and said hey well, saySSL you this land and and of Cyprus on Church Creek. You know at that time I bought for like 130,000 or something and you know we probably want build in the next 10 years but probably after that it will serve and I sectionOf you know and under " " underserved area now Leica Boulevard the property.the were working on panorama Park that area has been underserved for a long time we have acquired the property about 15 years agoSo, we try to take advantage we have opportunities to bylined even though we want necessary helpThe rest are just as a resource at that time to develop it but when we also took dictation last year south of our church that was open space which is actually incorporated County Latona Road which about some otherRiverfront property that we have there so it is you know weWe it's a blending of both ? >>Sure that make sense. Our fight J I recall this from previous element and recall this storm water detent " " the 10 train basin and I think that's a fantastic idea and I'm just curious if you know consideration was given to any other co-location of parks with other types of facilities >>So there's a school Parkside consideration that the pension basin has you know kind of wasted opportunity to sit there and only hold water so that's why we took at that for a place to infield into a neighborhood with some additional recreation opportunity right now were working on that she seen a rancher with a dog park so we think that could be a successful model other committees we have done there's actually you know part design where the whole part is the tension based in our serve in stormwater capacity so it's really just looking at those other opportunities so that's regrown were able to maximize the use of those spaces >>Commissioner Benner any questions? >>Thank you very much did a presentation that I think what we do now is take some comments from the public and then will bring it back to the Commissioner so let's see first one I have your Mr. James Fink >>Good evening, I promise I'll give my comment short and sweet my name is James's bank and on current chair of the community service advisory community and I'm here tonight to let you know that I believe seaside as well as the astounding staff the steam of the parks and recreation department and the 20 members he dissents focus group representing expertise and held wellness use a sports recreation Lighting natural resources by historic and cultural I can sure all of you that we have done our due diligence. To put forth for your consideration what you believe is a wall taught our flexible responsible plan for the future. A feature that prioritizes smart growth a plan that is proactive not reactive, a plan that the states allowed and proud and we are community that values and takes great pride in our parks in our open spaces got in our trails got in our greenways and in our majestic natural resourcesIn closing I believe this is the right path to go down, when I was working I used to tell my staff This is all the timeline you work and work we are plan and if you do have you get to where you want to go now, I know the general plan of the city every size is much more complicated than that it's extensive it's ask Houston but if we did " " do it right it's well worth it but the heart of this plan, what I believe is the heart of our community is much more simple than that it's providing those spaces where we get our kids out in nature where we get them to appreciate it because if we don't, how do we expect them to every take care of it when they get to be an adult? It's as simple as letting families have a free places to go so they can connect. They get there a lot of distraction out there but this is where families can make memories that it's a simple as having a places for senior citizens where there are less lonely and less isolated where they can stay active in socialIn closing, I think this is where our priorities should be placed. Thank you very much. >>Thank you very much Mr. Fink. Mr. David Leger? >>Hello, my name is David Leger and president of Shasta environmental alliance and I'm also conservation chair of the shots that chapter of the California native Plant Society. And I think CSACI think the you know under section here is there's only one thing that I had an objection to which was in the first part where it talks about maximize and enhance said the recreational potential off their lever while they added economic and that always makes me more nervous because I think you know buildings close to the river and you knowConcrete close to the river and trees coming down so otherwise other than that which isn't on page 12 the very first section I think it's a great plan also want to mention to a friend of mine took his great grandson he takes him there quite a bit to skate Park so why thing whatOf this first time she says I want to stay all night in our ideas. >>Any more comments >>Good afternoon Mr. Chairman, members of the planning commission, public and staff. It's really interesting I met Natalie today who is Dia deputy city attorney and I told her I'd be in this community since 1981 and she looked at me she goes on thatWhen I was born how does that make you feel anyway I am representing several clients here I am from my frame in dais associates on being here since 92 as that " " Diaz associates but as I mentioned earlier I was here in 81Just if you don't if you could please stop my time I just don't understand that Mr.Manual all that you're saying that the planning commission is not going to make recommendation on the entire general plan to the city Council >>No, you must understood or didn't make myself clear will will not without having to go back to the sac right now be making modification to this element but element and the whole general plan will beOut for public review week along with the associated draft environmental impact report in the summer there will be a whole set of public hearing. There will be opportunities of this commissioner to make recommendations on the city Council is the time not only the rest of the elements but also this element and they will hold the public he isDr. cheering like >>Yes >>It's been done in the past okay so thank you for bearing with me.First of all I'm right here I'm representing Chris Curtis and occur because there are several I haven't have the opportunity to go around the street I received a call from Chris last Friday where he had concerned with regarding to the two general plan elements gone now, I recognize that in January he held a public meeting or workshop but unfortunately this latest inter-address induration that we received there was no figures attached to that January staff report and this figure is that we just received last Friday. We really haven't have an opportunity to look at that figure and bend them with the text to find out what the inflammation so that is our concern secondly there is really being inadequate ratification it seems all landowners in the particular private property owner should have been notified those that are effective by the proposed trails and also the main and secondary three beard 30 is related to the waters typically which regarded to the coders family that we work with the department or public works R&D part Marina Road diet in fact we think we have five meetings there was several workshop and to working with public and works on the part their roots planning was involved and was became what we have understanding and the concept with regard to thePedestrian now and bike trails that would affect their particular property. What they show no in figure 2 is 19 and the resembles a weight had an understanding with as a part of the partner in diet there is water crossings there is needs of breach as bridges no staff says that the conceptual but on page 1 it's predisputeThis effect that the " " you need to be referred to the tax map exhibit of the element. So I guess I'm going to come back to you when you talk about the natural resources element to finish my comments unless you allow me to proceed on the point on time >>Were going to give it to 30 minutes right now >>Thank you okay and full disclosure I have business interests with Mr. Catrett so I will not be speaking or commenting on any portion of the comments may be Mr. DIAZ , >>Good afternoon, I'm here representing the KUTCHER'S Andy comment specifically on the diagram. I guess it is to show said that trails I have concerning I understand the idea that it's good to alert the public in advance of where distress are going to be and the idea of being I understand that the owners of that property can be plan ahead as to what how they are going to develop the propertyNow in the diagram the best I know and I have other clients that are interestedIn that no property owner was ever conducted for that so my concern is if the city is going to produce them out " " mapThat shows where all the trends are going to be then what about the property owners? They are going to have if they are going to sell their propertyThey are half going to haveDisclosure the trails as a potential development that has impact on the value of their property so there's an inverse dimension issue with taking issues and secondly,What if property owners going to develop property dateTake a look at that map and what the city is telling them is that you're going to have that trail through your property so you makes it adjustments for that and I'm not sure the city has the right to do that because the adjustment would be that property is going to be dedicated to the city or the city is gonna require it .Disco ScottI don't know howWhat the city'sPolicy on this, butIt's concerning if you're going to have a dedicationThen the product that is property that is being developed and is to make the dedication only has to dedicateIts impact ofDevelopers want to that trail and 19You have or you can get an applicant to give a dedication That exceedsThe demands for thatBut the trail through somebody's property doesn't warrant a dedication to that propertySoca when the city talks about a trail systemThey should give some thoughtAbout how they are going to acquire getAnd in fact whether there has an immediate impact on the value of the property thank you. >>Thank you Mr. Kenny,Make same disclosure as before. SoThat's all the comments from the public?No more blue cards? Okay, so with that I'll take it back to the commission forAny comments at least for the record.Another question, please Commissioner >>Specifically related to open space if and then we have a few identified different partsBut I don't see them called out maybe I just don'tI'm not looking at direct specific name but I don't see them called out in parts inventory and not looking >>YeahSo Park inventor is for five plants so only provesSpaces in open spaces are considered by clan and that's only through their trails or other amenities. >>And so they don't start counting towards ourAcreage percentage until they develop? >>Yeah, it is developed or portion of those parts like there told me that is the trails counts so things that you can actually interact withThe open spaces just for open space is not necessary part of the level of service for the park system >>Okay got thank you >>Frederick on-- Comments? Commissioner Hatch? CommissionerJust for the record again understanding the changes or anything want be made moving forward, butDid at least want to bring up just some of my concern I know will get another opportunity down the road and so just curious just from technical standpoint on the trailThen that the diagram indicated or indicates we have some of this paved and unpaved and then figure 2 that " "(INAUDIBLE) paid from unpaid I'm not seeing and(INAUDIBLE) on the map >>Let me grab them up real quick Landmines in black and white so yes that was just a change that weMade and the actual plan so it sounds like it just made a " " text update >>So we changed the text not the map? >>The change should the tax not the map. Good catch >>Thank you okay, and then let's again just a few comments on my and I do appreciate the historicAnd culture are Resource portionI'm glad to see that I know lots of areas lost " " lose a lot of those historic structure and things we have throughout the cityA lot of times we import developmentMy primaries I think the main that is mine and I know it has been the policy and it has been the policy for some time it's the level of service 10AndyTrying to get within the have an egg or have them all from its residents? I've always felt a bit more strongly about trying to get them in the right location for the necessary just to on amount ofAcreage. I kind of I think it would general I found missing a bit from thisIn the maintenance portion and so if I could as well and I want to speak at this questionDirectly can you just give us a better breakdown of that landscape maintenance district process? I just want curiousWhatsoever got a new parking going start with an LMD and then how that goes forward in terms of Keeping that. >>So subdivision sponsored large neighborhood parks some talking about telling Faisal Creek heightWrite an upcoming she Stena ranch part as part of the entitlement process when we are approving the LMD for the overall subdivision we included a componentFor the neighborhood part and so they paid a proportional share depending on how many other houses in their services area outside of their subdivisionIn their service area so it's a little bit different so Highland Park as an example As a smaller share for the subdivision because there's a lot of other houses apartments and things in their services area so shared that so that goes for white every year day pays thatMoney I think at Salt Creek Heights I think it's 75% of the overall cost ofThe part is by the LMD landscape by the LMD landscape. >>There's a renewal process though correct >>Automatically for use until Ender is it can be protested through about 218 but generally with haven't had that happen >>Okay,And so again my overall concern Just were in general with regards to maintenance we want to make sureThat you knowOr as soon as several itemsHere in time to be had I just resent your spent a close part and different parts Of had to lease out parks had to be built out parks we've had just told number of things and my fear is always we get too much acquisitions too many Parts were not able to maintain them that again I think it's Mr. Frank put it want to make sure this place isThat families can goAnd we have just got into many parts down here.I just want to make sure that our policies reflected of God as well in terms of and I know it was sold as well that were doing this kind of can't currently but made it going required separate approval hearings correct >>Correct when that comes where we do were going to putting together were going to put them and take it on right after the implementation we did fairly Significant update in 2018 but because the sequel was relying in 2000 general plan it was determined that we need to wait until we had our current EIR for this journal plan so we will do updates on going from 2018 to 2023 it's not going toBe that hard but will plan that soon as sequence finished for the EIR >>Okay and again along with the Commissioner hatch did appreciate the part regarding dryness facilities of you know there can move school it's already next door better to use in terms of the calculations and again this is more on Konsyl call but not having all approved open spaces and private parts in that calculation I disagree with if they are being used there is a portion of the population that can use them I do think they should be counted towards that even if it's a ratio although I think it's at least private parts it should be hundred percent certainly there is value in the open space and if we are asking for the open space to we place that value on it take that value should be reflected in our level of service calculation the land also just disagree in terms of what was here? And again know this is a high that is higher-level call but just in terms of our succeed just disagree with the commercial require commercial or development to pay impact fees for doing this over a number of citizens number of acres that number of house numbers of households I think by doing as they are commercial as well for getting way outside their old of trying to hit that particular trying to hit that goal-based up at that as a financial use H a number of people they bought house there they are at the house they counted for in debt free think when they go to shoppingAs well I don't see where somehow they got to place his job there is more need for the part and they can explain the art 90 the parking portion I think that's fine on that and again it was our tendency just ongoing maintenance is an issue if it's an issue in a way of ways of providing services need expire ration prior to any provision and development of this park and recreation facilities know we have innovationThat such innovative ways but normally that Ms. Gen. would ratherHave fun dollars we've got some other methods think in my opinion I would rather have that identified ahead of time and I think the only other I had you covered that on thoseAnd that one was coveredAnd I do believe that's it. There was much specifics on that I mean if you list the CDCity managers ordinance committee if that's a very short Monday night meeting on that here of the late and I know I didn't get any details in terms of how often that would updated general plans not supposed to stop any kind of direction on that or did community service have any directions in terms of what how often they taught that would be >>I think you will see the natural resource Elmo we have similar language do you regular and think about updates it's really is probably because no specific dates but as have bent over while since 1990 when the first is the ordinance was adopted with community comes forth the stop and counsel things are brought upAnd the will started moving >>Okay, very well. Those are my comments. Commissioner Hatch? Commissioner banner? No further comments? Okay,They could all set >>Thank you very much appreciate the presentation thank you very much >>All right with that we will move on identified a attachment B and this is the year general plan updateAttachment B and this is the year general plan update draft natural(INAUDIBLE) >>Good evening commissioners, staff and residents the natural resource element is combination of the conservation and open spaces elements required by the office of planning and research, so what did you are ready? DOS? Is it proposed methods for conserving soil water wildlife and mineral in the community there is an overlap between these two elements, which is why we decided we should combine under one single topic the natural resource element so how we really this sign it is we've taken the requirements of both elements and put them together because it if is so an overlap of a lot of a topic so the requirements of the conservation elements includingWhat are and it's hydraulic for that such force Forest Oil Scott beavers and other water apartments and fisheries wildlife minerals and other resource and the requirements of the open spaces element include open space for natural resource manage production of our resources out of open spaces for outdoor recreation open spaces for public health and safety Military support and tribal resource. The natural resource element combines all the above of the air-quality element which in the current general plan is a standalone and today the first place is going to be on surface and groundwater resource the road topic will cover the goals and oneAnd choose three and not one addresses all erosion and sediment problems resource resulting from development activities the policies address is complying to California jet " of regional water quality words regulation and standards for improving quality of the stormwater and of controlling resource of population to improve and to maintain urban water and of pursuing three of the Mitigation measures when erosion damages discoversSupporting adequate training and educational for erosion and sediment control and grading and working with local regional and federal agencies to reduce the amount of toxic chemical or public " " believe that release into the water system and R2 is about maintaining adequate water supply for the massThat is domestic and fire suppression purposes the policies addresses of all waking upTrends for encouraging that is increasing CDs whether landscape and agriculture uses our protecting quality and quality of service and groundwater resources. The policy under this goal talk about the Whiting impact to groundwater recharge areas working with local regional and tribal agencies to identify and map out what their charge areas and support the recommendation and activities contaminated solid surface areas and periodic review and grading what basin water resources for long-term sustainability so that acceptors that is not just is going biological resources >>Why don't we go through them and again go through our question and just in terms of informative question? Do we have any question on public through in our city and then will come back through for public comments and then our comments seeing none, please continue >>The next section is biological resources we will be covering in number four, five, six and seven and are four addresses the protection and preservation of significant habitats plants and wildlife the policies cover conserving special state spaces encouraging innovative design and site planning for habitat protection providing adequate buffer encouraging education volunteerism and community standard ship encouraging landowners to establish conservationists " " is meant and prioritizing is the a contamination of invasive species management efforts that and preserving click party there said the party and areas vernal pools and wetlands the policies also talk about enhancing is that native vegetation minimizing erosion providing an impact passage avoiding disturbance or disperse the spiral of wildlife and incorporated natural vegetation buffers and riparian areas they are also thought about requiring new development to provide you for an increased auditor setback which is discussed in zoning arguments in our six is about protecting Dia aesthetic and biological value of oak woodlands in other natural vegetation the policies also addresses identifying areas for replacing native threes periodic revenue of the city stream management ordinance and protecting and managing urban forests by maintainingJust increase planting nutrients improving shades canopy and exploring finding for the maintenance of the urban forest protecting me that such habitat link the great dateThat's just enhancing habitat to engage white left court that escorted ours and sensitive habitats graded any spaces Greenway that identified the client that is great general plan discouraging development that could impact such guardians and preventing unlawful uses that could damage the public and private open spaces areas >>Do you have any comments >>No hold on of get going >>Our rate is about representing the stress preserving areas containing excessive the slopes in the hundreds your floodplain open space is the policies that talk about public dedication of flood prone line limiting development in this area passive low impact and establishing private open spaces is meant to where public that that his dedication is not visible in our nine is about protecting and enhancing historical and cultural resource through partnership with appropriate agencies and the local winter tribes to facility exchange traditional ecologicalKnowledge unlike management practice the city of loss will be working on obtaining certified local government status and our tent talks about maintaining current information on status and location of deposits and publishingOf income and compatible development or near critical mineral resource overlay areas and number 11 in richer's carbon emissions through electrification investment in zero carbon technologies and the use of renewable energy resource. The policies cover utilizing California green building code standards in construction promoting electrification other energy resource technologies investing in public electric vehicle charging infrastructure and using integrated resource planning process to establish long-term and major research plan to needs or exceeds the states clean energy Mondays and our 12 talks about promoting the economicVitality of agricultural resource the policies cover providing buffers between development and active agricultural are that minimize impacts encouraging in the development proposed on time to provide community gardens with edible landscape and avoiding fragmentation and conversation of a good could subtly manage lines and higher fireSeverity so as to reduce the risk of the fire community. Any questions? The next action is air quality will be covering goes in on our 13 and 14 cut 13 talks about regional coordination towards the development of consistent and effective approach of the regional air pollution problem the policies addressed at hearing of Dia trust hold adopted by this The County air quality management District when determining air quality impacts on discretionary project encouraging efforts to reduce VMT promote makes use of development and other alternative modes of transportation and referring all projects that involve sanctity of sensitive receptor uses the Shasta County air quality management District for comments and recommendation 14 talks aboutReducing greenhouse gas emission and also develop adoption and implementation of the climate action relicensingOf the dependence bell and establishing a formal internal process for project environmental revenue process >>Okay very well cut any more questions for senior plan or Christian? >>Is just one kind of theThe that I could term of open spaces and support family installation military training routes underlying a space do we have a big problem with that or if there is any we should know about that you know >>That's given by the OPR guidelines >>Okay so >>Actually you know for what it's worth a year or soDid manage to look at their menu first there is a website you can get to see where the trade maneuvers are for the air forces and we were not weeding any of the flight paths here at this day were released for what they showed as >>Okay. Thank you for checking appreciate that Commissioner Hatch? >>Thank you for your presentation >>Wondering if you can talk a little bit about the maps at the end of the element and kind of what we're seeing is there and more specifically you know what extent there incorporated you know there'sSatan like on figure 1 of. For example it talks about these setbacks for me to but threes tributaries in Sacramento River and second tributaries is that part of the general plan or is that zoning code or the other organs? >>There's only argument gives a specific information on the weeds on this but just talk about the corridors that's okay so the wheat with the buffer buffer especially in the disowning okayThey do fall within the 50 foot in the Sacramento River and attributes 25 feet that shows up on the exhibit >>They followed that get that little more explicit about how to convert a back story versus multiple accessory Perry and vegetarian and do sort of how is that? >>That is content like says drip line here?That determines the drip line that replying to the right >>Riparian vegetation has to be map okay because so it's based on map that would be done on looking figure 2 is private open spaces is meant >>And you give a definition of what that Needs? I'm for that is more familiar with conservation easement but that is private open spaces. >>We have a number of development where you have up on top you haveHouse event The lot line extend down into the canyon where is the break in the that is in that 20% slope of out of canyon's private open spaces is man's stipulation under his bed as you can develop if you can fence it you can plant it over time frankly we have particularly well, not maybe before the car fired the fire marshal does get involved more and more open discusses with property owners? What kind of selective vegetation light living up in distorting thing can be done for the protection but basicallyThat's unable >>Okay to but it's under is meant that city enforcement maintain yesWe can enforce it and we have when we get completed of people doing things in the easemen >>Okay, cannot I'm talking about the sensitive have a dead one? >>Yes the VPFS critical habitat that the PTS critical habitat >>It's all that means I mean this was prejudiced by the biologist was putting together the environmental impact report so they did on mapping >>It's a great nice but I don't know what it means.That figure for this are just showing that the bids? How does this relate figure 1? >>Doesn't talk about the bids is just the segment is just what does watershed >>Is okay can then figure 5 which I believe we got the information off.this one has been dear colored that's in the packet is prime farmland and then Orban slip up in the glazing line >>Yes it's from the NRCS >>Okay that's when the energy and I guess what I am so this is just mopping the farm landed in terms of what would be depressed serve or what we want to create buffers from? >>Yes God there are policies that talk about presentation >>Okay of our great doctors agricultural uses then that seems like it that's a part of the inventor be so in the OPA are guidelines, I guess I'm curious it doesn't say that the open space element must contain an inventor be of specified categories of open spaces resource the inventory must include any parcel in one of the listed categories that is coded essentially what essentially unimproved and to designated on any local regional or state open spaces blunt and it gives a government code however weBeyond those mop just want to we just went through how are those other things invented in this? >>There are no state plans that I'm aware of under that definition for open space and of course locally our open space policies of the general plan 20% slope floodplains and mapping would seem to me satisfied that requirement >>Okay, so are you with the a figure number two I think it was that one is like 20% slope but do we have other open spaces that are owned by the city map and the general plan? >>We do haveIt stands the end of Canyons CT own property that was slated as a landfilled at one time and now is a designated open space trust going to be construction those so that the sorts of things might be now that you bring it up might be helpful to add exhibit showing the city is open space aligned both zoned and owned perhaps that I can think of anything beyond that one but as a neighbor probably knows of other but will check that outOkay, Commissioner if I may I don't know if this can be may be put together a nude the CT we have CT on properties and open-space zone areas will be able to in within be in overlay of two? >>Is that what you're referring to >>The middle gentle plan land use map but the zoning map welcome >>Yeah >>If you look at the CD list internally I don't know what's out there externally designate the old plan mapping is that we have available on GIS doesn't a native whether it's a park I think it might have an open space designation as well is it will. And make that mapping more complete >>Yeah and I guess the Commissioner Green pointed earlier that from the last element you know this doesn't necessarily included the open spaces got so maybe having in this section would make more sense to have that map out then just had another question it does talk about having features included and obviously we do that is you don't leave on the coast if we don't leave you know next to the ocean, but given that the Sacramento River is swatting ground for someone I was curious if we should include that as fishery >>The existing general plan has remember if it's exhibit city has a map that " " entitled fisheries and we probably have two double check with the department feature and wildlife it was arrived at in about 1999 in concert with With the Department of Fish and game at the time using either knowledge local knowledge of where fish around so we could see if we can update that you know I don't know how much data they really have but will pursue it >>Okay, thank you and will open it up on the public, seeing none if we will Mr. David LEDGER? >>I just have a few comments here I generally like what does had done but there were few sections that kind of contradict I think the city ordinance and may be sevenEvent state like what their boards one of them is on page 55 and R1D a lot of stuff regarding erosions in crossed out and that it says strive to ensure he day erosion control devices are installed prior to the start of the rainy season and I think that's really that is already a requirement for the planningWould make you know and just they would have to set those up so that would be one thing and then on page 64 it saysSeek to minimize and the destruction ofHabitat Containing a special status as basis and I think it should be just minimize because that's required by seek was to protect special status his business and Fred:you can't do it 100% but rather than strive which is kind of a big word. I think it should be minimizedThe other thing was in goal on page 65 gold and are six--NR6Let's see if I'm not repeating myself kind of the same special protect specialist let's say it's a crossed out protect specials that discuss business plant and animal and just say strive to preserve and protect greatCorridors riparian areas vernal pools and wetlands and vernal pools have to be protected long the prime areas but otherwise those are just my comments on that thank you very much >>Okay, thank you very much Mr. ledger and with that next item is an inner DEUS >>Again in ourDSD's associate representing the goose's family a couple of points to make out first of all how do the water resources? I in odd streams and so forth that tributary secondary tributaries conflict with proposed rail system I think that needs to be that just identified what is the impact of the riverfront specific plan were $1.2 million is being spent do we have the trail that is still what gun the dog or what's going on here with the general plan update building with natural resources and also parts trails and open spaces we haven't had the opportunity to review the natural resources element. I don't think you have either people.our focus group and so forth the majority of our one nonprofits and governmental agencies and so forth they had the opportunity to review them we in the private sector have not that opportunity my clients and their representative also haven't had that opportunity and also property owners that we know I need to note that we are more than willing to work with the parks and recreation department public works and blinding as we did with the part Marina Road diet we reach an understandingIt was a true partnership throughout the D document everybody talks about partnership and there is reference here to the Sacramento River trail. The turtle Bay area explore that just exploration park in the Sunday Elbridge and the Caldwell Caldwell Junior bike parked three of those are Macon " Macon L project and we think MacDonell for their contribution for the community but it should be nice to have some private partnership. I know that you have private partnership with JeB Allen and also note that was behind those partnership there was and give and take both sides enter they came to that through theses are more than willing to work with the diesese department but we haven't had the opportunity nobody switch out and it's until that game I had that all set in were sayingOh my God what's happening? This is not like thePrevious general plan update where directed by people representing various segment to the community 30 they ended up that general plan committee and there was a win-win situation and you know potential litigation do you wantQ terseness to anything their property since given? What is proposed sent a very clear signal to the trust and we would like to get a read that signal and work with the city in the various department to come up with a true win-win partnership thank you! >>Thank you,The itinerate my disclosure, next item Mr. Tiger Michaels? >>Good evening, my name is Tiger Michael's I represent I am a party that is property owner and I also represent several property owners within the city ofREDDING.The are not private to any of this information on the general plan change I had an opportunity today finally to look at several of the documents especially Dem apps because I didn't have time 30 every time excuse me but the terminology and some of the maps and the acronyms they are impossible to understand the map overlay sometimes the overlay goes to The north to south to east to west they don't really match maps 5251, 100 to 104 all of this I have a question we all have questions about will like to have the opportunity.I like to have the opportunity again toWith you to understand what's going on.Specially that I think it's not want for probably 105 all of them and say that thank you very much >>Thank you Mr. Michaels any further comments from the public weUnder mental being bring it back to the commission for comments. Commissioner Greene? >>This specifically calls out in a goal of on are to maintain adequate water supplies for domestic and fire Suppression soup " As per proposed and then as we go through in our two there is a very little as I cease some you know what her efficiency drought tolerantPlanting but I see every little mention of fire utilization is that not? Are there not fire suppression purposes in here or am INot seeing them? Or is that indication just to be thought about plantings? >>45 suppression purposes to be a ready address is somethingIn the health and safety element so, we have spoken about the slopes and hillside so, this is the rest of it and this is already something that we have,In our day-to-day " " data and it is accessible so we don't really think there'sTo be and a water storage I believe that said the comment that you brought up in the last element so I don't think there is a necessity at the bringing up water storage in any other areas which is to way is not as in a policy on my concern >>Here was done the art to immediately is talking about on the heating like requiring additional allocation of water rights and so I'm just wondering if that's where the fire suppression? >>Yes the elements. Thank you onNR8, can you give expedition of what the low inaccuracies of the other food planner that is placed 20% slopes areas would be I know those are areas are really protective and so what I'm not understanding what the low impact this would be taken about recreation trails and inks like that >>Okay and then every 10th it's look like they're just were 13 holdover in their. I'm not sure those all be in our tent or in I was taking? Looks like just a numbering. >>Commissioner Green, would you mind clarifying that comment for staff? I think were not following you on that it's a numbering or a type of issue packet >>I go it13 scratch out to be in our 10 strikeout Lucia strikeout worship >>There's or it should be a clean version after the strike underlined it shows the elements so it's a bit difficult to follow district underlined >>So that school Empire and over 30 in section >>So with the current element it was another 13 N really moved a couple goals be combined them and all that so many little resources is nowR10 is not an undertaking and an undertaking is air-quality so if you see the declaration you'll understand it was a >>It is really difficult to follow when you're striking out will section and then moving them elsewhere it's complicated.. >>So give us one moment, >>Commissioner green are you on packet page 71?Is that when your comment originated from where we've struck 13 and added 10 but the remaining policies and am looking at? >>I'm looking at both the district and the new version and what package are you? >>Page 97 on the clean version is on air quality. >>The staff can look into the freighter if sort of typo graphical number issue >>Will go through that's all I was going out I just was 13 and now then I understand that what still 30 doesn't match from one to the other >>Okay got think you buy >>Will take note and then to sometimes to be graded strike outline and have a new version old and compared to strike on a diversion and sometimes be confusing will look into that >>You should pretty good to know your figures 556, we get to 12, 13, 11 >>Yeah. >>Thank you. Commissioner Hatch? >>All right that we receive some public comment via email it looks like one from Mary and I'm wondering every MacPhee writer and wondering if you could speak did you have any chance to look at that one by chance? >>No I didn't >>Okay, she makes some good points here and more most specifically about you know how is climate changes and considered in this part of the element and I know that there is some that are some things that and about greenhouse gas emission and that sort of thing but I was hoping that maybe you can look into that and add be curious on your comments? >>Forgiveness:I think with this game in late last night so we haven't >>Okay Gagliano problem so many comments and looking andR4 I can to fill some kind of this Mr. lecturer point about strengthening specifically and four may be we don't use tribes when we say conserve all spaces similar toNR4B you know we trying to minimize said the destruction of habitat but at like to try to is strengthen those in some ways that it would be you know is still allowable within the general plan contacts and then specifically andNR4F I really would like to dimension allies this a bit and consider retaining city owned properties that contain environmentally sens

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Mar 14, 2023 4:00 PM - Redding Planning Commission - Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9f366e597a332a29c0824c38b3f42be4. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record