POLISCOPE

The public record

PINELLAS COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners Work Session/Agenda Briefing 4-2-26 · Transcript

Thursday, April 2, 2026 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Board of County Commissioners Work Session/Agenda Briefing 4-2-26 — Transcript

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

YouTube captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed May 31, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 198,341 stored characters

Heat. Heat. Baby Lou. St. It's time. Everything is It's time. Wonderful. Take it. It's a Let's do everything. We're going to go ahead and get started. Staff, just uh bring your conversations. down. Thank you. I know we don't always get a chance to get together, so we play catchup, but it's good to have everybody here this morning. Um, want to welcome the Phillies uh organization who are here today. Good to have you in the room. Uh, I know we'll be having a 10-minute uh presentation. Um, if there are specific questions from the board on the presentation, um, they can ask, uh, Brian at that point. uh and then we'll we'll kind of go into some open discussion and any questions about things from that point will be towards uh towards staff. Um so without further ado, we got a really busy schedule today. Uh really important exciting topics to to discuss and I look forward to that uh um exchange of thoughts and ideas um today. With that said, Brianst Jr. come on up. and um good to hear from you this morning. Welcome. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's a it's a great honor and privilege to be here today uh representing the Philadelphia Phillies who have been intrinsically intertwined in the fabric of our community for nearly 80 years. Uh as you all know well, uh the Phillies have the second longest spring training relationship with the city of Clearwater uh in Major League Baseball history. Uh we're only one year behind Lakeland and the Detroit Tigers. Uh so we're we're doing pretty good in terms of being a trends setter and uh and leading the charge for uh local commitment to spring training uh and that really that sister city, sister community relationship uh with the city of brotherly love. Uh as you know, the Phillies exude excellence throughout their entire organization. Whether it's here in Clearwater in Penllis County, in Philadelphia, or anywhere in between where they have a footprint, they are the longest continuously operating single name, single location team in the history of Major League Baseball. They are the epitome of stability, founded in 1883. Uh again, they've exuded excellence as an organization that entire time. Uh they are the largest media market in the United States with only one major league baseball team and they're the fourth largest media market uh in the country. Uh as you know, their fans are committed and they're committed to Clearwater and they're committed to Penllis County. We received the uh updated statistics for the 2026 spring training season. We had an attendance a paid attendance of 143,000 352 which is consistent with how we have performed every year over the last 25 years uh of our relationship at Bayare Ballpark which as you know is the current home uh of the Phillies organization in Clearwater. The Phillies led uh the Grapefruit League in percentage of paid attendance. We had 106% capacity. So percentage of paid capacity. Uh and we also had the highest single attended game uh in the grapefruit league uh this year. Uh so this is a relationship that has been nurtured for generations from yourselves uh from your predecessors uh and it will continue with the renewal of their lease which expires in 2028 uh for an additional 20 years until 2047 which will have kept the Phillies continuously operating in Penllis County for 100 years. Uh and I'm very very hopeful that I can make it to see that day uh because that will be a very very special day. But you are laying the groundwork uh to continue that proven success and that commitment and that dedication to nurturing that very special relationship with not just the Phillies organization but with the entire Philadelphia community that entire you know multi-state area whether it's Pennsylvania, Delaware, New Jersey, Maryland. Uh they're committed to us and we're committed to them. Uh the uh these are some statistics on the historical funding. uh the ask today uh you can see in the second uh part of the slide. Uh either way, whatever direction you provide today, uh the total commitment from the county in the entire 80-year history will add up to less than $und00 million. As you know, the city of Clearwater uh commissioned an economic impact study which analyzed historic data over the last 20 years. So not speculative data but actual economic data and found that the Phillies have an economic impact of about $80 million per year going forward on a going forward basis over the next 20 years based on that historic data. So that is a $1.6 billion minimum economic impact over the next 20 years based on the historic performance of this asset and of this relationship. So essentially whatever funding level of TDC funding, tourist development dollars that you commit today will be recouped in the first year of the the renewed lease uh in 2028 2029. This is the marketing assets as you know um the Phillies provide significant marketing assets to visit St. Pete Clearwater. Uh that total was about 587,650 uh recently. In 2021, that contractual obligation to provide those assets ceased, but the Phillies continued to do it anyway because it was the right thing to do and because it's mutually beneficial for the Phillies to encourage and to continue to encourage the promotion of Visit St. Pete Clearwater. They work very closely with Mr. LOAC and your and your consultants on uh updating those assets, making sure those assets are uh oriented to the things that you want to promote and that we want to uh to uh to demonstrate uh to the market about visit St. Pete Clearwater and you you're very familiar with those assets and you've seen a lot of those assets in your one-on-one meetings and you've also seen them in practice when you visited Philadelphia. Um, you've seen uh the folks who come here for the Phillies and their recognition of everything we have to offer as a community and their deep appreciation for everything we have to offer as a community. That's why you have thousands of people who get second homes here, who retire here from that market. That's also why it's no coincidence that Philadelphia is the number one feeder market in hotel revenue for Penllis County. This is a slide that was presented to the TDC I believe uh last month or maybe February. Uh and you can see there Philadelphia doubles the revenue from any other major market except New York City and it's still about a quarter more revenue from Philadelphia than from New York City. So even though it's the fourth largest market in the United States, uh it's still the number one market by far for Penllis County. And that's not that's simply not a coincidence. just shows that that that seed that was planted in 1947 has grown into uh this incredibly incredibly beneficial relationship. I want to make it very clear for the public and you all know this well the money that you're talking about today is tourism development dollars that come from tourists overnight stays as a tax on tourism. It is not advorum property tax dollars. Not one penny of Advalor property tax dollars is coming from Penelis County uh to this project and nor did it uh in 2004. That that figure that you saw before was all TDT money. Not one penny is going to the Philadelphia Phillies. This is going to the city of Clearwater for their asset to renov to uh renovate uh and bring up uh to date through 2047 this uh this asset for an A+ tenant, the Philadelphia Phillies. So, this is all part of the lease renewal with the city of Clearwater. I also want to make it clear, not one piece of public property is being transferred or conveyed to the Phillies. The Phillies actually invested in the southern portion of that shopping center uh to the tune of two $22.5 million, which is a key activity center corner under the US 19 plan to activate that corner as a mixeduse development consistent with the US 19 plan. So, not only will the the uh continuity, the renewal of this relationship benefit from a tourism perspective, but it will also benefit from an activation and revitalization perspective for this key activity center corner on Drew Street in US19 for the city of Clearwater. And we hope will act as a catalyst to redevelop other portions of that key activity center corner as well. You will not be able to read this, but it is available in your packets. Uh this is the uh aerial site plan and every uh box that you see there is tied to a key project component that is part of the term sheet that we've been negotiating with uh administrator Burton and city manager Pouyet and your teams. Uh each one of these uh a aspects of the project is laid out in a detailed narrative and also has a specific budget. Uh so you will be able to see that when we get to the term sheet. Some of the fan amenities that you can see here are the video board replacement, replacing the field lights, larger concourse, upgrade to the west plaza, expand and enhanced concessions, entirely new fan seating, uh center field fan deck, which I'll show you uh in a minute, retail store expansion, which I know is very important to some folks because it is very difficult to get into that store uh during spring training. Uh there are long long lines to get into that store. center field restrooms uh and new service to the burm, the diamond dugout restrooms upgrades uh and enclosing first base club area and the suite hallway addition to the south and west fan servicing elevators. Uh refresh suite interiors and home plate concessions and upgrade grounds crew area wayfinding signage. So I've got some aerials here. Uh this is the aerial looking at the left field corner on the third baseline. You can see that the playground and the picnic area has been expanded and moved actually uh to the east of the concessions and uh the Frenchie's uh tiki bar. That Frenchie's tiki bar is staying put, but it is going to be expanded. Uh so it's going to increase its footprint and increase its access. That picnic area and uh playground area will also allow for greater ingress egress. As you know, that area gets uh congested during the spring training games. We're adding concessions there to the left where the current playground is uh and also um some uh additional fan amenities in that area. This is the batter's eye which you know exists today. But what we're going to do is we're going to put outfield restrooms on the bottom floor behind it. And then we're going to put a fan amenity area above it which will be a really unique feature and will really activate that batter's eye which right now is kind of dead space unless you're trying to hit a fast ball. Um so that will be another innovative fan amenity that we are providing uh as part of this project. Uh this slide is looking from carpenters complex. On the left you can see that playground area and that picnic area. Uh and then uh behind that uh that facade would be the concession area. Um and then this is a image of the player development area and expanded administrative area. Um that concludes my presentation. I want to thank uh express my deep sincere gratitude to uh administrator Burton, city manager Pouyet, uh all of you, county commissioners, uh Don Crowwell, uh Mayor Recctor, all of the city council members because you all have been actively involved in um and understanding and participating in nurturing this relationship uh and and really being involved as leaders uh to ensure that this relationship will continue u for decades. decades to come through the 100th anniversary uh of the team here in the city of Clearwater. So, that concludes our presentation. I very much appreciate your consideration and um looking forward to getting some direction on the TDT portion of the funding so we can finalize the term sheet here with Mr. Burton and city manager Porier and your teams. Thank you, >> Brian. Thank you. Um before we go to staff's going to have a small presentation as well. Before we do that, does anybody have any questions on the presentation uh that Brian um just gave us? Yes, Vince. >> Thank you, chair. Um >> Brian, you said um that the contract ended, but Philly continued to like keep paying that advertisement or something. What was that amount? >> Yeah, so the Phillies um were contractually obligated under the original uh funding agreement to pay to provide uh roughly $587,000 in uh marketing assets to promote visit St. Pete Clearwater. that ended in 2021, but we continued to do it and continue to do it. Um, and we won't have a contractual obligation to do it even with this deal until 2028 because the current deal doesn't expire until 2028. So, we're going to continue to do that for, you know, 7 years. And that value as of today is $650,000. Um, so today we're providing that value for free and we're continuing to work directly with Mr. Lowak and his team in a very collaborative way. Uh, and I I've, you know, I think you've seen the commercials and stuff. They're really They're really well done. They're very, very good. And that comes from the expertise of your local team in what we really want to promote to the Philadelphia market. >> Thank you. >> Any other questions? What's the dollar breakdown uh on the fan enjoyment piece versus the, you know, uh facilities? Just give me a rough idea like of the >> It's about half >> about half half going for fan enjoyment, half correct for development of facilities. Yes, sir. >> Uh, nonrelated to the fan experience. >> Correct. >> Um, do you have a question? >> Yeah, Commissioner. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I noticed, uh, this year I went to a game or two and noticed that there were some improvements already, uh, like a scoreboard that wasn't there last year. um did the uh team pay for that and how much improvements uh costwise uh have been made already to the stadium and who paid for it? >> Yes, Commissioner. Thank thank you for that question. That's an excellent question and the answer is yes. So again, showing the excellence exuded by the Phillies and their commitment and their partnership with this community. The Phillies have already started this project uh even without having a lease renewal. So, we've put in about $49 million uh in in already into this project. So, this project has already completed phase one. It's ongoing. Um and you've seen the Burm structural improvement, which was something that was a structural engineering thing that needed to be done, but that Burm is incredibly popular. It's very accessible. It's not an expensive ticket even for spring training. Uh people love that area. Uh Fourth of July, it is just an excellent excellent area. Um and uh you've seen the scoreboard, you've seen the batter's eye. Um so a significant number of things have already started and the Phillies have fronted all of those costs with, you know, no reimbursement or anything like that. Um the uh the other thing that we need to remember too is that the stadium did flood from Alligator Creek uh after uh Hurricane Milton uh from the rain and that did cause about seven or eight million in damage and the Phillies have fronted those costs as well. though obviously there'll be insurance claims and things like that but the Phillies went ahead and took care of all that so that they were spring training ready for 2025 which they were and that spring training was of course a huge success as as they all are. So yes thank you sir. Yeah, the uh just looking back on on on the last two years as the storm the memories of the storm fade, people are still working to get their places fixed up. And I just really wanted to publicly thank the the organization for how they stepped up the month after the storms because again, people were doing, you know, we were all kind of scrambling trying to figure out what next. um and they were at the ready and and came to the assistance to some degree with our residents and I I think that's I think that's notable. And so just to your comment on that, >> Mr. Chair, if I could just on that note, the Phillies did donate a million dollars to the Amplify Clearwater uh hope recovery fund which was matched and that went directly to local businesses and homeowners who could not afford their repairs. So, and again, that had nothing to do with this. It was just the right thing to do and Mr. Middleton himself came down, you know, to present that check uh to Amplify, which again just shows um you know, what a great great partner they have been. >> Talks about the community and how important that is as well. So, thank you for sir. I'm not I'm not seeing any other questions. >> No, you there's a couple. >> I'm sorry, Commissioner Pet >> and Commissioner Flowers, too. >> Goodness. >> Yeah, go ahead. >> Um so, and I know I talked to you and I talked to the Phillies back when I was chairman, so it's long time ago now. um about when we invest with TDT dollars that we should look at in particularly North County um how those investments can be made as an asset during emergency management. And since you brought up the storm, I wanted to bring that up because it's my understanding you're making changes that could then um make that an asset to Clearwater and or the county um where utility staff that don't have a safe place to be if we get 20 inches of rain could possibly be there and could quickly be executed into the community once the storm passes. Could you talk about that? because you didn't talk about that and you're really like the first ones that have if you if we give this um you would be the first ones that are following up on that kind of a commitment to provide an extra asset to the community during emergency management. >> Commissioner, again, thank you so much for that question and also for your leadership on that issue. We know that that has been something that's been incredibly important for you to have that resiliency and that emergency operations ability uh for uh for response. And so this southwest building, I don't know if you all can see it. Um I'm got my pointer here for the commissioners on the rear screen. This southwest building is is designed to house uh emergency response whether it's linemen whether whoever it needs to be uh during a hurricane and is being built uh and with with resiliency and redundancy in mind particularly from the lessons that we learned over here from the flooding over here uh after hurricane Milton. And this uh the stadium itself is already uh obligated to be a staging area for the city and is utilized I believe by Duke and others for staging now and that will obviously continue. But the ability to actually physically house uh people and to keep them safe and uh electricity and fed while they're out there doing that hard hard work of uh of hurricane recovery will certainly be something that we provide. >> So thank you. Thank you. I really appreciate it because North County is short on assets. We're currently building a shelter and we just don't have that many assets up there uh in North County. So, this this is a true community benefit in a whole another way. >> So, thank you. >> Thank you, Commissioner Peters. Commissioner Flowers, >> thank you. Um for earlier discussions, Barry, I don't know if you remember this. Um, one of the things that was presented to us was um the space where the players actually go where they're fed or whatever um um during or after practice and whatnot and that they needed some support or desired some support in that area to kind of enhance it. I didn't see that in the presentation. Did I miss that? >> You can cover it. >> Yeah. U so mad madam commissioner, thank you again for that. That is part of what we're doing, but um we've already kind of accommodated that with a it's not really a temporary structure. It's it's really like an industrial grade. They call it a tent, but it's it's very permanent. It can be moved, but it requires almost like a military level of engineering to move it. Um, but that is part of the of the project is the player development aspect just like the Blue Jays had. And you know, the Blue Jays were in the World Series. Uh, and part of that starts here in in Deneden. It it starts here in Deneden. It really does. Um, so those things are all required by Major League Baseball to retain spring training teams. Um there's certain requirements that have to be met and we're do we're meeting those requirements as part of this agreement and that will again allow Major League Baseball to allow the team to remain here uh for the next 20 years. So yes, thank you. That is part of it and part of that has already been completed but uh there will be some additional parts of that and that's really this area here. Uh so from this part this part of this building is offices and then you'll have some training and player development and cafeteria here and then obviously this entire area which is currently existing as carpenter complex is getting an upgrade and this will be specifically a new baseball lab for the player development in that in that respect. >> Thank you ma'am. >> Commissioner Scott. >> Uh thank you Mr. Chairman and thank you very much Brian. Good to see you this morning. Um, Commissioner Flowers partially answer asked my question. U, but of the $49 million affiliates have already spent. Um, is any of that on required MLB upgrades? >> Yes. And that would be the batter's eye for example. Um, and there were some other things >> the lower level, right? >> About how much? Any idea? I'm looking for help from the uh from the manager. About $10 million. >> Is any of that um money that's already been spent envisioned to be for the Phillies to reimburse themselves from the from the public ask? >> It's a credit. It's it's a credit towards the 75 million that the Phillies are committing to put in. So, of the 75 million they're committed to put in, they've put in 49. Okay. Approximately 49. >> Thank you, Mr. >> Any other questions? >> Okay. Thank you, Brian. >> Thank you. >> Morning commissioners. Um, so in rebuttal, no, actually, you know, this has been this has been a very, um, uh, collaborative process. It really has been between the city, uh, between the Phillies and and the county. And, you know, everything that Brian uh, just uh, just presented, you know, we agree with. The reason we're here is because the Phillies do um, travel well and and it is an economic engine not just for Clearwater, but for all of Penelis County. what we've provided you is some comps and you know and and we've had these conversations individually u but we really needed you needed to have this and discuss it as a board there's many different thoughts individually as I've talked to uh talked to each of you and the Phillies have met with you but you need to collaborate as a board and give direction to staff to where we can finish the term sheet uh there are several key provisions that based upon the discussion today will enable us to go forward and do that what I've what I put up here as you can see pick a facility ility around the country and each one of them has a different flavor and each one has a different commitment not just in terms of capital outlays uh but then in who's operating the facility and the cost associated with that the capex um so we've put um some of the slides up there that that you can use for your deliberation but what we really wanted to get to and I asked Brian to come up is because of the impact that it has um as Brian previously shown for the economic impact what's being requested um from the Phillies was $80 million from tourism development tax as he stated. Uh the the there is a state grant of 20 million that'll be paid back a million a year. So the net present value is about 15 million. Um and again the team uh committing to 75 million of which 49 million's already been spent. But they've also um as part of the agreement will assume any cost overruns associated with the project. That's very um uh that's significant and and needed because as you look at stadiums around the country, not many have come in under budget. They've typically come in over budget. So we did our own analysis and confirmed um the uh estimates of the team using an uh one of our outside estimating firms. Um, so but as you can see, and you can certainly ask Brian any any questions, but you know, you can see it's not just the visitors that come during spring training. It's visitors that come year round because this becomes a destination part of their home. Um, and we we do receive a significant um impact uh economically from uh our Philadelphia partners. uh the investment of tourism tax will be not just for uh in the in the the form of that but we'll get a return through the marketing piece and the marketing benefits. Again, all of this has been presented. You can read that at your leisure. Um but the what we need, you know, direction from today is they've asked for $80 million. How much of that are you willing to commit? Um, we've also asked uh for a marketing term as as they said it was it used to be 500 and some odd thousand dollars. We've asked for 850,000 in annual marketing assets, but we've also asked for a 3% escalator to where the marketing dollars 20 years from now um are are based upon the market cost at that time. Um, and so we we have also requested that to be part of the term sheet and those are be happy to answer any questions. Brian's here with me. Um, but you've heard this before. And so with that, >> that ends our presentation. >> Thank you. Um, any questions for staff before we kind of get into our >> I had some questions. >> Go ahead, Commissioner Shear. >> Uh, yeah. Uh, Brian, the, um, you have in here the 380,000 total visitors from Philadelphia. How long do they usually stay for? >> Uh, two to three days, four days. >> I don't have a good answer for that, Commissioner. Um, if if you give me some more time, I I may drill down to it, but I don't have one for you right now. >> I I just I was looking at some of these numbers, and they they look very low to me. Uh, $300 million in annual e economic impact divided by four nights or divided by the number of visitors, it's like $789 that a person would spend on their trip here. I don't know how they would do that in three nights. I'm just It just seems very low. I $780 is like $197 a night. That's That's extremely low. I I would think to people if if people were just spending a,000 I'm just trying to my numbers are right. If people spent $1,000 while they were here on hotel rooms, tips for their valet, the beer, 12-pack for the room, they're going to be well over a thousand bucks in four days. You know, that's what I'm seeing. I I just I think at least $1,000 that would be $380 million in impact. If they spend $1,200, you know, you're talking $475 million. Those that $380,000 number is huge. So, I just thought that was low because I really commissioner. >> Anyway, um I wanted to ask you on the the Brian for I mean uh Barry for the uh TDC dollars. What do we have on hand in in cash and what are we projecting in the next year? I mean, we're going to have to write a big check. I don't know what the >> have those figures available. We we have sufficient cash in reserves to be able to cover this using cash. We don't need to bond it. Um and and that is even with the um look after doing the beach nourishment. >> Yeah. I mean we can go through this in in detail but looking at all all of the projects you know even after we drill down pay for the uh the cost of the um uh beach nourishment and everything we still have sufficient reserves. >> Okay. I was just trying to get a handle on what we'd have left after the this year and next year if we we fund this in 27, right? >> Well, no, it would be actually paid out over a couple of years. Um part So, this is going to be an a non-binding term sheet. Okay. Uh the term sheet will generally outline uh the project. We will come back to you with definitive documents later after they complete the design, but they don't want to go forward with their detailed design unless they have a commitment. Um, and so part of that would be on the constructibility review and what type of phasing they're going to do for building do the renovations. And so you'd probably do it over two years. >> Okay. >> So we' they'd have one one year and and another draw the second year. We're going to set that through a construction funds trust agreement that then we'll we'll handle all of the dollars so they'll be appropriately distributed based upon project outcomes. >> Okay. All right. I'm good. Thank you, >> Mr. Flowers. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, total total cost for the project, total total cost, the team's money, our money, city of Clearwater money, total cost for the project, >> 205 million is the estimate. Um the and again, the the city council hasn't discussed that yet. So, that's what they're but that's a general um what they're looking at >> based on what they're asking of from us. What is your recommendation that we >> Well, I didn't put a recommendation in probably one of the first times I haven't and that's that's kind of the the reason that we we did the presentation the way we did and and the reason for that is because you've you all have had direct discussions on this and and there's many different thoughts amongst you. So, I wanted to hear the debate today. What the teams requested is 80. Um obviously I'm your administrator so I negotiate, right? um you know and always want you know the best deal possible but um but that really is a policy call and how much how much you choose to put forward in the project both on terms of the that and what you want out from marketing. >> The reason I'm asking is because if the team is doing 75 million um the request from us is 80 and then I believe up on the screen I saw the 20 million from the state. It only gets us to $175 million of a $25 million project. Am I missing a number other than the city of Clear Water? >> Well, that's the final number is the city of Clear Water and they have they're going to take that up at a future city council meeting. >> Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. >> So, estimated at 205 and anything above 205 uh is on the on the Phillies. >> Correct. >> Uh Commissioner L. Well, depending upon the how much you provide. >> Understand? >> But whatever whatever we provide will be capped. >> Okay. >> Same way with the city. >> Commissioner. >> Uh thank you, Mr. Chair. That uh pretty much uh answered my question. My question was going to be what was their total ask from uh in terms of public dollars between the county and um the city. Uh, I have heard that it was 115. Um, but then I guess you add in the state dollars. Um, which also goes to the city, correct? >> It does. It comes in. So, the city's going to have to front that um, and then get paid back a million dollars a year. So, you know, so it's $20 million. Net present value is about 15 million. >> Okay. And then net present value is real. So it's amazing. >> It is right price of money. >> Yeah. Um and so uh again I think one of the things that we're going to talk about is the the escalator. Um and I you know just from my perspective um one of the things that uh gave me heartburn on a previous deal that we were working on was the amount of advalorum tax dollars that the county or the city uh residents of a particular city south of here was going to have to pay. So that bothered me that it was so high that um we we had we were significant contributors to that deal. So for me just from the deal that I'm you know that I'm looking at um less adorum tax dollars are good in my mind for the residents of Clearwater which are also residents of our of our of our county. So it's not just city versus county. >> Um so from my perspective you know I'd like to see a little bit more flexibility there but at the same time I'd like to see the Philly step up on the 3% escalator and maybe from a lower starting point than 850. Maybe it's a 650 750 number, but see that regular escalator because the value that we're seeing, we just talked about, you know, that 15 million versus 20 million. It's real. And so, if we don't get any escalator going out, the value that we're getting is not the same. So, but I would appreciate maybe a a lower starting point than the 850 for the escalator. Maybe it's more like six because we weren't they weren't required to do that for the last several years in my mind. Some compromise on that starting point makes some sense and then the escalator also makes some sense and it's their piece of the pie that we're we're getting from them while we're maybe doing a little bit more on the ad valorum excuse me on our contribution versus the city of Clearwater. Just a general thought that's I just wanted to throw it out there for not for you. That's that's that's the reason we're here is to get that type of board direction. >> So dialogue our presentation and sit down and you can >> Yeah. So I think questions are are done on the on the presentation. Did you have a Okay. Go ahead, Commissioner Scott. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. >> Um so Brian, on the $850,000 uh annual marketing ask that was how how do you feel about that? Because didn't we start the conversation higher than that? Yeah, I I uh we feel strong with that 850,000 uh annual um marketing contribution so long as it has that 3% escalator in there. Um and I think the 850 is, you know, in discussions with the teams. Um they they feel the 850 is a good number. It's just that escalator where um we may disagree. >> Thank you. Any other questions? Uh for I mean they're not going anywhere. So if we in our in our discussions and dialogue if we want to ask them any questions of course we can do that. Um I'd like to have all the questions directed at Barry and and Brian. Okay. Thank you. Appreciate it. >> Okay. Um, so again, I think in an effort to kind of give that direction uh not only to staff uh to finish out our side of it, but also to the affiliates, the city of Clearwater, I think it's incumbent upon us to maybe provide some of that direction today. It's not that we have to, but I think it's healthy for us to do that. Um, and so I told you kind of just some general thoughts on my from my perspective. I think less property tax dollars is good. we're having visitors pay more. I think that's a good thing. Um and um we have a a good partner at the table. Um I think having an escalator on the on the on the advertising makes total sense to me. Uh I think maybe starting a little different spot. I mean, I understand Brian's comment on that, but again, we've we've been doing pretty good the last four or five years where it wasn't ab actually required. Um, so maybe a lower starting point, 3% escalator. Um, maybe 85 million on the on the TDC money. Um, and that would bring Clearwater in closer to 30 million at least the way I'm doing numbers and maybe my maths off, but I'm also talking 15 million on the state. It's not 20, it's 15 today's numbers. So, um, just kick it around. So, any thoughts from the commission? any um yes, Commissioner Law. >> Thank you, Mr. Chair. As the uh other single member commissioner who represents Clearwater, I wholeheartedly agree with you that the less uh tax burden we can give to the residents of Clearwater um and put it on our tourists, the better. Um and uh using our uh bed tax dollars uh for this project. Um I agree with and so I support the um doing a 85 and if the math is correct uh 85 from the county and 30 from the city. Um and so I support that. Uh as for the escalator I you know whatever the board wants to do I'm fine with. >> Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Chair Commission. >> As I said, I I think the economic benefits are greater than they're they're outlined here. >> Yeah. >> Um also, uh on on the on the um advertising when I first started evaluating this over a year ago, I I saw the advertising dollars. I was like, "Wow, that's a benefit that people weren't talking about." And I did ask uh Brian Lowak to try and get more, and he did. uh and and moving up to 850 is a big number to move and I was really happy to see that and then the escalator on top of that's great and I understand what you're saying about coming in lower and then adding getting the uh accelerator in there the CPI or whatever they're using but I don't like to take money off the table so I I like that 850 I'd rather but you know I that's just my idea just leave it I I'm pretty happy with the deal that they've negotiated because it's a big increase and it does have an escalator after 29 2029. So uh also on the dollars itself any chance we get to use the TDT TDC dollars in lie of uh property tax money I think just helps our affordability uh problem in Penelis County. And so I'm I'm I'm for using more TDC dollars than than is proposed. So 85 might be the the number, but um I'm I'm in favor of that. So, and then uh just uh the other benefits, you know, I I toured the we have the emergency quarters coming up, which is great. I mean, I think that great, the emergency facilities, and you know, I did a lot of I toured the facilities a couple times and looked at the plans and I I'm I'm comfortable with the cost of the project as a whole. So, that's where I am on it. >> Thank you, Commissioner. Commissioner Scott. >> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh 100% agree um with Commissioner Shear on the 850 number. I don't think we should back off of that at all and I think we need to make sure that we get that 3% escalator in there as well. Um I absolutely believe in the in the Phillies partnership and that the county needs to be at the table and part of these discussions. It's just at what level that I'm comfortable with the I want to do this in a way that honors the partnership with Phillies but also respects the the taxpayers whoever those taxpayers are wherever the money is coming from whether the TDC whether it's the city or whether it's the state because I don't believe that a state local or federal taxpayer are three different are three different people so when this conversation started we were at 40 million and now we're at 80 and and maybe 80 85 million and and I was on board as this escalated up until about we got north of 65 million because then I started looking at the numbers and what's the breakdown between public and private money and that's where I'm a little challenged with this because I always believe that something like this that public dollars should be the last dollars in and that's the way that we approach any type of grants that we do whether it's employment sites program whether that's capital funding, whether that's elite funding, whatever it is, we're always the cherry on the top. We're not the base. We're not the base of the cake. So, what's being proposed right now has with the county in at at 80 and the city at 35 and the state at 15, that is 63.4% public money and 36.6% private money. That's that's a challenge for me. I I always feel that we should be last dollars in or at least pretty darn close to 50/50 because that's where we were with with the raise. Now, if you put a credit back into that for the value that we're going to get, assuming it's 3% adjusted for Visit St. Pete Clearwater over 22 years, and that comes into just under 25 million in advertising value, that's still 58.4% 4% public and 41.6% private. So, I'm I'm still I'm still just I'm just challenged with that. I'm just, you know, just bringing this up and I just kind of want to want to talk through this. So, I started kind of looking for some some objective criteria of how do you value a spring a spring training game? And you know what we did last year with our capital funding projects for TDC is TDC made made a recommendation and then we all got lobbied like crazy for you know this group should have more money. We think this group should have more money over here and we asked Brian and his team to come back go back and come up with a with a different more objective process based on measurable metrics that takes emotion and politics out of it as much as could be possible. So, we approved a new set of standards for capital funding. In our meeting last what, two weeks ago, we approved new criteria for elite funding as well, elite event funding. So, that got me thinking about looking at a spring training game as an elite event. And if we looked at a spring training game that way, how would we fund that? And we've got five categories for for elite event funding. top is is $250,000 and there's only two events to get that and that's the Firestone Grand Prix in Valpar that takes place over over multiple days and you got to have 40,000 attendees for that 40% of them need to be tourists you got to have 500,000 broadcast views etc etc and that's up to 250,000 so a spring training game you know wouldn't qualify for that um and they got a category three and it's 15,000 attendees a spring training committee would almost qualify for that, but that's up to 75,000. Well, then criteria number two is 40,000 attendees, which a spring training game doesn't meet, but 250,000 broadcast views, which it does. So, I just took that number of up to $150,000. And if we applied $150,000 to every spring training game over 20 over 20 years, okay, that's 16 games a year, let's say, that's 312 games. That comes up to $48 million. which is not too far from where this conversation started and a number that I was very comfortable with. If you inflation adjust that number at 3% a year, it comes up to basically $65 million which is a number that I was also comfortable with. And if we applied that number 65 million to this and gave the credit to visit St. P Clearwater $25 million in advertising. That gets a split of 50.1% on the public side and 49.9% on the private side. That's the number that I'm that I'm comfortable with. We get north of that and then I'm not quite so comfortable with that. So, I just want to kind of put that out there just for thought. Thank you. Anybody else? Thank you, chair. Um, yeah, I mean, I'm I'm supportive of a less burden on the Advararm, you know, property taxpayer. Um, and so, I mean, without really knowing, you know, how much actual cash, you know, we have on hand if we're very flush, I mean, you know, why stop at 85? Maybe go to 90 um in support of not having a burden on resident taxpayers, put it more of a burden on the tourists. Um, so I would be 100% in favor of, you know, 90 million any anything we can do to reduce the tax burden on local residents. Um, you know, you know, as Commissioner Shear said, as you know, you said, chair, I mean, I think that's, you know, what we should be exploring. And you know, in terms of the escalator, you know, I would be okay with an escalator if we start at the point where we credit $3 million that they've already paid over the last, you know, four or five years that they weren't required to pay. Um, I mean, which would probably be like 20 plus years of them not having to pay the escalator, uh, because they've already paid, you know, almost $3 million that they weren't required to pay. Um, so I'd be, you know, in favor of an escalator once they're credited, the 3 million that they weren't required to pay but have been paying. Um, so, so I'm in favor, you know, whether it's 85, 90, anything we can do to reduce the the burden for the adworm taxpayer, I'm in favor of. Um, and then in terms of the raise deal, I mean, I was under the impression that it was a third from the city, a third from the county, and a third from the team, not a 5050 split. Barry, do you know? Um, >> it was it was a 50/50 split. Um well roughly um that the team took on anything above the 50% which it it escalated while we were in negotiations but it was 50/50 us and the city and 50% team. >> Okay. Um but then they took on all capex. >> So similar like capex like with this cost overruns in this deal. >> That's correct. They took on off cost overruns and that is the same with the Philly deal. And then what was the con marketing contributing from the raise? How much were they? >> Brian, do you remember? I I I I really He's We have a We have a marketing agreement with them, but I I really don't recall off the top of my head. I I I don't know the answer to that. >> Okay. Well, >> yeah. So, I mean, I'm in favor. I mean, I would be in favor of going up to 90 to take the taxpayer burden off the table. So if we're if we're flush with a lot of cash um you know I don't know why we wouldn't put more of the burden on tourists versus the taxpayers especially you know we're facing any possible you know things from the state you know with reducing property taxes I think it's more incumbent to put the burden on tourists than our local residents so that's where I stand chair thank you >> anybody else Okay. >> Y >> um since we're talking about my least favorite subject, I wanted to chime in. On the raise deal, weren't they getting land a land deal separate? That wasn't part of um what St. Pete was contributing as well as infrastructure improvements that were like 125 million from the city. uh taxpayers. The land deal by itself was in the hundreds of millions of dollars. The >> development deal. >> Yeah, the development deal. So that I mean it wasn't exactly a 50-50 split. Um I mean it in all honesty if it was just, you know, 300 million from the city and 300 million from the county, which that wasn't really truthful because we had to bond it. So after we bonded it, it was close to a billion. So to say that it was just a 50-50 split, I don't think is completely accurate. Um on paper it was a 50-50 split, but once you dig deeper, um you know, I would say that it wasn't so much. That's why I opposed um the raise deal. And I opposed it for the same reasons that uh Chair Edgars did was because the residents of St. Pete were getting hosed uh especially on their advorum uh taxes. and other fees. >> Thank you. Um any other thoughts? Um, you know, just in having the conversation today, we have it looks like we have four at least four that have spoken in favor of of more more TDT dollars than the 80 million that's on the table um in deference to our advorum taxpayers of Clearwater. Um, I'm not saying that that's where we're going to finish. I'm just saying that's kind of what I'm just the numbers. One of the one of the four suggested 90 um and three were uh suggesting the 85 million. Um I think everybody seems to be on board with an escalator. Um couple of us talked about the some some kind of recognition of the like the last four or five years. Uh you talked about a credit I talked about maybe a a little uh lower starting point. Uh the escalator is real and I think it's really important for us. Um and I think it's it makes the value of of that package um well stand on its own. it's really what we should do. Um so I think maybe that starting point is little um in flux. Uh we had a couple of people that talked about that. We talked about it specifically. Uh you were a little bit open on it. Um and Commissioner Shear, you were okay with the with that number. >> I'm happy with the advertising numbers the way they are. >> The way they are now. >> I'd rather not start taking money off. >> Start 850 in 2028. That's what we're talking about, right? Yeah. >> 850 in 2028. >> Yeah. >> Um and so that I mean I I think we're a little bit all over the board on the on the escalator piece, just just differences here. Um but I I I think we're kind of moving in the direction of well, at least four of us moving in the direction of of more TDT dollars. Um >> Mr. Chair, >> yes. >> Um you can add me to that. That's comfortable with more TDT dollars. >> More TDT dollars. So, we have five more TDT dollars. Um, a couple uh still kind of mulling things around. I'm not not going to put words in the mouth. Commissioner Scott, you spoke uh to your point. Um and um can we give any more thought and just again just pause for a minute, take a deep breath. Uh if we're not prepared to today, that's that's okay. But uh can we talk a little bit more to the the advertising? I think I'd like to hear more a little bit more from staff about the advertising since 2021 when they were not required to do it. What we've been collecting since then, what we are supposed to be collecting from now till the start of the new contract in 2028. So we can just see what that number is. Um and then and then the the deal on the table starting at 850 in 2028 with escalator. So maybe we could just do that summary. >> So you know I as I asked Brian to come up on that because you know he can really speak to that but let me just start by saying that that's jointly beneficial right they're they're marketing their team and and they're marketing you know themsel and and obviously it promotes our market. Okay. So it's it's jointly beneficial to that. But Brian speak speak to that and how do you got to your recommendation? Yeah. Uh, if you're asking me to do math up here, that's a that's a bad question. Um, so, um, when the last agreement expired, uh, last payment was made in 2021. Um, after that ended, the Phillies continued to provide those, uh, marketing deliverables. Um, so we, uh, up to this point, an additional three years of those at the 650. the the latest um value on those assets was about 650,000 um annually. So for three years that was provided. Um what we talked about moving forward was continuing that uh and starting that advertising. Uh we've worked very closely with the Phillies team um to already produce um what we would use for 2026 uh assets. And the thought process on how we structured this um is that every year we wanted to leave it open and broad because every year um assets are going to change, opportunities are going to change, the way we market to people change. So we meet every year annually, talk about what worked, what do we want to what do we want to do differently, are you are the Phillies willing to do something that maybe we we haven't thought of yet. And so that's why we did it the way that we that we did. And I think we came um to that number. One of the things that that we we wanted we don't have is a billboard uh in the outfield wall and they simply don't have the the real estate for those. Um you can only you can only have so many billboards in the wall and right now those are all taken up. Those are multi-year deals. So that just wasn't an option. And so, uh, when we thought about where we, uh, what what we wanted to get in advertising value, um, that considereration was made and that 850 is where we came to. >> 850 is where you came to for what year? I'm just for the starting point in 2028. >> The starting point in 2026, what we proposed was that it would start in 2026. >> Okay. So, what we've been getting those is the 650 value. three the three the previous three years. Um we did not Yes, that was >> what you're saying is if they built the green monster out there, we'd have room to put a sign up. >> I don't know the MLB rules. I'm kidding. >> And you know and commissioner, >> we need more real estate is what I was getting at. >> Just understand that was a compromised amount. Okay. They started higher. They they wanted 1.1 million. Okay. Right. And and and so that was a that that was a modified amount and was negotiated and and agreed upon. the 850. >> The 850 >> for 2026. >> Correct. >> But escalator was not discussed in part of that. >> No, the escalator was discussed. The Phillies disagree with that with the escalator. Um we don't it has >> what you agreed on was the 850. >> Correct. >> Not nothing beyond that. >> Nothing beyond that. And just so just to put it in dollars and cents. Okay. Over the 20-year period, that's about a $5 million. >> No, it's a big number. Yeah. That's why that's why my thought about backing off the 850 to start makes some sense because with that escalator you really get caught you catch up pretty dog on quickly at least in value. That that was my only my only thought on it. >> This negotiation's not going very well up here. >> No, I'm I we've been at this for a while, guys. >> Well, we haven't. >> I know. >> So, we're we're we're kind of coming into it right now. So, >> but the wrong way. >> Well, that's your thought. Um, any any other thoughts on on >> Yeah, just just one final thought. I just wanted to be clear on my comments earlier. I'm not questioning at all the value of the partnership with the Phillies. It's just it's just for me it's the value of the spend and the the the split between public and private dollars. I absolutely agree that TDC dollars are better spent than Advil tax dollars, but I think what really makes this deal better for me is more private dollars, just not more public dollars. So, I just wanted to be really clear on that on that point. And I also think that, you know, the public is wary of big subsidies for professional sports teams. And in an environment that we have right now with affordability, it, you know, the t the timing of this isn't good. timing of it is probably never good, but you know, with $5 gallon gas prices and the affordability problems that we've been having, it's just the optics of it are not good. So, that's all. Thank you. >> Any other closing thoughts? Um, well, it sounds to me like um at least you have some direction on 85 million, Barry. Uh, it seems like we have four four of us have four of us have said 85, one of us said 90. Um, >> what's that? >> I would support 85, too, obviously. >> No, no, I understand. I just wanted to Yeah, there there's five of us that would support the 85. >> 85. >> What about on the escalator for the >> I think the escalator we're seem to be. >> Chair, I just want to be clear. I'm I'm good on the 85 if it's a equal reduction to the >> amount that Clearwater has to kick in. >> Correct. >> It would the I don't want an extra five floating around. Yeah, it would be >> that the city would re >> right. I just want to be clear. It's got to be >> what's it I mean not >> it would come off the city side, not on not off the Philly side. >> Yeah. So, no, I I I totally agree. Um and I think the escalator is something that we all feel pretty strongly about and it sounds to me like we the idea of starting with the 850 >> in 2028 >> with the escalator seems to have some legs here. I'm not I I'm not quite sure how to point to it. I mean, I'm not saying everybody. >> Well, I'll put it in the term sheet and if you you mean if you want to start the escalator in 28 and uh and have the base amount in 26, um that's that's a compromise. I mean, um I'll bring that back to authorities. I'll bring it back in the term sheet, we'll we'll have that back to you in a few weeks and you can make the decision. You're >> talking about having a base of to 650 for three years and then starting Oh, starting at 850 in 26. Absolutely. >> Which we Okay. Yeah. Okay, that's >> compromise. >> I know. Well, well, what's the compromise? >> I mean I mean I know how we got to where we I got, but I'm saying where are you compromising now? >> On the 28. Start in the escalator in 28. >> Oh, starting the escalator. Okay, that's what I wanted to hear. Okay. >> Okay. Very good. >> Um I'm not I'm not hearing push back on that. So that's kind of where we're going to land at this point. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. in our Thank you. And in our um effort to um move our facilities to Alton and Alt 19, there are a number of facilities here, a number of pieces of land here in downtown Clearwater that um would be made available uh to sell. And um and so here we're going to talk a little bit about the disposition of those properties. We're also going to talk about um taking a pause in April to get more resident input. I just just for the record, we did do a city of Clearwater did do a Clearwater visioning session not too long ago. When I say that, I'm thinking a couple years ago, but I don't know exactly when where they got apparently lots of input from the public about how that plan stacks up. So, I'd like to maybe hear a little bit about that. Um, and we're so we're going to talk a little bit about that aspect as well. talk to our our folks from CBRE about the process that we're going through and some other additional thoughts that they may have on this. So, with that, I'll turn it over to Blaine to get us kicked off here. >> Thank you, Chair. Good morning, commissioners, staff, public. Uh, we have a team from CBRE here led by Leanne Karst, and I'll let her introduce them. >> Thank you, Blaine. Lean Course. I lead our um southeast region government practice and with me here today, last time I was here, Barry said it's just Leanne. So, uh I brought the rest of the team up today and uh we have Kelly Mouth. Uh Kelly is a Panelis County resident and so she's here in our local Tampa office. Uh Roman Dari is next to her. He's also a part of our government practice specializing in economic development and large-scale redevelopment projects. and Robert Shaw, who many of you already uh most of you already know. He is the owner's representative for our government campus. >> Thank you, Leanne. Thank you all for being here. Uh so, I'd like to start the presentation uh talking about the goals. Uh if we could advance that slide. Oh, >> okay. Okay. Thank you. So, Chair Edgars alluded to this in his introductory remarks, but um they are separate projects, but we have the new campus that is really driving this in in a number of ways. One is that the new campus down in Merton at the Icott site will be the space in which a lot of our employees um 1100 to be exact to that will be moving there and we'll be vacating these spaces in downtown Clearwater. Uh we have determined or CBRE has determined in the past that we will avoid taxpayers will avoid um $150 million of maintenance expenses over the next 50 years if we were to stay here. So there's some there's some fertile ground there for us to to make that move with the downtown Clearwater the sale of the properties. Uh I think from the beginning it was always hoped that there would be uh a significant amount of revenue generated to help offset the cost of that new campus and thereby decrease the burden on the taxpayers to for the resulting debt service. So in doing so and partnering with CBRE who is uh done this very same process in many different cities um we wanted to not be overly prescriptive in soliciting developers to come in here make sure that it make makes sense financially and for them to bring some creative ideas about how to redevelop downtown. Um and these goals that you have up here aren't necessarily in order of priority. We hope to accomplish all of these, but I start with that one because that's where we started with the new campus. And we have talked to u elected officials, we've talked to staff, we've talked to folks in the public, and we have heard hopes and concerns about this project. And one thing that those hopes and concerns have in common is that downtown Clearwater be activated, that there would be activity down there. uh taking cues from the Clearwater 2045 plan that uh Chair Edgars referenced and elected officials that there be a mixed use uh people living downtown, businesses, office space, uh connecting to existing assets that the city of Clearwater have invested in. Uh and so in all of that that there be some activation of downtown. So that is one of the goals of this process. In order to activate it, in order to asssure there's accountability that the deal be structured such that when the commission is presented with uh these visions and you select one to for us to negotiate with that what is ultimately negotiated is actually built and not just built but activated. So, so this is all this is all this all comes together in these goals and then from the beginning you know in the hopes that taking these government properties which aren't uh on the tax roles and putting uh private uh uses there that there would be some additional tax monies um raised in the near term of course mostly in the CRA and the CRA wears off in 2034. So t

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners Work Session/Agenda Briefing 4-2-26 — Transcript

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 9def51cbf1133f3acdf3c4967a4f8396. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record