POLISCOPE

The public record

BURBANKUNIFIED (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech published

11.10.20 Special Meeting - Board of Education

Tuesday, November 10, 2020 · School board meeting record

The 30-second read

Summary pending

Meeting-wide summary not available

No meeting-wide AI summary is available yet. The item-by-item board record below uses the published agenda materials.

Why it matters

The board digest below separates planned business from source-backed outcomes.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

Official minutes publish outcomes and identify speakers and the topics they addressed.

People and votes

Commissioner format. She

1 statement

  1. Statement

    Commented on novels in the English curriculum and shared concerns regarding process.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

109 ADOPTED MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION BURBANK UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT November 10, 2020 Virtual (Online) Meeting Burbank, California MEMBERS PRESENT: Armond Aghakhanian Steve Frintner Charlene Tabet Steve Ferguson Roberta Reynolds Also present were Matt Hill, Superintendent; Sharon Cuseo, Assistant Superintendentt, Instructional Services; Debbie Kukta, Assistant Superintendent, Administrative Services; John Paramo, Assistant Superintendent, Educational Services; and Sarah Niemann, Assistant Superintendent, Human Resources. 1. CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by President Aghakhanian. Board Clerk Charlene Tabet, led the Pledge of Allegiance. 2. REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD 2.a Public Communications Anna LeMaster, teacher and English Department Co-Chair, was allowed to join the meeting via a Zoom format. She commented on novels in the English curriculum and shared concerns regarding process misinformation and transparency and asked that the District work on three key areas, policy, practice, and accountability because removing books from the curriculum was not the answer. Paul NcNiff, teacher and department Co-Chair, was called to join the meeting via a Zoom format. He is a member of the DEI Committee who reviewed the novels in question and shared his concerns regarding the removal process. He felt that the original complaint should have been addressed by the specific school to avoid such actions. He urged the Board and staff to follow Board Policy, revise the Committee procedures, and before making a decision think about the message being sent to students, staff, and the community. Dina Harney, teacher and ASB Advisor, was allowed to join the meeting via a Zoom format. She also commented regarding the novels and echoed the issues raised by her colleagues. She shared her concerns regarding the process and her feelings working in the Committee and the hardship of trying to follow a bias process. She asked that the decision be placed on hold until a replacement list is reviewed and a clear plan and directive on how to teach and address these problematic issues in the classroom with or without these books. 2.b Staff Responses

Board of Education Special Meeting – November 10, 2020 110 Superintendent Hill thanked the teachers for their comments and thanked them for teaching District students. He also thanked them for being a part of the Committee and provided an update regarding the book process. A complaint was received regarding the five books in question. He followed Board Policy; however, he decided to form a Committee to get as many perspectives and feedback as possible instead of making his own decision. He is aware of the emotional views shared by parents and staff, but it was important to allow different views. He will receive the Committee’s report by November 13. He will then review the petitions and Board Policy. A decision will then be made within two-weeks. He greatly appreciated the comment and the suggestions. 2.c Board Members' Comments and Responses Member Reynolds thanked the teachers for their thoughtful comments, for all the work in the Committee, and for dealing with this complicated issue. President Aghakhanian also thanked all the teachers for their comments. 3. STUDY SESSION 3.a Discussion on Employee Equity Focus Groups Matt Hill, Superintendent, facilitated a discussion with the Board of Education regarding employee equity focus groups. Focus Group Report Burbank September 2020_111020 (OF 28, 468) Superintendent Hill reported that BTA Executive Director Nathan Banditelli and BTA President Diana Abasta had entered into a partnership to address diversity, equity, and inclusion regarding the culture and structure of the District and to increase its capacity to be more diverse, equitable, and inclusive in its policies and practices. California Teachers Association (CTA) Consultant Gail Watts was introduced. She then reviewed the Focus Group Report with the Board and the major categories, which included Equity and Excellence, Culture and Relationships Among Employees, Social Justice, and Community. These perceptions will be explored individually and systemically. Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) are three prongs of a social justice lens. The report recommends that an employee and student committee is formed to create Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion definitions. This Committee would also need an outside analysis of the organizational structure. If the Committee then wishes to move towards anti-racism, the committee would need to utilize the racial transitional assessment tool. She also reviewed the DEI specific recommendations for each area and asked the Board for feedback. 3.b Board and Staff Comments Vice President Frintner asked if the words phrases in the categories were the most commonly used. Ms. Watts noted that these were most of the word used as the goal was not to interpret the responses. The report recommends that an employee and student committee is formed to create Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion definitions. This committee would also need an outside analysis of the organizational structure. If the Committee then wishes to move towards anti-racism, the committee would need to utilize the racial transitional assessment tool. Other recommendations were made in core areas in Diversity, Equity and Inclusion. The phrase Equity and Excellence needs to be redefined to include all aspects of the community and Focus Groups for parents and students to hear their perspectives and experiences and to look at the hiring practices. Vice President Frintner said that he appreciated the report’s overview. He felt that it was a good idea to include students in the discussion, as many passionate students would be able to do a great job. He noted that this is the reason why practices are being looked at and that the hiring process must be reviewed.

Board of Education Special Meeting – November 10, 2020 111 Member Ferguson noted that the information was well received and helpful. There were many complicated factors when trying to form such committees, but it is the best way to have a discussion. The feedback was welcomed so that the Board can monitor the situation. Ms. Watts noted that similar challenges are taking place in other District's and that the concepts were not unique. President Aghakhanian asked for clarification regarding the issues of treatment between the high schools. Ms. Watts explained that one school seems to have a large Armenian population and the way they are perceived differently. Vice President Frintner felt that the LGBTQ Community statement was concerning since diversity and inclusion clubs are in place and felt that an effort has been made to make staff and students more welcoming and that the comment was not realistic. Member Ferguson agreed and noted that there's still more work to be done. Diana Abasta noted that the clubs at the high school are helpful; however, the issue needs to trickle down, including starting at the elementary level. Member Reynolds felt fortunate to be able to talk about these issues; however, it doesn't mean that other groups may not be as open to these conversations. Clerk Tabet asked for an example regarding introverts and extroverts as leaders at the high schools. Ms. Watts explained that certain students who exhibit certain behaviors, such as well spoken and outgoing are those who will overachieve; thus, participating in thigs that other students may not have the opportunity to do. President Aghakhanian asked about the recommendation for purposeful structures to include the Armenian and Black communities. Ms. Watts noted that normally students in marginalized groups tend to go through a lot of effort in deciding if this is something they want to pursue. Foundational concepts such as bias, privilege, power, de-colonization, socialization must be a huge part of establishing a DEI lens. Vice President Frintner noted that there was a great amount of information in the report and asked about the next steps and how to move forward. Ms. Watts said that the recommendation to create an employee group that can internally begin to explore these concepts, build on the concepts and then consider a process to educate their peers which is workable for Burbank. President Aghakhanian asked if the data was unique. Ms. Watts explained that Burbank was not unique and she has not found a district in California were significant changes have been made. Burbank does have a few advantages by working collaborately with the Board, staff, and the employee unions. Clerk Tabet asked if the current DEI Committee included employees. Superintendent Hill noted that the Committee included employees, parents, students and reported that a recent meeting was held with union leaders to discuss the possibility of creating smaller groups and then share with a larger group. He likes the option to also include parent and student feedback along the way. Ms. Watts reported that this report included a total of 34 employees and a few Board Members. Member Ferguson thanked Gail Watts for her report. He asked that Superintendent Hill bring back the recommendations and how it is intended to work to be able to move forward. President Aghakhanian asked what would be the one recommendation to move forward. Ms. Watt said that it would be to implement an employee group to begin to develop a lens and to consider a process to view their work and role, which is critical and then look at the organizational assessment tool and the Human Resources concepts, which will provide a road map. Different assessment models are available and will depend on what the Committee select.

Board of Education Special Meeting – November 10, 2020 112 Superintendent Hill thanked the BASA, CSEA, and BTA leadership for the collaboration on such important issue. BASA President Oscar Macias noted that during the meeting Consultant Gail Watts had said that such conversations would create discomfort and that discomfort is the empathies for growth which is also discomfort. He felt that this was an important moment for the District. He was proud to be a part of this, to be included, and to represent school administrators. Diana Abasta said that she was pressed for time and she wished to discuss a timeline, as she knew that staff were ready to take on the challenge. Superintendent Hill said that he would like to create the employee Committee, as it was the first recommendation. He would like to work with each of the union representatives to select a Committee of 10-15 people to begin the work and agreed that the work should begin sooner than later. Clerk Tabet felt that this is going to be a long-term project, as it calls for changing people’s behaviors and cultures and it cannot be rushed through. She would like to see how the Task Force is coming along to not overlap the work. Change is hard and she does not want to rush it. Member Ferguson felt that a road map is important. We need to get moving, but want to make sure that finding time to do the training, better in person and how to facilitate in a remote environment. He asked that staff go through it now and decide if it feasible during the year and/or to better plan. President Aghakhanian noted that currently Committees such as the Task Force, JET, and PTA have been established and now we are trying to create another committee and he wants to make sure that these four groups are not working on similar issues. Ms. Watts said that it was important for all groups to work together and overlapping may be different for each group. The task for the new Committee would be to develop the DEI lens. CSEA President Joseph Louis Ayala agreed that unity is good to come up with the solutions because CSEA want to see the changes. He agreed that it must be done and he was glad to be able to work as a team to find real solutions. Superintendent Hill said that the Committee had highlighted five immediate next steps and that he will bring it back for the December 17 meeting, but in the meantime the new employee committee should get started with the work, including the organizational assessment and he will come back with a more detailed plan. 4. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 8:36 p.m. MINUTES APPROVED: ______________________________________ MATTHEW HILL, SUPERINTENDENT SECRETARY OF THE BOARD 12/17/2020 ________________ DATE _____________________________________ CHARLENE TABET, CLERK

Any individual with a disability who requires reasonable accommodation to participate in a Board meeting may request assistance by contacting the Superintendent’s Office at (818) 729-4422. BURBANK UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION SPECIAL MEETING Tuesday, November 10, 2020 7:00 p.m. - Public Session Virtual Meeting - Burbank, California Disclaimer: Please note that the Burbank Public Libraries (as listed below) are currently closed. Due to the Coronavirus Pandemic Social Distancing Guidelines, please continue to view the online agenda at www.burbankusd.org. AGENDA The entire agenda packet is available for review online at www.burbankusd.org; at the District Office Building, Superintendent's Office, 1900 W. Olive Ave., Burbank, 91506; and at the Reference Desk in all Burbank City Libraries at: 110 N. Glenoaks, Burbank, 91502; 300 N. Buena Vista, Burbank, 91505; and 3323 W. Victory Blvd., Burbank, 91505. 1. CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 1.a NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Closed Session will be held by teleconference to discuss matters on the Closed Session agenda, at 6:00 p.m. The teleconference (6:00 p.m.) and online meeting (7:00 p.m.) is held pursuant to Executive Order N-29-20 issued by California Governor Gavin Newsom, which suspends certain requirements of the Ralph M. Brown Act. Balancing the health risks associated with the Coronavirus (COVID-19), while appreciating the public’s right to conduct the people’s business in a transparent and open manner, during the current State of Emergency and in the interest of public health and safety, most-and possibly all of the Board Members will be participating by teleconference. District facilities are closed to the public until further notice and the public will not be able to physically attend the Board of Education meeting. The Board will reconvene in Public Session at 7:00 p.m. The District is providing alternatives to in-person attendance for viewing and participating. Any individual or group representative may address the Board of Education on any agenda item or subject within its jurisdiction. The meeting will be streamed by visiting the District's website Board of Education page at https://www.burbankusd.org/site/Default.aspx?PageID=1945. The Board of Education is committed to ensuring the health and safety of the entire Burbank Unified community. Pursuant to Executive Order N-29-20 issued by Governor Gavin Newsom on March 17, 2020, Board of Education meetings will be closed to the public until social distancing directives have been lifted. A new system has been implemented to allow Public Speakers to provide live comments. Please note that Public Comments will no longer be accepted via email or voicemail. Listed below are the new instructions for public comment during Board of Education meetings:

Burbank Unified School District Board of Education Special Meeting - Tuesday, November 10, 2020 Page 2 of 3 1. Public Speakers please email Kimberley Clark at kimberleyclark@burbankusd.org no later than 1 hour and 15 minutes prior to the start of the public meeting (before 5:45 p.m.) stating your full name and the topic you wish to speak about. 2. Speakers are asked to log into the Board meeting virtually through the Zoom invitation no later than 5.45 p.m. The meeting will open at 6:00 p.m. and will be locked at 6:45 promptly. Please note that only those individuals who have emailed Kimberley Clark prior to 5:45 p.m. will be allowed to enter the Zoom meeting. Upon receipt of an email request, the Zoom meeting login details will be emailed to each individual speaker. 3. Speakers should rename their Zoom profile to indicate their real name to expedite this process. 4. When it is time for a speaker to address the Board, the speaker’s name will be called and the microphone on the Zoom account will be activated. Speakers must be present in the Zoom meeting when their name is called in order to be given an opportunity to address the Board. Speakers are also requested to state their name prior to addressing the Board. 5. After a speaker completes their public comment or if the five-minute (5) time limit has been reached, the microphone for the speaker’s Zoom profile will be muted. 6. The Zoom meeting will be closed following the Public Communications portion of the meeting. If you have questions or need assistance regarding the process, please email Kimberley Clark at kimberleyclark@burbankusd.org or Rose Garcia at rosegarcia@burbankusd.org. 2. REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD 2.a Public Communications An individual or group representative may address the Board of Education on any agenda item or subject within its jurisdiction. In order to facilitate public participation at Board meetings while adhering to proper social distancing guidelines, the Board of Education will accept public communications virtually through a Zoom invitation no later than 5:45 p.m. on November 10, 2020. The meeting will be locked at 6:45 p.m. promptly. Please note that only those individuals who have emailed Kimberley Clark prior to 5:45 p.m. will be allowed to enter the Zoom meeting (please see the Notice to Public in the agenda section I to see the new instructions regarding Public Comment via a Zoom invitation). The meeting will be streamed by visiting the District's website Board of Education page at https://www.burbankusd.org/site/Default.aspx?PageID=1945. 2.b Staff Responses 2.c Board Members' Comments and Responses 3. STUDY SESSION

Burbank Unified School District Board of Education Special Meeting - Tuesday, November 10, 2020 Page 3 of 3 3.a Discussion on Employee Equity Focus Groups Matt Hill, Superintendent, will facilitate a discussion with the Board of Education regarding employee equity focus groups. 3.b Board and Staff Comments 4. ADJOURNMENT

Any individual with a disability who requires reasonable accommodation to participate in a Board meeting may request assistance by contacting the Superintendent’s Office at (818) 729-4422. BURBANK UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION SPECIAL MEETING Tuesday, November 10, 2020 7:00 p.m. - Public Session Virtual Meeting - Burbank, California Disclaimer: Please note that the Burbank Public Libraries (as listed below) are currently closed. Due to the Coronavirus Pandemic Social Distancing Guidelines, please continue to view the online agenda at www.burbankusd.org. AGENDA The entire agenda packet is available for review online at www.burbankusd.org; at the District Office Building, Superintendent's Office, 1900 W. Olive Ave., Burbank, 91506; and at the Reference Desk in all Burbank City Libraries at: 110 N. Glenoaks, Burbank, 91502; 300 N. Buena Vista, Burbank, 91505; and 3323 W. Victory Blvd., Burbank, 91505. 1. CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 1.a NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Closed Session will be held by teleconference to discuss matters on the Closed Session agenda, at 6:00 p.m. The teleconference (6:00 p.m.) and online meeting (7:00 p.m.) is held pursuant to Executive Order N-29-20 issued by California Governor Gavin Newsom, which suspends certain requirements of the Ralph M. Brown Act. Balancing the health risks associated with the Coronavirus (COVID-19), while appreciating the public’s right to conduct the people’s business in a transparent and open manner, during the current State of Emergency and in the interest of public health and safety, most-and possibly all of the Board Members will be participating by teleconference. District facilities are closed to the public until further notice and the public will not be able to physically attend the Board of Education meeting. The Board will reconvene in Public Session at 7:00 p.m. The District is providing alternatives to in-person attendance for viewing and participating. Any individual or group representative may address the Board of Education on any agenda item or subject within its jurisdiction. The meeting will be streamed by visiting the District's website Board of Education page at https://www.burbankusd.org/site/Default.aspx?PageID=1945. The Board of Education is committed to ensuring the health and safety of the entire Burbank Unified community. Pursuant to Executive Order N-29-20 issued by Governor Gavin Newsom on March 17, 2020, Board of Education meetings will be closed to the public until social distancing directives have been lifted. A new system has been implemented to allow Public Speakers to provide live comments. Please note that Public Comments will no longer be accepted via email or voicemail. Listed below are the new instructions for public comment during Board of Education meetings: 1

Burbank Unified School District Board of Education Special Meeting - Tuesday, November 10, 2020 Page 2 of 3 1. Public Speakers please email Kimberley Clark at kimberleyclark@burbankusd.org no later than 1 hour and 15 minutes prior to the start of the public meeting (before 5:45 p.m.) stating your full name and the topic you wish to speak about. 2. Speakers are asked to log into the Board meeting virtually through the Zoom invitation no later than 5.45 p.m. The meeting will open at 6:00 p.m. and will be locked at 6:45 promptly. Please note that only those individuals who have emailed Kimberley Clark prior to 5:45 p.m. will be allowed to enter the Zoom meeting. Upon receipt of an email request, the Zoom meeting login details will be emailed to each individual speaker. 3. Speakers should rename their Zoom profile to indicate their real name to expedite this process. 4. When it is time for a speaker to address the Board, the speaker’s name will be called and the microphone on the Zoom account will be activated. Speakers must be present in the Zoom meeting when their name is called in order to be given an opportunity to address the Board. Speakers are also requested to state their name prior to addressing the Board. 5. After a speaker completes their public comment or if the five-minute (5) time limit has been reached, the microphone for the speaker’s Zoom profile will be muted. 6. The Zoom meeting will be closed following the Public Communications portion of the meeting. If you have questions or need assistance regarding the process, please email Kimberley Clark at kimberleyclark@burbankusd.org or Rose Garcia at rosegarcia@burbankusd.org. 2. REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD 2.a Public Communications An individual or group representative may address the Board of Education on any agenda item or subject within its jurisdiction. In order to facilitate public participation at Board meetings while adhering to proper social distancing guidelines, the Board of Education will accept public communications virtually through a Zoom invitation no later than 5:45 p.m. on November 10, 2020. The meeting will be locked at 6:45 p.m. promptly. Please note that only those individuals who have emailed Kimberley Clark prior to 5:45 p.m. will be allowed to enter the Zoom meeting (please see the Notice to Public in the agenda section I to see the new instructions regarding Public Comment via a Zoom invitation). The meeting will be streamed by visiting the District's website Board of Education page at https://www.burbankusd.org/site/Default.aspx?PageID=1945. 2.b Staff Responses 2.c Board Members' Comments and Responses 3. STUDY SESSION 2

Burbank Unified School District Board of Education Special Meeting - Tuesday, November 10, 2020 Page 3 of 3 3.a Discussion on Employee Equity Focus Groups Matt Hill, Superintendent, will facilitate a discussion with the Board of Education regarding employee equity focus groups. 3.b Board and Staff Comments 4. ADJOURNMENT 3

Sources and limits

Published sources used on this page

This meeting has been held, but no source-backed decision record is available yet. Agenda items remain proposals.

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.

Canonical record: 9d0b2739b924112b2f1dc94fff466024. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record